Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP261: The Future Of B2C Ecommerce Platforms: Why Vendors Need To Think Seriously About Niche & Vertical Specific Solutions
Transcript
- 0:02You're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast, hosted
- 0:05by experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 0:08Insidecommerce is your fast tracked additional knowledge
- 0:10featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 0:13industry thought leads and the C-Suite of key tech companies to
- 0:16explore the latest in digital strategy, customer experience
- 0:18and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 0:21really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 0:24help fine tune your ecom strategy and tech stack.
- 0:27Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 0:30like to discuss an ecommerce project.
- 0:32We hope you enjoy the latest episode.
- 0:35Welcome to the Inside Commerce podcast Sport supply Centre and
- 0:38grabbing more about later. Myself and Paul actually sat
- 0:41right next to each other in an office.
- 0:44Hello Paul. Today we thought we'd do
- 0:48something a little bit different.
- 0:49Today we're going to talk about the future of DTC ecom
- 0:52backbones. How will vendors differentiate?
- 0:55So we, we asked ourselves a question this week if we were
- 0:58running an E and what would we do and why?
- 1:00And just to set the scene of why we think this is important, but
- 1:03a few conversation, research, people asking about the event
- 1:06again, do you think they're going to be dominant in the UK
- 1:09and I in the next three to five years?
- 1:10Where's about going? And like the E com marketplace
- 1:14is really quite glossophobic today.
- 1:16I've worked with a lot of merchants as is bull where
- 1:18people struggle sometimes to tell the difference between
- 1:20platforms because a lot of platforms take very similar
- 1:22stories about what they can do, functionality, whether it's
- 1:25around multi storefront or it's about integrations or it's about
- 1:28apps, etcetera. We're going to focus on UK and
- 1:32Ireland and Europe there because there are regional merits.
- 1:36So you have to based on Latin America, Vtechs or in Asia.
- 1:39There are some very countries as well.
- 1:42And the UK now has got its stalwarts, it's got the big SAS
- 1:46players that have grown rapidly shot by big commerce, but it's
- 1:50also had new entrants in the past couple of years vying for
- 1:53headspace. So brands like Central come for
- 1:57Scandinavia, making really good headways.
- 2:00You've got scale from Germany, you've got some really big like
- 2:03brands and more complex businesses on the platform have
- 2:05won prestige brads Man United and you've got shop line as well
- 2:09as a, a a newer SAS entrant, stronger marks Asia who are see
- 2:14trying to make headway as well. And the layers of sales activity
- 2:18is off the charts. So if you're head of ECOM or a
- 2:20director of ECOM, you are being hammered from agencies,
- 2:24consultants like us and you know, platforms, etcetera.
- 2:30And we see a lot of noise and we see a lot of repetitive
- 2:32messages. That's not criticism of anyone.
- 2:34It's because the market's hard and people are trying to get cut
- 2:37through to their their ICP. So following an interesting
- 2:42conversation I had with Joshua Borton from better commerce this
- 2:44week about how a new entrance from fare.
- 2:46We wanted to pull spark and go what, what, what do we think
- 2:48what we do? So our our bold statement
- 2:51discussed today is the future econ platforms is
- 2:53differentiation and niche solutions.
- 2:56So Paul, why don't you rebuild this?
- 2:58Because we were talking about what, what, what really gets cut
- 3:01through and, and, and where are the where's this heading?
- 3:04Yeah, absolutely. So I think one thing I'd just
- 3:06say in response to some of the bits you said as well, I think
- 3:09sometimes kind of way you said about like the salespeople
- 3:13saying the same things. Every now and then I'll talk to
- 3:15a brand that's like in the process of reviewing platforms
- 3:19or vendors and there will be a very clear need and upfront
- 3:23they've, you know, given detail around a need and then a
- 3:26platform will really double down on that need.
- 3:29And actually that person will have a completely wrong view of
- 3:32like where that platform strengths are.
- 3:34I don't think, again, that just comes from, you know, sales
- 3:38people being very focused at the moment and the way the market
- 3:41is. But yeah, I do think that's
- 3:42definitely, I see that a lot more than I have historically.
- 3:46But yeah, to your point, so I think, yeah, the challenge at
- 3:50the minute, I think a lot of people would see or say is that,
- 3:54you know, Shopify particularly dominant, you know, they're
- 3:58growing very quickly. They've got an unprecedented
- 4:01number of merchant using the platform and I think it would
- 4:05take a lot for someone to get to that same point and compete with
- 4:09them head to There's a few others as well.
- 4:25And I think what where they need to be going is more kind of, you
- 4:29know, depth in the relevant features and really kind of
- 4:32sticking to that niche. But I think the challenge that
- 4:36they have, which I think is probably the original question
- 4:40is that if you've got, you know, if you've still got a win
- 4:43business in order to continue to grow, in order to please
- 4:46investors, whatever, whatever else.
- 4:49And you've got a limited amount of resource focused on
- 4:52developing the platform and building new features and
- 4:55capability. Do you, you know, develop one
- 4:59feature? So let's say it's pre-order and
- 5:01we'll come on to some examples later on.
- 5:04And do you add real depth to that flexibility and put the
- 5:07time into understanding the UI and understanding like how
- 5:10people need that to work? Or do you introduce 5 new
- 5:13features, a higher level perspective or maybe needing
- 5:17more input from the business users, whatever else.
- 5:21And then essentially enable your sales team to compete with other
- 5:27vendors. Like I think that's the
- 5:28challenge that the most people have right now, particularly if
- 5:33you are more of a mass market platform and you're not going
- 5:36after the niche. Greb and create digital flagship
- 5:39stores for iconic brands of today and tomorrow.
- 5:43We are the number one Sentra agency in the world with more
- 5:45than 50 Centra implementations to date.
- 5:48We are also e-commerce design specialists, platform and tech
- 5:52partner agnostic. Try our new e-commerce design
- 5:55subscription. Visit greben.com.
- 5:58Yeah, I think, I also think if you just deliver a high level
- 6:03solution like an real envy take loyalty, loyalty subscriptions,
- 6:08good example, you could give that and maybe that will attract
- 6:1210 to 20% of merchants who just need to lodge something but
- 6:15don't have any advanced needs and they don't have like
- 6:17advanced customer wants. Where you miss out on is you
- 6:20miss out on specific businesses that have got, you know, a
- 6:25particular style of loyalty that needs to be delivered.
- 6:28This more than just points and prizes.
- 6:30You also, when you get into premium and luxury brands,
- 6:34you'll end up with something office that's generic that just
- 6:36doesn't give them the the brand experience, the customer
- 6:38experience they will deliver, which then is no longer an
- 6:42advantage to you as a platform having that feature.
- 6:44And it can be a disadvantage because you can put, I've been
- 6:47in a room where people have been showcasing very basic
- 6:49functionality and it's like, great, look, we can do this, but
- 6:51actually the execution's not so good on the front end.
- 6:54And you see senior level people looking, well, that's not what
- 6:58our customers want at all. And the third party app place
- 7:01has accelerated so rapidly. And it's not just Shopify apps,
- 7:04it's Shopify, it's big commerce, it's third party specialist with
- 7:06open API, really loyalty price. How many platforms out there
- 7:11used to be people would talk about, you know, one or two like
- 7:14loyalty lines, for example. But there are so many offering
- 7:16loyalty and more and more platforms are doing multi
- 7:20capability reviews, loyalty, you name it.
- 7:22But actually how do you get an advantage as a platform?
- 7:25Because surely it's no longer the launch, it's the
- 7:28connectivity is the. Well, I think this is and I
- 7:30think we could probably talk about this all afternoon, but I
- 7:33think the interesting thing is if you're because I think the
- 7:36situation in the market is Shopify's probably the toughest
- 7:38competitor that anyone's ever had E com space just because of
- 7:42their market. And you know, they're, they're
- 7:44pretty far along in terms of like a modern approach to a tech
- 7:47stack. And I think realistically, you
- 7:51know, you might end up giving a better solution to a merchant by
- 7:54going to market two or three partners, add the debt and you
- 7:59build a better solution. But there's multiple problems
- 8:01with that, I think. So one is those partners
- 8:04probably exist in the Shopify ecosystem.
- 8:06So there's no like competitive advantage or uniqueness there
- 8:10unless you really invest in like the deepest possible connection.
- 8:13But even then, I think in most instances that's not real like
- 8:18competitive advantage. I think then you're the other
- 8:21thing with a lot of these vendors is they actually have
- 8:23really high costs. So quite often I'll see a brand
- 8:26using a Shopify, for example, or another platform and they'll be
- 8:30paying more to their search and merch platform or more to, you
- 8:33know, a personalisation platform, whatever else than the
- 8:36actual platform. And realistically, for these
- 8:39platforms to grow and to raise more money and everything else,
- 8:42they need the money and the, you know, progress towards
- 8:46profitability. So yeah, I think that's a really
- 8:49interesting thing because you can't build everything and you
- 8:52can't expect, you can't just build extensibility for a client
- 8:56to build their own capability for everything.
- 8:59So it's that kind of, yeah, picking and choosing, I guess.
- 9:02But I do think that kind of route to market or go to market
- 9:06with the third parties is also really important.
- 9:08And we were obviously talking about that.
- 9:11Yeah, it's an interesting because the I guess there was a
- 9:13terminology we're going to talk about same story, different
- 9:16words about how we how one of the biggest issues is is needed
- 9:19to talk to customers based on use cases and solutions and
- 9:22value props, not on industry terminology.
- 9:24The industry is terrible at this.
- 9:25Like the industry is headless, but I've I've never worked with
- 9:30a merchant where a genuine business goal is we want to be
- 9:34headless or we want to be unified.
- 9:37Commerce is the latest obsession.
- 9:39Be honest, be rattlers like Proximus talked about this
- 9:42year's years ago. So it's not a new thing.
- 9:44It's just more terminology. Same thing with Matt.
- 9:48It's like apart from a very few select high end tidy complex
- 9:52businesses, the leadership teams are not sitting there going we
- 9:55should be Matt because it doesn't mean anything with its
- 9:58own. It's not denigrating Matt
- 10:01technology. It's it's the whole point is, is
- 10:03people want to want fairness to understand the use cases they
- 10:08need satisfied to have solutions articulated that alignment.
- 10:11So I, I think I agree with you because precomposed, I've seen
- 10:14this in a few vendors where they've built a snack, which
- 10:16might be platform plus a search and match Algodia plus a
- 10:20personalization content engineer like a Nosto.
- 10:22That's great. And but you're prescriptively
- 10:26pushing people into a very narrow set of solutions.
- 10:29And there are cost implications that are function implications.
- 10:34Sometimes other people you know merchants have their preference
- 10:36of. I only work with vendor ETT
- 10:38where you don't have any. Ideas.
- 10:41Exactly. So I don't think that is a
- 10:43sensible future unless you are so niche with a set of customers
- 10:47where you know that 80% of the customer base uses, for example,
- 10:51they're all on algo all they're all on before we are, they
- 10:54wouldn't be. So I agree with you on that.
- 10:57Centre is the only commerce platform built exclusively for
- 10:59fashion brands. Over 300 fashion brands run on
- 11:01Centre, including icons like Paul Smith, Jeff Ave. and Nudie
- 11:04Jeans. Centre solves business logic
- 11:06challenges for fashion brands. I know of the platform and they
- 11:08are on a mission to help you scale up rapidly globally across
- 11:11all online and offline channels. Take your fashion brand global
- 11:14faster, further stronger today. So let's talk about this because
- 11:18this this thing about we, we said about industry talk and and
- 11:23the the vendors need to be much sharp at identifying the use
- 11:28cases that customers give a shit about.
- 11:30So whether that is better on the channel process flows, better
- 11:34management at multiple international stores and
- 11:36simplicity, relative management. Where Where do you see some?
- 11:39How can how can merchants be swayed into buying into Ted?
- 11:46What? What are merchants looking for?
- 11:48The vendors need it better. So, so I think and again I come
- 11:51at this from a very fashion perspective because our average
- 11:54client is in the fashion space. I would say rather for your
- 11:57border puts in my examples will be fashion.
- 12:01But I think your examples there, I think taking Sentra and
- 12:04Shopify, I think, you know, for a long time you would look at
- 12:07Sentra and their capability around order management and
- 12:10internationals really strong ahead of a number of the other
- 12:14platforms, including Shopify for the that are relevant.
- 12:19And I think they were positioned really well.
- 12:21And then now it's a bit more even.
- 12:23And actually, because I think the thing that's really
- 12:25interesting is what really matters in a lot of cases is
- 12:29when you're sat in a room and you're doing the demo and you're
- 12:32walking through the platform and you're kind of seeing this
- 12:34stuff. And I think so they're good
- 12:37examples, but now they're not as relevant.
- 12:40But I think the example that we've written down here and that
- 12:42we talked about earlier is I think Centre's wholesale
- 12:46offering is an example of a feature where they've clearly,
- 12:50you know, serviced clients and given clients this capability.
- 12:52And then they've designed the front end of the wholesale
- 12:56channel based on how fashion brands should be merchandising a
- 13:02catalogue. And you know how that experience
- 13:05should work in terms of, you know, like buying volume and you
- 13:09know, being able to kind of build in like looks and things
- 13:14like that. So I think that's a really
- 13:16purpose built feature that is based on the need of of the
- 13:20types of people they want to attract.
- 13:21And I think realistically for a number of these niche players to
- 13:24continue to compete with Shopify, I think they need to
- 13:27invest in more areas like that. So some of the examples we
- 13:31talked about earlier were like pre-order are VIP slash, private
- 13:36selling slash, whatever else. And I think it's, it's basically
- 13:40taking the your ICP and I hate that term or acronym or whatever
- 13:46it is. But you're, you're taking your
- 13:48group of clients and you're trying to understand what the
- 13:51priorities after that where like there's areas for them to
- 13:54differentiate etcetera, like what areas can really add value
- 13:57to the business and then you're trying to prepackage
- 14:00functionality or build that into integrations.
- 14:03I, I, I think that's 100% it because I, I've been in so many
- 14:06pitches and I don't, I, I like, I like most of the platforms
- 14:10that are out there because they can see specific UK as well.
- 14:13Yeah, a big, big fan of big commerce Shopify, Sentra really
- 14:18interested with what scale it as well that, you know, there's,
- 14:21there's lots of really good solar platforms and really good
- 14:23teams behind it. But what I, I think struggles to
- 14:26cut through is coming into a pitch with a very specific use
- 14:30case and VIP sells a great one. Well, we've been through this
- 14:32with yeah, we were. You need to basically understand
- 14:36what VIP means to to different businesses, how they execute it
- 14:41from a campaign, marketing, merchandising and a visual
- 14:44proposition way how that has through a pricing point of view.
- 14:50Yeah. What are those points of
- 14:51difference to the standardized e-commerce experience on the
- 14:54front end and what is the back end implications?
- 14:56And then you need that functionality and logic built
- 14:58into the system and whether that's built into theme or
- 15:01whether it's just over the from the back end, from the front end
- 15:04point of view so that there aren't hacks and workarounds.
- 15:06And I know that all platforms can achieve stuff, but there are
- 15:09always compromises if you can deliver that.
- 15:11And another good example, I think is in, in jewelry, having
- 15:14worked with quite a few jewellers where they, where
- 15:17engagement is a strong bet. Engagement rings are really not
- 15:21out to be compared with standardized rings because
- 15:23you've got, you've got multiple components.
- 15:27Those components which you say, for example, you know, you could
- 15:29have the, the set in which can be different styles, you can
- 15:32have different gemstones, you have different sizes of
- 15:34gemstones. If you're on diamonds, you've
- 15:36got cut clarity 4 CS and each of those, depending on what you
- 15:40select impacts price and impacts the components being selected.
- 15:44Then you've got the ability to change metals.
- 15:46You've got all these configurable components that
- 15:48actually nothing I've seen out-of-the-box has it like that
- 15:52exactly with the data world, the pricing model that the the the
- 15:55merch you can achieve it and you can build it seen it down on big
- 15:59commerce on magenta. I know you've said that the shop
- 16:02flags are, but the proposition isn't there to take it and go
- 16:06there you go. That's exactly how it works.
- 16:08It's OK, so here's how our day model works now here's how we
- 16:12kind of did it here and we did a different solution for this
- 16:14other brand. You think it's not a joyed up
- 16:16story? I.
- 16:17Think the, I think this is always a really interesting
- 16:20discussion. I think the other thing is like
- 16:23it's having a capability to achieve something and a route to
- 16:27doing it as well versus like I guess something that might be a
- 16:31new addition that adds material value to the business.
- 16:34Like in my head, I was just thinking about things like, I
- 16:38guess loyalty, like if you've got a really solid loyalty
- 16:41engine or like customer segmentation alongside that or
- 16:47gift lists might be another. I think like some areas that for
- 16:51the right business can add. Yeah, tangible impact and that's
- 16:55out-of-the-box. Yeah, I personally if I and it's
- 16:59interesting because the other thing, so we've always took that
- 17:01mat and the trend over the last five years with composability
- 17:05and moving away from monoliths. Whereas now I feel like
- 17:10actually, I'm not saying that everything has to be monolithic
- 17:14or everything has to be built in a certain way.
- 17:15But I do think that the way we're going now is in order to
- 17:21create demand and service that demand and be able to show
- 17:24something tangible. When you're, you know, when
- 17:27you've got skin in the game and it's a proper capability, I
- 17:30think you're kind of going back to like, yeah, building things
- 17:33into the core of the platform a little bit.
- 17:36Yeah, I this, I find it interesting because they're
- 17:39clearly are some businesses where they genuinely buy into
- 17:43the that micro services and fully open API and the ability
- 17:48to create, yeah, custom and package business capabilities
- 17:51where they can take the code and build it to how they wanted to
- 17:55live something quite custom. And I totally get why that
- 17:57architecture worked. But I would argue that is like
- 18:00the exception because and that's a specific type of of
- 18:04organization and organizational complexity.
- 18:08The majority and I would say 90% plus of the businesses that I've
- 18:11worked with in the last 10 years do not need fundamentally it's a
- 18:15level of technical complexity. They don't need it.
- 18:18It's not going to materially impact their business strategy.
- 18:20What they need is flexibility, agility to speed to market.
- 18:24That can be achieved with a certain degree of of and you say
- 18:27like a Co application model if with a deep feature provided
- 18:31they have that front end layer and ability to connect into
- 18:34others as your systems is there so that your road map isn't
- 18:37delayed by 12 months because you're waiting for resource
- 18:39bandwidth to do a heavy integration.
- 18:41So I'm not, I'm not sure that's that's required for me.
- 18:45It's more use case. Everything I come up against
- 18:48where I see people's heads drop in a pitch is where they want to
- 18:52do something, as you said, whether it's around loyalty or
- 18:54it's around content management, you know, whatever that
- 18:59capability is. And actually the platform
- 19:02doesn't do it properly and there are apps for one single app
- 19:06doesn't do it all. Therefore they probably need 2
- 19:08apps to achieve the exact. Form then you might outgrow the
- 19:10app. Exactly.
- 19:11And then there's concern around, well, what if that app doesn't
- 19:14keep supporting this product and it doesn't grow with me?
- 19:17Therein lies most of the the issues I find that people see
- 19:20within vendors and then you're into workarounds and most of the
- 19:23vendors and the vendor teams and the pre sale solution
- 19:26consultants and the agencies really, really good at
- 19:28troubleshooting and coming up with creative workarounds.
- 19:32But it does put business teams off when you've gone from one
- 19:35creative workaround to four or five within single project
- 19:37during the technical discovery. And I think where we're at with
- 19:40the industry at the minute is I think Shopify has lure in the
- 19:44market and there's, you know, there's a real kind of, you
- 19:47know, it's got a brand that there's a lot of appeal around
- 19:49Shopify. People have experience with it
- 19:51because it's so broad. But realistically, the big
- 19:54brands are still going to have those workarounds for the next
- 19:57one to two years, in my opinion. And I think where the
- 20:00opportunity lies and then, you know, as you get into more niche
- 20:04use cases, there's going to be more workarounds just inherently
- 20:07because of the nature of the platform.
- 20:10But I think where the opportunity is, is, yeah, the
- 20:13other platforms. Can go, yeah, less broad focus
- 20:16on 10% and then yeah, really double down on having that
- 20:22capability. They can demo, they can sit in a
- 20:24room and they can say, you know, here's an example of a loyalty
- 20:27program, here's the front end UX and you know, here's how it
- 20:31works in the back end and here's how reporting works and here's
- 20:34how we can pass data around. And I think that's where there's
- 20:38opportunity. Yeah.
- 20:39It's, it's that end to end pieces there because in a, in a
- 20:43business that's doing loyalty, you've got the, the person who's
- 20:46responsible for the, the brand of customer experience out of
- 20:48it. So how does it land?
- 20:50Then you get the strategy, proper position piece to make
- 20:53sure that it is financially sustainable, is going to drive
- 20:57like positive benefits. You've got the person who's got
- 21:00to actually execute it on the website.
- 21:01You've got the data person by the scenes who's got to get all
- 21:04the data points to analyse impact on retention, lifetime
- 21:07value, you name it. So yeah, I think it's that
- 21:10ability to walk end to end rather than just so here's a
- 21:13platform feature and I think that miss that's missing a lot
- 21:17of pictures actually it is a big opportunity.
- 21:19So and I have I have seen because we're talking about like
- 21:23niche and differentiation being important we all see in this.
- 21:25So you mentioned central, I think central roots law now
- 21:28they're building out proposition fashion and centric mainly
- 21:32fashion, you know, obviously some additional lifestyle
- 21:34business around there. I've talked to you about big
- 21:36commerce a few times. We're not focusing on B2B today
- 21:39because it's such a, a diverse and complex part of, of commerce
- 21:43anyway. And there's a whole new set of
- 21:45platforms in there especially. But what I think is interesting
- 21:48is that big commerce clearly recognize that the future is
- 21:52having a niche proposition as well as your, your core mass
- 21:55market is they announced their big travel accelerator in part
- 21:58UB Digital, which is digital transformation agency.
- 22:01So they're building on their new catalyst headless storefront.
- 22:05So they are obviously not pushing people down the route be
- 22:08constrained by a stencil clean and therefore having the
- 22:11limitations around the logic that you've got within that.
- 22:14And given given that sort of the flexibility to create that
- 22:18travel experience and therefore to, to, to work with whatever
- 22:21other third parties and APIs they need to pull in the data
- 22:23from the disparate systems exist in the travel space.
- 22:26So I think that's, that's a, that's another indication that
- 22:29that some vendors have already recognised this.
- 22:31I'm intrigued. Yeah, Yeah, I completely agree.
- 22:35And I think, I mean, we've seen this in the past a little bit,
- 22:39but I think where people have introduced maybe like almost
- 22:43like an accelerator proposition within a niche, I think we've
- 22:49seen it and it's kind of worked a little bit.
- 22:51But I think now it's it's much deeper.
- 22:54Yeah, exactly. There there is the potentials in
- 22:57there to carve out very specific solutions for for Yeah fashion
- 23:02one travel that luxury, definitely luxury and also then
- 23:09thinking about from AI guess if you're going down the platform
- 23:12that have themes, but also then have headless capability from a
- 23:16theme point of view of making that theme have a version that
- 23:19is very unique to that particular vertical.
- 23:23So the design ethos, the functionality, the other third
- 23:26parties that that become really important in that space you.
- 23:29Could still, I mean, the thing that we were talking about
- 23:31earlier was that the problem with headless and how people
- 23:34perceive headless and how people position headless.
- 23:36But with headless, you can still build out functionality.
- 23:40It's just that you then need to build on top of that.
- 23:44But I still think if you've got like an approach to yeah, or if
- 23:48you've essentially got all of the VIP stuff, all of the
- 23:51segments are available in the front end.
- 23:52Like everything curled. Yeah.
- 23:55It's just about going deeper and then trying to prepackage as
- 23:59much of that functionality. As possible, I I I really,
- 24:02really wish all vendors have stopped using terminology like
- 24:04headless because IT businesses don't seek to go headless as a
- 24:08goal. It's a solution to a problem.
- 24:11And you don't start with headless.
- 24:12And I, I, I've had to speak to a few people, agencies and
- 24:15pictures who have stopped talking about being headless
- 24:17because a lot of people, they still don't really, it's not
- 24:19patronising me, but a lot of people in, in clanticing still
- 24:21don't really get what that means.
- 24:23And it feels like onerous. The whole point is let's take
- 24:25content management. And so Sentra, which is headless
- 24:28first platform, they are closely wedded with headless CM s s like
- 24:32story. So actually you flip that and
- 24:35you talk about what use it, what are the benefits of business of
- 24:38using something like a story block?
- 24:40What are the common limitations that whether it's a fashion
- 24:42brand, a beauty brand, yeah, money course content management
- 24:45team come up against in terms of managing like navigation and
- 24:49mega menus or handling like more complex user journeys or
- 24:53customized user journeys or personalization of content based
- 24:56on different parameters, whether it's URL parameters or, or
- 24:59session, like whatever it might be.
- 25:01And how you can then turn that into a explanation of this is
- 25:06how you achieve that. Yeah.
- 25:07And even down to that, the VIP piece we talked about, if we
- 25:10take away through the the architectural terminology and
- 25:13focus on the business use case, I think vendors have a big
- 25:17opportunity to create niche specific stories, even if it's
- 25:20not fundamentally changing how what that platform is and how
- 25:24it's working technically. I think the thing that's
- 25:26interesting about like when some of the early composable vendors
- 25:30start coming into the market and particularly coming down market,
- 25:33they were, I don't want to say lazy, but I feel like the
- 25:37approach was we're going to focus all of our development
- 25:39results on the back end and building like the best APIs in
- 25:42the world. And then we're just going to
- 25:44essentially position ourselves as like, you know, the strongest
- 25:49foundation and then everything else has to be built on top.
- 25:52And there are no, you know, there's no consideration around
- 25:54building a deeper connection for CMS or merchandising tool
- 25:57whatever. Whereas now I think centre and
- 26:00storyblock have a really deep connection, you know, that that
- 26:03integration allows for like their markets kind of
- 26:07segmentation and functionality, etcetera.
- 26:10And I think, you know, it's already fairly deep.
- 26:12I think there's and they have the equivalent depict.
- 26:15Whereas I think now it's like you can provide a headless
- 26:18solution and work with the partners in a way that, you
- 26:22know, the impact that you might have had from being headless in
- 26:25the past where there's shit loads of unknowns and you know,
- 26:28everything is a bit of a black box.
- 26:30And, you know, if you're non-technical, you kind of don't
- 26:33really have a leg to stand on if you're trying to argue how long
- 26:35something needs to take or the approach or whatever else.
- 26:38And you can try and like, yeah, almost like, yeah, to integrate
- 26:43a much deeper level and actually have pre, pre built approaches
- 26:48to things. And yeah, I think that's kind of
- 26:50the future of some of this stuff.
- 26:53I always come back to use case and use stories of, of you've
- 26:57got to understand what an e-commerce team wants to do,
- 27:01what are its challenges, what it's trying to deliver and stop
- 27:04talking about the tech and talk about the delivery and how it's
- 27:07achieved. So one, one example of like
- 27:10conversations I, I'd be involved in where, where people have
- 27:12looked at, say like a shop find big.
- 27:14It's not single and now, but this is a conversation I've had
- 27:17other times where people are asking, OK, so Shopify's got
- 27:20headless and so is big commerce. I what, what's the difference?
- 27:24They as soon as you start down that technical route with a, a,
- 27:28a trading team or a more business workers team, you end
- 27:32up in confusion. What it should be is what what
- 27:35are you trying to do from a content execution point of view?
- 27:37How do you publish content? How distributed is your content
- 27:40publishing? What workflows do you have?
- 27:42Are there like approvals, etcetera?
- 27:44Like how do you work for like staging to live?
- 27:48How much differentiation is there across different sites?
- 27:52All that stuff. Nail those down and then go
- 27:54right now. Let's find out how each of those
- 27:57achieves it and how much is pre built into these frameworks.
- 28:00How much of this is already templated?
- 28:02How much of these components exist, Therefore you don't make
- 28:05them from scratch. How can you adapt them?
- 28:06How can you then old brand them and and customize?
- 28:10I think that's that's the thing. It's just flip it that vendors
- 28:13have a massive opportunity to come in and you can then make it
- 28:16these specific because if you if you're thinking beauty versus
- 28:19fashion versus travel versus home wares, etcetera, you can
- 28:24then come in with a narrative that is basically tackling those
- 28:27pain points specific to that brand.
- 28:30And it's far, far better than just saying, yeah, you know,
- 28:33it's a headless framework. You can build it and do it
- 28:36however you want. That just feels quite.
- 28:38Yeah, I completely agree. And I think there is that
- 28:41element of like I've seen it come out with certain types of
- 28:45stakeholders in the past of like the skin in the game as well to
- 28:47say you want your, some people will want their ecom platform to
- 28:52essentially be handling as much the complexity and, you know,
- 28:57the high value elements as possible because, yeah, they
- 29:00they want to buy into one platform.
- 29:02They want, you know what the one choke to what was that one folk
- 29:05to choke like thing. And like, you know, they want to
- 29:09be able to, yeah, simplify a number of ways of working with
- 29:13the vendors by, yeah, having more of that capability within
- 29:16the platform and. Let's talk about new, new
- 29:19capabilities because I, I personally believe that new
- 29:22capabilities quickly becomes table stakes and they are the
- 29:25meaningful form of differentiation unless you
- 29:27really have pushed ahead quicker than any other vendors, say AAI,
- 29:32generative AI, things like right and prompt descriptions, SEO
- 29:35metadata, you've got AI systems get built into black.
- 29:40And I'm not criticized because I think it's a grain big.
- 29:42It's logical and it adds a lot of value to it.
- 29:44But I don't think these are competitive differentiators.
- 29:48I think for. Platforms.
- 29:49I think these are early use cases and I think the use of AI
- 29:54will change. Like I think that as an example,
- 29:56I guess like one competitive, just one competitive advantage
- 30:02you could build using AI might be if you really doubled down on
- 30:05like reporting and data and then you used AI to support some of
- 30:09like the predictive stuff. So like in line on a product,
- 30:11it's like based on 12 months of sales data, you are likely to
- 30:15sell out X or like, you know, even like some of the
- 30:18merchandise and stuff as well. If you were to build that in and
- 30:21like encourage the brands to like make moves or even like
- 30:25offer the option to like increase exposure behind
- 30:29product, all of that kind of stuff, I think there will be
- 30:31capability. I think at the minute and I
- 30:33think the other one which will really impact the market is I
- 30:36don't think it'll be none before with Shopify, you can build a
- 30:39store or buy a prompt. So you can already do that with
- 30:42some of the some of the content like build a tool laying out
- 30:48there. And I think it would Shopify
- 30:51would be very close to that. I'd imagine it really exists,
- 30:54you know, today, but it's just not readily available.
- 30:56And I think a lot of what they're doing now is probably
- 30:59more like testing and, you know, using AI to just support people
- 31:03where they need it, particularly like someone like Shoppa who are
- 31:06way ahead in the space. But they have, you know,
- 31:08probably what, 80 plus percent of their users will still be
- 31:12tiny and they're really, you know, efficiency is really
- 31:15important and maybe they're even a one month bat.
- 31:18So I guess it's like some of that stuff the the tough class
- 31:20we work with would use. I think it's probably still
- 31:23valuable whilst they're working out how AI is best leveraged at
- 31:28the bigger brand. But right now, I don't think
- 31:32there's too much within that. I think it's the third part is
- 31:36that are really pushing the boundaries because they've got
- 31:38more specific news spots. Yeah, exactly, because it's
- 31:41very, very, I agree. Anything where the the AI
- 31:44improves the admin processes when you're in the back end and
- 31:48you're managing customers, you're setting up promotions,
- 31:51you're creating anything that can do can do like command and
- 31:54prompt based automated flows. Because a lot of the flow
- 31:57builders that exist and the lots of the platforms have it are
- 32:00really good for like connecting data points, but you have to go
- 32:05in and unstand all the different connections that are possible.
- 32:08Takes time to learn it. The ability just to write a prod
- 32:10and that can be guided through. I would say.
- 32:12Have you thought of this or why don't you use this?
- 32:16And I think there are platforms out there now that are like
- 32:19building integrations via prompts and stuff like that.
- 32:23And I think the other thing I was going to say was, I think
- 32:28one of the, the only use cases I've seen that's very early and
- 32:31I don't think it's fully ready is Shopify's catalogue
- 32:36enrichment stuff. So where you can essentially add
- 32:38attributes and Shopify and add a load more if that gets good.
- 32:42And they've obviously got a really wide user base.
- 32:46If that gets good, then I think that'll be a differentiator for
- 32:50certain types of businesses. Like you've got 6,000,000
- 32:53products and yeah. Yes, yeah, if you could do that
- 32:56at scale, I guess what's interesting is third parties
- 32:59like Attract have had elements like this for for ages, like
- 33:02Attract with its image. I always love the actually
- 33:04Richmond where you have an image and then it can the AI can
- 33:07detect attributes that you haven't created for it.
- 33:10So I guess the question is at what point the platforms take
- 33:13over? And if if that skill going to
- 33:16because I mean, the interesting thing is, well, it's like,
- 33:18obviously there's no sort of like capabilities that the
- 33:20platforms could introduce using AI like image generation,
- 33:25whatever else. But they're probably never going
- 33:26to be bigger than a, you know, a company that's sitting over in
- 33:29California that have got 20 million behind it and there's 50
- 33:33people very specifically focusing on generating lifestyle
- 33:37Madrid. So it's like, yeah, it's like
- 33:39you say it's like, where do you I guess it's back to that same
- 33:42point. It's like buy partner.
- 33:44Yeah. What level of capability do you
- 33:45need? Well, I, I think if you're a
- 33:47small business, there isn't God hasn't got the budget to buy
- 33:51lots of third party specialists. You want the platform to have
- 33:55the, all the core features and to have the basic stuff there
- 33:57sort of ticks the core boxes. If you are a, a growth plan and
- 34:01you know you're a 10/20 million plus business, you're going to
- 34:05have the budget to invest in special tools.
- 34:06So key areas that are going to give you a competitive reality
- 34:09just give you a better tool. And I can't see the econ
- 34:12platforms keeping pace with the market leaders in those
- 34:16specialist areas. They might be 70% of the way
- 34:18there, but it's that extra 30% that makes the massive,
- 34:21especially if you take search and merch.
- 34:23If you go into like a big commerce or a Shopify, look at
- 34:25their search and merch. OK, good enough out-of-the-box.
- 34:28They they compared with like the business logical rules.
- 34:31You can buy the specialist like they playback.
- 34:33They're not even close. So I don't think that is where
- 34:36the vendors can compete and they're willing to invest insane
- 34:40amounts of money on there. But let let's let's try and do
- 34:43summary because I know this is one of the topic.
- 34:45We could sit, sit in a pub and and drink hours.
- 34:47And so let's let's the question we said is, is if you're an
- 34:52e-commerce platform, what would you focus on?
- 34:54Why? What is your summary to wrap up?
- 34:56I mean, I think in today's market you almost have to go
- 34:59niche or at least start niche and then broaden slightly.
- 35:02And I personally would be focusing on the features that
- 35:07are most important to the people that are buying my product and
- 35:10going as deep as possible whilst trying to add additional value,
- 35:15adding features that, you know, something new or some kind of
- 35:19additional win. And I'd make sure that all of
- 35:20those, yeah, features, I guess, are better than what else can be
- 35:25found on the market. Yeah, I think it's for me it is
- 35:29connectivity with with market leading specialist but but also
- 35:33connectivity with, with mid and lower level providers.
- 35:36And that's not dismissive of them.
- 35:37But those who are more basic function and cheaper but are
- 35:41going to be open for smaller businesses that have the budget.
- 35:45People want connectivity, they want the pre integration so they
- 35:47don't have to pay a developer thousands of money to do that.
- 35:52And then it's building on your niche.
- 35:55It's niche, but building out scenarios where you can, where
- 35:59you've understood what you have a jeweler needs, what a beauty
- 36:02brand needs, what fashion brand needs.
- 36:04And you've got those core set of use cases across content
- 36:08management, trade in a merchandise in loyalty, CRM,
- 36:13etcetera. And you have an actual way of
- 36:16demonstrating what that looks like and how it's executed from
- 36:20execution of the front end through to how it's set up in
- 36:22the admin, through to how the data passes down to the various
- 36:25systems and the integrations with third party apps to to
- 36:28overlay market leader functionality.
- 36:30That to me is is what people need to go into pictures with.
- 36:34I think this is almost like the impossible discussion though,
- 36:36isn't it? Because it's like you kind of
- 36:37got a balance of think out, like you could have the best
- 36:40capabilities for the right brands over here, but then they
- 36:43might be really, you might have to write the wrong price point
- 36:46or you might not have, you know, the relevant ecosystem around
- 36:49you. And yeah, you might not have the
- 36:52road map there. Another platform has its like, I
- 36:54guess so much of this I, I think it's definitely like what we're
- 36:57saying is the right direction and like investing in One
- 37:00Direction. I guess it's like you've kind of
- 37:02always need to be chipping away at some of those other.
- 37:04But, but this is about targeting big commerce come out targeted
- 37:07travel and that's Part 1 of their evolution into targeting
- 37:10travel specifically that that product will not be mature and
- 37:14that target won't be mature. They will, they will get there.
- 37:17I I know that they are, they've done that to B2B and they've
- 37:20done some really smart stuff like open source in their I
- 37:22portal, which should take it away loads of barriers to a lot
- 37:25of more complex B2B businesses. So I the whole point is you've
- 37:29got to yes, you're right. It's going to be commercially
- 37:31viable. You've got the right size,
- 37:32market and potential, and you've got to have a credit and story
- 37:35and therefore a go to market strategy.
- 37:37But if you try to do it everything to every vehicle,
- 37:39you're fucked. It's going to cost an effort,
- 37:42but start something. Improve the modern well the
- 37:44lighting ribs on meeting room. Assume that means.
- 37:47We're getting kicked out if. They've on meeting room.
- 37:49Oh, we've got a dark mode or we've triggered somebody
- 37:52basically. So look, thanks for listening.
- 37:55Hope you've enjoyed the day night mode experiences like
- 37:58being at AT20. Look, do reach out.
- 38:01We we deliberately did this episode to kind of thought
- 38:04provoke. If anyone disagrees, we've got a
- 38:06different viewpoint on the market or where vendors scale
- 38:08any vendors thing want to challenge?
- 38:10I thought we said that we'd love to have a conversation.
- 38:12Do add some comments and do recommend the episode to others
- 38:16if you think of the adventurous. Thanks everybody.
- 38:20You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast hosted by
- 38:22experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 38:25Inside Commerce is your fast tracked additional knowledge
- 38:28featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 38:30industry thought leads and the C-Suite.
- 38:32Key tech companies to explore the latest digital strategy,
- 38:35customer experience and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 38:38really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 38:41help fine tune your ecom strategy and take stack.
- 38:44Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 38:47like to discuss an Ecom's project.
- 38:49We hope you enjoy the latest episode.