Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Algorithmic Trading to Manage Their Own Stock
Transcript
- Lucas: If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, you're in the right place. Lucas: There's a quiet revolution happening in the back offices of post ipo companies. It's not about a new product or a hiring spree. It's about how they trade their own stock. Luna: You mean buybacks? Companies have been doing those for decades. Lucas: Right, but the old way was clunky. You'd authorize a buyback, then a banker would execute it over weeks or months. Maybe you'd get a decent average price, maybe not. It was opaque. Lucas: Now, a growing number of newly public companies are handing that job to algorithms. They're using automated trading systems that buy shares in small increments all day, every day, responding to real-time market conditions. Luna: So they're essentially becoming their own market maker. That's a big shift. Lucas: Exactly. And it's spreading fast. According to a survey by the corporate treasury association, about 40 percent of companies that went public in the last three years now use some form of algorithmic execution for their buybacks. That's up from maybe 10 percent five years ago. Luna: What's driving that? Is it just better technology, or something else? Lucas: It's partly technology, but it's also volatility. Look at what's happened just this week. Meta is up over 8 percent in the last five days, while Coinbase is down over 4 percent. When you're a newly public company, that kind of swing can be unsettling — especially for employees whose compensation is tied to the stock. Luna: Right, because you don't want your engineers checking their RSU balance every hour. Lucas: Exactly. So companies want a tool that can smooth out some of that noise. An algorithmic buyback can be programmed to buy more when the stock drops and ease off when it rallies. It's like a dampener on volatility. Luna: But isn't there a fine line between dampening volatility and manipulating the stock? The SEC has rules about that. Lucas: There is a line, and companies have to be careful. The SEC's safe harbor rule — Rule 10b5-1 — allows buybacks if they follow a pre-arranged plan. But the algorithm itself has to be designed to avoid creating artificial prices or volume. Most firms use volume-weighted average price, or VWAP, algorithms that just try to match the market's natural flow. Luna: So it's more about execution quality than price impact. Lucas: Yeah. But it's still a powerful tool. Take Snowflake, for example. They went public in 2020, and within two years they had an algorithmic buyback program running. Their CFO said in an earnings call that it allows them to be 'consistent and disciplined' without distracting the management team. Luna: And Rivian? They've had a rough ride since going public. Are they using this? Lucas: They are. Rivian authorized a $1 billion buyback last year and uses an algorithmic program to execute it. Their stock has been volatile — it's down about 2.7 percent this week alone — so having a steady buyer in the market, even a small one, can provide some floor. Luna: But doesn't that raise questions about using corporate cash to prop up the stock instead of investing in the business? Lucas: It's a fair question. And some critics argue that buybacks, algorithmic or not, can be a way for management to hit EPS targets without actually improving operations. But the counterargument is that if a company has excess cash and its stock is undervalued, buying it back is actually a good investment. Lucas: The algorithmic piece just makes it more efficient. You're not trying to time the market, you're just executing a plan consistently. Luna: That makes me think about the data. If the company's own algorithm is buying all day, do they see that data in real time? Could they use that to inform other decisions? Lucas: They do see it, and some companies are getting sophisticated with it. They can analyze the order flow to understand who's selling — is it retail, is it institutional, is it an index fund rebalancing? That can feed into their investor relations strategy. Luna: But they have to be careful not to use that information to trade on — that would be insider information. Lucas: Absolutely. The compliance walls have to be strong. The buyback team is usually separate from the IR team, and the algorithm itself is often run by a third-party broker to maintain independence. Luna: You mentioned this is spreading fast. Which sector is leading? Lucas: Tech, by far. The companies that went public in the last five years — the Snowflakes, the Crows, the Rivians — they're digital-native themselves. They're comfortable with algorithms running things. And they tend to have high volatility, so the benefit is larger. Luna: And they also have the cash. A lot of these companies raised huge amounts in their IPOs. Lucas: Right. But interestingly, we're starting to see it in other sectors too. A biotech company that went public last year used an algorithmic program to buy back shares after a failed trial sent the stock down 30 percent in a day. They said it helped stabilize the stock while they communicated with investors. Luna: That's a very different use case — almost like a circuit breaker. Lucas: It is. And it brings up a broader point: the role of the corporate treasury is changing. It's no longer just about managing cash and debt. It's about active capital markets management. Lucas: We're going to see more companies hire people with trading backgrounds, not just accounting backgrounds, to run these programs. Luna: That's a really interesting career path — from sell-side to the corporate side. Lucas: We deliberately don't run ads on this show. If you want to support that choice, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a clean way to keep these conversations going without any interruption. Lucas: So back to the algorithmic trend — the next frontier might be using these programs during lockup expirations. When insiders are finally allowed to sell, the stock can get crushed. An algorithmic buyback could step in to absorb some of that supply. Luna: That seems like a natural extension. We've talked about staggered lockups before, but adding algorithmic buying on top of that could really smooth the transition. Lucas: Right. And the technology is getting cheaper. A few years ago, you'd need a bespoke system from a bulge-bracket bank. Now, there are fintech platforms offering algorithmic buyback as a service for a flat fee. Luna: So it's democratizing. Smaller IPOs can do it too. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why I think within five years, it'll be standard practice for any company that does buybacks. The question won't be 'should we use an algorithm?' but 'which algorithm works best for our stock?' Luna: That's a fascinating shift. We'll have to check back in a year and see how many more have adopted it. Lucas: I'd love to. Until then, keep watching those volume patterns.