Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️105 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 28nd Sep Water Day 4 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. The day began with another application to adjourn the inquiry, and once again it came back to water. The concern was that some of the basic information needed to assess the receiving waters is still unresolved. There were three matters raised: further information following the
- 1:17transboundary consultation, the fact that we still do not have an appropriate assessment and the outstanding water quality parameters. The application for an adjournment wasn't accepted, so the inquiry continued, and we moved almost immediately into the evidence from the applicant's consultant On the
- 1:40shadow habitats regulation assessment, and there were lots of consultants. In fact, the biostitutes were out in force this morning, and I use that term with apologies to an entirely different profession. See podcast 103 to read more about that. For the next couple of hours, we got an education in
- 2:06aquatic biology. We had salmon spawning, salmon eggs, smolts, trouts, pearl mussels, otters, eDNA, electrofishing surveys, and even the size of salmon red. Something was actually very interesting, and I now know considerably more about the reproductive habits of an Atlantic salmon than I ever
- 2:32expected to know. And that evidence was in response to what we heard from the Locks Agency Last Thursday, one of the main disagreements concerned the pollen row burn, and whether Atlantic salmon actually spawn there. Martin O'Farrell challenged the Locks Agency interpretation of its surveys.
- 2:59His evidence was that salmon are present in the lower reaches of the burn, but that evidence doesn't show that they spawn there. His position was that the trout do. That brought us into a detailed discussion about the size of salmon reds. And salmon reds are gravel nests built by the female salmon in river beds
- 3:23to lay and safely incubate their eggs, water temperatures, the timing of hatching, degree days, and electrofishing results. We then moved on to eDNA, which is environmental DNA. The applicants' consultants referred to sampling, which they said had not detected Atlantic salmon EDNA in the Coronel Burn. There
- 3:50was also discussion about the limitations of EDNA and the different ways traces of a species can end up in a watercourse, including through other animals, from salmon we move to freshwater pearl mussels. We heard about their extraordinary life cycle, including the larvae attaching
- 4:14themselves to fish before eventually dropping off into the river bed. The juvenile stage is particularly sensitive and requires clean, stable, well-oxygenated habitat. The applicant's consultants argued that the smaller burns aren't particularly important as feeding grounds because otters
- 4:38have very large territories and can forage elsewhere. There was also discussion about whether the smaller salmon and trout in these barns would represent an important food source. By this time, we had been listening to the applicants' biology lesson. Evidence for more than two hours, it was kind of
- 5:03extraordinary. Later in the day, Fedelma brought the discussion back to something more basic. All of this detailed ecological assessment depends to some extent on knowing the existing conditions of the receiving waters. Her point was that the NIEA still doesn't have a baseline information for some of
- 5:29the parameters being discussed. Her description of the situation comes from an old show in the 60 called Dad's Army, and in it there was a phrase from Captain Mannering, which you may remember, which he repeated when everything went belly up to carry on regardlessly. Doctor Stephen Emerman also came in
- 6:01with three fairly straightforward points. The first concerned the table, which appeared to attribute standards for total suspended solids or TSS and selenium to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Steve said that he, as he understood it, the U.S. EPA doesn't have the water quality
- 6:26standards being attributed to it in the table, and that the source of those figures need explaining. That came back later in the afternoon when Commissioner asked mr.
- 6:38Behe specifically about the TSS and selenium figures. Doctor Stewart was helicoptered in to respond. We then heard that selenium isn't proposed as a parameter in the discharge consent, while TSS is proposed at 10 milligrammes per litre, the commissioner asked the applicant to come back with the
- 7:07information on selenium. Steve's second point concerned the proposed diversion of water through a pipe. We had also heard from the applicant's own consultant, that salmon are known to stray and can turn up in places that aren't necessarily optimum habitat. Stephen pointed out that there
- 7:31appeared to be nothing preventing fish from swimming into the diversion pipe, and his third point was about algae. Earlier evidence from the applicant's consultant had played down the likelihood of algae blooms in flowing rivers. Stephen agreed that flow makes algal blooms less likely, but
- 7:55pointed out that it depends on the amount of flow. That was particularly relevant after everything we had heard over the past few days about reductions in downstream flow associated with the project. The water balance evidence and today's ecological evidence therefore crossed over at that point. The
- 8:18afternoon then returned to the water quality parameter with a substantial contribution from Pat Hawley. One of the substances he concentrated on was tellurium. Pat referred to tellurium associated with the proposed mine, and to the applicant's own information about its presence in the
- 8:38mineralisation. He then dealt with the fact that there doesn't appear to be a water quality standard for it in the proposed discharge consent. Part of the explanation was that tellurium had previously been screened and wasn't found at elevated concentrations in the receiving water. Pat pointed out that
- 9:01those measurements relate to conditions before mining and processing have begun. His argument was that the absence of an elevated concentration before mining doesn't deal with what concentrations could arise during mining. He also raised selenium, silver, and other substances, and argued that
- 9:21appropriate standards need to be established during the assessment process, instead of being left to conditions at a later stage. The discussion then moved forward to drainage and possible seepage beneath the dry stack facility. Pat's position was that the shadowy HRA identifies water beneath the DSF
- 9:43which isn't properly covered by the discharge application, and the commissioner invited the NIEA into the discussion. mr. Byass referred to Article Six and Seven A of the Water Order. He explained that the requirement for a discharge. Consent depends on whether the discharge contains pollutants.
- 10:04If pollutants are present, it becomes a controlled activity. NIEA's present conclusion is that discharge consent isn't required for that drainage based on its position. That contaminants won't be present. mr. Byass also indicated that the matter could receive further consideration if issues arise
- 10:28later. There was quite a bit happening around mr. Beatty during the afternoon. At one point, the commissioner was dealing with NIEA when mr. Beatty wanted to return to the video evidence of otters that brought a Tim Goodwin into the picture, another of the applicant's consultants. His
- 10:51evidence was that nobody disputes the otters using the burns. His argument concerned how important different sections of those burns are to the otter population, and how that should be dealt with as a functionally linked land. The applicant's position is that the fact that the land is functionally linked
- 11:11to a special area of conservation doesn't automatically mean that every part of it has the same ecological importance or has to be treated in exactly the same way as the SAC, and that brought us to case law. mr. Beatty introduced a recent English High Court judgement from July this
- 11:33year. The commissioner asked whether it had already been submitted to the inquiry. It hadn't, and Beatty explained that it was a recent judgement and that he considered it relevant. Then there was a quite a lengthy exchange about whether new case law should be introduced at this stage. The
- 11:51commission pointed out that we are now on day four of the water hearings, but it was actually day five, and we're supposed to be moving on to Pete, she also reminded mr. Beatty that she had been strict with other parties about producing new evidence at the appropriate time. mr. Beatty didn't accept that new case law
- 12:13should be treated in the same way as new evidence. He said that EU law and other material had already been dealt with on the hoof as issues developed during the inquiry.
- 12:26That discussion continued for some time. Goodwin returned to the Locks Agency evidence from last Thursday and disagreed with the way functionally linked land had been characterised. His position was that the ecological importance of the habitat has to be assessed in practical terms. Some parts may be more important
- 12:48to a species than others, and the loss or alteration of a piece of functionally linked land doesn't automatically amount to a loss of integrity of the SAC. mr. Beatty also said that he had expected more discussion around functional linkage, and felt entitled to respond to what Commission had
- 13:08heard from the Locks Agency. The Commissioner reminded him that he had already spent around two hours on these matters earlier in the day, so by the end of the day, we had covered once again a remarkable amount of ground. We started with an unsuccessful attempt to adjourn over unresolved water information. We
- 13:33spent a couple of hours with the applicant's consultant on the story of salmon, trout, pearl, mussels, otter, and the smaller burns. Steve Everman raised the provenance of some of the water quality figures, the diversion pipe, and the relationship between reduced flows and algae. Pat Hotty brought the discussion
- 13:53back to tellurium, selenium, silver drainage beneath the DSF, and the substance for which standards have haven't been established. NIE explained its position on when drainage becomes a controlled discharge, and the final part of the afternoon was largely occupied with the applicant's response to
- 14:12the locks agency, and the argument over functionally linked land. And despite the extraordinary amount of technical evidence we've now heard, we finished again today with some of those basic water parameters still unresolved, and on Monday we're supposed to move on to Pete. Thanks for
- 14:35listening. See you all soon. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the
- 14:55conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment. Share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further.
- 15:15Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.