Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Peter Lynch's GARP Blueprint: Doubling the Market with Growth
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Today we're looking at something
- 0:03pretty special, I think Not just market history, but more like a
- 0:07blueprint for building wealth over the long haul.
- 0:09Yeah, that's right. We're diving into Peter Lynch
- 0:11and his, well, legendary approach.
- 0:14Growth at a reasonable price. JRP.
- 0:17JRP yeah, it really is sort of the golden mean of investing,
- 0:21isn't it? It's this discipline way of
- 0:22finding that that sweet spot. Sweet spot.
- 0:25Yeah, blending the, you know, the careful price watching of
- 0:29value investing with the upside potential you get from growth
- 0:32stocks, right. It's about trying to avoid
- 0:34paying crazy prices for growth, that growth at any price thing,
- 0:38but also, you know, avoiding those deep value stocks that
- 0:41might just stay cheap forever. And the results he got with
- 0:43this, they're just incredible. Lynch ran the Fidelity Magellan
- 0:46Fund. What was it, 77 to 90?
- 0:48That's the period 13 years. And over those 13 years, he
- 0:52averaged 29.2 percent per year. Astonishing number.
- 0:56I mean the S&P 500 at about 15.8%.
- 0:58Then he almost doubled the market.
- 1:00Think about that turning $10,000 into nearly $280,000.
- 1:04Yeah. And that wasn't just luck,
- 1:06right? It came from a process, a
- 1:07repeatable system. OK, So that's our mission today,
- 1:10really to unpack that system. It's a mix of hard numbers,
- 1:14quantitative stuff, but also a lot of qualitative common sense.
- 1:17The core idea being find. Solid, sustainable earnings
- 1:21growth that the market just hasn't fully recognized or
- 1:25priced in yet. That's Jaro P at its heart.
- 1:28OK, let's get into the toolkit then.
- 1:29The quantitative side, Lynch's most famous tool has got to be
- 1:32the PEG ratio. Right, absolutely.
- 1:34The PEG ratio, you know the standard PE ratio price to
- 1:37earnings, it's OK, but it only tells you about past earnings,
- 1:40right? It's.
- 1:41Backward looking. Exactly.
- 1:42The PEG ratio adds that crucial forward look.
- 1:45It brings in the growth dimension.
- 1:46How does it work simply? Well, it's just the PE ratio
- 1:49divided by the annual earnings per share growth rate, the EPS
- 1:52growth, OK, Lynch's, whose big insight was this?
- 1:56A high PE isn't necessarily expensive if the company's
- 1:59growing really fast. Makes sense?
- 2:01So the PEG formalizes that basically, the faster the
- 2:05growth, the higher the PE should be willing to pay.
- 2:07And the target number he looked for.
- 2:09He famously aimed for a PEG ratio of one point O or less.
- 2:12One point O or less. Yeah.
- 2:14So if a company's growing earnings at say 25% a year and
- 2:18it's PE ratio is 25. Then the peg is 1.0.
- 2:21Exactly. And Lynch would say that's
- 2:23probably a reasonable price, fairly valued.
- 2:25OK. But here's where I always get a
- 2:27little hesitant. That G in the formula, the
- 2:31growth rate, how reliable is that?
- 2:34Aren't forecasts often wrong? That is a critical point,
- 2:38absolutely critical, and it's why Jump isn't just punching
- 2:40numbers into a formula. It's a philosophy, meaning
- 2:42meaning you, the investor have to do the hard work.
- 2:45You need to really dig in and validate that growth rate
- 2:47yourself. Is it sustainable?
- 2:49Is it realistic? The PEG gives you the framework,
- 2:51the context. So it hinges entirely on
- 2:53believing that growth number. Precisely.
- 2:56Your own research has to back up that growth story.
- 2:58Let's maybe use that classic example to make it clearer the
- 3:01two tech companies. Oh yeah, the aha moment example.
- 3:03It works well. So imagine two companies maybe
- 3:06in the same sector, tech let's say both trading at APE of 30.
- 3:10OK, so on the surface they look equally expensive.
- 3:13Right. But Company A is growing its
- 3:16earnings at a whopping 40% per year.
- 3:19It's PEG is 30 / 40 which is .75.
- 3:24Below one point O. Right now, Company B, maybe it's
- 3:27struggling a bit, only growing at 15% per year.
- 3:30Same PE of 30. Same PE of 30, so it's PEG is 30
- 3:33/ 15 which is 2 point O. Way above one point O.
- 3:37Exactly, so even though they have the same PE company A the
- 3:40faster grower is actually trading at a much more
- 3:43reasonable price relative to its growth.
- 3:45That makes it crystal clear Company A is the Jargop winner
- 3:48there. Definitely.
- 3:49But Lynch didn't just hunt for these super fast growers, did
- 3:52he? He had categories for other
- 3:54types of stocks, like the big steady ones.
- 3:56The Stalwarts. Right.
- 3:57The stalwarts, yeah, for those more mature, maybe slower
- 4:00growing companies that pay dividends.
- 4:02Think you know the Coca Cola's are Johnson and Johnson's of the
- 4:04world? He tweaked the formula a bit.
- 4:06How so? He used what's sometimes called
- 4:08the Yield Adjusted PEG ratio. He'd add the dividend yield to
- 4:11the earnings growth rate in the denominator.
- 4:14Ah, OK. Yeah, why add the yield?
- 4:16Well, because your total return isn't just from the earnings
- 4:18growth, right, It's also from the cash dividend you receive.
- 4:21Right, total return. So if a company is growing at,
- 4:24say, 12%, but it's also paying a 3% dividend yield.
- 4:28Your potential total return is closer to 15%.
- 4:31Exactly. So by adding that yield into the
- 4:34denominator, he made sure he wasn't automatically discarding
- 4:37a solid, stable company just because it's pure earnings
- 4:41growth didn't quite hit that one point O peg target.
- 4:44It gives a fuller picture for those reliable cash generators.
- 4:47OK, it makes sense. So beyond the PEG ratio, Lynch
- 4:51was big on checking the actual health of the business, wasn't
- 4:54he? Not just the growth forecast.
- 4:56Absolutely. He was actually pretty skeptical
- 4:57of hyper growth. You know, companies growing
- 4:59consistently over 50% year after year.
- 5:01Why skeptical? Isn't faster always better?
- 5:03He saw that kind of extreme growth as often unsustainable.
- 5:07Maybe it's fueled by a fad, or it attracts crushing competition
- 5:10really quickly. It's just hard to maintain.
- 5:11So he preferred something more. Controlled, yeah, The Jiddarb
- 5:14sweet spot for him was more like consistent, sustainable EPS
- 5:17growth between, say, 15% and 30% annually.
- 5:21OK, fast enough to really build wealth, but potentially actually
- 5:25manageable and repeatable over time.
- 5:27And he had some simple operational checks too.
- 5:29I always liked the inventory versus revenue growth test.
- 5:33It seems like pure common sense. It really is.
- 5:35It's a great red flag, especially for retailers or
- 5:37manufacturers. How does it work?
- 5:39If you see a company's inventory, the stuff sitting in
- 5:43warehouses piling up faster than its sales, are growing
- 5:47consistently, that's a worry. Suggests problems.
- 5:52Yeah, it could mean demand is weakening, or maybe their
- 5:55products are becoming obsolete, or they're just mismanaging
- 5:58things badly. You want to see the opposite?
- 6:00Sales growing faster than inventory, right?
- 6:02Strong revenue growth outpacing inventory buildup that helps
- 6:05confirm the demand is real. OK.
- 6:07And then there's the financial strength side, the margin of
- 6:10safety. Lynch famously hated debt.
- 6:12Right. Oh yeah.
- 6:13He was really wary of debt, especially for younger growth
- 6:15companies. If they hit a bump in the road,
- 6:17too much debt could be fatal. So how did he quantify that?
- 6:20Well, quantitative models based on his thinking often screen for
- 6:24a low debt ratio, specifically looking for a three of care Gray
- 6:30total liabilities to assets ratio of maybe 25% or less.
- 6:34Keeping the balance sheet clean Exactly.
- 6:36Gives them resilience if the economy turns down or if their
- 6:39growth slows unexpectedly. And we mentioned PE relies on
- 6:42earnings, which can sometimes be fuzzy.
- 6:44Lynch focused on actual cash, didn't he?
- 6:47Yes, real cash. That's why looking at free cash
- 6:49flow or FCF is important. Remind us what FCF is?
- 6:53It's the cash leftover after a company pays its operating costs
- 6:56and invests in necessary capital expenditures like new equipment
- 6:59or buildings. It's the cash management can
- 7:01actually decide what to do with. Like pay dividends, buy back
- 7:04stock. Or fund more growth, Yeah.
- 7:06So if you look at the price to free cash flow ratio PSCF.
- 7:09Lower is better. Generally, yeah.
- 7:11If a company's PSCF ratio is lower than its industry peers,
- 7:14it might suggest the market isn't fully appreciating its
- 7:16cash generating ability. FCF often tells a clearer story
- 7:20than reported net income. OK, now let's shift gears a bit
- 7:23to the part of Lynch's approach that really resonated with
- 7:26everyday folks. The qualitative side, the famous
- 7:29mantra? Invest in what you know.
- 7:32Right. This is where he argued ordinary
- 7:34people actually have an edge over Wall Street pros.
- 7:37Now so. Because you, the listener,
- 7:40interact with companies constantly as a customer, maybe
- 7:44as an employee, or just through your hobbies.
- 7:46You might spot a great local restaurant chain that's
- 7:48expanding, or notice everyone suddenly using a new product
- 7:52long before it shows up on some analyst's radar in New York.
- 7:54But here's the catch, right? People here invest in what you
- 7:57know and think that's the whole story.
- 8:00Just notice something cool and buy the stock.
- 8:03Exactly. And that's the big
- 8:04misunderstanding, that observation.
- 8:06That's just the start. It's the hypothesis.
- 8:08It's not the investment thesis itself, no.
- 8:10You have to follow it up with the homework, the rigorous
- 8:13research, he called it kicking the tires.
- 8:15So check the numbers. Check the numbers, check the
- 8:18management, check the competition, check the balance
- 8:20sheet. Does that popular store actually
- 8:22make money? Does that hot tech company have
- 8:25a mountain of debt? If you don't connect the
- 8:28observation to the fundamentals, it's just anecdotal.
- 8:31It's not investing. And he had a great way to make
- 8:34sure you actually understood the business before investing the
- 8:38crayon test. The crayon test, brilliant in
- 8:41its simplicity. Explain it, he basically said.
- 8:43If you can't explain what the company does, how it makes
- 8:46money, and why it's going to succeed in simple terms that a
- 8:5010 year old could understand, well then you probably shouldn't
- 8:53invest. Forces clarity.
- 8:55Codal clarity. It stops you from investing in
- 8:57things that are just too complex or opaque, where you don't
- 9:00really grasp the risks. And that clarity was needed
- 9:02because Darper wasn't just one single strategy for him, was it?
- 9:05He famously broke stocks down into categories. 6 categories.
- 9:09Yeah, this is crucial because you don't analyze a giant stable
- 9:13company the same way you analyze a tiny startup or a cyclical
- 9:17industrial firm. The approach has to be tailored.
- 9:19His main hunting ground for those huge winners, the 10
- 9:22baggers, was the fast growers. These are the potential rockets.
- 9:25Yeah, smaller aggressive companies capable of maybe 2025%
- 9:29growth or more per year. High potential but also higher
- 9:33risk. Then you had the stalwarts, the
- 9:35big guys. Right.
- 9:36Large, stable, well known companies maybe growing slower,
- 9:39say 1020%, but they're reliable. They often pay dividends.
- 9:44Lynch saw these as portfolio anchors, the defensive players
- 9:47you hold onto during downturns. Always have some stalwarts, was
- 9:50his advice. Pretty much, yeah.
- 9:51They provide ballast. OK, Next up, cyclicals.
- 9:55These sound tricky. They are tricky.
- 9:57Think autos, airline, steel, chemicals.
- 9:59Their fortunes rise and fall dramatically with the overall
- 10:02economy. So the usual Jr. pre rules don't
- 10:05quite apply. Not in the same way with
- 10:07cyclicals, Lynch said. Timing is everything.
- 10:10The time to buy them, counterintuitively, is often
- 10:12when things look absolutely terrible.
- 10:14When they're losing money. Exactly when losses are piling
- 10:17up, the PE might even be negative.
- 10:20You buy based on the expectation of recovery when the price is
- 10:25reasonable compared to their potential earnings in a normal
- 10:27economy, not their current depressed state.
- 10:30That takes guts. It does Contrarian, yeah, And
- 10:33you have to be prepared to sell when the cycle turns up again.
- 10:36OK. What about the other couple of
- 10:37categories? The riskier ones?
- 10:39Right, you have turnarounds. These are companies that have
- 10:41been beaten down badly but might have a shot at recovery.
- 10:44What drives a turn around? Could be new management, a major
- 10:47restructuring, selling off a bad division, something that
- 10:50fundamentally changes the story. The G here isn't steady growth,
- 10:54it's the potential snap back from deep trouble towards
- 10:58profitability. High risk, high reward.
- 11:01And finally, asset plays. Yeah, these are interesting.
- 11:03Asset plays are companies where the value of their underlying
- 11:06assets, things like real estate, maybe a pile of cash, patents,
- 11:11even brand names, is significantly greater than the
- 11:13value the stock market is putting on the whole company.
- 11:15Hidden value. Exactly.
- 11:18Lynch loved digging for these. Maybe a retailer sitting on
- 11:21incredibly valuable downtown property that the market was
- 11:24ignoring. It takes deep dive research to
- 11:27uncover these, OK? Let's make this concrete a fast
- 11:29grower example. Taco Bell.
- 11:31Perfect example. Lynch noticed Taco Bell early
- 11:34on. It was a simple concept, easy to
- 11:36understand. The crayon test.
- 11:37Pass the crayon test. And importantly, institutional
- 11:41investors were largely ignoring it back then, maybe thought it
- 11:44was too small or just fast food. So he saw an opportunity others
- 11:48missed and the numbers. He kicked the tires, found the
- 11:51company had excellent unit growth, a scalable model and,
- 11:54crucially, no debt. The debt thing again.
- 11:58Yeah. That gave them huge flexibility
- 12:00to expand without financial strain.
- 12:02And when the market got nervous and the stock dipped
- 12:04temporarily, he saw it as a buying opportunity because the
- 12:07underlying business was still firing on all cylinders, growing
- 12:10profits around 25% a year. And it became a massive winner.
- 12:13Huge home run eventually bought by PepsiCo.
- 12:16Classic Jar, our fest grower story.
- 12:17Now contrast that with a cyclical Ford Motor Company.
- 12:20The sounds of the opposite situation.
- 12:22Completely different playbook required here.
- 12:25Lynch bought Ford in the early 1980s during a brutal recession
- 12:29for the auto industry. How bad was it?
- 12:31Ford was losing staggering amounts of money, over a billion
- 12:34dollars in 1980 alone. The headlines were terrible.
- 12:38The PE was negative. So how on earth was that a
- 12:42reasonable price according to JARP?
- 12:45Because for cyclicals, the reasonable price isn't based on
- 12:48current terrible earnings, it's based on what the company could
- 12:51earn in a normal economic environment once the cycle
- 12:54turns. So he was betting on the
- 12:55recovery. Exactly.
- 12:57He was buying when the stock price reflected maximum
- 12:59pessimism, maybe even fears of bankruptcy.
- 13:02He understood the cyclical nature of the industry, saw
- 13:04management was cutting costs and believed demand would eventually
- 13:08return. And the bit paid off.
- 13:09Massively, The stock went up something like 500 percent or
- 13:12more over the next decade as the economy and Ford recovered.
- 13:15Pure cyclical investing. Group style.
- 13:17That really shows the flexibility, doesn't it?
- 13:20Applying the core idea growth at a reasonable price, but adapting
- 13:23the method based on the company type.
- 13:25That's the genius of it, but it leads us to think about Garp
- 13:28today. Right.
- 13:29How does it work in the modern market?
- 13:31Well, there's a bit of a paradox.
- 13:33The quantitative screening part, Finding stocks with a peg under
- 13:36one point, O low debt, etcetera. That's easy.
- 13:39Now anyone with the basic stock Screener can do it in seconds.
- 13:42So that initial screening doesn't give you an edge
- 13:44anymore. Not really the simple
- 13:46quantitative filtering. That alpha is largely gone
- 13:48because it's too accessible. OK, so if the Screener is just
- 13:51table stakes, now where is the edge for a modern GARP investor?
- 13:56The edge has shifted almost entirely, I think, to the
- 14:00qualitative side and the deep proprietary research, meaning
- 14:04the real work now is figuring out if the market's consensus
- 14:08forecast for growth that G that everyone plugs into their PEG
- 14:12calculation is actually wrong, specifically if it's too low.
- 14:16So you need to find something the market is missing.
- 14:18Exactly. You need to do the legwork to
- 14:21uncover a reason why this company will grow faster than
- 14:25analysts expect. Maybe it's a hidden competitive
- 14:28advantage, A new product line the market underestimates,
- 14:31superior management? A structural shift in the
- 14:33industry? Your research has to give you
- 14:35confidence that the G should be higher.
- 14:37The Screener just gives you a list of candidates to start
- 14:39digging into. That makes sense and that focus
- 14:42on growth, even if you're looking for a reasonable price,
- 14:44that protects you from value traps, doesn't it?
- 14:47Precisely. A lot of stocks are cheap for a
- 14:49very good reason. Their business is dying.
- 14:52They're melting ice cubes. Right jury RP, by demanding
- 14:55growth as part of the equation, forces you to look for companies
- 14:58with at least some forward momentum.
- 15:01It steers you away from just buying cheap stocks that are
- 15:03actually in terminal decline. So when you put it all together,
- 15:06this jar approach it seems built for the long haul, maybe not
- 15:09always the flashiest, but solid. I think that's the key take
- 15:12away. Jor RP is about resilience.
- 15:15It's real power isn't necessarily about getting the
- 15:18absolute highest return in a roaring bull market.
- 15:21Sometimes pure expensive growth stocks might outperform then,
- 15:25but JARP strength lies in minimizing the damage during
- 15:30bear markets. During downturns that focus on
- 15:32reasonable price and financial health provides A cushion.
- 15:36And over a full economic cycle that often leads to smoother and
- 15:40ultimately better risk adjusted returns.
- 15:43Resilience is how you compound wealth effectively over decades.
- 15:46Minimizing losses can be just as important as maximizing gains.
- 15:50That's a powerful final thought. Now, Speaking of market
- 15:53conditions, for those of you interested in tracking the
- 15:55overall market temperature, you might want to check out the iOS
- 15:58app Buffett Indicator. You can find it in the Apple App
- 16:00Store. Yeah, the Buffett Indicator app
- 16:02can be a useful tool. It gives you a sense of overall
- 16:05market valuation, which can provide some context for your
- 16:07individual DARP investment decisions, helping you gauge if
- 16:10the market environment is getting frothy or looks more
- 16:12reasonable. Good point.
- 16:14And just our standard reminder, all the analysis we've discussed
- 16:18today is based on publicly available information.
- 16:21It's for educational purposes, OK.
- 16:23It's definitely not investment advice.
- 16:25Always do your own homework, your own due diligence before
- 16:28making any investment decisions. Absolutely.
- 16:30And hey, if you enjoyed this deep dive and want to hear more
- 16:33discussions like this, please subscribe to us on Apple
- 16:35Podcasts or Spotify. Just search for deep value
- 16:38investing.