Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Angry Bob & Good Mentors
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, I get a text from you the other week and you
- 0:05tell me that there's a New York Times article that is pissing you off.
- 0:09Yes, I forgot to bring it. I have it right in front of
- 0:11me, right, So let's go over that and find out what made you
- 0:15so angry. Yeah. Right, For the listeners out there, Bob just
- 0:19made two fists or two claw claw hands because he was so frustrated with the
- 0:25article. This article is called does Therapy Really Work? By Susan Dominus.
- 0:31So I'm just going to read sections. I I'm not going to read the
- 0:34whole thing, but there's different excerpts that I pulled. Over the decades,
- 0:39and especially since the pandemic, the stigma of therapy is faded. It has
- 0:43come to be perceived as a form of important self care, almost like a
- 0:48gym membership, normalized as a routine, healthy commitment and clearly worth the many
- 0:53hours and sizable amounts of money invested. Just so far, is it pissing
- 0:58you off? Yet? Gym membership sends a little well, I'm not a
- 1:03gym guy, so to me, that sounds like a little unimportant way to
- 1:07put it. And I think people should go to therapy if they need to,
- 1:11but not everybody needs to. So I think that's a big glib Yeah,
- 1:15it's a little dismissive. On one hand, I celebrate the fact that
- 1:21people are much more likely to go to therapy. I mean, you don't
- 1:25live online, really, but you should know that the phrase I talked with
- 1:30my therapist the other day is a very frequent phrase that you will hear from
- 1:34influencers, podcasters, YouTubers, actors, famous people. I would guess most
- 1:42of the famous people that you know of, directors, actors will talk openly
- 1:48about going to therapy in a healthy, humble manner. And that was not
- 1:55the case when we were younger. Correct, Yes, no, it wasn't.
- 1:57Yeah, I mean we're old and and we've been therapists long enough to
- 2:00remember when just saying that we were a therapist or a counselor was a way
- 2:07to shut down a conversation because everyone would be like scared of us, or
- 2:12they would be skeptical of even our profession. What are we doing, or
- 2:17or you just talk to crazy people or something. And it's really different now
- 2:23in our pocket, but in the West coast, on the West coast,
- 2:27but it is something that I celebrate. On the other hand, the tone,
- 2:30especially knowing where she kind of goes with this the way she words it,
- 2:35because you know, she's a New York Times author. She knows how
- 2:38to read, she knows how to write between the lions, if you will,
- 2:42and she says, yeah, almost like a gym membership normalized as a
- 2:46routine, healthy commitment and clearly worth the many hours and sizable amounts of money
- 2:52invested. So that last little bit just emphasizes that people are spending many hours
- 2:59and sizable amounts of money, isn't it. I mean it's not untrue,
- 3:05yeah, but it's just interesting that you would emphasize that you do. Okay,
- 3:08So in twenty twenty one, forty two million adults in the United States
- 3:13sought mental healthcare of one form or another, up from twenty seven million in
- 3:17two thousand and two. So just chiming in here, So there are what
- 3:22three hundred and fifty million people United States? Yes, so that's like one
- 3:28seventh and that's like thirteen percent. Huh yeah, yeah. I guess when
- 3:36I think anecdotally or within my circle, I would say that's low. But
- 3:39when you think about the entire population United States, including young people, adults,
- 3:46people living in Oklahoma, people living in Los Angeles. That's that's that's
- 3:50interesting, right in twenty Yeah, so in the span of one year,
- 3:53not having you know, in twenty twenty one, forty two million adults.
- 3:58Yeah, and especially during the pandemic, right, Yeah, Increasingly Americans have
- 4:02bought into the idea that therapy is one way they can reliably and significantly better
- 4:08their lives. Okay, hundreds of clinical trials have now been conducted on various
- 4:14forms of talk therapy, and on the whole the vast body of research is
- 4:18quite clear talk therapy works, which is to say that people who undergo therapy
- 4:25have a higher chance of improving their mental health than those who do not.
- 4:28So that's good, good to mention. Right. So I'm skipping over a
- 4:32lot of the article because there are long sections where she raises these questions of
- 4:39efficacy. But I just included that last bit because that was the conclusion the
- 4:43body of And as I was reading the article, because I knew that you
- 4:48didn't like it, so I was I was reading for what it was that
- 4:54was pissing you off, and I was wondering if the article was going to
- 4:59state a therapy doesn't work, because you will hear people will say stuff like
- 5:02that, and I just wanted to highlight that she did acknowledge. You know
- 5:08that hundreds of clinical trials and now I've been conducted and talk therapy works going
- 5:13on here, the body of scholarly work on therapy may show inflated effects.
- 5:18Okay, so now she starts into her thesis of does therapy work. I
- 5:26mean she states earlier that it does, but then I guess maybe she's starting
- 5:30to scrutinize the consensus opinion or something as a journalist that doesn't know anything about
- 5:35the field. Pim Kypers wrote in twenty twenty one meta analysis confirming that therapy
- 5:44was effective in treating depression compared with controls, but he also found that more
- 5:48than half of the patients receiving therapy had little or no benefit, and that
- 5:54only a third entered remission, meaning their symptoms less than enough that they no
- 5:58longer met the studies creat area for depression. Given that patience or assessed just
- 6:03one to three months after treatment started, Kuipers said he considered these results a
- 6:08good success rate, but he also noted that more effective treatments are clearly needed
- 6:14because so many patients did not meaningfully benefit, meaning that many people with depression
- 6:21did not benefit from the therapy that was provided. Falk Lyson, Ring and
- 6:28Christine Steinert surveyed studies comprising some six hundred and fifty thousand patients, So another
- 6:34meta analysis suffering from a broad range of mental illnesses end quote. After more
- 6:42than half a century of research and millions of invested funds, they wrote,
- 6:45the impact of therapy and medication for that matter, had on patient symptoms was
- 6:49limited. What do you think about this? Well, he kind of could
- 6:56get in the weeds here about well, what was the what was the link
- 7:00the clinical trial? What do they consider limited improvement? But you know,
- 7:02I've just keep thinking about that line from City Slickers, you know that film
- 7:06City Slickers. It's like, spend fifty weeks getting knots in your rope and
- 7:11you expect two weeks to kind of untie them. It's not going to happen.
- 7:14And I think about me, and I thought, I think, man,
- 7:17I spent the first twenty years of my life getting knots in my rope.
- 7:21I don't really expect them to untie too easy, particularly because of you
- 7:26know the way the brain is, and so I think this was this.
- 7:30The way this is written, it's too sweeping and condemning, and it cuts
- 7:35out some of the nuance. Now, I do have a bias. I
- 7:38believe in therapy kind of drink the kool aid if that's a that's kind of
- 7:43a crap way to put it. But um so, I think that the
- 7:46average reader is not going to see this, is not going to see this
- 7:50properly. So it bugs me. Yeah, especially given how many people are
- 7:57already skeptical of mental health right and general. At first, I was assuming,
- 8:01of course, that you would not like this article as a therapist,
- 8:05because it means your profession, your work, your life's work, and your
- 8:11clients. But it could also demean yourself as a client, someone who has
- 8:16invested a lot of time and money in the enterprise of therapy, and to
- 8:24have this journalist just flippantly say you've been wasting your time, Yeah, it
- 8:30would be upsetting you. It's just a journalist, a journalists who wrote an
- 8:33article for the New York Times magazine that's going to get a wide readership.
- 8:37Yeah. The thing that I'll say about this take is that it's all true.
- 8:43That they will find, for example, this highlighted met analysis and it's
- 8:48not cherry picking. This meta analysis by Pim Kuypers is representative of a lot
- 8:52of studies. If anything, it highlights that therapy actually works because you'll do
- 8:58a meta study on other kinds of therapy or for other kinds of conditions and
- 9:01see lower rates of remission. But just reviewing what she writes here twenty twenty
- 9:09one met analysis treating depression compared to controls, and by controls, they usually
- 9:15are either no treatment at all or they go to therapy with someone who what
- 9:22they call supportive therapy, where the therapist listens and does a lot of Rgerian
- 9:28listening, and then the treatment group are going through a specific usually CBT with
- 9:35depression or something right. So he also see he found that therapy was effective
- 9:41in treating depression comparing compared to controls, but he also found that more than
- 9:46half of the patients receiving therapy had little to no benefit, and then only
- 9:50a third entered remission, meaning that it was long term. So of the
- 9:56of the different groups of people, so you could say there's a group of
- 9:58people who went to the treatment, there's a group of people who just went
- 10:01to supportive therapy that arguably could be conducted by a non clinician, just someone
- 10:05who listens for an hour a week. And then depending on how they manualize
- 10:11the supportive therapy right on the different studies, and then there's a control group
- 10:16that didn't go to therapy at although the waiting list group, they'll often refer
- 10:20to them as that. And so what this is indicating is that for the
- 10:24treatment group long term remission of symptoms, you have about a third and then
- 10:28of the supportive therapy group usually maybe say twenty percent, fifteen percent, I
- 10:33don't know. It's usually that because the supportive therapy is helpful, you know,
- 10:39someone to talk to you. Plus some people just for other factors have
- 10:43remission and depression. You know, maybe their life improved, or their biology
- 10:48improved, or they just figured things out on themselves. You know, there's
- 10:52a lot of other factors that can lead to someone having a remission and depression.
- 10:56And then the weight list group might be say five percent or something seven
- 11:01percent improvement over time. So it's not like the other control groups had zero
- 11:07improvement. Usually there's there's some there's some change. Yeah, So the difference
- 11:13between the controls and the treatment group let's say, you know, in the
- 11:16order of fifteen twenty percent different, so you have a ten percent without any
- 11:20of a thirty three percent with the treatment group, and you think, okay,
- 11:24well that's pretty low success rate, pretty low effectiveness, right, and
- 11:28that from the outside, if you don't know what is happening on the inside,
- 11:33then that that sounds pretty depressing, if you will, right, Like,
- 11:37how do you hear it? Michael J. Fox raised two billion dollars
- 11:41for Parkinson's. That's really amazing. And we don't have a we don't have
- 11:46a cure for Parkinson's. And nobody looks at that and says, well,
- 11:48yeah, we have got we got these crap treatments. They're not really all
- 11:52that helpful. They just keep at it. And the same thing with Jerry
- 11:56Lewis. He used to do that telethon, you know, for muscular dystrophy.
- 12:00I guess probably billions of dollars too. I don't really I don't actually
- 12:01know. And you know, there's improvements, there's incremental improvements. I mean,
- 12:07this is therapy is what one hundred and fifty years old, roughly one
- 12:09hundred and seventy years old, maybe somewhere in there, but but not that
- 12:13old, and our understanding of the human psyche is m boy. I'd kind
- 12:20of like to be alive one hundred years from now to see what it is
- 12:22that we understand. And I think we got a good handle on the just
- 12:26on the fundamental of it, but there's probably a lot more to learn.
- 12:28So and you know, like people that get cancer go see an oncologist and
- 12:33the cur rates are really not so great, but they keep at it.
- 12:37They keep at it, they keep at it, and we make incremental progress.
- 12:41That's what I don't like about this argument this article is it's not talking
- 12:43about incremental progress. It's sort of just doing a report card. Well therapy
- 12:48gets to see. Well, come on, man, it's stupid. I'm
- 12:52in passion darning. That's a good thing. It makes for a good podcast,
- 12:58Bob. So it makes you angry, Yeah, man, it's just
- 13:01stupid. It's like a poorly written article. Yeah, this article really did
- 13:05piss me off. It's poorly written and it's conclusions are faulty. Yeah,
- 13:09and what really bugs me about it is someone's going to read and say,
- 13:13ah, yeah, fuck it, therapy. I'm not going to that,
- 13:16you know, because it doesn't really work. And depriving themselves of something.
- 13:18I don't necessarily need my depression to remit entirely in order for me to think
- 13:22that my experience in therapy was successful. And people that do therapy like you
- 13:26and I do it well. See, how do I want to say this.
- 13:31I don't really want to beat my chest. I don't want to be
- 13:33self aggrandizing, but I'll say this in my therapy, the thing that's been
- 13:39most helpful is my therapists have loved me. And I don't know how to
- 13:43quantify that. I don't I don't know how. I wish. I wish
- 13:46someone write an article about that, because to me, that's where the money
- 13:50is. And she's just writing about results and talking about gym memberships. It's
- 13:54just kind of shitty and as you said, dismissive. Yeah. A very
- 14:00similar thing one might say along these lines of this author is that pastoral care
- 14:07or end of life care never saves someone's life. They all one hundred percent
- 14:13of them die. So why are we doing end of life care? Right?
- 14:18Why are you talking to the patient as they contemplate their death over the
- 14:24next week. It's a worthless endeavor. It's a highlighting of this very reductionistic
- 14:31American version of quote unquote success without acknowledging the realities of life. Right,
- 14:39that there's a lot of people who are depressed. There's a lot of reasons
- 14:43to be depressed, and to have someone love you while you're depressed is apparently
- 14:50valuable enough that people keep spending all this time and all this money on right,
- 14:56Otherwise people wouldn't be doing it, right, I mean presumably so.
- 15:03Yeah, And it also is painting a picture of therapy as being this really
- 15:09simplistic thing, and the presenting problems are really simplistic, the kinds of things
- 15:16that people come into therapy for. You know, there's a a In fact,
- 15:22I'm confident in saying this. I don't know if I've ever said it
- 15:24like this before, but I in my entire career, I would say less
- 15:28than one percent presented a problem to me, meaning that they sat down on
- 15:33my couch and said I would like help with X that involved something in the
- 15:37DSM. More than my clients sit down on my couch and what they asked
- 15:45me to help them with has nothing to do with the DSM, right,
- 15:48maybe a V code from the DSM four, But those are kind of silly
- 15:54things. So so, so then what where are we there? Yeah,
- 15:58there's no treatment protocol and there's no or there's very few randomized controlled trials for
- 16:07the kinds of things people coming. You know, sometimes they'll get categorized.
- 16:10It's like self factualization or something. But it's it's it's even different than that.
- 16:14I mean, the measurement for the success of therapy that I employ and
- 16:19I'm pretty sure you do as well, is I asked the client is it
- 16:23worth it to you? Is this helpful? Has this been a waste of
- 16:27time for you? Or not? And if they say that it hasn't been
- 16:33a waste of time and they do find value coming and it is worth their
- 16:37time and money, then I say, all right, let's let's keep going.
- 16:41Yeah, I know, and if not, then then if not.
- 16:45And sometimes those are related to specific kinds of things. And sometimes obviously there
- 16:48are ancillary goals like anxiety or PTSD or borderline or something, discernment as to
- 16:56whether or not you should break up or not, infidelity, covery, lower
- 17:00conflict. You know, there are concrete things, but the I don't know
- 17:06what to say. But anyway, so let's go on with the article.
- 17:11Here. Tallen has started to wonder. So that's some sort of skipping forward
- 17:19in the article. Yeah, Tallen has started to wonder if it's time for
- 17:23research to shift away from talk therapy towards more innovative strategies for depression. There's
- 17:29some evidence that therapy plus psychiatric medications is more effective than therapy or medication alone.
- 17:36Bob, what do you think about that? Yeah? Yeah, right,
- 17:38you know, the gold standard for treatment of OCD is CBT plus med's
- 17:42great. I'm on Webby Try night, you know, and webbi Tran saved
- 17:47my baking about twelve years ago. I was really suffering. I hadn't been
- 17:51depressed like that since I was twenty five, and so I am ProMED.
- 17:55And I still don't like this sentence. It's too innovation. I don't.
- 18:00That doesn't sound very innovative to me at all. That sounds like that's like
- 18:03old school. Yeah, we've fucking known this for fifty years. Yeah,
- 18:08that's not innovative. Yeah. And the medications that we have been using for
- 18:14depression in particular also have not changed for decades. Yeah, very much.
- 18:18Prozac. I remember when prozac came out, and let's see nineteen ninety one,
- 18:25that's when it started to be used. Really probably probably poured before that,
- 18:29but but that's when it entered into my zegeist, and that was people
- 18:34still use prozac. Yes, well, well the class of SSRIs Oh yeah,
- 18:38there's a lot of SSRIs Prozak being one. Ye, So this notion
- 18:45I just went. There was a podcast called Invisibilia, Oh yeah, yeah,
- 18:49that I really liked at first, and then they started getting into therapy
- 18:53and they had this one episode about therapy that was just so stupid that the
- 19:02journalists, the two women, had no idea what they were talking about,
- 19:06and the experts quote unquote that they had on their podcast were not knowledgeable about
- 19:12how to talk about therapy. I mean they had like a psychoanalyst or something.
- 19:17And it was not that psychoanalysts are stupid, but when I see journalists,
- 19:23it's almost like they have this idea and they start with a thesis,
- 19:27right, and then they just get experts to kind of support that, and
- 19:30then they put it out yeah, instead of just asking an actual expert,
- 19:34what do you think about this thesis? Right, and the expert would say,
- 19:37well, it's actually way more complicated than that, and let me give
- 19:41you some context. And then and then they can actually figure you know,
- 19:44there's another angle there. There's a lot of things to write about. I
- 19:47mean, for God's sake, I've been yammering into this microphone as a as
- 19:51a pseudo journalist for fifteen years and I never ran out of topics to touch
- 19:56on. So there's a lot of things to get into. But you don't
- 20:00have to just make something up and then look for information to support it.
- 20:03And of course, while I'm listening to this podcast and while you're reading this
- 20:07article, you just you know, put yourself in the shoes of the masses
- 20:11and know that they have no idea that what they're being fed is a bunch
- 20:15of bullshit. Yeah, so I just this is when I got to the
- 20:19article, and I just thought, was this when Bob got upset, because
- 20:23you know, Tallen has started just Tallen some expert that she's interviewed. Tallen
- 20:30has started to wonder if it's time for research to shift away from talk therapy
- 20:34toward more in innovative strategies. And I think, well, yeah, there's
- 20:40a lot of researchers that are looking into all sorts of things and guess what,
- 20:44none of it fucking works. The you know, transcranial magnetic stimulation.
- 20:51Does it not work well? It has some seeming effects for things like epilepsy
- 20:57and maybe treatment resistant oppression for a minority of people. I'm not up on
- 21:03the research, but if we had such technology, you and I would hear
- 21:07about it. If all you had to do is hook your brain up to
- 21:11a magnet or something or stimulation, and suddenly everyone's PTSD was done. You
- 21:15know. It's similar with psychedelics. You hear about these claims about psychedelogy and
- 21:19you're just and I'm just like the date that data doesn't show that this is
- 21:22going to be a panacea. Yeah, so, yeah, of course we
- 21:27have this, and I just the hubrists of people who from the outside of
- 21:33an industry will claim that, you know what, maybe psychiatry should look into
- 21:40this. It's like, yes, what do you think they fucking are doing?
- 21:45For years, there are researchers toiling away on an underfunded research group because
- 21:52their mom died of suicide and depression, and this researcher has dedicated their entire
- 22:00life and that's one of thousands of people, and you, from the outside
- 22:03suddenly had an idea that maybe someone should look into it. Thank you,
- 22:07So much that that's just great. And then and then uh, you know,
- 22:11for depression. This is Susan the journalist for depression. There's there's some
- 22:15evidence that therapy plus psychiatric medication is more effective than therapy or medication alone.
- 22:22There's not just some evidence. There's a shit ton of evidence, and we
- 22:26all understand that, and that's the standard of care. And the key is
- 22:30talk therapy is involved in that. Yeah, right, Yeah. It doesn't
- 22:33say psychiatric medication is better than talk therapy. It says that them together work
- 22:38better than And this is on average. By the way, there's tons of
- 22:41people who would benefit from one or the other better than if there were both,
- 22:45right, so it's just on average. Yeah, yeah, Okay,
- 22:49she says there's some evidence that is a bug. Yeah yeah, going on.
- 22:53David tollen director of the Anxiety Disorder Center at the Institute of Living in
- 23:00Hartford, Connecticut, He believes that researchers should be focusing more attention on drugs
- 23:04that work in novel ways, such as one that has been shown to stimulate
- 23:10the same neurons that are active during cognitive behavioral therapy. Okay again, dah
- 23:15yeah, thank you David Tollin, and thank you journalist for pointing out something
- 23:21that we all understand, all right, going on the most significant difference and
- 23:25patient outcomes, Wombpole says, and Wompole actually is a known author. The
- 23:30significant difference in patient outcomes, Wobpole says, almost always lies in the skills
- 23:34of the therapist rather than the techniques they rely on. Hundreds of studies have
- 23:38shown that the strength of the patient therapist bond, a patient sense of safety
- 23:44and alignment with the therapist on how to reach define goals is a powerful predictor
- 23:48of how likely that patient is to experience results from therapy. So, just
- 23:52drimming in here, we call that the working alliance or the therapeutical alliance,
- 23:56and it involves three things. It involves a consensus on the goals of therapy,
- 24:02a consensus on the tasks to reach those goals, and a strong bond,
- 24:06strong enough bond between the therapists and the client. Yeah, but what
- 24:08distinguishes the therapist most likely to But but what distinguishes the therapists most likely to
- 24:15forge these bonds is not intuitive? But what distinguishes the therapists most what Wompole
- 24:22says that some of the attributes that would seem most salient a therapist agreeability.
- 24:27Years of training and years of experience do not correlate at all with effectiveness of
- 24:33care. Any thoughts on this, Yeah, it could be. I mean
- 24:36I've met burned out therapists, so they kind of the years of experience and
- 24:40whatever, but that none of that talks about do you love your client?
- 24:45Like do you love your client? And as you help me? But you
- 24:48know this better than I do. But I think young green therapists can be
- 24:52very very effective simply because we're not simple, because but in part because they
- 24:56are very enthusiastic and are interested in the turned on and they're motivated in working
- 25:03with their people. So I keep I keep coming back the same damn thing,
- 25:08which is when you want to raise kids, you got to raise them
- 25:11with love. And if you don't raise them with love, you fuck them
- 25:15up. So if you want to help people who are fucked up, you
- 25:18have to love them. You have to. I mean, how it seems
- 25:22like stupid to think anything else, because what do humans respond to? They
- 25:26respond to love, and love isn't just like this this airy fairy woo woo.
- 25:30You know, It's like love is a very active thing. To do.
- 25:36It requires a great deal of paying attention, paying good attention. I
- 25:40can love my clients now better than I could even five years ago, simply
- 25:45because I have five more years of practice and training and consulting with you,
- 25:49and you know, all the things that I do thinking about I think about
- 25:53my clients all the time, thinking about them. Being in my own marriage
- 25:57has taught me a lot about how to love my clients. So actually,
- 26:00what it's done is it's increased empathy. Because you know, if you chew
- 26:04the dirt, it's it's easy to see someone else is chewing the dirt.
- 26:08So yeah, so I wish somebody would talk I wish she whoever wrote this
- 26:15thing would have talked about that. Yeah, beautifully said think and well emphasized.
- 26:21The thing that I'll add is that this passage is fine. I don't
- 26:26think this is a bad thing to put out there. It's complicated, and
- 26:32I worry that the readers, the lay readers, wouldn't really comprehend what's being
- 26:37told to them here. Yeah, but it is true that when we look
- 26:41at our profession as a whole. And the thing that I like to compare
- 26:47this too, is if we imagine doing an effectiveness study of every physician in
- 26:52the country, including dentists. So any medical profession imagine saying how effective is
- 27:03medicine? Okay, well, what is the goal post? What are you
- 27:07saying is effective? Because we've already been over that. Some people are terminally
- 27:12ill and are definitely going to die in the next month, So how do
- 27:18we gauge success? And of course you can have perfectly healthy people come into
- 27:21the hospital and there could be an accident and they can die. So is
- 27:26death the thing that we measure the entirety of medicine? Symptom reduction? What
- 27:30are the different conditions? Pancreatic cancer is not very at this point treatable,
- 27:36So are we saying we're lumping that in with like simple skin cancers that could
- 27:41be prevented with proper preventative care, brained ankles, Right, so what are
- 27:47we talking about? Therapy involves arguably more variety of clients and more variety of
- 27:53goalposts than what medicine does, or at least to a similar extent. Yeah,
- 27:59right, So when we measure effectiveness of therapy, what are we talking
- 28:03about? But okay, fine, so maybe you measure it by asking clients
- 28:08if it was worth their time or something, or they improved on whatever it
- 28:12was that they came in, Okay, And what they find is that the
- 28:18much more important factor in determining the variance between success and not success in therapy
- 28:26has to do with this working alliance, therapeutic alliance, and has much less
- 28:32to do with the particular modality of therapy. That's interesting. Yeah, And
- 28:37what in the article they talked the Dodo bird of effector meaning that from Alice
- 28:45in Wonderland, there's a everyone wins. I can't remember exactly how this story
- 28:48goes, but it's this parable of no matter who enters the race, everyone
- 28:55wins is essentially and that's ridiculous, right, Like there needs to be someone
- 29:00and if everyone wins, then maybe no one is winning, or maybe everyone
- 29:06is thinking they're on a race that doesn't actually exist or something. Yeah,
- 29:10and so it's easy to conclude based on those findings that therapists aren't really doing
- 29:15anything right, or they're doing something that is very much secondary to what they
- 29:21think they're doing. You know, the effectiveness of their therapy has to do
- 29:23with listening and a bond and has almost nothing to do with the particular theoretical
- 29:30modality. You know, whether it be psychoanalysis or CBT or humanistic or something,
- 29:33right, and it is worth contemplating for us, and it certainly should
- 29:40put it into context because a lot of people will one be very focused on
- 29:44their modality. And of course you have in fighting where those you know your
- 29:48your model is dumb. But when you look at the at least the aggregate
- 29:52data, all models are equally good, if you will. Yeah, but
- 29:56again this is lumping every single client of every single type into one large pool.
- 30:02If someone comes in with borderline and you proceed to do ten weeks of
- 30:07cognitive therapy, it's probably not going to help their borderline very much. Right.
- 30:12It might help in a way, It might help them with emotional regulation,
- 30:17it might be a first step or something, but it's not going to
- 30:19have any long term remission of symptoms. So and if someone comes in with
- 30:26a phobia and you proceed to psychodynamic oriented therapy or attachment based therapy, it's
- 30:32not going to do shit for the fucking phobia. So treating all clients the
- 30:37same, treating all modalities the same is really silly. So there's that.
- 30:41And the other thing is that there is variance based on the modality, so
- 30:47it's just less than these other factors, the relationship, the working lines,
- 30:52and the thing that I also will say is that the working alliance is completely
- 30:59within known forms of therapy. H The concept of the working alliance emerged out
- 31:03of psychodynamic therapy and arguably humanistic therapy. So this idea that all the models,
- 31:12so you know, this idea of the dichotomy where you have this working
- 31:15alliance thing where you talk about bond and collaboration, and then you have all
- 31:19the models of therapy that are separate from that. You know, having a
- 31:22good bond is central to attachment based therapy is central to at least a particular
- 31:29brand of psychoedonymic therapy is absolutely central. Well, I don't know if it's
- 31:33central, but it's definitely a byproduct of humanistic therapy. Rogers and Gastal in
- 31:37this kind of thing. So that's what always bugs me as well. You
- 31:41could argue that what they're finding when they're finding that the model, the particular
- 31:47model, doesn't work, but the relationship matters more than the model. What
- 31:52they're discovering is that psychodynamic, attachment based humanistic therapy is the best form of
- 31:57therapy for most clients. Not for everyone, but for most clients. You
- 32:01know what I mean, I do. Okay, take a break, all
- 32:07right, back from the break, So just a little bit more of the
- 32:10article here, right. The answer struck me as yet another frustrating unknown in
- 32:15the field. I had, perhaps as a long time consumer of therapy in
- 32:20search of reassurance, I had perhaps hit my limit with the disputes among the
- 32:24various clinicians and researchers, the caveats, and the debates over methodology. So
- 32:30actually I thought this was the best written and the most wise section of the
- 32:36article that I think. It's the final paragraph. So she's talking about how
- 32:39she's been to therapy, and she had talked to a lot of people,
- 32:44you know, presumably she did a lot more research than she highlighted in her
- 32:46article. And she is saying she hit she hit her limit with the disputes,
- 32:52the research she's quoting, No, she's quoting herself. The research seems
- 32:57very baggy. Have you have you heard that word before? Baggy that I
- 33:00don't know. I think she means like loose or something. Okay, oh,
- 33:07baggy, Right, the research seems very baggy, I said, not
- 33:12bothering to hide my frustration. It's not very satisfying. So I think she's
- 33:16talking to an expert in this moment. It's not very satisfying. The research
- 33:21seems very baggy, you know. I think the author was at least proposing
- 33:25to look for an answer as to whether or not her time in therapy was
- 33:29worth it or something, and she found a lot of different claims according to
- 33:32the expert. You know what, I'm thinking. What she had to talk
- 33:37about that with her therapist. Yeah, exactly. I could practically hear a
- 33:42smile on the other end of the phone from the expert. Well, thank
- 33:45you, Anderson said, that's what makes this research so interesting, that there's
- 33:51no simple answers. Right, A handful and then at the end of the
- 33:54quote, a handful of well chosen words. And I felt soothed. So
- 33:59bet now she's equating this expert as helping her go through the emotional process of
- 34:06not finding a firm answer in the research that she did. Right, it's
- 34:10a elegant reframe. Right, A handful of well chosen words by Anderson.
- 34:15And I felt soothed, even touched by his positivity, which included with that
- 34:21question mark at the end of his sentence, a hint of inclusiveness confronted with
- 34:25my clear annoyance, he had offered me a non defensive, constructive, and
- 34:30positive response, which I mean it just shall I say, humanistic, attachment
- 34:35based, psychodynamic should we were in this together. The exchange made me think
- 34:40of the best hours I spent in therapy, times when I felt the depth
- 34:45of a therapist caring, or experienced the reframing of a particular thought that I
- 34:50hadn't even known could be cast in so different a light. So at the
- 34:54end of the article, yeah, right, what do you think of that
- 34:57ending? Good ending? A little bit? Yeah, I don't know.
- 35:02I don't like this article. She's writing it like she went on some personal
- 35:07journey. I think it was very limited in short journey. And she's a
- 35:10writer, so she has to write something right, So I'm dissatisfied with the
- 35:15thing. On the whole. I was listening to a podcast and they were
- 35:20journalists themselves. I can't remember what podcasts it was, but they were talking
- 35:22about how when they pitch a story to their editor yea, that their editor
- 35:28would always say, it might have even literally been the New York Times,
- 35:30the editor would always say, where's the conflict or something like that, Right,
- 35:35where where's the controversy? There needs to be a fight within the article.
- 35:40You can't just say I did this thing and discovered everything's fine. Like,
- 35:44there has to be some kind of rub. And so this article,
- 35:47when you read the final paragraph, it looks like it's a manufactured rub,
- 35:52right it does. Yeah, where she starts out questioning things, then she
- 35:58kind of cherry picks experts that highlight the quote unquote problems in this simplistic,
- 36:02almost silly way. Yeah, and then in the end it concludes that,
- 36:09well, maybe therapy is worth it, but it's not as simple as I
- 36:15wish it were that kind of a thing. Yeah, you know, like
- 36:17when we were kids, did you did you ever writer see a kid write
- 36:22one of those stories about having this like awful, awful experience and then the
- 36:24end is and then they woke up and it turns out it was all a
- 36:28dream. This is kind of like that. Not too impress with this article.
- 36:32Yeah, all right, let's read some emails. Yeah, anonymous patron
- 36:38from Canada, She says, fellow Asian therapist here in Canada, I wanted
- 36:43to get your thoughts on how to cope with feelings of incompetence as a therapist.
- 36:46It says something that ever goes away. I think my insecurities as a
- 36:52therapist were also compounded by being a person of color in a white dominated field
- 36:58and not getting the proper guidance and super vision I needed. Just chiming in
- 37:02here, Yeah, I have had people come to me and also tell me
- 37:07and email me that their training and their supervision was poor and insufficient, which
- 37:15it does not surprise me given my anecdotal experience of the field. True supervision
- 37:22and good education and deep helpful mentorship is rare, apparently. I feel like
- 37:30it wasn't, at least anecdotally for you and I when we started out in
- 37:34the nineties. I feel like we had people that would shepherd us. I
- 37:38mean Paul David, my early mentor. He forced his membership his mentorship on
- 37:45me. I mean not forced, but I was not seeking it. I
- 37:47wouldn't you out of a crowd. Yeah, I wouldn't. I wouldn't have
- 37:51thought to ask him, you know. And he really forced the issue,
- 37:57and I was happy about it because I thought, why me? But so
- 38:00much of my early career was based on his help, and a lot of
- 38:06my insecurities were also helped by him. He just always believed in me.
- 38:10He just never questioned anything and would highlight things that I was doing well,
- 38:17which I'm sure he must have seen some problems because he didn't observe my work
- 38:22as a therapist that much, but as a professor, he was right there.
- 38:25I taught under him for a year and he would watch me teach,
- 38:31and I'm sure it was brutal, but he was always complimentary and nice and
- 38:37highlighted what I was doing well. And that was a big deal for me,
- 38:42because you know, in the beginning when I started teaching, I was
- 38:44just like, oh, I remember, I was just like, I'm stupid.
- 38:46I don't know what I'm doing. You would get so so nervous about
- 38:50teaching a class, so you remember specifically, Oh, I remember being in
- 38:52your apartment over there. I'm Ridian, and you were getting ready to go
- 38:57and you were telling me about how nervous you felt class. And it wasn't
- 39:00the first time you taught it. Yeah, yeah, you weren't there the
- 39:04first time I was teaching because I was all by myself in the depths of
- 39:07an anxiety attack. Oh man, and I was very close to pulling the
- 39:13plug and saying, Paul, I can't because it was an unpaid assistant professorship.
- 39:19And I didn't have to do it, but I felt beholden to him,
- 39:23you know. Ironically, a very similar thing happened about my foray into
- 39:28being a musician. Was I was, you know, just a regular kid
- 39:32and a jock if anything, in high school. And my girlfriend, who
- 39:37was a couple of years older than me, she was known for being a
- 39:42performer and a singer and an actress and all this stuff. And I was
- 39:46I was her boyfriend, who was this jock, you know, and she
- 39:50wanted me to sing with her in the talent show a duet. Yeah.
- 39:53It was somewhere out there the song from American Tale, Yeah, with Linda
- 40:00Roden's dad and umah no no, um. I can't remember his name,
- 40:07but I mean it could be that, but I don't think it's anyway.
- 40:09The point is is that, you know, somewhere out there beneath the pale
- 40:13moonlight or something, and I thought a duet, Like you understand, I'm
- 40:16not a singer, right, but she had heard me sing with the radio,
- 40:21which I would do sometimes, and she thought that I'd be able to
- 40:23pull it off. And I thought that's absurd. Yeah, I mean that
- 40:28now looking back, I'm like, well, of course I can. I
- 40:30can sing because i've I've been singing my thing. But at the time that
- 40:35was not a part of my identity. I literally never sang in front of
- 40:39anyone really in that way, you know, just and plus I'm terrified of
- 40:44the stage, which is a big part of why I was terrified of being
- 40:46a professor. And so I would have, under almost any other circumstance declined
- 40:54even if I wanted, because you know, there's a part of me I
- 40:57was like, oh, that'll be kind of fun, is to see how
- 40:59it goes. But I did it because of how much I wanted to please
- 41:04her. I just wanted her to be happy with me, and so I
- 41:09did it solely on that. And I was so nervous about to go on
- 41:15stage, a very similar panic or anxiety attack about my first time teaching.
- 41:22And I was a hairs with the way from just running away and having her
- 41:28seeing the duet by herself, which she would have done fine. She would
- 41:31have improved this boy girl duet thing. And she she would have you know,
- 41:37she would have managed. She didn't need me as a thing, and
- 41:40she wanted to do it with you. She did, and and I did
- 41:45it, and it got me over that hump. And then you know,
- 41:46I was still nervous on stage after that, but it got me over that
- 41:52that hump. And it just makes me wonder at times now, in particular,
- 41:55if you know, my Sarah, my high school girlfriend, and Paul,
- 42:00my mentor in my early career, hadn't pushed me and hadn't and if
- 42:07the relationship were different, like if you pressured me to do something, I
- 42:09wouldn't do it because I don't I'm not afraid of you. So it was
- 42:19it was a particular style of relationship that I had. I mean, Sarah,
- 42:22I wasn't abusive, but I was you know, I was fifteen,
- 42:28she was like eighteen or something, and I just looked up to her,
- 42:31and so I and with Paul, like already back then in the nineties,
- 42:37he was this god in the field, and so I just was so desperate
- 42:43to please him. So if it hadn't been for the style of relationship that
- 42:47was cultivated, if they hadn't pressured me, would I be a musician,
- 42:52Would I be a professor? Would I be a podcaster? Because being a
- 42:55podcaster and grew out of me being a professor, right, So it's just
- 43:00it's bizarre to think. Yeah, but they're but for the grace, right,
- 43:05yeah, yeah, yeah. So the person that wrote in is saying
- 43:08that, you know, in a mill, in a white person dominated field,
- 43:14that they feel like they doubt their own competence. I'm I getting it.
- 43:21What's been your experience with working in a white dominated field. Well,
- 43:24I'm half white, so that helps. And also being a guy also is
- 43:32maybe more of a noticeable difference than my colleagues, So that would have an
- 43:38effect if I were to extend my Asian person of color, you know,
- 43:44experiences to what it would be like to be full Asian it you know,
- 43:49there's a lot of racism, and there's a lot of stereotyping, there's a
- 43:52lot of reductionism. People will I got a lot of Asian clients referred to
- 43:55me in the beginning, which I was happy because I was I'd take anyone
- 43:59in the beginning. But it felt funny because I'm fourth generation Asian American,
- 44:06which is you know, particularly well, and the Asians that would be referred
- 44:08to me were Asian nationals, you know, people that were born in Korea
- 44:13and China mainly, And the other thing is like just treating all Asians the
- 44:15same as if Japanese immigrants are the same as Korean, the same as Chinese,
- 44:22and creating or even just treating all Chinese immigrants as the same. I
- 44:27mean, there's this vast difference between different subgroups of China. You could argue
- 44:31that there are more differences between subgroups in China than there are in all of
- 44:37Europe. Between the different It'd be like treating French people and Bulgarians as the
- 44:42exact same sort of people, you know what I mean. Yea, So
- 44:45it's a bit of a silly thing there. So yeah, I mean,
- 44:47there would be stuff like that. There would be a kind of assumption that
- 44:54I was more cognitive or intellectual or something, which I guess could be in
- 45:00my favor. You know, people have a stereotype, not everyone, of
- 45:05course, but I think there's a there's a stereotype of what the archetype of
- 45:12a therapist is. And the archetype is a white woman, middle aged with
- 45:16very comfortable shoes, you know, And that's the stereotype. And I'm guessing
- 45:23there's a good number of you listening right now who are middle aged, white
- 45:28women therapists with comfortable shoes there's something wrong with that. No, but I
- 45:31got all of that except for the women partner. Yeah, very comfortable.
- 45:35Probably a purple shawl in there somewhere, you know what I mean. I
- 45:37remember I gave my mom and cardigan when she got out of graduate school for
- 45:42Christmas purple. It was royal blue. Okay. Yeah, So I think
- 45:47there's another archetype, which is someone like you who is an older, white,
- 45:52middle aged white guy with comfortable shoes. Very and Asians don't fit in
- 45:59there. When you think of the archetype of a therapist, you don't think
- 46:02black people, you don't think Asians, you don't think Hispanic people, And
- 46:09so I think there was some problem there, right, and also just role
- 46:15modeling. It Even adults need role models, right. You know, there's
- 46:20a reason why when I would go to certain communities in Seattle and talk to
- 46:25black kids, that one hundred percent of the boys, or I don't know,
- 46:30maybe the boys their career plan was to play in the NBA. Because
- 46:37for them, black guys who were successful and famous and seem to have it
- 46:43all that were following the laws and weren't a drug dealer were playing in the
- 46:49NBA. Right. And of course that's not the only place where you can
- 46:52look. But it was a compelling gravitational force for these young boys, right,
- 46:58and thus school didn't really matter. I mean Lebron James was drafted.
- 47:02I think his after his was he okay, I mean he didn't he he
- 47:07didn't he got drafted. He didn't graduate from college and then get drafted high
- 47:12school like um, you know, like Michael Jordan whatever something. Yeah,
- 47:15And so for these young men, for these teenage boys, um to them
- 47:22like that that was one of the only ways to get self respect or to
- 47:27have some security, to be attractive to women and to not be a loser,
- 47:30you know. And so for Asians, Asian men, where are our
- 47:37role models? You know, where are the the Asian men who can be
- 47:42a gravitational force for other Asian people to enter the field and to feel like
- 47:49you're not an impostor that that you belong. Right, Like, if you're
- 47:52I'm guessing a white Jewish person in New York, you probably feel like you
- 47:58fit in psychoanalysis or therapy in general, right, because so many white Jewish
- 48:02people have come before you in the field. So it's just there's that kind
- 48:07of thing. But but honestly, when anonymous Patron Canada talks about not feeling
- 48:14very competent and will it ever go away, I would say that that's just
- 48:20kind of normal. I don't know. I don't know any white person who
- 48:22is who feels competent as a as a therapist. I think that it takes
- 48:30a long time and there's just so much to learn. There's I would say
- 48:35for myself, and I had an accelerated process because I was a professor and
- 48:39had to learn the stuff so I could teach it. Yeah, and a
- 48:43supervisor. So I had an accelerated and I was a nerd about it,
- 48:47and that, you know, being a podcaster actually really accelerated too. And
- 48:52added to the fact that I have two master's degrees and a doctorate, like
- 48:55there's a lot of time spent. And I would say that it probably wasn't
- 49:01until after my doctorate that I actually crested a hill where I was like,
- 49:07yeah, I think it all is galvanized in my head now. I think
- 49:10I feel like it's really coming together for me. Like I think about some
- 49:14of the papers that I wrote, and this would have been in you know,
- 49:20so this would have been twenty twelve, like halfway through my doctorate and
- 49:25that would have been like fifteen years into the field. So so I'm fifteen
- 49:30years into the field as a professor and a therapist. And I think about
- 49:32this one paper that I wrote for Phil Cushman, by the way, you've
- 49:37heard people have heard me talk about him. He died last year, and
- 49:39it was ignorant. I wasn't there yet. I didn't really understand the big
- 49:45picture of therapy. And I was also kind of relying on this arrogant sense
- 49:52that I could just make stuff up instead of actually following the greats, you
- 49:57know, and then making stuff up, Like you have to understand the greats
- 50:00before you can make shit up. You can't just make shit up and or
- 50:05at least it's not likely to work. And so I was just making shit
- 50:08up because I thought, well, can't we all just make shit up?
- 50:10And I didn't understand the bigger picture? And um so, and that's fifteen
- 50:15years in of being a therapist and a professor and a supervisor. What kind
- 50:19of feedback do you get it in the paper? Well, Phil, I
- 50:21think I about have told you this before. I know, I've talked about
- 50:22the podcast. His primary feedback was, I'm unconvinced that's awesome. Yeah,
- 50:29that's just awesome, A great a bit of feedback. Yeah, it was.
- 50:35It stung, but it was motivating. Yeah, because he's saying,
- 50:38convinced me. Yeah, And I'm not gonna just check mark. I'm not
- 50:44going to just say good paper, interesting premise. I'm gonna tell you go
- 50:49back to the drawing board. He invited you into a into dialogue and into
- 50:52growth. He invited you. Yeah that's a good teacher. Yeah yeah,
- 50:55and he was very complimentary. Phil Kusherman was, you know, sort of
- 51:00my later mentor, and he was also very nice and he he I wish
- 51:07I had met him. Yeah, well you kind of have. I mean,
- 51:08I a lot of If you ever hear me say something smart, it's
- 51:14from Phil. Yeah. When you look back on that paper, do you
- 51:22look at it like, Yeah, I was unconvinced. I'm unconvinced. Well,
- 51:25not only was I unconvincing, but I was arrogant to think that I
- 51:30possibly was being convincing. Yeah, maybe it was. And as subsequently I
- 51:37would see similar It was a rare profile of student, but I would come
- 51:43across future students that were like that too, and it would particularly tweak me
- 51:49because I know I'm capable of that. You know what I mean, of
- 51:52course, and uh but anyway, Yeah, so this is just anonymous patron
- 51:58in Canada. So I'll tell you when I reached the point where everything started
- 52:02to integrate. I would say it would be around twenty fifteen ish or something.
- 52:08And I still have a lot to integrate after that. I mean,
- 52:10I had yet to make my attachment deep dive. I had yet to do
- 52:15my deep dive on and a personal I had yet to learn about other schematherapy.
- 52:21I had yet to learn scheme of therapy. But by that point I
- 52:23had, I had integrated trauma. That was another thing. Twenty twelve.
- 52:29I had yet to really understand trauma and really understand how to treat trauma.
- 52:34Even though I would have proposed that I was an expert and I was probably
- 52:37better than a lot of other people in treating trauma, but I was ten
- 52:42percent down the road of understanding. Yeah, And a lot of that learning
- 52:45I attribute to a mentor. He was more of a colleague mentor, Bill
- 52:52Hoisler. He's a good friend of mine, but he also knows a lot
- 52:54of stuff, but it is very humble about it, and helped me with
- 52:58that if people are associated with Antioch, they know Bill. He still teaches
- 53:00there. Good guy in the program or the Yeah and the Doctor program.
- 53:06He started out as a mental health counselor like yourself, and a police officer,
- 53:10I believe, and then went back to get his doctorate and became a
- 53:15psychologist and became a professor of that kind of thing. He's he's a real
- 53:20charming guy, knows you know, knows a lot about DBT and trauma and
- 53:23psychoanalysis and collaborative therapy. He's really big on, like on solution focus,
- 53:29and he's a collected you know, all the stuff. Yeah. Anyway,
- 53:32So I would say that is around twenty fifteen when I crested the hill,
- 53:37or I thought I did, and maybe later on I'll look back and say
- 53:40I hadn't yet really crossed, but I kind of feel like I did.
- 53:44I feel like I finally was able to pull a lot of things together and
- 53:49understand the bigger picture while zooming in at times, you know what I mean,
- 53:52And mind you, this is eighteen years or sorry, twenty years because
- 53:58I started my masters in nine, so we have twenty years of being of
- 54:06two master's degrees, a doctorate, you know, years of study, years
- 54:09of writing papers, years of reading, years of teaching. And then I
- 54:13was and I was a therapist, mostly full time, but part time at
- 54:19times, but pretty robust part time therapists for eighteen of those years. Then
- 54:22I was a professor for eighteen of those years. I was a supervisor for
- 54:27you know, sixteen of those years. And I was also a podcaster by
- 54:30that point of eight years, which provided me or seven years. It provided
- 54:34me a lot of time to kind of get into some stuff. So that's
- 54:37a fuck ton of effort in time, and a lot of people helping me
- 54:42along the way. Good mentors I came. I had a lot of shitty
- 54:45professors and a lot of and a lot of shitty supervisors at the very least
- 54:51mediocre and some abusive. So I was lucky and also cultivated. Tried to
- 54:59cul devate these mentorships when they were when they were working. Well, it
- 55:02was a slog for twenty years. And then I felt competent and then I
- 55:06felt confidence in my competence. Fantastic, But that highlights just how much work
- 55:12it takes. It takes a lot of work. Yeah, a lot of
- 55:15work. So the person who wrote in I'm thinking similar cultivate good mentorships,
- 55:21get people who believe in you and who are willing to teach you. I've
- 55:24had several I I feel very, very lucky to have had the kind of
- 55:30learning, but I had to seek it out. A master's degree is a
- 55:34quick and dirty way to get a license. It is a good start.
- 55:38But if that's where, if that's where training ends, I'd be floundering in
- 55:43the dark, not even knowing why, and probably very unhappy and burned out
- 55:46by you know, miss miss attunements, missing, missing too much. So
- 55:54I've spent a lot of time getting training after graduate school and finding people.
- 56:00And you do a lot of thinking as well, Like you don't just leave
- 56:05it at the office. Oh no, I don't. I carry people around
- 56:07and think about them all the time. And you iterate on your learning in
- 56:13session with clients. Yeah, you're not just lazy and sit back and rely
- 56:16on your old no pattern. Yeah no, that's really gratifying, very gratifying.
- 56:22But I'm as long into this as you. I don't have a lot
- 56:27of the experiences you have had my own path and journey, and it took
- 56:30a long long time, Like I think I studied a couple therapy for while
- 56:34I've been learning and practicing that for twenty three years. I'd say I only
- 56:37got pretty good at it, reasonably good at it in the last five but
- 56:43not for lack of trying, and not for lack of shiny moments along the
- 56:45way, and a lot, a lot of teaching, a lot of learning,
- 56:47a lot of really good trainers who very kindly shepherded me. So yeah,
- 56:55very similar to you is there were people that helped me on the way,
- 57:00and I'm forever grateful, lovely folk. Yeah, you're the sort of
- 57:05therapist that at a party when you're relaxing, you might actually talk with me
- 57:10or someone else about being a therapist about what it's like, what you're learning
- 57:15or because there's another type of therapist that doesn't do that, where they're just
- 57:19like which is fine because they just want to relax, but it helps to
- 57:23accelerate one's competence and confidence to be a nerd about the profession. I love
- 57:30that be a nerd about the profession. And if there's some people listening that
- 57:36don't feel like they're nerdy and the profession and they are in the profession.
- 57:39What I'm not talking about some sort of innate drive, but inspiration, you
- 57:46know it. Presumably every therapist was inspired by something that touched them deeply.
- 57:52And if you can tap into that, if you can have the landscape to
- 57:58play and to be motivated. A lot of clinicians are so pigeonholed into a
- 58:04particular career path, or isolated from mentors, or they're introverted themselves, or
- 58:10they're not. You know that I have the privilege of maybe even being a
- 58:16guy. You know, maybe the fact because all that my mentors are men,
- 58:21and maybe they were just looking for another guy to you know, there
- 58:24was a bit of like Phil Cushman. He was a football he was really
- 58:29into football and h and later became a therapist. It's just like me,
- 58:34you know what I mean. He was known as as a kid, as
- 58:37a jock, you know, in San Diego, and I, uh,
- 58:42we had a similar kind of viber around that around that. Yeah, And
- 58:45so I probably had the privilege of being a guy. I'm tall. I
- 58:52don't know if that makes me stick out a little bit more or something.
- 58:55I don't know. I've always carried a kind of confidence, even though I'm
- 59:00not particularly confident, arrogance. I don't know what it is, but maybe
- 59:06that helped. So I'm not saying that everyone has a level playing field when
- 59:09it comes to this, but encourage people to have another factor along these lines
- 59:14is actually before that, I had a stint for some time at a chemical
- 59:21dependency treatment center. So I had already worked with a lot of addiction and
- 59:24had a lot of education around that. But you know, I was the
- 59:29only non chemical dependency treatment professional on staff. There were a lot of dual
- 59:34people who were chemical dependency professionals and also therapists and psychologists, but I was
- 59:40the only one that wasn't a chemical dependency professional and got a crash course in
- 59:45their profession and addiction and just the ground level of what it's like to be
- 59:52with a variety of different presentations of addiction and their families. And I would
- 59:57do psychological assessments and I would supervise a lot of the folks, and so
- 1:00:01I learned a lot there too. So there were these you know, these
- 1:00:06these moments, you know, my my work with the perpetrators who were convicted
- 1:00:09of a crime and had to they were mandated into my group, you know,
- 1:00:15as a similar kind of experience that you just you know, you can
- 1:00:17learn about domestic violence, you can learn about intimate partner violence. But going
- 1:00:22through something like that is a thing, you know what I mean. Yeah,
- 1:00:25but it kind of took me a while to kind of integrate that as
- 1:00:29well. Like when I was there, I was absorbing a lot of data
- 1:00:32that didn't really integrate until maybe even decades later, I don't know. Another
- 1:00:38part of this is last year with the Johnny Depp amber Heard trial. That
- 1:00:42was a whole thing too, and that also helped integrate a lot of things.
- 1:00:45It actually made me look back not only to my work with perpetrators,
- 1:00:50but also look back to my my education and experience with forensic psychology with providing
- 1:00:55testimony and stuff, because I'm trained to do that, wow, And I
- 1:01:00didn't want to do that, so I stepped away from that work, in
- 1:01:02that education, in that field. But the trial helped me to learn that
- 1:01:07again, to refamiliarize myself with the MMPI scales and all the different kinds of
- 1:01:15anyway, sou But for you, Bob, when was it? What year
- 1:01:21would you say? And maybe I had a different kind of bell or different
- 1:01:24kind of learning curve than I did, but when would you say you could
- 1:01:29confidently say I am competent at this job. I feel like I don't have
- 1:01:35to work as hard to just be good at this job. Two years ago
- 1:01:40really so twenty one, twenty one, So what happened? I don't know
- 1:01:45what did it feel like? I noticed I would come out of my office
- 1:01:49at the end of the day and Collin would say how to go, and
- 1:01:52I'd say, I was soft and sharp, soft towards my people, but
- 1:01:57sharp, like mentally sharp. And I started saying that more and more often.
- 1:02:01And I also noticed that I wouldn't feel so anxious or irritated. A
- 1:02:07lot of that has to do with, you know, consulting with you.
- 1:02:10And now I'll still get my cage rattled occasionally, but um, not not
- 1:02:16much in the last two years. But a pivotal thing for me was I
- 1:02:21had I had one hundred and fifty hours of EFT supervision with my friend Lillian,
- 1:02:28Lillian Buchanan, great therapist down And just to put that in context,
- 1:02:30So a typical stint of supervision, you know, might be fifty hours or
- 1:02:36something. Yeah, one hundred and fifty hours. So is that one hundred
- 1:02:39fifty weeks? Yeah, so three years of one hour a week. Yeah,
- 1:02:45And if the supervisor is good and really gets into it because you know,
- 1:02:49there are a lot of supervisors that'll phone it in. No, she
- 1:02:52was She would not phone it in by any stretch. No, she taught
- 1:02:54How did she help you? She taught me a lot. She taught me
- 1:02:58a lot about softening up and um, but but what do you mean by
- 1:03:04m? Yeah? What do I mean? And by the way, can
- 1:03:07people hire her before I forget? Yeah, she's in Texas. Now,
- 1:03:09what's her name? Lillian Buchanan And she does IDT supervision. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:03:15she's one of their Factum. I was one of her supervises when she
- 1:03:20was going through that certification training. So. Um, so she's like all
- 1:03:24supervisors. Um, she's part therapist. So I you know, i'd have
- 1:03:30stressors in my marriage and this would be predominant in our meetings from time to
- 1:03:34time, not often. And she watched me, um do it. She
- 1:03:38watched a lot of video of me teaching me working. And she was unfailingly
- 1:03:45supportive. She was I wouldn't say she was ever critical of me, but
- 1:03:51she wasn't afraid to say that she didn't think that that was working, or
- 1:03:54that she thought I should consider something else. Did she believe in you?
- 1:03:59Yeah? Yeah, yeah, yeah, she did. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:04:02really really, She's very kind to me, and I've had a few good
- 1:04:08supervisors. Her and my old friend David Taylor supervised me for the first six
- 1:04:13years in my career. Yeah, you know, I think that is a
- 1:04:15central feature of good supervision. Mentorship. Yeah, Paul and Phil and Bill
- 1:04:24is I mean Bill, there's a chance that Bill might even be listening.
- 1:04:27So I don't even know if Bill would consider himself we're colleagues, but he
- 1:04:32didn't. He did, mentor I did. I did. I did look
- 1:04:34up to him. Hey Man, for a time, I got that with
- 1:04:38you, but with Phil and Paul, it was all one directional. I
- 1:04:42was always looking up to them. Yeah, that was never I never felt
- 1:04:46that collegial with either one of them. So with them, they believed in
- 1:04:54me, you know, not like they said everything I did was great,
- 1:05:00but they believed in me. And as a supervisor and professor mentor myself,
- 1:05:04it was about halfway through my career that I discovered that that mattered to people.
- 1:05:09I knew it intuitively as a mentee myself. But I'll then forget.
- 1:05:15I had a student and she was taught. She was toward the end of
- 1:05:20her master's degree and she I think she brought up that she and a person
- 1:05:26of color, by the way, again, maybe that matters. She was
- 1:05:30saying, you know, interns are pretty insecure and in a survival mode usually,
- 1:05:36and they're just they just hope that they get through it, right,
- 1:05:39and they're not usually thinking about bigger goals with their career. And she was.
- 1:05:43She was, I think, saying that she wanted to be a professor
- 1:05:45and an author, and you don't usually hear that from interns, right,
- 1:05:49And she wasn't arrogant or narcissistic. She just had a seed of a question
- 1:05:56of just like, I wonder if I could do that. You know,
- 1:06:00I'm not there yet, but I wonder if I could one day be a
- 1:06:03professor and be an author. And when she brought this up to me,
- 1:06:09I had a beat to kind of think about it and think about what she
- 1:06:14was saying and think about maybe where this was coming from from her, that
- 1:06:17it wasn't just this pipe dream, and I intuited in the moment that this
- 1:06:23was a big deal to her. And so I said to her, Yeah,
- 1:06:27I think you'd be a fantastic professor. Now do I know that?
- 1:06:30No, but I did in my mind highlight because I didn't know her very
- 1:06:34well. The people that were in my case consultation class were typically in that
- 1:06:38class for fifteen months, so and the class is only five six students,
- 1:06:43so you get to know each other pretty well. Yeah, and I knew
- 1:06:46enough about her to know that there were a lot of strengths about being a
- 1:06:50professor and an author. That she had a good mind, she had a
- 1:06:55lot of experiences, She was a very she had a charismatic to her.
- 1:07:00She you know, she could compel an audience. You know, she was
- 1:07:03driven. I could see a lot of strength, and I could see it.
- 1:07:06Did I know that she could succeed as a professor or an author?
- 1:07:10No, I didn't know. But but I took a beat to in my
- 1:07:14not just say, but to highlight in my soul, in my heart,
- 1:07:16what qualities that I saw in her that would aligne with being a professor and
- 1:07:21an author. And I didn't even say much. I just said something like,
- 1:07:26you know, maybe a few sentences that was supportive of that and believed
- 1:07:29in her. Yeah, it was not hard for me to do. Months
- 1:07:32later, she comes to me and she's crying and she says, I proposed
- 1:07:36my dream to other professors, other supervisors. You were the only one that
- 1:07:42said what you said, Wow, you know what, It makes me cry
- 1:07:45thinking about it. And she said it was like I can't. It meant
- 1:07:49a lot to her and she became a professor and an author. Hey wow
- 1:07:55her. Now, of course it has little to do with me. It
- 1:07:58has everything to do with her, but I at the time. So she
- 1:08:00tells me this later on, and I'm like, wow, you know,
- 1:08:04we downplay ourselves as supervisors with it. You know, they don't really care
- 1:08:09what we think about them. It's not that big of a deal, but
- 1:08:12they do often. Yeah, And to fully understand that, to fully understand
- 1:08:17that when you're in a position as a supervisor or even just a colleague,
- 1:08:20to believe in someone, to say that you're proud of them, to say
- 1:08:25that, know that they have this ye, to see someone's strengths, to
- 1:08:30see someone's power is one of the best gifts that you can give someone that's
- 1:08:35under end, one of the best gifts that you can receive. And those
- 1:08:38gifts that we received, where would we be if we didn't have those gifts?
- 1:08:43Are so at some point two years ago, what were all the things
- 1:08:46that led up to feeling confident because it wouldn't it wouldn't just be EFT training
- 1:08:50and just this supervisor. Well that was a long journey though. I started
- 1:08:55learning EFT in two ten, two thousand ten, and I took a one
- 1:09:01week class, came back from that kind of inspired, but didn't want to
- 1:09:05do the certification stuff, so put that off. But found another class actually
- 1:09:10that Lillian taught for six months, and then hired her as a supervisor.
- 1:09:15And then I went and did the certification training, which I thought, I'm
- 1:09:19just gonna, you know, finished this out because I already know all this
- 1:09:26stuff and yeah, right, yeah, and so but I'll just do this
- 1:09:30because I want to beef up this part of my practice or whatever. Nope,
- 1:09:32learned a lot. I had two really good teachers in that. It
- 1:09:35was over four weekends over about nine months. I flew to Toronto and Laurie
- 1:09:43Brubaker. I love Lourie and Gail Martin that's my other teacher. So at
- 1:09:47the end of that, but but you're thinking about you're saying this thing about
- 1:09:51how mentors can be encouraging. Gail needed a ride to the airport, so
- 1:09:56I drove her to the airport. I was going there myself and on the
- 1:10:00way, she's like, have you considered becoming a supervisor? And this is
- 1:10:03like just finishing up that certification star, I wouldn't even certified as an EFT
- 1:10:09person. I just finished the coursework and I was like no. She's like,
- 1:10:15well, yeah, I have to think about it, because you'd probably
- 1:10:15be all right and you probably could do that, and that'd be a good
- 1:10:18thing. It's just really delightful to me. Made me feel really confident.
- 1:10:21You didn't become a supervisor. Not no, I think I might be able
- 1:10:25to do it. Yeah. Yeah, But the thing the thing about that
- 1:10:29is is my countertransference of being oh I'm responsible and this thing about faith that
- 1:10:33you and I talked about the other day, Um oh yeah, yeah,
- 1:10:39that was so strong. Back then. I don't think I could have been
- 1:10:42all that helpful to anybody. I would have been too brittle. But I
- 1:10:45think now I could do it. I don't know that it's really my calling,
- 1:10:49but I could do it. But in any case, getting getting certified
- 1:10:53in that so credential that I hang on my way. It's the only thing
- 1:10:56I actually credential wise, I have hanging on my wall as my EFT certification
- 1:11:00and my diplomas and whatever, though those are just in a closet somewhere.
- 1:11:03Does your Antioch diploma look like mine? Yeah? Yeah, that the small
- 1:11:06size, Yeah yeah, yeah, it looks just like that. Yeah yeah
- 1:11:10yeah, Um, it's in my closet. Well, so I'm guessing that
- 1:11:15all the hard work that you did prior to that as well, all the
- 1:11:19clients you worked with, the DBT class that you had, Yeah, that
- 1:11:24was that was something other supervisors. Did you have other important mentors prior like
- 1:11:30in graduate I mean you had, I know, you had one supervisor that
- 1:11:32was important to you, Pam, I don't know. Oh, well,
- 1:11:38so who was important to you in the beginning. In the beginning, Um,
- 1:11:43Roger Rozario was the supervisor at the mental health clinic I worked at when
- 1:11:46I first came here. Was he a mentor? Yeah? And a really
- 1:11:49good guy and encourage me to go to graduate school? Yeah? Actually got
- 1:11:54I lost my job. Yeah. Because anyways, so let's take a break
- 1:11:58and in the middle of this, and when we get back, let's continue
- 1:12:01this conversation. What do you say, Bob, Yes, all right,
- 1:12:08we're back from the break. And to be clear, what I mean by
- 1:12:11mentor for you people, out there that are wondering, is it's like a
- 1:12:16parental figure who cares about you know, and maybe you only meet up once
- 1:12:21a week for an hour, so they're not constantly in your life, but
- 1:12:27they And I write about this in my supervision book and in my exploration of
- 1:12:31what's a really good book? Thanks? What's it called again? It's a
- 1:12:35terrible title, multi Role Clinical Supervision. Yeah, yeah, it's a good
- 1:12:45book. Yeah, it's it's not a yeah, I stand by the book.
- 1:12:50It's it's concise, it's research based. I sprinkle in a lot of
- 1:12:55my personal experiences. You helped me write a lot of it. And one
- 1:13:00of the multi roles to the nineteen roles, which is kind of an odd
- 1:13:03number, but you know what you're gonna do. Prime number one of the
- 1:13:06nineteen roles is to be a mentor and very important one. There are other
- 1:13:12related roles that we're talking about. A good listener is another role that you
- 1:13:15need to be a teacher, like a true teacher, because a lot of
- 1:13:19supervisors they think they're just signing off on ours and signing your notes and making
- 1:13:26sure that you're filling out your paperwork, and that is a part of that's
- 1:13:28one of the roles of multi role clinical supervision. But now can every supervisor
- 1:13:33be a mentor now? Because it just you need a good fit. Not
- 1:13:38every supervisor has time or the effort or something. Maybe you don't even want,
- 1:13:42Like if I somehow needed to be supervised right now, I don't know
- 1:13:45if I would want someone to put that much effort into me or something anyway,
- 1:13:49So it depends. But there are people listening right now, perhaps even
- 1:13:54an anonymous patron Canada, who have literally never had a mentor, and they
- 1:13:59might even be twenty five years into the professional, but definitely in the first
- 1:14:01few years of the profession. Yeah, and research even shows this that mentorship
- 1:14:09is a huge factor in satisfaction and success in our field. So how do
- 1:14:15you find a mentor? It's hard, you know, at Antioch, at
- 1:14:18least in the past, maybe they still do. Hopefully they still do.
- 1:14:20They have mentor Day where actually they'll have mentors show up and then students and
- 1:14:26other people will also show up and they'll be kind of a get to know
- 1:14:29each other session so that people can connect with one another in continue mentorship.
- 1:14:33Yeah. Wow, that's cool. Yeah, so there's that. You can
- 1:14:38also just reach out to someone you can also hire someone as a supervisor,
- 1:14:42so so it's a win win, you know, you give them money and
- 1:14:45they give you mentorship. Yeah, and uh, you know it's it's I
- 1:14:50guess similar to therapy in that way. You can also be mentored by a
- 1:14:55therapist. You know, therapists can have that vibe with which even if you're
- 1:14:59not a clinician and right, you can kind of think of your therapist as
- 1:15:01a mentor. So that's true. Uh, yeah, that's that's pretty But
- 1:15:05anyway, so you learned a lot during your the first decade of being a
- 1:15:13therapist outside of the mentorship with the fella that you mentioned. Yeah, were
- 1:15:17you acquiring data that became integrated later or was it just kind of coasting in
- 1:15:25a sea of confusion and being overworked. It was more than coasting in the
- 1:15:29sea. It's you know, it's such an evolution. I can't say it
- 1:15:33was this or that or that. There was some kind of plan, thoughtful
- 1:15:38plan. I sought out training and stuff that I wanted to learn about,
- 1:15:43Like I made effort to get trained. I mean, you learned a lot
- 1:15:45about exposure therapy and CBT and stuff in the beginning, so that was helpful.
- 1:15:50Yeah, I sought that training out and then, but in terms of
- 1:15:55your deeper knowledge that you know now about attachment was not not growing at the
- 1:16:00time. Now, I can't even say in my EFT training that that was
- 1:16:03much of an element of emphasis, though in retrospect I think it ought to
- 1:16:09have been. Well. EFT presumably is based on attack. It is,
- 1:16:12it's based on but but the talking about that is um not so over it.
- 1:16:16Yeah that yeah, yeah, I find that too, and that you
- 1:16:20know, I think that that's a failing that it ought to be more present,
- 1:16:26Yeah, more overtly present. Yeah, and I think it might depend
- 1:16:29on the teacher. Yeah, because certainly Sue Johnson, the figurehead of EFT
- 1:16:34currently oh yeah, talks about attachment a lot all the time. Yeah.
- 1:16:39Yeah, that's interesting. So if you hadn't taken a turn into couple therapy
- 1:16:44and EFT, you might still be in a sea of confusion and being overworked
- 1:16:49and uninspired and burnt out and not as effective and not yet not as understanding
- 1:16:57what I what I understand now. Yes, that maybe even not in therapy,
- 1:17:01the sort of the type of therapy that you know now you need.
- 1:17:04Yeah, that's yeah, that's true. It would be a lot different.
- 1:17:09It would be a lot different. Yeah, I'm really lucky. So it's
- 1:17:12almost like marriage of family therapists are better than counselors. Yeah, of course
- 1:17:15they are, right, but their football team sucks. It's just funny to
- 1:17:21think, you know that your entrance into marriage of family therapy. Yeah,
- 1:17:27because EFT is within marriage of family theory primarily. Yea, And that that's
- 1:17:33when your eyes are open, that's when the scales fell. I know.
- 1:17:38Is that's weird and true? Yeah, Like I undergraduate school in nineteen ninety
- 1:17:43five and didn't learn anything about attachment till probably about twenty fifteen. And yet
- 1:17:47that's the basis of everything I think about when I'm working with my clients and
- 1:17:51probably will remain. So I can't imagine that shifting too much, because you
- 1:17:56know, humans are basically human. Yeah. I think the moral of the
- 1:18:00story that I'm getting is that there's a few one as it takes a long
- 1:18:03time, yeah, which I don't think i'd ever really fully comprehend it until
- 1:18:09talking this out from myself and hearing from you. There are multiple paths to
- 1:18:15true integrated competence and confidence. You have to work at it, and you
- 1:18:19might not know you're on the path because if I, you know, if
- 1:18:21we would have asked you at the time while you're taking EFT, you'd be
- 1:18:26like, yeah, you know, it's good, I'm learning, and yeah,
- 1:18:28I feel like I get it and you hadn't really fully got it yet,
- 1:18:32and you just never know. It's similar for me if you would have
- 1:18:36asked me in twenty twelve, as I'm writing that arrogant paper, I mean,
- 1:18:40it wasn't terrible. I'm playing it up. It was. It was
- 1:18:42It's a fine paper. It was unconvincing. Yeah, I would have said,
- 1:18:47well, yeah, I mean, I've been a therapist and professors for
- 1:18:50fifteen years and the supervisor. Of course I know what I'm doing right,
- 1:18:58and I didn't feel lack of confidence while I was working with my clients.
- 1:19:03But yeah, you just don't know. You don't know, you don't know
- 1:19:06what you don't know. And to be okay with that, you know,
- 1:19:11to be okay as a preintegrated you know. I'm using the word integration because
- 1:19:16that's the best word I can use for that moment when it all kind of
- 1:19:20comes together, right. Yeah, And the phrases I keep referring, you
- 1:19:26know, returning to are seeing the bigger picture and being able to zoom in
- 1:19:30on a particular micro moment in therapy and frame it in the way that you
- 1:19:38understand humans to be in yourself and therapy, and then be able to zoom
- 1:19:41out and kind of know where is this, where does this fit within the
- 1:19:45various schools of therapy and research and the course of therapy and what am I
- 1:19:50missing? Maybe? And that that ability to see the bigger picture but also
- 1:19:56be present in the moment and be able to conceptualize it and verbalize it in
- 1:20:00a way that helps us to galvanize our own thoughts, you know, so
- 1:20:04we know what we're doing right, and so there's It takes a long time.
- 1:20:11Yes, it involves mentorship and hard work. You never know where you
- 1:20:16are on that path, and you just have to keep at it. You
- 1:20:21just have to keep learning. You just have to keep trying, and it
- 1:20:25requires effort and you have to be proactive, if you you know, for
- 1:20:30people who don't know, it's not normal for therapists like Bob to decide to
- 1:20:36go deep into a particular field or a particular training program post graduation. You
- 1:20:44know, most people with their continuing education requirements, they you know, they
- 1:20:47go to a training here, they're training there. But you made a choice
- 1:20:50of, like I'm going to really get into this, yeah EFT, which
- 1:20:55was outside of your profession by the way, like it was not within your
- 1:21:00professhion not to work with couples and to study EFT. So you actually,
- 1:21:05in a very you know, intentional way, decided to really stretch and take
- 1:21:12a leap of faith that this would be worth your time. If we could
- 1:21:15do graduate school over again, I probably would have just done that couple yeah,
- 1:21:19and family therapy program, right, Not that that would have it would
- 1:21:23have been a beginning, yeah, yeah, just a more suitable beginning.
- 1:21:27Yeah. I dabbled in, well dabbled. I've studied DBT for twenty five
- 1:21:30years during all that, and yeah what you had in my run yeah yeah,
- 1:21:36yeah, but but I wanted to learn that and threw myself into learning
- 1:21:42it. That was never going to be handed to me, though I did.
- 1:21:44I lucked out. I fell into a training at the clinic I worked
- 1:21:46at, and then pursued the shit out of it after that on your free
- 1:21:53time. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, that's the point. It's like you
- 1:21:57had to make a choice. Yeah, No one made you do it.
- 1:22:00You didn't even really have to do it. No, I could have coasted.
- 1:22:02I got if I had to. If I had coasted, I'm thinking
- 1:22:05about how I might have languished without that kind of I mean, I'm a
- 1:22:11guy, I'm kind of tall too, I'm why so who knows what kind
- 1:22:15of doors that opens for me? But I don't. That's a that's an
- 1:22:18invisible blessing to me. I actually can't see that very well. But I
- 1:22:23do know that if I want something, I'm gonna have to work for it,
- 1:22:27like like it it will require. And so I'm thinking about the person
- 1:22:30that wrote in and I'm hoping that they will seek out whatever it is that
- 1:22:34they're interested in, that they'll go find someone to teach him. I can't
- 1:22:39read read books and learn that way. That's not sufficient for me. I
- 1:22:43need somebody alongside me. I hope that they find mentorship at least in the
- 1:22:48thing that's interesting to them and then just pursue the shit out of it.
- 1:22:54Yeah, and this podcast is a part of that. Yeah, you and
- 1:22:59I and EA as clinicians will in a way, in a sort of a
- 1:23:04unidirectional way, if you will mentor normalize teach a lot of clinicians out there,
- 1:23:12people will I didn't know that this would I always knew that this podcast
- 1:23:16could help educate, but I didn't know that people would feel held emotionally and
- 1:23:24mentored in a way. You know, And people will email in, so
- 1:23:27there is some back and forth with some people, right and we answer emails,
- 1:23:31so you know, it's it's at least a synchronous mentorship in a sense.
- 1:23:35And that's one way. It shouldn't be the only way, obviously,
- 1:23:40but you know, that could be. Or if it's not this podcast,
- 1:23:43there are a lot of other clinicians who are podcasting and on YouTube who can
- 1:23:46also provide that, uh, they're not as tall. I don't know that.
- 1:23:54I don't you know, I don't know how tall these other folks are
- 1:23:57actually so, and you know, along those lines, if a part of
- 1:24:05being a nerd about this field is to listen to podcasts and watch YouTube channel,
- 1:24:11it makes it easy to be a nerd these days compared to when we
- 1:24:14were ye that passively. You just have to subscribe to three of the psychology
- 1:24:19podcast that that you vibe with, and then you just listen while you're commuting
- 1:24:24or doing the laundry and stuff. Just German hates perleg Yeah, and you
- 1:24:30absorb it. Yeah. So anyway, all right. The last little bit
- 1:24:34of the email here, an anonymous from Canada says, on a totally different
- 1:24:39note, I know you react to Love is Blind, the reality TV show
- 1:24:44on Netflix. Have you seen Love is Blind Japan? It's so different from
- 1:24:47the American version. It's really I'm really impressed with the participants ability to communicate
- 1:24:53maturely and empathize. Wow. End of email. Yeah. I have watched
- 1:24:58bits of Love is Blind Japan, and Stacy, my wife, watched the
- 1:25:01entire season seasons, and I would occasionally sit down and watch bits with her
- 1:25:09and she would say the same thing. And a lot of other people would
- 1:25:12email in and say, oh, you gotta watch Love is Blind Japan,
- 1:25:15and I one don't have the time. Probably to the value that I think
- 1:25:21I can add to the Internet is when I have when I watch scenes on
- 1:25:27these reality TV shows, and it gives me an opportunity to use it as
- 1:25:30a jumping off point to talk about clinical stuff. And the Love is Blind
- 1:25:35Japan although it did have seemingly and I asked Stacy, I was like,
- 1:25:39should I watch it? And SE's was like, because Stacy knows what sort
- 1:25:44of shows lend itself to the YouTube channel, and we basically decided that it
- 1:25:48didn't provide enough issues to actually comment on. There was too much health,
- 1:25:53you know what I mean? Too much health. Now a lot of people
- 1:25:55will say, well, how come you don't comment on health? And I
- 1:25:58do sometimes absolutely, But if that's all I do, it's it's not very
- 1:26:01compelling viewing, right, Like if I just watch a bunch of scenes of
- 1:26:06people being healthy or non toxic, then I'm just like, well, that
- 1:26:12looked good. Nothing to say there, or let me say what they could
- 1:26:16have done that would have been bad or so. I don't know. It's
- 1:26:18it's just it's not very it's not ray say so, but yeah, I
- 1:26:24would love to. There's there's so many shows, including this one, that
- 1:26:29are on a shortlist that if and when I get a clone, they will
- 1:26:32watch those shows. And everyone out there, take care of yourself because you
- 1:26:38deserve it.