Latest / Trumponomics / Are We Being Priced Out of Happiness?

Transcript

Are We Being Priced Out of Happiness? · Trumponomics

0:02
Speaker 1: Bloomberg Audio Studios, podcasts, radio news.
0:16
Speaker 2: I'm Stephanie Flanders, head of Government and Economics at Bloomberg,
0:20
Speaker 2: and this is Trumpnomics, the podcast that looks at what's
0:22
Speaker 2: happening in the economic world of Donald Trump, what's shaping
0:26
Speaker 2: the US and global economy, and what could happen next.
0:32
Speaker 2: This week we're talking about the Great Fun Shortage. You
0:36
Speaker 2: might think it was an odd topic. I mean, the
0:37
Speaker 2: cost of living, we know is still a major issue
0:40
Speaker 2: for households on both sides of the Atlantic, and definitely
0:43
Speaker 2: for Donald Trump approaching the midterm elections. But the cost
0:47
Speaker 2: of laughing, of having fun seems to be going up
0:50
Speaker 2: even faster than other things, and there are fewer and
0:53
Speaker 2: fewer places to lay your hands on it. The FIFA
0:56
Speaker 2: World Cup, which culminates this Sunday, the nineteenth of July,
1:00
Speaker 2: is a case in point. I mean, watch parties are fun,
1:03
Speaker 2: but for those of us like me who prefer to
1:05
Speaker 2: see their sports live, it's been a disaster. Game tickets
1:09
Speaker 2: leading up to the tournament were either incredibly hard to
1:11
Speaker 2: get hold of or ruinously expensive, often both, and the
1:15
Speaker 2: cheapest official ticket for the final this Sunday will cost
1:18
Speaker 2: thirty two times more than the equivalent ticket for the
1:22
Speaker 2: European Football Championship final two years ago. Now, if you
1:26
Speaker 2: have zero interest in football, you'll be completely fed up
1:28
Speaker 2: with hearing any further word on this topic. But this
1:32
Speaker 2: phenomenon being priced out of fun is part of a
1:36
Speaker 2: broader trend spelled out in a recent Bloomberg piece that
1:39
Speaker 2: got a lot of traction online by the reporter Ben Stevenman.
1:43
Speaker 2: As he points out, Americans are spending less time socializing
1:47
Speaker 2: than they used to. Over the past twenty years, America's
1:49
Speaker 2: lost two thousand golf courses and seven thousand bars and nightclubs.
1:54
Speaker 2: We're not just talking about leisure time in general, but
1:57
Speaker 2: the shared in person kind of leisure, live shows, family trips,
2:01
Speaker 2: nights out with friends. Time Youse surveys that have been
2:05
Speaker 2: run since the early two thousands show double digit drops
2:09
Speaker 2: in the hours spent by Americans on things like that,
2:12
Speaker 2: on arts, on sports, and social events. Now, this may
2:15
Speaker 2: be a business opportunity for some industries, but for everyone
2:18
Speaker 2: else it raises a bigger question. What happens to an
2:21
Speaker 2: economy and a society when people just can't afford or
2:26
Speaker 2: don't make time to have fun. Well, I'm happy to
2:29
Speaker 2: say I'm joined by Ben who wrote that piece. He
2:31
Speaker 2: writes about money and people for Bloomberg and is based
2:34
Speaker 2: in New York. Welcome Ben, thank you, happy to be here.
2:38
Speaker 2: And an economist who spent a large part of his
2:42
Speaker 2: career thinking about what makes people happy and more importantly,
2:45
Speaker 2: why it matters. Professor Lord Richard Layard, co director of
2:50
Speaker 2: the Well Being Program at the Center for Economic Performance
2:53
Speaker 2: at the London School of Economics and also the author
2:55
Speaker 2: of several books, including the Origins of Happiness and Can
2:59
Speaker 2: We Be? Professor Leon Richard, thank you so much for
3:03
Speaker 2: taking the time.
3:04
Speaker 3: My pleasure.
3:11
Speaker 2: Conferentent Ben, How did you come to this topic the
3:16
Speaker 2: Great fun Shortage.
3:18
Speaker 1: I've been thinking about happiness and community in America for years.
3:24
Speaker 1: When you look at the American Time You survey that
3:27
Speaker 1: ask people how they spend their time, you see these
3:29
Speaker 1: sort of very depressing trend in terms of how much
3:33
Speaker 1: work just socializing face to face. We're just doing it
3:37
Speaker 1: a lot less than we used to do. And it's
3:39
Speaker 1: been my hunch for years that like that is having
3:41
Speaker 1: major effects on us, on our politics, on our economy,
3:47
Speaker 1: and it doesn't seem like it's sustainable. But When I
3:51
Speaker 1: started the research for this particular piece, I was just
3:54
Speaker 1: really thinking about high gas prices and I was sort
3:56
Speaker 1: of like, oh, like, maybe this is making this summer
4:00
Speaker 1: a summer of scarcity, where people will be cutting back
4:03
Speaker 1: on vacations. And then I was surprised to see that
4:06
Speaker 1: people didn't really cut back that much on travel as
4:08
Speaker 1: much as you would think. People seem to really want
4:10
Speaker 1: to get out there. And I started looking at all
4:13
Speaker 1: the different ways people like to have fun, that gets
4:17
Speaker 1: them out of the house, that gets them out with
4:18
Speaker 1: their family or friends or the community, and just seeing
4:21
Speaker 1: the supply shrinking in area after area, industry after industry,
4:27
Speaker 1: And so that's why I wrote the piece.
4:29
Speaker 2: You just mentioned it there. There's there are two elements
4:31
Speaker 2: to this, isn't it. Sort Of there's less available and
4:34
Speaker 2: I guess often goes with this, but also just a
4:37
Speaker 2: massive increase in the cost of a lot of these
4:40
Speaker 2: events and this kind of activity. But what are you
4:43
Speaker 2: seeing driving those things.
4:45
Speaker 1: There's just the baseline of inflation generally is first of all,
4:50
Speaker 1: squeezing the sort of a fun budget. People have less
4:53
Speaker 1: money left over for discretionary purchases. That's one thing. The
4:57
Speaker 1: other thing is the fixed costs of running a hotel
5:00
Speaker 1: or a nightclub just sword. But then there's also a
5:04
Speaker 1: supply issue. We really don't build beachfront resorts in the
5:08
Speaker 1: United States anymore. We have thousands and thousands of miles
5:12
Speaker 1: of coastline and we don't build on places people can
5:15
Speaker 1: gather and have fun and then anymore. So then we've
5:18
Speaker 1: also had this inequality trend in the United States. So
5:23
Speaker 1: who ends up in those beachfront luxury resorts. It's the
5:27
Speaker 1: wealthy and the rest of us who maybe these are
5:30
Speaker 1: places you started bringing your kids to and now they're
5:34
Speaker 1: older and you really have to stop going to those
5:37
Speaker 1: beach towns and you got to find something else to do.
5:39
Speaker 1: So I think it's a combination of factors, and it's
5:42
Speaker 1: different for different kinds of fun. But I think it's
5:45
Speaker 1: a complex mix of dynamics that are really coming together
5:48
Speaker 1: in twenty twenty six.
5:50
Speaker 2: And demographics, I guess, is another piece of it.
5:52
Speaker 1: Yeah, there's just more people, there's just more people fighting
5:55
Speaker 1: over fewer spots.
5:57
Speaker 2: But I mean and also older people. You know, there's
5:59
Speaker 2: a chunk of people who are kind of entering retirement,
6:02
Speaker 2: who have all the money and maybe are also pushing
6:05
Speaker 2: up prices that way.
6:06
Speaker 1: Yeah, baby boomer is retired and they can't stop going
6:09
Speaker 1: on trips.
6:09
Speaker 2: So they're taking all the lounges on the beach.
6:11
Speaker 1: Yeah, the national parks are full of baby boomers with
6:14
Speaker 1: blots of free time, and there's just less sparts for
6:18
Speaker 1: everybody else.
6:19
Speaker 2: Richard, I thought you would be a sort of perfect
6:21
Speaker 2: person to talk about this too. You've always said happiness
6:24
Speaker 2: is what should be the ultimate yardstick of the success
6:29
Speaker 2: of an economy. I guess we're talking about fun, which
6:32
Speaker 2: isn't necessarily the same as happiness or good mental health.
6:35
Speaker 2: So how do you think about the connection between the
6:37
Speaker 2: kind of activities that Ben's talking about and the kind
6:40
Speaker 2: of happiness mental well being that you have focused on
6:45
Speaker 2: for so long.
6:46
Speaker 3: Well, all the research shows that social connections are absolutely
6:50
Speaker 3: central to people's happiness, and the social connections, of course
6:55
Speaker 3: depend on the amount of time that you spend on them,
6:58
Speaker 3: and so the time evidence that people are spending less
7:01
Speaker 3: time socializing is absolutely central to understanding the other huge fact,
7:08
Speaker 3: which is documented in the World Happiness Report that overall
7:13
Speaker 3: happiness has fallen in the US by more than in
7:17
Speaker 3: any other country other than I think fourteen out of
7:20
Speaker 3: all the countries in the world, and this is particularly
7:23
Speaker 3: affecting young people, and I think that that is a
7:27
Speaker 3: very bad omen for the future, because we know that
7:30
Speaker 3: the best predictor of a happy life is how happy
7:33
Speaker 3: you are when you're young. America has now dropped to
7:38
Speaker 3: sixty second position for happiness of young people, and I
7:44
Speaker 3: think all of this is connected with the growth of
7:47
Speaker 3: online living. So I very much agree with Jonathan Heights's
7:53
Speaker 3: line on this that the social media are having a
7:58
Speaker 3: poisoning effect on young people, and it's because young people
8:03
Speaker 3: use the more than older people that they are suffering
8:06
Speaker 3: more as a result. And we know that he showed.
8:10
Speaker 3: I thought it was extraordinary that over half of young
8:13
Speaker 3: people say they wish social media didn't exist, but they're captive.
8:17
Speaker 3: They have to go on them because everybody else is
8:21
Speaker 3: going on them. So there's a huge amount of evidence
8:25
Speaker 3: that time spent online is destructive of happiness for two reasons.
8:31
Speaker 3: I mean, one is obviously lack of social ordinary face
8:35
Speaker 3: to face social contact, which has been the way humans
8:40
Speaker 3: enjoyed themselves from the beginning of time. But also the
8:43
Speaker 3: negative side, the encouragement of social comparisons and comparing yourself
8:49
Speaker 3: with the perfect life of the influence, etc. So I
8:54
Speaker 3: think all of that is going into this diminution of
9:00
Speaker 3: and increase in unhappiness, which is particularly present in the
9:06
Speaker 3: English speaking world. People of course questioned whether social media
9:11
Speaker 3: are so important because they are prevalent in other parts
9:15
Speaker 3: of the world. I think what is so interesting is
9:17
Speaker 3: that the English speaking world has been particularly strongly affected,
9:21
Speaker 3: partly perhaps because of the way that the tech companies operate,
9:25
Speaker 3: but also that these are the societies where young people
9:31
Speaker 3: have broken away more from their families and are less
9:35
Speaker 3: controllable by their parents and parents' values seem to have
9:40
Speaker 3: kept social life going in Latin America other parts of
9:43
Speaker 3: the world in the way that they haven't in the
9:46
Speaker 3: United States and Britain.
9:47
Speaker 2: You've partly answered the question I would have asked you,
9:50
Speaker 2: but it does feel like, you know, large parts of
9:53
Speaker 2: Europe people are extremely online, but they don't seem to
9:57
Speaker 2: have had, certainly from your world happiness, which also Ben
10:01
Speaker 2: mentions in his piece, they don't seem to have had
10:04
Speaker 2: the same fall in unhappy in happiness.
10:06
Speaker 3: Well, the old English speaking world actually includes Australia and Canada.
10:11
Speaker 3: I think that it is to do with the fact
10:15
Speaker 3: of parents having more influence on young people's social norms
10:22
Speaker 3: in the rest of Europe as compared with Britain. I
10:25
Speaker 3: think that's a very very important fact.
10:27
Speaker 2: One of the things that you mentioned Ben in your
10:29
Speaker 2: piece is the potential political consequences of some of this,
10:32
Speaker 2: and I guess we'll get onto some of the policy responses,
10:37
Speaker 2: but in terms of the many reasons that you might
10:39
Speaker 2: worry about it, you cite and there's studies that show
10:43
Speaker 2: that voters are more likely to vote for populist candidates
10:48
Speaker 2: in years after social spaces and pubs and bars have
10:53
Speaker 2: closed down.
10:54
Speaker 1: Yeah, there are two studies, one from France looking at
10:58
Speaker 1: bar tabas the place to buy you can get a
11:01
Speaker 1: cup of coffee, or you can place a bet, or
11:03
Speaker 1: just buy a newspaper that thousands of those in small
11:07
Speaker 1: French towns have shut down and it actually takes a while,
11:11
Speaker 1: it's not an immediate effect. But when those places closed down,
11:16
Speaker 1: according to this new study, in the next decade or two,
11:20
Speaker 1: those places become gradually more and more right wing and
11:24
Speaker 1: more more willing to vote for not just conservative parties
11:27
Speaker 1: but sort of the extreme right wing parties. And then
11:29
Speaker 1: there was another study in the UK looking at pubs
11:32
Speaker 1: and showing similar things.
11:34
Speaker 3: Could The closure of youth clubs has been an extraordinary
11:37
Speaker 3: thing in Britain. We've lost seventy three percent of a
11:41
Speaker 3: level of activity and funding for youth clubs over the
11:45
Speaker 3: last ten or fifteen years. And of course the closure
11:49
Speaker 3: rates is different in different areas, and you can see
11:51
Speaker 3: straight away that the effect on crime in the areas
11:55
Speaker 3: where youth clubs have been closed is quite dramatic. I
12:00
Speaker 3: think if we could just go back to the question
12:02
Speaker 3: of populism, I mean, the clearest fact that's been established
12:07
Speaker 3: really in almost every country is that the people who
12:10
Speaker 3: vote for populists are the discontented people, some of whom
12:15
Speaker 3: have become discontented for policy reasons and some of them
12:18
Speaker 3: for cost of living or other reasons. But discontent is
12:23
Speaker 3: driving people into extreme right wing or extreme left wing positions.
12:28
Speaker 3: And that's why one extraordinarily powerful reason why we have
12:33
Speaker 3: to try and put the contentment of the people more
12:36
Speaker 3: central to public policy if we want to preserve democracy.
12:40
Speaker 2: Ben As Richard says, part of this is about a
12:42
Speaker 2: cost of living issue, which is obviously issue number one,
12:46
Speaker 2: not just in the US but also in the UK
12:49
Speaker 2: and other places, and it doesn't just relate to this.
12:52
Speaker 2: I mean it relates to the of groceries in the
12:54
Speaker 2: price of petrol gas going up. But does the people
12:59
Speaker 2: being priced out of fun activities or hold days and
13:03
Speaker 2: over the does that have a particular resonance. How much
13:05
Speaker 2: is it politically sailing on its own or is it
13:09
Speaker 2: just being sort of pushed together and along with other things.
13:12
Speaker 2: I know just you mentioned in New York sort of
13:14
Speaker 2: having more more liquor licenses as a way to try
13:18
Speaker 2: and encourage some of the bars to come back.
13:21
Speaker 3: Yeah.
13:22
Speaker 1: I think that inflation in and of itself, and the
13:25
Speaker 1: price of just food that you bring home and need
13:28
Speaker 1: at home like that is something that is infuriating to
13:30
Speaker 1: people in and of itself and is sort of disconnected
13:34
Speaker 1: perhaps from this fun happiness conversation. But I think when
13:39
Speaker 1: you go to a concert and you feel like you're
13:42
Speaker 1: being squeezed into, like to actually get close enough to
13:46
Speaker 1: see the artist and not just watch a screen from
13:50
Speaker 1: the back row, when you have to pay hundreds of
13:53
Speaker 1: dollars to do that, it's really dispiriting. But when people
13:57
Speaker 1: will go out and try to do that, they're subject
14:00
Speaker 1: to these premiumization regimes where to get in and have
14:05
Speaker 1: the same experience you had a decade ago, is going
14:08
Speaker 1: to cost you four times as much, even if the
14:10
Speaker 1: official inflation rate hasn't gone up that much. For that
14:13
Speaker 1: particular activity, we've really created these tiers, whether it's on
14:17
Speaker 1: an airplane or in a concert hall.
14:19
Speaker 2: Everyone's forgotten that now because the World Cup's been quite
14:21
Speaker 2: popular in the US, but then the lead up to it,
14:23
Speaker 2: it was that very intensive tiering by FIFA that I
14:27
Speaker 2: think had sort of have brought that home. And Richard,
14:30
Speaker 2: I can't help thinking, I mean, many many years ago,
14:33
Speaker 2: you know, you were the person who had really contributed
14:36
Speaker 2: to the people focusing on relative inequality and how that
14:39
Speaker 2: was related to people's happiness. And we're seeing that now
14:42
Speaker 2: with the way that the sort of aggressive rent seeking
14:46
Speaker 2: and segmenting of the market into more and more upper
14:50
Speaker 2: tiers seems like a very there's a very close connection
14:54
Speaker 2: between that and people's general sense of well being, even
14:57
Speaker 2: if it's a somewhat trivial example sitting in a.
14:59
Speaker 3: Com Yes, so one mustn't exaggerate the influence of economic
15:05
Speaker 3: factors in the production of discontent. I mean, if you're
15:10
Speaker 3: try and explain who are the most discontented people. In
15:15
Speaker 3: most advanced countries, the number one factor is going to
15:18
Speaker 3: be mental health and loneliness. These factors are coming through
15:23
Speaker 3: at least as strongly as as simple living standards. I
15:28
Speaker 3: was very impressed by the US Surgeon General Vivek Murti
15:33
Speaker 3: when he went on his first tour as surch in General.
15:36
Speaker 3: What were the greatest problems of health as he thought
15:40
Speaker 3: facing people? They said, loneliness. That was what people reported
15:44
Speaker 3: to him. And that's behind the death of despair and
15:49
Speaker 3: all the rest of it. And it is behind populism
15:53
Speaker 3: because people join these populist parties because it gives them
15:57
Speaker 3: a sense of identity that they feel they belonging to
16:00
Speaker 3: something that actually means something. It turns over their insids.
16:05
Speaker 3: So it really is crucial that we deal with this discontent,
16:13
Speaker 3: and it really is important for politicians to understand that
16:19
Speaker 3: the factors that will determine this is studies of both
16:23
Speaker 3: European elections and US presidential election the fact that which
16:27
Speaker 3: will determine whether a government goes through elected are more
16:31
Speaker 3: to do with non economic factors affecting their happiness than
16:36
Speaker 3: economic factors. And we need much more attention to things
16:40
Speaker 3: that generate the social interactions which we started as than
16:44
Speaker 3: just the cost of living.
16:57
Speaker 2: We have potentially a moment of opportunity in the UK,
17:00
Speaker 2: despite their not being electioned and arrival of a new government,
17:04
Speaker 2: a new Prime minister anyway in the coming days. And
17:07
Speaker 2: E seems to be quite open to some of these ideas.
17:10
Speaker 2: And I know we've also heard and Ben mentioned in
17:13
Speaker 2: his piece. You clearly have Democrat politicians on the ground
17:16
Speaker 2: in the US also trying to address some of these
17:19
Speaker 2: sources of discontent. But when you look at the sort
17:23
Speaker 2: of cost effectiveness of different interventions to improve happiness, but
17:28
Speaker 2: how do you rank something like more spending on counseling
17:36
Speaker 2: and direct efforts to address high levels of depression, for example,
17:40
Speaker 2: against having more parks and more sort of social infrastructure
17:45
Speaker 2: ways of getting people together, or youth clubs for that matter.
17:49
Speaker 3: Well, as you say, we have been looking right across
17:51
Speaker 3: the board at the cost effectiveness of different types of
17:55
Speaker 3: public spending. And the most extraordinarily effective is you call
18:00
Speaker 3: it counseling. I would call it psychological therapy, which is
18:04
Speaker 3: basically paying for itself within a couple of years, both
18:08
Speaker 3: when it's done for adults and when it's done for
18:12
Speaker 3: young people.
18:13
Speaker 2: Paying for itself in what way are they returns in
18:16
Speaker 2: terms of people working or returns in terms of people
18:19
Speaker 2: feeling better.
18:20
Speaker 3: Of course, the real, really important return is people feeling better.
18:24
Speaker 3: But from the government's point of view, it's of great
18:26
Speaker 3: interest that it won't cost them anything because they get
18:29
Speaker 3: the money back within a couple of years.
18:31
Speaker 2: From people work, from tax revenues or from reduced health costs.
18:35
Speaker 2: I'm just trying to work out what the saving would.
18:37
Speaker 3: Be when you're talking about adult anxiety and depression, which
18:43
Speaker 3: is the biggest single set of problems. It's just people
18:47
Speaker 3: getting back to work and coming off benefits. The savings
18:50
Speaker 3: there are so immediate. When you're talking about addicts, you're
18:55
Speaker 3: talking about healthcare costs as well being saved, people not
18:59
Speaker 3: turning up any not turning up in patient facilities and
19:05
Speaker 3: so on. But you mentioned parks. They are also good value.
19:10
Speaker 3: Small parks being close to green space turns out to
19:13
Speaker 3: be very cost effective. Actually, things like the police turn
19:17
Speaker 3: out to be are the cost effective. They actually encourage
19:21
Speaker 3: people the theme we are on mixing freely because they
19:25
Speaker 3: feel safe. Things which are much less cost effective are
19:28
Speaker 3: extra new roads, new railways. We spend an extraordinary amount
19:33
Speaker 3: on these in a way that's not really questioned, and
19:37
Speaker 3: I think that we need to subject all public expenditure
19:42
Speaker 3: to this test. What does it ultimately do for the
19:45
Speaker 3: quality of life as people experience it.
19:48
Speaker 2: Ben You obviously spend your time dipping in out of
19:50
Speaker 2: lots of different topics, but I know that you're particularly
19:53
Speaker 2: interested in the sort of dynamics of wealth and how
19:57
Speaker 2: it affects society and affects people. And you've obviously demonstrated
20:01
Speaker 2: that in this piece. And there's been a lot of
20:03
Speaker 2: talk about wealth taxes. But do you think with all
20:06
Speaker 2: this discussion that maybe we'll get into talking about high
20:09
Speaker 2: end consumption taxes.
20:11
Speaker 1: That's really interesting In terms of policy interventions, I was
20:14
Speaker 1: thinking a little bit more about creating new or more
20:18
Speaker 1: fun infrastructure. This seems like an opportunity for local politicians
20:22
Speaker 1: to bring a little life back to communities, whether that's
20:26
Speaker 1: a free concert or a dance party on a Friday
20:28
Speaker 1: night on a block this shut to traffic. But the
20:32
Speaker 1: tax issue, I've looked into these taxes on wealthy people
20:37
Speaker 1: and people's attitudes about billionaires and trillionaires, and in the
20:41
Speaker 1: United States, for a long time, there was a sense
20:44
Speaker 1: that people didn't really resent billionaires that much when you
20:47
Speaker 1: pull them. But that's starting to change, and there's less
20:50
Speaker 1: admiration for the wealthy than there used to be. And
20:53
Speaker 1: I do wonder whether one of the factors there is
20:56
Speaker 1: that there is this sense that the experience is the
21:00
Speaker 1: cool places and the cool experiences that were once available
21:04
Speaker 1: to a broad middle class population, you know, are becoming
21:08
Speaker 1: these premium, expensive, rare luxuries.
21:10
Speaker 2: When you were saying that, I was thinking, yeah, well,
21:12
Speaker 2: I guess the billionaires in the past were a bit
21:13
Speaker 2: more low key about spending their billions. But of course,
21:16
Speaker 2: as Richard points out, it's that we see it all on.
21:18
Speaker 2: If we don't see it when we're trying to go
21:21
Speaker 2: to these events, we see it all online in their
21:23
Speaker 2: perfect lives, and it's all it's very much in front
21:26
Speaker 2: of our faces.
21:28
Speaker 1: That reminds me of the Yeah, like billionaires posting from
21:31
Speaker 1: their yachts during COVID when we were all stuck at home.
21:34
Speaker 1: That they're similar dynamic.
21:36
Speaker 2: Yeah, it's not particularly good, pr Richard. People who regularly
21:39
Speaker 2: listen to this show will find this a curious topic perhaps,
21:42
Speaker 2: or an unusual topic for us to have gone into,
21:44
Speaker 2: because we haven't been talking only about economics, but I
21:48
Speaker 2: guess that's that's part of the point you're making.
21:51
Speaker 3: I'm a member of something called Action but Happiness, that
21:53
Speaker 3: is promoting a way of life where you pledge to
21:56
Speaker 3: try and create as much happiness as you can in
21:58
Speaker 3: the world. That's putting that as a principle for yourself
22:03
Speaker 3: how you should live. But of course it's also a
22:05
Speaker 3: principle for what the government should be doing. But coming
22:09
Speaker 3: back to your original theme, Stephanie, I do think that
22:16
Speaker 3: this decline of face to face contact is a massive problem.
22:24
Speaker 3: And we know that people they don't go to meetings.
22:27
Speaker 3: I mean they don't get You can't get people to
22:30
Speaker 3: go to things because they are spending so much time online.
22:35
Speaker 3: And even if they're together, like for example, in the
22:39
Speaker 3: big space in the university, you'll see one hundreds of
22:41
Speaker 3: people sitting around and there's no noise anymore. It's quite
22:46
Speaker 3: They're all texting each other. They're even texting people who
22:49
Speaker 3: are in the same room. This is a fundamental cultural
22:54
Speaker 3: change which I think is not for the better. And
22:59
Speaker 3: I'm hoping, you know, we can get a reform school
23:02
Speaker 3: education where people are taught better life skills I understand
23:06
Speaker 3: that measurements have been made which showed children can't make
23:09
Speaker 3: eye contact in the same way that they used to.
23:13
Speaker 3: We need to restore the basic practice of social living
23:19
Speaker 3: as central to people's enjoyment of life.
23:24
Speaker 2: Richard Layard, Ben Stephenman, thank you so much, Thank.
23:28
Speaker 4: You, thank you, thanks for listening to Trumponomics from Bloomberg.
23:39
Speaker 2: It was hosted by me Stephanie Flanders. I was joined
23:41
Speaker 2: by Bloomberg News reporter Ben Stevenman and the economist and
23:45
Speaker 2: LC professor Lord Richard Layard. Toponomics was produced by Moss
23:50
Speaker 2: Andam and Summer Sadi with help from a Keen, and
23:53
Speaker 2: sound design was by Blake Maples and Kelly Garrett. And
23:56
Speaker 2: to help others find this brilliant show, please rate and
24:00
Speaker 2: review its tide wherever you listen