Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 96: Presidential Election Debrief: Macron part II with Chris O'Brien
Transcript
- 0:07Here's the thing. To the New Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host. The V term you do today is the
- 0:13day after the conclusion of the French presidential election,
- 0:16which means it's the first day of knowing that Mac home will
- 0:19continue to govern France. After his first term officially
- 0:22ends on May 13th to some. This feels like a Band-Aid on a
- 0:26gaping wound to others assign. That reason has one.
- 0:30Whatever your perspective, there's a lot to discuss about
- 0:33this experience and what Mac home means for France moving
- 0:36forward. I'm joined today by someone.
- 0:38I've wanted to invite on the show for a long time.
- 0:41Chris. O'Brien is an American
- 0:43journalist in the Paris region, who has reported about
- 0:45Technology Innovation and Entrepreneurship for more than
- 0:4820 years. He previously covered Silicon
- 0:51Valley for the LA Times and brings a deep understanding of
- 0:53startup culture and Technology to the French landscape.
- 0:57He also has a lot of opinions about Mac home and this.
- 1:00Action. We talked about the way that
- 1:02Global media has helped normalize extremists.
- 1:05Mac, homes, highs and lows the French Tech scenes Evolution and
- 1:09what to know about Mac homes. Second chapter.
- 1:16Chris, welcome to the show. It's great to be here.
- 1:20Thank you for having me. We gosh, what a whirlwind, the
- 1:25last 48 hours, the last two weeks.
- 1:28The last six months have been quite intense.
- 1:31We are the day after the final presidential vote back home has
- 1:37just been reelected and I think would be good to take a few
- 1:40minutes to unpack that before we get into other things.
- 1:43Because, you know, my initial reason for You know wanting to
- 1:47have you on the show was because you are so entrenched in the
- 1:50tech scene and you have this incredible knowledge, having
- 1:53been, you know, a reporter in Silicon Valley when you were
- 1:57still living in the u.s. You have just a reservoir of
- 2:02knowledge that I think is so helpful for people looking at
- 2:07the sort of startup culture here and wanting to understand it,
- 2:10but not following French journalist, but you also have
- 2:13been a very astute Observer of everything.
- 2:16That happening in the election. And so I actually want to start
- 2:21with something you tweeted on Saturday, which went viral as
- 2:25the kids say you in a series of tweets the night before, the
- 2:29last round you touched on something that I do, fear puts
- 2:33the entire election process at risk moving forward, which is
- 2:37normalizing, the extreme, right? You highlighted the shocking
- 2:41number of headlines, about my new pet and what motivates her.
- 2:43And her base in the New York Times during the elections.
- 2:46Go. So, you wrote even if the tone
- 2:48toward her is - she has absolutely dominated the way the
- 2:51times covers and thinks about this election, it in much the
- 2:54same way Trump used to drive media, narratives lessons, not
- 2:58learned, I guess so, you know, the New York Times, isn't the
- 3:02only publication guilty of doing this?
- 3:05It seems like this is a kind of a disturbing Trend and it's
- 3:09been, it's been done. Just as recently as this
- 3:11weekend, again, with a far-right, figure emerging in
- 3:14the US. What do you Think is
- 3:16particularly dangerous about this sort of coverage and were
- 3:20French titles is guilty of the same to a degree.
- 3:25I think the French titles had a bit more nuanced, but just to
- 3:30back up on that. I mean, on the high-level
- 3:32question, you know, I think the danger is, is two things it
- 3:36focuses on the divisions and the failures.
- 3:41And so it continues to sort of stoke this idea.
- 3:46That government has failed. Its that is a failing thing and
- 3:52it focuses on, you know, in the mccrone side of the Ledger, all
- 3:56the things, he's done wrong. All the things he's failed to do
- 3:59all his foibles. And I say that, as someone who
- 4:02personally has, frankly, a mixed opinion of him.
- 4:05There's things he's done that. I was like, there's things that
- 4:09I'm in disagreement with there's things.
- 4:11I'm disappointed about. But, you know, 02 to constantly
- 4:17sort of focus on that aspect and then, you know, continue to sort
- 4:22of highlight those divisions and to really, again, and again,
- 4:27give voice to people who have grievances is that again, is
- 4:30that their grievances aren't real, but to sort of paint this
- 4:33picture of that, everyone's unhappy without sort of talking
- 4:38about like, okay, here are the things that have worked.
- 4:40And again, I think you're seeing it the same dynamic in the u.s.
- 4:43There's things about Biden. Same thing for me.
- 4:46I have mixed feelings about there's things he's done better
- 4:49than expected, things that I'm disappointed with.
- 4:52There's a lot going, right? But it's always more.
- 4:56Well, he's not doing this. He's not doing that.
- 4:58And, you know, here's all the far right, people complaining
- 5:01about it. It's if you follow that account
- 5:04on Twitter pitch, pot, New York Times pitch, but I mean, it is
- 5:09amazing. Can I just explain?
- 5:10Can you just explain what that is for people who don't know?
- 5:12Yeah. It's I think a guy's name is
- 5:14Doug balloon. I'm not sure.
- 5:15His real name, but it's New York Times pitch pot.
- 5:18And it's sort of tweets, satiric summaries of stories.
- 5:22As you would see them in the New York Times.
- 5:24And and it's at the point where, you know, you do read them.
- 5:27And you think, yeah, that's actually the stories they're
- 5:30doing and it's not just the time.
- 5:32So it's a lot of people. But, you know, how many
- 5:34reporters you have to send to a small Cafe and Rural France to
- 5:39listen to some elderly racist. Person, complained about the
- 5:43world not being as good as it used to be.
- 5:45And people wearing Muslim veils and scarves and people looking
- 5:51different. I mean, again, you you want to
- 5:55be in touch and understand those people to a degree.
- 5:57But if the whole campaign coverage is repeatedly focused
- 6:02on that. You had this, you had this view
- 6:05that I think just feeds into that narrative.
- 6:08That everything is broken and it can't be fixed.
- 6:11Well, sure. And also, it's this idea that,
- 6:14you know, essentially mine Lopez.
- 6:15Is based her entire campaign on those failures and that she
- 6:20somehow she's going to be the Savior which we know is not
- 6:22true. But you know, she's not saying
- 6:25what she will do. She is saying what the other
- 6:27side has not done and that's a very different position to be
- 6:30coming from. I do know though that the French
- 6:33I agree with you that they tend to be more nuanced but there
- 6:35have been a couple of things that were quite surprising.
- 6:37I mean the way that they did a sort of trumpian coverage of
- 6:42zamore throughout this entire process.
- 6:45They gave him a ton of air time and then, of course, even
- 6:50recently there were some headlines like in French is
- 6:52Lupin really on the far. Right?
- 6:54And I think that similarly does a disservice to anyone who you
- 7:00know, is on the fence and, you know, if they're not really
- 7:03reading the news in the way that they need to be.
- 7:05And there's, you know, we know that there's a whole population
- 7:07of people who are not following us, a Sara Lee as deeply as they
- 7:09should be. They see that and they, you
- 7:11know, maybe that does enough to tell them, you know, she's not
- 7:14as bad but The way it normalizes her as a candidate.
- 7:18The one other thing is if I can establish the thing, the, the
- 7:22one of the thing and this is hard for me to articulate a
- 7:24little bit. I don't know how much of a TV
- 7:26Watcher you are. But as an American living in
- 7:30France, what are the things that kind of astonishes me is just
- 7:33the sheer volume of evening, news shows.
- 7:37And again, we all have 24-hour cable news, wherever we live and
- 7:41multiple versions of that particular in the US or the UK,
- 7:44but really feels like majority of the programming on French TV
- 7:49across. Countless channels is basically
- 7:53a handful of people dissecting the news and so there's one
- 7:58full. Yeah, industry of people whose
- 8:02main reason for being is to get on these shows and just be
- 8:08yelling about how awful the incumbent is and and so it keeps
- 8:13like I was surprised after they lack last.
- 8:15Le Pen was right back on TV, you know, 2017, you know, ranting
- 8:21about this or that and and so it's a strange beyond the
- 8:25newspapers. It's just sort of the strange
- 8:29Dynamic that this stuff is sort of Relentless across all the
- 8:33channels all the time. And so it sort of connects with
- 8:37that and that's what the campaign process that does not
- 8:41begin. Nearly as early as it does in
- 8:43the u.s., I mean, this is like a short Up compared to what we
- 8:46experience in the u.s., You know, where they start two years
- 8:49in advance. And you just already exhausted
- 8:52by it. By the time, it comes to, you
- 8:54know, voting in primaries or, you know, but but it is it does
- 8:58seem to be taking a kind of pattern here where it's just
- 9:03sensationalism. And obviously at work, people
- 9:06are clicking. And I think that's also a
- 9:07problem across the media landscape one lens on this whole
- 9:12thing has been the sort of persistent pessimism among the
- 9:14French. The way that they constantly
- 9:16think they have it the worst and sin Devante song, who's a writer
- 9:20famously, wrote that France is a paradise, inhabited, by people
- 9:23who think they're in Hell, how much of that was at play here.
- 9:27How much do you think this is like, culturally, they will
- 9:30always think that they are just the declining, you know, once
- 9:36great power, you know, I think really since the, the period I
- 9:42wouldn't forget the exact range, but you know, the French could
- 9:44ever have missed. Logically referred to this head
- 9:48of, they say at the truant Glory o, the thirty glorious years
- 9:51after World War Two. And it seemed like the economy
- 9:54was booming, and they're sort of Third Way, was really carving
- 10:00out a distinct path in the global economy.
- 10:04And then I think since the late 70s the 80s and then since then,
- 10:10you know, there's that feeling of they've sort of fallen from
- 10:14that state of grace. And so the things are just a
- 10:17progressively getting worse. It's, you know, it's like, I'll
- 10:22just like a small example currently with the inflation
- 10:28rate. Just as an example, if there is
- 10:32high inflation in France. It's much better than
- 10:36surrounding countries, much better than the US.
- 10:40So, how do you convince someone to be happy about the fact that
- 10:45Rising prices? Started as bad as they could be.
- 10:48You know, it's a tough argument for macron or someone in power
- 10:51to make that like, hey, you should be happy because it could
- 10:55be worse. Like, that's not a really
- 10:57compelling way to convince people that their lives are not
- 11:00so bad. So it's a tough Dynamic.
- 11:02And then, you know, you and again, I want to be clear like,
- 11:07there are legitimate reasons for people to feel upset.
- 11:13I mean, there are people's drawers, you know, there are
- 11:15Are, you know, things that need to be addressed, like medical
- 11:20deserts in the rural areas? Lack of jobs, a feeling that
- 11:25kids don't maybe have the same opportunities that they did.
- 11:29And again, I think the big big big one particularly for the
- 11:32Youth is the environment, you know, there's a decline in Fall
- 11:37of France, things are good as they used to be.
- 11:38But there's a there is a genuine fear about the future that's
- 11:41legitimate. And for those people to look
- 11:44around and say No one's addressing it.
- 11:48As dramatically as I think they should be, is a real, is a
- 11:51legitimate really reason to feel disaffected.
- 11:53I think. And also, during the debate last
- 11:56week between Mac horn, Lupin, you know, all of the
- 12:00environmental environmentally focused voters commented on how
- 12:05little time was spent talking about the climate, every time
- 12:07it's the same sort of complaint and it's true.
- 12:11I mean, it's only, you know, the planet at stake, but That's also
- 12:16been one of the reasons why the youth didn't vote, you know, you
- 12:19could try to tell them that. Actually they're going to be in
- 12:21a worse off position. If they don't try to make their
- 12:25voice heard. I mean if there was really I
- 12:28mean, we're lucky that the election was not as close as we
- 12:31sort of Imagine, but you know, they could have made the
- 12:34difference between Mac on getting elected and Le Pen
- 12:36getting elected. And yet convincing them that it
- 12:39was still worth voting despite how much they felt left behind
- 12:44by you know, Both candidates Visions for the future.
- 12:49They just didn't want to hear it.
- 12:50And so that's that's a serious risk.
- 12:53We have going forward whether it's in the legislatives in June
- 12:56or in future presidential elections, you know, like do you
- 12:59think I guess the big question and you know, who knows we can
- 13:03always Hypothesized, but, you know, we don't have an actual
- 13:07answers. How much do you think Mac will
- 13:09really gets? You know, he when he accepted or
- 13:13when he made his speech last night, you know, he acknowledged
- 13:16some of the failings. He acknowledged that there were
- 13:17people who were unhappy but how much do you think his ego is
- 13:21really going to allow like move aside and allow him to address
- 13:25what needs to be addressed. I mean if I'm going to choose to
- 13:28be slightly optimistic, at least for the moment to me.
- 13:33That's his really Big. It was his big missed
- 13:36opportunity in the first five years.
- 13:39It's as big opportunity for the second five years, you know,
- 13:45it's been a long time since Francis head a second-term
- 13:49president, not facing re-election because they're,
- 13:52they're limited here by two terms just as they are in the
- 13:55u.s. So in a sense, his political
- 13:58career is over, right? He doesn't have to go before the
- 14:02voters. There will be the legislative
- 14:03elections in June. June, but really he's done.
- 14:07And so he has a unique opportunity.
- 14:09I think to really, if he means it to charge a different path
- 14:14and I hope that, if that's the case, the environment becomes a
- 14:18centerpiece. If you go back to 2017.
- 14:22He talked a really big game about that.
- 14:24You know, I'm sure you hear from your American friends.
- 14:28They look at macaron and they Swoon over his environmental
- 14:31credentials. We're here on the ground.
- 14:35It became pretty clear early on that.
- 14:37He was not moving in the way that people had thought he
- 14:43would. People who really are worried
- 14:44about that issue and that there were numerous signs throughout
- 14:47his first five years when his environmental Minister resigned,
- 14:52when the greens did really well in local elections, where he
- 14:55kept saying, okay. I got the message and I'm, you
- 14:58know, going to going to change now and he didn't really, I mean
- 15:01a little bit, you know, there were things here and there but
- 15:04not the Sort of radical break that people.
- 15:08The people were just describing, particularly young, people are
- 15:10looking for, so I think he has an opportunity to do that.
- 15:14Now, I think he did put some stuff in place.
- 15:17It was interesting at the end of his last term.
- 15:20So my hope is that he really does make that the centerpiece
- 15:25going forward for the next five years.
- 15:27And if he does, I think he'll succeed in bringing some of the
- 15:29people back into the electoral process.
- 15:33Hmm, but whether it Follow through, I mean, we'll see, you
- 15:37know, I mean, it's well he did. You know, he talked a big game
- 15:41about women's rights and protecting women in the first
- 15:44term as well and then brought on Domino.
- 15:49So, you know, there are a lot of a lot of big missteps along the
- 15:53way you were before you were living in the northern part of
- 15:58Paris or just north of Paris, North East West Harris, right?
- 16:02West-northwest. Sorry you were In Toulouse, what
- 16:06was that? Like in 2017 because that's if
- 16:11you were based in the southwest, that's a much different voting
- 16:14populous. Well in Toulouse actually, it's
- 16:16pretty, they're pretty Progressive.
- 16:19I mean, it was pretty strong, still on the local Regional
- 16:23level the party. The Socialist Party is pretty
- 16:25strong. The regional president, harreld
- 16:29alga is is Socialist Party. And she wanted to pretty big
- 16:34re-election mandate, you know, so that's a territory occitan e
- 16:37that stretches from you know, the Atlantic to Montpelier, kind
- 16:42of Central, South West South France.
- 16:47So there's sort of two Dynamics, there's two loose, which is the
- 16:49Aerospace capital and doing pretty well.
- 16:52And then, as is the case in a lot of France, right?
- 16:55When you get outside, that particular, least you have some
- 16:57of the poorest regions our allegiance of France, where, you
- 17:01know, Suicide rates of farmers are scarily high and the read
- 17:07those stories in the paper all the time.
- 17:09So, you know, going back to 2017.
- 17:13There was the you know, in between the two votes.
- 17:16There was the neela, penny macron marches.
- 17:20I think they were much larger to be honest, five years ago than
- 17:23they were this time, you know, there was some optimism amount
- 17:29around that Chrome because there is a big Big sort of Tech
- 17:33International Community down there.
- 17:34And they saw him as a they were, they were generally worried
- 17:38about the relationship with the EU.
- 17:41So I think it was generally positive for him with of course,
- 17:44some dissent among young, people who didn't buy the whole startup
- 17:47Nation thing. And and you have a team, right?
- 17:53You have a teenager in your household.
- 17:55I have. Well, I had to now I have one.
- 17:58I have one who's off to his first year in University and the
- 18:02second whose Pony are her junior year in high school.
- 18:07So what I'm just curious what their view of this process was,
- 18:13I'm assuming that the eldest could vote.
- 18:17Well, that's complicated. Not a citizen, so he could not
- 18:20vote, right? Okay at that, that's a whole
- 18:23complicated podcast unto itself getting citizenship in France.
- 18:26So we've been citizens now for a year, but in my mind and then my
- 18:30daughter's too young to vote. I mean my son.
- 18:32Do you know he's sort of a he's great.
- 18:34He's very much a Centrist macaron guy, I would say and you
- 18:41know, my daughter's definitely more, Greta.
- 18:43Tune Berg. Hmm, so, you know, they have
- 18:49their kind of views on the world.
- 18:52But you know, again at the end of the day, everyone's happy
- 18:55that the pain didn't get elected.
- 18:58Right? Right.
- 18:59Let's let's count that. As a win.
- 19:01Come in many would say that Michael has been good for
- 19:05business. Certainly.
- 19:06He's been good for Tech which we can talk about it in more
- 19:09detail. But you know as you as you've
- 19:12mentioned and I feel similarly he's done damage.
- 19:15Of other places, you know, there are areas where I similarly
- 19:18disagree fundamentally with some of his decisions.
- 19:21What do you think? Should be the biggest push from
- 19:23him aside from the climate which we've addressed in the next five
- 19:27years, you know, does it still relate to business?
- 19:31Is it more about social policy? Well, if you go, if you want to
- 19:35get, if you win back the clock five years ago, in the way, he
- 19:39presented himself as this kind of radical Centrist, where It
- 19:45would, they would be liberalization of the economy.
- 19:49And again, isn't as an American coming here and and encountering
- 19:52a lot of the rigidity of the French economy.
- 19:55I felt like okay. There's a reasonable case to be
- 19:57made that there's some reform needed around work and business,
- 20:03but then the promise was that would be balanced with social
- 20:06reforms to protect people environmental action and a sort
- 20:12of you know, open-minded. Channels sort of view of the
- 20:16world. I think we're Once he began
- 20:21governing, it became pretty clear that he felt his strategy
- 20:24was to, to lean pretty hard to the right.
- 20:28That was how he was going to deal with the right.
- 20:30And so a couple things happen. I mean, there were just two me,
- 20:34sort of inexplicable weird things like and maybe I felt
- 20:38this more in the southwest being in a rural area, but, you know,
- 20:41he spent a lot of time courting, the very conservative hunting
- 20:43Lobby. And yeah, and so again, it's a
- 20:47weird dynamic, right? If you look at their, their
- 20:50programs Le Pen for all her faults, which are many numerous
- 20:53has a has a very aggressive animal rights program.
- 21:01And, you know, a kind of thing that for most of us, you would
- 21:04think, like, you know, it's a radical leftist.
- 21:06Animal Liberation type thing. She's very big on that, you
- 21:10know, macaron was courting, this very conservative Lobby, which
- 21:14just seemed sort of baffling, you know, he picked his prime
- 21:17ministers from labor, Republican, you know, from the
- 21:22classic conservative party and gradually.
- 21:27We saw a kind of his lisp orders from the left kind of trick.
- 21:30Way the last five years and then the other big Dynamic again, we
- 21:35could spend a whole podcast talking about.
- 21:37This was really the arrival of the culture wars in full force
- 21:41and France. The Islamabad go Schism, the
- 21:43woke ISM. The, you know, the the battles
- 21:46about what's being taught in schools.
- 21:49The same kind of creep you've seen in the United States and a
- 21:53very sort of anti-American sentiment around some of those
- 21:57things. And it felt like again, When,
- 22:01you know, hearing some of his ministers, talk about Islam ago,
- 22:04Schism, or setting up committees to study.
- 22:07What's, what's been said? And taught at schools, just
- 22:11seemed like a bid to win that to play into that culture of war.
- 22:16And to me, I would just love to see him, put his foot down and
- 22:19say like, okay, I think he tried to kind of have his Minister say
- 22:24stuff and then he would try to stay above it.
- 22:26Act. Like he's not part of it.
- 22:27Like to me. I would love him to definitively
- 22:30say. That talk I stopped.
- 22:33You know, we are an open welcoming country, We're a
- 22:37nation of ideas and we're going to address some of the
- 22:40underlying issues rather than trying to come up with these
- 22:43phony labels. And then, at the same time, you
- 22:47know, pull in more people from the left, from his government
- 22:51and one of the big questions we'll see in the coming weeks is
- 22:53who he picks his prime minister, you know, I would love him to
- 22:57see, I mean surely there's got to be a woman out there.
- 23:00R who's worthy of being prime minister and surely there's got
- 23:03to be. Also, someone who's more
- 23:05left-of-center who could immediately kind of create the
- 23:10idea of a, maybe not officially a Unity government.
- 23:14That something that's makes a definitive statement.
- 23:18I'm reaching out in a different way than I did the first five
- 23:22years now, right. Mélenchon wants to be the Prime
- 23:25Minister, but that's a whole other ball of Wax.
- 23:28I mean, I think that's pretty bold of him.
- 23:29But we've seen nothing, but, you know, very audacious claims and
- 23:36and moves from that man. I also just love how in his, in
- 23:41his remarks last night. He was so grumpy, as usual, and
- 23:45basically criticized, you know, Mac home from top to bottom and
- 23:49then who's like, I would still like to be prime minister.
- 23:53I just can't, you could just imagine the the, you know,
- 23:57Firecrackers going off. If they were to be in the same
- 24:00room having to negotiate, but you've called Mac home the
- 24:04startup president and you've written actually a whole series
- 24:07of Articles looking at his rise primarily from, you know, when
- 24:12he was campaigning in the first, in the first election to now,
- 24:17how would you say your perspective of him has changed?
- 24:21Would you say he still, he still earns that label?
- 24:25Well, I think in calling him. Straight up president.
- 24:28What impressed me five years ago was he should have conjured this
- 24:32whole thing out of nothing. And you know, he the the what
- 24:39became now known as The Republic Amash, what was called during
- 24:42the campaign? I'm not much most of that time
- 24:47pundits, looked at him and thought of him as this sort of
- 24:49creature of the media, or a cult of personality or kind of a
- 24:53paper tiger candidate and they Continually surprised at his
- 24:59strength and there were, you know, other circumstances that
- 25:03came into play that helped him certainly, but I think they
- 25:08missed underneath the surface, this genuine movement.
- 25:13He had built using digital tools, using some of the Obama
- 25:17campaign tactics, which both helped him win the election and
- 25:22then in the legislatives, really shocked people that he got this
- 25:26sort of super A majority, I think it was a historic majority
- 25:31where after he won. They thought well, he'll never
- 25:34get it even enough people to run under his so-called party to to
- 25:40have a chance in majority and all of a sudden he gets a record
- 25:42majority. I think again the mistake he
- 25:47made and this is sort of similar in some ways to Obama who he I
- 25:50think he idolizes it, it, he kind of stopped the campaign.
- 25:54And he didn't really continue to sort of promote his message but
- 26:00also build out that infrastructure.
- 26:02And so when the local elections came around and the regional
- 26:05elections came around his party hadn't really deepened its roots
- 26:12on a local level. And so you saw they would vote.
- 26:14They were essentially non players at the local and
- 26:16Regional elections. Last was it?
- 26:20I'm losing track of time to or less.
- 26:22That's 2 years, I think before. Yeah action.
- 26:26So, you know, whether they can do that or whether the party
- 26:30turns out to be an ephemeral thing that just kind of goes
- 26:32away after he's out of office in five years.
- 26:35We'll we'll see It'll certainly get a test at the legislative
- 26:39elections. I mean if they get a majority
- 26:42again, there's some indication that there's something lasting
- 26:46that he's built. But I think it's unclear to me
- 26:50sitting here today. Just how much of a foundation
- 26:54He's really LED for a party. That's that's will continue his
- 27:00sort of Outlook. And again, we've seen some
- 27:03indications with gosh. I'm sorry.
- 27:05I'm going to forget his name now.
- 27:06His former prime minister of Philippe Edward for need wood,
- 27:10for the, who's kind of started his own party.
- 27:13You know, that's the fashionable thing.
- 27:15Everyone sort of starts, their own sort of egocentric party,
- 27:22but at the same time, it's also because the left and They're
- 27:24completely fractured. Like, where are they going to
- 27:26really go? So I think that makes the
- 27:28legislative elections kind of unpredictable, but you know, by
- 27:33mean, coming back to macaron. I mean, in terms of being the
- 27:35startup president, I think what he did was remarkable and I
- 27:39don't think in my view that sort of changed, I think, again, what
- 27:44was surprising was I think he sort of then Didn't continue in
- 27:49that vein in terms of really I mean, I hate to think of it like
- 27:55this, but it almost in this area.
- 27:56You almost have to be in a permanent campaign mode of or
- 28:02maybe a better way to put it as a sort of a permanent movement
- 28:05mode. You have to be sort of
- 28:06continually organizing promoting these ideas, convincing people
- 28:11there. I think a lot of macron.
- 28:13People think that Their successes are just self-evident.
- 28:19Sure, they've done stuff. And therefore people should just
- 28:21recognize that on its merits that I pass this bill.
- 28:25I made this reform. The unemployment rate is down,
- 28:29etc. Etc.
- 28:30You know are covid, lates rates were better than most countries.
- 28:34People, don't absorb that stuff. Naturally.
- 28:38You have to sort of think of it as continually building a
- 28:41movement. And frankly, you know, I think
- 28:42that's where someone like mélenchon fails like To me, he
- 28:46feels like a media creature. But you know, what has he been
- 28:49doing for five years to truly build an organizational
- 28:52movement. He and Le Pen after the last
- 28:55election talked big about. Oh, we're going to get a
- 28:57majority in the assembly working to oppose macron.
- 29:01And I think respectively, they got 8 and 17 seats out of five
- 29:06hundred and seventy seven seats, which is not really an
- 29:09indication that these are truly National parties.
- 29:12So we'll see if that's different in June, but They have a hill to
- 29:18climb to actually get anything close to a majority in the
- 29:23assembly. So I have to ask because the
- 29:27other Tech question I have which again connects to Mac home
- 29:30because it is during his term that we've seen the French Tech,
- 29:33the mission French Tech, emerge, cat, Borland going, who was the
- 29:37former director is one of the women from my book, which, you
- 29:40know, and we've seen her departure in the last year and
- 29:47it's during this time that I've never heard the word unicorn
- 29:50used as much as I ever really and in mine.
- 29:55Standing and this is going to be your expertise that's going to
- 29:58you know, shape the rest of this conversation.
- 30:00But a unicorn company was meant to be rare.
- 30:03Yeah and yet Francis constantly boasting about how many unicorns
- 30:07have emerged from the French Tech since macro has been
- 30:10president. What is this about?
- 30:12And is this even the right metric?
- 30:13We should be concerned about you.
- 30:14Do a lot of reporting on on Tech profiling companies.
- 30:19What, what is the deal? Well, I have two thoughts about
- 30:22that. I mean, on the Unicorn thing,
- 30:23that's a general technique. Check industry sickness at this
- 30:27point. I mean, the Oregon very briefly.
- 30:30I won't go down a big rabbit hole, but the origin of that was
- 30:32maybe a decade ago, Venture capitalists in Silicon Valley
- 30:36sort of coined that phrase because there was a shift going
- 30:40on that companies were not going public at the same rate.
- 30:44They used to they would say private longer.
- 30:46And so you were starting to see these private companies raise
- 30:52money that would push their valuation passed a billion
- 30:54dollars. So you were talking about a
- 30:57handful of companies and so the term unicorn was genuine like
- 31:02it's this rare, billion-plus company.
- 31:06Like I think Facebook was worth a billion before they went
- 31:09public, Uber, you know, but you counted them on two hands
- 31:12making. And then I just became kind of
- 31:15the mode and now you have I don't know how many thousands of
- 31:17so-called unicorns and now there's so many people talk
- 31:21about deck of horns, you know, companies with 10 billion
- 31:25valuation and you know, look, I think France sort of faced.
- 31:30So I came here, eight years ago, you know, France faced a serious
- 31:35image problem. In the tech world that people
- 31:39just didn't believe this was a country where you could build
- 31:42these huge companies. So a big part of the left,
- 31:46French Tech has been and continues to be kind of a
- 31:49marketing image exercise to really promote that message that
- 31:55this is a place. You can raise money that you can
- 31:57build these giant companies that you can build Global winners.
- 32:02So I appreciate to that effect, why they do that, why they get
- 32:08so excited because again, it wasn't that long ago where these
- 32:13investors just would not even think about writing these sizes
- 32:18of checks for a company based here because they'd say, oh well
- 32:20Francis labor laws and their taxes and this, and that.
- 32:24And the other thing, the French are lazy.
- 32:26They don't do email after 5:00, you know, all the cliche that
- 32:30are mostly in true, but you hear everywhere.
- 32:33Nobody says that anymore. Clearly, these people are not
- 32:38afraid to come here, write big checks.
- 32:39You see more and more Venture Capital firms, which are the
- 32:45types of investors. You back startups, coming here,
- 32:48opening bureaus. I get calls from foreign BCS all
- 32:52the time saying, hey, I'm trying to invest in France and I can't
- 32:55figure it out. Like, how do I break in?
- 32:58What do I got to do? You know, and I'm like, well,
- 33:01here's my general advice. But basically you're probably
- 33:03have to move here and hire a French person.
- 33:06Really connected system because it's big and it's fast and it's
- 33:10really changed a lot. But is it enough?
- 33:13I mean, I think there's a fair point to say and I think even,
- 33:18you know, the macaron people would agree with this that, you
- 33:21know, that sort of a phase one to really catalyze the creation
- 33:27of new companies. If you look at the top companies
- 33:31on the French Stock Exchange, and the macro and people say
- 33:36this all the time. You know, the top companies are
- 33:39the companies have been around in France for decades.
- 33:43Hmm, you know, they've been there forever, the luxury
- 33:45Brands, the hotel Brands. The all the classic ones that
- 33:49you associate with the Emily and Paris Type image of the French
- 33:54economy and they're fine. They're good.
- 33:56They're good companies. They're solid.
- 34:00But, you know, you go to the US and the top companies are all
- 34:04companies have been created in the last, you know, 10 or 15
- 34:07years or, you know, some older like apple Microsoft reports,
- 34:10but you know that those topmost, the high, most, highly valued
- 34:14companies are relatively new, and it changes a lot.
- 34:18So that's sort of a phase one to sort of generate those
- 34:22companies. But a phase two is obviously to
- 34:24make that economic impact more widely felt And so you've seen
- 34:30that and I think that grown people get this so we'll see but
- 34:35you know, they're advertising more of the manufacturing or
- 34:39secondary jobs. The length of these companies
- 34:41being kept in France, you know, it's a degree that if you build
- 34:45a product, they really want you to build it in France, and
- 34:48they're getting government support to do that.
- 34:50Particularly if it's a green related, climate change related
- 34:55product, so I think That's the key.
- 34:59And again, I felt like this the US, it's like, you know, these
- 35:03miners complaining about the mines closing.
- 35:06Look, someone should put a solar panel Factory in West Virginia.
- 35:10You know, I think there's there's areas of France where
- 35:13you have deep manufacturing experience.
- 35:17From going back generations and it's ripe for companies who need
- 35:21talent to do that kind of work. So but I think that's the next
- 35:24sort of step is to. Yes.
- 35:26I mean, it's fun to talk about the unicorns.
- 35:29It's genuinely were celebrating that the country can attract
- 35:34that kind of capital now. And it's also fair to say it's
- 35:37not enough like for to really transform it sort of phase 1 and
- 35:42transforming the economy, you know, you want companies that
- 35:45can start up but you want those economic Impacts to be felt
- 35:49beyond the pear, fig Beyond some, you know, école,
- 35:52polytechnique white dudes, who edgy?
- 35:56I mean again, we could go down a whole other Avenue and this like
- 35:59at the end of the day, France Falls trap into the same trap of
- 36:0490 percent of that money going to, you know, young white guys,
- 36:07and Paris. Yep.
- 36:09Yep. So, you know, there's plenty of
- 36:12challenges to tackle. There's plenty of ways to prove
- 36:19that France and Europe on a larger scale.
- 36:22Can do things differently than Silicon Valley, that it can
- 36:26carve out a path. That's somewhere between the
- 36:28cowboy image of Silicon Valley and the toe talion totalitarian
- 36:31approach of a China. So again, we'll see if it
- 36:37fulfills that promise but you know, I think yeah the Unicorn
- 36:40thing at a certain point it's like, you know again, it's
- 36:45someone who covers that stuff. That's just.
- 36:47Number on a piece of paper and those things are pretty
- 36:51fungible. It comes to, you know, probably
- 36:54yeah. And also half the time.
- 36:55It's, you know, it's not doesn't mean they're profitable.
- 36:58Oh, you don't remember, they're never profitable.
- 37:01Right? And that's a thing, right?
- 37:02At a certain point. That confuses people though.
- 37:05Yeah, who don't have your knowledge.
- 37:07I mean, I think it's, you know, shocking like one company of
- 37:10covered which again, gets area where I'm as an old guy who's
- 37:14been doing this forever, you know, areas of like, Blockchain
- 37:17and ft and the crypto stuff. Like, I'm still reluctantly
- 37:22having to learn what all this stuff means because that's
- 37:25clearly where the momentum is, but when a company like, the hot
- 37:30company of the moment is called Sir, our maybe heard it guys,
- 37:34they're like, no, basically it's a fantasy Soccer League Trading
- 37:41Card thing online. Oh boy.
- 37:44Okay, and you Use these new tools, crypto and nft to allow
- 37:50you and I to trade cards to build a fantasy league to win
- 37:56points to end it. And it's, it's a hot area,
- 38:00they've raised maybe more than 600 million euros.
- 38:05And beg loudll and they probably employ less than 100 people.
- 38:13And so, you know, that's always true, the beginning, these
- 38:18companies. There's a disconnect.
- 38:21Yeah, I think even when Google went public, it was less than a
- 38:23thousand people right now. It's I don't know how many sixty
- 38:27seventy eighty thousand people, you know, in those early days.
- 38:31It's kind of a slow ramp up and then when they become
- 38:34profitable, if they really succeed, then they become hiring
- 38:37engines, takes a little time and you have other companies like
- 38:41uber, which never recover. Affordable and just keep kind of
- 38:43using public money to subsidize cheap taxi rides and food
- 38:47delivery service. So I think that's you know yet
- 38:51another piece of the puzzle, can they build?
- 38:54Truly enduring profitable, meaningful companies over the
- 39:00long term and even if some of these ideas are maybe I'm not
- 39:05the right generation to Target some of these things.
- 39:09Who knows. I mean, maybe sir our can be
- 39:11that company. Maybe they can really be a huge
- 39:15French International Champion and then will they ever really
- 39:19generate enough jobs to have an impact back here on France that
- 39:22people think? Oh, yeah, this friends Tech
- 39:25stuff. It's really making the economy,
- 39:27um for me and creating opportunity.
- 39:31I think that's yet to be seen. Well, you certainly provide a
- 39:36wealth of that information free for people to read on the French
- 39:41Tech Journal, which you update multiple times a week.
- 39:45Now, there's a newsletter that's at least once or twice a week,
- 39:50you know, being a one-man band. That's a say that the schedule
- 39:55is variable the goal. Yeah, it's dry but still I hear.
- 39:59But that's it's still your very prolific and you're obviously
- 40:02this is an addition to your, you know, Wording for many outlets
- 40:07and you have another newsletter / website called French
- 40:11Crossroads, which is more travel focused and is also fascinating.
- 40:14And we'll let people into all sorts of regional insights, you
- 40:20know, help them think about where they're going to visit
- 40:23next. So you're kind of a very busy
- 40:25guy. I'm glad I managed to get you
- 40:27know, a bit of your time. So I think I'm a little
- 40:29masochistic about this stuff. But you know, it's you've been
- 40:33friends I think. Longer than I have.
- 40:34I mean, there's just yeah, it's just such an amazing place and
- 40:40so fascinating and Rich and so much going on.
- 40:44You know, I'm lucky about the tech stuff.
- 40:45I came from Silicon Valley before I moved here and the
- 40:50French people. I met in the valley thought I
- 40:52was in out of my mind, you know, they were all like we got the
- 40:57hell out of France because it's an entrepreneurial Wasteland.
- 41:00Look, why are you leaving Silicon Valley to go there and
- 41:04So the time he turned out to be good, you know, it's seen a real
- 41:07boom in that respect and a real transformation, you know, the
- 41:10travel stuff for me is just I've been lucky to do a lot of travel
- 41:14while I'm here and, you know, I couldn't even begin to write up
- 41:18a fraction of the stuff that I've done or places.
- 41:22I've seen or people, I've met. So it's great to just have a
- 41:24little Outlet to do that now and then Well, I highly recommend
- 41:29our listeners find you on Twitter, Chris O'Brien, always
- 41:33fascinating tweets, some of which go viral as we've seen
- 41:35this weekend and sign up for the French Tech Journal.
- 41:39If you're very interested in Tech or just understanding how
- 41:42that's evolving and French Crossroads.
- 41:44If you're interested in More Travel related stuff, Chris.
- 41:47Thank you so much. We're going to clearly have to
- 41:49do other episodes in the future drilled dig into some of these
- 41:53other issues, but this was a great start.
- 41:55Yep. Always happy to chat.
- 41:56Thank you for having me. That's the show for today.
- 42:01As always. Thank you for listening
- 42:03subscribing and sharing with Friends.
- 42:05You can find all previous episodes of The New Parish
- 42:07podcast, wherever you stream your podcasts and on world radio
- 42:10Paris. If you're enjoying these
- 42:12conversations, please consider picking up a copy of the New
- 42:15Paris book or my recent release for new Keynesian from your
- 42:19local book stores until next time.