Latest / Insights Now / Finding income for global investment portfolios
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Insights now,
- 0:05a series of conversations designed to shine a light of clarity on the complex world of investing so far.
- 0:11This season,
- 0:11we've invited a number of different fixed income portfolio managers and talk about the opportunities and bonds after a very challenged 2022 but investors don't just invest in bonds.
- 0:21So investing requires a decision on how to allocate all the pieces of the pie within a portfolio.
- 0:27In today's episode.
- 0:28I'm pleased to be joined by Phil Campli,
- 0:30a portfolio manager in our multi asset solutions group here at JP Morgan Asset Management as an active manager with a global opportunity set.
- 0:38He has to make that decision every day.
- 0:40What's the optimal mix of stocks versus bonds?
- 0:42And then how do you allocate within those sleeves?
- 0:45Where can you get the best?
- 0:46Bang for your buck in terms of returns while also managing risk in portfolios amidst a number of uncertainties about the outlook.
- 0:52These decisions largely depend on relative valuations,
- 0:56the outlook for interest rates and growth and the relative attractiveness of yields.
- 1:00So I'm eager to hear from Phil in today's episode on how he's shifting the dials and portfolios right now and the size he's allocated to fixed income.
- 1:07So,
- 1:08Phil,
- 1:08welcome back to insights now.
- 1:10Thanks for having me.
- 1:11So for starters,
- 1:12let's get a sense of your views in the current environment.
- 1:15How are you seeing the balance of risk for the economy and markets right now?
- 1:18Yeah,
- 1:18great question.
- 1:19And uh boy,
- 1:20am I happy that it's 2023 and not 2022.
- 1:23So,
- 1:24you know,
- 1:24one of the things as a multi asset investor,
- 1:26David that we care a lot about is the relationship between stocks and bonds.
- 1:31And I think 2023 is a return to normalcy in a way.
- 1:37And,
- 1:37and one of the things that really struck us about last year is that there was just nowhere to hide.
- 1:42So I think before we get into kind of what the balance of risks are,
- 1:46I think in,
- 1:47in a,
- 1:47in a world where the economy is either gonna hard land or soft land,
- 1:52we have the ability to navigate a lot better than what we did last year when bonds were the problem.
- 1:56And this year we kind of think bonds are,
- 1:58are part of the solution.
- 2:00So just how we're seeing things,
- 2:01uh we've come a long way uh since even though at the end of the,
- 2:04the end of last year.
- 2:06And I think once we got,
- 2:08once we got clarity on where and when the Federal Reserve would stop raising interest rates,
- 2:15um it really gave us a lot of clarity into how we would have to allocate.
- 2:19And what I mean by that is we have a neutral allocation to stocks.
- 2:22What does that mean in a 60 40 portfolio?
- 2:24It means we have about 60% in stocks and we're a little bit overweight bonds.
- 2:28So call it 40 to 40 a little over 40% in,
- 2:33in bonds.
- 2:33And our base case here.
- 2:35Ok.
- 2:35And don't kill the messenger.
- 2:36But our base case is that we do not believe we're going into a recession in the remainder of this year.
- 2:41We think it's going to be a close call,
- 2:43but our base case remains that we are not going into recession.
- 2:47Uh We think that the hard landing scenario is really the scenario that would force you to get very underweight,
- 2:56either stocks or other risk assets.
- 3:00And that's not just a scenario that would that,
- 3:01that we see.
- 3:02So again,
- 3:02while it's a close call,
- 3:04we just don't see the US economy heading into recession into the balance of this year.
- 3:08Ok.
- 3:08So I I get it that you're,
- 3:10you're still looking for a soft landing and,
- 3:12and thank you for being brave enough to make that call.
- 3:14Uh But that being said,
- 3:17what are the different roads?
- 3:18Do you think that could get us to either that self landing or a hard landing?
- 3:21Yeah.
- 3:22So the the window for a hard landing is closing really quickly again,
- 3:27if you go back to towards the end of last year.
- 3:30Uh And the Jack,
- 3:31even the Jackson Hole conference that the chairman gave at the end of the summer last year,
- 3:35you know,
- 3:35he used the word pain that the economy may need to endorse some pain in order for them to achieve their dual mandate.
- 3:43And at that point,
- 3:44David,
- 3:45the,
- 3:45the window for the hard landing was pretty open because that in uh for us said,
- 3:52OK,
- 3:53they may need to break the back of the economy in order to have any hope on achieving their inflation target.
- 4:00OK.
- 4:01Now,
- 4:01where have we evolved since then?
- 4:03We're now at the point where we have 10 straight drops in CP I after 10 rate hikes.
- 4:11So the window that can get you to a hard landing of the feds saying we have to take the federal funds rate,
- 4:18you know,
- 4:18back up through 6% or 6.5% in order to control inflation,
- 4:23the probability of that and accelerating inflation from here is just a low probability event.
- 4:29So that's the one road that can get you to a hard landing that fundamentally has changed over the last six months.
- 4:35The second road that can get you to a hard landing evolves around the regional bank story,
- 4:41David.
- 4:41Now it's not that they're going to tighten lending standards.
- 4:44I think the whole world knows and they were even tightening lending lending standards before the regional bank crisis in early March,
- 4:50I think the road that gets you to the hard landing is really a cute and chaotic deposit flight from these institutions.
- 5:00So again,
- 5:01not a tightening of lending standards,
- 5:02but something that shakes the confidence of the US consumer because they believe that their money is not safe in these institutions.
- 5:10And David that is simply not happening on a systemic basis.
- 5:14There are stories and anecdotes but there is nothing that we're seeing that is saying that there is chaotic deposit flight that would shake the confidence of the US consumer.
- 5:23So again,
- 5:24that's the second road that can get you to a hard landing,
- 5:27which almost then by default puts us in a world where yes,
- 5:30there are going to be challenges to growth below trend growth.
- 5:34There are going to be some challenges to earnings,
- 5:36but we do believe that the economy is going to remain resilient enough through those challenges.
- 5:41And most importantly,
- 5:42there are going to be some companies that are better than others in dealing with the tightening of financial conditions that have occurred.
- 5:50Ok.
- 5:50So I get that perspective.
- 5:53Um but I just want to talk about a different perspective because markets or the futures markets are currently pricing in a pretty sizeable pivot from the fed with multiple rate cuts before the year end.
- 6:04While the stock market is actually still up double digits this year.
- 6:07Seemingly pricing in more of a soft landing are stock and bond investors simply at odds with each other on the,
- 6:13on the fed outlook or what,
- 6:14what exactly do you think is priced into markets?
- 6:16Yeah,
- 6:17that's a,
- 6:17that's a fair question.
- 6:18And I would admit even,
- 6:20you know,
- 6:21something that is possibly a near term risk.
- 6:23It's like when Jerome Powell time after time has to say we're not easing,
- 6:27we're not easing,
- 6:28we're not easing.
- 6:29Um,
- 6:30we don't have an easing priced into our view until the earliest December of this year.
- 6:38And David,
- 6:38as you correctly stated,
- 6:41there is roughly 40 basis points of easing priced into the back half of this year that has recovered somewhat over the past couple of weeks.
- 6:50And we think that that's appropriate.
- 6:52Remember the chairman of the fed before Paul Volcker.
- 6:56Ok.
- 6:56Was the person that was blamed for letting inflation run rampant.
- 7:02His name is Arthur Burns and no one at the Federal Reserve wants to have the legacy of saying we took our foot off the pedal too soon um And allowed inflation to re accelerate.
- 7:14Now,
- 7:15that being said,
- 7:16we don't have the fed come back to tighten.
- 7:18I think that that's one scenario we're not positioned for if the fed had to come back and say,
- 7:23you know what,
- 7:23we have to do 15 basis points again because inflation is is accelerating.
- 7:27So I think the pause is almost like the new tightening at this point for markets where the market in the near term could be somewhat upset that they're not going to get the easing that they imminently want.
- 7:39But David that easing is coming,
- 7:41it's either going,
- 7:41going to be because of a hard landing scenario,
- 7:44which again,
- 7:44not our base case.
- 7:46But in that scenario,
- 7:46of course,
- 7:47the feds do mandate as full employment and price stability.
- 7:50And if the unemployment rate starts to go up,
- 7:52then you don't need and growth starts to go down,
- 7:55then you don't need this restricted federal funds rate anymore.
- 7:57So the easing would come then.
- 7:59But our base case is more of the fact that by the end of this year,
- 8:03year,
- 8:03over year,
- 8:04CP I looks more like a three handle.
- 8:07We have a shot at a two handle but more like a low three handle on CP I and then there'll be a lot of pressure on the fed of saying why do we need a five and a quarter percent federal funds?
- 8:17Right?
- 8:17If inflation is closer to three and not 56 or seven.
- 8:22So in that environment,
- 8:23that's where the ease comes in.
- 8:24But again,
- 8:25we just don't think again because of that Arthur Bernstein legacy that nobody wants and you can't wave the victory flag just yet.
- 8:31We don't think that easing could be priced in until at least December,
- 8:34but more likely early 2024.
- 8:37What I think are at odds with each other is the bond market and the bond market.
- 8:42So the yield curve is saying you are very,
- 8:46very flat here.
- 8:47OK?
- 8:48You have a yield curve that's inverted and usually that poor tends,
- 8:51you know,
- 8:52there,
- 8:52there's,
- 8:52there's,
- 8:53there's doctor yield curve,
- 8:54as I like to say,
- 8:54no offense to Doctor Kelly,
- 8:56but there's a doctor yield curve who's a great economist,
- 8:59that's,
- 8:59you know,
- 9:00that that's gonna,
- 9:00that's gonna be a recession.
- 9:02But I think what the credit markets are saying is something that looks more like our base case,
- 9:06David,
- 9:07where investment grade corporate bonds are trading about 100 and 50 over high yield bonds are trading about 403 104 100 over.
- 9:15And that for us looks more consistent with our base case view of yes,
- 9:20still somewhat challenged growth but not a hard landing view.
- 9:23Of course,
- 9:24it could be that,
- 9:25you know,
- 9:25it's very unusual also to have the Federal Reserve explicitly forecast that they are going to cut short term interest rates over the next few years.
- 9:33And that their long term view on the federal funds rate is about half of where it is right now.
- 9:38And that's very unusual.
- 9:39And that also,
- 9:40I suppose may be having some impact on uh on shaping the yield curve in in what looks like a somewhat more pessimistic perspective than your perspective of the stock market's perspective on the economy.
- 9:51And remember David,
- 9:52as you know,
- 9:52and as we lived through the FED,
- 9:54moved by 525 basis points in 10 meetings.
- 9:58They went 4 75 base point rate hikes in a row.
- 10:01What that did to the front end of the yield curve?
- 10:04We don't believe the back end had any chance of keeping up with because it was moving so violently to the upside and the front end.
- 10:11I think the flatness of the or the inversion of the yield curve is,
- 10:15is tend to be a little bit overstated in terms of its impact on growth.
- 10:19Having said that,
- 10:20are we gonna at some stage in the next few years?
- 10:23See a normal upward sloping yield curve again?
- 10:26And what would it take to get there?
- 10:27Yeah,
- 10:27so listen,
- 10:28on our long term capital market assumptions.
- 10:31As you know,
- 10:31David,
- 10:32we are forecasting a positively sloped yield curve.
- 10:35We have the,
- 10:36the fair value of the federal funds rate at about 2% the fair value of the 10 year treasury at about three and a quarter.
- 10:43So we do have this positively slope yield curve on a long term capital market assumption standpoint.
- 10:48But as you know,
- 10:49we can't just tell our clients,
- 10:51you know,
- 10:51don't look at your statement for a decade and everything will work out.
- 10:54I think the the the normal or the traditional path to getting the yield curve to be less inverted has to come again,
- 11:02either because the fed is fighting a recession and has to drop the front end of the curve.
- 11:08And then the curve kind of re steepens.
- 11:10So all the work is being done by the front end or David,
- 11:13you get kind of that soft landing scenario which just takes longer.
- 11:17The curve is going to be inverted.
- 11:19OK.
- 11:19For a while through that soft landing kind of gradual disinflation story.
- 11:24So if you want a yield curve to be positively sloped overnight,
- 11:28I think you need a hard landing.
- 11:29I think the flatness of the yield curve is going to be with us uh for,
- 11:33for a while as,
- 11:35as this disinflationary process takes a little time to go from kind of 3% where we have it at the end of this year.
- 11:42I think it might take another year,
- 11:44David in order for inflation to get back to to fed target at about 2%.
- 11:48And in that environment,
- 11:50you Kirk is going to stay pretty,
- 11:51pretty darn flat.
- 11:52OK?
- 11:52Um So maybe we can broaden the discussion a little bit beyond the bond market because of course,
- 11:56you manage global multi asset portfolios and so you're not wed to fixed income when you're just trying to get income.
- 12:03So what,
- 12:03what opportunities did you see outside of bonds to take advantage of right now?
- 12:07Yeah.
- 12:08So you know,
- 12:08II I grew up in the bond market and I really do believe that the risk free rate is,
- 12:13is kind of the straw that stirs the drink.
- 12:15I know you're a big Yankees fan,
- 12:16David.
- 12:16So I use the Reggie Jackson reference for you there.
- 12:19I think a Red Sox fan.
- 12:20But go,
- 12:21go ahead.
- 12:21Yeah,
- 12:23I know.
- 12:23I,
- 12:24I know,
- 12:24I know where I know where your loyalties lie.
- 12:26Um,
- 12:26but I do believe that there are really good opportunities outside of,
- 12:31outside of the US.
- 12:32David.
- 12:32And,
- 12:33and you guys in the guide to the markets have that really great slide where it shows the cumulative outperform of the US versus non US asset classes.
- 12:43And you know,
- 12:44that that gray shaded area which is us outperform and seemed like it would never end.
- 12:50And I think if you look closely on that slide now,
- 12:53David over the past year and a half and certainly year to date,
- 12:56you see significant non us outperforming.
- 12:59This is a trade we still believe in.
- 13:01Fundamentally speaking,
- 13:03um the US exceptionalism that occurred in interest rate markets when the Federal Reserve was tightening rates from 2015 to 2018.
- 13:13And the rest of the world,
- 13:14particularly the European Central Bank were caught in a negative interest rate environment and couldn't get out of it.
- 13:22And the upward pressure that,
- 13:23that put on the dollar,
- 13:25um was a really tough trade to fight against.
- 13:28And then you add on top of that,
- 13:30what happened in the pandemic through the Russian Ukraine crisis.
- 13:33And up through about the third quarter of last year,
- 13:36when the fed finally signaled that they could be less aggressive in their tightening cycle and the dollar was on a tear.
- 13:42And when you're a US investor investing abroad,
- 13:45you kind of have two bets on,
- 13:47you have the bet on yes,
- 13:49that international company.
- 13:50But you also have the bet.
- 13:52If again,
- 13:52if you're a US investor that want dollar returns,
- 13:55you have the bet on the US dollar at the same time.
- 13:58And now at this point,
- 14:00we can kind of definitively say that the um the strength of the dollar and the upward pressure that the US exceptionalism in terms of interest rate policy put on the dollar goes,
- 14:12that that field looks a lot more level.
- 14:14Now European central bank needed a pandemic and the inflation related.
- 14:19Uh I'm sorry,
- 14:20and the inflation uh that came out of the pandemic and all of the policy decisions they made during the pandemic,
- 14:25but they finally got the window to get out of negative interest rate policy.
- 14:29That's the first thing.
- 14:30The second thing that I think is really important uh with Europe is that there's a huge,
- 14:36huge home country bias in this country and it's an under owned asset class.
- 14:41I go around the country and everyone is asking this question why?
- 14:44Because they don't own it.
- 14:45So I think the the technical around,
- 14:49you know,
- 14:49the bid for non US asset classes when it is performing at a time when the dollar isn't just eroding all of your returns away,
- 14:55I think are pretty spectacular.
- 14:57And then the last piece that I put on this from a more tactical perspective is,
- 15:02you know,
- 15:02there's plenty of debate even internally David,
- 15:05as you know,
- 15:05with whether the US is going to go into recession or not.
- 15:08But the story that Europe is going to avoid recession in 2023 is really widely held.
- 15:14And there's a different trajectory of earnings based on that confidence of growth,
- 15:21staying positive in Europe,
- 15:23that simply doesn't exist in the US.
- 15:25So you put all that together,
- 15:26you know,
- 15:26the dollar behaving the good tactical fundamental story until we head into next winter.
- 15:32And the fact that it's under owned,
- 15:34uh David and,
- 15:35and you're creating a really a really good um a really good um story.
- 15:39Also,
- 15:40you have a 5% dividend yield in international stocks,
- 15:43the S and P is closer to four and then just doesn't aside some of the other things that we're taking advantage of outside of traditional bonds for income,
- 15:51you know,
- 15:51preferred equities still belong in an allocation for us for income yielding about 6%.
- 15:57Again,
- 15:58that's akin to the bond story where we have,
- 16:01you know,
- 16:01plenty of clarity.
- 16:02Now,
- 16:02we think on the terminal rate uh of,
- 16:06of,
- 16:06of federal funds.
- 16:07So,
- 16:07you know,
- 16:07preferred equities yielding 6% are also an interesting place for us uh to take advantage of,
- 16:13of,
- 16:13of income opportunities.
- 16:14So let's talk a little bit about balanced portfolios.
- 16:17Um as we predicted in our long term capital market assumptions which were published late last year,
- 16:22we thought the 60 40 portfolio would do better,
- 16:25a lot better in the long run and actually year to date,
- 16:27it's,
- 16:27it's doing pretty well up about 7% after a truly gruesome 2022.
- 16:32Do you think this performance of a 60 40 portfolio can be maintained?
- 16:36Yes.
- 16:37Absolutely.
- 16:37David.
- 16:38And it's because we think you can continue to get return from both the 60 the 40.
- 16:43I think,
- 16:44you know,
- 16:44you've,
- 16:44you've,
- 16:44you've said a lot of great one liners over the years,
- 16:47but the one that I've stolen the most from you this year is you don't position your portfolio for things that happen once every 50 years.
- 16:53And as you correctly observed and your team is correctly observed last year was the first year since 1974 where the 60 40 was down with both the 60 the 40 being down.
- 17:04And what that did was set us up for success as we came into 2023.
- 17:10If you believed that the um kind of inflation consequence that we saw in 2022 was a cyclical byproduct of the pandemic and not something structural that was going to last forever.
- 17:24So if you just believe that that it was a cyclical byproduct of the,
- 17:27of the pandemic and not something that would last forever,
- 17:30that's where we get the power of the bond story where all yields,
- 17:35whether it be the front end or the long end,
- 17:37we think now have a duration or an industry sensitivity tailwind and not a headwind.
- 17:43So we think the bond market that's probably our highest confidence view.
- 17:47You know,
- 17:47you can get a little bit on top of the traditional government bond story by using places like investment greed,
- 17:52credit or even high yield if you have an income mandate,
- 17:56David.
- 17:57But also the equity side,
- 17:59I think the equity side is also important in our long term capital market assumption swing,
- 18:04which is when we went from,
- 18:05you know,
- 18:054.3% annualized to 7% annualized in just one year we saw in the equity side.
- 18:12So the 60 side of the 60 40 a 290 basis point annualized swing in valuations coming from the equity market.
- 18:22So in other words,
- 18:23when the 60 40 was only delivering 4.3 equities looked expensive after a last year.
- 18:29Now we have a tailwind on valuations that we think can continue,
- 18:34especially the globally diversified equity.
- 18:38We mentioned non US equity a couple of minutes ago,
- 18:41you know,
- 18:41the normal pe discount on international equities is about 15% P discounts in the US and it's now trading closer to 30.
- 18:51So there still uh is a lot of valuation to take advantage of on both the 60 the 40.
- 18:57And remember that 7% that you quoted,
- 18:59that's just beta,
- 19:01that's just buying the indices,
- 19:03buying the the stock index and buying the bond index.
- 19:06What's really exciting about the forecast in my opinion is that if you throw alpha assumptions on top of the beta,
- 19:15you know,
- 19:15in most of our multi asset portfolios,
- 19:17you're getting between 100 and 100 and 50 basis points of alpha coming from tactical asset allocation and security selection.
- 19:25Where if you put that on top of the 7.2% return,
- 19:28we think the achievable total,
- 19:30David can be,
- 19:31you know,
- 19:328.5 to 9% which is really exciting.
- 19:34And again,
- 19:35something that we think we can,
- 19:36we can sustain and maintain,
- 19:38that is pretty exciting.
- 19:39But then I got to sort of think a little bit about investor behavior and I guess this is my last question to you.
- 19:44I,
- 19:44I think,
- 19:45you know,
- 19:45and investors have been pretty active uh so far this year,
- 19:48but the risk free rate is at about 5%.
- 19:51Um So you can sort of see why it makes sense to that,
- 19:55that so many people are putting money into money,
- 19:56market funds rather than the market.
- 19:58Do you think those flow is going to continue or you think it's soon going to be time for investors to add risk back to portfolios?
- 20:05Yeah,
- 20:05David,
- 20:06unfortunately,
- 20:06I think it's gonna continue until,
- 20:09until they finally see the easing.
- 20:11So I used to call,
- 20:13you know,
- 20:13a lot of other,
- 20:14other folks,
- 20:15my competitors over the years.
- 20:17And now my biggest competitor is the three month T bill because people are just piling into the front end looking for that yield,
- 20:25believing that it's risk free now for ca for cash investors.
- 20:30Congratulations.
- 20:31You're now getting a meaningful return,
- 20:34right?
- 20:34If you are a cash investor for the first time since before 2008,
- 20:38when rates got taken to zero for a prolonged amount of time.
- 20:42So those investors are happy.
- 20:43I'm happy for them.
- 20:44You know,
- 20:44congratulations.
- 20:45The people that I'm talking to David are the folks that derisk last year into cash because it was the only thing that was working and last year that was really the only solution because as I mentioned,
- 20:58first year since 1974 that both stocks and bonds went down with the 60 40 being lower.
- 21:04What,
- 21:05what I'm trying to get out there and tell people is that once the fed paused,
- 21:11which we think they did in their may meeting that now raised the opportunity cost for investors that have derisk away from balance returns.
- 21:21As you just said,
- 21:23the 60 40 is already up this year depending on which one you're looking at between six and 7%.
- 21:28Even if you're getting 5% in cash,
- 21:30you need a full year to get it.
- 21:32And every three months,
- 21:33if you're investing in the three month T bill,
- 21:35you gotta roll that thing.
- 21:36And I'm not sure whether it's going to be the fall December the first quarter of next year or the middle of next year.
- 21:42But at some point over the next 12 months,
- 21:44David,
- 21:44we're probably gonna be talking about the Federal Reserve optimizing rates a little bit lower to deal with either a different inflation or growth forecast.
- 21:54And in that environment that reinvestment risk becomes real.
- 21:57And David,
- 21:58those are the folks that I'm looking for now again,
- 22:00I don't think it's going to change until the fed actually reduces rates because people believe that that's a risk free rate.
- 22:06I'm talking about the opportunity cost here for investors that derisk last year that are gonna miss either on the 60 or the 40 side in a diversified portfolio.
- 22:16You know,
- 22:17that's a great,
- 22:17great piece of advice for long-term investors.
- 22:20I think people forget their long term investors and the problem is,
- 22:22you know,
- 22:22what,
- 22:22what,
- 22:23what happens when rates come back down again?
- 22:25Thank you so much for joining us,
- 22:26Phil and thank you all for listening.
- 22:28Thanks David.
- 22:28Great to be here.
- 22:29Please tune in to our next episode where we will conclude this season of a Bonds Eye view with a conversation with Bob Michael,
- 22:36chief investment officer and head of our fixed income strategies here at JP Morgan Asset Management.
- 22:40Drowned out this season with the outlook for bonds for the remainder of 2023 and beyond.
- 22:45On our next episode,
- 22:46I invite you to read or listen to my notes in the week ahead podcast where every Monday,
- 22:50I share a commentary on the latest in the markets and the economy to help you stay informed for the week ahead.
- 22:54For even more timely insights you can also follow and subscribe to my content on linkedin.
- 23:00This content is intended for information only based on assumptions and current market conditions and are subject to change.
- 23:06No warranty of accuracy is given.
- 23:08This content does not contain sufficient information to support investment decisions.
- 23:12It is not to be construed as research,
- 23:13legal regulatory tax,
- 23:15accounting or investment advice,
- 23:18investments involve risks.
- 23:19Investors should seek professional advice or make an independent evaluation before investing the value of investments and the income from them may fluctuate including loss of capital,
- 23:28past performance and yield are not indicative of current or future results.
- 23:32Forecasts and estimates may or may not come to pass.
- 23:35JP Morgan Asset Management is the asset management business of JP Morgan Chase and Company and its affiliates worldwide.