Latest / AST SpaceMobile Podcast / Anpanman - Updated thoughts on Globalstar rumors and recent precedent
Transcript
- 0:07This is the AST Space Mobile podcast where we.
- 0:11Just basically come from be seamless regardless of where you
- 0:15are. We don't want the user even to
- 0:16know that it's connected by satellite.
- 0:21Listen, the opportunity that we have is very, very, very large.
- 0:24Large. Hey everyone, Happy Sunday.
- 0:30It's a beautiful Sunday, more I guess afternoon here in New York
- 0:33City. The marathon running, which is
- 0:36always a great event. Just got back from some kids
- 0:40soccer and I have a little bit of free time.
- 0:43So I figured I'd run a space and provide some additional thoughts
- 0:47about the article or sorry, not the article, but the the post
- 0:50that I'd put up about global star and potential SpaceX
- 0:55interest and reported and SpaceX X interest and how Apple fits
- 0:59into that. If people can give me a thumbs
- 1:02up. I just want to make sure that
- 1:04before I start rambling that people can hear me.
- 1:07Just look here. What's weird about I mentions
- 1:16for Twitter Spaces is that you there's a delay, it's probably
- 1:2115 seconds, 10 seconds delay. And so when you're not live, you
- 1:26actually when I, when you ask for like thumbs up, you don't
- 1:30really see thumbs up until a few seconds later.
- 1:34So anyway, yeah, thanks everyone for joining.
- 1:37I wanted to talk about some latest thoughts about the the,
- 1:42the two information articles and then one Bloomberg article that
- 1:45leaked over this past week about a supposed global star sale
- 1:50process and what it means and what it what it could mean.
- 1:54And that there's an interesting precedent that I wanted to talk
- 1:56about, which kind of gives you a good sense of the potential deal
- 2:02dynamics and why a deal would be tough.
- 2:07Unless of course, I mean, all roads basically lead through
- 2:09Apple because they effectively control global star.
- 2:12And so if Apple has indeed changed their heart and is
- 2:17willing to work with SpaceX, then certainly a deal can can
- 2:20happen. And never say never.
- 2:22I mean, you know, there's, there's a whole host of reasons
- 2:26why Apple should work with SpaceX and there's, there's a
- 2:29whole host of reasons why they shouldn't work with them.
- 2:31And we'll, we'll kind of go through those.
- 2:32But but yeah, so I guess to start, I did want to answer a
- 2:37few questions. There was there was some people
- 2:39who reached out to me and said, hey, isn't leaking this stuff
- 2:42illegal because it's material, non public information?
- 2:44And can people get sued like journalists or the sources?
- 2:49And I'll just say, when I was an investment banker, you know, I
- 2:52did M&A in the tech industry for and, and you know, financings,
- 2:57IP OS for one of the big banks for, you know, call it eight
- 3:01years. And leaks are pretty common
- 3:04practice. I would say some firms, you
- 3:06know, definitely look down on it, but it's, it's part of like
- 3:08deal tap looks right. And so if you're a banker, an
- 3:12attorney or even APR firm working with the company,
- 3:15usually a thief PR firm gets engaged when a deal's about to
- 3:18get announced. And so they usually aren't the,
- 3:22the source of leaks, but it's usually bankers or lawyers and
- 3:25sometimes company insiders. And the reason why leaks happen
- 3:29is that it's, and This is why I've said whenever you read
- 3:33something in the journal about a sale process or something high
- 3:36profile, you always have to ask yourself, you know, why is it
- 3:39being leaked and who's leaking it?
- 3:40And you know, what's their objective?
- 3:43What, what are they trying to accomplish?
- 3:44And so often times leaks will happen for a number of reasons.
- 3:49For example, if a company is has put itself up for sale and let's
- 3:55say they send out, they send all feelers to various buyers and,
- 4:00and let's say they're not getting the reception that, that
- 4:04they thought they would. That's not as much interest.
- 4:07Then you might go out to Bloomberg and say, hey, the
- 4:10company is in, in the sale, in the process of selling itself.
- 4:14And you know, let's say Amazon, Meta and Google are thought to
- 4:19be lead bidders. Then all of a sudden that makes
- 4:22potential buyers snapped your attention like, oh, they've got
- 4:24real players there who are looking to tend to acquire the
- 4:28company. Maybe I should take a look too.
- 4:29And so that's one way where you can hopefully gin up more
- 4:34interest. It is risky though, because you
- 4:37know for any company that if you're in a hot sale process,
- 4:40it's actually usually a good thing because then you can
- 4:43informally let the market know that there's a lot of buyers
- 4:46involved. You might also put a price out
- 4:48there like the board might have some price expectations of like,
- 4:51hey, we, we, we think clearing price of $10 billion or more
- 4:55will get the deal done. And so often times that will get
- 4:58leaked too. But you know, the, the on the,
- 5:01on the flip side, it can be risky, right?
- 5:03Because if it's a, often times if there's a sale process, it's
- 5:09not going well and you try to leak things like, oh, you know,
- 5:12potentially Bain Capitals there and some other PE firm And, and
- 5:16here the price expectations. Well, it's not as if I the buy
- 5:21side get their advisors or the buyers are not sophisticated
- 5:24either. Sometimes they can kind of read
- 5:26the tea leaves and, and see what people in the process are doing
- 5:29and be like, oh, that article was Leech because this process
- 5:32is not going well. And so I, I can lower the price
- 5:35or I can just walk away like nothing's happening here.
- 5:38And so there, there is a risk. You know, often times some
- 5:42buyers who are in processes, if they see news leak, they will
- 5:45tell even before the process starts, they'll tell sell side
- 5:48advisors like if there's any leaks, like there's no deal,
- 5:51we're we're not going to be part of some public auction.
- 5:54And often times, like if the companies are in exclusivity,
- 5:58for example, let's say the buyer and the seller get into
- 6:03exclusivity for a period of, you know, call it 2, two weeks or
- 6:06something, then leaks, leaks at that point are, are quite
- 6:10dangerous because as the seller, you don't want to piss off the
- 6:13buyer. And if you're an exclusive
- 6:14talks, you know, you, you want to get that deal done.
- 6:19But then then there's also other leaks that try to kill the deal.
- 6:22Like if if you, if you're a, let's say, if you're a buyer who
- 6:27didn't make it to the final rounds or didn't get
- 6:29exclusivity, you might leak it to the Wall Street Journal to
- 6:32try to blow the process up. And so that's why there's so
- 6:35many different potential reasons why you might leak a deal or
- 6:40leak a situation. You might want to try to set
- 6:43price expectations. Another thing is like sometimes
- 6:45buyers who aren't in a target company, then they're unwilling
- 6:48to sell. They'll put them in play.
- 6:50Like they'll actually leak an article and say XYZ company
- 6:54approached so and so with a price of this high and were
- 6:58rebuffed. And then all of a sudden, the
- 7:00target, you know, is now that that's like a very hostile
- 7:04approach where then you might have ARDS and a Ventraven hedge
- 7:08funds start buying the stock and the stock goes up, you know,
- 7:112030%. And then you've got these hedge
- 7:14funds calling board of management saying, hey, you guys
- 7:16should sell the company. And they're incentivized to do
- 7:18that because all of a sudden they're involved in a stock
- 7:21that's up 2030%. And if the company doesn't sell
- 7:24itself, then the stock's going to drop back down.
- 7:26And so all, you know, there's this shoulder pressure to get
- 7:28something done. And so that would be like a
- 7:30hostile situation where, you know, a buyer tries to put a
- 7:34company in play by leaking that they approach them or somebody
- 7:37else approach them, and then the company rebuffed them.
- 7:41And so other things, other potential leaks are you could
- 7:45have attorneys or bankers, basically what we call like a
- 7:50trial blown like they, they, they float a potential deal.
- 7:53And Gold Star would fit into this construct, by the way, you
- 7:57might, you might float the idea of a potential deal.
- 8:00And then you have something to actually talk about with
- 8:02regulators. Like you could, you could
- 8:05totally see SpaceX going up to Chairman Carr at the rented car
- 8:10at the FCC and you know, the attorney general at the
- 8:14Department of Justice and say, Hey, you know that article, you
- 8:18know, just curious like what your thoughts are or get a
- 8:21reaction from maybe staff of what they think about a
- 8:24potential transaction. And so, you know, you might, you
- 8:27might float regulatory balloons to see what the market reaction
- 8:30is like if the market and this is like this is kind of deal tax
- 8:34one O 1. If you're a buyer and you're
- 8:37unclear whether or not the market would be receptive to a
- 8:40potential acquisition of another company, you might go leak it
- 8:43and then see what your stock price does.
- 8:44If the stock price goes up, then it's like, oh, investors think
- 8:47it's a good idea. And so I think I have,
- 8:49especially if you're issuing the stock, then you're like, oh, I
- 8:52have, I have the mandate. Or at least initially, it seems
- 8:55like the market would be OK with it.
- 8:57Obviously the market needs to understand what the terms are,
- 8:59but but that might be a trouble when you float to see what the
- 9:05market reaction is. And then, of course, if it is
- 9:07something that is sensitive from a regulatory standpoint, you
- 9:11might get some comments from politicians.
- 9:13You're like, oh, yeah, this is a good deal.
- 9:15Or this promotes, you know, American leadership in the
- 9:18sector. Or you might get other
- 9:20politicians or regulators who might come back and say, this
- 9:24thing's DOA dead on arrival. Like, there's no way we're going
- 9:26to let this deal happen. We're going to go try to block
- 9:28it or whatever. And so.
- 9:31So, yeah, that would be a potential regulatory like a
- 9:35child balloon that people float. They leak some article.
- 9:38But but going back to what I was saying before, you know, is it
- 9:41legal? Yeah, it's legal.
- 9:43It's looked down upon. But companies, bankers, lawyers,
- 9:46they all engage in it and they do it to accomplish what are
- 9:51objectives. They are whether it's, you know,
- 9:54there, there's always some angle, which is why it's rare
- 9:57when journalists actually dig up something and they get it right.
- 10:01Usually they get pieces of it fed to them and, and they're
- 10:04given hints and directions. And it's like, hey, I think you
- 10:07should go talk to this person or this company or, you know,
- 10:10here's here's a few crumbs. Maybe check out these filings or
- 10:13they'll just get told directly what it is.
- 10:15And by the very nature that this information is being fed to a
- 10:19journalist who then goes and publishes it, it's legal in a
- 10:23sense that that private information becomes widely
- 10:25distributed and public now. And so it's not material, non
- 10:28public information because it becomes material, but public
- 10:31information, if that makes sense.
- 10:33And so, and journalists have, you know, a high degree of
- 10:38protections given, you know, the freedom of speech and, and in
- 10:42the US and, and as long as they are widely disseminated, that
- 10:45information, then it becomes, you know, cleansed in some, in
- 10:49some regards. Now, if a journalist is talking
- 10:52to sources and then trades on that information on their own,
- 10:55then then obviously that's illegal.
- 10:56Or if they share that information directly to say a
- 11:01hedge fund and they trade on it, that's, that's illegal.
- 11:04However, if a, if an investor is talking to journalists and
- 11:08they're doing research and it's part of a mosaic where they,
- 11:11they get some hints that maybe a company is looking at some
- 11:15strategic alternatives. And that investor also looks at,
- 11:19I'll just make stuff up. Like, you know, the company
- 11:21recently put in a double trigger mechanism on the, on the
- 11:25executive compensation packages like a month ago, which you
- 11:28know, which typically you would do in a change of control
- 11:32transaction. You want to keep the executives
- 11:33around. And so sometimes that's a tell
- 11:36where people put double triggers in compensation packages like a
- 11:40few months right before deals announced.
- 11:42So they put that together, they put, they look at some of the
- 11:45other things that companies doing maybe on the conference
- 11:48call, you know, for example, radium on their conference call,
- 11:53you could tell like they're boxed in and they need to do
- 11:55something. And, and, and all the research
- 11:58channels are like, out of all the five or six companies, who
- 12:02are your top partners, then that seems pretty clear, like the
- 12:05company probably needs to sell itself.
- 12:07And so in that regard, if, if let's say hedge funds were
- 12:12talking to some of these journalists and journals are
- 12:14smart, they're not going to give any details away.
- 12:17And, and they know they can get in trouble too.
- 12:19But but if that hedge fund were to piece the pieces, piece
- 12:24together the pieces of the puzzle and create a mosaic of
- 12:27Leia, I think something's happening with this company
- 12:30that's legal. And that's, that's stuff that,
- 12:32for example, space mob does like you're, you piece together
- 12:36various pieces of information. You know, who, what, what is the
- 12:40company? You know, what is the company
- 12:42posting about? And you know, maybe there's like
- 12:44some logistics and variation things like that.
- 12:47And, and and maybe about has met has gone to Saudi Arabia a few
- 12:50times and then at their conferences and you know, maybe
- 12:54there's some Saudi Arabian officials who who posted about
- 12:58the company then then yeah, maybe there there could be
- 13:01something going on there. I mean, obviously the company
- 13:03had MO us with with or has MO us with the top three Saudi
- 13:08carriers, the M and OS. And so it seems very likely that
- 13:12a deal with one of the three at a minimum, and of course, all
- 13:14three is likely to happen. But anyway, that's a long
- 13:18rambling introduction to, you know, why these types of things
- 13:22get leaked. And and yeah, so I think it's
- 13:25important to really, when you see this type of stuff, to
- 13:29really take a step back and ask yourself, why is the news coming
- 13:32out now? Who's doing it and what is their
- 13:34objective? And so, so going back to the
- 13:37information back in May, I believe it was May or January,
- 13:44there was an article that that was leaked about how Apple, I
- 13:50should pull it up and just take a look here.
- 13:55There's a whole history about how satellite, Apple satellite
- 13:59ambitions have been threatened by Elon Musk.
- 14:02And then how the two companies, you know, I've kind of had the
- 14:05standoff relationship and then Global Stars kind of in the
- 14:09middle of it all. And, and so that kind of laid
- 14:11the groundwork. Sorry, this was in May of, of
- 14:132025. And so that laid the groundwork
- 14:16of where we are today. And that gave kind of an
- 14:19overview of what the relationship, how it kind of
- 14:23evolved. And, and I think for those who
- 14:25don't know, I believe Apple and this is kind of beyond the
- 14:28article, but I think Apple started testing with Global Star
- 14:31and thinking through the potential of providing satellite
- 14:35SOS and, and text messaging back in 2021.
- 14:38And there were hints of it where I think in some disclosures
- 14:41around related to Global Star, they talked about an unnamed
- 14:44partner that was giving them potential payments and, and
- 14:48testing the service. And of course, our, our industry
- 14:51consultant Inferrar was very close to that.
- 14:54He wrote about it at length. We all know that he works for
- 14:58Global Star in his recent industry presentation where he
- 15:02he talks about the DDT market. That whole presentation in a
- 15:05very, very tiny disclosure in one of the random pages, it says
- 15:09the whole report was paid for by Global Start.
- 15:11But the reason why I mentioned him is that he is, it does seem
- 15:16to me just kind of going through the articles is that he is a
- 15:19primary source of some of some of the information here.
- 15:23And so I think the company is using him as well as their
- 15:25bankers as a conduit to kind of feed these journalists.
- 15:29And so in that first article, it talks about the I need to
- 15:33relationship between, you know, Elon Musk and and Tim Cook about
- 15:38how obviously Apple was developing their service.
- 15:41And then when Musk found out that this was happening, he he
- 15:45supposedly, and this is according to the journalist and
- 15:47by the way, the two journalists at the information both cover
- 15:50have both historically covered Apple to the Wall Street
- 15:54Journal. And so so they do have some
- 15:56sourcing from former Apple execs and perhaps some Apple people
- 16:01who work at Apple now. But anyway, but in that article,
- 16:06they specifically mentioned how when Musk had learned in 2022
- 16:10that that Apple was going to include Global Star SOS
- 16:13messaging and the Rifund 14, he, you know, contacted the company
- 16:17and said, hey, we want to do this.
- 16:19We'll provide it for you and we want you to pay us.
- 16:23And, and by the way, this is like this goes back to like,
- 16:26hey, is this really a market and are people going to pay for it?
- 16:28Well, SpaceX wanted to charge Apple $5 billion upfront for 18
- 16:33months and then on an ongoing base after that exclusivity
- 16:39period ended, they would charge them $1 billion a year for the
- 16:42startling service. And they have supposedly, you
- 16:45know, 72 hours to decide. And of course, you know, Tim
- 16:48Cook and Apple rejected that. And then, and then infamously,
- 16:51SpaceX announced in August of 2022 that they were going to
- 16:57partner with T-Mobile. They, they supposedly created
- 17:00this, this new technology that could connect to cell phones.
- 17:03So they announced that in August 2022, which which is announced
- 17:07right before Apple announced their new product with Goldstar,
- 17:09which was September of 2022. Interesting.
- 17:12Of course, HD space mobile Blue Walker 3 was supposed to launch,
- 17:17I think it was that July or August and then it got pushed
- 17:20back to September. And so, you know, just like Musk
- 17:24does and you know that that's one of his talents as opposed to
- 17:29T-Mobile. They, they got to be, they got,
- 17:32you know, they, they, they were able to win mindshare amongst
- 17:35the news outlets. And, and they claim to this day
- 17:37that they were first announcing, you know, this potential product
- 17:41in August of 2022, when in fact, as we all know, AST space
- 17:45mobile, you know, kicked off this whole market in, in 2017.
- 17:50And so anyway, they in that article, it talks about how
- 17:56there's this uneasy relationship between these three companies.
- 17:59Obviously, you know, SpaceX slash Starlink slash Tesla have
- 18:04various potential competing products.
- 18:06I mean, the biggest hydro fall one would be Elon Musk's, you
- 18:10know, his alluding to potentially developing his own
- 18:14mobile phone to compete with with, you know, Apple and
- 18:17Google, but then also trying to provide Internet connectivity
- 18:21directly to phones and basically going around MNO carriers.
- 18:26And so for those that don't know, there's also some
- 18:28additional history here between Elon Musk and and Tim Cook.
- 18:33When Tesla was in trouble. I think it was like in 20, I
- 18:37forget exactly how many years ago, but there was a point in
- 18:40time when Tesla had Elon Musk tried to contact him Cook and
- 18:44and offered to sell Tesla to Apple when they were having
- 18:48tough times. And then from and depends on
- 18:52whose account you read, but supposedly when they did talk,
- 18:57Elon Musk was like, Hey, I want you to buy my company and then
- 18:59I'll be the CEO of the combined company.
- 19:02And then Tim Cook was like, no. And so there's, there's some
- 19:06history between the two and which I guess you know, it's a
- 19:11little bit of friction. But beyond that, obviously
- 19:14interventionist before given even where what SpaceX is trying
- 19:18to do, I think they're going to be increasingly competitive with
- 19:21Apple. And I'll talk a bit more about
- 19:23that later. But anyway, so yeah, there was
- 19:26this article, which I've posted it before.
- 19:29If you do a search on the information or go to my profile,
- 19:33you can see the first article where it talks about the, the
- 19:37issues between the two companies and how Apple was, you know,
- 19:41they, they made their bet with Global Star.
- 19:43And then internally they've had some potential infighting around
- 19:48whether or not that that relationship makes any sense
- 19:52just given kind of how the market is has evolved.
- 19:54And so Fast forward, I won't go through all that article, but
- 19:58Fast forward to I guess it was like two or three weeks ago, you
- 20:02know, we had another article from the information talking
- 20:04about how SpaceX was proactively including global stars spectrum
- 20:09banning to its next generation satellites, which as I mentioned
- 20:13before, that's something that you would just do anyway you
- 20:16want to make sure that. Any ASIC that you're developing
- 20:19for this new satellite, you'll want to include every single
- 20:22spectrum band under the sun because you never know what's
- 20:25going to happen in the future. And so, but then in this article
- 20:29too, it talked about how Apple would potentially support
- 20:34Spacex's spectrum and, and that, and in particular Echostar, AWS
- 20:404 spectrum, which they're buying when they announce the deal to
- 20:43acquire that spectrum from Echostar.
- 20:45And so as I mentioned in another call, Apple is a handset
- 20:51manufacturer. They're trying to, they, they
- 20:53want their handsets to work with everybody's spectrum, any
- 20:56spectrum that is currently in use today and any spectrum
- 20:58that's going to become available for use tomorrow.
- 21:00And so that's, you know, that was something where I have
- 21:03actually tweeted a post about back in April where Apple is
- 21:08trying to define, help define the next three GPP standard,
- 21:12which is going to include all MSS spectrum.
- 21:14And so they were actively working at the standards setting
- 21:19body to include not only echostar spectrum, which you
- 21:22know, specifically requiring, but also Legato biosat, I mean
- 21:26any number of other, you know, satellite spectrum.
- 21:30They are actively working on shaping the standards around
- 21:32that. And they're going to include
- 21:33that in their next generation iPhone, which makes sense,
- 21:36right? Because As for Apple, they want
- 21:39to make sure that they utilize, are able to utilize any spectrum
- 21:43or any technology that their M&O partners, whether that's AT&T,
- 21:47Verizon, T-Mobile or any M and OS globally, like whatever
- 21:52service they want to use, Apple wants to make sure that they
- 21:55have, you know, absolute compatibility with all right.
- 21:59And so that's something that you would expect.
- 22:01However, the new part, the new part of I guess the new
- 22:04information that was in that article was the fact that, you
- 22:08know, Global Star. You, you saw some specific leaks
- 22:13from Global Star, which, you know, specifically mentioned A
- 22:16and, and this and this kind of got further, I guess further
- 22:21picked up by Bloomberg who. And I'll explain the process of
- 22:24why Bloomberg ran, ran an article, but it hit the, the
- 22:28information article, talked about how, and it introduced the
- 22:31idea that James Morrow, who's the, the chairman of Global
- 22:35Star, he, he stopped being CEO and I think Paul Jacobs took
- 22:38over from Qualcomm, but he, he's the founder who owns over 50% of
- 22:42Global Star. And he's, he's kind of brought
- 22:45them back from the dead several times by pitching a new story
- 22:48about how Global Star would reposition themselves.
- 22:51And, and, and then Apple came in in 2022 and basically bailed him
- 22:56out, right? Like they, they invested money
- 22:58into them and in exchange for that, that prepayment, they got
- 23:0380. Basically Global Star had to
- 23:04give away their entire business. They gave away 85% of their
- 23:07current constellation capacity and and 85% of future capacity.
- 23:12And so whether Global Star builds that satellite, those
- 23:15satellites and then and then operates the constellation or if
- 23:19somebody else is doing it and they're using Gold Star
- 23:22spectrum, that 85% of capacity is, you know, it survives into
- 23:28perpetuity. And so in all, for all intents
- 23:31and purposes, Global Stars is effectively an Apple subsidiary,
- 23:34where as a public investor, you, you own 15% of that satellite
- 23:42network capacity, which hopefully, you know, Global Star
- 23:45can sell with somebody else. And then you get some economic
- 23:47return, hopefully off of the 85% that you're servicing for Apple.
- 23:51And that that's the deal, you know, in distressed in their
- 23:55distress situation, that's the deal that they were able to
- 23:57negotiate. The other thing is that Apple
- 24:02got 20% ownership in this this SPB that holds all of global
- 24:08star spectrum. And so, you know, there's very
- 24:11particular rights around what they can do around global Star.
- 24:15You know, they have a right of first refusal, which means if
- 24:18someone comes in and tries to buy the company, then Apple can
- 24:21come in and match them or top them in order to win a deal.
- 24:25But then some of these other business protections, which
- 24:28generally we don't know all the details, but you know, by by by
- 24:32effectively having that right of first refusal and having
- 24:35ownership of 85% of the network, that's a de facto poison pill.
- 24:38What I mean by that is if you don't have Apple's consent to
- 24:42buy the company, then again, you have to be comfortable with the
- 24:46fact that you only get 15% of the network and then some
- 24:49economic return on the rest. But if you don't have their
- 24:51consent, then they can de facto just block you from doing a
- 24:55deal. And what I mean by that is, you
- 25:00know, they they could always of course, threaten to match your
- 25:03deal or top it. But they can also just not give
- 25:07consent that that they agreed to a deal, right?
- 25:10Because they effectively control the entire company.
- 25:13Let me just look here. I wrote a few small notes here.
- 25:22But yeah, there there is a parallel to another situation
- 25:25which I'll talk about in a bit, but that I think is, is very
- 25:29similar and can kind of give us a sense of the weird, the the
- 25:33weird deal dynamics error. But but yeah, so that
- 25:35information article that came out recently, there were
- 25:38specific quotes in it which kind of allude to that they were
- 25:42being leaked by Gold Star. And in that, in that article,
- 25:46you could kind of get a sense that Gold Star kind of sees and
- 25:51I, I, I set this up in the, my, my Twitter post, but you know,
- 25:56Global Star specifically talks about, you know, a $10 million
- 26:00price that James and Rose supposedly told some people who
- 26:03had direct knowledge. And so whenever articles refer
- 26:06to sources as direct knowledge of the matter, that's typically
- 26:09principles like people at the company, whenever an article
- 26:12says people, you know, people familiar with talks, usually
- 26:15that refers to bankers or lawyers.
- 26:18And so these are this is kind of the when I worked at the hedge
- 26:21fund or was a banker, you read these articles very closely
- 26:25because they're written in a certain way and they can give
- 26:28your hints as to, you know, again, where they where they
- 26:31came from and what they're trying to do.
- 26:33But but yeah, if you take into account that the information
- 26:36article and then also the Bloomberg article that came out
- 26:40shortly thereafter. And the reason why Bloomberg ran
- 26:42an article is as a journalist, you, when you see something like
- 26:46that, you might go, one of your, one of the best things that
- 26:49journalists can do is to go try to go refute an article, Meaning
- 26:54the information puts out an article and says, Hey, the
- 26:55company is potentially interested in selling
- 26:58themselves. And then, but Bloomberg or Wall
- 27:00Street Journal might do be like, oh, hey, you know, I've got some
- 27:02free time. Let me go try to refute this
- 27:03article because that's, that's good reading as well.
- 27:06Like if, if I if, if you're able to, to basically write an
- 27:11article that says like the other one is complete bullshit, then
- 27:13that's a really fun and notable to write.
- 27:16So what they'll do is they'll go run the traps and talk to their
- 27:18sources. And so Bloomberg of course, talk
- 27:21to their sources and they're like, oh, there actually is
- 27:23something going on here. And so in their article, they
- 27:25talked about the fact that and this is where you would have
- 27:29global star advisors feeding Bloomberg the article because
- 27:32Bloomberg typically their sources are going to be bankers.
- 27:35And so the bankers told them, yeah, there's we have a, we've
- 27:39been talking early stages of talks and we're speaking with a
- 27:43few companies. Let's see here.
- 27:46Let me just pull this one up. Yeah, so Global Star in in the
- 27:53Bluebird article says specifically that they're
- 27:55exploring a sale. They've had early talks with
- 27:57with SpaceX and then other shooters bringing people
- 28:00familiar with matter. And so that's definitely
- 28:03bankers. And then they talk about how
- 28:07SpaceX is one of the parties the company's speaking to, but it's
- 28:10possible that others could emerge.
- 28:11And then, but however, SpaceX hasn't made a final decision or
- 28:15sorry, Global Star hasn't made a final decision and could remain
- 28:18independent. And so that, by the way, is a
- 28:21very specifically from Global Star to say we have, we're not
- 28:26in play. It's we're totally in control of
- 28:28the situation. We may decide not to sell
- 28:29ourselves. But of course, like, as we all
- 28:31know, it's not really not up to them.
- 28:33It's up to Apple because they hold the keys here.
- 28:36And so, so that's why I like when, when I analyzed the three
- 28:40articles and I wrote about it, you could tell it's primarily
- 28:44sourced from Global Star. They, they, they quote Tim
- 28:46Farrar in both of the information articles.
- 28:50And of course he, he talked in a very smug way about like
- 28:53something big that was happening.
- 28:54And so it's clear that he leaked a decent amount of it to them.
- 28:58And, and he also works closely to global stars.
- 29:00It's also why, for example, he hates AST space mobile so much
- 29:04for the past several years, because he, he works with global
- 29:07star and some of the other legacy guys.
- 29:09And, and so, and it probably doesn't help that, you know,
- 29:12space mob is called him out and all this bullshit.
- 29:14So that's why he hates the company.
- 29:16But anyway, but yeah, so you know, the the company global
- 29:20star is is effectively announced like without formally because
- 29:24sometimes like companies will formally announce that they're
- 29:28seeking strategic alternatives and that that's actually when a
- 29:31company does that, that that's pretty serious, right?
- 29:34Like if we're coming PRS and says we've been approached and
- 29:36we're bringing ourselves up for sale.
- 29:39When you do that, you have to feel really good that
- 29:41something's going to happen. Because if, if through that
- 29:44process, EPR that and then maybe one or two quarters later, you
- 29:48actually don't sell the company, that's really bad because then
- 29:51investors are like what just happened?
- 29:53Like, so you felt good enough about the process and you you
- 29:56ran an option and then no one showed up.
- 29:58It's like, well, why didn't you sell?
- 30:00Is there something bad? Like did buyers not like
- 30:02something, you know, if you, if it wasn't priced, you know, is
- 30:06there, is there a potential material issue with the company
- 30:10that we should be worried about? And so that's a really risky
- 30:12gamut. And So what Gold Star here is
- 30:15what they've done is they've put the company in play informally
- 30:17through these articles, but there's a reason why they did
- 30:19that, right? And so here it's it's a risky
- 30:24gamble for them because they're trying to create this narrative
- 30:26that there's a robust auction process.
- 30:28You know, the Bloomberg goal talks about Spacex's.
- 30:31It's faithfully saying like they're the lead horse and
- 30:33there's potentially other people there.
- 30:35And the reason why they're doing this is that they want to create
- 30:38this sense of urgency and, you know, demand that the company's
- 30:42in play. And it's and there's a lot of
- 30:44people involved and, you know, and, and potentially you could
- 30:47get over $10 million, which is the price that they keep stating
- 30:50in these articles, right. And so you know what that price
- 30:54was stated in the information. And then for it to be repeated
- 30:57in Bloomberg, that means that Bloomberg, the journalist went
- 31:00to Global Stars banker and said, hey, is this true?
- 31:02Is it, is it 10 billion? And and you're like, yeah,
- 31:04that's that's what we want. So are they going to get it?
- 31:06Who knows, right? But, but why?
- 31:09So taking a step back, you have to ask yourself, well, why is
- 31:11Global Star doing this? Why would they risk a potential
- 31:15potentially fail sale process? And you know what?
- 31:18What is causing them to kick this off now?
- 31:22And, and so I think for some of us, we've asked, well, why, why
- 31:26would SpaceX want to go by the company now or any other
- 31:32potential parties, right? Like Global Stars, obviously in
- 31:35a pretty tough position, even that Apple kind of runs a show.
- 31:39And so why would they do this? Well, after doing a little bit
- 31:42of research, you know, I was able to find that.
- 31:47And I haven't, you know, I haven't followed global starter
- 31:49that closely. But so in 2023, they, they took
- 31:53a prepayment of $252 million from Apple in order to, you
- 31:59know, start work on their service.
- 32:00And this this isn't prepayment, meaning here's money and and you
- 32:04get to keep it forever. It's actually it's a prepayment
- 32:07that has to be paid back to Apple.
- 32:09And whether that's in that's in in kind meaning like if if Apple
- 32:17users use a certain amount of messaging and then that
- 32:20messaging basically gets offset that whatever the Apple had to
- 32:24pay, that gets offset by the turn of 52,000,000.
- 32:26Like that's one way or if those that service is it the service
- 32:32isn't being used, then Global Star actually has to pay back
- 32:36that money to Apple in hard dollars, right?
- 32:39And so that initial tranche of $252 million, that payback
- 32:44period starts in this quarter, Q3 of 2025.
- 32:48And that's over 16 quarters of installment.
- 32:50So that's about 6, call it, $15.8 million per quarter, which
- 32:55is for Global Star. That's a pretty decent amount.
- 32:58So that's like just annually that's about $63,000,000 and
- 33:04that's for a company that as I mentioned before has had, you
- 33:07know, financial issues in the past.
- 33:09If I just look at Global Stars projections for 2025, you know,
- 33:14they're looking to me 265,000,000 of revenue, EBITDA
- 33:18of 129,000,000. Let's see, their operating
- 33:22income in total for this year was 11.7 million.
- 33:25I guess next year they're going to do like 3839 million of
- 33:29operating income in 147 million EBITDA.
- 33:31But I mean that's that's $63,000,000 that they have to
- 33:34pay back over 4 quarters for four years and so 252 in total.
- 33:41But you know, 63,000,000 annually.
- 33:42So that's a pretty decent size nut.
- 33:45And then you've got another tranche, you know, Global Star
- 33:48got another 235,000,000 prepayment from Apple that they
- 33:52used to pay off their twenty 2913% notes.
- 33:56And interestingly, those are the notes that our old friend
- 33:59Charlie Ergen had purchased and I think he controlled most of
- 34:02those. And so Charlie Ergen, who is the
- 34:06founder and owner of, of Dish and Echostar, he's had this
- 34:10history of buying credit in distress companies and then
- 34:14taking them over and do that with TBSD and Tarastar, which
- 34:17then ultimately those two satellite company Spectrum
- 34:20became what is known today as AWS 4, which then you flip to,
- 34:24to SpaceX for $19 billion. But anyway, but yeah, Global
- 34:28Star went to Apple and said, hey, we need to borrow another
- 34:31$235,000,000 in 2024 to go repay these notes so that Charlie
- 34:35Ergen, you know, doesn't give us a hard time.
- 34:37And they're like, OK, fine, we'll give it to you.
- 34:39And so that that 235,000,000 has to be repaid either in, in, in
- 34:47service, you know, Apple messages they, they, you know,
- 34:52Global Star charges them for the usage or in hard cash.
- 34:55And so $135 million over, let's see here, I think it's 30 two
- 35:01quarters. So that's about $7.4 million a
- 35:05quarter or that's $29 million a year.
- 35:08So now we're looking at 63,000,029 million, that's $92
- 35:12million that have to be paid back to Apple annually.
- 35:16For a company that's doing 130 hundred 50 million of EBITDA,
- 35:21that's a lot of money. And then on top of that, Apple
- 35:28provided the company you know, $278 million in March of 2025 to
- 35:34help build these were prepayments to help build the
- 35:37next generation of their consolation, which I believe
- 35:41Apple in the contract can give up to $1.1 billion, I think in
- 35:46certain cases 1.3 billion. But again, like this is not,
- 35:51this is not like free money that Global Star actually has to pay
- 35:54this back. And so whether they pay that
- 35:56back through the service they provide to Apple or through cold
- 36:01hard cash, that that's money that has to be paid back over
- 36:06time. So if you start adding all the
- 36:07stuff up, Global Star is in a tough spot, right?
- 36:11Like they, they, they're, they still need to try to find
- 36:15customers for the 15% of the network that they they currently
- 36:18operate or the future network. That network is doesn't do
- 36:22broadband, it just does SMS and SOS master G in the future one
- 36:28that they're going to roll out and we you know, I guess people
- 36:31at NDA space would know better, but I'm not sure the new
- 36:35constellation is going to be that much better.
- 36:37You know, I'm sure it'll provide better data services, but in
- 36:41order to pay back all this money, you're going to need like
- 36:44real, real service revenues. And you know, given, given
- 36:51where. And so if you're, if you're a
- 36:53global star, you've got these payments coming up.
- 36:56And the story right now is that for now is that, you know,
- 36:59Apple's your biggest customer and you've got this
- 37:01relationship. And and so global star seems
- 37:03like it's in a pretty good spot for investors.
- 37:05But then once investors start seeing these payments start
- 37:10going out the door this quarter and you know, maybe they have
- 37:13enough service revenues to cover them.
- 37:14But but once they start seeing this drag on, on their
- 37:18financials this quarter and into 2026 and beyond, then the story
- 37:23becomes a bit more precarious, right?
- 37:25Because then what if these Apple users then start using AST space
- 37:30mobile or Starlink direct to sell services?
- 37:33Then, then how are you going to end up, you know, then?
- 37:35And if, if there's a dearth of users on on your network, then
- 37:39then these these payments become hard cash payments that go to
- 37:43Apple, right? And so that's where I think
- 37:46you've Jay Monroe and he's not a dumb guy.
- 37:49Like he probably saw the writing on the wall and was like, OK,
- 37:53we're in a really tough spot. Like people feel good about our
- 37:56story to a degree, but it's going to be start becoming
- 37:59really bad once AST space Mobile and SpaceX get their
- 38:02constellations up and people really start using them.
- 38:04They're like, oh, wait, I, I can use these services.
- 38:07And, you know, for AST, it's, it's broadband and it works
- 38:10indoors and I don't have to put my phone at anything.
- 38:13Like why would I ever use this Apple SOS messaging service?
- 38:17And so that's where I think that became the, the impetus for all
- 38:22this activity of out of nowhere starting in May and then of
- 38:25course, October, you know, the second-half of October, like
- 38:29these leaks. And so, oh, the other thing I
- 38:33forgot to mention is, is for Apple that that 1.1 billion
- 38:36infrastructure payment of which they've dispersed 278 million.
- 38:40The other thing that's kind of scary for Goldstar is that if
- 38:44they lose any of their spectrum licenses, which by the way, like
- 38:47SpaceX at the FCC has been trying to like take their
- 38:49licenses away, which, you know, I guess that's part of SpaceX
- 38:53and playbook because they did the same to Echostar.
- 38:55So they like, they use a stick, then they, they ultimately gave
- 38:58them the carrot, which they, they bought them out.
- 39:00But if they lose any licenses and, and, or they can't deliver
- 39:08the new network, which I think there's like certain milestones,
- 39:11then Apple can claim immediate fault and, and ask for repayment
- 39:15of that one point, you know, whatever they dispersed out of
- 39:18the $1.1 billion. And so I know Tanner alluded to
- 39:22this, but I don't really know for sure.
- 39:24I think of course NBA space is building that satellite.
- 39:27And then I think Rocket Lab is providing some of the buses
- 39:30around that next generation consolation.
- 39:32But at least kind of at a high level, looking at the new, some
- 39:37of the pieces of news or, or social media posts out there, it
- 39:40seems like that consolation is behind or delayed.
- 39:43I don't think it's because of Rocket Lab, I think it's because
- 39:45of NBA Space or I mean, I think as we all know, space is hard.
- 39:49This stuff takes longer than you think for global star
- 39:52negotiating with Apple in a, you know, from their distressed
- 39:55position, they probably promised Apple the moon.
- 39:57And then when it comes to actually delivering, if you're
- 39:59using a prime and not doing it internally, building a
- 40:02concentration is really tough. And so they probably are feeling
- 40:06some level of stress that they're not going to be able to
- 40:08hit those milestones. And so, you know, for for Apple,
- 40:12they're in a really sweet spot like if.
- 40:15If global star slips on a banana and they don't, they don't do
- 40:17what they say they're going to do, then they can, they can
- 40:19immediately claim repayment and effectively put global star in a
- 40:23bankruptcy. And, and that I think is a
- 40:26pretty realistic. I, I wouldn't say it's not.
- 40:30I don't think it's Apple's MO to try to put companies into
- 40:32bankruptcy. But if they, if they got a a
- 40:35great, if they woke up on the wrong side of the dead one day
- 40:39and we're like, you know what, I want to own global star spectrum
- 40:41and then I'll go lease it to somebody else.
- 40:43They could totally put Global Star in a bankruptcy tomorrow by
- 40:48not giving them any more, you know, financial life lines and
- 40:51not allowing them to sell anyone.
- 40:53And then Global Star is in a tough spot, right?
- 40:55And and I'll talk about a precedent that kind of fits that
- 40:58derivative. But, but anyway, going back to
- 41:01what I was saying before, I'm sorry, I keep just kind of going
- 41:04all over the place. It's it's a lot to cover, but
- 41:07but for Global star to kind of start planning this idea and
- 41:12you've seen kind of the themes in his articles where it's like,
- 41:15well, Apple's kind of unsure what they want to do and and
- 41:18SpaceX is interested in working with Apple.
- 41:21But, you know, maybe, maybe a compromise potentially is, you
- 41:26know, one of two things. I mean, this is what global
- 41:27store would the whole objective of all this would be either to
- 41:31one buy more time with Apple or or, you know, loosen up this
- 41:37maybe some of these milestones or maybe get additional capital.
- 41:40Just get Apple to make a decision like either go all in
- 41:43on what we're doing and give us more money and give us more
- 41:46freedom or buy us. I mean Gold Star in in their
- 41:51world. Like the perfect situation would
- 41:53just be that the company that controls you just engineer that
- 41:58would be either either highest there, I'll come.
- 42:02And then the second one would be inject enough uncertainty here.
- 42:08And this is where the uncertainty comes, because I
- 42:09think in both of the information articles, like it's very
- 42:13specific where and Tim Farrar plays the leading role here.
- 42:16He's like, well, if if SpaceX is able to buy global star, then
- 42:19it's basically game over for everybody.
- 42:21But like that's an implicit threat from global * saying
- 42:25Apple, if you don't give us time, you don't help us out and
- 42:28and SpaceX ends up buying us, then then they're going to
- 42:30control everything right. And so, but it's kind of they're
- 42:34kind of playing both sides where it's like, we need your help,
- 42:38you're the optimal outcome, but then, you know, we're going to
- 42:40run the sale process and SpaceX is the main, main potential
- 42:44bidder. And if they win, then who knows?
- 42:48Who knows what's going to happen?
- 42:48Like maybe they'll be more competitive with you or or
- 42:50whatever it is, right? Like, but at the end of the day,
- 42:52Gold Star wants to sell to Apple because Apple own holds all the
- 42:56keys. And in these articles they, they
- 42:59talk about the obviously the, you know, Apple's right of first
- 43:04refusal and, and some of the deal dynamics there because they
- 43:09want to make sure that the market knows that, hey, we're,
- 43:12we're warning you that these things are out there just in
- 43:14case or any potential buyers should know that these are out
- 43:16there. Obviously, like if they're
- 43:18negotiate, if buyers are doing due diligence, they'll learn
- 43:21this stuff on their own, but they want to make the public
- 43:23know, know that these things are out there, right?
- 43:27And so, yeah, there was mention before, you know, global stores
- 43:30have crossroads, they face significant financial repayments
- 43:34to Apple starting now. Yeah, they're they don't have
- 43:37their the control of their own destiny in that they outsource
- 43:40the design, development and you know, manufacture of their
- 43:44satellites to somebody else. You know, they basically
- 43:46outsource by prime prime contractor.
- 43:48And then then of course, like if they see Space mobile and
- 43:52Starlink are successful, then what economic, economic return
- 43:56can they expect being a backer of service to, for, for Apple,
- 44:01right? Like, if no one's using the
- 44:02network and, and they owe Apple all these payments and, and
- 44:06they, they're not getting service revenues in return to,
- 44:08to make those payments, then they're going to be a tough
- 44:10spot, right? And so, so, yeah, I think that's
- 44:14why you're seeing all this kind of come to a head and, and
- 44:17global stars holding their nose and hoping, you know, they
- 44:20they've kicked off this process and they're hoping that, you
- 44:23know, either Apple buys them or they've put enough pressure and
- 44:28they have enough sponsorship with an Apple where Apple's
- 44:31like, you know what, we'll we'll just let you guys sell to SpaceX
- 44:35and we'll get some preferential firms or treatment for their
- 44:39next generation consolation and we'll call it a day.
- 44:41But the issue with that, of course, is that Apple sees, you
- 44:47know, SpaceX is a, is a direct threat in terms of, you know,
- 44:50wanting to make their own handset, you know, whether it's
- 44:52getting into on the, on the X side.
- 44:54And it's not just SpaceX, it's all of Elon Musk's, you know,
- 44:57ecosystem. And we've talked about like this
- 44:59vertical stack of, you know, with X, he's got social media,
- 45:04AI, you know, financial payments, calling, I mean, you
- 45:06can use X for chat and calling. And so these are all things that
- 45:11that Apple's interested in or are important to Apple and their
- 45:14ecosystem. And and you know, obviously you
- 45:17have to include Tesla as well and robots and just a whole host
- 45:20of things. It's not just SpaceX, but it's
- 45:23all these, it's X, it's rock, it's Tesla.
- 45:27And so for Apple like it, it's a pretty big threat.
- 45:30And so the key question is, you know, why would you underwrite
- 45:33your own demise, right? So why would you let Globalstar
- 45:37sell to SpaceX? And then, you know, they
- 45:41potentially start eventually because Globalstar has global,
- 45:45you know, worldwide SP and elevating spectrum that would
- 45:49just accelerate their ability to provide, you know, some type of
- 45:54Internet service directly to users without having to go
- 45:56through Apple or MN OS. And so, you know, for me that
- 46:00that seems kind of a bit of a stretch where I don't know if
- 46:03Apple, I think Apple's pretty strategic.
- 46:05I don't think they would give away the carbs like that.
- 46:08And so for those people who are optimistic that a Starlink or
- 46:12sorry, a SpaceX global star deal could happen, I would refer them
- 46:16back to a very painful experience of mine before.
- 46:18And this is the precedent that I'm going to talk about, which
- 46:21is there was this company that I invested in that would probably
- 46:24be a SPAC called Cano Health. And this is a value based care
- 46:28provider, which ultimately went into bankruptcy.
- 46:31But interestingly a lot of the dynamics are similar here where
- 46:35you have a dominant customer slash pair in the Apple ** Apple
- 46:40Global Star situation. You know Apple gets 85% of
- 46:43Global Star's total capacity from their network.
- 46:47And in the Keno Health, which was a a value based, you know
- 46:51health provider, it was basically a captive supplier for
- 46:55Humana. And so about 60-70, part 60 to
- 46:5970% of Keno Health's Medicare Advantage patients and the
- 47:03revenue went through Humana. And I believe Humana was like an
- 47:05early investor too, but for all kinds of purposes, like Humana
- 47:08was a critical customer and they had the ultimate say of what
- 47:12happened with Cano Health. And so interestingly, you know,
- 47:17Apple has a right of first refusal before any sale or
- 47:20change of control. Humana also had a right of first
- 47:23refusal with Cano before another protective provisions that
- 47:27basically would prevent a sale of Cano without their say right.
- 47:31And so Fast forward to, I think it was like 2022, you know, Cano
- 47:36Health was a highly leveraged density.
- 47:37And, and when rates started going up and, and their growth
- 47:40started flagging a bit, the company did the same thing.
- 47:43They, they announced through the Wall Street Journal, they leaked
- 47:47that they were in a potential sale process and, and they put
- 47:49everybody's names out there and they talked about like United
- 47:51Health, all the, all the other, all the big, you know, managed
- 47:55care providers, United Health, of course, Humana, they, they
- 47:58put their name in there too, and CVS and others, right.
- 48:02And so they were trying to create this, this sense of the
- 48:05potential sale process when everyone knew like it was, it
- 48:08was basically up to Humana to decide whether they wanted to
- 48:10come to sell or not. And was either going to be
- 48:13Humana that would buy them or they would say no.
- 48:16And and that was it like they couldn't sell.
- 48:20And so interestingly, when they leaked those articles, maybe
- 48:24it's like a month or two later handle health that leaks to I
- 48:27think it was in Wall Street Journal that that CBS was in
- 48:31exclusive talks with Keno Health and had been out the other
- 48:35players. And so that took the stock up
- 48:38and people were pretty excited. And again, just remember, this
- 48:41company was highly leveraged and, and faced some flagging
- 48:46difficulties because growth had slowed and and you know, they
- 48:49were and rates were going up. I think a lot of their debt was
- 48:51floating rate, floating rate debt.
- 48:53And so they were having it. They were going to have a tough
- 48:55time meeting their obligations. And so excuse me.
- 49:00But then what ultimately happened is that CBS decided to
- 49:04walk away from that deal because at the end of the day, they they
- 49:07just realized that Humana had the keys where they could not
- 49:13only match whatever CBS bid, but then they could just terminate
- 49:16the contracts that they had with with Cano.
- 49:19So for those that don't know, CBS owns, I think it's I think
- 49:25it's Aetna. Yeah.
- 49:26Aetna, which was a, a direct, which is a direct competitor to
- 49:29Humana. And so for Humana, it was, it
- 49:33was dead on arrival. Like they would never let Ano
- 49:36sell to, to CBS and have Aetna, you know, compete or, or be in a
- 49:42position to better compete with them.
- 49:43And so Humana basically put a kibosh on that and CBS walked
- 49:46from the deal, stock cratered. And then they tried to, you
- 49:51know, restructure the company a few times and ultimately, and
- 49:53Humana let this happen, right? They, the company went into
- 49:56bankruptcy. And then Humana, you know, in a
- 49:59smart way, they, they, they went into the bankruptcy and they
- 50:02bought the assets they wanted and they walked away, you know,
- 50:06so, so they were able to walk away with the assets that were
- 50:11important to them. And then the rest of Kendo's
- 50:13business, which served United Healthcare, CBS and other
- 50:17companies that, that went under. So they actually damaged their
- 50:21competitors and yeah, and they, they, they got what they wanted,
- 50:25but but that was all that full situation was started by Kendall
- 50:29Health because they were facing some financial difficulty and
- 50:33they decided to put themselves in play full well knowing that
- 50:36structurally they were disadvantaged because Humana
- 50:38ultimately had the cards like they had the right of first
- 50:41refusal. They had other protective
- 50:43provisions that would basically prevent the sale of the company
- 50:46to anyone else. And so there are it's almost
- 50:51like eerie parallels here where global stars in a famously
- 50:56they're they're looking at, you know, the market becoming
- 50:59increasingly competitive, HTC mobile Starlink are are coming
- 51:03in and they're going to get relegated to the like this
- 51:06backup service, but then they can't do anything about it
- 51:08because Apple holds the cards. And so they're going to now try
- 51:11to put the company up for sale and get something going And and
- 51:16it's a pretty, you know, dangerous gambit, right?
- 51:18Because either something does happen, but it's not going to
- 51:22happen without Apple's consent. And Apple could look at this and
- 51:24say, well, you know, I'm OK with it.
- 51:27Like I put some money into this thing.
- 51:29And I have seen, you know, senior security protection.
- 51:33I own, I own basically the current and future network that
- 51:37will run on the spectrum. You know, I have the, I have the
- 51:39money and the wherewithal to buy this, you know, to fully fund
- 51:43this thing or divide out of bankruptcy.
- 51:45So no one's going to push me around.
- 51:46I'm going to make a decision and in for people who are not
- 51:51familiar with the situation, looking at it, they might say,
- 51:53well, why would global star ever negotiate that?
- 51:55But it doesn't make any sense. Like they've they've painted
- 51:57themselves in the corner. And it's like, yeah, the the
- 52:00global star was on the financial ropes until Apple came in and
- 52:04gave them money to, you know, not only give them money, but
- 52:07gave them a market right for what they have previously, you
- 52:12know, Apple was like, OK, we're going to integrate you into all
- 52:14these these Apple iPhones and devices.
- 52:17I mean, Apple just recently, you know, they, they, they
- 52:21integrated it into one of their, their watches, the SOS messaging
- 52:26service. But but yeah, bubble story got
- 52:30an offer a deal that they couldn't refuse because there
- 52:32was no alternative. The alternative was, you know,
- 52:34financial ruin. And so I think when looking at,
- 52:41you know, space XS perspective or even, you know, some people
- 52:44have talked about AST space mobile.
- 52:46I don't know why either party would want to do this deal
- 52:49because essentially you're buying, you're, you're stepping
- 52:51into the shoes of global star who got a raw deal to begin
- 52:54with, right. And so you got to be comfortable
- 52:56with a raw deal and maybe that's worth it.
- 52:59Like working with Apple, like that's, that's worth it.
- 53:01But then for SpaceX, that doesn't seem to make sense
- 53:05because you you probably are going to be able to go cobble
- 53:08together global spectrum and do it, you know, take your time in
- 53:12doing that. I mean, global star would
- 53:14accelerate that. But then you've got you're
- 53:17locked into Apple and you know, it's almost like, what was it?
- 53:22I think circle, this is kind of a, a, a non sequitur red circle.
- 53:27They have this stable coin called USUSDC and in order to
- 53:31drive adoption, they basically got Coinbase to have it, you
- 53:35know, on their platform and, and it's been great.
- 53:37Like they've gotten to a massive my own adoption, but they gave
- 53:39away, I think like 80 or 90% of economics, not only on Coinbase,
- 53:43but wherever USDC trades, any yields that they get from it,
- 53:47they have to give it a Coinbase. And so that product is
- 53:50structurally flawed forever. And so that's what Gold Star
- 53:54too. Like they've it's flawed because
- 53:56Apple owns this thing and whether SpaceX buys it or like,
- 54:00you know, if AAC space mobile buys it, they would have to work
- 54:04out something with with Apple to make it more attractive.
- 54:07And that's why I mentioned that before.
- 54:09And so I think that's where this whole story and the situation
- 54:14kind of falls on its face now. Now, you know, could the parties
- 54:17work something out with Apple, like could SpaceX work something
- 54:19out with Apple and maybe become friends and do what happens?
- 54:22Sure, it could totally happen. But I think in terms of the
- 54:26market is saying some probabilities, I think the
- 54:28probability of something happening here that's going to
- 54:30be good for global Star shareholders is is lower than
- 54:33the market thinks. And but but you know, again, the
- 54:38home run scenario is like Apple decides to just buy the global
- 54:40Star and integrate it. But as we've read in some of
- 54:43these articles, you know, global star Apple is probably loads to
- 54:49become a service provider itself and compete directly with its
- 54:52M&O customers, which introduces a whole host of regulatory
- 54:56things from there. It's like being regulated by the
- 54:58FCC etcetera. But I think the, and yeah, I,
- 55:04I've been rounding here for maybe an hour almost.
- 55:06But the, the other, the other angle that I did want to talk
- 55:09about is the regular regulatory, the antitrust angle, because I
- 55:14think, you know, directed device is a, is a new market, But it,
- 55:20it shouldn't be a foregone conclusion that a, you know,
- 55:24SpaceX or even AC space mobile could buy global star or, or
- 55:27radium for that matter, because it's going to depend on how the
- 55:30market, all the Department of Justice, who I think they would
- 55:33be, not the FCCFTC, but the DOJ would probably review this deal.
- 55:38How they define directed device market?
- 55:40Like do they view it as something that includes all the
- 55:43players like, or do they, you know, like all data services,
- 55:48including satellite phones? Or are they focused on the new
- 55:52market, which is these these services to mobile phones and do
- 55:58they spice up the market into messaging?
- 56:01Or do they talk about it more broadly as just data in general?
- 56:05Or are there sub sectors of the market?
- 56:07So it's really gonna depend on how they they slice the market.
- 56:09But I think given how nascent this is and SpaceX is current
- 56:16dominant position and fixed wireless, yeah, it'll be an
- 56:19interesting exercise to see how regulators would look at this.
- 56:23Because I I don't think it would be a layup for, for example,
- 56:26SpaceX to buy global store or Iridium effectively, you know,
- 56:30putting a competitor out of business and then, you know,
- 56:33consolidating your market share. Because then that that would
- 56:37effectively, if you look at like old school traditional services
- 56:41and it's in the US, then maybe there's there's three players
- 56:45right now. That's how you would define
- 56:46market because AST space mobile content process is not to market
- 56:49yet. It's going to be next year.
- 56:51And of course, the DOJ would look at that too, But if you
- 56:55were just to say it's global star radium and SpaceX, that's
- 56:58that's a A3 player market going to two like that when it comes
- 57:02to the old school antitrust analysis, that's an immediate,
- 57:05you know, block like the DOJ is going to suit them to block that
- 57:08deal. And, and I think the chances of
- 57:12winning are probably low. But then if you include AC space
- 57:14mobile and you say, hey, they've got all these M and OS and and
- 57:18you know, they've got ATT and Verizon.
- 57:20So maybe that's a four player market and it's going to go to
- 57:22three that still would have pretty a pretty difficult review
- 57:27and maybe maybe it's approved with, you know, some conditions
- 57:30or concessions that SpaceX would have to provide.
- 57:33I'm not sure what those would be, by the way, But but even a
- 57:37four to three where the DOJ, I've mentioned this before, like
- 57:39they learned their lesson by approving the Sprint T-Mobile
- 57:43merger, which then created turned A4 player market into 3.
- 57:47And then, you know, what we what consumers have seen over the
- 57:49past couple years is just prices continue to go up.
- 57:52And and I think most people agree that that was a big
- 57:54mistake because part of the concessions get the yield done
- 57:59was to divest and Boost Mobile and some spectrum assets to dish
- 58:03networks. You know, good old Charlie
- 58:04Ergen, because he's going to create a fourth, what we say
- 58:08facilities based competitor, meaning somebody's going to
- 58:10actually build a physical network to compete versus, you
- 58:13know, a, a virtual network operator, which you can't really
- 58:17say like those guys are are have the the ability financially to
- 58:21compete. But anyway, we saw that fall on
- 58:24his face. And of course, Charlie Urgan was
- 58:26like, yeah, I'm going to build this out and then failed.
- 58:28And then, you know, he's selling his spectrum to AT&T and and
- 58:32SpaceX and probably Verizon as well.
- 58:34And so that's that's a case where a DOJ fix ended up being a
- 58:40complete failure. So they want they probably would
- 58:43want to avoid that. So I think even if, even if
- 58:47SpaceX were to try to get a deal done to Global Star and Apple
- 58:51did consent to it, you would have a pretty tough time in a
- 58:55regulatory review. And I'd probably give the odds
- 58:57of a deal like that actually going through probably like 20
- 59:00or 30% at those. But who knows, right?
- 59:03It depends on how they position it.
- 59:04It depends on the administration.
- 59:07I think even for a Trump administration, people would
- 59:11say, oh, they're business friendly and they'll help Musk
- 59:13out. I, I don't think you can assume
- 59:14anything, right? Because I think people assumed
- 59:17that about the Trump administration the first, the
- 59:19first term. And they're like, oh, it's going
- 59:21to be M&A, you know, cornucopia, like people are going to get
- 59:25deals done because this administration's going to just
- 59:27approve, be business friendly. And then of course, they came
- 59:30out of blocks. Oh gosh, I'm trying to remember
- 59:35they, they blocked like a few big deals just because of I
- 59:38think it was around media because Trump didn't like it or,
- 59:41you know, they didn't want there to be a yeah, it was, it was
- 59:46like politically motivated. I'm Warner and somebody else,
- 59:49which then ultimately, I think of course AT&T won that deal and
- 59:52then later they split it off. But anyway, I, I think where
- 59:55this administration, yeah, it's probably hard to handicap the
- 59:59odds of any deal being through regulatory review.
- 1:00:01But but I think when you when it's pretty clear cut when you
- 1:00:05have a four to three or especially and especially it's
- 1:00:073/2. That deal is most likely going
- 1:00:10to get blocked because the last thing regulators want is, is a,
- 1:00:14is a duopoly that you help facilitate versus, you know, the
- 1:00:18market kind of naturally goes there.
- 1:00:19I mean, the great thing is like you've got AC space mobile and
- 1:00:23Starlink, they're entering the market.
- 1:00:25You've got 2 legacy players. And so you know what the, what
- 1:00:29the regulars would say is I'm going to block this deal because
- 1:00:31Global Star should be a good competitor for long term because
- 1:00:34it's got implicit backing by Apple.
- 1:00:37They have deep pockets. And so they'll figure it out.
- 1:00:40They'll they'll, they'll get some type of competing service
- 1:00:43going. And and so I need to block this
- 1:00:44because Apple's not going to just let this die.
- 1:00:46And of course, Apple can tell regulators like, hey, we're
- 1:00:48going to let this thing die. And then regulators will be
- 1:00:50like, OK, well, then, then they'll go into bankruptcy and
- 1:00:53then we'll see who buys the assets out of it, right?
- 1:00:55And it can be somebody else, it could be Google or who knows?
- 1:00:59But anyway, yeah, I, I think, you know, I've been going on for
- 1:01:02an hour. Hopefully that that's been
- 1:01:05helpful. I'm kind of been rambling and
- 1:01:07kind of going over different, different aspects of this, but
- 1:01:10let me check the questions here just in case I miss something.
- 1:01:17Let's see already here. You got burned by Kennel health.
- 1:01:20Yeah, I was a big bull on kennel health and so, yeah, burned on
- 1:01:24that, which is why I know about the the parallel here.
- 1:01:27And for those that don't know, yeah, you can you can go back
- 1:01:31and read. I mean, the deal dynamics are
- 1:01:33very, very similar. You've got Humana that's
- 1:01:36effectively in control of Kano. They have a right of first
- 1:01:39refusal. They have all the other deal
- 1:01:40protections. And so it was basically up to
- 1:01:42them to whether the company could sell or not.
- 1:01:45It was either going to be to Humana or nobody.
- 1:01:48And then Humana was like, you know what, I'm just about?
- 1:01:49These guys go to bankruptcy, which is what they did, and they
- 1:01:51bought the assets out of bankruptcy.
- 1:01:53I'm not saying that it's going to happen to Global Star, but
- 1:01:56the same dynamic supply where it's up to Apple to decide if
- 1:01:59Global Star is going to sell or not.
- 1:02:00And and if they don't want it to sell to SpaceX, it's not going
- 1:02:04to happen because Apple can make it hard.
- 1:02:07Like let's just let's go back to the regulatory review.
- 1:02:10The regulatory review. If Apple is the owner of Global
- 1:02:12star and the DOJ and FCC are seeking comments about the deal,
- 1:02:17let's say SpaceX and Global star decide to the not to do anyway,
- 1:02:21then Apple can complain at the DOJ and the FCC and say, Hey,
- 1:02:25we, we, we think this is how the anti competitive and we wanted
- 1:02:29Gold Star to build this consolation for us.
- 1:02:31And they're not doing it. And we want to be build a third
- 1:02:34credible player and we're going to give the money to go do it.
- 1:02:37And once the DOJ reads that they're going to be like, oh,
- 1:02:39this is a insta block. And when you when they go in
- 1:02:42front of the courts and Apple, you know, as witnesses and files
- 1:02:48affidavits that they were going to go invest in this, I mean,
- 1:02:50that's an immediate deal killer, right?
- 1:02:53And then, of course, Apple for any number of these other
- 1:02:58aspects of of their agreement with Global star, they can make
- 1:03:01life really hard, right? So they do have the de facto,
- 1:03:04you know, blocking power and, and we'll decide ultimately who
- 1:03:09owns global star or no one will own global star.
- 1:03:12Let's see, am I recording the space?
- 1:03:16Yes, I'm recording. So if you can't hear, you can
- 1:03:18listen to it later. Let's see.
- 1:03:25OK, people are giving me thumbs up.
- 1:03:27So see if there, if anyone has any questions, feel free to
- 1:03:32write them. Oh, someone's requesting come
- 1:03:34up. I'll, I'll take them up.
- 1:03:35Let's see. Spack Willy.
- 1:03:41Hey, Spack Willy, are you there? You're on mute.
- 1:03:43Do you have a question? I'd be shy.
- 1:03:51Spack Willy, are you there? OK.
- 1:03:57Anyway, I, I think I cover most of it.
- 1:04:00Yeah. The key the I I would just say
- 1:04:03we'll probably hear more about this potential deal or deal
- 1:04:06process. I would I I might be wrong like
- 1:04:10I bet I could be totally surprised.
- 1:04:11You might see a deal if a deal is announced between SpaceX and
- 1:04:15Global star. That's certainly possible.
- 1:04:18It would have to have some type of blasting from Apple.
- 1:04:21I think in that type of situation, Apple probably, if a
- 1:04:25deal is announced, Apple probably get some type of
- 1:04:27sweetheart deal, but then they, they, they stay arm's length
- 1:04:31away from it because ultimately they kind of want to work with
- 1:04:33everybody. I think for, but I wouldn't, I,
- 1:04:38I think a high probability is that no deal happens or there's
- 1:04:42a small probability, maybe a deal with AST space mobile or
- 1:04:44somebody else, right. But I don't think, I don't think
- 1:04:48AST space mobile would, would buy global star themselves.
- 1:04:52They would have to be, you know, in partnership with Apple or, or
- 1:04:56something like that because it's, it's a pretty big
- 1:04:58financial nut global * if you let's just assume $10 million
- 1:05:02prices, correct. I mean, the company is only
- 1:05:04generating 130 billion, yeah, 130 million of EBITDA this year,
- 1:05:10150 million next year. There are some there are, there
- 1:05:14would be some cost savings if you did the deal, but Gold Star
- 1:05:18is effectively, you know, better dead than alive because all the
- 1:05:22values in the spectrum is not really in the current operating
- 1:05:24business because you you'd basically shut it all down like
- 1:05:26the constellations old the spectrum is valuable and with
- 1:05:32the new constellation, you could, you could certainly
- 1:05:35deploy a, a really good, decent broadband service on that.
- 1:05:40But you know, if you were just to look at things financially,
- 1:05:43for example, Iridium is much more attractive.
- 1:05:46It's spectrum is not as valuable because it it here.
- 1:05:50Let me just go back to my notes. I think Iridium has about 8
- 1:05:54megahertz, just one sliver of 8 megahertz of L band spectrum
- 1:05:57globally. And so that is, that is, that is
- 1:06:02attractive, but it's not great. But then Global Star has 8.7
- 1:06:09megahertz of spectrum L band spectrum and then you know, 17
- 1:06:13megahertz of S band spectrum globally.
- 1:06:14So their, their position is much better.
- 1:06:17But as I was saying before, Iridium, they actually have,
- 1:06:20yeah, they're generating call it 500 million of EBITDA this year.
- 1:06:23And so I think if you were to do some type of deal with them
- 1:06:26that's more interesting financially because you can, you
- 1:06:30know, they stop their share buyback, you could cut their
- 1:06:31dividend, you could take out a ton of cost and just run it for
- 1:06:34cash until you have a consolation that that would be
- 1:06:39able to utilize our spectrum. But anyway, maybe I'll end it
- 1:06:43there are my kids are back. So.
- 1:06:45Oh, I see. Francisco.
- 1:06:46Oh, maybe I'll bring you up here if you have a question.
- 1:06:51Hey, Francisco, are you there? Hey, what's going on, man?
- 1:06:55Yeah, I'm here. How's it going?
- 1:06:58Here Sunday, getting ready for the week, but real quick, I
- 1:07:02wanted to clarify that the CEO of Global Star on the third
- 1:07:06quarter, he actually mentioned that they have received the
- 1:07:09buses from Rock Lap and MDA and that they were expected to
- 1:07:12receive the second batch of buses like by the end of this
- 1:07:16quarter. So Rock Lap is not late on those
- 1:07:19buses for what it sounds like. I don't know where that rumor
- 1:07:21came from. Yeah, I, I don't know.
- 1:07:24I mean, it's I think Tanner, he's up here too.
- 1:07:27Maybe he can clarify but but I think the sorry go.
- 1:07:33No good. And I did listen to the CEO
- 1:07:36talking about this during the third quarter.
- 1:07:38So it's not something that I read or somebody told me.
- 1:07:41I've actually listened to it. Right, Yeah, go ahead.
- 1:07:47Yeah, I mean, I, I, as I was saying before, I don't think
- 1:07:49it's, it's a Rocket Lab issue, but I think I think Taylor was
- 1:07:54writing about how maybe the, the the the timing has been off,
- 1:07:59which is I was saying before, like it wouldn't be a surprise,
- 1:08:02right? And I think for, for a company
- 1:08:05like Global Star who was negotiating for a position
- 1:08:08weakness for them, they probably told Apple like, hey, we're
- 1:08:12going to do all these things and this would be great.
- 1:08:14And then of course, when it comes to reality, as we all
- 1:08:16know, space is hard and takes time and, and, you know, it's
- 1:08:20like, was it ViaSat? I, I mentioned this as an
- 1:08:24example for when, when people get all testy about things
- 1:08:27taking longer than you think, like bias that their second
- 1:08:29satellite game, what, five years delayed.
- 1:08:32I think it's launching on ULA in the coming weeks.
- 1:08:35But but yeah, that, that stuff happens.
- 1:08:36I mean, it's just normal. It's not good or bad.
- 1:08:38It's just, that's just what it is.
- 1:08:40But but yeah, I know. I appreciate it.
- 1:08:42Yeah, I, I don't think, I don't think Rocket Lab is delayed, but
- 1:08:45I guess I would say for a company like Gold Star, if
- 1:08:49you're outsourcing all your design and manufacturing it,
- 1:08:51it's tough, right? Because like, like we've already
- 1:08:53seen with AC where you know, they've, they've, they've taken
- 1:08:58longer to build the satellites because they wanted new features
- 1:09:03and they, they were able to incorporate them or they made
- 1:09:05changes. And so like for example, FM 1
- 1:09:08and FM 2, we don't really know all the features that are on
- 1:09:11those things, but they're much heavier.
- 1:09:13And then of course, the next satellites after those are, are,
- 1:09:15are going to be made of composites, which are much
- 1:09:18lighter. But then I think they're they're
- 1:09:19probably not going to have some of the same features as FM 1 and
- 1:09:22FM 2 because there's some like secret stuff going on there.
- 1:09:25But anyway, anyhow, But yeah, no thanks.
- 1:09:29Thanks for coming up and clarifying that.
- 1:09:32I think I'm going to end it. Yeah, I think I'm going to end
- 1:09:34it here because I got the kids here.
- 1:09:36I I didn't want to give a shout out to the Dodgers, which I was
- 1:09:39potentially going to do spatial survey, but then I was watching
- 1:09:42the game and it was probably one of the best World Series games
- 1:09:45I've ever seen. But sorry for Blue Jays.
- 1:09:48But hey, it was it was a great, great series.
- 1:09:51But yeah, we'll see. We'll see what this week brings.
- 1:09:54I think there's going to be more news from HP Space Mobile,
- 1:09:57especially as we head into the quarter.
- 1:10:00And so, yeah, I'm, I'm very optimistic and bullish.
- 1:10:03And, and I think as someone, you know, I alluded to this or I did
- 1:10:09a post about before, it's just interesting to see how this,
- 1:10:12this, this industry has evolved where what was once thought
- 1:10:16impossible is now kind of accepted.
- 1:10:18As you know, this is the new state of the market.
- 1:10:21It's and, and these legacy players are we've gone from, you
- 1:10:25know, one or two years or three years from them saying, you
- 1:10:31know, being comfortable and smug about their position to know how
- 1:10:34having to sell their companies, both Gold Star and Iridium just
- 1:10:36kind of nuts. But but yeah, that's, that's
- 1:10:39life comes at you fast, man. That's all, that's all three
- 1:10:41things working when when you got innovation at play.
- 1:10:45But but yeah, thanks everyone for joining.
- 1:10:48Hopefully that was helpful. Stay tuned for this evening.
- 1:10:52You know, Kook will have a space and, you know, maybe he'll talk
- 1:10:54about, I'm sure he'll talk about some of these things as well.
- 1:10:57But, but yeah, but we'll meet again.
- 1:10:59We'll talk again. And I hope this was helpful.
- 1:11:02Thanks everyone for joining. Thanks for listening to the AST
- 1:11:07Space Mobile podcast. If you enjoyed this episode and
- 1:11:10you'd like to help support the podcast, please share it with
- 1:11:13others, post about it on social media, or leave a rating and
- 1:11:16review. To catch all the latest news
- 1:11:19about AST Space Mobile, make sure to subscribe.
- 1:11:22Thanks again and I'll see you next time.
- 1:11:28We're doing something very, very big, and I think with this
- 1:11:30technology we can really affect billion lives.
- 1:11:33AFT Space Global is the only company that has full technology
- 1:11:38to deliver several broadband connectivity directly from space
- 1:11:42to do everyday smartphone. People will just basically turn
- 1:11:45their phone and be seamless, regardless of where you are.
- 1:11:49We don't want the user even to know that it's connected by
- 1:11:51satellite. Our role is to bring this into
- 1:11:55reality, always in partnership with the animal.
- 1:12:04Listen. Waffles.