Latest / Saigalseatrade Podcast / After the Ceasefire: Energy Shockwaves & Shipping Market Shifts
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, everyone and welcome back to the Segal Sea Trade Podcast.
- 0:04I'm Shruti, your host today, and we are going to deep dive yet
- 0:08again into what is happening in the world right now and how we
- 0:12are living into an era of supply constraints and how all of that
- 0:15is going to affect the global trade and especially the LNG
- 0:18markets. And I'm joined by none other
- 0:21than shipping and commodities expert, Mr. Sandesh Gandhar.
- 0:24So, Sandesh, welcome back to the podcast.
- 0:27Thanks Shruti. Thanks for inviting me once
- 0:29again. It's pleasure to be here.
- 0:32Well, starting with the hot topic right now.
- 0:34Now that a ceasefire has been implemented, how do you think
- 0:38the market will react in the immediate talk?
- 0:41Well, Shruti, first of all, historic day yesterday, we just
- 0:45heard of possible two week ceasefire and it means a lot for
- 0:50the global commodity and energy industry perspective.
- 0:55We are now living in such an era where anything and everything
- 0:59can be possible. We have never thought that there
- 1:02would be an actual war with Iran and US and Israeli.
- 1:07We never thought that Iran will close the entire Hormuz Strait.
- 1:11We never thought that the traffic of Hormuz Strait reduced
- 1:16from 135 vessels every day to almost zero.
- 1:19And then we never thought that Iran will, you know, start
- 1:23collecting toll. And we never thought that US
- 1:27will agree to that toll because they don't want this particular
- 1:31choke point get handed over to China and eventually Iran to
- 1:35become superpowers. Now the situation is like
- 1:38everything seems to be stopped at least for now and then how it
- 1:43will be moving ahead. So whenever we have such kind of
- 1:47news like ceasefire or attack or even the break of the ceasefire,
- 1:53so market initially react and then there are commodities which
- 1:57eventually start reacting LNG such commodity on immediate
- 2:01basis there will be impact on the LNG prices at least
- 2:06declining by 5 to 7%. But right now we are just into
- 2:10the 24 hours of window and the prices have not declined that
- 2:14far. And we expect that going forward
- 2:17within one or two weeks the prices will start falling.
- 2:20But given the fact that the entire other capacity is out and
- 2:25there is a supply outage, how the things will play ahead, very
- 2:28curious to watch. And then there are some players
- 2:32like China not playing aggressively in the LNG market.
- 2:35So we will have to see in future how the prices will react.
- 2:39Well, now that you have mentioned the prices and the
- 2:43Chinese demand, conceptually, after approximately 40 days of
- 2:48conflict involving Iran, which has had a major impact on energy
- 2:52markets, do you see this as a true demand destruction or just
- 2:56temporary disruption? Well, first of all, like what I
- 3:00said earlier, a lot of people started celebrating US and
- 3:05Iran's ceasefire specifically across the financial market.
- 3:08But there is a caution that I would like to mention here, the
- 3:12celebration, it looks premature because you know, the damage
- 3:17done to the global LNG market over the past six weeks or
- 3:21specifically 40 days is not something that gets fixed
- 3:25overnight and eventually it will reshape the way world buys LNG
- 3:30and prices gas for more years to come.
- 3:32So to understand why it is happening, we have to go back to
- 3:35the moment the conflicts truly broke the LNG market and it
- 3:40should not be when this Hormuz Strait is closed.
- 3:43But when Iranian missile hit the Raslafan LNG facilities and the
- 3:47first attack was painful from the global perspective and it
- 3:51was expected that it would be a temporary.
- 3:53But now we are into the 40 days of war and the entire Strait
- 3:57seems to be closed significantly because very few tankers for
- 4:02those who are compliant with the Iranian regime or those in
- 4:07diplomatic talks with the Iranian regime, they were
- 4:10allowed to move from not LNG but other type of vessels like
- 4:14tankers and even some of the containers.
- 4:16They started moving around the state of Hormuz, but not a
- 4:20single LNG vessel has moved. Over the last few days, we have
- 4:23seen two such Chinese vessels, LNG vessels try to move, but
- 4:28then they eventually turn back. This particular Strait crippling
- 4:32around nearly 20% of the world LNG and the world oil flow.
- 4:36It was the initial blow and then the 2nd and far more
- 4:39consequential blow landed on after 18 or 19 days after the
- 4:45start of the war. And when there was a second
- 4:47missile hit on the Raslafan Industrial City.
- 4:50It was the beating heart of the global gas supply, global LNG
- 4:54supply. So Qatar Energies LNG production
- 4:56has been halted since March 2, but the force major, it was
- 5:02declared from March 4 and the end 80 million metric ton per
- 5:07annum capacity, which represent around 19% of global LNG supply
- 5:12stopped suddenly and it happened in a single stroke and market
- 5:16wasn't ready for that. And when we talk about the
- 5:19capacity impacted due to force major, it is 80 metric ton per
- 5:23annum. But when we talk about the
- 5:25infrastructure that actually hit, it's around 17%, that is
- 5:3012.2 million tons per annum. That capacity needs to be
- 5:36redeveloped and repaired and that repaired cost for Middle
- 5:41East Gulf energy infrastructure reaching around 25 billion,
- 5:45which is a huge cost because they build that entire capacity
- 5:49with to the same amount of money in the past and there are only
- 5:53three global manufacturers. They produce the large frame
- 5:57turbines and now this major equipment which convert the gas
- 6:03into liquid energy. And so these particular
- 6:06turbines, those people who supply or manufactured for them,
- 6:12the order book of such infrastructure is already
- 6:15stretched due to the, you know, large energy requirement because
- 6:19the economy has been moved from the data centers to to the heavy
- 6:24electricity center economy. Then there are a lot of
- 6:29different economies who also tried to shift from coal like
- 6:32Germany and other European countries due to environment
- 6:36concern. The point is that, yes, Qatar
- 6:40has a capacity financially, they can rebuild this entire
- 6:44infrastructure. But the stretch to complete the
- 6:48operation or to bring the entire operation back online, it's
- 6:52around 2 to 4 years from today. So we have a ceasefire and after
- 6:57that, after ceasefire, we expect war to be completely stopped so
- 7:02that there could not be many more attacks on the energy
- 7:05infrastructure. But if that is not happening and
- 7:08if war will continue, there would be a massive constraint
- 7:11for this particular LNG infrastructure to bring back
- 7:14online and a very challenging situation for the global LNG
- 7:18market. How to drive this or how to
- 7:21upset this particular LNG supply from the global market?
- 7:25So to answer your question, whether demand destruction or
- 7:29demand decline. So these are two different
- 7:32things. So when we say demand decline,
- 7:34it is a decline of demand, which could be later recovered.
- 7:38But when we talk about demand destruction, it's gone.
- 7:41It's gone from the market. And for the countries like India
- 7:44and China, it's not the demand decline but demand destruction
- 7:49and the offset that have to be fulfilled is bit difficult
- 7:54because they have to compete aggressively in the spot market
- 7:58with European countries. So, Sandesh, since we have now
- 8:01distinguished between destruction of demand and
- 8:03disruption of demand in that background, let me ask you this.
- 8:07Many fuel dependent countries have reacted in panic during
- 8:11this conflict. So what do you think should be
- 8:13the path forward for these economies now?
- 8:15Well, I don't think that just fuel dependent countries
- 8:20reacted. The starting of the war itself
- 8:22was a historic event, but we have never seen such kind of
- 8:26situation earlier. So yes, you're partially right.
- 8:30In such event countries do react with panic and we have seen many
- 8:35fuel dependent countries, they reacted with panic.
- 8:38We have seen Australia, they face the biggest fuel crunch
- 8:43because largely they are dependent on the countries like
- 8:47China, India and others for their fuel needs.
- 8:50And then some of the Southeast Asian countries, they are also
- 8:53dependent on China and others. So when this particular
- 8:58situation was unfolded to us, it was dramatic and country started
- 9:03to react. So there are countries like
- 9:06China immediately stopped their exports.
- 9:09Then there are countries like India who place tax barriers so
- 9:13that exports could not decline but can be impacted so that the
- 9:17Indian refiners, they will focus more on the domestic front.
- 9:22And then there are some Southeast Asian countries which
- 9:24domestically put some measures on economy as well as from the
- 9:29perspective of their domestic consumptions.
- 9:32They started rationing of fuel and then some countries just
- 9:36switched their panic button. They started moving from oil
- 9:40dependent energy generation and move back to the coal dependent
- 9:43energy generation for such countries where the coal plants
- 9:47were idled. So they started executing those
- 9:50idle plants and it's an energy risk, it's an electricity risk,
- 9:54it's a fuel risk. So every country they started to
- 9:57make some kind of major so that they can avoid the chaos for
- 10:01domestically. And then we have seen in the
- 10:05panic market where ships, they started rerouting.
- 10:09We have seen some of the LNG carriers supposed to be in China
- 10:14for discharge. They started moving from China
- 10:16to going to Europe and then LNG vessels which supposed to be
- 10:22going to Europe. They started moving from Europe
- 10:25and as soon as they reach Mediterranean region, they move
- 10:29their route from Mediterranean to the Cape of Guru in order to
- 10:34meet the demand from the forest area.
- 10:36So ship routing has taken place. Then there are some of the
- 10:40traders offloaded some of their LNG cargoes.
- 10:43This kind of things they, they escalate the turn miles, they
- 10:47escalate the the LNG on water because just like the example I
- 10:52have given the vessel, LNG vessel which supposed to go to
- 10:56Europe, now it has been rerouted.
- 10:58So the turn miles get increased that the LNG on water gets
- 11:02increased and there is a repercussion in the market.
- 11:06It will impact the LNG prices. We have seen them increase
- 11:10substantially in the past few days, not just in the developing
- 11:14nation, but in the developed nations.
- 11:17There are some of the industries like electricity and then these
- 11:22developing nations try to pivot towards AI data centers and all
- 11:29those sort of things which you know highly energy intensive
- 11:33industry. So this particular industry is
- 11:36in dire need of gas because some of the electricity generation
- 11:40plants, they are directly dependent on them.
- 11:43So some of the buyers they kind of anticipated this particular
- 11:48situation specifically those are in the China and prior to that,
- 11:54prior to this situation getting out of control, they started
- 11:58getting cargoes from the other open markets.
- 12:01They switched their strategy to pivot away from the traditional
- 12:05buyers to the non traditional buyers.
- 12:07And even if there is increase in price, they started accepting
- 12:11those cargoes because it was a basic necessity for such
- 12:15countries because their large population depend on electricity
- 12:19generation. For the countries who don't have
- 12:22any access to the coal based power plant, US LNG now looks
- 12:26more attractive because the supply is stable.
- 12:30There is minimum risk to access those cargoes.
- 12:34But right now we have to see that how much volume is
- 12:39available for those particular which LNG plant which are under
- 12:44development where cargoes is still not committed.
- 12:47So we have some of the LNG will be coming online in the US by
- 12:522027 and 2028 and then we have Canada around 45,000,000 tons
- 12:58per annum will be coming online by end of 2029.
- 13:02So Asian countries are those who are largely dependent on the
- 13:07Middle East for LNG. They have to pivot, they have to
- 13:11go for long term contracts specifically from the Atlantic
- 13:15basin. We have other prospect also
- 13:18coming online. That means some of the East
- 13:21African economies like Mozambique and Tanzania.
- 13:25So one way is try to move away towards new contracts and then
- 13:31the other way is try to diversify the sources of energy.
- 13:34Now looking at this from a broader spectrum, how do you
- 13:38think the entire shipping market has reacted through this period
- 13:42of conflict? Like I have said earlier, we
- 13:45have seen the some of the ships started routing and then we have
- 13:49seen more LNG on water and then some of the traders, they
- 13:53already procured cargoes and the cargo is already on the ships.
- 13:57So this particular environment impact the turn miles, it
- 14:02impacts the procurement pattern. But this is for the vessel
- 14:05outside Strait of Hormuz, but those still trapped inside, for
- 14:09them the path is not that easy. The flag state has to be
- 14:14conveyed diplomatically to Iran so that Iranians, they will
- 14:18allow the LNG vessels to move from state of Hormuz and try to
- 14:23mitigate that risk of getting hit.
- 14:26And for the LNG vessels, they carry the cargo which is also a
- 14:30high cost cargo and then at the same time LNG vessel itself a
- 14:34high value asset. We have seen with respect to
- 14:36Indian and flagged LPG vessels, they get safe passage after
- 14:41diplomatic talks from the government and at the same time
- 14:45there is no insurance coverage. Now insurance are asking 40
- 14:49times more than that and this is kind of very huge for the
- 14:53shipping industry because they can't pay that much amount.
- 14:57So we expect that there is a huge impact at least for coming
- 15:03days. So to answer to your question,
- 15:07we have seen some of the shipping companies, they're
- 15:10already restricting themselves to go to the state of Hormuz.
- 15:15And then there are some chatterers who want their
- 15:18vessels to go inside the state of Hormuz with the incremental
- 15:23AWRP cost. And for them to bear such high
- 15:28cost is already a financial burden.
- 15:32So we expect that shipping industry will continue to react
- 15:37to the conflict. But since now ceasefire is
- 15:40there, we may see some favorable momentum for the shipping
- 15:43industry, specifically for the LNG one.
- 15:46Now that we have dissected and unfolded a lot of perspectives
- 15:51and aspects that could affect the shipping market and could
- 15:56have an impact in the geopolitical space, I think that
- 16:00brings us to the end of this episode.
- 16:03And to all our listeners. Please stay tuned for the next
- 16:05one because there are so many more perspectives to unfold.
- 16:08And do not forget to share and subscribe to our podcast.
- 16:12Until next time, navigate safely and stay tuned.