Latest / Taylor Tailored / The History of Money: Before Coins, Before Banks, And Whats Next?
Transcript
- 0:00The history of money before coins, before banks, and what's
- 0:04next? Money is not just stuff we
- 0:06trade, it's a permission system. Who gets to buy now, who must
- 0:11wait, and who carries the risk when trust breaks?
- 0:14The modern surprise is that most money is created mid
- 0:17transaction, not in a mint. But currently a bank approves a
- 0:21loan and credits an account. That makes today's central
- 0:24tension brutally simple. Money has become easier to
- 0:28create than the real things it claims.
- 0:30Homes, energy, labor, land, and every upgrade to money creation
- 0:35has shifted power toward Whoever runs the pipes will narrow the
- 0:38window to the most decisive arc. From state Ious and early
- 0:42central banking to post 1971 Fiat money, then into QE era
- 0:47balance sheets and cryptos attempt to rebuild money as
- 0:50software key points. Money is a trusted claim on
- 0:54goods and services. Its backing is ultimately the
- 0:57enforcement and tax capacity behind it.
- 1:00A decisive early model wasn't coins, but state recorded debt
- 1:04claims that became transferable and tax payable.
- 1:07Central banks scaled money by centralizing credibility and
- 1:11settlement, culminating in the Bank of England's state banker
- 1:14role. Modern money is mostly bank
- 1:17deposits created when banks lend, not primarily when central
- 1:21banks print. The post 1944 system tied global
- 1:25money to the dollar and the dollar to gold until that anchor
- 1:29broke in 1971. QE changed the composition of
- 1:33financial assets by creating central bank reserves to buy
- 1:37bonds, pushing down long rates and shifting incentives.
- 1:40Crypto challenged the issuer model by making issuance rule
- 1:43based protocol and verification decentralized network.
- 1:47The next battlefield is not where the crypto wins, but which
- 1:51parts get absorbed. Stable coins, tokenized deposits
- 1:55and retail wholesale CBDC experiments.
- 1:58Background Before money was sleek, it was messy.
- 2:02Coins clipped, waits argued over, and distance turned
- 2:05payment into a weeks long problem.
- 2:08States needed revenue and war finance merchants needed
- 2:12settlement that didn't depend on hauling metal.
- 2:15The core actors were predictable government seeking dependable
- 2:18taxation and borrowing, banks seeking profitable lending and
- 2:22privileged access, and households trying to store value
- 2:26without being ruined by debasement, default or panic.
- 2:29Two systems were already in motion by the time modern money
- 2:32emerged, state credit, tax backed promises and bank
- 2:36intermediation, turning illiquid loans into liquid claims.
- 2:40A society's money becomes decisive when it is the easiest
- 2:44thing to accept and the hardest thing to refuse.
- 2:47The origin, a decisive starting point, is the shift from money
- 2:51as metal to money as organized trust.
- 2:54State recognized claims that could circulate because they
- 2:57were enforceable and useful for taxes.
- 2:59In England, tally sticks illustrate the logic.
- 3:02A recorded obligation split into matching halves that could
- 3:06become transferable and effectively monetary because the
- 3:09state would accept it. It's an early proof that money
- 3:11can be a durable record of debt, not a shiny object.
- 3:15The central banks then industrialized this trust.
- 3:18The Bank of England's founding as banker to the government made
- 3:21credibility scalable, the state could borrow more predictably,
- 3:25and the financial system gained a settlement anchor.
- 3:28Once money is a system of recorded claims, the question
- 3:31becomes who is allowed to write the claims and under what
- 3:35constraints. The timeline pre medieval money
- 3:38before coins, and why coins took over long before anyone carried
- 3:43a wallet. Money was mostly an accounting
- 3:45technology. In the earliest cities of
- 3:48Mesopotamia, temples and palaces tracked obligations on clay
- 3:51tablets, grains owed, labor due and silver promised so value
- 3:56could be measured, stored and enforced even when nothing
- 4:00physical changed hands. One vivid tell is how often
- 4:03surviving tablets read like spreadsheets, balanced accounts
- 4:07of barley deliveries, or lists of silver payments to named
- 4:10people. What mattered wasn't metal, but
- 4:13standard units. Barley worked as a practical
- 4:16baseline because it was storable and central institutions
- 4:19controlled large stocks. Silver worked as a higher value
- 4:22reference because it could travel and compress wealth.
- 4:26Together they solved the same problem, turning messy local
- 4:29barter into transferable claims that could survive time,
- 4:33distance, and disagreement. Credit sits at the center.
- 4:36Here, money begins with who owes what, made portable by record
- 4:40keeping and enforcement. In ancient China, a different
- 4:43material solved the same trust problem, cowrie shells.
- 4:47Their value came from their recognizability, relative
- 4:50scarcity, and social prestige, making them useful for tribute,
- 4:54gifts, and exchange long before formal coinage became dominant.
- 4:58Over time, the idea of a standard shell becomes so
- 5:01entrenched that replicas appear proof that what people really
- 5:04wanted was the unit, not the original object.
- 5:07Coins arrive late, and they arrive for a blunt reason.
- 5:11Scale. Once states needed to pay
- 5:13soldiers, collect taxes, and settle accounts across wider
- 5:16territories, weighing metal every time became a bottleneck.
- 5:20The breakthrough in Lydia is not gold as money but stamped metal
- 5:24as certified weight and acceptability, a shortcut that
- 5:28turns trust into a portable object.
- 5:30From there, coinage spreads rapidly because it reduces
- 5:33transaction friction and makes state finance more legible.
- 5:37Imperial coinage then reveals a permanent feature of money.
- 5:41The issuer can change the rules. Rome's long monetary story
- 5:45includes repeated episodes where precious metal content shifts
- 5:49under fiscal pressure, reminding everyone that money is never
- 5:52just a neutral medium, it is also a policy instrument tied to
- 5:55legitimacy, taxation and military capacity.
- 5:58This pre medieval world locks in the central pattern.
- 6:02Money evolves fastest when institutions need to mobilize
- 6:05resources quickly and every improvement in portability tends
- 6:09to strengthen. Whoever controls the Ledger, the
- 6:12stamp, or the enforcement debt becomes portable.
- 6:15Medieval, early modern, on the ground, daily life ran on credit
- 6:20long before it ran on cash. Obligations travelled through
- 6:23communities as surely as goods did.
- 6:26The mechanism was record keeping plus enforceability.
- 6:29A claim mattered if courts, the Crown or custom made it
- 6:32collectible and if the state would take it for taxes.
- 6:36The constraint was scarcity of trustworthy settlement media
- 6:39over distance. When coins are rare, heavy, and
- 6:42easy to cheat, societies build money out of records.
- 6:46This phase quietly hands capacity over to whoever
- 6:49controls the Ledger. First the state, then
- 6:52institutions that specialize in keeping promises legible.
- 6:56Central banks turn credibility into infrastructure. 1694 to
- 7:001800's. The shift on the ground is
- 7:03subtle but enormous. Government finance becomes
- 7:06routinized rather than episodic, and markets start treating the
- 7:10state as a continuous borrower. The mechanism is institutional
- 7:14privilege. A central bank tied to the state
- 7:17can consolidate, trust standardized notes, and
- 7:20stabilize settlements. The constraint is legitimacy.
- 7:23Notes only circulate if people believe redemption or acceptance
- 7:27will hold in stress. As note issues and regulations
- 7:30tighten, Monetary Authority becomes less local and more
- 7:34national. Efficient but also more
- 7:36politically consequential. Gold standards discipline then
- 7:40strain 1800s to 1940s on the ground.
- 7:45Gold convertibility imposes a hard psychological rule.
- 7:49Paper is real because it can be swapped for metal until it
- 7:52can't. The mechanism is constrained by
- 7:54convertibility. Money growth is forced to track
- 7:57reserves and external balances, tightening policy when gold
- 8:01drains. The constraint is war and mass
- 8:04politics. Total War, finance and welfare
- 8:07era expectations collide with a system built for smaller States
- 8:12and slower economies. This phase locks in the idea
- 8:15that monetary order is geopolitics.
- 8:18Whoever anchors the system exports their rules.
- 8:21Bretton Woods builds a dollar world 1944 to 1971.
- 8:27Post war predictability brings about changes on the ground.
- 8:30The management of exchange rates, the expansion of trade
- 8:34and the dollar's emergence is the settlement language of
- 8:36global commerce. The mechanism is a layered
- 8:39promise. Other currencies peg to the
- 8:41dollar while the dollar is convertible to gold for official
- 8:44holders, an arrangement that works.
- 8:47While confidence holds and U.S. policy remains credible, the
- 8:50gold window problem serves as the pivot.
- 8:53When foreign dollar claims surpass the gold reserves that
- 8:56sustain the promise, the system becomes politically unstable.
- 9:00In 1971, convertibility ends and the regime shifts.
- 9:05Money becomes fully Fiat at the global core and monetary policy
- 9:09becomes a tool of domestic management as much as external
- 9:12discipline. Modern money is mostly bank
- 9:14deposits. 1970s to 2007. The big change is that money
- 9:19becomes overwhelmingly electronic and bank issued
- 9:22deposits, cards and interbank settlement replace cash.
- 9:26For most economic activity. The mechanism is loan driven
- 9:30creation. When banks lend, they create a
- 9:32deposit new spendable money. While capital regulation and
- 9:36profitability limit how far this can go.
- 9:39The constraint is confidence and risk management.
- 9:43While banks can quickly create claims, they cannot create
- 9:46solvency. Crises arise when asset values
- 9:49fluctuate or funding is depleted.
- 9:52This phase makes credit cycles synonymous with money cycles and
- 9:55ties housing markets, leverage and inequality to monetary
- 9:59plumbing. QE and balance Sheet Money 2008
- 10:03present on the ground. The crisis response changes the
- 10:07feel of money. Rates sit low, asset prices
- 10:10inflate, and central banks become dominant actors in bond
- 10:13markets. The mechanism is asset purchases
- 10:16financed by reserve creation, central banks by bonds, swapping
- 10:21them for reserves, aiming to lower long rates and support
- 10:24demand. The constraint is transmission
- 10:28and politics. QE moves through financial
- 10:31channels 1st and its side effects, distributional tension,
- 10:34fiscal monetary blur, and credibility questions become the
- 10:37story. This phase matters because it
- 10:40normalizes a new fact. In a crisis, the state can
- 10:44rapidly redefine the asset side of the financial system without
- 10:47printing physical cash. A money system that can be
- 10:50expanded in minutes will be judged by what it inflates
- 10:53first, trust, output or resentment consequences.
- 10:58Modern money creation immediately increases the
- 11:00elasticity of economies by enabling banks to extend credit
- 11:04for growth and central banks to stabilize panic more quickly
- 11:08than a world limited by gold could.
- 11:11The 2nd order effects are the price.
- 11:13Debt heavy systems amplify booms and busts, and the boundary
- 11:17between monetary policy and politics becomes porous whenever
- 11:21asset prices and housing affordability become public
- 11:23obsessions. In the longer run, the system
- 11:26hardens into institutional habits, inflation targets,
- 11:29lender of last resort doctrines, Deposit Insurance, capital
- 11:33rules, and now a growing regulatory perimeter around
- 11:37digital money like instruments. When money is mostly credit,
- 11:41every argument about the economy becomes an argument about who
- 11:44receives credit and on what terms.
- 11:47What most people miss the most significant misunderstanding is
- 11:51thinking the central bank prints most money.
- 11:54In practice, the day-to-day money supply is largely bank
- 11:58deposits created through lending, with the central bank
- 12:01steering conditions and acting as the settlement backstop.
- 12:04Cryptocurrency's real challenge isn't that it's alternative
- 12:07money, it's that it tries to relocate trust from
- 12:10institutions, banks, states, courts into protocol rules and
- 12:14distributed verification, which changes where failures show up
- 12:18not as inflation but as hacks, runs on stable coins, governance
- 12:22disputes and regulatory choke points.
- 12:25The next decade will be less about replacing Fiat and more
- 12:28about a tug of war over interfaces, wallets, stable
- 12:31settlement assets and who is allowed to connect to the
- 12:34payments bloodstream. What endured?
- 12:36Money still runs on trust under stress, not elegance in calm
- 12:40markets. States still defend monetary
- 12:43sovereignty because tax collection, sanctions, power and
- 12:47crisis management depend on it. Credit still concentrates where
- 12:51collateral is easiest to value, especially property.
- 12:54Unless policy fights the gravitational pull, networks
- 12:57still center around liquidity hubs, even when the ideology
- 13:01claims decentralization. And every new money still has to
- 13:04answer the old question, who absorbs losses?
- 13:07When optimism meets reality, the limits do not disappear.
- 13:11They simply migrate to a new layer.
- 13:14Disputed and uncertain points. Some historians emphasize state
- 13:18taxation capacity as the core driver of money's acceptability,
- 13:23while others stress commodity convertibility in market
- 13:26conventions as the decisive anchors.
- 13:28The extent to which gold standards cause stability versus
- 13:31simply reflecting broader institutional discipline remains
- 13:35contested because crises often involved banking and fiscal
- 13:38weakness as much as metal scarcity.
- 13:41Some historians interpret 1971 as an unavoidable correction to
- 13:45an unsustainable promise, while others view it as a political
- 13:49decision that paved the way for decades of monetary
- 13:51experimentation. Q ES effectiveness is debated.
- 13:55Supporters stress crisis prevention and demand support.
- 13:58Critics stress asset price distortion and the difficulty of
- 14:02clean exits without fiscal consequences.
- 14:05Whether crypto is money or speculative asset technology
- 14:08depends on which function you prioritize, medium of exchange,
- 14:11unit of account or store of value.
- 14:14And the answer varies by token and country.
- 14:16Uncertainty is not a flaw here, it's a map of where power and
- 14:20risk are still being renegotiated.
- 14:22Legacy. The legacy is a world where
- 14:25money is mostly software claims managed by institutions and the
- 14:29political struggle is over who gets to issue, verify and freeze
- 14:32those claims. Crypto did not create digital
- 14:35money. It revealed the possibility of
- 14:37rewriting the rules of money even beyond the initial state
- 14:40draft. Central banks and regulators
- 14:43have responded by pulling parts of crypto into supervised
- 14:46categories, especially stable coins, while exploring state
- 14:50backed digital complements, including a digital pound design
- 14:54phase running through 2026. The concrete institutional habit
- 14:58that follows is regulatory convergence.
- 15:01Money, like things, get treated like money when they get big
- 15:04enough to matter, especially if they promise stability.
- 15:07For more insight and less noise, subscribe and explore the full
- 15:11range at taylortaylor.co.uk.