Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / The Market Edge: Housing Affordability
Transcript
- 0:06Hello and welcome to another episode of the Market Edge podcast,
- 0:10a series created by the Market Intelligence Committee, members that feature
- 0:13industry experts who address the most pressing issues to members today with
- 0:18a focus really on market trends,
- 0:20economic insights and actionable strategies aimed at empowering engineering
- 0:24firms to drive growth, adapt, change and maintain their competitiveness.
- 0:29This series is brought to you by the Engineering Influence at the American Council
- 0:32of Engineering Companies.
- 0:33My name is Diana O'Leary and I will be your host today. In this special issue,
- 0:38we are actually sitting down with one of the most influential voices shaping
- 0:41housing policy, the Vice President of State and Regulatory Affairs at Leading Builders of America.
- 0:47As the nation continues to grapple with rising construction costs,
- 0:51regulatory complexities, and a growing demand for attainable homes,
- 0:54few people have clear view of these challenges and opportunities ahead.
- 0:59We have Phil Crone with us. Thank you so much for being here today.
- 1:02Thanks, Diane. I'm glad to be here. Awesome to have you.
- 1:05I just wanted to share a little bit more about Phil for those that aren't familiar with him or LBA.
- 1:10He leads the state and regulatory advocacy for leading builders of America or LBA.
- 1:16He works closely with member companies to advance housing policy and political
- 1:21initiatives in key states.
- 1:22He also directs their engagement on building codes and standards with a particular
- 1:27focus on the International Energy Conservation Code and National Above Code programs.
- 1:32He also previously served as the Government Affairs Director and CEO of the
- 1:36Dallas Builders Association.
- 1:39Phil is passionate about workforce development, as we are as well in the construction
- 1:43industry, engineering for us, and helped create a construction curriculum for
- 1:46managers and tradespeople at Area Community College.
- 1:50Heals a bachelor's degree from
- 1:51Purdue University and a Juris Doctor from Southern Methodist University.
- 1:55So let's get down to it. For those that aren't familiar with Leading Builders
- 1:59of America, can you set the stage by sharing the mission and purpose of LBA with our listeners?
- 2:05Yeah, you bet. LBA, we're a CEO-led trade association, so similar to a business
- 2:11roundtable and how we're comprised. And the organization is comprised of 22
- 2:17member companies collectively.
- 2:19They sell about 350,000 new homes annually and close to about half of all the
- 2:28new homes that are sold in the U.S. in any given year.
- 2:32And our purpose is very straightforward just to preserve home affordability
- 2:37for American families. And we do that by engaging in federal and state policies that,
- 2:44directly affect the cost and feasibility of building homes. Very similar to
- 2:49ACEC and our member base as well.
- 2:52And right now, the biggest thing that's coming through in this latest news cycle
- 2:56is housing affordability.
- 2:58And I understand from you that this is even more important because the president's
- 3:02expected to speak at the World Economic Forum on this as well,
- 3:05which I believe is happening now.
- 3:07But why don't you tell us, you know, how is the White House,
- 3:10or at least from your lens, expected to address the affordability issue?
- 3:14What's the latest coming out of Washington and what are we expecting to hear?
- 3:18Sure. Diana, I think expected is probably the key word right now.
- 3:23President is expected the day after this is being recorded and Davos lay out
- 3:28his vision for housing. We'll see how much in detail and in substance he gets
- 3:34into about that or Greenland or something else.
- 3:37I'm sure there'll be a little bit on everything. But overall,
- 3:40though, the White House has what we feel is a pretty good plan in the works.
- 3:44I mean, it has the right diagnosis for the problem.
- 3:47The housing affordability crisis is mainly a supply problem.
- 3:51And prices are high because we've spent decades making it too hard,
- 3:56too slow, and too expensive to build homes, especially starter homes.
- 4:01That really, you know, when we call this a housing affordability crisis,
- 4:06it's actually best described as a housing policy crisis because of all those
- 4:11aforementioned encumbrances.
- 4:13In fact, about $94,000 of the cost of a single-family home come from regulations alone.
- 4:20Some of those are reasonable and deal with things like life safety,
- 4:24but many are not. Zoning restrictions and long permitting timelines.
- 4:29Duplicative reviews, code mandates, all those things.
- 4:31And I think the White House is going to push towards faster approvals and fewer
- 4:36layers of review and try to rein in some of the federal policies that raise construction costs.
- 4:44And I think that'll be paired with some reforms that may help households,
- 4:48especially first-time homebuyers, younger families prepare for homeownership,
- 4:53things like tax relief or savings incentives.
- 4:56And then something we're both passionate about, workforce priorities that support
- 5:01more in the construction trades and higher wages.
- 5:05So we'll see. I mean, the federal government has limited direct control over
- 5:09this, but they certainly can convert and control housing. Yeah.
- 5:12Transportation dollars. And beyond that, a lot of what they're trying to do,
- 5:16like the tax stuff, is going to require some congressional action,
- 5:20which, of course, within GOP majorities, we'll see.
- 5:24But a lot of this is bipartisan, so optimistic that we'll see something happen as the year goes on.
- 5:30Sounds very positive, at least through your lens. And I'm very curious to see
- 5:33what actually comes out from the president here and when this podcast comes
- 5:38out and if it'll still be timely and what we hear in the next couple of days versus now.
- 5:42We kind of scratched the surface a little there on current regulatory and policy
- 5:47barriers that you all are tracking, especially permitting reform.
- 5:50Expedited permitting is something that we're really interested here.
- 5:54You know, specifically the ones that are slowing down the delivery of affordable
- 5:57housing, those issues and challenges. Is there anything you guys are doing to address that?
- 6:02Any trends that you're seeing or anything that maybe engineering firms,
- 6:06our members can do to help that along?
- 6:08Yeah, as mentioned, I work a lot in the state regulatory arena,
- 6:14and there are a lot of things.
- 6:17Texas fairly recently, but even California with freezing the advancements of
- 6:24some of their codes there, there are some really positive things that are coming out of the states.
- 6:31And I think a bipartisan acknowledgement that those barriers are everywhere.
- 6:36I mean, they're usually not individually dramatic. They're kind of more of sort
- 6:41of a death by a thousand cuts.
- 6:42So you'll have the zoning and entitlement delays.
- 6:45And then you had mentioned permitting challenges and friction could be inconsistent
- 6:52plan reviews, you know, rework for the same question, utility coordination issues.
- 6:59Actually, at my prior role in Dallas, I saw this, unfortunately, firsthand.
- 7:03You went from being able to get a single-family building permit the next day
- 7:08to it taking three or four months due to a system and a staff meltdown,
- 7:15and it really crippled the city and pushed housing and economic growth into surrounding cities.
- 7:21And so I think the more certainty and standardization that we can find, the better.
- 7:28And we've been working on that in a lot of places, certainly the ones that have
- 7:32a lot of housing activity and being able to make some inroads regardless of
- 7:37the political situation.
- 7:40Parties who are in charge there. So staying in line with what's happening in
- 7:45the latest news cycle, there's also other things that we've been hearing impacting
- 7:49the financial markets, for example,
- 7:51where there's talks of legislation that could prohibit institutional buyers
- 7:56or investors from purchasing single family homes.
- 7:59Do you have any of the latest on that?
- 8:02What effects could this have on this market or what stance would you all take?
- 8:06Sure. There are a few versions of that floating around.
- 8:10Certainly parts of the administration have talked about that.
- 8:13Some proposals go after large owners through taxes or forced divestment concepts
- 8:20and others just aim to restrict purchases outright or limit them significantly.
- 8:26We're seeing that also state level, state legislatures are looking at that right
- 8:31now in places like California and Nevada.
- 8:35And you asked about our approach on this.
- 8:38I mean, nationally large institutional ownership is a pretty small share,
- 8:43maybe a little bit bigger in some metro areas, but still in the single digits.
- 8:48And a ban in the existing market may be temporarily positive, but at the same time.
- 8:57You have to remember that a lot of these institutional investors saved markets
- 9:02like Atlanta and others on the tail end of the Great Recession.
- 9:05When it comes to new housing, completely different dynamic.
- 9:09We already know we don't have enough homes relative to demand and whatever is
- 9:16done at the state or federal level, it just can't encumber the production of new homes.
- 9:19Most people in the administration are intelligent enough to understand this
- 9:24and know that real live people reside there and thrive in these communities,
- 9:29which oftentimes these rental communities can be a bridge to first-time homeownership.
- 9:34So we know right now there's a lot of turbulence going on in the economy and
- 9:39how we see things fleshing out. But let's look ahead a little bit.
- 9:42If we go five to 10 years out, are there any trends or shifts that you are all
- 9:47expecting or looking to or forecasting that could really change and reshape
- 9:52the housing, affordable housing, housing affordability landscape? Yeah, I think.
- 9:57Maybe two things generally to look at here.
- 10:01One, insurance and climate resilience costs.
- 10:05I know, you know, there's a politically charged element of that,
- 10:08but really it's, you know, with the PITI, it's a big part of the monthly payment.
- 10:14And, you know, that's challenging homeownership right now.
- 10:18So I think especially in wind and wildfire and flood prone regions.
- 10:24That's where I think new construction really distinguishes itself given the
- 10:27advances in technology that go into every modern home and recent building codes.
- 10:33So I think there'll be more of a distinction between older product and newer
- 10:39product when it comes to that.
- 10:40And then the other one is labor constraints and something that I know LBA and
- 10:46ACEC are concerned about really.
- 10:48It's the people swinging the
- 10:51hammers on the job site, but it's also engineers and front office staff.
- 10:55Those constraints aren't going to go away. They really, I think,
- 11:00will push on one hand our industry to find ways to, as we have been doing,
- 11:05to do more with less on the job side.
- 11:08And so I think there's also a push that's going to come with AI starting to
- 11:14move into a lot of the white collar jobs.
- 11:17I think that may help bring back shop class and elevate the type of well-paying
- 11:21jobs that are in short supply.
- 11:24And I think maybe replenish our construction trades because it's going to be
- 11:31as much a craftsman or craftsmanship job as it is technology-driven when you
- 11:36look at being a plumber, being an electrician,
- 11:39all these things that are becoming a lot more, I think a lot more sophisticated
- 11:44than they were and always in short supply.
- 11:48So the first one you brought up kind of centers around that energy sustainability, energy efficiency.
- 11:53Do you think the industry can handle both while also addressing the urgent need
- 11:59for affordable housing?
- 12:00Is that going to delay it, make houses more expensive? Do you think that both can be done?
- 12:06That's that's the challenge right i mean that's where we
- 12:09can have housing housing policy can can
- 12:12either be part of the problem or part of the solution there's
- 12:15this mindset that some have you know hey you know
- 12:18a hundred dollars more here two hundred dollars more there isn't it worth it
- 12:22shouldn't we do it and that's that's kind of that death by a thousand cuts that
- 12:25i was talking about before but you know there are there are things for example
- 12:29on energy efficiency if if you can value a granite countertop when your home is appraised,
- 12:36you know, why can't you value the savings long-term that are offered by a more efficient home?
- 12:42And you should be able to do that and finance that house in a way that defrays,
- 12:49you know, the upfront costs that a lot of these systems have.
- 12:53So I think if we got a little smarter with our underwriting and appraising for
- 12:58energy efficiency, you could have you could have both. And that that really
- 13:02speaks to the importance of policy here.
- 13:05All right, let's stick with the design and housing design conversation for a second.
- 13:10Is there anything that we're looking at change wise in how homes are designed,
- 13:14whether that's through modular construction or any alternative materials?
- 13:17Are you seeing any trends there?
- 13:19Yeah, there are a lot of small improvements that are coming kind of under that
- 13:23theme that I was talking about before.
- 13:25Assembly more than fabrication.
- 13:29There are a lot of kits for systems that are modified in the factory for every nuance.
- 13:35And the design, I was talking earlier this week to a company that does that
- 13:39with PEX piping in the plumbing space.
- 13:42I also think window technology is likely to advance pretty significantly fairly soon.
- 13:48Everything else on the building envelope, certainly insulation.
- 13:53Especially fiberglass insulation has really reached the edge of its evolution.
- 13:59So the only real laggard there is window technology, but I see that catching
- 14:04up and then also load management for electrified homes.
- 14:08It's hard to get the utility company to give you a bigger meter to the house
- 14:14with the overall challenges that we have for the grid.
- 14:17So, okay, well, then how do you dry your clothes at the same time you're cooking
- 14:22dinner at the same time you want to charge your EV if you have one for the next day?
- 14:26There's a lot of cool things that are coming out to try to manage that situation,
- 14:30some of which are fairly expensive now.
- 14:32But I think as it scales up, there's, there's going to be some more innovation and competition there.
- 14:38You took my next question from me, but I'll see if there was anything else we
- 14:41wanted to add, and that was innovation in infrastructure, which would be most
- 14:46of interest to our engineering firms.
- 14:48So anything else that is trending for innovation in stormwater or transportation
- 14:53surrounding housing development or any utilities?
- 14:56Yeah, I think a few things just kind of under that work smarter, not harder theme.
- 15:02Most of your listeners would probably know more about those things in the detail than I do.
- 15:07But I think a few things that our members value are you look at stormwater,
- 15:12you know, let's have more performance-based standards, you know,
- 15:15smarter detention strategies,
- 15:17you know, things that are designed to be maintained and inspected more easily.
- 15:23Transportation, you know, try to align the access requirements with reality.
- 15:29Right-size improvements to a given subdivision or project.
- 15:34And instead of having, you know, some of these, you know, gold-plated mitigations
- 15:39that don't match project impacts.
- 15:41And then, you know, back to utilities, I think the more you can coordinate trenching,
- 15:46standardized details, you know, quicker interconnects, and just,
- 15:50you know, planning for load growth.
- 15:53You know, electrification without overbuilding, you know, all these things that
- 15:56we could plan for on day one when the dirt's churned and the trench is open.
- 16:01You can cut months off of schedules and tens of thousands per lot just with
- 16:06better planning and better standards and coordination and predictability.
- 16:11Yeah. Well, Phil, it looks like we've got time for about one more question here.
- 16:14And this is something we didn't talk about. So I hope you'll forgive me.
- 16:17And if you don't have the answer, that's fine, too.
- 16:19So the second thing you brought up outside of the sustainability as,
- 16:23you know, five, 10 year trend is workforce and labor constraints.
- 16:28And so I'm curious, because it's all over the news, anything on the latest immigration
- 16:32policy impacting your labor constraints, making it harder or worse,
- 16:37exacerbating the issue? And what stance are you all taking?
- 16:41Yeah, we see every day those disruptions occur in the communities and among
- 16:47the folks that we rely on to get the job done and no one else,
- 16:52frankly, is stepping forward to do it.
- 16:54So we need to have some certainty where those folks, if they follow the rules,
- 17:00can step out of the shadows and onto the job site confidently and at the same
- 17:03time, as I mentioned before,
- 17:05we really need to look at shop class and what we can do domestically.
- 17:10We have an education system with standardized tests and everything else that
- 17:14focuses on making kids mediocre, what they're not interested in,
- 17:19instead of extraordinary, what they are interested in.
- 17:21And I think that there are a lot of brilliant kids that express it in different
- 17:26ways in terms of building with their hands or designing, engineering things.
- 17:30And we need to foster that as much as we have the traditional path.
- 17:35And I think a combination of those two things would really help with housing
- 17:39affordability and have more positive societal impacts than maybe what we're
- 17:45seeing right now on both of those things.
- 17:49Thank you for that. I can definitely hear your passion and interest in the topic.
- 17:53I just wanted to tell our listeners, that's about all the time we have for today.
- 17:56Phil Krohn, thank you so much for joining us.
- 17:59Yeah, appreciate it, Diana. And hopefully your members found some,
- 18:02the listeners found some value in this and I enjoyed the conversation.
- 18:07And thank you to our listeners for tuning into another episode of The Market Edge.
- 18:11Don't forget to like and subscribe, ACC's Engineering Influence channel.
- 18:14I'm Diana Olaire. See you next time.