Latest / Burn the Playbook with Michael Starr Hopkins / The Oil Lobby Asked. The Bears Got Five Years.

Transcript

The Oil Lobby Asked. The Bears Got Five Years. · Burn the Playbook with Michael Starr Hopkins

• 0:00
  Alaska's oil trade group asked for five years of federal rules allowing activity around polar bears and Pacific walruses. The Fish and Wildlife Service made the rules final October nineteenth.
• 0:10
  That decision set a framework. It did not issue every company a permit.
• 0:15
  October twentieth, twenty twenty-six, the Alaska Oil and Gas Association sought permission covering exploration, development, production, and transportation around the Beaufort Sea year-round.
• 0:26
  The Marine Mammal Protection Act, passed in nineteen seventy-two, limited what the government could approve. The agency had to find that the activity involved only small numbers of animals and had a negligible impact.
• 0:37
  Those requirements applied when the rules were renewed. The new rules ran for five years, through twenty thirty-one. Specific activities still required companies to seek letters of authorization.
• 0:47
  Companies had to request those letters. A request was not automatic approval. For industry, a five-year framework offered planning certainty.
• 0:56
  For the public, the central question was: what supported the agency's conclusion that the effect on protected animals would remain small?
• 1:03
  The next questions were in the rule itself, the take limits, public comments, and data behind that negligible impact finding. Those materials were not examined in this summary-based reporting.
• 1:14
  A trade group asked, the agency answered. That did not establish that the agency abandoned the law or got the science wrong. It established a decision worth examining. The strongest defense was routine renewal.
• 1:26
  The previous rules used the same five-year structure. On that reading, the new rules continued an established process. Routine is a terrific defense when you are the one benefiting from the routine.
• 1:37
  Even a routine renewal required a decision. Past approval did not answer whether the new findings satisfied the law. Then look at the dates.
• 1:45
  The previous rules ran from August sixth, twenty twenty-one through August fifth, twenty twenty-six. The October nineteenth publication came seventy-five days after that end date. What governed during that interval?
• 1:57
  The published summary did not say. That left a question, not evidence of seventy-five days without protection. Federal wildlife decisions are made in the public's name.
• 2:06
  Ask members of Congress what supported the negligible impact finding and what governed during the intervening period. Now to a polling number that needed its date attached.
• 2:15
  BTP's congressional ballot average showed Democrats at fifty-one point three percent and Republicans at forty-two and a half among likely voters. That was roughly a nine-point Democratic lead in the included surveys.
• 2:27
  Three polling organizations contributed, and all the surveys were online. The newest survey had closed October fourth, sixteen days before this episode. The figure was a weighted average, not an election prediction.
• 2:38
  It described the included surveys, not where opinion necessarily stood on October twentieth. A large margin does not make an aging, limited field fresh. Finally, the job openings checked that week.
• 2:50
  The openings were checked October nineteenth.
• 2:52
  The AFL-CIO had headquarters openings in Washington and opportunities across a twelve-state central region from Ohio to the Dakotas, with a requirement to live within a hundred miles of a major airport.
• 3:03
  The state of Washington listed work in Olympia with a hybrid option. Louisiana listed openings in Baton Rouge.
• 3:09
  Other employers included Ventura County Superior Court, Surry County Social Services in North Carolina, and the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles. Nobody paid to appear on the list.
• 3:19
  The openings were live when checked October nineteenth. Availability could change. The oil industry got five years it could plan around. The law still required small numbers and negligible impact.
• 3:30
  Renewal did not make those words optional. Subscribe free at burn the playbook dot news for the reporting and next update. [upbeat music]