Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #53: Education Policy's Impact on Civic Engagement w/ Shaka Mitchell
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:02I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:05We're really racking up these guest episodes, aren't we?
- 0:08I always lead off guest episodes by saying that I do not take a specific stance for or against
- 0:13against political views or political groups they may belong to, even though that has not
- 0:17been an issue, and I don't foresee it being an issue, but I make that disclaimer regardless.
- 0:23So a few weeks ago, I made an episode, which was just me about political apathy.
- 0:29Why do people disengage from the political process?
- 0:33What are some ways that we can potentially lessen apathy?
- 0:36And today's guest wants to continue the conversation on the state of political
- 0:41engagement in this country, especially in regards to civil rights and education policy.
- 0:46How does how we teach our kids and adults about the political process, government function, and
- 0:52so on affect how invested people are in politics?
- 0:57Where are the areas most in need of improvement?
- 1:00How we teach civics and government is a major interest of mine, and that's also the case for
- 1:04today's guest, Shaka Mitchell.
- 1:06Shaka is a senior fellow with the American Federation of Children or for Children, AFC, an
- 1:12adjunct professor of constitutional law at Belmont University, and an attorney with his
- 1:18own practice.
- 1:19Previously, he was the director of state strategy and advocacy with the AFC, the
- 1:25director of external affairs with Lee Public Schools, and the chair of Tennessee's state
- 1:29advisory committee to the US Commission on Civil Rights.
- 1:33So without further ado, let's talk about education policy and how it relates to civic
- 1:38engagement and how it affects you, the listener slash viewer.
- 1:42Please welcome Shaka Mitchell.
- 1:44Shaka, thank you very much for being here.
- 1:46How are you today?
- 1:46I'm well.
- 1:47Thanks for having me on, Paul.
- 1:48Looking forward to our conversation.
- 1:49Absolutely.
- 1:50Me too.
- 1:50And I I I was really happy to see you reach out after that episode I had on political apathy.
- 1:57Sometimes you wonder who is this reaching out to?
- 2:00Is this having a real impact?
- 2:01And so when somebody it really resonates with somebody and they want to continue the
- 2:05conversation, it's it's always a a good feeling.
- 2:08So let's go back to the beginning for you.
- 2:11I wanna give a fuller picture of you and showcase why this topic is important to you.
- 2:15So how did you come to be so invested in the political process and how education policy
- 2:20factors into it?
- 2:22Yeah.
- 2:23Thanks, Paul.
- 2:24So I think that everyone has their own education story.
- 2:28Right?
- 2:29And so, obviously, there are folks like me who work in education, and whether or not that's in
- 2:35the classroom or at an advocacy organization or even as a policymaker, that's fine.
- 2:41But even if you are in a field like health care or, you know, say banking or maybe you work a a
- 2:50retail job or you're in manufacturing.
- 2:53It doesn't matter.
- 2:54We all have an educational story.
- 2:56Right?
- 2:56Because we all, in the process of sort of becoming, like, fully formed adults and which
- 3:03is not to say that we're all fully formed.
- 3:04I'm not sure when full formation happens, but, you know, education is a major part of that.
- 3:10So, you know, in my case, a big part of my story is that I was raised in New York.
- 3:18I was raised on Long Island.
- 3:20The schools that I was set to attend, my zone public schools were not safe schools.
- 3:25They were not schools that were academically gonna provide what, you know, my my mom at the
- 3:31time thought we needed.
- 3:33And so we started looking for other options.
- 3:36And and I say we, you know, I was three, four at the time.
- 3:40Right?
- 3:40So I didn't have a whole lot of say in it.
- 3:42But, you know, parents are really the first educators, and so they're looking out to see,
- 3:47hey.
- 3:47What is gonna be the education of best fit for my individual child?
- 3:53Because it can even differ within a family.
- 3:54You know, kids have different needs.
- 3:56I see that with my own kids.
- 3:57So, anyway, all to say, we found a school that worked, and I think that my folks just really
- 4:03drilled into me from the beginning that education was the the surest way to attain
- 4:09whatever your version of the American dream is, and I really bought into that.
- 4:14I you know, when I was in college, I really got invested in in education policy.
- 4:21I was a political science major, I think.
- 4:24You may have been a political science major also or
- 4:27or maybe you might
- 4:27have studied that.
- 4:28Yeah.
- 4:29And so, you know, I got really interested in education as sort of a matter of first
- 4:34principles.
- 4:35Really thinking about, like, hey.
- 4:37It's cool.
- 4:37Let's I wanna talk about our criminal justice system too.
- 4:42But by the way, if we don't fix education, I think criminal justice is actually a downstream
- 4:47often a downstream effect of a broken education system.
- 4:51And that's really kinda how I got engaged.
- 4:53And, yeah, I've been really fortunate to work in a a number of different organizations that
- 4:57advocate on behalf of high quality education for all kids.
- 5:02I mean, that's fantastic.
- 5:04Yeah.
- 5:04Just like you said, education policy, it just feeds into so many other aspects of society.
- 5:11So, I mean, obviously, it goes without saying that education policy is important, but
- 5:16sometimes even the people who think that, you know, school is boring or anything like that,
- 5:22it's just like but you you do enjoy learning about something.
- 5:25We all enjoy learning about something.
- 5:26It's a Yep.
- 5:27Critical part of of human development.
- 5:29So definitely agree with that.
- 5:32And so let's go more into this early development of education because I mentioned at
- 5:38the beginning of the interview that you are involved with the American Federation for
- 5:42Children.
- 5:43So how is the AFC and your work with them involved in education policy and how it relates
- 5:49to political engagement?
- 5:51Yeah.
- 5:52For sure.
- 5:52So at AFC, we like to say that we are the national voice for school choice.
- 5:57Another way to think about it is that in the k 12 education system, most of the adults,
- 6:03whether those are teachers, superintendents, even school boards, they actually have their
- 6:09own professional associations, and they have their own lobbyists.
- 6:13Right?
- 6:14But what about the most important group in the education system?
- 6:19I would say that's students.
- 6:21Right?
- 6:21Students and and parents don't have lobbyists who are going to a state capital and speaking
- 6:29on their behalf and sort of checking in with them constantly to see, hey.
- 6:33What what policies make sense for you?
- 6:35And so, you know, we've worked in dozens of states over the years to to pass laws that give
- 6:45options to families so that they can find the best educational fit for their children.
- 6:50And, you know, in the past five years, there's really been an explosion of these programs
- 6:54around the country.
- 6:56You know, I think since 2021, someone has said that it's been the year of school choice, and
- 7:03that just keeps happening.
- 7:05So I think we're now in a a four peat.
- 7:08I I don't know that that trend is gonna stop anytime soon.
- 7:12You just had a federal tax credit program that passed.
- 7:14And so, anyway, that's kind of how the American Federation for Children is engaged in passing
- 7:21laws and and constructing those.
- 7:23But another thing that we're doing is we're informing parents, cause that I think it's a
- 7:27major piece and that speaks to the sort of civic engagement and political engagement.
- 7:32People need to know how are the schools doing in my area.
- 7:36Right?
- 7:36Just really, let's be transparent with data.
- 7:39How do my elected officials think about schools and education and access to high high quality,
- 7:46you know, schools or even if it's, you know, homeschool or micro schools, whatever?
- 7:50And so we do a lot to inform parents of the programs that are in their cities and states,
- 7:57and then we also have allied organizations that inform voters about candidates' positions on
- 8:02educational choice.
- 8:03And I think that's a really important piece of political engagement.
- 8:07Gotcha.
- 8:07So it's mostly just focused on school choice, your your work then?
- 8:13Well, at AFC, yeah, we are we are a single issue, which I will say I appreciate in that
- 8:19we're a nonpartisan organization.
- 8:21Right?
- 8:22We're focused on on school choice.
- 8:26It's it's what we care about because that is the issue that, you know, we're sort of charged
- 8:30with, you know, making sure the kids have access to whatever education kind of best meets
- 8:35their needs.
- 8:36Now what we have learned, and I think you and I will talk about a little more, is we've learned
- 8:41that there are some other, like, ancillary effects of both choice, but also just high
- 8:46quality engagement.
- 8:47And I'll I'll tell you a little bit later about some stuff, some work that we've seen on civic
- 8:52engagement and how the two things kinda correlate.
- 8:56Gotcha.
- 8:56And I I'm I'm looking forward to it.
- 8:59Well, let's let's expand a little bit more on the work because obviously, it's not just AFC
- 9:04that you work for.
- 9:05I mentioned also that you are a professor at Belmont University and also a lawyer with your
- 9:11own practice.
- 9:12So how how do you use your work in those fields to facilitate this education policy and
- 9:18political engagement?
- 9:20Yeah.
- 9:21That's a really good question.
- 9:22I think that whether I'm facilitating meetings or teaching, I think it's really important that
- 9:30group members or class members, whomever they are, that they appreciate perspectives that are
- 9:36outside their own.
- 9:37And, you know, by no means am I, like, some postmodernist or kind of relativist.
- 9:45I don't think that that every idea carries the same amount of value or truth.
- 9:52Right?
- 9:53I I don't believe that.
- 9:55That being said, increasingly, people are stuck inside their own echo chambers.
- 10:00Mhmm.
- 10:01And and that can be really problematic.
- 10:03There's a an author, a sort of thinker, Renee Deresta, who's got a great phrase for this.
- 10:10She calls it bespoke realities.
- 10:13And this idea that given the way that we're targeted, you know, say online and by these
- 10:18kind of now AI algorithms, it's possible for two people within the same organization, even
- 10:25within the same family, to have totally different news feeds.
- 10:29Mhmm.
- 10:29Right?
- 10:30And a totally different impression of what's happening in their city, state, country, or
- 10:36even globally.
- 10:38I would say that that's not healthy.
- 10:40Right?
- 10:41It it's not that we want some kind of monoculture.
- 10:45It's that we want to have the ability to hold multiple ideas in our brain simultaneously and
- 10:52then have the skills to evaluate the veracity of those ideas.
- 10:57And so I think that's something that I'm that I'm always trying to bring to conversations is
- 11:02to sort of say, hey.
- 11:03Let's not let's not sign on so quickly.
- 11:05Let's let's really, you know, stress test an idea.
- 11:10Even the ones that I advocate for, fine.
- 11:12Like, pressure test them.
- 11:14Let's talk them out because we wanna make sure that we're coming up with a a a product or a
- 11:19policy that works really well and that's thoughtful.
- 11:23And the the only way I think we're gonna do that is to be in dialogue with one another.
- 11:29So, you know, I think we don't want a society that is so insular that it becomes, like, you
- 11:36know, provincial.
- 11:37We want to have exposure to different ideas, and I'm someone who thinks that exposure
- 11:46doesn't mean indoctrination.
- 11:48Right?
- 11:48I think it's that's kind of the balance that we're that we're looking for.
- 11:52Yeah.
- 11:52And I think there there is just that whole yeah.
- 11:56You you can point to some parts and say, arguably, okay.
- 11:59Yeah.
- 12:00They're just trying to force feed their opinion in in down your throat.
- 12:04But at the same time, I think a lot of people use that as an excuse to say, oh, this is
- 12:08indoctrination, so don't listen to it and just listen to what we to say.
- 12:12And, I I think education policy I mean, obviously, there's a lot of things that can
- 12:17improve on it.
- 12:18There's always room for improvement, but I think in particular, education policy really
- 12:22needs to and this is not just for politics, for anything really, is just really tell people how
- 12:28to be better about how to evaluate all the information that that comes through.
- 12:35Because like you said, not every bit of information is equally good.
- 12:39Some of it is just bad, but how do you determine what's what's bad?
- 12:42And how much of it is subjective and objective?
- 12:44And I think that's something in particular that really needs to be improved on when it comes to
- 12:53education policy.
- 12:53Actually, this just made me think of since since you are a professor, have you whether
- 12:59it's your students in particular or students that you've seen at Belmont University, have
- 13:03you seen that be a particular issue with any of your students?
- 13:08Especially when it comes to constitutional law, I think a lot of people have a specific idea of
- 13:13Yeah.
- 13:13What the constitution means.
- 13:14Is it original intent?
- 13:16It does it also change with the times to some extent?
- 13:19What do you think about that?
- 13:21Yeah.
- 13:21I've I've been really pleasantly surprised, I would say.
- 13:25So just this past spring, I was in a in a class.
- 13:30It's this was and I was just doing kind of a a guest lecture at Belmont University here in
- 13:35Nashville, is my alma mater, so shout out to Belmont.
- 13:38But I was there doing a guest lecture.
- 13:40It was a a media and politics class.
- 13:45And we were talking a little bit.
- 13:47I was speaking with the class about just different ways that I try to communicate with
- 13:53audiences in my own work.
- 13:55And and we were just, you know, sort of talking about something like First Amendment and free
- 13:59speech issues.
- 14:00And I was really pleasantly surprised by how engaged the students were.
- 14:06They had a desire to not be manipulated.
- 14:10Right?
- 14:11I think we're sort of maybe maybe five, six, seven years ago, this wouldn't have been the
- 14:15case, but I think that right now, students are aware that, hey.
- 14:20You can't trust everything you see online.
- 14:22We're we're past that.
- 14:23Right?
- 14:23And so I that's a a much healthier place to be than maybe where we were, you know, again,
- 14:29seven years ago or something.
- 14:30I don't know.
- 14:31Seven's the exact right number, but where people sort of said, well, I saw it online, so
- 14:35it must be true.
- 14:36Okay.
- 14:37So so I I actually think that students are developing some more savvy about this.
- 14:43They know that, like, hey.
- 14:45Let's take a beat before we just repeat everything that we heard online because there's
- 14:52some there's some wild stuff out there.
- 14:53Yeah.
- 14:54And and, again, this is where I think education is really important because you need to be
- 14:59educated so that you can evaluate these claims so that you can ask not just the first
- 15:04question, but the second and third and follow-up questions to get to the heart of the
- 15:09matter.
- 15:10Oh, that's that's great to hear.
- 15:11And, yeah, I mean, it can happen to all of us.
- 15:13Every once in a while, we all have knee jerk reactions to things, but I I that is great to
- 15:18hear that younger people are becoming a little bit more, you know, a healthy skepticism.
- 15:22Don't wanna get to the point where you're absolutely cynical, which admittedly sometimes
- 15:27I step over the line and get a little too cynical and so skeptical.
- 15:31But at the same time, unfortunately, there's just there's just so much nonsense out there
- 15:37that you really gotta be careful.
- 15:40And I I know, like, when I was when I was younger, when I was doing my my bachelor's
- 15:45degree and, yeah, just before I started doing my my master's was actually, I was just talking
- 15:54about this with my guest last week briefly.
- 15:57It was just this whole especially on Facebook and Twitter, these neatly packaged videos that
- 16:02have a clear slant one way or another, and people just share them without a single thought
- 16:07because, oh, well, this I agree with this, so it's it must be true.
- 16:10But that that's that's great to hear that you personally have encountered a lot less of that.
- 16:16So more on those biggest issues that we have with education policy.
- 16:22So a little bit more of it.
- 16:23Maybe you're you're you pointed out something that you is really positive to say, but let's
- 16:26talk about areas that we can improve.
- 16:29So what do you think are, let's say, two to three of the biggest issues with education
- 16:35policy in our nation's schools as it pertains to political engagement or lack thereof?
- 16:40And what are a couple of ways that you think that we can fix them?
- 16:43Mhmm.
- 16:43Mhmm.
- 16:44Yeah.
- 16:45When I think about lack of engagement when it comes to schools, I think a lot of it is well,
- 16:53I I think there's, unfortunately, this, like, symbiotic relationship where in many places, do
- 17:00have lack of engagement in and I'm gonna say in the in the public school system.
- 17:04But I would suggest that much of that comes because the system hasn't been responsive to
- 17:12parents when they do engage.
- 17:14So you kind of get this what I think is a a pretty natural response.
- 17:19Right?
- 17:20If I'm a parent and I bring my complaints to to a school and the school sort of, you know,
- 17:28documents it, and as soon as I walk out, it seems like it just crumples it up and throws it
- 17:31in the waste paper basket.
- 17:33Well, I'm not gonna come back a second time.
- 17:36Right?
- 17:36The problem is in many places, if if families don't have an option, well, they have to
- 17:42continue to send their child back to that school, but they don't but it's not being
- 17:46responsive.
- 17:47So, you know, I think that there that's kind of a a big issue.
- 17:52Right?
- 17:52And so this lack of responsiveness to parent need, customer need, you wanna put it in those
- 18:03kind of economic terms, that's a a major issue.
- 18:06You know, another thing I'll say is I think that there there can be a bit of apathy on the
- 18:15part of not just not just parents, but even community members and taxpayers when it comes
- 18:21to schools because you hear all the time, oh, schools are underfunded.
- 18:27But I would say you hear a lot of that, and and then when you poll people and say, hey.
- 18:31How much do you think your your neighborhood public school gets per pupil?
- 18:36And people routinely say, I don't know, $34,000 per pupil, and they are off by 500%.
- 18:43Oh, wow.
- 18:44I mean, a you know, schools in my city I'm in Nashville.
- 18:52If you now count capital costs, so facilities costs, you're up around $22,000 per pupil per
- 19:00year.
- 19:02Right?
- 19:02So each student.
- 19:03If you take capital costs out, you're still around $15,000 per pupil per year.
- 19:09I don't think people realize that.
- 19:10Right?
- 19:10If you said to a parent, hey.
- 19:13Students attending that high school every student attending that high school basically
- 19:17carries with them $15,000 at the beginning of the school year.
- 19:21And by the way, the average ACT score at that school is a is a 14, I think people would like,
- 19:30you'd see hair on fire.
- 19:33Yeah.
- 19:33But I think we're not really transparent about that, and so people can't really evaluate,
- 19:40like, the the ROI.
- 19:42And so I think that's a that's a a major issue.
- 19:44So I think that lack of transparency can lead to sort of apathy, and then you then you're
- 19:49just in this downward spiral.
- 19:51So, actually, we we tend to spend more money year over year in public schools, and the
- 19:57results stay basically flat.
- 20:01We wouldn't really tolerate that in other sectors.
- 20:04Right?
- 20:04So that's a, yeah, major issue there.
- 20:07Right.
- 20:07And, I mean, it's I mean, partly because, you know, when you're talking about college, you
- 20:12you you have a much clearer number of dollars that you can point to to say, okay.
- 20:19This is what it's costing.
- 20:20It's not so easy to get it with public schools.
- 20:22And and one thing I try to really emphasize with my work is more on this transparency is
- 20:28when it comes to state and especially local government, which you're talking about schools,
- 20:33a lot of it is local government related.
- 20:37It's really difficult to find information.
- 20:40Even for you and I who are invested in this kind of stuff, we're involved in politics.
- 20:46It's hard for us to find this stuff.
- 20:48If it's hard for us to find it, how can we expect regular people who have all sorts of
- 20:53other things to to worry about as well?
- 20:55Their their work is not in politics.
- 20:57How can we expect them to be able to find this stuff easily?
- 21:00So I I I definitely agree with that point.
- 21:04And I also wanna get your take on, excuse me, on something my guest last week, Alex Vassar,
- 21:11he's with the California State Library.
- 21:13He told me that's really stuck with me, and I wanna see if if if you see it the same way or
- 21:19or basically what your opinion on it.
- 21:21But, basically, he said there has been a shift over time from teaching civics to teaching
- 21:26governments.
- 21:27And the primary difference being civics focuses on how the political process involves you, the
- 21:33citizen, but government focuses on them, the government itself.
- 21:37And so teaching the latter can sometimes be just kind of rote and just facts based with
- 21:42less direct application to the public, and it's contributed to this political disconnect for a
- 21:47lot of people.
- 21:48So what is your take on that?
- 21:50Do you agree?
- 21:50Do you think that that is a major contributor to the political disengagement we see today?
- 21:55Yeah.
- 21:56It's an interesting way to frame it, the difference between, yeah, teaching civics and
- 22:03teaching government.
- 22:04You know, let me give the big disclaimer here that I am not an expert on on curriculum.
- 22:10I I will say, though, that in the past fifteen years, you've seen people at the k 12 level and
- 22:18in higher education start to start to have a a take a very different approach to free speech
- 22:27in the academic context than than they did, you know, in the prior, I don't know, 300.
- 22:35Right?
- 22:35And so you see things getting you see people talking about speech in more weaponized terms.
- 22:47And listen.
- 22:48There is certainly a category of dangerous speech.
- 22:51Right?
- 22:52Whether it's threats, etcetera.
- 22:53I mean, it's something that that that every lawyer has has had to study.
- 22:59But the rye I'm think what I'm thinking about are things like the rise of safe spaces on
- 23:05campuses.
- 23:06And, you know, the idea that you've gotta give a a trigger warning to a class of high school
- 23:12or college students before discussing facts about the civil war.
- 23:16Like, I would say that that's not constructive to students.
- 23:19Right?
- 23:20Students can wrestle with tough topics that are presented appropriately, you know, in an age
- 23:26appropriate way, explained in a way that's thoughtful, but but in a way that's not sort of
- 23:33attempting to indoctrinate them.
- 23:35So I so I think that regardless of whether or we're talking about civics or we're talking
- 23:39about government, I think that there's been to me, that's been the undercurrent that has
- 23:44really changed the dynamics is because you've had this rise of folks saying, well, if I hear
- 23:52something that I disagree with or don't understand, then that's doing harm.
- 23:58And I and that's a very different way of thinking about lessons than we used to.
- 24:04Again, there is a there is a category of of, like, actual dangerous speech that I think we
- 24:11need to be be wary of.
- 24:13But, yeah, it's a it's an interesting frame that that Alex kinda presented, and, yeah, I'd
- 24:19like to think more about that.
- 24:20But there has definitely been a shift in in the past fifteen years for sure.
- 24:25Yeah.
- 24:25Yeah.
- 24:25There the and we we can talk a more about, like, that's what is the proper balance between
- 24:33yeah.
- 24:33We want to to some extent, yeah, you wanna protect people, but at the same time, we can't
- 24:38you can't coddle them, but at the same time, you need to yeah.
- 24:43Well, can't really think of exactly how I'm trying to word this, but, yeah, what is the
- 24:47proper approach?
- 24:48But at the same time, yeah, we can't just coddle kids and because then we're also
- 24:52treating them like they can't learn about this stuff and think critically about it.
- 24:56So I I can I could definitely agree with that point?
- 25:00So
- 25:00I mean, I think we wanna be respectful.
- 25:02Right?
- 25:02And we wanna and you wanna have classroom dialogue that's respectful.
- 25:05I mean, I wouldn't I wouldn't tolerate that in a class if people were you know, if students
- 25:09were being disrespectful towards one another.
- 25:12Right?
- 25:12So that civil discourse is super important.
- 25:15Yeah.
- 25:16But just because we disagree I mean, man, if if you wanna you wanna disagree with people, it's
- 25:24not that hard.
- 25:25Walk into a political science class or walk into a philosophy class or walk into a religion
- 25:28class.
- 25:29Right?
- 25:31And and oftentimes, the people who disagree the the most heatedly are the ones who are actually
- 25:38pretty close in opinion.
- 25:40Right?
- 25:40It's on some really small kind of niche, nuanced, you know, use of language or
- 25:47something.
- 25:47Yeah.
- 25:47Anyway, we there's gotta be a a way that we can do those things.
- 25:52You know, I will say there's a stunning lack of understanding of how the government works.
- 26:01So I don't know how this plays into what Alex is talking about, but, you know, I saw just the
- 26:06other day that a a gentleman running for congress where I live in Tennessee was getting
- 26:14he he took to he took to x, you know, formerly Twitter, to say that he thought it was unfair
- 26:21that one of his opponents could run for the office, and she doesn't live within the
- 26:26district.
- 26:28Well, he can think and and he sort of presented it as if it was this big conspiracy.
- 26:35Well, that has been settled law that you can do that for decades.
- 26:41It's not I mean, now I'm not saying it's the, it's best practice.
- 26:47It seems to me that, yeah, you should wanna be represented by someone who, lives pretty pretty
- 26:52close.
- 26:54But, like, them's the rules.
- 26:56You know?
- 26:57And he was sort of presenting it what it said to me was, oh, you actually don't understand
- 27:01how this system works, yet you wanna, you know, represent a big part of this district.
- 27:08Yeah.
- 27:08So they could we could use a lot more understanding even on the part of elected
- 27:13leaders.
- 27:15Yeah.
- 27:15And I I I do it does seem very often that the people who are loudest about these kinds of
- 27:21things are the ones who tend to think they understand more than they actually do.
- 27:25And and, yeah, to some extent, we all think can realize, oh, this thing I didn't understand
- 27:30about government.
- 27:31Oh, it's actually this way.
- 27:32But but, yeah, first, there are a lot of people that just have this whole, this is exactly how
- 27:36government works.
- 27:37I figured it out.
- 27:38I'm right.
- 27:39Not gonna listen to anybody else.
- 27:41And this this whole like, what you talked about earlier with this disagreement is basically
- 27:46disrespect.
- 27:47It's there's this whole politics has become I I I don't expect people's political views to not
- 27:53be a big part of who they are.
- 27:55I I I get that.
- 27:56But when it's just like the thing that people lead with and when you have a disagreement that
- 28:02is you consider that an existential threat to your exist to your existence.
- 28:09Yeah.
- 28:09That's that's just that's a serious grievance of mine that hopefully I'm trying to make that
- 28:17just a little bit better, that whole bit of dialogue in that respect.
- 28:21But is there a state or local area, any any area in particular that you think handles
- 28:28education policy well in regards to enhancing political engagement?
- 28:33Yeah.
- 28:33I don't know that I would say that there's an entire state because, you know, so much, I
- 28:38would say, the on this front, the political engagement front, really happens at the local
- 28:42level.
- 28:45That being said, I'll I'll I'd turn to two things.
- 28:48I mean, we've got there's some folks at an organization called the Daniels Fund, and the
- 28:55Daniels Fund started the National Civics Bee.
- 29:01Right?
- 29:01So like a spelling bee, but it's a civics bee.
- 29:03And and that has now moved to I mean, I think a majority of states now have one, which is
- 29:08pretty cool.
- 29:09And so so getting peep you know, getting kids, you I think these are middle school kids,
- 29:16right, engaged in their understanding of civics.
- 29:19And I think that's a that's a pretty cool movement that's taken shape in in just the past
- 29:25few years.
- 29:27The another thing that I would point to is there's a researcher out of University of
- 29:31Arkansas.
- 29:31His name is Patrick Wolf.
- 29:33And Patrick has done some really interesting work on the civic effects of school choice
- 29:42programs.
- 29:43And, you know, I I work in school choice, and so this is kind of in in my space.
- 29:48But he found some pretty interesting things.
- 29:51So for instance, he thinks that there's a relationship between when when parents actually
- 29:58have the agency to choose their own school.
- 30:02Right?
- 30:02Another way to say that is when parents have the ability to deselect a school, right, to
- 30:09say, hey.
- 30:10That that one, school a, does not work for my child, but school b does, that that actually
- 30:16leads to some other civic engage higher levels of civic engagement.
- 30:21Right?
- 30:21It kinda makes sense.
- 30:22So that same dynamic that we were discussing earlier where we said, hey.
- 30:25If you went to your school and they didn't listen to anything you said, well, what would
- 30:29you do?
- 30:29You'd probably just check out.
- 30:30You wouldn't go back.
- 30:31You wouldn't keep going back to the well.
- 30:32Right?
- 30:33Because nobody's listening.
- 30:34Well, if you're if the dynamic kinda flips and you go, oh, actually, when I I wanted to make
- 30:41this change, I was able to make this change and find a school that works better for me.
- 30:45It actually Patrick shows that it leads to higher levels of civic engagement.
- 30:51And so that's a that's a pretty cool, I think, like, secondary effect of some of these choice
- 30:58programs.
- 31:00Gotcha.
- 31:01I I I like the where'd you say that civics bee started?
- 31:05The well, it started from a group called the Daniels Fund, which is based in Colorado.
- 31:11Colorado.
- 31:12Civics be now is you know, they're doing it in a a majority of the states.
- 31:16It might have spread to nearly all 50 states.
- 31:18Oh, wow.
- 31:19I really like that idea.
- 31:20Man, that that never even occurred to me.
- 31:22That's I mean, see, all all sorts of things that people come up with that I would have
- 31:27never thought of maybe ever or at least not further down the line.
- 31:31That's that's really cool.
- 31:32I like that idea.
- 31:33I'll have to look more into that.
- 31:34Yeah.
- 31:35It's cool.
- 31:35Myself.
- 31:36Yeah.
- 31:36Okay.
- 31:37Yeah.
- 31:37Thank you.
- 31:37Thank you for for for bringing that up.
- 31:41But let's talk a bit more about that.
- 31:44We talk especially with the, earlier on with the first few questions, more about the
- 31:51involvement of parents.
- 31:52And one of the things that is, you know, I I talked about with my podcast episode on
- 31:57political apathy was another major contributor to it is the lack of being surrounded by other
- 32:02civically minded individuals such as people's own parents.
- 32:06So how do you think parents can get more involved?
- 32:10And I know you talked a little bit about it, but maybe a little bit more about how parents
- 32:14can get more involved in their students' education to better enhance those students'
- 32:19political engagement down the line.
- 32:22Yeah.
- 32:22The this, I think, is a is a tricky one, and I say this, you know, as a parent.
- 32:28This one's tricky because in general, kids don't wanna hear about political engagement
- 32:33from their parents.
- 32:35Right?
- 32:35I mean, I think that's just that's not a new phenomenon.
- 32:38Yeah.
- 32:40You know, I didn't want to hear from my parents, and, you know, that's just my my guess
- 32:46is that at a at a certain age, when kids are coming into their own sort of political
- 32:49consciousness, they are less inclined to listen to their parents.
- 32:53So it is what it is.
- 32:55So I might point to to two ways that parents could increase that you know, increase their
- 33:04child's affinity maybe for political engagement.
- 33:06And the first would be just to model it.
- 33:08Right?
- 33:09And I would say to model things at the at the local level.
- 33:16Right now, nearly every issue is nationalized.
- 33:22So when you look at at at politics, I mean, in you there might be a a local school board race
- 33:31or a local city council race, and and people are talking about climate change issues and
- 33:38immigration.
- 33:39And listen.
- 33:41Those are important issues, but I assure you that no one on the school board or the city
- 33:49council has any ability to do anything about them.
- 33:53Right?
- 33:54So, like, why are we talking about them?
- 33:55So I think that too many things are just nationalized, and I would say, like, let's
- 33:59model engagement at the local level.
- 34:02Let's like, do you actually know your neighbors?
- 34:05Let's try to meet them.
- 34:07What are some things that we can do?
- 34:08I mean, this is some of the stuff that Robert Putnam has talked about, kind of the the
- 34:13dissolution of these of social cohesion, but more at the local level, not just the state and
- 34:20national level.
- 34:21So that's one thing, to model engagement that way, get involved.
- 34:24I mean, we got a really fun thing that we've got a a this, like, neighborhood kind of
- 34:28festival that happens in my neighborhood that's happening this this coming weekend.
- 34:33It's called the tomato festival, and, you know, everybody goes out.
- 34:37And one of there's a a little parade, and people dress up in red and green.
- 34:41And it's like a day and a half, and it's fun, and it's just you know?
- 34:46It it's a it's a great thing.
- 34:47It feels a little bit more like kind of Americana.
- 34:50You know?
- 34:51Yeah.
- 34:51The second thing I'd say is I really do think, like, parents, even if they didn't love it
- 34:56themselves, ought to encourage their children to learn about and read read about and study
- 35:05history, if for nothing else, because it's a way to help your children avoid being taken
- 35:14advantage of.
- 35:16Right?
- 35:16Meaning, if you haven't studied anything, like, how are again, how are you gonna weigh the
- 35:22veracity of claims that people are making to you?
- 35:26Some of these claims that are just overblown or these promises that, you know, about how
- 35:31economies work.
- 35:32And you go, actually, that doesn't make any sense.
- 35:35Right?
- 35:36But what are you gonna weigh that against?
- 35:37You can't just do it based on vibes.
- 35:40So I would say, like, model engagement and encourage them to, you know, study a little
- 35:47bit.
- 35:47Yeah.
- 35:48Yeah.
- 35:48And that that's something that's easy for somebody like me to take for granted.
- 35:53My my parents are pretty politically engaged, and I took an interest early on.
- 35:59I I really realized that that was where my interest was was in high school.
- 36:04I didn't quite know exactly what I wanted to do with it at that point, and, obviously, I had
- 36:08different view some of my views are different now than what I had then and just my general
- 36:14approach to politics.
- 36:15But it's it's very easy to like, especially when I was younger, I I wondered just mentioned
- 36:22this on LinkedIn the other day.
- 36:23It was this whole, if you don't vote, you don't get to complain.
- 36:27I I used to believe in that, and it's not I mean, in short, that's that's really not
- 36:33helpful.
- 36:34There's a whole lot of other mitigating factors.
- 36:36And if you and also if you if you beat people over the head with that idea, then it I mean,
- 36:42that's just that's not gonna make them wanna get more involved.
- 36:46Yeah.
- 36:46I agree with
- 36:46that.
- 36:47Yeah.
- 36:47So I I definitely think that that's like you said, that's the having to model engagement why
- 36:53they should get more involved.
- 36:54And even just like you said with the with the just going out and meeting your community.
- 37:00It doesn't even have to be anything directly political, but just having that cohesion and
- 37:07and mingling with other people in your community really gets you to, you know what?
- 37:11I really care about this community.
- 37:13I really need to think more about the community issues.
- 37:16So appreciate you bringing that up.
- 37:19But let's move to beyond school because I think Yep.
- 37:24A little bit more on these adults getting more engaged because I think we don't really focus
- 37:30enough on adults slash continuing education.
- 37:33We have all these debates about how to teach our children and everything, but what about
- 37:39people who are out of the formal schooling system?
- 37:41So AFC, of course, looks at children's education policy specifically.
- 37:46But how involved are you in the continuing education front, and in what ways could we
- 37:53improve adults' political engagement with changes to how we deal with continuing
- 37:59education policy?
- 38:01Yeah.
- 38:02Yeah.
- 38:03So we don't we don't at AFC, don't do a ton in the higher ed space, but I will mention one
- 38:10thing that I think is is important.
- 38:12And we've seen recently you've probably heard of and some of your listeners have probably
- 38:16heard of education savings accounts, and these are these sort of new educational choice
- 38:23vehicles, right, where a family gets the usually, it's the state per pupil amount, and
- 38:31they can spend it on a range of educational issues.
- 38:35So in in Florida, for instance, I think over 400,000 kids now use ESAs, and there are
- 38:44something like 19 programs across the country.
- 38:48So these are people are are using these with increasing frequency.
- 38:53One of the things they're using them for is for career and technical education.
- 38:57So a lot of students are using these using ESAs and ESA dollars to pursue certificates, right,
- 39:07to do things that maybe aren't necessarily an AP course, right, but but maybe something that
- 39:13allows them to go into the trades or or I say the trades, but maybe allows them to get, like,
- 39:19some kind of programming certificate.
- 39:21Right?
- 39:22Because they're gonna they wanna do that.
- 39:23So that's been a pretty interesting use and I think is is apt to show some real return on
- 39:30investment.
- 39:31I would say there's been a whole lot of movement in this space.
- 39:35There's some work that's come out from a group called the Burning Glass Institute.
- 39:40They put out some great work on the the the power of these certificates.
- 39:46But in some cases, it's the hype surrounding certificates too.
- 39:50So I wanna sort of call that out too because there you can get a certificate to do lots of
- 39:54different things.
- 39:55Mhmm.
- 39:56Burning Glass looked at them and said, alright.
- 39:58Out of this whole wide world of certificates, there's actually only a a relatively small
- 40:03percentage that seem to have much economic impact on, you know, your future job prospects.
- 40:11So I think that that it's a it's a shifting place.
- 40:14It's a changing place.
- 40:15I do know that a lot of a lot of career or what you might call, like, community colleges or
- 40:24places where you can get an associate's, a lot of them have a really low, you know, graduation
- 40:29rate, sort of matriculation rate.
- 40:31So I think that's that's something that states need to work on.
- 40:36I also think that those are it seems to me those are prime opportunities, if we're not
- 40:41doing them already, to do things like have voter registration drives.
- 40:45You've got a captive audience.
- 40:46Like, why in the world are we not signing every one of those students up to have a a a you
- 40:54know, to vote?
- 40:55Right?
- 40:55Why aren't we informing them of their when these kind of off timed elections are
- 41:03happening?
- 41:04So, like, you know, in in my city, we do school board elections in
- 41:09Odd years.
- 41:10August, in odd years.
- 41:11Mhmm.
- 41:11Yeah.
- 41:12I mean, it's just at these really goofy times.
- 41:14Well, if you've got a captive audience, somebody needs to tell them about that.
- 41:18So, you know, I I'm not an expert in that space, but I do think there's some things that
- 41:23we could do to to increase engagement among that audience.
- 41:27I really like those points because like I said, I think there is just that whole continuing
- 41:32education front.
- 41:33I think that kind of gets neglected, especially if, you know, even if you had civics work out
- 41:39or if civics was taught well in schools, well, what about the people who are already out of
- 41:44school who didn't have that
- 41:45Yeah.
- 41:45Civics education?
- 41:46So how do we Yeah.
- 41:50Build that up?
- 41:52But a lot of citizens feel that part of this whole disengagement is because, like you said
- 41:59several times already, a lot of citizens just feel that the government is not there to work
- 42:03for the public.
- 42:04They're just for the benefit of the government officials and for special interests.
- 42:09So how do you think that impacts education policy and people's willingness to want to
- 42:16learn about how the government works or more more specific ways that you've seen that impact
- 42:22their willingness to learn?
- 42:25Yeah.
- 42:25Yeah.
- 42:26I mean, listen.
- 42:28I think when people are frustrated with with government systems, I think when they are
- 42:37cynical about government's responsiveness, they will probably find a sympathetic ear for me.
- 42:46I tend to also be cynical about the responsiveness Yeah.
- 42:51Of of government.
- 42:53You know, I I think in my world, this is definitely something we see in the public
- 43:00education system.
- 43:01I mean, again, I I don't wanna believe her, but we've talked a lot about that already.
- 43:05I mean, folks but I I'll give I'll give one additional example, and that is people hear
- 43:16about this phrase, like, special interest all the time.
- 43:19Special interest, and and it's amazing that something that that euphemism has such a
- 43:25negative connotation.
- 43:27Okay.
- 43:28Special interest.
- 43:29Special interest could mean that you just want sprinkles on your ice cream.
- 43:32Right?
- 43:32That's a special interest.
- 43:33But, you know, but unlike a real what we really know special interest means, there's not a
- 43:39there's no lobbying group for sprinkles on ice cream that I'm aware of.
- 43:43Right?
- 43:45You know?
- 43:45So take what I think is one of the most challenging jobs and also a a profession that
- 43:52is is really kind of beleaguered, and that's teaching.
- 43:55Teachers, you often hear teachers don't make enough money.
- 44:00They've got a a really challenging situation, especially in in kind of the years immediately
- 44:07coming out of COVID.
- 44:08I mean, classrooms were just a mess.
- 44:10Classroom behavior was just, you know, super challenging environment.
- 44:16Lots of teachers left the profession.
- 44:18So you hear, oh, teachers are are teachers don't seem like they are at the have the
- 44:29respected status and stature that maybe they ought to.
- 44:32Okay.
- 44:34I can generally agree with that.
- 44:39Why then do the teachers' unions who ostensibly represent them bring in hundreds of millions of
- 44:48dollars every year in revenue?
- 44:51Like, where's that what are they doing?
- 44:54What is their advocacy doing?
- 44:55And I think many teachers end up finding out that, oh, what their unions are actually
- 45:01advocating for is whether or not and this is a real example.
- 45:06Whether or not the a a teacher's union position, this is on Oakland, I believe, was
- 45:13that The US should rejoin the Paris Climate Accords.
- 45:18Okay.
- 45:19Well, if you're a third grade teacher in Oakland, I mean, maybe you're you get really
- 45:24fired up about the Paris Climate Accords, but I bet you're more fired up about either your
- 45:30compensation or whether or not you've got the supplies you need in your classroom.
- 45:35Right?
- 45:36Anyway, it's just an example, unfortunately, of those groups kind of being out of step with the
- 45:41people that they're supposed to represent.
- 45:43And I think so when I think about public being frustrated with special interests and and sort
- 45:51of disengaging, I think that's a lot of it.
- 45:54Because for too long, there's there have been organizations that make a really pretty penny
- 46:02by by gathering dues, but they don't really represent the people that they that they claim
- 46:07to.
- 46:07And so I I get it.
- 46:09So when people are are kind of frustrated, disenfranchised, I get it.
- 46:14But I also think that's why you've seen, you know, again, in that example, over the years, I
- 46:20mean, the the inclusion or membership in unions across the across industries is really
- 46:27declining because I think people are sort of saying, like, I don't know if I need a a
- 46:31teacher's union.
- 46:32I can just, like, share my thoughts on Reddit and and get it and get my voice out there.
- 46:38Right?
- 46:38And so I think people are finding new ways of organizing.
- 46:42I think that's only gonna continue in the in the coming years.
- 46:47Yeah.
- 46:47The point you made about special interest, I was just I was just saying this to a couple of
- 46:52younger guys I had on the podcast few weeks ago that they they got involved in the Florida
- 46:58legislative process and and on several bills.
- 47:00And it was just sort of a joke, but also really there is some truth to it is when you talk
- 47:06about special interests is lobbyists are bad.
- 47:09Advocates are good.
- 47:11They're both this they're both basically the same thing, but the lobbyist just has that
- 47:14negative connotation.
- 47:15But you're like, no.
- 47:16No.
- 47:16No.
- 47:16I'm advocating for something.
- 47:19So even though it's really not a big difference, but, yeah, it just it just kinda
- 47:23made me think about that.
- 47:25So getting more away from the so we talked about some of the reasons how you've seen
- 47:34citizens disengage from the process and try to make this not such a general question because
- 47:40this is such an open ended there's, like, a million ways that you could probably answer
- 47:44this.
- 47:44But what are some ways that it will take to reconnect citizens with the political process
- 47:51in your estimation?
- 47:54Yeah.
- 47:55To reconnect.
- 47:58Well, you know, I think we spoke a little bit about that local kinda localizing things.
- 48:04I really do think that that that that matters.
- 48:09You know, I'll say I get much more enthusiastic about local my local elections where I live
- 48:17than I do national ones.
- 48:19Right?
- 48:19Because, you know, a national national candidates are talking to people maybe around
- 48:25the whole state, maybe around the whole country.
- 48:29You know?
- 48:30And what I'm dealing with is, like, I mean, real real talk.
- 48:37I'm like, can we get our trash and recycling picked up when it's supposed to get picked up?
- 48:41Right?
- 48:42Can we can we have our, I don't know, like, our infrastructure maintained in a way that's safe?
- 48:52Because I'm about to have a a teenage driver in my house, and, you know, I'd like for the
- 48:57bridges to function and work.
- 48:59Right?
- 48:59So, like, many of those things are the like, that's the stuff of daily life.
- 49:05And I would sort of suggest, like, man, let's let's let's go bottom up, right, instead of
- 49:12instead of getting so frustrated and so hot about whatever the the newest national thing
- 49:17is.
- 49:18Not to say those things aren't important.
- 49:20A lot of a lot is happening internationally that that is important.
- 49:24Yes.
- 49:24But I just don't think that we have the capacity to be thinking about 45 national
- 49:32issues simultaneously.
- 49:34Like so I, yeah, I really do think that localizing things is is helpful.
- 49:41I recently talked to a friend.
- 49:44She she used to be a teacher at a school that I was a part of, and and she I don't know how she
- 49:51got on this thing.
- 49:52Probably, she sent an email, and they responded back.
- 49:54And next thing you know, she's on it.
- 49:56But she is on this, like, advisory board on, like, transit and traffic calming.
- 50:04Okay.
- 50:05Cool.
- 50:06Now I I will tell you, she has no desire to be like the traffic czar of East Nashville.
- 50:13Yeah.
- 50:13You know, she she writes.
- 50:15She's doing her own thing.
- 50:19But this is a a way for her to be engaged with some other members of the community that are
- 50:27not, you know, necessarily like her.
- 50:29They live in different parts of the city.
- 50:31They have different interests, but they get they're they come together and say, hey.
- 50:35Here's what we see is working where we live.
- 50:37Here's where where we have all these, you know, sidewalks that don't connect and lead to
- 50:43nowhere.
- 50:44And here's where, you know, we see that that kids are getting injured because they can't
- 50:48ride their bikes to school or whatever.
- 50:49Right?
- 50:49And so that's a I think that's a great, like, local I don't know if it's advocacy, but it's a
- 50:57sort of a local way to engage in in the political process, and I don't think there's
- 51:01any shame to doing that instead of, you know, attending a march on some international issue
- 51:10that you probably aren't gonna change a whole lot.
- 51:13So, yeah, I I really encourage folks to to localize a little bit, and I think it it's
- 51:18probably have to be much more fruitful too.
- 51:21One of my big issues that I say mean, and I have I have lots of complaints, but Yeah.
- 51:29One of the big things is this whole nationalization of everything.
- 51:34And it it almost gets to a either they the local stuff just gets thrown by the wayside or
- 51:41people think that national level, state level people can fix local issues that they really
- 51:46have no power over.
- 51:48Right.
- 51:48Or it's just there's just like a once sometimes people think there's a one size fits all.
- 51:54What worked here is absolutely gonna work here if we do it one to one.
- 51:58I mean, maybe it will, but Right.
- 52:00You gotta take into account all the local details to everything to to really see, oh, is
- 52:08this other thing going to work down here?
- 52:12And yeah.
- 52:13So I I I definitely like that whole localizing of things, but it it is that is one of those
- 52:19unfortunate things I've I that I think we've seen is the whole everything's just becoming so
- 52:25nationalized in their context, and it's just let's let's break things down a little bit like
- 52:32you said.
- 52:32So since we're running out of time, one more question before the fun random nonpolitical
- 52:39question that we have.
- 52:41Do you think that improving our education policy, particularly with how we teach civics
- 52:47and government and and why people should be invested in the political process, do you think
- 52:53that that will lead to a discernible decrease in our nation's polarization?
- 52:59Yep.
- 53:00Yeah.
- 53:00I I really do.
- 53:03I do think it will lead to a decrease in polarization because I think it's I think
- 53:11education is a way to sort of push back on what is the this thing called the Dunning Kruger
- 53:20effect.
- 53:20Yeah.
- 53:20I don't know if you're familiar with this.
- 53:21Right?
- 53:22But this sort of it's this it's this cognitive bias that lead people with less knowledge or
- 53:28less skill to overestimate their competence.
- 53:32Right?
- 53:33It it reminds me of I don't know if you saw this or they made the rounds, but there was
- 53:40this Joe Rogan interview with this actor, Terrence Howard, and it's where Howard makes
- 53:46these wild claims.
- 53:48Two plus two is not does not equal four.
- 53:51Two plus two does not equal four.
- 53:53He has it.
- 53:54He comes up with his own, like, periodic table.
- 53:56The math ain't mathing.
- 53:59Yeah.
- 53:59And I kinda and I kinda say, like, do not take math or chemistry advice from Terrence Howard.
- 54:08He seems he he seems like a nice enough guy, and he's got he has some real skills, but, you
- 54:16know, he is I think, like, typifies this effect where you go, okay.
- 54:23He does not have expertise or competence, and he way overestimates his Yeah.
- 54:28Himself.
- 54:30That kind of describes a lot of the Internet.
- 54:33Right?
- 54:34And it and it describes and I think it definitely describes what can happen, again, if
- 54:40people don't have the the broad based knowledge to be able to evaluate claims.
- 54:47And so that's that to me is is ultimately it about education.
- 54:51I'm because, listen, I'm also not a chemist, But I think I could read enough about people
- 55:01who claim to be chemists to determine where there's somebody who's just kind of a
- 55:06charlatan.
- 55:07Yep.
- 55:07And that's really important.
- 55:10And I think it's important in chemistry and mathematics, but it's also super important in
- 55:15the political space.
- 55:16Right?
- 55:17Can we evaluate which one of these candidates is just kind of a charlatan?
- 55:23Because there's a lot of them.
- 55:26Can we evaluate who's got some claims that maybe aren't aren't perfect but have some truth
- 55:32to them, have some value, and and they're thoughtful?
- 55:37And I think a part of that a part of why that works is because when you are educated, you
- 55:43realize that that life requires a lot more nuance than just staying in your your small
- 55:48little bubble.
- 55:50Education helps us to ask and answer questions.
- 55:53It helps us to frankly like, once you realize how much knowledge is out there that you don't
- 55:59have, well, I actually think the the thing to do is to be humble and to actually ask people
- 56:04for help.
- 56:04Right?
- 56:04So you can be now in community and in communication with people.
- 56:08So, yeah, I really do think education will help us to to get out of the polarization.
- 56:15Also, you know, last thing I'll say about it is I think this is especially important with with
- 56:21AI just making such tremendous strides, you know, in the past just months and years, and
- 56:28it's gonna continue.
- 56:30I don't believe that AI anytime soon is gonna help us answer questions about what it is to
- 56:37live a good life.
- 56:39Yeah.
- 56:40It may help us, you know, with, like, create a plan for me to, you know, build a new chicken
- 56:51coop.
- 56:51That was that was our summer project, and I did that.
- 56:54Okay.
- 56:54Cool.
- 56:55Although the geometry on it was not great.
- 57:01But to answer these questions about, like, ethics and morals and and religion, I think
- 57:07we're gonna still have to be in communication with other humans, and and hopefully, are other
- 57:14thoughtful humans.
- 57:15So I think that education gives us the tools to evaluate those types of questions.
- 57:21Yeah.
- 57:22And I I think as as obviously as much as we value open mindedness, and you should be open
- 57:30minded.
- 57:31If somebody has the attitude of, well, I figured everything out and my worldviews
- 57:36explain everything a 100%.
- 57:38You probably don't need to listen to them.
- 57:40So Kinda.
- 57:42Yeah.
- 57:42Yeah.
- 57:42And and unfortunately, I I I feel like there's a lot of those kinds of grifters across the
- 57:48political spectrum right now.
- 57:51But, you know, yeah, I great points.
- 57:55So And and and you and
- 57:56I are both podcasters.
- 57:58We both have you know?
- 57:59But there is this there is this unfortunate trend right now that sort of feels like that by
- 58:07purchasing a microphone, it means you know everything.
- 58:10Yeah.
- 58:10Right?
- 58:11And and so I think we wanna again, we wanna not be that guy.
- 58:15And I find that, like, reading about other people, learning learning new things helps me
- 58:24to I hope to not be that guy because I realized, oh, there's there's a pretty big
- 58:27world out there, and nobody's got the capacity to know it all.
- 58:31Yeah.
- 58:31And so and some of those the ones that where I just where it's just me, I sometimes have to
- 58:36refresh my memory or be like, I wanna be sure that I have that correctly.
- 58:41And part that's partly also anxiety.
- 58:43I'm I'm like, overly worried about, like, oh, do I have this one minor detail wrong that
- 58:50might not actually be that important, but I still try to keep it as as accurate as
- 58:55possible.
- 58:56But, yeah, I I still gotta make sure I'm researching things.
- 58:59And in case there's a point that I didn't even think about, like, oh, I can also teach people
- 59:03this.
- 59:04And and then sometimes I learn something new about a a topic that I had a pretty good grasp
- 59:09of, but then there's something else that I'm like, oh, I didn't know that.
- 59:12That's a good thing to put in there.
- 59:14So Yep.
- 59:14Definitely agree with that.
- 59:16So as much as, you know, we could keep this conversation going on and on and on, we are
- 59:22obviously don't wanna keep you too much longer.
- 59:25So we're gonna go ahead and get to the fun random question of the day.
- 59:30So for anybody who's new to this podcast, at the end of each episode, I end with a fun
- 59:36nonpolitical question to change things up a bit, make some things a little bit more varied,
- 59:40and variety is the spice of life after all, and let our listeners hear another side to the
- 59:46guests.
- 59:46So Shaka, today's random question of the day is, besides where you were actually raised,
- 59:52assuming you like the place, which sounds like you did or you do, where is a place you think
- 59:58would have been cool to grow up?
- 1:00:03That's that's a good question.
- 1:00:05A place that would have been cool to grow up.
- 1:00:09I always thought so I was raised in New York, and then I went to high school in, like, in
- 1:00:16Powder Springs, Georgia outside Marietta, which is outside Atlanta.
- 1:00:20I always thought that it would have been really, really cool to to grow up in
- 1:00:28California, sort of, like, Southern California, you know, San Diego, West Coast, surfing, learn
- 1:00:36to surf.
- 1:00:36I got I have no idea how to surf.
- 1:00:38I always thought that that would be a pretty cool and very, very different experience from
- 1:00:45the one that I had grown up in New York.
- 1:00:47I gotcha.
- 1:00:48Yeah.
- 1:00:48That that I could definitely see that too.
- 1:00:51I I I love my state for all its flaws, Florida.
- 1:00:56So I would pick there are several places I would still love to have grown up.
- 1:01:00Saint Augustine.
- 1:01:01I don't know if you've ever been to Saint Augustine.
- 1:01:03Yeah.
- 1:01:03That's an that's an incredible place.
- 1:01:05I love that place.
- 1:01:06I've we've my family and I have gone there, like, four or five times now.
- 1:01:10So definitely there.
- 1:01:11I have a lot of family up in Virginia, so I think that could be cool to have grown up in.
- 1:01:15And I've not actually been here or been there, but the Pacific Northwest, like the Seattle
- 1:01:22area, I have a sort of fascination with that whole ambiance, especially because my favorite
- 1:01:29band of all time is Alice in Chains, and they're they were part of they're originally
- 1:01:34part of that Seattle grunge scene.
- 1:01:35So yep, be being around that and it's was born in '93, so I would have been a little young for
- 1:01:41that.
- 1:01:41But but just that there's just something about that Pacific Northwest vibe that is really
- 1:01:46intriguing to me.
- 1:01:47So those are those are several places I would have I that would've been cool to grow up in.
- 1:01:53But Yeah.
- 1:01:53Like I I am glad that I grew up in the Tampa Bay area, though.
- 1:01:57Yeah.
- 1:01:57Yeah.
- 1:01:58Yeah.
- 1:01:58Great question.
- 1:01:59Yeah.
- 1:01:59California would've been a a that's probably top of my top of my list.
- 1:02:03I don't know that I would wanna live there right now, but I think it would have been fun
- 1:02:07to grow up there.
- 1:02:09Yeah.
- 1:02:09I gotcha.
- 1:02:10Well, Shaka, I wanna thank you very much for being on here.
- 1:02:15Actually, real quick before I close out, any other media or works that you would like to
- 1:02:19share?
- 1:02:20Yeah.
- 1:02:20Thanks.
- 1:02:21You know, if folks wanna check out more of my work, I've got a Substack, and it is
- 1:02:27appropriately named Shaka's Substack.
- 1:02:30So not super original, but very easy
- 1:02:33to find.
- 1:02:34Yeah.
- 1:02:34That's right.
- 1:02:35And yeah.
- 1:02:36Yeah.
- 1:02:36And so you're welcome to check that out, and and thanks for the conversation.
- 1:02:39Really appreciate it.
- 1:02:40Yeah.
- 1:02:40No.
- 1:02:41Absolutely.
- 1:02:41So I'll I'll go ahead and put a link to to the Substack.
- 1:02:48I believe you also did a TED talk.
- 1:02:49Right?
- 1:02:50I sure did.
- 1:02:51Yeah.
- 1:02:51Did a a TEDx Nashville talk.
- 1:02:53Yeah.
- 1:02:53Okay.
- 1:02:53So I I can put a link to that in the show notes when this when this episode comes out.
- 1:02:59And then for my links, my Facebook, Paul Raider author and speaker, my LinkedIn, mymedium.com
- 1:03:05profile right on political science from time to time, my matchmaker f m profile, if you want me
- 1:03:11as a guest on your podcast or you want to be a guest on this podcast, my email, Paul Raider
- 1:03:17Wrights at Gmail dot com, my websites, my oh, my five day educational email course about some
- 1:03:23of the mistakes we make when trying to depolarize the political climate, why we make
- 1:03:27those mistakes, and how we can fix those mistakes.
- 1:03:30And I believe that's it.
- 1:03:32So once again, to all of you listening and viewing, thank you so much for tuning in, and
- 1:03:37until next time.
- 1:03:39Take care.