Latest / Saigalseatrade Podcast / The Energy Paradox: Oversupply Ahead, Volatility Now - Part 2
Transcript
- 0:10Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the Segal Sea Trade
- 0:13Podcast. I'm research analyst Shruti,
- 0:15your host today, and I'm joined by shipping and commodities
- 0:18expert, Mr. Sandesh Ghandat. Sandesh, welcome back.
- 0:22Thanks Shruti, thanks for inviting me once again.
- 0:24Pleasure to be here. Well, Sandesh, let's get right
- 0:27into tankers. Our listeners love freight talk
- 0:30because it's where geopolitics needs real money.
- 0:33We have seen Afromax availability tighten in the
- 0:35Americas, VLCC is getting pulled into China and the Mr. and LR
- 0:40product tankers swinging on refinery maintenance.
- 0:43So what's your vantage point? How are ship owners navigating
- 0:47this volatility? And do you think there are
- 0:49structural winners in this market?
- 0:51Well, Shruti, you have hit the sweet spot of our industry and
- 0:56it is where all the big macro forces like oil prices, OPEC
- 1:00policies, sanctions, refinery runs, they suddenly show up in
- 1:05the dollar per day earnings. So for sheep owners, volatility
- 1:08isn't just a buzzword, but it's their profit and loss.
- 1:11For understanding, let's break it down segment by segment
- 1:15because each class is living its own story right now.
- 1:19So let me start with the VLCCS. They are the real giants.
- 1:22So these are the workhorses of long haul crude, 2 million
- 1:26barrels carriers connecting the Atlantic basin to Asia,
- 1:29specifically to China, South Korea and even Japan.
- 1:33So right now they are seeing a steady demand and we have to
- 1:37thank the arbitrage. We talked about South Atlantic
- 1:40barrels flowing E because the brand Dubai swap is narrowing.
- 1:45So US Gulf exports have been hitting 4 to 5 million barrels
- 1:50per day, with a big chunk sailing on the VLCC to China and
- 1:54South Korea. And then you have to add
- 1:56Brazilian Tupee and the Guyan is screwed and suddenly the
- 2:00Atlantic Asia trade is pulling in Tunnage like a magnet.
- 2:04For context, let me give you this example.
- 2:06A single VLCC voyage from US go to China ties up a ship for 4045
- 2:12days. Now compare that to Middle East
- 2:14to India and that run takes maybe two weeks.
- 2:17So every time an arbitrage window opens, you are
- 2:21multiplying 10 mile demand. And that's why even if total
- 2:25global export don't rise dramatically, VLCC earnings,
- 2:29they can search and we have seen the spikes of 30 to 40% in rates
- 2:34in a matter of days when a wave of fixture hits the tape, that's
- 2:38about the VLCC. And if you see the Afromax
- 2:41market, the segment is in contrast with the VLCC.
- 2:45So the Afromax supply in the Americas has been tied and in
- 2:49the US Gulf, Caribbean shuttle work and occasional storms
- 2:53disrupting the schedules and owners suddenly have a leverage.
- 2:57And that's how this Aframex market in the Americas shows the
- 3:00tonnage replenishment, it's consistent and sometimes we have
- 3:04seen spikes in the freight rates, mostly because of the
- 3:07geopolitical reasons and the arbitrage.
- 3:10So in some weeks, Aframex availability in the Caribbean
- 3:13has been so thin that the rate shot up 20 to 25% almost
- 3:18overnight. You know, every time Chevron
- 3:21gets a new Venezuelan Weber, we all know that Aframax list is
- 3:25going to clear in 24 hours. And that's how sensitive this
- 3:28segment is to the policy headlines.
- 3:30And the product tankers or the clean tankers, we have Mrs. and
- 3:34LRS. And this is where the refinery
- 3:37maintenance demand swings, government policy really come
- 3:40into the play. So let's look at India.
- 3:43Recently, Indian clean product exports dropped sharply because
- 3:47of refinery turnouts. So that pulled the tonnage out
- 3:50of the LR market, the softening rates for weeks.
- 3:53But then you had Europe stepping in with the strong gasoline
- 3:56imports ahead of the driving season where this entire
- 4:00scenario put Mr. tankers back in play on the transatlantic runs.
- 4:04And here is where volatility shows its teeth.
- 4:07So one week an Mr. Owner in Europe complaints about the
- 4:11oversupply and low rates. Then the next week, US Gulf
- 4:15gasoline export to Latin America surged because of refinery
- 4:19outages in Mexico, and suddenly those same ships earning $20,000
- 4:24a day more so the swings are brutal, but if you are
- 4:28positioned right, the rewards are massive.
- 4:30So. Sandesh, in that case, do you
- 4:32think Aframaxes are opportunistic winners?
- 4:35Well, Aframaxes are opportunistic winners because
- 4:37you know, they benefit from the regional tightness because they
- 4:41do a short haul voyages and they benefit from the tightness in
- 4:44Venezuela, They benefit from the Caribbean disruptions,
- 4:48Mediterranean geopolitics and their earnings are headline
- 4:52driven almost day by day. Then Mrs. and LRS, the LRS
- 4:57specifically, sometimes switch from clean to crude.
- 5:00So this particular Mrs. and LRS, they are more cyclical and tied
- 5:04to the refinery runs and the demand patterns.
- 5:07But with India's diesel demand booming and Europe still reliant
- 5:11on imports, I would say product tankers have plenty of upside in
- 5:15the medium term. Now let's not forget the flip
- 5:19side because volatility cuts both ways and Aframax earning
- 5:23$40,000 a day current week could be down to $20,000 per day next
- 5:29week if the flows dry up. So the VLCC rally can collapse
- 5:33if Chinese teapots get a hit with the new regulations and
- 5:37stop buying. So owners who survive are the
- 5:40ones who understand the timing and the positioning.
- 5:43For you, here is a little anecdote.
- 5:45Running tankers is like surfing the is bigger than you and you
- 5:51can't control it. So all you can do is catch it at
- 5:54the right time and ride it as long as you can.
- 5:57And you know that's the mindset ship owners are taking along
- 5:59with them. So answer to your question is
- 6:02ship owners are navigating volatility by reading the
- 6:05signals and those signals are the crude spreads, OPEC policy,
- 6:09refinery runs, geopolitics and positioning their ships to catch
- 6:13the next. They have to anticipate where to
- 6:16ballast next week or how to catch the next cargo in what
- 6:20region. So structurally, VLCCS are
- 6:23winning today, Aframax maybe tomorrow and Ms. maybe the day
- 6:27after. So the trick is surviving long
- 6:29enough to enjoy the upcycles, because in the tanker business,
- 6:33the only certainty is that the cycle will turn.
- 6:36Well, I think India is such a fascinating story right now.
- 6:40On one hand, diesel demand is booming with almost no EV drag.
- 6:44On the other, India is rolling out to E 20 ethanol nationwide
- 6:47by 2025 and even talking about cutting gas imports by half with
- 6:52coal to SNG. Can you break this all down for
- 6:55us? And what does India's demand
- 6:57picture really look like? How do you think will it ripple
- 7:01into global trade? You have hit one of the most
- 7:04important energy stories of this decade, and it's about India.
- 7:08So I'm very glad that you have raised this point.
- 7:11Let's analyze from this point of view.
- 7:14So if China was the demand engine of the early 2000s or
- 7:19early 2010, India is increasingly stepping into that
- 7:22role now. And what makes India so
- 7:25fascinating is the contradiction between the hydrocarbon demand
- 7:29and aggressive government policy experiments.
- 7:32Let's start with the basics and that is diesel.
- 7:36I would like to say this casually that India runs on a
- 7:39diesel. It fuels the trucks that carry
- 7:42goods across the country, the buses that moves millions of
- 7:46people and even a backup generator that keeps the lights
- 7:49on when the power grids falter. And the numbers are striking.
- 7:55Diesel demand has been outspacing gasoline by a wide
- 7:59margin. So post pandemic, as the economy
- 8:02rebounded 2 years back, the diesel demand surge on the back
- 8:06of infrastructure spending, ecommerce, logistics and the
- 8:10increasing industrial activities.
- 8:12You know the IMF April 2025 World Economic Outlook, it
- 8:17projected Indias economic growth around 6.8% this year.
- 8:21And you know what, it's one of the fastest among the major
- 8:24economies. And that growth translate
- 8:27directly into the diesel barrel. We are looking at the diesel
- 8:30demand growth of several 100,000 barrels per day with the minimal
- 8:35EV penetration. So unlike in Europe or even
- 8:38China, electric trucks and buses still a tiny fraction of India's
- 8:42fleet. So while Europe talks about the
- 8:45diesel demand, picking Indias diesel story is just hitting its
- 8:49stride. Now coming back on the main
- 8:52topic E 20 ethanol. So India has committed to
- 8:55rolling out E 20 that is 20% ethanol blended with the
- 9:00gasoline and they will be doing that with the nationwide
- 9:04campaign by 2025. That's not just a talk.
- 9:08The government is building out 90,000 pumps to supply it and
- 9:13ethanol procurement target around 10.16 billion litres.
- 9:17So you know, there's 90,000 pumps equal to the half of
- 9:21European pumps available on today's ground.
- 9:24And you know that translates into roughly 130, 37,000 barrels
- 9:29per day of gasoline equivalent demand being displaced by
- 9:33ethanol. So on paper, that sounds like a
- 9:36huge policy win and less dependence on important
- 9:39gasoline, more support for the local farmers who grow the
- 9:43feedstock, and a greener footprint.
- 9:45But let me point out the nuance because ethanol blending reduces
- 9:51the gasoline demand, but not diesel.
- 9:53And as I just said, diesel is the dominant growth driver.
- 9:57So yes, E 20 will shave the age of gasoline imports, but it
- 10:03won't fundamentally slow India's thirst for the hydrocarbons.
- 10:07So, Sandesh, what does this mean for global trade and do you
- 10:10think there are any ripple effects?
- 10:12Well, I think there are three ripple effects.
- 10:14First is diesel imports and as well as export.
- 10:18So as Indian demand for diesel booms, local refiners are
- 10:22running hard and that affects the clean product tanker market
- 10:26across Asia and Africa because if India pulls back exports to
- 10:30feed its own demand, Mr. and LR owners fill the pinch
- 10:34immediately because, you know, we export largely to the
- 10:37compliant fuel it is going to Europe and even for the East
- 10:41Africa. And those trade lines were
- 10:44mostly from the West Coast of India.
- 10:46And then the second one is the gasoline flows.
- 10:49So with a 20 coming in, refiners could redirect surplus barrels
- 10:54abroad and that keeps India engaged in the product export
- 10:58market, just in a more complex way.
- 11:00And then the third is LNG trade. So government came with the coal
- 11:05to SNG, that is synthetic natural gas scenario, the
- 11:08ambitious plan. And if that plan really scales
- 11:12up, India could cap India's LNG imports over the long term.
- 11:15And I'm talking about 2030, five, 2040 scenario.
- 11:20So you have to remember this, India has been a swing buyer in
- 11:24the spot LNG market. So when they step back, Asian
- 11:28spot LNG prices like JKM lose one of their biggest demand and
- 11:32you know that could soften volatility in the LNG freight as
- 11:36well. So here is an anecdote for you.
- 11:39So when we look at Asia, China is the elephant but India is a
- 11:44tiger. So China moves slow but huge,
- 11:48then India moves fast, unpredictable and sometimes it
- 11:52bites and that captures it because India's demand picture
- 11:55is dynamic and every policy tweak whether it is ethanol,
- 11:59SNG, refinery runs, refinery growth ripples across the tanker
- 12:03markets and the price paid. So to sum up, India is A2 sided
- 12:08coin. On one side you have a roaring
- 12:10diesel demand and economy charging ahead and the refinery
- 12:14shaping regional product flows and then on the other you have
- 12:18policy experiments like ethanol to bend the demand curve but
- 12:22don't fully succeed. So India is both an opportunity
- 12:26and bit of risk. Ignore it at your peril because
- 12:30in the 20 twenties, India is the market mover everyone
- 12:34underestimated. Sandesh, let me pivot to one
- 12:38headline that really shook people recently.
- 12:40Was Israel's strike on Qatar the first time you've seen such
- 12:44direct military action on Qatari soil?
- 12:47Given Qatar's importance as the world's second largest LNG
- 12:51exporter and its role as a mediator in the region, what do
- 12:54you think are the short term and long term implications of this
- 12:58attack for the oil and LNG markets?
- 13:00Well, this incident is one of those moments where geopolitics
- 13:06collides directly with the energy security.
- 13:08So let's unpack it carefully because it has both immediate
- 13:13ripple effects and the long term consequences.
- 13:15So first, the short term picture.
- 13:17So markets initially reacted with a jolt, crude spiked
- 13:22briefly and LNG future source more rally and the risk premiums
- 13:27widened. But within the prices settled
- 13:30back and you may ask why? Because the buyers and sellers,
- 13:34they have learned to separate headline risk from the flow
- 13:37risk. And even if there is a direct
- 13:41attack on the Qatari soil, we have not seen a significance
- 13:45with respect to damage to the energy infrastructure.
- 13:49So unless there is a physical disruption to the production
- 13:53facilities, ports or shipping lanes, markets tend to fade the
- 13:57noise quickly and that's exactly what we saw here.
- 14:01Kartas, LNG exports, they are around 77 million tons per year
- 14:06today and projected to move around 126,000,000 within next
- 14:11two to three years and they might continued it without any
- 14:15interruption. So Ras Lafan, the crown jewel of
- 14:18the LNG terminal was untouched during these attacks and even
- 14:23the oil infrastructure wasn't hit.
- 14:25So in the immediate term prices corrected back to the
- 14:29fundamental which as we have discussed are over supplied in
- 14:34oil and relative balanced in LNG.
- 14:36But don't let that lull you because this is the first time
- 14:40Israel military action touched Qatari territory and Qatar isn't
- 14:44just a producer and let me be very apolitical here.
- 14:48So Qatar isn't just a producer, it's a mediator hosting US
- 14:53bases, financing regional diplomacy and being central to
- 14:57the LNG supply chains. So even if flows weren't
- 15:00disrupted this time, the buyers and sellers now have to assign a
- 15:04higher probability to the future disruption.
- 15:07And that means a persistent risk premium could creep back in,
- 15:12especially on the LNG shipping insurance.
- 15:14Now let's think about the long term implications.
- 15:17And I think there are three big ones.
- 15:19So one is LNG trade security. So Qatar supplies roughly 20% of
- 15:24the global energy trade and they have the key buyer in Europe and
- 15:28Asia. So if the geopolitical
- 15:30instability rises, then we may see the importers like Japan,
- 15:35South Korea and Germany, they will rethink their dependency.
- 15:39So you might see the diversification into US which we
- 15:42already witnessed in last couple of years.
- 15:45And then we have Australian LNG projects or even the floating
- 15:50regassification units or the FSR US, they are the closer to the
- 15:53demand centers. And another one is the insurance
- 15:56premiums for the careers out of the Gulf.
- 15:59It could also creep higher. So even a 10 to $0.20 per MBTU
- 16:04insurance uplift adds up when you are moving millions of tons.
- 16:09The second one is more of a geopolitical perspective and
- 16:13that is the Middle East power balance.
- 16:16Qatar has always played the role of the quiet mediator between
- 16:20Hamas and the US and between Iran and the West.
- 16:23So if Israel strike undermines Qatar's diplomatic standing, the
- 16:27region could tilt into a more polarized axis.
- 16:30Saudi plus UAE on one side, Iran on the other, and Qatar caught
- 16:35in between. So for energy, that means less
- 16:38stability in OPEC Plus negotiations and more
- 16:41fragmentation of supply coordination.
- 16:44So remember, even if Qatar isn't a major crude player, it shapes
- 16:49the LNG strategy and LNG is increasingly intertwined with
- 16:54the global gas and oil prices. Then third one is from the
- 16:57financial perspective. So Qatar has been rolling out
- 17:00its Northfield expansion, attracting billions from Exxon,
- 17:04Shell, Total and CNPC. So if investors start to price
- 17:09in higher political risk, till now it's a mid whether Qatar's
- 17:13energy risk or political risk will increase.
- 17:16So the idea that even Qatar is no longer untouchable, the
- 17:21financing cost will rise. So the future expansion could
- 17:25get delayed or repriced. And that matters because the
- 17:29world is counting on Qatari LNG to fill the gap as goal is
- 17:33phased out and Russian pipeline gas remain under sanction.
- 17:36So any slow down could tighten the LNG balances post 2027.
- 17:42So I have summarized 3 implications and let me add this
- 17:47will not be a long time implication.
- 17:49But from the shipping perspective, the LNG carriers
- 17:52are among the most specialized vessels in the world.
- 17:55Ice class Arc 7 for Russia, Qplex and Qmax giants for Qatar.
- 18:01So if insurance cost or war risk premiums flying for the Gulf
- 18:04calls, owners may demand higher charter rate and we may see a
- 18:09spike of around 10 to 12% on the LNG shipping and it could ripple
- 18:14through into delivered prices, specifically in Asia where the
- 18:19gas based utility margins are already thin.
- 18:22So we didn't see cargoes get cancelled after this attack, but
- 18:27every underwriter started revisiting their Gulf exposure
- 18:31models and asking what if Ratul Afan was hit even accidentally.
- 18:36And that's not a dollar one move in prices, that's a structural
- 18:39shock. And that's exactly right.
- 18:42Markets they struck this time, but the mental model has
- 18:45shifted. So to answer directly, short
- 18:48term the strike didn't cut the flows.
- 18:50So prices they calm down quickly.
- 18:53But in the long term, the implications are far bigger
- 18:57because we are entering a world where no producer is off limits,
- 19:02where the risk premiums creep back in and where the bias
- 19:05rethink dependency on the single suppliers.
- 19:08So for oil, it's another reminder that geopoliticals can
- 19:12override fundamental in an instant.
- 19:14But for LNG, it's a flashing warning light.
- 19:17The supply security everyone took for granted in Qatar is not
- 19:22bullet troop. This is what we have seen from
- 19:25the recent attack. And that's why I always say in
- 19:28this market, you have to price not just the barrels and the
- 19:31cargoes, but also the possibility of disruption,
- 19:34because one day the headline won't fade, one day it will be
- 19:39the disruption itself. Well, thank you Sandesh for
- 19:41summing it up for our audience. And that brings us to the end of
- 19:46this episode and to all our audience.
- 19:48Do not forget to share and subscribe to our podcast.
- 19:51Until next time, navigate safely and stay tuned.