Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / What do you do when students won’t cooperate
Transcript
- DJI 20261104135446 0214 D: You've done everything right. You've set up the routines, your transitions are tight, you followed the advice, and yet you still find yourself sitting beside a desk arguing with a nine-year-old about whether they need to finish three questions of math. At what point do we stop repeating the same strategy and start asking a completely different question? Because sometimes students are cooperating and you need to know what to do next. I've been thinking about some of the comments that teachers have been leaving on my videos. And there's a question I really wanted to get into, which is what happens when the behavior continues even after you've taught the expectations, built the relationships, and brought in additional support. And I think this is where a lot of the advice that teachers get really falls apart because you put in all of that hard work of relationship building and making sure the day is predictable as possible while reinforcing positive behavior, but you also need to know what happens when you've done all of those things and the student still isn't doing what they're supposed to be doing. So let's talk about it. Because I don't think the answer is like repeating the instructions louder, longer, and with incre increasingly visible veins popping out of your forehead. So first things first, stop asking the same question five different ways. This has the potential to completely derail the lesson because you'll give a student direction, they don't follow it, then you repeat it and then they argue. You explain why it's important, they argue about that, you offer another choice, they're still rejecting the options, and now you spent six minutes negotiating over something that should have taken thirty seconds, and the rest of the class is basically just watching this like failed courtroom drama that's occurring in front of their eyes, right? And the problem with this whole back and forth is that somewhere along the way, the original task completely disappeared. When you're no longer teaching the lesson, so you've got all these students watching what's going on, while you're two, just trying to get one student to agree with you. And those are extremely different jobs, right? when a student refuses a reasonable direction, I personally want to be careful about how much attention and energy I give the refusal itself, right? I'm not there to defend my Instruction or the direction that I've given? So instead I give two options. I say it's time to start the first question. You can do it independently, or I can help you get started. If the student doesn't say anything or grants or whatever, I I leave them. I walk away and and I do a circle of the room checking to make sure everyone's got it, understands what's going on, because then that gives me a natural ending point as well where I can then check in with that student and see what's going on. And no, when you walk away it doesn't necessarily mean that that student is going to pick up their pencil and get right into it. But what it really means and what is happening here is that you're not gonna do a lengthy argument and make an already difficult situation harder. And I really need you to remember that staying calm does not mean that you are abandoning the expectation. You can be calm, respectful, and completely serious about what needs to happen next. And if they're still not doing it, you know, this is when need to start documenting these things, going to your school-based team and connecting home. Hey, this student had, you know, wasn't able to finish this or to get started. I'm noticing that they're having a harder time initiating a task. I've given it to them as homework. Please return it, you know, whenever it's due tomorrow. Maybe even just highlight a few of the questions so they don't have to do the whole thing at home. and the reason I really like checking in with their with their caregiver or at home is because then the student sees like, there's open communication. Like the expectation is actually going to follow me when I get home. I also find that powerful even when the students, knows that at home they're not going to do it, because then at least you've communicated this home and you are now, keeping track of this so that you when report card comes Or if you get more support through school based team the school district, then you can kind of show what's happening and what's going on, right? So that was number one. Number two, accountability is not the same as winning a power struggle. And I do think that sometimes teachers do get caught between two extremes. On one side, there's this idea that you need to be firmer, follow through, and make sure that students experience consequences. But on the other hand, there is this fear that if we hold a student to a high standard or to an expectation, then we're not being understanding of their needs. And I don't think choosing between those is ever the option. Those two truths can completely exist simultaneously. And students really do just need adults who are going to recognize when a response isn't working and then adjust to it, right? So let's say a student refuses to complete an assignment. We can acknowledge the refusal. offer an appropriate way to get started and make a plan for completing the essential learning. If the student disrupts others, we need to protect the learning of everyone else in the classroom because let's face it, classrooms are full. We are responsible for more than one student, sometimes 30, sometimes more if you're in high school. You know, this doesn't mean that every refersal needs to turn into a consequence, particularly if the consequence actually ends up just removing the task the student was avoiding the first place, right? If the student was refusing to do work and the result is that they get sent out or lose access to the activity or just spends the rest of the lesson doing nothing, then like what's actually been accomplished here? You know, sometimes a consequence is appropriate, but also we need a different response that keeps the student connected to their learning while maintaining the expectation. You know, is the reason they're refusing it because it's too daunting? Can you give them a sentence starter? Can you chunk it? I honestly sometimes just cut the paper with all the different things and I'm like, here's the first thing to do, when do they do that? Then I give them the second thing. Do they have a ready to do done? Is there an exemplar of what the finished product is gonna look like, right? Like if it's if they're refusing to do it because they are absolutely racked with anxiety that they're not gonna be able to do it or there's p like they have perfectionist tendencies, then like how can you help them? If it is a power struggle, then it is about making those connections home. It is about making sure that the school based team knows what's going on huff: Make sure to like and subscribe so you don't miss all of the tools that you didn't get in teachers college. Okay, so number three. What do you do when it's actually the whole class who isn't following the expectations? One teacher left a really interesting comment about One teacher left a really interesting comment about attention getters and practicing routines. They described having students practice a routine repeatedly when the class wasn't responding. sometimes even if it meant being late for recess or late to start the next subject. but then some parents complained to them about their how their children are being punished for something other students had done. And I think that's a genuinely difficult situation, especially with our large class sizes, you know, you're not always exact Sure, who's been off task. And so, firstly, I think there's a really important distinction between reteaching a routine as a class and this idea of punishing a whole class for the behavior of a few students. You know, if the class genuinely doesn't know how to respond to an attention signal, then yes, processing it together makes sense because it is a shared routine. But if the majority of students are practicing the expectation and it's just a few students who are repeatedly disrupting it, making everyone rehearse it over and over again can create resentment. without actually addressing any of the problems. So really ask yourself, does this class need more practice or do particular students need some support with their follow-through? Or do particular students need a different kind of support and follow-through? You know, if the routine needs reteaching, keep the practice brief, specific, and purposeful. Tell students what you're practicing, show them what success looks like, and then move on when they've demonstrated it. Remember it's gonna take a couple of times. You're going to need to give them some reminders. but yeah, you just want to teach the class what they need to learn and then give individual students the support and follow-through that they need. Remember, recess is not a bargaining chip, and it doesn't teach your routine any better because honestly, taking it away means that everyone now is annoyed with you. So just make sure that you've got students who understand the routine, helping the students that don't understand the routine, because that is what your classroom community is for. Alright, so the fourth thing we're going to get into is what do you do when it's just the few students who aren't following the routine. So this is where I really want to bring in my perspective as an inclusive education teacher. You know, when a student is repeatedly refusing to participate, you really do need to look beyond the refusal itself. I know that can sound like we're making excuses, but understanding why something is happening is not the same as saying it's okay for that to continue. You know, think about a student who refuses to write. You could interpret that as defiance and spend the lesson trying to convince them to do the work. But what if writing is genuinely difficult for that student? What if it's that they can't start a sentence? What if they can't organize their thoughts? What if they struggle with spelling? What if they have significant gaps in their Fundament foundational skills, or they just become overwhelmed when they're presented with a full page of writing. The expectation that the student participates may still be reasonable, but the support needed to meet that expectation could look very different. You know, use a sentence starter, have them write one good sentence instead of a paragraph, or let them explain orally, or use technology. Find what works best for them and let them use that as a tool for their success. The same principle applies to students who struggle with transition. Attention, emotional regulation, communication, or managing frustration. Notice the patterns. When does the refusal happen? What comes immediately before it? Does it happen with particular tasks, adults, environments, or transitions? What helps the student re-engage? And if you've tried reasonable adjustments and the problem continues, Once again, go to your school-based team because that is information they need, and it is now time to collaborate with your learning support staff, specialists, families, and administration to develop a more consistent plan. Understanding the barrier, knowing that it exists, does not mean that it's yours alone to solve. All of the information needs to be brought to the school-based team, and everyone needs to be responsible for creating a plan that involves more than you and only you supporting this student. And I know that it can be hard, especially if you're working in an environment where maybe someone who has the best relationship with a student refuses to work with them or refuses to help anybody else work with them. And it can be hard when you're doing everything you can and you're trying your best and someone is looking at you and saying you're doing it wrong. But just remember if those people aren't giving you anything that's constructive, anything you can use and they're just saying things like that to you, they're not actually helping you and they're not there for you. And honestly, it's Also showing us that they're not there for the students. Because if they were there for the success of the student, if they were there to help you help the student succeed, they would be giving you pointers, support, they'd be checking in with you instead of just making those kinds of comments. So find the people who will help. Hold everyone accountable because everyone in that school building, counselors, youth and family counselors, learning support teachers. all the kind of different supports in that school, in your school, are there to help support that child that needs it. Okay? You are not doing anything wrong. Some students need extra support. And we know that and that's fine. And if it's not forthcoming, you need to fight for it. Okay. Not all classrooms have the staffing or resources that is needed to provide the level of support the student requires. You need to be honest about those differences because telling a teacher to build a better relationship isn't a complete answer to every problem and is quite frankly very toxic. So number five, what if nothing seems to be working? the behavior continues even when administration comes in to help out. And this idea of just feeling completely drained, trying to support students who can't read or write while also managing everything else in the classroom. including students who are in extreme dysregulation, students who are running out of the out of the room. And I am genuinely concerned that you think that if a strategy isn't working, that it's on you, that it means that you're not implementing it properly or you're not trying hard enough. And while I do think that reflection as teachers is really important to make sure that we are continuously moving forward and adjusting our expectations from ourselves and our students. That does not mean that every persistent problem is evidence of the teacher's failure. If the same behavior is keeps happening, you need to look at the pattern, you need to look at what the student needs, you need to look at the environment, you need to honestly track the consistency of this response, this extreme dysregulated response, and understand the support that is available to you. You need to ask whether the current plan is actually helping And whether the people involved agree on what to do. You always have those other students in the classroom that you need to consider as well. Inclusion cannot mean that one student receives support at the expense of twenty-five or twenty-eight other students who are also need in need of instruction. You know, the goal is to create a plan. The goal is to create a plan that supports the student while protecting the learning and safety of the class. That might require additional adults, targeted intervention, changes to the learning environment, you might need to have specialist input or a more coordinated school response. This is going to take time to work out what is needed, but simply asking the classroom teacher to try harder, to be more patient, or to build a strong relationship. Is not a support plan. that is toxic behavior that only results in more stress and overwhelm for the classroom teacher. And if you are a teacher listening to this and thinking, I've tried all of this and I'm still stuck, I want you to hear this. You can be a good teacher and still have a student whose needs exceed what you can reasonably address on your own. if you want to know what to do when your student runs out of the classroom, watch this video next. Now I want to hear from you what's the one student behavior you find hardest to respond to when the usual strategies aren't working? Tell me in the comments because your answers might help shape a future episode. I'll see you next time.