Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / 2026 New and Revised CAR Forms: Buyer Representation, Buyer Listing, and Landlord/Tenant
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome everyone. My name is Howard Gould and
- 0:06I'm co -chair of the real estate section for
- 0:09the Beverly Hills Bar Association and we're very
- 0:12happy to have you back for what is an annual
- 0:15program we do updating on the updates of the
- 0:18CAR forms and other real estate related matters
- 0:21and delighted to have Jana Gardner with us again
- 0:25this year. Before we begin there's a few comments.
- 0:29Members of the real estate section are welcome
- 0:32to join our monthly executive committee meetings.
- 0:35We have one on March 24th next week. We usually
- 0:39do them either Tuesday or Thursday afternoons
- 0:41about three o 'clock, and they're all on Zoom,
- 0:43so it's easy to attend. And we are doing our
- 0:46planning for upcoming programs and sometimes
- 0:48batting around some current real estate issues.
- 0:52We're looking for people who might want to take
- 0:54on a leadership role at some point, so you might
- 0:56consider that. I also want to remind you for
- 1:00this program, your questions should go in the
- 1:03Q &A, not in the chat, and we'll be following
- 1:05the Q &A. You can find in the chat a link to
- 1:08the program materials and other information about
- 1:11what's going on at the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 1:15BHBA is very good about getting you your attendance
- 1:18certificates after the program, and they're also
- 1:20available on the BHBA Plus site if you want to
- 1:25get them later. In terms of our upcoming programs,
- 1:29we have actually two next month. On April 16th,
- 1:32Howard Fisher and LaVon Lawson are going to talk
- 1:34about 1031 exchanges. So you'll have some tax
- 1:37expertise on what's going on with 1031 exchanges.
- 1:44April 23rd is our annual review of the prior
- 1:46year's case law with Larry Jacobson presenting
- 1:49for us. May 21st, we have a program we've never
- 1:54done before. It's Landlord Insurance Coverage
- 1:57for Habitability Claims in Landlord Tenant Dispute.
- 2:01Steve Raucher, who's a specialist on insurance
- 2:05matters, former president of the SPAR Association,
- 2:08is going to lecture about... the law and his
- 2:12experiences and what you find in the policies
- 2:14to get coverage for habitability claims on behalf
- 2:18of landlords. June 25th, we're also doing something
- 2:21we haven't done before with our speakers, Brian
- 2:23Maschian. Brian spoke for us the last couple
- 2:25of years. He does a lot of presentations for
- 2:27American Industrial Realtors Association. The
- 2:31last couple of years, he talked about their purchase
- 2:33agreement and their lease form. This time, he's
- 2:35going to do something different. The topic is
- 2:39how to effectively represent a small tenant in
- 2:42negotiating a commercial lease. So it'll be more
- 2:44practical information about what to do when you
- 2:48have a client who arguably doesn't have a lot
- 2:50of leverage in a commercial lease negotiation.
- 2:54July is open for the moment. On August 20th,
- 2:56we're looking at doing a program on the newly
- 2:58revised CCP Section 664 .6 on settlements. Scott
- 3:04Rahn, who is a trust probate and a state lawyer,
- 3:08a litigator, he and a couple of people from his
- 3:11firm did an article that appeared recently on
- 3:14the revised Section 664 .6 and what they called
- 3:17the death of finality. And there's a number of
- 3:20changes in this provision by which you can enforce
- 3:24settlement agreements and apparently special
- 3:26considerations for probate and family law practice.
- 3:29Scott's going to handle the probate side of this,
- 3:32and Al Provinziano, who's going to be president
- 3:35of the Sparr Association shortly, is going to
- 3:38present the family law side of things. So my
- 3:42pleasure again to introduce Jana Gardner. Jana
- 3:45is senior counsel with the California Association
- 3:47of Realtors. Since joining CAR in 2014, she has
- 3:52primarily focused on advising members through
- 3:54the legal hotline, as well as presenting legal
- 3:57update, outreaches, and teaching classes on disclosures
- 4:00and the residential purchase agreement. In addition,
- 4:04Jana prepares legal resources such as the legal
- 4:07Q &As for CAR. their quick guides and co -hosts
- 4:11CAR's Legal Matters podcast. And she also presents
- 4:15the monthly Legal Tools Talk on CAR's Facebook
- 4:19page. Prior to joining CAR, Jana practiced commercial
- 4:24real estate law with Cox Castle and Nicholson
- 4:26focusing on acquisition, financing, and leasing
- 4:29of commercial properties. Janet worked with clients
- 4:32ranging from national banks and insurance companies
- 4:34to small private lenders on real property secured
- 4:37financing transactions. including acquisitions,
- 4:41refinancing, loan assumptions, and modifications.
- 4:45Jana received her bachelor's degree in social
- 4:47science from San Diego State University and her
- 4:50JD from USC. And as I mentioned, she's a repeat
- 4:54speaker for us. And welcome back, Jana. All yours.
- 4:59Thank you so much. Very happy to be back. Let
- 5:01me get my screen on here for us. All right. Looking
- 5:09good. Very good. Excellent. Well, thank you again.
- 5:14It's very wonderful to be back with you all.
- 5:15I'm happy to have the opportunity to come back,
- 5:17usually this time of year, give you an update
- 5:19on what's been happening at the California Association
- 5:22of Realtors over the past 12 months or so. As
- 5:25usual, it's been a busy few months with the new
- 5:28laws and going into effect on January 1st and
- 5:31a lot of corresponding changes to our forms.
- 5:34as well as a few other changes that have transpired
- 5:36late last year since I was here about 12 months
- 5:39ago. So we have quite a bit I want to cover today.
- 5:44First talking about agency and sales transaction
- 5:48issues. I always like to start with our RPA since
- 5:51that's kind of the backbone of everything what's
- 5:53new in our residential purchase agreement. One
- 5:57of the newest aspects to it is the federal reporting
- 6:01requirement purchase addendum, new FinCEN reporting
- 6:04requirements just went into effect at the beginning
- 6:06of this month on March 1st. So I'm going to talk
- 6:08about how we're handling that. Another important
- 6:12new issue locally, new law relating to prohibitions
- 6:15on unsolicited offers in fire affected areas.
- 6:19And then I want to talk about agency updates.
- 6:22listing agreements, buyer representation agreements,
- 6:25constantly evolving area, and let you know what
- 6:27the current status of all that is. And then before
- 6:30we wrap up, I want to give a brief leasing and
- 6:32property management update. As there is every
- 6:35year, there are some pretty significant new laws
- 6:39that residential landlords of all sizes need
- 6:43to be aware of and stay on top of. And so of
- 6:46course, we have updates to our forms to help
- 6:49landlords comply with those ever increasing requirements.
- 6:54So, like I said, I'm going to start off with
- 6:56the purchase agreement and start off with the
- 6:59ongoing hottest topic in it, which is how buyer's
- 7:03agent's compensation is handled and negotiated.
- 7:06So this is something that's, if you've been following
- 7:09along or even just have come to this presentation
- 7:12over the past two to three years, you'll have
- 7:15seen a change every time I've been here. There's
- 7:18been a lot of evolution in how this has been
- 7:20addressed in the contract. And so just to give
- 7:24everyone a very brief recap, if you haven't been
- 7:27paying close attention, it was back in 2024 when
- 7:31the NAR settlement occurred, settling some lawsuits
- 7:35relating to buyer's agent's representation. And
- 7:39then after the NAR settlement occurred, We updated
- 7:42our forms. There have been some new California
- 7:44laws I'm going to talk about corresponding with
- 7:46it. And since that time, we've been wanting to
- 7:49make sure putting realtors in the best position
- 7:51as possible to be in compliance with all of these
- 7:54requirements while making sure that transactions
- 7:57can close successfully. And so that brings us
- 8:00to the current language we have in our purchase
- 8:03agreement about buyer's agents' compensation.
- 8:06What we're looking at here is paragraph 3G3.
- 8:09of the residential purchase agreement where buyers
- 8:13can request sellers to make certain concessions
- 8:16or pay certain compensation, broken it down sort
- 8:20of into two sort of three sections. 3G1 is where
- 8:24a buyer can ask a seller to just give a general
- 8:27credit typically applied to closing costs. That's
- 8:30the default. So for a buyer who they're putting
- 8:33every last cent they have into their down payment,
- 8:36they want the seller to contribute to closing
- 8:38costs. We have that section there. There's a
- 8:42place for them to sort of maybe if they're asking
- 8:44for that, provide an explanation of what it is
- 8:47or why they're looking for. We've been hearing
- 8:49that it's becoming increasingly common for buyers
- 8:51to ask sellers to pay for interest rate buy downs,
- 8:55to pay for insurance premiums or HOA costs or
- 8:58things like that that might be especially financially
- 9:00burdensome. So they can indicate that. And then
- 9:04finally, separately. 3G3 is where the buyer can
- 9:07ask the seller to pay the compensation that's
- 9:11going to go to the buyer's agent. And I've had
- 9:14some questions about why is this broken out separately?
- 9:16Why can't the buyer just ask, you know, bottom
- 9:19line, here's the credit, let me apply it as necessary.
- 9:22And the answer to that, as the answer to most
- 9:25things is, is because of lenders, lending regulations.
- 9:28Lenders have very strict requirements about what
- 9:31credits a buyer can get. And in order to satisfy
- 9:35lender underwriting requirements, they want to
- 9:37see a separate breakout for, okay, this is a
- 9:40credit for a buyer versus buyer's agent, which
- 9:43is not going to hit that buyer credit limit.
- 9:47So that's why it's broken out separately. Ask
- 9:50the seller to pay whatever amount could be a
- 9:53percentage could be a dollar amount for the buyer's
- 9:55agents compensation. Now the big change since
- 9:58I was here last is that there used to be an obligation
- 10:03of buyer's agents to provide or buyers I should
- 10:06say to provide their buyer agent representation
- 10:08agreement together with the offer to substantiate
- 10:11the dollar amount or at one point there was an
- 10:14attestation about them. dollar amount that was
- 10:17called for in the buyer representation agreement
- 10:19and after a lot of sort of feedback and analysis
- 10:23of how that was impacting transactions and brokers
- 10:27practice that went away and so now it's just
- 10:30a bottom line yes or no seller are you willing
- 10:33to pay this amount. Now that doesn't change the
- 10:37existing rule that exists that comes from the
- 10:39nr settlement that says. Buyers agents cannot
- 10:42earn from any source an amount that exceeds what
- 10:46was agreed to in their buyer representation agreement
- 10:48that they were supposed to have entered into
- 10:50when they started working with the buyer prior
- 10:52to even showing them a property. So they have
- 10:55negotiated in advance. Here's the amount that
- 10:58I'm going to earn. And they cannot now go into
- 11:01the contract and ask the seller to pay some higher
- 11:03amount. They could ask for less, but they can't
- 11:06ask for more. And so. We do have in our brokers
- 11:10compensation section further down in the contract
- 11:13in paragraph eighteen you'll see there is basically
- 11:16a reminder there in advisory just so that everyone
- 11:19remembers that. That is the role that buyers
- 11:23brokers can't receive an amount greater than
- 11:24called for in the buyer representation agreement.
- 11:28I do find this is just a little bit more anecdotal
- 11:31practice focused i think a lot of escrow may
- 11:34still be asking to see buyer representation agreements
- 11:36i get the sense that that's. a little bit sort
- 11:39of regional, might be more common in certain
- 11:41areas or with certain companies than others.
- 11:43But I do get that question of, well, it doesn't
- 11:46have to be submitted with a purchase offer. What
- 11:49if escrow asks for it? And well, if escrow asks
- 11:51for it, then typically you're going to provide
- 11:53what escrow asks for. So it still may be produced
- 11:56in that context. Otherwise, that's what we're
- 11:59looking at with how buyers and sellers can negotiate
- 12:02for payment of buyer's agents compensation. And
- 12:05when we get to the agency agreements in just
- 12:08a couple of minutes. I'll mention a couple of
- 12:10other relevant points there. I note that this
- 12:13says the commissions will be based on the final
- 12:16purchase price just to be clear that when things
- 12:19get changed at or near the end of the escrow
- 12:22period, the commission is going to get reduced
- 12:24if the price is going down. Yes, exactly. So
- 12:28if there's been a percentage that's been agreed
- 12:29to, if the purchase price is reduced for whatever
- 12:33reason prior to closing, then that percentage
- 12:36is going to be based on that final closing price,
- 12:38that is correct. All right, just a couple other
- 12:43things to note in the purchase agreement that
- 12:46I want to highlight. Once again, like most years,
- 12:49we do have new mandatory disclosures for the
- 12:52sale of residential one to four unit properties.
- 12:55And there are a couple of them relating specifically
- 12:57to electrical systems and electrification. That's
- 13:00a really hot topic now and has been for a few
- 13:02years. A lot of air quality management districts
- 13:05and other types of local entities want to institute
- 13:08electrification requirements saying, okay, you
- 13:10have gas appliances. Well, no more. If your gas
- 13:14appliances break, only new installations can
- 13:16be electric. can could be significantly burdensome
- 13:20to someone who buys an old house with an old
- 13:23electrical system you know they could find themselves
- 13:25facing a great deal of expense if they end up
- 13:28having to comply with electrification requirements
- 13:30so. New law says that for residential one to
- 13:35four unit properties buyers need to be advised
- 13:37that they should get an electrical inspection
- 13:39because this is something they should be considering
- 13:42so because it has to be disclosed on every residential
- 13:45one to four unit transaction. unless tds exempt
- 13:49but the vast majority of them um it's built right
- 13:52into our contract paragraph 11e of our purchase
- 13:55agreement right in there here's the advisory
- 13:57buyer you should consider getting an electrical
- 13:59inspection because you might be facing lots of
- 14:03expenses if you have to upgrade your electrical
- 14:04system to comply with future electrical electrification
- 14:09rules um and just a note that they're a second
- 14:13part of this law is that if sellers have actual
- 14:16knowledge of a pending electrification requirement
- 14:18in their area, they know that there is a rule
- 14:22or there is one that could be coming down sometime
- 14:25soon, then our seller property questionnaire
- 14:27has a place to ask seller, are you aware of any
- 14:30existing or pending requirements? And if seller
- 14:32has actual knowledge, they need to let the buyer
- 14:34know that so they can take that into consideration
- 14:37as well. A side note on this regarding our recent
- 14:41fires and palisades and the eaten fire zone is
- 14:45that if you had gas previously, you may be exempted
- 14:48from some of the new requirements on electrifying
- 14:52everything and still be allowed to have some
- 14:54gas units at your property when you do a rebuild.
- 14:57Oh, that's good to hear. Stay in effect. You
- 15:01know, I can't tell you. But, you know, right
- 15:04now, my understanding and I am involved in this
- 15:07personally is that you can put gas in your property
- 15:10if you're doing a rebuild. Okay, very good to
- 15:13know. All right. And then one more purchase agreement
- 15:19paragraph I want to discuss before we start talking
- 15:21about the FinCEN rule in our addendum is an update
- 15:25to our assignment paragraph. So we've had this
- 15:28assignment paragraph dating back, well, we've
- 15:31always had a shorter version of it. It's been
- 15:33expanded for about five years or so now. because
- 15:36there's been an increase in the prevalence of
- 15:38assignments. We hear a lot of reporting from
- 15:43agents out in the field of what they refer to
- 15:45as wholesaling, which is essentially people getting
- 15:47into contract, tying up a property, and then
- 15:50trying to go flip the contract for a profit during
- 15:53escrow. And so we have an assignment paragraph
- 15:57that lays out when and how assignments can take
- 16:00place during an escrow period. added is a little
- 16:04bit more of an explanation about what might be
- 16:07deemed a reasonable failure to consent. So basically,
- 16:14what we've always said is, OK, buyer can request
- 16:17an assignment. Seller shall not unreasonably
- 16:19withhold their consent with a time period that
- 16:23says, but if you don't get the request in by
- 16:26our default, which is day 17, but could be negotiated
- 16:29to a different length. If you don't get your
- 16:31request in by day 17, then seller's consent shall
- 16:34be deemed reasonably withheld and seller doesn't
- 16:37have to agree to it. They could have they wanted,
- 16:40but they don't have to. That section has been
- 16:43expanded a little bit to still say that if buyer
- 16:46delivers the request after the deadline, that's
- 16:49a reasonable excuse for withholding consent.
- 16:53But it now also says that withholding consent
- 16:56shall be deemed reasonable. If buyer's gonna
- 16:59receive monetary or other compensation for the
- 17:01assignment or buyer makes a misrepresentation
- 17:03to seller about any aspect of the assignment
- 17:06so this is you probably gather is in a response
- 17:10to what's been happening with. Sellers feel like
- 17:14they've been misled buyers tying up their property
- 17:17not being honest about their intentions and then
- 17:20going out and. trying to get money in their own
- 17:23pockets and have the seller close with somebody
- 17:25else. So just a couple new expansions on their
- 17:29clarity about what everybody's options are, if
- 17:31there is going to be an assignment. We get a
- 17:34lot of calls about this on our legal hotline
- 17:36and they tend to come in waves. So I always get
- 17:39the sense that there's trainings out there, maybe
- 17:40telling people how you can make money in real
- 17:42estate with no money down by assigning contracts.
- 17:46And so we see these trends come and go and they've
- 17:48been kind of prevalent recently. Jan, excuse
- 17:52me for going back for a moment just on the commission
- 17:54issues. There's a question whether there's a
- 17:57circumstance where a buyer representation agreement
- 18:00could obligate a buyer to pay compensation even
- 18:03if the deal doesn't close. And is that customarily
- 18:07negotiable? So typically not. Typically, on our
- 18:11buyer representation agreements, compensation
- 18:13is owed if an agreement is entered into during
- 18:16the representation period that then successfully
- 18:19closes escrow. The only time essentially where
- 18:24I think someone could or would pursue a compensation
- 18:27for a deal that didn't close would be in the
- 18:31event of a breach. If the reason the deal didn't
- 18:34close is because the buyer breached that contract,
- 18:38then maybe theoretically the buyer's agent could
- 18:40say, well, that's also breaching my agreement
- 18:43and I've been damaged. I haven't heard of that
- 18:45happening. But short of that particular circumstance,
- 18:49the way our agreement's set up, compensation
- 18:52is owed at the successful close of escrow. But
- 18:54I think either way, it could be negotiated if
- 18:57the parties wanted a different arrangement. Then
- 19:00the buyer, if they want, can simply negotiate
- 19:02a fixed dollar amount for the compensation to
- 19:06the buyer's broker? Absolutely, they can. Yep,
- 19:09they can negotiate a fixed amount or whatever
- 19:12amount they see fit. Absolutely. Thank you. Okay,
- 19:17so... Now, changing gears a little bit, still
- 19:21kind of talking about the purchase agreement
- 19:23because this is an addendum to the purchase agreement.
- 19:26And for now, it is this FRRPA. It is attached
- 19:31right at the back of our residential purchase
- 19:34agreement. But I'll go ahead and tell you that
- 19:36as of June, the language in this addendum, or
- 19:41at least... these concepts are going to be folded
- 19:43into the purchase agreement directly. So if you're
- 19:45looking at our contract six months from now and
- 19:47you're like, where did that addendum go? It won't
- 19:50be there anymore. But but this language or something
- 19:52substantially similar will just be folded into
- 19:54the purchase contract the next time we do an
- 19:57update. probably otherwise minor, in our June
- 20:00forms release. But we update our forms in December
- 20:04and June, and sometimes laws go into effect in
- 20:06March, which is why we have the addendum for
- 20:09the time being. And so this is in response to
- 20:12these new FinCEN reporting requirements from
- 20:15the Treasury Department. And just to give a little
- 20:17background, for a long time, there have been
- 20:20what are called geographic targeting orders.
- 20:23So for properties in certain counties, not all
- 20:26certain sort of more high value counties in the
- 20:29Bay Area, Los Angeles, things like that. If the
- 20:33buyer of the property was an entity, And they
- 20:36were paying all cash and the purchase price was
- 20:38at least three hundred thousand dollars. Then
- 20:40that buyer had to report certain information
- 20:43to the title company that they could then report
- 20:45to the treasury department and it's an anti money
- 20:48laundering law it's basically. These nameless
- 20:50entities are spending cash on houses and we think
- 20:53they're doing it to launder money so for these
- 20:56sorts of transactions we want to find out information
- 20:59about the people the human beings behind these
- 21:01entities and crack down on money laundering.
- 21:04And that's been the case for a long time, but
- 21:06apparently it was decided that that was not going
- 21:08to be sufficient in terms of cracking down on
- 21:11this. So now we have greatly expanded reporting
- 21:15requirements above and beyond what we've had
- 21:19previously. So there's no longer a location limit
- 21:24and there's no longer a dollar amount limit.
- 21:28And who has to provide information has been expanded.
- 21:33I know. And also on this form, I will say there's
- 21:37a brief history of how we got here. I can tell
- 21:40you this rule was passed last fall. It was supposed
- 21:44to go into effect in October. It got delayed.
- 21:47It was supposed to go into effect in December.
- 21:48It got delayed until March. And title companies
- 21:52and some other industry folks had really been
- 21:55fighting this because it is pretty burdensome.
- 21:59escrow and potentially title to gather this information
- 22:02be responsible for reporting it but none of those
- 22:04challenges were successful and the rule did in
- 22:06fact go into effect as of march first so anything
- 22:09that's closed since then that meets these requirements
- 22:12has been subject to these rules um and because
- 22:16it lays out what the requirements are in paragraph
- 22:20two so These reporting obligations apply if it's
- 22:25a residential one to four unit property or vacant
- 22:27land with the intention to construct residential
- 22:31one to four unit property. And the buyer is an
- 22:35entity or a trust. So it could be an LLC or corporation,
- 22:38but it also could be any kind of trust. There's
- 22:41no limit on revocable versus irrevocable family
- 22:44trust or not. If the buyer is an entity or trust
- 22:47and the buyer is making what is considered an
- 22:49all cash purchase, which includes paying literal
- 22:53cash with no financing, but also includes hard
- 22:56money or private loans, financing through a banker
- 23:00institution that does not have its own independent
- 23:02money laundering reporting obligations. So that's
- 23:07pretty broad. That's basically any investor type
- 23:09transaction. where they're paying cash or using
- 23:12a private loan. And it includes, like I said,
- 23:15not just entities, but trusts as well. And then
- 23:20the other really significant big expansion is
- 23:23that it's now not just buyers who have to provide
- 23:26information, it's sellers as well. So even though
- 23:29it's triggered based on the buyer's identity
- 23:33as an entity or trust, if They meet those other
- 23:37requirements entity trust paying cash then both
- 23:41the buyer and the seller have to provide certain
- 23:45information to escrow and title for reporting
- 23:48purposes and you know this includes not just
- 23:52signers also beneficial owners and beneficiaries
- 23:56and this is. Where i've been getting feedback
- 23:59from escrow and title officers who i've spoken
- 24:02to about the implementation of this where they're
- 24:04seeing the biggest sort of roadblocks because.
- 24:07You know normally you're doing the transaction
- 24:09as long as all the signers are on board and working
- 24:10with you that's fine but now because there's
- 24:12reporting requirements from beneficial owners
- 24:14who might not be signatories to the transaction.
- 24:17They're going to track down people to get information
- 24:19reported and that information can be a lot since
- 24:24it's legal names dates of birth dates of execution
- 24:26of trust. addresses, DBA, citizenship information
- 24:31for certain parties, tax ID numbers, social security
- 24:35numbers, account numbers. And a lot of this was
- 24:38already required to be included on a statement
- 24:40of information for buyers and sellers, but it
- 24:42is expanded and it does cover more people. Generally
- 24:49being obtained using the title company's statement
- 24:52of information Form or is the escrow or the escrow
- 24:55is having their own forms for these things My
- 24:58understanding is that the escrows are having
- 25:00their own forms that there's like a separate
- 25:02questionnaire I have heard and and Again, just
- 25:06sort of anecdotal reporting that there is also
- 25:08like there's additional charges being charged
- 25:11for this. So You know, it's an additional questionnaire.
- 25:14I've heard it's like a hundred point questionnaire
- 25:16of information between all the parties, and that
- 25:20escrows are charging $100, $200 because there's
- 25:24a fee for FinCEN reporting paperwork. And I'm
- 25:29also hearing that it's taking more time, right?
- 25:31I've heard some escrows say, you have one of
- 25:34these transactions, add a week to how long you
- 25:37think it's going to take to close. We need to
- 25:38factor that in. Be prepared to bring money in
- 25:41to close a transaction earlier so that we have
- 25:43more time to work with. It's only been a couple
- 25:46of weeks. I will say I haven't heard any horror
- 25:49stories. I've talked to plenty of people that
- 25:51have successfully closed transactions. It's mostly
- 25:53just complaints about extra paperwork. Everyone
- 25:56already is not happy with the amount of paperwork
- 25:59involved in a transaction and this is just a.
- 26:01You know, I've heard like five to nine more pages
- 26:04of paperwork involved. So that's been reports
- 26:08of foreign buyers saying, I'm not doing this
- 26:11and we're terminating the purchase. Not yet.
- 26:15So yeah, not not yet, thankfully. You know, and
- 26:19as far as it is sort of wrapped up into our contract,
- 26:23we have provision here that buyer and seller
- 26:25agree that, you know, within seven days within
- 26:28The seven days of basically being informed they
- 26:30need to provide this information. They will get
- 26:32everyone everything to escrow to collaborate
- 26:35with the reporting and letting them know that
- 26:39if someone refuses to cooperate, the transaction
- 26:42is just not going to close and that whoever refused
- 26:44to cooperate, you know, could be responsible,
- 26:47you know, could be liable for breach of contract
- 26:49for failing to do so. I've had some people, some
- 26:53realtors, some lawyers tell me that, you know,
- 26:56They might include a provision in the contract,
- 26:59basically creating a contingency for this, saying
- 27:01if they're unable to do it, excuse performance
- 27:03on the contract. Obviously, that's something
- 27:05someone could choose to include, but we have
- 27:07it just built in as, hey, this is a contractual
- 27:10obligation. If you are in this circumstance,
- 27:13you got to cooperate with escrow to close the
- 27:14deal. Otherwise, there could be problems. We
- 27:19have a question whether there's anything similar
- 27:21to this for commercial or five plus unit residential.
- 27:25You know, I wish I knew the answer to that off
- 27:27the top of my head. Someone asked me that yesterday,
- 27:30and sort of really the question being, why is
- 27:32this just residential one to four? It kind of
- 27:36logically leads me to believe that maybe there's
- 27:39some other requirement that is satisfying everybody's
- 27:41concerns for five plus or commercial. But unfortunately,
- 27:45I'm just not sure off the top of my head. For
- 27:48whatever reason, this particular rule that went
- 27:50into effect this month is only residential one
- 27:53to four. Well, there are, I think, other suggesting
- 27:57suggested here reporting requirements for the
- 28:00banks who are probably more involved in the commercial
- 28:02transactions. And obviously, this was their focus
- 28:05for money laundering was the residential residential,
- 28:08residential cash purchases. Yeah. Yeah. So if
- 28:11someone and all of this goes away, if if anyone's
- 28:14getting a loan from a sort of conventional bank
- 28:17of any kind, then you don't have to worry about
- 28:19any of this because they're handling all of that
- 28:21on their end. So it really is only for these
- 28:24cash or private lending transactions. All right.
- 28:32So just a couple more things on transactional.
- 28:37Specifically, I wanted to highlight our unsolicited
- 28:41offer attestation. We were just talking briefly
- 28:43about issues relating to rebuilding and fire
- 28:47affected lots. And there was a, you know, there've
- 28:51been All kinds of rules and emergency orders
- 28:53since the fires happened more than a year ago,
- 28:57regulating, prohibiting abusive practices, people
- 28:59coming in and trying to take advantage and buy
- 29:02up damaged properties or vacant lots cheap and
- 29:05limit that, cut out any predatory behavior. That
- 29:08was originally being done through executive orders
- 29:11and things, but as of October of last year, it
- 29:15is now California law that there is a prohibition
- 29:18on making unsolicited offers in Certain zip codes
- 29:22basically fire affected zip codes. I don't know
- 29:27if you don't have the list of the zip codes actually
- 29:28take it back we do it's in the title so if you
- 29:31want to see what zip codes are affected it's
- 29:32right up there at the top. I like I said this
- 29:35has been in effect since october tenth and so
- 29:39if for any transaction that is closing in one
- 29:43of these affected zip codes. This attestation
- 29:48or one in a substantially similar format. has
- 29:51to be signed and it has to be recorded with the
- 29:54deed at the time the transaction closes. And
- 29:57so what they're attesting to is that basically
- 30:00the property was listed for sale by the owner
- 30:04or their agent and it was marketed on either
- 30:08the multiple listing service or a publicly available
- 30:10marketing platform. You know the owner had a
- 30:14for sale sign on the property or advertise it
- 30:17in a print publication or public place or otherwise
- 30:20the owner publicly indicated their willingness
- 30:22to sell the property basically saying. We need
- 30:26we need you to a test we need you to promise
- 30:28that this is not a circumstance where you buyer
- 30:31were just cold calling people who weren't otherwise
- 30:34interested in selling their properties to try
- 30:36to get them to sell to you. We want to know that
- 30:39this was a voluntary choice the seller made and
- 30:41that they actually. you know we're publicly marketing
- 30:44the property or otherwise going on the record
- 30:46with yes i'm offering my property for sale great
- 30:49buyer by that property but trying to weed out
- 30:53people making unsolicited offers and so. This
- 30:57has to be like i said recorded with the deed
- 31:00is quite possible that i know i don't know if
- 31:02that's frozen title companies have their own
- 31:04versions of this or anything like that we wanted
- 31:06to make sure it was available so that if somebody
- 31:08is. closing an escrow in any of these zip codes.
- 31:12And I will say it's just in any of these zip
- 31:16codes. It's not, and there are parts of these
- 31:19zip codes that, you know, could just be a house
- 31:21that was otherwise unaffected by the fires. Doesn't
- 31:23matter if you're closing an escrow in that zip
- 31:25code. Make sure that no one's making a unsolicited
- 31:29offer to begin with and that the attestation
- 31:32is recorded when the transaction closes with
- 31:35the grant date. All right. So couple agency notes
- 31:44before we in the end of this program talk more
- 31:47about landlord tenant issues. But I want to talk
- 31:50about our listing agreement and our buyer representation
- 31:53agreement. Those of course have also been evolving
- 31:56a lot over the past couple of years. I want to
- 31:59highlight this line item here in paragraph to
- 32:04see of our residential listing agreement. This
- 32:06is new. If you follow residential real estate
- 32:11or the goings on with organized real estate NAR,
- 32:14you might have seen some discussion about this
- 32:16at the end of last year. A lot of talk about
- 32:19referral fees, payment of referral fees, and
- 32:22transparency relating to that. And so there's
- 32:27a lot of discussion about it. And this is Been
- 32:30sort of discussed for a long time there have
- 32:31always been rules in place whether it's in the
- 32:35bmp code or the realtor code of ethics or just
- 32:38fiduciary duty concepts for people to be disclosing
- 32:42if they are receiving compensation of any kind
- 32:45right and that compensation could be for referring
- 32:48a client to somebody else and so. We have a form.
- 32:53I don't have a picture of it today, but we do
- 32:55have a form that can be used to make this disclosure
- 32:58of realtor acknowledgement and disclosure form.
- 33:00But what is sort of important to know here is
- 33:03that in the listing agreement and also in the
- 33:05buyer representation agreement, there is now
- 33:07a place. If the broker is paying a referral fee
- 33:10related to the representation of that of that
- 33:12client, they can disclose that and attach the
- 33:17disclosure that basically says as much. I am
- 33:20paying a referral fee. if I close a deal with
- 33:23you. And the disclosure also should be made by
- 33:26the person who is actually the one receiving
- 33:28that referral fee. And maybe they've already
- 33:31done that at the time the referral was made.
- 33:33I've talked to people who say, oh yeah, we've
- 33:35always done this. We get the client to initial
- 33:36on the referral fee agreement. If that's a practice
- 33:39people already have, that's fantastic as well.
- 33:41But we just wanted to make sure this wasn't getting
- 33:43missed by anybody. So now both in the listing
- 33:46agreement and in the buyer representation agreement.
- 33:49there is a place to indicate the payment of a
- 33:51referral fee and attach the document that's going
- 33:55to be used to make that disclosure, which can
- 33:58also be used as a standalone by the person receiving
- 34:00the referral fee as well. All right. And then
- 34:06one more note on the listing agreement. And this
- 34:08is another development based on another new law
- 34:11that went into effect on January 1st. You might
- 34:14have heard of this new law relating to The use
- 34:18of digitally altered images in advertising. And
- 34:21so this has been a hot topic in real estate for
- 34:23a long time and fairly common for a long time.
- 34:26The concept of digital staging, you know, showing
- 34:28what a vacant property would look like with furniture
- 34:30in it or maybe taking the furniture out. But
- 34:34there. our long -standing concerns about truth
- 34:37in advertising, avoiding misrepresentation. I'm
- 34:40sure plenty of people have looked at a advertising
- 34:43for a property and then gone to see the property
- 34:45and feel like they're not looking at the same
- 34:47thing they saw in the photos online. And so now
- 34:50there are very specific rules about what has
- 34:53to be disclosed and what information has to be
- 34:55provided if the property is being advertised
- 34:58with what the law calls digitally altered images.
- 35:02And just to be clear, It doesn't include standard
- 35:07photo editing, brightness, sharpening, you know,
- 35:09you take a photo on your smartphone and it kind
- 35:11of automatically brightens it up and looks nice.
- 35:13They're not worried about that. It really is
- 35:16digitally modifying the property, changing the
- 35:18paint color, putting in. furniture, taking it
- 35:21out, changing the view outside the window, whether
- 35:24that's removing a utility pole, or I heard an
- 35:28anecdote from someone where they did a sky replacement
- 35:30and put a beautiful sunset that you could see
- 35:32out the window only for a prospective buyer to
- 35:35come to the property and realize that that window.
- 35:38face the direction that you would never see the
- 35:40sun set from that direction. So let's see it
- 35:43out. Photographers have a lot of tricks they
- 35:45get up to. Long story short, if you're going
- 35:47to have digital altered images in advertising,
- 35:53what the real estate licensee has to do is one,
- 35:56disclose that the image has been digitally altered
- 35:58either on or like in a caption immediately adjacent
- 36:01to the image and then provide a way for the consumer
- 36:07to see the unaltered image. That could be a link,
- 36:10it could be a QR code, or they could just, you
- 36:13know, depending on the type of advertising at
- 36:16play, right? If it's a flyer or something, you're
- 36:18probably going to have a QR code. If it's on
- 36:20the website or, you know, certain MLSs, multiple
- 36:23listing services have certain rules, you just
- 36:26include the unaltered photo immediately preceding
- 36:30or following the altered one. And I've already
- 36:32started noticing this. I was scrolling through
- 36:35some listings on some publicly available websites
- 36:38earlier this week and started seeing an altered
- 36:41image with an unaltered image behind it. So that
- 36:44was good to know. But that's been sort of one
- 36:47of the hottest new laws that we've been talking
- 36:49to licensees about this year is this use of digitally
- 36:52altered images. And so now we have a provision
- 36:55in the listing agreement that talks about it
- 36:59so that sellers understand what you know why
- 37:03agent why are you including you know you you
- 37:05fix it up to look so nice why are you including
- 37:07the unedited version well because the law says
- 37:10we have to so it's in the listing agreement so
- 37:12there's no confusion about that all right and
- 37:17then by representation agreements by representation
- 37:20and broker compensation just a couple of updates
- 37:24here but i wanted to highlight this one because
- 37:26this is once again, tied to a legal development
- 37:30that went into effect on the first of the year.
- 37:33I mentioned before that we've kind of had this
- 37:35evolving regulation of buyer representation agreements
- 37:39started with the settlement in 2024. Then January
- 37:421, 2025, AB 2992 was passed, which was the California
- 37:47law mandating buyer representation agreements.
- 37:50And that law lined up in some ways with the requirements
- 37:53of the NAR settlement. but not others in some
- 37:56ways it was more expansive or in some ways it
- 37:59was more restrictive and so you know we've had
- 38:03kind of this year of okay there's certain settlement
- 38:05requirements there's certain legal requirements
- 38:06and then like with any. Law that gets passed
- 38:10people start finding the ambiguities the points
- 38:12of confusion in it and so what we finally got
- 38:15on january first was a new set of department
- 38:18of real estate regulations applying to an interpreting
- 38:21that particular law so the d re came out and
- 38:24said okay. You know here's what you two nine
- 38:27nine two says here's. what it actually means
- 38:30from our enforcement perspective and one of the
- 38:33one of the significant ones relates to a mandatory
- 38:36time period for biorepresentation the law said
- 38:39three months maximum and a three month deadlines
- 38:44seem to be more confusing than i think anyone
- 38:46might have really expected how do you count three
- 38:48months and doesn't that make it uneven if you
- 38:51have february in the mix versus july and so the
- 38:54re said that's. not worth any confusion over
- 38:57and they came out and said well three months
- 38:59means 90 days. So the maximum buyer representation
- 39:03agreement period is 90 days no matter when it's
- 39:08entered into or what time of year. You'll see
- 39:11we have a note here in the representation period
- 39:14sort of a bit of a safety clause which says okay.
- 39:18establish what your representation time period
- 39:20is, that the representation period shall end
- 39:23either on the ending date specified above or
- 39:2690 days from the beginning date, whichever is
- 39:28sooner. So a little bit of a safety clause in
- 39:31there to say no matter what you write in here,
- 39:33that legal maximum of 90 days is the maximum
- 39:36representation period. The DRE also clarified
- 39:39that yes, you can do a renewal. for 90 days as
- 39:42well. That's been the biggest pushback I've gotten
- 39:45from practitioners over the past couple of years,
- 39:48which is just markets can be really hard. Buyers
- 39:51can't always find a property in three months
- 39:53or 90 days. You know, and that that's not surprising
- 39:57to me, especially in certain parts of the state.
- 40:00But Renewals are okay. They're just also capped
- 40:03at 90 days, and they're capped at 90 days from
- 40:05the date the renewal is signed. So you can't
- 40:08enter into an agreement and then automatically
- 40:10extend it for 90 days. But if you get towards
- 40:12the end and the parties want to renew, they can
- 40:15do a 90 -day renewal from the date that that
- 40:19is signed. All right. And last thing on buyer
- 40:24representation, periods. Just a note there. You
- 40:26can see I also highlighted we have the same disclosure
- 40:30about payments of a referral fee on paragraph
- 40:33E4 there on the buyer side as we do on the listing
- 40:36side. And then we added some clarity to our paragraph
- 40:40relating to continuation periods. So this is
- 40:43the provision that says, okay, even after the
- 40:48transaction expires or if it is canceled, you
- 40:51know, there may be a continued right to compensation.
- 40:54for the broker for certain, what are called broker
- 40:57involved properties. And this is to try to prevent
- 40:59any sort of practice of, okay, I'll get a broker
- 41:03to show me a bunch of properties and then I'll
- 41:05just immediately cancel or wait out the expiration
- 41:08and then, you know, cut someone out of the deal
- 41:10and go buy the property. And so, and it's optional.
- 41:13This time period does not have to be filled in.
- 41:15People can just say, no, when we're done, we're
- 41:16done. But if this is what they want to agree
- 41:18to, they can say for a set number of days, you
- 41:22know, I'm entitled to continuing compensation
- 41:25if the buyer ends up purchasing one of those
- 41:28properties with broker involvement. And we just
- 41:30clarified what the triggering date is when that
- 41:34sort of continuation period begins, that it can
- 41:36be either at the end of the representation period
- 41:39when the contract expires or if it's canceled,
- 41:43then it's from the effective date of the cancellation.
- 41:48I think logically, that's always how it made
- 41:50sense, but this makes it crystal clear that that's
- 41:54what the rule is. So, and I will say I get the
- 41:56question a lot. Is there a maximum time period
- 41:58for continuation periods? It's not discussed
- 42:00in the law because this is a concept from our
- 42:02contract and not from AB 2992 or the regs or
- 42:06anything. But I do advise people to maybe keep
- 42:09it to 90 days to be consistent with the representation
- 42:12and renewal time limits. Jane, I think reflecting
- 42:17some of the ongoing confusion we have about these
- 42:20buyer representation agreements, we have a couple
- 42:23of other inquiries. Someone asked me to speak
- 42:27about the buyer broker agreement and the buyer
- 42:30needing to agree to pay the buyer's agents commission
- 42:32even if the seller declines to do so. But I think,
- 42:36you know, it just shows where people are not
- 42:39quite understanding the sequence and the absolutely
- 42:42new agreements. And along with that is a question
- 42:44about where the buyer buyer representation agreements
- 42:46typically entered into. So absolutely sort of
- 42:49run through that sequence and how that works.
- 42:52For sure so yeah this was sort of the this sequencing
- 42:56has been the big change over the past two years
- 43:00when this concept was introduced and so how it
- 43:04works now under the settlement rules and california
- 43:07law. Is that the buyer does our buyers agents
- 43:11do need to enter into a by representation agreement
- 43:14with their clients basically when they start
- 43:17working with them and prior to showing them.
- 43:20any properties. And I will say that specific
- 43:23rule about prior to showing properties, that
- 43:25language is in the NAR settlement. But the California
- 43:29law says it needs to be entered into as soon
- 43:31as practicable. And the DRE regulations have
- 43:35now created a rebuttable presumption that as
- 43:38soon as practicable does mean prior to showing.
- 43:40So we kind of circled all the way around to that
- 43:44being the final answer, which is, you know, prior
- 43:47to showing them a property, prior to driving
- 43:49out somewhere or even getting online and looking,
- 43:52doing a virtual tour, the expectation and the
- 43:55requirement frankly is that yes, buyers and buyer's
- 43:57agents will enter into a buyer representation
- 44:00agreement. And then, so the natural next question
- 44:03that somebody asked about how compensation works
- 44:05is that has to specify the compensation amount
- 44:09that the buyer, that the buyer's agent is gonna
- 44:11earn. And it's a contract between the buyer and
- 44:13their agent. So yes, the buyer is agreeing Agent
- 44:16i will compensate you x amount for representing
- 44:21me if we successfully close a transaction and
- 44:24maybe they do you know it's i'm gonna tell you
- 44:27right now that's probably not the most common
- 44:28way this plays out but sure the buyer could absolutely
- 44:31say yeah. Okay, I will pay you. This is a contract
- 44:33between me and you. We can negotiate whatever
- 44:36amount we see fit. And buyer's agreeing they're
- 44:38the one who's going to pay. But like we talked
- 44:40about at the very beginning in the purchase agreement,
- 44:42that's what that 3G3 section in the RPA is all
- 44:45about. That is a place where when the buyer writes
- 44:48the offer, the buyer can say, hey, seller, you
- 44:51know, I don't have or, you know, for whatever
- 44:53reason, whether I don't have or I just don't
- 44:55want, it doesn't really matter why. Seller, I'm
- 44:58asking you out of your proceeds to pay. the compensation
- 45:01that's going to go to the buyer's agent. And
- 45:03that obviously is also totally negotiable. The
- 45:07seller can say, yes, absolutely. The buyer seller
- 45:10can say, absolutely not. Or they can say, well,
- 45:12I don't want to pay that amount. I'll pay a lower
- 45:15amount. And if the seller says that they'll pay
- 45:18a lesser amount or they'll pay nothing, then
- 45:21contractually the buyer does owe their broker
- 45:25that compensation. if they end up proceeding
- 45:27with that transaction. It remains negotiable
- 45:32between them if the broker wants to reduce their
- 45:35compensation amount or make some other sort of
- 45:38arrangement. That's going to just depend on all
- 45:43the parties involved. But contractually, yeah,
- 45:45that's the idea. The buyer has agreed that they'll
- 45:47pay that amount. And then they can use the RPA
- 45:50to ask the seller and see what happens from there.
- 45:53So how does that work, Jana, if the listing agent
- 45:56has a 5 % commission and then... buyer's representation
- 46:00agreement is a dollar amount that's less than
- 46:02half of that. Is the listing broker getting a
- 46:06windfall of more than half of the commission
- 46:08out of that? Or is the seller going to come back
- 46:11and say, wait, the commission should be reduced
- 46:12now? Yeah, so great question. So that's one of
- 46:15the things that changed, right, is that when
- 46:18these new buyer representation rules went into
- 46:19effect, our listing agreements now specify that
- 46:24the compensation, and let me see if I have...
- 46:28Right, so if you look at paragraph 2C1 there,
- 46:32the compensation for seller's broker, you'll
- 46:34see it says only seller's side of the transaction.
- 46:37So the idea is listing agent enters into a contract
- 46:41with their seller and says, okay seller, you
- 46:44are going to pay me, just me, I'm not gonna share
- 46:47it with anybody, it's not going elsewhere, you're
- 46:49going to pay me X amount for representing you.
- 46:53And then the conversation they have with their
- 46:55client is, You know buyers are entering into
- 46:58agreement to pay their agent when they submit
- 47:00an offer they might ask you to pay money to pay
- 47:03that agent at that time but you know the amount
- 47:07the sellers agreeing to the listing agreement
- 47:09is exclusively how much they're paying their
- 47:11own agent for representing them so there shouldn't
- 47:14be any windfall or anything like that it's just
- 47:16this is how much i'm earning and then it's up
- 47:18to the seller how much if anything they're then
- 47:20willing to contribute to the buyers agents. and
- 47:23your section section c2 here says that the that
- 47:27listing agent the seller's broker is going to
- 47:29get more if they also represent the buyer if
- 47:33so that this section is a little bit tricky and
- 47:37it's evolved a lot too what c2 is saying is it
- 47:40is asking if the if the seller is willing to
- 47:45pay the agent extra money if they are dealing
- 47:47with an unrepresented buyer. So not for a dual
- 47:50agency, but truly an unrepresented buyer. And
- 47:53I can tell you just policy wise, this is in there
- 47:56and was put in there because there was a fear
- 47:58at the time when all of these rules went into
- 48:01effect that there may be a flood of unrepresented
- 48:04buyers. Buyers who say, well, I'm not going to
- 48:06sign a buyer rep agreement. I think I can do
- 48:08this on my own. I'm going to come in here and
- 48:11do the transaction. And the concern being Okay
- 48:14well if they're gonna do that that's probably
- 48:16gonna be a lot of extra work for the listing
- 48:18agent involved and if they're not representing
- 48:20that buyer they don't have a buyer rep agreement
- 48:22to get paid by them they're just dealing with
- 48:24a lot of extra headaches so they could with their
- 48:27seller agree hey if we find ourselves in this
- 48:29circumstance. I'll get additional compensation
- 48:32for all of the extra work that would go into
- 48:35that particular type of transaction. I have not
- 48:38got a lot of questions about this. I don't get
- 48:40the sense that it's happening really that often
- 48:42at all. I think most buyers still need and know
- 48:45they need assistance and are working with agents,
- 48:49but that's what that's there for. Just if there
- 48:51is a truly unrepresented buyer and if that might
- 48:55increase the listing agent's compensation. And
- 48:58if there's being a dual agent, is that? Come
- 49:00under then then they would have if they're a
- 49:03dual agent they have their buyer their representation
- 49:05agreement with the buyer as well and so you know
- 49:08and it it works contractually it works the same
- 49:11way obviously practically you know the conversations
- 49:13could look different but. It still doesn't have
- 49:16a conflict with that clause where they start
- 49:19the buyer wants to ask the seller to pay their
- 49:21side of the commission because now the brokers
- 49:24squarely in the middle of that negotiation on
- 49:27both sides. Yeah, I mean, it's, you know, dual
- 49:29agency is a very fraught, I think, set of circumstances.
- 49:33But yeah, that's they're going to have a representation
- 49:35agreement with each client. And then the seller
- 49:38can decide how if they want to contribute to.
- 49:42the compensation that's designated as being for
- 49:44the buyer's representation. So we have a question
- 49:47about open houses and representation agreements
- 49:49and they're asking what do you think about requiring
- 49:54people viewing a property at an open house to
- 49:57sign a buyer representation agreement? So it's
- 50:00not necessary. I can tell you both from this
- 50:03is another thing that was in the NAR settlement
- 50:05and the new DRE regulation specifically Clarify
- 50:09this as well, the DRE regs specifically say that
- 50:13if you are showing the property in the capacity
- 50:16as the seller's agent or the listing agent only,
- 50:19it could be in an open house, it could even just
- 50:20be as a showing. But if you are the listing agent
- 50:24and you are sort of making the property available
- 50:28in that capacity, that's not considered working
- 50:31with a buyer at that point in order to. have
- 50:36to have a representation agreement to show them
- 50:37the property. You can just say, I'm here in my
- 50:39capacity as the seller's agent, here's the house.
- 50:43But what if you want to be signing up these people
- 50:46to be representing them on that or maybe other
- 50:49properties? Is it still acceptable, you think,
- 50:52to get that by a representation agreement from
- 50:54somebody coming unrepresented to an open house?
- 50:57So I would say that that would be a conversation
- 50:59for sellers to have or listing agents to have
- 51:01with their sellers, right? Because maybe that's
- 51:03going to keep some people from not wanting to
- 51:04come in if this is a requirement of viewing the
- 51:06property. So you want to make sure the sellers
- 51:08on board with that. But that, you know, obviously,
- 51:12if they're already represented, your hands are
- 51:14probably tied. But if it's an unrepresented buyer,
- 51:16you know, it would it would really be I would
- 51:20say need to be a conversation had with the seller
- 51:22of how do you want me to handle this? Are you
- 51:23comfortable with this policy? and making sure
- 51:27the seller is on board. Very good. Thank you
- 51:33We're once again our last 10 minutes and I want
- 51:36to make sure we can talk about these landlord
- 51:39tenant issues I think we will be able to get
- 51:42it in just fine So yeah switching gears in our
- 51:45last 10 minutes or so here There are of course
- 51:48once again new tenant protection laws new laws
- 51:51that landlords in California have to comply with
- 51:53just like we see Every year and frankly, it feels
- 51:56like multiple times a year The biggest and most
- 51:59significant one that everyone's dealing with
- 52:01right now is AB 628, which amended civil code
- 52:061941 .1, which is the habitability requirements.
- 52:10So I think most people are familiar with certain
- 52:12habitability requirements. You need to have doors
- 52:15that lock. You need to have hot and cold running
- 52:16water. You need to have a heat, you know, a working
- 52:19heat source. Right. Well, now also that list
- 52:23includes. a working stove and refrigerator. So
- 52:27the list of habitability characteristics now
- 52:29includes a stove that is maintained in good working
- 52:31order and capable of safely generating heat,
- 52:34and a refrigerator that is maintained in good
- 52:36working order and capable of safely storing food.
- 52:40And the reactions has been interesting. A lot
- 52:43of people were surprised that stoves weren't
- 52:46already required, but they weren't. There was
- 52:48no requirement to have a stove until now. But
- 52:50the bigger sort of hurdle for people to clear
- 52:54is the refrigerator issue, because it's really
- 52:56common. I think actually more in the greater
- 52:58Los Angeles area, people in other parts of the
- 53:00state are like, oh, I've never seen a rental
- 53:02without a fridge. So this can vary a lot, but
- 53:05it's kind of common from what I've heard and
- 53:07frankly, in my own historical experience, for
- 53:10rentals in Los Angeles to not have a refrigerator
- 53:12and tenant that's just on you. And that is no
- 53:15longer going to be allowed. Now a refrigerator
- 53:19has to at least be offered to be provided. And
- 53:22we'll look at what the technical rules are. Just
- 53:25to get ahead of a few different questions, the
- 53:27kind of questions I've been getting is, is there
- 53:28a minimum size the refrigerator has to be? No,
- 53:32we're literally looking at the text of what the
- 53:34requirement is, but I always tell people. don't
- 53:38get cute with habitability requirements. I wouldn't
- 53:41want to be standing in front of a judge defending
- 53:43the little dorm size mini fridge that I put in
- 53:46my rental property as a refrigerator. It doesn't
- 53:49have to be brand new. It just has to be maintained
- 53:51in good working order. Does it have to have a
- 53:54freezer? The law doesn't say capable of safely
- 53:58storing food. I think you could craft an argument
- 54:00that that might include an ability to freeze
- 54:02things. That might be sort of a conservative
- 54:05approach to say, yeah, I should have a freezer.
- 54:07But does it have to have an ice maker or filtered
- 54:10water or anything like that? No, just a refrigerator
- 54:13that works that can safely store food. Now, this
- 54:18is a habitability requirement that in a certain
- 54:20way is kind of waivable, unlike most habitability
- 54:23requirements. The tenant, because maybe they
- 54:25have their own fridge and they say, I don't want
- 54:27yours. I want to bring my own fridge. Well, they
- 54:29can choose to supply their own refrigerator if.
- 54:33As long as the lease retain contains a required
- 54:36notice about their rights also though. The lease
- 54:40has to allow them to change their mind so they
- 54:43can say i'm bringing my own fridge but at any
- 54:45point let's say their fridge breaks and they
- 54:47don't want to buy a new one. They can give a
- 54:49thirty day notice the landlord and now the landlord
- 54:51does have to provide a refrigerator and this
- 54:55is not something the lamp landlord can't make
- 54:57this mandatory they can't say i'm only going
- 54:59to rent to you if you. sign you know agree that
- 55:02you're bringing your own fridge um it has to
- 55:04be voluntarily entered into and this new rule
- 55:08applies to leases that were entered into extended
- 55:11or amended after january 1st so if something
- 55:15has someone's been in a fixed term lease since
- 55:17before then nothing has to change but if that
- 55:21lease um is going to be you know signed and extended
- 55:25for another year then This all needs to be dealt
- 55:29with and for existing month to month tenancies
- 55:32it's not one hundred percent clear but what.
- 55:37The sort of most logical interpretation of the
- 55:39law seems to be as soon as you amend that so
- 55:43if you're gonna do a rent increase or anything
- 55:45that's gonna modify the terms of month to month
- 55:47tenancy that is when this requirement is going
- 55:50to kick in. So, of course, we have updated our
- 55:53forms to address these issues. We also do note
- 55:58there are some exceptions to this requirement.
- 56:01So permanent supportive housing, single room
- 56:03occupancy, residential hotel, you know, something
- 56:07with communal kitchen space. It also doesn't
- 56:10apply to true vacation short term rentals of
- 56:1229 days or fewer. Otherwise. Rental agreements
- 56:16need to have the notice the language that's included
- 56:18in eleven be there letting them know that the
- 56:21law requires the landlord to provide them a refrigerator
- 56:24that's kept in working order and stove. But if
- 56:28they have they're being asked to acknowledge
- 56:31if they want to bring their own refrigerator
- 56:33that is something they are doing by choice and
- 56:36there is a checkbox them there for them to indicate
- 56:38that but again of course they can change their
- 56:40mind at any point. on 30 days notice. So this
- 56:43is in our standard residential lease and month
- 56:45-to -month agreement, and it's also in our extension
- 56:47of lease and our change in terms of tenancy forms
- 56:50as well. Does this stove and refrigerator requirement
- 56:53apply to guest units within a multifamily building?
- 56:58Like an ADU, for example, it seems to. If they
- 57:04have their own kitchen space of any kind, then
- 57:11it's not like it's a single room occupancy, right?
- 57:14It's not like you're renting out a room. If you're
- 57:16renting out a room, that's fine. But if it's
- 57:18an ADU and the tenants are residing in it, then
- 57:24yeah, it seems like that is going to apply in
- 57:26that circumstance. What is the remedy if the
- 57:28landlord refuses to provide the refrigerator?
- 57:31So it is because it's included on the list of
- 57:35habitability requirements. It's the same potential
- 57:38remedies for any non - Non habitability claims
- 57:41theoretically so you know withholding rents defense
- 57:46to an unlawful detainer action deduct you know.
- 57:51Buy it themselves and then deduct it from the
- 57:53rent theoretically so yeah it's a it would be
- 57:57considered a non habitability claim just like
- 57:59if the landlord didn't fix a broken heater or
- 58:02something like that. And if the tenant had already
- 58:04bought the refrigerator before this law came
- 58:06into effect, they can just leave it there, or
- 58:08I guess they can take it out and ask for a refrigerator.
- 58:11Yeah, that's correct. All right. So with our
- 58:15last minute, I just had one more landlord tenant
- 58:18law I wanted to mention, which is yet another
- 58:22new rule for the handling of security deposits.
- 58:25We've also seen the security deposit law change
- 58:27so much over the past couple of years. This year's
- 58:30change is that now there is a new rule that if
- 58:35the security deposit was paid electronically,
- 58:38then by default, the landlord has to return that
- 58:43deposit electronically. Previously, they could
- 58:46just send a check. But if the deposit was paid
- 58:49electronically, the landlord has to return it
- 58:51electronically, also presuming that there was
- 58:54only one tenant. If there are multiple tenants,
- 58:58then The default is still okay it's gonna be
- 59:01returned via check in all of the tenants names
- 59:04unless the tenants elect otherwise in writing
- 59:07which they have to be given the opportunity to
- 59:10do also the default is still that the itemized
- 59:13list of deductions is going to be provided by
- 59:15mail. that they can elect to have that sent electronically
- 59:18as well. And this all needs to happen at the
- 59:21termination of the tenancy. So in our notice
- 59:25of right to pre move out inspection, as well
- 59:27as our pre move out inspection form itself, we
- 59:29have the required notice letting the tenant know
- 59:32about this rule and that their deposit will be
- 59:35electronically if they returned if the conditions
- 59:37are met. And then also giving them the opportunity
- 59:41to request that their itemized statement be sent
- 59:43via email or If they even if they didn't pay
- 59:47the deposit electronically or there's multiple
- 59:50tenants or something along those lines they can
- 59:52opt in and provide information to have the deposit
- 59:55returned electronically as well. Two more questions.
- 1:00:01Someone has asked if you could provide information
- 1:00:04for attorneys to get access to the CAR forms.
- 1:00:07My understanding is that you might get exemplars,
- 1:00:12but the forms, you have to sign up with CAR,
- 1:00:15right? Yes. My understanding is that it is possible
- 1:00:21for attorneys to purchase access. I don't know
- 1:00:24what the current rules are as well. But if someone
- 1:00:28wants to send me an email, I can connect them
- 1:00:30to the best person at CAR that handles those
- 1:00:33sorts of things. So JanaG, J -A -N -A -G, at
- 1:00:38car .org. If they want to get in touch with me,
- 1:00:41I can put them in touch with the people that
- 1:00:43handle all that stuff. um that you can always
- 1:00:48send a request to me i'll forward it on another
- 1:00:51question are you aware of a situation where about
- 1:00:54when a buyer refers us to pay the buyer's broker
- 1:00:57and the buyer's broker steers the buyer to properties
- 1:00:59where a commission will be paid i guess assuming
- 1:01:02they're saying it'll be paid by the seller but
- 1:01:05right i know i'm going to be very honest with
- 1:01:07you no i have not heard about that um you know
- 1:01:11the the whole point of all of these rules and
- 1:01:13everything is so that exact thing doesn't happen
- 1:01:16and that you know, compensation is completely
- 1:01:18negotiable between clients and their own agents.
- 1:01:21And then principal to principal buyer and seller
- 1:01:24with each offer that is submitted. And so that
- 1:01:28is that is what is happening out there. There's
- 1:01:31there's nothing new on background checks of Tenant
- 1:01:33Scissor. Not this year, not recently, no. I know
- 1:01:38there's been additional rules over those the
- 1:01:40past few years in terms of if you do a background
- 1:01:42check and having to basically you know tell them
- 1:01:45what the results of it were and how they can
- 1:01:46see their own information and all of that but
- 1:01:49nothing's changed in the past couple years. So
- 1:01:51I want to thank everyone for attending we had
- 1:01:53a very big group here today and a huge thank
- 1:01:56you to Jana you're always fantastic and on top
- 1:01:59of everything and field we had a lot of questions
- 1:02:02today and all of them got answered so thank you
- 1:02:04so much and we're so happy that you joined us
- 1:02:08again this year thank you. You're so welcome
- 1:02:09it's always great to be here thanks for having
- 1:02:11me.