Latest / Film And Whiskey / American Sniper / Rebel 10-Year Single Barrel Bourbon Whiskey
Transcript
- 0:00In 2014, director Clint Eastwood and star Bradley Cooper gave the
- 0:05world a brutal introspection into the eternal cost of war.
- 0:10In 2024, Brad, we get to try our favorite brand once again.
- 0:15A very expensive version of it the film is American Sniper.
- 0:20The whiskey is Rebel Single Barrel 10 year bourbon.
- 0:24And we'll review them both. This is.
- 0:27The Film and Whiskey podcast Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:49podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:52glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:55I'm Brad G. And this week we are in 2014 to
- 0:58look at the highest grossing film of that year, Clint
- 1:01Eastwood's American Sniper. Bob, Clint Eastwood is just the
- 1:08wildest of directors 'cause I don't know if we have many
- 1:12directors who have a starred in a bunch of movies, starred in
- 1:18television shows, became a director, directed.
- 1:22Probably. He's probably directed like 40
- 1:24films and like 32 of them are average to bad.
- 1:29And eight of them are like, I don't know, is this going to be
- 1:32a best picture for the year? Yeah, I mean, listen, he's
- 1:35batting 250. Like, that's a that's an
- 1:37acceptable batting average in the Major League. 100% man.
- 1:41And I like, dare I say it, I think American Sniper might be
- 1:46my favorite of his films that we've watched.
- 1:49I've been interested to hear what's going to come out of this
- 1:51episode, Brad. So let me give a little bit of
- 1:53context. About a year ago, we were in one
- 1:56of our director based seasons where we were watching four to
- 2:00five films from a director to try to get a sense of who they
- 2:03are, what they thematically like to make movies about.
- 2:06And Clint Eastwood was one of those directors.
- 2:09And at the time we looked at Unforgiven, Mystic River, we
- 2:13revisited $1,000,000 Baby for our patrons.
- 2:16What else did we watch from Clint Eastwood at the time,
- 2:18Brad? Oh man, I honestly I can't
- 2:22remember right now. We've watched a lot of Clint
- 2:25Eastwood films, Bob. Yeah, we sure have.
- 2:27And Eastwood's an interesting director because in our very
- 2:31charged political times, I think people have really started,
- 2:34especially people on the left have really started to criticize
- 2:36Clint Eastwood. And I think in a really
- 2:38reductionistic way, they see him as a conservative director, even
- 2:43though his films don't always follow suit with that.
- 2:47Gran Torino was one of the films we watched, Brad.
- 2:49And I think if any movie is ever going to label Clint Eastwood as
- 2:52like, a black and white, sort of, you know, conservative, it
- 2:56would be Gran Torino. And I think it's unfair to
- 3:00Eastwood, though, to suggest that he's not dealing with much
- 3:03murkier waters and that he's not implicating both sides of the
- 3:06aisle in a lot of his films. And this is no exception.
- 3:09And I think this movie, I wanted to wait until we got to this
- 3:12season to talk about American Sniper because it it deserves
- 3:16its own conversation. As Eastwood got older and people
- 3:19started lobbing these really easy to throw.
- 3:21You are conservative, so therefore you are bad takes.
- 3:25I think this movie really became the victim of that.
- 3:28And that's not really what this movie's a about at all.
- 3:32And BI think it's a really bad faith reading of the movie to
- 3:35assume the portrayal of what happened to 1 soldier therefore
- 3:41is A what Clint Eastwood thinks about war or B is an endorsement
- 3:46of war for the sake of war. Like, it's just a really, really
- 3:49awful reading of this movie and I wanted to get it out of the
- 3:52way now because I I frankly think it's a waste of time to
- 3:56debate it. I just reject that premise
- 3:58altogether. This is a much more complicated
- 4:01and nuanced movie than that. And while it is a flawed movie,
- 4:04I think there are better conversations to have than that
- 4:07one. 100% I think that any time you walk into something that
- 4:14someone has produced and created and you've heard that they are X
- 4:20and your Y, therefore I'm going to find the worst possible
- 4:25reading of this film. Like, that's just boring.
- 4:30Like, I, I don't know, man. Like, sure, people can do that
- 4:33if they want. It's America.
- 4:35This is a free country. I, I would rather have a
- 4:39conversation about how Clint has created here.
- 4:43What I would say is a very nuanced understanding of what it
- 4:49means to be an American at war in the 21st century.
- 4:53I think there's going to be a lot of comparison films brought
- 4:55up today, Brad, because as I was watching this movie and I'm
- 4:58thinking of films we've done on the show that I want to draw
- 5:01comparisons too. But before we get into all that,
- 5:04let me set the stage here. So if you're new to the show,
- 5:07welcome into film and whiskey. The premise is right there in
- 5:10the title. We talk about movies, we drink
- 5:12whiskey this season. What we're doing is we're
- 5:14looking at the highest grossing films of each calendar year from
- 5:181988 to 2019. American Sniper was perhaps
- 5:23among the biggest box office surprises of any film we're
- 5:27going to be talking about this season.
- 5:29It is far and away the most financially successful Clint
- 5:32Eastwood film it and it it's kind of a weird asterisk year
- 5:37for us, Brad, because this movie, while a quote, UN quote
- 5:402014 film, it premiered in four theaters in 2014 and it didn't
- 5:46go nationwide until mid January of 2015.
- 5:51So when I was looking at like the highest grossing in calendar
- 5:54year releases, it was actually like one of The Hunger Games
- 5:57movies. And then it said like, well, by
- 5:59March of 2015, American Sniper had overtaken it.
- 6:03And it's like, yeah, but it made all of its money in a completely
- 6:06different year. So like I I just I hate how
- 6:09Hollywood does that. Please know I understand film
- 6:13and Whiskey Nation that you probably saw this movie in 2015,
- 6:16but you know, too bad we're talking about it today.
- 6:19Yeah, and I'm really glad we are, Bob, because this is an
- 6:23excellent movie that is worth talking about.
- 6:26I do think that the fact that this movie made half a billion
- 6:28dollars is kind of staggering. It's Wildman.
- 6:32It's the highest grossing war film of all time.
- 6:36Adjusted for inflation, I think it's the second highest grossing
- 6:38war movie of all time, Is one of the seven I think movies at the
- 6:43time that was an R rated film to earn $500 million worldwide.
- 6:48And I already said it's it's Eastwood's most successful
- 6:50movie. And because of that, you know,
- 6:51people were expecting, OK, maybe this movie, it came out on MLK
- 6:55weekend. It was a long weekend in January
- 6:57where no one usually goes to the movies.
- 6:59Maybe with the star power of Bradley Cooper and the excellent
- 7:02marketing campaign, this'll earn a couple 100 million bucks.
- 7:05And it went freaking bananas, dude.
- 7:07I remember it was the year we moved to Kentucky.
- 7:10I went to the movie theater that weekend to see something else,
- 7:14and I walked into the lobby and they had set up one of those
- 7:18like velvet rope, like snake things because they're the the
- 7:21line inside the lobby to buy tickets was so long and
- 7:26everybody was going to see American Sniper.
- 7:28It was freaking nuts. I'd never seen anything like it
- 7:30before. This movie was an absolute
- 7:32phenomenon in the worst months of the year, usually for movies.
- 7:37Yeah. So did you end up seeing it?
- 7:39I waited a week, 'cause I didn't want to deal with crowds.
- 7:41I'm just like, I'm not that guy right now.
- 7:43Like, but yeah, I saw it in the theater.
- 7:46It's, you know, and I remember even in the build up to it, it
- 7:49had one of the best trailers for a movie that I had seen in
- 7:52years. It was basically just that scene
- 7:54of him up on the roof looking at the mom and kid who have the
- 7:58grenade. And they just play it out like a
- 8:01full 3 minutes of just an uninterrupted scene basically.
- 8:05And that's the trailer for the movie.
- 8:07It was suspenseful as hell and it worked like crazy because it
- 8:10got people in the theaters. Man, the moment I know we're
- 8:14not, we haven't even done, Brad explains.
- 8:16But the moment when he's back in the barracks and his buddies are
- 8:20trying to like, be like, hey, man, it's no big deal.
- 8:22Like, you popped your cherry, it's OK.
- 8:24Like, doesn't matter how? And they zoom in on Bradley
- 8:29Cooper's face and he, I don't remember the exact line, but he
- 8:32essentially goes like, I didn't think it would be like this.
- 8:35I I already liked Bradley Cooper as an actor.
- 8:42That was the moment for me where I was like, oh, damn, yeah.
- 8:45Like Bradley Cooper's got some chops.
- 8:48Well, we're going to talk about that in detail because this is
- 8:50his movie through and through. But before we get there, let's
- 8:53go to our first segment of the day, which we call Brad
- 8:56explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 8:58movie plots with only 60 seconds ticking on the clock, so let's
- 9:02go ahead and hear your take with this little segment that we
- 9:05call, Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 9:08show where Brad breaks down the plot of the movie that he has
- 9:12has just seen, often for the first time.
- 9:14Brad, how many times have you seen American Sniper?
- 9:171. Oh, this is the first time.
- 9:19Wow. OK, this is the first timer for
- 9:21me. Yeah, It's one of those movies
- 9:24that, like, my brother was in the military in the late 2000s,
- 9:31never went to Iraq, but it always kind of hung over us if
- 9:35he would go or not. And I remember him seeing it and
- 9:39being a big fan of it. And I, I, he gave me the book.
- 9:42I, I never got around to reading it.
- 9:44And so it's always been kind of on the radar.
- 9:47But you know, life happens and it's 10 years later and I, I
- 9:50finally sat down to watch this film.
- 9:52All right, man. Well, I think you just wrapped
- 9:54up watching it a couple hours ago too, so your thoughts are
- 9:57pretty fresh. Let's dive right in, Brad.
- 9:59You have 60 seconds on the clock to break down the plot of the
- 10:02film with full spoilers. So folks, if you haven't seen
- 10:06American Sniper and you don't want it spoiled for you, hit
- 10:08pause here. Go watch the movie and then come
- 10:11back and join us again, Brad, One minute and go.
- 10:15American Sniper is a biopic film about the Navy SEAL Chris Kyle,
- 10:21who was a sniper during the Iraq War of the late 2000s.
- 10:25He that follows him as he joins the SEALS, goes through
- 10:30training, falls in love with his wife Taya and eventually goes to
- 10:36Iraq 4 separate times, has two children and kills a lot of
- 10:41people. It it pits him against a Syrian
- 10:44sniper who is killing U.S. troops and ends with him back in
- 10:52the US and trying to care for other veterans and find his own
- 10:56peace in the midst of that and ends up being killed by one of
- 11:00the veterans who has mental trauma.
- 11:05All right, there it is, American Sniper.
- 11:08Now, Brad, this is, as with most military films that are set in
- 11:12the modern day, there's just some difficulty inherently
- 11:16folded into it when you want to critique a film because, again,
- 11:21we live in politically charged times, but we also live in a
- 11:23time where, you know, the mantra is we need to support our
- 11:26troops. And you and I have have kind of
- 11:29discussed this already in a lot of our episodes, Like, what does
- 11:31it mean to support the troops? Does it mean inherently, you
- 11:35know, automatically approving of everything that they do?
- 11:37That's. I don't think that's the case,
- 11:39and I don't think you do either. But I think this movie unfairly
- 11:44suffered for Eastwood, honestly, portraying both the acts of
- 11:50heroism that Chris Kyle did and he doesn't very matter of a
- 11:54matter of factly. And frankly, like, if there is
- 11:57no big celebration of him and all throughout the movie, he's
- 12:00like, oh, yeah, I do. I have that many kills.
- 12:02All right, cool. And it's so frank and so matter
- 12:05of fact that I think it rubbed some people the wrong way.
- 12:08Again, I think there's there's unfairness in how it's treated,
- 12:12but Eastwood basically just portraying Chris Kyle as a guy
- 12:17who does his job garnered a lot of criticism.
- 12:21And I guess I just want to start today by asking you like when
- 12:24you think about the other movies that we've talked about that
- 12:27fall into this camp. And I think the the main one
- 12:29would be Saving Private Ryan, where we talked a lot about
- 12:33Spielberg getting accused of being jingoistic and you know,
- 12:37that rah rah patriotism. And I don't, I've never seen
- 12:40that film that way. I think that he just says, like,
- 12:43these are guys that were there to do a job.
- 12:45They did a job. And if nothing else, we need to
- 12:49appreciate the fact that they did what they were asked to do.
- 12:53And I think that's kind of what's going on here with
- 12:55Eastwood. But I think Eastwood, honestly,
- 12:57probably what's the word not investigates, interrogates Chris
- 13:04Kyle's motives more than Spielberg interrogates the
- 13:07motives in Saving Private Ryan. And yet he gets even less credit
- 13:10for doing that. So, you know, I'm, I'm wondering
- 13:13Brad, like taken as a whole, what do you think Eastwood's
- 13:17trying to say with this movie? I think that as I as the movie
- 13:24ended and and I'll I'll be honest with you, Bob, I did not
- 13:27know that he passed away. I I had like the ending was
- 13:32truly A twist for me. I mean, the moment you know, she
- 13:36looked the the wife looks at him, Taya and like you see her,
- 13:40you're just kind of like, well, crap.
- 13:42Yep, this isn't good, but it kind of hit me like a like a
- 13:47freaking freight train man. And, and I think the the thought
- 13:51that popped into my head was that Clint seems to have this
- 13:58deep and abiding respect for the US military in one hand.
- 14:05And in the other hand, he holds the belief that war and violence
- 14:11will cost you everything. And, and he holds those two
- 14:16things in tension where he recognizes that there's evil in
- 14:21the world and we have to fight it.
- 14:23And in the act of fighting it, you will lose everything up to
- 14:28and including your life. And I like that is one of the
- 14:34most brutal tensions that I don't think many of us are
- 14:38willing to face. And I think that that's exactly
- 14:41man, we, I think we could just end the episode.
- 14:43I think you you summarize it perfectly.
- 14:45And Eastwood to his credit, leaves you in that tension.
- 14:49And so your reaction to this movie, in my opinion, is totally
- 14:54based on what side of that camp you fall on in regards to that
- 14:58tension, because Eastwood doesn't take a side.
- 15:01And so I think that the criticism, both the criticisms
- 15:03of this film and the celebrations of this film say a
- 15:06lot more about the people watching the movie than the
- 15:09people that made the movie. You said that he holds a respect
- 15:12for the military in one hand and the belief that that violence
- 15:17and war will cost you everything.
- 15:19I think that is a perfect summary, Brad, because it does
- 15:24cost Kyle everything and it reminds me so much of
- 15:28Unforgiven. I think if there's a movie that
- 15:30I'm going to compare this to throughout the day, it's going
- 15:32to be Unforgiven because that's the one where he's really
- 15:35interrogating something to the same extent that he does here in
- 15:38that movie. It's much more about the the
- 15:40mythos of the Old West and the idea of the quote UN quote being
- 15:45a legend and what that does to a person.
- 15:48And that kind of happens here. Like they call him the legend
- 15:51all through the movie, but whereas Unforgiven is about this
- 15:55legendary outlaw and having to embrace this moniker of being
- 16:00like the Angel of Death, this one is much more about the the
- 16:03same sort of burden, but on the opposite side of the coin.
- 16:07What does it mean to deal with being a hero?
- 16:09What does it mean when someone comes up to you and says you
- 16:12saved my life? How do you handle that burden?
- 16:15How can you ever live up to that legend?
- 16:18But also, when you are considered a hero, you're looked
- 16:23at as if you've got it all together, and this guy clearly
- 16:26does not for the entire film. And I think that's the most
- 16:29interesting part of this movie is that it's not shipping on
- 16:34what he did, but it's asking honest, true questions about the
- 16:39guy that is considered the biggest hero is the guy no one
- 16:43checks in on throughout the movie.
- 16:46Yep. And I think if it's
- 16:47interrogating anything, it's interrogating the people around
- 16:49him. It's interrogating himself and
- 16:51why he why his coping mechanism is just to go do more heroic
- 16:55things to kind of paper over what is really going on inside.
- 17:00I I found this movie incredibly fascinating.
- 17:02I don't think that it's critical of Kyle's actions on the
- 17:07battlefield, but it's also it doesn't get enough credit for
- 17:12investigating and interrogating what's going on in his mind.
- 17:15And frankly, Brad, like a lot of biopics that are made by people
- 17:20on the political left about their heroes, don't go this far
- 17:24into questioning motives. And I think Eastwood really
- 17:27deserves more credit than he gets for that.
- 17:30Well, and, and in the midst of that, there, there's no
- 17:33commentary on whether or not they should be at war.
- 17:37Like, like throughout the movie, The people who are depicted as
- 17:41evil are depicted as evil for their actions in the midst of
- 17:44war. And continually Kyle is
- 17:49portrayed as somebody who defends his men.
- 17:53And he's given that that motivation of like, I don't get
- 17:58jazzed about killing people. I get jazzed about defending
- 18:01people. And I, I think that there is an
- 18:04element of importance to that. And at and at the end of the
- 18:08film, it's kind of it leaves you with this question of was it all
- 18:14worth it? And and that like that for me
- 18:19is, is a question that all of us should be facing.
- 18:23Like in the midst of war, in the midst of home life.
- 18:27Kyle continually had this element of like, I want to
- 18:30defend my family and his family extended to veterans who have
- 18:35come back from the war and he cared for them and and tried to
- 18:38help them deal with their own things.
- 18:41And I, I think in the midst of that, you, you see Eastwood
- 18:45struggling with this reality of war and violence and brokenness
- 18:50and, and how it affects the human soul and, and it, it
- 18:54interrogates Kyle to say, Hey, like, was it all worth it?
- 19:00And when, you know, when somebody dies early, I, I just
- 19:04love the moment where she looks at him and says, like, I'm so
- 19:07proud of you. You've done so much to become
- 19:11the man that I've always known that you are, and the brutality
- 19:15of the ending then just it forces you to reckon with like
- 19:20the journey. Yeah, I do think that if there
- 19:23is a part of the movie that I I want to focus on for an extended
- 19:27period of time, it is that ending.
- 19:29So if if it's OK with you, let's set the ending aside for just a
- 19:31little bit because I think we'll come back to it and discuss it
- 19:34more in depth. One of the things I love about
- 19:38the both the script and the way Eastwood portrays this character
- 19:40of of Kyle is that it has a very like 1970s character study vibe
- 19:47to it. You know, we used to get movies
- 19:49about characters that were big flawed people and there wasn't
- 19:52often comment on if their flaws are supposed to be interpreted
- 19:57as good or bad. They just were.
- 19:59There were people who just were and you would go to the movies
- 20:01and be presented with complex people.
- 20:04I think about movies like One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest,
- 20:09right? Like Jack Nicholson in that
- 20:10movie is the guy who I think is. Being sent to the, you know,
- 20:15what do you call it? The I almost said loony bin.
- 20:18That's incredibly offensive, but there you go.
- 20:20Because because of I think he's a rapist in that movie.
- 20:23Like your protagonist is a guy who's convicted of rape.
- 20:26And in this movie, you get Chris Kyle and I, I don't want to draw
- 20:29the comparison between those actions, but what I'm saying is
- 20:33we're in an era of movie making now where audiences on both side
- 20:38of the political divide need to be spoon fed like this guy is
- 20:42bad, this guy is good. And we're going to tell you out
- 20:45loud, this is good and this is bad.
- 20:47This movie's not interested in that.
- 20:49And I appreciate that so much more.
- 20:51Whether that leads to some bad faith readings or not, I'd
- 20:53rather have it this way than the other way.
- 20:56But what I love about the portrayal of Chris Kyle is that
- 21:00from the get go, he is not a perfect person.
- 21:03Like he clearly has no capability of discussing his
- 21:06emotions. You know, you get a flashback to
- 21:08this pivotal moment where his dad kind of gives him his
- 21:11mantra. And I think that you can
- 21:13interpret that scene as like, oh, that him up for life or like
- 21:18that implanted a seed of heroic behavior or both.
- 21:22You know what I mean? Like, I think it's kind of both
- 21:24happening. I love the fact that the first
- 21:27time he gets an idea to join the military, what's he doing?
- 21:31He he got dumped by his girlfriend or he dumped his
- 21:34girlfriend and he has gotten absolutely hammered sitting and
- 21:38watching TV with his brother. And he's angry about what
- 21:41happened with his girlfriend. And he's drunk.
- 21:43And in that moment, he decides to join the military.
- 21:46Like, Eastwood is not, you know, blinking a red alert sign that
- 21:50like, this is not the state of mind he should be in to join the
- 21:53military. But it's presented as this is
- 21:56how it happened. Interpret it for yourself.
- 21:59And I appreciate that because it is possible for a person to both
- 22:02do really good things and to have severe character flaws.
- 22:07And Chris Kyle seems like that kind of person who, you know, I
- 22:10don't want to say that like, his work with veterans was was in
- 22:14any way a character flaw. But he clearly also had some
- 22:17stuff going on psychologically that he needed to deal with.
- 22:20That is presented just as frankly throughout this film.
- 22:23I I guess what I'm saying in a really long winded way, Brad, is
- 22:26I like that Eastwood is not using kid gloves here.
- 22:29And then like a lot of it is just laid out as kind of like
- 22:33unstructured data and you piece it together to make meaning out
- 22:38of it as you see fit. Viewer of this film.
- 22:41Yeah, And even in the way that the girlfriend treats him at the
- 22:46start of the film, like there's a, there's a layered nuance to
- 22:51that where what she accuses him of is true.
- 22:54And that doesn't excuse her actions.
- 22:57But he reckons with the fact that like, you know, she's
- 22:59right. Like I like, I treat her like
- 23:01garbage. I leave her at home.
- 23:03I go do all these things, like, who does that make me as a
- 23:05person? And I, I think that that's kind
- 23:08of where the military catches a lot of their recruits is in
- 23:13young people who are asking themselves, who am I and what am
- 23:18I about? Do I have a purpose in this
- 23:20life? And, and the military provides
- 23:22that with so many people. And I, I think that's why this
- 23:25movie is so successful in that it portrays the entire arc of I
- 23:31don't know who I am. The military gave me I an
- 23:34identity. Who am I if the military is not
- 23:38my identity? And, and it follows that entire
- 23:41arc. And I think for the first time
- 23:45I've watched a Clint Eastwood movie and said, like, I think
- 23:49Clint actually has some nuance in his bones cause like that.
- 23:54Like what is our one critique of, of, of Eastwood constantly,
- 23:59Bob. Like, I mean, it's not even just
- 24:01that he has no nuance, it's that he finds actors who have no
- 24:04nuance too. Like just to double down on.
- 24:07Like, do you get what I'm trying to say about poor people in
- 24:10Million Dollar Baby? Yep, exactly.
- 24:13Yeah. And, and so I think that here
- 24:15you finally have multiple actors and characters as they are
- 24:21written that have a depth of character and nuance to who they
- 24:26are. And, you know, even the even the
- 24:29side characters, the guy in the tire shop who who tells the kid,
- 24:33hey, your dad's a hero like that.
- 24:36Like there doesn't need to be any nuance there.
- 24:38He's just a character for one minute in the film, but there's
- 24:42a depth to that little C tier performance that felt authentic
- 24:50and real and it allowed Cooper to play off of it.
- 24:53And and it gave Cooper a chance to shine it and to flex his
- 24:58acting muscles in acting awkward and uncomfortable and like, OK,
- 25:03yeah, thanks, man. I yeah, cool.
- 25:04I'll just go pay the lady now. Like, that was one of my
- 25:07favorite scenes of the film. And it's not because he was
- 25:09being honored, it's because you can feel the discomfort of like,
- 25:15what is going on in Cooper's soul.
- 25:18So that actor, that scene is actually Jonathan Groff, who
- 25:21just recently won his first Tony.
- 25:24He's a very esteemed theatre actor who has also done quite a
- 25:27few films and television shows. And we just talked about him
- 25:31last week because he was the voice of Kristoff in Frozen.
- 25:34Oh my goodness, showing up again.
- 25:37And. I.
- 25:38Think that's actually really good segue into finding
- 25:41something redemptive about the movie Frozen because we spent a
- 25:45long time talking about that song Let It Go last week and how
- 25:48it is severely misinterpreted and misused due to its placement
- 25:52in that movie. Because Elsa gets really messed
- 25:56up by her parents, she has some really unhealthy coping
- 25:59mechanisms wherein she sings Let It Go.
- 26:02And then the end of the movie essentially undoes that mindset
- 26:05of let it go where she actually experiences healthy community
- 26:09and and processing through her trauma.
- 26:12And I think this movie actually follows a pretty similar pattern
- 26:14to that Brad. Like I don't think that Eastwood
- 26:17is 100% endorsing the way that Chris Kyle continually returns
- 26:23to Iraq as a way of papering over.
- 26:27And I think, again, that's where people continue to misinterpret
- 26:29this movie. But on the comparative front, if
- 26:33there's another movie that this is obviously a a comparison
- 26:37point to, it's The Hurt Locker. It's a movie we talked about a
- 26:39lot last year, Brad. I thought you were going to say
- 26:41frozen. That's why let's make it
- 26:45embarrassments aren't obvious with the Hurt Locker.
- 26:49It's a movie that seems to get the benefit of the doubt, and I
- 26:51actually might scorching hot take is that I think this is a
- 26:53better movie than the Hurt locker and I always yes, I just
- 26:57think it's a it's a much better produced movie.
- 26:59I think it actually communicates its point just as well with more
- 27:02nuance than The Hurt Locker, and I also think Bradley Cooper's a
- 27:05better actor than Jeremy Renner, so there you go.
- 27:08But it's funny to me that with The Hurt Locker, which follows
- 27:11almost the exact same pattern as this film, that movie seems to
- 27:15get the benefit of the doubt and this movie does not.
- 27:18Especially when you have Chris Kyle following that sort of Elsa
- 27:21Let It Go arc here. If there's one thing I didn't
- 27:27expect coming into this episode, it was that we would be
- 27:30comparing Chris Kyle to Elsa from Frozen.
- 27:34I mean, look, they both shoot people in the heart like this is
- 27:37the comparisons are never ending, Brad.
- 27:39Look at that. I mean, Elsa doesn't shoot
- 27:41children in the heart, so. She, well, she shot her child
- 27:45sister in the head. That's true.
- 27:47Headshot, headshots, dude. She's more more vicious than
- 27:51Chris Kyle. OK.
- 27:54Listen, we're in a spot right now where we have not really
- 27:57talked about the film. We've talked about what the film
- 27:59means. I think that we need to take a
- 28:02break. Let's talk about the performance
- 28:04of Bradley Cooper after the break.
- 28:06Let's talk about what we actually liked in the film
- 28:09making itself. But before that, I'm really,
- 28:12really anxious. Not anxious.
- 28:13I'm really, really antsy to get to try this Rebel 10.
- 28:16Brad, let's let's get to whiskey, if that's OK with you.
- 28:19I am so ready, Bob. Let's get to it.
- 28:28All right. Today we are checking out Rebel
- 28:3010 Years Single Barrel Bourbon. This is the new release from Lux
- 28:34Rd. Distillers.
- 28:35I think this is like our third or fourth week in a row, Brad,
- 28:38of doing new release whiskeys on film and whiskey.
- 28:42It's a wild time. Yeah, I've been.
- 28:44I've been enjoying it. Now, as Brad said, this is one
- 28:47of their more expensive offerings.
- 28:49It's because it's a single barrel and it's 10 years old.
- 28:52You know, we've, we've established the principle of $10
- 28:57per year of aging that our friend Wes tells us about all
- 29:01the time. This is $100 at 10 years.
- 29:04So it seems like at least in terms of the market, this is
- 29:08priced right where it should be. Again, this is a weeded bourbon.
- 29:11We've talked about Rebel a ton. Rebel Distillers Collection is
- 29:14one of our favourites. Rebel 100 is one of our favorite
- 29:17budget bourbons. This one is bottled at 100
- 29:21proof, Brad. So we're talking about a 10 year
- 29:23single barrel version of that Rebel 100.
- 29:26I'm freaking pumped, man. And I have to ask you, have you,
- 29:29have you had it already? Are you drinking it live?
- 29:32Oh dude I I cracked this bad boy open immediately.
- 29:36I was so, so excited about this and not to spoil all my takes,
- 29:41but I'm I'm excited to review with you, Bob.
- 29:44I'm drinking it live. I've been holding on to the
- 29:46bottle for a little over a week now, so you can understand why
- 29:49I'm so excited. Brad, I've just poured it out.
- 29:52I'm going to get into my nosing here as you give your notes.
- 29:55So why don't you lead us off? I think this is a really solid
- 29:59nose. The there's caramel right off
- 30:02the bat. There is a really nice soft
- 30:05oakiness to this, which is making me excited.
- 30:09There is some nuttiness. It's very peanutty in my mind.
- 30:14And, and the longer I sat with it, the more I got some
- 30:17interesting kind of fruity notes that I, I finally labeled as
- 30:23pineapple. But I, I, I don't know, there's
- 30:26this. It's not quite citrusy.
- 30:29It's not quite appley there, there's just some sort of really
- 30:33nice sweet fruity notes that I'm enjoying.
- 30:37I give it an 8 1/2 out of 10 here.
- 30:39I think I'm going to be almost in the exact same place score
- 30:41wise as you. Caramel dominates on the nose
- 30:44and you know they have tasting notes printed in their little
- 30:48press release. I I disagree with them frankly.
- 30:50Like I don't get as much vanilla as they said I was going to get.
- 30:53It really is like almost caramel cheesecake at first.
- 30:56Those fruit notes start to come out.
- 30:58Brad, they came out a little bit more like Peach for me than they
- 31:01did pineapple. But it does remind me of sort of
- 31:03like an upside down cake. Like there's that sort of
- 31:06caramelized drizzle on top. There's a little bit of
- 31:09breadiness. I don't know if they make Peach
- 31:11upside down cakes but that's what I'm going with here as.
- 31:15It's Sat. And it's been sitting in my
- 31:16glass for a little over 10 minutes now.
- 31:18There's a note that I'm glad you didn't pick up on because I
- 31:21think it would have lowered your your nosing score once those all
- 31:25dissipated. It is like straight black
- 31:28licorice to me and almost like a powdery sort of black licorice.
- 31:31Like it's a good and plenty or something.
- 31:32And I love good and plenty's and I like black licorice so I'm on
- 31:36board. Dude, I'm giving it an 8 1/2 on
- 31:38the nose. Do I need to pour?
- 31:40Some more because I did not get any anise on this and and like I
- 31:45said I'm. Very glad you didn't.
- 31:48You know what's a a whiskey that I actually got black licorice
- 31:52notes on after drinking it for a while.
- 31:54And I I used to really love it and I still like it.
- 31:58I still think it's a good one. The Sexton.
- 32:01Oh, interesting. Yeah, I after.
- 32:03Drinking it for a while, I was like, man, this just has black
- 32:06licorice notes on the nose, not on the palate, not on the finish
- 32:10anyways. The the palate here, it turns
- 32:14into a really nice dark cherry for me.
- 32:17There's oakiness all throughout. There's a burnt caramel vibe, a
- 32:23bit of like a sauteed butter. Vanilla is coming through on the
- 32:27palate, much more so than the nose.
- 32:30I think that this is a really solid expression of Rebel I I'm
- 32:34going to add an 8 out of 10 on the palate.
- 32:36Yeah, I think solid is the. Word here, Brad.
- 32:39It's a little bit thin on the mouthfeel, which I wasn't
- 32:42expecting. Definitely still packs a punch
- 32:44like that. 100 proof is coming out, but it it almost has like a
- 32:48pepper spice to it. There's the burn from the
- 32:51ethanol as well as almost like some cayenne pepper on the back
- 32:55of my palate here. Oak definitely dominates.
- 32:58You're absolutely right there. It's oak and wheat and there's
- 33:00not a lot of nuance to it, which is unfortunate 'cause I think
- 33:04like the Rebel Distillers collection has quite a few more
- 33:06waves of like sweet notes and things going on.
- 33:10In my mind, I'm kind of comparing this Brad to a bottle
- 33:12that we bought at the Kentucky Bourbon Festival last year, that
- 33:15Lux Roe 4 grain, which I think it's probably a little bit
- 33:20better than this. I think there's definitely more
- 33:22nuance and complexity to that whiskey.
- 33:25This one's just kind of like a very above average notes of
- 33:30anise wheat and oak flavored bourbon.
- 33:34So it's going to be a 7 1/2 for me on the taste and I'm curious
- 33:38to hear if it improved or kind of fell off for you on the
- 33:41finish. I actually liked it.
- 33:44On the finish, a little more than the palate, the cherry
- 33:48stuck through strong to the end, the vanilla really rounded out
- 33:53the experience for me, and the the the nice dusty peanut vibe
- 33:58just stuck around for the finish.
- 34:01I was at an 8 1/2 here and I think overall this is a pretty
- 34:05well balanced whiskey. It's an 8 out of 10 for me.
- 34:08On balance. It has just enough complexity to
- 34:12move it into that upper echelon the the 8 out of 10 area.
- 34:16I I just wish there's a little more going on here that it could
- 34:20hang its hat on. Yeah, I'm going to give it A7.
- 34:22And a half on the finish, I think.
- 34:24I think you're pretty much right.
- 34:25The vanilla comes back and it's really appreciated.
- 34:28I'll give it an 8. On balance, I was kind of
- 34:30waffling between a 7 1/2 and an 8, but overall this is a well
- 34:33above average whiskey and there weren't any like significant
- 34:36dips, so I'll give it an 8. When it comes to value again,
- 34:40we're talking about a $100 bottle of whiskey.
- 34:43This might be the first time that I think a bottle of Rebel
- 34:46is overpriced based on the whiskey itself.
- 34:48I do think it's a fair market value here if you're, if you're
- 34:53a fan of the Rebel line like I am, I would still probably give
- 34:57it like between a 6 1/2 and a 7 out of 10 on value.
- 35:01I don't really see myself personally going back and buying
- 35:04another bottle of this one, Brad, especially when I can
- 35:06still get distillers collection for like half the price.
- 35:09So I'll give it a 6.5 here. Yeah, I am.
- 35:12Literally at a 6.5 on value, Like I think this is a good
- 35:16whiskey that gives a pretty solid experience.
- 35:20It's just a little bit on the expensive side.
- 35:24All right, Brad. That's bringing me out to a 38
- 35:27out of 50. What are you coming out to just
- 35:30under? 40 I'm at a 39.5 All right, so
- 35:33that takes us to a. 38.75 once again, I mean, it's approaching
- 35:3740 and 40 is where we consider things like a no brainer
- 35:40recommendation between 35 and 40 is is like a less enthusiastic
- 35:47thumbs up, but still definitely a thumbs up.
- 35:49I would recommend this whiskey. It's good.
- 35:52It's just that like, if you want to get a pour of it at the bar,
- 35:54this is going to cost you probably, what, 20 bucks for a
- 35:57poor Yeah at. Least like 15 to 18.
- 36:00Yeah, you're just kind of starting to.
- 36:01Get into some territory where it's like.
- 36:04For the price I think. We could probably find things we
- 36:06like a little bit better than this one.
- 36:09Yeah, 100. Percent man, and I'm I'm not
- 36:12sitting here saying it's not a good whiskey.
- 36:14It is absolutely delicious. It's just the price here.
- 36:17The the value is not quite right.
- 36:20But once again, Bob, we have drink.
- 36:25A rebel whiskey. That just tastes delicious and I
- 36:28I will never stop singing the praises of Rebel now, I think.
- 36:33We do need to add the caveat to our score here.
- 36:35This is a single barrel. They could just be the barrel
- 36:38that we got that it's not quite hitting those extra decadent
- 36:41sweet Rebel notes that we like. They do make a Rebel 10 year.
- 36:45That is a a batch. You know, that's a blended
- 36:48version, and I think that I'd really like to try that one on
- 36:50the show, Brad, because I think that will be a little bit more
- 36:53in the sort of general flavor zone that we're used to.
- 36:57So folks, if you're a fan of single barrels, I think this is
- 37:00like, you're not going to go wrong picking up a bottle of
- 37:03this. But in our specific case, it
- 37:06just felt a little bit too far outside of the general Rebel
- 37:10vibe for me. Yeah.
- 37:12I think I'll recommend this. I I think that you're getting
- 37:17yourself a solid whiskey, especially if you want to split
- 37:20it with a buddy. Pay 50 bucks each.
- 37:22I think this is a good purchase. All right, man.
- 37:25We have drank our whiskey. Let's get back into talking
- 37:28about American Sniper. What do you say?
- 37:31Let's get to it. All right, everybody.
- 37:38That was Rebel 10 year single barrel, a whiskey that we are
- 37:42fans of. Just wish it cost a little less.
- 37:46Just how Bob feels about war. Big fan.
- 37:51You know, I just, I got to give it a three on the value score.
- 37:54Yeah. All right, man.
- 37:58It is time for us to get into our next segment, which we call
- 38:012 facts and a falsehood. Brad.
- 38:04Is going to try to stump your ball 2 All right and what is
- 38:09wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 38:13and a falsehood. Is the part of the show where
- 38:15Brad presents me with three items about the making of this
- 38:18movie, all of them presented as fact, one of which is completely
- 38:22made-up by him. Brad on the season, I believe I
- 38:25am at 15 and 11 right now. I am I'm slowly slipping back
- 38:29towards 500 and I do not like it.
- 38:32Oh, I'm. Definitely with you really don't
- 38:35like it. I I just want to see you
- 38:37succeed, Bob. I'm sure you do.
- 38:39Brad, that's always been your motivation.
- 38:43All right man, hit me with your. Two facts and a falsehood fact
- 38:46#1. Fact #1 pre fact, the IMDb page
- 38:53for American Sniper is very strange 'cause there's a lot of
- 38:59facts on there that are just kind of like weird things about
- 39:02Chris Kyle's life. So I'm just going to let you
- 39:05know, Bob, this was a hard, a difficult week, not to write the
- 39:09falsehood, but to find, like, decent facts about the making.
- 39:15Yeah. So I, I did my best.
- 39:19We'll, we'll see how it goes. Fact number one, the clothes
- 39:23worn by Bradley Cooper whenever he was at home were Chris Kyle's
- 39:27actual clothes loaned to the studio by the by his family.
- 39:31The family was so grateful for Cooper's portrayal of Kyle that
- 39:34they gave him several items of clothing as a gift after the
- 39:37shooting was complete. Fact #2 Chris.
- 39:40Kyle met the star. Well, the how would you say it?
- 39:46I'll just read it as is and then you'll understand my confusion.
- 39:49Chris Kyle met lone survivor from 2013's Marcus Luttrell
- 39:54during their BUDS SEAL training and became close friends with
- 39:57him. Although they graduated with
- 39:58different classes, kept in contact often, and they remained
- 40:01friends for the remainder of Kyle's life, specifically saying
- 40:04that Marcus Luttrell was the biopic subject.
- 40:09Subject. Thank you.
- 40:12Of Lone Survivor fact #3 Bradley Cooper used Chris Kyle's workout
- 40:16playlist as music to to which to listen to while working out for
- 40:21the role. He also pinned a picture of
- 40:23Chris Kyle to his wall of his gym to always have his goal in
- 40:26front of him. These are pretty good, Brad.
- 40:31I'm not. Going to lie, you did did a good
- 40:32job rounding these up. I'm going to go ahead and assume
- 40:36that number two is true. You've been getting better at
- 40:40tricking me with these, so I could be completely wrong, but
- 40:43for the sake of argument, I'm going to say that one or three
- 40:45is the falsehood. So it's really a question of
- 40:47like, did they give the studio his clothes and or does Bradley
- 40:52Cooper work out facing a picture of Chris Kyle?
- 40:58Which one do you? Feel worse about not being true.
- 41:02I want #1 to be. True, I think that's kind of
- 41:04cool. So I'll go ahead and.
- 41:07Say #1 is true and say #3 is false, with the caveat that I
- 41:13have absolutely no confidence in this one.
- 41:16And you were? Right to not have confidence,
- 41:19Bob, because you were wrong. What was the falsehood?
- 41:23The number one was the falsehood.
- 41:25Was it OK? Yeah, yeah.
- 41:29Thanks. A lot they.
- 41:29Didn't even give him any clothes.
- 41:31Come on man, the guy exclusively wore T-shirts.
- 41:35You couldn't give him one T-shirt that that is.
- 41:38That's true, man. They, they could have.
- 41:41All right, man, Let's talk. About the Bradley Cooper of it
- 41:43all. Cooper's a really interesting
- 41:45figure in Hollywood, especially in the 10 years since this movie
- 41:48has come out. So, you know, he was a, a member
- 41:51of the Actor's Studio. He kind of made his bones in
- 41:55comedies. Like I think one of the first
- 41:56times I remember seeing him outside of TV was in Wedding
- 42:00Crashers as the like huge douchebag boyfriend of Rachel
- 42:04McAdams. Then he does The Hangover and
- 42:06really blows up. But even in that movie, he's
- 42:09playing the douchebag of the group.
- 42:10Like he's he's just a self-centered prick.
- 42:13He has the sort of face that says I am a self-centered prick.
- 42:17And he makes, you know, a couple movies with David O Russell.
- 42:20He gets nominated for an Oscar, I believe for American Hustle.
- 42:24And then he goes into this movie and he puts on like 40 lbs of
- 42:27muscle and he takes on a completely different persona and
- 42:30demeanor for this film. And I have to say, man, of all
- 42:35of the Bradley Cooper performances and I I really like
- 42:38Bradley Cooper and I think he's a very good actor.
- 42:40He Hey, Bob, go. Ahead, can you give me your
- 42:43favorite line of the 2000s that Bradley Cooper said.
- 42:48Oh. It would be.
- 42:51Do you ladies like peanut butter sandwiches?
- 42:54I'm pissed off he didn't say it in this movie.
- 42:56I know it's it's a. Very.
- 42:58He should have said it right before he shot.
- 42:59Mustafa like it should have been like an Arnold Schwarzenegger
- 43:02one liner he liked. These peanut butter sandwiches
- 43:06bop you like peanut? Butter sandwiches.
- 43:08Poo poo poo poo. OK, he actually shoots off 4
- 43:11rounds all through the eyes. Man that is impressive with the
- 43:1550 Cal this. Is his best performance in a
- 43:18movie. He is unbelievable in this film.
- 43:22Brad, Bob, I've been waiting. All day to talk about the fact
- 43:28that Bradley Cooper is a freaking revelation in this
- 43:32movie. Unbelievable.
- 43:33I like, I don't know if there is a better war portrayal character
- 43:41ever done by an actor. He has so much nuance in being
- 43:48able to portray the exhilaration of war, the brokenness of what
- 43:53it asks you to do, and the level of PTSD and interiorness of a
- 44:02soldier who has come back from the war.
- 44:04I It's just stunning how he juggles all of those different
- 44:09aspects of the role and and it all comes across so clearly on
- 44:14the screen. He does a believable Southern
- 44:16accent. He really put on the weight for
- 44:19the movie. I mean, like, so the physical
- 44:21things he's doing, yes. It never seems showy and it
- 44:25never seems to be begging for an Oscar.
- 44:27And I think the worst Bradley Cooper performances, including
- 44:31this past year in Maestro are like so nakedly begging for
- 44:36attention that it it kind of seems embarrassing for him.
- 44:41And and this is like the complete opposite of that.
- 44:43And I think maybe that's why this seems like such a
- 44:45revelation to me upon revisit is like the last time I've seen
- 44:49Bradley Cooper was as Leonard Bernstein in Maestro.
- 44:52And this character couldn't be farther from that.
- 44:55But he's so perfectly embodies. I, you know, I don't want to
- 44:59just call him the strong, silent type, but like, he has a laid
- 45:02backness to him that really does reflect the culture of the
- 45:06South. But there's also the
- 45:09woundedness, the guardedness, what he's able to do with like a
- 45:13grunt or like a small little tick when someone finally gets
- 45:18to him. It says so much.
- 45:20It's a really restrained performance.
- 45:22And I think that Cooper, when he's criticized, it's because
- 45:26he's going too far in the other direction.
- 45:29And I'd like to see him do more of this because this is just,
- 45:32it's really nuanced stuff, man. Yeah. 100% I am.
- 45:38This might sound weird, but like I'm thankful that we got to see
- 45:41Bradley Cooper do this because in my mind it, it puts him into
- 45:45an upper echelon of actors. And I, I just think that it's
- 45:50incredible. And, you know, a few, a few
- 45:52years back, we were doing our director series and we would
- 45:55rate the directors at like, man, I wish that this had been on the
- 46:00list for Eastwood because I I think that the way he handles
- 46:05Cooper as an actor is really impressive here.
- 46:08I do kind of wonder. Like, you know, Eastwood is
- 46:11famous for doing like the first take is the take I use.
- 46:15I just wonder if maybe Bradley Cooper needs to be directed like
- 46:17that more often. Like, I I think when he's
- 46:20directing himself like he did in Maestro, I think he he
- 46:24micromanages himself to death a little bit.
- 46:26Like he wants to be perfect so bad that he ends up kind of
- 46:29getting lost in the sauce a little bit.
- 46:31Oh, is that a? Reference to burnt OH.
- 46:35Oh no, it's not. I've never seen that movie.
- 46:37Is that good? Yes.
- 46:39I liked it. It's not perfect there.
- 46:41There's a lot of issues. It's like a 7 1/2 to an 8.
- 46:45But literally everything you just said is the entire
- 46:49character he plays in burnt like obsessed with perfection, gets
- 46:52lost in the sauce, doesn't know how to connect with other
- 46:55humans. That's that's great.
- 46:57My favorite? Critique of a Bradley Cooper
- 46:59movie is in the office in the episode where they're all going
- 47:02to Gettysburg and they're watching movies on the tour bus
- 47:06and someone says after this I'm going to turn on Limitless.
- 47:10And Phyllis goes, is that the one where the guy becomes
- 47:13limitless? Oh, man.
- 47:19OK, So Bradley Cooper, what? We've gotten him out of the way.
- 47:23I do want to say this was an absolutely crazy year for actor
- 47:27performances at the Academy Awards because this is the year
- 47:30that Michael Keaton and Eddie Redmayne were duking it out at
- 47:35the Oscars for the for Birdman and The Theory of Everything
- 47:39right, respectively. And it just makes me even more
- 47:42mad that Eddie Redmayne won an Oscar.
- 47:44I think his performance in that movie is very good.
- 47:46As Stephen Hawking, Michael Keaton gives one of my favorite
- 47:49performances of the century in Birdman.
- 47:52And it's unfair to Bradley Cooper because I I do think I
- 47:55like Keaton just a little bit better in Birdman.
- 47:57But in any other year, I think both Michael Keaton and Bradley
- 48:03Cooper would be winning Oscars for those two performances.
- 48:07And it's just crazy to me that like, now, now Eddie Redmayne is
- 48:10the Oscar winner of the three. What Bob?
- 48:13What do you have against Eddie Redmayne?
- 48:15What? Why do you hate the beloved soft
- 48:18spoken British actor so much? You know what's really funny is.
- 48:21I I don't. And he actually came under fire
- 48:24this past couple weeks because he gave a performance at the
- 48:27Tony Awards that Twitter just loved to make fun of.
- 48:30He's he's starring in the musical Cabaret right now.
- 48:33And man, my guy got raked over the coals and I don't understand
- 48:37why people hate him so much. I just think that he's made
- 48:41really bad career choices ever since he won his Oscar.
- 48:45Like maybe he won it too young. And it's like, how do I follow
- 48:48this up? And so he's just, he's done some
- 48:50bad work and he's been in some bad films.
- 48:53He seems like a good guy and I like, I think he's got the
- 48:55chops, but because he's never rebounded from winning that
- 49:00Oscar, I think the Oscar win is starting to look worse and worse
- 49:04as the years go on. Bob, do you want to know?
- 49:06A personal embarrassing story about me, always.
- 49:11About. Halfway halfway through college,
- 49:15I nearly joined. I auditioned for and received
- 49:19the role in a like community stage performance of Cabaret.
- 49:25Oh, interesting. And I was set up to be like one
- 49:28of the male dancers who had like 10 lines in the whole show.
- 49:34And I didn't do it. But I came close.
- 49:37Why is that? Embarrassing I.
- 49:40Male dancer in a in a stage production are are we
- 49:44embarrassed? Because you can't dance.
- 49:47No, I can dance pretty solidly. Bob, we've you and I have both
- 49:51cut it up on the wedding dance floor a few times.
- 49:53Yes, we have. We have done quite.
- 49:55A two step together. I think it's it's not the.
- 49:57Idea of a man dancing. It was more of the male strip
- 50:01club cabaret dance. Got it.
- 50:03That was slightly embarrassing. Well, as you know, I've been.
- 50:06Trying to talk you into doing that on camera for an exclusive
- 50:09Patreon tier that we're going to introduce $25.00 a month for
- 50:12Brad's Only Fans channel. So now I just have more fuel to
- 50:16add to that fire. I'm going to.
- 50:19Move on from that room. American Sniper.
- 50:21Yeah. American Sniper Everybody I.
- 50:22Want to talk about Eastwood? Here, because it's pretty rare
- 50:25that we get Eastwood in action movie mode, and I don't think
- 50:30that he has the action chops of somebody like a Spielberg, where
- 50:34you, like, completely understand the geography of every space
- 50:37you're in. I was attached to direct this.
- 50:39Film he was. I just, I don't know that that's
- 50:42necessarily Eastwood's intent either.
- 50:44The chaos of these hollowed out cities is kind of the point.
- 50:49And within, you know, I don't understand where we are inside
- 50:52this building. But from shot to shot, he's not
- 50:54breaking the rules of like the 180° line.
- 50:57It's solid filmmaking. And I think when you couple it
- 51:00with the fact that Eastwood was like 82 when this movie came
- 51:02out, like the energy my guy was working with in creating this
- 51:07film, it's an impressive movie. Just on that front.
- 51:10I think it captures. The the fog of war element of
- 51:14fighting in Iraq from what we understand it to have been like
- 51:19incredibly well. I think that that's what I've
- 51:23started to really appreciate about war films is how they
- 51:27shoot the action. And I always come back to like a
- 51:30sicario as one of the few examples of a, you know, quote
- 51:37UN quote war film. It's technically like the CIA
- 51:40killing people, but it captures the precision of the American
- 51:45military industrial complex really well.
- 51:49And yet here in American Sniper, I think you do capture the chaos
- 51:55of door to door fighting so incredibly well.
- 51:59Along with one thing I appreciated is that he captures
- 52:04the boredom of being a sniper really well too.
- 52:07Like there's this, there's this element of like the guys walk up
- 52:12to tell him like, hey, you're good to come down now.
- 52:15And they're like, Oh my God, it reeks up here.
- 52:18Like you clearly have been peeing in the corner and also
- 52:22you covered our asses and got us out, got so many of us out of
- 52:25there alive. And once again, it's this
- 52:28tension between like the grossness of war and the honor
- 52:32of war. All right man, where do?
- 52:34You want to go from here? We've got just a few minutes
- 52:36left before we get into our our last couple segments.
- 52:38Is there anything else about the film making that you think we
- 52:41should touch on? He used Ennio.
- 52:43Morconi at the end and. I freaking loved it.
- 52:47Man, it was so good. It comes on and I'm like, oh
- 52:51wow, they're playing, Oh no, Oh no, they're not playing taps,
- 52:55they're playing the funeral. And I, it just, I didn't know
- 52:59that they were going to use that.
- 53:01And I, I think it might be the best use of that song in the
- 53:05film. And I say that knowing it was
- 53:07written for a film, you know, 40 years before.
- 53:12I want to talk about the. Ending briefly and briefly
- 53:14because I don't know if I can actually articulate my feelings
- 53:17about it without sounding like callous, like this is a real
- 53:21person who really died in a very tragic way.
- 53:24But every time I see this movie, there there's two things that
- 53:27kind of strike me about the ending.
- 53:29It's a really abrupt ending and. Because of its abruptness.
- 53:35I always assumed that Chris Kyle died like during the production
- 53:38of the movie because the, the ending feels so tacked on.
- 53:42Like it's he comes back from Iraq and he's readjusting, and
- 53:47then all of a sudden the movie's just like, boom, you know, he
- 53:49died that day. And I think that, A, it's really
- 53:52abrupt, B, it's a very respectful ending.
- 53:57Obviously, Eastwood has the tact and the class to not show this
- 54:02man be murdered at the end of the movie.
- 54:05But I do think that it just ends in such a way that's like fade
- 54:08out. He died that day.
- 54:11And and then you get a shot of the funeral, which is real
- 54:13footage of his funeral procession.
- 54:16But I was expecting like, maybe more words to come up on the
- 54:19screen, maybe Eastwood to let us sit with those images for a
- 54:22couple minutes. But it literally fades up on the
- 54:24funeral procession. It says directed by Clint
- 54:26Eastwood. There is really no epilogue or
- 54:28epitaph or epigraph on this movie.
- 54:31It's just like he died, directed by Clint Eastwood.
- 54:36And I think that if he drops the ball anywhere, it's in that
- 54:39department. Because while I respect how much
- 54:43respect he gave to his subject, you do kind of have a
- 54:46responsibility as a filmmaker to really land the plane at the end
- 54:49of the movie. And I know you said you were
- 54:51very emotional at the end of the film.
- 54:54I felt like frankly, he should have, he should have milked it
- 54:57just a little bit more or a little bit longer with the
- 55:00images of the funeral before going to end credits, or he
- 55:04should have put some more words up on the screen.
- 55:06Like something, something just feels missing from this ending
- 55:08for me. And for a movie that has not
- 55:11pulled any punches throughout the film in terms of implicating
- 55:16Kyle and interrogating Kyle's own psyche and his unwillingness
- 55:21to to work on his trauma, that to just end that way, it puts a
- 55:27finality on it without really grappling with the implications
- 55:31of that. And, and I just, I don't know,
- 55:34man, I don't know how to how to phrase it.
- 55:36It's, it's too, I don't want to even call it stoic.
- 55:39It's just too much of A bow to put on a movie where it feels
- 55:41like he hadn't finished tying the bow yet.
- 55:43You know what I mean? Yes, I, I.
- 55:46Think every single thing you are saying is 100% true and I think
- 55:51that is representative of the life of Chris Kyle.
- 55:55Like like to me. That's the point of the ending.
- 55:58Like we didn't get to experience who Chris Kyle could have
- 56:04become. To me, it really brings you to a
- 56:08place of where his family must have been to say, we're proud of
- 56:14you, you're making progress, you're getting better, you're
- 56:16helping others. And yet.
- 56:20It feels so. Disconcerting and discomforting
- 56:24and just broken To think that this upward trajectory, this
- 56:31this beautiful life in the making just completely is gone
- 56:37out of nowhere. And, and I, I've sat with enough
- 56:40families who have lost loved ones suddenly to know that that
- 56:45that feeling that you're feeling is real when when you experience
- 56:49the loss of somebody before their time.
- 56:54This movie wins at an. Oscar for sound editing or sound
- 56:57mixing. I don't know what they were
- 56:58calling it at the time, and I think that it is absolutely
- 57:01deserved. But what I really found
- 57:03fascinating were some of those moments where Eastwood's using
- 57:06both sound effects and the score to have this kind of eerie,
- 57:10discordant sound. The last time you get it in the
- 57:13movie is when the camera's on Sienna Miller's face at the end
- 57:17as she's closing the door because she understands, like,
- 57:20there's something off about this guy that my husband's going off
- 57:22with. And I found that like a really
- 57:24interesting addition because it's not only saying like she
- 57:28feels unease because that's this is the musical cue for unease
- 57:32that we've used throughout the film.
- 57:34But it's almost like this idea of, you know, throughout the
- 57:36movie, he's been on edge. He's constantly checking like
- 57:39the rearview mirror every time that they're driving to, to
- 57:42scope things out for threats. Whenever the dog is playing with
- 57:45his kid and he thinks the dog is a threat, these moments come up.
- 57:49And now it's not him who's feeling it.
- 57:52Like he's finally let go of that feeling.
- 57:54And the last time anyone in the movie experiences that feeling,
- 57:58it's her. And I found that to be to really
- 58:01under score the message of the movie, which is to your point,
- 58:04Brad, the toll this takes on families in America because it's
- 58:09almost like this. This infectious.
- 58:13Disease, kind of like the the sense of distrust and unease has
- 58:18almost passed from him to her at the end of the movie.
- 58:21And then you get the tragic kind of confirmation of that, that
- 58:24that feeling of unease that she had proved to be true because
- 58:28her husband gets killed. I just think, go ahead, sorry.
- 58:31I think that. The military throughout the
- 58:35entire film represents Chris Kyle's only blind spot.
- 58:40It's the only thing that he doesn't question, that he always
- 58:43believes in that. You know, it's always the
- 58:46mission. It's always my brothers.
- 58:47It's always the people I need to save.
- 58:49And she is the one who always questions it, who says, hey,
- 58:53like I, I'm all about, you know, country and, and all that.
- 58:56But like, your family is here. And so he never sees the
- 59:02military for the threat that it is to his family.
- 59:06And she does. And I think that's kind of the
- 59:09element you get there at the end I, you know.
- 59:12IA 100% agree with you. I think both things are
- 59:14happening there. Honestly, you're right.
- 59:16Like it does portray the military as his blind spot.
- 59:19And again, I've I've been trying to under score this the whole
- 59:22episode. Eastwood does a really good job
- 59:24of holding these things in tension, and I think that people
- 59:29on both sides of the aisle have really failed to grasp that
- 59:32tension when it comes to this movie.
- 59:34I think a lot of people went to this movie and supported it as
- 59:38the sort of rah rah patriotic movie that it was accused of
- 59:41being. And that's obviously a bad faith
- 59:44reading of the movie. I think on the other side of
- 59:46things, the people that dismissed this movie as just,
- 59:49you know, America, yeah, kind of movie are also 100% wrong.
- 59:54This is a movie that's much more interested in the toll that war
- 59:58takes on one life, and I think it tells that story more
- 1:00:01powerfully than The Hurt Locker, especially since this is
- 1:00:05ostensibly a true story. Brad, I think I'm ready to get
- 1:00:09into. Let's make it a double if you
- 1:00:11are. We're near the end of.
- 1:00:13The episodes. Oh, thanks.
- 1:00:15Listening to the film and Whiskey Show.
- 1:00:17Let's pair another film with this one, even if it's
- 1:00:19struggling. It's a final segment of the day.
- 1:00:21Now let's make it a double. Yeah.
- 1:00:23I'm 100% ready, man, this movie is great and everybody should
- 1:00:27watch it. And I think I'm, I've been
- 1:00:30really struggling with finding a movie that captures the
- 1:00:33psychological nuance of war quite in this way, 'cause like,
- 1:00:37you could, you could pair it with an Apocalypse Now, but I
- 1:00:40don't, I don't know that that's just vibes so much differently
- 1:00:44than this. I think I'm actually going to
- 1:00:47pair it with Saving Private Ryan 'cause I think that that movie A
- 1:00:51deserves to be watched. B is incredibly made, similar to
- 1:00:56what I think American Sniper is incredibly made.
- 1:00:59And CI think it dives into the mentality of the troops of their
- 1:01:03respective wars in a way that matters and helps us think about
- 1:01:09war as a whole. I have a.
- 1:01:11Million different directions I could go.
- 1:01:12I just watched a new movie that came out a couple weeks ago
- 1:01:16called The Bike Riders, and that movie is freaking fantastic.
- 1:01:20It's one of my favorite films of the year.
- 1:01:22But it's also about like people who do dangerous, violent things
- 1:01:27as a way of covering up, like the fact that they don't want to
- 1:01:30feel things. And so that's been on my mind a
- 1:01:32lot. I don't think I'm going to pair
- 1:01:33it with that, but I need a movie that kind of fits that mold.
- 1:01:37And I think for me, Brad, you mentioned how well this movie
- 1:01:41captures the boredom of being a sniper.
- 1:01:44And it threw me back to a movie that I haven't seen in almost 20
- 1:01:47years. It's a movie by the director,
- 1:01:49Sam Mendes, and it's called Jarhead.
- 1:01:52It has Jake Gyllenhaal in it as a guy who is training to become
- 1:01:55a Marine sniper. And it is all about the
- 1:01:58psychological toll that it takes on a person to have to wait
- 1:02:02months and months and months to take one shot and what happens
- 1:02:05to you if you don't make that shot.
- 1:02:07I have no idea how that movie holds up.
- 1:02:09Like I said, I haven't seen it in 20 years.
- 1:02:11I might go ahead and make it a double tonight, Brad, just watch
- 1:02:15Jarhead to see how that thing holds up.
- 1:02:17But I think you can do it a lot worse.
- 1:02:19You talked. Earlier about American Sniper
- 1:02:22having a great trailer, I just I have vivid memories of Jarhead.
- 1:02:28I don't even know the name of the song that plays in the
- 1:02:30trailer. Jesus walks by Kanye.
- 1:02:31I remember that trailer, dude. Yep dude.
- 1:02:34Tell me that's. Not just one of the greatest
- 1:02:36needle drops in the trailer ever.
- 1:02:38It was such a good trailer. That I was actively pissed off
- 1:02:41at the movie for not I don't think it uses the song in the
- 1:02:44movie and I was like, God bless it.
- 1:02:46Like I came here for that song. Yeah, 100% maybe that's.
- 1:02:49My let's make it a. Double Maybe I just want to pair
- 1:02:51this movie with Jesus Walks by Kanye.
- 1:02:53Yeah, that's the. Move 100%.
- 1:02:57All right. Dude, let's get into some.
- 1:02:58Final scores here. I'd like for you to go first.
- 1:03:00Brad, I've been talking a lot today and it sounds like you
- 1:03:02might be even higher on this movie than I am.
- 1:03:05Dude, I I. Think this is one of the best
- 1:03:07war movies we have watched on this podcast and we've watched
- 1:03:11quite a few, like all the way back from like paths of glory up
- 1:03:15through I mean, American Sniper might be the most modern war
- 1:03:19movie as far as made the latest and you know, a war that is the
- 1:03:24most recent. I think I'm going to give this
- 1:03:27A9. And a half.
- 1:03:27Wow. Like that.
- 1:03:29There are issues. The not all the acting is
- 1:03:32perfect. There are, especially early in
- 1:03:36the movie, there's stuff that feels a little rushed and
- 1:03:38sloppy. But I think he lands the plane
- 1:03:41and from about maybe 30 to 40 minutes into the end, you know,
- 1:03:47and this is a what, two hour and 15 minute movie?
- 1:03:50Yeah, somewhere in there. Like.
- 1:03:52For solid almost two hours. This is incredible filmmaking,
- 1:03:58investigating the psyche of an American soldier.
- 1:04:01And I, I think it's great. Now I think I'm actually going
- 1:04:04to come out. Significantly lower than you
- 1:04:05then, Brad. I think this movie is like for
- 1:04:0980% of its runtime. It's like an 8 1/2 to a nine for
- 1:04:12me. It's really, really good like
- 1:04:14you said, but the two bookends on either side of the movie are
- 1:04:18like everything when Chris Kyle is a kid is horrifically bad
- 1:04:23acting. Like truly awful, awful movie
- 1:04:25making and acting. And then I think the way this
- 1:04:28movie ends it, it both loses a lot of steam and it feels like
- 1:04:33an anti climax. And I understand to your point
- 1:04:36that that's probably part of the movie making that his life felt
- 1:04:39anti climactic because it was ripped away from him.
- 1:04:41I just think Eastwood has to do a little bit more there to earn
- 1:04:45an emotional pay off for what we've been watching for two
- 1:04:47hours and 15 minutes. I've been waffling between an 8
- 1:04:51and an 8 1/2 on this movie. I think I'll give it an 8 and a.
- 1:04:55Half, Brad, but that's probably just because I, I am happy that
- 1:04:59you like it so much and I don't want to hurt your feelings by
- 1:05:02giving it an 8. So I'm, I'll give it an 8 1/2.
- 1:05:05That brings us out to a nine out of 10 on average.
- 1:05:08This is one of our highest rated movies of the year now, Brad
- 1:05:11really at a nine. Out of 10, man, it's almost like
- 1:05:15we've had a lot of. Sevens and eights this year,
- 1:05:18yeah, but really? Fun sevens and eights.
- 1:05:21Yeah, and this is a nine. And it's probably the least fun
- 1:05:23movie we've done all season. Oh yeah, I, I.
- 1:05:26Will maybe watch this movie once or twice more in my life.
- 1:05:29It was so hard to watch dude. Looking ahead at the next few
- 1:05:35weeks, we've got three Star Wars movies and two MCU movies to end
- 1:05:39the season. I I want to put an.
- 1:05:41Asterisk 3 Disney produced Star Wars movies.
- 1:05:46All that to say. Maybe this does deserve an 8 1/2
- 1:05:49just for being the last real movie we're going to watch for
- 1:05:52the rest of the season. Thank you.
- 1:05:54So it's a nine out of. 10 from us on American Sniper.
- 1:05:57But we'd like to know what you think.
- 1:05:59Reach out to us on social media. You can find us on Facebook,
- 1:06:02Twitter, Instagram, TikTok or YouTube at Film Whiskey, or you
- 1:06:08can join the. Discord.
- 1:06:09We are on there every single day talking to you guys, fans of the
- 1:06:12Film and Whiskey podcast. So if you'd like to join the
- 1:06:15conversation, you can find a link at the end of every single
- 1:06:17one of our show notes next week. We're kicking off the Disney
- 1:06:22Star Wars Renaissance, Brad, with The Force Awakens, JJ
- 1:06:27Abrams. Absolute turd of a film that I
- 1:06:29can't wait to watch again. All right, we'll see you next
- 1:06:32week for Force Awakens. But until then, I'm Bob Buck.
- 1:06:35I'm Brad G. And we'll see you next time.