Latest / Why We Do What We Do / Not So Sweet Revenge
Transcript
- 0:03You're listening to Why we do what we do. Welcome to Why we do
- 0:16what we do. I am your retaliating host, Abraham, and I am
- 0:21your so mad ho sheene. Oh. We're a psychology podcast. We talk
- 0:26about the things that people do and the things the animals do, and sometimes
- 0:30we talk about philosophy. Sometimes we talk about diagnoses. Sometimes we talk about
- 0:35the ugliest of emotions, which will be what we talk about today. Revengeance.
- 0:41Revengeance. We're not prevengers, we're avengers. Yeah, and we've got
- 0:46a halt and we've got a hold. And his name is Justin and he
- 0:49does all of our sounds. So thank you Justin for that true story,
- 0:52true story. If you're joining us for the first time, welcome. We're
- 0:55so happy to have you here. We unpack all these psychological concepts. We
- 0:59try and do it about less than an hour. Sometimes we go way over
- 1:02that. And as we said, we're talking about revenge today. Vengeance.
- 1:07Yes, if you're joining us for the first time, thank you so much.
- 1:08If you'd like to support the show, you can join us on Patreon,
- 1:11pickup some merch, leave a rating and review, tell a friend,
- 1:14do all those things. But first I would like to wish you a happy
- 1:18Don't step on a bee Day? Yeah, that would hoot. Would hurt
- 1:22for you or the bee? Probably both both. I don't want to be
- 1:25stung by a bee. I don't like being I don't like being be stung.
- 1:26It's not my favorite, understandable, it's just the be getting back at
- 1:30you. Yeah. It's also International Nikola Tesla Day, which is fun.
- 1:36It's National Kitten Day. Oh that's adorable. Yeah, that's great. I
- 1:41think that's great. It's National Pina Colada Day. I hope I never had
- 1:45to serve a penal klota again. I did that for like a summer and
- 1:48it was the worst peanut colota summer. It's Teddy Bear's Picnic Day. I
- 1:52don't know what that means, but I'm assuming it's you include your teddy bears
- 1:55and a picnic. Sure, that's my assumption. It's Pick Blueberries Day,
- 2:00which is delicious and I love that. Very good. US Energy Independence Day,
- 2:06Get on that grid, get off the other grids. Yeah, it's
- 2:08funny to think that that's like a thing that they're celebrating, because you know,
- 2:12I mean, let's we're not really we're not really independent from other energy
- 2:16it is air Conditioning Appreciation Days. As a Floridian myself, that is every
- 2:22day. Yeah, because it is wildly hot down here right now. Yeah,
- 2:27as they're now having to update the maps for like what regions are considered
- 2:31to have what like rain, and what types of regions they are because the
- 2:36climate is changing. We can all get on board with air Conditioning Appreciation Days
- 2:39most definitely. So for some reason, it is be nice to New Jersey
- 2:44week, so you get those week New Jersey. Yeah, that's it.
- 2:49That's it Jersey. It's a creative maladjustment day. Is dog days of summer.
- 2:54Sure, I mean sure, why these days? Who knows? But
- 2:58that's what it is. It's freedom week. So the week that this comes
- 3:01out, you've you've already maybe lost some limbs during fourth of July, so
- 3:06maybe maybe that's what it is. Yeah, that's my freedom week. Yeah,
- 3:10yeah, exactly. It is National Aborigines and Islanders Day Observance Committee Week.
- 3:15That's a lot of words. There's so many words in that we don't
- 3:19even really know what we're celebrating there. It's a National Fairier's Week, Okay,
- 3:23it is Nude Recreation weekend. Fun go back and listen to our episode
- 3:29on nudism. Yeah, oh that was such a great episode too. That
- 3:31was so fun And then is Operation Safe Driver Week so excellent? Now it's
- 3:37funny think that like maybe people are driving in the nude? Is that safe
- 3:40though in their cars? Ac that would that would have to be how that
- 3:46takes it takes place. Yeah, anyway, we just like to celebrate those
- 3:51holidays because you know, it's a thing that we can do. And part
- 3:53of what we like to boast is that we help you be better at trivia
- 3:55sometimes. So now you know if the week it is, yep, if
- 3:59that comes up in something and maybe what weak it is, and so there's
- 4:02that if you're all caught up and everything. But as I said, we
- 4:05are talking about revenge, and the reason I wanted to talk about this is
- 4:09I think that there's been a lot of talk. I mean, I think
- 4:13this is the thing first of all, that we as humans experience and do
- 4:16a lot of. And second, it feels like it's become increasingly relevant recently
- 4:21with just a lot of talk in the news about certain people who are talking
- 4:26about getting revenge. And so it had me thinking about revenge. It had
- 4:30me at a heightened awareness of other people talking about a revenge, and it's
- 4:35just kind of around us a lot. You know. It's a thing that
- 4:39I think about a lot working in therapy, because what I find is that
- 4:44when I'm working with families and something goes wrong, or like working with teachers
- 4:49or whoever, like, I find a lot of people really want like there
- 4:54to be justice, like it goes it's this idea that like, oh no,
- 4:58the skills are not bou so I need to take it upon myself to
- 5:01balance the scales. And so I see this a lot, a like low
- 5:05level, low magnitude types of forms. Yeah, you know, not to
- 5:09the point where it's like I'm going to get back at them and make their
- 5:11life a living hell. Like it's nothing like that, but there is that
- 5:15low level of like having to balance the scales that people tend to have because
- 5:19they feel like stuff is off kilter because people quote unquote got away with stuff,
- 5:24you know. And so I see this a lot like in day to
- 5:27day discussions with folks. That's a great point and actually I kind of think
- 5:31now I would like to do a whole episode on the concept of justice,
- 5:35which I mean is kind of there's a lot going to be a lot of
- 5:38overlap with our discussion today. Yeah, although yeah, it does have its
- 5:42kind of unique history because obviously we have an entire system of government that is
- 5:46supposed to be dedicated to justice. Now it's just dedicated to political expediency.
- 5:50But they used true justice. Yeah, those are the days. I mean,
- 5:56there's probably a brief would note because like before that, it was just
- 5:59sort of you know, also do anyway, the concept of justice is a
- 6:03fascinating one, and there's thinking about something that's like what is being just?
- 6:08What is being fair? What is being forgiving? What is being compassionate?
- 6:12And I think those are kind of wrapped up in the idea of having a
- 6:15system of justice and what it means to get justice and what that what we
- 6:19feel like. But what we're we're actually tackling today specifically, is this idea
- 6:24of revenge, which is inherently linked to that. Right. It's this like
- 6:29I'm gonna get back at you thing, right, And so I think today
- 6:32what we're gonna ask is what is revenge? What are the pros and cons
- 6:35of revenge? How does it affect us? And why do we do it?
- 6:40Right? That is the name of the show. Yeah, why it
- 6:43is that we do the things. That's right, That's what I should have
- 6:46called it. I don't know why I picked the title off the song.
- 6:49Yeah, all right, so let's actually start by telling a quick story here.
- 6:54So there's a story that I found that as I was pulling in some
- 6:57notes from this about this this woman named Carla. She's out a stopplight.
- 7:00She gets rear ended, and she gets out of her car and the person
- 7:03that re rended her also get out of the car, and apparently there's some
- 7:06kind of exchange. They're yelling at each other, like you have a car
- 7:11and like you stop too fast or something, you know whatever. They're yelling
- 7:15at each other, and essentially it escalates to at some point, the second
- 7:18girl, the one who did the render, and slaps the first girl.
- 7:20Okay, so the first girl, who already is is now feels that she
- 7:27has been wronged by being rear ended, that this was like this person is
- 7:30now responsible for this has now been slapped and is like, oh no,
- 7:35you didn't. And so it turns into a fistfight pretty quickly. But I
- 7:41mean it's also over very quickly because what happened is Carla throws a punch at
- 7:46the person who editor whose name was Regina. This girl falls to the ground,
- 7:49and there's like onlookers, right, this is a screaming match. There's
- 7:53an accident, like people are watching, and so Carla is like punching and
- 7:59kicking this girl in the face and stomach who's like on the ground, Like
- 8:01she's beating this body that's basically laying there, right, And so she's arrested
- 8:07for aggravated assault and says, quote, I wasn't going to let her get
- 8:09away with what she did to me, especially in front of that crowd.
- 8:13End quote. So we hear this, and I think, at least for
- 8:18me, I'm hearing this is petty, stupid, prideful nonsense. I was
- 8:24like, oh yeah, like everyone's taking notes, be like let's get that
- 8:28girl's name and number. I want to be friends with her now, Like
- 8:31yeah, what is what is your actual thinking? I don't know. I
- 8:35feel like there's just there's no logic at all to that kind of reasoning,
- 8:37and it just it's really sad to hear that, Like it would even turn
- 8:41to that. There is a version of me, Shane that relates to this
- 8:46historically. Yeah, yeah, Like there's a part of me where I'm like
- 8:50Oh, if this were Shane when he was seventeen, eighteen, nineteen years
- 8:54old, then sure, like I could see a fistfight ensuing, right like
- 8:58if somebody But to be fair, if somebody threw a punch at me,
- 9:01then yes, I'm gonna defend myself, right Like I think about that version
- 9:03of me now today, I'm like, I don't want to fight anybody,
- 9:05Like, what are we doing. We're adults here, so like you know
- 9:09and kind of going like as like a mature, wiser wizard than I am,
- 9:13I kind of go, no, I don't relate to that as myself
- 9:16today, Like I can understand it, but I don't. I'm not that
- 9:20person. And so but I think a lot of people who are listening and
- 9:22hear that story are probably going, yeah, I get it, I would
- 9:28do that or that's me, Like there's like some level of relation to that
- 9:33or at least that feeling of wanting to get back at somebody totally yeah,
- 9:37exactly right is I think that that story will connect with a lot of people,
- 9:41even if it's not who they are now or like right in this moment,
- 9:43they could maybe see themselves in that situation and a similar thing. And
- 9:48like I know, yeah, exactly for myself at some point in my life
- 9:50that maybe could have been me. But I've also been a pacifist for so
- 9:54long at this point that I also can't. Like it's harder for me to
- 9:56even imagine reacting way, you know, like I'm not gonna start punching it,
- 10:03Like, let's just say somehow I was so enraged that I even threw
- 10:09one punch. Once they're on the ground, I'm like, I'm not going
- 10:13to be punching and kicking someone who's actually on the ground, Like, what's
- 10:16wrong anyway. Normally, when we start these kinds of discussions, we want
- 10:22to kick it off with talking about a definition, right, And that's because
- 10:24we need to distinguish our terms. We need to understand the parameters, what
- 10:28it includes, was it doesn't include, and that by itself can help us
- 10:31both illuminate that concept so that we're really clear about what we're talking about,
- 10:35but also it allows us to poke holes in that concept, which is a
- 10:39fun way to discuss it. But rather than just give a definition, I'm
- 10:43going to do a little bit of walking backward through non examples for just just
- 10:48a minute. So bear with us, because I think it helps actually underscore
- 10:52what revenge is by ruling out the things that it's not, by basically saying,
- 10:58like, let's start with just a piece of it and then expand it
- 11:01out until we get to what it includes and what it doesn't, right exactly.
- 11:05So I think that we can intuitively understand what revenge is. I don't
- 11:09think that's a difficult concept for people to understand, But I think where it
- 11:13gets difficult is distinguishing the use cases that can help not only pinpoint a good
- 11:16definition, but lay the foundation for how to start to understand this topic.
- 11:20So I think it's kind of like, you know what pornography is, but
- 11:24it's hard to describe or define. Like that's kind of what revenge is.
- 11:26It's like, you know what it is, but it might be a little
- 11:28bit hard to define without some more context. Eventually, I think because of
- 11:33that quote, I'm just going to do a mini on pornography, like you
- 11:37need to just do it. I think we probably just need to do a
- 11:39whole series on it because it's a whole thing that's fair, but just for
- 11:43the definition part. Yeah, oh yeah. So going back to revenge,
- 11:46let's start with no context, right, So we have person A does something
- 11:50to harm person B. That's all you get, is that revenge. Well,
- 11:54maybe what's immediately clear from that example is we need to know something more
- 12:00about the situation to be able to call it revenge. Just because personal harm
- 12:03person B. I don't know, maybe there's revenge, it's not clear,
- 12:07So that by itself is insufficient. We can't just say harm has happened,
- 12:11right right, So then let's add a little bit of context. Imagine that
- 12:15we set an expectation for a child that they must put their toys away before
- 12:18going to bed. They don't put the toys away, So we take the
- 12:22toys away for a brief period of time and later return them. Is that,
- 12:26by definition revenge? It sounds like an attempt to punishment. But yeah,
- 12:31you know, I would think most people would hear that and think,
- 12:33no, right, like they're gonna they're gonna here, like you take it.
- 12:35You basically told the kid this is the expectation. They don't do the
- 12:39thing, and then you take away the toys as a consequence, because like,
- 12:43look, these have to be these have to be picked up. They're
- 12:45not picked up. They go away and we'll bring them back later, but
- 12:48for now they're lost. People are not thinking like, oh, yeah,
- 12:50you really got that kid good. You know. Instead it's like, what
- 12:54was the intention of doing that? Okay, So let's go to a second
- 12:56scenario. Imagine we have an employee, maybe coworker, maybe with a supervisor
- 13:01whatever. They're constantly late to work and after several instances of this, and
- 13:07let's say like egregiously late, they're like half an hour late. Yeah,
- 13:09right after several instances of this, we're like, okay, we have to
- 13:13write you up. This is happening too much. Is the supervisor getting revenge?
- 13:18I mean, like you could see how it reads like that, But
- 13:22at the same time, it's like, you know, that's again that's that
- 13:24blurry line of like, well, is this revenge? And there are people
- 13:26that will say, oh, that's just revenge. You're just trying to get
- 13:30You're just trying to get me for whatever reason, like you just don't like
- 13:33me, and da da da dah. That's retaliation and all that fun stuff.
- 13:35Right. I've heard employees that say stuff like that often. I think
- 13:37what you might say is then the employee might try to get revenge, but
- 13:41the write up in this case, it feels to me it's like, I
- 13:45mean, certainly it could be revenge, right, Like, that could be
- 13:48what's going on here, but it also is like, that's also what's going
- 13:52to happen in most employment situations. If you're constantly like late, you're gonna
- 13:58get in trouble right up, my be the best thing that could happen to
- 14:01you in those circumstances, right, Right, So I think it's just worth
- 14:03considering, Like, you know, it could be it could be revenge,
- 14:05but like by itself, it feels like that's not enough. I think what
- 14:09we have in here is there is often the temptation or the inclination to sort
- 14:15of conflate revenge with punishment. Yes, but both of these examples that we've
- 14:20provided, looking at the punishment side of things, right, it's the we're
- 14:24trying to have some kind of consequence that decreases the likelihood of that behavior being
- 14:28a problem in the future. But they're not really in what we're thinking of
- 14:33revenge. We're talking about people who are getting back at someone or getting their
- 14:35vengeance, right. You Know, when we use these examples and it comes
- 14:39up, there's always that question of like whether or not somebody is trying to
- 14:43get back at you, like or trying to get back at that person.
- 14:46Like, one thing that comes up a lot is when ads play, it
- 14:50feels like somebody's trying to get back at us. So well, luckily you
- 15:01always write this in the notes that I always have a hard time saying this
- 15:03word colloquially speaking. That was good. Hey, thanks, my mouth works.
- 15:09Sometimes we tend to talk about punishment as a penalty for some violated expectation,
- 15:13in which the punishment is intended to teach something about the future behavior.
- 15:16But in both the scenarios that we just kind of referenced, the punishment may
- 15:20be and also hopefully is delivered without anger. Right. Typically, when we're
- 15:24delivering a punishment based situation or like trying to impose some kind of outcome as
- 15:30a result of not following expectations, they're typically delivered without anger. When they
- 15:35are delivered with anger, it's a little bit iffy, exactly, right.
- 15:37Yeah, Like if you imagine the parent is like yelling at the you know,
- 15:41they're like, I'm checking your tours away, Like it's gonna feel maybe
- 15:46a bit more yucky and sort of on the revenge spectrum of things, right,
- 15:50But they're like, oh, that was what happens like I told you,
- 15:52and if you're not going to do it, then that's what happens.
- 15:54So I think oftentimes in those punishment Now, punishment certainly can be delivered with
- 15:58anger, sure it can function that way, but oftentimes punishment is specifically calculated
- 16:04to be delivered in a specific way to have a specific outcome. Like,
- 16:08Okay, we're almost strategizing here, we want to prevent this thing from happening
- 16:14in the future. Let's like, what is going to be the outcome that
- 16:17we deliver that's going to have that effect. Sure, So, of course
- 16:21in both examples, they could be done as active revenge. But let's continue
- 16:26for a second. So maybe maybe they were intended to cause harm. Okay,
- 16:30So, like, as an example, let's use a military sniper killing
- 16:33a target or murder attacking a victim. Are these scenarios, these circumstances,
- 16:38Are these considered revenge? I mean, it's it, you know, as
- 16:42we start to unpack this, it's it's hard to say, right. So
- 16:45it's like, okay, if we just started so we went the like punishment
- 16:48route, Okay, now let's just go someone's just doing harm to someone route,
- 16:53Like, Okay, maybe maybe what revenge is is it is intentionally causing
- 16:56harm. I'm like, okay, Well, a military snipper like target,
- 17:00what it like? They could feel bad about that, right, they could
- 17:03have protest against that. There have been a sign to do that thing,
- 17:07murder, attacking a victim. It could be out of revenge, right,
- 17:11that could be why they did it, but it also might be for any
- 17:14other number of reasons that people do that sort of thing. I guess,
- 17:17right, So, like by itself, it feels like it's insufficient to call
- 17:22it revenge like like it could be, but not in most cases. And
- 17:26I think that that sort of highlights is it must mean that there's something about
- 17:30whether it is felt to be deserved harm, right, the recipient deserves that
- 17:36harm for something that they've done. So I think we've done some good sort
- 17:40of stripping away like what it isn't. So let's let's step away from the
- 17:42what it isn't format and start talking about I think, just what else is
- 17:48entailed and trying to get the definition of revenge right. So it's not just
- 17:52that they did something to deserve it, it's whether it is perceived as intention
- 17:56and if they have agencies. So basically, what I'm saying is like,
- 18:00it gets even worse when the avenger, the person who is in you know,
- 18:03engaging in the vengeance type of behavior, engaging in the revenge, is
- 18:07feeling angry. So there is this kind of conversation around so much of it
- 18:12is implementing this stuff based on the fact that somebody else deserves it because they
- 18:18have wronged somebody and I'm angry about it. Yeah, And so this part
- 18:22about the intention and agency is really important because let's say, for example,
- 18:26children, we tend not to try and get revenge on children. They often
- 18:30don't know any better. It's for yourself. I'm just kidding. I love
- 18:37children. They often don't know any better. Oftentimes it's just being reckless.
- 18:40Like we look at that and we think of probably not trying to get revenge
- 18:45people with intellectual disabilities when they like do something that's like this is not something
- 18:48that's normally acceptable, and not that it is acceptable, but we're not actually
- 18:52trying to get revenge on them. We understand that for their circumstance there maybe
- 18:56was a lack of intentionality or like something there, So like the purveyor of
- 19:00retribution must perceive that it was done intentionally or recklessly and therefore the recipient deserves
- 19:07it, so like they had intention, they had agency, or like.
- 19:11Another one is often people who are significantly inebriated, they might do something and
- 19:17although that can be really frustrating and really upsetting unless it's vehicle related, most
- 19:22of the time like people will sort of give them a bit of like,
- 19:26Okay, I understand in most circumstances you wouldn't have done this, but in
- 19:30this case, you were inebriated. You shouldn't have been inebriated, and certainly
- 19:32not to the level that you were, so that's a problem. But like
- 19:36you did something bad, we're not necessarily going to try and get revenge because
- 19:40we know that you were under the influence of whatever you were under the influence
- 19:44of right. And then there's this whole aspect of the idea that like revenge
- 19:48seems warranted or like called for, and increasingly so as long as the action
- 19:55done is perceived as wrongful to the person now seeking the revenge right, so
- 20:02they had to be harmed in a way that felt wrongful and unjust right,
- 20:07So this leads us to a close to an official definition of this right.
- 20:11So definition of revenge or vengeance would be to do harm to someone who is
- 20:17perceived to have done wrongful, unjust harm to us. And that is with
- 20:22intention and with agency, right, Like, like you just mentioned, like
- 20:25we tend to give people more grace and compassion when we feel like they are
- 20:30not in control of the behavior that is wrong. Like that doesn't necessarily excuse
- 20:33the behavior, but we tend to be like, oh, okay, Like,
- 20:37if you'd have done this under any other circumstances, we would be having
- 20:40a long conversation about this. Yeah, exactly so, And I think that's
- 20:42unique. That's kind of an interesting aspect of this as considering like under what
- 20:48condition does it happen? And it's kind of a very specific niche, but
- 20:52it's a kind of very specific niche of circumstances that happens a lot a lot,
- 20:57and so, like, I think we experience opportunities for thinking about revenge
- 21:03even when it's not directly related to us throughout the day. And a good
- 21:07example of this too is like we tell stories about revenge all the time.
- 21:11Stories throughout human history love revenge. Yeah, motive as a theme. We
- 21:18were just talking before we hit record, John Wick, like the very popular
- 21:22movie series all about revenge. Yeah, John Wick, Monkey Man on a
- 21:27newer one that came out. Take the Taken movies. Oh my god,
- 21:30taking movies. Yeah, like I mean the Avengers. Yeah. In the
- 21:34name, the literal point of them getting together was to beat up Loki.
- 21:38Yeah. Yeah, is to get revenge. Yeah, man on fire.
- 21:41And then like many Shakespearean plays, Hamlet, many Greek stories throughout time,
- 21:47there's is a hugely popular motif to set up storytelling. Yeah, that people
- 21:52resonate with the person who's getting revenge. Yeah, like they're on the side
- 21:57of the venge seeker. Right. The comic book Deadly Class. Deadly Classes
- 22:02is like an entire series that is dedicated to one person seeking revenge. Okay,
- 22:06it's great, it's a great series, but it is one that's like,
- 22:07oh, here's another one. I think, isn't Ninja Scrolls too,
- 22:11like like anime, Like there's all kinds of there's there's so much out there.
- 22:15Don't quote me on that, because I'm not an anime. I want
- 22:19people to get mad of me. But I think Ninja Scrolls is like a
- 22:22revenge story. Okay. I was actually just thinking as you started saying that,
- 22:26I think you could really say that The Dark Tower is a revenge story.
- 22:30Oh my god. Yeah, like both sides, like both your antagonists
- 22:34and your protagonists are getting revenge against one another the whole time, forever,
- 22:38forever, and an endless struggle of cycles of vengeance. So yes, just
- 22:45let it go, you know, just let it go. That's actually you
- 22:48know what's funny is now that you said that the entire story is that,
- 22:52right, The moral of the story is just let it go. Yeah,
- 22:55Yeah, it's great. Yeah, And I think several state and King stories
- 23:00do that, And I think a lot of stories do that, Like that's
- 23:02not unique to him and at all, Like this is a very very common
- 23:06thing that we see. Yeah, and I think also, as you said,
- 23:08like I think he has the underlying like we seek the revenge, but
- 23:12the morals let it go. I think of the Green Mile is kind of
- 23:15a good idea. Yeah. Yeah. So anyway, there's a lot of
- 23:19like sort of pop culture type references and literary references. But the other thing
- 23:25to think about too is that, like, although we do have these stories,
- 23:27a lot of them are sort of the protagonists seeking revenge and we identify
- 23:30with them. We also have a lot of stories that talk about like the
- 23:33recipient of revenge and we identify with them instead. It's all in how the
- 23:37writer wants to tell the story, and I think we have there's very good
- 23:41examples of us having mixed interpretations of what we think about revenge in our culture.
- 23:48Sometimes revenge is good. We have the bad guys that get their comeuppance,
- 23:53the good guys get the bad guys, right, is a sort of
- 23:56common way. But then we also have revenge as fearing bad. It can
- 24:00appear petty and childish and just spitefully mean, you know, and like inappropriate,
- 24:07and then sometimes it's kind of in this neutral gray zone. And I
- 24:11think that's very common when we're sort of telling historical narratives about two warring factions
- 24:17where they both feel aggrieved toward one another, and it just sort of seems
- 24:21like they're both trying to settle that grievance, but they're kind of going back
- 24:23and forth, and sometimes one sort of getting a leg up and then the
- 24:26other. Kind of makes me think a little bit about Star Wars, although
- 24:30it's very clearly who the bad guys were in that, Yeah, the Jedi,
- 24:33the gi Oh got me there. And then there's these these moments and
- 24:41stories where we see our hero or a protagonist. Often they do this has
- 24:45an opportunity to exact their revenge and then they avoid it, And then we
- 24:51see this as being like this almost saintly, very compassionate, very mature sort
- 24:56of approach. But we could also see someone who had an opportunity to get
- 25:00the revenge and didn't and see that as being weak or cowardly and ineffectual.
- 25:06Yeah, it's plays out a lot of different ways. This is really not
- 25:08a clear cut way that we sort of think about and talk about it in
- 25:12our storytelling well, and I think there is something to be said too,
- 25:15like to the point of like sometimes we see it's good, sometimes we see
- 25:18it's bad. And I think it really depends on what side you're on of
- 25:21the moral argument, right, Like there's got to be because they think about
- 25:25it's the same mechanism, right, But when it's a bad guy getting their
- 25:27come up and so it's justice. Yeah, when it's you know, somebody
- 25:30coming after me to intentionally harm me, then it's revenge, you know.
- 25:34So I think there's also that framing device that changes the way that we perceive
- 25:38it and how much of it can we accept, not even just like how
- 25:42we enact it or how people enact it, but like what we will accept
- 25:47as a reasonable response to a situation, you know, like okay, you
- 25:51know, and there is like going back to somebody broke the law, they
- 25:55go to jail. Is that in itself revenge? Not necessarily? But then
- 25:57when you think of like the movie Death Sentence with Kevin Bacon, where you
- 26:03know, if you've never seen that, he his son is killed by some
- 26:07some gang members like during like a like a robbery, and he ends up
- 26:11the whole movie is a revenge movie where he is going and finding these gang
- 26:15members and killing them all. So you know, it's a great movie,
- 26:18great, great, great movie, but it is one of those ones where
- 26:19you're like you're rooting for the guy who's literally murdering everybody. Yeah, yeah,
- 26:25and we're going that's good, and we're going that's good. And it's
- 26:26like, no, that's not. That's not good. That's bad path that
- 26:30go down. But you know, it's it's it's really how how it's framed,
- 26:32because like you could frame that a is going he's just getting justice for
- 26:34his son's death. Something you said though, is so important and that you
- 26:38were sort of alluding to in that story is that like in real life outside
- 26:44of stories and movies, everyone is the hero of their own story. Yeah.
- 26:48There. I think there are circumstances where it's pretty easy to say you
- 26:52were in the wrong, and there are people who will even admit I was
- 26:55in the wrong right. But a lot of the time, when we're in
- 26:59these situations where there's like a back and forth revenge seeking going on, both
- 27:06people think they're on the right and honestly, if you were to consider that
- 27:08other person's perspective and what they're dealing with from your revenge, and then I
- 27:15think you start to understand, like nobody's in the right here. Right,
- 27:18you know, there is no right side of this. This is just and
- 27:22sometimes like it's just a big complicated mess, like maybe one person started the
- 27:26grievance, but then the other person, you know, they followed up with
- 27:30a revenge, and then they just go back and forth until they've both done
- 27:33so much harm to each other that it doesn't even matter where it started.
- 27:37They both did terrible things, right, and the person who started it probably
- 27:41again it was not in bad faith, like they probably did something that seemed
- 27:45like it was appropriate and justified to them at the time. And again We're
- 27:49not trying to excuse bad behavior here, but I think oftentimes we get into
- 27:53these conflicts where they're totally unnecessary because both sides have done wrong and you just
- 28:03have to stop and break the cycle. Right. Speaking of breaking the cycle,
- 28:07here's an ad welcome back from that broken cycle. We'll reinstate cycle now,
- 28:19all right. I like that. So some other things sort of talking
- 28:23about here is and considering an understanding revenge is a lot of the research and
- 28:30science, and I guess you could say observation loosely speaking, has sort of
- 28:33classified what people tend to do and the revenge seeking, and I think that
- 28:38that does help illustrate what we're talking about here and why it matters. Right,
- 28:44So, people tend to exact revenge more when there is less of an
- 28:48opportunity or less of a likelihood that the recipient of said revenge will actually seek
- 28:52further revenge against them. Basically, what this is saying is people are more
- 28:56likely to get revenge if there's no return on that revenge, right, Like
- 29:02you are not going to get back at me if I act on this,
- 29:04this is gonna be the end of it. People are more likely to do
- 29:07it. Yeah, So often there's just an imbalance of dynamics here, so
- 29:14they're more likely to try and get revenge when they're larger, stronger, they
- 29:18have more physical or metaphorical power, they've got better weapons or better defenses.
- 29:22So like in the example you said of like when you're seventeen years old,
- 29:26like someone rereends you and you, guys, get out that person slaps you
- 29:30in the face. Let's also say that they're standing at like seven foot six,
- 29:33they weigh two hundred pounds and or three hundred pounds in the air professional
- 29:37boxer, Like, are you going to try and get revenge on them for
- 29:40that slap? No, but I will definitely. I would like at that
- 29:42time, I would have left them with something that would have made them question
- 29:45everything, Like I would have like dropped some psychological bomb on them somewhere,
- 29:49because that's that's the kind of That's the kind of revenge I like, is
- 29:52the one that's like a deep seated, like it stays with you forever.
- 29:56Yeah, to put the plant a little nugget that has them a question reality.
- 30:00Yeah, Hey, yeah, it's great. That's my favorite. Yeah.
- 30:03So yeah, like they're not going to do the when there's an imbalance
- 30:08in that and you there's a high likelihood that if you try and get revenge,
- 30:12they're going to get revenge back. People tend not to try and get
- 30:15revenge. Yeah, and so it's like again, now this is illustrating that,
- 30:18like revenge is the big guy picking on the little guy, and like,
- 30:22yeah, is that who you want to be? Right? I also
- 30:25don't want to be revenged, you know, I don't want to do that,
- 30:30and I don't want to be revenge. So and the thing is is
- 30:32people tend to seek to inflict harm at as least as as great as the
- 30:36original offense, if not greater, so like at least at that level.
- 30:38So when people go to get revenge, it's again I kind of mentioned at
- 30:42the top of the show, where it's that balance is off, so they're
- 30:47trying to rebalance the scales. So it's like it has to be tit for
- 30:49tat, you know, eye for an eye type of situation like oh you
- 30:53did this, so here's equal and swift response to that situation, yeah or
- 30:59more or like it's either like you're gonna get You're gonna get it, or
- 31:02I'm gonna make this so bad for you that you'll never do this again,
- 31:06Yeah, avenge sevenfold. And then thinking about like where revenge takes place.
- 31:11Oftentimes revenge will happen in existing relationships, and I think it's because when you
- 31:15have a close relationship with someone, both people are a little bit more vulnerable
- 31:19to one another, which means they are a little bit more vulnerable to potential
- 31:23harms or interpretations of slights or or wrongs or whatnot. Right, But of
- 31:29course this can happen between total strangers, as in our story at the top
- 31:33of the episode. It can even happen between nations of people and leaders,
- 31:37and it does seem like they're that social aspect can really complicate the dynamic of
- 31:41that, right. The neurology studies that we were able to look at neurology
- 31:45studies report that people tend to expect a feeling of reward and satisfaction when planning
- 31:51revenge. So like, as we're getting it together, like you know,
- 31:53Macaulay Culkin is doing his battle plans for the trap houses that he's working in,
- 31:57and like he's like, Yeah, I'm gonna ge back of these guys
- 32:00for being mean. I take that, Marv. You know, like there
- 32:02is like a level of like reward and satisfaction that is expected while you're kind
- 32:07of going through the plotting stages right yeah. Now, although often revenge is
- 32:14is kind of reactionary, revenge might be a quick response to some perceived slight
- 32:19or transgression. Obviously, you can think of revenge is plotted and sort of
- 32:23planned out for a really long time. And I think there have been actual
- 32:28stories of people who waited, you know, like three decades, and then
- 32:30they got back at someone three decades later, they planning their revenge the whole
- 32:36entire time. Count them on Christo. That I mean a fictional story,
- 32:39but that's the basic idea in there. He's like spends years and years and
- 32:44years building his revenge and then once he amasses enough wealth and power, just
- 32:49goes around just destroying the lives of every person who was responsible for imprisoning him
- 32:54and ruining his life. That's the path I'm on right now. So you
- 33:00if you are somebody who has harmed me and you're listening to the show,
- 33:06just you wait. I genuinely don't have the energy for that, Like I
- 33:12that's something I was I guess we're kind of going through this. I'm like,
- 33:14I don't even have like the like, I don't have the mental capacity
- 33:16right now to even consider revenge on somebody, let alone the time and the
- 33:22response effort. I just can't do it. We're getting too old for this,
- 33:24and we're getting too old for revenge. I don't know, I'm just
- 33:27you know, I just can't. So let's talk a little bit about the
- 33:30pros and cons of revenge, which you know, is funny to think,
- 33:32like, what are the pros of revenge? Right? You know, as
- 33:36a general rule, these are some benefits that are discussed around this. First,
- 33:38it might be that the revenge is rightly justified, like, or it
- 33:43could be politically expedient. Right. The idea is like, there's some benefit
- 33:46in that you're gonna get what you want out of that situation because it was
- 33:51justified. It was helpful from a political standpoint. It's doing something to benefit
- 33:54you in that moment. It feels justified. At least it feels righteous,
- 33:59right, Yeah, maybe it is not actually, well anyway, that'd be
- 34:04a sort of values discussion. Sure. Another potential benefit here, and a
- 34:09heavy emphasis on the word potential, is it may create a sense of restoring
- 34:16the balance of suffering, which a balance of suffering might be good. Is
- 34:22this a band name, an album name, a song name at least,
- 34:25oh for sure that sounds like a Black Dolly Murder record that does. Yeah,
- 34:30that could be considered a benefit that if it works that way. Is
- 34:34this this sort of it levels the scales as yours have you as you've said
- 34:37multiple times, now, yeah, Equity theory actually states that people feel distressed
- 34:43when they feel like they've been treated unfairly. So if something has happened to
- 34:45you and you feel like you've been treated poorly, then yes, this is
- 34:49something that will you'll feel some distress around that, and revenge may actually serve
- 34:53to alleviate that distress by making the situation more fair by kind of like going
- 34:59back and going, Okay, well, now this feels fair because it was
- 35:01not fair before. And so all that is to say, when you sort
- 35:05of put that all together, that getting revenge may have someone feel better about
- 35:08the situation. That's a purported potential potential benefit of getting revenge, right,
- 35:16But there are drawbacks obviously. So first, it tends to perpetuate an endless
- 35:22cycle of retaliation. I mean, all you got to do is look at
- 35:24the hat Fields and the McCoys spanning generations. Yeah, yeah, like for
- 35:30real, it was like you murdered my uncle, I'm gonna murder your uncle.
- 35:35And they just went on like that for many, many, many decades.
- 35:37That is exactly one of the biggest problems with this. It almost always
- 35:42results in a back and forth. For not almost always. There are lots
- 35:45of instances where it's kind of a one off. Something does something, someone
- 35:50does something else, but it can quite easily lead to this just ongoing,
- 35:53perpetual like you get back at me, I get back at you for getting
- 35:58back at me, and then you get back at me for getting back at
- 36:00you for getting back at me, and it just goes on and on.
- 36:02Right. Another one is that this is an important one, I think.
- 36:07So the avenger tends to feel because they've exacted their revenge, the tendency that
- 36:14they've reported is that they actually tend to feel an increased sense of fear that
- 36:19they're going to then receive additional retaliation from the recipient of the revenge, and
- 36:23that they can actually that fear can persist for a long time. So it's
- 36:27like even if they had an immediate like burst of yes, I got back
- 36:30at them, then they it turns pretty quickly into what if they try and
- 36:35get back at me, Yeah, or someone related to them or in their
- 36:38circle does, right, And so like now I'm kind of on a bunch
- 36:43of people's hit list, and now I need to watch my back and just
- 36:46be constantly on the lookout, and that that fear just sort of carries out
- 36:50for a long time. Yeah. Another thing too is the Avenger tends to
- 36:53think about it, think about the situation, and think about the revenge and
- 36:57the experience aversive emotions for longer. So I was reading that thinking about that.
- 37:00I was thinking of the scene and end game Avengers Endgame where Scarlett Witch
- 37:07says you took everything from me and Thana says, I don't even know who
- 37:09you are. Yeah, Like if that, if that doesn't tell you how
- 37:13revenge is so powerful. Like she was like thinking about this forever and He's
- 37:17like, nah, I don't even I mean I you know, it was
- 37:22like it didn't even impact him, Like it wasn't even not on his register.
- 37:23So like the person who was avenging Scarlet Witch was like having all of
- 37:28this emotion around this, and Dano's didn't even for a long time, Yeah,
- 37:34just carried it with her. Yeah. Another job. I think pretty
- 37:37clear drawback to revenge is that, because we talked about how it can happen
- 37:42in like interpersonal relationships with people that you know, it can pretty quickly damage
- 37:45those relationships, often beyond repair. Now, sometimes there's sort of a dynamic
- 37:51in relationship where it's just a lot of back and forth going at each other,
- 37:55and that just persists for a long time and it kind of works.
- 37:59But when it turns into like a cycle of revenge, and particularly it is
- 38:04it escalates, which those things can do, Like it gets to a point
- 38:07where it's like that maybe was once a valuable relationship is now both a source
- 38:12of distress, fear, frustration, anger, and like misery, and it
- 38:16just continues to get worse and worse over time. And it's like now that
- 38:20person who was once a friend is now like a bitter enemy and like so
- 38:24that and that happens that can happen because of revenge, right, it's bad.
- 38:30Another drawback we would argue is that rather than being cathartic, it tends
- 38:35to keep feelings of the injury present for longer, Like so it just kind
- 38:39of festers and doesn't really get better, Like it doesn't like now I've resolved
- 38:45the situation, Now what because you've spent and also you spend so much time
- 38:50planning and plotting your revenge and having that feeling around it, Like you're still
- 38:53gonna have the feelings about that situation. Yeah, Like it doesn't make you
- 38:58feel better that you hurt somebody else. Very rarely does that happen, So
- 39:01there is that experience around that too, and very often we come to regret
- 39:07those vengeful acts. Like it's in the moment, we're all heated, we're
- 39:10all worked up or escalated, and we get we go and flicked our revenge
- 39:16and after a while we kind of have to sit with that and feel like
- 39:20I wish I hadn't done that, and like the damage is done. You
- 39:23can done doo it. There's no control y for this, you know.
- 39:27It is just you just have to live with that now and then that's something
- 39:30you regret. So it's like try and act less impulsively, right, That's
- 39:36what I'm saying, Like just just don't do it, just to try to
- 39:39like get get that under control, get that under control, and you know,
- 39:44I think at the end of the day, like it can escalate the
- 39:45conflict, it can make things way worse because you're just kind of again perpetuating
- 39:50that cycle of back and forth, back and forth, back and forth,
- 39:52and as a result of that, like, not only do you end up
- 39:55getting hurt and the person that you're trying to hurt gets hurt, but people
- 39:58around you get hurt. I mean, I think genuinely the Hatfields McCoy is
- 40:02like, now that I've brought that up, now that's all I can think
- 40:05about as far as like the revenge tale goes, Yeah, because so many
- 40:08members of the family ended up getting killed as a result of that back and
- 40:13forth between two people. It started with two people and it just turned into
- 40:17a family affair, you know. Yeah. I ran into several stories that
- 40:22talked about there being some countries where like some people in power have blood feuds
- 40:28that have been going on for generations where they're basically killing off, you know,
- 40:32groups of people, maybe families, you know, or or some group
- 40:37of people that they're killing off members that have just been going gone on for
- 40:39decades, right that they've they've been keeping it going. So oh we I
- 40:44talked a long time about that TV show Hunters, and the whole premise of
- 40:49that show was it was mostly Jewish people. I think it was mostly I
- 40:54think there were some people who weren't in like the nineteen sixties, I think
- 41:00hunting down x Nazis, yeah, and killing them and like that was the
- 41:04whole show. Like the whole premise is sort of John wick Ish in that
- 41:07sense, right, the Nazis who survived, who are sort of out and
- 41:09about, they were hunting them down, particularly those who were like practice,
- 41:14you know, continuing to be Nazis. But also just yeah, so anyway,
- 41:20like as you said, like it can escalate and it just gets worse
- 41:22and worse and worse, and the conflict grows more and more severe. That's
- 41:25also one of the major drawbacks and a major drawback to like having a podcast
- 41:30is having to play ads. All right, let's get back to it.
- 41:39We're in our home stretch here, I think. Yeah, so let's ask
- 41:43the question why why do we revenge? How we revenge? And there is
- 41:47the question I've kind of mentioned a couple of times, is that there is
- 41:51you know, some folks want to restore balance. They might want to they
- 41:52might feel like the scales are unfairly tipped and so they've got to do that
- 41:58or what they want to do is they wanted to turn future behavior right.
- 42:00So it's like I've got a big stick and I'm gonna swing it right.
- 42:02The idea that like, Okay, you got back at me, I'm gonna
- 42:06get back at you so bad that you're never gonna want to do this again.
- 42:08But this is never born out of observation or research. Like people will
- 42:13just often overdo revenge so it's not balanced, so they actually tip the scales
- 42:17the other way. And even if it is equated, people will typically not
- 42:22report feeling fair or balanced afterwards. So like, even when they do get
- 42:25revenge, it doesn't work the way that they think it will. Yeah,
- 42:30it doesn't seem to actually restore balance. And another one we mentioned is that
- 42:32people will say, oh, I want to deter future problem behavior from occurring
- 42:37again, like that's why to get revenge right. Well, the thing is
- 42:42like that doesn't seem to hold up. Deterrence seems to fail because again it
- 42:46tends to escalate and prolong the conflict and and fight for the retribution. And
- 42:52I think this is not something that is lost on people because they walk around
- 42:55and fear. People tend to expect further retribution when they've been vengeful right,
- 43:01right, They've actually done research on this where not only do they expect more,
- 43:06they're more fearful and they expect retaliation when they've exacted their revenge, but
- 43:10when they have not been vengeful, they are much less likely to expect any
- 43:15further aggression from the original transgressor again if they had not been vengeful. And
- 43:21then another reason that it seems like deterrence is not really true and not really
- 43:25an actual motive for what's going on here is because in these studies, when
- 43:30people have been given an opportunity to seek revenge on a stranger they'd never see
- 43:35again, they were much more likely to try and exect revenge, and they
- 43:40were more likely to do it more severely, so they would never even have
- 43:45a chance to see if this deterrence work. Right, So it's actually pretty
- 43:50clear it's not ever being used as a deterrent, not really. It seems
- 43:55like the deterrent rationalization is more of just a post talk excuse for saying I
- 44:04was angry, I was escalated, I wanted to get back at the person,
- 44:08and then to justify that, I'm like, well, this will prevent
- 44:12them from doing that again in the future, even though we know that it
- 44:15won't. You're more likely to do it if you think you can get away
- 44:17with it and not have retribution. And it tends to and in most circumstances,
- 44:22it tends to escalate, and most people kind of know that that can
- 44:25happen too, so like deterrence is kind of it's just a myth, right,
- 44:31Yeah, it's an excuse. I mean, it's an excuse now.
- 44:34Oh, Enders Game, that was what I was thinking of when I was
- 44:37thinking about this, because an Enders Game, he kind of has this whole
- 44:40spiel about like even though he's he's feeling like he's not that violent of a
- 44:45person, He's like when he was getting bullied, he's like, I have
- 44:50to put that person down so that they can't hit back, And that was
- 44:52part of what has them select him as like sort of the leader of things.
- 44:57Yeah, is like we want this kid because his ration now is end
- 45:00any future threat, and so they're like answer genocide. Yeah, what a
- 45:07wild book. Yeah, it's a great book, but it's it's that series
- 45:12is interesting dark. It's dark, yeah, and it doesn't really get lighter
- 45:15as you go through the rest of the series. No, it's weirder,
- 45:19weirder, Yeah, for sure, Now, revenge generally happens in the context
- 45:22of an angry emotion, and so anger is often a key part, if
- 45:27not central, to revenge, and that in itself is a pretty significant driver
- 45:31for people. But people are angry, they tend to want to do things,
- 45:36and maybe they don't think about the outcomes of those things and whatnot.
- 45:38But when people are angry, they tend to do a lot of things,
- 45:42and that in itself that burns out very quickly if you want to kind of
- 45:45use the idea of like emotion as like a motivation and stuff like that.
- 45:49But yeah, like basically, like emotion is so fluid, like you know,
- 45:53when you read stuff like on Act and the kind of talk about the
- 45:55idea that like emotions are really more like visitors that kind of like magnify certain
- 46:00motivations at a time. Anger is one that's like a quick visitor that magnifies
- 46:05the need for revenge, and then it goes away and then you get revenge,
- 46:07and then you're left with the fallout and no anger from that situation or
- 46:12maybe some like resentment or whatever. You know, there's a lot of kind
- 46:15of weird stuff to unpack inside of that. Yeah, very much, so
- 46:19Another thing that can happen with revenge is that there can be a very important
- 46:24and significant social component, like what will people think if I don't retaliate.
- 46:30I think I see this a lot in politics, right, yes, And
- 46:34there's this sort of like I have to look like I'm taking action Otherwise people
- 46:38will think I'm weak, or they'll think I'm ineffectual, or they'll think,
- 46:42you know, I can't handle this, or they'll basically say like you need
- 46:46to get back at this person or entity or group of people or whatever.
- 46:52And so I think there's a social component of not wanting to appear, not
- 46:57wanting to feel embarrassed, wanting to avoid them, ra not wanting to appear
- 47:00weak. That with those things, I'm kind of like, honestly in my
- 47:06mind what people think right like that really is not when when the difference is
- 47:14like someone's life is on the line or someone's going to be mad at me,
- 47:19I'll take someone being mad at me right right. And again, it
- 47:22is a values thing. It's a big values thing. The other thing,
- 47:24too, is just thinking about like it does escalating all that. So it's
- 47:27like, am I willing to risk escalating this situation so I don't look bad,
- 47:30and I think most people are not most, but I've seen it happen
- 47:35a lot in very public forums, right exactly. It's unfortunate because people care
- 47:39so much about how they're perceived that they yeah, it serves as a detriment.
- 47:45Yeah. I think one of the more interesting things that came out of
- 47:46this is that people who enjoy, like they self report enjoying hurting people,
- 47:52also tend to report supporting revenge seeking behavior. So what does that say about
- 47:57revenge? Do you want to be in that group? You want to be
- 47:59in the group of being people that like are totally good and think it's okay
- 48:01and actually really enjoy hurting other people, because that's the people that are like,
- 48:06that's they're the revenge approvers. Yeah. Yeah. You go to a
- 48:08party, you meet a person, and you say to what do you like
- 48:10to do? I like to hurt people. You're like, oh, let's
- 48:13be friends. I like to revenge. Yeah, I want to be friends
- 48:16with you. You like to hurt people, right, Like, you don't
- 48:21want to be in that camp, Like people who report enjoyed hurting people are
- 48:24psychopaths, right, like right, And that's a very loaded thing to even
- 48:28say on a show like this, and I think we need to address psychopathy
- 48:30at some point in the future. But I think speaking more loosely and off
- 48:35the cuff of like that shouldn't be your idol, right, you know,
- 48:39like let's let's not aspire to that. Yeah, it's bad news. There's
- 48:44also whenever anything happens that humans do, they're like, why did we evolve
- 48:47this? And I mean, on the one hand, I can understand we're
- 48:51obviously doing it, so it was a product of evolution in one capacity or
- 48:53another. But there's one thing about this is that biologically, this is not
- 49:00entirely unique to humans. Right. There are many examples of animals who have
- 49:04attacked other animals when those animals stole their food. There's even there's like hyenas
- 49:08stole a kill from some lions, so the lions killed the hyaenas, and
- 49:13it's like, right, were they seeking revenge? We don't know, but
- 49:15it does seem like there was like a really targeted I'm going after you after
- 49:20you took my food type of thing. And most the examples that I came
- 49:22across were food related. And then there was an interesting one too with recess
- 49:28monkeys, where if one of the one member of the group found food and
- 49:31didn't share that food with a group or like alert that group to the food
- 49:35and they found out, then they would like beat up that monkey. Oh
- 49:38yeah, so there was like some amount of revenge there. So what aspect
- 49:44of this is biological? I mean, obviously we have the capacity for it.
- 49:47So there's that right right now. This was when it comes to revenge.
- 49:52It's almost certainly cultural too, when we really get into it. Possibly
- 49:55had to turn it first for those who would selfishly attack others to take resources.
- 50:00Eliminating the threat of people trying to take from others would result in equitable
- 50:05access to those resources for people in the group or else lost resources by all.
- 50:09Like we've got the situation where, you know, all the stuff could
- 50:13happen, but at the end of the day, it again, it doesn't
- 50:15really serve as a deterrent, Like revenge doesn't prevent because revenge occurs after something
- 50:21has happened, right, So like, yeah, it's weird to look at
- 50:23it like that, but but if we get rid of a threat, then
- 50:25we keep our resources and that makes sense from that perspective. But at the
- 50:30end of the day, like it's still hurting other people. I think the
- 50:34idea with talking about this aspect of it being cultural is thinking about sort of
- 50:40end of the world type setups, mostly zombie movies like or shows Walking Dead
- 50:46and Last of Us, that sort of thing. Let's say you're living in
- 50:49that situation and someone's like a group of marauders who go around basically attacking people,
- 50:54stealing their stuff, burning down their walls and whatnot, and then people
- 51:00seek revenge against them, they jail them or maybe even kill them, and
- 51:04then those people are no longer out attacking and killing and burning things down.
- 51:08What you've done in that case is you've essentially secured your resources and your people
- 51:15against that potential threat. So what the idea here is that like this could
- 51:21have this almost certainly evolved culturally back way back in time when cultures were starting
- 51:27to form and tribes were coming together, and there were certain people or other
- 51:31smaller tribes that were running around basically looting from other existing tribes, and then
- 51:37they were like, we got to stop this from happening anymore. There's a
- 51:42suggestion essentially that that's how that kind of came to be that makes sense.
- 51:45Another thing that sort of speaks to the cultural aspect of this is that the
- 51:49sort of acceptability of revenge and the motives for revenge, they tend to vary
- 51:54across cultures. So you can find different I guess, approaches to revenge in
- 52:00if you go to different countries. And so for one example, they did
- 52:02this study where they were I think they were just surveying people, and Americans
- 52:07were more likely to seek revenge if they felt that their individual rights or liberties
- 52:12were threatened or were removed. And alternatively, Koreans were more likely to seek
- 52:17revenge for duty based harms, so related to their obligations and their work and
- 52:23what they were sort of allowed to do. And also there was a huge
- 52:25component of like social aspect of revenge there. So that I think again further
- 52:31speaks to the fact that the motives for revenge are different in different places and
- 52:37consider acceptable under different circumstances. Alludes to the idea that the culture plays a
- 52:42significant role in how this is shaped up. Oh, most definitely. And
- 52:45I think you know, at the end of the day, when we start
- 52:47talking about kind of the behavior surrounding revenge and the experience of revenge and all
- 52:52that, I mean, it's absolutely learned, right. So there's really great
- 52:54quote about this that says, quote, children are not born with hate in
- 52:58their hearts, they must be taught it, right, And I think that
- 53:00that is so critically important for understanding how any of this works and how we
- 53:06operate as humans in that space. This is a quote from the TV show
- 53:09Ghosts that I've recommended before on here, and so they have this Viking character
- 53:15who tends to avoid using b verbs, so he says, children not born
- 53:20with hate in their hearts, they must be taught it. And it's played
- 53:23up for a joke because basically what happened is he wanted his son to hate
- 53:29Danes, but he died before his son grew up, and then his son
- 53:31grew up and married a Dane, and so he was like originally mad about
- 53:36it, and then he was like, well, it's not his fault.
- 53:37I wasn't there to teach him to hate Danes. That's sort of how the
- 53:40joke goes. Sure in my mind, I was like, what an incredibly
- 53:44profound quote to use as a joke for this, because it's absolutely correct,
- 53:47Like, yeah, children are not born with hate, they're taught to hate.
- 53:51So when that that develops, it's because it's been taught. And I
- 53:53think that we should look at it, look around at each other and be
- 53:57like, let's be ashamed of the fact that we've done this to this kid,
- 54:00right, and maybe be ashamed of the fact that we have to depend
- 54:02on ads. Okay, we're on our very last thing here. You just
- 54:14I think unpacking just a slightly different angle to take and understanding revenge. Yeah,
- 54:20so let's talk about the behavioral part of this. Now, behavior itself
- 54:22can be reinforced by relief. Right, the idea that somebody else's behavior is
- 54:27stopping. Somebody else's behavior that I dislike is stopping, right, and the
- 54:31individual caused the stop, so like as me myself, I have caused the
- 54:37stop. And there might have been this idea of signs of damage, like
- 54:39the idea that like, not only do I get this behavior to stop,
- 54:43but like I actually like seeing this person suffer. Yeah, And that is
- 54:47for our folks that agree that they enjoy hurting other people, that signs of
- 54:52damage pieces is fair game to consider. And for those of you who are
- 54:57not familiar, signs of damage simply means that another organ is am will enact
- 55:00harm on another organism just because they enjoy the result of the harm. It
- 55:06could be blood, it could be pain on the face when saying crying,
- 55:08the actual damage itself, like all of that's kind of what signs of damage
- 55:12means it Actually it can be damaged to inanimate objects as well. Yes,
- 55:15but the reinforcer, like the thing, the consequence they're working toward, or
- 55:21the thing that works to maintain that behavior, is that they got to see
- 55:25damage done, right, And that I think is sort of a behavioral way
- 55:29of unpacking, Like what is revenge. It is behavior that is reinforced when
- 55:34someone else's behavior stops. So you got someone to stop doing what they were
- 55:37doing, and so that is a reward. And you specifically were the one
- 55:42who caused that thing to stop, and when you did that, you were
- 55:45able to observe some signs of damage. You do cause some damage that was
- 55:50clearly observable. We call that multiple control. And so I think that's just
- 55:57a way of thinking about it. From like if we strip out like anything
- 56:00from intention, anything from motives, anything from anything else, what we can
- 56:05look at that is pretty empirically and objectively observable. Is that aspect of it,
- 56:09And that just again I think helps clarify ways that like how would we
- 56:13measure this if we were just watching and we didn't have context, if we
- 56:16knew those things, right, right, So I just think it's useful to
- 56:20think about that in that way sometimes. Another one we've talked about is this
- 56:23idea that like the act of revenge can result in like this long term persistence
- 56:30in our thoughts and emotions of the of anger, of the whatever, that
- 56:37if the original injury was, the last retaliatory injury was. And I think
- 56:42it's helpful to look at this as a verb, right, So we're going
- 56:45to go back to revenge is not a thing really, it's like an abstract
- 56:50noun, but when to turn into a verb avenging right, right? And
- 56:53when we think of this as an action. Every time we take an action,
- 56:57that's a behavior, and when we do that, it's strength that action
- 57:00and our psychological past and present. It's in our repertoire, right, it's
- 57:04there. Right. The more we do it, the more we're likely to
- 57:07continue to do it, particularly if it works in some way, and it
- 57:12just goes back to this endless cycle, the mathematical equation violence equals violence,
- 57:17yeah, and it just goes on forever. There's no additional solution to it.
- 57:22So at some point we've got to change what the other side of the
- 57:27equation is if we wanted to stop repeating right exactly. And another thing to
- 57:30think about too, is it makes sense that we would as an organism try
- 57:35to minimize harm to ourselves, like just from a basic survival standpoint, like
- 57:38I don't want harm to come to me, because if harm comes to me,
- 57:42then I will not survive, right, And so so we can not
- 57:46only just engaging this behavior that's revenge behavior for our own survival, but we
- 57:51also will do it because we can get away with it. And there is
- 57:54that piece too where it's like, Okay, I've been harmed. I'm going
- 57:58to get away with this by enacting revenge on somebody else. And so there
- 58:00is like this component of it makes sense that from a self preservation standpoint,
- 58:06it makes sense from a reward standpoint, I can get away with it.
- 58:08I get relief from doing this. There's all kinds of things that play a
- 58:12role in this, and so all of those contingencies make sense for why somebody
- 58:15would do this. So I think we're sort of getting to what I would
- 58:20think of as sort of a take home here, And I think one of
- 58:22the big take homes for understanding. This is like, the problem with revenge
- 58:25is it doesn't do any of the things that it promises to do. It
- 58:30doesn't work as a deterrent. It doesn't work to make us feel better.
- 58:32A matter of fact, it often makes us feel worse for longer, or
- 58:35at least continue to feel bad for longer. And it doesn't work to restore
- 58:38balance. Like, it doesn't work, It doesn't do anything. It just
- 58:43fails spectacularly at everything it says that it's trying to do, and it makes
- 58:46things significantly worse. That's exactly what I was going to say, is like,
- 58:51not only does it fail to resolve the issue, it makes things worse.
- 58:53It makes things worse by escalating conflicts, by causing distress and anxiety,
- 58:59by injuring relationationships. And then you live not only with the fact that you
- 59:02had to you had to commit this act of revenge, but now you have
- 59:07to live in fear after the fact because you don't know if you're going to
- 59:09get revenged on, like you might get revenged, which is like my I
- 59:14think I like saying that. I like I don't like saying it be the
- 59:15victim of it. I like you got revenged, You got revenged. I
- 59:20like it. I think that's great. Yeah right, I personally think we
- 59:22should turn all of our past tense verbs into just add ed to the end,
- 59:27like I drive to work today. Yeah, just make English. It'll
- 59:30make a little bit more sense. Yeah yeah, big fan. All right,
- 59:31So thinking about this, we've sort of already been espousing this. But
- 59:35what can we do about this? I think, I mean, we as
- 59:38a podcast nothing we can tell you what we think, and sure, you
- 59:43know, maybe you'll listen to us, but I mean you're here with us
- 59:45now, so thank you. But in terms of us as a species,
- 59:49we can end the cycle by doing things that are are kind of obvious.
- 59:52Right, Instead of getting revenge, we practice forgiveness, right by considering the
- 59:57perspective of the other person. We can try and put ourselves in their shoes
- 1:00:01and understand where they're coming from, and these things, and again never to
- 1:00:07justify when things. When people do bad things, and people are going to
- 1:00:09do bad things, and we want a system that deals with that appropriately.
- 1:00:14But the system shouldn't be Hamaabi's code. You know, you looked at me
- 1:00:19sideways, so I chopped off your arm. You called me a bad word,
- 1:00:22so I hung your whole family Like that is not the way to go,
- 1:00:27No, not at all. Instead, it's really just considering the perspective
- 1:00:30of understanding where they're coming from when it makes sense to do so, trying
- 1:00:32to bring some level of compassion to this. I think that's the best possible
- 1:00:37endpoint. Like I think that it it doesn't serve anybody anything. It really
- 1:00:45truly is the worst kind of way to go about resolving the conflict, because
- 1:00:50ultimately, what you're talking about is there is a conflict in place, right,
- 1:00:52and so your response is to go bigger, go harder, scare this
- 1:00:55person, hurt this person, and that solves none of the problem because the
- 1:01:00problem has still existed, it will continue to exist, And now you're left
- 1:01:05with not only do I have the original problem, but now I've created more
- 1:01:07problem. Like it just does nothing but fuel the fire. Another thing that
- 1:01:13we can do about it is practicing mindfulness. There's actually been some experimental research
- 1:01:17that's shown that when people practice mindfulness, they it'll de escalate some of those
- 1:01:22more intense emotions and they're less likely to report wanting to even seek retribution afterward.
- 1:01:29It's not a panacea It won't fix everything, but it does help at
- 1:01:32least turn the dial down a little bit on the temperature of that experience,
- 1:01:37and so people are able to sort of make more intentional decisions then right,
- 1:01:42and then finally again, just thinking about this, this violence equals violence,
- 1:01:45this escalation, this endless cycle of revenge. What we can try and do
- 1:01:51instead is, as often as possible, lead with compassion. Lead with compassion,
- 1:01:55even when we feel we've been wronged the whole turn the other cheek.
- 1:02:00Right, it's just another thing we can try and make this world a less
- 1:02:05scary place to live if we can trust each other because we're compassionate toward one
- 1:02:09another. Right, Like, it seems like mostly we want our species to
- 1:02:14continue. Like we keep having kids, We keep like building medical institutions to
- 1:02:19like support people medically, right, we keep trying to make things safer,
- 1:02:22so like, I think we want our species to keep going. So like,
- 1:02:25let's also take on this psychological aspect of be kind to one another and
- 1:02:30practice compassion and forgiveness and see if we can then move toward not killing each
- 1:02:36other anymore. Right, you know, yeah, hanging fruit, Yeah,
- 1:02:39it seems nice enough. I do want to end really quick on just a
- 1:02:42little personal note. I know we're gon kind of long, but you were
- 1:02:45sort of speaking about like when you were younger and you would get you know,
- 1:02:47had someone done that to you. I used to love the idea of
- 1:02:51revenge. I loved revenge stories. I loved revenge movies. I loved the
- 1:02:53idea of getting revenge and this idea that I would get revenge on people that
- 1:02:58had wronged me, whatever that's supposed to mean. And every time I had
- 1:03:01an opportunity to get revenge and I tried, it was horrific, Like it
- 1:03:07backfired so badly, like I might have been successful, and then I like
- 1:03:10actually injured that person in my relationship with them, and then it was like
- 1:03:15I just felt really bad afterward, and I was unable to repair it right,
- 1:03:19even little things, you know. It was like, you didn't do
- 1:03:21this thing for me when I expected it, so now I'm not going to
- 1:03:23do this thing for you when you expect it. And there's like why would
- 1:03:27you do that to me on purpose? Like you're a bad person, And
- 1:03:29I get that. I was like, yeah, that was a pretty dick
- 1:03:31move, right. It just it's never worked. It's just always been the
- 1:03:36wrong answer. Anytime it's ever felt like the right answer, it has been
- 1:03:37the wrong answer. So it's I think it's just worth considering. Like,
- 1:03:42there's just no way to fix a broken system like this. It is by
- 1:03:46it, it's very nature. It is an unworkable, unsustainable system, right
- 1:03:52right exactly. It burns out really quickly and leaves everybody in the lurch.
- 1:03:57Okay, so we made it. That is everything. That is everything that
- 1:04:00you will ever need to know about Revenge. Yeah, just can never have
- 1:04:02to study it again. That's right. Thank you so much for being here
- 1:04:06with us. We're gonna go ahead and recommend some things that are unrelated to
- 1:04:10Revenge as far as I know, or at least somewhat unrelated. I don't
- 1:04:14know mine's unrelated, but we like to recommend some things. But first I
- 1:04:17like to do the credits. If you would like to support the show,
- 1:04:19you can join us on Patreon. If you do get access to all kinds
- 1:04:21of behind the scenes content. You can add free content early episodes. You
- 1:04:26can like talk to us and stuff. I mean, you can talk to
- 1:04:28us anyway. Yeah, but there's like a little community of people that are
- 1:04:30there, and it's great consider joining us over there. You can join for
- 1:04:33as little as as like a dollar a month. Technically you can join for
- 1:04:36free. You don't get any of the benefits, but you can hang out
- 1:04:39them. Sure. Yeah, But I would like to otherwise thank our patrons
- 1:04:43who have been so generous with us, and that is Mike, m Megan,
- 1:04:45Mike T, Justin, Kim, Joshua, Brad, Stephanie, Olivia,
- 1:04:48Brian, Ashley, Kiara and Michelle. Thank you all so much for
- 1:04:53your continued support. Yes, absolutely, we love you so much. Also,
- 1:04:57of course, thank you all for listening who are with me here today,
- 1:05:00even if you're not a patron supporter, because that will be most of
- 1:05:01you, and I do appreciate you for listening and continuing to make this show
- 1:05:05feel a little bit relevant. And then my team of people are very necessary
- 1:05:10to have the show even happen. I would like to think writing and fact
- 1:05:14checking from Shane and myself. Our social media coordinator coordinator Coordinator Coordinator coordinator is
- 1:05:19Emma Wilson, and Justin does all the audio stuff that makes it sound like
- 1:05:24a real podcast. If you'd like to reach out to us directly to tell
- 1:05:27us and your thoughts on the things we're about to recommend, or revenge things.
- 1:05:31Maybe listen more things that we didn't list that were great revenge stories.
- 1:05:34You can email us directly at info at wwdwwdpodcast dot com, or of course,
- 1:05:41you can reach out to us on the social media platforms that are not
- 1:05:44dedicated to hate speech and misinformation. Yes, we are on those ones,
- 1:05:48most of them are few of them. I don't know several the main ones
- 1:05:51I guess that you think of, So anyway you can find us. There
- 1:05:56is there anything else that you'd like to add, or anything I forgot before
- 1:05:59we get to our recommendation, No, I think I'm good. Okay,
- 1:06:01revenge for talking about revenge. Let's do something different and do some recommendations.
- 1:06:05Yay, I love it. Recommendations all right, So my recommendation this week.
- 1:06:19I think I've recommended this before, but I've recently revisited this series and
- 1:06:25I'm really happy about it because it's just such a delightful read. And it
- 1:06:28is a comic book series called Fables. So Fables was originally published in July,
- 1:06:32started in July two thousand and two, so it's like that old oh
- 1:06:36okay, But the story is basically a group of fairy tale and folklore creatures.
- 1:06:44They've set up a community inside of New York. And so like all
- 1:06:47these characters are updated. They're living in modern day New York. They're dealing
- 1:06:50with it because they've been kind of kicked out of their fairy tale lands due
- 1:06:55to this character called the Adversary. And I'm not going to spoil any thing
- 1:07:00about that, but you discover who the Adversar area is and it's a great
- 1:07:02kind of thing. But the Fables are all like, you know, it's
- 1:07:04it's snow White is like the executive commissioner of fable Town, King Cole is
- 1:07:10the mayor. Prince Charming is a real piece of sh in it Jack of
- 1:07:14the Beanstalk folklore. He's like always trying to grift somebody, like he's always
- 1:07:18got like some new get rich quick scheme. So like the characters are all
- 1:07:21kind of like modern takes on these characters and what they would be doing if
- 1:07:25they lived and what they call the mundane world our world or the Munday world.
- 1:07:30And it's great, it's such a great read, and it's it came
- 1:07:33out on the vertico of the Vertigo publisher, which does like Sandman and Preacher
- 1:07:41and like some of those stories that are kind of like more off kilter.
- 1:07:44The book is incredibly violent. It's ridiculous, like just really fun storytelling though,
- 1:07:48because then they'll do like these kind of like one offs where it's like,
- 1:07:51oh, how did you get to the Munday world? And they you
- 1:07:55know, have blue Beard, and they have you know, little boy blue
- 1:07:58and they have all these like they have all all these characters kind of come
- 1:08:00in and play a role in different ways. So it's a fun read.
- 1:08:04It does give you a little bit of backstory on like these folklores that you
- 1:08:08might not know. It explores multicultural folklores as well and brings those characters in.
- 1:08:12At some point in time. Aladdin is there and kind of like the
- 1:08:15original story of Aladdin is pulled in and stuff. So like there's it's really
- 1:08:17cool and it's just a fun read. Like I think, I just have
- 1:08:20a lot of fun with it. It's not very difficult to pick up and
- 1:08:24follow either, neat all right, cool the Fables comics series. Yes by
- 1:08:29Bill Willingham. Cool, all right, very good. Yeah. I have
- 1:08:33had to do some recent renovation home DIY projects. I had the good fortune
- 1:08:40to use an orbital sander for the first time. You know what, it
- 1:08:43is. I have no idea. Nope, Okay, do you know what
- 1:08:46it's like? A sander is like a sanding belt or something. Yeah,
- 1:08:48yeah, okay, yeah, it's basically one of those. But it's a
- 1:08:50circle and it kind of spins around. It doesn't exactly spin, but it
- 1:08:54kind of wiggles around in the really fast circle. Sure, it is maybe
- 1:08:58my favorite tool to use. Now, obviously I'm not going to try and
- 1:09:01use it to screw in a nail, but it is it. But for
- 1:09:04the for using it for tools that require for a projects that require an orbital
- 1:09:09sander really fun. Okay, Now my hands dig it very tingly after holding
- 1:09:13it for several hours sanding. But it is a really cool tool. So
- 1:09:16if you're ever in the need to sand something, particularly like a smooth surface,
- 1:09:21like you're trying to get something smooth, yeah, I mean that's kind
- 1:09:24of how all sanders kind of work. Sometimes sanders are kind of grinding down,
- 1:09:29and orbital sanders can do that too, but a lot of times you
- 1:09:31put like a really fine grid on there that's mostly for smoothing. Yeah,
- 1:09:34and so you can use an orbital sander and they're pretty neat. I just
- 1:09:39didn't use the handheld one. They're really large ones and smaller ones, but
- 1:09:43I just use the handheld orbital sander. But it was pretty cool. I
- 1:09:45was impressed. So if you ever need one, go check one out for
- 1:09:48a sanding project. Mine was we were sanding countertops to make them smooth.
- 1:09:54So okay, nice, I like that? All right? Cool? That
- 1:09:58is what I have to say about orbital sanders. As I said, reach
- 1:10:00out to us info at WWDWWD podcast dot com. Of course, leave us
- 1:10:05a rating review. I think that was it? Anything else for you before
- 1:10:09I let them go? Nope, that's all I got. Cool. Be
- 1:10:11compassionate to each other, don't seek revenge. Yep, we love you exactly.
- 1:10:15This is Abraham and it's for Shane. We're out. See. Yeah,
- 1:10:18you've been listening to Why we Do what we Do. You can learn
- 1:10:21more about this and other episodes by going to WWDWWD podcast dot com. Thanks
- 1:10:29for listening, and we hope you have an awesome day