Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / He Turned $70,000 Into $264,000,000 — LEGALLY (Buffett’s Best Secret?)
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we've got a story that
- 0:03honestly, it sounds like financial fiction.
- 0:06It's almost too incredible to be true.
- 0:08It really is. We're going to be taking a
- 0:09forensic look at Ted Weschler, who a lot of you will know as
- 0:13one of Warren Buffett's lieutenants at Berkshire
- 0:14Hathaway. Right.
- 0:15But this is about the time before Berkshire.
- 0:17This is the story of how he took a, you know, a pretty modest
- 0:21retirement account, about $70,000 and grew it into an
- 0:24astonishing $264.4 million. And that's the key point.
- 0:29This isn't some tech IPO, lottery win, or an inheritance.
- 0:34This was done almost entirely through a deep, deep value stock
- 0:38picking, all within the rules of a standard retirement account
- 0:41anyone can open. It's a total outlier, but one
- 0:44that actually has a road map we can follow.
- 0:45Exactly. It's a master class in strategy
- 0:47and discipline. So today our mission is to
- 0:50unpack that. We're going to break it down
- 0:51into 3 distinct phases. We'll.
- 0:53Look at the accumulation phase, then the hyper compounding
- 0:56phase, and finally the tax efficiency phase.
- 0:59It's really a blueprint for compounding.
- 1:01OK, let's unpack this. Let's start at the very
- 1:03beginning with phase one, the Genesis, and the Crucible.
- 1:07So this all starts in 1983. Weschler graduates from Wharton
- 1:11and he takes a job as a junior financial analyst at WR Grace.
- 1:15His salary was about $22,000. And the foundation for this
- 1:19quarter billion dollar or fortune was something the
- 1:22sources call the simple habit. Yeah, and it's not
- 1:26revolutionary, but it's the consistency that matters.
- 1:29Even on that salary in New York City, he just religiously maxed
- 1:32out his contributions to his employer's retirement.
- 1:35Plan and WR Grace had a really generous matching program,
- 1:38right? Like 50% or even 100?
- 1:40Percent a huge match and he saw that not as a perk, but as a
- 1:43guaranteed risk free return on his capital.
- 1:46It's basically free money. If you don't take it, you're
- 1:48just turning down a race. It's that simple.
- 1:49Absolutely. So that discipline, plus, you
- 1:52know, the bull market of the late 80s helped him build a real
- 1:55capital base. By 1989, when he's just 27, that
- 1:58account is at $70,385. $70,000, we should probably pause there
- 2:03because that was a lot of money in 1989.
- 2:05It's something like $170,000 in today's dollars, a very serious
- 2:09seed. A very serious seed, but the
- 2:11really critical move, the one that changed everything,
- 2:14happened that same year. This is where he goes from being
- 2:16a passive saver to an active investor.
- 2:18Right, he rolls the whole thing into a self-directed IRA.
- 2:21That was the key. It let him break free from the,
- 2:24you know, the boring list of mutual funds from HR and start
- 2:27picking his own stocks directly. But the moment he takes the
- 2:31wheel, the market just decides to teach him a brutal lesson.
- 2:35Oh, it was a baptism by fire. His very first full year of
- 2:39active management in 1990 was an absolute catastrophe.
- 2:43What happened? The portfolio suffered a 52%
- 2:46decline, a 52% drop. That $70,000 he'd saved up
- 2:50plummeted to about $33,000. Wow, I can't even imagine the
- 2:55panic to lose half of your life savings in 12 months.
- 2:59That would make most people swear off stocks forever.
- 3:01Most people would have sold everything and gone to cash.
- 3:04And we see the specific losses. He lost 67% on a stock called
- 3:07Continental Health Affiliates, 55% on some bonds.
- 3:10Just Bruce so. What kept him in the game?
- 3:12This is maybe the most important part of the story.
- 3:14This is the unmonetized lesson, as we call it.
- 3:17It's a huge psychological turning point.
- 3:19He didn't panic. Instead, he analyzed it and
- 3:23concluded his mistake wasn't taking risk.
- 3:25It was the kind of risk he was taking.
- 3:27Meaning he was speculating, not investing.
- 3:29Exactly, he realized he needed to do the deep fundamental work
- 3:33and he had the perfect training ground for that in his day job.
- 3:36He just Co founded a private equity firm, Quad C Management.
- 3:39And private equity is a totally different ball game.
- 3:42Totally different. You can't just sell tomorrow.
- 3:43You're locked in for 5-7 years so you are forced to do
- 3:48exhaustive due diligence. It makes you see a stock not as
- 3:51a ticker, but as what it really is.
- 3:53As fractional ownership in a real.
- 3:55Business. Precisely.
- 3:56And that mindset shift is what fueled the explosive growth in
- 3:59Phase 2. OK, Phase 2, the hyper
- 4:02compounding engine. This covers the period from 2000
- 4:05to 2011. You have to remember the
- 4:07context. Here, the lost decade.
- 4:08Lost decade exactly. The S&P 500 after the.com bust
- 4:12and the financial crisis basically went nowhere.
- 4:15A cumulative return of pretty much 0. 0% for the market, but
- 4:20Weschler's personal account, which we can proxy with his
- 4:23hedge fund Peninsula Capital, did something well, something
- 4:27almost unbelievable. What was the return?
- 4:28Over that same period, it returned accumulative well,
- 4:311236%. That's about 26% a year
- 4:35annualized while the market was dead flat.
- 4:38That is just staggering. So how?
- 4:41How do you do that? The secret wasn't some complex
- 4:44algorithm was it was actually the opposite.
- 4:46It was extreme concentration. He threw out the textbook on
- 4:49diversification. He would typically own only,
- 4:51say, 9 to 15 stocks. And the concentration within
- 4:54that was also extreme. Absolutely.
- 4:56His top two or three positions would often be 50-60, sometimes
- 5:0070% of the entire portfolio. This just magnified the impact
- 5:03of his big winners so. Let's talk about those home
- 5:05runs. This is where you see the genius
- 5:06at work. Let's start with WR Grace, his
- 5:09old employer. Right.
- 5:10So Grace files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2001.
- 5:13They were buried under 100,000 asbestos lawsuits.
- 5:16The stock collapses to about $1.30.
- 5:19Wall Street writes it off as worthless.
- 5:21But Wesley knew the business, and he saw a legal angle
- 5:25everyone else was missing. He did a deep forensic dive into
- 5:29the US Bankruptcy Code, specifically a provision called
- 5:32Section 524G. OK, let's break that down.
- 5:35What does that mean for an investor?
- 5:36Why is that important? It's a great question.
- 5:39Basically, it's a legal tool that lets a company channel all
- 5:43its asbestos liabilities, past, present and future, into a
- 5:46separate trust. It walls off the healthy part of
- 5:49the business from that specific crippling risk.
- 5:52So it's like a legal quarantine for the liability.
- 5:54That's a perfect way to put it. And his calculation was that if
- 5:57they could pull this off, the core chemical business without
- 6:00the asbestos taint was actually worth closer to $24.00 a share.
- 6:05So while the market is screaming asbestos, he's quietly reading
- 6:08the Bankruptcy Code. And he didn't just buy the
- 6:10stock, he got on the equity committee to help steer the
- 6:13process. He held it for a decade and the
- 6:16result was roughly an 11 fold return, an 11 bagger.
- 6:20That's the definition of analytical alpha, finding an
- 6:23edge where nobody else is looking.
- 6:25Now let's look at another one, Cogent Communications.
- 6:28This is right after the.com bubble burst.
- 6:30The telecom sector was just a wasteland.
- 6:33Total carnage, but again, he sees opportunity in the
- 6:36wreckage. Yeah, he identifies Cogent as
- 6:38the scavenger. They were buying up all this
- 6:40distressed fiber optic cable for literally pennies on the dollar.
- 6:45His big insight was to bet on the operator of the network, not
- 6:48the company that spent billions building it.
- 6:50Because the operator has the better unit economics.
- 6:53Far superior and as Internet traffic started to explode,
- 6:57Cogent was perfectly positioned. That bet turned into a 13 fold
- 7:01return. So we've got asbestos,
- 7:03bankruptcy, A telecom wasteland, and then he finds a gem during
- 7:06the 2008 financial crisis in junk mail of all places.
- 7:10Right Velasis Communications. They did coupons and direct mail
- 7:13in 2008, with everyone predicting the death of print,
- 7:16the stock got crushed. It fell to between 1:00 and 3:00
- 7:19dollars a share because the market was terrified of its
- 7:22debt. So what was the tiny detail that
- 7:24he found in the fine print that everyone else missed?
- 7:26The market was panicking about bankruptcy, right?
- 7:28They thought the company would run out of cash.
- 7:31Wechsler actually read the debt documents, and he found that
- 7:34their biggest loan A term loan B, didn't mature for seven more.
- 7:39Years. Seven years.
- 7:41That's an eternity in a crisis. It's all the breathing room you
- 7:44need. It completely removed the
- 7:46immediate threat of bankruptcy and he saw that their cash flow
- 7:50was actually pretty stable and they were using it to
- 7:53aggressively buy back their own stock at those ridiculously low
- 7:56prices. That's created massive value for
- 7:58the remaining shareholders, another 10X return.
- 8:00The pattern is amazing, isn't it?
- 8:02It's bestest junk mail plumbing. He found value in these ugly,
- 8:06complex situations where Wall Street was just too scared or
- 8:09too lazy to look. And we should also mention
- 8:10DaVita, the kidney dialysis provider that was his long term
- 8:14compounder. That was the exception, not a
- 8:16special situation, but a fantastic business with a secure
- 8:19revenue stream from Medicare and a duopoly structure.
- 8:22He held that for decades and even got Berkshire to invest in
- 8:25it. So these incredible concentrated
- 8:27bets compounded and compounded and by 2012, that initial
- 8:32$70,000 had become about 100, $31 million, which brings us to
- 8:37phase three. The tax efficiency singularity.
- 8:41The account had reached this critical mass, and now he makes
- 8:44maybe the boldest move of his entire career.
- 8:46The Roth conversion. A truly staggering move so for
- 8:49you listening to convert a Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA,
- 8:53you have to pay income tax on the entire balance all at once
- 8:56upfront he had. To pay taxes on $131 million in
- 9:00one year. Correct.
- 9:01The sources say he voluntarily wrote a check to the federal
- 9:03government for approximately $28 million in 2012.
- 9:07Wait. And that money, that $28 million
- 9:09had to come from outside the IRA, right?
- 9:11That's the crucial part. He had to have that much cash
- 9:13just sitting around to pay the tax bill.
- 9:16It's an unbelievable level of conviction.
- 9:18It's the ultimate high conviction trade.
- 9:19It was a massive non refundable bet that one, future tax rates
- 9:23would go up, and two, that the power of decades of future tax
- 9:27free compounding would dwarf that $28 million upfront cost.
- 9:32I mean, the mass is just so powerful at that scale.
- 9:35In a Roth, when you get a 30% gain, you keep the whole 30%
- 9:40forever. The geometric effect is
- 9:42astronomical. And the bet paid off.
- 9:44We know this because in 2021 Pro Publica got ahold of the data
- 9:48and by 2018 the account had reached $264.4 million.
- 9:53And that report, of course, kicked off the whole Lord of the
- 9:56Roths debate, the argument being that these accounts were meant
- 9:59for the middle class, not to shelter 1/4 billion dollars.
- 10:03Right. And Weschler's response was
- 10:05actually very measured. He made two key points.
- 10:08First, this was all done with publicly traded stocks, not some
- 10:11private valuation games. And second, he did pay his
- 10:14taxes. He wrote that huge $28 million
- 10:17check. He even said he supported
- 10:19changing the rules for accounts once they reach a certain size,
- 10:21which is a pretty remarkable thing for him to say.
- 10:24Very remarkable. He agreed with the policy
- 10:26critics, essentially. So as we kind of synthesize all
- 10:28this, we have to touch on how we even got to Berkshire Hathaway.
- 10:32Such a classic story. It is.
- 10:33He won the charity auction to have lunch with Warren Buffett
- 10:36not once, but twice. He spent a total of $5.25
- 10:40million. It was philanthropy, but with a
- 10:43built in career option. Exactly.
- 10:45It gave Buffett a way to get to know him as a peer, not as a job
- 10:48applicant. And now he and Todd Combs manage
- 10:51over $30 billion. Yeah, and he hasn't lost his
- 10:54touch. Just look at his investment in
- 10:56Dillard's in late 2020. Everyone assumed department
- 11:00stores were dead. But he did the same thing,
- 11:02ignored the narrative, focused on the balance sheet.
- 11:05Dillard's owned its real estate, had very little debt.
- 11:08And the stock went from around $25 to over $400.00.
- 11:11The Weschler algorithm still works.
- 11:13So let's distill that algorithm for you, the listener.
- 11:16What does this all mean? There are really 3 core
- 11:18components. OK.
- 11:19First, you have the structural alpha.
- 11:21That's using the Roth IRA to eliminate tax drag, just letting
- 11:25the money compound without the government taking a piece every
- 11:27year. Then you have the psychological
- 11:29alpha. This is the iron stomach to
- 11:31handle that 52% drawdown and not panic.
- 11:34It's the courage to run into the fire in 2001 and 2008 when
- 11:37everyone else is running out. And finally, the analytical
- 11:40alpha. This is the 60 hours a week part
- 11:43reading the fine print. The bankruptcy codes, the debt
- 11:46covenants better than anyone else on Wall Street.
- 11:49And it's important to mention Weschler's own advice.
- 11:51For most people, he says. Start early.
- 11:53Use stocks. Ignore the noise.
- 11:55But, and this is a huge but, he says, if you're not willing to
- 11:58do that analytical work. Just buy the S&P 500 index.
- 12:00Exactly. And that's a really useful
- 12:02comparison. If he just put a $70 K into an
- 12:05S&P 500 index fund back in 1989, he'd still have ended up with
- 12:08about $1.6 million. A fantastic outcome, a great
- 12:12retirement, but it's not a quarter of a billion dollars.
- 12:15It's not. His story really proves that
- 12:17markets can be deeply inefficient, especially when
- 12:20fear and complexity mix. So we've seen the whole journey
- 12:23from a $70,000 seed and a devastating crash, to using
- 12:27arcane legal details to find 10 baggers, all culminating in this
- 12:31$264,000,000 tax free fortune. It's incredible.
- 12:36And here's the final provocative thought I want to leave you
- 12:38with. In 2012, Ted Weschler chose to
- 12:42write a check to the government for $28 million for nothing more
- 12:45than the promise of future tax free growth.
- 12:48Just think about the insane level of conviction and long
- 12:50term thinking that requires. Was that Roth conversion a tax
- 12:53move? Actually, the single biggest,
- 12:55highest conviction trade of his entire career.
- 12:57Something to think about. Thank you for joining us for
- 12:59this deep dive.