Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / Are protests calling for an Israel-Gaza ceasefire "antisemitic"? (Anjali Appadurai)
Transcript
- 0:02Check Podcasts. Welcome back to this as Van Color, her featured guest Night
- 0:11is the campaigns director at the Climate Emergency Unit. But you may recognize her
- 0:15as the woman who was some would say unfairly disqualified from running for the VCNDP
- 0:21leadership in twenty twenty two. She could have been our premier. She is
- 0:24Angelie a Patterai And this conversation is supported by Shelter Point Single Malt Whiskey to
- 0:30stink Lee, Vancouver Island uniquely shelter Point, Hi, Angelie. So we've
- 0:38seen these huge protests, these huge pro Palestinian protests around the world. Obviously
- 0:43there are different groups that are converging and advocating for Palestinian rights, But really,
- 0:48broadly, what do the pro Palestinian protesters want? What are they advocating
- 0:53for? Yeah, I mean you're right, there is a very very diverse
- 0:57and growing movement across the world, across Canada and right here in this town.
- 1:03You know, it's less of a it's less of a clearly defined movement
- 1:08that has a specific goal. I would actually characterize it more as a reaction
- 1:14from people, and the reaction is just one of horror and outrage at what
- 1:19is happening, and so the reaction is the reaction to Israel's response to the
- 1:25events of October seventh. That's right. The current is really assault on Gaza,
- 1:30and I would say that the number one thing that people want, people
- 1:34from all walks of life want is just to make the violence stop, to
- 1:38just end the atrocities and to end the killing of civilians, and so essentially
- 1:42a ceasefire now a permanent ceasefire. Now. I think another piece of this
- 1:48that is, you know, I think a reflection of people's sense of hopelessness
- 1:52and anger in watching this moment unfold so graphically across our social media and it's
- 1:59just the images everywhere, is just a demand to end Canadian complicity in it.
- 2:06And so what do you mean by that by Canadian complicity in what's going
- 2:09on in Gaza in Israel right now? Well, our Canadian government has not
- 2:12only failed to condemn the atrocities, the killing of civilians, you know,
- 2:16it's twelve thousand children that have died at this point, but they're actively green
- 2:23lighting it and we're actually materially supporting it. We've approved, you know,
- 2:29twenty nine million dollars in military exports to Israel since October seventh, and that's
- 2:34actually an acceleration of our previous military support. And so there's this this deep
- 2:39divide between what these large, historic protests are calling for and what's actually being
- 2:46done. And I think that's fueling this movement even more is just seeing that
- 2:50we do not want to be paying, you know, into this government that
- 2:58is is unaccountable essentially. So I guess the protest is international in a sense
- 3:04because it is protesting the actions of the government of Israel, but also protesting
- 3:07our federal government as well. Yeah, I think the reaction is very visceral,
- 3:12it's very raw. There's no I don't think you could draw a calculated
- 3:16line from like we are protesting to achieve this. I think people are people
- 3:21want the violence to stop, and we want an overall shift in the conditions
- 3:24that created this violence. One of the issues I've seen around the protests is
- 3:29a fear that the protests are harboring or perhaps even amplifying anti Semitism. And
- 3:34again, there's a diverse group of people that are involved, so sometimes those
- 3:37extreme voices, when they get found, they get painted onto the whole group.
- 3:40So one thing I want to ask you is why don't we see these
- 3:45protests advocating for the release of the Israeli hostages that are currently being held by
- 3:50Hamas. You know, mo, I really think it's a misnomer that these
- 3:53these movements have not spoken out against the loss of Israeli life. I think
- 4:00that that has happened. But the fact of the matter is is that our
- 4:03governments have roundly and unequivocally condemned him US. You know, we're not funding
- 4:09him US, We're funding Israel. We're not supporting him US, We're supporting
- 4:13Israel actively. And so the direction that our foreign policy is going is it's
- 4:17already there, and so there wouldn't be much point to a movement that is
- 4:21encouraging what is already there. I think what's I think what's really concerning is
- 4:27that there there is no justification for the number of civilians and especially children that
- 4:34have died in Gaza since October eighth, and we we were watching this unfold
- 4:41and we see our government fail to condemn that, and so I think that
- 4:44there's a real there's a real one sidedness. And also bringing up the accusations
- 4:50of anti Semitism, to me, are are concerning because they actually erase the
- 4:58strong Jewish leadership of this movement. You know, since day one, we
- 5:02have seen Jewish folks across the country, thousands of them and across North America
- 5:08really mobilizing, leading this movement, organizing not just the mass demonstrations that we're
- 5:15seeing, but within communities as well. I think that's a real defining feature
- 5:18of this movement, is that it is the demonstrations on the streets, but
- 5:23it's also just an incredible array of you know, neighborhood organizing, parents groups,
- 5:29cyclist groups, artists, cultural workers, teachers, faculty, universities.
- 5:33You know, it's a really diverse array of people who are organizing and demonstrating
- 5:40in multiple different ways. And there's so much is there's so much. There's
- 5:47a deep criticism of Israel from our Jewish comrades, and that I think is
- 5:53really important to acknowledge. Just the movement, though, have a responsibility to
- 5:56stamp out anti Semitism within its ranks when it sees them openly in protests.
- 6:00Absolutely, and you know I'm not I fully acknowledge anti Semitism is a hate
- 6:04crime, and it is. It is real and well and alive in Canada,
- 6:09and we've seen a rise in it and it is there, and I
- 6:11think we have to be very careful about naming it when it's there. That's
- 6:15what I've witnessed in these movement spaces is being very careful to not blur those
- 6:20lines and to absolutely differentiate criticism of the State of Israel's actions from antisemitism,
- 6:28and I have witnessed that as a practice in this movement. The demands of
- 6:32the movement do not reflect anything antisemitic at all. It is purely a criticism
- 6:38of this ongoing even clearly signaled genocidal intent from the Israelly government, which is
- 6:46acknowledged around the world as a pretty extreme government, you know, calling for
- 6:53extreme measures, and so that's very different. I have a question, why
- 6:57do protesters target provincial politicians or municipal politicians, because again you talked about Canada's
- 7:01complicity, which I appreciate in terms of understanding the protests, But why target
- 7:05Premier David ebe or mayor Vancouver mayor Ken sim You know, it's a great
- 7:11question, and I think you know, when I spoke about before this protest
- 7:15being so much bigger than demonstrations, it's really people speaking out within their communities
- 7:21calling for a clear moral stance from all levels of government and from all the
- 7:26institutions in their lives. And you know, it's really important that we have
- 7:30you know, when you have a signal from say us City Council or Burnaby
- 7:34they pass these cease fire motions, that's a really important signal to send.
- 7:38I mean, does it matter though, I mean it's New West minister.
- 7:41No offense to know, New West Minister, but it's a little municipality.
- 7:45I think one of the one of the roots of this movement is identifying and
- 7:49calling out anti Palestinian racism, which is deeply inherent. And you know,
- 7:55we've seen that be a sort of inherent bias in in the media, in
- 8:01our foreign policy. We've seen we've seen that be expressed and very concerning sentiments
- 8:07from a provincial former minister Sinila Robinson. We've seen that from our local government
- 8:13leadership. And you know, I think it's really important for us to target
- 8:18that and to call that out and to root it out because that's part of
- 8:22what is fueling the conditions for something terrible like this to happen in the first
- 8:26place. And you know, I mean there are groups like groups that are
- 8:31specifically have a pro Israel agenda, like Sija, who are also talking to
- 8:39provincial and local government, and so then it becomes it becomes part of the
- 8:43broader conversation about rooting out anti Palestine and racism and separating that from criticism of
- 8:50Israel. Absolutely, Angulie, I know this can be a very difficult conversation,
- 8:54so I appreciate your courage for coming out to the show and talking with
- 8:58me tonight. Thanks for asking the quest. Absolutely, folks, she is
- 9:01a powerful voice in our province. She is Angelia Paterai. Big thank you
- 9:05to Shelter Point, Single Malt Whiskey for supporting local conversations, including the topics
- 9:11that no one else wants to touch. Now up next, I forgot to
- 9:13mention that tonight is this is Van Kuller's one hundredth episode, and apparently Sonic
- 9:18Radio's Angela Valiant has a surprise for me. That's up next.