Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 14 - We Created The Returns Monster - Now What?
Transcript
- Keith: Welcome to Under the Pallet Wrap and we have a special guest today Helen Baynes. I've had the fortune of working with Helen three times in my career. Give us a little intro Helen. Helen Baynes: Keith and I worked together at Net-a-Porter and at Cult Beauty and then most recently on a project with Richemont and I think we've already really connected because of our focus on the customer and how we can do better by them and in a way that is practical that serves the customer well and serves the business well is probably the right summary I work as a consultant, working with individual founders to help them hone their customer proposition, to make sure that it address their needs in ways that get the right balance between the customer need and the business need, I guess is the right way of describing it. Dan Culverhouse: Nice to have you with us. Keith: We've worked on a lot of initiatives together Helen Baynes: Thank you. Keith: over the years, often to reduce customer friction. One of the Helen Baynes: Yes. Keith: big things we've always touched upon is returns. So that leads us into the subject of today's podcast. Should returns always be free? We've all got different opinions. We did a podcast on this a few weeks ago. Returns are one of the biggest drains on the margin for any business. It's a problem that's almost never gone away. So Helen, what's your opinion to kick us off? Helen Baynes: Well, I think it's a really interesting one because, you know, there's a precedent that's been set around returns being free and it's dependent. And I think it's very much with e-commerce in the place that it is, remote selling and buying in the place that it is, I think it really depends on the business and on the product and the customer need. so you've almost got these three points of the triangle that you've got to consider. from the product side, it's really understanding what the barriers might be to purchase around that product. And if making it easy to return if the item isn't right is really that valuable or not to the customer. And how much it impacts their decision-making. I also think like returns get bundled up in this much bigger drive for growth in businesses. And it's seen as an easy win that can be switched on to try and increase conversion, but it really depends around what point you're measuring conversion and whether it's at the point of purchase or whether it's at the point of keeping it and the amount that's being returned is more of an accurate measurement of success. So yeah, I mean, it's incredibly complex and nuanced, but I suppose if I think back to the beginning of having started working in distance selling when really like we were selling items, we were selling brands to people who'd never tried them before, so they didn't know how they were gonna fit. And it was such an essential part of getting people over the line and instilling this confidence that, you order clothes online. It's a great way to shop, make it easy for you. You try things on at home, you send it back if you don't like it. It was a cool part of the story that we told and we tried to provide more information to help people make the right decisions in the first place. And that was something that I was really involved in. So saying, actually these are the questions that customers are asking us about. So let's provide more information around this up front But I think things have evolved so much. since then and you know the growth of the e-commerce industry has been so huge and it's not really a one-size-fits-all anymore. Dan Culverhouse: But y you kinda say that though, Helen, but I think the default for pretty much every retailer who sells online is still to offer free returns. And there are some exceptions, but it's pretty much still the default, right? And Helen Baynes: Yeah, I think Keith: It's the expectation. Helen Baynes: it has become the default, but I also think it's quite often a sign that people don't know their customer well enough. Dan Culverhouse: I wouldn't disagree with that. And I think the other the other point is it's not only now because that it's free, but it's now also so easy to return. Helen Baynes: Mm-hmm. Dan Culverhouse: You know, you don't even have to put any effort into it. You know, so it's not only does it not cost Helen Baynes: No, it's super easy. Dan Culverhouse: you any money to send it back, you don't even have to package it up anymore. You can just drop it at the post office and they'll put it in an envelope for you. You know, so it's become so easy that it is Yeah, it's absolutely Keith: sometimes it's collected from your doorstep. It's not just... Dan Culverhouse: Encouraged, it's almost it's almost like come on, buy as much as you like and just return what you like. We don't care. But the reality is that that isn't sustainable, right? It's killing margins or it's pushing the price of products up. And it's kind of like it's a monster Helen Baynes: I it's quite... Dan Culverhouse: that was necessary to get it going, but it really feels like it's in a place now that we've created a monster that we're gonna find very hard to get back in the cage, right? Helen Baynes: Well, I think businesses also have to learn to be brave as well and think about and ask more questions of their customer, which quite often they're not that comfortable about doing. There's so many businesses don't actually want to know what their customers think. I mean, I actually had a great returns experience last week. I ordered from a High Street brand, an American brand that I'd not ordered from before for my son. I ordered completely the wrong size, even though I referred to the measurement chart and I tried measuring for him. The joys of having a teenage son who's growing like grass, who doesn't really know what he wants to wear, but needs a new pair of shorts. And so I was like, right. And I made all the wrong decisions. The t-shirts were too big. Everything was too big, basically. And so I went on to look at how I could return. And actually, their online returns was really good. and it asked for a lot of information. There were even three points of feedback that it took you through for each item, which was really interesting. But online wasn't the only way that you could return. And in fact, if you were going to return through post, you were gonna have to pay for it. You could also return in store. And in fact, what they incentivized you to do was that the free return option was to make you to take it back into store. And in the end, I was like, right, come on, we're gonna go to town and we're gonna do this in town because otherwise I'm gonna order, I'm gonna be back in this cycle and I don't particularly want to be dealing with a box of stuff. And I don't want to order another load of stuff that is not gonna work because actually that's quite inconvenient too. So we went to town and we took everything back in town and we got found the right sizes and we bought what we needed. that was all done. So, you know, I think with Omnichannel working the way that it does, there's a real opportunity, like, within that. I think as is with everything, you know, one size never fits all. So, you know, where is there a need for an easy returns process? If you don't live in the middle of wherever and you have to drive. I don't know, one, two hours to get to the nearest town to go shopping. And there is a much more of a definite need or user case for that level of service for you to have access to the items that you wouldn't be able to get to otherwise more easily. You know, that can work really well. But I think also, you know, the ones has all thing is a bit of an Achilles heel for businesses really. It's like quite often businesses only look at customer value through an amount spent lens. They don't look at frequency, they don't look at longevity or lifetime value. So you can be like, we'll build our customer value segments, but it's only based on how much they've spent. And then, you know, within that, you mask all these other behaviors. And the same would be for returns. Like if you are not looking at the spread of, there will be a cohort of customers who don't return at all, as they always are. They may be tied to a geographical destination. But equally, you've probably got a small cohort of customers who are messing it up for everybody and are the serial returners and are constantly ordering 12 things and returning 12 things. And you've almost like built this habit with them. So I think in many ways it's about trying to understand, okay, where are the valuable behaviors and why do they exist? what can we do to encourage more of those? And which are the behaviors that we don't want to encourage because they're our problem children and they're creating Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: operational issues, eroding margin, Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: or all the rest of it through those behaviors. And how can you tackle those? Keith: Yeah, it's like Helen Baynes: Bravely. Keith: a lot of things. Data is so much more available than when we started on our journey. you know, as we touched upon, we were treading new ground back in the early days of Net-a-Porter and we thought, well, customers must want returns. And to touch on your point, We were trying to deliver directly from the catwalk to women all across the world. So Helen Baynes: Yeah. Keith: the very premise that we were making it easy was part of what we were trying to achieve. And of course we had to offer returns. Helen Baynes: And it was all part of creating market share and acquiring customers to, you know, getting customers to change their habits and buy with us. But that's not such a driver anymore, really. Dan Culverhouse: No. Keith: No. So what changed? I like your point about looking at the data properly. There's always outliers to just look at Helen Baynes: Mm-hmm. Keith: at data and not break it down. The average customer might return two items a year. But when you've got repeat returners, you've got the geographical element. How do you factor those nuances into a returns policy realistically? How do you deal with the problem cases? Is it a policy thing? Is it a systems thing? How would you say that's been addressed? Helen Baynes: Hmm, well, I suppose that's the difficulty isn't it? the process has got to be the one size fits all, but then it's about how you manage the exceptions within. you could build it into your policy that if you return over a certain level, you'll need to pay for it, whether it's value, quantity, Dan Culverhouse: Absolutely. Helen Baynes: what have you. I mean a smart business could build it into its loyalty program if it's got a you can encourage behaviors and you can discourage other behaviors. Incentivize, that's Keith: You can incentivise them. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: the word I was looking for. That's exactly the word I was looking for. Dan Culverhouse: Ha ha ha. Keith: Yeah. Helen Baynes: So yeah, but it's also, it's lifting the lid in the first place. It'd be really interesting piece of work to do actually. It's almost like reverse Dan Culverhouse: I I I think you've Helen Baynes: segmentation. Dan Culverhouse: yeah, I think you've really kind of touched on a really critical point for businesses to do is firstly they need to look at their data because you can't treat every customer the same, right? You can have a a policy, you can have an approach, but you do need to analyse that data and let's face it, we've got all the tools we'll ever need to be able to get real insight into each of your customers. They can be categorized by the the way that they behave. and you need some policies to to sort that out. But then I what I really was was quite liked was this gaining feedback. So, you know, if you if if customers want to return, asking them some questions about why. So it builds Helen Baynes: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: up you a more a more in-depth database as to what's driving that, which can then drive better solutions or better policies to to make returns more nuanced. et cetera. Because you know, and I think we can get into what are the various different things you can offer a customer. But is it simply that when when someone presses I want to return that they just have to fill out a questionnaire? you know, I mean is that the right way to do it or how would you approach that to get that much more nuanced insight? Helen Baynes: Well, I think, yes, definitely. And I think a lot of businesses now have... some kind of online returns portal where you can go into your order, you select the item that you want to return and you give a reason. And that was something we implemented really early on at Net-a-Porter that was one of my projects. just from a purely operational level, we had a customer care team who were, it was like 70 % of our workload was dealing with returns requests, which was a complete waste of everybody's time and horrendously boring, frankly. And there was definite concerns that at that point, I remember there was a very definite conversation around, were we just making it too easy for people to return by not making them having to write in and request? However, you we were at that point, which was a long time ago now, people were emailing into requests, but we then really wouldn't have any visibility on the data or the reasons or what have you. Or you'd then have to, in the response, if they didn't say why they're returning, you might ask, but the chances are they wouldn't return to you. So it was very like, it was the very beginnings of the process. I think it's, if you want to capture that kind of level of insight from your customers, you have to to make it easy because otherwise people won't share it or respond it. So the best way to do it is to build it into your returns process online. So I want to return this item. Please, can you tell us why? Drop down reason. Then you can ask. So in this instance of this return that I was doing last week, I think there was a level one reason and then you had to give like almost like a level two reason. Keith: and more comment. Helen Baynes: And then there was a free form text box, was like, you know, is there anything else you'd like to share with us about why you're returning this item? So actually for me, it was very simple because it was like, I picked completely the wrong sizes for my time. But you know, for someone else, it might be, well, I normally buy this size from you, and I've been buying this size for years, but you know, this just, this doesn't fit me this, this time And of course, I suppose what's difficult about all of this is, you know, capturing the insights is valuable, but there's always going to be a level of subjectivity, especially if you're going to add to the qualitative. insight level. But on the other hand, if you don't ask for the qualitative, you can miss quite a lot just by getting the bog standard responses So you could be just Keith: the balance. Helen Baynes: missing that gem exactly. Keith: I'm working on one right now. I'm working on implementing returns portal There is a question around the right amount of information because returns are very costly Helen Baynes: Mm. Keith: and too much information that you don't know what to do with it. So where is the balance? and what do do with the data when you get it? Like what to do with that data? You have to make decisions. Helen Baynes: Test and learn. That's the other thing. It's all very well capturing the data. If nobody's analyzing it, then you know, it's all kind of a waste of everyone's time. So you do have to make it, it has to be an overarching, you know, if you're gonna do it and really get the value from it, you have to commit to it and allocate the resource to it. Keith: It has to direct you to the root cause otherwise it's more and more speculation and more generic decisions. Helen Baynes: indeed. Dan Culverhouse: What my mind can't help but just flip back to last week's episode, Keith, where like if if you're gathering all this data, you know, with tools that AI can offer, you know, you can augment with your AI and it can give you a huge amount of insight by just dumping that information into an AI and asking it to summarize it for you, right? I mean, it isn't hard. So it's pretty Helen Baynes: That is true. Yep. Dan Culverhouse: unforgivable for a business to Capture all that data and do nothing with it, or or at least not even analyze it. I mean, I think you can't help people if they can't even get around to doing that. So I think it's pretty inexcusable of people these days to say, well, we just don't really have time to to go through the data. And it's like, yeah, you do. is it unrealistic to start having people qualify or fall into different categories of customer that says these customers very rarely return, so if they do they can have it for free. You return fifty percent of what you buy, you've you've gone past your, you know, your quota. You now have to pay. You know, i are are some of those things really 'cause you know, the systems and AI could categorize all your customers that way, you could you could communicate it. You know, i is is that a realistic prospect in your mind or is that just gonna encourage customers to go shop and Helen Baynes: No, think it should be really realistic and I think ultimately it's the key with customers is always how you communicate it. so, and in terms of how it lands and how you can encourage those behaviours, I think one of the reasons why people shy away from managing like high returners is the backlash that it can cause. can, you know, people can become very public about how they feel about a business these days, as we all know. And, Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, share it on social media, et cetera. Yeah. Helen Baynes: you know, and there's a reputational damage that can occur through not handling that in the right way. People can feel like they're being that they're being picked out or, you know, Dan Culverhouse: yeah. Helen Baynes: if some, and they are. However, you don't necessarily understand. if you don't handle it in a way that's sensitive, because you're gonna make assumptions about behavior. So it might be, Keith: Mm. Helen Baynes: maybe somebody is disabled and they can only shop from home So therefore they're ordering a lot. I'm trying to come up with an exception Dan Culverhouse: yeah. No, I know. Helen Baynes: user case, right? So they're ordering a lot and it's quite a difficult shopping's quite difficult for them. Or Dan Culverhouse: Mm. Helen Baynes: maybe somebody has like lost a lot of weight or is dealing with a lot of weight fluctuation and so, or has put on a lot of weight or So their body size is changing and they don't really know what's going to work for them anymore or they're still buying what they used to buy and now they're realizing it's not the right size. I suppose what I'm trying to say is like, there's a lot of nuance and whilst I'm not saying that there's still the girl that's buying 20 things because she's going away on holiday and she may or may not want all of them and maybe she's only going to wear two and she'll return 18. I'm not gonna say that that doesn't happen, but you know, it's. Dan Culverhouse: No. It's the unintended consequences of trying to put a qualifying position in Helen Baynes: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: place, right? 'Cause you've got some people that will accept it and will work within it. There others that will re react 'cause they feel they're being prejudiced against. and there'll be others that will just scream about it because they like doing that. Helen Baynes: Yeah, exactly, and you don't want people to feel like that. Yes, like equally. So, you know, and it all becomes like can become really challenging from a relationship point of view Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: from like, from a brand point of view. So, yeah, so I guess actually if you've done that piece of work and you understand the returns patterns within your business that's what then gives you the context of, well actually How many people are, know, okay, so we've got, maybe we've got this small number of people that are creating a disproportionate amount of work, but how disproportionate is it to the bigger segments? So maybe there's this group who consistently are spending to a certain level, so they're ordering five things, they're returning three. Okay, we can see that actually, because... they are ordering the three things that take them to the free shipping over this amount level. They're doing that. I'm gonna try this on in the fitting room approach. So I'm gonna get undressed to try one thing on. Therefore I'm gonna try those five things on that I quite like as well, even though it's this one thing that I really like. But because I'm getting undressed, I'm gonna do that. Same kind of psychology for delivery. So I'm gonna order this one piece because I really love it. Well I've ordered these other things that I quite like as well, then I can decide whether I really like them or not and I'll just send them back. So. Yeah, so, you know, so there's lots of, yeah. Keith: We talked about incentivization. Yeah, lots Dan Culverhouse: Yeah yeah, so it's a fair point. Keith: of different reasons. We can never truly, truly understand them all. We never truly understand what people are going through, the addictive personalities, et cetera. There's so many different reasons. Everyone seems to focus on incentivization from a sales perspective, don't they? Everything's Helen Baynes: Mm-hmm. Keith: about driving one end of the supply chain, but not the other. It could be a very subtle Helen Baynes: I agree. Keith: way of managing this by having incentivization for the whole customer journey. There's so many things. Helen Baynes: Yes, and I think this is where businesses don't look at their customer journey holistically. And this is where it is really challenging and it's quite often there in terms of how businesses are structured. You you quite often get marketing focus sort of really up to, you know, where you get performance marketing, which is all about conversion to, you know, from awareness through to conversion at order stage. And then you've got retention marketing, is generally about bringing them back in. And then you've got your post purchase window, which is normally handled by Customer Care and dealt with by operations. they are generally speaking, they are not all linked up. Keith: Yeah, absolutely. I think I agree with you. Everyone sees the returns in the warehouse as a big pile of unlabeled boxes all tattered and you can sense the lack of value, you know, the money Helen Baynes: Yes, exactly. Keith: pit and Helen Baynes: It's about turning it into an opportunity, isn't it? Dan Culverhouse: So shouldn't we Keith: Absolutely. Dan Culverhouse: reward should we reward those who don't return then instead? So, you know, if you can't really manage the top end because it's such a quagmire is it then to say, Okay, if you're willing to commit to not returning, or if you did need to return that you have to pay, you can have five percent discount. So everybody pays, but if you commit Helen Baynes: Well, then you erode your margin in other ways, right? So, I mean, look, it's not, yeah, because if you're giving... Dan Culverhouse: Are you? Are you though? Because if they they don't if they're not gonna return it, then you're never gonna have to incur that expense. So take the cost of the return off. Keith: I might not buy again. Helen Baynes: Yeah, well I just think that I think... Dan Culverhouse: It's and the reason I ask. Helen Baynes: It's too complicated to talk about Silver Bullet though, isn't it? Right? Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I I'm I I it's not a silver bullet, but it's just another step towards trying to help the process. And the reason I asked that is that, you know, and I can only use myself as a as an example. and I think I said this in the in the last podcast. you know, so you know, when I buy shirts, I I know I buy shirts from basically the same place every time, but buying the years, I know what size they are. So I'd be very happy to click a button and say, I won't be returning these. and therefore if they gave me, you know, just a little bit of a discount that says I won't incur you won't incur any costs on returns from me. so maybe I should I you know the little bit of the cost that's in the margin or in the cost of that product to cover the cost of returns, take it out for me because I won't return it. Or take out a portion of it. So, you know, Keith: I think. Dan Culverhouse: they're still paying. Everybody is returning, it's not paying, but it's in the it's in the price. Helen Baynes: It's something that you could, yeah, it could be tested. Keith: for men's clothing I think we are a little bit more, a bit luckier I think then in terms of... Dan Culverhouse: There's just certain products that people buy and they don't tend to return. And and you know, I don't know. Helen Baynes: Yes, exactly. Dan Culverhouse: If it's built into everybody's price, I think that's a little bit unfair. And and maybe if you just gave people an option, if you commit to not returning, you can have a slight discount. might change some behaviours. Because ultimately we're trying to slowly but surely move this tanker to people buying a bit more responsibly. and maybe there was an option if you said I won't return it, or if I do need to return it, I'll pay. Therefore I get Helen Baynes: I it could... Dan Culverhouse: a little bit of a discount, I'd be really encouraged to go to that retailer. Helen Baynes: I think in the right business it could be effective, yes. Keith: I think using, from a continuous improvement perspective, Dan Culverhouse: In general, no. Keith: is something you would trial, isn't it? It's something you could trial. And all these Helen Baynes: Mmm, exactly. Keith: things are open to test. You don't have to go all out. You could segment your approach and do some research on it. But I think it all amounts to getting into that data and making informed decisions. There is a lot of founders out there that would turn to industry benchmark. I've been asked. What's the general industry benchmark for return? Well, Helen Baynes: Yeah. Keith: you can share that, but that wouldn't be a responsible answer. It's like ultimately how many returns are you getting? Let's look at your situation. Let's look at your customer journey. Let's look at what your customers are telling you. And often they don't know what the customer is telling them. also there's not a link between the customer facing side and the operational requirements. So the margin could be being bled because they're not getting duty free returns. The operations don't have the visibility. People talk of returns, but it really is informed by so many upstream influences and decisions. I think it should be looked at. It should be as focal as anything that's related to profit and loss. I don't think it often is. I think it's often looked at as a convenience and ease. addition rather than a driver for commerciality really. Helen Baynes: Well, I guess it's become such a focal part of offering service, hasn't it? It's been that, you Keith: Yes, that's it. Helen Baynes: know, it's seen as a service to the consumer. But yeah, but you're right, Keith, you know, there is always another side to offering the service and then it's how you address that and account for it. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Is it fair to say Keith: from my perspective, my geeky perspective, I'm always thinking about the connections between one thing and another. We talked about Helen Baynes: Hmm. Hmm. Keith: silos in business a couple of weeks ago. I think it comes down to that as well. It's seen as either an ops problem or an EComm problem rather than a business problem. So we talked about a lot of ideas and we know a lot of people. We've experienced a lot of these ideas. Try before you buy. So many different ideas being put about and some have a major impact. They clearly do. What have you seen working Helen? What brands have been brave and tried new things in the market that you've seen? Helen Baynes: Well, I mean, this is quite a small example that haven't been involved in M-powder, the menopause supplement from the first product. And the founder was always staunchly like averse to free returns. And actually, because it was such a like natural product with no fillers and no like artificial sweeteners and what have you, it meant that the taste was quite a challenge. However, and it didn't work for everybody. And it was also, it was quite a niche product. it was, you know, 75 pounds for a month supply as a supplement. so, yeah, so you can imagine that the dichotomy in one's mind around buying it, but also reasons for returning it. And there was definitely, I think, probably a bit of a fear of... people just buying it and then not liking it and just wanting to send it back. So we were, one of the privileges of being small was that we could manage that on a case-by-case basis. However, so then as the market shifted and conversation about menopause has opened up significantly over the last five years, but also there are a lot more products entering the market as well. So I kind of brought it up again last year really when we were looking at growth or stagnant growth or how, you know. ways that we could be clever to encourage more growth. And actually what we went with instead of saying free returns wasn't really the right message because it wasn't really relevant to the product. But what was relevant to the product was you know, like a one month guarantee. So if you buy our product and you take it every day and you track your symptoms and you don't see a noticeable improvement, we'll money back guarantee. So it created this like risk free, which is sometimes what returns is about, right? this risk-free scenario where you could try something new, see if it works for you and not be worried that you've just thrown your money out of the window if it doesn't. And yeah, so... I guess that was a different pivot on looking at the returns angle and actually what the customer need was. And also, the reality was, there's nothing that a business can do with half a pouch of, or an open pouch of a powdered supplement. You have to destroy it, you incur Dan Culverhouse: That's routine. Helen Baynes: the cost of it being shipped back. But it still Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: was about addressing the customer needs around hesitancy. I haven't tried it before. Will it work for me? Will I like it? In a of, a risk-free way without creating that operational overhead created the safety net. Exactly. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Created a safety net, right? Helen Baynes: Exactly. Keith: I think that's good way of building confidence in the brand. Helen Baynes: Exactly. Keith: It's a good very smart. That's why people call on you Helen. Helen Baynes: And when we were talking about it and that was really, you know, part of the conversation about it was, well actually this is a very confident messaging on our part in terms of like, you know, Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: if it doesn't work for you, we'll take the hit. But, and also, you know, and actually we didn't do huge numbers behind it because our assumption was that it was more likely to encourage that it wasn't really worth doing the numbers because the number of people that it was likely to happen to was not likely to be high enough to warrant not doing it. It was actually a very low-risk way of testing something Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: new and then if for some reason I mean, it wasn't really the kind of product that was likely to be massively abused, but Dan Culverhouse: No. Helen Baynes: you can reverse if you do it in the right way and you do it sensitively. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. I mean it sounds like a very sensible approach. You say it's a pointless product to return because it can't be reused. But I guess when you launch that kind of thing, your fear is, especially when it's quite an expensive product, that people Helen Baynes: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: will buy it and then they will automatically say, Actually I didn't like it, even if they did, right? But so Helen Baynes: Yeah, exactly. Dan Culverhouse: I mean so and my question on that is How easy was it to get your money back? Do they have to fill out and and explain? Or is it just like I don't like it, press one button and then they get a ref you know it has to put some effort in. Helen Baynes: No, I think there is a returns portal now and actually we used to have, you know, there were lots of different scenarios in that business actually. because we also had a subscription business, which was really positive for retention. But also it meant that if your behaviors change and you say you were on a three month subscription and you weren't taking it every day, you might end up with a glut of Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, accumulate loads. Yeah. Helen Baynes: And they're quite big, like kilo sachets. So you could end up with a bit of a backlog. So we might have people that had taken it for a really long time and then for some reason have overbought. So then they would contact us about whether they could return a couple of pouches. But it was all because of the size of the business. And we developed this very high touch service proposition to the Health Concierge. So we always try to use it as an opportunity. for the health concierge to have a conversation with the end Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: customer to find out actually, you know, was it not working for them anymore? Why wasn't it working for them anymore? Could we offer any other solutions? Maybe they'd be better trying one of our other supplements. So we try to sort of turn that situation into a positive and an opportunity too because we didn't want to lose them. And actually, because Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: many of the women who were buying from us were feeling really rotten a lot of the time, and we really saw that as an opportunity to have a high touch conversation and to make sure that they went away feeling good about the overarching experience they'd have with us, even if the reason was that they couldn't stomach the product. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: So we really just try to make sure that it wasn't the end of the conversation, it was the beginning of the next one. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: And even before we started with the 30-day guarantee or the sort of risk-free policy, if someone had contacted us going, I can't take this, I can't, because it was quite bitter, especially at the beginning for some people. Dan Culverhouse: I've tried them. Helen Baynes: You know, we would always, even if we were going to offer someone a refund in the end because it just really wasn't working for them, we would always say, you know, we'll give you your money back, but please pass this on to somebody else who might benefit from Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, that's Helen Baynes: it. So, yeah, so, you know, there's... Dan Culverhouse: And that's great customer Keith: But so for a small business, Dan Culverhouse: interaction, right? Keith: for a small business, that personal touch and that idealism is always close to the founders Helen Baynes: Yes, exactly. Keith: heart. How do you maintain that as you grow when a product explodes? You know, how do you maintain that personal touch? Do you think it's a case of building the right frameworks from the very beginning? Helen Baynes: I do. Yes, definitely. Part of it is culture and it's making it intentional, right? It's part of your culture of service and how you expect your staff to manage issues. then as you scale, really what you need to be able to do is distill, like, okay, what's working from this and how can we build that? So if we're putting in a returns platform, Like how can we still create this based on the reasons for return that you might want to select? I don't know, does it then pop up with a, would you like to be book an appointment with our health concierge who can talk to you about blah, blah, blah, So how or is it that you still enable them to go through that process, but maybe there's a follow-up action that is automatically sent through into your customer platform? that says, hey, can somebody call this customer on this day at this time? Or this customer is returning for this reason. Actually, Keith: Yep. Live chat. Yeah. Helen Baynes: live chat never worked for us, interestingly. But yes, but it could be live chat. It could be on any of the, you know, it could be on any. Keith: Again, it depends on what level Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: of connection you want. I mean, Dan Culverhouse: Hit the scale. Keith: it's difficult for a founder because they obviously, you know, they've got a great idea. They will come from different backgrounds, you know. Not everyone comes from an operational or customer service background. that's where consultants come in like us. We're there to give them that insight. But when do you think a founder should should call for help. When is the right moment? It's a tough one because you're not automatically born with this insight So when is Helen Baynes: Well ideally you wouldn't be calling for help, would you? No, it's Keith: the signal that maybe your returns procedure is A, eating into your margin, B, not serving its purpose? What are signs that you should look for? Dan Culverhouse: Not making any money. Helen Baynes: Well, yes, it's probably the first. The first sign is going to be around margin erosion and cost, it? That's usually the flag that makes everybody sit up and take notice. Dan Culverhouse: Easily the first one that's gonna come up. Helen Baynes: And unfortunately, if you've had the foresight to look at your experiences of 360-degree continuous wheel, then you would have avoided that in the first place. Keith: I don't know if everyone does that on day one, know, that's the chip. Helen Baynes: Well, no, we know that they don't and there are multiple reasons for that. Some of it's experience, some of it is just because of the focus being in a particular way. Not everybody sees everything and maybe you just haven't got the team around you that join all the dots together. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Helen Baynes: But yeah, the red flag is likely to be cost. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Can I can I just jump back to something you said a minute ago? 'cause I think obviously we've been trying to talk about what things would actually make a difference. And you talked about subscription. Helen Baynes: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: and I have to say, as someone who buys a few things on subscription and I appreciate it doesn't work for every product, doesn't work for clothing and things like that, right? But I I think this subscription model is a is almost kind of a way of talking about what I was suggesting before that if you're not going to return it you can get it you can buy it for less. Because when you subscribe, right, you don't return generally when you subscribe, you do get a discount. Helen Baynes: Yeah, you might. Mm-hmm. Dan Culverhouse: And what I love about I buy coffee on subscription. Helen Baynes: Yeah, we have that too. Dan Culverhouse: and what I love about it is the firstly, yeah, it I get it cheaper. They keep giving me gifts, lovely gifts, which is Helen Baynes: Mm-hmm. Dan Culverhouse: wonderful. and definitely, you know, definitely works to kind of keep me wanting to do it. But The bit that I really love is how easy it is to pull it forward or push it back. If if like you say, you know, cause you kinda like I'll get me one a month Helen Baynes: You can manage it. Dan Culverhouse: and it never works quite right. So every now and then I have to go to get I need to get two this month to give me a bit of a buffer because I keep running out. But it does Helen Baynes: Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: also say, you know, it your shipment is due on, let's say, the twentieth of August. but there's a one button where you can just pull it forwards and say, ship it now. And it'll just pull it forwards. And and I love all that stuff. And I think that's a fantastic interaction. the subscription service definitely reduces your returns because you know people are buying it because they want it. but I do think it's a fantastic development in that area and they really drives that customer loyalty and because they you know they keep sending us like really nice stuff on top of the discounted Keith: connection isn't it? Dan Culverhouse: things to make me Helen Baynes: Hmm. Dan Culverhouse: a loyal customer, and we are so loyal to this business now, that we love it. Helen Baynes: Yeah, I really agree with you on that, and I think it can work really well for certain products and I think you're right. Dan Culverhouse: Yes. It's difficult to see how that would work in the fashion industry, but which is the biggest area of covering. Helen Baynes: Yes, it's, yes, well, you know, because with apparel, some of it's bought based on need, but so much of it is bought based on desire or want. And it's so Dan Culverhouse: But not much of it. No. It's an emotional purchase. Helen Baynes: much, yeah, it's a highly emotional purchase, which is why there are so many variants in it. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah. It's it's it's definitely Keith: It's one of the hardest product types to tackle really because it is so inconsistent and there are so many variables and it's why the return rate for apparel is so comparatively high compared to a lot of other products. Dan Culverhouse: And I and I do think that the the big boys in this game, right, have have made it really difficult because, They can manage that cost of returns within their within their margin in a in a better way, because they have such scale, right? But I think if you're a small business, trying to emulate that is is is so expensive and so difficult. But I do also think as a small business you have the opportunity to really, as you said, Helen, talk to your customers, create a clear message like we are different. if you're a niche clothing retailer, maybe you're quite natural cottons or something, you know, you've got to play on what that is. It's like We don't offer free returns and do you know why? It's because, you know, we care about the environment and the cost of a return is enormous. Therefore, we want you to try and use all these tools to buy correctly. You know, you've got the opportunity to have a much closer relationship with your customers so you can have much more of an interaction to get it right. maybe I'm dreaming a little, but I do think that smaller niche retailers got a real opportunity to be different, right? To be different and have a different message. And people buy that. Yeah. Helen Baynes: I agree completely. and it is and it's also it's about being brave and being open about like this is who we are because also Dan Culverhouse: Absolutely right. Helen Baynes: it's also a reason why people buy from them but you know this is the Dan Culverhouse: It makes me buy things that way, for sure. Helen Baynes: Yeah, exactly. You know, and there's been such a drive around buy local or, yeah, making choices differently and making considered choices. And there are different ways that you can tell your story that can instill the same level of confidence without having a, you know, free returns. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Yeah. I I you know, I think there's a real need for society, you know, just to get on my soapbox a little bit, to get more into sustainable consumerism, right? you know, you can't just Helen Baynes: 100 % Dan Culverhouse: buy, buy, buy, buy and chuck, chuck, chuck. You can't we can't carry on that way. you know, and I think it is the smaller niche companies that can drive a change. You know, I think people are more willing to accept different services from a niche, local, very specific brand that that that matches their values, right? And I think that that that there's there's a big opportunity there for companies to really emulate their values with their customers' values and therefore drive a different relationship. Helen Baynes: Yes, indeed. Couldn't agree more. Keith: with the upcoming regulatory changes and customer behaviors that we've seen, with pre-loved and lot of communities being built Dan Culverhouse: I'm not vinted. Keith: around resale and the rise of vintage, et cetera. You know, the industry's changing again and it is much more in the conscience. again, fashion's always moving business is always moving everybody's got to... Stay in tune with the customer. think my takeaway from this discussion is know your customer. It always has been, it always Dan Culverhouse: One hundred percent. Keith: will be. Speak to your customer, use your data. The answer to the question, should returns always be free? No. What about you two? What's your verdict? Dan Culverhouse: Go Helen you're the guest. You should go next. Helen Baynes: No, I don't think they should always be free. I think it depends on the business, it depends on the customer, it depends on your competitive landscape. There's so many factors that come into it, but it should not be a blanket decision. Dan Culverhouse: No. No, and I think one of the things that I'm really taking away from from this conversation you have the ability to collect so much data and insight that will help you create a more positive customer experience. that Helen Baynes: Exactly. Dan Culverhouse: will mean you don't need to always offer free returns, but you won't be upsetting your customer because there's ways around it. and I think that you made a really important comment, Helen, about companies being brave and being Helen Baynes: Mm-hmm. Dan Culverhouse: willing to be different. But talk to your customers, ask them, you know, get some feedback and find find a a nuance that that works, that isn't just simply buy what you like, return what you like. Keith: I'd add a small closing line to this. Isn't it weird that it's now seen as brave to talk to the customer? It sounds very logical, but it's amazing Dan Culverhouse: Ask the customer. Keith: how many businesses maybe hold back from being open. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Keith: We'll see how it goes. Businesses will be forced to be transparent in the next six months and we'll see how it evolves the industry from here. But thank you so much for... joining us today Helen, it's been an absolute pleasure and a privilege to hear you Helen Baynes: Well, thank you both for having me. Dan Culverhouse: I'm pretty sure it Keith: anytime. Dan Culverhouse: won't be the last time we talk about returns, so who knows? Maybe you'll be in part two. Helen Baynes: Excellent. Excellent. Keith: So for now, goodbye and like, share, subscribe. Pockets. Dan Culverhouse: And above all, comment, please. We love your comments.