Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Ithaca's North Sea moves, offshore wind optimism, and the place for CCS
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:05podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:10the UK energy market. Each week, three of our
- 0:14reporters give their two cents on the headlines, ensuring you
- 0:18get the first word on the sector that keeps Britain's lights on.
- 0:23Today we're going to be talking about why Ithaca Energy is
- 0:27raising hopes for Rosebank and Cambo.
- 0:31We'll also talk about why offshore wind is heading into
- 0:35the doldrums. And although we usually focus on
- 0:38the positive developments for carbon capture and storage,
- 0:41today we're going to hear a little bit more about the case
- 0:44against CCS. I'm Erica Askland, the news
- 0:47editor of Energy Voice. This morning.
- 0:50I'm here with Michael Baer, our renewables correspondent, as
- 0:54well as Jessica Davies, who's our London and Net 0
- 0:58correspondent. How is everyone today?
- 1:01I'm doing great. It's sunny up in Edinburgh,
- 1:04Jessica. How are things down in down
- 1:06South Oh? It's equally sunny here.
- 1:07It's absolutely beautiful the weather yeah, I have corralled
- 1:12A2 year old to nursery this morning, which was which was
- 1:14which was very fun but so. That's a a really great
- 1:17achievement already, so we'll just jump right on in.
- 1:21So earlier this week, you know, one of the big stories that I
- 1:27had on my list To Do List that was Ithaca Energy.
- 1:33So they basically were Hawking the limelight earlier this week,
- 1:39coming out with a series of announcements.
- 1:41First was their acquisition of the Cygnus field from Spirit
- 1:46Energy. So that was them basically
- 1:49upping their stake in one of the UK CS's largest gas producers.
- 1:55Then the next day it was also talking about its quarter one
- 2:01results. But it one of those things, I
- 2:04mean, they were saying that they're, you know, pleased with
- 2:07the fact that, you know, following their strategic tie up
- 2:10with any, they don't use the word merger, but following that
- 2:14they are now achieving record production, which they're quite
- 2:18pleased about. But then they also discussed a
- 2:21little bit about what is going to be going on with the Rosebank
- 2:26field, in which they're 20% shareholder alongside of
- 2:30Equinor. And as well as Cambo, which is
- 2:33the even more controversial oil field West of oil and gas field,
- 2:39West of Shetland, which umm, in I think it was 2022, Shell,
- 2:46which was their joint venture partner in the Cambo field,
- 2:49walked away from it just because it was so toxic.
- 2:53There was just so many people who were upset about Cambo.
- 2:55There was people in the streets of London and across the UK, uh,
- 3:00with signs and banners saying uh, Cambo was not what the
- 3:04industry needed, particularly as uh, we are aiming hoping, uh, to
- 3:09achieve net 0 and that combo didn't fit into that situation.
- 3:12However, it turns out when the Ithaca put out its quarter one
- 3:20results, they said that they were planning to go ahead with a
- 3:25subsea campaign construction campaign for Rosebank.
- 3:30Now that's going to be in partnership, obviously with
- 3:33Equinor, who is the main lead on the project.
- 3:39But of course, before they want to do that, there's a number of
- 3:43things that yet have to be decided.
- 3:46One of those is the actual operatorship of Rosebank because
- 3:51Equinor, as we famously know, is now putting its North Sea
- 3:57operations into the joint venture with Shell.
- 4:01Now I was talking with someone and I will ask maybe, you know,
- 4:05kind of Jessica and Mike to weigh in.
- 4:06So we've been kind of calling this joint venture with Shell
- 4:10and Ecuador Shequinor. Although it was a friend of
- 4:13mine, I won't say who he is, but he was saying, you know, the
- 4:17other one is that other people have been calling it Ecuahel.
- 4:21So which one do you think we should go for?
- 4:23Shequinor? Ecuahel, which is our favorite.
- 4:26Oh, that. I mean, that is too loaded, I
- 4:29feel like. I mean, what if we've tanked it?
- 4:32What if they're going to have to go with Echo Hell because
- 4:35they're like no energy boys are going to claim the copyright on
- 4:38Shellenor. See, I think Shequinor sounds
- 4:42like it's got a little bit of rhythm to it, you know, like he
- 4:44could maybe, you know, kind of put it to song and echo hell,
- 4:47actually just sounds like, I don't know, just something that
- 4:50maybe, you know, we wouldn't want to get into.
- 4:52But yeah, I want to be. What about you, Jess?
- 4:54Which would you vote for? I'm sort of on the Shellenor
- 4:57side. Shellenor, I certainly
- 5:00appreciate the double entendre behind epic hell.
- 5:05Absolutely. Shall I know it just sort of
- 5:08rolls off the? Tongue it does.
- 5:09It's true, it's true. That does have a certain
- 5:12fluidity to it. So no cool.
- 5:14Well, thank you ever so much. So I think once that is whatever
- 5:19it's going to be called because I do remember speaking to
- 5:23someone from Shell at a recent event and they said it's all
- 5:25called Chuck Menor. They seem to, I don't know if
- 5:28they don't didn't have a sense of humor about it anymore.
- 5:30But you know, I guess it's a busy time.
- 5:32But that will be decided soon. And my hearts go out to all of
- 5:36our pals and associates who working in these companies in
- 5:41Aberdeen, who are also our neighbors because, you know,
- 5:45hey, change is hard nevertheless.
- 5:48So that should be decided sometime this year, whatever
- 5:53that is going to be called. And also now, of course, before,
- 5:57you know, the Rosebank really actually starts progressing,
- 6:01guess what? It also needs, it needs to
- 6:03resubmit and get approval on an environmental assessment because
- 6:09of the decision in the Supreme Court made on the Finch case,
- 6:17which said that, you know, kind of anyone who's producing oil
- 6:20and gas has to, you know, kind of really do a lot more work on,
- 6:24you know, kind of what their scope 3, which are downstream
- 6:27emissions are going to be. And then of course, the Scottish
- 6:30courts then ruled on the basis of that, that actually what was
- 6:35going on with Rosebank and Shell's Jackdaw where their
- 6:40approvals had been unlawful on this basis.
- 6:43So they have to go back with this improved environmental
- 6:48assessment, taking into consideration what Finch has
- 6:52suggested and they are awaiting government guidance.
- 6:57So, and I don't know, like I think we should start a clicking
- 7:01ticking clock on this one because I think, you know, the
- 7:05UK government has been promising that they're going to be
- 7:08delivering this guidance. So oil and gas firms can then,
- 7:13you know, determine what they actually need to do with their
- 7:17environmental assessments in terms of scope 3 in order to
- 7:21meet them. I mean, honestly, you know, are
- 7:25they going to go ahead? Yes.
- 7:27Well, I think with what you get in the Ithaca update from this
- 7:33week is that yes, it's going ahead.
- 7:36I mean, they always said that they were going ahead, but
- 7:37actually, you know, kind of when you actually have cutting steel
- 7:41and putting on the on the subsea floor that that's a really
- 7:45significant movement towards progress and that they said is
- 7:49going to be starting in April 26th.
- 7:53So that was kind of one of the big exciting stories that were
- 7:57coming out. And then of course what they
- 8:00also said is that Cambo, which is West of Shetland and also
- 8:06kind of actually not that far away from Rosebank will also be
- 8:11progressing. So what what Ithaca told the
- 8:20markets was that they are looking at a new partner.
- 8:25They need to find someone to farm into the deal or farm out.
- 8:30They expect that that means that they will be able to make a
- 8:35financial investment decision once they find that partner.
- 8:39And then of course, they're also kind of working on the technical
- 8:42aspects. You know what I was, I was
- 8:45having a bit of a chat with Jana Friedman, who's the executive
- 8:49chairman. It was all off the record.
- 8:52And so I can't really attribute anything that he said because it
- 8:55was just a bit of stuff on background.
- 8:56But he was saying that, you know, since any has joined the
- 9:02party in the North Sea with Ithaca, they have really brought
- 9:08a lot of different approaches to the in a way that they're going
- 9:13to be managing their North Sea assets.
- 9:16And so that this is being brought to bear with Cambo,
- 9:19which is exciting. But the question is who is going
- 9:23to be the one buying into Cambo? I mean, you know it.
- 9:27I think if, you know, they decide to go ahead with Cambo,
- 9:31whoever decides to buy in is probably going to face a lot of,
- 9:36you know, people who are going to be upset.
- 9:38You know, the sort of people who like to glue themselves to
- 9:41pavements and protest these sorts of things I'm sure will be
- 9:44hired. I don't think it'll be a very
- 9:47good look for Ed Miliband, who, you know, kind of is also really
- 9:51trying to push net zero and the clean energy, you know, plan for
- 9:582030, which of course is facing all sorts of challenges.
- 10:02But you know, again, you know, there has been other parts of
- 10:05government gear, Starmer, for example, who has probably maybe
- 10:10kind of put his money on ensuring that North Sea projects
- 10:14such as Rosebank go ahead and then perhaps Cambo.
- 10:18So we shall see. But then who's going to be that
- 10:21partner? Well, you know what, it makes a
- 10:22lot of sense into my mind if it's actually Shequinor.
- 10:26So hey, cuz like Shell walked out and Shell would be back in.
- 10:30But then it would also be along with the Equinor assets with
- 10:34whom they could probably develop a really good kind of production
- 10:37sharing, you know, kind of subsea tie back sort of
- 10:42operation. So I mean, it's all kind of
- 10:44working out, I suppose, but you know, and still, you know, maybe
- 10:48a long road ahead. And of course, I don't know.
- 10:52We were also looking at, you know, the latest effort from
- 10:56Aberdeen Grampian Chamber of Commerce.
- 10:58And so they wrote a letter to Keir Starmer with that attracted
- 11:042500 signatures, which I think is probably the biggest yet.
- 11:09And they are kind of talking about why, you know, the UK
- 11:13needs to stop the energy profits levy.
- 11:16A, because there aren't any big profits, there aren't any big
- 11:20windfalls being made on the price of like oil and gas right
- 11:24now. And they reckon that, you know,
- 11:27if they don't, that they're going to kill the industry and
- 11:30the supply chain and that there won't be any workers left to
- 11:35help with whatever's coming up next, whether that be floating
- 11:38offshore wind, carbon capture and storage or hydrogen, or even
- 11:42ensuring that we have some oil and gas coming in while we will
- 11:46still need it up into 2050. So like, that's my mind dump.
- 11:51But next we are going to be talking about the actual green
- 11:56energy and decarbonization plans and maybe some of the challenges
- 12:01facing those. Welcome back to Energy Voice Out
- 12:43Loud. And here we are going to hand
- 12:46over to Michael Baer, who's going to tell us a little bit
- 12:49about what's blowing in the wind for offshore wind.
- 12:54It's kind of like slowing down a little bit.
- 12:56Is that the case, Michael? According to one piece of
- 12:58research, yes. You know, we were both at All
- 13:01Energy last week. Sorry, Jessica, to kind of
- 13:04exclude you from from this little bit of the conversation.
- 13:06But I would say that definitely that when you're at a big event
- 13:10like this, one of the the things that as journalists we're trying
- 13:12to work at is what is the sort of general mood of the
- 13:15convention? And it felt like we were
- 13:20bringing up a lot of the setbacks.
- 13:22You know, things like Hornsey four kind of coming being
- 13:26discontinued, I think is the the exact term.
- 13:29And let's make sure that we use a.
- 13:30When it comes to setbacks, that was a pretty big one though,
- 13:32right? So I mean, that was like pretty
- 13:34much all of the AR six round, you know, which, you know, Yeah,
- 13:41it it doesn't, it's not a good look.
- 13:43But you know, I still feel that despite something of that
- 13:46magnitude happening that there was still a lot of confidence
- 13:49and positivity. But now, you know, we're kind of
- 13:51we've got some new research that's come out that maybe has
- 13:54me thinking, I wonder if a lot of the industry is just putting
- 13:57on a bit of a brave face. So Westwood has produced
- 14:00research that basically they kind of gauge optimism in.
- 14:06So this was specifically for floating offshore wind which?
- 14:09Is and floating offshore wind is huge for Scotland, right?
- 14:12Because like they we have what, 5 gigawatts of floating planned
- 14:17in Scotland or something? Yeah.
- 14:19And and this was global. So floating is really kind of
- 14:22being, I think, you know, let's, let's not assume anyone has a
- 14:25working, working knowledge of these things.
- 14:27Floating offshore wind is very much the next phase of offshore
- 14:31wind. We're running out of space for
- 14:34fixed bottom because ultimately there's a lot more deep water
- 14:38than shallow water. And also the shallow water areas
- 14:41are the parts that are in demand for other ocean use.
- 14:46So the idea is very much that if we want to roll out this kind of
- 14:51clean energy revolution on a global scale, we're going to
- 14:54need to start sighting offshore wind turbines further and
- 14:57further into the sea. And that means using floating
- 15:00floating platforms rather than fix bottom.
- 15:03So there's a a lot of expectations on it, but
- 15:06unfortunately, by the sounds of it, confidence is falling.
- 15:10So Westwood's new new poll, they spoke to people, they spoke to
- 15:16developers, they spoke to the supply chain and they found that
- 15:20the the percentage of respondents who felt less
- 15:26optimistic about the state of floating wind has increased
- 15:31quite dramatically. And especially among developers,
- 15:34the people who are actually looking to to cite these.
- 15:37And there was a number of of reasons they kind of gave about
- 15:41this. You know, I think a big part of
- 15:44it is financial barriers. Now, obviously, when Orsted kind
- 15:49of discontinued Hornsey, the, the, the listed quite frankly,
- 15:54the usual suspects that we've heard of from, from companies
- 15:59that had to back away from offshore wind projects.
- 16:03You know, anyone feel free to add something to this, but
- 16:07inflation, commodity prices going up, interest rates on on
- 16:13capital, all the roading, the financial case of, of projects.
- 16:18We saw these kind of in 2022-2023, you know, from Orsted
- 16:22when it canceled its American Ocean Winds project in the US.
- 16:27It felt like we'd moved past them.
- 16:30But there is starting maps creating concerns that these
- 16:34issues are sticking around. Sorry, can I just also say that
- 16:37there's probably another elephant in the room when it
- 16:39comes to major hurdles and cost issues?
- 16:44Transmission, charging, honestly, like, that sucks,
- 16:47right? I mean, you know, that's not
- 16:48working out for anyone. Oh yeah.
- 16:50But we can need to and there was another report on that too.
- 16:53Or do you have that to hand as well?
- 16:55Yeah, So it was a trio of developers.
- 16:58I think Ocean Winds is the one that comes to mind.
- 17:01Northern power, they were in there.
- 17:03And if you just let me bring up the research.
- 17:07Well, of course ocean winds has Murray east and West.
- 17:10And you know what I was when I was up in Banff not too long
- 17:15ago, You know, there's that beautiful, you know, Banff
- 17:18Springs Hotel. And, you know, if you just like
- 17:21on a clear day, you look out to sea, you can just see, you know,
- 17:25kind of like the, the Murray offshore wind farms.
- 17:28And it's, it's really kind of quite striking.
- 17:31And it just, you know, there's just so much development having
- 17:34gone on there and ocean winds is leading that.
- 17:36And so you kind of have to listen to what they have to say
- 17:39about what it all goes. Like they're spending so much,
- 17:42they're shutting down those turbines and having to get paid
- 17:45for it. And, you know, like it's, it's
- 17:48really kind of putting a spanner in the works, I think for
- 17:51offshore wind developers. And they finally kicked off
- 17:53about it, right? Yeah, curtailment charges are
- 17:56one of those just absolute. I'm trying to even think of the
- 18:02the word anomalies of our of our transmission system.
- 18:05And obviously these developers were kicking off about
- 18:07transmission charges, which are basically the charges that are
- 18:11applied to to you if you're plugging into the grid.
- 18:15Now as they pointed out, this system was created decades ago
- 18:19when power was based around put in coal powered stations in
- 18:24Yorkshire next to coal mines and sending it down South.
- 18:29The idea is to get it to the populated areas.
- 18:32There's essentially incentivizing building power
- 18:36plants near population centers to to minimize the amount of
- 18:40transmission infrastructure you need.
- 18:42This doesn't make sense when we're trying to roll out huge
- 18:45amounts of power capacity, not just in the north of Scotland,
- 18:49but offshore where there's literally no one there.
- 18:51So they were pointing out, look, the charges that we're getting
- 18:55applied to us are I think the, the, the, the research said it
- 18:59was a billion pounds. It added to the cost of a one GW
- 19:03Scottish offshore wind farm relative to a similar farm down
- 19:08in the South of England. And when you consider the
- 19:09economics of the, the project, that's huge.
- 19:12I mean, what is the sort of average price that I've I've
- 19:14seen of offshore winds part in the sort of 4 to 5 billion, you
- 19:18know, so that. That's like 1/4 to 1/5 of the
- 19:21cost, right? On top of that, because of, you
- 19:24know, crappy grid problems. And at a time when.
- 19:26Rickety grid problems. Yeah, exactly.
- 19:29And at a time when we're, the economics and finances of a, of
- 19:34a project are being particularly squeezed, it does feel like that
- 19:39is an issue holding things back. And I remember it was, you know,
- 19:42speaking with people at Ocean Winds, they pointed out that now
- 19:46is actually currently the worst time to, to be taking financial
- 19:50investment, final investment decisions on projects.
- 19:54And I was shocked because I thought, well, we've, I think of
- 19:572022-2023 as being the, the peak of all the sort of financial
- 20:02economic issues facing projects. It really feels like this is.
- 20:09You know, the, that narrative that I've created in my head is
- 20:12not, is not holding up. The things are getting started.
- 20:15And obviously the transmission charging issue, it's, it's Auk
- 20:20issue. It could be in, I don't know
- 20:23about the regimes in other countries.
- 20:25You know, I can't claim expertise on French, Chinese,
- 20:28American transmission charging issue, but I imagine they will
- 20:33have similar issues because like Britain, we created our power
- 20:37system in the 50s, sixties, 70s that we are having to look to
- 20:43adapt. And I think that is partly a
- 20:45slow progress on adapting is a bit of an issue.
- 20:49And going back to the, the floating offshore wind research,
- 20:52you know, I think ports they're another big limitation and
- 20:56technology standardization. So there does feel like there's
- 20:59a laundry list of issues eroding confidence in and not just
- 21:06floating offshore wind, but offshore wind.
- 21:08Right, Well, you've heard it here first.
- 21:11The Dirty laundry list for the offshore wind industry is slowly
- 21:16coming and emerging, but you know, hopefully it'll all come
- 21:21clean in the coming years, particularly as we move to clean
- 21:25energy 20-30. Stay tuned, we're going to take
- 21:29a wee break and when we come back we will be talking a little
- 21:33bit about how clean energy and carbon capture and storage might
- 21:38yet face a few more challenges. And we're back.
- 22:37So Jess, when you were on break, did you have a little bit more
- 22:41time to think about what is going on in the courts and the
- 22:47Net 0 Teesside project? You've been speaking to some
- 22:50people who have, you know, a bee in their bonnet about this.
- 22:55Absolutely, Absolutely. So for all of the progress
- 22:58that's been made in the carbon capture and storage or carbon
- 23:01capture usage and storage space, there is still quite a bit of
- 23:04scepticism, it turns out, particularly among environmental
- 23:08campaigners and also among some of the ministers in the Green
- 23:12Party, for example. I think there's a bit of
- 23:15division within within government itself and what
- 23:19campaigners are looking to do at the moment is to educate
- 23:21citizens and also to educate MPs just about some of the potential
- 23:26caveats and risks around the actual technology.
- 23:29I think the interesting thing about CCUS, carbon capture usage
- 23:33and storage is that obviously it's an emerging technology.
- 23:37It hasn't been used widely in this country and people don't
- 23:41really necessarily understand the technicalities of it.
- 23:46And sometimes these people with even people within the industry
- 23:48might not know all of the potential studies that have been
- 23:51done that might allude to the potential for the technology not
- 23:56to meet its stated ambitions, let's say.
- 24:01So in this case this year we have the net zero key side
- 24:10project, which is the first gas with carbon capture and storage
- 24:15project in the UK ever, which has been planned in in Teesside
- 24:21as part of the East Coast cluster up in the northeast of
- 24:24England. Now this project is very, very
- 24:26controversial. It's been developed by BP and
- 24:29Equinor I believe, which have put in their plans.
- 24:34They've got really extensive plans as to how they will
- 24:36essentially create a new gas fired power plant and capture
- 24:40the emissions from, from the power plant from the flu.
- 24:44And they, they want to capture about 95% of of emissions, I
- 24:48believe, if not more from, from this gas fired power plant,
- 24:52which is which is planned from for the, for the northeast East
- 24:55Coast cluster. Now, why this project is
- 24:58controversial on the surface of it is, is pretty obvious, right?
- 25:02I mean, this almost gives oil and gas companies a sort of free
- 25:07pass to develop new oil and gas products when we're meant to be
- 25:10cancelling the licenses from these from these for these
- 25:13projects. That's something that Edmund
- 25:14Levant has said that he wants to do in government.
- 25:16And you know, the country is also on a path to net zero and
- 25:21looking to to decarbonize the electricity system by the end of
- 25:25the decade or 20202035 with some sort of minimal 5% unabated gas
- 25:32percentage factored into that. So there's a really fundamental
- 25:40controversy right at the center of these projects, which is, you
- 25:43know, are we going to allow new gas projects to be built even if
- 25:48the emissions are captured? And I think that is that is the
- 25:50fundamental central conflict with with a project like Net 0
- 25:54Tea side, which which essentially just angers people
- 25:57and people are very confused as to whether or not this is a good
- 25:59thing. Although no, I mean, I get it.
- 26:02Although, you know, the Climate Change Committee says that
- 26:07they're keen on carbon capture and storage, you know, just to
- 26:11abate particularly industries that are basically impossible to
- 26:16to carbonize like cement and steel.
- 26:19And then, you know, also, you know, kind of if we are
- 26:23retaining some gas capacity, which kind of is needed for
- 26:29flexible generation, you know, when the wind don't blow and the
- 26:32sun don't shine, is that something that you know?
- 26:36And, and so that's why I think CCC is, is still kind of into
- 26:41carbon capture and storage because they say we need it.
- 26:44And then of course, Ed Miliband seems to think so too, because
- 26:48of course the Northern Endurance Partnership and net 0T side is,
- 26:53you know, kind of one of two projects that received 21.7
- 26:57billion / 10 years in commitment from government in order to make
- 27:02it go. So now, but you've been talking
- 27:05to Andrew Boswell who's taking these these things to court
- 27:11because he sees them as being problematic.
- 27:13So tell us about about that. Yeah, Yeah, exactly.
- 27:16OK, I think you've totally hit the nail on the head.
- 27:18You know, government is investing billions in in CCUS
- 27:21and the Climate Change Committee has said that both nuclear and
- 27:24CCUS are technologies that it essentially endorses because,
- 27:28you know, these technologies represent potentially a magic
- 27:30bullet when it comes to reaching net 0.
- 27:32Capturing the emissions from fossil fuel plants is is
- 27:36potentially an absolute godsend, a panacea for allowing existing
- 27:43systems to continue the way that they do.
- 27:45But but sort of taking, taking the thorn out of them, taking
- 27:48the problem out of them. Now, the reality is, and what we
- 27:50of course do here at Energy Voices, you look a little bit
- 27:52closer, right? And so the reality is that that
- 27:55the technology is still relatively unproven.
- 27:58And So what Andrew Boswell, who's an environmental
- 28:00consultant has done with the net 0 project is take a bit of a
- 28:04wide lens. That was the net 02 side project
- 28:07I'm talking about in the northeast of England.
- 28:09Is it he's taken a bit of a wider lens view of the emissions
- 28:14rating of that project. So he essentially took the
- 28:17project to task over its climate impact by looking at upstream
- 28:22emissions, which are the the emissions which are created
- 28:24beyond the the life, the immediate life cycle of the
- 28:28project itself. So, so his argument is that
- 28:32upstream emissions including the emissions produced by importing
- 28:37LNG liquefied natural gas from places such as Texas and the the
- 28:41tankards that would the D often diesel powered tankers that
- 28:44would actually transport that LNG into the country.
- 28:47That those emissions should also be looked at on top of the
- 28:51emissions that are generated and largely we would hope captured
- 28:55as part of the project. So he his the central thrust of
- 29:00his argument in court, which he did fail last year in the in the
- 29:04High Court at putting against the against the developers
- 29:08behind the project. His central argument was that
- 29:11the upstream emissions haven't been taken into account and that
- 29:15the emissions would far exceed the 20 million tonnes of
- 29:18emissions that the project had stated that it would essentially
- 29:23be limited to. He's put the case that this
- 29:27jeopardizes the UK's plans to reach net zero by within the
- 29:31electricity system anyway, by by 20-30 or slightly beyond that,
- 29:37so he lost his argument in court last year.
- 29:39He's trying it again, but when do you think you know when?
- 29:42When will this current hitless latest salvo come to find out
- 29:47about what's going on with that? So, so what's happening is there
- 29:50was a deferred judgment. So the, the case went to court
- 29:53in to the appeal court at the World Courts of Justice just
- 29:55down the road from our Fleet Street offices, in fact in
- 29:58March, so the 4th and 5th of March and there was a deferred
- 30:01judgment. So I think that they were
- 30:02expecting a judgment in April, but it's been kicked back.
- 30:05So we're now nearly at the end of May and they're not expecting
- 30:07now judgment to be announced probably until mid June.
- 30:12If you could put a risk of like in between 1:00 and 10:00 that
- 30:15this judgment could shut down net 0T side, what would you say
- 30:19that number was? So, you know, I'm not.
- 30:21I'm reluctant to speak that. Not a betting woman, are you?
- 30:24No, no, no, that's OK sometimes. So, so I think the fact that
- 30:28he's already lost his case in the High Court doesn't bade well
- 30:32for him frankly. And I think also the fact that
- 30:34Ed Miliband, well, actually, it's Keir Starmer has taken a
- 30:36really hard stance on push backs to major infrastructure projects
- 30:40in the UK, saying, you know, look, that he's had enough of of
- 30:45these major energy projects essentially being delayed due to
- 30:47legal challenges. I think that all bodes really
- 30:49badly for this case in an appeal.
- 30:51I personally, I think it's very hard to tell.
- 30:54But on this, on the face of it, that case in particular doesn't
- 30:58necessarily look like it will. It will.
- 31:01It stands much chance of succeeding at the appeal court.
- 31:04That that's my view. How However, I don't want to end
- 31:07it there because, because, because so, so so I think while
- 31:12BP and and Equinor might win out in this case, I think what's
- 31:17interesting about what Boswell is doing and what some of the
- 31:22MPs are doing now is that they're looking at the specific
- 31:27technicalities around the climate case for CCUS and taking
- 31:31it beyond just net 0T side. So net 0T size side will be the
- 31:34first carbon capture project in the UK which essentially allow
- 31:38unabated gas to continue and catch those emissions.
- 31:41His climate case, the case he was allowed to put to the courts
- 31:43was incredibly narrow. The focus was really on this
- 31:46fundamental point, which is if the emissions exceed, I believe
- 31:50it was around 20 million tonnes. Is it?
- 31:53Does it contravene the net zero goal that Ed Miliband is is
- 31:56trying to aim for? Ed Miliband might take a shine
- 31:59to the idea he might get. He might decide that that you
- 32:04know that Andrew Boswell has a point.
- 32:05It seems a bit highly unlikely at this point, but he he has
- 32:09outside the courts taking it one step further.
- 32:11So Andrew Boswell, the environmental consultant he's
- 32:14campaigning to shut down net 0T side.
- 32:17His case is expected to receive a judgement at the appeal courts
- 32:21at the end of June. Let's say he's expecting it by
- 32:24the by midway next through next month.
- 32:27It seems relatively unlikely that he'll necessarily win, but
- 32:30what he's done is he's partnered with with MP Watch, which is a
- 32:34an organization representing and mobilizing MPs within the UK to
- 32:39have a voice on issues such as this.
- 32:42So essentially he's engaging Parliament to allude to some of
- 32:46the risks of CCUS, which include upstream emissions from LNG
- 32:52production outside the UK, but they also include the life cycle
- 32:57emissions of the project beyond what we know today.
- 33:04So for example, a, the his argument is that by allowing
- 33:12these products to continue with CCUS, it's essentially creating
- 33:15an extended market for gas. And if we're running out of gas
- 33:19in this country, if we have declining resources in in the
- 33:22North Sea, we've seen Centrica exit Cygnus gas plant in the
- 33:27North Sea and sell half of that to nearly half of that to
- 33:31Ithaca. They have said that they are not
- 33:33investing. I spoke to the CEO of the
- 33:35company last year for an interview and he said that he is
- 33:38not investing in North Sea gas anymore.
- 33:41So we've got declining reserves. And essentially what Andrew
- 33:44Boswell is saying is that and some of the other environmental
- 33:48campaigners that he's working with is that we are essentially
- 33:52prolonging a market for for gas in this country when we've got
- 33:56declining reserves. And as soon as that runs out, we
- 33:58will be reliant on imported LNG with greater emissions for the
- 34:03world and that all geographicizes on net zero
- 34:06goals. Well, we have to make sure that
- 34:09we're making sure all emissions are taking into consideration
- 34:13now and in the future. We heard it here first at Energy
- 34:16Voice. Thanks ever so much, Jessica.
- 34:18Thanks ever so much for joining us too, Michael.
- 34:20And that's a wrap for this week's edition of Energy Voice
- 34:24Out Loud. You can catch us on all of the
- 34:26platforms if you want to ever get a podcast to, you know,
- 34:31download on. So make sure you catch up with
- 34:33us there and catch you next week.