Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 567. NDT or T4/T3? Breaking Down the Thyroid Medication Debate
Transcript
- 0:00Ultimately, the best thyroid hormone treatment that you can be on, my favorite, favorite, favorite medication, is the one that works for you and the combination that works for you and the dose that works for you. Welcome to the Thyroid Fixer podcast, where we dive deep into the world of thyroid and hormones, especially for you ladies navigating perimenopause and menopause, and really for anyone struggling with hypothyroidism.
- 0:25I'm your host, Dr. Amy, thyroid and hormone specialist and CEO of a global telemedicine practice where we prescribe the right thyroid treatment and bioidentical hormones to all 50 states and most of Canada, helping you become that badass human that you're meant to be. So if you're battling weight gain and hair loss, you can't lose weight no matter what you do. Your energy levels are plummeting and your libido left town.
- 0:50that you're in the right place and you have found your tribe. Remember, I want you to embrace every inch of that badass woman that you truly are. So if you're ready to dive in and fix things, let's get started. NDT versus T4 and T3, like Synthroid, Liothyronine, Cytomel,
- 1:11Tyrosin versus maybe T3 only versus Compat. There are so many medication choices out there. And the bottom line is the best, best, best thyroid treatment is the one that works for you in the combination that works for you in the dose.
- 1:30that works for you. There is no one size fits all. And the most important message I can give across every single episode of the Thyroid Fixer podcast is that you are a unique individual and you deserve to be treated as such. So your thyroid treatment should always, always be tailored to you. Thyroid optimization is a nuanced art. It really is an art. And it's a gift to be able to do this.
- 1:59And this is something that I really, really pride myself on in my entire team because they've all trained under me and they've been with me for so long. I really am proud that that is what we do. That is what we specialize in. And we don't just advertise that we do it. We nuance it to you. We listen to you. We hear you when you say that these are things.
- 2:24the symptoms that I'm struggling with. Now, we're going to set expectations. If you're complaining a month in that your symptoms haven't gone away, obviously, we're not quite there yet. We can't get you optimized in a month. But when we do work on optimizing your thyroid, we're working to find what that exact point
- 2:43beautiful combination of thyroid hormone replacement is for you, for your body, for how you process it, for how you convert T4 to T3, for how your cells pick up T3. It's a very, very nuanced art. So I just want to lay that foundation first. Now, when you're looking at the different medication types, there's a couple different categories. We're going to break this down and then we're going to
- 3:08really help you to better understand those medication categories and really what it means for you and for your treatment. Okay, first and foremost, we'll start with natural desiccated thyroid, NDT.
- 3:22Now, yeah, it's on the chomping block with the FDA. You've heard me talk about it over and over again. If you're not yet subscribed to the newsletter, I give you updates every single week as to what's happening with that. Right now, we're kind of in this limbo waiting period. I will say that I do believe that certain...
- 3:42NDT medications will make it through. That's just my gut feeling. I don't think that they're going to pull everything. I don't think they can. I think the ripple effect will be too great. And there'll be way too many of us complaining. So I do believe that a couple of them are going to be pushed through. I don't think that as a supplement company that we're going to win. I don't believe that we're going to be able to continue making...
- 4:06thyroid glandular, and I do believe the FDA will start coming after different glandulars after that because it kind of opens the door and sets a precedent. However, I do believe that your NDT medication will be safe, at least one or two forms.
- 4:23Now, there are a couple of manufacturers out there. So we have Armor, which I've done a separate episode about and how they were purchased by AbbVie Pharmaceuticals that also owns Synthroid. So there's a little bit of a shady factor going on and I'm not quite sure how that's going to play out because as I said in the episode, you can certainly go back and listen to it. I also state that...
- 4:48You know, ironically, Abby just invested in an antidepressant medication, an antidepressant antipsychotic. Well, what's going to happen if we pull NDT and we put everybody on T4 only? Yeah, you're going to be depressed. You're going to need that depression medication.
- 5:05But I digress. So you have Armor, and that's really considered a brand NDT. NP is actually considered a generic NDT medication. So if your provider, let's say, writes for Armor, brand only, and you take it to your pharmacy and your pharmacy says, you know what, that's going to be like $300 a month,
- 5:30Because your insurance isn't going to cover it, but your insurance will cover NP thyroid because it's the generic form. That's why. It's literally considered brand and generic. The same way that Synthroid or Tyrosin, those are the brand T4 medications. We'll get to those. Whereas Levothyroxine is the generic.
- 5:54So we have NP as the generic form of NDT. Armor is a brand. And there's a new kit on the block called Ren, R-E-N. They're also a brand. And really, there's no huge difference. So NDT is NDT is NDT.
- 6:12Now, you might be sitting there saying, but I can't take NP thyroid. I do really well on armor thyroid. Hold that thought. I get you. Yep. Hold that thought. So when we're talking about natural desiccated thyroid, it's important to note that all NDT medications, I don't care if someone's over here going, this is the best.
- 6:30one. This is the best one. They're all 80% T4 and 20% T3. And if you don't convert well, that's not going to be the right medication for you. If you have conversion issues, if you tend to push your T4 over to reverse T3, then you probably don't want to take a medication that is
- 6:5380%, 80%, 80% T4, because you have a really high propensity of that pushing over and converting to reverse T3 and you feeling worse and feeling like your body's in survival mode. And that 20% T3 is sometimes not enough. Now, what we can do for those of you on NDT, and let's just say your reverse T3 is just a little bit wonky, like it's not horrible. Yeah.
- 7:18but it's a little bit elevated, you're coming in at like a 15, a 16, then what we can do is add T3 to your NDT.
- 7:28And again, under the category of natural desiccated thyroid, it's always, always, always derived from a pig's thyroid gland. We don't get that many variances from one medication to the next. We really don't. Taking a pig, drying out the thyroid gland. Yes, this manufacturer might put in this filler or this manufacturer puts in this filler. The fillers might be different, but the source of the thyroid hormone is the same. It's the same.
- 7:56So don't be fooled. There's no major difference from one manufacturer to the next. There really isn't. It's all natural desiccated thyroid, 80% T4 and 20% T3. Now with that, if you find one that you're like, well, you know, I'm doing okay on it, but I'm just, I'm not quite there yet. Or I started on it and then like the benefits kind of were there and then they faded away. Well, it might be that you need to add in T3. You might need to change a ratio.
- 8:23So instead of you being stuck at an 80-20 ratio for NDT, you add in some T3 and now all of a sudden it's like 60-40 or it's 50-50 or it's 40-60. You've really shifted because the amount of T3 that you're adding in plus the 20% T3 that's in the natural desiccated thyroid medication is...
- 8:47is becoming 60% of the total thyroid med where there's only 40% of the T4. So we can do that to better optimize it for you. Again, it's a nuanced start. It depends on you and how you feel and how you convert and how do you utilize the actual thyroid hormone.
- 9:09Now, if you're in that camp where you're like, you know what, armor I do really well on, but NP I don't. That is a complete possibility. I've seen it go both ways. I've seen patients on NP that can't do armor. I've seen patients on armor that can't do NP. Ren is the new kid on the block, so we don't have much data on it. But it's going to be the same thing. It's like you've got to kind of play with it and see what jives for you and your body.
- 9:34Sometimes it's the fillers. Sometimes someone can be super, super sensitive to the smallest amount of filler in that medication or however it is compounded and made at the pharmaceutical factory. Right. It's not being compounded in a compounded pharmacy. It's made into a drug.
- 9:53And that's the other big thing with NDT. Everyone hears the term natural, desiccated thyroid, natural. And they think, well, this must be the best for me because it has the word natural in the title.
- 10:05Remember, I just said that AbbVie, former Abbott Pharmaceuticals, that also owns Synthroid, that also manufactures a depression antipsychotic medication, and many, many, many others. I mean, just look it up. Just look up Abbott Pharmaceuticals or AbbVie and see all of the different drugs that they make. They are a drug company. They are a pharmaceutical giant. They are making your NDT.
- 10:35at a pharmaceutical factory. I mean, for lack of a better word, it's a drug manufacturer. It's not an organic farmer putting together your ren or your armor. Like, it's not happening. They are pharmaceutical giants.
- 10:50I don't think there's anything wrong with that because I love the pharmaceutical giant that makes lyozirinate. Like, please continue to do so. However, it's important to know that just because it has natural in the title does not mean that it's better for you. Again, the best, best, the ultimately the best thyroid hormone treatment that you can be on. My favorite, favorite, favorite medication is the one that works for you and the combination that works for you and the dose that works for you. And we don't know what that is until we get going.
- 11:20So don't get hung up and think, that's it. All I'm going to do is natural desiccated thyroid. That's all I want to do. I'm not going to put lyozironine in my body. I'm not going to put synthroid in my body because those are synthetic.
- 11:33Your natural desiccated thyroid medication is made at the same factory as Synthroid. So although it's not synthesized in a lab to be identical, because I call those synthetic medications Biosynth, they are biologically identical and synthesized to match the T4 and the T3 in your body. Just because they have the Biosynth name and NDT has the natural desiccated thyroid name when natural in the title doesn't mean that it's better for you.
- 12:01Ultimately, it's whatever is going to work for you. How about that? How about you be open enough to play around and to say, hey, maybe NDT is enough for me. Maybe I need to add in some T3 to my NDT or maybe I need to change completely.
- 12:16Don't know. You're a unique individual. So we start somewhere. We test you appropriately. We're always looking at that reverse T3 to see how well you convert. We're looking at all of the other factors that come into conversion and see if you need some help in some areas.
- 12:31And then we adjust and we personalize and we nuance this treatment. So that's your NDT. Now, the only other issue I have with NDT, and I teach this all the time in masterclasses, webinars, if you have Hashimoto's, and this is a huge point, I say it over and over and over again. If you have Hashimoto's, what is Hashimoto's essentially? Hashimoto's is an autoimmune condition. It is where your body...
- 13:01which I always love to use the analogy of soldiers with autoimmune. You have these soldiers that like to go out and they like to attack your thyroid gland because these soldiers are very confused and they think that your thyroid gland is a bad guy. Just like if you have rheumatoid arthritis, those soldiers think that your joints is a bad guy. And then if you have Crohn's disease,
- 13:22Your soldiers think that your whole gastrointestinal system, including your colon, is a bad guy, right? Celiac, the villi in your small intestine are bad guys. So these soldiers go out and attack. Now Hashimoto soldiers literally think that your thyroid gland is an invader and we go out and attack it.
- 13:42The problem is it's not an invader. And ultimately, we want to quell those soldiers and keep them in their barracks and keep them from going out and attacking because there's no need. So that's where we add in things like Hashimoto's support by the Fixer, which contains black cumin seed oil. I've done podcasts on that. We add in low-dose naltrexone. I've done podcasts on that. We go gluten-free. We do all the things to lower those antibodies and push that Hashimoto's into remission.
- 14:09For some people, when they take a natural desiccated thyroid medication, natural desiccated thyroid, it is derived from drying out a pig's thyroid gland. Are you going to follow me here? Stop what you're doing and listen. We dry out a pig's thyroid gland. Okay.
- 14:33Thyroid gland. Thyroid gland. We're literally drying out invader, putting it in a capsule and giving it to you and saying, here, take this. And then you take it and you go, wow, I feel so much worse. What the hell happened?
- 14:48Well, is it that you're taking 80% T4 and you have conversion issues and it's driving your reverse T3 up? Or is it that you're literally taking a dried thyroid gland in a capsule and your poor body that has Hashimoto's is literally thinking like it's another invader coming in and your soldiers are going, Whoa, it's time for war, guys. Let's amp up. There's an invader coming in. We got to go get them.
- 15:13And that's the same thing that I tell you happens with gluten because gluten, the protein in gluten is gliadin. Gliadin has a molecular mimicry to the thyroid gland. It can trigger an autoimmune attack. Well, what the hell do you think happens when you take the thyroid gland itself? When you take a dried pig's thyroid gland, glandular, what do you think your soldiers are going to do? Now, does this happen in every single person? If you're sitting there thinking, well, I'm on armor and I feel freaking fantastic. Awesome. Awesome.
- 15:39That's fine. That's good. That's great. I'm not saying that this happens in 100% of cases. I'm giving you things to think about as reasons why you might not be feeling better on NDT medication. Could be the dose is too low. I've talked about baby doses of T3. If you're on 30, if you're on 68 milligrams of NDT, that might not be enough. And it certainly might not be enough T3 to fuel every cell in your body. Yeah.
- 16:03It might be that you're on that dose or higher and that amount of T4 is pushing up your reverse T3 and keeping you in survival mode. Or it could be that that natural desiccated thyroid in you spurs on an autoimmune attack where literally your soldiers go out and they beat up your thyroid gland, further destroying it, further impairing its ability to produce T4 and T3 and impairing its ability to convert T4 and T3 because the thyroid gland does a lot of that conversion.
- 16:33So it could be, it could be. I'm giving you things to think about.
- 16:37Now we move over to T4. I've already said earlier, there's brand, there's generic. Now, as we kind of go through the ranks, right, there's levothyroxine. There's nothing wrong with the generic. Yes, it does contain some additional fillers. There are multiple manufacturers of generic medication. So when we're looking at Levo, there's three, four, five different generic manufacturers of levothyroxine.
- 17:04Just like there are a variety of generic manufacturers of lyothyronine, T3. So we have the generic. That's where we start. Now, in general, this again, in general, people do better with a brand T4 than a generic. In general. Now, if you are one that you're like, it is literally a $200 difference between Levo and Synthroid, then make the Levo work because it'll work.
- 17:34It'll work if it's paired up with T3. T4 only will never work. I don't care if you're on the bright and shiny Tyrosin or Tyrosin sole that we'll end up getting to. If it's T4 only, you're stuck. You're going to be hypo. But we can make that levothyroxine generic T4 work when we put it with the proper amount of T3 for you. When we dose that T4 at the right amount for you.
- 18:00So there's Levo, then there is Synthroid. Synthroid is the next step up. Now Synthroid is brand. So when you get that prescription, if you want to use Synthroid, your doctor has to say brand only. Okay, so Synthroid is brand. Above Synthroid is Tyrosint. Above Tyrosint is Tyrosint Soled.
- 18:23Now, Tyrosin has less fillers than Synthroid, much more pure. So those of you who are celiac, who have celiac disease,
- 18:32You can't even have a speck of gluten. So you can't do the levothyroxine generic. And I'm not even positive about Synthroid. You got to go to Tyrosin or Tyrosin Sol. Now Tyrosin Sol is a liquid form of a T4 medication. Zero fillers, purest of the pure. These are for my super sensitive people. Super, super sensitive. But please know that it costs more.
- 18:57And the chances of your insurance covering Tirson and Tirson Soul, Slim and Nun and Slim Just Left Town. Now, again, if you have like this rock star insurance, fine. But the majority of insurances are not going to cover Tirson or Tirson Soul. But I want you to have the knowledge just in case.
- 19:17Now, you might even have to do some price comparison if you're like, ah, I'm so sensitive to Levo and those fillers and synthro, not for me. You might have to do some price comparison between Tyrosin, Tyrosin Sol, and maybe even just a compounded T4.
- 19:32right? Because it may actually be cheaper for you to have a compounding pharmacy, just compound it without any fillers whatsoever than it would for you to spend the money on Terrasin or Terrasin Sol if your insurance doesn't cover it. Then we move over to T3. We have lyothyronine. That's generic form of T3. Sun Pharmaceuticals, Greenstone. There's always new ones. Sigma Farm. There's always new ones coming up.
- 19:55Now, of those generic manufacturers, and I haven't seen this as much with levothyroxine generic T4, I've seen it more with lyothyronine generic T3, that the different manufacturer, it can react differently in your body. It really can. So if you've been using, let's say, Sun Pharmaceuticals,
- 20:13And you're there and you're optimized and you're feeling great. And then all of a sudden you pick up your pills from the pharmacy and you're like, wow, they look different. You call the pharmacy, you go, are these still, you know, I'm taking the 25 twice a day. Are these still the 25? Yeah. But we had to change generic manufacturers because we can no longer get sun pharmaceuticals from our distributor. We can only get Sigma Farm. You know, okay. And you try the Sigma Farm for a while and you're like, why? Why?
- 20:39Am I all of a sudden feeling hyper or why am I all of a sudden feeling hypo? Well, it's how your body is utilizing that particular generic manufacturer's T3. I mean, some people just do, they react a little bit differently from the generic to the generic manufacturer. So sometimes it's going to behoove you to call different pharmacies if you know you're on Sun Pharmaceuticals and you know that that's doing really well and your particular CDS can't get Sun Pharmaceuticals anymore,
- 21:08Call Walgreens, call Walmart, call Costco, call different pharmacies and see if they can get Sun Pharmaceuticals in. As long as that generic is not being totally discontinued, see if another pharmacy will get that in for you because that shift in generic manufacturers can shift your body. I know I had it happen to me years ago.
- 21:27Okay, next up we have CytML. Now, it's completely and totally flipped from the T4 theory of brand versus generic to the T3 theory of brand versus generic. I actually see people do better on the generic, and it's obviously more affordable, than going to CytML brand.
- 21:48There was a chart that I saw with a breakdown of fillers years ago. So I don't know for sure if this is still the case. I will look it up. I will update you as I am saying this out loud. But years ago, when I saw the chart of, okay, here's the fillers that are in levothyroxine, synthorotiracine, here's the fillers that are in lyothyronine versus cytomel,
- 22:13there were more fillers in Cytamol brand T3 than there was in the generic T3 lyothyronine. So most people do really, really well on the generic lyothyronine. Nothing wrong with that. And I will tell you, I was on Cytamol for a little while and wow, it went to like $700 a month. My insurance just stopped covering it. It was stupid. And then I changed the generic and I did totally fine on it. There was really no major difference.
- 22:43Now, there's not another step up. It really is that simple when it comes to T3. It's lyothironine with a variety of different manufacturers and Cytomel, the brand. There's no higher tier of that. And again, I consider the T4 and the T3, Levo, Lyo, Synthroid, Cytomel, I consider those to be biosynth, biosynthetic, biosynth, meaning they are biologically identical
- 23:12to what your body makes in terms of thyroid hormone. You're not doing better going to the NDT if it doesn't work for you. I certainly could never take natural desiccated thyroid medication because the 80% T4, I don't convert.
- 23:29I've given the story of my dear patient, Amanda. She's just amazing. And she came to us from another clinic as well who had her on NDT because they hyper focus on T4 numbers and they have people test at the four hour mark after they take their medication. So she was showing this beautiful free T3 number, but her damn reverse T3 was in the 20s.
- 23:54Nobody was paying attention. They only wanted to give her more NDT. She came to us. You know what? She's T3 only. She's just like me. She hasn't converted at all. Once we got her on the right thyroid treatment for her, nuanced, nuanced art. Not everybody gets put on T3 only, but you're going to get put on T3 only if you've got a reverse T3 problem and you're in the 20s.
- 24:15nuanced art. So we put her on T3 only. She lost a crap ton of weight, living her best life, has more muscle now than ever. She's amazing, gorgeous, beautiful, sweet. And her husband actually jumped on board and started taking care of his health as well. Nuanced, nuanced, nuanced. So maybe, maybe NDT is doing phenomenally for you. Fantastic. Okay, good. Keep riding that wave because here's the absolute bottom line. I've already said one bottom line is
- 24:44My favorite thyroid medication is one that works for you and the combination that works for you and the dose that works for you. The other bottom line is you always go by how you feel. I can dump on you all kinds of information, all kinds of data, and none of it matters if you're not feeling your best. If you are on any or all of the treatments that I just spewed out, if you're on NDT, if you're on NDT and T3, if you're on T3 only, if you're on T3 with a little bit of T4, if you're on majority of T4 with a little bit of T3...
- 25:14and you are not feeling your best, something needs to change. We've got to tweak something. Now we can look at the other factors too. There's hormones, there's cortisol, there's insulin, there's all the things. Right now we're focused on thyroid and thyroid medication and what do you need? You just have to experiment, preferably with someone that knows what they're doing so you don't waste your time and money, and figure out that exact nuanced, beautiful combination of
- 25:40that works with your body. But knowledge is power. I always want you to know what you're taking, what's in it, what it does. Like if I stop you on the street and I say, all right, Janet, what thyroid medication are you on? I want you to be able to say I'm on armor 60 twice a day, T3 10 twice a day with my armor. Beautiful. Beautiful.
- 26:04And then I'm going to go, Janet, how do you feel? I feel great. For the first time in my life, I've stopped shedding hair. I'm actually losing weight. I'm not gaining weight, looking sideways at a brownie. This is amazing. But then if I stop you on the street and I say, Rebecca,
- 26:19What thyroid medication do you want? Well, you know, I'm on 60 milligrams of Ren Pharmaceutical twice a day, and I'm on 5 micrograms of T3. How do you feel, Rebecca? You know what? I thought I was feeling a little bit better when I started on it, and now I feel worse. And I lost like two pounds, but now recently I've gained it all back. I don't know if it's water weight. I'm tired all the time.
- 26:44Well, then that's not right for you. Then that's not right for you. Just because it works for Janet doesn't mean it's going to work for you, Rebecca. So we need to find the exact treatment, combination, dose, and type of thyroid medication.
- 27:00that is going to work for you. We need to dig and say, hey, did that Wren, did that armor cause an autoimmune attack? Or do you just maybe need some T3 to balance that out and change the ratio? I know it's confusing out there and you're not supposed to know how to do this on your own, but the more knowledge and power I can dump into your brains, the more powerful patient advocate you will be.
- 27:25And you will know where to spend your money and you will know where to invest your time and energy in working with someone. And you're going to know immediately whether or not they know what they're doing. Because at the end of the day, I want you to be the badass human that you're meant to be and live your best life.
- 27:43So thank you for listening. I hope I broke this down beautifully for you. And I'm always going to invite you to go over and join, if you're not yet in there, the Just Fix Your Thyroid Facebook group where you will get love and support and answers and where I go live every single week answering your questions live. We do fix or supplement giveaways. We have a lot of fun in there.
- 28:07So absolutely bounce over there. Ask any questions that have popped up for you based on this episode. I am here to answer all of them.