Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Aggressive Joking, Canceling Friends, and Nerd Stuff
Transcript
- 0:00So Berto emails from patrons. What do you say, Let's do it.
- 0:03This is the Psychology and Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkhana.
- 0:06I'm a therapist and I'm also a professor. My name is Umberto Casn and
- 0:11I develop cranes to lift heavy elephants. Listener Johanna from Oakland. She says,
- 0:17what is this psychology of using a joke in a defensive manner? Recently,
- 0:22my roommate Michael and I have been having communication problems. So she Johanna
- 0:28lives with Michael and they have communication problems. Since I started living with Michael,
- 0:33he would make jokes. He would be like, there is no way
- 0:36you love Joey my dead dog. So Joey is her dog that had died.
- 0:41There's no way you love Joey more than Winnie, which is his current
- 0:45dog. There's no way you love Joey more than you love Winny. And
- 0:49another thing apparently that Michael said was wow, you so dumb? And another
- 0:53thing, wow you are getting fat? Going on with Johanna's email. Every
- 0:58time I confront him on the issue, he says that he is just making
- 1:03a joke and he doesn't really mean it. This may me wonder if joking
- 1:07can be used as a defense mechanism or can it be used as in a
- 1:11passive aggressive manner? What would be the motive to use jokes in such a
- 1:15behavior? Brito? What do you think? Wow? Okay, So this
- 1:21is not where I thought this was going, because at first I thought this
- 1:26is gonna be more like you know, because I use humor to diffuse situations
- 1:30famously so and I also use humor in defensive ways. I definitely have used
- 1:36humor in passive aggresive ways. But you don't call people dumb or but but
- 1:38this is what I was gonna say. First of all, these don't sound
- 1:42funny at all. A number one two, I wouldn't call it passive aggressive.
- 1:49I would call it aggressive aggressive. Yah. Now I do agree that
- 1:56there's obviously more layers here. It's possible that they feel terrible about themselves and
- 2:01are projecting and spewing horrible things. But basically, like, look, I
- 2:07have certainly been passive aggressive in my life, and not necessarily with quote jokes,
- 2:13but passive aggressive aggressive statements as a result of my own insecurities or not
- 2:16knowing how to communicate properly. And I have you know previously said things that
- 2:22I would regret that I would say. You know, for example, I
- 2:24might I might have said things passive aggressively like are you sure you know?
- 2:30Like as an example, like are you sure you should like are you sure
- 2:36you should eat that? Or something. I don't know if I literally said
- 2:38that, but that's kind of a passive aggressive way to say I think you're
- 2:43eating too much, or I think you wait too much or something like that.
- 2:46That's not a joke. It's just shitty passive aggressiveness. But in this
- 2:50case, I think what's happening is that, well, the person's confronting the
- 2:54other person and they're saying, oh, no, no, no, it
- 2:58was just a joke. That one is interesting because instead of like owning up
- 3:04to the sentiment, they're saying, oh no, no, no, no,
- 3:07it's just a joke. But the follow up is like, well,
- 3:10what's the joke and whether it's supposed to be a joke or not. That
- 3:15hurts me. And so if I were doing this either as the receiver or
- 3:21the or the giver, like if I'm thinking about times where I've told a
- 3:25joke that was mean, I don't think of any specifics, but I'm sure
- 3:30I've done it. I don't know. I mean, that's not your style.
- 3:32But if someone confronted me, like, wait, why did you say
- 3:36that, I certainly don't think I would say, oh, it was just
- 3:39a joke, Like I think I'd be like a little taken aback, maybe
- 3:44by oh, but I don't know. It's just you don't really do that
- 3:47sort of thing, don't you know? Can neither of us do well?
- 3:51So here's my thought about that first statement that she says that apparently he said
- 3:59there's no way you love your dog that died more than you love my dog,
- 4:02And apparently he says it in a joking way, or he claims it's
- 4:06joking. I have to imagine that at least it has the cadence of a
- 4:11joke. And who knows, Johanna, I don't know, but it's possible
- 4:17that when you're living together, it's two of you and there's a dog in
- 4:23the house and it's his dog, it's possible that he might, Michael the
- 4:29human might worry that you don't like his dog very much, or that you
- 4:34don't like him very much, and instead of saying that directly or trying to
- 4:40improve the relationship, he is hurt by it, and then all that gets
- 4:45through some flow chart in his head that leads to a behavior which is a
- 4:49dig at you liking your dog. But what he's hoping you will say is
- 4:58haha, no, but I love your dog, or oh no, I
- 5:02love living with you, or some you know, some people will use quote
- 5:05unquote jokes as a way of bidding for love and attention. All of us,
- 5:11or a lot of us do that do that, But if you're particularly
- 5:15insecure and maybe particularly hurt and angry, then the sort of things that will
- 5:20come out of your mouth might be, you know, pretty awful. You
- 5:23know, I'm just trying to think, Like in a typical couple, I'm
- 5:25trying to think with my wife, well, like in the morning, we
- 5:30have a routine where we kiss each other in the morning, and if I
- 5:35you know, if we wake up and it's like an hour later and one
- 5:40of us realizes that the other one that we haven't kissed each other in the
- 5:43morning, we will make a little bit of a joke like, well,
- 5:47I guess you don't want to kiss me today, or well, I guess
- 5:50I'm pretty gross you don't want to kiss me, or something like that,
- 5:53and it's delivered in a way that's clear. You know, if Stacey said
- 5:57that to me, I would know immediately that she's not actually being mean or
- 6:01a dick, that she is making a joke that's a bid for me to
- 6:05kiss her, or vice versa. So you know, all of us do
- 6:10those kind of jokes to mask a little bit of insecurity or to make it
- 6:15to make it a little lighter than to be Hey, you did not kiss
- 6:16me today. You know, it's more indirect and playful. But you can
- 6:21imagine having that model to you and taking it way too far. He could
- 6:27be playfully trying to bid for you to like his dog, you know what
- 6:30I mean? Who knows? So I used to have this situation with my
- 6:34wife where we would be at parties and she would gang up on me jokingly,
- 6:46but it was so much that I because she she is an adamant supporter
- 6:55of you. This was before we make like I've I've noticed that early on
- 7:00when I met the two of you, that she will never talk shit about
- 7:04you. I mean, she might be kind of playful, kind of no,
- 7:09no, no, this is about things that are not below the belt.
- 7:11This was before we met, before you and I met, and in
- 7:15my interpretation, who knows if I'm right, I think she was probably feeling
- 7:18like when it was just the two of us, I would be I would
- 7:21dominate the topic or the or the conclusion of anything. And she also had
- 7:29a resentment towards me on a lot of fronts, some rights and not whatever.
- 7:31But then in a party setting or social setting, she had power.
- 7:35She had power because, as you know, A, I am very self
- 7:40deprecating. B. Some people take advantage of that and like Pylon. And
- 7:45then so she would join the parade, and then she was in a position
- 7:46of power in the situation because if she says something, everyone around would like,
- 7:50oh, well, you know and so. But this would happen a
- 7:54lot and I would be like hah. But eventually it got to be so
- 7:58much that I actually talked, and luckily, I don't know why, but
- 8:01I was able to actually like tell her what I felt about it, and
- 8:05instead of like lashing out and like tangentially doing it, and I literally told
- 8:11her, you know, like, it actually hurts me when we're in those
- 8:13social situations, and I don't know why you do that, because it feels
- 8:18like you're trying to hurt me. Well, did it lead to a conversation
- 8:20about you dominating conversations at home. No, and sadly at that time probably
- 8:26neither of us were as self aware or we were in that advance maybe,
- 8:33but at least it was a healthy conversation and it actually did lead to that
- 8:37behavior changing. Yeah, it's a very frequent thing that happens between maybe friends,
- 8:46but particularly spousal relationships where that exact thing will happen, whether it'll be
- 8:52because of the you person dominating or the other person, you know, the
- 9:00person in your wife's position just not being assertive. You know, like in
- 9:05another couple, the person in your position would be completely open to talking about
- 9:11things, but the other person, for trauma reasons, has a really hard
- 9:16time asserting or bringing things up, and so they suppress, suppress, suppress.
- 9:22But when they're around other people, they have they have a little bit
- 9:24more liveliness and their step and will come out swinging, and we'll say things
- 9:31to their spouse that their spouse has never heard before, and all of a
- 9:35sudden, they're hearing it in front of ten people. Yeah, and you
- 9:41don't know what to do, you know what I mean. So so it's
- 9:43it's yeah, it could be, but you know, that's that's that's more
- 9:48a different dynamic that I will say. You know, when I was young
- 9:52and I was in junior high in Columbia, me and my friends had very
- 9:56unhealthy humor towards each other because we would insult each other horribly, and it
- 10:05was like what would you say, Well, each person had there was there
- 10:07was a hot button for each person, And unfortunately what happened is that,
- 10:13like I'm just trying to like how low was the because me and my friends
- 10:16did that too. Like in college, we had a group of friends and
- 10:18one of my friends, we had gone out to the clubs and he had
- 10:22gotten really drunk and he had gone home with this woman from the club that
- 10:28he just met. That the next day he very much regretted having done that,
- 10:33and so there were certain elements of that story that we would pick on
- 10:37him for years and years later, you know, but it wasn't really below
- 10:43the belt because he would laugh about it too, you know. Well,
- 10:46the problem I think in this case is that the things we were teasing each
- 10:52other about actually weren't initiated by us. Other kids in the class would have
- 10:58at some point teased and one of us about that thing, but then for
- 11:01some weird reason even though we were friends. Instead of us kind of like
- 11:05uniting and being like, well, f you like, shut up, we
- 11:09would start teasing each other about the same thing. Were you was your friend
- 11:11group being teased a lot by other kids, not our friend group individuals.
- 11:18Every every individual in the class except probably a couple that were like there was
- 11:24this one guy that was two years older than everyone and two heads taller than
- 11:28everyone. So I don't think anyone teased him, but almost everyone at some
- 11:33point was teased about something by someone. But you would think, like,
- 11:37if you're tight close friends, you would think, well, if some jerk
- 11:41is saying something, so why did you do that? I have no idea,
- 11:46but we would. We would tease each other about those things and make
- 11:50it a running joke for the entirety of our relationship until we became adults and
- 11:54stop doing And it's weird, like it was so so you could see Johanna's
- 12:03roommate Michael, perhaps you know one of the many hypotheses coming from a friend
- 12:07group that's like that and is just a custom to that kind of ribbing of
- 12:11each other. I mean, I can certainly say in my case, part
- 12:16of it must have been defensive obviously because oh that they made fun of me.
- 12:20Well, shit, I need to have something on everyone. Well,
- 12:22oh yeah, that's a good one. I'll make fun of them because of
- 12:24that. Yeah. I mean, I don't think this applies to what the
- 12:28listeners talking about, but I noticed this when I was young, that there's
- 12:35always someone that is being made fun of more than other people in a friend
- 12:39group or even just a random group of guys that or people that are put
- 12:43together. And you really don't want to be that person. No, so
- 12:46you need to like play defense, right, But if you play defense too
- 12:52much, you will definitely become that person because there are inviting elements or attractive
- 12:58element of being a defensive person or someone who's really trying hard to stay out
- 13:03of that role that will make you an easy target. So it's a very
- 13:07careful dance. And I remember when I was like twelve, I remember there
- 13:13was this system that you know, I wasn't very success, I wasn't super
- 13:18successful. I mean I benefited from growing up with the same group of people
- 13:24since I was in preschool all the way through high school and some through college,
- 13:28such that I was connected to a lot of people and was friends and
- 13:33friendly with a lot of people, so I was very rarely ostracized it that
- 13:37way. But there was this one moment that I can distinctly remember where I
- 13:41was spending a night at a friend's house. We would have been twelve years
- 13:45old, I think thirteen, and you know, my whole neighborhood community was
- 13:48all white people, and since I was not completely white, that was a
- 13:54pretty big highlight of my identity in this community. We were it was late
- 14:01at night, it was probably like three in the morning, and we're all
- 14:03kind of giggling and stuff, and someone one of my very close friends saying,
- 14:09did you know like the quintessential stereotypical song you know, bit that is
- 14:20that signals that someone's Asian, you know, or Japanese? And someone giggled,
- 14:26and then another person did it, and then it became this running joke
- 14:31that night and kind of over time, and you know, in the beginning,
- 14:35I was like, oh, yeah, that's just it's just normal back
- 14:39and forth. But by four in the morning, I was, you know,
- 14:43more jokes were coming my way. It was just this excuse to be
- 14:46racist against me or something, and I did not like it. And I
- 14:52remember having this feeling of like, but you guys are my best friends.
- 14:56What's happening? What's happening? Like, I'm not a random dude, what
- 15:00you know? And I remember noticing that in other context is like, oh
- 15:03that guy is the scapecode that's do it? Yeah? And how do I
- 15:09avoid having it shift to me? I guess you were actually hitting on it,
- 15:16because I think that's what it was. Is Okay, So there's there
- 15:18was this one kid in the class that was the best at coming up with
- 15:22things to to tease other people about. Ironically, he was not a good
- 15:28student, he was not good looking. I don't think he was even that
- 15:31good at sports or anything. But his one skill was he could find the
- 15:35weakness and whisper to wherever I was listening, like, oh, such and
- 15:41such. Do you know what he did for a living? Because he could
- 15:43have become a co I don't know. Maybe, I mean, he would
- 15:46appear to be your friend, but then behind your back you would go and
- 15:50say something I was never friends with him, but he would appear to be
- 15:52like anyways, So that was one of the main people that would label things
- 15:56right. But then I think what would happen is we had probably be like,
- 16:00Okay, well, I can't become what you're saying like this, Kip,
- 16:03so I need to have little things at the ready. And I was
- 16:06never that creative to insult people, and I think neither of us were.
- 16:11So we would always use whatever was okay, that works. Okay, that's
- 16:15the one I'm using, and it's horrible. Well, fast forward to high
- 16:19school, when you're being made fun of for being Colombian all the time,
- 16:22right, and then after that it would make sense that in that context that
- 16:27you're talking about in Columbia, where you had a very vicious group of kids
- 16:32in your class, that that's maybe when you learned how to be self deprecating
- 16:37as a defense against the people that might make funny. That's a good point.
- 16:40And actually high school, now that I think about it, pretty horrible
- 16:45cross racism too. Like I mean, we didn't mean it, quote unquote,
- 16:48but because I was being teased by my Asian friends about being a Mexican,
- 16:52as they would put it, I would tease them about any number of
- 16:56Asian things. One night, me and these two of the Asian not the
- 17:02ones you know about these other two. I was in between them too,
- 17:03and it was a late night because we were working on a project, and
- 17:07the two of them were just going to town with all the Latin jokes,
- 17:12and I was fending one off and insulting the other. But it's impossible.
- 17:15It's like two on one, I can't and like you're saying, at first,
- 17:19it was all fun and games, but it went on for like an
- 17:22hour or more, and I eventually was like, I don't like this.
- 17:26Yeah, I mean, you know, it's obvious that another reason why this
- 17:30phenomenon happens is because of systemic racism and the system of racism, but also
- 17:37that when you're insecure, and young people are particularly insecure, that you look
- 17:41for ways to temporarily feel not insecure, or at least not as bad as
- 17:48other people. And if you put other people down, then you elevate yourself
- 17:49a little bit. I got to tell you that is another key insight,
- 17:52because there are some friends of mine that we never did that with each other,
- 17:59even back in Columbia. So I was talking about my group of friends,
- 18:02Well, the one you met, Jue Migain, Him and I never
- 18:06actually did that, and I don't think he did it as much. Well,
- 18:11he might have done it with some of the others, but him and
- 18:12I didn't well, are you saying that you had security between the two of
- 18:19us. I guess that is a good question. I don't know, but
- 18:25I mean, yeah, I don't know. It's a fascinating question. First
- 18:30of all, there were few things for me to make fun of him about.
- 18:33Did he come from a good family, No, no, particularly,
- 18:36but there were a few things for me to make fun of him about.
- 18:38Like his last name is giddy Yo means grasshopper, so you know, I
- 18:44could make sort of fun of that, but like not really something to hang
- 18:47on to. And he chose not to make fun of me. I mean,
- 18:51he would make fun of me more in the more casual ways, like
- 18:52we're playing basketball and I shoot and I missed. It was like, well,
- 18:56it's wrong, you didn't wake up this on the right side of the
- 18:57bed, way whatever. I like teasing each other about momentary, non racial
- 19:03or personal trait things have at it lovely, awesome, But the thing was,
- 19:10I don't know why. And then here in the States someone like Tie
- 19:14Tie, and I never did that ever. I mean, okay, maybe
- 19:18like trivially, but not well, not really. Thinking of those Asians and
- 19:25half Asians that you were friends with in Tacoma, Tie, it comes across
- 19:29as perhaps by a long shot, the most secure of all those. Yes,
- 19:33yes, yeah, yeah, absolutely, by a long shot, long
- 19:37shot. Yeah. And so I think, you know, that's a really
- 19:41interesting insight because left, like you know, left in my own little by
- 19:45my own devices, I'm actually fairly secure. But then if you drop me
- 19:49in the wrong context, I start feeling all sorts of insecure, and then
- 19:53I'm gonna lash out in those unhealthy ways. But when you put me in
- 19:56the Petri dish with the more secure people, and I'm fine and they're fine,
- 20:00and we're fine. I hesitate to say this, but there are times
- 20:07when I notice that I have kind of a skill of doing what you're talking
- 20:14where I can make fun of people in public and get everyone till in fact,
- 20:18when we were playing poker the other night with your brother, I did
- 20:22it to your brother. I made fun of them, So you know,
- 20:26I'm there with all of his friends. Your brother's friends are playing poker,
- 20:30and then you know all of his friends. But I've never met these guys,
- 20:36so I'm kind of insecure. I mean, not terribly, but I'm
- 20:41It's been a while since I've been in a group of people where I'm like
- 20:45the outsider, you know what I mean, I'm the one who is very
- 20:49much. You know, everyone else is talking about old stories and they know
- 20:52each other, and I'm the new guy and you and your brother are talking
- 20:57with all those guys and so, you know, and I was fine.
- 21:00I'm old enough now that that doesn't really get under my skin like it would
- 21:03have when I was younger. But but even with my friends that I know,
- 21:07well, I'll find sometimes that I'll get somebody and everyone will laugh and
- 21:12I'll regret it. I'll be like, dude, Kirk, like calm down,
- 21:15Like, don't you don't have to go after you know, I'm not.
- 21:19If I was cool, no one would laugh, you know what I
- 21:22mean. But you go to a certain edge there. Yeah, And I
- 21:26noticed that like a long time with me. No, no, I mean,
- 21:32I don't do it very often, is the thing. And if I
- 21:34did do it with you, you would I would do it in a way
- 21:38that you would be completely fine with and would laugh too, you know,
- 21:44like because you don't take things personally in that way it was supposed to me.
- 21:49And your brother is in your direction. He's not as much as you,
- 21:53but he's also very self deprecating and well, and the thing with my
- 21:57bro is actually he does get a lot of shit from a lot of his
- 22:00friends. But it's they I think they pick on things that are not like
- 22:07character philosophy. They're all like, you know, like, dude, you
- 22:11know in your late twenties, you're a mess, You're totally like late for
- 22:14everything, or something like that. You know, Well, it'll be some
- 22:18joke about I don't know anyway. Point is is I've never or like Seth
- 22:23will tease him about, like you didn't like you have terrible taste in horror
- 22:27movies or whatever. You know, right, I have never. Yeah,
- 22:30that's a good one. In fact, we might have done that that night
- 22:33because Seth and I were bonding over are very similar tastes in music or in
- 22:37movies, and I can't believe you've found one in Rainbow's fan in there.
- 22:44Yeah, that was actually pretty funny because the one actually avowed critic of movies
- 22:48and music happened to be in your corner on that one. Well, we
- 22:53were in alignment through a lot of conversations. But I've met a lot of
- 22:59people who say in Rainbows it's their favorite Radiohead album. By the way,
- 23:03I know a lot of fans of kid rock. Oh boy, I mean
- 23:08you realize that In Rainbows is their least accessible, but perhaps most artistic of
- 23:17all the albums. You know, arts, it'd be like criticizing Sergeant Pepper
- 23:22or something, you know, like well, I like original Beatles. No,
- 23:26but it could be okay, But it could be like saying, look,
- 23:30I hate to say this, but it could be like saying, look,
- 23:33the White album could have been a single album, right, they could
- 23:37have cut But there's some great tracks on web. There are amazing tracks on
- 23:41the White album, but you disavow the entire album. I don't. Look.
- 23:45My honest take about it is this. Every time I have heard it,
- 23:47and like I said in two thousand, whatever it came out, I
- 23:51had it on constant replay, like constant. I am always floored by their
- 23:56musicality, their talent, his voice, everything. I just always have always
- 24:02gravitated to catch your singing lyrics. Sure, and this album has very little
- 24:07Yeah, And so why you know why this weekend I listened to all of
- 24:11the Innocence Erasure back to back because there's only one bad track on that album,
- 24:18This one stupid sixty five thousand track that's got like the beat, the
- 24:23beat. I don't even know what the hell they were doing. It's like
- 24:26the stupidest thing. But every other song is that early erasure? That song
- 24:30because they were more like eighty eight, maybe it's not early erasure, it's
- 24:37just they just throw in some wacky thing in there. Yeah. All right,
- 24:40well, let's take a break and when we get back more of your
- 24:44emails. What do you say burto Let's do it all right, we're back
- 24:49from the break. Let's do an opp bird already say. These people became
- 24:53patrons all the way back in twenty twenty one. These folks are all monthly
- 25:00patrons. We have Bina from Broomfield, Colorado, Deborah from Caernarfon from Great
- 25:07in Great Britain. I'm sure I'm pronouncing it. Ron Lamarus from Chappaqua,
- 25:12New York, Chappaqua, Chris from Chicago. Oh no, actually, all
- 25:18these are middle tier patrons. I'm sorry. Up. Middle tier patron Bina,
- 25:22middle tier patron Jeprah, middle tier patron Lamarius, middle tip to your
- 25:26patron, Chris, middle tier patron Jack from Decatur, Alabama. Middle tier
- 25:30patron Seca from Denver, Colorado. Militaire patron Alice from Newton Iowa and middle
- 25:37tier patron Kate from to Tawson, Towson, Maryland, and then the following
- 25:45folks are all annual regular patrons. We have zil Gorb from Bolton, Ontario,
- 25:52Kaylee from Brownwood, Texas. Christina from Garden Grove, California. Demeris
- 25:57from u CR Birto country code CR takes some guesses. Croatia CR is South
- 26:08Korea? What CR, what why? Why isn't it n K right rsk
- 26:18SK Laura from Grand Marsh, Wisconsintanya from Jamaica Plaine, Massachusetts, Olga from
- 26:27from Germany. The dee is the two letter word for Germany the Iceland.
- 26:33That Yeah, Biata from Lithuania. I have a great great grandmother named Biata.
- 26:41Oh, I thought you were going to say from Lithuania. From Sweden.
- 26:45Sarah from Germany. We have Nicole from Lease Summit, Missouri. Tuna
- 26:53or Tuna from Munich, Germany, a lot of Germany. Kim from Palo
- 26:59Alto, californ You Lori from Plantation, Florida. That's an unfortunate name for
- 27:04it. Yeah, I live in the town of KKK, Alabama. And
- 27:12uh Ego manulis from Potsdam, Germany's a lot of Germany folks. Wow,
- 27:19thank you for being a patron all the way out in Germany and everywhere else
- 27:25and staying a patron through thickened things. All right, it's next email anonymous
- 27:29listener. They say, how can one deal with micromanaging at work? Coming
- 27:33from the higher ups? So how would you define micromanaging? Bertow? Yeah,
- 27:37so micromanaging. Hey, Kirk, I need you to grab all these
- 27:42guitars, tune them up, get them ready for the customer. You got
- 27:47that, yes, Berto? Okay? Cool? Cool? Five minutes later,
- 27:51are you are you starting? Oh? You're getting okay. Ten minutes
- 27:55later, Oh, I wouldn't start with that one. Uh, I probably
- 27:57start with the one on the on the other end. Fifteen minutes later,
- 28:02are oh, you're tuning them? I see. I would tune them the
- 28:04lowest string first. And basically at one point they literally say here, give
- 28:10me the guitar. They tune several of the guitars for you, and you're
- 28:14just watching them, and you're watching them and they're actually not even teaching you
- 28:18because they actually like, here, I'll just do it. You go clean
- 28:21the bathroom for a second. Oh but wait, tell me how you're cleaning
- 28:23the bathroom, and essentially you feel completely disenfranchised. No power. The power's
- 28:27taking it from you. They don't even attempt to like teach you so that
- 28:30next time they don't have to micromanage you. It's horrible, dude, when
- 28:33that happens. It's horrible. If someone were to micromanage you at your current
- 28:37job, what would that look like? Well, it happens all the time,
- 28:41sadly, but oddly I'm the boss, so it's like it happens in
- 28:45reverse. But really what it is is like I'll be sitting there and I'm
- 28:52like, all right, I have a task, right, And I'm like,
- 28:55well, all right, well let's let's just go ahead and do this
- 28:57and do what do what kind of things? Do? You have? Heavy
- 29:02things with cranes? You know, And it's like, what are we going
- 29:04to do here? How are we going to do this problem? And then
- 29:07and then what happens is they start micromanaging me like, well, don't use
- 29:11that crane. And then so Maydiot's like why don't we use actual, like
- 29:15mechanical cranes. I'm like, you're fired, and then then they micromanage me
- 29:18in the firing. So anonymous listener says aside from leaving the job, Are
- 29:22there any ways to respectfully communicate that you recognize micromanaging and would like it to
- 29:27stop? Is the root cause the desire to control everything? Is it even
- 29:33possible to assert your ability to perform well without being micromanaged past a certain point
- 29:37of no return? Burrow? What do you think? Yeah, dude,
- 29:41Okay, so, hey, it really has happened to me that, and
- 29:45and I've done it like, it's happened both ways for real. So to
- 29:49answer noneal listeners question, why were you micromanaging? Right? Okay, So
- 29:56when I have micromanaged, First of all, I was an experienced manager.
- 30:00That's the first thing. I just didn't realize that I was micromanaging. Number
- 30:04Two, I didn't trust. I just didn't trust that the job would get
- 30:10done the way I wanted it done. Number Three, I was insecure about
- 30:12what that would mean for me in my career. Because basically, it's okay
- 30:18if I were like secure in my position. It's okay if there's some amount
- 30:22of failure, because that could be a learning moment. But if I feel
- 30:26like any failure could spell doom for me, I can't possibly afford to delegate
- 30:30anything. And so those were definitely causes in my case. Right, So,
- 30:34anonymous listener, you ask, is the root cause the desire to control
- 30:38everything? The way I answer that pretty much in every context is we don't
- 30:45have a desire for control. People talk about it like that all the time,
- 30:51Like I mean, unless you're a psychopath or something, which is a
- 30:53very rare individual, we don't have a need for control. We don't spring
- 30:59from the wom with a need for control. We have a need for safety.
- 31:04Somebody will say, well, you have a need for power. No,
- 31:07we have a need for safety. We don't care about control or power
- 31:11if we're completely safe. You know, the reason why we exert power or
- 31:18concern ourselves with power or become obsessed with power and possibly with control, like
- 31:22in intimate partner violence relationships domestic violence relationships is because we do not feel safe.
- 31:29Now, it could be a distortion. In intimate partner violence relationships,
- 31:33it is a distortion, right, It's because of the trauma that the person
- 31:37went through growing up regarding attachments and other kinds of things that led to them
- 31:41having a chronic sense of feeling in danger and thus they resort to some sort
- 31:45of defense, which could be control and abuse. But it's not a need
- 31:51for control or a need for power. It's a need for safety. And
- 31:52so for someone that's micromanaging in a way that is detrimental to those around them,
- 32:01it's because they don't feel safe. Now, you might have nothing to
- 32:05do with that. In all likelihood, you don't like what Berto was saying.
- 32:08His subordinates had nothing to do with Umbardo's insecurity. There was some other
- 32:15reason for Embardo's insecurity, and you could argue that it's a top down thing
- 32:19where your boss should have been making you feel more secure back there, you
- 32:22know what I mean, That's quite possible. There's also okay, there are
- 32:25also also cases where you screwed up hiring someone and now instead of taking the
- 32:32hard step of like maybe letting that person go or at least moving them to
- 32:36a different thing or training them or training them, imagine that the only option
- 32:40you think you have is to fine, here, I'll do it right.
- 32:45Or if you have trauma regarding letting other people doing things, like you had
- 32:49an alcoholic parent or a spouse that would screw things up or whatever. You
- 32:53know, there's a lot of roads. But what do you do if you're
- 32:59being mic managed burto how do you get out underneath that? So I've been
- 33:02very direct in now I'm older, had several experiences, I've been very direct
- 33:07with managers that were doing that to me. What'd you say? I literally,
- 33:12just in our one on one said, so, here's the thing.
- 33:15So remember we had that presentation and you didn't like the way I was putting
- 33:21the sides together, and then you just said I'll do it, and then
- 33:22you did it, Like I don't learn anything from that, and it really
- 33:29feels like I'm not empowered in that in that moment. And you know,
- 33:34the better managers, because everyone slips up. The better managers will go like,
- 33:37oh, you know, good point, or let me think about that
- 33:40or whatever. And then other other times you might realize that you're not under
- 33:44a good manager and then you got to maybe think about that, because sometimes
- 33:46it'll be like, well that one was just too important, or oh I
- 33:51know, but just you know, like excuse excuse, excuse, yeah,
- 33:53or even just telling you listen, you keep making the same mistake I tried.
- 34:00I'll remind you blah blah, like even that would be more direct and
- 34:02then you know, but but usually that's not the way it goes it's usually
- 34:07like an excuse or whatever. But the times that I've done that with a
- 34:09manager that's actually experienced, they even as I'm saying it, they're like,
- 34:14oh, you're right, you know, like it's I can see the shame.
- 34:17Yeah. Yeah, So that's one thing. Some other strategies. These
- 34:22are all things that I've tried because I've been micromanaged before. It's been a
- 34:27while, but I if I think back, and one style, which you
- 34:32know isn't as mature as Burdo, is just to avoid the situation by not
- 34:37being around them very often. You know, if you're not avoid them,
- 34:42if you're not in their vicinity, then they can't micromanage you. Another option
- 34:47is to over deliver for a while. This is more my style is that
- 34:53if someone is micromanaged me, or more broadly, I get the sense that
- 34:59they don't feel secure in my abilities to be independent, then I will work
- 35:07seventy hours a week so that they will you know, there will be no
- 35:13doubt that I know what I'm doing and that I can do it well,
- 35:16and that I will get the job done. And I want to over deliver
- 35:22in that way for not only the reason of getting someone to stop micromanaging me.
- 35:28But even if I have a I've had bosses that weren't micromanaging me.
- 35:32But I just I don't I don't like any managing. Forget about the micromanaging.
- 35:40I don't want. I don't want even an ounce of managing. And
- 35:45so when I have had new jobs, I will I will always strategize that
- 35:51I will always over deliver, and then I will have established a reputation as
- 35:59someone who gets shit done. Then the manager can spend their time paying attention
- 36:05to other people, and then I can actually pull back and kind of coast
- 36:08a little bit, because my reputation carries a day, and I work better
- 36:15when I'm not being managed at all. Honestly, you know, I don't
- 36:17want people breathing down my neck. So that's one thing. There's different cultures
- 36:23too, like meaning depending on the company, some cultures will make it even
- 36:29worse, because that is the culture from the top down, where literally from
- 36:34the CEO or whatever, they are already micromanaging their vps. The vps are
- 36:37micromanaging the directors, the director and so then if you're caught in that system,
- 36:42it's actually really hard because it's cultural, it's organizational. You might need
- 36:47to make a change. If that's the case, well, another option in
- 36:52that situation is to just smile and internally judge them because and I've been in
- 36:59these shoes when I was much younger, like high school, college, where
- 37:04you have no power and there's nothing you can do about it, and people
- 37:07think of you as you're just an idiot and there's nothing you can do to
- 37:13convince them otherwise. And so I remember just quietly letting things happen and internally
- 37:22just saying this person is dumb, you know, or whatever, and just
- 37:27letting it go. Is like, well, I'm getting paid the same by
- 37:30being micromanaged or not. I don't you know. I'll do my job,
- 37:36you know, I get my paycheck. That's what I'm here to do.
- 37:37Another thing to do is to get out ahead of them. You know,
- 37:44you can usually hear micromanaging as it's coming down the tracks, and you can
- 37:49headed off at the past by saying yep, totally. I thought of that.
- 37:52You know, you can assert yourself and say I know where you're headed
- 37:55with that, thank you, And I thought of that I did. This
- 38:00is what you can kind of demonstrate that you know what you're doing. And
- 38:06maybe if you do that enough they will go, oh, I guess I
- 38:08don't need to explain every little detail to them. Another thing is more what
- 38:14Burto was saying is to tell them, but also to develop a strong relationship
- 38:19with them. It's very important in my estimation, and it's under emphasized.
- 38:27I think in our culture that your work relationships, whether it's your boss or
- 38:31your subordinates or your coworkers, there are so many opportunities, as we all
- 38:36know, for emotional problems and conflict and misunderstanding and hurt and anger and resentment.
- 38:44That is the same sort of emotions and things that happen in a family.
- 38:47But in a family, we at least culturally understand that you're supposed to
- 38:52bond with your spouse and your kids and your parents, and you're like,
- 38:55you're supposed to be good friends, you're supposed to like each other. But
- 39:00somehow at work it's like, well, we're at work. It's the same
- 39:04thing. Arguably in some context you're closer to the people at work than you
- 39:07are the people that you live with at home. You'll spend a lot of
- 39:10time with people at work. So starting out or at least retroactively starting to,
- 39:20you know, go on a campaign to develop a strong relationship with the
- 39:22key people that you work with, where you just hang out, where you
- 39:27like each other, you know each other, you find things in common,
- 39:31you bond in some way, you share things with each other, you self
- 39:36disclose, so that when push comes to shove and there's the inevitable conflict,
- 39:40you have some foundation to rely on. Like for you, Berto, when
- 39:44you went to that manager and said, Hey, that thing you did at
- 39:46the meeting, you know it really stepped in my toes. If you have
- 39:52I'm guessing a better relationship with that person, where you can joke around like
- 39:55each other, you feel much Yeah, you feel much freer to say such
- 40:00a thing, and you're going to trust the person who's going to give you
- 40:02the benefit of the doubt, and the manager is much more likely to regard
- 40:06what you're saying than if you barely know each other completely. The one caveat
- 40:10I will give just from personal experience is when you are new to an environment,
- 40:15like you started a new company or whatever. I've found through bad experience,
- 40:22like there's this one time I literally had this where I trusted too quickly
- 40:29someone I literally just met and disclosed way too much too soon over beers and
- 40:36then they talked about that to other people behind my back at work. Yeah,
- 40:40what was I mean, what what like we were you know, after
- 40:45hours we went for a beer and we were both kind of but what did
- 40:47you share with them that what we were complaining about things that we didn't like
- 40:52at the office, and I thought we were like kind of having a little
- 40:55bit of a bonding thing or whatever. No, that person went and talked
- 41:01to other people about what I had said, and it was Anyways, the
- 41:06point is, dude, I trusted this person too quickly. Yeah, and
- 41:09I disclosed too much too soon. Now am I What should that person have
- 41:14done that? And of course I would never do that, But I'm saying,
- 41:16you don't know who you're interacting with at first. So I'm not saying
- 41:19don't do that, just you know, kind of play your cards a little
- 41:23wisely at first. Also, just another thing is when you're coming into a
- 41:29new environment, was there a consequence? Like, yeah, were you Oh
- 41:34so this was brought up by one of the people in charge as a negative
- 41:42about me, because yeah, absolutely there was a consequence. So I'm just
- 41:45saying, like, when you walk into a new environment, listen a lot
- 41:47first, get to know people, but remember that you don't know these people
- 41:52yet, so don't like put all your eggs in one basket with someone that
- 41:57you don't know if they were trustworthy or not. That happened to me in
- 42:00my senior year of high school playing football. We had a new coach and
- 42:07he was supposed to be like God's gift of football because he took our team
- 42:13to state championship like ten years earlier or something, and I was really looking
- 42:19forward to having him as our coach. And very quickly I realized that he
- 42:23didn't know what he was doing. For those people who know, I'll just
- 42:27explain it. It won't be that hard to explain to people who don't play
- 42:30football. But so, there's this particular play called an option play, and
- 42:35if you know where the quarterback is right, Essentially, it's a play that
- 42:38can be any one of three different things. So you can hand the ball
- 42:45off, you can not hand the ball off, but you fake the handoff
- 42:50and the quarterback runs around the end. Or you fake the handoff, you
- 42:53run around the end, and you pitch it while you're on the sideline.
- 42:58And is this agreed upon on ahead of time? Yeah, like everyone knows
- 43:02this is going to happen, you know, if it's right or left,
- 43:06and it's all dependent on the quarterback's decision. Like the quarterback can decide based
- 43:09on what the defense is doing, do I hand the ball off? So
- 43:13the motions are going to be the same, but the delta is going to
- 43:16come from the quarterback, right what they do? Okay, right, Like,
- 43:19if you're the pitchman, you always run as if you're going to get
- 43:22a run, but you might not get the pitch. If you're the dive
- 43:24you know, the up the middle running back, you run up and you
- 43:29don't know if he's going to give you the ball. If it's in your
- 43:32stomach, then you run. If you don't, then you act like you
- 43:35got it and anyway, So the normal way of defending against this play is
- 43:39that you assign a defensive player to each of the possible ball handlers. So
- 43:45you put typically like a cornerback on the pitchman, you put maybe one of
- 43:50the linebackers, maybe an outside then backer on the quarterback, and you put
- 43:53an inside linebacker on the dive man or the initial up the middle running back.
- 44:00And the way that it works is, say so if I'm I played
- 44:04middle linebackers. So if the running back comes up the gut, there's really
- 44:08no way to tell if he has the ball or not because there's so many
- 44:12bodies that are in the mix. You have the offensive lineman, the defensive
- 44:15lineman, and I'm right behind the defensive lineman. I can't tell who has
- 44:21the ball at least for a second, you know. It takes a bit
- 44:23and one second then it's everything. I'm out of the play, you know,
- 44:27because everyone's still running. It's a very quick acting play. So what
- 44:31you're supposed to do when you're assigned the dive man is I just have to
- 44:36hit him, you know, just take the thinking out of it. Yeah,
- 44:38just hit him, hit him, and if he has the ball,
- 44:42take him down. If he doesn't, well you did your job. Other
- 44:45people have the other things. Okay, So what this genius of a coach
- 44:50decided, And he was supposed to be a defensive genius, and you're supposed
- 44:53to be particularly a genius with linebackers, which I was very excited about.
- 44:57The linebacker is kind of like the quarterback of the of the defense, by
- 45:00the way, and I'm, you know, captain of the football team.
- 45:01I've been varsity a number of years, so you know what you're doing.
- 45:06Yeah, And I've played against the option before because there are certain teams that
- 45:10just tend to run the option more and so you tend to anyway. So
- 45:15his genius approach was the middle linebacker. And we had three linebackers, so
- 45:21you had one linebacker, and I was that linebacker. I am smack dab
- 45:24in the middle of the defense. I am responsible for the diveman, the
- 45:30quarterback, and the pitchman on both sides. Oh my gosh, there are
- 45:35ten other defensive players, none of which have any assignments. What yeah,
- 45:42So, so I mean, is he doing that because like you're the better
- 45:46No, it's just his scheme And looking back, honestly, he probably forgot
- 45:52or he was suffering from dementia. There is no coach on the plan would
- 45:57have done that. I mean, just my explanation to it doesn't immediately went
- 46:00like that sounds like the obvious thing. And I'm not even leaving anything out.
- 46:05It wasn't like I sort of had everyone that was the assignment. And
- 46:09that's just one example of how how what I thought to be how bad his
- 46:14coaching was. And there were a number of other things, and so early
- 46:17on in the season. Before the first game, I started talking shit about
- 46:22him to other players, and you know, I was probably being arrogant because
- 46:28I feel like I'm hot shit because I'm captain of the football team, I'm
- 46:30a senior. He's kind of the new guy. He's a new coach,
- 46:35and I had all these high aspirations for him. I was a bit angry
- 46:38at him, be because the other thing is we would run in practice and
- 46:42I would miss my assignments because it was physically impossible to meet them, and
- 46:47I'd get bitched out and I'd and I just I started talking shit about him,
- 46:52and one of the players told him, oh no, And there was
- 46:55a sit down meeting with all you know, there's probably like eighty players,
- 47:00I don't know, fifty players in the stands. We all sit down and
- 47:04the coach has this long just chewing out of the entire team. Wait,
- 47:08how many players? Uh? Yeah, like probably fifty fifty. What yeah
- 47:14for an eleven, isn't it how many people are on the Yeah, well
- 47:16you have eleven on offense, eleven on defense. Oh gosh, maybe forty.
- 47:21I mean, it depends on it depends on. He's got all these
- 47:22people in the stands. Yeah, so all of us players and he's just
- 47:25you know, bitching us out, and uh, but everyone knows that he's
- 47:30yelling at me, you know, because by then everyone knows like he's like
- 47:35it shows a lack of respect people talking about Yeah, well, and it's
- 47:39true. I mean, as the captain, I should have gone straight two
- 47:43horse, of course, But I was being a child, and you trusted
- 47:47the wrong people, and I trusted the wrong people, and he didn't start
- 47:53me in the first game. I remind you we had three linebackers. It
- 47:58was just kind of a weird defense. You can make it work, particularly
- 48:00in high school and for those following along, that doesn't include the outside landbackers.
- 48:06There were three middle linebackers and I had been varsity. How many normally
- 48:09would there be two? Yeah, it's pretty weird to have three. Anyway,
- 48:15point is is there are three possible positions on the field that I can
- 48:20play. Since I've been starting for two years and I'm captain of the football
- 48:22team, and he didn't start me in the first game, I wonder why,
- 48:27Well, random coincidence, just tried to strategery. Yeah, yeah,
- 48:30but by that point I was losing a lot of enthusiasm for the game,
- 48:37and I didn't really care, but I was starting the rest of the season
- 48:43anyway. That's my long, dumb story about that, all right, anonymous
- 48:46patron, She says, my very close friend has a friend who was driving
- 48:52drunk and killed a nineteen year old girl. Okay, so my very close
- 48:57friend, so nice patron, Her very very close friend has another friend who
- 49:02she knows, by the way, that was driving drunk and killed a nineteen
- 49:06year old girl. It was shocking, horrific and heartbreaking. My friend so
- 49:10not the one that drove drunk. Yeah, my friend feels like she is
- 49:15grieving the loss of her friend, you know. Yeah, and I don't
- 49:19know how to help her. My friend that wasn't the drunk drive. I
- 49:22have said to her, you know, given that she's really distraught, I've
- 49:27been trying to help her. I have said that it's okay to have conflicting
- 49:30feelings and care about her friend while also believing that her friend should face justice.
- 49:36But there's a general sense from my friend of numbness, confusion, and
- 49:38grief. I think it is hard for her to process her sadness and empathy
- 49:43for her friend, the drunk driver without feeling immense guilt because of the victim
- 49:47and her family. It reminds me a little bit about the Ashton Kutcher Mila
- 49:52Kunis Danny Masterson situation that you briefly talked about. Do you know about that
- 49:57situation? Yeah? What do you know about that situation? I know that
- 50:00first of all, Ashton and Mila wrote support letters for Masterson, and that
- 50:10also there was yet to sing Danny master O. Sorry I assumed. Yeah,
- 50:15Danny Masterson from the That seventies show was accused and convicted of raping women
- 50:22and h the But then you know, because Ashton and Mila knew him personally
- 50:29and we're very good close friends, they they were asked to give support character.
- 50:34What is a character? I think was it a sentencing letter? Yeah,
- 50:38it was something like supporting him to reduce the sentence or whatever. Right,
- 50:42anyway, so they wrote their letters to the and then people came out
- 50:45going like, how could you support him? Et cetera. Then there were
- 50:49also some rumors, who knows, total rumors that Ashton might have felt like
- 50:54he had to because Danny Masterson might have known more about Ashton's involvement in Ashton's
- 51:01discovery of a girl he was dating. Who was murdered by a psychopath.
- 51:07Anyways, long story short, people got upset at Ashton and Mila because they
- 51:12wrote those others and then they released a quote apology apology video that really just
- 51:19points to the fact that just because you're an actor does not mean you know
- 51:23how to write or direct, because this video is one of the worst apology
- 51:30videos I've ever seen. I mean, it's so stilted. Now, you
- 51:34know, I just wish I were there with some of these folks and I
- 51:37could just sort of get them out of their head because if they just apologized
- 51:42from the heart, because in all likelihood, Ashton Kutcher and Mila Kunis have
- 51:46a heart, they have relatable story to tell, but they always write this
- 51:54really like it's like they thought about it too long, you know, and
- 52:00then they deliver it in this really disingenuous way. And so yeah, that
- 52:07that video's pretty bad, and so there's a lot of backlash on them because
- 52:09to me, I wouldn't be surprised if what was in their hearts was very
- 52:16con similar to what anonymous patrons talking about of like when initially when Danny Masterson
- 52:22was accused, they were like, no way, Danny Mashison is he's one
- 52:28of the best. Apparently, Danny Masherson to Ashton, Kutcher and me,
- 52:31Lakunis was one of the nicest, kindest people that they had ever met,
- 52:37which can be true of court, you know, even though the Internet doesn't
- 52:40believe that, you know, and so when they first hear the accusations,
- 52:45they're like, no way, And they might have even been hanging out with
- 52:46Danny Is like, and Danny would be like, no, no, that
- 52:50never happened DDD to d And then you know, and famous people are probably
- 52:53pretty used to hearing these kinds of accusations occasionally, you know that are fault
- 53:00not those kind, but you know, random rumors that people say, and
- 53:04you can imagine that Ashton Amela are just like, one hundred percent no way
- 53:07he did it. He even told us, you know why that story is
- 53:12bogus. As a story start to mount, and you can imagine, if
- 53:15you're Ashon Emila, you probably aren't super enthusiastic about following this story. You
- 53:22know, you're not. Your Google alert isn't saying you new stories about more
- 53:27accusations, so you're probably not super in the loop. But the critical mass
- 53:31eventually enough information comes out and you have to face the fact that, oh,
- 53:36my god, did he do these things? And what you know in
- 53:39your heart? What do you do with that? That's a very confusing place
- 53:44to be. Then over time you reckon with the fact that he did do
- 53:49these things, but you still love the man. You might have some anger
- 53:53towards him and some sadness for the victims, and you still love the guy,
- 54:00and you believe that he probably needs to do time, but with treatment,
- 54:06maybe he can get better. And so you write a letter to the
- 54:08judge behind closed doors, saying, hey, he did these things and that's
- 54:14bad, and there's another side to him that can be redeemed. There's a
- 54:19good side to him. And if you're Ashton and Mela, at the very
- 54:22least you think, well, I'm doing this for my friend. It probably
- 54:24won't do anything, because you know, it's not like a letter from ash
- 54:28It's not like the judge looks at that and goes like, well, then
- 54:32Danny gets just six months of probation, like oh but no. But to
- 54:37be fair, it's not because it's Ashton and Mela. But the reason those
- 54:39things even exist is judges do, in fact, almost robotically take into account
- 54:45mitigating factors and then do things like Okay, well it was supposed to be
- 54:47twelve years, I'm going to do ten years plus whatever, Like yeah,
- 54:51these things can happen. But it's not because it's me, Lai and Ashton.
- 54:53It's because, yeah, it's a part of the process, right And
- 54:58there I'm sure were victims were also and families were writing writing the opposite,
- 55:02much more convincing letters, you know what I mean. So it's not like
- 55:07I think the public thinks that Ashon and Me that pulled strings to get Danny
- 55:10off. It's like that would never happen, you know what I mean.
- 55:15But I get the backlash because their apology it almost came across it was too
- 55:20defensive as the thing. They were basically like, you know, we've we've
- 55:23given money to charities for victims. It's has nothing to do it's nothing to
- 55:28do with what you're being accused of. Like it, I just use it
- 55:31in any other context like the extremes. By the way, pet peeve of
- 55:36mine, people really dislike when you use an extreme analogy, but they misunderstand
- 55:40why you're doing it. I'm doing it to show that there is a limit
- 55:45and if there is a limit, then we have to discuss where that limit
- 55:46is. Right. So in my case, like the thought experiment exactly,
- 55:50the example would be, imagine they do this in philosophy all the time,
- 55:53right, Imagine I go out and I you know, I kill a thousand
- 55:57people tomorrow. Right, Well, let's not go that far, okay.
- 56:00Nine? And then you're like, You're like, Barrow, what what are
- 56:04you doing? And I'm like, dude, I've donated a lot of money
- 56:07to charity. I've like what, Yeah, I mean that's the extreme.
- 56:12So in this case, they think that that you can't point a finger to
- 56:16me about not supporting victims. Look at all this shit I've done. Yeah,
- 56:22And so to your point, they unfortunately missed the mark on what they
- 56:27were supposed to. I mean, all they had to say was yeah,
- 56:30I could see how this would look bad. And I've just been completely busted
- 56:35up about this whole thing. Do I believe that Danny did these things?
- 56:38Yes, I've seen and it's horrible what he did and what he did to
- 56:42these people, to these victims, it's just horrible. Yeah. But I
- 56:47beseech you to be in my shoes for a second. This was my best
- 56:51friend and you know, you're just gonna take my word for it. There
- 56:53were no signs that he did those things, and he was a good guy,
- 56:58and he was good to me. You're just gonna have to believe me
- 57:00on that. He was the nicest guy, one of the nicest people I've
- 57:06ever met. Maybe it was all an act. I don't know. So
- 57:09when I was asked by him to write a letter saying that I knew him
- 57:15to be a nice guy, I just felt like I should do it.
- 57:19But I get it, it could look like I'm not standing with the victims.
- 57:23I don't know what to do. I'm just one guy. I'm just
- 57:27trying to do them. I'm confused, you know, just say something like
- 57:30that. Yeah, I would even keep it like fairly simple, like this
- 57:35is a horrible situation. There's no good sides to this. I'm very saddened
- 57:39by everything that's happened. It came to light that myself and my wife wrote
- 57:45a letter of support for our lifelong or whatever long friend, Danny, and
- 57:51I understand why people would find that upsetting. I understand why the victims and
- 57:54the victims family even find that upsetting. Sadly, I don't know what to
- 57:59do he was my very good friend, and that's what we did. End
- 58:02of Sorry, So let's listen to their to their apology. It's only a
- 58:06minute long. Yeah, we are aware of the pain that has been caused
- 58:10by the character letters that we wrote on behalf of Danny Master's We support victims.
- 58:16We have done as historically through our work and will continue to do so
- 58:21in the future. Again, the delivery is so so scripted and poorly delivered,
- 58:28you know, totally. Now, I will say the first sentence is
- 58:30fine, Like you know, they're like, all right, we are aware
- 58:31that there's been pain. Okay. But I if I were there, I'd
- 58:37be like, don't just say you're aware? Yeah, sure, Like say
- 58:42you understand why people are upset, you understand why it would look bad,
- 58:46and like you're saying the delivery is like we are aware. And then and
- 58:51then the second statement is the defensiveness is the defensiveness? Okay. A couple
- 58:57of months ago, Danny's family reached out to us and they asked us to
- 59:00write character letters to represent the person that we knew for twenty five years,
- 59:06so that the judge could take that into full consideration relative to the sentencing.
- 59:10The letters were not written to question the legitimacy of the judicial system or the
- 59:15validity of the jury's ruling. They were intended. So yeah, not a
- 59:21bad thing to say, But most people have already xed out of this thing,
- 59:25you know what I mean. You got to get him in the beginning.
- 59:28That's what I would have said to them. You got to lead with
- 59:31we totally understand why people are angry at us. Yeah, that's the case.
- 59:37I acknowledge what's happening. I acknowledge that it would be incredibly hurtful,
- 59:42that the whole thing is horrible. Yeah, and then kind of the statement
- 59:45he just made is kind of all you needed, which is we were asked
- 59:47to write for our friend for twenty five years, and that's what we did.
- 59:51Well. I feel like more given today's context, because people would say,
- 59:55how could you possibly consider him to be even a friend? You're not
- 1:00:00going to be able to I don't think you're going to be able to talk
- 1:00:04your way out of that way. You know, you're probably right, and
- 1:00:07experts that I've heard PR experts basically say that, like you want to say
- 1:00:12as little as possible. I could never do that if I had to do
- 1:00:15one of these videos it would be five hours long because I would just say,
- 1:00:22you know, well, I guess I kind of did something like this.
- 1:00:23Like during the Johnny Depp ever Herd trial, I did have not an
- 1:00:29apology episode, but I read people's emails, and although most were positive or
- 1:00:34neutral, there were a couple that were hurt and angry at me, and
- 1:00:37I did respond to those. But I responded from the heart. And I
- 1:00:44believe that if I tell people, and this doesn't always work in real life,
- 1:00:49but I think it works more often than an alternative to this, that
- 1:00:53if I just walk people through my heart and my thinking process, I think
- 1:01:00it gives people a better chance to at least understand where I'm coming from,
- 1:01:05you know, because you know, like the when I was role playing their
- 1:01:07apology, I'm I think it'd be important to communicate just how confusing it would
- 1:01:15be. You know that Ashton and Mila didn't wake up and go ha ha,
- 1:01:19we're going to ignore victims and we're going to write a letter like it
- 1:01:22was done with a lot of consternation and difficulty and confusion and pain and care
- 1:01:30for the victims, you know, like like the three upgrades so far from
- 1:01:34what we listen the three upgrades that I think would have sufficed for me anyways.
- 1:01:37Were Number one, like you said, in terms of delivery, show
- 1:01:40a little more like warmth. I guess yeah. Number Two in humanness,
- 1:01:45right number two? Uh no, no defensiveness, like don't don't. We
- 1:01:51don't need to know your acumen with you know, victims, because it's irrelevant.
- 1:01:54Number Three, we also don't need to know the things you weren't trying
- 1:02:01to do. That's okay. There's a long list of things you weren't trying
- 1:02:05to do, and I don't. I don't. It was because she started
- 1:02:07saying we weren't trying to subvert the justice system. We weren't. I'm like,
- 1:02:10I don't. That's okay. I think what we needed was basically the
- 1:02:15statement of acknowledgment, like you said, like, I can totally understand how
- 1:02:20this has hurt people. Number Two, the thing that you did, which
- 1:02:22was we were asked blah blah blah, friend twenty five years and we did
- 1:02:27that, and it's a very hard thing to do. I can understand why
- 1:02:30people may not understand it. But put yourself in our and then like,
- 1:02:34I understand you want to go on. In my case, i'd be like
- 1:02:37that that's it, that's the message, and then people will still hate.
- 1:02:39But at least you can't say that like, well, they were being defensive
- 1:02:44or they didn't care or whatever for the judge three and not to undermine the
- 1:02:51testimony of the victims or redhoumicize them in any way. But see again of
- 1:02:58the jury's ruling, they were intended for the judgery and not to undermine the
- 1:03:04testimony of the victims or rehoumicize them in any way. We would never want
- 1:03:07to do that. Yeah, but see that. That's the kind of stuff
- 1:03:09that I find unhelpful, which is, you know, if I break your
- 1:03:14guitar, Like right now, I'm like spam, okay, spam, yes,
- 1:03:17spam like Batman style spam, and You're like, barrel, what the
- 1:03:22hell? Like, there's a lot of bad things I've done today. I've
- 1:03:25killed nine or night and nine people. I broke your guitar, and I
- 1:03:29start thinking that far and I start saying, look, I am sorry,
- 1:03:31listen. I wasn't trying to make a political statement here. I wasn't trying
- 1:03:36to like get charge in your wall. I wasn't trying to accidentally also break
- 1:03:39your stuff. Yeah, why are you saying all this. Just apologize,
- 1:03:45Just apologize. Yeah, we're sorry if that has taken place. Our heart
- 1:03:52goes out to every single person who's ever been a victim of sexual assault sexual
- 1:03:58abuse over I think what they might have been told or maybe they decided,
- 1:04:03was like, don't edit it, don't produce it. The more candid the
- 1:04:06better. And there's an angle there, I guess, But look, it
- 1:04:12sucks. Like the whole thing has to be mindful of the message and the
- 1:04:16and the style, because that is what they're trying to do. They're trying
- 1:04:20to do damage control. Like they're not doing this. This doesn't actually help
- 1:04:25the victims in any significant way. It's damage control. So if you're trying
- 1:04:29to do damage control, this comes off as cold and unfeeling to a lot
- 1:04:32of people. So yeah, yeah, And by the way, I feel
- 1:04:38terrible for that whole situation as well, because like, as far as I
- 1:04:44know anyways, like the two of them didn't really have anything to do with
- 1:04:46the actual horrible acts that their ex friended or a friend whatever. I understand
- 1:04:53they got caught up in this, and I understand why they would. I
- 1:04:56would write a letter for in many cases, for a friend I don't know
- 1:05:00no, if I would have in this, I don't know. You know,
- 1:05:01it's hard to know. Yeah, that is a good question, but
- 1:05:04we've never been in there. There's still a hard situation, right, Yeah,
- 1:05:08Like now, the writer of the question for us about the drunk driving,
- 1:05:14there is a categorical difference in my mind, which is that as irresponsible
- 1:05:17and horrible and life altering as that is, and as much as people absolutely
- 1:05:21need to pay the price, I still think there's a difference between that and
- 1:05:25knowingly raping people. Right, Like you say, well, but they knowingly
- 1:05:30drove drunk. Yeah, absolutely, that's why they need to pay the price.
- 1:05:33But if we're like, there are categories to crimes, and if I
- 1:05:36were categorizing, I think, like, yes, and that is manslaughter.
- 1:05:42And in my mind I realize, no one has to adhere to my rules.
- 1:05:45But in my mind, when you actually explicitly go and rape multiple people,
- 1:05:51you are transgressing even more knowingly or whatever. So if I were having
- 1:05:57to write a letter, I would sooner write the letter in support of a
- 1:06:01friend who who killed someone out of a drunk driving accident, then for a
- 1:06:09friend who raped to women. Again horrible, and I would never hope to
- 1:06:15be in this situation. But I'm just thinking through, like, well,
- 1:06:17kind of I guess, well, I guess it kind of depends on the
- 1:06:19circumstance, right, Because if the friend of a friend was a typical person
- 1:06:26who drinks occasionally and doesn't usually drink drive drunk or never drives drunk, and
- 1:06:33something happened and it was a freaking right, you're right, context that's critical.
- 1:06:38If the friend of a friend had been driving drunk or doing this and
- 1:06:42they've had yeah, totally. Now that's a great point. The context is
- 1:06:45everything because again, in the case with the person that raped to women,
- 1:06:49what if I don't actually believe that ever happened. I think they're they're wrong
- 1:06:54to be incarcerated. I could be right or wrong, but if that's how
- 1:06:57I feel, then yeah, I probably will the letter. So context is
- 1:07:00everything in either case. These are horrible situations to come up. Yeah,
- 1:07:08but so I do feel bad. I feel bad that their apology video was
- 1:07:12poorly done and wasn't well received. I feel bad they had to make an
- 1:07:15apology video. But yeah, So my question, how do you come to
- 1:07:18terms with someone you Karen love doing a horrible thing? Is it okay to
- 1:07:23reach out to the woman who drove drunk and remain a friend with her.
- 1:07:28What can I tell my friend to help her? Well? The problem here
- 1:07:33is that people on the If everyone was left to their own devices, you
- 1:07:39know, if your friend was able to just act from her heart and her
- 1:07:45own mind and maybe from people you know closely around her, then in all
- 1:07:50likelihood things would progress normally. Normally there would be difficulties, but it probably
- 1:07:57would work itself out. The problem is we live in a society today,
- 1:08:00and maybe we always did I don't know where there's such a black and white
- 1:08:06way of looking at things where you could be literally fired from your job because
- 1:08:14you, you know, continue to have somewhat of a relationship with someone who
- 1:08:18drove drunk and killed someone, or you could be canceled from your friend group,
- 1:08:24or you could be I don't know, cyber bullied online, you know,
- 1:08:29by a whole mob of people, And so it complicates things, and
- 1:08:33that way of thinking has kind of gotten under our skin and made it so
- 1:08:38that I think a lot of our morals or judgment considers the mob online to
- 1:08:45be valid, to the point where the mob is now in our head,
- 1:08:49where we end up pre canceling ourselves in a way like it's a very nuanced
- 1:08:55situation. You have a friend, you know, a clo like just put
- 1:09:00you burtow. You drive drunk one night and you haven't driven drunk, or
- 1:09:06you don't drink much anymore. But I used to drive drunk and I could
- 1:09:11have easily have killed someone. Yeah, but my point is this, you
- 1:09:13haven't done that in a long, many many years. So the point is
- 1:09:17is that just that context, and you have a freak thing, maybe someone
- 1:09:24in your life, dot in your maybe one of your parents dies or something.
- 1:09:28You have a really bad night and you make a bad judgment call,
- 1:09:31you get in a driving accident, and you kill a nineteen year old.
- 1:09:36I would have very complicated fucking feelings about that. But I guarantee you I
- 1:09:43would not divorce you as a friend because you're my friend, and I would
- 1:09:49be devastated. It would alter my view of you, It would affect my
- 1:09:57relationship with you for a great deal of time. But I wouldn't just go
- 1:10:00like, well, he's dead to me, And if anyone asked me,
- 1:10:03I will say he is a drunken criminal, psychopathic, narcissistic. I mean,
- 1:10:10that's what the Internet wants me to do. To you, right,
- 1:10:14and and again there is this categoricical difference, like, what if in this
- 1:10:17scenario everything in same up to the point you said it. But the thing
- 1:10:21I do is I still get drunk, but I don't drive and kill someone.
- 1:10:25I go downtown and I knife murder someone. A Were you drunk in
- 1:10:30this scenario? Sure, and same thing, some terrible thing happened. I
- 1:10:34got drunk, but I didn't drive drunk and killed someone, presumably on accident.
- 1:10:40I went downtown Seattle and I murder someone with a knife. Well,
- 1:10:43knowing what I know about you, I would strongly suspect that alcohol was the
- 1:10:48main factor in you committing that murder. So you have to take away the
- 1:10:51alcohol. Yeah, I guess. I mean, I get what you're trying
- 1:10:55to I'm just trying to say that between that and even in what you're bringing
- 1:10:59up. But well, okay, let's go on that. Let's say that
- 1:11:00I conclude that you were drunk, but not you know, to get in
- 1:11:04a drunk driving accident, you don't have to be that drunk. So let's
- 1:11:08say, oh, that's the thing. I So maybe you're just mildly drunk
- 1:11:12and you go downtown and you knife someone you come what then, Well,
- 1:11:15I guess it would depend on what you said about it and what I was
- 1:11:18convinced about. If you were just like, well, he looked at me
- 1:11:21funny, then then maybe I would divorce. That would have to change your
- 1:11:26perspective of who you thought I was totally, and that that's the point,
- 1:11:30Like, is there ever a world, a universe in which you would imagine
- 1:11:32Barrow would have done that? Right? Like? Yeah, So therefore,
- 1:11:35as if you said something like I don't know what happened to me, you
- 1:11:41know something that was you know you as my friend. I am friend of
- 1:11:45yours and friend and your and I considered you to be your friend. And
- 1:11:49I guess I never really thought about this, but it's based on an assumption
- 1:11:53of my evaluation of your overall character, Like you wouldn't have ever been puzzled
- 1:11:58by how the Bardo you knew. Let's let's rewind the clock fifteen years.
- 1:12:01Let's say I go, I go get very drunk downtown and I there was
- 1:12:06no uber back then, so I stupidly get in my car and drive.
- 1:12:10I'm not that drunk, but I'm drunk. I would definitely fail to test
- 1:12:14driving. I look away for a second and boom, I hit someone and
- 1:12:17they're old or whatever, they die. I don't think you would be like,
- 1:12:21that's not the Umbaro I knew. Like, No, the Umberto I
- 1:12:24knew did used to drink downtown and sometimes looks stupidly drive like a lot of
- 1:12:29fucking people. And this is horrible and tragic. And I don't know if
- 1:12:32I can talk to him right now, but it's certainly not going to be
- 1:12:34like, but that's not the Umbardo I knew. Whereas I go downtown,
- 1:12:38I murder someone that knife. That's like, Okay, I don't know what
- 1:12:41you never I've been living in the well and we don't have to go very
- 1:12:45far to actually identify some things that you actually did that aren't as bad as
- 1:12:50that, but were bad that I had to struggle with you. Would you
- 1:12:57know, we talked about this in the last episode, or one of the
- 1:13:00last episodes, where years ago you would act out your sexual abuse trauma with
- 1:13:06women and it wasn't severe, you know, it was it was mild,
- 1:13:14but noticeable and and very concerning to me. And I had complicated feelings about
- 1:13:21that. And I suppose because that was sort of in the beginning of our
- 1:13:28relationship there probably was a bit of a question mark about who you were and
- 1:13:33thus my loyalty to you in those in those instances, but I did see
- 1:13:39the way you reacted afterwards. You would feel a lot of remorse. You
- 1:13:44would come clean immediately, You would go to the person and apologize meaningfully,
- 1:13:50without any excuses. You would tell people close to you in your life and
- 1:13:56your family, people that you didn't have to tell you just be like,
- 1:14:00by the way, I gotta confess this happen, you know, and I
- 1:14:03didn't erase it, but it did show an overall and I guess what it
- 1:14:09is is. It's like one who do I want to be close to me?
- 1:14:15Do I want someone that is a wild card, meaning that they might
- 1:14:19knife someone randomly and not feel bad about it the next day. Or do
- 1:14:24I want someone that has occasional bad actions coming from trauma but ultimately cares and
- 1:14:32apologizes. Well, it's like with the drunk Like if we stick with the
- 1:14:36driving thing, imagine my friends are saying, hey, don't do that,
- 1:14:41like here, I'll drive it whatever, and I keep being like ask for
- 1:14:45you, like who cares? And I just keep doing it. Then I
- 1:14:46might even get like a couple of DUI's maybe I've even been in jail,
- 1:14:50and I'm still like that, fuck this, I don't care. And then
- 1:14:54I kill someone. That's a lot harder to come back from, you know,
- 1:14:58like because that's that's that's a pattern, that's a thing. Now again,
- 1:15:01everything's horrible, Like anyone dying is like beyond horrible. So so in
- 1:15:06this scenario, there's just no like happy story hiding. But I don't even
- 1:15:11you know, even in that scenario that you said, where you have repeatedly
- 1:15:15rejected bids to cut back or not drive drunk, you're still not pulling a
- 1:15:19trigger. You're taking a risk. Obviously, people should not be driving drunk.
- 1:15:24It is considered immoral for a reason in our society because because it is.
- 1:15:28But we all have to understand that there's nuance, you know, and
- 1:15:31there's a lot of things that are happening in someone's heart. And like with
- 1:15:35you, Berto, if you had done that, if you had rejected attempts
- 1:15:40to stop drunk driving, you're like, screw it, I don't care,
- 1:15:43and then you get behind the wheel and you kill someone. I still don't
- 1:15:45know if I would just completely write you off. And it's and it's that's
- 1:15:49the complexity is you don't know how you would react when someone you love does
- 1:15:53something horrible. Yeah, and I wouldn't. I would not be happy about
- 1:15:57it. And I would probably like target you with a bunch of micromanaging if
- 1:16:01you will, and monitoring, and might even say, look, dude,
- 1:16:04if you even if you even come closer to doing this again, we're done
- 1:16:08because I cannot stand by someone that continues to make those choices. But our
- 1:16:13friendship is so big and significant and meaningful and important to me that you know,
- 1:16:17given your character, if you did that, I wouldn't just throw it
- 1:16:20away. And again it's the difference between Again, I'm just I don't know
- 1:16:25why I'm such a horrible person today. But tomorrow you read in the paper
- 1:16:29that they arrested a person here in the Greater Seattle area. They found one
- 1:16:33hundred bodies in his fridge. Turns out I was a serial killer this whole
- 1:16:38time. Yeah. I mean, when something like that is a realization,
- 1:16:41then you really realize. Oh okay, okay, actually I never I mean,
- 1:16:45it will devastate that, it will devastate you for the rest of your
- 1:16:47life. But I wouldn't break up. I break up with you because I'd
- 1:16:51feel like, why didn't you include with you and the slaughter just so yeah,
- 1:16:57yeah in the example, yeah, well one that would completely alter everything
- 1:17:01you ever thought you and make me wonder like was I trying to kill you?
- 1:17:08Like could I have trusted anything? It doesn't it doesn't make sense.
- 1:17:11So the problem with that is essentially that we are not capable. We're not
- 1:17:15equipped with hard and fast rules for how to deal with these things, because
- 1:17:19guess what, these extreme examples, there are human beings that I've had to
- 1:17:24deal with those kinds of examples Jeffrey Dahmer's parents or whoever's parents, right,
- 1:17:28like literally deal with like that is my son, my daughter, my whatever,
- 1:17:32And it turns out that they've done some of the most incomprehensible things possible.
- 1:17:38And by the way, this is why we have a legal justice system
- 1:17:41that doesn't incorporate family member's opinions in criminal hearings. You know, they'll hear
- 1:17:47it and consider it. But I'm pretty sure the try or of fact listens
- 1:17:51to the victims much more than family members that are standing by the perpetrator.
- 1:17:56But what I'll say to the writer of the question is that, of course
- 1:18:00it's natural to have conflicting feelings for everyone involved in this, and it would
- 1:18:05be pot like it would be you'd be a psychopath. Possible, Yeah,
- 1:18:10you'd be a psychopath if you just wrote her off right, like there's something
- 1:18:13wrong with you like that, You're just like, oh, fuck her,
- 1:18:16my best friend killed someone. Yeah you know se La v. Yeah.
- 1:18:23Well again it depends on the context, right yea. But even yeah,
- 1:18:28even then, like you just can't micromanage people's emotions to that the fucking Internet
- 1:18:33wants to. And I think that's the problem is that if you, anonymous
- 1:18:39patron, if you and particularly your friend were to do anything other than completely
- 1:18:45reject publicly, you know, because silence is violence, Burdo that if her
- 1:18:49friend doesn't on a daily basis, uh, you know, pronounce her rejection
- 1:18:57and her hatred for her friend that got in the drunk driving accident unfortunately killed
- 1:19:01someone, then it would I would not be surprised if if the Internet and
- 1:19:06her close circle were to completely bully and reject and cancel her. Yeah.
- 1:19:15I don't know if that would happen in every context, but I would not
- 1:19:17be surprised. And you know, like with Ashton Kutcher and Mila kunis you
- 1:19:21know, well, let me ask you, Bertrow, Given the little that
- 1:19:25we know, was it wrong for them to write the letter to the judge?
- 1:19:30Wrong and morally wrong, morally wrong? Not from what I know?
- 1:19:34Yeah, not from what I know. I mean because in the end,
- 1:19:39I'm not their relationship. I'm not them, I'm not even Danny. I
- 1:19:42wasn't in the room any like, who am I to say any of this
- 1:19:44stuff? The law took care of the things right or wrong, and they
- 1:19:48had a friendship and they made a decision personally. Yeah, And do we
- 1:19:53believe that Ashton and Miela, both of them, they don't care about victims
- 1:19:59of rape? Do we think that they're just like no, yeah, whatever,
- 1:20:02No, we do not believe that. Yeah, I mean, I
- 1:20:04guess, I guess. Like again, you could set up these extreme cases,
- 1:20:09like the parent of the serial killer writes such a good letter that the
- 1:20:14serial killer is somehow released or relief for I just good behavior, which would
- 1:20:18ever happened. But and then they go and kill more people. So then
- 1:20:23can you hold the parents? No, you can't. You get it's the
- 1:20:26system's fault, yea for being so stupid. Yeah, So if we don't
- 1:20:29believe that writing the letter was wrong. Then the only thing we can really
- 1:20:33point to is just their ill conceived apology video, Yeah, which came across
- 1:20:40as being insufficient, stilted, and defensive. But then we got to point
- 1:20:45our fingers to ourselves and be like, and I know I'm the first guilty
- 1:20:49party, Like, why do we have to be such critics of everything?
- 1:20:55Yeah? Why are we the ratitudey character? We like the least? Now
- 1:21:00have you said all that? I know that there's another angle to the story
- 1:21:03that with Ashton Kutcher and other people on that seventies show and other men in
- 1:21:09Hollywood have been routinely harassing women in Hollywood and beyond. You know, there's
- 1:21:16a lot of stories of this sort of thing happening, particularly among younger men
- 1:21:23when they hang out in Hollywood, that kind of thing, and really in
- 1:21:26any subculture yeah a Wall Street, the tech industry, whatever, Yeah,
- 1:21:31even underage girls. There's this one clip that I saw of Ashton Kutcher and
- 1:21:36someone else talking about one of their co stars I think, who had maybe
- 1:21:41just turn eighteen, and Ashton Kutcher was laughing and it's like, oh,
- 1:21:45yeah, we used to talk about you. We'd be like, oh,
- 1:21:46wait till she's eighteen, which you know, was something that people said back
- 1:21:51then that was completely acceptable, which is why Asten Kutcher wasn't canceled back then.
- 1:21:57But we now understand that there's rape culture, misogyny, sexism, sexualizing
- 1:22:04of miners, sexualizing minors, excusing, well, boys will be boys or
- 1:22:10rapists or she must have wanted it. You know, there's a whole system
- 1:22:14that props up perpetrators and denies victims. And that's a context that is definitely
- 1:22:21at play here. But we can't blame Ashton Emila for that, you know,
- 1:22:28like they're like retroactively right, yeah, right, it's that. That's
- 1:22:32the other thing that drives me nuts, like that, Right, the last
- 1:22:35couple of days, they were pulling out tweets from Taylor Swift's current boyfriend or
- 1:22:41something from who knows how long ago, Travis kelcey, yeah, some football
- 1:22:45player, yes, or soccer I don't know, football, And then there
- 1:22:49was some tweets that were like somewhat offensive, you know, oh really,
- 1:22:56yeah, I don't know, And it's like, yeah, I guarantee you
- 1:23:00everyone would be canceled if we look at everyone's what everyone said even a decade
- 1:23:06ago. Let alone fifteen twenty years ago. Like you know, everyone is
- 1:23:11canceled permanently if you rewind the clock a certain amount of time. Like I
- 1:23:15don't know a single person in my life that didn't say things that were horrible.
- 1:23:21Yeah back then. Yeah, it's putting myself obviously. Yeah, let's
- 1:23:27see what see what? What was it? Just gave a squirrel a piece
- 1:23:32of bread. No, those are the cute ones. There's one that came
- 1:23:35out like what was? One was like something about women. So watching a
- 1:23:44fat person fall is hilarious because they like roll or something like there's something about
- 1:23:48fat people stuff like that, which again, yeah, like don't say that,
- 1:23:54but like this is fifteen years ago whatever, I don't know how long
- 1:23:58ago it is. Yeah, No, can we say something about those old
- 1:24:00tweets? Sure, we could say, hey, that's dickish, Travis,
- 1:24:06what do you have to say and he'd probably say, yeah, that's why
- 1:24:10they're not up because I was an idiot, young idiot, and I embarrassed
- 1:24:14of that, right, and maybe even more detail of like, well,
- 1:24:17I was a part of our culture that would shame that, and I have
- 1:24:23some inner shame about that kind of thing, And sometimes that would play itself
- 1:24:27out and the stuff that I would joke about. I mean, I said
- 1:24:30worse things than that tweet, honestly when I think about it. And I
- 1:24:32could show you movies from five years after that tweet that were still making fun
- 1:24:36of. Well, I could show you movies five years that's defensive. But
- 1:24:41that's defensive. No, I know, but I'm saying no, I'm not
- 1:24:43saying that's what he should say. Yeah, but I'm just saying I'm jumping
- 1:24:45out to the defense of everyone what everyone said. Well fifteen years ago,
- 1:24:50Yeah, I think that it's a conversation, not a cancelation. Yeah,
- 1:24:57but that on a T shirt. I love that. Yeah. And now
- 1:25:00I'm exaggerating slightly because if fifteen years ago the thing you said was, you
- 1:25:05know, we must exterminate blah people, then I don't care how much you've
- 1:25:10grown since then, like you know, obviously, But well again it would
- 1:25:14depend like how old was where were they coming from? Like for example,
- 1:25:19point is that it depends. Like for example, in graduate school, I'm
- 1:25:24twenty four getting my masters, and I'm in a class and we're supposed to
- 1:25:28be writing about race in America, and I don't remember what I was writing,
- 1:25:32particularly but I mentioned something about Ferikhon and I most of what I knew
- 1:25:41about Ferikhn came from one of my friends who knew a lot about politics and
- 1:25:45stuff. And I had in this paper been apparently passable to this teacher and
- 1:25:54had said things that were on the up and up. But this bit about
- 1:25:58Ferikhn was off the mark. And this is almost thirty years ago, and
- 1:26:00I remember this mark and it wasn't even like you failed. It was just
- 1:26:04like this little note that said, handwritten in the margin in red pencil of
- 1:26:10like something like I don't think this is true or something. It was his
- 1:26:15pre internet, So I'm just spouting stuff about Farakhn. That was And I
- 1:26:19thought about it. I was just like, where did I get that?
- 1:26:21I got that from one friend, a source that I trust. But he's
- 1:26:26just a guy my age. What the fuck does he know about anyway?
- 1:26:29But that's the way a lot of us are. We hear something from a
- 1:26:32credible source, we don't hear any opposition to it, and we just go,
- 1:26:35okay, that goes into my brain. And that's the thing. Now,
- 1:26:39Well, when it comes to culture and oppression and ideas about who it's
- 1:26:45okay to dehumanize. We have incorporated thousands of statements from thousands of people in
- 1:26:50movies, and for a young person to tweet things along those lines is expected.
- 1:26:58It'd be weird if they didn't. It's not okay, I think,
- 1:27:01but it's a conversation, not a cancel. I think. There's some things
- 1:27:05that have no shouldn't have a statute of limitations. Other things should. For
- 1:27:10example, let's say Hitler had had found the Fountain of Youth and he was
- 1:27:15still around, and he'd actually totally reformed his way of thinking. He was
- 1:27:19giving money to charity. I don't care. Sorry you lost that battle.
- 1:27:24Yeah. Well a better example, which because it's more tame, is if
- 1:27:30you can believe that, is Harvey Weinstein, because he was a known philanthropist
- 1:27:35who fought a lot of good fights. But he's never recounted. Sorry,
- 1:27:40he's never recanted. He's never changed, he's never changed. He hasn't like
- 1:27:45he hasn't come twenty years later and be like I realized I was a monster.
- 1:27:49I'm so sorry, I'm actually trying to make amends and things like that.
- 1:27:53Yeah. The scenario I was trying to give was imagine a historical person.
- 1:27:57Yeah, but if Harry Weinst did apologize and say I'm so sorry for
- 1:28:04raping all those people. Is that what you're saying? Yeah, Like,
- 1:28:06what's the there's there's there's no there's no amount of goodwill regardless of how awesome
- 1:28:14Harvey Weinstein was outside of the raping, that would make him uncancellable in my
- 1:28:19mind is actually you can't free him at this point. That's why I was
- 1:28:23saying, Harvey Weinstein, yeah, yeah. And similarly with Hitler, it'd
- 1:28:26be like, you know, we're still executing you. I'm sorry, like
- 1:28:29sorry to the world the great that you found that you were wrong. But
- 1:28:32even that way of thinking, you know, if we're drawing a line of
- 1:28:36conviction or something like with this anonymous patron, the friend the close friend to
- 1:28:43the drunk driver who knows what her position is, but it's possible that she's
- 1:28:47like my friend should do the time. At the same time, I love
- 1:28:55my friend and care about her and know that she's genuinely a good person,
- 1:29:00and I want to be there to support her. I'm not going to write
- 1:29:01a letter asking that the sentence be reduced necessarily, but I will accept collect
- 1:29:09calls while she's in prison, and I will talk to her, and I
- 1:29:11will support her, and I if things go normally, I'll be a friend
- 1:29:15when she's released. Anyway, now, can the friend say? You know
- 1:29:20what? I just don't know if I can stand by a friend who did
- 1:29:25who made a choice like that, even if it was just once she knew
- 1:29:29that she was intoxicated, she got in that car and she took that risk.
- 1:29:31It wasn't you know. It's not a huge percentage chance of killing,
- 1:29:35but there's a chance. And even though I've never lost anyone in my life
- 1:29:40like that, I know of others who have and I just can't stand by
- 1:29:45you. I'm really sorry about that, but our friendship is over. Could
- 1:29:48you say that? What do you say? Did? They'd be totally within
- 1:29:51their rights. I think if if I were the other person, the person
- 1:29:57that was in jail now or whatever, I would feel so bad and buy
- 1:30:00that. But I mean, it's totally within the rights. Yeah, and
- 1:30:04you could do it for way less than that. Like imagine that someone.
- 1:30:09Did you just spit on the bike? Yeah, a little bit. Sorry,
- 1:30:12that was because you were wiping the microphone. That's that's mainly your well,
- 1:30:16I guess Bob and Rebecca used that mic so imagine that someone actually again
- 1:30:21me, I'm just gonna be the bad guy. I I break I'm not
- 1:30:27drunk, I'm sober. Uh. I break in and I steal stuff,
- 1:30:31Like I break into a place and I steal stuff and I go to jail
- 1:30:34for that. I could see someone writing me off like that's horrible, like
- 1:30:44whatever me, even though it's less not I didn't kill anyone, not one
- 1:30:46of your close friends though well, I mean again, I would be devastated
- 1:30:50if I was written off. Although it's kind of a weird scenario because like,
- 1:30:54why was I stealing some But whatever, But I just look at it
- 1:30:58from the outside looking in. I think people are within their rights to say,
- 1:31:01hey, look totally. If you're going to be that way, then
- 1:31:04I guess we're not going to be friends. Yeah, I think beyond a
- 1:31:06certain threshold, I guess, including burglarizing places because it's so premeditated, I
- 1:31:15think the perpetrator doesn't have any moral high ground to say, how dare you
- 1:31:21reject me for such a small reason? You know what I mean? Because
- 1:31:25by taking those actions as a perpetrator, you should know it's not hard to
- 1:31:30imagine that you're putting everyone around you in a very difficult spot because of what
- 1:31:39you're doing, you know. And the thing with the drunk driving is I
- 1:31:42guess I'm starting to think, well, part of it is the culture doesn't
- 1:31:45help, because it's a culture of drinking. Right now, I think there's
- 1:31:49been so much messaging now and so many and so many options with uber and
- 1:31:55that it is getting harder and harder to say, well, they were drunk.
- 1:32:00Thirty forty years ago, it was totally the norm. It was understood
- 1:32:06you're not supposed to do that, but it was rampant. I remember my
- 1:32:11dad driving us home completely drunk one time in Bogota, and it was so
- 1:32:16scary. I was scared for my life because he was swerving all over the
- 1:32:21place and I was like and it was like two am in the morning,
- 1:32:25and I'm like, now, luckily it was back then and not. But
- 1:32:30anyways, that wasn't seen as like a monstrous thing, even though it is
- 1:32:36a monstrous thing. But back then, it's like that happened all the time,
- 1:32:39right, Yeah, sucks. Yeah, people would even joke about it.
- 1:32:44One for the road, Yeah that ksa. Yeah, yeah, pretty
- 1:32:47pretty awful. I just think that we have this black and white thinking when
- 1:32:53it comes to quote unquote criminals, that the criminals are over there and they
- 1:32:58go in prison and they're bad people, and then there's all of us,
- 1:33:00yes, instead of recognizing the real story because you don't hear the stories because
- 1:33:05no one's posting about it on Facebook, that a lot of people You and
- 1:33:12I and everyone we know, everyone they know. If we all really knew
- 1:33:17what everyone was doing, there are a lot of things that would be considered
- 1:33:20cancelable or something not to say, that's okay, but and we should definitely
- 1:33:27try to stop it. I'm not saying it's we should just be complacent like
- 1:33:30it's normal. But my point is is that this notion, this dichotomy,
- 1:33:33or this black and white between the criminal and the good people. When someone
- 1:33:39does something that crosses the line in the criminality and in moral behavior like driving
- 1:33:44drunk, then as a black and white society, we're just like, well,
- 1:33:47then they're dead to it. That's over. And if you don't consider
- 1:33:50that person dead to you, then you're on the other side of the line,
- 1:33:54and you haven't even considered where the line is. Let's say there was
- 1:33:57no alcohol involved, the person is driving trying to get something out of their
- 1:34:00glove compartment. They're not even looking at their phone. They're like, oh,
- 1:34:03maybe they might even have a bloody nose. Trying to get something out
- 1:34:05of them is bothering them, and they run. They kill someone? Yeah?
- 1:34:12Is that where the line is? Hopefully not? But they did kill
- 1:34:15someone. Should you have been not paying attention to the road? No,
- 1:34:18you should have been. But like, so, what I'm saying is life
- 1:34:24is not it's anything but black white, right they So in this case,
- 1:34:30the ambivalent features feelings are the feature. Yeah. And also when you talk
- 1:34:36to a lot of family members of victims, you know, surviving family members,
- 1:34:42they often will talk about forgiveness and goodwill to the perpetrators. So the
- 1:34:48people that have the most moral high ground to make a judgment about these things
- 1:34:55are often some of the most forgiving people, right that they're just like,
- 1:34:59you know, there's a long time I was very angry at that person,
- 1:35:01and I have dealt with it, and now I have a perspective that you
- 1:35:08know, sort of like with you and your sexual abuse perpetrator, the girl
- 1:35:12who raped you when you were a kid, you have a very similar I
- 1:35:15mean, you could be angry and yet you have a sympathetic position about her,
- 1:35:20just like you're like, I'm pretty sure she must have been abused herself.
- 1:35:25You know, she's twelve, that's not very old. What she did
- 1:35:28was horrible and damaged me and it wasn't good, and I just feel sorry
- 1:35:33for her. Actually, I feel like there was something wrong with her.
- 1:35:36I mean, unless she was like a complete psychopath, but you know,
- 1:35:40I don't think she was. And whatever. Yeah, and so that's a
- 1:35:44similar kind of situation where you are allowed to do that, society will let
- 1:35:48you do that. But imagine if her friend were to have a sympathetic view
- 1:35:57of that twel year you know, wherever that twelve year old, right that
- 1:36:00twelve you know, wherever that forty three year old is right now, and
- 1:36:04our fifty three whoever that fifty three year old person is right now, and
- 1:36:09her friend knows about what she did to you, and that friend of the
- 1:36:15girl who raped you was you know, had a complicated feeling. It was
- 1:36:19like, you did that when you're a kid, and you know your perpetrator
- 1:36:24is just like, yeah, I did. I was pretty screwed up back
- 1:36:27then. It's really horrible. Do we cancel the friend of your perpetrator?
- 1:36:30Cancel everyone? You know what I mean, that's essential. I mean,
- 1:36:33and that's in my book. I think we should cancel anyone that they ever
- 1:36:39talked to, whether they knew what happened or not, because they should have
- 1:36:42known. Silence not knowing is worse. Silence is violence, Bruno, Ignorance
- 1:36:48is aggression. Let's take a break. What do you say? Let's do
- 1:36:53it? Middle tier patron Joscelyn G. Good old Joscelyn G. She says,
- 1:37:02if a time machine brought the Beatles to the present day and you had
- 1:37:06to choose a contemporary artist or group for them to perform with, which would
- 1:37:11you choose? And why? Oh? Yes, absolutely, one hundred percent
- 1:37:15Blur Because not only are the Blur Damon alb and all those guys, they're
- 1:37:20huge, huge beetles. So those don't know the lead singer of Blur is
- 1:37:25the lead singer of the Gorillas. Oh yes, the Gorillas. Not only
- 1:37:28are they huge Beatles fans, I also love their music, So that alone,
- 1:37:32like I just want to give them that present, but it would also
- 1:37:35drive a steak into oasis, Yeah they would. Can you imagine how upset
- 1:37:42oasis would be? Yeah? For those who don't know because you're too young,
- 1:37:45there was either an actual rivalry or a fake rivalry between Blur and Oasis.
- 1:37:53Oasis was a much more popular band, but Blur was an actual music
- 1:38:01well, Blir was a better band. I you know, I thought Oasis
- 1:38:06is some good songs, and songs were fine. They were perfectly passable for
- 1:38:13top forty at least two, if not three things. One. I think
- 1:38:16it's a great matchup. Actually, they'll do great music together. And both
- 1:38:20bands were compared to the Beatles all the time, all the time. Yeah,
- 1:38:24yeah, and you know, to be fair, there were a couple
- 1:38:27of very beatlely Oasis songs, but I just want you know, and I
- 1:38:30do love those songs, but I think that it would be great to see
- 1:38:32the chagrin. Yeah, those Oasis songs that are beatlely have melodies that are
- 1:38:40reminiscent of the six Sies and perhaps the Beatles kind of. But the instrumentation
- 1:38:45is so boring and bland. I mean that the guitars are just playing chords.
- 1:38:50John and George and Paul never did that. They never just like chord
- 1:38:56chord, chord, chord chord, you know what I mean. For me,
- 1:38:59that's a good Blur, But I would go with Doctor Dog. Do
- 1:39:01you know the band Doctor Dog. I think Paul has told me about Doctor
- 1:39:05Dog. I love Doctor Dog. Listen to them now. They are very
- 1:39:11much like the Beatles. I don't know if they are fans of the Beatles,
- 1:39:15but they seem like they are. And I've seen them live and they
- 1:39:17have multiple And when I say Paul, I don't mean Paul McCart. Paul
- 1:39:21are extra, my extra. Jocelynre G has another question. Can you explain
- 1:39:28what attachment the Jedi deny? Does attachment theory apply to the Jedi? So
- 1:39:34in Star Wars Star Wars burto what do they mean by denying attachments? Okay?
- 1:39:41So or what are the rules for Jedis regarding marrying and attachments? Right?
- 1:39:45Well, okay, but are you going by episode one or three garbage?
- 1:39:50I mean, because I think you got enough in fourth through six.
- 1:39:54But fine, I think that the general idea very monkish in this way,
- 1:39:58you know, like Tibetan monk kind of said, situation. Uh. The
- 1:40:00whole goal of the Jedi is that, you know, getting in tune with
- 1:40:03the force is not trivial. Yes, the force is all around us,
- 1:40:06but you really got to work at it. Clearly, you gotta go to
- 1:40:10Daegoba and run through the swamps with Yoda on your back. You gotta really
- 1:40:13work hard, and part of it is you gotta let go of all material
- 1:40:17things. You gotta really like just feel the force. So if you're like,
- 1:40:21oh wait, I can't practice today, I gotta get back to my
- 1:40:25family. My kid is sick, my wife needs something, my uncle is
- 1:40:29blah, my boss is blah blah. All that stuff is going to distract
- 1:40:32you, antiqu you away from the connection to the force. Yeah. That's
- 1:40:36the same thing with money and power and fame and all those things. Yeah
- 1:40:41right, I think that for obviously it was what George Lyricus was gearing it
- 1:40:46towards was Buddhist monks, or at least what he thought to be Bootisable or
- 1:40:50a random samurai with no attachments. Yeah, but even samurai had allegiances in
- 1:40:58this sort of thing. And for or the Jedi, at least, the
- 1:41:01way Yoda was describing it was that don't go to the Cloud City to save
- 1:41:05your friends, because that's an attachment and that will create risk because Vader could
- 1:41:13kill you, and you're our only hope. They're serving this bigger cause,
- 1:41:16which is to bring balance to the force. So anything that gets in the
- 1:41:19way of that is bad, right, and you have to even get rid
- 1:41:24of desire. You have to be free of emotion. You have to be
- 1:41:29you know, mindful and aware and above it all sort of a thing.
- 1:41:32And in one through three in the movies they say more specifically, you can't
- 1:41:38have romantic relationships. So it's hard to say. And you know, I'm
- 1:41:42sure if you get into the weeds, there's a lot of lore regarding exactly
- 1:41:46how this is adjudicated. Because it seemed frowned upon that Anakin was with Padme,
- 1:41:55right, they had to keep it secret, but what do you have
- 1:41:57been kicked out? I think that was in Pantli right, that he would
- 1:42:00be kicked out of the Jedi Order if it was known that he was married.
- 1:42:04Here's the thing that is so inconsistent is that apparently the Jedi powers are
- 1:42:10something that you can pass along genetically, and well, you don't even get
- 1:42:14me started, and you can't do that if you can't have a relationship.
- 1:42:17The fact that you can pass them along, it's just so dumb because of
- 1:42:21the Palpatine bullshit, and it just well, but even I mean to be
- 1:42:26fair, even in episodes four or five, like, why is Luke so
- 1:42:29powerful with the Force because his father was Darth Vader was Anakin. Well,
- 1:42:32is that what they were saying, because you're you're like, you're so much
- 1:42:36like your father the Forces. I don't know. I mean, I think
- 1:42:39there's an implication. Yeah, there's definitely an implication. I did get that
- 1:42:43when I was watching it as a kid. I got the implication that if
- 1:42:47you if anyone wanted to, but very few people did because of you know,
- 1:42:53you could make an argument that if anyone wants to become enlightened, for
- 1:42:57example, in the Buddhist way, anyone can avail themselves of that. But
- 1:43:00it's a pain in the ass because you have Actually no I will agree with
- 1:43:03you that. When I was a kid, I thought of it more like
- 1:43:06the Karate Kid, more like these kind of movies. You're right, It
- 1:43:10was basically like I just have to work hard enough. In fact, that
- 1:43:14is so true, because, as we've discussed before, the Force to us
- 1:43:16as children seem like an attainable, real thing. Yeah, so I agree
- 1:43:20with you. It is a retcon that basically it's like this genetic gift.
- 1:43:26Well one through three, it doesn't even suggest it's a genetic gift. It
- 1:43:30just says Midi Chlorians because his mom the Immaculate conception. Mom didn't have or
- 1:43:38they didn't ask. She didn't, she wasn't for sensitive. But by the
- 1:43:41time we get to episode nine, apparently it just runs in families and I
- 1:43:46have to say, like, ah so, but no, no, episode
- 1:43:48one through three, I think it's pretty clear that, like it's I think
- 1:43:54it's pretty clear that that Midi Chlorians are genetically transferred. I don't think so.
- 1:43:59I could be wrong either way. By the time we get to episode
- 1:44:04nine, and by the way, I am wrong, maybe I'm not remembering
- 1:44:08it. I'm gonna I made a note to myself to take down our episodes
- 1:44:13about Star Wars because I can't stand by what I had. Like, we
- 1:44:17probably made an episode about episode eight. Yeah, yeah, and I probably
- 1:44:21was talking very positively about it, and certainly episode eight I did like at
- 1:44:26a time, But after episode nine, when I look back at episode eight,
- 1:44:30I don't like episode eight anymore. Well, that's probably true. I
- 1:44:33do remember railing against the whole casino section of Oh totally me too, but
- 1:44:39I remember thinking overall it was okay. Yeah, I remember thinking there were
- 1:44:43some problems like the chasing. We have to retractively disavow that. But I
- 1:44:47remember walking out saying, well, it wasn't as good as episode seven,
- 1:44:50but you know, it's good. But I still like episode seven. I
- 1:44:53still I don't even like Episode seven very much anymore because the where it's headed.
- 1:44:59No, I still like the Matrix, and the Matrix is fine.
- 1:45:02But the Matrix, the first Matrix movie self contained. It's so self contained.
- 1:45:06Yeah, you don't need to care and need the other ones. That's
- 1:45:10whereas in episode seven when you see Ray on the screen and Finn and you're
- 1:45:16just thinking, well, who cares about Finn? Finn doesn't do shit moving
- 1:45:20forward? Yeah, but I still could see myself enjoying the first five seasons
- 1:45:26of Game of Thrones, like rewatching them, you know what I mean.
- 1:45:29So I watch a lot of analyzes of Game of Thrones, which of course
- 1:45:33inevitably lead to the hated seasons. And I will reiterate something I said at
- 1:45:40the time when people were very upset about those latter seasons, that if you
- 1:45:45read the books, you understand the problem. Because but I didn't read the
- 1:45:48books, I know, but when you read the books, there are there's
- 1:45:54so much that they the TV show left out of the later books, even
- 1:45:59in the good seasons, because George Martin the way that he writes, he
- 1:46:04he keeps expanding on characters. In the fifth book, he's adding new characters.
- 1:46:11I get it, man, And and as I'm reading the books,
- 1:46:15I'm like, Okay, if this is going to be a seven book thing,
- 1:46:18I do not see how it's possible to wrap this up. And what's
- 1:46:21happening to George Martin right now is as he's he can, he's writing the
- 1:46:27sixth book. It's not even the seventh book. He's writing the sixth book.
- 1:46:30It's apparently one of the biggest novels ever written in terms of pages.
- 1:46:34And he's so frustrated with it because there are so many things to keep track
- 1:46:39of and so many things to to accomplish that he is telling the press now
- 1:46:45that he doesn't know if he'll ever finish even the sixth book. So when
- 1:46:50when they started quickly wrapping shit up in the latter season of the Game of
- 1:46:56Thrones, yeah, I was like, wow, that was quick. But
- 1:47:00in my head I'm like, well, but what else are they supposed to
- 1:47:02do? But there's levels they could have made it and George Bartney who said
- 1:47:08this, it's like, instead of making it eight episodes in the final season,
- 1:47:13they should have made it sixteen episodes, and they could have done that
- 1:47:15and it would have been better. But even certain episodes like you didn't have
- 1:47:20to have the Big Winter's Coming threat, scariest thing of all time for this
- 1:47:26world basically show up and wrap up in one episode getting stabbed by a girl
- 1:47:30in one scene. Totally. But as I'm watching the TV show prior to
- 1:47:36that season anyway, I knew that there were all sorts of nuances that were
- 1:47:42left out of the TV show. There's so many details that are There's whole
- 1:47:45characters that are not even focused on, like there's a there's another egg on
- 1:47:51Thrones aside, though, my point was simply that I am I am.
- 1:47:57I think I'm okay with certain maybe not lost, but with certain shows or
- 1:48:02movies where I can still enjoy a part of it. As an example,
- 1:48:06I still enjoy episodes four, five, and six, Yeah, right,
- 1:48:12absolutely, even though I know what all the surrounding Mailstrom is. But to
- 1:48:16me, I think what I'm you're saying that those are well encapsulated and their
- 1:48:20self suspisis well not only that, but yeah, because of all the other
- 1:48:24bad TV shows like Ahsoka was pretty bad in my I know, some people
- 1:48:29like it. I me and my wife tried to watch it and literally fell
- 1:48:33asleep both times, and we watched the first few episodes, fell asleep at
- 1:48:40some point, and then a couple days later we're like, Okay, I
- 1:48:43guess we got to start over. So we started over the whole thing and
- 1:48:46then fell asleep again, and then like a week later, we're like,
- 1:48:49I think we should watch the show, and we both looked at each other
- 1:48:54like it just felt like homework, you know. I got to it eventually
- 1:49:00and just found the writing. I mean, the acting is great, yeah,
- 1:49:03the everything else is fine, but the writing, it was like,
- 1:49:09in my head, I'm like, there's so many other things that could have
- 1:49:11done with a TV show about Ahsoka other than what they did. It was
- 1:49:15just so blah so to me, you know, other than and Or and
- 1:49:19Rogue one. I'm saying, in order for me to enjoy Star Wars,
- 1:49:24I have to kind of erase, just erase everything. And honestly, episodes
- 1:49:29one through three are looking pretty fucking, pretty fucking good these days, and
- 1:49:34more and more hardcore Star Wars fans are starting to say that I will say
- 1:49:39this. I will agree because at least they make sense and there's a through
- 1:49:43line three movies. I will agree with you that there was nothing in episodes
- 1:49:49one through three as bad as episode nine. Yeah, and you haven't even
- 1:49:55seen Obi Wan yet. I haven't. No, I mean that TV show
- 1:49:59is. And the other thing about episodes one through three is like, literally,
- 1:50:04the things you could do to fix them is actually a lot simpler than
- 1:50:08what you could do to fix episode nine. Episode nine you basically cannot fix.
- 1:50:13But episodes one through three, like you know, extract jar jar or
- 1:50:15make him more more like, you know, toned down from the start,
- 1:50:18right Number one, number two basically make Anakin less annoying in all three movies,
- 1:50:26but certainly the first two, number three tone it down a little bit
- 1:50:30with the the overly dramatic scenes, even just those three things would make people
- 1:50:35like cringe less. And then, like you said, the story's still there.
- 1:50:39Is it the greatest story of all time? No? Is it the
- 1:50:41greatest dialog? No? But it's not like something you necessarily need to burn
- 1:50:44with fire. Yeah, So I'm actually unbelievably going to agree, And I
- 1:50:49hate to say this, but like when I see Star Wars stuff, Like
- 1:50:54ten years ago, when I saw Star Wars stuff, if I had if
- 1:50:58I saw someone wearing a Star Wars tea shirt, or I was in a
- 1:51:00store or something, I got excited. Now I actually have a negative and
- 1:51:06a negative reaction to Star Wars. That sucks, but that happened to me
- 1:51:10with the episode. I mean, I still have the bad taste in my
- 1:51:15mouth. I don't know. I gotta be careful with what I say about
- 1:51:17episodes one or three because there are little kids wearing pilot blast shield helmets practicing
- 1:51:27with live light sabers. I mean that's so bad. Well, and then
- 1:51:32Darth Vader and Yoda Muppet show jumping around. I mean, come on now,
- 1:51:41yeah, there's some oh wait, but least the story made sense.
- 1:51:45But just to come back to what I was saying, I think what it
- 1:51:48is for me is that I can still enjoy episode seven. If, like
- 1:51:53you were saying, if I erase if, I'm like, it's just a
- 1:51:56one shot. It's too bad they never made any more movies. Absolutely,
- 1:52:00And then that's how we were at the time when you and I walked out
- 1:52:01of that movie. Yeah, we were like we were ecstatic, but but
- 1:52:05we thought it was going to go in this great direction. I did,
- 1:52:09but I also didn't really care at the time because I figured it wouldn't be
- 1:52:14horrible. And I also was so happy to see a proper directed and cinematic
- 1:52:21experience after one through three, because you know, the one thing you can
- 1:52:25say about episodes one through three is none of them are cinematic experiences. And
- 1:52:30I'm getting chills thinking of her finding Luke at the end of episode seven and
- 1:52:34the sadness of how they ended up playing that. I know, so along
- 1:52:39those lines. You know, when I first saw episode eight and there were
- 1:52:42people criticizing all that, I was like, well, I don't know,
- 1:52:45like the writer, Ryan john decided to go a different way. But after
- 1:52:49seeing episode because I saw I watched a whole you know, I've watched a
- 1:52:55lot of videos of people breaking down what happened, you know, what went
- 1:52:58wrong and behind the scene kind of stuff. And this one guy was saying
- 1:53:01that Ryan Johnson's movie. Episode eight wasn't as bad as some of the people
- 1:53:08were saying, but it did paint the next writer into a corner because of
- 1:53:14certain plot plot points that were hard to continue the story because because Snoke is
- 1:53:21dead, so you have I guess as the only two bad guys. You
- 1:53:29have Kylo Rinn, but you also have Hucks, who is who now is
- 1:53:32like what in cells would call a beta, right, He's just this joke
- 1:53:36of a character that's been thrown around by So really you just have Kylo and
- 1:53:42that's not epic, right, You need something that's epic for it. Could
- 1:53:46have for sure, but you could see how some writers would be like,
- 1:53:50what do we do here? You know? Now, could you have done
- 1:53:54something to provide some epicness without going like ten thousand times overboard that the way
- 1:54:01that jj Abrams did. I mean, you know, not only is you
- 1:54:08know, Palpatine back, but he also has like a bunch of Snokes in
- 1:54:12a jar, and he's got thousands upon thousands of Star Destroyers that are under
- 1:54:17the earth, and for some reason, out of the blue, every starship
- 1:54:23comes to their aid against a bunch of start Destroyers. One of my favorite
- 1:54:27YouTube creators this galp Jenny. She makes all these really funny videos kind of
- 1:54:33reviewing books and media, and a lot of it is Star Wars and she
- 1:54:36also worked at Disneyland, so she's reviewed Star wars Land and all these but
- 1:54:42in her review of episode nine, she has this thing about like, and
- 1:54:46you know, it's unbelievable that the Emperor can lift with his forest powers a
- 1:54:53massive fleet of star destroyers out of the ground. I mean, imagine how
- 1:54:57powerful that is. But if you like pick them up, he's like,
- 1:55:00oh no, put me down, put me down, and then you can
- 1:55:03just throw them down. Is that that popular YouTuber Jenny so So. Yeah.
- 1:55:09I literally just watched that video for like the fourth time. Oh my
- 1:55:14god. It's the title is something like, oh no, episode nine is
- 1:55:17so bad? Oh no, yeah, something like yeah, I guess I
- 1:55:20didn't like episode nine. I think that's what that. There's actually an oh
- 1:55:25no in there, like yeah, because because because she was like and she's
- 1:55:28wearing, she's wearing. She's always wearing like gear and stuff. I love
- 1:55:31her. Yeah, yeah, I didn't know she worked at disney but yeah
- 1:55:34she has not now she she had worked at Disneyland. Yeah, but she
- 1:55:38has a great delivery. Oh yeah, she's really funny. I've seen her
- 1:55:41do so many different things. She's got this thing where she was analyzing there
- 1:55:45is this church, uh movement where they put on all these elaborate musicals with
- 1:55:53uh characters. I watched that whole video. Yeah, she she she,
- 1:55:58she did her homework and she analysis this church remaking movies and she watched all
- 1:56:05the YouTube videos and analyzed everything. Anyway, anyways, but so I've gotten
- 1:56:13into this problem recently where I have these conversation end or interactions where someone,
- 1:56:17you know, we're talking about whatever, and then someone's like, oh,
- 1:56:20like, oh, have you watched Obi Wan. I'm like, oh,
- 1:56:23no, not yet, and they'll be like, oh, it's great,
- 1:56:26and I I mean, you know, people can like what they like and
- 1:56:29I haven't seen it. But at the same time, I've heard from people
- 1:56:30I trust, so I don't want to go anywhere with it. I'm like
- 1:56:33or even unrelated to Star Wars, like so many things with Elon Musk.
- 1:56:40Like I'll be talking the other day, I was at a at a a
- 1:56:44friend's house playing games, and this older couple was there and randomly we're talking
- 1:56:48about things, and the husband used to work at NASA, and then the
- 1:56:53conversation I was like, oh man, everything that Elon Musk is doing is
- 1:56:57just so amazing. And I was like, oh yeah, I mean,
- 1:57:01you know, he is a really savvy investor in early companies. He is
- 1:57:08really good at making a lot of money from that. Well yeah, but
- 1:57:11I mean, like think about all the inventions he's made, and like he
- 1:57:15made the Tesla cars and he said, well he he invested early in that
- 1:57:18company. And then and and I was trying to be social and nice,
- 1:57:25but I'm like, oh my god, no, you're so far down the
- 1:57:29wrong rabbit. Well here, if he you know, this guy that this
- 1:57:33party just wasn't up to date on the news, that's one thing, and
- 1:57:38that's fine. But if he is actually aware of the news and still saying
- 1:57:43no, it's because like the common perception is that it's turned for sure,
- 1:57:46But the common perception is that he is a genius inventor. But you can't.
- 1:57:50That's different to me than have you seen Obi Wan, Because that's just
- 1:57:56someone that isn't just up to date. Because that was the name, there's
- 1:58:00an opinion that well, yeah, it was the narrative like a few years
- 1:58:03ago. In fact, I listened to a podcast or I guess what I
- 1:58:09mean is I cannot. I don't have the heart to sit there and start
- 1:58:13spewing out facts that will change their mind about Elon musk No similarly, who
- 1:58:17I wouldn't want to or have the heart to sit there and try to tear
- 1:58:20down something that someone just said is amazing that I think is probably not going
- 1:58:24to be good. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Now, for those who
- 1:58:29liked obi Wan, it's great that you liked it. It did have its
- 1:58:31moments, and I was actually completely on board until about halfway through, even
- 1:58:35with some of the major changes they were making to the narrative, you know,
- 1:58:42because this is a prequel to episode four and they're doing things that I'm
- 1:58:46like, well, that doesn't make sense given what we know about episode four.
- 1:58:51I mean, it's not completely impossible, but problems, And yet I
- 1:58:58was still fine with it. But then so you don't you haven't. Just
- 1:59:01I'll just give you one detail that in both obi Wan and in Ahsoka,
- 1:59:08there are multiple people, multiple people who get stabbed through the chest with a
- 1:59:15lightsaber and live. What yes, what? That doesn't make any sense a
- 1:59:25canon wise, we have seen that that is never a survivable thing. Number
- 1:59:29one. Number two. Oh actually though, through the chest, because I
- 1:59:32was pretty pissed to find out that somehow Darth Maul survived. That's pretty weird.
- 1:59:38But anyways, my point is that. Yeah, that's weird. Yeah,
- 1:59:42but at least with Darth Maul, he was cut you know through the
- 1:59:45bottom, which people survive those kinds of war wounds. Was fine, and
- 1:59:50yeah, but a lightsaber would instantly incinerate all the primary organs and they don't
- 1:59:57do anything to justify the fact that these people come back. And you can
- 2:00:00just see the writing right, Yeah, they're like, oh, wouldn't it
- 2:00:03be epic if Darth Vader just like runs her through? Yeah, that'll be
- 2:00:08epic. But wait, we don't want to kill her. We need to
- 2:00:11keep her around because this is because, you know, because Kathleen Kennedy is
- 2:00:15telling us we have to do something with this character. So all right,
- 2:00:18she's well, she's instead of rewriting that scene, instead of Darth Vader runs
- 2:00:23her through, maybe he does something else to her or you know, but
- 2:00:28they cuts off a hand, you know. I mean, like the point
- 2:00:30is an empire if Darth had stabbed Luke through the heart with the lightsaber.
- 2:00:34Yeah, and then the next scene he's like being healed up by that.
- 2:00:36It's like, come on now, but not even healed up. They they
- 2:00:41they just the character just walks out and it's like, yeah, the doctor
- 2:00:44fixed me up, so that there are at least three nothing. There's at
- 2:00:49least there's at least three moments burn. There could be more. And just
- 2:00:54those two TV shows, Those two TV shows, I think have a total
- 2:00:57of sixteen episodes. In sixteen episodes, you have at least three people run
- 2:01:01through the heart with a lightsaber and in the very next there's not a long
- 2:01:06Imagine if in and or the TV show someone got injured, there would be
- 2:01:12a long series of episodes where they recover. You know, there'd be stakes.
- 2:01:16But it's and that's just one aspect to the writing of the Seriously,
- 2:01:23in my mind, becoming a writing in Hollywood seems like an insurmountable hill to
- 2:01:29climb, right, How are these people getting these jobs without the obvious basic
- 2:01:32knowledge of like, if you lower the stakes, no one cares. It's
- 2:01:35the same in the Marvel universe. You have the money people influencing the script
- 2:01:42writing. You give someone the ability to write a movie like the First Iron
- 2:01:46Man, for example, or Infinity War. I'm guessing because if the current
- 2:01:53MCU were to write Infinity War, none of them would have died. Iron
- 2:01:58Man would definitely not die because he is your bread and butter. But they
- 2:02:02back then had writers that wanted to write a good story, so they were
- 2:02:06given that freedom once the billions of dollars and Disney got involved. Now you
- 2:02:14have a boardroom of idiots that are just like, okay, well you have
- 2:02:18to do this with the script you have, and then as a writer you
- 2:02:21probably throw your hands up and be like, I can't do this. And
- 2:02:25then they get some hack that is a yes man to the boardroom and they'll
- 2:02:30do whatever you want. And those writers apparently are terrible or they're made to
- 2:02:34be terrible by the pressures that they're under. You know. So along those
- 2:02:40lines, Burdow, I didn't tell you this. I think I was telling
- 2:02:42someone else's that I am so upset with the way Obi Wan the TV show
- 2:02:47was written that I asked chat gbt to write a better script. And I
- 2:02:51know this is controversial because the big strike was about using AI to write scripts.
- 2:02:58But chat GBT it took a couple iterations. I had to be like,
- 2:03:02well, don't do that with the story, because that doesn't make sense.
- 2:03:05Like after five or six prompts, it wrote a better outline for a
- 2:03:10script that was way better. But you know why, because it pulls from
- 2:03:15from actualoid stuff. Well, it also pulls from canon because it's I'd never
- 2:03:20thought about this, but you know, the language models are not predicting what
- 2:03:25would come next from what it knows so far. Right, from what it
- 2:03:29knows so far, it's like, well, what's the most likely thing or
- 2:03:32word to happen next? That it also in the AI and all of its
- 2:03:35neuronal connections are the pulling from data regarding how to write a story. Right,
- 2:03:41you have to have an arc, because the chat GBT clearly had that
- 2:03:45arc of like the Hero's journey. And that's my point is that like it
- 2:03:48it is formulaically, but the thing is like formulas are great when used properly.
- 2:03:55Yes, there's a reason music. It's true and right in anything here
- 2:04:00journey, you know, just watch Joseph Campbell talk about it. This goes
- 2:04:03back centuries, uh millennia that the importance of the hero's journey to us as
- 2:04:11humans as a narrative structure is clear, going back to the ancient Greeks,
- 2:04:16ancient Chinese. And and there's there's a meta sense in which the like the
- 2:04:24even just observing nature, you can't help but think that the more interesting thing
- 2:04:29is a hero's journey because when you're if you're watching a river flow, right,
- 2:04:34like a simple thing like a river flow. What's interesting about the river
- 2:04:39flowing is that there's all this kind of chaos that adds like this interesting variety.
- 2:04:45But it's got a beginning, middle end, right like it's got a
- 2:04:47little storyline. And that's just watching a river flow. Everything in nature,
- 2:04:51the more interesting things that you watch in nature, and that's not even a
- 2:04:55human telling a story, so it's not random. I think what you're right
- 2:04:59about is that there are all those pressures for like, well, hey,
- 2:05:02we got to get this out by such and such date. B we got
- 2:05:05toy tie ins, movie tiants. No no, no, no, dude,
- 2:05:10like you were saying, you got to keep that one alive. I
- 2:05:11don't care what you do. I mean I do care, so but bring
- 2:05:15it back like and we have to set up the next sequel. And dear
- 2:05:18listener, if you're still listening, god bless you, because this is just
- 2:05:23two old men, shakefisted nerd shit. So I think what I'm saying that
- 2:05:29I was thinking to myself halfway last week is that I don't know if I'm
- 2:05:33a Star Wars fan anymore, huh, Because when I look at Star Wars
- 2:05:40things, it brings me down. I will watch and or season two and
- 2:05:44I will love it. But we're talking about a very narrow band of material
- 2:05:50of the overall cannon Star Wars universe that I enjoy these days. Yeah,
- 2:05:56I guess, I don't know. I see your point. But I can
- 2:06:00still be a fan of the Ogs, you know, and be like,
- 2:06:02yeah, if I uh but Palpa team comes back, I don't care.
- 2:06:08I don't the entire care. It meets you, but I can't help at
- 2:06:14this point in my life. I can't help but to think. As I'm
- 2:06:17watching episode six and Luke prevails, I'm like, that's just less. It's
- 2:06:23pointless. It's pointless matter he just he he comes back. It doesn't what
- 2:06:29you just did, Luke. I Darth Vader died. That sucks or is
- 2:06:33that good? I don't know, But now you know how I felt for
- 2:06:35all those years when I would pretend episodes one through three just didn't even exist.
- 2:06:42And who cares about the Second Death Star because in fourteen years they build
- 2:06:47the Desk Star. That's the size of it's literally a planet that can kill
- 2:06:51other planets in other solar systems. It can shoot a multiple you know,
- 2:06:58in episode seven, this planet sized death star shoots a number of other planets
- 2:07:03at the same time. So the thing you saved the world from it was
- 2:07:09it was bad enough that episode six again had a death star, but you
- 2:07:13still haven't saved the plan In fact, that it's only gonna get worse.
- 2:07:15You haven't saved the universe. It's gonna get way worse than this. Yeah
- 2:07:18yeah, in fact, well worse, and nothing changes. The team's still
- 2:07:23around. The First Order is basically the Empire. A metaphor for the problem
- 2:07:29here is. I saw this Reddit thread where someone was asking or quorra maybe
- 2:07:32it was. Someone was like, why does obi Wan not remember owning droids?
- 2:07:39You know? Yeah? And someone you know tries to make it all
- 2:07:43make sense, like, well, no, technically obi Wan says, I
- 2:07:47don't remember owning a droid, and technically he never owned the droid, I
- 2:07:54think, And then someone else is like, uh no, the real reason
- 2:07:59is that when that movie was made, no one had thought through any of
- 2:08:01this other bullshit, right, and it's all red con Yeah yeah, I
- 2:08:07mean those kinds of issues are kind of insignificant compared to the Palpatine coming back.
- 2:08:11But it did. But it did, Yes, you're right, but
- 2:08:13it did bother me. I mean, there was no care to that.
- 2:08:16Having C three po and R two in episode one through three owned by Anakin
- 2:08:24is one of the d I mean, I mean Lucas did it as well,
- 2:08:28but the other writers do it a thousand times built yeah, built three,
- 2:08:37Come on. That was clearly a random protocol droid that got caught.
- 2:08:41In fact, that's what's adorable about it is that he got caught in a
- 2:08:43random crossfire with the only droid that actually mattered, which was R two D
- 2:08:48two. Yeah. Yeah. Because people, I don't know a certain section
- 2:08:54of people that I am not in, they want everything to be connected.
- 2:08:58Yeah, they want everything to have a through line. So R two can't
- 2:09:03just be a random droid. He has to have come from somewhere and he's
- 2:09:07going somewhere, and you know, like and Ray can't just be a random
- 2:09:11person. She has to be connected somehow. I mean, if like they
- 2:09:16wanted to throw imagine how cooy would have been an episode two or maybe three
- 2:09:20that as they're doing what the good script would have done, somewhere you see
- 2:09:26in the distance as a knees strike a little assembly line and they're putting together
- 2:09:30our two units and one of them or not. But but listen to me.
- 2:09:35If you did that, I'm okay with it. Yeah, you know,
- 2:09:37but you know what I mean not okay with is an episode one R
- 2:09:41two is fully there and they go like, oh, we shall remember this
- 2:09:46droid. What's this droid's name? Oh let me see, Oh it's R
- 2:09:48two D two. Yeah, I mean episode four. It starts off with
- 2:09:54two random droids. You see other droids by the way, and the camera
- 2:09:58focuses on these two random droids we are supposed to believe, and it works
- 2:10:01much better as a story if these are just two random droids who probably haven't
- 2:10:07even seen a lot of war up until this point. They're just kind of
- 2:10:11like randomly there the sense I got that comes across this R two unit,
- 2:10:16just a random R two unit, and the story begins. Yeah, because
- 2:10:20it's the it's the hero's journey of little R two, right, Like he's
- 2:10:24I mean, I got the sense, maybe not as a kid, but
- 2:10:28in rewatching, I was like, obviously you wouldn't have how do you say
- 2:10:33this? You didn't have twenty R two units running around so this was the
- 2:10:35designated R two unit for that ship. Great. So Princess Leiah is like,
- 2:10:39oh, where's the R two I need to Great? And of course
- 2:10:41she doesn't go to the C three PO unit because that's not what a C
- 2:10:43three PO unit would be used for. R two is a highly specialized kind
- 2:10:48of little thing that can store information. Right, so that's what I'm going
- 2:10:52to go to. That's the end of it. See three PO barely knows
- 2:10:54Princess Leah. He knows that there's oh, the princess is here. That's
- 2:10:58it. Three PO a nobody, but he's a protocol, right, that's
- 2:11:03it, and it's beautiful and now and he you know, And apparently these
- 2:11:07two droids have a bit of a friendship and so C three PO. But
- 2:11:11even that, it's like they just happened to be assigned to the same ship.
- 2:11:15But there was an implication early as they are getting into the the escape
- 2:11:20pod, that's C three PO has that kind of relationship with Archio, just
- 2:11:26like, well, if you're going, then I'm going kind of a thing,
- 2:11:28right, Although I get the sense I still would see it as like
- 2:11:31they've just been assigned to the ship, so they've kind of gone to each
- 2:11:35other, sure, but they're not like old friends. Our two is able
- 2:11:37to move away from C three Po on Tatoyne when se Threepio doesn't want to
- 2:11:41go that way. Ye see Threepio is willing to abandon R two initially,
- 2:11:45Yeah, they become closer as time goes on. Instead, what we are
- 2:11:50now watching when we watch episode four is oh, it's Darth Vader's that's the
- 2:11:56robot he made. But don't worry. See three Po's memories get wiped.
- 2:12:00Not only is that the robot he made, but he because you know you
- 2:12:03haven't watched the cartoons. No, the amount of adventures that Obi Wan and
- 2:12:09and Anakin and R two and C three Po and Ahsoka, they're the five.
- 2:12:16Yeah, they are the five that travel across the galaxy for several years
- 2:12:22on hundreds of missions together. And then when a short I don't know eighteen
- 2:12:28years later, Obi Wan sees R two D two one of his dearest friends
- 2:12:35not centuries. No, Luke was born at the end of episode three,
- 2:12:41and I think he. I think he's similar right, something that Obi Wan
- 2:12:45bad he might be seventeen obi Wan comes over the hill. I mean the
- 2:12:48very least he would wonder, is that our two D two you know,
- 2:12:52because come on, you and I met, and he's certainly never indicated knowing
- 2:12:58C three at all. Yeah yeah, yeah, but again that pales in
- 2:13:05comparison to the bullshittery anyway, So, Burdo, we recorded all of this
- 2:13:13nonsense at the beginning of that so but I'm going to put it all at
- 2:13:15the end people can so that people can skip over, so that DEESI for
- 2:13:18that episode of Psychology and Style. Everyone out there, please take care of
- 2:13:22yourself because you deserve it.