Latest / MBA Training Marketing / Brand repositioning: what Man City Women kept and changed
Transcript
- 0:00Host: Welcome to the Leaders Insights Podcast. Today's episode, Man City, women's rebrand,
- 0:11Host: repositioning a sports brand without losing the fans who built it. Man City women just
- 0:15Host: rebranded and everyone's clapping. But rebrands usually mean someone screwed up the last one.
- 0:21Host: So which is it? Fixing a mess or fixing something that wasn't broken?
- 0:25Expert: Neither, and that's the interesting part. This is the rarer case, a brand that works
- 0:30Expert: today but won't fit the room they're walking into tomorrow. Women's football in England
- 0:35Expert: has gone from a curiosity to a proper commercial property in about five years. Attendances at
- 0:42Expert: the top tier have more than tripled since the 2019 season. If your identity was built
- 0:47Expert: for the small version of the sport, you'll be wearing a coat two sizes too small at
- 0:52Expert: exactly the moment you need to look the part.
- 0:54Host: Fine, but we're rebranding for the future is what every consultant says before they
- 0:59Host: set fire to a logo. What's the actual durable lesson here?
- 1:03Expert: Don't cut the rope behind you. The people who built your brand when nobody was watching
- 1:07Expert: are the ones who will defend it when everybody is. City kept the core visual language, the
- 1:13Expert: sky blue, the connection to the men's setup, the club heritage, and evolved the parts that
- 1:19Expert: signaled junior partner. That's the discipline. You reposition the meaning without torching
- 1:25Host: the memory. That sounds like a nice way of saying they were scared to actually change
- 1:30Expert: anything. No, there's a real difference between timid and surgical. Gap tried a genuine full
- 1:35Expert: rebrand in 2010. New logo dropped it in six days after the backlash. That wasn't
- 1:41Expert: bravery. That was not understanding what the logo carried. Compare that to when Burberry
- 1:46Expert: cleaned up its identity, but protected the check pattern people actually bought the brand
- 1:50Expert: for. The skill isn't in how much you change. It's incorrectly identifying the two or three
- 1:56Host: things you're not allowed to touch. So how does a marketing team know which threads
- 2:00Expert: are load bearing and which are just old? You listen to where the emotion sits, not
- 2:04Expert: where the money sits. Ask fans what they'd riot over. Usually it's colors, a crest,
- 2:10Expert: a chant, a founding story, cheap things to keep, the expensive looking stuff, the taglines
- 2:16Expert: and the campaign fonts. Nobody's emotionally attached to those. City clearly worked out
- 2:22Expert: that the sky blue and the club lineage were sacred and the rest was negotiable. Get
- 2:27Host: that map wrong and you delete the wrong thing. Let's talk numbers. How do you even measure
- 2:32Expert: whether a rebrand landed beyond the fans didn't revolt? Two horizons. Short term,
- 2:38Expert: you watch search behavior and sentiment. SEMrush data suggests branded search, people typing
- 2:44Expert: your actual name into Google rather than generic terms, tends to spike around a well-run relaunch.
- 2:50Expert: Though I'd flag they sell SEO analytics software. So treat their framing as directional and
- 2:55Expert: cross-check against your own traffic. Long term, the real metric is whether new
- 3:00Expert: fans arrive without the existing ones leaving. That's the whole game. Growth that costs
- 3:06Host: you your base isn't growth. It's a transplant. But isn't there a trap there? If you're
- 3:12Host: so obsessed with not upsetting current fans, you never build for the newcomers who aren't
- 3:16Expert: in the room yet. That's the exact tension and most brands
- 3:20Expert: get it backwards. They over-index on the loyalists and end up with an identity that
- 3:25Expert: feels like a members club, off-putting to anyone new. The move City is making is to
- 3:30Expert: signal ambition to people who've never watched a match, while keeping the handshake with
- 3:35Expert: people who watched when the stands were half empty. You're building a door, not a wall.
- 3:40Expert: The mistake is thinking you must choose one audience.
- 3:44Host: Give me the tell. How do I spot a rebrand that's about to fail?
- 3:48Expert: When the announcement talks entirely about the company and not the customer. We're bold,
- 3:53Expert: we're modern, we're reimagined. That's a brand talking to itself in a mirror. A good
- 3:58Expert: relaunch tells you what changes for you. The fan, the buyer. If the story is all adjectives
- 4:03Host: about them, they haven't done the work. One thing people can actually use this week?
- 4:07Expert: List the three elements of your brand your best customers would genuinely be angry to
- 4:12Expert: lose. Protect those with your life. Everything else is fair game and probably overdue for
- 4:18Host: a rethink. Sources for today's episode. Semrush vendor
- 4:22Host: SEO analytics tools marketing week digit day. That's a wrap. Fresh CMO briefings drop daily
- 4:29Host: at MBA-training.com.