Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Yoreh De'ah 271:1-3. Sefer Torah: Which Hides, Processed For the Sefer Torah, By a Jew, Lime, Gallnuts, Gvil vs. Klaf. By Rav Reuvain Mendlowitz

Transcript

Yoreh De'ah 271:1-3. Sefer Torah: Which Hides, Processed For the Sefer Torah, By a Jew, Lime, Gallnuts, Gvil vs. Klaf. By Rav Reuvain Mendlowitz · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

• 0:00
  Good morning. OK.
• 0:01
  We are in the middle of Hirsa Sikhatario facial analysis Dalit
• 0:05
  Kosov Mikzaso al Aqvil. If you have if you have, you
• 0:11
  have different if cloth in your veal, you want to make a safer
• 0:14
  Terra. So you want some of the some of
• 0:17
  the safer Terra on veal or Mikzasso.
• 0:20
  I'll have cloth paragon cloth puzzle.
• 0:24
  That would be puzzle because you need to have everything that
• 0:30
  it's it's key lira Parton ore important cloth.
• 0:34
  It's two different it's like 2. It's has two different Shamus
• 0:39
  eve also Hetzio Gveal Hetzio svarium.
• 0:42
  If he used Hetzio Gveal of a of a cow and Hetzio svarium, he
• 0:47
  used the hide of of SVI of a deer or whatever.
• 0:52
  Alphabisha Enochaya, Alphabisha Eno in a Mitsubinum of car
• 0:56
  kosher, even though it's it's it's kosher because they're both
• 1:01
  of the same shame of veal. They're not two different shame
• 1:05
  of even though they're from different animals, But that's
• 1:07
  not that's not going to be as big of a big of an issue.
• 1:10
  Hey, safer turrets are seer tooth and this is an important
• 1:15
  din in and it needs seer tooth. It needs to have inscribed lines
• 1:24
  at the top of each, you know, line of the safer terror that
• 1:27
  there there's a indented like groove, you know, whatever line
• 1:34
  and on the from there the the the safe and bright keep the top
• 1:39
  the top of the of the letters all on the all straight on the
• 1:43
  line. Now there's a mahikis about
• 1:45
  what's the point of Siri Tut? Is it it didn't needs to have
• 1:48
  Siri Tut or or is you know, or is the others say that no, the
• 1:53
  point it should just be written in a straight line, you know,
• 1:57
  for you know, So, for example, different, coolest, different
• 2:00
  things. If it's missing, you know, if
• 2:02
  someone wrote without, can you put Siri Tut And afterwards
• 2:05
  someone wrote things which are, you know, missed 2 letters and
• 2:08
  it's definitely straight then and then is that good enough?
• 2:13
  There's different there's different halach.
• 2:14
  I think the red bars is more of the opinion that that just so it
• 2:19
  should be straight. Others say no, it has to be
• 2:22
  actual proper seer tooth. Not saying everyone holding it
• 2:26
  to a seer tooth. The question is if he wrote it,
• 2:27
  but he evident, you know, didn't have it.
• 2:30
  It's it was missing, but it's seer tooth and he wrote it
• 2:32
  straight. What would be the dinner in that
• 2:34
  case? That's that's the Shiloh Al
• 2:36
  Capone in in Kosovo, but those seer tooth puzzles.
• 2:39
  But if he wrote, if you wrote, you know, without any C or two,
• 2:43
  that's puzzle. Although you started the O
• 2:46
  ferrisk you it's about should Sylveya and you're not allowed
• 2:49
  to write with any sort of like a pencil or anything like that,
• 2:52
  because that's Sylveya C or two needs to be scratched into the
• 2:56
  into the cloth. There's a discussion about when
• 3:01
  often sometimes if there's a mistake and they have to erase a
• 3:03
  letter sometimes or they have to scratch off the letter, they'll
• 3:07
  scratch, they'll they'll scratch off the erase the C or tooth as
• 3:10
  well. So the question is, and if you
• 3:12
  were sorry, you know, if you if do you need to do seer to it
• 3:16
  again? Do you need to like redo that
• 3:18
  little bit and then we and and then and and then write the
• 3:23
  write the ice. So there's Wiki Wenger here is
• 3:26
  marshmallow. I mean here it could be.
• 3:30
  And I didn't look up the Chuvas. It's nicer to it's nicer to say
• 3:34
  that that you need to have seer tooth either.
• 3:37
  You always need to have seer tooth before you write a letter
• 3:40
  and therefore and and and and and that's there for you should
• 3:44
  be you should be Mahmid on it. The the Piscachuva brings brings
• 3:52
  a sheet of the Aqua. I think Piscachuva brings a
• 3:55
  sheet to us. It's not a big deal.
• 3:57
  So it's a mochaigus. It's a mochaigus soccer.
• 3:58
  I never be Osha's. It's quoted as being saying it
• 4:01
  should be Mahmir like Rukhi veger.
• 4:05
  Again, it's a it is a mochaigus and here, especially in in in,
• 4:11
  you know, in here on the Daf Kwig is not like he says her as
• 4:15
  sub shop, but he's not it's not like a borrower.
• 4:18
  Kapoor Yoshua was it was Mahmir. Again, if you're looking for
• 4:21
  again, there's levels of Hiduri, levels of Hiduri and safer Tyra.
• 4:25
  And of course, you know, if he did it, did it without, I don't
• 4:30
  think anyone's going to pass all the safer Tyra.
• 4:33
  But again, the the person that Maggia someone's fixing it
• 4:37
  should try and and and try, you know, should should obviously
• 4:40
  try and do that. Yeah.
• 4:42
  The question is this is quite if you if you redo it sometimes it
• 4:45
  could tear the clock. OK, these are discussions.
• 4:48
  No, if you would do the suit to it again.
• 4:50
  No, no, no for you to though, no, some say, some say you have
• 4:57
  to add some, some say there's an issue that if you, if you the,
• 5:02
  the, the redo the CR2 that it might take because it's weak, it
• 5:05
  might tear through. So that's why there's a, you
• 5:07
  know, you have to do in a little bit more, but you have to patch
• 5:12
  it up. It depends on the whole.
• 5:14
  I don't get to that, you know, but Uncle Paneem, that's, you
• 5:18
  know, that's the issue over here.
• 5:20
  There's some sheet, there's a whole, some sheet of the CR2
• 5:23
  down the side, but that's whatever.
• 5:26
  That's just sheets of Alma, you know, obviously it's something
• 5:30
  hugging me or whatever. Hello Vav.
• 5:35
  I don't know doesn't need the Shima CO2 does not need the
• 5:37
  Shima. I don't know.
• 5:39
  It could be it could be done to be done by machine.
• 5:42
  Like for example, the Rabat says everything in the Rabat.
• 5:44
  If you folded it, can you if you just folded it is that he
• 5:47
  encourages that could be that's good enough based on helpless
• 5:50
  kids and and whatever Vav safer tire.
• 5:55
  It's actually the venue with DI. I see Vittora has to be written
• 5:58
  with Dio also in the ocean Hashmaneim, Charmaine fatsim,
• 6:03
  and this should be made from ash or you know, ash from you know,
• 6:10
  or from shmane doesn't create ash, but it creates, you know,
• 6:15
  smoke or whatever it is. It should be made from from
• 6:20
  burnt to shmaneim, which is so which is soaked to mea fatsimi
• 6:24
  fatsim call nuts Yeah, OK, fine walnuts Khila totally Zarisha
• 6:30
  Larsson so diary key means very her bohemian aids and the Khila
• 6:35
  based on the czar is she only use stuff which comes from comes
• 6:40
  from eights the in Kosova may EFTA the kantom kosher.
• 6:47
  If you use may EFTA or you use kantom, it's also black.
• 6:54
  It is kosher although the charminate Sivoni but not any
• 6:59
  other color. If you're going although in a
• 7:01
  yaroic red or green or yellow or blue is a discussion a bit.
• 7:07
  If it blue, it's blue at 1st and it turns black, turns very and
• 7:10
  turns black. It's it could be OK, but look
• 7:14
  here it's a Bahamian Kosova Phil OS akas with Charminin, Sivonium
• 7:18
  or Bazov puzzle. If you write any of the other
• 7:21
  OCS with any other colour or you or you or you do resolve it
• 7:26
  puzzles, the safer tire. The what they do nowadays is a
• 7:30
  discussion in the in the Ukrainian saying that the the
• 7:34
  Geo that they that the it's very black.
• 7:37
  The Geo that they use with if you use certain things, but it
• 7:42
  it never it but it but it, it, it wasn't such a strong Joe and
• 7:47
  therefore the letters cracked easy, easy and things and
• 7:50
  whatever. So they started using at some
• 7:52
  point they started using. That's why I mentioned the thing
• 7:55
  about like metal, like iron, water, things like that.
• 8:00
  I'm not sure exactly how they make it the recipe, but with
• 8:04
  some guma like with like with some rubber that different
• 8:07
  things in it, which yeah, OK, which which make it which make
• 8:15
  it a much stronger DO. The issue is, is that what the
• 8:19
  police can discuss is that over time it does it, it does turn
• 8:24
  reddish. Old Safritura, the old
• 8:28
  Safritura, the, the, the iron rods like the iron compound in
• 8:32
  it turn or can turn a bit reddish.
• 8:34
  And the question is, is that a lot of people can say, you know,
• 8:37
  that's that, that that is OK 'cause it was originally written
• 8:40
  black, you know, even though over time it has turned, it has
• 8:45
  turned reddish. You know, obviously it's better
• 8:48
  if you know, you know, if you know, if you can't and to, and
• 8:51
  to write straight over it to just color over.
• 8:54
  It is also an issue. You know, if you wanted to fix
• 8:58
  it, you have to like I say, a letter to red, you'd have to
• 9:00
  like scrape it off. But Akhopanyim OK, so OK, so
• 9:06
  that's we'll get to that in a second.
• 9:08
  So that I mean that's in the general that's in in in in the
• 9:11
  situator. Now, what about chemical based?
• 9:13
  Pasha says it's OK. Pasha says it's OK.
• 9:16
  There are I've since I've seen Magim heard of Magim who you
• 9:20
  know, they they haven't saved a term with a little crack in the
• 9:23
  leather that take a magic marker out and and color it a little
• 9:27
  bit. I've seen it or someone told me
• 9:29
  saw someone take out a Parker pen and just yeah, colour just
• 9:34
  the colour in that little spot. I've seen someone using I heard
• 9:40
  someone using a Parker pen. I've seen someone using any.
• 9:42
  Black ink discussion. So, yeah, so Lahore, if you went
• 9:45
  ahead and you took a magic marker and you wrote he's like a
• 9:48
  permanent marker and then you wrote a whole safe Vitara with a
• 9:51
  permanent marker, Lahore would be a kosher safe Vitara.
• 9:54
  I don't wouldn't be mohoder. But you know, Lahore, it would
• 9:58
  have Kadusha. It would have kadusha safe
• 10:00
  Vitara printing. You know, we'll get to a few
• 10:06
  minutes about, about, about, about, about printing at the.
• 10:10
  We got there in a few minutes. You have to say when you place
• 10:14
  it with Schmal when you're. Right.
• 10:15
  Yeah, we'll get to that. That's all.
• 10:17
  Everything's discussed. And if you're we get there,
• 10:22
  Haglavachen also lift the shame. Shame misafer S Viva arba swarm
• 10:28
  Sheila with Joe. Some say you have to write if
• 10:31
  you write a not naveen, you have to write it with any shame with
• 10:35
  Joe. Yeah, I'm sorry.
• 10:39
  I mean, you have to write the yes, Hi, Ravi.
• 10:44
  You're showing me. It could be.
• 10:46
  Yeah, seems to be you're showing me.
• 10:48
  So they'll be in and 0 rock with Safetori and some say no, the
• 10:51
  only Joe by by a Safetori. You don't have to be macked and
• 10:56
  0 by by by Nazimi law Zion Safetori Kozlovi Yamin a
• 11:05
  Safetori. It has to be written with the
• 11:08
  right with the right hand, because it says shark Tam Saftam
• 11:13
  and we're there's a hackish it's all for all.
• 11:17
  It says by chiller. That's for all.
• 11:19
  Stam Stam discussion is what about a inter yard?
• 11:24
  The shark brings the inter yard. So the shark is Mako.
• 11:27
  The shark says inter yard. Small D-Day.
• 11:29
  Who you mean right That's she does a shock that that his his
• 11:34
  his his small is actually his yummy.
• 11:36
  That's a stronger head. There are those who understand
• 11:39
  staff could be yummy and they're in the even those who she
• 11:43
  doesn't would who's impossible in in in by the it's Riyadh.
• 11:47
  I don't think we go like that, but it might be.
• 11:50
  There are those who are Mahadhar, the armahader, not not
• 11:54
  to have have used a safer tour by an inter yard.
• 11:57
  There are those who say that's only the only Mukhum heathers
• 12:01
  really only by filling because they're they're the possible
• 12:05
  says clearly that shark shark term of saften, and that's by
• 12:10
  filling, even though it's a heckish to say for Tyra.
• 12:13
  We learned to say for Tyra, but there's no shark term by safer
• 12:16
  Torah. So therefore we can there's more
• 12:18
  room to be Mako. Famous Softer who's a lefty in
• 12:23
  the neighborhood He claims that a lefty actually has a neither
• 12:28
  because there's no chance that his hands going to.
• 12:31
  Go over the ankle right now, let's say it again, but I said
• 12:35
  he during there's a lot of sometimes they either also pee.
• 12:39
  I'll pee, you know, pee soda. Pick a bottle of yummy and and
• 12:42
  Rachamim and and they're that. So that's where a lot of these,
• 12:45
  some of these, some of these things come in.
• 12:49
  It's yeah, it's, it's, it's not a gamor.
• 12:55
  It's yeah, it's, it's it's it's based on the task.
• 13:02
  It's based on the draw on the Drasha of Lukhcharta Safta.
• 13:11
  The you have to use coolness of a of a of a of a Condor of a
• 13:17
  Reed. A lot of the notes because the
• 13:18
  notes are scratch. When we get into the issue of
• 13:24
  Hakika, it has discusses it says that that using a connoisseur
• 13:30
  Varzal. What about using a metal a metal
• 13:33
  a metal tip thing. So he says, he says the problem
• 13:37
  there is that when you write with a metal tip thing, it
• 13:41
  scratches it. It scratches it first, it could
• 13:44
  be and and then the ink goes in. It might be an issue of Hoktos.
• 13:48
  There's another issue which is not not to use metal because of
• 13:53
  insanegrios and Sanegar. There's like the mid by the
• 13:56
  misbeyer. You don't use selling metal
• 13:59
  which is used to it was used for rasika.
• 14:02
  You shouldn't use it for safer Torah either.
• 14:06
  So so those are the two reasons why not to use.
• 14:11
  I don't using I mean fixing safer term with a Parker pen.
• 14:15
  I don't know that it could be it's you know, it could be just
• 14:18
  you just do it lightly. It's not hakika, but you do have
• 14:21
  the issue you do have. What has this question of LP
• 14:24
  Barzel again, according to the safer the the lot about Barzos
• 14:29
  and the TAZ. The thing about the about Katika
• 14:32
  Tiger's bench is mentioned again.
• 14:34
  These things are mentioned ringing up things which are
• 14:35
  mentioned the possible he during possible timing.
• 14:39
  The tasks were harshish for that fact that it's Hakiko first.
• 14:43
  Now the Tasman's over here. What about a printing press?
• 14:46
  Can you write slurring with the the way I understand the TAZ is
• 14:51
  that is that can you write the slurring which are written with
• 14:55
  a printing press? Does it have Kadusha?
• 14:58
  Does it have Kadusha? Do they have Kadusha because is
• 15:01
  it is a printing press considered Siva?
• 15:04
  Yeah, the printing press, it used to be they had tons of
• 15:06
  letters and they would have a whole board and they would set
• 15:09
  up all the letters and then then they would and they would put
• 15:13
  whatever there's ink on it and it pushes it together.
• 15:16
  So that says that that's, you know, that is a printing.
• 15:19
  Who cares if you if he, if he writes it or, or, or if he well,
• 15:26
  it's not, he says it's not Hakika, it's that it's actual,
• 15:29
  it's his actual sieve of things arrived from the Abdi Milouim.
• 15:33
  And so they used to write that there being the manager.
• 15:35
  So they would write the ice on the Abdi Milou and the Shamir
• 15:38
  would follow, would follow the ice so and and engraved inside.
• 15:44
  So you said you see that one of you know so he said so you know
• 15:50
  if if he says that what if, if, if, if, if mice it's first is
• 15:55
  hakika. So he says why, why You know the
• 15:58
  question. The question was out in Muluum,
• 16:00
  how they engrave in it without Hakika, right.
• 16:03
  Without the some there are different sheet of something.
• 16:05
  They used Andy Malou on the show Andy Malou.
• 16:10
  They engraved the letters in so they couldn't use they couldn't.
• 16:15
  Yeah, yeah, of course some say they used it by Shaney.
• 16:18
  They they used chamber acid whatever because they didn't
• 16:21
  have the show near. But the question is is why don't
• 16:23
  why don't they just use fuss? Because that's the shot the
• 16:26
  stamp it that's the shot. The town says if, if, if, if, if
• 16:31
  if a stamp is not is is is not is Hakika, then you know, then
• 16:38
  they they you know, so they should have mentioned that.
• 16:40
  So he's he says it's not Hakika. The Episcotuva understands the
• 16:45
  tiles to say to to say that even a safer tire written print, a
• 16:50
  printing press will be a cost for safer tire.
• 16:52
  That's how the physical Tuva understands other Arcanum.
• 16:55
  Other Arcanum also understand that tiles way I understood the
• 16:59
  tiles is more just he's just saying that there is Siva and
• 17:03
  therefore it is it does have the safer would have actual Kalusha
• 17:07
  to it. If it's the printing press
• 17:14
  printing press if you if you have you know, if you have a
• 17:18
  full much from 60 years, yeah, yeah, whatever yeah, yeah.
• 17:30
  The the the the thing with nowadays nowadays I said that
• 17:33
  the the place can say whatever the prime if Yasu both said that
• 17:38
  listen, even once printed nowadays do have Kedusha to
• 17:42
  them, you know, but it's not it's not to the same level they
• 17:45
  archive Geniza, but it's not to the same it's not to the same
• 17:49
  not to the same level as as something which was printed.
• 17:53
  So nowadays, you know, printed firing and things, but actually
• 17:56
  probably probably have a lesser because it's not it's not see,
• 18:00
  it's that it wouldn't fit into the top of the idea of Siva.
• 18:03
  But since I had shame, it's a shame.
• 18:04
  Whatever the horror it would be whatever den of whatever den of
• 18:10
  of of Kedusha about, you know, digital, you know, digital
• 18:16
  thing. That's not a digital screen.
• 18:19
  That's not the difference between photo offset and let's
• 18:22
  say inkjet. Inkjet actually writes it, it
• 18:27
  writes, it writes a line, a line that's not writing a letter.
• 18:32
  It's that's still writing a letter.
• 18:33
  But you know, listen, I didn't say that.
• 18:38
  Therefore you should be knowing. Listen, obviously there's still
• 18:41
  not borrow to us. So you should be knowing, you
• 18:43
  know, you know, knowing you know, Uncle Punnim and of course
• 18:48
  digital, you know, digital is not is not considered Siva on
• 18:55
  the screen, on the screen even that it's not, but even it's not
• 19:06
  a paper. I think it's not paper and it's
• 19:09
  not, it's not paper. So therefore the idea there's a
• 19:15
  Siva by in in one of the Chavez the the fine Siva is taking an
• 19:26
  ink and attaching it to paper. You need like 2 components to a
• 19:30
  certain degree to have a mice Siva to have a what's called a
• 19:34
  writing on the on digital screen.
• 19:36
  It's you know, you miss it's it's you're missing part of it.
• 19:40
  So is there Kedusha? I don't know.
• 19:43
  I mean, yeah, that's the thing I heard of someone said that we've
• 19:48
  heard of mahmiri and that they wait till the the shame Hashem
• 19:51
  on the screen, wait for the screen to go black, to go blank,
• 19:55
  and then to close it. Whatever.
• 19:57
  I don't know. I mean, that's a nice hydurian.
• 19:59
  It's you know, you know, Yeah, and you can, you know, but the
• 20:02
  the pastas is not actual seva. Let's just start.
• 20:08
  We'll, we'll start.