Latest / Politics with Paul / How Representative is Our Government—And How Should it Be? | Politics with Paul #87
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09Today, we're gonna talk about how representative our government is and how should
- 0:15it be representative of us?
- 0:17One of the most important components of a government is to be a representative of the
- 0:23people who elect them.
- 0:24After all, they are supposed to emulate the voters' will because that's why they were
- 0:29ultimately elected.
- 0:31But there are a lot of challenges toward this end.
- 0:34There are sometimes that government officials don't represent their constituents well.
- 0:39Could be for any number of reasons.
- 0:41Maybe they just use their office to enrich themselves or elevate their prestige or they
- 0:46only listen to their campaign donors or they just aren't effective at getting policy enacted
- 0:52for their constituents, and then they'll get voted out in the next election.
- 0:55But there's another issue that arises in this regard.
- 0:59What exactly should a representative government look like?
- 1:03We all want a government that acts in our interests, that reflects us in some way, that
- 1:08is similar to us in some way, but that could mean a lot of different things.
- 1:12Should their demographics be similar, their ideology, their partisanship?
- 1:17Should they do every single thing we want or do we trust them to do the right thing according
- 1:22to their conscience?
- 1:23A lot of questions to answer.
- 1:25And it's easy to say that government should be representative of the people.
- 1:29I think just about all of us can agree on that.
- 1:33But it's a
- 1:33lot harder to say how that government and how that representativeness should manifest and how
- 1:42we get agreement on that.
- 1:44So today, we're gonna tackle this topic of representative representativeness and what it
- 1:50looks like.
- 1:51Let's go.
- 1:52First of all, what is representativeness in government?
- 1:55Sounds like
- 1:56a very obvious question, and in a way it is.
- 1:58But the short answer is it's how much our elected officials reflect their districts that
- 2:04they were elected to and the rest of the people that their government has jurisdiction over.
- 2:09So if we're talking about federal government, how much do members of Congress reflect their
- 2:13districts and the nation?
- 2:15Because, yes, you have to reflect and represent the district that elected you, but you are also
- 2:22part of a national body, so you also have to, to some extent, represent the entire nation.
- 2:29On a somewhat smaller scale, how much do state legislators reflect their districts and their
- 2:34states?
- 2:35So they have to reflect the district that elected them in
- 2:37the state and also the rest of
- 2:40the state at large because they are in that state's legislature.
- 2:42And then similarly, it can be for county commissioners and how much they reflect their
- 2:47districts and their overall county or city councilors for their district and their overall
- 2:52city.
- 2:52But then there's also not just whether they are representative, but how much people feel like
- 2:59they're being represented by governments.
- 3:01So how much do people feel that they are represented by whatever government is in
- 3:06question?
- 3:07Now, obviously, we're going to find that out primarily through polls because you're trying
- 3:10to get public sentiment in this regard.
- 3:13It partially depends on the government in question.
- 3:16Usually, when we ask how satisfied you are with the government, it's typically in the context
- 3:22of Congress, not state or local governments because polling is expensive and less people,
- 3:28fewer people pay attention to state and local governments and congress gets all the
- 3:33attention.
- 3:34So typically, people ask how or pollsters ask people how they feel about congress.
- 3:41Also, there's 50 different states.
- 3:42So there's 50 different state legislatures, and that's hard to keep track of
- 3:46all of them and public sentiment about all of them.
- 3:49And when pollsters ask people how they feel about congress,
- 3:53they don't necessarily directly ask the question, do you feel well represented by
- 3:57Congress?
- 3:58Sometimes they do, but they don't always ask that or a similar question.
- 4:02But they do ask other relevant questions like how much trust do you have in government or in
- 4:08Congress specifically?
- 4:09Or do you approve of the way congress is handling its job?
- 4:13And in this regard, polls tend to find low trust and low approval ratings in or of
- 4:20congress.
- 4:21Gallup, for example, in February 2026 found 80% disapproval, eight zero, of the job Congress
- 4:30was doing, and they haven't measured a plurality of approval in this poll since 2004.
- 4:35And then in a separate poll in September 2025, they found 66% of people had not very much
- 4:42trust or no trust at all in the legislative branch.
- 4:46Now those didn't ask specifically, do you feel well represented by Congress?
- 4:51But if people did feel well represented by Congress, they probably wouldn't be saying
- 4:56those things.
- 4:57They'd probably have a lot more trust in Congress.
- 5:00They'd probably have a lot more approval of the job Congress is doing.
- 5:05But especially lately, those opinions have been in the tank.
- 5:10So I think it's safe to say that people typically don't feel represented by congress,
- 5:17and that's also partially affected by the party of the respondent to the poll and which party
- 5:25is in power.
- 5:26When Republicans have control of Congress, Republicans in the electorate are more likely
- 5:32to feel like they're well represented.
- 5:33If Democrats are in power in Congress, then Democrats in the electorate are going to
- 5:38typically feel more represented.
- 5:41But beyond that, let's talk a little bit more of the philosophical, the abstract, the main
- 5:49models of representation.
- 5:51So, the four main models of representation.
- 5:56At least two basic ideas of how government should represent the people's will exists, and
- 6:01it isn't inherently about partisanship or ideology or anything like that.
- 6:06And I say at least two because there are a couple of other models that are proposed by
- 6:11some people, more on that shortly, but the four main models and the first two that we're gonna
- 6:16deal with are delegate and trustee, and then there's also politico and partisan.
- 6:22But it makes sense to discuss delegate and trustee first, and I'll show you why.
- 6:27In a delegate model, a political representative acts as a direct mouthpiece for constituents,
- 6:33strictly voting according to their beliefs.
- 6:36And some people call this the instructed model because voters are telling you exactly what
- 6:41they want you to do.
- 6:43And then there's the trustee model, which is where a political representative is entrusted
- 6:48to use their own judgment and knowledge to make the best choice for their constituents.
- 6:54And sometimes this is called uninstructed.
- 6:56You're entrusted to do what's the what is best according to your own conscience.
- 7:03So which one of these do you like?
- 7:06The delegates or the trustee?
- 7:08Maybe it's
- 7:08the delegate model.
- 7:09Of course, you want a congressperson or a state legislator or whoever to do exactly what you
- 7:16want them to.
- 7:16That's why you voted for them, that you voted for them according to your beliefs, and so it
- 7:22would behoove them to do what you want.
- 7:25Or maybe it's a trustee model because, of course, you can't keep up with everything that
- 7:29your representative is doing.
- 7:31There's just too much going on in your life and Capitol Hill or in your state capital.
- 7:37So you these representatives need to use their conscience
- 7:41to do what's best.
- 7:44Well, like every model used in politics because you're dealing with human beings, both of these
- 7:50models have their shortcomings.
- 7:52So
- 7:52if we look at
- 7:53the delegate model, I'm gonna
- 7:56go with four weaknesses for each of these for these two models here.
- 8:00And in the delegate model, one of the problems is what constituents do you listen to on a
- 8:06given issue?
- 8:07Because there's going to be some disagreement among them, including people who voted for you.
- 8:12You can't be a delegate for all of them all the time.
- 8:15So group a and b, let's say they both voted for you, but group A really likes this one bill
- 8:22you're gonna vote on and group B doesn't.
- 8:24Well, which one are you gonna be a delegate for?
- 8:27Supposedly, both of these groups voted for you to do what they wanted you to do, but you can't
- 8:33do what both of them want you to do in this case, because they both have different opinions
- 8:38on this bill.
- 8:40There's also the problem that constituents don't always have the facts on hand because
- 8:44they are not up there in Capitol Hill.
- 8:46They are not always researching this stuff, so they won't always make
- 8:50the best judgment.
- 8:52And some, of
- 8:52course, will just be selfish and just want what benefits them and not necessarily the whole
- 8:57community, or they might tell themselves that what's best for them is best for the community.
- 9:03And also, if you were to be a delegate, you can't always know what all of your constituents
- 9:09want on every single issue because there's just too many issues
- 9:13for them to follow and for you to get people's opinions on.
- 9:18So that also is a problem for delegates.
- 9:21And then lastly, a delegate has no core convictions of their own.
- 9:24They're just going where the wind takes them.
- 9:27They could be easily swayed.
- 9:28They're just going to simply vote for what gets them elected.
- 9:32Is that somebody who's trustworthy?
- 9:35So all those problems I listed for the delegate model, maybe now you're thinking, well, okay,
- 9:40then I guess the trustee model is the way to go.
- 9:43Not so fast.
- 9:44Let's talk about four weaknesses for the trustee model as well.
- 9:47For a trustee, many representatives abuse the trust given to them by constituents, like using
- 9:53their office to enrich themselves, to elevate their prestige, to get more media attention.
- 10:00It's not about doing work for the community.
- 10:03It's about getting on a soapbox and getting all the attention and getting all these hits on
- 10:08podcasts and social media.
- 10:11And there's a lot of those kinds of people we've seen.
- 10:13Maybe we disagree on who those people are,
- 10:15but we've undoubtedly seen a lot of those kinds of people.
- 10:20Also, for a trustee, your constituents did elect you to act in accordance to their wishes
- 10:25to some extent.
- 10:26So at some point, it is expected that you vote based on what your constituents want, not just
- 10:31what you want.
- 10:32So that's a tough balancing act to to strike there.
- 10:37And also trustees can rightly or wrongly, sometimes this is a proper perception,
- 10:43sometimes it's not.
- 10:44It can be seen as elitist because of this perceived sense of thinking they know better
- 10:48than their constituents about everything.
- 10:50I'm the person that's in government.
- 10:52So I'm just gonna vote what my conscience tells me because I know what's going on.
- 10:56You don't.
- 10:58They might be actually thinking that they might not actually be thinking that.
- 11:01And then lastly, even if they're not being elitist, a trustee's judgment can still be
- 11:07faulty just because they're in office.
- 11:08Oh, boy.
- 11:09Yeah, definitely.
- 11:10Just because they're in office does not mean that they're going to make the right decision.
- 11:14And just because they're entrusted by their constituents to make that right decision
- 11:18doesn't mean they always will make that right decision.
- 11:22So because of those shortcomings of both the delegate and trustee model of representation,
- 11:27some people subscribe to what's called the politico model, just basically a hybrid of
- 11:31delegate and trustee where a representative follows the trustee model for the most part
- 11:36where they're supposed to act on what they think is best, but they will be a delegate on
- 11:41issues that their constituents deeply care about.
- 11:45And so this may sound like the solution.
- 11:46After all, I just showed you some of the flaws of both delegates and trustees.
- 11:51Not so fast.
- 11:53It is not that simple.
- 11:54Again, these are models we're talking about.
- 11:56They describe things in a very simplified manner, but when you're talking about human
- 12:01nature and behavior, things are never so simple.
- 12:04Some of the shortcomings of the political model now and the political model may be what happens
- 12:11a lot of times in reality in some cases, but some of the problems with the model include how
- 12:18basically every issue has some people that deeply care about it.
- 12:23So how many people does it have to be that deeply care about it for a representative to
- 12:28turn into a delegate?
- 12:29If we talk about the Iran war, for example, Maybe your district doesn't have that many
- 12:36people who care about the Iran war specifically, but there is
- 12:42a a group that very, very deeply cares about it.
- 12:47do you
- 12:47start voting on bills related to it according to those constituents' wishes?
- 12:54What if that group of constituents that deeply cared about the Iran war was bigger?
- 12:58Would you then start to become a delegate instead of a trustee?
- 13:01It's it's hard to figure out how many voters that needs to be.
- 13:06And even if the political model is objectively the right way, can we trust a delegate or a
- 13:13representative to correctly, quote unquote, assume when they should be a trustee versus a
- 13:19delegate.
- 13:19Maybe there's something where they they should think, should in quotation marks, they should
- 13:26act as a trustee on a bill when they really should have acted as a delegate and vice versa.
- 13:32There's no real objective way to determine that.
- 13:37And then politicos can still be seen as calculating it out for their own ambitions
- 13:41because they're just, whether it's rightly or wrongly perceived as this, they might be trying
- 13:47to toe the line just to get themselves elected where they're trying to do just enough to
- 13:51please their constituents so they get reelected, but also do just enough to please
- 13:56their party leadership so that they can elevate their prestige so they can get big time
- 14:03committee assignments or run for a higher office.
- 14:06Like, if they're in the US house, they might run for US senator or for the governor of their
- 14:10state, or they might even run for president.
- 14:13And so then that leaves us with the fourth model, the partisan model, and it's just as it
- 14:19sounds.
- 14:19You're just simply voting on party lines.
- 14:22Doesn't matter what the constituents say.
- 14:24A lot of times those constituents will, at least the very loud ones, some of
- 14:29them will still want you
- 14:31to vote the party line anyways.
- 14:32And in this era of hyperpolarization, you see a lot more of this happening.
- 14:37But might be obvious why this is a problem, but we're still gonna talk about the problems with
- 14:42it anyway, just to lay them out there.
- 14:45So you're only going to increase toxicity and global divides because all you're doing is just
- 14:50voting along the party line.
- 14:51You're not listening to any other criticisms.
- 14:55And guess what?
- 14:57Parties are not a monolith.
- 14:58Not every Republican thinks the same way.
- 15:00Not every Democrat thinks the same way.
- 15:02So what if those voters think a different way than the rest of the party thinks?
- 15:08Do you just completely ignore them?
- 15:09Well, in this model, you do.
- 15:11And then that's
- 15:12not to say anything about the fact that you're completely disregarding the other major party.
- 15:18So if it's a Republican district, it's disregarding Democrats.
- 15:21If it's a Democratic district, disregard Republicans, and then they're both disregarding
- 15:25third parties and no party voters, but they are also your constituents.
- 15:30A lot of people wanna act like only the people that voted for them are their constituents, but
- 15:34no, it's everybody in your district is one of your constituents, whether you like that or
- 15:39not.
- 15:40And also, a partisan model can still be calculating and ambitious.
- 15:45Representatives in the partisan model can be calculating and ambitious, especially in
- 15:50staunchly partisan districts because they're simply following the party line to enrich
- 15:54themselves and elevate their prestige.
- 15:56They don't have to worry about the district voting against them because they've just been
- 16:00going along the party line the whole time, and there's not enough of the opposition in the
- 16:06electorate to vote against that person.
- 16:08So there's nothing really to stop them from doing that.
- 16:12There's no real accountability.
- 16:14So as is with the case, as is the case of all models of anything political, you can't find a
- 16:24perfect one for every scenario, whether it's one that we should follow or one that explains
- 16:31every situation.
- 16:32You're never gonna find one like that.
- 16:34But now moving from the abstract to more of the practical now, what are these different kinds
- 16:40of representativeness that we're talking about?
- 16:43Because there are a bunch of different ways that we can look at this and different people
- 16:48place different kinds and levels of emphasis on different kinds of representativeness.
- 16:55How many times can I say different in one sentence?
- 16:58So for time's sake, we're just gonna focus on four different kinds of representativeness.
- 17:04We're gonna talk about partisan, ideological, racial, and gender.
- 17:08So first up, partisan representativeness.
- 17:12How much does a party division of congress or the state legislatures reflect the party
- 17:17divisions of the public?
- 17:20So we can't really answer that question neatly because even though we can obviously see the
- 17:26party labels of each member of congress, not every state tracks party affiliation of voters.
- 17:32In fact, only 30 states do that as of August 2025.
- 17:37So we have to use polling data to some extent to see how voters identify themselves.
- 17:42Now, obviously, that target will be moving around a little bit, but that's the best that
- 17:47we
- 17:47can do.
- 17:48If you're gonna
- 17:49use those to compare to congress's partisanship at surface level, congress's partisanship
- 17:54doesn't look much like the electorate because a plurality or close to a plurality of voters
- 18:00regularly identify as independents.
- 18:04But the vast majority of partisan elections, which is what congress is, they're partisan
- 18:09elections, vast majority of them are won by either democrats or republicans.
- 18:13You almost never see independents in there.
- 18:16And the couple of handfuls that you see in there right now in the US senate, they caucus
- 18:22with democrats.
- 18:24So when you're talking about quote unquote true independents, you don't really see much of
- 18:32those at all anymore, at least not in congress.
- 18:35But if you take the leanings of independence, so a lot of independence will, if they get
- 18:41prodded enough by pollsters, will say, okay.
- 18:44Yeah.
- 18:44I leaned Republican.
- 18:45Okay.
- 18:45Yeah.
- 18:46I leaned Democrat.
- 18:47And a lot of them actually lean harder Democrat or Republican than they care to admit.
- 18:52But then when you start to get those numbers, it starts to look a little bit more like
- 18:59congress.
- 18:59Now, obviously, how the poll splits across congressional districts compared to, you know,
- 19:08what what districts they were pulled in.
- 19:10Obviously, it can make things look a bit different.
- 19:13But to some extent, is a little bit more representativeness there when you're comparing
- 19:18partisanship divisions in Congress to partisanship divisions in the electorate.
- 19:23But then it gets a bit more complicated when we look at the state legislative level because
- 19:28there are 50 states that we'd have to talk about, and we can't talk about all of them
- 19:31because there's just not enough time.
- 19:33But some state legislatures, party divisions do align more closely to their electorate, at
- 19:40least in states that track party affiliation.
- 19:43Remember, there's 20 states that don't do that.
- 19:45And in Republican states like Wyoming and Florida, if you compare how many Republican
- 19:52percentage of Republicans in the state's legislatures in those two states compared to
- 19:58the number of registered Republicans in the electorate, it does look a little bit more like
- 20:06did they do start to look a little bit more similar.
- 20:08Although there are a lot of independents in Florida.
- 20:11But, again, if you'd start taking leanings of towards Democrats or Republicans, it could
- 20:17start to look more like the partisanship you see in government.
- 20:20But then on the flip side, Democratic states where percentage of Democrats is similar to in
- 20:30the electorate is similar to the percentage of Democrats in the state legislature are ones
- 20:33like New York and Maryland.
- 20:36Again, these are not perfect alignments, not perfect comparisons, but they do start to look
- 20:40a little
- 20:41bit more representative in terms of partisanship.
- 20:46And then other state legislatures aren't so partisanly similar to their electorates either,
- 20:52or at least it's hard to see how partisanly similar because of whether independence in
- 20:58those states lean one way or another.
- 21:00But Colorado has a huge plurality of independence and it's almost a majority and in
- 21:06Massachusetts does have a majority of independence, but neither of those states have
- 21:12many independent legislators.
- 21:15I think there's a like a couple of them in Massachusetts possibly, and I don't I don't
- 21:19think there's any in Colorado, but a lot of independent voters, but very few independent
- 21:24legislators.
- 21:25And I'm not entirely sure if those voters how much how many of those voters lean democrat or
- 21:30republican, but
- 21:31I suspect a lot more of them tend to lean democratic based on this those states' overall
- 21:39partisan leanings.
- 21:41And then for
- 21:41a local level, it's that's too hard to really tell and give a case study on at least here
- 21:47because there are so many local governments and many are officially nonpartisan offices.
- 21:53So that would take monumental amount of research and it might not even be a question
- 21:58you could answer.
- 21:59Some local places you could, but you would have to spend a lot of time researching that.
- 22:05So the second kind of representativeness we'll talk about is ideological representativeness.
- 22:11How much does the ideological makeup of congress or the state legislatures reflect the
- 22:15ideological divisions in the public?
- 22:18Again, I've said this on previous episodes, you cannot use party interchangeably with ideology.
- 22:25Yes.
- 22:26Republicans tend to be conservative.
- 22:28Yes.
- 22:28Democrats tend to be liberal, but they are not the exact same thing.
- 22:31Some Republicans would not call themselves conservative.
- 22:35Some would even call themselves liberal.
- 22:36You'd be surprised.
- 22:37Democrats, likewise, you'd be surprised how some of them call themselves conservative or at
- 22:42least not liberal.
- 22:44Those numbers are dwindling.
- 22:46But, again, you cannot just use party and ideology interchangeably even though Congress
- 22:53and many state legislatures have become more ideologically divided and voters have to some
- 22:58extent too.
- 22:59But we overestimate the level of ideological division because it is the most extreme voices
- 23:05that get most of the attention.
- 23:06So we start to think that, oh, wow, everybody's ideologically polarized.
- 23:10Well, no, it's just a lot of loud people.
- 23:14But also the elites or elected officials are much more ideologically inclined than the
- 23:21general public.
- 23:23A lot of the general public, you might be surprised to find, does not care about
- 23:27ideology.
- 23:28They care about party, but they don't care about the ideology or they don't think in those
- 23:33terms, or they just use party and ideology interchangeably.
- 23:37But ideological voters, more ideological voters tend to vote at higher rates than the less
- 23:43ideological and non ideological voters do.
- 23:48So you do that's why the public can be less ideologically polarized while congress or some
- 23:57state legislatures can be much more ideologically polarized.
- 24:02And so more state governments are becoming more ideologically uniform as well, though it still
- 24:07varies because some state versions of the Democratic Party are less liberal than the
- 24:11national, and some state versions of the Republican Party are less conservative than
- 24:16their national counterpart.
- 24:19But, again, the impact of the more heavily ideological voters is pronounced in these
- 24:24elections, probably even more so at the state level than the federal level because there are
- 24:29generally fewer voters that care about state politics versus federal politics, except for
- 24:34maybe like governor.
- 24:36And so the impact of ideological voters can be even more pronounced there.
- 24:42Third type of representativeness we'll talk about is racial representativeness.
- 24:47So it's no secret that the racial makeup of Congress is less diverse than the general
- 24:54public's racial makeup.
- 24:56But that being said, the beginning of the current Congress, which is the one hundred and
- 25:00nineteenth, is the most racially diverse we've had.
- 25:03At the moment, I can't think of any from the start of Congress who have resigned or passed
- 25:08away, so it might still be the same number as at the beginning, but 139 total US senators and
- 25:15representatives identify as at least one racial minority in the current Congress.
- 25:20So 66 black members of Congress, 53 are Hispanic, 21 are Asian American, and four are
- 25:25Native American, and then there are five that are multiracial House representatives, none of
- 25:31those in the US Senate, at
- 25:33least not yet.
- 25:34And then states are going
- 25:36to vary considerably in this regard and there's too many to cover in this episode, but you have
- 25:40seen some state legislatures that have been breaking records of racial minority
- 25:47representation in their respective states as well.
- 25:51And then lastly, gender representativeness has somewhat of a similar dynamic to racial
- 25:58representativeness.
- 26:00Women make up a little more than 50% of The US population, but are not even close to that in
- 26:06congress.
- 26:06There's something like 28 to 29%.
- 26:09Because at the beginning of the one hundred and nineteenth congress, 150 members of congress
- 26:13were women, which was almost the highest we've had in history.
- 26:17And then that's not even including US Senator Ashley Moody from Florida, my state, who would
- 26:23join this group later because she was appointed to Marco Rubio's old seat when then he became
- 26:27Secretary of State.
- 26:29And so that was with her, I believe that was one yes.
- 26:33It was one less than the highest number of women that we've had in congress, which was
- 26:40152, and that followed a series of special elections in 2024.
- 26:47So not quite at the beginning of that congress, but later on during that term.
- 26:53And once again, states are gonna vary considerably in this regard.
- 26:56There are too many to cover in this episode, but women have started to make up more of state
- 27:00legislatures as well, and some of them have been pushing or breaking records.
- 27:07Now, all this talk about representativeness, we have to talk about challenges to representation
- 27:13because regardless of your politics, basically, everybody can agree that there are some
- 27:20challenges to representativeness in governments, whether it's congress or state
- 27:26legislatures.
- 27:27Now some people might think that there's not a problem, but even if they aren't necessarily
- 27:32problems now, they can be problems in the future.
- 27:36Whatever model of representation you subscribe to, so if you're the delegate model, you're the
- 27:40trustee, the politico, the partisan, there are many hindrances to having a government that
- 27:46emulates the interests of the people.
- 27:49And unfortunately, there are no easy answers to fixing them.
- 27:53But we're gonna talk about a handful of the most pressing challenges that
- 28:01representativeness in government faces.
- 28:04So first up, low turnout in elections.
- 28:09Among democracies in the world, The US typically ranks pretty low in voter turnout,
- 28:14and it's been this way for some time.
- 28:18Even in presidential elections, you don't see necessarily that many people vote.
- 28:23And now turnout rates can be calculated in different ways.
- 28:27Some people calculate voter turnout based on voting age population, because obviously, not
- 28:33everybody in the population could vote.
- 28:35Some people will use the voting eligible population, which is another subset of the
- 28:40voting age population because not everybody who is of the age to vote is registered to vote,
- 28:46and then some people will use registered voters instead of voting eligible population because
- 28:52not everybody who's eligible to vote is registered to vote.
- 28:57And so the voter turnout rate can fluctuate depending on that.
- 29:01We've talked about it in a couple episodes of the podcast.
- 29:04But in any case, however you cut it, voter turnout rates in The US aren't exactly anything
- 29:11to write home about.
- 29:12They're some of the lowest in the world.
- 29:14And then turnout gets worse when it's not a presidential election.
- 29:17So presidential elections get the highest turnout rates.
- 29:20Midterms drop a lot more past that.
- 29:23They might be as low as 15 to 20 to 25 percentage points lower than what you get in
- 29:29presidential elections, maybe even more.
- 29:32Odd year elections, ones that are specifically set for odd year elections, those can be even
- 29:37lower.
- 29:38So like a 2021, 2023, 2025, 2027 next year.
- 29:44And then you get the special elections, which are inherently irregularly timed because you
- 29:49have to come up with a date for them.
- 29:52So those tend to see even lower turnout rates.
- 29:55And then you can also look at it from federal to states to local level races.
- 30:01Federal government tends to see the highest turnout rates.
- 30:04State executives like a governor or attorney general will see maybe something a little bit
- 30:10similar to like Congress, for example.
- 30:13And then other state level races like state legislators and state judges, those will have
- 30:17even lower turnout.
- 30:19And then local level races will generally speaking, they have putrid turnout.
- 30:24You might see as little as ten, fifteen, 25% of voters that can vote in their local
- 30:31government's elections.
- 30:33That's that's all of them that will vote.
- 30:35So lots of problems with low turnout rates in elections.
- 30:40But why does that pose a threat to representativeness?
- 30:44If they just chose not to vote, then I mean, that's their decision, right?
- 30:48Well, to some extent it is.
- 30:51But low turnout is a problem for representation because by definition, it means fewer people
- 30:57are making their voice heard.
- 30:59Democracy needs people to participate in it in order to legitimize it.
- 31:04If you're not having enough people participate, then really what is the point of having things
- 31:09being voted on?
- 31:11There's not really much of a point to doing that.
- 31:15And you can't possibly be representative in full of your population because we aren't even
- 31:20hearing from nearly all of the eligible voters that that could make their voice heard.
- 31:28We're not even hearing about them.
- 31:29So you hear things like, oh, you know, half the nation voted for Donald Trump or Joe Biden.
- 31:35That's not true.
- 31:36First of all, they almost never get a majority.
- 31:39Well, I don't wanna say almost never, but a lot of times they only get a plurality because
- 31:42there are people that vote for a third party candidate or they vote for a write in.
- 31:49But, also, it's not even counting the people who didn't make their voice heard.
- 31:54Who were they gonna vote for?
- 31:55Were they gonna vote for Donald Trump?
- 31:57Were they gonna vote for Joe Biden?
- 31:58Were they gonna vote third party or a write in?
- 32:01Would they have just left the presidential election blank and voted on other races on
- 32:06their ballot?
- 32:07We don't know.
- 32:08They didn't make their voice heard.
- 32:12So it's not even half of people that could vote that are choosing an elected official.
- 32:19It's more like or a president, it's more like 35, 40% of the electorate maybe are choosing
- 32:29the presidents of The United States.
- 32:31And then you'll see sometimes even similar numbers for like a governor of a state, or you
- 32:37might see even fewer people.
- 32:39Remember those lower voter turnout rates?
- 32:41The lower in government that you get or the lower of a level of government that you get.
- 32:46So you're really only having a small subset of people choose their elected officials because
- 32:54so many people are not participating.
- 32:57That can't possibly be representative.
- 32:59Challenge number two to representativeness in government is hurdles in ballot access laws.
- 33:06So ballot access simply means how people get on the ballot.
- 33:10There's a whole bunch of different laws depending on where you're running and for what
- 33:13office you're running for that dictate how you can get on the ballot.
- 33:17But typically, there's two ways to get on the ballot.
- 33:20You either pay a fee or you get a certain number of petitions signed to put you on the
- 33:25ballot instead.
- 33:27But here's the kicker.
- 33:29The vast majority of third party and no party candidates often face a much tougher time
- 33:34getting on the ballot than Democrats and Republicans do, and not because they don't get
- 33:38attention or they don't have enough money.
- 33:40I mean, that's that's that's part of it too.
- 33:42But a lot of times, they often have no option to pay a filing fee, and the number of
- 33:48petitions they need is often considerably higher than their Democratic or Republican
- 33:54opponents need.
- 33:55Now I'm this is not arguing that we should or shouldn't have more independent election
- 34:00winners.
- 34:00I'm just simply stating the reality of uneven ballot access laws.
- 34:05They are considerably tougher for independent candidates than they are for Democrats and
- 34:09Republicans.
- 34:10Though some Democrats and Republicans have their own hurdles, and I'll talk about those in
- 34:15a little bit.
- 34:16But why do these hurdles in ballot access limit representativeness?
- 34:22We don't want a whole bunch of people running for office that we and we can't keep track of
- 34:26all of them.
- 34:27Right?
- 34:27Well, it's a hurdle that's based on trying to limit party competition, not about trying to
- 34:33make elections more efficient or simplified.
- 34:37Sometimes that's the argument that's used or there's an argument about the right to
- 34:43association with the parties and some pipe people are not actually associating with a
- 34:48party or they say, oh, well, because these third parties are so small, they they shouldn't
- 34:52have get the same kinds of benefits and law that Republicans and Democrats get.
- 34:58Whatever the case may be, a lot of these arguments are really just trying to limit the
- 35:02pool of competitors to the Republicans and Democrats. Democrats
- 35:06Democrats because if there's one thing that those two parties can agree on, it's that they
- 35:09don't want more competition.
- 35:11But again, I'm not saying we should have more independents.
- 35:14I just have a strong opinion about the need for competitiveness in our elections.
- 35:22And there are also a ton of voters who are independents and what you might call quote
- 35:26unquote soft Democrats and Republicans.
- 35:29And they're not actually soft.
- 35:30It's just that they don't identify as strongly with their party.
- 35:34And they might want a third candidate, but they can't vote for that kind of candidate if that
- 35:38candidate doesn't even run or doesn't get their name out there.
- 35:42So you are effectively shutting out those people who wanna make their voice heard, and so
- 35:48they'll have to just toe the line of what the parties want, whether that party is even
- 35:54competitive in that district or not.
- 35:55Sometimes a local Democratic party is so dwarfed by the Republican party there or the
- 36:01local Republican party is so dwarfed by the Democrat there, but they still are very rigid
- 36:05in what they want, and their respective constituent bases will just have to deal with
- 36:14it because they don't have any other choices to go between, which is a good lead up to this
- 36:21next issue for representativeness.
- 36:24And this is actually talking about the two major parties this time.
- 36:28Litmus tests for Democrats and Republicans and excessive partisanship because even some
- 36:33Democrats or Republicans have a tough time running for office, but, of course, for
- 36:38different reasons typically than independents do.
- 36:42The parties often have favored people in mind or at
- 36:46least people they don't want to run
- 36:49and that they work to give certain candidates an easier time towards the nomination.
- 36:54They might give more resources to those candidates even if they publicly say, you know,
- 36:59they don't endorse a candidate.
- 37:01Sometimes they will publicly endorse candidates.
- 37:03Sometimes they won't, but they will still funnel resources towards them.
- 37:08And, of course, these people who run these local and state parties have their own opinions
- 37:13about who would be the best candidate.
- 37:15And primaries also tend to see more rigidly partisan and ideological voters participating
- 37:22than in the general election.
- 37:24Some people just don't care about the primaries and say, okay, just just let me know when when
- 37:28they get selected and then I'll come out in November.
- 37:30But because they do that, you let more ideological and partisan voters dictate who's
- 37:37getting to the general election in the first place.
- 37:39So a Democrat or
- 37:40a Republican that, quote, unquote, steps out of line because they didn't do every single thing
- 37:47that the party wanted, they're gonna have a tougher time getting support, and they're just
- 37:54gonna be also rants.
- 37:56Excuse me.
- 37:57That's the word I was looking for.
- 37:58But why do these litmus tests pose a threat to representativeness?
- 38:03Well, just just said it.
- 38:04They treat parties like they should be monoliths subject to groupthink, and there
- 38:10should not be exceptions to the rule.
- 38:11We shouldn't hear their voices.
- 38:13You have to just deal with the party line or go join the other party or go move somewhere else.
- 38:19And it also increases partisan polarization because candidates have to fit into a certain
- 38:23mold.
- 38:24So the overall parties will then become even less representative because there are more and
- 38:29more of these kinds of candidates that are taking office.
- 38:33So fewer and fewer people feel represented by government and more and more of them are
- 38:38becoming disenchanted.
- 38:39Next major roadblock to representativeness is gerrymandering, and this can get a little bit
- 38:45tricky, and I'll tell you one reason why in particular in a minute.
- 38:50But, of course, gerrymandering is you're picking and choosing where to place voters to
- 38:54deliberately give you and your party the greatest electoral benefit.
- 38:59Now sometimes these are very obvious with weirdly drawn lines.
- 39:03You'll look at a congressional map and it's just this very weird squiggle and you're like,
- 39:08there's no way that that can be legal.
- 39:09And sometimes it won't be legal.
- 39:11Sometimes they will.
- 39:12A court will rule it unconstitutional.
- 39:15But then other times the gerrymandering is a little bit more surreptitious, a little bit
- 39:21harder to find.
- 39:23And gerrymandering attempts have generally gotten more clever over time, but some have
- 39:27methods for catching it and trying to prevent it.
- 39:31And, of course, currently, both parties right now are trying to redraw lines in states that
- 39:36they firmly have a grip on to consolidate the majorities and then make up excuses for why
- 39:41they're justified in that regard.
- 39:42Both parties.
- 39:43Yes.
- 39:44But there is one aspect to these redrawing of lines that is controversial and doesn't really
- 39:52have an easy answer.
- 39:53Yes, generally speaking, gerrymandering is clearly unfair, but there is a little bit of a
- 40:01gray area when it comes to these majority minority districts.
- 40:04So these are districts where a majority of the districts voters are at least one racial
- 40:10minority.
- 40:11Maybe it's a predominantly black district or predominantly Hispanic district.
- 40:15So these districts make it much more likely that a racial minority gets elected and that
- 40:20they have some level of representation in Congress or in the state legislature.
- 40:25But why would these be controversial?
- 40:27Well, some people think that having a seat that's basically guaranteed to a racial
- 40:33minority is an unfair act of racial gerrymandering.
- 40:37But not every racial minority supports these kinds of districts either Because some of them
- 40:43think that this helps prevent what's called cracking, which is you take a specific segment
- 40:48of the population, you try to spread them out across multiple districts so you completely
- 40:52dilute their power and their influence so that they can't really get a foothold anywhere.
- 41:00And the idea behind these majority minority districts is saying, well, let's not split up
- 41:06these minority voters because then they're not gonna be able to get anybody to represent them
- 41:11because their power is diffused across a whole bunch of districts.
- 41:15But some racial minorities all think instead of empowering their communities, it actually does
- 41:22what's called packing, which is different kind of gerrymandering where you put the entire
- 41:26community you're trying to dilute the power of into one whole place.
- 41:30So you can say, okay, fine.
- 41:31We'll we'll just give up on this one, maybe two or three seats, but we will consolidate our
- 41:38power even more in or give ourselves an even better chance in all these other districts.
- 41:44So they basically lost these particular battles, but they're gonna win the war, so to
- 41:49speak.
- 41:50And so people some people will say that instead of empowering these minorities, it'll actually
- 41:58limit how much influence they can have in Congress or in state legislatures because it
- 42:02says, well, maybe these voters, if they weren't packed into one district, they could actually
- 42:07get more than one person from their community elected.
- 42:12They might be able to get like a handful of them elected.
- 42:15So it's really not a consensus one way or another amongst racial minority activists and
- 42:23candidates as to whether these districts are beneficial to their communities or not.
- 42:28But regardless of whether you support or oppose these kinds of districts, it does pose a lot of
- 42:34important questions for representativeness.
- 42:37Now those kinds of districts aside, in most cases, gerrymandering obviously hinders
- 42:43representativeness because you're trying to rig elections in favor of you or your party.
- 42:49Doesn't get much more unrepresentative when you try that because you're not actually trying to
- 42:53represent everybody in your district.
- 42:54You're trying to pick the people you want to represent so that you can get yourself in
- 43:00office.
- 43:01And then the last hurdle to cover of that is an obstacle to representativeness in government's
- 43:10large average population per congressional district and to some extent state legislative
- 43:16districts.
- 43:17Back in episode 60 of this podcast, I explored an idea for reform that a lot of people have
- 43:22suggested, which was to expand the number of representatives in the US house.
- 43:26The idea was basically, there's too many people per district.
- 43:30If we add more people to Congress, we can have a lot fewer people per district.
- 43:35And then you could actually have them be able to listen to everybody.
- 43:42Because the US house has been fixed at four thirty five members since a congressional act
- 43:46back in 1929.
- 43:48So it's been almost a hundred years now that it's been set legally in stone, but it's been
- 43:53435 longer than that.
- 43:56And the average population of a congressional district following the 2020 census was about
- 44:04761,000 people, and that's a huge jump from 2010, which was about 711,000 people per
- 44:12district, and then in 2000, was about 647,000 people per district.
- 44:17So these districts are just getting far bigger in a short span of time, and some of these
- 44:25state legislative districts have a similar problem as well, although they're a little bit
- 44:29more able to address those problems specifically.
- 44:33You see state legislatures change the number of legislators they have a little bit more often
- 44:38than you do in Congress.
- 44:41But why would these large populations per district pose a threat to representativeness?
- 44:46Well, legislators can't possibly reach out to everyone in their districts.
- 44:52Think about trying to contact now, obviously, not all of them are going to be registered
- 44:57voters or voting age population or anything like that.
- 45:00But let's just say you have 761,000 people in your district and maybe 550,000 are voting age
- 45:07population, and then, I don't know, 500,000 of them are registered voters.
- 45:13500,000 people that you have to reach out to.
- 45:16And even if you just want to reach out just to your own party, that's still a ton of people
- 45:21that you have to reach out to.
- 45:23You can't possibly talk to all of them and hear everybody's concerns.
- 45:28And even though not everybody is looking to contact their member of Congress, even if they
- 45:32generally support that member of Congress, they're not necessarily trying to always
- 45:35contact them.
- 45:37Enough people will try to get ahold of their member of Congress that it's basically
- 45:42impossible for that member of Congress and their staffs to hear all those constituents.
- 45:49And then for state legislators who have lower compensation than Congress does, smaller
- 45:55staffs, fewer resources to tackle this problem reached out to constituents.
- 45:59This problem is pronounced even more.
- 46:02You can't possibly represent all these people no matter how hard you try to because there's
- 46:07just too many of them.
- 46:08And the population is only going to get larger, so the problem is only going to get bigger.
- 46:12Now, I'm not trying to necessarily say that I agree or disagree with this idea of expanding
- 46:18the US House, but it is something that does need to be addressed.
- 46:22It is a very big problem that we are facing right now for representation in government.
- 46:27And speaking of which, it's a really good segue into this final point about the future of the
- 46:33representativeness in government.
- 46:34And just a few final thoughts here.
- 46:36And I think it behooves me to talk about there's a certain level of arrogance that some
- 46:44people have that they think they speak for the
- 46:48American people.
- 46:49Always be aware of people who act like they speak for the American people or at least be
- 46:55skeptical of them because there's so many talking heads on Fox News, CNN, MSNBC, One
- 47:01America.
- 47:02I know I used those specific examples, but there are a lot more examples than that.
- 47:07So many of these talking heads on these places that stay they like to say things like, oh,
- 47:13well, know, the American people want blah blah blah.
- 47:16The American people are tired of blah blah blah.
- 47:18And really, it's just a thinly veiled partisan or ideological statement.
- 47:22It's not actually anything that's born from polling.
- 47:26And even if it is born from polling, saying like 54% of people or 55% of people or whatever
- 47:33that agree with this thing and saying that, extrapolating that to the entire American
- 47:37population is absurd.
- 47:40But America is a very eclectic population with many different policy views, as it should be.
- 47:46We keep treating we
- 47:48really just want to treat things as monoliths when they're not.
- 47:52There's a whole lot more variety to people than we want to give them credit for.
- 47:58Now, the core of what people want is largely the same though, and that's something we should
- 48:04be more cognizant of.
- 48:06Things like the importance of respect.
- 48:08They want a good economy.
- 48:10They want safety.
- 48:11They want freedom and so on.
- 48:13This is what the supposed proclamations of what Americans want should actually focus on, not
- 48:18these polarized or politicized statements that you hear.
- 48:25So this drives me crazy just to bring this back to the whole idea of representativeness.
- 48:30A lot of these people think that they themselves represent America.
- 48:36No.
- 48:36They they represent their own slice of America that they want to listen to, and they don't try
- 48:41to listen to anybody else.
- 48:43And that is a very big problem that we have in this nation.
- 48:47You can't just not listen to other people and try to act like you're representing everybody,
- 48:54that you're being a true representative of your government or of your population, no matter how
- 49:02heavy that district leans towards one party or another, you're never gonna be truly
- 49:08representative of your district.
- 49:12And so when we talk about how to improve representativeness in our government, because I
- 49:17think most of us can agree that we should be improving our representativeness in government,
- 49:22the problem is again, how do we
- 49:25do that?
- 49:26So some of
- 49:27the questions to ask ourselves is which types of representativeness are important?
- 49:32We talked about partisan and ideological and racial and gender, and some people didn't even
- 49:40get to talk about this one.
- 49:43They really care about the career backgrounds of Congress.
- 49:47Back in the day, it used to be the vast majority of them were lawyers or they were in
- 49:52public service already.
- 49:54Today, you have a wide, wide range of occupational backgrounds of these legislators
- 50:00in congress and and state legislatures.
- 50:03Things like teachers and firefighters, police officers, activists, musicians, actors, all
- 50:10sorts of different kinds of candidates from all sorts of different backgrounds.
- 50:15A lot of people also care about that kind of representativeness because they want people who
- 50:19have lived similar experiences to them.
- 50:23Military veterans has always been a very popular choice as well, not not just recently,
- 50:28but even back in the day.
- 50:29So a lot of times it was just military veterans and politics and existing politicians and
- 50:36lawyers way back when, but now you see a lot more kinds of people.
- 50:40So which of these types of representativeness are important and how important should they be?
- 50:46Because there are some that we're gonna place more of an emphasis on than others.
- 50:51But then how should we incentivize these kinds of representativeness?
- 50:55We can't force them.
- 50:56You can't force a law that says the partisan makeup, the ideological makeup, the racial,
- 51:03gender, career makeup, whatever needs to be exactly like the rest of the population that
- 51:10they represent.
- 51:10So Congress needs to look like the nation.
- 51:12Each state needs to look like the state's electorate.
- 51:16You can't force that, but is there some way that you can incentivize it?
- 51:20Maybe we need to find more varied candidates to run for public office.
- 51:26There are a lot
- 51:26of groups that work towards that end.
- 51:29So it's one thing to say that we need to
- 51:31be more representative, but how do we make that happen and how should we incentivize it without
- 51:37trying to brute force it?
- 51:39Because if you try to brute force it, a lot of people are going to push back on that.
- 51:43And then lastly, because sometimes people like to poo poo other people that have different
- 51:51political views on them for all sorts of different things, but even if people aren't
- 51:55necessarily quote unquote, right about not feeling represented, if you think that their
- 52:03arguments are unjustified or whatever, the fact that they still feel that way matters because
- 52:11there is a lot of disenchantment and disengagement and lack of feeling represented
- 52:19by government that we see today.
- 52:22A lot of disaffected people, people not feeling like government is listening to them can, will,
- 52:29and has led to lashing out against government and other citizens in violent manners.
- 52:37And it's happening more and more often, and it's getting a lot more attention.
- 52:43You you talk about, for example, what happened with Charlie Kirk on the Republican side or on
- 52:49the Democratic side, Melissa Hartman.
- 52:52Those might not have necessarily been directly tied to not feeling represented, but it's
- 52:57something that does happen from people who don't feel represented.
- 53:02They don't feel like the government listens to them.
- 53:04How many times have people tried to, you know, make a statement basically.
- 53:09Now, of course, obviously, that doesn't mean that their actions are correct, that they're
- 53:13justified and violence is never justified.
- 53:15But if you let these feelings of not feeling representative fester, it could lead to more
- 53:23and more situations like that.
- 53:26And even though you might feel represented by government, there's always gonna be somebody
- 53:31who doesn't, and they might have a point.
- 53:34Maybe they don't ever get to feel like government is ever listening to them.
- 53:39And sometimes they might be right.
- 53:42Just because you win an election doesn't mean you don't owe anything to the losers of the
- 53:49election.
- 53:49A lot of times people feel like they don't owe anything to the losers in election.
- 53:54But if we constantly feel like that, we're just gonna keep dealing retribution to each other
- 54:00whenever the pendulum swings and the quote unquote other side wins.
- 54:05Then they're gonna try to exact vengeance on other people for not listening to them.
- 54:11And then it's just gonna keep going back and forth, back and forth.
- 54:14And that's not how you get a representative
- 54:15government.
- 54:17So, of course, obviously a lot of this starts with our government specifically
- 54:24because they're the ones who ultimately have to be more representative of us and not care about
- 54:29their own careers, but that's a lot easier said than done.
- 54:34There is some level of responsibility that we as voters have to take as well.
- 54:39We have to make governments be more representative of us.
- 54:45Again, not through violent means, through peaceful, legal, electoral means.
- 54:51And we also have to be willing to not be so obsessed with this twisted notion we have of
- 54:58winning where we have to win everything at all costs.
- 55:02That also hinders representativeness of government because we're gonna feel like we're
- 55:08being represented, but there's a large chunk of the population that's not gonna feel that way.
- 55:13And when you see much more cooperation between people and everybody feels like they're getting
- 55:19a little bit of
- 55:19something out of this, you're gonna
- 55:22see a lot more people feel represented and you're gonna see a lot more of a responsive
- 55:26government, a lot more of a representative government.
- 55:30And that's gonna end things here for the podcast for today's episode.
- 55:35Thank you all so much for listening.
- 55:36Please like, comment, share, on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and then if this
- 55:42expands out to other places in the future, please spread the word about this podcast and
- 55:50what it's trying to do, trying to take a different route on all these political topics
- 55:57and give a unique angle to things, try to touch on things in a manner that people may not have
- 56:03thought of.
- 56:04And it is impartial a manner as I try to be as impartial as I can.
- 56:08Can't ever be fully 100% impartial, but certainly try to be as unbiased as possible.
- 56:16So thank you so much for listening.
- 56:18My links in the show notes, Facebook, LinkedIn, medium.com.
- 56:22I'm start running on Substack soon.
- 56:24Websites, Paul Raider dot org.
- 56:26My email, PaulRaiderwrites@Gmail.com.
- 56:29And my five day educational email course about how to more effectively tackle and decrease
- 56:36polarization in this country because a lot of the ways that we try to decrease polarization
- 56:41is not only ineffective, but sometimes has the opposite effect.
- 56:45So please check that out.
- 56:46It's free.
- 56:47Just a little sign up for five days.
- 56:49And that is, I believe, everything.
- 56:51So thank you all
- 56:52so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.