Latest / Defender Radio and The Switch / Why I Left The Fur Industry with Mike Moser
Transcript
- 0:00[Michael Howie] This is Defender Radio.
- 0:07[Michael Howie] I'm Michael Howie, and this is Defender Radio, the podcast for wildlife advocates and animal lovers, brought to you by The Fur-Bearers.
- 0:15[Michael Howie] For more than a decade, Mike Moser was one of the people defending the international fur industry.
- 0:21[Michael Howie] As a senior director with the International Fur Federation, and later CEO of the British Fur Trade Association,
- 0:28[Michael Howie] Moser visited fur farms around the world, evaluated animal welfare standards, and defended the industry to politicians, journalists, and the public.
- 0:38[Michael Howie] But over time, what he saw on those farms began to challenge what he believed about animal welfare.
- 0:45[Michael Howie] In 2018, he resigned from the industry and today works with Humane World for Animals, campaigning to end fur farming and the fur trade.
- 0:54[Michael Howie] What changed his mind, and what can someone who spent more than a decade inside the industry tell us about its practices, its public messaging, and its future?
- 1:04[Michael Howie] Mike Moser joins us to discuss his journey from industry defender to animal advocate, the realities of fur farming, and what it might take to bring the industry to an end.
- 1:14[Michael Howie] I think to start out, it would be interesting, we were talking before we started the recording, a bit about your history, and while a lot of people, I think, in fur farming grow up in that kind of an agricultural space, or it's part of their family tradition, or community tradition, you didn't necessarily start in fur.
- 1:31[Michael Howie] Could you share a bit about your path towards working with the International Fur Federation?
- 1:37[Mike Moser] It's 18 years, it's quite remarkable, just the other day I was thinking this, it's 18 years the fur industry has been part of my life, a big part of my life.
- 1:46[Mike Moser] For 11 of those years, I was a senior director for the International Fur Federation, and also for the British fur trade.
- 1:55[Mike Moser] I held various senior levels there, and I can go back 18 years to that time I got the phone call from a headhunter.
- 2:07[Mike Moser] I'd been working on a short-term communications contract with the local government, and that'd come to an end, and I had a little bit of time, and I got a call.
- 2:16[Mike Moser] And the voice said, hello, Michael, I've seen your details, I've got an opportunity I think you might be interested in.
- 2:24[Mike Moser] I said, okay, please tell me more.
- 2:27[Mike Moser] It's to do with internal communications, which is something I'd specialised in previously.
- 2:32[Mike Moser] And they started to elaborate, but they didn't tell me who it was with.
- 2:37[Mike Moser] Naturally, I said, oh, this sounds interesting, who's it with?
- 2:40[Mike Moser] And they kind of swerved on that one, carried on talking, really, this is a fantastic opportunity, you'll be so good as they do.
- 2:49[Mike Moser] Who's it with?
- 2:50[Mike Moser] And for a second time, they swerved.
- 2:52[Mike Moser] And by that point, my interest is getting a little bit piqued here, why aren't you telling me?
- 2:56[Mike Moser] When they came around to actually then say it's with the fur industry, my immediate response was, fur, really?
- 3:05[Mike Moser] That actually became a little bit of a statement for myself, because I thought, well, hold on a second, what do you know about this?
- 3:14[Mike Moser] And I went away, and I undertook what I believe to be due diligence.
- 3:19[Mike Moser] My understanding of fur was very limited, like most people's.
- 3:23[Mike Moser] It was catwalk models and a winter and having red paint thrown over her, that famous incident.
- 3:30[Mike Moser] But other than that, I didn't know much about it.
- 3:32[Mike Moser] So I went and I had science training years ago, in my degree.
- 3:38[Mike Moser] So I went and I sought out some peer-reviewed scientific literature, particularly around welfare.
- 3:44[Mike Moser] I understood that welfare was the main issue as regards the fur industry, the main arguments against it.
- 3:51[Mike Moser] And I sought out and read lots and lots of scientific papers to do with welfare.
- 3:57[Mike Moser] And it intrigued me, because up until then, I'd always felt good welfare basically meant a happy and healthy animal.
- 4:05[Mike Moser] I think most people would feel the same.
- 4:07[Mike Moser] But as I read about this, I saw that, no, you can objectively define and measure animal welfare.
- 4:14[Mike Moser] And that fascinated me.
- 4:16[Mike Moser] And so I looked at the regulations under which the industry was obliged, and still is, to operate.
- 4:23[Mike Moser] And my impression was, it's probably, it's a well-regulated and misunderstood industry.
- 4:29[Mike Moser] And from a communications professional perspective, that looked like a great opportunity.
- 4:34[Mike Moser] I can get out there, present the facts, and look, no people, this is it.
- 4:40[Mike Moser] Fur, really?
- 4:41[Mike Moser] Yeah, really.
- 4:42[Mike Moser] And so that's how I came to join.
- 4:45[Michael Howie] From 2008 to 2015, you're with IFF.
- 4:48[Michael Howie] In 2014, you become CEO of the British Fur Trade Association.
- 4:52[Michael Howie] Through this time, you were visiting fur farms.
- 4:55[Michael Howie] You were traveling internationally.
- 4:56[Michael Howie] Was there anything at that point that was starting to raise the red flags for you?
- 5:01[Michael Howie] Or were you able to maybe sit with the dissonance or change your perception somehow?
- 5:07[Mike Moser] Both.
- 5:08[Mike Moser] Initially, my role was looking at welfare regulations.
- 5:13[Mike Moser] And if I take a step back, I think I'd like to maybe explain.
- 5:20[Mike Moser] There's two fur trades, if you like.
- 5:22[Mike Moser] There's the fur trade, the official one, the structural one, which is comprising businesses
- 5:27[Mike Moser] that belong to national associations, like the Fur Information Canada.
- 5:32[Mike Moser] Then those associations have come together in a federation to form the International Fur Federation.
- 5:39[Mike Moser] And then there's the trade in fur, where it's lots of companies.
- 5:44[Mike Moser] Some belong to these associations, some don't.
- 5:46[Mike Moser] We have some lots of manufacturers out in the Far East making fur trim, key rings, bobble hats.
- 5:53[Mike Moser] And the official trade would say, well, that's nothing to do with us.
- 5:56[Mike Moser] But to the outsider, well, it's one and the same.
- 6:00[Mike Moser] Yeah.
- 6:01[Mike Moser] So let's call it the regulated industry.
- 6:05[Mike Moser] Part of my role was to look at compliance.
- 6:08[Mike Moser] How well are businesses and countries complying with the relevant regulations and industry standards?
- 6:14[Mike Moser] And so it involved my visiting quite a few countries.
- 6:19[Mike Moser] And in my time as director of standards, I saw fur farms across Europe, in Russia, China, even in Namibia.
- 6:30[Mike Moser] And I came out to Canada to go and see some fur farms.
- 6:35[Mike Moser] And they had, and this is rather ominous, but they had an outbreak of something called Aleutian disease.
- 6:41[Mike Moser] And that is a virus which has a catastrophic effect on mink.
- 6:47[Mike Moser] And in all the years I've known the industry, it's never managed to eradicate this virus.
- 6:53[Mike Moser] And that actually is an important fact, because as we'll discuss a bit later on, the fur industry has a very uncomfortable relationship with viral outbreaks.
- 7:03[Mike Moser] I didn't actually get to see the fur farms in Canada.
- 7:07[Mike Moser] What I would say, Mike, is I know exactly what they would look like, because all fur farms all over the world look exactly the same.
- 7:16[Mike Moser] Yeah.
- 7:17[Mike Moser] Thousands upon thousands of tiny wire cages packed together in open sheds and the absolute breeding grounds for disease, for virus.
- 7:29[Mike Moser] They're very dirty places, Michael.
- 7:31[Mike Moser] I'm not sure if people realise, I think I'm right in saying, fur farming is the only on-land carnivore farming industry.
- 7:42[Mike Moser] It has an impact because the smell on these fur farms, because they're carnivores, is overpowering.
- 7:49[Mike Moser] I mean, I'll paint a picture.
- 7:50[Mike Moser] So if you look at one particular cage with foxes, I know it's predominantly mink farming in Canada, but the foxes, these cages can be less than a metre by one metre.
- 8:02[Mike Moser] And the foxes have been specifically bred to get larger and larger, and these foxes are barely smaller than the cage itself.
- 8:09[Mike Moser] It's a bit like putting a terrier, a dog, in a cage for its entire life.
- 8:14[Mike Moser] And these animals can't move freely.
- 8:17[Mike Moser] It's an absolutely terrible place.
- 8:20[Mike Moser] But when I first started to visit the farms, I was persuaded that the scientists who helped devise these regulations and what's called the competent authority in the countries that inspect the farms say this is OK.
- 8:37[Mike Moser] So initially, I thought to myself, well, this must be the case.
- 8:42[Mike Moser] Yeah.
- 8:42[Michael Howie] Yeah.
- 8:43[Michael Howie] And that's in Canada as well.
- 8:45[Michael Howie] The regulations in some provinces exist and some they don't.
- 8:48[Michael Howie] There's not really any federal level ones.
- 8:50[Michael Howie] There are guidelines that people can choose to follow.
- 8:55[Michael Howie] And the other element of that is in agriculture.
- 8:58[Michael Howie] And I'll bastardize this, and I'm sure our legal followers will let me know.
- 9:03[Michael Howie] But effectively, the agricultural industry has a line that says you follow all these practices unless it's considered a best practice within the industry.
- 9:12[Michael Howie] And then that just overrides everything.
- 9:15[Michael Howie] So exactly what you're saying is you have all these animals in tiny cages.
- 9:17[Michael Howie] And if you saw that in a pet store with dogs, it would be an outcry.
- 9:22[Michael Howie] But as soon as you say it's a standard agricultural practice, it just kind of shuts down the conversation.
- 9:28[Mike Moser] The morality of fur farming is wholly inconsistent with the way that we treat any other animal.
- 9:38[Mike Moser] And as I can liken it to domesticated animals, cats or dogs, it's immoral and undoubtedly illegal to keep an animal in a cage, a small cage for its entire life.
- 9:50[Mike Moser] And yet fur farming seems to, or it has up to now, enjoyed a special license to be able to abuse these animals.
- 10:01[Mike Moser] So, yes, I think every fur farm in the world is exactly the same.
- 10:06[Mike Moser] I was frequently being asked, you know, did you see any bad farms?
- 10:11[Mike Moser] Well, most of the farms I saw probably would be considered well run.
- 10:16[Mike Moser] But that only means that they ran according to the regulations.
- 10:22[Mike Moser] And as I've already said, that meant that these animals are in tiny wire cages, unable to exhibit what we call natural behaviours.
- 10:31[Mike Moser] Minks swim.
- 10:32[Mike Moser] They hunt.
- 10:34[Mike Moser] They explore.
- 10:36[Mike Moser] They can't do this in tiny wire cages.
- 10:39[Mike Moser] They've got padded feet, padded webbed feet.
- 10:41[Mike Moser] They're standing on tiny wire floors.
- 10:44[Mike Moser] They've got to have wire floors.
- 10:45[Mike Moser] People say to me, why do I have to have wire cages?
- 10:47[Mike Moser] Because their feces fall through onto the floor.
- 10:52[Mike Moser] That's an essential part.
- 10:53[Mike Moser] That's the systemic cruelty within the fur farming methodology.
- 10:58[Mike Moser] Yeah.
- 10:59[Mike Moser] Why does it continue this way?
- 11:01[Mike Moser] Because fur farming model is predicated on the need for intensive farming practices, where you have thousands of cages on what is a relatively small footprint of a farm.
- 11:13[Mike Moser] If they were forced to have enclosures, let's just say, which would still be cruel, fur farming, which is not profitable today anyway, would be catastrophic.
- 11:22[Mike Moser] They'd close overnight.
- 11:23[Mike Moser] So, it's systemic.
- 11:25[Mike Moser] It's absolutely inbred into the fur farming methodology, the need for these cages.
- 11:30[Mike Moser] Therefore, that's why I can confidently say they are systemically cruel.
- 11:37[Michael Howie] And I find it curious, as you were exploring these, as you're being asked to check compliance, you're clearly, you're building this worldview that ultimately tells you this isn't acceptable.
- 11:52[Michael Howie] But it was shortly after a parliamentary committee, which I don't necessarily think you, I'll let you explain a bit about that.
- 11:59[Michael Howie] But it was an inquiry into fur mislabeling and the overall fur trade.
- 12:03[Michael Howie] And shortly after that, you stepped away as CEO from BFTA after trying to defend the industry.
- 12:12[Michael Howie] What happened for you sort of between, and I'm asking you to compress several years here.
- 12:18[Michael Howie] I recognize that.
- 12:19[Michael Howie] But effectively going from supporting, trying to make it work, trying to get it better, defending the industry to saying, I can't anymore.
- 12:29[Mike Moser] There were two things, Mark.
- 12:32[Mike Moser] There was both a slow realization that something wasn't right.
- 12:38[Mike Moser] And if you like the empirical data, what I was seeing for myself wasn't matching the theory of the regulations.
- 12:46[Mike Moser] My initial presumption that the regulations said these animals could be farmed in this way didn't match what I was seeing.
- 12:56[Mike Moser] And the inconsistency of looking at animals on a farm and then coming home and looking at my dog, it just wasn't right.
- 13:06[Mike Moser] As a communications professional, yes, I could and I did still go out there to defend the industry.
- 13:13[Mike Moser] Famously, I guess, you know, one of the more difficult ones was, I think it was the meeting that you just pointed at.
- 13:22[Mike Moser] It was what's called a select committee that had been held by Parliament because there had been some accusations of misselling, where some real fur had been found on some items that were allegedly fake fur.
- 13:38[Mike Moser] And so they had this political inquiry.
- 13:42[Mike Moser] And I went along and I represented the industry.
- 13:44[Mike Moser] And it was difficult.
- 13:45[Mike Moser] There was a group of MPs there and there was lots of grilling.
- 13:48[Mike Moser] But I was confident in what I believe to be the facts.
- 13:52[Mike Moser] And as it turned out, we got what I think the industry would have considered to be a good result.
- 13:57[Mike Moser] But I'd actually, at that point, I would have resigned.
- 14:00[Mike Moser] Not many people know this, but I'd actually already resigned.
- 14:02[Mike Moser] And I said to the industry, look, I will, I will, as I'm committed, and while I still work for you, I will be the consummate professional.
- 14:09[Mike Moser] I will get you through this.
- 14:11[Mike Moser] And after that, that's when I'm leaving.
- 14:13[Mike Moser] So it was a slow, gradual realisation that it's simply not right to see these animals in cages.
- 14:21[Mike Moser] But there was one particular visit to a fox farm.
- 14:26[Mike Moser] And there were thousands of foxes.
- 14:27[Mike Moser] It's difficult seeing mink, Mike, but it's even more difficult with foxes because they're bigger, but the cages aren't that much.
- 14:34[Mike Moser] And, of course, you know, they are, we see them in our back gardens.
- 14:38[Mike Moser] We see foxes playing on trampolines and playing with footballs.
- 14:43[Mike Moser] And they look like our dogs.
- 14:45[Mike Moser] So it's even more difficult.
- 14:47[Mike Moser] And I'd seen on one farm thousands of foxes, but one particular fox was curled up because its cage was so small.
- 14:55[Mike Moser] And as I approached it, it didn't even stand up.
- 14:58[Mike Moser] It barely lifted its head.
- 15:00[Mike Moser] And it really was a terrible moment for me.
- 15:04[Mike Moser] The animal was broken.
- 15:06[Mike Moser] It was spiritually broken.
- 15:08[Mike Moser] And I guess I've asked myself many times, had you not seen this in other animals before?
- 15:14[Mike Moser] And I think you hit the term perfectly before, dissonance.
- 15:18[Mike Moser] And it's almost like I didn't quite see what I was seeing.
- 15:22[Mike Moser] But that one animal was so clearly broken.
- 15:25[Mike Moser] It was aware, Mike.
- 15:27[Mike Moser] It was aware of its surroundings.
- 15:28[Mike Moser] And that sentience took my breath away.
- 15:32[Mike Moser] I came home and I was sitting in my kitchen and I was telling my wife, Sophie, about this.
- 15:37[Mike Moser] And our Labrador was sitting next to me, Barney.
- 15:41[Mike Moser] And he looked at me in much the same way as that fox.
- 15:45[Mike Moser] And it really was that moment, almost an epiphany, saying, hold on, how can I go out there and say it's OK for the fox?
- 15:53[Mike Moser] But don't you dare inflict that sort of cruelty on my dog?
- 15:57[Mike Moser] And it really was a moment of awareness, of the hypocrisy.
- 16:02[Mike Moser] And literally the next day I resigned.
- 16:04[Mike Moser] I went in the next day.
- 16:05[Mike Moser] I said to my wife, I cannot do this anymore.
- 16:07[Mike Moser] And literally the next day I resigned.
- 16:10[Michael Howie] Wow.
- 16:10[Michael Howie] It's a telling moment.
- 16:12[Michael Howie] And it's one I've heard from others as well, both within and not within the industry, of having that kind of encounter.
- 16:19[Michael Howie] And it just opens your soul up in a way that you didn't know was possible sometimes.
- 16:25[Michael Howie] And I think that's something that we need more of, but it's not necessarily something you can force upon people.
- 16:32[Michael Howie] That ability to say, hey, really open yourself up for a minute and let yourself feel what this is and then allow that to guide you.
- 16:44[Mike Moser] I've thought about this so much.
- 16:47[Mike Moser] So much.
- 16:49[Mike Moser] And I guess it's what I might call the transition stage from taking a cerebral professional approach to communications, developing the messages, confidently standing, whether it's in front of a rather feral group of MPs and peers in the House of Lords.
- 17:08[Mike Moser] And it was the all-party parliamentary group.
- 17:10[Mike Moser] And they went for me.
- 17:12[Mike Moser] I accepted the invitation to go and defend the industry.
- 17:16[Mike Moser] And they went for me.
- 17:17[Mike Moser] I held my own.
- 17:18[Mike Moser] And in a small part of me, I rather enjoyed the pugilism.
- 17:25[Mike Moser] And then when I look back now, and I think, but you weren't inured to what you were seeing.
- 17:31[Mike Moser] I think part of it is maybe it's a little bit like being standing really close to a cliff face, and you see a small little crack, and you think, my word, that's a fissure.
- 17:46[Mike Moser] And as you take a step back, all of a sudden, you know, your contrast is changing.
- 17:50[Mike Moser] And you step back, and you step back, and after a while, you just think that tiny little crack is insignificant.
- 17:55[Mike Moser] Well, look at the size of the cliff.
- 17:58[Mike Moser] And certainly, as I've been away looking back now at that transition, my context and the contrasts of how I felt then has changed dramatically.
- 18:06[Mike Moser] During that transition, it was an increasing awareness of my discomfort in what I was seeing, in being the defender.
- 18:18[Mike Moser] I know that my family and my friends were fascinated in what I was doing.
- 18:25[Mike Moser] And certainly, in a dinner party situation, if somebody had not met me before, and they would say, well, what do you do?
- 18:32[Mike Moser] Fur? Really?
- 18:34[Mike Moser] And I would, you know, they'd wind me up, and off I'd go.
- 18:38[Mike Moser] So I could easily do this.
- 18:40[Mike Moser] But nobody was rude enough to say to me, what are you doing?
- 18:46[Mike Moser] What are you doing?
- 18:47[Mike Moser] I mean, really?
- 18:49[Mike Moser] Afterwards, when I was telling people I was leaving, 100% of family and friends said to me, you know, wow, great.
- 18:59[Mike Moser] I'm so, so pleased to hear this.
- 19:01[Mike Moser] They've actually already been rather kind to me.
- 19:04[Michael Howie] Well, it's nice to know that you had the support of your family and your friends in that community.
- 19:10[Michael Howie] I am curious, you worked alongside a lot of the folks in the fur industry for many years.
- 19:16[Michael Howie] What happened with those relationships?
- 19:18[Michael Howie] Was there any upset pressure?
- 19:21[Michael Howie] Was there any comeuppance tried as a result of you deciding to step away?
- 19:28[Mike Moser] Not stepping away.
- 19:31[Mike Moser] When I left, Mike, I didn't leave because I had any acrimony.
- 19:36[Mike Moser] I didn't feel any acrimony towards the industry.
- 19:39[Mike Moser] The industry is not populated by bad, evil people.
- 19:42[Mike Moser] I mean, that's something that's really important to get across.
- 19:44[Mike Moser] I met at one end of the supply chain.
- 19:47[Mike Moser] Let's talk at the manufacturing end.
- 19:49[Mike Moser] People that had the most remarkable tailoring skills, fur handling skills.
- 19:55[Mike Moser] I met an 86-year-old fur cutter, and he was using a pair of scissors that were 150 years old.
- 20:02[Mike Moser] Honestly, just remarkable.
- 20:05[Mike Moser] And, of course, it's got a lot of history, the fur industry, of immigration in Europe particularly.
- 20:11[Mike Moser] A lot of people who fled persecution in Germany took their fur skills, first of all, to London, and then further on to other countries.
- 20:20[Mike Moser] So the history of the industry was fascinating.
- 20:23[Mike Moser] And then at the other end, at the farming end, fur farmers are very proud of what they do.
- 20:28[Mike Moser] But they don't see what they do through the eyes of outsiders.
- 20:32[Mike Moser] I think there's a little bit of what we used to call in the UK, there's a football team called Millwall.
- 20:40[Mike Moser] And their claim from their fans is, nobody likes us and we don't care.
- 20:48[Mike Moser] I think the fur industry was quite a bit like that as well.
- 20:52[Mike Moser] So when I told people, look, I'd lost my conviction, that's the reason why I'm leaving.
- 20:56[Mike Moser] It was a shock because I had been in the industry, quite a high profile in the industry.
- 21:01[Mike Moser] But hey-ho, you know, these things happen.
- 21:04[Mike Moser] I didn't immediately decide to campaign against it.
- 21:08[Mike Moser] I left just because I couldn't defend it anymore.
- 21:12[Mike Moser] And it was about six months when I spent a period of reflection.
- 21:18[Mike Moser] One of my main debating adversaries had been the Humane World for Animals, or Humane Society, as it was called then.
- 21:26[Mike Moser] And we had locked horns in Westminster, on live television, in radio.
- 21:33[Mike Moser] And one particular person, Claire Bass, who was the executive director.
- 21:37[Mike Moser] And it was always quite respectful.
- 21:41[Mike Moser] And increasingly, I would listen to her messages and I would try to use my prediction of what she was going to say in order to get my answers.
- 21:52[Mike Moser] But increasingly, I believed more and more of what she was saying.
- 21:56[Mike Moser] And that was a big part of my deciding to leave.
- 22:00[Mike Moser] But after a few months, Claire and I met up and had a coffee.
- 22:05[Mike Moser] And she said to me, would you consider, I'm so pleased that you've left and you're no longer defending the indefensible.
- 22:12[Mike Moser] Would you consider coming to campaign on our behalf?
- 22:16[Mike Moser] And I wasn't quite ready then, because I didn't want people to think that I was leaving the industry and then turning around to attack it.
- 22:25[Mike Moser] So I said, look, Claire, not at the moment.
- 22:26[Mike Moser] Just give me some time to think about this.
- 22:29[Mike Moser] And after a few months, I thought my feelings have changed considerably.
- 22:33[Mike Moser] Being further away from the cliff face, seeing the context through the eyes of the greater society, I realized just how wrong the industry was.
- 22:43[Mike Moser] And I wanted to play a part in communicating what I believe to be reasons why the industry should lose its moral and legal license to operate.
- 22:55[Mike Moser] And so I joined, I accepted their offer to campaign with them.
- 23:00[Mike Moser] And now I provide some consultancy services to them.
- 23:03[Mike Moser] And I'm happy to explain to anybody that wants to listen why the industry has had its day.
- 23:09[Mike Moser] Its farming methodologies belong, not even in the last century, the century before.
- 23:15[Mike Moser] It's a product that nobody needs.
- 23:18[Mike Moser] Man-made fabrics.
- 23:19[Mike Moser] I've been on a mine site in northern Canada, actually, Mike, where it was close to minus 40.
- 23:25[Mike Moser] I didn't see anybody wearing fur.
- 23:27[Mike Moser] They've got man-made fabrics.
- 23:29[Mike Moser] I've got far greater thermal insulating capacity.
- 23:34[Mike Moser] So there's no necessity value.
- 23:36[Mike Moser] It's purely for vanity.
- 23:37[Mike Moser] And there's no reason today to abuse animals for a product that nobody needs.
- 23:42[Michael Howie] And I think more and more people are agreeing with that.
- 23:44[Michael Howie] We see polling in Canada.
- 23:46[Michael Howie] Over 70% of Canadians do not support killing an animal for their fur.
- 23:51[Michael Howie] I think internationally we're seeing huge movements.
- 23:54[Michael Howie] Over 20 countries have banned or are in the process of banning fur.
- 23:58[Michael Howie] There's a massive European Commission news story that I've had in my little process timeline of this story's coming for about four months.
- 24:07[Michael Howie] But it's coming.
- 24:08[Michael Howie] We're looking forward to that.
- 24:10[Michael Howie] And I think it's interesting because the fur industry keeps trying to sort of revive itself and defend itself and say it's necessary, it's better.
- 24:18[Michael Howie] What are some of the other messaging that the fur industry is using that you think is working on the public that we should be paying more attention to?
- 24:29[Mike Moser] What are the core messages?
- 24:31[Mike Moser] They would always say that tradition.
- 24:35[Mike Moser] We carry traditional skills and we don't want to lose those.
- 24:40[Mike Moser] Businesses that have been handed down from parent to child, we should be able to protect this.
- 24:45[Mike Moser] But of course, these days, there's very few children wanting to inherit fur businesses.
- 24:51[Mike Moser] So we should say that.
- 24:52[Mike Moser] They talk about sustainability.
- 24:55[Mike Moser] That's a key one.
- 24:57[Mike Moser] Well, look, synthetic fibers are catastrophic, environmentally speaking.
- 25:04[Mike Moser] Therefore, fake fur is bad.
- 25:05[Mike Moser] Therefore, you must use natural fur without forgetting to say, but it's not a binary choice, guys.
- 25:11[Mike Moser] Until such time that you've got environmentally friendly synthetic fur, don't use either.
- 25:18[Mike Moser] They'll talk about economy.
- 25:22[Mike Moser] But there's been recently some quite fantastic economic triage reports looking at the full cost analysis of the fur farming in Europe.
- 25:31[Mike Moser] And it costs the European Union 445 million euros a year to keep the fur farming industry going.
- 25:47[Mike Moser] If you take into account the environmental impact and the health impact of fur farming, 445 million euro loss a year.
- 25:56[Michael Howie] That's a whole lot of money.
- 25:58[Mike Moser] So, yeah, other reasons.
- 26:00[Mike Moser] And this is this is the latest one.
- 26:03[Mike Moser] Certification.
- 26:04[Mike Moser] Yes.
- 26:05[Mike Moser] We could have certified fur.
- 26:08[Mike Moser] And what does certified fur mean?
- 26:10[Mike Moser] Well, it means that when you see a particular icon on a label, you know that that fur can be traced back to.
- 26:21[Mike Moser] A tiny wire cage.
- 26:22[Mike Moser] Hey, guys, what's different there?
- 26:25[Mike Moser] So that's all certification is.
- 26:27[Mike Moser] It's a gold star for tracing back to the same tiny wire cage that uncertified fur comes from.
- 26:36[Mike Moser] So as far as the animal is concerned, that mink in that cage on that Canadian farm, it makes no difference if that farm is certified or if that farm is not certified.
- 26:48[Mike Moser] To the animal, it's exactly the same.
- 26:49[Michael Howie] I think that's a very difficult point for the public at times, too, because we have been taught to listen for a lot of key terms.
- 26:57[Michael Howie] So that idea of, oh, it's sustainable.
- 26:59[Michael Howie] Oh, we've got welfare standards.
- 27:01[Michael Howie] So don't worry about it.
- 27:03[Michael Howie] But then, as you note, as soon as you start to worry about it, as soon as you start to ask uncomfortable questions, most of the responses end up being old science without ethics approval or really talking points.
- 27:16[Michael Howie] As opposed to actual ethical arguments, morality arguments or science that proves welfare.
- 27:23[Michael Howie] And I think that's another element of this that's fascinating is talking about the science behind the diseases.
- 27:29[Michael Howie] As you noted earlier, in Utah, in the last couple of weeks, we're at the end of October right now.
- 27:34[Michael Howie] There has been a massive outbreak of avian influenza, H5N1, which is a very concerning disease.
- 27:42[Michael Howie] And I believe, and I will double check this, that they had said it hasn't necessarily transferred between people yet.
- 27:49[Michael Howie] But on a mink farm, internationally, experts are saying, why haven't we shut it down?
- 27:55[Michael Howie] Why is it not a complete cull?
- 27:56[Michael Howie] Like, in every other industry, when something like this happens, there is a definitive huge response.
- 28:03[Michael Howie] On the mink farm, they're waiting and seeing, it seems.
- 28:07[Mike Moser] We've seen countless times the impact of avian flu, certainly in the UK and undoubtedly across Europe and in the world.
- 28:14[Mike Moser] And even if it doesn't migrate into human form, the impact, for example, on poultry farms is huge.
- 28:25[Mike Moser] Do we want to see another outbreak of that?
- 28:28[Mike Moser] Well, we don't.
- 28:29[Mike Moser] And one of the reasons why they are hotbeds for these viral outbreaks, the faeces, in my experience of visiting loads of farms, the faeces drop through the bottom of the cage.
- 28:45[Mike Moser] They have to.
- 28:46[Mike Moser] And they end up as a pile.
- 28:48[Mike Moser] Now, I remember asking one farm, because this particular farm, it was awful.
- 28:53[Mike Moser] The smell was awful and the sight was awful.
- 28:55[Mike Moser] And you can imagine there's thousands of cages.
- 28:58[Mike Moser] And I said to the farmer, because he was crawling with vermin, all these faeces, and I said to him, how often does that get cleared up?
- 29:06[Mike Moser] And he just shrugged.
- 29:07[Mike Moser] He literally just shrugged at me.
- 29:10[Mike Moser] So is it cleared up daily?
- 29:13[Mike Moser] I doubt it very much.
- 29:14[Mike Moser] But those are breeding, absolute breeding grounds for all sorts of vermin and disease.
- 29:21[Mike Moser] And the close proximity of the animals to each other means if there's one animal gets ill, it spreads throughout.
- 29:27[Mike Moser] So, and they're close to local communities.
- 29:30[Mike Moser] Who wants to live close to a fur farm?
- 29:33[Mike Moser] I mean, it's...
- 29:35[Mike Moser] So, morality, ethics, very, very complex field.
- 29:41[Mike Moser] But I would say to the listeners, Mike, let's strip this down to the bare minimum.
- 29:46[Mike Moser] If you take a cage the size of a mink cage or a fox cage on a fur farm, would you keep your cat or your dog or any of your pets in that cage for its entire life?
- 29:59[Mike Moser] The answer is no.
- 30:01[Mike Moser] So why is it okay for a fox or a mink or a raccoon dog or chinchilla or any other fur-bearing animal?
- 30:09[Mike Moser] Yeah.
- 30:09[Mike Moser] And that, to me, is a very simple, ethical question to ask.
- 30:12[Michael Howie] And it's interesting because I don't often hear a direct response to that.
- 30:15[Michael Howie] It often ends up being a, yeah, well, or a straw man, effectively, in response.
- 30:21[Michael Howie] And as we're talking about this, one of the biggest threats to the fur industry right now, I think, is disease spread, pandemic threats.
- 30:29[Michael Howie] It's been very well discussed and documented by experts.
- 30:33[Michael Howie] But where do you see, or what do you see happening for the global fur industry in the next five or ten years?
- 30:40[Mike Moser] At some point in the future, Mike, there is no question.
- 30:44[Mike Moser] This is with 100% certainty.
- 30:47[Mike Moser] At some point in the future, there will be no more fur farming.
- 30:51[Mike Moser] The question is, when is that date going to happen?
- 30:56[Mike Moser] And obviously, that's going to go by country.
- 30:57[Mike Moser] And as you've pointed out, already, there are 24 countries that have already banned fur farming.
- 31:03[Mike Moser] In Europe, there's Finland and there's Greece.
- 31:06[Mike Moser] There's a little bit still going on in Spain.
- 31:09[Mike Moser] But at some point, fur farming will end in Europe.
- 31:14[Mike Moser] We're seeing that the demand for fur has just plummeted.
- 31:21[Mike Moser] You rarely see it on catwalks.
- 31:24[Mike Moser] Most of the major fur fashion weeks, I think Paris still allows it.
- 31:29[Mike Moser] Milan have started to limit it.
- 31:31[Mike Moser] The others tend to frown on it.
- 31:34[Mike Moser] Maybe New York still allows it.
- 31:35[Mike Moser] I'm not sure about that.
- 31:36[Mike Moser] But certainly, the big couture labels are rejecting it.
- 31:41[Mike Moser] Certainly, in all the major capital cities I've visited across Europe, it's almost impossible to see a fur shop.
- 31:48[Mike Moser] What little fur is sold is sold through fashion shops, where it's a little bit of a mix.
- 31:53[Mike Moser] Fur sales, auctions have been plummeting.
- 31:56[Mike Moser] The auction houses have closed.
- 31:57[Mike Moser] There used to be four major auction houses.
- 32:00[Mike Moser] Of course, NAFA in Canada.
- 32:02[Mike Moser] They've closed.
- 32:03[Mike Moser] There's only one major one left, and that's in Helsinki.
- 32:07[Mike Moser] So all the metrics point to an industry that is in a terminal decline.
- 32:13[Mike Moser] The price of fur auction has dropped, I think, I don't know, is it at the moment, maybe $24 a pelt.
- 32:20[Mike Moser] In most cases, it's below cost.
- 32:23[Mike Moser] They only keep going because of subsidies.
- 32:25[Mike Moser] So the future is dim, and it's going to stop.
- 32:29[Mike Moser] The question I can't answer in my own head is, why is it taking so long for the politicians to react and respond to the public?
- 32:39[Mike Moser] It's quite clear with survey after survey that there is no appetite and no support for fur farming or the fur industry more general.
- 32:49[Mike Moser] Yet the political inertia is puzzling.
- 32:56[Mike Moser] If we take the UK, it's a classic example.
- 32:59[Mike Moser] We banned fur farming in the year 2000.
- 33:02[Mike Moser] The last fur farm closed in 2003.
- 33:05[Mike Moser] Yet 23 years later, we still allow the continuing importation and trade in fur.
- 33:12[Mike Moser] That political hypocrisy is really quite startling.
- 33:16[Mike Moser] We don't want it produced here, but we will support it being produced somewhere else.
- 33:22[Mike Moser] That inconsistency at some point will stop.
- 33:26[Mike Moser] So what I ask people to think, I don't know if you've got this show in Canada, Mike.
- 33:31[Mike Moser] There's a show in the UK called It Was All Right in the 70s.
- 33:36[Mike Moser] And it's rather comical and a bit shocking.
- 33:39[Mike Moser] Basically, they look back to the 1970s and they look at some of the TV programs or some of the adverts.
- 33:46[Mike Moser] And you look back and you think, my word, no, you said that.
- 33:51[Mike Moser] You thought that was funny?
- 33:54[Mike Moser] Because that's how society has changed.
- 33:57[Mike Moser] I think there's one in the 1980s as well.
- 33:59[Mike Moser] At some point in the not too distant future, they'll look back at the 2010s and the 2020s and they'll say, politicians, you had the chance to take action and you did nothing.
- 34:11[Mike Moser] Why?
- 34:11[Mike Moser] Why did you say it was OK to allow this to continue?
- 34:15[Mike Moser] So that's what I would say to politicians that I meet today.
- 34:17[Mike Moser] You have a chance today to listen to the public and make a decision.
- 34:23[Mike Moser] What is it that is stopping you from doing it?
- 34:25[Mike Moser] It's not economics.
- 34:26[Mike Moser] It's not employment.
- 34:28[Mike Moser] It's not this.
- 34:30[Mike Moser] I can't see why, other than we don't like banning things.
- 34:35[Michael Howie] And I think that's a real political truth that they're not going to say outright at times.
- 34:40[Michael Howie] I completely agree.
- 34:41[Michael Howie] I think it's unpopular to say, well, you can't do that anymore.
- 34:45[Michael Howie] But there are also some great success stories, and we're working on sharing a few in the near future, of fur farmers transitioning into new careers with a little bit of help.
- 34:55[Michael Howie] We've seen strawberry farms, breweries, bakeries, like people who are producing something valuable for their community, in their community, and profiting from it.
- 35:05[Michael Howie] So to me, it does seem like there are ways forward.
- 35:09[Michael Howie] Do you think transitions are going to be part of that?
- 35:11[Michael Howie] And what's a fair transition for a fur farmer?
- 35:15[Mike Moser] I'm not an agricultural specialist by any stretch of the imagination, Mark.
- 35:19[Mike Moser] Look, I guess, yes, it's important to support transitions, and you don't simply take away somebody's livelihood brutally.
- 35:32[Mike Moser] And that's why there generally is phase-out periods.
- 35:36[Mike Moser] And in some cases, it could be seven, eight, nine, ten years.
- 35:40[Mike Moser] Compensation is taken, and the farm's got a chance to transition or to close.
- 35:46[Mike Moser] That's an economic discussion to be had.
- 35:54[Mike Moser] Something strikes me, and that is, it wasn't that long ago that the trade in ivory was deemed acceptable.
- 36:02[Mike Moser] And we look back now with horror that animals could be killed solely for a product that nobody needed.
- 36:11[Mike Moser] And, okay, they were mostly became endangered species, but they still needed protection.
- 36:18[Mike Moser] And I would suggest that animals on fur farms need protection in much the same way.
- 36:24[Mike Moser] So, yes, we do need to look at how we can help farmers transition.
- 36:30[Mike Moser] Time is going to be a big part of that.
- 36:33[Mike Moser] Look, you've got time to transition.
- 36:35[Mike Moser] It may not necessarily be the responsibility of government to tell them what to transition to.
- 36:41[Mike Moser] If you can take compensation and you've got time, well, guys, you've got valuable land there.
- 36:47[Mike Moser] What you wish to do with that is a personal choice.
- 36:51[Mike Moser] But I do think that leaving it another year is not doing the fur industry any good.
- 36:57[Mike Moser] I think a lot of farmers are probably waking up each day thinking, I wish I didn't do this anymore, but I don't know what else to do.
- 37:04[Mike Moser] So you probably need support in making what will be afterwards, as it was with me, Mike.
- 37:09[Mike Moser] Once they've left, they'll look back and just say, thank heavens for that.
- 37:14[Mike Moser] I wish I'd done it sooner.
- 37:16[Michael Howie] Yeah, and I think we will see that.
- 37:19[Michael Howie] I genuinely believe it.
- 37:20[Michael Howie] I think there's a lot of interesting socioeconomic studies, too, that show if you tell people they don't need to do their job right now and you can give them the basics to live, a lot of them go back to school.
- 37:30[Michael Howie] They start new businesses.
- 37:31[Michael Howie] They try new things and become happier, more contributories or better contributors to their local society.
- 37:41[Michael Howie] And ultimately, that benefits everyone.
- 37:43[Michael Howie] Yeah.
- 37:43[Michael Howie] But I've got two final questions to wrap with.
- 37:46[Michael Howie] I've used up a lot of your time today.
- 37:48[Michael Howie] One is, if you could offer one piece of advice to advocates working to end fur farming in Canada, what would it be?
- 37:55[Michael Howie] What would the priority message be?
- 37:57[Mike Moser] I do think about this a lot.
- 38:01[Mike Moser] I think Canada and the U.S. face different challenges to other countries.
- 38:10[Mike Moser] In part, I think, correct me if I'm wrong, animal welfare tends to not be...
- 38:15[Mike Moser] It tends to not be a federal issue.
- 38:17[Mike Moser] It tends to be done at state level.
- 38:19[Mike Moser] So you've got a difficulty there.
- 38:21[Mike Moser] And, of course, when you get down to that, it's a bit like going back towards the cliff rather than standing further away from it.
- 38:30[Mike Moser] And you start to get maybe a closer relationship at state level with the farming community.
- 38:40[Mike Moser] What's key to this is trying to understand the psychology, the thinking within the political leadership as to why they won't take action.
- 38:49[Mike Moser] I don't think there's any further information needs to be made available to political leaders in Canada, USA or anywhere else.
- 38:57[Mike Moser] They are well aware of the facts.
- 38:59[Mike Moser] They're well aware of all the facts we've discussed and more.
- 39:02[Mike Moser] So try to second guess why a senator or another political leader in any particular province in Canada would say, look, this is wrong.
- 39:14[Mike Moser] I'm now going to offer my support to a bill to close this.
- 39:19[Mike Moser] Needs to be understood as to why up to now you haven't taken that.
- 39:23[Mike Moser] And we've touched on this.
- 39:26[Mike Moser] People matter.
- 39:28[Mike Moser] I guess the answer, right, to twist my own arm, it's to continue to build a groundswell of vocal support from the public.
- 39:41[Mike Moser] Because ultimately the politicians will listen to the electorate.
- 39:45[Mike Moser] And at some point, if there's enough, they will be forced to take action if enough people on the ground say, listen to us.
- 39:52[Mike Moser] So ultimately, that's going to make a difference.
- 39:56[Michael Howie] Okay, excellent.
- 39:57[Michael Howie] And finally, one of the things I always ask about, almost on any issue, is what gives you hope through all of this?
- 40:04[Michael Howie] Where do you find the energy to keep moving forward and to say, yes, this is going to change.
- 40:10[Michael Howie] It's going to be meaningful.
- 40:12[Michael Howie] And we're all going to be a part of it and keep on moving forward.
- 40:16[Mike Moser] The biggest part of the biggest, I think, is age.
- 40:21[Mike Moser] When I look now at, if I do an anecdotal survey, so within our children are all in their 30s.
- 40:32[Mike Moser] So if I take them and their partners and their friends that I've known for years, so lots of people in their 30s and their wider circle friendship.
- 40:40[Mike Moser] I think that we know probably in the region of about 100 people, both directly and indirectly, in that sort of age group.
- 40:48[Mike Moser] Fur trade would have viewed those in the past as being the next generation of customers.
- 40:54[Mike Moser] They need to replace the ageing people who bought fur in the past and they need the next group of aspirational, hopefully cash rich at some point.
- 41:06[Mike Moser] People, not one single person I know in that age group would even consider buying fur.
- 41:13[Mike Moser] 100% think the fur should be shut down.
- 41:18[Mike Moser] And so if I extrapolate that, and I admit it's a very, very rough survey.
- 41:22[Mike Moser] My belief is that if I was to take that survey amongst the greater number of people of that age group, they would all say exactly the same thing.
- 41:31[Mike Moser] And I think that's true, not only in the UK, but probably right across Canada as well.
- 41:36[Mike Moser] So at some point each year that goes by, the fur industry is making less money.
- 41:41[Mike Moser] They've got fewer customers.
- 41:43[Mike Moser] And at some point, the economics will make the decision.
- 41:47[Mike Moser] So I'm absolutely of the belief.
- 41:49[Mike Moser] I want it to happen sooner, Mike.
- 41:51[Mike Moser] And that's down to the politicians saying, I listened to you.
- 41:54[Mike Moser] Now's the time to stop it.
- 41:56[Mike Moser] Yeah.
- 41:56[Michael Howie] So show up and vote, everybody, I think is one of the big messages there too.
- 42:00[Mike Moser] That's absolutely it.
- 42:01[Michael Howie] Oh, look, we've had a great time together.
- 42:03[Michael Howie] I really want to thank you.
- 42:05[Michael Howie] I'm sure you hear this a lot, but your courage to stand with your convictions, to listen to your heart, to make a change in your own life has affected so many others from the individual animals who are no longer on fur farms in some places to the hundreds of thousands of people who have heard you speak.
- 42:25[Michael Howie] And I think it's very important that we recognize just what a huge impact that is, and it takes courage to do.
- 42:33[Michael Howie] So thank you for that.
- 42:35[Mike Moser] Mike, they're really kind words.
- 42:38[Mike Moser] And I generally thank you for saying that.
- 42:40[Mike Moser] You know, I hope this doesn't come across as a hideous cliche, but I mean this sincerely.
- 42:46[Mike Moser] It doesn't take courage.
- 42:48[Mike Moser] It really doesn't take courage to say and do the right thing.
- 42:53[Mike Moser] And what I'm doing today is not – I don't sit in the least bit courageous.
- 42:58[Mike Moser] The people who deserve that description are those that have been fighting against the fur trade for decades.
- 43:10[Mike Moser] People who have fought so hard for so long.
- 43:14[Mike Moser] I'm just one person adding a voice to it.
- 43:17[Mike Moser] They're the people I've got huge respect for.
- 43:19[Mike Moser] And if I can do a small bit, then I will be pleased.
- 43:23[Mike Moser] But it's really to support decades and decades of hard work by so many other people.
- 43:28[Mike Moser] But once again, thank you for the words.
- 43:30[Mike Moser] I do appreciate them.
- 43:32[Michael Howie] I'd like to thank Mike Moser for joining us.
- 43:36[Michael Howie] Mike continues to work with Humane World for Animals, supporting campaigns to end the fur trade in Britain and across Europe.
- 43:42[Michael Howie] You can learn more about those campaigns and read Mike's own writing about his experiences inside the fur industry through links in this episode's show notes.
- 43:50[Michael Howie] And to learn more about fur farming in Canada, including how you can help bring it to an end, visit furfarming.ca.
- 43:57[Michael Howie] Until next time, I'm Michael Howie for Defender Radio and The Fur-Bearers, reminding you to stay informed and stay strong.