Latest / Ego and Other Things / Is Government Necessary?
Transcript
- William: Is the state necessary? That's the question that we are going to try to address today. You guys might notice that voice is a little off today, that my nose ⁓ ⁓ maybe a little bit more ⁓ or raspy. I've been sick for the past f at least four days or so. but I would like to get a video out for you guys this week, so I'm feeling a little bit better today and I I would try to tackle this this topic and and get a video out this week. Now this question whether or not the state is necessary is a a natural outgrowth from the philosoph the philosophy I pr I've presented so far. If authenticity is the highest value, acting for the sake of what you truly value, if that is the the highest aim in life And being free from force and coercion and violence a necessary precondition to be able to do that, then naturally the question comes up, what is the place of the state? Because the state, or how other people often call it, government, is based in violence and force. It's based in some way or another on the monopolization of violence. And so what is the place of the state? How does it differentiate, in my opinion, from something like government? Aren't these the same? Because oftentimes these are talked about in the same kind of breath. And isn't the state necessary in some way or another for something like authenticity? Doesn't it provide the security ⁓ the rights ⁓ the social supports that make authenticity possible? How can it be that the state being a product of force ⁓ detrimental to authenticity when it seems so necessary for human life in human society? And we're gonna address all that. the degree of its necessity how it impacts authenticity. But there was a point I wanted to highlight at the beginning here, which is How I view the importance of kind of this level conversation that is politics in general. Because I really don't spend most of my philosophical energy on politics. I'm interested in in the individual. I'm interested in the conditions for the individual to be able to live a meaningfully good life. Meaning that I look at society in po In politics, in relationship to the individual and not for their own sake. I believe essentially that the problems of society or the the the political problems ultimately come down to individual problems, that something like the violence of the state has its origins in the violence against the individual. And that all the state and society ultimately is is ⁓ Collective embodiment of the violence of individuals. The violence of the state is really just the violence of people. And things like wars economic depressions and genocides ⁓ and general structural and mismanagement come down to expressions of violence that we find within people. This is just to reiterate that if you want to solve the problems of the state, then you have to solve the problems of the individual. And if you ha if you want to solve the problems of the individual, you have to solve the problems of yourself. I think oftentimes people get interested in politics because is ⁓ abstract one way or another. They're sort of easily able to Project and express their emotions onto the abstract entity called the government or the state or political party they're opposed to, or whatever ideology they're opposed to. They're able to e expend all of their emotional energy these abstract constructions because it's dangerous to express all of that emotion against abstract entities, which are basically unreal and really can't respond to you. Then it is to Deal with the concrete problems of one's own life, deal with the concrete history of one's own inauthenticity, deal with the concrete examples of violence and force and threat and coercion that's been used against you as an individual. It's much easier to go on Twitter and argue with strangers about the ethics of the current administration and its use of power it is to sit down and have an honest conversation with your parents about how you felt as a child. This isn't something that's unique to politics. It's something that I think many intellectuals do. you try to resolve your personal issues through the use of philosophy, through the use of abstract that have no concrete reality. This doesn't mean that politics is ⁓ useless isn't talking about anything. Obviously. Politics has consequences, as we can see in our own day, but even just taking a quick look at the twentieth century, we can tell that politics has consequences. In the same way that has consequences when somebody has a heart attack. But Philosophically I'm more interested in what caused a heart attack what's the proper way of surgery when somebody has heart had a heart attack, just to use a simple analogy. Because I'd rather prevent the heart attack to begin with. rather prevent politics and prevent the violence of the state from ever occurring than I would than I am interested ⁓ figuring out, okay, now that there's a monopolization of violence, what do we do with it? Which is much of what politics talks about. So, this political question of whether or not the state is necessary, while it's related to authenticity, and while the state can impose on authenticity, It's secondary to the individual task of becoming authentic in and of itself. And it's a realm in which the person has little to no control. We have little to no control over the power of the state. It's so beyond powerful, it is so it is so beyond the ability for the individual to impact in any meaningful way that oftentimes authenticity sort of has to just reconcile itself down to. being as authentic as it can be within the context of the political society that one lives in. And our best hope for a society that is truly free from force is to free ourselves from our own inauthenticity and thus desire to control and be consumed by the fear of survival. with all that being said, we'll get into the ⁓ actual meat of the question here. we're gonna do a couple things. I'm gonna try to briefly explain the difference between governments and states, because I think there's a useful distinction there that sometimes gets mixed up in these two concepts. we're gonna briefly go over arguments for the necessity of the state. So this largely revolves around questions of security. freedom, especially rights ⁓ supports ⁓ safety nets. from I'm gonna talk a little bit deeper about the nature of the state, like what is a what is a state really, and try disintegrate the abstract way that we often think about it. And I'm gonna a little bit about its origins and its history. Where did the state originate from? How did it come about? And compare it to a couple other other theories that Have been popular explanations of the state in the past. we kind of get that genealogy out of the way, then we're going to get into ⁓ the heart of the question of as to whether the state is necessary and more specifically does it actually achieve these it actually achieve security, freedom ⁓ social support in the way that we we often think it does. And then we'll wrap things up. starting off with the distinction between governments and states. And essentially the difference goes something like this: all states are governments, but not all governments are states. And so the definition of government would be body of individuals that come together to organize A group of people for the sake of some given end. So we oftentimes think of governments in terms of in terms of states, in terms of something like the United States government or the Chinese government, or the French government. But there are all kinds of other types of governments that exist that have nothing to do with nations. Like church government, for example. Oftentimes churches have a certain structure of government that involves a hierarchy between the priest or preacher, deacons, churches write up a sort of body of doctrines that they that they organize their activities around and make based in ⁓ through a a a selected hierarchy of people within the church. And the people the church, people who join the church, submit themselves to this organization. They submit their rules of conduct to this kind of person ⁓ this kind of organization. And there's different types of governing structures within churches. Some are more democratic and some are more or authoritarian, you might say. you know, the the difference between sort of like a Presbyterian church which is more democratic and something like the Catholic Church, which is sort of top down governing structure. You can also extend this to organizations that run like sports leagues even to the structures of businesses and corporations in terms of how they go about making collective decisions for the people that are within the organization and who makes those decisions. Of course, nations have governments themselves as well. They have, again, hierarchies, ways of deciding which individuals make decisions for the rest of the collective body. Documents which the rules of the game, so to speak, or the rules of government for that particular nation. And so we can see that the idea of government can exist. Along a number of different lines in a number of different organizations. They don't necessarily just relate to nations themselves. what distinguishes the kind of governments that nations have from a government like a church government or a corporation or a sports organization? Well, the principal difference is that. One is voluntary and one is involuntary. Meaning that for a church organization, I have a choice as to whether or not I enter that organization or not. I have a choice as to whether or not I'm going to participate in this church or not. For a business or corporation, I have a choice as to whether I'm going to work for this corporation or not. Whether I'm going to voluntarily submit to the rules because I value the structure. Or whether I'm going to refrain from it altogether and not not even participate in the organization. But when we talk about nations, a nation's government, we are talking about something that is involuntary, meaning I am born into it. And from the moment that I am born into it, I am subject to its rules, I am subject to its organization, regardless of whether I individually value it or not. Now, there's complexities with this. Some people would say that democracies represent a form of voluntary nation-based govern government. We'll get into that more when we get into a a separate video ⁓ whether or not the state is voluntary. And we'll tackle democratic republics in particular, different forms of supposed consent. But just laying out the picture here, the the major difference between something like a church government and a nation's government is its involuntary nature, the fact that one is born into it and subject to its rules, regulations, documents, procedures of power and authority, regardless of whether ⁓ has decided to participate in it. And essentially, what I would call a involuntary government, the name for an involuntary government is a state. Another way you can put it, this is a classic libertarian way of putting it, though I am not myself a libertarian, that the state is the involuntary monopolization of violence within a given geographic area. So the technical way of basically saying that a group of people have the majority control over violence within a given country. ⁓ they have the right to use violence within a given country The individual is subject to that use of force and violence and coercion, regardless of whether the person wants to be involved in it or not. But there's an additional aspect to the state that's important to consider here, which is all of those institutions Which would which only exist because of the presence of that monopolization of violence. So In something like the United States, you have the United States government. And you could consider this to be the bureaucracy or the publicly owned of the United States government. So this would be of course, the the legislative and the judicial and the executive, as well as all the bureaucracy that's around it. Military, police, public utilities. post office. These all would constitute elements of the state. But the same time The rules that something like the legislator the legis the legislative body has made for, for example, economic Sectors. Prevents and chooses certain winners and losers. For example, something like corporations only exists because of the state. The state sort of has an arbitrary definition of an entity called the corporation, which gets to play by certain special economic rules. especially around the non liability of the individuals who actually run the company or run the corporation, give a advantage to those Businesses. And prevent a degree of competition and market check on something like corporations. And many of the rules that the government issues essentially allow some businesses to exist while destroying other businesses, allows certain institutions to exist while destroying other institutions. And so things like the university system, for example, exist heavily on the fact that the United States government has. create rules and regulations, economic incentives and investments that Keep those universities running, even private universities. In a way they might not run in a private situation. And it's the same thing with agricultural, for example. Agricultural is not really though it's owned by it's even though it's supposedly owned by private individuals, it's heavily subsidized by the United States government and so exists sort of as a sustained product of that of the state of the United of the United States. Same thing with the healthcare industry. There are a number of these industries there, but I would consider these all to be aspects of the state, because they only exist because of state violence to begin with. They are in in one sense an extension of the monopolization of the use of violence. An analogy you might use to explain this is like if you looked at a a mafia, right? You have the structure of the mafia itself, which has to do with you know the boss and the the underboss, the soldiers, the captains, kind of have the structure of the mafia itself. But then some of the businesses that ⁓ exist within, you know, the mafia's controlled area only exists because the mafia allows them to exist and prevents competition from coming elsewhere and helps these people when struggling. And uses their shops and whatnot as fronts for other kinds of activities, meaning that the mafia doesn't simply extend to just the structural organization that it presents ex explicitly, but also into those entities which only exist because of the mafia's presence. And the entities which exist only because of the mafia's presence help to reinforce the power of the mafia structure itself. And this is the parallel case when it comes to states. The healthcare industry, the agricultural industry, the oil industry, the ⁓ weapons manufacturing industry, the corporate America, et cetera, et cetera. These all exist because of state violence, and they also to reinforce the power of the state, meaning there's a reason why the state was interested in developing and creating and sustaining all of these entities, even though they're not they're they're so called private rather than public. So they're not explicitly ⁓ part of State violence. anyway, that's the general ⁓ I'm making here between governments on the one hand and states on the other hand. And my analysis ⁓ going to be on states, not necessarily on governments. I don't really have ⁓ an an issue with voluntary government structures like churches, or sports I have an issue with. monopolization of violence, the involuntary monopolization of violence. Another way you could put this is that I'm not against hierarchy or organization or rules, or even the enforcement of rules in ⁓ the sort anarchist tradition. I'm interested in whether or not the rules are voluntary. and so I'm I'm As I've talked about before, I consider myself to be a voluntarist, not an anarchist or a statist. Okay. That being said, are ⁓ ⁓ arguments for the needs of the states? I mean, what do we learn in our high school civics one on one class about why the state exists in the first place? the arguments essentially ⁓ three lines. the first being security. ⁓ So argument goes that society, people society, we need protection. I mean we need like physical protection from bad actors. ⁓ so this could violent people within the itself. ⁓ or within that society itself, and violent people in general who are interested in doing harm to other people for whatever reason. we need protection from other states, right? So we don't want to be invaded. If we live in the United States, we don't want to be invaded by somebody like China. So we need people who are going to be able to us in case that we get attacked. or who are powerful enough to Ward off potential invasion or violence or enslavement by other countries and other peoples and other societies, right? And so this is where you get the basis of something like ⁓ police officers and the military. The police officers are there to make sure that nobody is using violence against anybody else. if they see, you know, ⁓ ⁓ person over here attacking this person, they break up. the the engagement and they used their weapon what or whatever to ⁓ punish the person or to to break up the fight and then to either put that person in jail, punish them in some way to get them not to do that in the future. And the same thing with the military. make it so that it's costly to kind of attack some place like the United States if another country had intentions to do that. And If there ever was something like a war, then there is ⁓ you know a group of trained professional people who are able to fight off an invading an invading force. And so you know, it's a whole question of sort of national security, right? National security. And this helps to keep society nonviolent by preventing violent actions from happening in in the first place. That would be sort of the first idea. The second is the idea of freedom or rights. The idea is that the state exists to ensure that its citizens have access to certain kinds of rights. So in the United States this would be something like to ⁓ in the Second Amendment, access to free speech, the ability to speak one's mind about whatever, long as it doesn't directly harm somebody, like you know. Saying fire in a theater. protection of property rights, the people from something like slavery or in ⁓ enslavement, labor, protecting children's rights. ⁓ protecting women's to ⁓ to be able to go work. Essentially the state exists to protect certain freedoms that are reserved for their citizens to be able to utilize. ⁓ anybody impinges on those freedoms, if anybody says tries take your guns away, tries to force you not to speak, tries to induce you force labor, prevents you from voting, etc. etc. The state steps in to stop that person from. Preventing you from exercising your freedoms. And the idea is that if we didn't have the state there, people would be able to im on our freedoms without consequence. Only through the state can those freedoms be categorically protected. And the last thing would here would be social support. now it depends on who you're talking to as to whether or not they think this is necessary. but idea here is that the state should provide access to Things which are necessary and basic for a a life, you could say. So this would be something like education. Food and water, electricity, in some places health care. And also protecting the citizen from You might catastrophic situation, especially economically. So if you lose your job and you can't make any money, the state steps in, gives you a paycheck so that you're able to sort of buy the things that you're you're you you're gonna need, right? and you can include this services like libraries and the post office and firefighting, ⁓ which it's that everybody ought to have universal access to in order to be able to live safely and functionally ⁓ within society. And these are sort of positive things, right? The state actually goes out of its way to create these institutions to provide positive goods and services to people. Based on what it deems necessary for people to actually function in society. there's also the reverse side of this, ⁓ ⁓ is argued that the state is necessary to prevent people from doing or participating in things that could be harmful to society. So different in history, this has been sex work, this has been alcohol, tobacco. Child labor. Drugs. I mean those are just a few examples, but the idea is that there are certain things or certain activities, certain goods and services that the government needs to step in and and ban or prevent people from pursuing or getting or procuring in order to protect its citizens from social harm. And the idea with all three of these is that it's it's only because of the state's monopolization of violence that these things can be possible. If the state wasn't able to fund itself through taxation, they wouldn't be able to to fund even the basic things like a justice system that could ensure rights, police and military that could protect us, or social supports that could help us in our times of need. And so the state in this scheme as a of the basics ⁓ of life that enable citizens then to Do something like be authentic, like act for the sake of what they truly value. The monopolization of force allows to do this on a categorical level, allows it this apply allows this to apply to everybody within the given society that it's operating within. That is force is necessary to ensure all of these benefits from the state in one way or another. And we're gonna address all of these. And point out how the state often not only fails to live up to three supposed purposes of state violence, but actually contradicts them. before we do that, I want to get into ⁓ the nature, ⁓ origins and the history of the state, because I think it's important to just contextualize where the state has actually come from and what the state actually is. and the thing to start off with is to recognize that state is nothing but people. this is gonna be important later, ⁓ oftentimes talking about the state. we're talking we talk about just in the way that I've I've been talking about it, as if it's sort of this separate Now we kind of have to talk about it because it's a it's a giant social construct that comes about as a result of the actions and the coordinations of individuals. And I'm not going to sort of repeatedly describe the, you know, totality of actions of individuals which produce the state. I'm just going to talk about the state. But in doing so, you can easily obscure the fact that the state is nothing but people. ⁓ there is no part of the state which exists outside of a person, their actions, ⁓ and their, you know, the and the and their utilization of force and violence. There's nothing out outside the state but but people. the people within the state are not any way morally different from you and I. Everything that I talked about in the morality of authenticity applies as equally to the people of the state as it applies to you and I. the people of their state are not sort of superiorly morally moral beings, they're not necessarily smarter than you and I. They're not necessarily more righteous than you and I. They don't escape the nature of what it means to be human being just because they're they're a part of the state. They are people and individuals just like you and I. but oftentimes we put them when we put them in the category of the states, suddenly we start to think about them differently, right? As as though they aren't people, as as though because we call them the state, different moral rules should apply to them. Meaning, you know, s you know, a simple example like this is is that ⁓ this is just a parallel example to explain what I'm talking about, right? if go ⁓ to neighbor I say You have to give me twenty percent of your income for the rest of your life. ⁓ so that I can put it into a reti ⁓ retirement account for you. And if you don't, I'm gonna lock you in my basement for an undetermined amount of time. if you try to resist me, I'm use against you. I'm gonna threaten you with some sort of physical violence. I'll beat you up or I'll threaten you with a gun. If you try to resist effectively, then I'll kill you. Basically if you don't comply with what I'm telling you, I'm gonna kill you. Which is essentially the foundation of the state and the foundation of law, which is comply or die. If I do that as an individual, that would be considered a heinous crime. It would be even if the the so called intention was for that person's good, right? Setting up a retirement account for them because I'm I'm planning for them, would be considered Essentially to be a violent lunatic. And most people would morally condemn that. But if calls themselves a tax agent and says they're from the United States government and says you have to pay what's called Social Security so that we can put it into a collective retirement account and maybe you'll get that money back when you're retired at this age that come up with. That is considered good governance, That is considered the legitimate use of force and violence. But of course, the person the tax man or the guy who comes up with the rules or the who's investing the money, who are all part of the state government, is no more is no more morally different than you or I. So when you and I use violence to achieve ends in the world. Even if those ends are intended for somebody's benefit, it is condemned. But when those when the same kind of individual is labeled as a part of the state, as a part of the nation's government, does the same exact kind of thing, is considered morally justified. And so there's this there's this gap in our moral understanding between the sort of private individual and the sort of public individual. individual, even if the interaction is exactly the same. And so it's important to keep in mind this entire conversation that what we are talking about is people. What we are talking about is individuals. When I talk about the state, it's just a collection of people. It's just a collection of people who, for one reason or another, and are in the position of using of they're in positions of power, meaning they're in the position to use force and violence against other individuals who happen to live in the same general area or the or predefined area. you might say that this arrangement again is necessary, but the necess the the the the supposed necessity of the situation does not sweep under the rug the ⁓ moral that we're talking about here, the moral gap between the so-called public and private. Which again are really the same thing. So that's something to keep in mind in this discussion. the next thing I'm gonna go over here is just the origin of the state. ⁓ I think people get a little bit mixed up on this. civics class, we're the philosophy of government. We're taught the yeah, we're taught the philosophy of government, which often comes with a a fictionalized world in which you know, a group of people at one point came together and said to one another, you know, all of this all of us having to survive on our own and being at each other's throats all the time is really exhausting and ⁓ bad. So how about we all come together and, you know, put aside certain of our own individual freedoms in order to participate in a society that will protect all of our freedoms simultaneously. And we're gonna choose the structure to be, you know Monarchy or king or feudal society or democracy or whatever, right? And the idea is that this fictionalized story is supposed to rationalize why does the people create states in the first place? the question becomes: like, why did we ever organize into a state to begin with? Why did we ever allow the monopolization of violence to begin with? but sort of Glosses over, sort of a tragic fact of human history, which is that we never actually allowed it to begin with. There was never any ⁓ council elders that got together and decided, yes, this is the way that we are going to ⁓ use in society. the truth of the fact is that from the beginning time, certain individuals, because of their ⁓ situation within a social group. Had immense power over other people. the most common example used here is something like the within the family union. The father was the grown ⁓ male And in a time where the intellectual and social capacities were not as ⁓ developed they are today. the physical power an adult male was enough to keep a family line or under the domination of the father figure. Now maybe that father figure was more or less benevolent, more or less interested in the welfare of their family, but again the power structure was the same. you might say today that a a dictator can be more or less benevolent towards their people, a king can be more or less benevolent towards their subjects. But the same dynamic of domination persists. It's an involuntary. The people underneath the father in the family are in an involuntary organizational structure, which they are subject to, regardless of whether they want to be or not. And this includes, of course, the the children, but also the mother. there is, you know, different ranks of power, as the father had power over the mother, but the mother often had power over the children. And those differences matter, but the point is what's the structure of domination here? But the point is to say that the state originated in the family structure. the ⁓ physical power capacity for physical power over the rest of the family. Now ⁓ ⁓ came together into tribes and tribes came together into nations, of course the the nature of power became more complex. ⁓ you got emotional, ⁓ intellectual, resource based of power that develop as a consequence of people working together. and power would often have to be strategically shared in order to stay truly dominant in the hands of an individual. And so this is why you get hierarchies where the person at the top of the hierarchy is telling his you might say, I don't know, let's say his captains, right? His captains If you use violence and force in this the way that I'm telling you, then you'll get these kinds of benefits from it. playing the captains against one another, as societies become more complex, ⁓ the ⁓ for dominance become more complex themselves. But the same structure pertains ⁓ where individual or group of individuals has some sort of overwhelming power of. violence, threat or coercion, especially the threat of death, over a much broader population and through a variety of mechanisms uses that power ⁓ in an efficient way. Foucault was really good at talking about the efficiency of power. Like how is it that a person can go from just having, you know, access to great physical power to actually be able to dominate an entire society. In the United States, for example, the military Of course is an overwhelming example of physical force and violence, but even a military couldn't by itself dominate something like the United States. It needs other mechanisms of power like culture and education. An ideology in order to that power efficient within a society. But it the of power does not ultimately undermine the nature of power. And so the state originated out of this voluntary coming together of all the of society to a mutual agreement about the rules. It came about ⁓ the per the progressive situation of a person or a group of people being in the position of power and using that to dominate the rest of the group through today through something like culture and ideology and concepts. And so the origin of the state is not itself voluntary. The origin of the state is involuntary. It's sort of involuntary all the way down. And this is important to understand because the of the state begins in domination. Now you might argue that just because the history of the state begins in domination and doesn't pertain to today, that today's form of the state is really about, you know, protecting security and freedom and happiness, right? but it is important to understand the the genealogical roots here. The state began in domination, began the domination of the of the family. It has extended through domination Because of that, we have to be skeptical of the state how the state describes itself to us ⁓ people who are not in positions of power. If you wanna look at exam at a ⁓ at a sort of a clear example that we can see in history, you know how was the the monarchy of the past ideologically justified to its its citizenry? it was done through something like the divine right of kings, right? The Idea that God had placed each person in their place on purpose for an ultimate good, and this included the king himself. The king didn't rule because he had the power of domination over his subjects. The king ruled because God had placed him there, right? And this was the ideological justification that was bought by the citizens of that state that helped the king to maintain his power, because if The citizens understood that the king was just dominating them through power, they might have been motivated to find ways to overthrow him. So is the question about the state being necessary for security and freedom and social supports, is this true, or is this just another ideological cover up for domination? the state being necessary for security and freedom and social supports, is this true, or is this just another ideological cover up for domination? My argument is going to be that it's another ideological cover. And you know, part of the reason I can I can say this is just in at the history of the state itself. Which is to say that, you know, if you want to find if you wanna find the the entity, right, in history that has committed the greatest kinds of crimes, it is always and everywhere the state. ⁓ if you want to find the entity, that has committed the greatest kinds of crimes, it is always and everywhere the state. ⁓ And all three of these things that we talked about in the beginning, security, freedom, and social support, these have all been routinely destroyed by state violence. the state has always been the greatest destroyer and corrupter of these kinds of things. And all three of these things that we talked about in the beginning, security, freedom, and social support, social supports, these have all been routinely destroyed by state violence. And and the state has always been the greatest destroyer and corrupter of these kinds of things. All you have to do is is take a look at the century, for example, to see example after example of states. which have used the monopoly of violence to kill and destroy even their own citizens, strip freedoms away. cut people off from the resources that they need. commit acts ⁓ of and slavery and torture oppression, the likes of which could not be imagined in the context of any given individual in and of themselves. We are often so worried about, you know, the lone thief or the lone murderer or the lone assaulter, but it has often been the coordination of the state by its monopolization of violence that has been able to perpetuate categorical theft and categorical murder and categorical assault and categorical violence against its citizens, without any power of opposition, because it held the monopoly on violence. And the people, because they were cut off from any kind of power themselves, by the monopolization of the power of the state were entirely helpless to resist this. and this is not just the sort of totalit the totalitarian regimes of know communist ⁓ Russia, China. Or Nazi Germany, those are though those of course are major examples, but anybody who knows anything about United States history knows that even this so called democratic republic has extended history ⁓ murder, violence, and oppression of practically every category of person, that exists, even today, ⁓ in terms of its wars in the Middle East. United States continues to use its monopolization of violence on the world stage to destroy security, freedom and Access to what people need in order to live. The very power of violence itself leads to the greatest possibilities of violence in the world. Something like the nuclear bomb, for example, only exists because of state violence. I mean, where how in the world could people get the resources together to understand how to build, let alone build a nuclear bomb without the violence of the state pulling together all of these kinds of resources. Even something like global warming can be attributed or climate change can be attributed to the violence of the state because the vi ⁓ through subsidization the state has so advanced the industrial output of a global society as to rapidly increase CO two emissions far beyond what the planet could adapt itself to. and has greatly shortened our time and our resources and our ability to figure out how we might solve the issue. So those are just two examples. The state is always at the at the the root of so many of the greatest crimes the world has ever seen, not simply the individual. And that is something to keep in mind when it comes to whether or not the state is necessary. and this just leads to my general arguments against the state. the first being that this that the state sort of intrinsically violates all three of these things. we talk about security, right? Well, in the first place, because of the nature of the violence of the state, it is able to ⁓ destroy your security any moment any any time it wants to. And you have no power to resist it, right? ⁓ world of without states, without a monopolization of violence, there is at least the capacity to individually resist violence that comes your way. whether or not violence can be totally ⁓ from the world is, you know, one question. But at least in a society without states, the violence that you come up against is not an overwhelming violence, right? It it is a much individualized kind of violence. And you can easily coordinate with other people in order to prevent this kind of violence from from happening to you. But you have power, right? You have power over the ability to r resist violence or not. When it comes to the state, not only do you crafty individual aren't only are are crafty individuals able to outsmart the state and use violence against you anyway, but now you have a group of people who have power over a kind of violence that you have absolutely no ability to resist, right? If ⁓ the United States declares war tomorrow and decides to draft you, your choice is either to go to jail or to be killed, and you have no power to resist that. Maybe you can escape to Canada or something like that, but Within the the context of the state you have absolutely no power to resist that violence if it turns against you. And it often does. In fact, historically it's more likely to turn against you than not. is the same thing with freedom. you know, if you're worried about ha ⁓ having a right, right? Having a right to free speech, having a right to ⁓ vote, a right to work. You know, these rights that we talked about, I think I think the rights are this again false conceptual tag. What is a right? Right is the thing ⁓ that state allows you to get away with. if a right inconveniences state power, if it gets in the way of state power, you don't have access to that right anymore and you have no power to sustain of yourself because you've you've not not that you have seceded your your power to the state but the state has has eliminated your own power over speech eliminated your own power over something like organization eliminated your own power to labor for you know whoever you want to labor for right the state has taken away your ability to choose categorically and then given back to you so as it doesn't but given back to you temporarily some rights ⁓ that interfere with its own power, right? In fact, helps it to maintain this power. Something like the, you know, the right to free speech, right? Does this ⁓ the the state doesn't care whether or not you speak freely it, because if ⁓ You speak freely against it and nothing happens, then you, you know, it just gets it just allows people to vent about state violence and then go on with their own lives. And then if you actually speak against the state and it starts to change something, well, they're just gonna find some sort of underway, underhanded way of taking you out or find some law that they can use to arrest you for that has nothing to do with your free speech. You know, they're going to work around the supposed rights to In order to curb your your your right to to free expression anyway, or to make it so that people won't listen to you because you've been discredited. ⁓ so rights don't really exist, right? They just they exist as a tool of ideological enslavement because you say, Well, I have a right to do X, Y, and Z. But if you ever utilize those rights in a way that actu that that threatens state power, then they either suspend your rights or find ways to get around it. A right in reality is what you have the capacity to do, what you have the power to do, not what some who's never met you writes down on a piece of paper. and again, so long as it if it doesn't run into their interest, they'll let you do whatever you want. In fact, it again it benefits them. Something like the right to labor helps, you know, the capitalist system ⁓ run that benefits their their pockets, their ability to tax people. So they're perfectly fine with giving you rights that benefit them. that benefits the state and and the the continuation of state power. But if it doesn't benefit the state, they take it away, they find a w a way around it. They're not actually interested in your freedom. ⁓ they're not interested in in your protection. the same thing with social supports. I think the devious thing about the social supports is that they they create a dependence of people. And I don't mean this in like the conservative tropey kind of way, where it's like You shouldn't receive welfare because you should be working hard or something like that. I mean that, you know, the the government takes over the agricultural industry by proxy through subsidi subsidiz subsidization. And now the entire food industry r relies on the United States subsidizing it. it relies on the United States being heavily invested in petrol, for example. And actually crowds out any other kinds of, you know, options that an individual might take in order to feed themselves. Right. And so we have an entire agricultural industry that is enti like completely hardlined into monocropping. where Where other forms of agriculture are completely left out. And strangled out. So now that now that all the alternative options are gone because of state power, we are forced to you know live with the glyphosate infected rotations that they give us. And this is true across many different kinds of industries. I mean you can't The the the tech industry used to be something more freely oriented in the eighties and nineties, but now it's been completely regulated and subsidized and protected by the United States governments and through a variety of mechanisms. ⁓ so now we're stuck with the same, you know, NASDAQ that have been there since two thousand. Because any real competition has been completely crowded out. Here's something, you know, that's relevant with the AI bubble: that AI is receiving so much support from the United States government that It no longer matters whether AI is actually of value to anybody. Because it doesn't actually matter. The existence and the success of these AI companies doesn't depend on whether people buy their products or not. It depends on whether they can get another subsidy or support from from the government. So we're completely pushed out from getting any alternatives to the things that people are monopolizing. there might be, you know, alternative to things like roads or firefighting departments or the police stations or post office or the welfare state or subsidized care or the ag the the way that agriculture is being run, the corporate America, the oil industries, there might be, you know, creative alternatives that individuals could come about and produce if it wasn't for for the sake of state violence. And what happens is that when these social supports fail because governments can no longer feed them or because they don't actually produce any value, we have no alternatives left. So we just suffer, right? I mean, you can see this happened in the in the Great Depression. the the heavy reliance of agriculture around the United States completely fell apart with the Dust ⁓ and there was alternatives to the agriculture, right? we people just have to suffer ⁓ the effects of the dust bowl because there had been no alternatives. And this is just one instance. I mean there's plenty of different little instances here. and it's not necessarily wise to get into all the instances because you could argue them into oblivion, but you have to look at the principle, right? Whenever state violence comes in, it makes only one option available or one range of options available. And the question happened the question becomes when that range of options fail. What comes up to replace him? the answer is nothing, right? So when g a government necessarily when a state necessarily mismanages some industry, it's monopolized. We just suffer through it. We just suffer through its destruction rather than having a multitude of options available because people have been able to freely pursue what they actually value. And so what I and this is again, this has happened again and again in history. And I so I would argue that the the state is actually the greatest enemy to all three of these, to security, freedom, and social support. And this makes sense when you take a look at you know the reasons why people argue for state power to begin with. They say something like you know, there's something about human nature that is evil, that is selfish, that is power seeking, that is egoistic. That only thinks about itself, that is willing to use whatever means necessary to get what it wants. and so, you know, we need a state to protect us from these kinds of people, right? Or to protect us from ourselves. But the state is nothing but people, it's nothing but individuals, it's nothing but selfish, ambitious, egoistic, violent, kinds of people. And all that happens is when you create a monopolization of violence is that The the state gets filled up with exactly those kinds of people who are going to use violence in the ways that are about domination and ideological capture. I mean they're going to use it for selfish ends is is sort of what I'm saying. even if you say, well, you know, okay, well most of people are good. It's just just like a small section of people which are evil. And my question to you is like if there's only a small section of people that are evil and you kind of concentrate all the violence of a society into one area called the state, where do you think all of those evil people are going to be attracted to being in? Right? Like where do you think all the sociopaths are gonna go ⁓ to seek power? They're gonna go for the state. And sort a process of evolution, you know, those sociopaths who can be ⁓ who can the sociopaths who are best ⁓ at passing off as not sociopaths are gonna be the ones who are both pursuing the power and actually achieve it and use it for all kinds of ends. I think if you're worried about evil people affecting you, the last thing you want to do is have a state. You want to have individual power in conjunction with other good people to be able to resist them. Not in a on a voluntary basis. Not put all the the power of violence in the hands of a few people and sort of let it ride. we've seen the consequences of letting it ride, ⁓ the consequences are the atrocities that we see all throughout history. So in in in my perspective, the state is not necessary for security rights or flourishing, social ports. I mean, these are all things that can be done on a voluntary basis. Howe is a whole separate conversation. But the the point I'm trying to make here is that the state is not necessary for these things. The state is the enemy of all of these things. The state is in one sense the opposite of all these things. the degree that you see today of so called freedom and ⁓ and know social supports, this is not the peak of civilization. This is the basics of civilization. It is the state which actually prevents all three of these things from truly flourishing within a a given society of individuals. it is violence which actually prevents the fulfillment and the completion and the wholeness of these kinds of things. And it's the violence which ultimately creates these giant where all three of these are repeatedly violated. I mean the headlines about the government, about the United States, about governments around the world is nothing but the headlines about how the state has violated how the violence of the state has violated security and freedom and social support. The state is the enemy of these things, not its solution. So I think that's where we're gonna leave off. what are your thoughts on this? You know, and did you did you resonate with what I'm talking about here? Do you have different thoughts about the necessity of the state? Are you pro-state? You know, do you think I I missed a few things here? Do you think I'm sort of off my kilter? I'd love to know your thoughts. ⁓ if you want to put them down in the comments, I would be more than happy to to answer them, to talk with you guys about these ideas. Again, that's really the whole point of this. channels to be able to talk about philosophy with other people, get insight on what people think about what I'm talking about here, and really just other understand other people's perspectives as well. If you like this video, then you know please give it a like. If you think this information would be helpful to somebody else, please share it with them. And if you want more videos like this, then please click that subscribe button and I'll be posting at least every week. These kinds of videos? The next video that we're gonna do ⁓ in this objection series is going to be not is the state necessary, but is the state consensual? Because much of the argument that I've made in this video hinges on the idea that the state is involuntary, that it is not something that we sort of to participate in, but rather are forced to participate in. And people question this, considering that a lot of ⁓ states today are some form of some form of a democratic republic. So we will address ⁓ voluntariness ⁓ states in our next video. But as always, thank you guys for watching and I'll talk to you next time.