Latest / The El Paso Matters Podcast / West Texas measles outbreak spreads
Transcript
- 0:00Hi there, and welcome to the first episode of the El Paso Matters podcast.
- 0:05I'm your host, Diego Mendoza-Moyers, and I'm a staff writer here at El Paso Matters.
- 0:10You may have read an article or two on our website, but for the first time, we're taken
- 0:14to the audio space to bring you more news and information about El Paso, and to share
- 0:18insights and analysis from our reporters who crisscross the city to cover stories about
- 0:22education, city politics, immigration, the environment, and all other things El Paso.
- 0:28We're looking to continue our mission of sharing free, in-depth news and perspective
- 0:31about the borderland, but now in podcast format.
- 0:35For our first episode, we explore an ongoing measles outbreak in Texas, which claimed a
- 0:39life of an unvaccinated school-aged child this week who was hospitalized in Lubbock.
- 0:44It was a first known fatality for measles in the U.S. since 2015.
- 0:47State officials have now reported over 100 cases, and 18 people in Texas have been hospitalized
- 0:52with measles.
- 0:53So far, no cases have been reported in El Paso.
- 0:56To help us understand what's driving this outbreak of measles and the risk it poses
- 0:59for El Pasoans, we welcome El Paso Matters health reporter Priscilla Totiapum Prasert.
- 1:04Priscilla, welcome to the show.
- 1:06Hey, thanks for having me.
- 1:08So Priscilla, can you give us a summary of this measles outbreak?
- 1:11Where did it start and among whom, and any perspective on the number of cases that we're
- 1:15seeing in Texas so far?
- 1:16Yeah, so the Texas Department of State Health Services identified the first case an outbreak
- 1:22in late January.
- 1:24This was in Gaines County, which is next to Lubbock, about a four and a half hour drive
- 1:28from El Paso.
- 1:29In the next couple of weeks, measles was confirmed in five other school-aged children.
- 1:34They were all unvaccinated residents of Gaines County.
- 1:38Since then, the outbreak has spread in not only that county, but multiple surrounding
- 1:41counties, including one in New Mexico.
- 1:44Altogether, there's been about, I think, 130 cases, more than 130 cases, sorry, including
- 1:51more than a dozen hospitalizations.
- 1:54As you mentioned, the first death was the school-aged child who was hospitalized in
- 1:58Lubbock.
- 1:59We don't have a lot of information about that, so we don't know if that person was living
- 2:03in Lubbock, where they were living, but this is a pretty big deal.
- 2:10Yeah, and how does this compare to past outbreaks of measles we might have seen in prior years?
- 2:15This is a pretty big outbreak.
- 2:17For comparison, there was an outbreak, the last one in El Paso was in 2019, and this
- 2:23was six people.
- 2:25This happened in Fort Bliss.
- 2:27This is the biggest, the current outbreak is the biggest outbreak in Texas in about 30
- 2:33years or so.
- 2:35And why is Gaines County the epicenter of this outbreak this year?
- 2:38In Gaines County, there is a low vaccination rate.
- 2:43Last school year, only 82% of Gaines County kindergartners were vaccinated against measles.
- 2:49That is way below the threshold for herd immunity, at least the CDC's target.
- 2:56The thing about Gaines County is that there is a close knit Mennonite community there,
- 3:01and that's where authorities believe the outbreak started.
- 3:05Mennonites vary by community, but the more conservative ones tend to be more mistrustful
- 3:09of medical institutions and vaccines.
- 3:13There's no religious doctrine against immunization, so it is a personal choice if families choose
- 3:19to gain an exemption from any of the school required vaccines.
- 3:24Can you talk about the exemptions that students are able to get for vaccinations?
- 3:30So Texas tracks exemptions by what's called conscientious exemptions.
- 3:36Vaccinations are religious, personal reasons, and nationally, there has been an increase
- 3:43in parents asking for exemptions from at least one school required vaccine.
- 3:50I do want to clarify, there is a difference between a conscientious exemption and a medical
- 3:54one.
- 3:55So there are people who are not vaccinated for medical reasons, either, for example,
- 4:00they're too young to get the vaccine, or there are health issues that they have that would
- 4:07make it complicated for them to get the vaccine.
- 4:10Pregnant people also cannot get the MMR vaccine.
- 4:13So this is why doctors and public health experts really stress that if you are able to get
- 4:19the vaccine, you should get it because we need that herd immunity to protect the vulnerable
- 4:25people who can't get vaccinated.
- 4:27Interesting.
- 4:28And so how are measles transmitted and how severe is the disease usually?
- 4:33Measles is a respiratory illness.
- 4:35It transmits through breathing in infected droplets.
- 4:40So it can also be droplets on surfaces, not just in the air.
- 4:45And they can last in the air for up to two hours, as well as on surfaces.
- 4:50So for example, if a child has measles and they leave a classroom, whoever enters that
- 4:56classroom within the next two hours is at risk for exposure.
- 5:01And the most visible sign is a rash.
- 5:03It usually starts the hairline on your face, but it can take two weeks after exposure for
- 5:09those symptoms to show up.
- 5:11That means that if you're infected, you could be walking around spreading the virus without
- 5:15knowing it.
- 5:16How sick you get kind of depends on a few different reasons.
- 5:20So two doses of the vaccine is 97% effective to prevent you from getting measles compared
- 5:27to just one dose.
- 5:29And if you're vaccinated, you could get a breakthrough infection, but your symptoms will
- 5:35probably be more mild and it's going to be harder to spread the virus.
- 5:40If you are unvaccinated, you will have a higher risk.
- 5:45This is what doctors say, that you will have a higher risk of getting the more severe complications
- 5:50and this includes blindness as well as brain swelling.
- 5:55And so if you get a vaccination for measles as a child, is that the only time you need
- 5:59it for your entire life?
- 6:01The measles vaccine is supposed to be good for your lifetime, but there are instances
- 6:06where immunity could wane.
- 6:08There are tests out there that you can take to check your immunity level.
- 6:13For example, when you're pregnant and they do a blood panel, they see like for that you
- 6:18might have low immunity for rubella, but it should be good for your whole life.
- 6:24So what's the vaccination rate in El Paso for measles and how does that compare to other
- 6:28major communities in Texas?
- 6:31In El Paso, so the MMR vaccine, that's the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine, it is
- 6:36required for schools.
- 6:38And in El Paso, among kindergartners last school year, there was a vaccination rate of 96%.
- 6:44That is higher than the CDC target of 95%, the threshold for herd immunity.
- 6:49It is also higher than the state average and it is also higher than all the big major
- 6:56counties where Dallas, Houston, San Antonio, Fort Worth are located.
- 7:02Why do you think the vaccination rates higher here?
- 7:05What I hear from doctors and public health experts in El Paso is that people tend to
- 7:11trust their doctors.
- 7:14There was a big public health campaign, it's still actually going on right now, to get
- 7:20kids vaccinated before the school year.
- 7:22Yeah, would you say that getting vaccinated is the main way to protect yourself from measles?
- 7:27Well, I am not a doctor, but from what I hear from doctors is yes.
- 7:33Our health authority here in El Paso, Dr. Hector Ocaranza, as well as Dr. Mini Taneja
- 7:40are public health director, they have both spoken in support of vaccinations as a preventive
- 7:45measure.
- 7:48And we're seeing some new policies among state lawmakers and the state legislature.
- 7:52We're sick into limit vaccine requirements or question the need for vaccines generally.
- 7:57Can you talk about some of these new policies state lawmakers in Texas are pursuing?
- 8:00Yeah, so there is actually quite a flurry of bills that have come out since the COVID-19
- 8:07pandemic started.
- 8:09One of them, a Senate bill, has for example, if it were to pass, it would take away the
- 8:15authority for schools to exclude unvaccinated students from attending school during an epidemic
- 8:22or a public health emergency.
- 8:25Along with what's happening at the state level, there's also what's happening at the federal
- 8:29level.
- 8:30Recently, at a cabinet meeting with Trump and the new health secretary, Robert F. Kennedy
- 8:36Jr., it was brought up in the cabinet meeting about the measles outbreak, and RFK said that
- 8:45it is not unusual outbreaks happen every year.
- 8:49I think that mischaracterizes the current outbreak because this is the worst outbreak
- 8:55in Texas history in about 30 years.
- 8:58Also, there was a death of a child for a vaccine preventable disease, and there hasn't been
- 9:05a death since 2015.
- 9:08So I'm not sure I would characterize that as not unusual.
- 9:12Yeah, and can you talk about the trend of declining vaccination rates that we've seen
- 9:18in El Paso, which despite, as you said, we still have a high vaccination rate, we saw
- 9:21a little bit of a decline after the pandemic.
- 9:23I'm curious if that's a similar trend elsewhere as well.
- 9:27So what's happening in El Paso is not unique, is happening nationwide.
- 9:31There has been a decline in vaccinations.
- 9:34What's alarming about this is that prior to vaccination, there were 400 or so deaths
- 9:41that happened every year.
- 9:44And after the measles vaccine was introduced in the 1960s, that number dropped significantly.
- 9:51And by 2000, the CDC actually declared measles eliminated.
- 9:56Eliminated in this case means that there hasn't been a continuous spread for 12 months.
- 10:01So now we're seeing a resurgence of measles and it's making it come back.
- 10:06And in recent years, we are seeing a higher number of cases now.
- 10:10So something that was considered a thing of the past is now coming back.
- 10:15And health experts worry that outbreaks are going to become more common.
- 10:20This is only the beginning.
- 10:22This is important reporting, Priscilla.
- 10:23And we look to you to keep us updated about this measles outbreak in Texas going forward.
- 10:27Thanks so much for joining me.
- 10:28Thanks.
- 10:29Thanks for listening to our first episode.
- 10:31And we hope you'll follow our podcast and check out El Paso Matters.org to read all
- 10:34of our latest reporting.