Latest / NEURO MOTION LAB / Mini season_ Relationships and Environment EPISODE 1 You are not reading the other. You are reading your own story
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome to Neuro Motion Lab, where we explore the fascinating
- 0:14intersection of neuroscience and athletic performance.
- 0:17I'm Fabio Gida, Physical Therapist, trainer, mental
- 0:21performance coach and I'm passionate about helping
- 0:24athletes like you to reach your full potential.
- 0:45You think you know the people around you, your partner, your
- 0:48boss, that friend who always does the same thing.
- 0:53You think you know what they think, what they feel, what they
- 0:58meant when that silence with that look, with that tone of
- 1:03voice. But there is something that
- 1:06neuroscience has been documented for decades and that almost
- 1:10nobody wants to hear. What you think you see in the
- 1:14others is not the other. It's a construction.
- 1:17It's projections, a movie that your brain generate from your
- 1:22story, your previous experience, your fears and your expectation
- 1:27and project it onto the black screen that is the other person.
- 1:34This is not a metaphor. It is neurological architecture.
- 1:40Welcome to Neuro motion lab podcast.
- 1:43I'm Fabian Ernesto Guida and today we start a mini season
- 1:49that is going to be uncomfortable.
- 1:52The theme of the season is relationships and environment,
- 1:57but we are not going to talk about how to improve your
- 2:00relationships because this is not a self help channel.
- 2:04We are going to do something deeper and more disturbing.
- 2:08We are going to questions whether that thing you call
- 2:13knowing the other really exists. Today's episode has one
- 2:19underlying question, a question that if you let it in, is going
- 2:24to change the way you look at every conversation, every
- 2:29conflict, every moment where you believe you perfectly understood
- 2:33what the other felt. The question is this, when was
- 2:38the last time you reacted to the other and not to the story that
- 2:44your brain invented about them? The brain do not perceive the
- 2:50other, it simulate the other. There is a finding in
- 2:53neuroscience that should fundamentally change how we
- 2:57understand relationships and that however very few people
- 3:02know and it's this. The neural network that you use
- 3:07to think about yourself and the network that you use to think
- 3:11about others are to large extents the same network, the
- 3:17middle prefrontal cortex, the one that builds the narrative of
- 3:21who you are. What you think, what you feel is
- 3:25the same region that activates when your model others.
- 3:31People's mental states, what researchers call mentalizing or
- 3:36theory of mind. That ability to say he thinks
- 3:40that or she feels that does not operate from a neutral place.
- 3:47It's operate for the same subtract that builds your own
- 3:52self. What dance means is brutal if
- 3:55you think it out the way through.
- 3:58When you believe you are reading the other, you're actually
- 4:02generate a simulation of the other using the materials
- 4:05available in your own system. Your story, your patterns, your
- 4:11fears, your expectations. Your nervous system takes those
- 4:16materials, organize them, and project them onto the other
- 4:20person as if they were the others reality.
- 4:26It is not that you are bad at reading people.
- 4:30Don't misunderstood that friends.
- 4:32It's that nobody reads anyone. We all simulate.
- 4:37And the question that this opens is uncomfortable.
- 4:42If what you perceive in others is to a large extent a
- 4:46projection of your own nervous system, how many of your
- 4:51relations conflicts are conflicts with real people, and
- 4:55how many are conflicts with the version of those people that
- 5:01your brain fabricate? Talking about neurological
- 5:05structures, the network involved in simulated the other has three
- 5:11main nodes. The middle, prefrontal cortex,
- 5:14is the architect of the simulation.
- 5:16It builds the mental model of the other using in the same
- 5:20materials with which it builds the model of the self.
- 5:24Now we imagines. Studies show that when we think
- 5:29about people close to us, the activation of this region is
- 5:33almost indistinguishable from when we think about our self.
- 5:39Per side closeness erase the narrow boundary between the self
- 5:44and the other. The temporal Paratar junctions
- 5:48has the job of keeping one's own perspective and the other's
- 5:54perspective separate of then distinguish what I feel from
- 6:00what the others feels. When this region operates under
- 6:03condition of high emotional activation, stress or fatigue,
- 6:08that separation become less precise.
- 6:12The brain collapses the two perspective into one and the
- 6:17result is projection, assuming that the other feels what you
- 6:21will feel in the same situation and the amygdala always present.
- 6:27Our amygdala's friends colors the entire simulation with an
- 6:31effective evaluation that arise before any rational analysis.
- 6:37If the amygdala reaches 3, the simulation of the other is built
- 6:41from that filter. Every ambiguous signal is
- 6:45interpreted in terms of danger. The model of the others that the
- 6:50brain generate is no neutral. It is a model tinted by the
- 6:54emotional state of that moment. The question that this raises
- 7:00is, are you in conflict with the person or with the model of the
- 7:07person that your amygdala built when it was on alert?
- 7:13Let's talk about neurochemistry. Here comes something that the
- 7:18previous episode on predictive processing already anticipate,
- 7:22but applied to the social territory in a way that change
- 7:26everything. Dopamine not only regulates
- 7:29motivational learning in social circuits, dopamine regulates
- 7:33salines. That is how much important we
- 7:37assigned to a signal. And there is something
- 7:41disturbing in how it operates in interpersonal reading.
- 7:45When the brain construct a social narrative, especially a
- 7:48narrative of threat, the dopaminergic system do not seek
- 7:54to refute it. It's 6 to confirm it.
- 7:58Matthew Lieberman at UCLA demonstrate that activate social
- 8:03narratives have almost addictive properties.
- 8:06The brain prefers A coherent negative story to the discomfort
- 8:13of ambiguity. What that means in practice is
- 8:18once your brain decide that someone is angry, or that they
- 8:23are ignoring you or that they don't respect you, it is start
- 8:28to actively filters the evidence That is like to say.
- 8:33In other words, the brains want to affirm its hypothesis.
- 8:39What confirms the narrative is amplified, what contradicts its
- 8:43minimize or reinterpret it. So that is fits cortisol
- 8:49reinforce that loop. When elevated cortisol, social
- 8:52reading becomes more negative, more rigid, more resistant to
- 8:56updating the stresses. Brain do not read with more
- 9:02precision, it's read with more certainty, and certainly in this
- 9:08context is the problem. The question that arise is how
- 9:14many of your conviction about what the others feels are
- 9:20readings and how many are narratives that you and your
- 9:26dopaminergic system refuse to question.
- 9:31There is an idea in social psychology that is 100 years old
- 9:36and that modern neuroscience is confirming with an intimidation
- 9:41precision. Charles Cooley at the beginning
- 9:45of the 20th century proposed the concept of looking glass self,
- 9:52the mirror self. The idea is this, the imagine we
- 9:57have of our self is not built from the inside out, is built
- 10:04from the perception of how we believe others see us, not how
- 10:11they really see us, but how we believe they see us.
- 10:17Yourself, esteem, your sense of worth, your confidence are
- 10:21rarely based on energetic evaluation of who you are.
- 10:27They are based on a prediction of the evaluation that others
- 10:31make of you. A prediction generates by your
- 10:34own brain a prediction that can be completely wrong.
- 10:40What that means is that a large part of what you feel about
- 10:44yourself is the results of simulation upon simulation.
- 10:50Your brain simulates the other, simulates how the others
- 10:54evaluates you, and uses that simulation to build your own
- 10:59narrative of value. You never ask it.
- 11:02You never verified the system operate in automatic mode using
- 11:07the materials of your story, the criticism you received, the
- 11:11rejection you leave, the approvals you sought to build
- 11:17and imagine of yourself. That may have a little to do
- 11:22with really as the imagine you build of the other.
- 11:27And here comes the question that is most uncomfortable.
- 11:31Who will you be if you stopped basing your sense of yourself on
- 11:37what you believe other thinks about you?
- 11:42I got to illustrate this with an example and try to be the most
- 11:45precision that I can. I promise Andreas and the
- 11:50conflict that occurred on his head.
- 11:54Andres has no spoken with his best friend of 15 years for
- 11:59three weeks there was not fight, there was no betrayal.
- 12:04There was a dinner a month ago where the friend, let's call
- 12:09him, I don't know. Pablo made a comment about
- 12:13Andres and Andres work, more precisely a comment that in the
- 12:18moment sounded neutral, maybe even positive.
- 12:23But that undressed brain process different.
- 12:29That night in bed, undressed nervous system started working.
- 12:33It retrieved Pavel's tone of voice is reliable, a facial
- 12:38expression. It remembered another comment
- 12:42from six months ago that at that time he does not give importance
- 12:46to, and it builds A narrative. Pablo doesn't respect me what I
- 12:53do, he never respected. Maybe he do not even value me as
- 12:59a person. In the following weeks, every
- 13:02interaction with Pablo was processed through that filter.
- 13:06A late ripple to the message. Guess what?
- 13:09Confirmation. And absent of that event, more
- 13:12confirmation. A photo on social media where
- 13:15Pablo was with other friends? Definitely confirm it.
- 13:21Andres didn't ask Pablo anything.
- 13:24He didn't not verify anything. He simple stopping calling him.
- 13:29Pablo, meanwhile, is completely confused by Andre's silence.
- 13:35The comment at the dinner, which in his mind was generally
- 13:38positive. He does not remember it clear.
- 13:43The conflict that destroyed 15 years of friendship occurred in
- 13:47Andre's nervous system. Pablo never participate.
- 13:51He did not even have the opportunity to defend himself
- 13:55from accusation that was never formulate out loud.
- 13:59And the most disturbing question is not why Andres did that.
- 14:05The question is for you. How many times have you done
- 14:12exactly the same thing? Well, as is usual in this
- 14:18channel, I'm going to provide you with practical tools, tools
- 14:22so that you can apply them and manage the interruption of the
- 14:26simulation tool #1 the question you never ask.
- 14:31The most powerful tool to interpret the simulation is also
- 14:35the most avoided. To verify directly.
- 14:39No from accusation, no from already constructor narrative.
- 14:44For genius, curiosity and real vulnerability, say things like I
- 14:50want to ask you something. I noticed something in your last
- 14:54interaction and I'm not sure if I interpreted it correctly.
- 14:59Can you help me to understand that?
- 15:02What did you mean when you say that these kind of questions?
- 15:08The fear of asking that question is proportional to the certainly
- 15:14with which the brain holds the narrative.
- 15:18The more sure you are that other judge you, the more terrified it
- 15:23seems to ask. There is no a coincidence that
- 15:27is department electric system protecting.
- 15:30It is a story tool #2 the projection in inventory.
- 15:36When you are in conflict with someone.
- 15:38Before acting from the that narrative, ask yourself this
- 15:41question in sequence. What I do believe the others
- 15:45faults or think, what evidence do I have directly verified of
- 15:52that? What part of this narrative
- 15:55could be a projections of my own fear, my own story, my own
- 16:01current state, Not deny the conflict.
- 16:05To separate what is real from what your nervous system
- 16:09fabricate, it's essential that you give the opportunity to make
- 16:12yourself these questions to #3 state as context.
- 16:18Before elaborating an interpersonal reading, check the
- 16:23state of your nervous system. Are you reset or exhausted?
- 16:27Regulate or an alert with low or elevate cortisol?
- 16:32The same social signal, the same silence, the same tone, the same
- 16:36expression is going to be interpreted in a radical
- 16:39different way depending on your psychological state.
- 16:44It's not that sometimes you read well and other times badly.
- 16:48Is that the state of your nervous system that terminate
- 16:51the filter through which you build the simulation of the
- 16:56other? I want to close this podcast
- 17:00with something that is going to make you little uncomfortable.
- 17:06Look at that, it sounds like a joke.
- 17:08The author of this podcast myself in predictive mode.
- 17:15Anyway, let's see. If sizing is right and it is a
- 17:22very solid evidence, then a large part of what you believe
- 17:28you know about the people around you is a construction of your
- 17:33own nervous system, a simulation, A projection.
- 17:39How you thought about how huge that implied, because it implies
- 17:46that many of the conflict you carried in your body never
- 17:51occurred the way that you remember them, that people you
- 17:55distance them from perhaps never did what your brain decide they
- 17:59did. That judgment you hold about
- 18:02others were built with materials that have nothing to do with
- 18:07those people. And the most uncomfortable
- 18:11question of all, the one I want you take with you today, is, if
- 18:18the other is not what you believe they are, who is the
- 18:23person you really are in conflict with?
- 18:28I'm going to leave you thinking about this.
- 18:32Well, well, well, what intense episode my friends, isn't it?
- 18:38Well, if this episode made you uncomfortable, good.
- 18:44Share it with someone who also needs to be made uncomfortable.
- 18:49If you are not subscribed, subscribe to Narrow Motion Live
- 18:52podcast on Spotify, Apple podcast or Amazon podcast.
- 18:57So you help me to reach more people that could use this
- 19:02content. OK, well, this was Narrow Motion
- 19:08Live podcast. My name is Fabian Ernesto Guida.
- 19:12And remember, maybe you don't know anyone.
- 19:18Maybe you only know what your nervous system decide to see in
- 19:24them. See you in the next episode.
- 19:28Bye. Music.