Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #Channel-Episode 8-What is an authorial voice in gaming
Transcript
- 0:00Wow, this is hashtag channel a podcast about discord with Ben and Steve.
- 0:08Well, actually, a hashtag means it's a channel. Get get where's my
- 0:23Where's where's my switch? Where's my switch? One? Get to its news
- 0:30shows? What a fucking the film podcast? Now? What show is this?
- 0:35What are we doing this time? What show is this? This is
- 0:37the Channel one? Right? Yeah, you got it right? Now?
- 0:39Do I have to pick funny names for people? No, that's a news
- 0:42show? Different show? Are we doing an A M A? No new
- 0:45show? God? Like, you just have me podcasting day and night.
- 0:49Ben. I know, it's like it's like it's like you're one of those
- 0:53lads who build the pyramids. Finally I finally understand what it's like to be
- 0:57working class exactly, podcasting the classic working class profession. So listeners, welcome
- 1:04to the more podcasters in the world right now than So, the reason Steve
- 1:14is having that little loll about me being a slave driver is that I did
- 1:17call him yesterday and said, Mabe, we've got two shows. Yeah,
- 1:22I apparently work for Ben now? Yeah, yeah, the salary is great.
- 1:26How much of that juicy patronage am I getting loads pleasure? Minus whatever
- 1:32you contribute to the patron. I mean, I get kudos on the discord,
- 1:34so with this though, I mean, you were the one who sort
- 1:38of pressurized me into doing the movie show. You were like really into it
- 1:42and that. So I don't even know where the idea came from. Did
- 1:45it just sort of is it like the Ironian Burger Canal promo card? Like
- 1:48we sort of both? I mean, really was my idea? We sort
- 1:52of who first on the credits? Whose name comes first? You're before Vi
- 1:56Rosenberg. That's right outrageous. Yeah. So yeah, but you know,
- 2:00you know you're out there, You're respected. People come up to you at
- 2:04conventions and go, hi, you Ben, who's this Dickare you know what
- 2:07I mean? Hilarious? Yeah, so welcome Dashtag channel. We'll get onto
- 2:12our main subject in a minute. But Steve's got a little bug bear because
- 2:15I bullied him on the discord Before that, I was listening to our battle
- 2:21report coming over, because I'm nothing if not an incredible narcissity. I assume
- 2:23that you listened to the whole thing right after editing it and before you post
- 2:29it with misspelled Oh, I listened to it of the game look on the
- 2:31look on the website, and you really you you really just live in the
- 2:36moment. It's not misspelled at all. It's not misspelled at all. It
- 2:39isn't you're accusing me of misspelling the episode alder Bar and Dull. Yeah,
- 2:44yeah, you misspelled it. I'll show I'll show your name. Ah is
- 2:46that what you were doing in the bathroom? Well, wait a minute,
- 2:53wait a minute, will the new will the new episode with the new title
- 2:55that was never changed Aldebar and Jewel? It's about correctly? Will it be
- 3:00spelled correctly on my phone? Just because where I have already downloaded, just
- 3:04because Tim Cook's a I can't spell things correctly. Look at that real time
- 3:09updating. Don't you mean real time it was always spelled correctly. I feel
- 3:14like I'm being gasolt. I'm turning the lights down. One thing for the
- 3:20listeners. That's the play gas light. Where where the our listeners know the
- 3:23reference? Ben, you're talking about hours? Do you think they know the
- 3:27reference nineteen fifties play gas lit. They either do or they will pretend that
- 3:30they do. Oh, certainly, certainly that anyway. So I was bullying
- 3:36you on the discord, and because because you're a bully, because you would
- 3:39just have to diminish others to make yourself feel better. You were talking about
- 3:43pathetic. You don't think that's bullying. I'm standing up to a bully.
- 3:52Oh is that what it is? Standing up to a book? Come from
- 3:54a standard? Grand State? Yeah right, fucking it's New Jersey a standard.
- 4:00But Florida is My mom lives in Florida. Okay. Anyway, So
- 4:03you were talking about playing through the Ages? Yes, and I said to
- 4:08you, you need to talk about it on a video game channel. Yes,
- 4:11that was That was a very It was a stunning quip. Yeah,
- 4:14it me. So I'm going to ask you the question that I want you
- 4:17to ask me back. If you're playing like on BGA or on a vassal
- 4:23that people talk about vassal tabletop simulator stimulator, are you are you really playing
- 4:30a board game thing? I mean, this is exactly my question, Ben.
- 4:33If you're playing a board game online on one of these simulation tools,
- 4:39are you really playing a board game? Does it count as playing a board
- 4:42game or is it a I don't want to say video game, but a
- 4:46digital game that it represents a board game? So do you need the social
- 4:48component? And is a social component accurately captured by you know, mediated interaction.
- 4:55Why did you get into board games? God, I don't know.
- 5:00I mean they were physically put in front of me, and they were they
- 5:02were fun, and they were full of like hidden surprises. They're stimulating.
- 5:06There's like puzzles to figure out I mean everything that has to do with them
- 5:11being in person, in life present. But there was also not really any
- 5:15other option. Yeah, so I got into board games because I was in
- 5:19my mid thirties and I was looking for a social activity that didn't you know,
- 5:26that wasn't going to the pub and drinking. Yeah, definitely doesn't worked
- 5:30really well. But it turns out you can combine drinking with just about anything,
- 5:35included driving the school bus. So the thing is, I so there
- 5:42is a reason I don't play through the ages on the app. And I
- 5:45discussed this many times. I think you don't want to get better at it.
- 5:48That's not the issue. I don't want to get burnt out on it.
- 5:51I haven't yet. Yeah, something I don't think you would, to
- 5:55be honest. Well, also to play Civilization. I did play Civilization.
- 6:00Yeah, could you conceive of burning out on that? Like? I think
- 6:02you could probably get tired of it after a day, but you would never
- 6:04get tired of it permanently. Yeah, well, I don't know. I
- 6:08mean, because a game is through the ages doesn't say very long on the
- 6:10app, does it not? Particularly it depends how many opponents you have or
- 6:13if you're playing with real people are just the AI And also so firstly I
- 6:17don't want to get burned out in it, but secondly I love sitting around
- 6:20a table and the whole that that, to me is part of the experience.
- 6:26Though I think board games as an art form should be appreciated as mechanical
- 6:30devices. It doesn't have to be either or though, does it? No,
- 6:33of course it doesn't. But it's how often you get to play through
- 6:35the Ages? Well, I could play it more if I requested it more,
- 6:41right, But it's it's all about It's all about it. So I
- 6:46guess I'm a theater actor, right, And so there is something intangible about
- 6:55a communal sort of brain connection that you can't get from an app. When
- 7:00you're so being on stage, you can tell, and it's not through sort
- 7:08of obvious demonstrable reactions, but you can tell if the audience are into the
- 7:13show you're doing this is what I always loved about going to the theater,
- 7:15just being somewhere where like there are like it's different than going to the movies,
- 7:19right, because there are real human beings there and it creates an entirely
- 7:23different kind of And there's this idea, you know that for a game to
- 7:30be fun, that you have to be going woo woo and boo woo,
- 7:33standing up in a roll in dice. It's just not true. You can
- 7:35have a very intense, very silent interaction between four people around a table from
- 7:44the outside. This is why. This is why you know, photos of
- 7:47conventions don't convey conventions because or photos of people playing games don't convey that thing.
- 7:55Because you see people with these sort of they look either angry or bored
- 8:00staring at a table, and you say, my god, that looks so
- 8:03boring. These people look so bored, but they're not. They're intensely thinking.
- 8:05I see this as leading toward you taking the Tory position that all technology
- 8:09is bad. No, I think technology is great. I wouldn't be able
- 8:15to disseminate your great wisdom to the world if we didn't have technology. It's
- 8:18just something in board games, something I admire about board games is the fact
- 8:24that they're wilfully analog. What about the board games that require usage of an
- 8:28app. It depends on the use depends on the usage of the app.
- 8:31I mean. The thing is, I'm not against anything on principle, You've
- 8:35got to try it before you can decide whether you like it or not.
- 8:39But there is something wilfully it's something look at the whole milliea board games right.
- 8:46Firstly, it's wilfully analog in a way that the society is running away
- 8:52digitally, right, AI is now the big thing? Does it need to
- 8:56be? I mean, can you imagine a future and maybe for you this
- 8:58would be a ystopia in which basically there doesn't seem to be a need to
- 9:05have a polish. You have a glass top table with generic electronic components on
- 9:09the Apple goggles. Right, You don't actually have to publish this shit anymore.
- 9:13You don't have to like manufacture things in China and ship it overseas.
- 9:16And I might I might say incredibly Malthusian here, but I think there is
- 9:20the reason people love board games is that they're wilfully analog. That they get
- 9:24you around a table with people that you're into interfacing with wood and even even
- 9:31especially when you're with me, well indeed plastic components and you're you're manipulate.
- 9:37The thing about board games, computer games do all they do, all the
- 9:41tabulation for it for you, whereas board games you're manipulating that yourself. It's
- 9:46it's hands on. It's why people like handmade shit. It's why people like
- 9:50to see their coffee made and not come out with the computer. And the
- 9:52computer doesn't cheat, doesn't make mistakes, right, and which you know you
- 9:56don't want to cheat or make mistakes in a board game, but it does
- 9:58take a a little bit of the human edge. The thing is, we
- 10:01are human. We evolved as as we are, and so unless we move
- 10:05to a next stage of evolution that we become silicon beings and live in the
- 10:09client, board games give us something ineffably human, right, Yeah, Ben
- 10:16Maddox at the vanguard of human evolutions. Well, it's it's like sport,
- 10:20right, And people are very resistant to technology and sport because there's this feeling
- 10:26that it somehow takes away, especially in refereeing, that it somehow takes away
- 10:31from the human You're not allowed to use technology, and there's somewhere they always
- 10:37use it. I mean I don't remember. I mean, I know American
- 10:39football. They I think that they in order to determine if you've gotten a
- 10:43first. This is Steve pretending he knows something about sport. I don't.
- 10:48I don't. I don't funk all about sports. I remember hearing things,
- 10:50Oh, they used to do this, and now they do that, or
- 10:52like it's got to be up to the referees. Even if they had a
- 10:56camera, they can't use the footage. So like, whatever does you see
- 10:58on TV? The referees aren't looking at it. I don't know. Somebody
- 11:01who knows about this shit just write it on the discord. So also,
- 11:05right, I like this topic because it's not precisely black and white. And
- 11:09in part, I'm just I'm very curious about this online board game scene because
- 11:13people constantly talk about it. They will even say it's better to play certain
- 11:18games on tabletop. So I can think I can think of a game that
- 11:22is better to play on bold game arena than it is around a table.
- 11:24What can't stop? Okay, why just because during the pandemic? Yeah,
- 11:30just because it just seems ball game arina especial. I don't talking about tabletop
- 11:33simulator. I think tabletop simulator is an item out failure essentially. I've never
- 11:39looked at it. It's no fun because it tries to simulate a tabletop and
- 11:43you have to pick shit up and it doesn't really work and anyway, but
- 11:48there's something about the just the fiddliness of passing the dices. I mean,
- 11:54it takes longer if you're playing it in real time than it does with BGA.
- 11:58It sounds a bit like special pleading though for this one particularly. No,
- 12:01that's just an example. So the point is, are you playing a
- 12:03real board game if you're playing on the app, if you're playing the carcassion
- 12:07a Particular Ride app through the Ages app, I don't think you are right.
- 12:11That's not to condemn it. If that's what you're fucking into, that's
- 12:16fine. I don't think you're playing the board game though, but I do
- 12:18believe that you have to. Yeah, but understand you're saying that the game
- 12:22is in somehow is somehow captured. The essence of the game resides in its
- 12:26physicality, absolutely, because I think some people would argue that the essence of
- 12:31the game isn't its physicality, it is the met as mechanism. Yeah,
- 12:35like I could. I could, Like I could build you through the Ages
- 12:37right now with like some random cubes and some paper, right and it would
- 12:43be the same game essentially. Yeah, but you would have to say that
- 12:46it's different. For if I did that, you would have to be able
- 12:48to say that those two things are different. Yes, because if the essence
- 12:50of the game is in the mechanics, then you can have a digital representation
- 12:54which is the same game. Yes. But but but the thing is,
- 12:56if you have a digital representation, especially like an app. I'm not talking
- 13:00about Vassal or tabletop simulator BGA sort of straddles the two. But if you're
- 13:05talking about an app, as I said this, you're doing the bookkeeping yourself.
- 13:09That is a very that is a very typical thing about board games.
- 13:13The digital games don't offer you the ability to do that. You don't have
- 13:16to set it up, you don't have to put it away. Through the
- 13:18Ages app in particular, it has me like many different modes you can play
- 13:22in that don't exist in the board games. It's actually like more game than
- 13:26the board game. The thing is that in the entire world of competitors that
- 13:28you have available. The thing is I think you so. Board games for
- 13:33me are a local medium too, right, I think there is so.
- 13:39I know a lot of people on the internet, but they don't become solid
- 13:45people until I meet them in person. I think that's something intrinsically human and
- 13:48I and it's the same. I could play carcass On on the app and
- 13:54then come to play it as the board game. I don't think I've played
- 13:56the board game until I've played it on the table. I think people are
- 14:00often looking for interchangeable competitors. They don't care about the actual people sure behind
- 14:05the avatar. Well, also, they're looking for the opportunity to play and
- 14:07because so there's lots of factors. I know people who've only played certain games
- 14:13on Yeah, there's lots of factors as to why people may search for an
- 14:16app, often simply because if you look at the massive boom in online role
- 14:24playing, which blows my mind because I've tried it and I find it a
- 14:26completely over a zoom. Yeah, yeah, and I found it a completely
- 14:28sterile experience. It's because people just want to do it and the people around
- 14:35them in meat space are fucking unreliable. Right, And then if the app
- 14:39is compelling enough it compels you to play it, But then you also have
- 14:43to understand the ramifications of that. I mean, you could live in the
- 14:46middle of nowhere and have nobody to play with, you could have kids,
- 14:50and it's just too hard for you to get out. But the point is
- 14:52the options are digital games or solo games. You might have to resign yourself
- 14:56to the fact that you don't get to play through the Ages in person again,
- 14:58or if you do, you don't get to enjoy it because now you've
- 15:03played through the Ages many many more times than me, because you've played on
- 15:07the cuck app, And so I don't know how much better I'm getting out
- 15:11of it, To be honest, I mean you you are like I was
- 15:13listening to the Battle Report coming over, and you are sort of Dustin Hoffman
- 15:16and rain Man. So I mean, you're gonna be better than me anyway.
- 15:18But I mean, play against famed board game designer Isaac Shallev, right,
- 15:22you may be incredibly superior to me. And it's like that thing if
- 15:24you play tennis. If two people of the same standard play tennis with each
- 15:28other, they have a great time. If two people, if fairly massively
- 15:31disparate, play together it's do you know, terrible for both The app gives
- 15:35you that you don't get in real life, not as easily. It gives
- 15:39you all the data about what's going on in the show, like the complete
- 15:41game state, like what cards you're using, I think, like what's been
- 15:45played. You can always like you can always look at everything that is like
- 15:48that. You could know in the game. All the information that could be
- 15:52available is in various screens. But I never look at that stuff. I
- 15:56think famed board game designer Isaac Shalev does, and it makes him more competitive.
- 16:00I mean, he can, he can weigh in on this on his
- 16:02own, as I'm sure he will, But do you know what it does?
- 16:03But I think that that stuff probably makes you good at playing the app
- 16:07version of the game, but you can't. I wonder if that translates to
- 16:11the table. I'm sure you must to somebody. I think a little bit
- 16:12like probably working with the card display. You get better at that, you
- 16:18know, you get you simply understand how the game functions better. You know
- 16:21what what should I go for? What should I go for? How?
- 16:22I mean, I think through the ages of the game in which you have
- 16:25to be incredibly opportunistic yes, and you need to know how to how to
- 16:29play that row of cards, but it's probably not the only way that you
- 16:33can get better at the game. I know that Isaac likes to optimize for
- 16:37what resources he's producing, for like which things that he wants to build,
- 16:41and I never never go there mentally, But but do you know, do
- 16:45you know what he doesn't give you? Right this beautiful face sitting I mean,
- 16:49look at this. I'll just have a shave today because it's Valentine's Day
- 16:52as we record this, So you look, you look ten minutes younger exactly,
- 16:56So you through the ages and you know you're about to declare war on
- 17:03a person in the next round. What it doesn't give you, what an
- 17:07Apple will never give you is that sitting there with the card in your hand,
- 17:12knowing or going to do that. It doesn't give fucking war of culture
- 17:15that at you the first time, let's not talk about it. It doesn't
- 17:19give you that wonderful anticipation of their facial expression when you put the card down
- 17:25and you go you your fuck. Apps will never give you that. It
- 17:30will never give you that instantaneous sort of look of fear, rejection and and
- 17:34focus that you get when you go right, how the fuck am I going
- 17:37to fix this? Apps will never give you that intense, valuable human connection.
- 17:45A lot of players just aren't looking for that, or are they in
- 17:48denial about the fact that they are are not looking for that. I think
- 17:52I think both can be true. And you know, you see instances,
- 17:57and I don't think this is the sole reason, but you see instances of
- 18:00sort of depression and stuff rising and anxiety rising, and it's because you can't
- 18:07get away from us as animals, and we're supposed to be in groups.
- 18:12And capitalism. I think it's a capitalist lism thing. I think companies,
- 18:18whether it's deliberate or whether it's just a it's a happy chance that companies want
- 18:26us to be isolated because that gives us a gap within our for want of
- 18:33a better soul. I don't know if they want us to be isolated.
- 18:34I think it serves their interests. It just happens to serve their interest.
- 18:38Well, if we have a hole inside us, we want to fill it
- 18:41with things, because it usually gets filled with human interaction, and it gets
- 18:45filled with fucking exact rinkets and bullshit the attention economy. So I mean one
- 18:51reason I don't get into digital board games, I think is like, in
- 18:56my mind, I've just categorized boardgaming as a social activity, and if I
- 19:00to play digital board games, it would feel to me like it's at the
- 19:02expense of social activities somehow, Right. I already spend enough time like on
- 19:07my phone and looking at the screens, which is partly another reason why I
- 19:11love games, because they're willfully analog. All Right, So that was interesting,
- 19:14Steve, wasn't it. Yeah, but we want to hear from you.
- 19:15I'm pointing at the mic. Should we move on to the next section
- 19:18that indicates that if you're in the discord? Yeah? So do people who
- 19:22listen to the hashtag channel show? Are they patrons? Or is this this
- 19:27one's on the main feed. I know you're exhausted from all the podcast in
- 19:30work you've been doing. What isn't on the main feed isn't on the main
- 19:34feed? Film show okay, buttle reports Okay, everything else is on the
- 19:38main feedab So we're trying to like pull people into the discord. Yeahw dot
- 19:44five G for d dot com, the w W W five G for d
- 19:47dot com, five G for d dot com and click thepinposts at the top
- 19:53of the page of that website, which is an invitation, like a permanent
- 19:57invite, your permanent invite. I'm pointing at the mic again to join us
- 20:02in the most scintillating board gaming community. On the good it's good, it's
- 20:07very intellectual. We like the intellectual dark web. On we I mean,
- 20:11I mean, I'm not kidding. Are you like the Sam Harris of the
- 20:14board game media sphere? Is that? Is that praise or damning with faint
- 20:18praise? I don't know. Well, let's move on to after altogether too
- 20:23much consultation with the greatest minds in the world, topics we present this is
- 20:34all right? So this topic was a Steven Cyrex suggested topic, so you
- 20:40could tell that it was the sort of airy intellectual side. I don't even
- 20:45remember which one, so much so that a lot of people's a lot of
- 20:48people's responses yep. On the channel wasn't like a response to the question,
- 20:52it was what do you mean? That was a lot of responses. Why
- 20:56do you have to be like this? Because you're just too clever for all
- 20:59of us, Steve, So, like, what question would you ask?
- 21:00What would be your question of the month? Huh, what it professional podcaster?
- 21:07They can't scare quotes? Scare quotes? Yeah, why is it scare
- 21:12quotes? I don't know. I think I'm scar I call him inverted commas.
- 21:15But there we are. They do it like this in Germany. Yeah,
- 21:18he's doing the Germany. I hate the German. And even when they're
- 21:22doing it, they do it like this, do they? I think they
- 21:22do. They go like this, Oh, like your like you're fucking feeding
- 21:26a horse and something. Anyway, So the question was Steve, is there
- 21:30such a thing as an authorial voice in games? Oh? Yeah, this
- 21:33one. I think this sparked quite a lengthy discussion, didn't it. Well,
- 21:34yeah, most people going, oh, what do you mean? Which
- 21:37designers have the strongest voices? Is it a black mark against you to not
- 21:41have a distinctive voice. So so, Stevie, I'm going to ask you
- 21:48this, because a lot of people were asking this, what do you mean
- 21:52by authorial voice? I think if you watch certain films or read certain books,
- 21:56you can detect a voice. It can assistant voice, the mark of
- 22:02the artist somewhere in the in the in a distinctive style that comes out in
- 22:07any given in genre. And I'm wondering does this exist in games? Right?
- 22:11Like if you watch like we're gonna watch Nigmar Bergmann film. Yeah right,
- 22:15I'm sure if you watch all of his films, you could say that
- 22:18they're they're all of a piece somehow, even if they're on different topics.
- 22:22So this could be technically, it could be thematically, Like I think David
- 22:26Fincher, I think he's got like a vibe, right, he does have
- 22:29a vibe. And Alfred Hitchcock's got a vibe. Charlie Kaufman, Yeah,
- 22:33a vibe. Joseph Heller has a vibe. Yeah, yeah, you know,
- 22:37do you know? I was thinking about this, why Milton? Why
- 22:41people were confused? And do you think if you'd have asked the question in
- 22:45German rather than English? I mean, obviously I think most of the people
- 22:48are German, don't think so. But would Germans have less of a problem
- 22:55grasping the concept and didn't think about it? Why? Why would they?
- 22:57Because ball game design is on called board game designers in German? What do
- 23:02they call? They're called board game authors? Authors? Okay, and so
- 23:06and so those dimmer desk outours right, those two concepts intimately connected because we'll
- 23:12get to a post that someone talks about later, which I think highlights I
- 23:17mean, I I feel like the sort of Western anglophone attitude to what the
- 23:22designer's job is. I think that if we're gonna we're gonna carry on with
- 23:26this argument that board games are art, then there must be an authorial voice
- 23:33that you can identify sook at the games of like like Uve Rosenberg. By
- 23:37the way, we're gonna get to Ryan Orkinitzier, and I think he does
- 23:41and he doesn't. But Uve Rosenberg, he certainly seems to have a lot
- 23:44of Chivato, certainly seems to have this authorial voice. The Splatter guys have
- 23:48an authorial boy the sort of definitely does so. So I think it's I
- 23:52think it's fascinating that I think there is a resistance. So when I interviewed
- 23:57Inca Brandt all those years ago, I asked her if board games for art,
- 24:03and she said no, I mean you could look at them as simply
- 24:07craft. Yeah, yeah, exactly, just you compose them. You don't
- 24:11so maybe design not composed? Right, you design and publish. There's something
- 24:17that a company pieces together and puts out into the world as a product,
- 24:22not as somehow representative of one person's creative genius. But is that not art?
- 24:27Is art? Is that conception of what art is completely anachronistic? Does
- 24:33it come from the age in which a lot of artists would gentlemen and didn't
- 24:40have to fund themselves through their art, they could be amateurs when an amateur
- 24:45wasn't a sign of skill, it was a sign of status because you weren't
- 24:49so grubby as to be paid. And I feel that that appends itself to
- 24:55the concept of art, And that's that seems incredibly anachronistic to me. Art
- 24:59concept of art is like very much influenced by the Romantics of the nineteenth century,
- 25:03this idea that artistic production comes from inspiration or something like that. But
- 25:07the point is artists as a creative gene, independent, creative genius, untethered
- 25:11to any any influence. But all but again, you're looking at Byron,
- 25:17you're looking at Keats, you're looking at those kinds of people who were aristocrats
- 25:21essentially, who didn't need to work. And yeah, and people like Pope
- 25:26were looked down upon, sure, because they were grubby people who made money
- 25:30from their art. But that's that's anachronistic. No, I agree it's anachronistic.
- 25:34I mean if you look at I was listening to a podcast about it.
- 25:37But we assume that there are like you know, our our idea space
- 25:41is eternal. Somehow the way we think about things is the way people always
- 25:44did. Yeah, of course we did. The painting wasn't considered It's the
- 25:47chauvinism of the modern day century as ago painting. I mean, you don't
- 25:49consider someone who paints, uh, you know, paints are painting. You
- 25:55know, well, Titan was considered a craft. If you Titan, Yeah,
- 26:00if if you hire someone to paint your wall, it's not the same
- 26:03thing as like, you know, painting the Birth of Venus. But in
- 26:07that time period, what about William would have been considered very similar? But
- 26:11what about William Morris? Who mister arts and crafts? Whose whose whole?
- 26:17Whose old mo o was decorating that. I'm just saying people consider hip fact.
- 26:21I'm just saying that ideas themselves and concepts have a historicity to them.
- 26:23So you could argue, I think that art is essentially craft with an authorial
- 26:32voice. What what what makes William Morris art and not just wallpaper? Well,
- 26:37because William Morris is a very definitive authorial style. No, I think
- 26:41if we get into like the general question of what is art, we'll be
- 26:45talking for hours. All right, So I'm gonna move more gaming partake of
- 26:48this conversation at all, I think is what we're interesting. I think it
- 26:51absolutely does. But anyway, we're gonna move on to Oofaga and I can
- 26:55do an impression of him because he's him. He's from Stroud, you know,
- 26:57Strout's Stroud, Gloucestershire. Okay, you can do like a Gloucestershire.
- 27:03Yeah absolutely, they can do accents with that kind of precision. Yeah absolutely,
- 27:06Okay, let's hear it all right, My lover or you have a
- 27:08friend who tends to obsessively focus every voice you do in DNV, this is
- 27:15Gloucestership. This is specifically Stroud. So how does this read like country Bumpkin
- 27:18or something? That's what they sound like a Gloucestershire. You have a friend,
- 27:22my lover girl lush through this who tends to obsessively focus is quite a
- 27:30long quote. Who tends to obsessively focus on a designer's work, rather than
- 27:34make more measured judgments on whether a game has value, he automatically jumps on
- 27:38a designer's back catalog. I don't know how he depends how all it is
- 27:42I suppose, or latest offering praised based purely on the success of a previously
- 27:48enjoyed Some authors achieve remarkable consistency. What's the example he uses there? Do
- 27:56you think Shakespeare? Who they? Or have published humorous hits allowing them to
- 28:00say authors? Yeah? He uses authors for game designers, or of published
- 28:07numerous hits, allowing them to accumulate credit. Who does he use there?
- 28:11Or example? Does he use there? Would this be kinisia? Yes?
- 28:15Yeah, but most haven't. My friend always seems surprised and or disappointed when
- 28:19he's when this rationale fails. Perhaps it's unfair to apportion onus. It's a
- 28:25bit like anus. Isn't it a little bit solely to the author for the
- 28:27success of a game? When so many games seem to lack identity? In
- 28:32this postmodern stroke silver age post golden he asks, do we look to flagship
- 28:37designers to steer us out of this malaise? I suppose I would answer the
- 28:44concluding question with no, But where are we in a malaise? You know?
- 28:48It's interesting the way he describes the production of games is the way I
- 28:53was attempting to describe the production of plays in my never completed dissertation. So
- 29:02I was kind of making an argument that, well, one of my fundamental
- 29:06presuppositions is that you don't look at the text as being solely the work of
- 29:08one person Shakespeare, but as the product of, like, let's say,
- 29:14a lot of work shopping. Right, you can't simply say that the actors
- 29:18had no input, no involvement, because we actually have no idea what his
- 29:21intention was. He didn't publish it himself. And any of these plays,
- 29:23and many of them exist in multiple versions and quartos. There's a folio version.
- 29:29There's no like single text for Hamlet, for King Lear that we could
- 29:32say, like this is the definitive version. It doesn't exist. There is
- 29:36no even concept of a text with an author from this period. So I
- 29:40mean it could be very similar, right, Like we have chosen to create
- 29:45this idea of like a coherent work of art with a single author, But
- 29:49it isn't actually the way things work in the real world. It's just convenient
- 29:52for us to think about. It depends, So I think so the reason
- 29:56we appulsioned things to single is because we're human. It's that idea that you
- 30:03know, you hear that one person dies it's a tragedy, and you hear
- 30:07that ten thousand have died is a statistic. Because we focus the creative,
- 30:11we focus on the INDIVI also we like the idea because I think essentially we're
- 30:15an optimistic aspirational We like it. We'd like it now then it would have
- 30:21been inconceivable to take credit for really Yeah, I mean you don't think.
- 30:25You don't see the idea of the author like emerged at this time. You
- 30:27don't think marlow Christopher Marlowe coming from a different milliyear aristocratic, I don't think
- 30:33you but you don't think or for a laugh maybe he asserted, probably more
- 30:37of a laugh with him, but asserted some sort of pride in is that
- 30:42the face that launched a thousand ships? You know, maybe some sort of
- 30:47But the the idea that we have of what an author is like assigned work,
- 30:52right, this didn't exist, so I think it was just emerging.
- 30:55So I think it's interesting that you have that all sort of art forms since
- 31:00since people started taking games really seriously, which I would say is sort of
- 31:06but you know, your example of doctor Faustus is a good one because it's
- 31:10a derivative work, right, And this is another important point. A lot
- 31:14of what we consider to be original work is in some sense derivative. And
- 31:18if it's not, like obviously derivative, because it's just a version of some
- 31:21other stories someone else is told, then you know you exist in a kind
- 31:26of cultural milieu and you're drawing on various influences to put together your your own
- 31:32you know, your nie contribution. We were standing on the should as a
- 31:33job. Yeah, nothing is entirely new, right, And this is especially
- 31:37the case for board games, like you couldn't imagine a board game that comes
- 31:41like x NI low right, because any like most board game designers are avid
- 31:45board game players themselves, sure, and they will come up with a game
- 31:48that is like somewhat reminiscent when the time, When was the last time?
- 31:53A genuine original mechanism, king original mechanism, And they all seem to be
- 32:01like deck building, maybe, I mean believe in deck building like magic the
- 32:06gathering is also I think that's a spurious argument that everyone bloody uses magic.
- 32:09The gathering is not the same as dominion, but it's not the same.
- 32:13But I mean like, you know, it's completely different. You can't say
- 32:16that they're not related. Well, I mean Donald Donald Xbackerino says they're related,
- 32:21but it doesn't even matter what he says. I'm I'm Roland bart on
- 32:24this. I don't think they are related. But the point is, I
- 32:28think you're making an argument that a board game is an inherently collaborative experience,
- 32:34in the same way people argue we shouldn't put so much onus on the director
- 32:37of a movie, because I mean, because they're collaborative things, right,
- 32:43But I think to a greater or lesser degree, you can argue that they
- 32:46are and they aren't. Where do the boundaries of a game end? Like,
- 32:51for example, we are co designers of Ronienburger canal right, yes,
- 32:54yes, so before that card that we designed existed and completed the game and
- 33:00it playable, Yeah, yeah, absolutely, Like what was that game?
- 33:04And now that the card exists, what is it now? So it was
- 33:07it was a sort of fairly barely functional sort of hack work. Yeah,
- 33:12you wouldn't even really want to own it, and now it's the king Leader
- 33:15of board games. Yeah, exactly. So the point is, though I
- 33:17think I have heard so if you ever meet me in public. I'll tell
- 33:22you this, but I'm not. I'm not mentioning any names on a public
- 33:25medium. But I have heard tell because I know people within the board game
- 33:29industry of designers submitting designs, and the thing you get in the box as
- 33:34a customer is completely different, completely different. It has been completely reworked by
- 33:38the developer that just reskinned. No, no, no, completely different.
- 33:43Maybe there was one sort of central core idea and everything else is different.
- 33:46Then I think it would be very difficult to argue that the Splotter guys are
- 33:53in a process of deep collaboration. You can't attribute the ethos, the design
- 34:00ethos to their games because they seem very singular and very particular. And also
- 34:06they do have playtesters. Though sure you have playtesters. But so this is
- 34:10interesting. I was thinking about playtesters when you were talking. And playtesters are
- 34:16fascinating, right because to what degree? So I was reading. I was
- 34:21reading a biography of Derek Parfit, the famous British philosopher, and when he
- 34:24was writing his second book, he would send every chapter to one hundred different
- 34:30philosophers who would write notes and send them back, and then he would work
- 34:35on those notes. R norm particulously. Does that mean Derek parf it didn't
- 34:39come up with us ideas? Does that mean Derek Parfit didn't author the book?
- 34:43Well, I don't think this is necessarily like an interesting or important question.
- 34:46I'm not like denigrating any particular type of work by saying it emerge from
- 34:51a collaborative process. It just sounds like the point with Faga is making like
- 34:55I think this is the way art is produced. But does say that we're
- 34:59like in we're in a malaise right now? Is that because of that?
- 35:01Does that negate the notion of an authorial voice, because as opposed to a
- 35:07book which also goes through the hands of an editor. Apparently Raymond Carver,
- 35:10Raymond Carver is very sparse prose if you read the unedited versions, is very
- 35:15flowery, and his author was merciful. You know the history of the poems
- 35:21of Emily Dickinson, the original when they were first published, they were like
- 35:24heavily edited, right because her poems they're not like perfectly metered, they don't
- 35:29rhyme, And when they were first published, the editor thought that they needed
- 35:32to be because she wrote in a very distinctive style that was just uncommon and
- 35:36not done at that time, and it was only later that the originals were
- 35:39published, well, the poems and the original forms were published. They definitely
- 35:44do have an authorial voice. We can get into whether or not like his
- 35:47versions represent an entirely different version with a different voice, or even like translations,
- 35:52like do translations manage to capture an authorial voice if they're going if you're
- 35:55going from one language to another. I mean, I don't know. These
- 35:58are interesting questions, and it's why I asked. I don't have a clear
- 36:00answer. So let's move on to Scott Hill okay, closely related to Scott
- 36:06Valley, King of the I think most designers, I think he's American.
- 36:12What American accent should I do? How many American accents came? All of
- 36:15them? Let's do Kentucky Okay. I think most designers have a very clear
- 36:22and distinctive voice. He's put inverted. It comes in the forum of the
- 36:29mechanics. They choose the degree to which I integrate the theme into those mechanics
- 36:35and how they link various subsystems of the game together. So he's doing the
- 36:39argument, which which was my when you suggested this to me, and I
- 36:43thought that's a good topic. I have this thing that games and mechanical art
- 36:47forms in the authorial voice comes with the mechanisms and how they are combined.
- 36:52Right, I think I agree. A new the Rosenberg game feels like a
- 36:57new the Rosenberg game, not because of the clement froms Are, but because
- 37:00of the mechanisms. Now yeah, no, I sure. The one point
- 37:04though, that I want to dig into further is the integration between theme and
- 37:08mechanics. Okay, do we need that? Because I think a lot of
- 37:13Uve Rosenberg games have the mechanical bit down, like, oh, this is
- 37:16clearly an Uve Rosenberg game. How integrated are they with their I think he's
- 37:22one of the great. How much do they need? I think he's one
- 37:23of the great. Thematic here games consistently across all of them. I mean,
- 37:30I thought was very thematic. I sort of wondered, could you basically
- 37:36eliminate the theme and you would still have the game? Halla time that crop
- 37:38rotation mechanics, I love the corprotation is incredibly thematic. I think Uve Rosenberg.
- 37:44I think rosenbig even to the point to start with the theme and I
- 37:46have no idea, but even to the point where agricola. You're putting out
- 37:51fences and you're putting sheep in and you're fencing in those shape. That's incredibly
- 37:54thematic, I feel. I'm not disagreeing. It feels thematic to me.
- 37:58I wonder how other people think about this, Like you could you could do
- 38:02away with the theme and still have the game. So I'm trying to make
- 38:05like we're o the Ring. You couldn't really well the new the new Fight
- 38:09for Aracus is just into the back of his hands, now, you know.
- 38:14I backed it, and then I canceled the pledge because like, I
- 38:15don't need a three hundred euro o game that I'm gonna play like once,
- 38:19right, But if you have it and you live in Berlin and people are
- 38:22talking about me, people are talking about it now, and I don't know.
- 38:27I'm just I've just seen photos of people. We're about to start playing
- 38:30blah blah blah. And maybe so he's given a list of designers and I
- 38:35want you to tell me on a I want you to have a bit of
- 38:37a public rank. You love ranking everything, don't you, Yeah, love
- 38:42it. I got told off the other day for doing tier lists on my
- 38:45streams. Why because they told me games weren't about ranking tierlesss. Yeah,
- 38:52okay, I don't watch your stream, so I don't know what you're doing.
- 38:53So who told? Who told? You? Are some lad on YouTube
- 38:57and you fucking anyway suck me on. So I'm gonna want give you the
- 39:01name of the designer, and I want you ten super distinctive authorial voice.
- 39:07Yep, zero. They could just be any other bloody designer. Right,
- 39:12Well, I had heard of all of these people. I think you you
- 39:15definitely heard of all of them, and I think you have played. There's
- 39:17one whose designs I haven't played, but you have. I mean, this
- 39:21is a list of people that was Scott Hill. Scott picked them because they
- 39:24have author He thinks they have a thory of voices. Okay, So basically,
- 39:28if you asking me the contradict Scott, if you don't have high marks,
- 39:30you're telling Scott he's a bullshitter. Is he a patron? Yeah?
- 39:34Yeah, okay, I mean I knew. I think he gets a nickname
- 39:37in the next news episode. Oh when is that? Well? This week?
- 39:40Can I go home first? No? No, I don't want to
- 39:45go back to as you As you know, both of us are in the
- 39:49fucking big Ks Dungeon and we have been since we went to Distledorphan. He
- 39:53hasn't a podcast, does he need? He needs all of them, all
- 39:59right, So I mean I'm sat next to go in the next rooms,
- 40:01Bluddy Tom vassel in there. Ks is on top of everything. So vital
- 40:07aserta distinctive authorial voice on a scale of one to ten. Yeah, So
- 40:10this is not a quality. This is not where you like them or not,
- 40:14whether you think they have a distinct No, I understand. I'm just
- 40:17trying to think whether like across his games, there is a consistent authorial voice.
- 40:22I mean, obviously yes, I mean the themes are very different.
- 40:28He definitely likes to create these highly involved, interchanging I mean thematchanistic thematically.
- 40:36He feels like, you know, he's got those you know, those verbose
- 40:39those word dice that you roll. Yeah, that's what that's interesting. He
- 40:45just rolls these dice and it says monkey cats on. It was it famed
- 40:51word game designer Isaac Shaalver or someone else who pointed out the way he likes
- 40:54to like deconstruct a process or something. Yeah, yeah, someone a lot
- 40:59of that and very clever fameball game. I mean I'm to get a little
- 41:02sick of him, to be honest, being cleverer than you. Yeah,
- 41:07that's a bit much, and thinks he's so smart. Did you know I
- 41:08went on when Uli used to do a stream, I went on ULI's stream.
- 41:14Yeah, and then two weeks later, Isaac went on uliz stream and
- 41:16do you know what i Ouley said live on the stream to Isaac, something
- 41:21insulting toward you. This was the best episode we've ever done on this stream.
- 41:25You're never two weeks two weeks before I was on that bloody streams.
- 41:29You're you're never letting him on this show unless Chaos, you know, wants
- 41:32to dictate. All right, so add him to the collection. Come on,
- 41:37we can't be here all day. Give us a mark out of ten.
- 41:38I'm public rank. I'm going to say, I'm going to say eight.
- 41:42Okay, nice, There's there's enough differentiation that I don't think he I
- 41:45don't know. I don't know if ten is good. By the way,
- 41:47so well, it's just distinct authory of voice. This is not a qualitative.
- 41:51I don't know what I'm doing. Rosenberg. God, the guy likes
- 41:58FARMI games and you know, flipping over tiles and that and Polyamino's Stut nine.
- 42:05Yeah, stefan Feld ten. He is mister point salad, right,
- 42:10I think. I think these games feel like stefan feld games like very very
- 42:15much, and they feel like they're complex but very simple. I think he's
- 42:20I think he's a wonderful designer, Stefan I don't think every one of his
- 42:22games is hit, No, because he publishes a lot. But I think
- 42:25if you look at the archetypal chef Unfeld title, I mean, what do
- 42:30I like better than Trajan Castler Burgundy? Yeah, that's good. But Okay,
- 42:35besides those two, I really love Americo. I haven't played it.
- 42:40I've got it. We can play it today. No, I haven't got
- 42:44it with me. It's a bloody huge box. I've got Amsterdam myself.
- 42:47Haven't played that. Oh, we should play that. Cole Worley hmmm.
- 42:52Does he have a distinctive authorial voice? I mean, hasn't published that many
- 42:55games. I guess this is interesting because his games are pretty distinct right,
- 43:01I think they're incredibly distinctive. Yeah, so I suppose having an authorial voice
- 43:07doesn't mean that all of your games need to like feel like they're by the
- 43:12same designer right, because I individually they have a very strong voice. I
- 43:16think, I think these games feel very similar mechanically. I think, will
- 43:21you tell me that they're generally I think they're generally mechanically very simple. I
- 43:25think because I would, I would definitely say for him, like like ten
- 43:29in the sort of like distinctiveness, I think he's for good and ill.
- 43:32I think he's concept forward. So when I had my what are the similarities
- 43:38you see between like Infamous Traffic packs Premiere jeh On Company, the fact that
- 43:43the fact that there's almost the fact that there's almost no mechanisms Route is quite
- 43:46is a bit different. But the root is kind of throwing me. But
- 43:50the very similar I mean, if you look at Out, it's a very
- 43:52very simple game. And and you look at I thought Earth was like a
- 43:59box of components that you could get for designing your own game exactly. Well,
- 44:01if you look at if you look at Infamous Traffic, it's very simple.
- 44:06It's just it has so he This is when I got into my argument
- 44:10with C. T. Noyan on my show Well argument kind of spirited debate.
- 44:16We were talking about the difference between a crafts person and an artist and
- 44:22I think Cole Whorley goes into it trying to create art. Sure, he's
- 44:25very concept forward. I think he sometimes is an academic. I think he
- 44:30sometimes forgets about mechanisms. Frankly, Phil Ecklund, I think by reputation he's
- 44:37probably Yeah, I can't really talk to it because I've never played one of
- 44:39his games, like A nine, But I don't know if I've played anything.
- 44:42We've got to play a packs Renaissance though, Alban v Art. So
- 44:46I've played Time Center or whatever, small small city. Yeah, I have
- 44:52Clinic and I'd love to play that. They they look like they come from
- 44:57the same author, But I don't know if I can really say I haven't
- 45:00played enough of his games. Seven all right, So next one, Matt's
- 45:05Serrated Blade Coat. I love the fact that he has got a very cool
- 45:08nickname. It's a cool nickname. But the only reason he has the nickname
- 45:10is because you'd used the serrated blade earlier in the day to cut some bread.
- 45:15You never said how I need to come up with the name. So
- 45:17this is what I was referring to at the top of the show. It's
- 45:23an interesting question. Yeah, Matt Coate has got me British, isn't he
- 45:28Why? It just sounds like a British name, Matt Coats, doesn't it.
- 45:30I mean, I don't know any name could be American ben, So
- 45:34where's he come from? You think I'm a big fan of Yorkshire ebar gum,
- 45:39it's an I have to do that to get into the actic. It's
- 45:44an interesting question because I think a board game design as more engineering than art,
- 45:49not that it can't also be art, but the engineering is very central.
- 45:53With writers, directors, individual voice comes through in both what they're saying
- 45:58and how they're saying it. However, with board games, I feel like
- 46:01the how is much more important than the what. I think it's a perfectly
- 46:07valid point that he's making. I could see why he feels that way.
- 46:10I have a hard time agreeing that it's only engineering because board games are not
- 46:17like a problem to solve. They present problems to solve for the players.
- 46:22But usually engineering is applied to solving a particular problem, right, And there's
- 46:27obviously a mathematical component, But there's a mathematical component to like music and painting
- 46:31as well. Proportion and you know your favorite Greek Pythagoras, So I think
- 46:38I think what's really interesting is when I asked, as I've referred to earlier
- 46:44in Cabrand, is our board games art? And she said no. But
- 46:47did she say that their craft or what did she say that they I can't
- 46:50remember, but my instinct is the reason she would deny that they were art
- 46:57is twofold. Firstly, she doesn't think of herself as an artist, because
- 47:01that's a very particularly loaded term, whether anti They don't know that Shakespeare thought
- 47:07of himself as an artist, right. And also also there is this fitting
- 47:15things together. It's very difficult to argue that a car engine is art,
- 47:21right, Yeah, And I think a lot of you know, Steve Jobs
- 47:24had all of his engineers signed the inside of the first Macintosh computer, right,
- 47:29because artists should sign their work, right, So I think So the
- 47:34thing is, I think it's people think that games are about putting functioning kulgs
- 47:40together to create a machine that runs. There's something more than that, though,
- 47:45because they inspire something within the player. That is what art. Art
- 47:52is. What it's like a made thing like it is artificial, it is
- 47:57created by humans. What are game designers doing when they sit down and design,
- 48:00like? What is that activity called? And what I love about the
- 48:04art form of games is they are an art form in which the artist is
- 48:09expressly trading and unforeseen, so in unforeseen consequences, right, I mean,
- 48:14it's arguable that games are less like art because they aren't exactly in most cases
- 48:20trying to deliver a message or multiple layers you look at you look at Mondrianne.
- 48:27I mean, you could abstract out of the twentieth century. The whole
- 48:30point was to remove message, right, was to just doesn't start people from
- 48:34writing articles about it. No, of course it doesn't. So the point
- 48:37is right, As I said, games deal in unforeseen consequences. The artist
- 48:40expressly wants unforeseen consequences. Excuse me, So you have this notion breast writing
- 48:47a play. I went to see the Threepenny Opera last year and the whole
- 48:52last time we did it cast to get in. Oh it's Bellina Ensemble,
- 48:55so it was like fifteen quid more than thrupenny. Yeah. So, so
- 49:00the whole last twenty minutes is this big socialist hymn, right, and so
- 49:07brest sounds tedious. Actually it was brilliant. But I think I actually walked
- 49:10out on this show and I saw performed in New York. But Brest doesn't
- 49:14want unintended consequences. Brett also wants his audience is to suffer. I think
- 49:17yeah, but Bret's purposes deliver a message, whereas game designers kind of want
- 49:23to go back to reading or watching people play their games six months after they
- 49:30come out and go. I never saw that you could bloody do that,
- 49:35right. Games are all unintended consequences, and I think that's a fascinating art
- 49:40form, I guess. I guess that makes games closer to abstract artists,
- 49:45who I assume wanted the person coming to their art to bring the message rather
- 49:53than the artists themselves delivering it, and games do that. I think.
- 49:57I think game designers a designer to say anything interesting on this particular topic,
- 50:00I don't think I've ever asked think about it. I don't think I've ever
- 50:04asked designers on this particular topic. But what's what's fascinating, right is many
- 50:08designers, especially German designers, And I think this is a a factor of
- 50:14German designers being that it is not an aristocratic hobby in the way that it
- 50:22can be in the Western world, because a lot of people Gentleman designers brilliant
- 50:25designers who who don't. I was talking to Tony Boudell on Facebook the other
- 50:31day. He is a gentleman designer, so he's a great example. I
- 50:35was talking about Richard Brees and saying it's such a shame that he doesn't license
- 50:38his games out to other publishers because we played this, ironically, was it
- 50:44like Cathedral? We played Cathedral? Cathedral shouldn't be this grail game that no
- 50:50one can play because it's bloody brilliant. He should someone like Capstone Games would
- 50:54gobble that up and publish it in America because it's great. Maybe it doesn't
- 50:59occur whereas yet because it's a kind of even these brilliant paragon for him,
- 51:04it's like a cottage industry. Yeah, it's kind of amateur. British games
- 51:07is quite like that. German, Yeah, British, the British world is.
- 51:10German game designers a bloody professional. They work for professional companies, big
- 51:15publishing houses, and so their attitude towards their games are different. I guess,
- 51:20and they they don't like I don't want to get something wrong here.
- 51:24I guess. Germans don't publish their own games. Typically they go to the
- 51:28conventions and they work the booths and they pitch and they pitch and they pitch.
- 51:30Look at Kitsia, you see very few because also my friend ryaner Kinitzier.
- 51:36By the way, also, you know Americans, it's all about,
- 51:38you know, pulling yourself up by your own bootstraps. Right. So Kickstarter
- 51:44published games are dominated by American companies, I would assume. And this is
- 51:49game publishing in the heroic mode. Yeah, and German German game designers feel
- 51:52like it's much more of a craft than an art, right, Yeah,
- 51:54I mean it's more like communitarians somehow. All right, So moving on to
- 52:00Jim Krim, who's one of the finest minis painters I've ever seen. Yeah,
- 52:04keep the images coming, Jim, because they're very cool. Their work
- 52:07is amazing. I'm saying that because this is a little bit of a shit
- 52:08sandwich now, because I'm going to disagree with what he says. Well,
- 52:13we're here for, like I said, spirited debate. So he'd say,
- 52:19authorial voice is not that important, and the example he gives I fundamentally disagree
- 52:23with many. Ryan Kanizzi games run smoothly and they could be anybody. Yet
- 52:30some designer's fingerprints are obvious, but often this has little bearing and out good
- 52:34the game. So that second part is right a strong authorial voice. I
- 52:37think Oath is the most coal worlly game out there, and I think it's
- 52:44not very good, but most why because it feels so conceptual. It's all
- 52:51about like all of the locations have these very like lifted out of a literature
- 52:54textbook, and it's all this idea about creating a narrative, and it's all
- 53:00it feels like an academic. I want to go back to one of my
- 53:01arguments from a prior episode and say that potentially Root is his masterpiece and Oath
- 53:06is the It's like the thing that you do after your masterpiece, when you're
- 53:08trying to like outdo yourself over the hills and through the woods by Hemingway,
- 53:14for instance. I think that's what it's called. Isn't it something like that?
- 53:15Anyway? King Lear king Lear is the best player, but anyway,
- 53:22So he says that Ryan Kanisi Games could be anybody. I think that is
- 53:25so wrong. I think Ryan Kinizia has this one defining characteristic. Well,
- 53:31how do you even capture the qualities of someone who's published like six game Because
- 53:38basically what you have to do. And this may be and people will say,
- 53:42well, that completely invalidates your argument, and that's fine, But what
- 53:44you have to do with Kinetzia is go, Okay, we need to pick
- 53:46the fucking great ones. It's like I was watching a video last night about
- 53:51klaus Kinski and he did over two hundred films, and I thought, I
- 53:54really want to watch kl Kinsky. So what am I gonna do. I'm
- 53:59gonna focus out with m R exactly. I'm going to focus on the Venna
- 54:02Hertzog movies because I think that encapsulates what Kinski is as an actor. Probably,
- 54:08Well, they're they're like this company. It's like a Kia Krasaua and
- 54:13right, I think Verner Hertzog and Klaskinski had like the same, like one
- 54:16of these famous duos exactly film history. And so you need to look at
- 54:21Kninsia with the great ones. And I think Kanisia has this one authorial trick
- 54:27and I don't want to denigrate it by saying it's a trick, but this
- 54:30authorial device that he uses, and whether this is intentional or not, And
- 54:35I asked the points in the lower category, but I asked this and I
- 54:39think he kind of agreed with me, but I was complimenting him, so
- 54:42who knows whether he thought of it before we spoke in English. But yeah,
- 54:49I believe this. You're Ben Kanisia is a wonderful observer, whether consciously
- 54:53or unconsciously, of the human mind and what it what leavers it takes to
- 55:00pull to generate incredible experience. That's just good the quality of mind of a
- 55:06good designer. Or does that indicate an authority needs here? Does it particularly?
- 55:09What is the what is the voice? Kanatsia does it particularly brilliantly.
- 55:13If you look at his if you look at his great games, you look
- 55:15at modern Art, High Society, Stevenson's Rocket. These are games in which
- 55:21he manipulates the player behavior to generate fun. He does this more than any
- 55:25designer I know. That is distinct the idea that they could be anybody,
- 55:30sure, I'm sure there's lots of games that could be. But he often
- 55:35designs games that they feel like they can really stand the test of time,
- 55:38you know, because what they are, what he understands instinctively I think as
- 55:43a designer, is that it's actually about human interaction. It is not about
- 55:47a beautifully tooled machine. But why why does so few of his games really
- 55:52like break Out? Like? He doesn't really have hits, does he?
- 55:55He simply has like endurance or something. It's something about So I think a
- 56:00lot of I think there is a journey. I think putting his name on
- 56:04the box is not going to sell. No, it doesn't because he fucking
- 56:07because he spunks his name on fucking every box. Right. But the point
- 56:09is, and I just want the listeners to put he means that literally,
- 56:16So I think there's a gamer journey. It might just be me and my
- 56:22like does the authorial voice even make you want to buy a game? I
- 56:23mean, you keep going, but you'll buy any Uve Rosenberg game? Reesels
- 56:27right, and it must be for that reason. I can't think of anything.
- 56:30I trust him. I trust him. Yeah, So the point is
- 56:31Knatsia, right, I think. So I'm going to tell you my story,
- 56:35and I think it's maybe And if you can go on the discord and
- 56:37you can tell me whether I'm talking out of my ass or not, they
- 56:40will. I think it's often the story of many gamers. I got into
- 56:45games, and when I got into games, rinding about twenty eleven twenty twelve
- 56:47the big names of Uber Rosenberg, Steffan Felt in the euro Arena right,
- 56:52and then Fantasy Flight with the with the behemoth standing astride ameritrash gaming right.
- 57:00And I went years and years and I'd hear I'd listened to podcasts and I'd
- 57:04hear people talking about Canetsia and I never got it. And there's a very
- 57:07good reason why I never got it, which is I'd never really played any
- 57:12of his games. Okay none, Yeah, I mean I'm sure I had
- 57:15from time to time. But the classics are considered what like Samurai Tigers and
- 57:20Neufridi mod not through the Desert Blue High Society. I don't think Blue Lagoon's
- 57:24considered classic. I mean there's like that that group of games that are the
- 57:28auction games are considered classic. And then then I started, maybe sort of
- 57:35five six years into my gaming career, I started playing Kanitsi games. For
- 57:38some reason, they sort of popped up, and once you play one,
- 57:42you're like, oh, I've got to play them all now, which you
- 57:45want? And then you I realized, oh, I see it now.
- 57:52I understand why he is held in such high esteem because these games are astonishing,
- 58:00a bit like the Shakespeare of modern board gaming. I think who he's
- 58:04the greatest leading designer right, well he is, but he's also a businessman,
- 58:07and he's out there to sell product. And Shakespeare was out there to
- 58:10sell product. And the same person who wrote Hamlet and King Lear also wrote
- 58:15The Comedy of Errors and the Two Noble Kinsmen or whatever. The point is.
- 58:17The person who painted the persistence of Time was a fucking hack. It's
- 58:22just an incredibly good hack, you know, like all the Jesus stuff that
- 58:27he did. Yeah, I think Darley's great, but he when you say
- 58:30hack, what do you mean doing it for the fucking money? Okay?
- 58:34Yeah, right, sure? I mean who said was it? Was it
- 58:37Alexander Pope? Who said only or was it? Was it Benjamin Franklin?
- 58:39Like only a fool? Was it? What's the line like, like you
- 58:44would have to be a fool not to write for money? I don't remember
- 58:45the exact quote, no idea, Please someone find it later. Samuel Johnson.
- 58:49That sounds like a Samuel Johnson. Maybe Samuel Johnson. Anyway, we
- 58:52got one more, one more comment, Steve. Is it from famed board
- 58:55game designer it was? Did he not weigh in on this one? Now?
- 58:59So I'm punishing Isaac. Well, I mean we're going to find out
- 59:01everything he thinks in March other Riacon. Yeah, I'm punishing him. Why
- 59:06because bringing him in the corner. I did a new thing this month,
- 59:09because because the thing is I compile the episodes, right, yeah, which
- 59:15means I have to go through all the Discord posts, right. It's difficult
- 59:17to find the Discord post sometimes, So I used the functionality on Discord,
- 59:23the thread functionality, which you can start a thread right, and then every
- 59:29response underneath it is just linked to that thread. So you can then click
- 59:34on the thread and you see every takes It takes you out of the channel
- 59:37though, and I think people just miss it specifically. So all of these
- 59:40they're in the threat answered on the thread. I didn't see them. Guess
- 59:44who didn't answer on the thread. Famed board game designer Isaac sho Oh,
- 59:49so you want to get on the show, answer on the thread. It
- 59:51only counts if it's in the thread, now, yeah, well for the
- 59:53show, Yeah, I mean you can go on the hashtag channel ab true,
- 59:55you are you are a harsh mistress. Well, I was worried that
- 59:59it might not work, but I got eight there was eighty one responses on
- 1:00:01the thread, So I'm like, how many eighty one? Eighty one responses?
- 1:00:06Yeah, do we have eighty one people in there? No, eighty
- 1:00:08one responses, So eighty one people having conversations and shit, oh eighty one.
- 1:00:13Okay, I got anyway, some comments or something. So I'm going
- 1:00:16to read you this because this is very much in the style of the author.
- 1:00:22This person certainly has an authorial voice. Okay, this is from who
- 1:00:25do you think? C? Hunter? Yes? It is, yeah,
- 1:00:31our favorite. So I don't want I agree with him. I want you
- 1:00:36to unpack this statement. There is an authorial voice, but it isn't located
- 1:00:42in the designer. It's located in the critic and the consumer. Is that
- 1:00:46the hall that's the quote? So firstly, what the fuck does that mean?
- 1:00:51With all respect, why didn't he write like ten paragraphs of legally He
- 1:00:55didn't. He didn't. Actually that was the quote that would be that would
- 1:00:59be more in keeping his own authorial voice. So I don't get it.
- 1:01:05I think he's trying to say that there's something that we perceive it we project
- 1:01:08authorial voice onto work. I wonder if he was a philosophy major they talk
- 1:01:13about philosophy a lot on the discord. Yeah yeah, I mean this could
- 1:01:15be like a philosophical sort of perspective, with all due respect, as it
- 1:01:20exists independently of our perceptions. With all due respect, I think that's bollocks.
- 1:01:22Tell me why well? I think. I think if you read a
- 1:01:25Chuck Palahuniac book, yeah right, the way he constructs sentences is. I
- 1:01:30am not imposing that particular cadence and rhythm and use of words that Chuck Palahunik
- 1:01:37uses. It's there, it is. It is the way he constructs sentences.
- 1:01:42Right. I'm not just saying, oh, it sounds the same.
- 1:01:45I think if you there are so many distinctive writers, and Aaron Sorkin,
- 1:01:52fucking what's his face? What's Bob Johnson? Johnny Bobson. Who's the guy
- 1:01:57who does all the sweepy, sweepy camera movements, really thin red line guy.
- 1:02:02Oh, Terrence Mallet, Terrence Malick, you're not telling me I'm imposing.
- 1:02:07Terry Gilliam, Terry Gilliam, You're not telling me I'm imposing a style
- 1:02:09on that. I mean, it is not imposed by the consumer and the
- 1:02:13critic. It is. It is instantiated by the artist. Now I'm not
- 1:02:16saying that it doesn't happen. I mean, surely it does. But the
- 1:02:21idea that that is an absolute statement, it's clearly wrong. No, you
- 1:02:23know, probably it's a matter of perspective. And these are two like irreconcilable
- 1:02:28points of view. On the one hand, saying that is objectively the case
- 1:02:31that these qualities exist in these works independently of any observer, as you can
- 1:02:36clearly see from the evidence that you just cited, or actually all of these
- 1:02:38ideas are really just products of our own mind and perception and they can't possibly
- 1:02:44exist like inherently in this it's the argument that color doesn't exist. Right,
- 1:02:47color doesn't exist. It's something like that, because he's actually all it does
- 1:02:52is a frequency of raise coming that is that that is what color is.
- 1:02:58Well, how we perceive it is a different thing, right, But yeah,
- 1:03:00I don't I don't know. There's like no way out of I tried
- 1:03:04to. I tried to speak about science then, and I realized halfway through
- 1:03:07you did really well though, thank you. Yeah, I don't think there's
- 1:03:10a way to, like, as I'm saying, reconcile these two points.
- 1:03:13If you think, well, I think I think one is impossible. I
- 1:03:15think one is demonstrably false. How do you demonstrate it by through reasoned argument
- 1:03:21like what I just done? Well, I think that for the summer party,
- 1:03:25of the five D for D summer party that ceed Hunter is throwing in
- 1:03:28New Zealand. God, God, I'm not sure. Honestly, after the
- 1:03:30Christmas party, I'm not sure I can deal with it. I know he's
- 1:03:34an animal, but if we're really like hash this out, we need to
- 1:03:36do person Literally, I went to New Zealand and someone just got my liver,
- 1:03:40put it on a table and just hammered it repeatedly. I'm not sure
- 1:03:44I can deal hostess with the mostus indeed, so shall we move on?
- 1:03:49What are we moving on to? Post? Months? In an act of
- 1:03:52willful competition, we present our all right, Stevie, I would like to
- 1:04:00say Lee because he didn't post. I'm actually thinking it should be Solid Steve.
- 1:04:04Solid. Steve didn't post a poster of the moment. Anyone who compliments
- 1:04:10you is instantly un valid. Unvalid, that's what unvalid is not allowed to
- 1:04:17be posted a month why because they've complimented you. Ben Maddox is five g
- 1:04:23f D. So if they compliment you, then what oh the post for
- 1:04:26a month of my heart? Yeah, because you don't choose poster in the
- 1:04:29month, choose every time. So I don't have too many options here,
- 1:04:31do I got loads of options? Well, I'm only among the ones that
- 1:04:34you read out loud on the air. Yeah you got Faga, You've got
- 1:04:38Scott Hill, You've got mace Errated Blade Coach, you got Jim Krim,
- 1:04:41you got that quite a lot. C. D. Hunter. I think
- 1:04:45I'm gonna so what is my criteria here? Who you think post of the
- 1:04:49month is? Okay? So Ufaga was the one where I kind of found
- 1:04:54some like relationship to Yeah, I did the great Stroud accent. Yeah,
- 1:04:58yeah, okay? And then who's next? Scott Hill was the one who
- 1:05:00had the list of lads, right next, mat Serrated Blade was the one
- 1:05:03who said it's more engineering not design yep. Then Jim Krim was the one
- 1:05:09who said Ryan Knezia doesn't have an authorial voice, okay, and then CD
- 1:05:13Hunter says it's located in the critic and the consumer. It's funny. I
- 1:05:16feel like I don't really agree with any of them, right, We're like,
- 1:05:19there's much more to be said much more to be said on this topic,
- 1:05:23but I think that O Faga led to the most voluminous conversation between you
- 1:05:28and I. So I'm going to give a poster of the month to FAGA.
- 1:05:31Congratulations. That was our all right, So this is the octroly been
- 1:05:42going on far too long stage. There's more. I'm going to go through
- 1:05:45this list. There's more. I'm gonna go through this list and then we
- 1:05:47can go out list of what what the wrap up the podcasts? We're going
- 1:05:53out? He's letting us out. Yeah, Well, I mean into the
- 1:05:57designated exercise where oh okay, I like the exercise square all five minutes I
- 1:06:02get to spend in it. So, first of all, how do people
- 1:06:05join the disc called Steve? First of all, you need to imagine yourself
- 1:06:12as part of this community, and then you are part of that community.
- 1:06:15Exactly. To practically engage with it, you need to go to five g
- 1:06:18for d dot com and click on the pinned post at the top of the
- 1:06:23page. Well, you don't really need to click on the post. You
- 1:06:25need to click the link that's in the post exactly, because that link is
- 1:06:28you need to click on the post to find the link. You need to
- 1:06:30click the invite link the pinned post at the top of the pageplosives here,
- 1:06:35and you'll be readirect You'll be. You'll be there immediately, immediately thrown in.
- 1:06:40You'll be. You'll be holding hands with Matt Coates and famed board game
- 1:06:43designer Isaac Shaalev and wrestling with CD Hunter and Saga and Cuthulu Dreams. The
- 1:06:48whole gang is there waiting to welcome you. Excellent, so also tell them
- 1:06:54what they should do. With regards to ratings and reviews, Steve, you
- 1:06:59need to find a way to rate and review this podcast. I don't actually
- 1:07:01know how to do it. Where do you go to rate? Like fucking
- 1:07:03iTunes on that? But where is iTunes these days? Have no idea,
- 1:07:06Like it's not on Apple. These people are probably I'm like you. I
- 1:07:10don't want to marry Tim Cook. We're both we're both boomers, and I
- 1:07:14think our listeners are more technologically sophisticated him too, love you. I think
- 1:07:19you were great. Who was that an impression of? Was that an impression?
- 1:07:24Yeah, it was an impression. I thought that was a recording.
- 1:07:26No, no, no, the recording would be far more New Jersey than
- 1:07:29that. Do you have a recording of me. No, I don't like
- 1:07:30that. I wouldn't say anything like that out Okay, So what was the
- 1:07:34question? How do people rate and review on itune? Just figure out how
- 1:07:39to do it. Please, five stars would be great. Leave a nice
- 1:07:42comment for Ben stroke his ego. I guess he always says if you want
- 1:07:45to say something horrible about the show, but honestly, if you do,
- 1:07:47he's going to turn into like a whiny mobi baby for like the next day,
- 1:07:50listen to the latest bout report. No way, I can't take criticism,
- 1:07:55all right, So how can they support the show in a more financially
- 1:07:59focused way, Well, you can join me as a patron of the five
- 1:08:03Games for Doomsday podcast Empire. Yeah, and go to patreon dot com slash
- 1:08:10five G for D. That's it, lovely and become a patron. If
- 1:08:13you contribute five euros a month, you get all the content. I think
- 1:08:16Ben should charge ten euros a month, but he is generous and wants you
- 1:08:20to hear the battle reports, our new film show. Yeah, other stuff,
- 1:08:25other stuff, and we go on trips. You're creative writing. What
- 1:08:29do we call that? Five G for D expeditions? Yeah, five GD
- 1:08:34Loria CON's coming up soon. It's gonna be a lot of lulls. Don't
- 1:08:38don't miss it. And I myself am a patron and you will never be
- 1:08:43able to You will never be a patron at the level I'm at. I
- 1:08:46challenge you to try. Listener. So I just want to say thank you
- 1:08:49to everyone who contributed. You make this show. This is your show,
- 1:08:54not ours. It's not ours, No, it's theirs. Can can they
- 1:08:57make it instead of us? Then? Next? Yeah? Yeah, well
- 1:09:00I'll just then I'll send out some of send them all a Mike. Can
- 1:09:02you please? Can you do this for us? Like I can't. I
- 1:09:04can't keep doing podcast episodes every day, every fucking day. I have to
- 1:09:08do a new podcast episode, all right, say goodbye, Stave Karthur.
- 1:09:11Can I go outside now? Without you, this show wouldn't exist. So
- 1:09:23really, you're to blame, So thank you for listening, and oil up
- 1:09:27your ears for the next hashtag channel