Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / 5G4D Classics-Cole Wherle
Transcript
- 0:02So five d Ford has been going for nearly five years now, and I'm
- 0:06sure many of you will have missed some of the early interviews because you weren't
- 0:10there at the beginning. I mean, why would you have been. So
- 0:13what I'm going to do is I'm going to release some classic episodes from some
- 0:18legends of the industry that you might have missed. And so I hope you
- 0:22enjoy these shows, and I hope you enjoy the brand new ones that come
- 0:26out every two weeks. So thank you for listening and enjoy. Out of
- 0:40the street corners, they scream. You knew it was coming. You've been
- 0:44waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now they scream
- 0:48at you, the sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the white noise
- 0:52of the city, and you run. You run to pick up those things
- 0:56that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days when they
- 0:59still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn to your
- 1:03shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games for Doomsday.
- 1:12Five Games for Doomsday as a show in which board game personalities are thrust
- 1:15into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but can only
- 1:21take five of their games with them. But which will they choose? My
- 1:25guest this week is not only a designer of games, but a ruminator on
- 1:29the role games play. He's designed games that deal with weighty historical things like
- 1:34John Company and an Infamous Traffic, as well as more whimsical fair with Root.
- 1:38His designer diaries read like popular history books, and his reviews are probably
- 1:42the most thoughtful and rigorous in the industry. My guest this week is Cole
- 1:47Whirley. Cole, Welcome, Thanks, Ben, I'm glad to be here.
- 1:52So before we start, how difficult was it for you to choose these
- 1:55five games? Was there a lot of gnashing of teeth or was it very
- 1:59easy? It was hard. It was hard because I couldn't. I had
- 2:04trouble. I was trying to imagine those that would be with me, and
- 2:07I'm a big believer of bringing the right game to the right audience. And
- 2:09then I thought, no, I'm thinking about this completely backwards. I need
- 2:13to imagine that that isn't an issue, and to just pick the games that
- 2:16resonated most with me, which just made problems worse because the first list I
- 2:21think it was probably twenty titles. But after I kind of you created the
- 2:25right kind of categories, it became pretty easy to snap up the ones in
- 2:30those categories. And so what were the categories, What were the stipulations that
- 2:34you used? Games that I could think about a lot and play a lot
- 2:38so something. So I ruled out games that I imagined myself easily getting tired
- 2:45of. And so there are certain war games that I think that are probably
- 2:50amazing for the first five plays, but then they start to wear on you.
- 2:53So that was important as a criteria. And then I wanted a variety
- 2:58of topics and weights just so that so games that approached kind of different problems
- 3:06and even within the space of the game had a really big dynamic range.
- 3:09So I didn't want just an economic game. I wanted an economic game that
- 3:13could be very strategic or very tactical, that could scale well at different player
- 3:16accounts. So, believe it or not, I think if I had to,
- 3:20if I changing the premise of your show a little bit, if I
- 3:23had to cut down my collection to just five, like in the here and
- 3:27Now, these would probably be the five that I would pick, even outside
- 3:30of Apocalypse. Well, my premise is very flimsy, so feel free to
- 3:36do whatever you wish with it. But do you I mean when you sent
- 3:38me a bio when you said that, you know, with having kids and
- 3:43stuff, your your game time has changed and the types of game you play
- 3:47have changed. So do you have you found yourself playing a lot lighter game,
- 3:52shorter games, games that require less investment than the big heavy war games
- 3:58in certain respects. My wife and I are you know, partners and so
- 4:02many things, and we're also good, good game partners, and we used
- 4:08to indulge in a lot of weighty two player games and that's been a category
- 4:11that's been somewhat evacuated. In fact, Titan is on there because it was
- 4:14a game I played a lot with my wife. But with kids, we're
- 4:17usually doing the shorter fair So lately it's been a lot of a Zool and
- 4:21Heaven and Nail. But without you know, the distraction of movies and TVs,
- 4:28I could imagine Titan kind of coming back, and that's why made it
- 4:31on the list. Yeah, you know that changes partly to do with the
- 4:38kids, and it's also you know, something that is still in flux,
- 4:41like as the kids have gotten older, and gotten better about going to sleep.
- 4:44We have found ourselves kind of regravitating towards those heavier titles. In fact,
- 4:47just a couple of nights again, we pulled out Duel of Ages after
- 4:50the kids were in bed and played probably three hour grudge match of it.
- 4:55So if we go back to the beginning, so you up until fair recently
- 5:00have spent your life in academia, just give us a quick background of what
- 5:06you studied, why you studied it, why did you go into those areas.
- 5:11So I was I've just recently defended and kind of exited, exited the
- 5:15academy, maybe for a little bit, maybe for a long time. I
- 5:18was a journalism student growing up or not growing up. As an undergrad,
- 5:21I studied journalism, and as I kind of I was a kind of a
- 5:27wayward student, like a lot of people in the academy. High school didn't
- 5:31really or my secondary school didn't really motivate me at all. And then when
- 5:35I got to college and things got difficult and my teachers got really interesting,
- 5:40I found myself subconsciously kind of stepping up more. But I studied mostly so
- 5:46I studied journalism kind of with the intention of being a reporter and then found
- 5:49that it was a little little it was it's exhausting in ways that I hadn't
- 5:57I didn't understand what I was really getting into. I think when I first
- 6:00started studying journalism, and I was also at in journalism school during a time
- 6:03where the Internet and Craigslist especially had destroyed newspapers, but social media hadn't saved
- 6:12journalism, and so there were just there were no jobs for young people wanting
- 6:15to be reporters. And so while I was filling out my schedules, I
- 6:19started taking more English and history classes, and I happened to be at a
- 6:25school that was very, very strong in nineteenth century studies, so I was
- 6:29taking a lot of classes with very prominent victorians and a lot of people studying
- 6:32Empire. And at the end of that program, I worked a variety of
- 6:39jobs, but was also doing some freelance research work, and my mentors were
- 6:44encouraging me to apply to graduate school. So, because it seemed like the
- 6:47right thing to do at a time at the time, I applied for a
- 6:50PhD program and then spent the better part of a decade in Austin at the
- 6:56University of Texas, where I studied nineteenth century literature and the British Empire,
- 7:00specifically in India, but in some other corners as well. And I loved
- 7:05graduate school. I think by the time it's over, many people find themselves
- 7:10pretty bitter about the experience. But I loved it all the way to the
- 7:13end, and I would have been very happy. I think finding a university
- 7:16gig. So when did games come into your life? How long were you
- 7:21playing since childhood or was this more of a pursuit you got into as you
- 7:27got older when you got to university. Games were important from my earliest memories.
- 7:32My dad taught us how to play chess when we were very young,
- 7:36and I think, or actually maybe it wasn't so much. Games were important
- 7:41as play. I had parents who played make believe with their children, and
- 7:47games for sports and board games and puzzles and riddles and all manner of kind
- 7:56of play. What was a really important element of just growing up my household.
- 8:00I have lots of siblings, and all of the siblings had a way
- 8:01of bringing all their friends into the house, so we were always at play.
- 8:05And that was that that that thread was fused with kind of an anti
- 8:11establishment you know, I really want you to understand how to play soccer and
- 8:16hockey, but don't ever join a league. If you want to play a
- 8:18game of football, you should go find nine friends and then we'll build some
- 8:22nets in the backyard and you should play that way. So gaming was social,
- 8:28it was symptomatic of a larger kind of importance of play. And we
- 8:33were playing games. I mean, I I some of my earliest memories are
- 8:37playing Statigue with my father, and then I had there were just lots of
- 8:41little happenstances which kind of led me to games. While when I was quite
- 8:45young, I played Katan in elementary school on an old German copy and it
- 8:52was it was just we we we wore, we wore that game out.
- 8:56And then I had friends who who had uncles and grandparents who were interested in
- 9:03kind of modern euro games, and so when the Christmases and birthdays rolled around,
- 9:07there were always copies of Puerto Rico, taj Mahal Battle Cry get very
- 9:16close to their actual release. So you know, I think I think I
- 9:20probably played Puerto Rico the same year it came out, and I would have
- 9:24been in middle school at that time, and we were of course just completely
- 9:28massacring all the rules. But these were just the things that happened to be
- 9:31floating around my childhood. It wasn't something I sought out. And so I
- 9:35mean reading your design and divers and your reviews they come across, if not
- 9:39academically rigorous, certainly journalistically rigorous. Were games always Did you always look at
- 9:46games in a sort of more analytical sense or did that come later? I
- 9:52think the thing that pulled me, you know, growing up again playing lots
- 9:56of different kinds of things in video games are certainly included. The thing that
- 10:01pulled me to games was at the start was I think something like their self
- 10:09containment and the rigor of this city. I wouldn't be able to I wouldn't
- 10:13have described it that way as a kid, but there was. I mean,
- 10:16I remember moving from from playing a lot of miniatures games, games workshop
- 10:20games too, that those hasspro avalone Hill games. This is the like the
- 10:26late nineties version of a Choir and History of the World and Battlecry. What
- 10:33was so compelling about those titles was that they were the entire world of the
- 10:37game was inside that one box. And so suddenly I didn't need to cajole
- 10:43my friends into building these miniature Armies, we could just play it in that
- 10:48set. And then when I got to university, I started looking at the
- 10:54games a little bit differently because I found myself preferring board games to video games.
- 11:01And then because that was a strange I think it was a strange opinion.
- 11:07I was being constantly asked to defend that position to my friends who would
- 11:11prefer that we play a bunch of Half Life. And I think that little
- 11:15crucible of just justifying to you know, my dorm mates that we should play
- 11:18a game of El Grande instead of Unreal, I think that's where, like
- 11:24that apologetic is kind of where my own thinking about games was really shaped,
- 11:28because I did I looked at something like like El Grande actually and would think
- 11:33this game is more aggressive and interactive and brutal than any shooter that you can
- 11:39play on your computer right now. And in working that defense and just trying
- 11:46to fill the table on our dorms lounge with players, I think I started
- 11:52crafting a way of talking about games. And then it helped that I was
- 11:54using BDG a lot and was talking to people who were a lot older and
- 11:58had been thinking about games a lot more than I had, and they started
- 12:03giving me pieces that I could use to kind of build a language for talking
- 12:07about the games. So we'll go in to your first game, and the
- 12:11people who know you and have seen your work, the games you've designed,
- 12:16and also the criticism that you've created, might be surprised at this first one.
- 12:20And this first one is Bonanza. Why did you choose this one?
- 12:26Well? I wanted a Rosenberg game because I like I admire his designs a
- 12:31lot, and it was I thought, first, it should surely be a
- 12:35Griccolo, which is a seminal game of my wife and I his courtship,
- 12:41and something that we still play. I probably have over one hundred games of
- 12:43a Griclo logged, But a Gricola is not his best game. It's a
- 12:50great game, but it's not his best, and his best is so clearly
- 12:56Bonanza. So I think online I tend to talk about the heavier games that
- 13:03I play, but if someone catches me at a con, they're as likely
- 13:07to see me like flicking wooden discs, or like wearing a Goofy crane on
- 13:11my forehead, or playing like some of the sillier games as well. And
- 13:16I because I find that I like a clever design in any form it can
- 13:24be. And Bonanza is just brimming with cleverness. What does he do in
- 13:30this game that makes it an evergreen? I mean it's sold, It's sold
- 13:33over two million copies Bonanza, and it's it's sold in corner chemists in Germany.
- 13:41I can buy a copy if I go down the road to buy a
- 13:43bottle of shampoo. You know what is it about this game that makes it
- 13:46so captivating for everybody? It seems when you're designing, there is a temptation
- 13:54to try to get the players to think that you are very clever a designer.
- 14:01And when you're playing a game that is cleverly designed in that way,
- 14:05you're thinking what was like, what is the value of the family growth action
- 14:09at Grikla? What's Rosenberg thinking? And in Bonanza, Rosenberg like a like
- 14:13a great designer should understands that the designer can never ever ever be as clever
- 14:20as the players. And Bonanza is a game about understanding the people who are
- 14:26sitting around the table and how they value things and manipulating those values. So
- 14:31it doesn't matter what the jumping being might be worth in the game, it's
- 14:37understanding what that being is worth to the people sitting there and then creating this
- 14:43language of obligation about what that favors worth of maybe taking something that you don't
- 14:48need. So this game is just thriving in this kind of weird donkey space
- 14:52of suboptimal play where where players are being rewarded for coming up with really clever
- 15:00solutions to problems that go so far beyond a logic of like a set exchanges
- 15:05or something. And I think because the design emphasizes the people that are playing
- 15:11it, it has a replayability that is going to surpass any other system that
- 15:18Rosenberg creates and is his range. You know, little games like Bonanza and
- 15:24Patchwork and big games like A Feast for Road and Agricola. Is that an
- 15:26inspiration for you as a designer. Would you like to go into those areas
- 15:31of small card gazer? I mean, you've done pas Poma, but you
- 15:33know lighter Fare, yeah, and pax is a small game that only looks
- 15:39small and then it it is it's too big for itself. I think actually,
- 15:45as I've transitioned to working in the in the industry commercially, the thing
- 15:48that is so cute about Premier in a small box is actually just sort of
- 15:52misleading, and I think it potentially would have done better, not that it
- 15:56didn't do bet it did poorly, but I think it was a bit of
- 16:00a cheat and in a you know, it would have been better like marketed
- 16:03in kind of a GMT form. I think that. But to your question
- 16:08about range, I think that there is something remarkable about Rosensberg's range and his
- 16:19consistency. I mean there I think there's a whole coterie of German designers especially
- 16:23that seem to be able to work well at any form factor, and that
- 16:30flexibility is something that that I admire. I don't think I can emulate it.
- 16:33I mean I do have projects that would be better suited to the smaller
- 16:37form than I'd love to be able to see through. But I think that
- 16:41there is there's a second thing about Rosensberg's range that I think is particular to
- 16:47his position in the industry and to designers like him, which is that he
- 16:52had he is able to keep making the same game over and over again and
- 16:57to play it's almost like like variations or something. Right, So you have
- 17:02a gricola and then you have fields of r all and they're different, but
- 17:07he's he's asking similar kinds of questions and then Feast for Rodin. There's a
- 17:11little bit of patchwork in there, but it's like if I were to keep
- 17:15making packs games for the rest of my career, and then you know,
- 17:18you could see influences of other things I'm working on and that. So,
- 17:22like, his range is both wide and then also he's able to go very
- 17:26deeply into a single space. And that second part of the range is not
- 17:30something I think I'm personally interested in, but I really admire it. Like
- 17:34I think some people looked at Feast Rodin or whatever, his the one I
- 17:37can't pronounce the game about Norway or something. Yeah, no, necessaried.
- 17:44I think people look at that and they say, like, he just keeps
- 17:45making these Viking games. And I actually think it's sort of wonderful that there's
- 17:51a place in the industry for somebody to just be investing in this project of
- 17:55kind of working through similar problems and finding different ways of approaching those problems.
- 18:00That element of his range I could never emulate, but I do think it's
- 18:06it's great that the industry can support it. So why did you go into
- 18:11design and what were your first forays into design. I went into design because
- 18:18there were certain types of games that I just didn't feel like I was seeing.
- 18:23So it was, which is to say, it was purely selfish.
- 18:29And I think there are some folks and this this means to I mean,
- 18:33to Castino Shade. I know a lot of people who go into design because
- 18:37they want to produce things that have their names on boxes, which I think
- 18:41is awesome. I mean, it is a wonderful thing to bring something into
- 18:45being. And but also like they they want to make sort of small adjustments
- 18:52to previously worked formula. And I think that's fine, and there's a lot
- 18:56of room for that kind of like incremental work. But for me, it
- 19:00was I just I was reading these these uh these you know, history books
- 19:07and finding all these really fabulous tensions that I just felt like were nowhere.
- 19:14They were just nowhere in games. My first I don't think we're actually talked
- 19:18about this. A lot of my first designs were, I guess more properly
- 19:22just variants. I played a mountain of risk growing up, just a huge,
- 19:27impenetrable mountain. I think I could probably draw the risk map from memory,
- 19:33and I still think it's a fabulous game despite what everyone might might think.
- 19:37But I came up with lots of variants for risk that had feudal politics
- 19:42and vassal ships and kind of really complicated diplomatic systems because I would play a
- 19:48game like Twilight Imperium or Game of Thrones, and the diplomacy always felt it
- 19:57always so as it's different, like if you take the Fantasy flight, Game
- 20:02of Thrones and Twilight Imperium. As different as those two games are and the
- 20:06way they approach economics and science and military concerns, their diplomatic worlds are exactly
- 20:15the same. You have kind of like betrayals, and everybody has like this
- 20:21little contiguous nation state. And I didn't realize this when I was in high
- 20:25school, but they're all trapped in essentially like nineteenth century conceptions of the state,
- 20:30Like they're just stuck. They have not thought about the way that politics
- 20:33can be different and more multilateral than like a one person, one nation,
- 20:38one state model. And you know, Sidmyer, civilization is stuck there too.
- 20:44And what's so interesting is when you read books about diplomacy and books about
- 20:48politics there it's complicated. The state is always kind of tearing itself apart with
- 20:53all these different interest groups, and so I had it. So these were
- 20:57just intuitions I had that I wanted to see something that was a little bit
- 21:02more robust and that really fleshed out the problems that I thought were really interesting,
- 21:07and so that led to little risk variance, and I tried to make
- 21:11a computer game version of The Three Kingdoms, which didn't quite work but sort
- 21:17of works and maybe I'll revisit it someday. And lots of like Twilight imperium
- 21:22variants that I came up with, so I started working in variants and then
- 21:27eventually created little systems, but I couldn't really see any project through. I
- 21:36think Pamir is the first project that I completed properly. And so how did
- 21:40it feel to be published by Phil Ekland, because when you wrote to me
- 21:45that you played his games quite extensively before then, was that did you have
- 21:52a sort of a feeling of I'm trying to find the word now, did
- 21:56you feel sort of like very privileged or was it, oh, this is
- 22:00just a natural progression of my designs. I didn't really like if I hindsight's
- 22:08a funny thing here, because looking back at it, Phil offering me money
- 22:14for premiere and publishing it was clearly this huge moment that my whole career kind
- 22:19of pivoted around that one moment. But at the at the time, it
- 22:25did not seem important, like it was exciting, but it was like it
- 22:29was obvious because and I think that has to do with how Phil develops games,
- 22:36Like you know, I'd been developing Pamiere and it was so obviously the
- 22:41kind of game that he would publish, and what I did all the graphic
- 22:44design for it, and I made it look like his game's look, and
- 22:48I just when I offered it to him, my own thinking was, and
- 22:52this comes from my own experience working on the editorial side in at the university,
- 22:57the articles that have the best chance of being published are the ones that
- 23:00look a lot like the things you already published and do interesting things and will
- 23:04require very little work on the parts of their editors. So when I was
- 23:10when I was building Premiere Submission, I just tried to hit those criteria like
- 23:15I wanted it to look, and so there were footnotes in the rules for
- 23:18instance, I wanted it to look like the kind of game that Phil would
- 23:22publish, and to seem like the kind of project that wouldn't require a lot
- 23:25of his work, and it just seemed like a very natural thing that he
- 23:29would pick it up, and so, you know, I sent it to
- 23:32him and then about a week later he played it and said, oh,
- 23:37well, I want to buy this and do you think you can have it
- 23:38ready for May and then we'll pub you know, it'll it'll be released in
- 23:41the following year. And I said, of course, and we worked out
- 23:45terms and signed a contract. And it because I had been helping and was
- 23:51in a lot of the conversations around Greenland and had kind of seen that project
- 23:56grow, you know, Phil and I had had lots of back and forth
- 23:59and emails and this was like yet another project. It wasn't until later when
- 24:07I think Phil after the release of Greenland, I think Phil had kind of
- 24:11a meteoric rise in terms of his visibility, which coincide with my own very
- 24:17small like starting to publish, the kind of beginning of my design career.
- 24:21And it was I think it was really later like with with with John Company,
- 24:27actually, when I was getting through that and I realized, like it
- 24:32is, I started becoming overwhelmed by the fact that, you know, here
- 24:37was this game I had really worked on which is being published along with alongside
- 24:41a major release, and this is bios Megafuna, two of one of my
- 24:45favorite designers, and I get to be in his group and in his stable
- 24:49on in in this area. And I think that over the last year I
- 24:55was a little overwhelmed by it all. But it took many years for me
- 24:57to have enough perspective to know that to realize how lucky I had been.
- 25:02And when I had started talking to Phil, see your next game is I
- 25:07must confess a game I had no idea existed until I went on BGG after
- 25:12I got your list. This is Titan, which is an old Avalon Hill
- 25:17game. Can you for the listener, can you just give them a quick
- 25:21pracie of what this game is. Titan is an old Avalon Hill game.
- 25:26It was originally designed outside of Avalon Hill, and then I think they took
- 25:30it in and might have done a little bit of development on it. And
- 25:33it is a game. So before I describe it, I'll say it is
- 25:36a game that everyone should know about and people who design should study it because
- 25:41it is. It is among the best game, the most interesting and best
- 25:45games ever made. And now that I've built it up, I will tell
- 25:48you it's theme, which is it is a fantasy monster slug a thon like
- 25:56war game. I guess. You recruit armies centaurs and you battle with each
- 26:00other and that, and then one player wins. You try everybody has a
- 26:04big Titan, which is kind of an RPG hero that levels up throughout the
- 26:08game, and then you try to be the last Titan standing. And that
- 26:11description. The kinds of people I played games with an undergrad were usually put
- 26:18off by fantasy themes. They seem like a little childish, and I think
- 26:22I myself was contaminated a little bit with that and sort of moved away from
- 26:25the more thematic games for several years. And when I got a copy of
- 26:29Titan, I didn't teach it to them because I thought, this is like
- 26:33they're not they're not gonna like this, They're gonna think it's scoofy. But
- 26:37then as I started playing it with my wife, my girlfriend at the time
- 26:41who is now my wife, it was so rich and so I couldn't help
- 26:47myself and say, like, look, I want you to ignore the fact
- 26:49that we're fighting with bears wearing armor, and just look at the math,
- 26:53look at the beautiful structure of this game. And it won over the house
- 26:59and it was in constant play. So the thing. So Titan does a
- 27:02bunch of remarkable things. It's sort of like the shared ancestor of I mean,
- 27:07it's inspired a lot of things. I think, like Richard Garfield has
- 27:10talked about Titan with respect to Magic and also if you've played the game Heroes
- 27:15of Might and Magic, Titan is the board game version of that. So
- 27:18there's like a there's a world map, and then when you get into battles,
- 27:22there's a little battle map. But what makes the game so remarkable is
- 27:27that all of the numerics systems, all the numbers are I think sometimes people
- 27:37who know more about math than me talk about there being a beauty in mathematics,
- 27:41and I think I know kind of what they're talking about when I think
- 27:45about a game like Titan, because every number is used in a bunch of
- 27:52different ways. So a number might be, on the one hand, used
- 27:56for movement, and on the other hand it's used to termine the hit value
- 28:03of a particular to figure out the hit value between units, and another number
- 28:07is the number of units like the unit's toughness. And then it has another
- 28:12thing that I for some reason can't think of right now, I'm probably oh
- 28:15no. And also how many dice they were in combat, and when you
- 28:19multiply those numbers together, suddenly you have the experience points that are gained when
- 28:26you kill that creature, and all of that is overlaid this really wonderful probability
- 28:33game where you're trying to muster and move around your armies and figure out the
- 28:40best ways to grow your forces. I mean, it's really quite remarkable,
- 28:45and the rules are so clean and just so there is an abstract beauty to
- 28:51the design as well. I love the first edition of the game because everything
- 28:55is hand drawn, but it is done in silhouettes, so it almost has
- 28:59like a chest like character. And I could play that game one hundred times
- 29:03and be completely satisfied. So I've wat an article that you wrote about an
- 29:11American Civil War game. You mentioned that Avalon Hill started bringing what you called,
- 29:15I think adult respectability into games. Firstly, what does that mean and
- 29:19how does Titan reflect that? What I mean is there when it comes to
- 29:26the kinds of hobbies you're allowed to have, and as an adult, there
- 29:30is a little game that gets played about class and about respectability. So you
- 29:37know, for instance, board games I'll get just as an example, board
- 29:41games seem very expensive, and I would be hard pressed to spend many hundred
- 29:45dollars on a board game. And even if I did do that, and
- 29:48I have for certain rare, weird train games, I would never tell someone.
- 29:53So I'm sure you're not going to tell anybody, Ben that I spent
- 29:56all some money on board games. But if I spent that much money on
- 30:00a golf club, that is hardly something that would require even note in fact,
- 30:04if I had a nice pair of golf clubs, it'd be assumed that
- 30:07I'd spent a lot of money on them. So there's a there's a thing
- 30:10that happens. And if you go back to H. G. Wells and
- 30:14Little Wars, his book about war gaming, there are these ways where he's
- 30:18trying to justify the hobby as something that is more than just for children.
- 30:23And when you get into when you get into board games in the fifties and
- 30:26sixties and seventies, you can see it all over the place. So the
- 30:30old avalon hill games are very clean looking games are a serious, worthwhile endeavor
- 30:37for the thinking adult, and I think that is something that you don't really
- 30:42see in the game industry at the current moment, and it's sort of interesting,
- 30:45and I think it has to do a little bit with the I'm going
- 30:51to screw up all my terms because I'm so far away from a sociology class,
- 30:55but like the trend around the infantilization of the adult, right, So,
- 31:00like it's okay to like Disney and be an adult. So it's also
- 31:03okay to like play a bunch of board games. And so when you look
- 31:07at I'm surrounded by board game shells right now. So I'm looking around,
- 31:10I'm looking at all these game covers that could be marketed to kids or to
- 31:15adults, or do some kind of adult child And I think that's great because
- 31:19it, you know, it shows a comfort with a wider range of human
- 31:23experience. But it's important too to know that like we have like this is
- 31:29something that we had to earn because a long time ago, you know,
- 31:32forty or fifty years ago, it was a little it was a tenuous thing
- 31:36to have friends over and play a strange board game. So do you think
- 31:40it's not it's do you think I think you're kind of saying this, but
- 31:42do you think it's not just sort of taken as red now within the hobby
- 31:47board game world that these are for adults, and adults are the main consumers,
- 31:51and so we don't need to show men in waistcoats sipping whiskey on the
- 31:56backup boxes because we all know it's for us as adults now, right right,
- 32:00And so like I'm looking, so my boss is a bunch of zombie
- 32:02side boxes right across from me, and they have a kind of comic book
- 32:06look that is I think well pitched at the twenty something or thirty something gamer
- 32:14with some money who wants to play in this sort of fantasy world, and
- 32:17you don't have to pretend that this is a kind of a respectable thing.
- 32:23So yeah, I completely agree. I think that the hobby is moved,
- 32:27has moved to a place where everything is sort of assumed to be for a
- 32:32kind I mean, I hate, I hate the term gamer because it's so
- 32:36loaded, But there is this kind of gamer class that all of these games
- 32:40are directed at, which kind of is assumed a certain level of complexity and
- 32:45fiddliness and expense that's built into the games. And when you go to the
- 32:49older titles, you don't quite see those categories as cleanly so a big issue,
- 32:53and this is something kind of skirting around, is gender right, Like
- 32:55a lot of these games are being sold to men, and they have there's
- 33:00a kind of like masculine play. The z Ombius side font looks very serious,
- 33:04very like manly, for instance, And when you look at something like
- 33:07a choir, there are men and women playing and this is sort of like
- 33:14what you're doing at a cocktail party. And so in some respects, even
- 33:17if like an old game box seems retrograde in certain areas, in other ways
- 33:22it's quite forward, even though you know, the gender politics of the ninety
- 33:27sixties are not something anybody would want to ever return to. So with respect
- 33:31to Titan, though, I don't know who that game was marketed for because
- 33:36it has the Avalon Hill. Cover of that game is hilariously bad. I
- 33:40think it's like got a weird like it's got like a strange like Greeks and
- 33:46God face on it, and there's like two monsters fighting, and the actual
- 33:52like layout of the game is very garish. But within that, like once
- 33:58you step into its palette, if you can, if you can imagine that
- 34:02it's quite beautiful and functional. Um, but it doesn't make any effort at
- 34:06respectability at all um, and it, in fact, it was often I
- 34:10think that the original boxes like they almost they might even advertise it as like
- 34:15a monster slugathon, which is such a kind of I find that like a
- 34:21little demeaning because the game, like I would call it like a it's it's
- 34:27it's it's a game about like outwitting your opponent, it's highly strategic um and
- 34:31it's it's almost chess like UM. I think it would be more at home
- 34:37being thought of alone in the lines of like chess and backgammon than Um Rising
- 34:44Sun or blood Rage. So moving on, I need you to help me
- 34:50because I have a friend who is a died in the wool grocknad and nothing
- 34:58angers him more than when I call Small World a war game. And so
- 35:05first of all, I mean, you play a lot of war games,
- 35:07and you've played a lot of war games for a long time. Can you
- 35:10give me a concise definition of what a war game is. There's no way
- 35:16to do this without aggravating at least like thirty percent of everyone listening, but
- 35:21I'll do my best. So I tend a while back. Someone I kind
- 35:28of consider a friend who I talk a lot about board games with they said,
- 35:31you know, it's important to remember that whenever we talk about genre,
- 35:35we're really just talking about marketing. And so genre is a very useful way
- 35:38to sell something, in a very bad way to describe something. And so
- 35:43I think along those lines, war game is a conflict simulation. It has
- 35:49to have some kind of simulation value to it. Now that doesn't mean,
- 35:53you know, we can talk about the different the different levels of accuracy,
- 35:59right. I remember once we figured I was playing a battle Cry game and
- 36:04we sort of did some back of the envelope calculations to figure out how large
- 36:07the units were in our Battlecry game, and then we were very gratified to
- 36:12find that the casualty, the casualties at the end of the game were actually
- 36:15quite in line with what it historically happened. So and battle Cry is not
- 36:20a game that really has any tries to do anything interesting with simulation outside of
- 36:25some command and control issues, of which it excels at. So I think
- 36:30there are kind of two tiers to it. Like I think you can be
- 36:32very ecumenical and say, you know, war games are any kind of conflict
- 36:36simulation that includes the conflicts between various like mismatched fantasy empires fighting each other in
- 36:43something like Small World, or you know, it could be a highly calibrated
- 36:47like campaign for North Africa. We're going to count all the food rations.
- 36:52Both of those things can be war games. That the question, the harder
- 36:55question, is what is the war game simulation? What are you getting?
- 37:00And this is the place where I think that the grognargs who want to push
- 37:07Small World or even something like Twilight Struggle out of their camp. What they're
- 37:10trying to say is war games have to have some kind of simulation value.
- 37:15And Small World maybe a wonderful game, but it like doesn't It doesn't have
- 37:20any It doesn't tell you anything about the way these people work. So I've
- 37:25talked a lot about my attitudes to war games, and I'm squeamish with a
- 37:31lot of the themes of war games, simply because how do I say this?
- 37:37It feels to me slightly unseemly to be recreating on a tabletop the deaths
- 37:45of real people in real situations that we're hugely scarring and traumatic for whole continents.
- 37:53Am I wrong with this? And if so, one you're not wrong,
- 37:58And more people should be queamish This is a funny thing coming from someone
- 38:02who made a game about the opium Wars. But I was going to play
- 38:08a game of Fire in the Lake, which is a big coin game designed
- 38:13UM by Mark Herman and Vocal rundign. I can reprounce this last name.
- 38:20I think those are the two that design Fire in the Lake UM. But
- 38:22it's a big coin game about the Vietnammese the war in Vietnam, And in
- 38:28order to uh, in order to prepare for it, I started watching the
- 38:32Ken Burns documentary and found myself so affected that I gave up my seat at
- 38:40the game. I just couldn't play it. And I play games about awful
- 38:45subjects, but there was the war. UM. War gaming is a privilege
- 38:52of distance when you can only like so I think. I think that the
- 38:58way, the way I tend to think about it is your distance from a
- 39:00circumstance enables you certain kinds of perspectives, and some of those perspectives can be
- 39:07indulging in thought experiments such as what if the Nazis would have done this?
- 39:13Or what if they would have done that? And these thought experiments can be
- 39:16really interesting, but they are also so two things can be true at the
- 39:22same time, these thought experiments can be extremely interesting, but they can also
- 39:25be morally depraved. So the example that comes to mind a lot is a
- 39:30game that has really impacted me and I really love is GMT's recent game Triumph
- 39:37and Tragedy, which I tend to dislike World War two games because of their
- 39:43distance from politics and their distance from the things that are so interesting about the
- 39:47nineteen thirties, and tripeh and Tragedy is the first World War two game I've
- 39:52played which understands that World War Two was this colossal historic accent that didn't necessarily
- 40:00need to happen the way it happened, and it gives you the feeling of
- 40:06paranoia and the feeling of the modern world like runaway from itself. And I
- 40:14can only enjoy that game and enjoy playing each of the powers, all of
- 40:17which have different levels of of moral compromise, right Like, I don't mean
- 40:23to put an equivalency, but the West was awful, but the Fascists were
- 40:28much worse. But I can I can take the Fascist position, and I
- 40:32can allow myself to kind of experience some of the thoughts that were informing both
- 40:38their strategic and their political posture, but it is purely a privilege of my
- 40:45own distance from that war and from the human trauma. So so I sympathize
- 40:51with people being squeamish about games because I think, if you look at a
- 40:54game, if a game like I like my I like games that attempt to
- 41:00traffic and things that matter. And if a game makes you feel, if
- 41:07it revolts you, if it makes you feel awful about something, I'm happy
- 41:09for it because that is the power of the form. I think games are
- 41:14engines of affect. They can really allow us to understand different perspectives. And
- 41:19for that specific reason, I like games that put me in morally complicated positions.
- 41:25But only the games that are smart, only the games that treat their
- 41:32subject matter seriously. So the coin games, which are about contemporary insurgent operations
- 41:40and multilateral conflicts, they are disturbing. Andy and Abyss is about the Columbian
- 41:47drug wars, Cuba Libres with the Cuban Revolution, Distant Playing takes the recent
- 41:52war in Afghanistan. And these games look squarely at hard topics, and they
- 42:00make me uncomfortable when I whenever I play any and Abyss or Kuba Librey,
- 42:06I feel extremely uncomfortable and I feel like I have to make horrible things.
- 42:09But play is that is a space where players can kind of explore an uncomfortable
- 42:15moment and then step out and reflect. And a game that enables that kind
- 42:22of stepping out and reflecting is something that I'm going to be interested in.
- 42:25On the other hand, when I see a war game that is a little
- 42:30more flippant or jokey, I tend it tends to turn me off and to
- 42:35make me feel to maybe feel like it's both not necessarily worth my time and
- 42:42also like it's undercutting the seriousness of what it can do. So I actually
- 42:45I find myself not playing a lot of war games for that for that reason.
- 42:50But I think that this is something that everybody has to kind of negotiate
- 42:52for themselves and to think about the kinds of experiences they want to they want
- 42:55to inject themselves with. And do you think the wall games that strictly focus
- 43:00on the tactics and strategy of battle, the role of the general, do
- 43:06you think they're neglectful? They are, But you have to make decisions.
- 43:14I think the most interesting decisions in any designer makes are the decisions about victory
- 43:17and the decision about who the player is. All the other decisions are kind
- 43:22of boring, and they're not boring. There's not as important. There are
- 43:25an order of magnitude less important, or they're less important by an order of
- 43:30magnitude. And for that reason, a game that focuses on the concerns of
- 43:37a general um, if I'm going to make a game about about a conflict,
- 43:43it seems like that that isn't necessarily something that moves me. And and
- 43:49I think that it's there can be a lot. There's a lot of wasted
- 43:51room there, and it's it's also there are there are good ways to simulate
- 43:55those concerns, but there are also bad ways to do it. And so
- 44:00a game a game I love and respect. Squad Leader's sort of quite bad
- 44:05about this because its view of squad level combat in World War Two is just
- 44:10hilariously a historic It's it is a lot more like a classic Hollywood movie about
- 44:17squad combat in World War Two than it is about actual squad combat. And
- 44:22so a game like Upfront, which is a card game that was later published,
- 44:28which focuses a lot more on morale and about uncertain geography, gets it
- 44:36right. And so I'm okay with with the game saying, you know what,
- 44:40we don't have space to do the refugee crisis. That that is a
- 44:45reasonable decision. But if you're not going to make a game about the refugee
- 44:50crisis, make sure the thing you're doing is also important and interesting. And
- 44:54I think that there are a lot and I'm picking on World War two games,
- 44:59but I think that they are particularly afflicted with this. They're just there
- 45:00are a lot of games that are kind of like easy war games, where
- 45:06even though they might have lots of rules, they're neglecting the things that are
- 45:08really interesting. Just to you know, have everybody played General And that's something
- 45:14that I'm kind of never interested in. So your next game is a game
- 45:17I love from people I'm developing something of an obsession with. And this is
- 45:23the Great Zimbabwe. So two questions really. Firstly, why do you think
- 45:30the Splotter guys are held in such high regards? They're sort of the connoisseurs
- 45:37producers. And then, out of all of their titles, why is it
- 45:42this one you chose? When you play a Splotter game, you sometimes get
- 45:46the feeling that the only games they play are the games they design. And
- 45:52I mean that, and I know, first of all, I know that's
- 45:55not true, because I mean, if you look at Droon's writing like it's
- 46:00it's just it's patently not true. He plays lots of games and then they
- 46:04clearly have an influence on them, but they are so focused on the questions
- 46:08that they are interested in and not on the marketplace that you get this almost
- 46:15hot house effect where these are games that are interesting, heavy games that are
- 46:21interesting, bread by other heavy games that are interesting, and they're not deck
- 46:27builders because that's the flavor of the month, or they're not at work replacement
- 46:30games because that's the flavor of the month, their role selection games, because
- 46:32I'm kind of going back in history here, like they're never impacted by it,
- 46:37or they never feel like they're impacted by it because they are so thick,
- 46:40they're so focused on the questions in game design that compel them personally.
- 46:46And I think that it produces something that is almost singular in this hobby,
- 46:53and the hobby is exploded over the last decade, and that has done a
- 46:58lot of good. And I'm always happy that, you know, a wider
- 47:00array of different kinds of people are making games, which is a good thing.
- 47:04But I also I think that in that connectiveness it breeds a kind of
- 47:10homogeney where games are starting to be kind of similar to one another. One
- 47:15Dude's on a map game is kind of like all the other ones. And
- 47:17then when you look at a company like Splotter, they are still so clearly
- 47:22doing their own work that I think they well deserve the kind of seminal place
- 47:29that they've arrived at because for a lot and you know this is as well
- 47:31as I do, for a lot of especially newer gamers who are playing the
- 47:37kind of heavier, stranger, harder games, Splotter is something that you kind
- 47:40of arrive at, like, you don't learn about them right away. You
- 47:44go deep into Reddit or deep into board game Geek and then somebody mentions food
- 47:46Chain, Magnator, Roads and Boats, and then it's probably the first game
- 47:51you spend one hundred dollars on, and when you play it, it's like
- 47:54nothing else. And then you discover that all their other games are like nothing
- 47:58else. But of their games. So I think I've played all of them,
- 48:05and that's courtesy mostly the Board Game Geek library, But and I like
- 48:08I like them all, even the weird ones. Like I love Can.
- 48:12I love the art of Can. I just I think I think it's amazing.
- 48:15Can is an amazing game. It may be a little broken, but
- 48:20it's amazing. And I almost picked Can, but I thought it's got it's
- 48:22got some problems. Um. And and I really admire roads and boats,
- 48:28which is exhausting, um, especially if played combatively. But of all of
- 48:32their designs, The Great Zimbabwe, to me, feels most like every element
- 48:39of their production, their kind of idiot uh syncretic aesthetics, um, the
- 48:46mechanics and the interactions of the players, the weird bits of asymmetry and spatial
- 48:52problems that they put in their games, every single thing that they do in
- 48:55the same way that Rosenberg is kind of like always working in a similar area,
- 49:00every single thing that they investigate in I feel like in The Great Zimbabwe
- 49:04it like every tumbler in the lock, just like is in Alignment. It's
- 49:07it is. I think it is absolutely their best game, by a fair
- 49:12margin. And and I don't say that to discredit their other games. I
- 49:15just think it's it's a It was just a completely remarkable achievement. So you
- 49:22published a few games, you published John Company, You published an influenced traffic
- 49:28and Pax Pamia, and then you became an employee of a game company,
- 49:34so you recently started with later games and your first game route is going to
- 49:37come out from them. How did this come about? It was. It's
- 49:43a strange thing. It's the kind of thing that if ever I'm asked to
- 49:45talk to people about careers, I couldn't give this as advice to anybody.
- 49:51I had just submitted my dissertation, and for anyone who's gone through that process,
- 50:00they know there's this about three week period where you submit your final draft
- 50:04and your defenses in a few weeks, and there's kind of nothing for you
- 50:07to do but be nervous. And so it's a Friday afternoon. I submitted
- 50:10off and I go to Twitter and I'm still at my desk, and I
- 50:15see a posting for a game developer position. And I hadn't really thought about
- 50:22working in the industry. I you know, everybody, I knew, everybody
- 50:29I knew who who did anything with board games. They did it part time,
- 50:31they did it because they loved it, and many of them weren't compensated
- 50:36at all. But I saw this job listing and I was still sitting at
- 50:38my desk, and it was early on a Friday afternoon, and I was
- 50:42on a little bit of a of an adrenaline kick from kicking off this,
- 50:45you know, two hundred fifty page document, and so I just I submitted
- 50:52it. I submitted an application for this job in Saint Paul, and I've
- 50:53been kind of wanting to live in the north where my kids could see winter
- 50:59and everything. And then that night or the next night, Patrick Leader,
- 51:04the publisher, wrote to me with some production questions and they were having some
- 51:08problems with a game they were working on, and he just kind of asked
- 51:13for my advice, and we just sort of started talking, and it begun
- 51:17this sort of two month long courtship where I never really had an interview,
- 51:23but we were just kind of always talking about games. And I liked Vast.
- 51:31It wasn't my favorite game, and I had critiques of it, but
- 51:35my critiques were on the order of I think he was I was very clear
- 51:39that I thought he was up to something quite interesting and that he still needed
- 51:44to work at it to get it right. And I started so he started
- 51:49learning a little bit. Because Patrick and I don't know this is public,
- 51:52but I'll say it Anyway, Patrick had never played any of my games.
- 51:55You know, I think he and I are at different parts of the hobby.
- 52:00It was like very much on the heavy side of the board game geek
- 52:01community, and Patrick was, you know, he's on board game geek,
- 52:06but he's he's in a kind of a different just a totally different corner of
- 52:07hobbies. So he didn't played any of my games. I had played Vast,
- 52:10and I was just sort of talking to him about games, and so
- 52:14he learned a little bit about my own design philosophy and how I think through
- 52:19problems, and then I learned from Patrick what he was trying to build,
- 52:24and you know, to that, Patrick had this idea that he wanted to
- 52:30move away from the submission based, part time based labor of that characterized a
- 52:35lot of the industry and start a small studio. And this studio was made
- 52:39possible because of Vast huge success on Kickstarter, and he wanted a small workforce,
- 52:45a full time labor committed to developing and building really really good and polished
- 52:52games, because there are a lot of games that get published that aren't they
- 52:55just aren't quite ready. And so he really wanted a like a just a
- 53:00absolute crucible to really come out with some lovely things, and that idea attracted
- 53:05me immensely, and so Patrick kind of waffle. He wasn't sure if he
- 53:08was ready to hire me, just because you know, for a small company,
- 53:13going from four employees to five employees is a huge, huge, huge
- 53:17commitment. And I worked at universities where I was just one other cog and
- 53:21you know, there were fifteen thousand people working for the university. To go
- 53:24from four employees to five was a big decision. And so eventually, but
- 53:30he was catching me like I had defended my dissertation. At that point,
- 53:32I was kind of in this middle place where I wasn't sure what my next
- 53:38move was going to be. I was thinking about doing a post stock somewhere,
- 53:43and so I was getting ready where I really needed to make a decision
- 53:45about where I was going to move my family. And so I just gave
- 53:47Patrick an ultimatum and said, look, I would love to spend my blood
- 53:52and sweat working for you, but offer me the job and I'll show up
- 53:54in a couple of weeks. And Patrick took a few days to think about
- 53:58it and offered me the gig. And suddenly I found myself, moving the
- 54:00family up to the north and doing this full time. Which has been can
- 54:07I mean it's been a huge transformation from the way I worked designed before.
- 54:12I mean it's it's a complete different ballpark ball game, I think, And
- 54:15so has it been everything you assumed? Did you have any assumptions and what
- 54:21are those differences in the design work to the way you were working before?
- 54:27Well before you had to go slowly because you had to work slowly just because
- 54:32you didn't have the time to work quickly, And so there was this rhythm
- 54:36in the way design works where you would work and then you would you would
- 54:39try to make changes to a version, and maybe if you made them fast
- 54:43enough, you'd be able to play tests on Saturday. And then you'd spend
- 54:45a week thinking about changes, maybe another weeks thinking about changes, and then
- 54:49you'd make updates and maybe you made the weekend deadline, and you would you'd
- 54:52print things off at work on Friday, you'd play on Saturday. And that
- 54:55was true with playtesting too, with you know, when I was thinking about
- 54:59playtestings, Jules, everything was built around how many weekends can my external playtesters
- 55:04work and what at what pace can I not exhaust them, so you'd kind
- 55:08of you would work slowly. Even if I knew a design was broken,
- 55:13I needed to fix it. I knew I couldn't send out an update right
- 55:15away because I'd exhaust my playtesters. So there was a there was a very
- 55:17processional nature to design, and a design could incubate. I mean Pamire incubated
- 55:24for many, many years, but then it had about a year of development
- 55:28before act development began, where I was working and playing it, but it
- 55:32was it could be slow, and when you're doing it full time. You
- 55:38know, when we when we did Route, and I guess I'm saying that
- 55:42in the past tense out of hopefulness because it's not quite done yet, but
- 55:45we're close. But when we did Root in the fall, Patrick said,
- 55:50look, this is a studio priority, which means if you need something,
- 55:54you can just grab playtesters from other people's tables, so interrupt the salesperson.
- 55:59He needs to go playtester right now. And if you need, you know,
- 56:02me to help you develop, you can just pull me away from my
- 56:05desk. And it allowed us to work so quickly, so previously, you
- 56:12know, I sort of think in terms of major iterations, an iteration would
- 56:15be maybe two months. You know, that's two months you'd maybe produced about
- 56:20ten plays, and then you'd create slowly a new version, and then you'd
- 56:23put out that and you'd get another you know, probably ten plays. Over
- 56:28those weeks. In the studio, we could do about two months of work
- 56:30in a single week because we're having morning playtests. Were maybe playing twice a
- 56:36day. So we have those morning playtests and by the end of the week
- 56:40I have notes, and then the following Monday, I build the next playtest
- 56:44kit and we play it all week. And that pace allowed us to iterate
- 56:51and develop the I mean I think Root would have if I would have worked
- 56:55alone on Route, it would have taken me several years. And the act
- 57:00development for that game has been about six months, and that is a scarily
- 57:05short period when I think about a lot of the other designs I've worked on.
- 57:08But it has been more than ad like. I think Route has had
- 57:14easily twice or even three times as much labor as any other product I've worked
- 57:17on, and it's happened in a fraction of the time. The other thing
- 57:22I'll mentioned about about the differences and working in terms of my own expectations,
- 57:24I didn't have a lot. I had worked at small companies before, and
- 57:29the thing that I really like working at small companies, and in fact,
- 57:32that was the one thing about working at the university that I never quite dialed
- 57:36into the idea that if I would have had a university post, I would
- 57:37have been like the victorianist in the English department in this big, vast tree.
- 57:44I always liked working at small companies where I often did little sidelines throughout
- 57:46graduate school, because everyone needs to be very accountable for their work, and
- 57:52you have a lot of freedom to define your own job description. And so
- 57:58one of the great like one of the things I love most about this job
- 58:01is I come to work and we are all still learning what it means to
- 58:07be a company that makes games. You know, Vast was made while Patrick
- 58:12was working as a programmer, and it was submitted by somebody who you know
- 58:16as a marketer, and so that they work together, but they were working
- 58:20on evenings and the artist was working on evenings, and route in some ways.
- 58:24Root is the first game developed in house by Leader Games, and it
- 58:32bears out on the art, It bears out on the design on every element
- 58:36because we have you know, Kyle is our full time artist. So when
- 58:38I tell him, you know, Kyle, I'd love it if we could
- 58:40have little sketches in the rule book. I think it would look nice and
- 58:43it would break up the flow of the text. He says, Okay,
- 58:45we'd love to do that. He's like, that sounds great, let's do
- 58:47it. And so because he's on retainer and he's like, we are all
- 58:52investing so much energy into the game that I think it's like, if you
- 58:59put it next to anthing else that's gonna post, it's gonna blow it out
- 59:00of the park. Just because the amount of time and energy that we're stuffing
- 59:05in that box is I think it's just huge. So your next game I'm
- 59:09absolutely intimidated by. And this is eighteen thirty. Why am I so scared
- 59:15of eighteen x X games? Because they're long, they're long, and you
- 59:20have to use a calculator. I think that. I mean that that's that's
- 59:24that was it for me. That was why I didn't play them for so
- 59:28long. They like I think that they they are games that ask a lot
- 59:36of their players. They are games that don't stop you from making a colossal
- 59:40mistake and then having to sit there on your hands for four hours while the
- 59:45game finishes because you don't know enough about the game to rescue your position,
- 59:50or as is often the case even with me, like my position is just
- 59:52not redeemable. They present a huge tax to their players. I mean,
- 1:00:00at the start of the show you talked about how I mentioned how I've been
- 1:00:04playing less of long games just because I've got a couple of kids now and
- 1:00:07my job sometimes takes up all of my time. I can't really sit down
- 1:00:12for six hours and play a game anymore. But despite all of that,
- 1:00:17they're worth it. It's a remarkable thing. They're just they are as interesting
- 1:00:25as a game that as interesting as games can get. The most interesting questions
- 1:00:30I find are all bound up in that genre they present me with. Really,
- 1:00:37I think that they present just fabulous, tricky situations that dwell in my
- 1:00:43mind long after we packed up the game. In the greater series of ATXX
- 1:00:49games, there are dozens of games, maybe even a hundred or so,
- 1:00:52that are so different you would hardly like despite the fact that they share the
- 1:00:58similar rules framework. There is different as any two euros could be from each
- 1:01:01other. And they're immensely competitive and interactive. And they are again like Titan.
- 1:01:09For people interested in design, you can do no better than play a
- 1:01:15lot of eighteen thirty, And so the reason I picked eighteen thirty in particular
- 1:01:19is it's one of the earliest and also probably the best of the series,
- 1:01:23at least of the ones I've played. There are some that I will,
- 1:01:25depending on the weather, maybe prefer more. But eighteen thirty is a game
- 1:01:30I've played thirty or forty times, which is a lot for a game that
- 1:01:31takes five or six hours to play, and I would gladly play it again.
- 1:01:37I am consistently learning things about that game which completely transform how I think
- 1:01:44about the entire game. And if you wish to think of yourself as a
- 1:01:46heavy gamer, do you think eighteen x X games are a necessary rite of
- 1:01:52passage. I think, I mean, they're definitely not for everyone because they
- 1:01:55are so interactive. I think there's a big group of heavy gamers that likes
- 1:02:01the crunchy conversion puzzles but doesn't really like interaction, and for those people,
- 1:02:08you should stay as far away from the eighteen x accent from eighteen thirties as
- 1:02:13you possibly can. But for the heavy gamers that like a wide selection of
- 1:02:19thumb screws of which they can put on their opponents. You can do no
- 1:02:22better, And I think that so I think for that group it's an absolutely
- 1:02:27a right of passage. You need to play them, and if you don't
- 1:02:30like them, you need to like you need to go through the process of
- 1:02:35reacting against them and writing about them. And to that group, I would
- 1:02:37add anybody who thinks about design should study that genre, because to build a
- 1:02:45system which can sustain a whole sub hobby for over thirty years is just a
- 1:02:52completely remarkable feat. I think. You know when when I think there's a
- 1:02:57thread recently about the kind of mount rushmore of gaming and kind of seminal designers,
- 1:03:02and you know, you see the usual names like Knitza and said Zachson
- 1:03:06and any one of those that doesn't include Tresham. Francis Tresham, the designer
- 1:03:09of eighteen x X is sorely missing because I think that he I think that
- 1:03:19there is there is a core elegance to that system that more designers would be
- 1:03:24good to study and understand. So what's in the future for Cole Worley is
- 1:03:34I assume all of your design efforts now going to LAYD games. Will you
- 1:03:38design other games on the side, or all of your energy go into this.
- 1:03:43So the agreement I have with Patrick is that he sort of gets right
- 1:03:46at first refusal on the things that I'm working on that I build in studio
- 1:03:52with the understanding that he has a brand and an audience and it's not exactly
- 1:04:00where I've where where I tend to put most of my work. In some
- 1:04:02ways, Root is my first game that's directed at this kind of general audience.
- 1:04:08Um, And with that in mind, you know, I've got a
- 1:04:12game I'm working on right now that I'm going to probably give the Holland Spiel,
- 1:04:15the company that did Infamous Traffic, And I've told that Patrick, and
- 1:04:19I'm working on this, this game about land. It's it's about a Jibway
- 1:04:26and American Indian that it's about a Jibway and Dakota land buying in Minnesota actually,
- 1:04:34and it's quite mean and strange, and it's I think an interesting story
- 1:04:38about the interactions between Native peoples and European empires in North America. And it
- 1:04:46is very much a Holland Spield game, and it would never there's no way
- 1:04:51it could possibly be retrofitted into the Leader Games brand. So I'm going to
- 1:04:55keep doing those odd games. I've got a bunch of games which I think
- 1:04:59will kind of compliment John Company that I'm working on a little bit, and
- 1:05:03then I have a lot of projects within Leader Games. The plan is right
- 1:05:12now I am working kind of every waking moment is being spent finishing Route,
- 1:05:16and after I'm done, I'm going to get some fallow studio time where I'm
- 1:05:20going to be able to work on a number of projects. We've got really
- 1:05:24exciting stuff that I'm kind of pushing along, adventure games and strategy games and
- 1:05:29all sorts of things that are kind of too early to be talked about profitably.
- 1:05:33But I think if anyone's worried that I'm going to stop making interactive,
- 1:05:38weird games, they should not worry, both because Route is one of those
- 1:05:41games. I just got a message from someone the other day that said they
- 1:05:45had assumed that Route wouldn't be a very like interesting game because it was being
- 1:05:49sold so much based on the art, which is so welcoming, but they
- 1:05:54were happy to find it was like it was a compelling design. And I
- 1:05:58think this is not Again, when I praise Root, it's purely meant as
- 1:06:01praise of everyone in the studio. But Root is definitely a game that I
- 1:06:06think people who like the stuff I've done will like Root. And all the
- 1:06:12products that I'm working on have that similar kind of ethos behind them. So
- 1:06:15your final game sort of brings us around in a circle to some degree.
- 1:06:19And this is Pack's Porfiriana. And my first question is what is Phil Eklund
- 1:06:26brought to gaming? He found a way around the America trash problem, and
- 1:06:34the America trash problem is how do you make a game thematic in this era
- 1:06:45which prioritizes smooth gameplay and really clean interlocking systems, Like what do you do
- 1:06:51with theme? And so the way a lot of people answer that problem is
- 1:06:56they have event decks, and they have like lots of like crofts and special
- 1:07:00powers and goofy things like that. And Phil understood that you can't just adopt
- 1:07:09a euro engine if we think about this in video game terms, like you
- 1:07:12can't just take like the Puerto Rico engine and then put a bunch of flavor
- 1:07:15text on it, Like That's not the way you make a thematic game.
- 1:07:19You have to think about the core structure of the corn sentims of the game,
- 1:07:24and you need to think about the period and the theme, and you
- 1:07:28have to wait until you can get those things in alignment. And what is
- 1:07:32so remarkable about that answer is that Perfiriana is a game that took basically a
- 1:07:43massive open world, almost an RPG economic sandbox called Lords of the Sierra Madre
- 1:07:49that was published in the eighties and then in the nineties and a second edition.
- 1:07:53He took this big, ten hour game and he folded it into a
- 1:07:57card game, but without using any of the detail. In fact, in
- 1:08:01some respects PAxx, Perfuriana is more colorful and more thematic and tells a better
- 1:08:06story than the massive game. And then what's even more remarkable is that he
- 1:08:14did it again in packs Renaissance. And I've been playing a lot of Megafuna
- 1:08:16two and him Um and Andrew Marker and Andrew Dole, who are the he
- 1:08:23designed Bias Megafun two with he like he took American Megafuna, this massive,
- 1:08:29crufty old war game, and he collapsed it all into the sleekest, most
- 1:08:35thematic and delightful little box imaginable And so of all the packs games, I
- 1:08:42think that Perfurriana has a cleanness to it and has I think it is perfectly
- 1:08:49well suited to its period and perfect and because of that, it has a
- 1:08:56level of immersion that I don't think has ever has really been equalled in games
- 1:09:00like that. So, okay, final question. You're driving off to the
- 1:09:04cabin and you've got your foot down and you go around a corner and the
- 1:09:11car skids and the back door flies open. Four of the games fly out
- 1:09:15of the car, down a ravine, and a swept Away down a river.
- 1:09:19Which game do you hope is sitting on the back seat? Ah,
- 1:09:25that's so hard. I mean, does every guest just pick the last game
- 1:09:28they talked about. I think it's got to be Perferiana because it's scales so
- 1:09:32well and it's so goofy, and I can always read all the flavor text.
- 1:09:36It's like a novel in there. I think it has to be Perferriana.
- 1:09:40So if people want to get hold of you, how can they do
- 1:09:43that? The best way to get a hold of me is on Twitter.
- 1:09:45I am at Cole Worley and it's cl w e h r L. I
- 1:09:49also am pretty good at responding to private messages on Board Game Geek, although
- 1:09:54right now I have a bit of a backlog, and I'm sorry to tell
- 1:09:56those people so col worthy. Thank you very much, this was an absolute
- 1:10:01pleasure. Thank you, Ben. And if you want to suggest a guest,
- 1:10:05or if you want to say something nice about the show, or if
- 1:10:08you want to say something horrible about the show, you can contact me on
- 1:10:12at five Games for Doomsday on Twitter, you can send me an email at
- 1:10:15five Games for Doomsday at gmail dot com. You can support the show at
- 1:10:19Patreon dot com, forward slash five G four D. And if I haven't
- 1:10:25had to pogo stick as fast as my springs will carry me to avoid the
- 1:10:28green tooth beasties and the over opinionated belens, I'll see you in two weeks
- 1:10:32for another five Games for Doomsday