Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Why Your One-on-Ones Need a Better Structure
Transcript
- Lucas: There's a number that bothers me. According to a 2023 survey by the management software company 15Five, about 60 percent of one-on-one meetings between managers and their direct reports are used primarily as status updates. Task check-ins. 'What did you get done this week? Here's what's next.' Luna: Okay, and that sounds productive on the surface. What's wrong with it? Lucas: What's wrong is that you're paying a manager and a senior employee — or a junior employee — to sit in a room and essentially read a to-do list. That's an email. Or a Slack message. The one-on-one is supposed to be the highest-leverage conversation you have all week. If it's a status update, you're leaving about 80 percent of its value on the table. Luna: Eighty percent — that's a big claim. Where does that number come from? Lucas: It comes from Google's Project Oxygen, which analyzed thousands of manager feedback surveys and performance reviews to figure out what actually makes a great manager. One of the top behaviors was, and I'm paraphrasing, 'holds effective one-on-ones that focus on coaching and problem-solving, not task tracking.' And when they dug into what 'effective' meant, the key variable was the ratio of who does the talking. Luna: Manager versus direct report? Lucas: Exactly. The best one-on-ones, the ones that correlated with higher team performance and lower turnover, had the manager talking only about 20 percent of the time. The direct report drove the conversation. The manager listened, asked questions, and removed obstacles. Luna: That's a very specific ratio. Twenty-eighty. So most of us are doing it backwards. Lucas: Completely backwards. And I think the reason is that managers feel pressure to 'run the meeting.' They come with an agenda — which is usually their agenda. But the one-on-one is not a meeting for the manager. It's a meeting for the employee. The manager's job is to create a space where the employee can bring their real concerns, their career questions, the things they're stuck on. Luna: So how do you actually structure that? Because if you just say 'so, what do you want to talk about?' you might get a lot of silence. Lucas: You will, especially at first. That's why I like a simple three-part framework I picked up from a fintech company called Brex — they went through a big management training overhaul a few years ago, and they shared some of their learnings. The framework is: first, check-in. Second, coaching. Third, planning. Luna: Break those down for me. Lucas: Check-in is literally two minutes. 'How are you doing? Anything urgent since we last talked?' That's it. It acknowledges the human first. Then coaching — this is the main event. The manager asks open-ended questions: 'What's the most important thing you're working on? Where are you stuck? What would make your job easier?' And the manager mostly listens. Then planning: the last few minutes are about next steps, commitments, and making sure the employee leaves with clarity. Luna: I like that the coaching part comes before the planning. Most people would reverse that. Lucas: And that's the error. If you start with planning, you're already in task mode. The coaching part is where you surface the real stuff — the team dynamics, the career anxiety, the frustration with a process. And once you've addressed that, the planning becomes much more meaningful. Luna: I want to push back a little. Isn't there a risk that this structure becomes too rigid? Some people thrive on informal, spontaneous conversations. If you turn every one-on-one into a three-part formula, you might lose the human connection you're trying to build. Lucas: That's a fair concern. And I think the answer is that structure is a scaffold, not a prison. You don't have to say 'Now we're moving to coaching.' It's more like a mental checklist. The point is to make sure you don't accidentally spend the whole 30 minutes on status updates because you didn't have a framework to remind you to go deeper. Luna: Okay, that makes sense. So the structure is for the manager, not for the employee. Lucas: Exactly. The employee shouldn't feel like they're going through a template. The manager uses the framework to stay disciplined. After a few weeks, it becomes natural. And the employee starts showing up with their own topics because they know they'll have space to talk. Luna: Let's talk about that employee experience. What does it feel like from the other side? Because I think a lot of managers assume their direct reports are happy with the status quo. Lucas: Well, there's data on this too. A Gallup study from 2024 found that only 30 percent of employees strongly agree that their manager involves them in goal setting or helps them prioritize their work. That's a huge gap. Employees want coaching. They want to feel like their manager is invested in their growth, not just their output. Luna: So when the one-on-one is a status update, the manager is basically saying 'I care about what you produce, not about you.' Lucas: That's the message, whether intentional or not. And it's one of the top reasons people leave jobs — they don't feel supported or developed. A good one-on-one is a retention tool. Luna: Okay, but let's be real. A lot of managers have 8, 10, 12 direct reports. If you're doing a proper one-on-one with each of them, that's easily 5 to 6 hours a week. Is that realistic? Lucas: It's a real constraint. And I think the answer is that you don't have to do 30 minutes with everyone every week. The frequency and length should vary based on the employee's experience level and the nature of the work. A new hire might need 30 minutes weekly for the first three months. A ten-year veteran who's fully autonomous might be fine with 20 minutes every other week. Luna: So it's about matching the investment to the need. Lucas: Right. And the key is to be intentional about it. Don't cancel the one-on-one because you're busy. That sends a loud signal. Instead, shorten it or reschedule, but keep the rhythm. Consistency matters more than duration. Luna: If today's episode was useful to you and you want to keep it ad-free, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo helps. Lucas: Yeah, listener support is what keeps these conversations going without any sponsor interruptions. So if you found this helpful, that's the link. Luna: Back to the one-on-one: one more thing I want to touch on is the idea of a shared agenda. Some teams use a collaborative doc where both the manager and the employee add topics before the meeting. Does that work? Lucas: I think it's a great practice, with one caveat. The agenda should be a suggestion, not a straitjacket. If the employee shows up with something urgent that's not on the agenda, you drop the agenda. The agenda is a starting point for the coaching part, not a contract. Luna: So what does a good agenda item look like? Give me a concrete example. Lucas: Sure. Instead of 'update on Q2 marketing campaign' — which is a status item — a better agenda item would be 'struggling with cross-team alignment on the Q2 campaign — need help navigating the product team's priorities.' That's a coaching item. It's a problem the employee is bringing to the manager to solve together. Luna: That's a much more interesting conversation. Lucas: And more productive. Because the manager can actually help. Maybe they can set up a meeting between the marketing lead and the product lead. Maybe they can reprioritize the employee's workload. That's the kind of thing that makes the employee feel supported and also moves the work forward. Luna: I want to talk about the Brex example you mentioned earlier. What did they actually change? Give me the specifics. Lucas: Brex is a fintech company — corporate credit cards and spend management. They grew really fast, like from 300 to over 1,000 employees in a couple of years. And they realized their managers were all doing one-on-ones differently. Some were great, most were mediocre. So they built a one-on-one training program. The core was this: every one-on-one must have a clear purpose — coaching, not status. They gave managers a simple template with three questions: one, 'What's your biggest win this week?' Two, 'What's your biggest challenge?' Three, 'How can I support you?' Luna: Three questions. I like that. Lucas: And they tracked adoption. Within six months, employee engagement scores on the question 'My manager cares about my development' went up by 15 percentage points. That's a huge swing in a company that size. Luna: Fifteen points. And that's just from changing how you run a 30-minute meeting. Lucas: That's the power of the one-on-one. It's the single most leveraged time you have as a manager. If you do it well, it ripples into everything else — trust, productivity, retention. Luna: Okay, but I have to ask about the other side: what if your manager is the one running bad one-on-ones? How do you, as the direct report, steer the conversation? Lucas: Great question. I think you can be proactive. Come with your own agenda. Say, 'Hey, I'd really like to use our time today to talk about my career path — can we spend 15 minutes on that?' Most managers will say yes because it's a legitimate request. And if they still turn it into a status update, you might need to be more direct: 'I appreciate the update, but I was hoping to get your advice on something I'm stuck on.' Luna: So you're essentially managing up. Lucas: Exactly. And if your manager consistently refuses to engage, that's data. It might be a sign that the manager isn't right for you, or the company culture doesn't value development. But in most cases, managers aren't malicious — they're just not aware. They think they're doing a good job. Showing up prepared and steering the conversation is a gift to both of you. Luna: Let's talk about virtual one-on-ones. A lot of teams are remote or hybrid now. Does the framework change? Lucas: The principles don't change, but the tactics do. In person, you can read body language. On a video call, it's harder. So you need to be more explicit about creating space. I'd recommend starting with a genuine check-in: 'How are you really doing?' And then silence. Let the employee fill the silence. Also, keep your camera on. If you turn your camera off, the employee feels like they're talking to a black box. And don't multitask — that's the number one trust killer. Luna: Yeah, you can always tell when someone is reading emails during a one-on-one. Luna: One more thing: what about skip-level one-on-ones? That's when a senior manager meets with employees two or three levels below them. Is that a good idea? Lucas: I think it's a great practice, but it has to be done carefully. The risk is that the skip-level manager undermines the direct manager. So the purpose should be clear: it's for the senior leader to understand the ground truth and for the employee to get visibility into the broader organization. It should not be a performance review or a way to bypass the direct manager. Luna: And how often should skip-levels happen? Lucas: Quarterly is a good cadence. And the senior manager should share general themes with the direct manager — not specific complaints, but patterns. That builds trust across the chain. Luna: Let's bring it back to the core takeaway. If a listener takes one thing from this episode, what should it be? Lucas: The ratio. Talk less. Listen more. Aim for 20 percent of the airtime. And if you're not sure what to do, ask your direct report: 'What's the most important thing we could talk about today?' Then shut up and listen. Luna: That's a good note to end on. Next week we'll talk about how to give feedback that actually changes behavior. Lucas: Looking forward to it.