Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Scottish Clan Tartans Aren't Ancient. They Were Invented in 1842 by Two English Con Men.
Transcript
- 0:00You already know the story, or at least the version everybody's
- 0:03been handed down. Clans, sacred tartans, a warrior
- 0:08culture supposedly older than memory itself.
- 0:11That's the myth. And what I want you to sit with
- 0:14for the next little while is that the myth was a product.
- 0:17Somebody built it deliberately, and they built it to sell.
- 0:21So let me walk you through how it actually worked.
- 0:24You've got 2 con men, a single forge manuscript, a textile
- 0:28industry up in Manchester running looms that had gone
- 0:30quiet, a king who badly needed a spectacle, and a novelist who
- 0:35understood the thing that most people never quite grasp, that a
- 0:39nation without a legend is a nation without a market.
- 0:42And the place where it all came together was a counting house.
- 0:46The room where somebody keeps the books.
- 0:48Which isn't where you'd expect to ever picture a national
- 0:53legend getting born. What these men were really doing
- 0:56was incorporating Scotland, not recovering it, taking it clan by
- 1:00clan, clad by Plaid, 1 bolt of cloth at a time.
- 1:04By the time we're done here, you won't be able to look at a
- 1:07tartan again without seeing the invoice sitting right behind it.
- 1:30Welcome back to Hidden Forces in History.
- 1:32I'm your host Jeremy Ryan Slate, the CEO of Command your brand.
- 1:37Check us out at commandyourbrand.com.
- 1:39So our story, it really starts on a Moor and not a romantic 1.
- 1:44Whatever you're picturing. A flat, wet, windswept stretch
- 1:48of ground outside Inverness on the 16th of April 1746.
- 1:54That's the Battle of Culloden, and it lasted less than an hour.
- 1:58The Highland army was poorly fed, poorly armed, standing in
- 2:01the wrong formation on the wrong ground, and the government
- 2:04cannon tore it apart in under 60 minutes.
- 2:08Something like 1000 Highlanders died on the field itself, and
- 2:12roughly another thousand in the hours after, because what
- 2:15happened next had stopped being a battle at all and turned into
- 2:18policy. The Duke of Cumberland, the man
- 2:21history ended up calling the Butcher, didn't just want to win
- 2:24that day, he wanted to end something.
- 2:27And he managed it. Within months, the British
- 2:29government passed a whole series of acts built specifically to
- 2:33take the Highland clan system apart and keep it apart.
- 2:36The Heritable Jurisdictions Act stripped the clan's chiefs of
- 2:40their legal authority over their own tenants.
- 2:43The 10 Years Abolition Act hold down the feudal military
- 2:46structure that had made a Highland army possible in the
- 2:491st place. And then there's the one that
- 2:52matters most for what we're going the Dress Act of 1746.
- 2:57The Dress Act made it illegal to wear Highland dress in public.
- 3:01No kill, no Plaid, no tartan, none of it.
- 3:04Get caught the first time and you're looking at six months in
- 3:08prison. And a second offense meant being
- 3:10shipped off to the colonies for seven years.
- 3:13Sit with that for just a second. Because it's a piece of cloth
- 3:16they're making criminal. And they're doing it because the
- 3:19cloth is a symbol, not because it's actually dangerous.
- 3:22And symbols hold a culture together about the same way that
- 3:26load bearing walls hold up a house.
- 3:28Take the symbol away and the identity underneath it starts to
- 3:31come apart. Which was more or less the whole
- 3:34idea. And for the next 36 years, it
- 3:37worked. The Chiefs lost their military
- 3:39power, then their legal authority, and slowly, with the
- 3:43agricultural revolution pressing down on everything at the same
- 3:46time, they started losing something harder to name, which
- 3:50was their actual economic reason to exist.
- 3:53Because it turned out sheep were worth more than people, A lot
- 3:56more. And the math is where the
- 3:58Highland Clearances came from. Whole communities pushed off
- 4:02their land, families had worked for generations.
- 4:05Villages emptied out almost overnight.
- 4:08Families loaded onto ships bound for Canada, Australia and Nova
- 4:11Scotia. You're watching a civilization
- 4:14get liquidated in real time and the people doing the
- 4:17liquidating? The landlords and new capitalist
- 4:20chiefs and the so-called improving aristocracy.
- 4:24They needed something very specific to go along with it.
- 4:27They needed a story. Not a sad one that wouldn't
- 4:30sell, but a proud 1. Something that made the
- 4:32Highlands feel dignified and noble and even romantic right at
- 4:37the moment the actual Highlanders were being pushed
- 4:39towards the sea. And the strange part is that the
- 4:42story was already being written before anybody thought to ask
- 4:45for it. The first man who really
- 4:47understood there was money in Scottish nostalgia wasn't.
- 4:51And a Scotsman. Not in a temperament anyway.
- 4:54His name was James McPherson, a Highlander by birth and an
- 4:58opportunist by trade. In 1760 he published what was he
- 5:02said was a translation of ancient Gallic poetry.
- 5:06He claimed he'd gathered it from oral tradition all across the
- 5:09Highlands. He transcribed it, translate it
- 5:12and rescued it for a whole world that had no idea even existed.
- 5:16He gave the supposed original poet a name.
- 5:19Ossian and the poems were genuinely good, dark,
- 5:23melancholic, full of mist and heroism and loss, the kind of
- 5:28thing that Red, like Homer had been picked up and set down in
- 5:32the Scottish Glens. They were also entirely made-up.
- 5:36McPherson hadn't translated old poetry he'd written to himself,
- 5:40and he knew exactly what he was doing.
- 5:42He didn't get away with it cleanly, either.
- 5:45Samuel Johnson was alive while all of this was happening, and
- 5:48he called McPherson a fraud almost immediately and told him
- 5:52to produce the originals, and McPherson never could.
- 5:55But here's the part that actually matters, which is that
- 5:58nobody could prove it, not right away, and not in a way that
- 6:01stuck. And the gap between everybody
- 6:04suspecting and anybody proving. The market just moved.
- 6:08The ASEAN poems went through Europe like a contagion.
- 6:11Napoleon carried them on campaign and reportedly said
- 6:14they inspired him more than any classical text.
- 6:17Goethe quoted them in The Sorrows of the Young Werther,
- 6:21which was one of the most widely read books of the entire 18th
- 6:24century. Schubert set them to music.
- 6:27Mendelssohn went up to Scotland partly because Ocean had made
- 6:31the whole place feel sacred. So you've got a Highland Bard
- 6:35who never existed, becoming one of the most influential literary
- 6:38figures of the century. The market for a Romantic
- 6:41Scotland was open now and the demand was real and sitting
- 6:45right there. What didn't exist yet was the
- 6:48supply chain to feed it and building that took a few more
- 6:50decades and honestly a few more forgers.
- 6:54So meet John and Charles Allen. They were born in England and
- 6:58their father was Thomas Allen, a Lieutenant in the Royal Navy.
- 7:02The grander version came later, and they made it up themselves,
- 7:06this claim that their grandfather had been an Admiral
- 7:09who secretly smuggled a Stewart heir to safety, which is a story
- 7:13that doesn't exist anywhere outside their own telling.
- 7:16They had no real Scottish blood and no Highland ancestry anybody
- 7:20could document. But in the early 1820s, they
- 7:23showed up in Scotland with a story, And the story was that
- 7:27they were the grandsons of Bonnie Prince Charlie, the lost
- 7:30heirs of the Stewart line, exiled royalty finally coming
- 7:35home. They changed their names to
- 7:36match John became John Sobiski Stewart.
- 7:40Charles became Charles Edward Stewart.
- 7:42They dressed in Highland costume.
- 7:44They talked about Highland culture with the easy authority
- 7:47of men supposedly born into it. And they were welcomed openly,
- 7:51which is not what you'd expect. You'd think a couple of
- 7:54Englishmen, Sassanax as the Scottish like to call them,
- 7:58turning up claiming to be lost. Stewart royalty would get
- 8:02nothing but suspicion and instead they got open arms.
- 8:06And the reason is that the Highland chiefs needed them.
- 8:09Think about the timing. The Dress Act had been repealed
- 8:12back in 1782. A generation had gone by since
- 8:15Kaladin, really closer to 2. The old ways hadn't been
- 8:18carefully preserved through all that.
- 8:20They've been outlawed. And now you've got these two
- 8:23chiefs sitting in a comfortable Manor house watching the
- 8:26romantic movement repackage the Highlands as a place of noble
- 8:30tragedy, and they want their heritage back.
- 8:33Or to put it more honestly, they want to look like they have
- 8:36heritage, which is a completely different thing, because
- 8:39heritage isn't really something you inherit at that point, it's
- 8:43something you perform, and a performance needs a costume.
- 8:47The trouble was, the chiefs didn't actually know what the
- 8:49correct costume even was. And that's the exact problem.
- 8:53Sobisky Stewart Brothers were there to solve.
- 8:56In 1842 they published a book called The Vistarium Scotium.
- 9:00They presented it as years of careful research, and they
- 9:04claimed it was based on a 16th century manuscript, something
- 9:08that had been quietly preserved and hidden and protected, that
- 9:12in fine detail. Which tartan pattern belonged to
- 9:15which Scottish clan? One clan, one tartan.
- 9:19A whole ancient codified system laid out for you.
- 9:22Except no one else had ever seen this manuscript.
- 9:25No historian confirmed it existed.
- 9:28No library had a record, no estate archive so much as
- 9:31mentioned it. And when scholars asked to see
- 9:33the original, the brothers always had a reason that you
- 9:36couldn't It was too fragile. It was being protected.
- 9:41It just wasn't available right now.
- 9:42And eventually it wasn't available permanently, because
- 9:46it didn't exist. You, Trevor Roper, who did more
- 9:50than anyone to pull this whole thing apart later on, didn't
- 9:54bother being polite about it. He called the brothers work pure
- 9:57fantasy and barefaced forgery, but look at what they'd actually
- 10:01pulled off, because it's precise.
- 10:04They'd spotted a real need in the market, which was the chiefs
- 10:07wanted historical legitimacy for a clan identity system that
- 10:10didn't have any. And then they manufactured
- 10:13exactly the product to fill it, an authenticated, codified clan
- 10:17by clan tartan registry with a 16th century back story nobody
- 10:21could check. And then they sold it.
- 10:24And the chiefs bought it. And not just in the sense that
- 10:27the book sold widely, though it did.
- 10:30They bought the premise because accepting the vistarium meant
- 10:33publicly treating your clans ancient tartan as the real
- 10:36thing. It meant hiring weavers to
- 10:39produce it. It meant dressing your family
- 10:41and your household and your tenants in a pattern that was,
- 10:45at the very most, about 20 years old.
- 10:48But it looked ancient, and it felt ancient, and it had a
- 10:52citation behind it, and in the business of identity, that
- 10:55citation is basically the whole game.
- 10:58Now this is where it turns properly commercial, because the
- 11:01brothers were really just the mythology department.
- 11:04The actual manufacturing was already up and running, and not
- 11:08where you'd think, either. It was happening in Bennett
- 11:11Buckburn, a small town near Sterling, nowhere near the
- 11:14Highlands and not in Edinburgh, in a textile work run by a
- 11:18family named Wilson. William Wilson had started the
- 11:21business back in the 1770s, and by the early 1800s Wilson and
- 11:25Sons was the dominant producer of tartan cloth in the whole
- 11:28country. And their pattern books tell you
- 11:31everything. Wilson wasn't matching his cloth
- 11:33to some ancient clan record. He was designing a pattern 1st
- 11:37and naming it afterwards. He'd weave something new, settle
- 11:41on a color combination, and then hand it a name.
- 11:45Sometimes a clan name, sometimes a place, sometimes just
- 11:48something he invented because it sounded suitably Scottish.
- 11:52So the clan tartan system people treat as recovered from history
- 11:56was actually getting built on the workshop floor.
- 11:59And his order books, which do survive, show the same patterns,
- 12:03getting renamed and reassigned and repurposed all through the
- 12:07early 19th century. A weave he sold to 1 customer as
- 12:11a clan's tartan turns up in another order under a totally
- 12:14different clan name, same cloth, different label.
- 12:18And that was just the catalog doing exactly what a catalog
- 12:20does. No oversight about it.
- 12:23And a catalog is always looking to grow.
- 12:26So when a chief turned up wanting his clan's ancient
- 12:28tartan, Wilson didn't tell him it didn't exist.
- 12:31He opened the pattern book, pointed at something that would
- 12:34do, and said, that one's yours. The chief placed the order.
- 12:38The looms ran, the invoice went out, and the tartan was now
- 12:42ancient. And here's the elegant part of
- 12:44it. Wilson's commercial operation
- 12:47and the brothers mythological fraud weren't formally working
- 12:50together at all. They didn't need to be, because
- 12:53they were serving the same market from two different
- 12:56angles. The brothers handed the product
- 12:58a history, Wilson handed it a skew, and between the two of
- 13:02them, they built something neither one could have built
- 13:04alone. They built a system, and a
- 13:07system like that needs a launch. Walter Scott might be the single
- 13:11most important figure in this whole story.
- 13:14And the interesting thing is not because he was lying to anyone,
- 13:18because he really wasn't. Well, not exactly.
- 13:21He was something more dangerous than a liar.
- 13:23A true believer also understood the commercial power of belief.
- 13:28Scott genuinely loves Scotland. It's history and it's landscaped
- 13:32and it's tragic romance, and he spent his whole career turning
- 13:35that love into product. Waverly, Rob Roy, the Lady of
- 13:39the Lake, the heart of Midlothian.
- 13:42His novels made the Scottish Highlands fashionable across the
- 13:45entire English speaking world. You had women in London weeping
- 13:49over Highland heroes they'd never met, and men in
- 13:51Philadelphia buying land in Scotland they'd never laid eyes
- 13:54on. By 1820, Scott was the most
- 13:56commercially successful novelist who'd ever lived, selling in
- 14:00London and New York and Paris and Saint Petersburg.
- 14:04He built the brand, and now he was about to run the campaign.
- 14:08In 1822, George the 4th announced he'd be visiting
- 14:11Scotland, the first reigning British monarch to make the trip
- 14:14in about 170 years. The last one had been Charles
- 14:18the 2nd, and that's a significant thing, politically
- 14:22significant, because George badly needed good press.
- 14:26His reign had been one embarrassment after another.
- 14:29His marriage to Carolyn of Brunswick was a public
- 14:31catastrophe, and his attempt to divorce her, which played out as
- 14:35a parliamentary process conducted completely in the
- 14:38open, had turned him into a laughingstock.
- 14:41Even his coronation was scandal, with his estranged queen showing
- 14:45up at Westminster Abbey on the day and physically trying to
- 14:49force her way in, the doors barred against her on the King's
- 14:52own orders, while the crowd outside cheered her on.
- 14:56So a royal visit to Scotland was really a calculation, a chance
- 15:00to look regal, to look beloved, to look connected to something
- 15:04old and legitimate. And the man they put in charge
- 15:07of staging it was Walter Scott. And staging is the precise word
- 15:12for what he did, because Scott didn't organize a visit.
- 15:15He produced a pageant. He had about six weeks to put
- 15:18together what he privately called a great historical
- 15:21spectacle, and he went at it with the precision of a theatre
- 15:24director. He sent written instructions out
- 15:26to the Highland chiefs telling him to turn up in full Highland
- 15:30dress, the tartan and kilt and brooch and the clan badge and
- 15:35the Dirk at the hip. There was just one immediate
- 15:37problem, which is that most of them didn't own any of it.
- 15:42So a circular went out from Scott's office, essentially
- 15:45telling the chiefs to go buy or Commission a full Highland
- 15:48costume before the King got there.
- 15:50Edinburgh tailors were buried in orders.
- 15:54Wilson's down in Bannockburn was running double shifts.
- 15:58The tartan market didn't just grow in that moment, it
- 16:01detonated, and Scott was meticulous about every detail,
- 16:05right down to specifying the Lowland chief should appear in
- 16:08Highland dress too. Men whose families had no
- 16:12Highland ancestry of any kind. So let's stop and think about
- 16:15that for a second. These are families who lived in
- 16:18Scottish Borders for centuries, men who'd never worn a kilt in
- 16:21their lives, whose own ancestors had fought against the Highland
- 16:25clans rather than alongside them.
- 16:27And Scott put them in a tartan anyway, because the whole thing
- 16:31was a performance. And in a performance, everybody
- 16:34wears the costume. On the 15th of August 1822,
- 16:39George the 4th arrived in Edinburgh.
- 16:41He came off the Royal George at Lathdocs wearing a Royal Stewart
- 16:45tartan kilt with a flesh colored tight underneath it, because in
- 16:49the summer heat the kilt was riding shorter than dignity
- 16:52would really allow. And the crowd loved it.
- 16:55Newspapers all over Britain reported the scene like it was
- 16:58breathtaking. The King in Highland dress,
- 17:01Ancient Scotland. Welcome back.
- 17:04A warrior culture revived for the sovereign.
- 17:07John Preble, who wrote the definitive account of the whole
- 17:09episode, named it about as plainly as you can, right there
- 17:14in his title, The King's Jaunt, a piece of theatre staged on a
- 17:18national scale, with Scott directing.
- 17:21Scott wrote afterward that we have all been in the Highlands,
- 17:25and that one sentence is worth sitting with because they hadn't
- 17:28been in the Highlands at all, not even close to it.
- 17:31They've been in Edinburgh, which in 1822 was a city of Georgian
- 17:36architecture and Enlightenment philosophy and lowland
- 17:39commercial ambition about as Highland as Paris's.
- 17:43What they'd actually done was manufacture the Highlands, build
- 17:47a stage version of the place, import the costume and the
- 17:50symbolism, and then perform all of it in a city.
- 17:53They'd spent the previous hundred years trying to put
- 17:56distance between itself and exactly that culture.
- 17:59The pageant ran two weeks with Highland games and military
- 18:03reviews and clan gatherings and formal banquets, and every
- 18:07single event called for tartan. Every participant needed a
- 18:10costume, and every moment of it was choreographed by Scott, who
- 18:14by this point was basically Scotland's chief marketing
- 18:17officer. And the economic effect landed
- 18:20right away. Tartan sales didn't just climb,
- 18:23they moved into a different category altogether.
- 18:26Before 1822, tartan was a regional cloth with a bit of
- 18:29fashionable appeal. After 18/22 it was a national
- 18:33symbol with royal endorsement on top of it, a real production
- 18:37system behind it and a fraud backed authentication scheme
- 18:41handing every clan its own specific pattern.
- 18:44The product was fully assembled at this point, so the 1822 visit
- 18:48opened the market. What locked it in for good came
- 18:52about 20 years later. In 1842, Queen Victoria and
- 18:55Prince Albert made their first trip to Scotland, and Victoria
- 18:58fell for the place completely. And she meant it.
- 19:02She genuinely wanted to live there.
- 19:04And in 1852, they bought the estate outright.
- 19:07And what came next is the remarkable part, because they
- 19:11didn't just buy a house, they more or less redecorated
- 19:14Scotland. Prince Albert, who had
- 19:16meticulous organizational energy and a real aesthetic streak,
- 19:20designed a brand new tartan, Balmoral tartan, Grey, black and
- 19:26red with grey, chosen deliberately to echo the granite
- 19:29of the castle itself. He designed it personally and
- 19:32had it registered as the exclusive property of the Crown,
- 19:35and to this day, it's worn by members of the royal family and
- 19:39a handful of people they specifically authorized.
- 19:42And inside the castle, every carpet was tartan.
- 19:45Every curtain, every upholster chair, every runner going up the
- 19:49stairs, the estate workers were put in Highland dress.
- 19:53Highland games got revived, or a lot of cases simply invented
- 19:57from scratch and then described as revival.
- 20:01Victoria kept a detailed diary of Highland life, the intimacy
- 20:05of it, the landscape, the Gillies, the stag hunts.
- 20:09And then she published it. Leaves from the Journal of Our
- 20:11Life and the Highlands became an immediate best seller, which
- 20:16meant the Queen had effectively become a content creator.
- 20:19Putting the Highland lifestyle out for mass audience, 10s of
- 20:23thousands of readers who would never set foot in Scotland.
- 20:26We're now consuming the Queen's version of it.
- 20:29And once the Queen is endorsing a product, the market just
- 20:32follows her. Aristocratic families all over
- 20:35Britain started building Highland retreats and buying up
- 20:38shooting estates in Perthshire and Sutherland.
- 20:41The shooting season, the glorious 12th of August when the
- 20:45Grouse season opens, became a fixed point on the English
- 20:48social calendar. And the part I find almost too
- 20:51neat is that a lot of the wealthy industrialists buying
- 20:54these estates came straight out of Manchester and the northern
- 20:58mill towns. They wore the tartan, they kept
- 21:01Gillies, they held Highland dinners, and they'd personally
- 21:04built the exact kind of factory that the Highland costume was
- 21:08now helping everybody to forget. Which is about the circle
- 21:11quietly closing right there. Now here's the detail the whole
- 21:15pageant was designed to keep you from looking at While Edinburgh
- 21:19was dressing up for the King in 1822, while Victoria was
- 21:22publishing her Highlands Idol in 1848, while the tartan industry
- 21:27was spreading out into global product, the Highland clearances
- 21:30never stopped. They ran right through all of
- 21:33it. Up in Sutherland, the Countess
- 21:35of Sutherland, who is one of the wealthiest land owners in all of
- 21:38Britain, cleared hundreds of thousands of acres of Highland
- 21:42farmland for sheep pasture across the 1810s and 1820s.
- 21:46Thousands of families were forced off their homes burned
- 21:50behind them so they couldn't come back, and they were pushed
- 21:53onto coastal strips too poor to actually support them.
- 21:56A lot of them immigrated. The estate factor who carried
- 21:59those Sutherland clearances out, a man named Patrick Seller, was
- 22:03actually tried for culpable homicide after several elderly
- 22:07tenants died during those forced removals.
- 22:10He was acquitted, and the clearances kept right on going.
- 22:13TM Devine, who's probably the leading modern historian of the
- 22:17clearances, makes exactly this point, that at this possession
- 22:21was happening through the very same decades, the tartan
- 22:24industry was taking off. The marketing of the Highland
- 22:27identity and the emptying out of the real Highlands weren't a
- 22:30century apart from each other. They were the same moment, and
- 22:34the big wave of clearances came in the 1840s, driven partly by
- 22:38the potato famine that hit the Highlands about as hard as they
- 22:41hit Ireland, and it emptied out entire Glens.
- 22:44All of it. While the tartan trade was
- 22:46booming, while clan societies were forming, and while the
- 22:49Vistarium Scotium was still selling copies, the people whose
- 22:53culture was being marketed were being removed from the land that
- 22:56culture had grown out of in the 1st place.
- 23:00So the Highland tradition functioned as a replacement
- 23:03rather than a recovery, a product laid carefully over the
- 23:07wound. The wound was the clearances,
- 23:10the product was the tartan. And you don't get to see the
- 23:12wound, you only get to see the cloth, which is the sort of
- 23:16whole point of how it was built. So let me pull back from the
- 23:20detail for a second and look at the shape of what got built
- 23:23here. Because what happened in
- 23:24Scotland between roughly 1760 and 1850 isn't only Scottish
- 23:29history. It reads like a playbook and it
- 23:31has actual steps to it. The first one is that you
- 23:34destroy or suppress the original culture, which is what Kaladin
- 23:38and the Dress Act was doing. The second is that you create a
- 23:42commercial vacuum and 36 years of banned Highland dress gave
- 23:46you exactly that, 36 years of identity pushed down and
- 23:50waiting. The third step is that you fill
- 23:52the vacuum back up with manufactured version, the same
- 23:55culture you just suppress, and that's the Mcpherson's and the
- 23:58Sobieski, Stewart's and Wilson's of Banach Berm all walking on
- 24:02the stage. The 4th is you get a monarch to
- 24:05put his name on the product, which is George the 4th and a
- 24:08kill and then Victoria at Balmoral.
- 24:11The 5th is that you build a permanent industry around
- 24:13performing that identity. So now you've got the Tartan
- 24:16mills and the clan societies and the heritage tourism all
- 24:20running. And then there's the sixth step,
- 24:22the one nobody really shows you, which is that you make the
- 24:26dispossessed pay to get back their own heritage.
- 24:29So the Highlander who's been cleared off his land, who's
- 24:32immigrating to Nova Scotia or working in a Glasgow factory, if
- 24:36he wants to feel connected to the thing he's lost, he has to
- 24:39buy it back. The very cloth his culture has
- 24:41made illegal for wearing now repackaged and authenticated and
- 24:45sold back to him at a premium, with his own clan name printed
- 24:49on the label. That's the invoice.
- 24:52That's what the Ledger actually shows when you read it and it
- 24:55tells you these people didn't simply play the game in front of
- 24:58them, they went and redesigned what the game was going to cost.
- 25:02The Vistarium Scotium actually got exposed fairly quickly.
- 25:06By the mid 1840s, serious historians were questioning it
- 25:09out loud, the language in the supposed manuscript was
- 25:12anarchistic and the provenance was implausible, and the details
- 25:16didn't line up with what real scholars knew about the actual
- 25:19history of Highland dress. The brothers got challenged
- 25:22directly in print and none of it mattered.
- 25:24And it's worth understanding why.
- 25:26By the time the fraud was formally nailed down, the system
- 25:29it had set off was already running on its own.
- 25:32The chiefs had commissioned their tartans.
- 25:35They'd already worn them in public.
- 25:36Portraits have been painted. The patterns were registered
- 25:39with manufacturers. Whole families have been dressed
- 25:42in these things for 20 years at this point.
- 25:45So debunking the vistarium didn't unweave a single yard of
- 25:48cloth. It didn't unstage the royal
- 25:51pageant. It didn't pull the King's
- 25:52portrait, tartan kilt and all, back off the drawing room walls
- 25:56in Britain because the fraud was really only the ignition.
- 26:00What kept the engine turning over was something else
- 26:02entirely, a mix of vested interest and commercial momentum
- 26:07and that deep human need to belong to something older than
- 26:10yourself and time. It does the rest of the work.
- 26:13Once a tradition has been around 20 years, it starts to feel
- 26:16established. 50 years and it feels old. 100 years and it's
- 26:21ancestral. 200 years and people treated as sacred.
- 26:26That's how something manufactured quietly becomes
- 26:28something real. And it's more or less the idea.
- 26:31Eric Hobsburn gave a name to the invented tradition, a practice
- 26:36that's actually recent, sometimes faked overnight, and
- 26:39that works precisely by claiming this deep, ancient past.
- 26:43And it's no accident at all that when Hobsburn put that book
- 26:46together, the case study he opened was the Scottish
- 26:49Highlands. In the end, it happens through
- 26:51time, not really through the deception itself, and the people
- 26:55who understood that earliest are the ones who made the most money
- 26:59off of it. The fraud was just the first
- 27:01chapter, and the institution was the real product.
- 27:05By the late 19th century, the Highland tradition wasn't only a
- 27:08Scottish product anymore, it had gone global.
- 27:11The Scottish diaspora scattered across North America, Australia,
- 27:15New Zealand and Africa, and they carried the whole system with
- 27:19them. Highland Games turned up in
- 27:21Ontario and Nova Scotia. Clan societies formed in New
- 27:24York and Boston and Philadelphia.
- 27:27Pipe bands were marching through Melbourne and Christchurch.
- 27:31Saint Andrews societies were hosting formal Highland dinners
- 27:34in cities that had never seen a Scottish Glen in their lives.
- 27:37And every one of those institutions needed a product to
- 27:40run on. The tartan cloth and the kilts
- 27:43and the clan badges, the clan societies and the crests and the
- 27:47whole heritage economy grew up just to supply them.
- 27:50And here's the brutally efficient part of it.
- 27:52The clans these diaspora Scots were identifying with had, in a
- 27:55lot of cases, been the exact landlords who cleared their
- 27:59ancestors off the land. The chiefs who'd sign the
- 28:02eviction orders. The men whose estate factors had
- 28:05burned the cottages down, their tarties authenticated by a
- 28:09fraudulent manuscript woven in a lowland factory endorsed by a
- 28:14king in pink tights. We're now being warned with real
- 28:17pride by the descendants of the people they've thrown out.
- 28:21The brand had come completely loose from the history behind
- 28:24it. The tartan had quietly become
- 28:26the clan itself, standing in for the people and the land and the
- 28:29language, when all of that was really left of it, was the
- 28:33cloth. Same playbook, different
- 28:35century. Scotland's tourism industry now
- 28:38brings in over £10 billion a year and the single biggest draw
- 28:42is heritage. The castles and the Glens and
- 28:45the clan history. Visit Scotland, the national
- 28:48tourism agency, runs campaigns built almost entirely on the
- 28:52imagery of Highland tradition, the tartans and kilts and the
- 28:56Misty Mountains, which is the exact product system that got
- 28:59manufactured back in the 1820s. DNA testing companies will now
- 29:03sell you a Scottish ancestry package that connects you to a
- 29:08clan history. You pay for the test, you get
- 29:11the clan and you get the tartan, the vistarium, Scotium all over
- 29:15again, just in digital form this time.
- 29:18Tartan Day, the 6th of April, is officially recognized by a
- 29:21resolution of the United States Congress.
- 29:24There are registered tartan patterns for American states,
- 29:27for corporations, for sports teams, for military units.
- 29:31Disney has a tartan. Coca-Cola has a tartan.
- 29:34There's a registered Dolly Parton tartan.
- 29:37So the thing that started on a workshop floor and Bannockburn,
- 29:41authenticated by a manuscript that was a forgery and launched
- 29:45by a king playing dress up at a pageant, has spread out across
- 29:49the global identity market worth hundreds of millions of pounds a
- 29:52year. And it keeps working for the
- 29:54same reason it worked the very first time.
- 29:57People want to belong to something older than they are,
- 30:00something with weight to it, something with a story attached.
- 30:04The product answers that want. And it doesn't actually matter
- 30:07that the product was designed last century, because what
- 30:10matters is it feels ancient when you put it on.
- 30:12In the business of identity, the feeling is the product.
- 30:17The feeling is the thing you're invoicing for, and the invoice
- 30:20is still going out today. So let's actually read the
- 30:23Ledger. Who built what and who ended up
- 30:26paying? James McPherson created the
- 30:28market back in 1760. He proved A romanticized
- 30:32Scottish identity, had real commercial value, faked the
- 30:35supply just to test whether the man was there, and the demand
- 30:39turned out to be very real. William Wilson and Sons built
- 30:42the supply chain, turning a regional weaving tradition into
- 30:46a national product catalog, assigning the names to the
- 30:49patterns, running the looms, sending out the invoices.
- 30:53The Sobeski Stewart brothers built the authentication side of
- 30:56it. They gave the product a
- 30:58historical signature had never earned, and they sold legitimacy
- 31:02to chiefs who needed to look ancient and had no way to get
- 31:05there. Walter Scott built the launch
- 31:07platform, taking a politically awkward royal visit and turning
- 31:11it into a national founding myth, choreographing every step
- 31:14of the pageant and then writing the narrative afterwards,
- 31:18telling the world Scotland had come home to himself.
- 31:21And Queen Victoria built the global brand, giving the whole
- 31:24thing it's ultimate royal endorsement and making Highland
- 31:28Scotland aspirational for the entire English speaking world,
- 31:32and not only for the aristocracy this time, but for everyone
- 31:35right down the line. So that's five people and one
- 31:38system running between them. The Highland tradition that's
- 31:41been handed down to every generation as ancient and
- 31:45organic and inevitable was a construction put together in
- 31:48deliberate stages by people who understood that identity is a
- 31:52market and nostalgia is a kind of currency.
- 31:55They understood that if you manufacture the past carefully
- 31:57enough, it stops being the past and quietly becomes the present
- 32:02you're living in. And the present, it turns out,
- 32:05can be extremely profitable. So you came into this hearing
- 32:08about a myth. Ancient clans, sacred tartans, a
- 32:12warrior culture older than memory.
- 32:14And now you've seen the thing as it was actually made. 2 English
- 32:19brothers who invented names and a manuscript that never existed.
- 32:22A textile firm in Bannockburn with quiet looms and a pattern
- 32:26book full of names they made-up as they went.
- 32:29A novelist who understood that nations need stories the way a
- 32:32factory needs raw material. And a king in pink tights who
- 32:36closed the whole deal in front of 20,000 people on Edinburgh's
- 32:41Royal Mile. They didn't recover Scotland.
- 32:44They incorporated it, clan by clan, bolt by bolt, one invoice
- 32:48at a time. And the register is still open.
- 32:52Every DNA test that hand you a clan, every tartan scarf for
- 32:56sale at an airport gift shop, every Highland game in some
- 32:59suburb of Toronto, Charlotte or Sydney.
- 33:01It's all the same operation, still running, same playbook,
- 33:05different century, and now you can see it for what it is.
- 33:09This has been hidden forces in history.
- 33:11I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate, do me a favor, like this video?
- 33:14Leave us a comment and hit that subscribe button if you want
- 33:17more hidden forces in history.