Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts & Bolts of CCPA and CPRA: California Privacy Law with Diana Iketani Iorlano
Transcript
- 0:00Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to nuts and bolts of CCPA and CRCPRA, California
- 0:13Privacy Law. My name is Belinda McCauley, and I'm the Executive Director of the Beverly
- 0:17Hills Bar Association, and I am very happy to be here today to introduce our speaker,
- 0:22Diana Iketani-Iorlano. Diana is the founder and managing attorney of Iketani Law Corporation
- 0:28in El Cidendo. She is a seasoned privacy lawyer, litigator, and outside general counsel with
- 0:34more than 25 years of experience advising businesses of all sizes across various industries.
- 0:39A fellow of information privacy through the IAPP and certified in multiple privacy disciplines,
- 0:45she is a thought leader in privacy, cybersecurity, and data security compliance. Diana frequently
- 0:51speaks on these topics, conducts trainings, and mentors aspiring attorneys. Her presentations
- 0:56for BHBA always get rave reviews, and we so appreciate that she agreed to return to do
- 1:02this installment of our nuts and bolts series. So with that, Diana, we really look forward
- 1:07to learning from you today, and I turn the Zoom floor over to you.
- 1:13Thanks so much, Belinda, and thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar Association for having
- 1:16me back. It is one of the best places to speak and to gain information. I am an avid
- 1:23consumer of your MCLEs, and I encourage everybody else to check out the library and see what
- 1:28else there is in there that you can learn about. But I'm thrilled to be here to introduce
- 1:33the nuts and bolts of CCPA, the California Consumer Privacy Act, and CPRA, the California
- 1:39Privacy Right. We did one of these webinars back in 2020 when the CCPA was brand new,
- 1:47and we're here to update that and tell you what's been happening in the world of privacy.
- 1:51So, for the first time in a while, we're here to give you some guidelines and teach you
- 1:58what you need to know to help your own clients, or if you are a client, what questions you
- 2:02need to ask your lawyers. And then a lot of people have reached out to me to say, hey,
- 2:07how do I get into privacy? So we're going to touch on that as well and really talk about
- 2:11what being a privacy lawyer means in the practical application, and then just in sort of what
- 2:17knowledge base you need to have. So I'm going to jump into the slides here, and we'll keep
- 2:26going. So just a bit of housekeeping, the CLE certificates, there's some information
- 2:31in the chat, but also they're going to be sent to you right after you finish this program.
- 2:34And if there are evaluations, I would also welcome any of your feedback in an evaluation
- 2:39that you can provide to me. Tell me what content you might like in the future. That'd
- 2:43be great. So today we're going to talk about CCPA and CPRA. I've really got about 45 minutes
- 2:51worth of information on this topic, and then I'm going to open it up for a Q&A at the end
- 2:56so that your burning privacy questions can be answered. But we're going to talk through
- 3:01the overview of the actual law, what compliance looks like, how does it affect other industries,
- 3:09different industries. You know, if you have an e-commerce client, it's going to affect
- 3:12them a lot differently than if you have a legal professional whose website that just
- 3:16kind of needs to be updated. We're going to talk a little bit about enforcement. There's
- 3:21very limited published enforcement decisions right now. We'll talk through some of those
- 3:27and sort of talk about what the future is, what we see as where the areas of enforcement
- 3:32will be in the future for CCPA, but also privacy enforcement in general. And then I'll just
- 3:37do a quick summary and then we'll have Q&A. So I'm going to jump into this. This is me.
- 3:42I'm Diana Iketani-Irolano. I have been practicing since 1997 in Los Angeles in the Graduate
- 3:48of USC Law School. I hold, as Belinda said, the Fellow of Information Privacy. These certifications
- 3:54on the left are all from the International Association of Privacy Professionals, IAPP.org.
- 4:00Many of you have heard of the organization. Maybe you've even attended seminars and events
- 4:07that they hold that they are sort of the preeminent privacy certification organization. There
- 4:15are many, many others that pop up all the time. But I hold the CIPP for U.S. that's Certified
- 4:21Information Privacy Professional for the U.S., for E, and for ESA. And then I also hold the
- 4:28Certified Information Privacy Program Management Certification. These are not necessary. You
- 4:35don't have to have these to practice in privacy. But it is helpful. And I'll talk a little
- 4:40bit about that when we talk about what it means to be a privacy lawyer. So I'll jump
- 4:45right in. CCPA stands for the California Consumer Privacy Act. It was passed in 2018
- 4:51and went into effect in 2020. And it was the first comprehensive state privacy law in the
- 4:57nation. We had just come on the heels of the GDPR in Europe, General Data Protection Regulation,
- 5:04and then California said, hey, we want to get in on that. So California came out with
- 5:09a law that was pretty hastily passed. So it got passed and it was the series of a very
- 5:17quick set of negotiations. And so there were some flaws with the initial law. And then
- 5:24they tried to iron some of those out with the California Privacy Rights Act, which amended
- 5:29the CCPA. So when we started out with the CCPA, there were certain definitions that
- 5:36were there. What businesses fall under the CCPA? And there were thresholds of 25 million
- 5:44or more in annual revenue. It was unclear in the first incantation of the law, whether
- 5:50that was worldwide revenues, just California revenues, or what it was. It applied to 500,
- 5:56if you had the data of 500,000 or more, I'm sorry, actually, that's the type of it's 50,000
- 6:01or more data subjects. And whether you had 50% or more of your revenue being derived from
- 6:13selling or sharing information. The consumers that were affected were California residents,
- 6:20people who were here for anything other than just a transitory purpose. And the definition
- 6:25of personal information wasn't exactly aligned with personally identifiable information that
- 6:31had been defined in the GDPR. So personal information here included names, addresses,
- 6:38email addresses, but it also included IP addresses, any sort of identifier that went with the
- 6:44device. And so it was a much more encompassing definition of personal information. It also
- 6:50had a definition of sale of information, which was giving information to a business or a
- 6:55third party for monetary or other valuable consideration was kind of vague on what that
- 7:01meant. And who were third parties service providers were defined, there are people that
- 7:06you had to have a written contract with that were providing a service to you. And that
- 7:11you could share information with because you had a written contract and the written contract
- 7:15had to contain certain things. The third parties were people that you didn't have a
- 7:19contract with. And so it encompassed a lot of people that we may share information with
- 7:25that aren't providing a given service to us as a business. The early version of the CCPA,
- 7:32the 2020 version, excluded employee data because employees and business to business data, they
- 7:38weren't consumers. So that exclusion, though, would eventually disappear and sunset out.
- 7:47But it gave important privacy rights to consumers in California, the right to know what information
- 7:52was being collected about them, the right to access that data, the right to delete that
- 7:57data, the right to opt out of the sale, the right to non-discrimination. And it introduced
- 8:04this concept of a global privacy control, which we'll talk about a little bit later
- 8:08as well. But the idea that there should be a setting that people can set to tell businesses
- 8:15that they visit on the internet that they don't want to have their information sold.
- 8:21The technology was not quite where the law was. And we'll talk about that. That's an
- 8:26ongoing problem with privacy is that typically the technology is going to outpace the law.
- 8:32Here the law sort of outpaced the technology where one of the creators of the CCPA, I heard
- 8:40him speak recently and he said, I just think that there should be one button you can push.
- 8:44And this theme is going to be ongoing. One button that you can push to opt out of things,
- 8:49to make it a seamless consumer experience on the web. And we just don't have that as
- 8:54of yet. But maybe it's coming. The CCPA also required reasonable data security. The minimum
- 9:02you had to have was a written information security program and an incident response
- 9:08plan. So those were sort of the minimums, but reasonable, like we all know if you're
- 9:13an attorney, you know, from law school, the reasonable person standard, we try to define
- 9:17that. But maybe there's a little wiggle room there. So the big issue that CCPA introduced
- 9:26was the private right of action. But the private right of action for an individual to sue under
- 9:32the CCPA only was limited to if a company had had a data breach, then an individual could
- 9:39sue for a violation of the CCPA. But you can bet that when they were going to sue for a
- 9:45violation of the CCPA due to a data breach, they might say, and by the way, you didn't
- 9:49comply with the CCPA in all of these other ways. I'm a former litigator, I litigated
- 9:56for 20 years before opening my own firm. I was at a big firm in West Los Angeles. And
- 10:01you know, as we all know as litigators, what happens is that a predicate violation of an
- 10:07underlying statute can be a violation of an unfair business practice. And so we were all
- 10:13very worried that a huge rush of unfair business practice, unfair competition types of claims
- 10:19would arise from strict violations of the CCPA. That didn't end up happening. It's definitely
- 10:25a component of the privacy litigation. And we'll talk about that. But I think that that's
- 10:31the risk is still there. So having clients comply with the CCPA as amended by the CPRA
- 10:38is a really important business step, because if they do suffer a breach, there's kind of
- 10:42an open door for consumers to come in and sue on these technical violations. And as
- 10:50we know, there are a lot of agencies, state agencies, federal agencies that want to enforce
- 10:57individual privacy rights and sort of what they expect of businesses that conduct business
- 11:02on the internet. So moving to the CPRA, the California Privacy Rights Act, it's not a separate
- 11:09law. So I just want to make that clear. The CPRA amends the CCPA. So some people will
- 11:16colloquially call it CCPA 2.0. But really, when you refer to it, it's the CCPA as amended
- 11:22by the CPRA. So you can keep using CCPA. You don't have to do CCPA, CPRA, even though
- 11:29that was in the title of our program. We wanted to hook you in with that. But it's the CCPA
- 11:35as amended. And how it has been amended is that it's still the thresholds are still the
- 11:4025 million in gross revenue in the preceding calendar year. So that was more helpful to
- 11:46define what the gross annual revenues were. And it's for businesses that buy, sell, share
- 11:52personal information of 100,000 or more California residents. So they actually raised the threshold
- 11:56from 50,000 to 100,000. Or businesses like data brokers that may derive 50% or more of
- 12:03their annual revenue from selling or sharing consumer personal information. Like I alluded
- 12:10to, the employee and business to business exceptions ended on January 1, 2023. So that's
- 12:17new, right? The CCPA applies to employee data. And it applies to even email addresses that
- 12:24you're connecting and a business to collecting and a business to business context. So it's
- 12:30much more encompassing. It's much more like GDPR in that way, where it really is just
- 12:35sort of looked at as a right that everybody, all California residents have. The CPRA also
- 12:41introduced some new privacy rights, the right to opt out of the sharing of personal information
- 12:46and to limit certain uses of sensitive personal information. The categories of sensitive personal
- 12:53information are going to include things like your social security number, some financial
- 12:57information, it's going to include health information, biometric information, and precise geolocation
- 13:04information. So if you have clients that have apps that are tracking people, they may be
- 13:09collecting sensitive personal information. And if they're sharing that with other businesses,
- 13:14then the CCPA as amended is directly relevant to what they do. And you have to know that
- 13:20when you're working with a client that may have those types of data collection. The right
- 13:25to correct inaccurate personal information, we all want that. It should be a fundamental
- 13:30right, but it just hadn't been articulated before. And then the right to enhance privacy
- 13:35about what a business does with the information they collect. So how long did they keep it?
- 13:41The data retention period is very important. And who are they giving it to? And why are
- 13:45they giving it to that other business? What's the business purpose for sharing information?
- 13:51It also created miners rights. So typically on the internet, we view people who are over
- 13:5716 as being able to interact, to contract, to agree to things. Query whether the age
- 14:05of majority in a specific state may be higher, might be 18, might be 19, might be lower.
- 14:12But on the internet, for most purposes, we say that kids over 16 can agree to things.
- 14:17Kids under 16, but over 13 may need to, you may treat them differently. The CPRA said
- 14:24that they actually have to give affirmative opt-in consent if they're between 13 and 16.
- 14:31And then for children under 13, 12 and under, we have to obtain parental consent if we want
- 14:36to send communications to them, if we want to market to them. Typically, there's going
- 14:40to be no marketing allowed to children who are under 13. But if a child who's 13 to 16
- 14:47expressly opt-in and says, yes, I want to get that information about my kids into Roblox,
- 14:52I want to get that information about Roblox, you have to create a mechanism for that. So
- 14:57if you are a company that is a child facing establishment, a child facing property, you
- 15:03need to know about the changes to these laws. And another big thing, excuse me, that the
- 15:09CPRA did was it created a separate agency, the California Privacy and Protection Agency,
- 15:14that was imbued with the ability to enforce the law too. Now the CCPA is up and running,
- 15:23it's a functioning organization, they're still having rulemaking and regulation discussions.
- 15:29And you can get on their mailing list if you want to get more information about the actions
- 15:33that the CCPA takes. I encourage you to go to their website, it's going to be listed
- 15:39in the resources that we provide with this, with the materials. But you can get bulletins
- 15:46and updates on what the CPPA is doing. So that's important. Again, we talked a little
- 15:54bit about sensitive personal information and what that means. Here's a little bit more
- 15:59detail about what's included under sensitive personal information. So what I'm hoping to
- 16:04do with today's webinar is really talk to you about ways that you can also value add
- 16:09with your existing clients, even if you are not a privacy lawyer, maybe you're a corporate
- 16:14lawyer, maybe you're a litigator, maybe you're just dealing with a lot of startups and entrepreneurs
- 16:19who have not so much guidance as to what they need to put into their privacy policies
- 16:24and what they need to do, or maybe you're helping somebody develop a new product. Having
- 16:29a background in privacy is really important for that, to understand data collection and
- 16:36data retention and data minimization, which is the concept that we want to encourage our
- 16:42clients to collect as little personal information as they need to provide the services that they
- 16:47provide. Data minimization is a really important concept globally, and it needs to be proportionate.
- 16:56The way that we handle the data needs to be proportionate to the sensitivity of that data.
- 17:01So we'll talk a little bit about that as we go on through this. But the CPRA, again,
- 17:06clarified these obligations on a business, that they had to provide a written notice,
- 17:12that they had to have retention periods for these things. And if any of you have worked
- 17:17with corporate clients, they sometimes say, hey, we keep information forever because we
- 17:23can. Now the CCPA, as amended, says, no, you can't do that anymore. And the data breach
- 17:31statutes for various states, all 50 states have different data breach statutes, they
- 17:36say, if you have unencrypted and unredacted information, that's a data breach. So it really
- 17:43forces us to talk to the clients about what data they're collecting, how long they're
- 17:48keeping it, and how is it stored? Is it encrypted, or is it just out there? Or is it still in
- 17:56boxes in a storage room somewhere that no one has gone into for five years? That's part
- 18:02of the conversation you can have about what kind of information is stale, what kind of
- 18:06information needs to be destroyed, and can we create a policy, even a prospective policy
- 18:12of, hey, we're only going to keep this information for X number of years. It's an important conversation
- 18:18to have with your clients. Deletion requests, do we actually have the ability to delete
- 18:25someone's information? Is it all stored in the cloud? Is it stored on our servers? Is
- 18:31it stored in multiple different places where maybe we don't actually know where it goes?
- 18:37Or are there employees in your company that downloaded a client list and it's residing
- 18:42on their hard drive that's not connected to the internet or not connected to your server?
- 18:48It really requires us to look at data hygiene and how clean we're keeping our data. We've
- 18:54heard things about clients who have clean desk policies where the physical information,
- 19:00you're not supposed to leave physical information out there for anybody to find. But let's say
- 19:05you have a client who's using Google Drive to store all of their information and they
- 19:10didn't know that there were security settings there that could lock the information. And
- 19:14so an employee sent a link to the information to themselves at their home address and then
- 19:20forwarded it to somebody else. We find these out sometimes in corporate espionage cases
- 19:29or an unfortunate departure of somebody from the company. You find out that they've sent
- 19:34information. But the company should know what data they're collecting and where it's stored
- 19:41and whether they have adequate security measures to protect that information. When you have
- 19:47Google Drive, there's a way that people can just send a link. If you don't have the document
- 19:51lock, they can just send a link to the document to anybody. And if that document contains
- 19:56sensitive personal information of customers or employees, that could potentially be considered
- 20:02a data breach. So there's things to think about there. The CPRA also imposes obligations
- 20:10for contract. So all of you transactional lawyers will love that you do need to add
- 20:15these terms to your basic MSAs or other agreements or the terms of service or the whatever terms
- 20:23your customers are agreeing to that talk about the relationship of who the company uses as
- 20:30a service provider or how they protect information that's provided to contractors or anybody else.
- 20:36We have to have adequate provisions that prevent those people from using the information for
- 20:43any other purpose than what we hired them to do. So that language actually is required
- 20:48to be in the contract. When we look at things like loyalty programs where we may be providing,
- 20:55the client may be providing a financial incentive, sign up for our newsletter and we'll send
- 21:00you a 15% off coupon. That happens all the time. We actually have to look at the value
- 21:06of the financial incentive and the value of the information that they're giving us. And
- 21:10sometimes we're not able to discriminate against people who give us their information and people
- 21:16who don't. So the clients may need to think about whether that offers to everybody who
- 21:21comes onto their website or is it really just tied to people who give their information.
- 21:26But it's an assessment that we have to do. We talked about the opt-in for minors who
- 21:30are under 16. It has to be an affirmative opt-in. And traditionally, the United States
- 21:37has been an opt-out regime where you sign up for something and you put in your email
- 21:43address and they can send you an email and then you have to affirmatively go and opt
- 21:46out or unsubscribe. But here it's different. So if you have knowledge that your audience
- 21:52contains members that are under 16, now you have to figure out a way to find out what
- 21:57age they are appropriately without collecting too much personal information. And so age
- 22:04gating, finding a way to restrict access to certain ages, may be part of your business
- 22:11plan at that point if you have a child-facing property. We also need to make sure that that
- 22:17consent is freely given. It's informed. So we're going to have to tell them, look, if
- 22:21you give us your information, here's how we're going to use it. And I think that we, as lawyers,
- 22:30sometimes we are bogged down by, we need to put all of these things into this policy.
- 22:34I like to joke that I write things that people never read because I write privacy policies
- 22:39in terms of use and cookie notices and things that you scroll through and you click. But
- 22:45I would encourage you, if you're interested in privacy, read what's in there. You will
- 22:49find out amazing things about what a company can do with your information. Now, you may
- 22:55not be able to do much with what Apple's new terms of service or the latest iOS update
- 23:01are going to be, but I think that it will open your eyes as to what you want to be doing
- 23:07and what consents you want to be giving out or whether you need to take a second look
- 23:13at a company's privacy policy to learn what they're going to do with your information.
- 23:19We have to do risk assessments now under the CPRA. Again, we're talking about the proportion
- 23:25of quality of whether the protection of the information is related to the sensitivity
- 23:30of the information. I think there's a lot more to privacy than just writing privacy
- 23:37policies. I'm sure that many of you get asked, hey, can you just write me a privacy policy
- 23:43or can you just look at what I pulled off the internet and tell me if it's okay? I want
- 23:48to throw up huge red flags and tell you there's so much more to it than just the privacy policy
- 23:56and what is the consumer facing part of privacy. Internally, the client actually has to be
- 24:04doing what they say they're doing in their privacy policy because otherwise it can be
- 24:09a violation and CPRA, CCPA violations can get quite expensive. As a practitioner, I
- 24:19want to tell you that privacy is obviously timely. I'm hoping that you walk away today
- 24:25with some information about ways that you can protect your own privacy, your own data
- 24:29privacy. Obviously, it's the subject of much news all the time, what's happening in privacy,
- 24:36what new states are coming out with privacy laws. But it is also creative where you are
- 24:41crafting solutions to actual problems and maybe acting as more of a business partner
- 24:47to your client to find out what is the reason why they're collecting this information? Are
- 24:52they just collecting it because they've always collected it or is there a reason why they
- 24:57need to keep collecting it and who do they give it to? We have to be creative about looking
- 25:02at the business reason, not just the legal reason, but also the business reason. But
- 25:09I'm also here to tell you that privacy is challenging and we'll go into this. This is
- 25:15one state's law that we are going through and it happens to be one of the most stringent
- 25:19in the nation, but other states are coming on hot. They're coming in hot with new requirements
- 25:26and so as a privacy practitioner, you have to look at what's going on internationally,
- 25:33what's going on in other US states, what is the exposure that your client may have as
- 25:38a former litigator. I love looking at the risk management parts of it to say, is what
- 25:45my client has done, is it going to be defensible? Litigators, this applies to you, transactional
- 25:52lawyers, this applies to you, compliance lawyers, government lawyers, this applies to you. When
- 25:57we're looking at what businesses do with their privacy policies, with their internal privacy
- 26:03practices. Okay. Some of the newer things introduced by the CPRA, but not quite fleshed
- 26:11out yet, are the disclosure of automated decision making technology and then the general idea
- 26:20that dark patterns are not valid consent. If you have a consent bar that says, I like this
- 26:28because I've always thought this was a horrible thing to do. You go into a website and they
- 26:32say, do you want this coupon for 15% off? It says, you know, claim my coupon. The other
- 26:38button says, no, I don't want to save money. I hate that. It's so offensive to me, but
- 26:45that's a dark pattern. When you're actually shaming somebody for opting out, right now,
- 26:51what we need to do is make sure that they're equivalent. So if it's accept, decline, that's
- 26:58going to be a much better thing than when you're sort of coercing somebody to accept
- 27:02because you've told them they're an idiot if they don't accept, they decline. So dark
- 27:07patterns are things where you may be persuading somebody to consent to something because maybe
- 27:14you're hiding the decline button or the no thanks button is really, really tiny and you
- 27:19just don't even know where it is and all they want to do is X out of that window, but there's
- 27:23no X and all that they see is accept. The enforcement agencies are going to look and
- 27:29say, that's not valid consent. You didn't give them an equivalent option. So we're still
- 27:35seeing more clarification on what dark patterns may be and other agencies are looking at this
- 27:43and saying, yeah, you can't do that. Let's just be transparent to people and say, accept
- 27:48decline. You've probably also come across it when you go to a cookie consent banner that
- 27:53pops up. And the only option is accept all. And you're like, well, I'm pretty sure I have
- 28:00the right to decline these, but I don't know how to do it. Or conversely, you get to the
- 28:06banner that pops up and it says, you know, it's a slider button. And you don't know if
- 28:11the slider button is it on or is it off? And if it's on, am I accepting the cookies? Or
- 28:17am I declining the cookies? We as privacy practitioners have to advise the clients on
- 28:22how to make that really clear and transparent to the users of their website, to their customers.
- 28:28So there's a lot of things about, you know, website UX user experience issues that that
- 28:34privacy practitioners have to learn about and have to use to advise our clients adequately
- 28:39on whether or not it complies with the law. So with the C P R A to, you know, there is,
- 28:45like I said, the C P P A, the California Privacy and Protection Agency, which is a separate
- 28:50state agency now charged with enforcing the C C P A as amended. In addition, though, the
- 28:58California AG's office, the California Attorney General still retains jurisdiction to file
- 29:04enforcement actions for violations of the C C P A, or, you know, it could be an enforcement
- 29:10action that also talks about this unfair business practice, this this dark pattern. So you have
- 29:15two agencies here and then federally, we have the FTC, the Federal Trade Commission wants
- 29:21in on the action, obviously, these are huge issues of importance. And this is a non partisan
- 29:28issue to if I might throw in a smidge of politics. These are issues, privacy issues are non
- 29:35partisan. They are issues that everybody wants. And I'll tell you that children's privacy,
- 29:40especially is a focus of a lot of these laws and a lot of the legislation that's happening
- 29:47around the country. Help privacy is also very, very much on the radar. So California also
- 29:54has, you know, the California Medical Information Act, California has, you know, 50 some odd
- 29:59privacy laws, in addition to the C C P A. So as a privacy lawyer, you also have to know
- 30:05what the landscape is of privacy in the state. But these are non partisan issues. So if
- 30:11someone's going to say, Hey, we have to protect children's privacy, there's a lot of people
- 30:16who can get behind that. So if your client is again, focused on child facing properties,
- 30:23they need to understand Kappa, the California or the Children's Online Privacy and Protection
- 30:28Act, which is a federal law, they need to understand these California laws, they need
- 30:31to understand laws throughout the world if they're marketing their services to other
- 30:38countries as well. But I think, you know, some of the major issues with the C C P P A,
- 30:46and the changes introduced by the C P R A in 2023 are that they're no longer required
- 30:52to give you notice a safe harbor period. Initially with the C C P A, you would get a letter,
- 30:59you'd have 30, that's gone. So if your client does receive a letter from one of the state
- 31:05agencies that says, Hey, we're investigating you, you must be prepared to respond. I think
- 31:12that that's really important. I'm sorry, I'm just looking at a couple of questions and
- 31:19I want to encourage you to ask questions. I'm going to go ahead and look at a couple
- 31:24of answer a couple questions. So one is, does the C C P A C P R A C A A D A and the Kappa
- 31:31applied to nonprofits, you have to look at the specific statute. So C C P A doesn't apply
- 31:37to nonprofits, but it might apply to some nonprofit activities. If you are sharing information
- 31:45that doesn't have anything to do with the operation of your nonprofit, could it apply?
- 31:51I think you want to do that analysis with your client to say, Hey, are there any other
- 31:55parts of the business where you are potentially profiting off of the selling or sharing of
- 32:01information of your, whether it's your donors or your volunteers or things like that. So
- 32:06I think it can be tricky. Kappa is going to apply to anybody who's directed at minors.
- 32:14So definitely take a look at that. If you were a nonprofit addressing minors, I would
- 32:21think you would still want to comply with Kappa, even if it strictly didn't apply to
- 32:25you. Because like I said, if you're collecting and buying and sharing the information of minors,
- 32:33that's not a great look. So, you know, are there people who are not going to use your
- 32:39organization because you haven't had a statement that you comply with these various laws?
- 32:44Possibly. I will talk at the end about the whole goal of this is to actually provide
- 32:52a better user, consumer, customer experience where they know that they can trust you because
- 32:59you've been transparent about how you use information. And this applies to all businesses.
- 33:03Whether or not you're required to comply with CCPA, you still need to, people still expect
- 33:11you to have a privacy policy. You still actually have to have one under other California state
- 33:14laws. But they want to know what you do with their information. And they're kind of expecting
- 33:20these things to be in a privacy policy now. So the idea of building customer loyalty by
- 33:26being transparent, that applies to everybody. Small businesses are exempt if there's less
- 33:34than 25 million in gross revenue. That's correct. The CCPA does not apply. But make sure you
- 33:39look at those other elements. You know, are you deriving a lot of your business from buying
- 33:45and selling information? You know, data brokers would still fall under CCPA even if they weren't
- 33:5125 million dollar companies because they are buying and selling information. So think about
- 33:58all three. If you're the three elements, the thresholds for CCPA application, if your
- 34:05client hits any one of those, if your client has 100,000 visitors on their website, maybe
- 34:11they don't have 100,000 customers, but they have, you know, 300,000 hits or, you know,
- 34:1710,000 hits a month from California residents, they may well fall under CCPA. So like I said,
- 34:24privacy is challenging. There's a lot to consider here. And like I said, too, the, the, what
- 34:32we're seeing is this focus on children's privacy. The CPRA amended the CCPA so that there's
- 34:37trouble damages for minors who are under the age of 16. So for clients who are in those
- 34:44areas, I think they really have to do a data privacy impact assessment, the DPIA. Really
- 34:51look at what information are we collecting, what's our business reason for collecting
- 34:55it, and have we made that transparent. Or maybe when we assess that information, I'll
- 35:00give you an example. I've had a client that likes to collect birthday information because
- 35:06they want to send people, you know, just a nice note on their birth month. And that's
- 35:12lovely. But we had to answer the question of they were asking for a birthday month and
- 35:18year. I don't know that they need the year, right? Maybe they need the month only. What's
- 35:25your birth month? That's a lot less personal information than asking somebody who may are
- 35:30already have registered with you their name, their email address for their birthday month
- 35:36and year. I don't think most companies need that information. That being said, maybe if
- 35:41you're a company that directed it minors and you're age gating, you're trying to figure
- 35:46out whether they meet the threshold, you might need that information for a year. But talking
- 35:52to the individual client and say, do you need to have that? Or if it's really just like,
- 35:56hey, we send you a happy birthday email, maybe you just need the day in the month, maybe
- 36:00you just need the month and you send them all out on the first of the month. Maybe that's
- 36:04possible. So thinking about the data minimization is kind of a constant struggle, right? We
- 36:10constantly have to look because it may be that your client hasn't thought of the ways
- 36:19they could limit their potential liability. I'm going to run back into the slides. I will
- 36:28come back to some of the questions that I see in the chat. And then again, we'll have
- 36:32Q&A at the end. So feel free if you would rather save your questions till later. You
- 36:36can drop them in there. We'll try to answer them. And then we'll definitely have the Q&A
- 36:39at the end. What I find really fascinating is that even during this holiday season, I
- 36:45don't know if you've seen it, the California Privacy Protection Agency is actually putting
- 36:49out ads to tell consumers what their rights are. There was a television ad I saw. I saw
- 36:55a print ad that's telling people, hey, hold businesses accountable. You need to know what
- 37:00information they have. And it's really not something that as a seasoned litigator, I've
- 37:05seen an agency like telling people, we want you to report things. And by the way, consumers
- 37:11can report what they believe are violations to the CPPA or to the California Attorney
- 37:16General. But they're messaging to consumers for all of these rights that we talked about
- 37:21is that your data should be locked. These are your rights. You have the L, which is the
- 37:26right to limit the use and disclosure of sensitive personal information. O, the right to opt
- 37:31out of the sale of your information or the sharing of it for cross-context behavioral
- 37:36advertising. C, the right to correct your inaccurate personal information. K, the right
- 37:42to know what personal information businesses have collected about you and how they use
- 37:48it and how they share it. E, the right to equal treatment. And this is the non-discrimination
- 37:53thing where they can't discriminate, businesses can't discriminate against you for not providing
- 37:58your information or for exercising your rights. So if you say, hey, I don't want you to have
- 38:05my information or I'm going to write in and tell you, hey, I don't, I want to change this.
- 38:11I want to delete it. They can't treat you differently. And then D is the right to delete.
- 38:16So they've come up with this catchy acronym that I frankly am just surprised about. So
- 38:23if a consumer wants to come to your clients and say, hey, is my information locked, they
- 38:28could come and say that. It's just going to be pretty interesting to see whether consumers
- 38:33respond in that way. Because the other thing that we've seen is that the amount of data
- 38:38subject requests has not risen to the level of what we expected to have happen once these
- 38:44laws came out. There are obviously companies that you can use that will go and opt out
- 38:50for you. You can use an authorized agent to opt out of having your personal information
- 38:55in places. And as a privacy lawyer, I sometimes have very dull Friday nights. So I will go
- 39:02and exercise my CCPA rights as a California resident, and then I'll see what they send
- 39:07back to me. Some companies, it comes immediately. Some companies take some time. But I'm always
- 39:14curious to know what their processes are and whether they're actually doing what they
- 39:18say they're doing. So, hey, if you have a free Friday night and you want to join me,
- 39:22start sending in your CCPA requests to various companies and see what comes back. It'll be
- 39:27interesting. I'm sure that there are better things to do with your Friday night. But
- 39:32privacy lawyers are kind of inherently a little nerdy. And I embrace that. I live that truth.
- 39:39So, CCPA compliance, like I said, it is challenging. But in general, we want to know what does
- 39:45it look like? What does it look like outward facing? The requirements for CCPA compliance
- 39:51are a notice that collection. This is the notice typically in a privacy policy or a
- 39:55separate notice that says, here's the information we're collecting about you. Here are the business
- 40:00reasons for which we use it. Here are the parties to whom we transfer it. And so it's
- 40:05a little bit more in depth than we've seen in prior privacy policies before CCPA came
- 40:10out. In California, if you are under CCPA, you also need to provide a notice to your
- 40:16California employees and job applicants and contractors about what information you're
- 40:22collecting about them. So, we know now that people use a lot of different sources to put
- 40:28up their job listings, right? Maybe you use Monster Indeed or LinkedIn. You really need
- 40:35to make sure that you have a link to a notice to employees prior to them sending in information
- 40:42about how you're going to use their information, how long you're going to keep it. And the
- 40:46employment lawyers here will also understand that there are different data retention requirements
- 40:52in California for certain information that you collect about job applicants or employees,
- 40:57whether it's EEOC stats or whether it's California statistics that you need to retain. Those
- 41:04may be in conflict with the general retention policy that the company has for all information.
- 41:10So employee information may be a very important thing to know. If you're an employment lawyer,
- 41:15you absolutely should have a basic understanding of what the CCPA requires. And then we all
- 41:21know that privacy policy terms of use, cookie policies, you know, there's some debate as
- 41:25to whether a cookie policy needs to be separate or not. But in general, you've all now seen
- 41:31there are so many ways that individuals can control our cookies, you know, except a decline.
- 41:37What do I do? And I'll tell you my preference on that. I have had enough situations where
- 41:44when I decline cookies, well, let me back up. In general, my settings are set up to
- 41:49decline the GPC, the global privacy control is activated on my browsers that I use. And
- 41:56I typically decline cookies when I have an opportunity to do so. Sometimes that will
- 42:01affect the functionality of the website. So then sometimes I'll have to go back, turn
- 42:05on my cookies, use the website, go back out, delete my cookies. It's really a personal
- 42:13a personal choice of how good you are about your digital hygiene. Right. If you're a person
- 42:19who leaves all of your browsers, Windows open forever and doesn't turn off your computer
- 42:24and and has, you know, 500 tabs open on your phone. You know, maybe you're not as vigilant
- 42:33about your digital hygiene. So maybe accepting cookies for you is is something that is a
- 42:38value add, but people are transacting in your personal information. So decline cookies when
- 42:44you can clean out your cookies, clean your cash, do all those things. And just like read
- 42:51the privacy policies, read what you're getting into. I would recommend that for anybody.
- 42:55CCPA compliance also requires that they have a mechanism for people to write in and request
- 43:02all of these different rights. So sometimes you've seen it as a web form. The CCPA required
- 43:09for a while that you also have a toll free number. And then they modified it saying,
- 43:14if you transact business exclusively online, you can have an email address, because a lot
- 43:18of people didn't have toll free numbers. So there were vendors that were we're touting,
- 43:23hey, you can get a CCPA toll free number with us and, you know, for that purpose, but they
- 43:30have evolved a little bit. They do not sell my personal information link should be there.
- 43:35And the agency has proposed this universal opt out icon that you may have seen on some
- 43:42websites, not everybody's using it, but it's this little blue and white. And again, the
- 43:47checks and the check. Still, I think some of you using even as a practitioner, does mean
- 43:53I've opted out or does the check mean I've unclear, but the CCPA has the CCPA has an
- 44:02icon for the opt out and it's available on their website. You can your clients can download
- 44:06it and upload it into their site if they want to use that. We have to if you're collecting
- 44:12and sharing sensitive personal information for cross contextual behavioral advertising,
- 44:17you can they can limit the sharing of it, you need to have information in your privacy
- 44:21policy that said you were either collecting it or not. And if you are, you have to allow
- 44:25them to limit it. Like any consumer requests, we always want to verify it. What does that
- 44:30mean? There is a proportionality test here now where look, if somebody's just asking
- 44:37you to delete their, their email address, and what they send to you is the same email
- 44:42address you have. Do you need to ask them for their driver's license to verify their
- 44:46identity that they're the right person who's asking for this act up? Probably not. Right.
- 44:52So verifying identity really depends on what type of information they're trying to access
- 44:57or delete or what their request is. If they're saying, Hey, delete all of my account information.
- 45:07You kind of have to understand why they're doing that. So maybe you really do want to
- 45:10verify that there's the other consumer that they're asking about, or that they have authority
- 45:15to ask for someone else's information to be deleted. Because you can have authorized agents
- 45:22making these requests. So if I wanted to make a request for my son, I could write in and
- 45:26say I'm his mother, I have the request, you know, the ability to do this and they might
- 45:30say, Well, how do I know that you're his mother? Maybe they wouldn't. But if I say, Hey, I'm
- 45:35requesting this for my husband. I might do a little bit more research here and say, you
- 45:43know, is there a document that grants you authority to do this? Because you know, we
- 45:48the worry is that somebody could nefariously use this to delete information that might
- 45:53need to be there. So put yourself in those shoes and kind of see if there's any risk.
- 46:00If you deleted the information, is there a tremendous risk to that person? Or is there
- 46:04not? And again, there are always exceptions to deletion. If it's an ongoing relationship,
- 46:09you need the information to fulfill a contract, your client can decline to delete the information.
- 46:14There's a whole list of exceptions on the CCPA for why they would not need to delete
- 46:19it. But they do have to respond and tell the request or why they're not deleting it. So
- 46:25there should be a workflow within your client to determine who is answering these requests
- 46:33and what is our standard procedure. So again, there's the external facing parts, but there's
- 46:39the internal parts for the company to understand what their privacy program looks like and
- 46:44who is in charge of actually fulfilling these requests. Typically under the CCPA, you get
- 46:5145 days to respond. You actually have to respond to the request within 10 days, but you get
- 46:5645 days to actually process it. And then if you need more time, you can get another 45
- 47:01days. But the opt out requests for emails should come within 15 days, just as a matter
- 47:08of the guidance that we've been provided. The other thing to think about is that the
- 47:14CCPA actually requires training and education of people who are responsible for handling
- 47:18these inquiries. So if your client has a customer service line and the customer service representatives
- 47:24have no idea how to process a CCPA or any privacy request, that's a problem. You've
- 47:30failed because they need to be trained. And I would recommend at least annually on privacy
- 47:37issues and sensitivity to information and how to handle requests. And again, it's reasonable
- 47:44measures for data security and privacy. So your IT team does need to be involved in this.
- 47:49We need to make sure that they've taken reasonable measures to protect the information. I'm running
- 47:55out of time, so I'm going to run through a couple of these things pretty quickly. The
- 47:59impact is going to be different on different industries. Data brokers are now subject to
- 48:03a data broker registry in California. And it's an annual fee and an annual registration
- 48:10and the enforcement actions. So the enforcement advisories have really focused on reporting
- 48:16requirements for data brokers and whether they've registered. So if you have a client
- 48:20who is a data broker who is actively buying and selling information, you need to make
- 48:25sure that they know that there are certain requirements under the CCPA. We're finding
- 48:32that e-commerce and retail companies that operate online, this is where we get a lot
- 48:38of requests for deletions and things like that. So make sure that their policies are
- 48:43up to date, that you've done the value out of saying, hey, I'll list your website. And
- 48:49I saw that your privacy policy hasn't been updated since 2018, which is a recent client
- 48:55I just got. I'm like, I'm pretty sure that if you haven't updated it since 2018, you're
- 49:00out of compliance. We are generally recommending that our clients review their privacy policies
- 49:07at least six months, every six months, because there are so many new privacy laws coming
- 49:13up around the country. So if you have a client and you're looking at their website and it
- 49:18maybe it doesn't have a date when they actually enacted it, or maybe it was prior to 2020,
- 49:23or if it was prior to 2023 when the CPRA changes affected the CCPA, hey, there's a value add.
- 49:29You can tell your client, hey, I was looking at your privacy policy, and I think it needs
- 49:33to be updated. Do you want me to take a look at that? And if you don't know what to do,
- 49:37call me. There is a lot that needs to be changed for these policies. GDPR 2018, CCPA 2020,
- 49:46changes in 2023. There are new states coming online with new privacy laws. There will actually
- 49:52be seven more states coming online with new privacy laws in 2025. So if your client is
- 50:00operating around the country, they need to update their privacy policy. Your client may
- 50:06be operating in Canada. Canada has a national privacy law, and they have provincial privacy
- 50:11laws might be important for clients operating worldwide. There are so many, there's like
- 50:16119 different countries that have their own privacy laws right now. So if you need to
- 50:21call in a professional, no shame in that. But I think the value add for your client
- 50:26of saying, hey, this may be something you need to look at is absolutely valuable to
- 50:32them. So when we talk about the enforcement actions that have happened, there aren't a
- 50:37ton. There are a ton of letters that have gone out though to individual companies telling
- 50:42them what is wrong. There are some resources that I've provided you in this deck that you
- 50:48can go to to see what the enforcement requests have been. Take a look at that. It's really
- 50:54important. The Sephora action was the biggest one that we had with the state AG in California,
- 51:00where it was a $1.2 million order. And it was about sharing information ostensibly through
- 51:07cookies and through tracking. So your clients really need to be aware of what they're doing.
- 51:13And it's not enough to say, well, I didn't know that we were doing that. The clients
- 51:17really need to understand how these tracking technologies are working on the website. And
- 51:21not giving people the opportunity to opt out. That was the door dash case and that was $375,000.
- 51:27Tilting point media for children's games. Again, because children's privacy is so important,
- 51:33what they have were software development kits that contain tracking information in them.
- 51:37And a lot of times with tech, the SD case, the software development kits might be open
- 51:41source. Maybe their developers didn't even know it was in it. They just put the code
- 51:45into the game, but it was tracking. And so they got hit with a $500,000 fine on that.
- 51:51So clients really need to understand what's in their code, what's happening. And I threw
- 51:57in the Google location privacy practices act or action here. It's not under the CCPA, but I wanted
- 52:05to explain how these privacy rights dovetail with unfair competition laws and false advertising.
- 52:11This was a $93 million case. Google it. Google the Google case. But it's really important for
- 52:18clients that are collecting location privacy issues and for information. It's really important.
- 52:24With the CPPA, it is only just recently gotten up and running. So their enforcement actions are not
- 52:30numerous. But what they did recently publicize was their settlement with data brokers. They were a
- 52:36number of data brokers that failed to register and paid this annual fee. And that was definitely a
- 52:41priority for them. So what we're seeing is that the CPPA has put out enforcement advisories.
- 52:48They're giving us a roadmap, what they are planning to enforce. Data minimization is part
- 52:53of it. I've given you the link here if you want to understand more about data minimization
- 52:57and avoiding dark patterns. There are only two enforcement advisories that the CPPA has put
- 53:02out. So read them and understand them and see if they apply to your clients. Other things to think
- 53:08about are how privacy issues might come up. There are specific requirements in your animal
- 53:14reporting to the SEC if you've had a data breach. So clients need to understand that the privacy laws
- 53:21not only would you have to potentially be subject to a CCPA action, but you could be subject to the
- 53:28various states' data notification and reporting requirements. But also you may have to report it
- 53:33to the SEC in your 10K or in your other filings. This also comes up a lot and I'm being called to
- 53:39consult a lot on M&A deals where we're trying to figure out whether the selling company has
- 53:45acquired valid consent for their customer list to be able to share it with a buyer. So think about
- 53:52those issues as well. There's an inherent value to information if you've collected it properly.
- 53:58If you haven't collected it properly, it's going to diminish the value of that information.
- 54:05Privacy litigation to, as a former litigator, I am seeing really novel uses of existing laws
- 54:12to address privacy and what information is being tracked. You may have seen or seen demand letters
- 54:19about pixel tracking, which is, there's a Metapixel Facebook pixel that's operating on your client's
- 54:24website. And so your client is giving information about the visitors to their website to Meta,
- 54:31but maybe they haven't disclosed it. Maybe they didn't even know it was happening. So we are seeing
- 54:38an uptick in that type of litigation, the Video Privacy Protection Act, the VPPA, which was
- 54:46originated with Justice Bork when Justice Bork was being nominated for the Supreme Court.
- 54:51Somebody went in and looked at his video viewing history. Now they're applying that to
- 54:57videos that people might look at on your client's website. Is your client telling YouTube that they
- 55:02looked at five videos on whatever topic they had on their website? That could be a violation.
- 55:09These are still novel concepts. They haven't gone all the way through to trial.
- 55:13But the idea of whether or not somebody actually has standing to raise some of this privacy
- 55:17litigation or does the CCPA supersede any of these claims, that's all still remains to be seen.
- 55:25Really quickly, still to come, the CPPA has not yet finalized the CCPA. So they're really looking
- 55:34at the regulations and what deletion mechanism might allow consumers to request
- 55:40this one, the one-shot, one-button opt-out. They are asking the CPPA to come up with a mechanism
- 55:49that would allow people to request in one-shot deletion from all of the data brokers of all of
- 55:54their information. Obviously, this is going to affect the data broker industry quite a lot,
- 55:59but I'm really curious to see what that's going to look like. Is it a website that people go to?
- 56:05Or is it something that gets conveyed to all these data brokers that are registered on the
- 56:09registry? It remains to be seen. They're still talking about whether the scope of cybersecurity
- 56:16audits would be available through the CCPA, whether or not what's the depth of a risk assessment that
- 56:24needs to be incorporated, and then automated decision-making technology. This is where AI
- 56:30is being used to make decisions. I think AI is obviously a huge topic also related to privacy.
- 56:37So the enforcement priorities here are going to be the sensitive data, children's privacy,
- 56:42artificial intelligence, dark patterns. I've outlined for you some other states that are coming
- 56:46online with privacy laws, and there are comprehensive privacy laws, and then there are other laws that
- 56:53just affect certain subsets of consumer data. So Washington and Nevada both have a medical privacy
- 57:01law that requires a separate notice. And we're still waiting on a federal privacy law.
- 57:08Don't know whether that's going to happen. There were some obstacles, and the California
- 57:13AG expressly spoke out against the federal privacy law that was proposed. And then if you're advising
- 57:19global companies, you do need to know what the landscape is for compliance with these other
- 57:24areas of law. Resources for you for specifically California. IAPP also has a great chart that
- 57:34talks about all the states that have privacy laws. And then the takeaways here are that privacy is
- 57:41timely. It's going to continue to adapt. There's not going to be less privacy laws. There are
- 57:46going to be more. The other states laws are here, so you also need to understand them.
- 57:50Businesses have to review and update their policies and internal practices at least annually,
- 57:55but every six months right now. And you have to think of privacy compliance just like you think
- 58:00of other compliance areas. So are they compliant with this in addition to being compliant for
- 58:05employment reasons, in addition to be compliant for tax reasons? The technological limitations
- 58:12are there as well. The law isn't keeping up with the technology. The technology is outpacing,
- 58:17but we have to kind of understand that this is all very dynamic. We have to be creative about how
- 58:23we're going to advise our clients on compliance. So again, the takeaway, if anything I can give you
- 58:29is it's not just about preventing liability for the company. It really is about increasing
- 58:33transparency, which will lead to customer loyalty and trust. It's proven that having these types
- 58:39of policies that are easy to read actually helps you gain customers. I'm going to jump into Q&A,
- 58:47and I have some questions that we still had, and I'm not going to be able to hit all of them. I'll
- 58:52try. If you have questions, feel free to email me. I'm happy to shout on Zoom if I can help you,
- 58:58or if it's something that I don't know, I'll let you know. Does this apply to employee private
- 59:05information and data? Yes, right. So if you fall under the CCPA, then you do need to comply with
- 59:12the employee notices as if the employee is now a consumer. So you need to tell them what information
- 59:18you're collecting and how they can delete it. And for employment lawyers, keep aware that you need
- 59:23to talk to the privacy lawyers, because let's say somebody says, I terminated my employment
- 59:28and I want to delete all my information, but maybe they're in the middle of a lawsuit with you.
- 59:33Hey, you got to talk. Both sides have to talk to know. Oh, there's so many. How do I stay abreast
- 59:40of privacy laws? This is a great question because it is hard. I actually set aside a day,
- 59:48most of a day, a week just to read because the laws are changing so quickly and so dramatically
- 59:55that I think you have to stay up on it. There are plenty of law firm blogs that are great resources.
- 1:00:03I happen to just know a lot of privacy people now. So LinkedIn, people will tell me, like,
- 1:00:08hey, this came out, this came out. And I actually spent a fair amount of time on LinkedIn looking
- 1:00:12at my trusted colleagues' evaluations and analysis of things. So if you are lucky enough to have
- 1:00:18those people in your sphere, feel free to connect with me on LinkedIn. I try to post relevant things.
- 1:00:24I know we're at 130. HIPAA, somebody asked about HIPAA. HIPAA is a federal privacy law,
- 1:00:31and I think people get confused a lot. But yes, it does dovetail. But there's California,
- 1:00:36the CMIA, the California Medical Information Act may actually be more relevant for some of your
- 1:00:40clients. HIPAA only applies to covered entities, and there's a whole other track of stuff we can go
- 1:00:46to there. Oh, gosh, there's so many. How should one approach to drafting a privacy with so many
- 1:00:54states to cover? Is there a single lowest common denominator section? The good thing is that
- 1:01:00California is really one of the vanguards. It's really one of the leaders. But I can't tell you
- 1:01:05that if you just make it CCPA compliant, it would be compliant for other states because these other
- 1:01:09states are coming in with new requirements. Maryland's coming out this coming year, and it has
- 1:01:15some funky stuff in it. And then there are these non-privacy laws. Washington has its My Health,
- 1:01:20My Data Act law that covers a lot of consumer data that we might not usually think of as medical data.
- 1:01:27Colorado has its own quirks where it's requiring the GPC. But it's also, I think some of the states
- 1:01:34are really trying to make their name in privacy by making it different from California, by really
- 1:01:40challenging people on how to comply. I apologize that I couldn't get to everything, but I hope
- 1:01:45you'll take away that privacy is amazing. If you want to make it part of your practice, I encourage
- 1:01:49you. I'm happy to talk to you about it. But it's challenging. You have to stay up on this. It's not
- 1:01:55where you're dealing with, you know, Paul's graph in law school and it being potentially precedent
- 1:02:01for what you're doing. Sometimes there are no precedents here. So it's really about studying
- 1:02:06and learning and maintaining your creativity on how to advise your client how to comply.
- 1:02:12I want to thank the Beverly Hills Bar Association for this opportunity. I'm sorry there was so much
- 1:02:16to cover. But I hope that you got something out of today and you have some actionable things you
- 1:02:21can take back to your clients today and say, hey, maybe this is something that we should talk about.
- 1:02:27So I'm Diana Iqtani-Law in El Segundo. And thank you so much for your time today.
- 1:02:33And you may be eligible for CLE credit in your state. Visit bhba.org slash podcasts for more information.