Latest / Arroe Collins Like It's Live / What Would You Do Adam Cohen's Captains Dinner Asks If Cannibalism Is An Act Of Survival
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Hey, if you're like me, you get a little tired
- 0:01of searching for your favorite podcast on one of those
- 0:03streaming outfits. You type something in and they say, oh,
- 0:06did you mean this? No, the only place to go
- 0:08is ero dot net A R r oe dot net.
- 0:12All seventeen of my podcasts are waiting for you to
- 0:15enjoy and to learn something. Thanks for supporting me throughout
- 0:18the years. Hello, and good morning, Adam. How are you
- 0:20doing today?
- 0:21Speaker 2: Very well? Thank you?
- 0:23Speaker 1: Dude. I got to talk to you about this book
- 0:25because this is a conversation starter and this I gotta
- 0:28tell you. I spent a long time since my wife
- 0:31and I have shared a book and we're struggling to
- 0:33get it from each other's hands and that and that's
- 0:35what's great about this book is that we were coming
- 0:38in with our own interpretations. You're giving us this information.
- 0:41And dude, did you feel like that people took sides too?
- 0:45Is it cannibalism or is it legal? I mean, you
- 0:47really hit a hot subject here, dude.
- 0:49Speaker 2: People are strongly on both sides as far as I candel.
- 0:52Speaker 1: Oh my god, and how did you even bump into
- 0:55this project? Because I mean we're talking about eighteen eighty four.
- 0:58Speaker 2: Here, Adam, Well, the story is first year of law school,
- 1:03my law school roommate and I gave a Halloween party,
- 1:06come as your favorite case or legal doctrine, and my roommate,
- 1:09who is now a federal judge in New York, dressed
- 1:12up as the cannibal a captain. He went to the
- 1:15supermarket and he got raw chicken and he spattered it
- 1:18with ketchup and he wore it around his neck. And
- 1:20you know, that made a big impression on me.
- 1:22Speaker 1: But you know what's really interesting about this, Adam, is
- 1:24that the way that the laws were written in eighteen
- 1:26eighty four versus where we are presently in twenty twenty five,
- 1:30I think it could sway in any direction because it
- 1:33is a little bit more lenient and or understandable when
- 1:36it comes to things like this.
- 1:39Speaker 2: Yeah, you know, eighteen eighty four was actually a really
- 1:41interesting time because England was changing its mind because for
- 1:44centuries England allowed cannibalism, and see they never prosecuted it.
- 1:48Suddenly in eighteen eighty four, with this case, they decided,
- 1:51you know what, we made a mistake. This is barbaric
- 1:54and it's murder. We're not going to allow it anymore.
- 1:56So we really see the beginning of the modern age there,
- 1:58which then comes all the way up our time.
- 2:00Speaker 1: But you know, Adam, we have all been locked into
- 2:03those conversations of what would you do if you were
- 2:05on a plane, if you were on a ship. I mean,
- 2:08every one of us have to have gone through this
- 2:09question period, absolutely, and you know you're torn.
- 2:13Speaker 2: Even if you believe, as some people do utilitarians, you
- 2:16know it's better to kill one person that three people
- 2:19can live. Some people don't believe that, ky you would
- 2:22you really be able to go up to the seventeen
- 2:24year old cabin boy who you've been sailing within a
- 2:27boat for months and take a knife and slit his
- 2:30throat and begin drinking his blood, Even if you believe
- 2:32in it in theory, it's really gross and difficult to
- 2:35think about in practice.
- 2:37Speaker 1: Well, where my heart stopped was that Captain Dudley had
- 2:39to really do a real gut check here because he thought, well,
- 2:43we're going to be remembered as heroes. That just did
- 2:45not happen. For mister Dudley, That's exactly right.
- 2:48Speaker 2: He was telling the story proudly. He was taking back souvenirs,
- 2:52made them. He made the boat the rescue and take
- 2:54back the lifeboat because he wanted to tell the story
- 2:57really well. And he was shocked when he got to
- 2:59fell with England that they slapped handcuffs on him and
- 3:02accuse him of murder.
- 3:03Speaker 1: Oh my god, I just when you think you're doing
- 3:07right once again. It's a position that no wonder people
- 3:09are addicted to this book when we think we're doing right,
- 3:12and it's the opposite attraction.
- 3:15Speaker 2: That's exactly right, and you can think like, of course
- 3:17I'm doing the right thing, and then suddenly you go
- 3:19home and everyone says you just killed a seventeen year
- 3:22old boat boy dragons flood. You know that's not so great.
- 3:25Speaker 1: See. And that's that's why I needed to talk to you,
- 3:29because because my head is not on straight when it
- 3:31comes to this book, because I know what my side is,
- 3:33I know what my wife's side is, and I need
- 3:34someone with your clear focus to give me direction.
- 3:37Speaker 2: Here I am on the side of the cabin boy
- 3:41had the right to live. Every morning he woke up
- 3:44in that boat saying, perhaps today's the day we're going
- 3:47to see land, or we're going to be rescued by
- 3:49a boat. He had the right to live his life
- 3:51as long as he could, hoping to be rescued, and
- 3:54no one had the right to come along and say,
- 3:56you know, we've done some calculations and it'd be better
- 3:58for humanity if we save three lives by killing you.
- 4:02He did not, and the katy did not have the
- 4:05right to do that as far as I see it.
- 4:06Speaker 1: Wow, now in this day and age, because you know
- 4:08how addicted we are to true crime, is this looked
- 4:11upon as being a true crime story or are we
- 4:13talking about a survivalist guide here.
- 4:16Speaker 2: It's a little bit of both. But I will say
- 4:18I was very pleased when I looked at on Amazon
- 4:20the Amazon page, this is the first book I've written
- 4:23that is actually listed in the category of murder and mayhem.
- 4:28Speaker 1: It was Okay, how do you deal with that? Because
- 4:30my first two books went into a category that I
- 4:32did not give them permission to put me in. How
- 4:34did you deal with that going into that category? Because
- 4:37I mean, we all have visions as authors that oh,
- 4:39this is where I'm going to be, this is my
- 4:41section of the bookstore. We miss out.
- 4:44Speaker 2: Yeah, I will say, I'm going to give Amazon some credit.
- 4:46They put you in multiple categories, so I think it's
- 4:49mainly thought of as a legal book, and I see
- 4:51it's mainly listed in legal history. That's first. But they
- 4:54put murdered Mayhem in there as well. And you know what,
- 4:57if it attracts readers who are are partial that category,
- 5:00I'm okay with that.
- 5:01Speaker 1: Please do not move. There's more with Adam Cohen coming
- 5:04up next, the name of the book, Captain's Dinner. We're
- 5:09back with author and historian Adam Cohen. You know, one
- 5:12of the things that I was really afraid of after
- 5:14I got past this unbelievable front cover was I was
- 5:17so afraid that you were going to turn it into
- 5:18a journalist news story. Not so much. No, you went
- 5:22the way of a narrative. No wonder. I feel so
- 5:24comfortable inside your paragraphs.
- 5:27Speaker 2: Well, thanks so much. I really love being able to
- 5:29tell the story about being on the open sea, which
- 5:32is it's almost a movie like story, being out there,
- 5:35first in the yacht, seeing the big wave that comes
- 5:38and shipwrecks that boat, escaping just narrowly in a lifeboat,
- 5:42trying to survive in that life boat. When the first
- 5:44night there in the lifeboat, a shark becomes it begins
- 5:48at hitting them from underneath and tries to capsize them.
- 5:51So it really is a drama that I really felt
- 5:53cried out to be written in dramatic form.
- 5:55Speaker 1: Now, Adam, you know how we are. We like to
- 5:58judge our books by their cover. And I'll tell you what,
- 6:00when we think of that ocean in the middle of
- 6:02the night, we don't think of the waves that you've
- 6:04got on this picture on the front cover of this book,
- 6:06because I mean, you totally forget that that ocean is
- 6:09a monster. It does want to devour you. And if
- 6:12it's sending out a shark to me in my heart,
- 6:14that was a warning sign.
- 6:16Speaker 2: I think that's right. And also remember they were in
- 6:18a much larger boat. They were in a yacht that
- 6:20was destroyed by a wave, and then they go in
- 6:22this tiny, little lifeboat. What are their chances in a
- 6:25little lifeboat if the bigger boat was just destroyed by
- 6:28a storm. They were very nervous, and were right to
- 6:31be nervous that their lives could end at any minute
- 6:33in that boat.
- 6:34Speaker 1: So in a position like this, to me, the captain
- 6:37is no longer the captain. You are now one of us.
- 6:39We have got to become one in order to survive
- 6:41on this on this life boat.
- 6:44Speaker 2: That's exactly right. And you know the captain normally had
- 6:47you know, he had unchecked power on a boat, but
- 6:50once they were in that lifeboat, he really didn't feel
- 6:53he needed to talk to the others about what they
- 6:55should do. And ye, he didn't kill the cabin boy
- 6:57told his mate agreed with him, So you're right, it
- 7:00became a little bit more collaborative. Although they never talked
- 7:03to the cabin boy, They never asked him how he
- 7:05felt about being killed.
- 7:06Speaker 1: Yeah, but can you imagine being a fly on the
- 7:08wall when they were discussing this, because you know, it's
- 7:10one of those and I'll bet you they asked it
- 7:11a million times. What do you want to do? So,
- 7:13what do you think we should do? Oh? You think
- 7:15we should contact somebody? What do you want to do?
- 7:17And because once again we've been in that position where
- 7:20we want to know, but we're relying on other people
- 7:22to give us that guidance.
- 7:24Speaker 2: That's right. And you know, the first suggestion the captain
- 7:26made was to draw lots, to draw straws would have
- 7:29an equal chance of dying, but the mate didn't go
- 7:32along with that. The mate only went along with killing
- 7:34someone once the captain said, well, we're not going to
- 7:37draw lots, We're just going to kill the cabin boy.
- 7:38Then suddenly the maid was like, okay, I'm fine with that.
- 7:42Speaker 1: See I'm a firm believer that before anything happens, there's
- 7:46a story beforehand. And you prove that inside these pages
- 7:49that the captain was given all of these warning signs
- 7:53before even hitting that water, but he didn't follow his
- 7:56gut feeling.
- 7:57Speaker 2: That's exactly right. And a lot of people were saying,
- 7:59you know, so it is too far to go from
- 8:01England to Australia in a yacht. I mean, it had
- 8:04been done before, but it was dangerous. There were big waves,
- 8:07there were icebergs. A lot of people told all four
- 8:09of the men not to go, but honestly, they wanted
- 8:12the money and they also wanted to see Australia because
- 8:15all four of them were thinking about maybe moving from
- 8:17England to Australia, so they had some incentives to go,
- 8:20and it made them overlook the real dangers of this trip,
- 8:23which they probably should not have undertaken.
- 8:25Speaker 1: Yeah, Noe to listeners and readers eighteen eighty four. There
- 8:29were no digital devices on board. They had to do
- 8:32it the old fashioned way in order to survive going
- 8:35to Australia, and that, to me, that's a wake up
- 8:38call for you, for us right here in twenty twenty five,
- 8:40when we could lose.
- 8:41Speaker 2: It all exactly. What first step is Always make sure
- 8:45your ship is big enough.
- 8:46Speaker 1: Yeah, I would love to see your research, because I
- 8:51am a show prep pig, I really do. I've got
- 8:53to categorize it, I've got to use continuity. I would
- 8:56love to see how you scribbled this into place and
- 8:59then it became this unbelievable book that is so attractive.
- 9:03Speaker 2: You know. I had a lot of fun going to
- 9:04the National Archives in London where all these papers are,
- 9:07where you can actually read the accountant and the captain
- 9:10wrote in his own handwriting about what happened. It really
- 9:13takes you to the place in time to be able
- 9:15to hold these documents and realize this is actually what
- 9:18the cannibal captain wrote after he got back to England.
- 9:20It's really quite a mind blower.
- 9:23Speaker 1: Can you, Adam? Could you handle that being called cannibal? Adam?
- 9:26I don't think I can live with that. I mean,
- 9:28the cannibal captain, Oh my god.
- 9:31Speaker 2: You know, it was worse than that this was an
- 9:33international story, so he was known as a cannibal captain everywhere.
- 9:36But also while this was going on, Madam Tusson's made
- 9:39a wax figure of him and put him in their
- 9:42Chamber of Earths. He was actually vilified at the time.
- 9:46Speaker 1: So do you think the question has been answered? Because
- 9:49I mean, I can sit there and talk with my
- 9:50wife all day about this and we're still going to go.
- 9:52I don't know when it comes to survival and can
- 9:55murder be justified when it comes to having just a
- 9:58bite to eat?
- 10:00Speaker 2: You know, this case is taught in many law school classes,
- 10:03also many moral reasoning classes, and from what I see,
- 10:07there really is a breakdown. Students take both sides and
- 10:10often still very strongly. There's no easy answer. And a
- 10:14professor at Harvard Laschool said to me. I asked him
- 10:16why did they like this case so much at Harvard?
- 10:18And what he said to me was he said, it's
- 10:19an impossible dilemma. This is like Harvard like impossible dilemmas.
- 10:24Speaker 1: Wow, where can people go to find out more about you, Adam?
- 10:27Because I want them to dive into your research and
- 10:29your journey forward.
- 10:31Speaker 2: Well, I've got my own writer's page, so you can
- 10:33just google me Adam Cohen writer, Adams Coen writer. Also
- 10:37there's some on the Amazon page. There's a biography of
- 10:39me there.
- 10:39Speaker 1: I love it. Please come back to this show anytime
- 10:41in the future. The door is always going to be
- 10:43open for you, sir.
- 10:44Speaker 2: I enjoyed it, Darrow very much.
- 10:46Speaker 1: Will you be brilliant? Okay, thank you