Latest / The Morning Information Center On-Demand / Scott Shea on the Mama's and the Papa's 9-8-2023
Transcript
- 0:00Hey Scott, good morning, Hey Mike, how are you? I am
- 0:02good and I am a child of the sixties. Love the music of the
- 0:05sixties, and yeah, Mamas and Papas one of my favorite groups back in
- 0:09nineteen sixty five. I'm a big Beatles fans. I'm a big fan of
- 0:12all the music of the sixties. Scott Shay is our guests this morning here
- 0:16on the Posts of New Hampshire, author of All the Leaves are Brown.
- 0:19How the Mamas and Papas came together and broke apart? So this group,
- 0:24Scott, they had the artistry, they had the commercial success. What are
- 0:27we missing here? You know, I guess just harmony within the group,
- 0:31which I don't know. Does any group have harmony? I don't think so.
- 0:35But longevity is what we didn't get from the Mammas and the Papas.
- 0:39They didn't last for very long. They gave us, you know, a
- 0:42lot of great music in a very short period of time. But you know,
- 0:45it's kind of sad to think of what might have been had they gone
- 0:48through the great musical movements of the early seventies. Yeah, how did the
- 0:52group actually come together? Because obviously they became they came on the tag of
- 0:56the British invasion on the end of the British invasion there, and we first
- 0:59heard about them in November of nineteen sixty five, right before all that they
- 1:02were in. All four of them essentially were involved in the folk boom of
- 1:07the early nineteen sixties. John, Cass, and Denny were all musicians,
- 1:12all singers, and had been signed to labels. John and the Journeyman were
- 1:18on Capitol Records, and Denny with the Halifax Three. They were on Epic
- 1:21Records, which was a division of Columbia, and then Cass was signed to
- 1:26with the Big Three and on a smaller label called FM. But they got
- 1:30together through folk tour packages, playing on hoot Nanny and just touring the South
- 1:36and the Midwest of the United States. And that's how John met Denny.
- 1:41That's how Denny met Cass, and you know, they they all lived in
- 1:45Greenwich Village at the time, which was the pulse of the folk movement,
- 1:49you know. And then you know, in nineteen sixty four, February nineteen
- 1:53sixty four, this group called the Beatles came to Town, New York and
- 1:57just kind of blew that movement right up and all the young musicians who were
- 2:01in it, like mcgwyn McGuire, you know, and David Crosby and Steven
- 2:07Stills. They all just kind of threw away their Martins and Gibson's and picked
- 2:10up electric guitars and bought a drum kit and formed rock and roll combos.
- 2:15And the Mamas and the Papas followed. It took him a little bit longer
- 2:16because John didn't want to do that. He wanted to stay in the folk
- 2:20boom. He wanted to form a folk trio with Denny and Michelle, and
- 2:24you know, they ultimately broadcast in and you know that led to the creation
- 2:30of the Mamas and the Pappas. Let me ask you this, why do
- 2:32you think they were successful? Because they had some pretty good harmonies and great
- 2:36melodies as well. They had a bunch of hits, enough to put on
- 2:38the Greatest Hits album after a few years, obviously, But why do you
- 2:40think that America and the rest of the world kind of gravitated to them in
- 2:45the sixties. Well, everybody likes a unique sound, you know, and
- 2:47you can bring in that unique sound that's very pleasurable to the ear. You
- 2:52know, you're going to get a good reaction, and they had that with
- 2:54John and John and a combination of Lou Adler and some great session musicians really
- 3:00gave us some great music. And then you'd put in the voice of cast
- 3:01which is just like Honey to the Year, and uh, you know,
- 3:05how could you fail with that? You know? And uh, you know,
- 3:08just the songs and then themselves California Dream and what a great you know,
- 3:13first of all, what a great message or song or is something that
- 3:16we can all identify with the Monday Monday is the same thing with such great
- 3:21music, you know, using those same great musicians that played on the Beach
- 3:24Boys records and Jan and Dean records and the Monkeys and countless others, even
- 3:30some of the Rolling Stones records. I think they would play on when they
- 3:31would record in Los Angeles. So just you know, a lot of a
- 3:36lot of the great things came together and uh, you know we benefited from
- 3:39it. Yeah, why did you decide to write the book? What did
- 3:43you feel that was missing from the history of this group that you wanted to
- 3:46listeners and viewers and readers to find out pretty much the entire story. I
- 3:50mean, they had not really even been written about. There's there was an
- 3:53oral history, which you know, does a does an okay job of telling
- 3:59the stories. You I was just interviews patched together in printed form, and
- 4:02they try to do it chronologically and it works sometimes and it doesn't work in
- 4:05others. And you know, there was another biography that came out it's very
- 4:09thin, less than two hundred pages, came out around the same time.
- 4:12And then you had John and Michelle's competing autobiographies, and there was a biography
- 4:16of Cast by Eddie Fiegel that came out in the early two thousand was very
- 4:19good, but there's nothing that told the whole story. And it's a it's
- 4:25a big story, it's a it's a story that needs to be told.
- 4:27It's it's filled with cliffhangers and drama and tension and music and sex and drugs
- 4:34and rock and roll, and it's just got everything. And the fact that
- 4:38it hadn't even really been written about, you know, in my opinion,
- 4:42it was just amazing to me. So when I was looking for something to
- 4:45write about it, and you know, I just kind of fell into the
- 4:47fact that nothing had been written about him in this century, I said,
- 4:49well, here's a no brainer. Yeah, Scott says our guest. He's
- 4:53author of the brand new book about the Mamas and Papas, All the Leaves
- 4:56of Brown, How the Mamas and Papas came together and broke apart. So
- 5:00what was their downfall? You said in the outset that they were not together
- 5:02very long, but yet they had to pretty much a very strong artistically and
- 5:06commercially successful career. Why did they fall apart? I think it was a
- 5:11combination of ego, uh and uh, you know, sex and drugs and
- 5:16just I think this they had just there was that there was so much stress
- 5:20put on the group from from all the dysfunction with the you know, the
- 5:26the cheating and the affairs, not even necessarily with each other, but even
- 5:29outside of that, and uh, you know Denny and Michelle, Denny and
- 5:32Cass, you know, and and and the unrequited love between them. I
- 5:35think it's just and John all, you know, just John just kind of
- 5:40ran out of gas as a songwriter. He just you know, in the
- 5:43era of the post Sergeant Pepper era where every group was writing their own songs
- 5:47and coming up with their own material, not relying on you know, little
- 5:51Richard Covers anymore. Chuck Barry and they just couldn't do that. Just John
- 5:56was just he was a great songwriter, but you know, I think he
- 6:00had run out of things to write about with Michelle, had moved on from
- 6:02her in his mind, and it just naturally just kind of ran its course.
- 6:06And so when they did Dream a Little Dream of Me, which was
- 6:09another cover song, I think the label just decided, let's go with casts.
- 6:13She's the hot hand right now. We can get stuff out of her.
- 6:15We don't, you know, we don't have to rely on her as
- 6:18a songwriter. We have other people who can do that for and uh,
- 6:21you know, and they ultimately went with her, and because they saw no
- 6:26foreseeable product coming from the mom from John Phillips. Yeah, I'm going to
- 6:29ask you this, what was John's ego hurt in a big way? Do
- 6:30you think when they went that direction? I think to an extent, you
- 6:34know, John just kind of rolled with I think he was ready to move
- 6:36on himself. But I do think, you know, seeing that Dream a
- 6:41Little Dream of Me on the forty five label was credited to Mama's to Mama
- 6:44Cast with the Mamas and the papas, you know, when you know it
- 6:47was his idea to record that song and was recorded in his home studio and
- 6:50he arranged it and all that. I think that was a bit of a
- 6:54slap in the face, But I do think he was ready to move on.
- 6:57And he quickly put out a solo album too, but it was the
- 6:59only one that he ever put out in his lifetime. Yeah, so was
- 7:01the problem I mean artistically? Were there a lot of challenges artistically or did
- 7:06they get along personally or was it as you say? And John was not
- 7:11a big fan of having Mama cass Elliot in the group to begin with.
- 7:13Is that true? Yeah, that is true. And then I think,
- 7:15you know, she had a pension of becoming difficult in the studio. I
- 7:20know, like she would have to eat when she got to the studio and
- 7:24then she couldn't sing until the food had digested, you know. And it
- 7:28just think a real rocks you know, real rock star stuff, like diva
- 7:31kind of stuff, you know that uh that we always hear about with certain
- 7:35people. And uh, I think you know, he was just Okay,
- 7:39I'm done with this, you know, I don't want to deal with this
- 7:42anymore. I know she had she had that problem with the Big Three too,
- 7:45when Tim Rose when she was in that group, she you know,
- 7:47in their you know, in their second album, she she started behaving the
- 7:50same way. So, you know, I just think it was just just
- 7:54they just hit it. And they never formally said in nineteen sixty eight we're
- 7:57done, We're over. They just kind of all went their separate ways,
- 8:00you know. And then they were brought back together three years later because the
- 8:03done ABC was going to sue them because they had they owed him one more
- 8:07record. Yeah, they kind of faded away, right, they did.
- 8:09They faded away. You know, just music is like a train, man,
- 8:13It just it keeps rolling and new people jump on, and you know,
- 8:16you got to do In the early seventies, you had the singer songwriter
- 8:18movement with Carol King and James Taylor and others, and he had Crosby Stills
- 8:22in Nash and Neil Young and uh just eventually guys like Bruce Springsteen and Billy
- 8:28Joel came in. So everybody, you know, they we the mom was
- 8:31the Lama was sadd but no, but you know, everybody moved on,
- 8:33moved The musical movements of that era were staggering. Yeah, where do you
- 8:37put them? Where do you put them? Scott. As far as their
- 8:41legacy goes in musical history, as far as creativity and artistic value, you
- 8:45know, they're I would say they're definitely in the top twenty five. You
- 8:48know, if we had the radom like college football, yeah I would.
- 8:52I don't think they would be in the top ten, but they would be
- 8:54definitely be in there because they in such a short period of time, they
- 8:58give us some really great music that carries on today. I mean Monday.
- 9:01Monday is still played in football commercials and you know I heard go Where You
- 9:05Want to Go in a commercial earlier this summer, so their music is still
- 9:09everywhere. Yeah. Scott Shay joining us this morning. Thank you for your
- 9:13time, author of All the Leaves of Brown, How the Mamas and Papas
- 9:16came together and broke apart. Great great group of the sixties and lasting music,
- 9:20no doubt. Thank you, Scott. Good luck with the book.
- 9:22We appreciate your time today. Thank you, Mike, thanks for having me
- 9:24on. All right, be well,