Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Childcare Legislation in the 2026 General Assembly
Transcript
- 0:09Kentucky. Tonight, as we
- 0:10continue our focus on issues
- 0:12confronting the Kentucky
- 0:13General Assembly in regular
- 0:15session, I'm Renee Shaw. Thank
- 0:16you for being with us. With
- 0:18more than half of the 60 day
- 0:20lawmaking session in the
- 0:21rearview mirror, a lot of
- 0:22crucial issues remain
- 0:24unresolved, and many are
- 0:25hopeful that policies are
- 0:26approved to make child care
- 0:28more accessible, affordable and
- 0:30ensure that kids have a
- 0:31brighter start in school
- 0:33readiness. Early learning
- 0:34opportunities are also an
- 0:35economic development issue,
- 0:37according to research by the
- 0:39Kentucky Chamber center for
- 0:40Policy and Research. A stronger
- 0:42child care system could help.
- 0:46Between 16,000 and 28,000
- 0:47Kentucky parents start looking
- 0:48for work and join the workforce.
- 0:50This could generate up to $1.1
- 0:53billion in new wages and state
- 0:54tax revenues throughout the
- 0:56state. So here to talk about
- 0:57some legislative proposals on
- 0:59child care that lawmakers are
- 1:01considering this session are
- 1:02State Senator Danny Carroll, a
- 1:04Republican from Paducah and
- 1:05chair of the Senate Families
- 1:07and Children Committee. State
- 1:09Representative Adam Moore, a
- 1:11Democrat from Lexington. State
- 1:14Representative Samara Heavrin,
- 1:15a Republican from Litchfield
- 1:16and chair of the House Families
- 1:17and Children Committee. Doctor
- 1:20Sara Vanover, policy and
- 1:21advocacy director for the
- 1:24Kentucky Youth Advocates and
- 1:25Doctor Charles Aull, vice
- 1:26president of policy for the
- 1:28Kentucky Chamber of Commerce.
- 1:29We certainly want to hear from
- 1:30you tonight. You can send us
- 1:32your questions and comments by
- 1:33X. Formerly known as Twitter,
- 1:35at Pub Affairs KET. Send an
- 1:38email to KY tonight at Keturah
- 1:41or use the web form at Keturah
- 1:44Craig Greenberg KY tonight. Or
- 1:46you can simply give us a call
- 1:48at one 800 494 7605. Welcome to
- 1:52all of our guests. We
- 1:53appreciate you being here.
- 1:54Before we start talking about
- 1:56some of the policy proposals
- 1:57that these folks on this side
- 1:59have offered up, I want to go
- 2:00to you, Doctor Sarah Vanover.
- 2:02You've been on this program
- 2:03many times and we've talked
- 2:04about child care, and you've
- 2:05literally written the books
- 2:07about this crisis that is a
- 2:08nationwide crisis. So help us
- 2:10understand, set the stage for
- 2:12where we are in Kentucky, how
- 2:13that compares nationally to the
- 2:16accessibility of affordable
- 2:17child care, and how dire is it
- 2:19and how and why?
- 2:21>> Well, in Kentucky, we see
- 2:24many of the same problems that
- 2:25are mirrored at the national
- 2:26level. Child care is a very
- 2:29fragile structure. What it
- 2:30costs to care for a child all
- 2:32day long is more expensive than
- 2:34what parents can afford to pay.
- 2:36So child care programs often
- 2:39subsidize their the tuition
- 2:42that's needed to operate
- 2:44basically by paying lower wages
- 2:45to the staff, which means that
- 2:47staff members who have a
- 2:48critical job of caring for
- 2:49young children every day are
- 2:51not paid a high enough wage in
- 2:53order to have the lifestyle
- 2:56that that they want,
- 2:57particularly for such an
- 2:58important job. In Kentucky, we
- 2:59have approximately 2000 child
- 3:01care programs, and this ranges
- 3:03from family child care homes,
- 3:05where there may be 4 or 5
- 3:07children watched by one adult
- 3:08all the way to child care
- 3:10programs that are licensed to
- 3:13care for up to 300 children at
- 3:15one time, depending on the size
- 3:16and the area. Many of these
- 3:19programs struggle with finding
- 3:21the staffing that they need.
- 3:23Again, because of a low paying
- 3:25wage. We have many entry level
- 3:26staff members who might not
- 3:28have the training that they
- 3:29need in order to feel
- 3:31successful at their job, and
- 3:32because of that, we have high
- 3:34turnover rates in child care
- 3:36providers throughout the U.S.
- 3:38we also see that child care
- 3:42programs are basically trying
- 3:44to break even at the end of the
- 3:46month if they can use tuition
- 3:49to pay their bills and make
- 3:50sure their staff are paid and
- 3:52their essential bills are paid
- 3:55like mortgage, rent, utilities,
- 3:57then they're successful. But
- 3:58when programs have something
- 4:00come up like a damaged roof or
- 4:01they need to replace an
- 4:04appliance, things of that
- 4:05nature, it can almost be enough
- 4:06to put the program out of
- 4:08business. So we look at this
- 4:09fragility, and then we also see
- 4:11the desperate need for child
- 4:13care throughout the state. We
- 4:15know that supply and demand do
- 4:16not match throughout the state.
- 4:18Many families need child care
- 4:19in order to be part of the
- 4:21workforce, but there may not be
- 4:23child care in their county. We
- 4:25have a few counties in Kentucky
- 4:26that have no care available,
- 4:28and those families that are
- 4:29working would have to travel to
- 4:31an outside county, or they may
- 4:34find a care with someone they
- 4:36don't know that well, someone
- 4:37who doesn't have background
- 4:38checks in place, someone who
- 4:39hasn't been properly trained.
- 4:41And so we need to increase
- 4:43access. But we also have to
- 4:44keep in mind the quality of
- 4:46child care. We know that these
- 4:48are the most precious assets
- 4:51that we have in the state. When
- 4:52a mother and father or
- 4:53grandmother are deciding to
- 4:54leave a child in a child care
- 4:56program, they want to know that
- 4:58their child will be healthy and
- 4:59safe and loved. And so we need
- 5:01to make sure that quality is in
- 5:04place, that children are
- 5:05getting the the play based
- 5:08education that they need, as
- 5:09well as being healthy and safe.
- 5:10And so all of these things
- 5:12together, we're looking at
- 5:13accessibility, affordability
- 5:14and quality to create the
- 5:16system that we need here in
- 5:18Kentucky and throughout the
- 5:20U.S.
- 5:20>> Yeah. And as you've said and
- 5:22written, that the child care
- 5:23industry is the industry that
- 5:24undergirds every single other
- 5:25industry that there is at every
- 5:27other sector.
- 5:28>> Absolutely. Without the
- 5:29child care workforce, no other
- 5:30workforce is going to be able
- 5:31to go to work. They support
- 5:34many more working families. If
- 5:36you think about in one
- 5:38classroom, you have two adults
- 5:39watching a classroom full of 24
- 5:41preschoolers in a Kentucky
- 5:44preschool classroom, a four
- 5:44year olds. That means that all
- 5:47those families are getting to
- 5:48go to work, be part of the
- 5:50community, contribute to income
- 5:51tax, all kinds of other things
- 5:52just because those two adults
- 5:54are there to support those
- 5:55children. And so it is
- 5:56essential for communities. It's
- 5:58essential for businesses
- 5:59because businesses lose a lot
- 6:01of productivity when people
- 6:02don't have reliable childcare
- 6:03and their employees aren't
- 6:05coming, or a veteran employee
- 6:07resigns because of lack of
- 6:08child care and they have to
- 6:09hire someone new, train someone
- 6:11new. And so all of this impacts
- 6:13the community itself,
- 6:15businesses, the families and
- 6:16the child care programs.
- 6:18They're all factors.
- 6:19>> And doctor, all I know that
- 6:20you can make the business case
- 6:22for wild child care makes
- 6:23dollars and cents. Really?
- 6:25Because we know that you all
- 6:26had done a study and a report
- 6:28issued last year that really
- 6:29talked about the business case
- 6:30for quality child care. So tell
- 6:32us about some of your findings.
- 6:33>> Yeah. No thank you. Renee.
- 6:35You know, oftentimes when I've
- 6:36had the pleasure to appear on
- 6:38this program, I'm usually here
- 6:39to talk specifically about the
- 6:40economy and talk through
- 6:42through that with other
- 6:43analysts. And I think the fact
- 6:45that I'm here today talking
- 6:46about childcare underscores how
- 6:47this issue relates to our
- 6:49economy and to the overall
- 6:51well-being of Kentuckians
- 6:52across the whole state. I don't
- 6:54think it's any secret that
- 6:56Kentucky has significant
- 6:57challenges with with workforce.
- 6:59We have one of the lowest rates
- 7:01of labor force participation in
- 7:02the whole country. And we also
- 7:04know that that's the type of
- 7:05problem that's not going to
- 7:06have a singular solution. It's
- 7:07going to be one of those things
- 7:09that requires us to bring
- 7:10multiple solutions to the table.
- 7:12And I think this legislature
- 7:13has done a really great job
- 7:14with that. Things like funding
- 7:16education, funding higher
- 7:17education, addressing problems
- 7:19like substance use disorder,
- 7:21benefits, cliffs, all those
- 7:22things. So we really are taking
- 7:23that multi-pronged approach.
- 7:25Childcare, though, is one of
- 7:26those areas where we can take a
- 7:28really big bite at the apple
- 7:30when it comes to solving our
- 7:32workforce challenges and the
- 7:33way that our folks at the
- 7:35Kentucky Chamber tend to look
- 7:36at this issue is we see it as
- 7:38sort of a two part solution. On
- 7:39the one hand, you have a lot of
- 7:41parents whose ability to
- 7:43participate in the labor force
- 7:44is dependent upon finding good,
- 7:46safe, quality care for their
- 7:48kids. And without that, they're
- 7:50simply not going to be able to
- 7:51participate in the workforce.
- 7:53At the same time, if you have
- 7:55really good, high quality child
- 7:57care, those kids are getting a
- 7:58head start in their education.
- 8:00It's going to make them more
- 8:01likely to be kindergarten ready,
- 8:02help them be more prepared for
- 8:04the third grade, and that helps
- 8:05us further down the line. And
- 8:07so you get a really strong ROI.
- 8:09If we can solve these childcare
- 8:11challenges at the top of the
- 8:12program. You mentioned a report
- 8:13that we produced last year that
- 8:15really tried to flesh this out,
- 8:17where we tried to put some
- 8:18specific numbers to this, and
- 8:19we looked at a broad range of
- 8:22survey data, as well as a
- 8:24number of other different data
- 8:25sources, to identify that if we
- 8:27could solve our childcare
- 8:29challenges in Kentucky, and by
- 8:30that we mean increased access
- 8:31and make it more affordable.
- 8:32We're not talking about free,
- 8:34but simply just making it a
- 8:35little bit more affordable. We
- 8:37can bring upwards of 16,000 to
- 8:3928,000 adults into the labor
- 8:40force, allowing them to look
- 8:42for work, find employment, hold
- 8:44jobs, and with that comes new
- 8:47wages, State state tax revenue,
- 8:49all these great things that we
- 8:50can bring into those local
- 8:51communities. And so it
- 8:53definitely is a major economic
- 8:54issue. And I think that's why
- 8:56you see organizations like the
- 8:57Kentucky, Chamber, our board of
- 8:58directors, which includes some
- 9:00of the top business leaders
- 9:01throughout the state, they they
- 9:03identified this as one of our
- 9:04top priorities. And so that's
- 9:05why the Chamber has been so
- 9:07heavily invested in it.
- 9:08>> And one of the data points
- 9:10that was mentioned in your
- 9:11report, that statewide formal
- 9:12child care services are
- 9:13unavailable for up to 56,000
- 9:15Kentucky children who may
- 9:16potentially need it. That's a
- 9:17lot of kids.
- 9:18>> Yeah, that's absolutely
- 9:19right. I mean, one of the
- 9:21reports that you're referring
- 9:22to is a partnership with the
- 9:23Buffett Early Childhood
- 9:24Institute, where we really
- 9:25tried to quantify that supply
- 9:26and demand gap, that Doctor
- 9:28Vanover was hitting serious
- 9:29problem, especially in our
- 9:30rural areas. That was a key
- 9:32takeaway with that report, is
- 9:33that if we want to help rural
- 9:35economies throughout Kentucky
- 9:37have have stronger economies,
- 9:38have more people in the
- 9:39workforce, it's going to be
- 9:40particularly important to child
- 9:42care.
- 9:42>> Yeah. And it said at 37
- 9:44rural counties, the report
- 9:45found over half of those
- 9:46children may need formal child
- 9:47care services and they have no
- 9:50option. So this is a really,
- 9:52really important issue to get
- 9:53our hands around. And we've got
- 9:55two who are here with us, two
- 9:57lawmakers who have proposed
- 9:58some ideas for that. And I want
- 10:00to start with chairman,
- 10:01Chairwoman Heavrin, first on
- 10:03House Bill six that is waiting
- 10:04to be assigned to a Senate
- 10:05committee. It's already passed
- 10:06the House, and it is supposed
- 10:08to help with safe, affordable,
- 10:11accessible child care. Tell us
- 10:12how what does it do?
- 10:14>> Yeah. Thanks, Renee. Thanks
- 10:15for having me on. This is my
- 10:16first time, so I'm very excited
- 10:18to be here. Glad to have you in
- 10:20a room full of friends. Yes.
- 10:21You know, I think the big thing
- 10:23with House Bill six is it sets
- 10:25a foundation for affordable,
- 10:26accessible, quality child care.
- 10:27Just like you said. We're all
- 10:28talking about the same things.
- 10:29And I think there are a lot of
- 10:31ways that we can try to solve
- 10:33child care. This is just one
- 10:35start of trying to figure out
- 10:36how we start doing that. And so
- 10:38we're looking at all star
- 10:39reform. We're looking at better
- 10:41data transparency. We're
- 10:43looking at what actually help
- 10:45when we invest in these
- 10:46specific areas, what actually
- 10:47helps move kids forward.
- 10:48Because we need to start seeing
- 10:50outcomes. And, you know, most
- 10:52importantly, I think what House
- 10:54Bill six is, it's a a product
- 10:57of 40 different stakeholders
- 10:59coming together from the
- 11:01Kentucky Collaborative on Child
- 11:02Care and saying, hey, these are
- 11:04things that we think are going
- 11:05to move Kentucky forward, and
- 11:06it comes from all different
- 11:08walks of life, all sides of the
- 11:09political arena. And I think
- 11:11that's really important when we
- 11:12talk about this. You know,
- 11:13Senator Carol and I, we both
- 11:15are. I think the beauty of the
- 11:16General Assembly is we both
- 11:18have different backgrounds. You
- 11:19know, Senator Carol has has
- 11:20lived experiences. He's ran a
- 11:21child care facility. And I feel
- 11:23like I bring the experience of
- 11:24policy and really trying to
- 11:25delve in and see what we're
- 11:27doing at the national level and
- 11:28all of these things. And, you
- 11:30know, Senator Carol is going to
- 11:31talk about Senate Bill 190,
- 11:33House Bill six, and Senate Bill
- 11:34190. They all bring something
- 11:35that's different. Kentucky
- 11:36we're a leader in child care in
- 11:38Kentucky. And I think both of
- 11:39these bills help show that. And
- 11:41it shows our Commonwealth that
- 11:42we're working really hard to
- 11:43solve this issue.
- 11:44>> So you got to have not just
- 11:46one, but you got to have both
- 11:48of them. Right. So they both
- 11:49need to pass in order to get to
- 11:51where you'd like it to be. I
- 11:53want to I want to hit a term
- 11:55that you said, chairwoman about
- 11:56all star. Okay. And this is the
- 11:58quality rating system. And for
- 11:59those who they've heard of it,
- 12:01they may not fully understand
- 12:02it. Can you help us understand
- 12:04what that is and why that's
- 12:05important? And if those stars
- 12:06don't quite line up the way a
- 12:08parent should, what should they
- 12:09do or not do?
- 12:10>> Yeah. So it is it's a safety.
- 12:12It's to make sure that kids are
- 12:14in a safe environment. And I
- 12:16think it also looks at the
- 12:18quality of the child care
- 12:19center. Now I'm going to also
- 12:22I'm going to throw this over to
- 12:24Senator Carroll. I know he has
- 12:25a lot of experience in all
- 12:27stars. I think what I can say
- 12:28from my perspective, Renee All
- 12:30Stars has been great for what
- 12:31it is, but it's time for us to
- 12:33look forward. And so part of
- 12:35House Joint Resolution 50 is
- 12:36looking at that. It's also the
- 12:38regulatory space. And when
- 12:39we're talking about child care
- 12:41and regulations, that's one of
- 12:43the number one things that we
- 12:44hear about is what can we do to
- 12:46do better. And you know, I
- 12:48don't know that the All Stars
- 12:49program is giving us the
- 12:50outcomes that we actually need.
- 12:52It's ten years old. And, you
- 12:53know, I think this really we're
- 12:55in a period of time where we
- 12:56can look at this and say, what
- 12:58can we do better to help future
- 13:00Kentuckians? And so that's
- 13:01exactly I'll let Danny get into
- 13:02the weeds of it. But the point
- 13:04of addressing all stars in
- 13:05House Bill six is, is to start
- 13:07making a change and laying the
- 13:09groundwork for us to be able to
- 13:10do that. And, you know, being
- 13:12able to look at from a national
- 13:14basis, what does what does our
- 13:15system look like from a state
- 13:17basis, what's working, what's
- 13:18not, but also look at things
- 13:19like outdoor child care. What
- 13:21can what does that look like
- 13:22for Kentucky? We've got a lot
- 13:23of nature based, Charles, and
- 13:25I've had a few conversations on
- 13:27that and just laying out some
- 13:28rules of what we can do better.
- 13:30>> Yeah, yeah. So I want to go
- 13:31to Chairman Carroll about one
- 13:33the All Stars program, because
- 13:34when you testified about one of
- 13:36your bills, I do believe it was
- 13:38191. You talked about that kind
- 13:39of being this snapshot in time,
- 13:41right? That happens once every
- 13:43three years. And I kind of took
- 13:44away from that, that you
- 13:46question whether or not that
- 13:47was adequate enough. So how
- 13:49does your measure address the
- 13:51All Stars program. And tell us
- 13:52more about your ideas.
- 13:53>> And I really don't think it
- 13:55is adequate. It is a one time
- 13:57snapshot. And then on the off
- 13:59years, you basically submit
- 14:01paperwork to show your
- 14:02compliance with Kentucky All
- 14:04Stars. And I want to say this
- 14:06upfront, I couldn't have been
- 14:08any prouder than the day that
- 14:09my center became a five star
- 14:12center. And I War that as a as
- 14:13a badge of honor, and I very
- 14:15much respected that. But but
- 14:17the reality of the program,
- 14:19when you look at the times in
- 14:21between those, those
- 14:23inspections, the quality and
- 14:25following Kentucky all stars
- 14:27provisions is not so much there.
- 14:29And I even had a meeting with
- 14:30some providers a couple weeks
- 14:32ago that talked about they
- 14:34actually lose money by
- 14:36participating in that program
- 14:37because of the metrics involved.
- 14:39And the cost to to be to get 4
- 14:42or 5 star programs. So an
- 14:45alternative that I'm offering,
- 14:46and I do want to make sure that
- 14:48everyone is clear that with the
- 14:50alternative that I'm offering,
- 14:51we are looking for ways to to
- 14:54marry these two programs. Right.
- 14:56So it's something we'll be
- 14:57looking at in the future. But
- 14:59what I'm looking at is it will
- 15:00be a pilot project through the
- 15:02University of Kentucky College
- 15:03of Education, and it's based on
- 15:05something that Charles just
- 15:07mentioned and that's
- 15:08kindergarten readiness. So it
- 15:09kind of joins the the funding
- 15:12aspect. And we talk a lot about
- 15:15in post-secondary,
- 15:16post-secondary, about
- 15:17performance based funding. Well,
- 15:19that's exactly what this does.
- 15:20It's performance based funding
- 15:22for child care based on
- 15:24kindergarten readiness. And
- 15:26when kids get to a school and
- 15:28they are assessed as being
- 15:30kindergarten ready, a child
- 15:31care provider, whether that be
- 15:32a center, whether that be a
- 15:35family home provider, or
- 15:36whether that be a low income
- 15:38parent, they would have access
- 15:40to a $20,000 award for that
- 15:43child being kindergarten ready.
- 15:45Or it could be.
- 15:47>> 20,000 or 2000.
- 15:48>> 2000.
- 15:48>> 2000, I thought, was there a
- 15:50committee substitute I wasn't
- 15:51aware of?
- 15:52>> Oh, I bet that race.
- 15:54>> Yeah.
- 15:55>> What's the fiscal note.
- 15:56>> On that? Yeah. That's right.
- 15:58Yeah.
- 15:58>> Two $2,000.
- 15:59>> And that could also be in
- 16:01the form of a refundable tax
- 16:03credit. So we're looking at
- 16:04options with that. And in
- 16:06addition to affecting
- 16:09kindergarten readiness which
- 16:10would be the priority, which is
- 16:11a metric we look at and we talk
- 16:14about all the time, this would
- 16:16directly approach that and
- 16:17impact that. But we looked at,
- 16:20you know, if if more kids come
- 16:22in kindergarten ready. And I
- 16:23think our overall average right
- 16:25now in the state, when you
- 16:27consider all sources, has
- 16:28dropped to around 46% readiness.
- 16:31Those kids that go to private
- 16:34centers, they're up 65, 70%. So
- 16:37there's a wide disparity there.
- 16:39And I think kids that stay at
- 16:41home, maybe 40%, 43%, if I'm
- 16:44not mistaken. So it would
- 16:47address those in the kids when
- 16:48they get to school and they're
- 16:50kindergarten ready. Think about
- 16:51the higher levels of
- 16:53achievement that each child
- 16:54could attain in those first
- 16:56three years that are so
- 16:57critical. And we know all the
- 16:59metrics. If a kid can't read by
- 17:01third or fourth grade, where a
- 17:03good likelihood of where
- 17:04they're going to end up when
- 17:05they grow up, and those metrics
- 17:07and those predictions, the data
- 17:09is there. So it makes perfect
- 17:11sense that we focus on that
- 17:13area. And that's where we
- 17:14invest our money is is working
- 17:17towards kindergarten readiness
- 17:20while protecting. And to make
- 17:22sure that we are serving kids
- 17:23with special needs and that we
- 17:25are providing growth and
- 17:27services across the state, and
- 17:30also for for infants and
- 17:32toddlers, which universal
- 17:33public pre-K does not really
- 17:35consider that age group. And we
- 17:37have to consider that age group.
- 17:39So a unique, unique idea, a
- 17:42different focus when looking at
- 17:45funding.
- 17:45>> And this is a statewide
- 17:46effort. So in the University of
- 17:48Kentucky College of Education
- 17:49would be doing this program and
- 17:51overseeing this program. How do
- 17:53they determine which centers
- 17:55which families would benefit?
- 17:56How does that come about?
- 17:57>> I've just been meeting with
- 17:59Doctor Collins Shepley and Dean
- 18:01pace with the College of
- 18:03Education. We're starting to
- 18:05talk through those decisions
- 18:07and kind of narrow down, and we
- 18:08want to give this pilot program
- 18:10plenty of time to to be able to
- 18:13get proper and complete data
- 18:15out of it. So it this, this
- 18:18process would not begin until
- 18:2120. It would be August of 27.
- 18:24So it would give them a full
- 18:26year to prepare and study what
- 18:28groups and how to contact those
- 18:30groups and set up all the
- 18:32parameters for the program and
- 18:33then use two full years to
- 18:35study that would get three and
- 18:36four year olds, and look at the
- 18:39difference in kindergarten
- 18:40readiness rates of those kids
- 18:41that are in centers, family
- 18:43home providers, or being cared
- 18:46for at home. Right.
- 18:48>> And and you want a mix of
- 18:50all those different settings.
- 18:51>> Right.
- 18:51>> To get an accurate reading
- 18:53to see if this is really a
- 18:54valid concept, we'll need that.
- 18:56And then when all is said and
- 18:58done, we'll look at ways that
- 18:59maybe we can merge some of this
- 19:01process and some of this, the
- 19:04data into what we're looking at
- 19:06within the Kentucky All-Stars
- 19:08program. We want to make sure
- 19:09that there's quality care. We
- 19:11want to make sure that we have
- 19:12a proper focus, and we want to
- 19:13make sure that it addresses all
- 19:15age groups, no matter what
- 19:17decision we come with.
- 19:18>> And there's $2 million that
- 19:19would go toward this pilot
- 19:21project that would have already
- 19:22been appropriated but was not
- 19:24used. Is that correct?
- 19:25>> It was.
- 19:25>> Part of the Horizons Act,
- 19:27and it was an idea to create
- 19:29some grant funding for
- 19:31incentive and for new programs
- 19:34that are innovations in child
- 19:36care delivery. I think was the
- 19:38name of the grant program, and
- 19:39this fits that perfectly. It's
- 19:41just a different way of looking
- 19:42at things.
- 19:43>> Yeah. Well, I want to come
- 19:44to you, representative Moore,
- 19:45what do you think about what
- 19:47you've heard?
- 19:47>> I'd actually like to at
- 19:49least just say directly some
- 19:50concerns that I have. So I
- 19:52wonder if some of our viewers
- 19:53have those as well. But this
- 19:55also then gives you an
- 19:56opportunity, Senator Carroll,
- 19:57to address those directly for
- 19:58things I may be missing on, and
- 20:00those watching at home may be
- 20:01missing on, I worry about the
- 20:03gap between the haves and the
- 20:04have nots. We've seen at the
- 20:06national level that those who
- 20:07are in the top quartile versus
- 20:08those in the bottom quartile
- 20:10are about 30% more likely to be
- 20:11kindergarten ready. And I
- 20:12looked at Kentucky specific
- 20:13numbers. And then those who are
- 20:15on the free school lunch
- 20:16program are 21% less likely
- 20:17than those who are not on the
- 20:19free school lunch program. So
- 20:20I'll worry about those affluent
- 20:22areas of Kentucky where parents
- 20:23can afford to send themselves
- 20:24to send their children to these
- 20:26wonderful child care centers
- 20:27that are getting them
- 20:28kindergarten ready, that those
- 20:29may be the areas where those
- 20:30being paid a little bit better,
- 20:32maybe in urban centers or areas
- 20:33that are more affluent. And so
- 20:35those bonuses will be going to
- 20:36areas that are already most
- 20:37well off. And those areas of
- 20:39rural Kentucky where we have
- 20:40child care deserts, that they
- 20:41may not be able to see as much
- 20:43of those grants coming out of
- 20:45it, those credits coming out of
- 20:46it, because we've seen that the
- 20:48high income, low income
- 20:49households already has a huge
- 20:50disparity in that kindergarten
- 20:51readiness. So does this system
- 20:53essentially, essentially give
- 20:54more to those who already have
- 20:55the most and have less
- 20:56opportunity for those who have
- 20:59the least?
- 20:59>> Well, let's stop there and
- 21:01have Senator Carroll.
- 21:01>> It absolutely would be.
- 21:03>> An equal playing ground and
- 21:04even would lean towards those
- 21:05low income families. To be
- 21:07eligible for this incentive,
- 21:09you would have to be eligible
- 21:10for child care assistance.
- 21:12That's the metrics that we
- 21:13would look at in the study
- 21:15itself would be geographically
- 21:17diverse and socioeconomic
- 21:19diverse. So it it is important
- 21:21that we get a snapshot across
- 21:24the state of families of
- 21:27providers to make sure it is
- 21:29accurate data, but understand
- 21:31that it would focus on low
- 21:33income families if they are
- 21:34keeping their child at home.
- 21:36And for whatever reason, they
- 21:37haven't been able to get a slot
- 21:39in a center because there are
- 21:40huge waiting lists all over the
- 21:42state. And if they're unable to
- 21:43get their their child in Head
- 21:45Start, this is an option for
- 21:47them. And there would be
- 21:48resources that would come with
- 21:49the program that would help
- 21:51them to understand what they
- 21:53needed to do for that child to
- 21:54get that child kindergarten
- 21:56ready. Using assets like hand
- 21:58the hands program and even some
- 22:00of the staff that currently are
- 22:02assigned to the All Stars
- 22:04program using the assets that
- 22:05we have to to help those
- 22:07families to know what they need
- 22:08to do to prepare those.
- 22:10>> And that's a good point,
- 22:11because that was going to be my
- 22:13question is, how are parents
- 22:14who were doing that at home
- 22:16going to know how to get their
- 22:17child kindergarten ready? Right.
- 22:18But you just answered that as
- 22:20far as the resources are
- 22:21concerned. So, Representative
- 22:22Moore, is there more that you
- 22:23have?
- 22:24>> No. I look forward to.
- 22:25>> Receiving do a Limerick
- 22:26there. It just happened
- 22:27naturally.
- 22:28>> Well, thanks for providing
- 22:29that with my name.
- 22:30>> It's wonderful.
- 22:31>> And I look forward to us
- 22:32receiving Senator Carroll's
- 22:33bill when it comes over to the
- 22:35House, because everyone knows
- 22:36there's hundreds of bills filed.
- 22:37I think we passed 800 in the
- 22:39House today. And so mine was
- 22:40seven. Mine was 7.99. So I know
- 22:42we're over 800. Yeah. So once
- 22:44it's in our Chamber, we can
- 22:45really sink our teeth into it
- 22:47and look at it more closely.
- 22:48He's already given me a
- 22:49firsthand account to some of
- 22:51the things that it's doing. I
- 22:52really do want to tip my hat,
- 22:54though, to Chairwoman Heavrin
- 22:55and her House Bill six. I think.
- 22:57>> It's voted for.
- 22:58>> I did vote for it. Passed a
- 23:00bipartisan, not quite unanimous,
- 23:01but still very bipartisan. Hats
- 23:02off to her. I know a lot of
- 23:04work went into that, and I
- 23:05think it's going to help people
- 23:07throughout Kentucky, especially
- 23:08look at micro centers and areas
- 23:09that, you know, maybe it's a
- 23:11smaller number of kids, but can
- 23:12we get a little more kids in
- 23:14the door because those margins
- 23:15are so small for those child
- 23:17care workers, like the wages
- 23:18are low, but they cannot charge
- 23:19any more because the parents
- 23:21don't have enough. So as you
- 23:22look into some of those reforms
- 23:24and House Bill six, I think
- 23:25that could be a game changer,
- 23:27especially in the rural parts
- 23:28of Kentucky that really need a
- 23:29program like this.
- 23:30>> So let's define, though,
- 23:31what micro centers are the
- 23:33number of kids that could be
- 23:34served, and what do these
- 23:36centers look like and is the
- 23:37quality any different.
- 23:38>> Yeah I'm going to kick it
- 23:40off and then I'm going to let
- 23:41Sarah and Charles finish up
- 23:43anything I miss. So micro
- 23:44centers is a new type of child
- 23:46care licensure that would allow
- 23:47for no more than 24 children.
- 23:49This is really supposed to help
- 23:52rural areas. Right now we have
- 23:54a cap at ten. Indiana and
- 23:57Tennessee have both passed
- 23:59legislation on this, and what
- 24:00it does is it allows more
- 24:02flexibility. The child care
- 24:03centers are still safe, safe
- 24:04for children, but it offers a
- 24:06little more regulatory relief
- 24:09in the sense of maybe it's a
- 24:10little more nontraditional. You
- 24:11know, I think a big
- 24:13conversation with child care is
- 24:14we're looking at child care for
- 24:16parents with all working hours,
- 24:1824 hours a day, not just from 8
- 24:20to 12 or 8 to 2. And so I think
- 24:22this will help some of those
- 24:24nontraditional, maybe that
- 24:25third shift or the second shift.
- 24:27You know, Toyota does a great
- 24:28job. They've got onsite child
- 24:29care and they have 24 hours.
- 24:31You know, that's one place in
- 24:33Kentucky. And so this I think,
- 24:34would allow more places to open
- 24:36child care facilities and have
- 24:38that type of flexibility. Sarah
- 24:40Charles, am I missing?
- 24:41>> And I do want to real
- 24:43quickly, before either one of
- 24:44you answer when you say some
- 24:45regulatory relief, some people
- 24:46perk up and say, oh, then that
- 24:48means they might be substandard.
- 24:49So address that for us, doctor.
- 24:51All.
- 24:51>> Yeah, sure. As Chair Heavrin
- 24:53mentioned, these are types of
- 24:54centers that are already
- 24:55allowable in states like
- 24:57Tennessee, Indiana, Tennessee
- 24:59in particular has been doing
- 25:00this for for quite a long while.
- 25:01And I think one of the ways to
- 25:03think about it is more along
- 25:05the lines of setting aligned
- 25:07regulatory frameworks. And so
- 25:08if you think about child care
- 25:09that you have these two broad
- 25:11categories, right, you have
- 25:12certified family child care
- 25:13homes, which is child care
- 25:15service provided within
- 25:16someone's home as as a business.
- 25:18And then you have these larger
- 25:20centers. Micro centers is
- 25:21something that's supposed to
- 25:22exist sort of in between those
- 25:23worlds. And as chair having
- 25:25said, they're meant to be more
- 25:26nimble, more flexible, so that
- 25:27they can respond to really
- 25:29specific needs within that
- 25:30community. So it might be
- 25:32something like the need for
- 25:33third shift or drop in child
- 25:34care, or it might be a place
- 25:36where you just have less
- 25:37density. And so it's going to
- 25:39work better in a rural area.
- 25:40And so you structure the
- 25:41regulatory framework to
- 25:43accommodate those, those, those
- 25:44different types of needs. And
- 25:45so that might include things
- 25:46like no requirements that they
- 25:48have to provide lunch. Maybe
- 25:50kids can bring food with them.
- 25:52Maybe they don't have to have a
- 25:53playground on site, but they do
- 25:55have to have rules to allow for
- 25:56that type of activity in some
- 25:58other form. So they have
- 25:59flexibility there. You can have
- 26:00things like mixed age groups.
- 26:03They also under House Bill six
- 26:04would have the ability to
- 26:06request under limited
- 26:08circumstances, unique variances
- 26:10where they might need a little
- 26:11bit more flexibility. But these
- 26:13would absolutely be high
- 26:15quality and very, very safe
- 26:17facilities for kids to be in.
- 26:18And we have good examples
- 26:20already in other states that
- 26:21are operating these.
- 26:22>> Doctor Vanover, anything you
- 26:23care to add?
- 26:24>> Well, one of the things that
- 26:25would ensure quality is that a
- 26:27micro center can only be opened
- 26:28by someone who already has an
- 26:30operating, high quality child
- 26:31care with at least three years
- 26:33experience. And I kind of think
- 26:35of it as a satellite site for
- 26:37that child care program. They
- 26:38know what they're doing,
- 26:39they've established high
- 26:40quality, and now I can open an
- 26:42additional facility with less
- 26:43red tape associated, and it
- 26:45gives kind of a one room
- 26:47schoolhouse feel in the fact
- 26:48that if you have center based
- 26:50care, we always separate our
- 26:52very young children from our
- 26:54older children to make sure
- 26:55that our toddlers don't get run
- 26:57over by a school aged child. In
- 26:59a family child care home. Those
- 27:00children are allowed to be
- 27:02mixed together by age. Because
- 27:03of the small nature and the
- 27:04micro center, they would be
- 27:05able to do that as well and
- 27:07have that mixed age group.
- 27:09However, the maximum number of
- 27:11children would be based on the
- 27:12age of the youngest child. So
- 27:14if you just have infants,
- 27:15you're not going to have 24 of
- 27:17them. You're going to have a
- 27:18much smaller number. But if you
- 27:20do have preschoolers, then you
- 27:21would have a little more
- 27:22flexibility there. But the
- 27:23quality piece is really based
- 27:26on the fact that we know that
- 27:28the owner director already has
- 27:30experience with quality and
- 27:31knows how to replicate.
- 27:32>> That, and that's a good
- 27:33point. And they still would be
- 27:34subject to all the inspections
- 27:36that happen with other I don't
- 27:37know if you want to call them
- 27:39full service centers.
- 27:40>> And health and safety is
- 27:41going to be non-negotiable on a
- 27:44lot of things. Most of our
- 27:45health and safety regulations
- 27:47in any state and child care
- 27:48come from the federal
- 27:49government, and we don't really
- 27:51have that much flexibility on
- 27:52how we implement that. So
- 27:54whether it's a family, child
- 27:55care home, a micro center, or a
- 27:57larger child care program,
- 27:59health and safety is always
- 28:00going to be at the top priority.
- 28:01But how the paperwork process
- 28:03the bureaucracy to open a
- 28:05program, the the number of
- 28:07classrooms, things like that
- 28:08can be negotiated. It's some of
- 28:11the little bit of wiggle room
- 28:12that we have. And when you take
- 28:14that and move it around a
- 28:15little bit, then particularly
- 28:17in our rural areas, centers
- 28:20cannot stay open in rural areas
- 28:22because 30 families are spaced
- 28:24way too far apart to all drive
- 28:25to the same program. You have a
- 28:27micro center that only needs 12
- 28:29to 14 children. Based on what
- 28:31they're offering. It's a lot
- 28:33more likely that that can
- 28:34survive in a rural community
- 28:36than a larger center.
- 28:37>> But when we think about
- 28:38deserts where there's not
- 28:39already a community or a
- 28:41facility, how does a micro
- 28:43center get started?
- 28:44>> Well, it could be. And we
- 28:46have instances where there are,
- 28:49I guess, chains, mom and pop
- 28:52chains open throughout Kentucky
- 28:54that leap over counties. You
- 28:56know, we have programs that are
- 28:57owned by the same individuals
- 28:59that are in southern Indiana
- 29:00and in Louisville, things of
- 29:01that nature. So it wouldn't
- 29:02require that the original site
- 29:04be in the same county. It could
- 29:06be that, you know, in Benton,
- 29:09Kentucky, there is a wonderful
- 29:10program that's open and they
- 29:11decide to open a satellite site,
- 29:13maybe in McCracken County. And,
- 29:16you know, close enough in
- 29:17nature that the person could
- 29:18still oversee, but maybe they
- 29:21are helping the needs of a
- 29:23community that doesn't have
- 29:24anything.
- 29:24>> Yeah. Well, thank you for
- 29:25that clarification. So this
- 29:27question from a viewer, Jane
- 29:28from Madison County, how can
- 29:30more funding be allocated for
- 29:32Head Start in educating
- 29:33children who live in poverty?
- 29:34And Chairman Carroll, I want to
- 29:36come to you because your idea
- 29:38with Senate Bill 191 does not
- 29:40address Head Start, correct?
- 29:42>> It does not. It would
- 29:43address if, say, a school
- 29:45district had their own child
- 29:46care facility that fell under
- 29:48the state child care regs. It
- 29:50would cover those centers. But
- 29:52Head starts a federal program
- 29:54in partnership with the state.
- 29:55And Doctor Vanover would know
- 29:57more about that.
- 29:58>> So what I will say in
- 30:00Kentucky, almost every Head
- 30:01Start program is also a
- 30:03licensed child care program.
- 30:04Federal funds come for Head
- 30:06Start to offer three hours a
- 30:08day to children that are at the
- 30:09federal poverty line or below,
- 30:11but many of those Head Start
- 30:13programs expand to full day by
- 30:16use by becoming a licensed
- 30:17center under Kentucky Child
- 30:18Care licensure, and then
- 30:19helping those families to
- 30:21utilize the child Care
- 30:22Assistance Program. And that
- 30:23pays for the second half of
- 30:24their day. We have very few
- 30:26programs in Head Start or Early
- 30:28Head Start, which is the birth
- 30:30to three component of that that
- 30:32that don't have license
- 30:35capacity. And so many of those
- 30:37programs double dip to to
- 30:39support and make it a stronger
- 30:41program. They get state funds,
- 30:42they get federal funds. And if
- 30:43they are licensed, then they
- 30:45would fall under the the
- 30:48expenditure of a licensed.
- 30:53Regulation change.
- 30:54>> Chairman Carroll, I want to
- 30:56come back to you to talk about
- 30:57your measure. And I was curious
- 30:59about when you offered this
- 31:01$2,000 incentive to
- 31:02particularly parents who are
- 31:03providing those at home daycare
- 31:05services. Would that be too
- 31:08much of a carrot for people to
- 31:10pull their kids out of a Head
- 31:12Start program just to get the
- 31:14$2,000? Do you envision that
- 31:15being a scenario that would be
- 31:17operable?
- 31:17>> I don't, and first we will
- 31:19have to look at the head start
- 31:21using state money to supplement
- 31:23a federal program. It you know,
- 31:25it really I'm not sure if
- 31:26that's where we would want to
- 31:28go, but I do know they
- 31:29participate in the All Stars
- 31:30program. So we would need to be
- 31:32sensitive to that. But $2,000 I
- 31:37don't think is enough to to
- 31:39sway someone if they do have an
- 31:41available slot, whether that be
- 31:43in Head Start or at a center or
- 31:45in a family in home provider. I
- 31:47don't think that that's enough
- 31:49where it would have any impact
- 31:50on that at all.
- 31:51>> Well, thank you for
- 31:52clarifying that. Any other
- 31:53comment on that before we move
- 31:55on. So let's let's do also talk
- 31:59about Senator Carroll. You have
- 32:00a Senate bill. 160 really is
- 32:03flexibility with state
- 32:05inspections. And so when we
- 32:06hear those words grouped
- 32:07together, sometimes that can
- 32:08resonate with some to be an
- 32:10easing of inspections or
- 32:12concern about the quality. I
- 32:13don't talk to us about.
- 32:14>> This at all. It gives.
- 32:16>> The inspectors some latitude
- 32:18that they currently don't have
- 32:20it. It kind of backs backs the
- 32:22OGS office into a corner
- 32:25sometimes where it says they
- 32:26shall. And then the bill simply
- 32:28sets up some some things that
- 32:30they need to look at at the
- 32:32center. Was it a self-reported
- 32:33incident, the history of the
- 32:35center, things of that nature
- 32:36to make a more educated
- 32:39decision on on what's happening.
- 32:41And in some cases, like with
- 32:43new centers that just opened
- 32:45their doors, it would provide
- 32:46some protections to get those
- 32:48centers through the first six
- 32:49months where they would have
- 32:51visits one in person two times
- 32:54a week, and to coach those
- 32:56centers along to make sure they
- 32:58are in compliance so they don't
- 33:00end up falling through the
- 33:01cracks and end up having their
- 33:03license suspended right off the
- 33:05bat. And then if that period is
- 33:06long enough, they may not ever
- 33:08open their doors again. So it's
- 33:09more supportive and being more
- 33:11proactive. And then on the
- 33:12existing center side, it's just
- 33:14more latitude. The same
- 33:15standards would be in place. It
- 33:17would not move those at all.
- 33:19But if if there was a center,
- 33:21let's say, was in a directed
- 33:23plan of care and something
- 33:25happened while they were in
- 33:26that directed plan of care, and
- 33:28it was something that had
- 33:29nothing to do with policy
- 33:30training, anything the center
- 33:32did or didn't do, it had
- 33:34nothing to do with that. It was
- 33:36simply an act of an individual
- 33:37that may have known better than
- 33:39to to to do that. So, so in
- 33:41those cases, that particular
- 33:42incident would have to be to a
- 33:45level severe enough that in and
- 33:46of itself would cause the
- 33:50licensure to be revoked in
- 33:51those circumstances.
- 33:53>> Doctor Vanover, a paper that
- 33:54you coauthored last fall, shows
- 33:55that problems with Kentucky's
- 33:57child care system aren't just
- 33:58limited to the accessibility
- 34:00and affordability, but also
- 34:02there was an increase in abuse
- 34:04at Kentucky child care centers
- 34:05that was linked to low wages
- 34:07and stressed out staff. And you
- 34:08talked about that from the very
- 34:09beginning when we first opened
- 34:11the program. And I'm just going
- 34:12to read this because the report
- 34:14found from the Annie E Casey
- 34:15Foundation that child care
- 34:16workers are paid less than 98%
- 34:18of professions. Another study
- 34:20found that the median wage for
- 34:21child care providers in
- 34:22Kentucky was just under $14 an
- 34:25hour, or 29,060 $60 annually,
- 34:29with many child care programs
- 34:31unable to offer health
- 34:32insurance or other benefits to
- 34:34staff. And this has created and
- 34:36you've talked about this before,
- 34:37perception of lack of
- 34:39professionalism for that
- 34:40industry. And does it also
- 34:43somehow feed into some of these
- 34:45incidents of abuse that we see
- 34:47in child care centers, and what
- 34:48can be done to address that
- 34:50that hasn't already been
- 34:51discussed this evening.
- 34:52>> So we have seen an increase
- 34:55of abuse in child care programs.
- 34:57Now it's not rampant. But what
- 34:59we do know is that any case of
- 35:01abuse needs to be eliminated.
- 35:04And the biggest thing that we
- 35:06see is often entry level staff
- 35:08that don't have enough training
- 35:09yet. They're left alone in a
- 35:11room full of children in
- 35:13Kentucky, one adult can be left
- 35:15alone with ten two year olds,
- 35:16two adults with 22 year olds. I
- 35:20don't know your all's
- 35:21background. I have been the one
- 35:22adult left alone with ten two
- 35:23year olds, and it's not an
- 35:25experience I really want to
- 35:26duplicate. It's very
- 35:27overwhelming. And if our staff
- 35:30don't have that training, if
- 35:31they're there just because they
- 35:32they desperately need a
- 35:34paycheck, this is an entry
- 35:35level job, then it's easy to
- 35:37become overwhelmed. We see that
- 35:39children with disabilities are
- 35:41often targets of abuse because
- 35:43they have very challenging
- 35:45behaviors that may come out in
- 35:46the classroom, and staff are
- 35:47not trained on how to support
- 35:49those children to reduce
- 35:50negative behaviors. And just as
- 35:52when parents stress levels
- 35:54increase and abuse increases,
- 35:55we see that in child care
- 35:56programs. Also, one of the
- 35:59portions of House Bill six that
- 36:02Kentucky Youth Advocates is
- 36:03really excited about is that it
- 36:05would require child care
- 36:07providers to get training in
- 36:09the area of special education
- 36:10every year. Right now, every
- 36:11child care provider in a center
- 36:13in Kentucky has to get 15 hours
- 36:14of training every year. They're
- 36:16already paying for it. It's
- 36:18already a requirement. But
- 36:19we're saying out of those 15
- 36:20hours, three hours every year
- 36:22would focus on how to support
- 36:23children with disabilities. The
- 36:27that portion of the bill also
- 36:28talks about our early
- 36:30intervention systems being able
- 36:31to come in and support children
- 36:33in the classroom with parent
- 36:35permission, but making sure
- 36:38that when the Kentucky early
- 36:40intervention system that used
- 36:41to be called first steps, when
- 36:42they come and they work with
- 36:44the child in the classroom, the
- 36:45teachers learn as well as the
- 36:47children. So the the speech
- 36:49pathologist or the occupational
- 36:51therapist is working with the
- 36:52child, but the teacher watches
- 36:53and learns how to support
- 36:55children in the classroom. And
- 36:56it's like hands on free
- 36:57technical assistance, and it
- 36:59benefits the children. It
- 37:00benefits the families because
- 37:01it's really hard to work all
- 37:03day long until 5:00 and then
- 37:04try and find therapy for your
- 37:06child. After that time period
- 37:07when most medical professionals
- 37:10have closed their offices. And
- 37:12then we know that teachers get
- 37:13get support. One of the biggest
- 37:17reasons Bright Horizons has
- 37:181000 child care programs
- 37:20worldwide, and not only in the
- 37:21US, but in Holland, all kinds
- 37:23of places. Several years ago, I
- 37:24was at one of their worker
- 37:27conferences when I worked for
- 37:28Toyota's child care program,
- 37:30and they did exit interviews
- 37:33with every person who left the
- 37:34child care program anywhere in
- 37:36the world. And wages was not
- 37:40the number one reason people
- 37:41were leaving. They said that
- 37:44number one was I didn't get
- 37:45along with my director. Number
- 37:47two was I didn't get along with
- 37:48my teaching staff. And number
- 37:50three was I do not feel
- 37:51prepared to do my job. And many
- 37:53of our child care providers
- 37:54feel that way when they get
- 37:56into the field, especially if
- 37:57they're entry level. You've got
- 37:58an 18 year old right out of
- 38:00high school going into work
- 38:01full time with young children.
- 38:03You're in a room left alone
- 38:04with five infants and they're
- 38:05all crying at once. It's very
- 38:08overwhelming. And so the more
- 38:09training, the more education we
- 38:11can get. What we've seen is
- 38:13correlations to a reduction in
- 38:15abuse because of that.
- 38:16>> Yeah. And it's three hours
- 38:18enough. Chairwoman Heavrin,
- 38:19when it comes to special
- 38:21education training.
- 38:22>> I think it's a really good
- 38:24step in the right direction.
- 38:25Renee three is better than zero.
- 38:28>> Which is what it is now,
- 38:29right?
- 38:30>> Yeah. And you know, my mama
- 38:31is a director of special
- 38:33education. And so I've grown up
- 38:34learning all about this and
- 38:36understanding it. And so
- 38:37whenever Sarah brought this, I
- 38:38just knew it was a great step
- 38:39to the right direction. And,
- 38:41Renee, I've got a few more
- 38:42points I want to make about
- 38:44House Bill six that I think are
- 38:45really important for the work
- 38:47that was done on this, and one
- 38:48we have cap reform, which is
- 38:50the employee child care
- 38:51assistance program, much like
- 38:52Danny's or Chairman Carroll's.
- 38:54I'm a first name basis. I feel
- 38:56like Senate Bill 190. You know,
- 38:59we really take pride in being
- 39:00innovative in Kentucky. And so,
- 39:01you know, to me, in 2022, when
- 39:03we passed the Employee child
- 39:04Care Assistance Program, it's a
- 39:05try share program. And so the
- 39:07employer puts in a little money,
- 39:09the employee puts in a little
- 39:10money, and the state puts in a
- 39:12little money. And you know, we
- 39:14are privatizing that in House
- 39:16Bill six. It's been you know,
- 39:18it's been really difficult to
- 39:19get off the ground. And it's in
- 39:21its current form. And I think a
- 39:23big part of that is the lack of,
- 39:26you know, everything is
- 39:27sometimes on fire in child
- 39:28welfare and you're trying to
- 39:29figure out what's right. And,
- 39:31and I think that if we can
- 39:32privatize it and be someone's
- 39:33full time job, it's really
- 39:35going to make a difference. I
- 39:36talked to so many people who
- 39:38are interested in bringing this
- 39:39to their company, but they're
- 39:40like, it's such a hassle. You
- 39:42know, one day it's an online
- 39:43form and the next day it's you
- 39:45have to fax it in or, you know,
- 39:47it just it's not consistent.
- 39:48And I think if we can make it a
- 39:50consistent program, it really
- 39:51will get its feet off the
- 39:53ground and really soar. This is
- 39:54just an extra tool in the
- 39:56toolbox for employers to be
- 39:57able to give to their employees.
- 39:59We also have a pilot program
- 40:00for military families. The
- 40:02Department of Defense reached
- 40:03out to us. They've also passed
- 40:05legislation in North Carolina.
- 40:07And basically military families
- 40:08move in. So at Fort Knox or
- 40:10Fort Campbell, and they have a
- 40:11really hard time with their
- 40:12licensure. And the federal
- 40:13licensure supersedes state.
- 40:16It's more strict. And so this
- 40:17would allow for those military
- 40:19families to to start child home
- 40:23based or home based child care
- 40:25centers specifically for
- 40:26military children. So it's a
- 40:27two year pilot program. We'll
- 40:28see if it works. And, you know,
- 40:31I think it's a really great
- 40:32idea to help our military
- 40:33families with that. We also
- 40:35have in cap We. This is a
- 40:38really big thing for Kentucky.
- 40:39And I'm going to struggle with
- 40:41this for categorical
- 40:42eligibility. Okay. Explain that.
- 40:44Yes. So we have allowed for
- 40:45child care workers to receive
- 40:47free child care through Cap
- 40:49funding. And just for, you know,
- 40:50Cap funding is the child care
- 40:52assistance program for low
- 40:53income families who work. And
- 40:55so that's a really big subsidy
- 40:56that we offer here in Kentucky.
- 40:58And so from that, we have we we
- 41:00expand the eligibility and that
- 41:01becomes permanent. We've done
- 41:02that in the last few budgets,
- 41:03but it becomes permanent in
- 41:05statute. And so I think that's
- 41:06a really big win. We also have
- 41:08the we we we revamp the
- 41:11certified child care community
- 41:13program. That was legislation
- 41:14we passed in 2024. And, you
- 41:16know, a few years ago
- 41:18Louisville did a study and they
- 41:19looked at the local zoning,
- 41:22their ordinances to see if they
- 41:23were actually preventing
- 41:24themselves from having child
- 41:25care centers open. We
- 41:27recognized from them that it
- 41:28was a huge barrier. And so what
- 41:31this does is it encourages it
- 41:33encourages. It does not require
- 41:36local cities and counties to
- 41:37look at their local zoning and
- 41:39planning ordinances to see if
- 41:41they're there in their own way
- 41:42of creating child care centers
- 41:44for their communities. This,
- 41:46unfortunately, was one of those
- 41:47things that we passed. And then
- 41:48I got a letter saying it was
- 41:50unfunded. So we're hoping that
- 41:52by moving it to the cabinet for
- 41:53Health and Family Services,
- 41:55that it also gets boots off the
- 41:56ground and we're able to see
- 41:59real success with that. It just
- 42:01encouragement. And so all these
- 42:02things we also have fiscal
- 42:04transparency. We really need to
- 42:05see where money is going. You
- 42:07know I think a really good
- 42:08example in the budget from last
- 42:11year, $9 million was taken off
- 42:14child care and moved to family
- 42:15based services. And so what
- 42:17kind of money are we working
- 42:18with? Because when we're
- 42:19spending taxpayer dollar, we
- 42:20really want that money to be
- 42:22strategically placed and make
- 42:23sure we're getting good use out
- 42:24of it. And it's and it's
- 42:26creating good, good outcomes.
- 42:28And then also we have data that
- 42:31is something we we continue to
- 42:33talk about. I was recently part
- 42:34of a the National Council of
- 42:36State Legislators. We did a I
- 42:38was on a child care task force
- 42:40there. And that was one of the
- 42:41biggest things is constantly
- 42:43looking for data. I had the
- 42:44opportunity to work with Linda
- 42:45from the Buffett Institute as
- 42:47well, and something that's just
- 42:48what we're missing for Kentucky,
- 42:49and I always am a big advocate
- 42:51for, we've got to make sure to
- 42:52have data or we're not going to
- 42:54be able to create good policy.
- 42:56And so I just I this is a
- 42:58really proud piece of
- 42:59legislation for all of us here
- 43:00to look at. And the community
- 43:02that brought it together in
- 43:032024, advocates were no one
- 43:04could really agree. We all knew
- 43:06childcare was a problem. And
- 43:07everyone sitting here, we all
- 43:08believe that the children are
- 43:10our future. So how do we make
- 43:11that successful? So we all are
- 43:13trying to figure out how we
- 43:14move child care in Kentucky. We
- 43:16all just have different ways.
- 43:17And once again, that's the
- 43:18beauty of the legislature.
- 43:20>> And what's the fiscal note
- 43:21or fiscal impact of your
- 43:22measure? House Bill six.
- 43:23>> $0 Renee. There's actually
- 43:25it's all into the budget. So
- 43:26what you saw in House Bill 500
- 43:28and the House committee
- 43:29substitute, that was already
- 43:30all in there. There's no it's
- 43:32actually a decrease because of
- 43:34the $9 million that was moved.
- 43:37So I think it's $53 million in
- 43:39the first biennium for child
- 43:41care. But it's very similar to
- 43:42the last budget cycle.
- 43:44>> Representative Moore, what's
- 43:45missing out of what we've
- 43:46talked about tonight.
- 43:47>> As far as what's missing, I
- 43:48want to highlight, just to give
- 43:50more shine on two of the things
- 43:52that rep Heavrin just mentioned,
- 43:53the C cap to allow our child
- 43:55care providers to have that
- 43:56cost given for their children
- 43:57as well a child care. I think
- 43:59that's going to be a great
- 44:00thing. But she mentioned the
- 44:02thing for our military families
- 44:03to have that for military
- 44:04children. And so one thing that
- 44:06we're trying to do in the
- 44:07Veterans Caucus is find ways
- 44:08for military families move to
- 44:10Kentucky. How are they
- 44:11supported? How can they thrive
- 44:12here and live their best life
- 44:13here in Kentucky? And so that's
- 44:15an option for military spouses
- 44:16and partners to have that
- 44:17business. Wise but for the
- 44:19children of all those military
- 44:20families to come together and
- 44:21have good, safe service that's
- 44:22already been certified by the
- 44:24DoD through their child care
- 44:25requirements. So I just want to
- 44:26make sure people who are
- 44:28watching, I know you said so
- 44:29much just then, Samara. So I
- 44:31wanted I wanted our.
- 44:32>> People to.
- 44:32>> Know two of those really
- 44:34cool things. As far as what's
- 44:35missing, supply and demand does
- 44:37not meet the moment here. And
- 44:38so government has to exist in
- 44:40some way, shape or form to meet
- 44:41the challenges that the private
- 44:43market either cannot or will
- 44:44not solve on its own.
- 44:45Capitalism has brought us so
- 44:46far, and it's done great things
- 44:48for this country, but it is
- 44:49just not taking care of child
- 44:51care. What is the appropriate
- 44:52role when we have $3.7 billion
- 44:54in the budget reserve trust
- 44:55fund, is that required to
- 44:57potentially help this industry
- 44:58where we don't have enough
- 44:59child care providers and we
- 45:02don't we don't have enough, and
- 45:03the ones that we do have are
- 45:04not being paid enough. Are
- 45:06there other opportunities when
- 45:07maybe it is raining? Maybe this
- 45:09is a rainy day and we need to
- 45:10look into this like historic
- 45:12amount that we have sitting
- 45:13there that we're not touching
- 45:14right now.
- 45:15>> What do you propose?
- 45:16>> That's a great question.
- 45:17>> I.
- 45:19>> I thought I knew your answer.
- 45:20So let me ask you, let me ask
- 45:22it this way. As posed by a
- 45:24viewer. This viewer wants to
- 45:25ask the entire panel how many
- 45:27of them received
- 45:28pre-kindergarten education.
- 45:31>> I did, I did.
- 45:32>> Yeah.
- 45:32>> I did not I did okay.
- 45:34>> And so let's let's talk
- 45:36about that. Do you think that
- 45:37was a value added benefit for
- 45:39the rest of your matriculation
- 45:41through primary and secondary
- 45:42education and beyond?
- 45:43>> I would say yes. I was
- 45:45blessed to have a mother who
- 45:46stayed at home with my sister
- 45:48and I until we entered
- 45:49kindergarten. But I did go to
- 45:51half day preschool at my church
- 45:52leading up to kindergarten, and
- 45:54the benefits of even half day
- 45:56programs, even if even if the
- 45:59family has someone who can
- 46:00watch the child, the benefits
- 46:01of even half day have a major
- 46:04social and emotional impacts on
- 46:05a child. If you ask a
- 46:07kindergarten teacher, you know
- 46:09what? What is it you need? They
- 46:11will tell you, I can teach the
- 46:13alphabet. I can teach numbers.
- 46:14I went to school to learn how
- 46:16to do that. But when kids come
- 46:19and they they don't know how to
- 46:21identify their own emotions,
- 46:22and so they become overwhelmed
- 46:24and they're disregulated and
- 46:25they fall down on the floor and
- 46:27are having these meltdowns. Or
- 46:30if they don't know how to play
- 46:31with other children, and I have
- 46:33to spend all my time mediating
- 46:35fights, then I can't teach the
- 46:37academic part of kindergarten,
- 46:38because I have to go back to
- 46:40the basics that kids should be
- 46:43learning in a preschool setting.
- 46:45So when we have solid preschool
- 46:49programs, quality that allows
- 46:50children to interact with
- 46:51others allows them to learn how
- 46:54to follow directions, allows
- 46:56them to begin those
- 46:59communication skills that
- 46:59they're going to need from from
- 47:01there on up that's going to
- 47:03benefit in our half days. It's
- 47:04going to benefit for our
- 47:05working families that are in
- 47:06full day, and it'll have an
- 47:08impact when we see those
- 47:09kindergarten readiness scores.
- 47:11>> Chairwoman Heavrin yes, so I
- 47:12went to First Baptist School. I
- 47:14went to three year olds and
- 47:16four year olds until they had a
- 47:18spot for me in kindergarten.
- 47:19And I think the pieces from
- 47:21that is missing out of that,
- 47:22though, is I also had a memo
- 47:24that helped my mom, and she
- 47:27helped, you know, if mom if mom
- 47:29had to work late and mom was
- 47:30there to watch me. And so I
- 47:32think that's the missing piece
- 47:33and kind of this universal
- 47:35pre-K conversation, which I
- 47:36kind of think the question was
- 47:37alluding to, is that if you
- 47:39take four year olds out of
- 47:40childcare center, if you take
- 47:42four year olds out of childcare
- 47:45centers, you're going to
- 47:46decimate the entire industry
- 47:47because there's not, you know,
- 47:48four year olds. You can have
- 47:50more of those. You can make
- 47:51more money off of them. I'm not
- 47:54anti preschool. I just think
- 47:55that we've got to look at the
- 47:57whole picture. And you know, as
- 47:59a small business owner myself I
- 48:00have clients. If school gets
- 48:01canceled for the day they don't
- 48:03have childcare. So they have to
- 48:04take off work. And so it's a
- 48:06whole it's a big issue that
- 48:08continues. And it's not just
- 48:09did you go and do you think it
- 48:11made you better? Well it's
- 48:12about what about for working
- 48:13parents that don't have the
- 48:15luxury of having a memo or a
- 48:16pap to help take care of them,
- 48:18or a dad or an aunt, whatever.
- 48:21We've got to make sure to have
- 48:22space for everybody. And so I
- 48:24think that we can have a
- 48:25conversation on on preschool.
- 48:27But I think we also have to
- 48:28look at childcare isn't just 8
- 48:31to 12 or 8 to 2. It is 24 over
- 48:34seven, seven days a week. They
- 48:36don't take off holidays, they
- 48:37don't have spring break and
- 48:38they don't have fall break. And
- 48:40so it's not a summer program.
- 48:41So there's I think there's a
- 48:42lot more to it. Yes, I think
- 48:44preschool is good. But I think
- 48:46when we're trying to solve this
- 48:48issue right now with childcare,
- 48:49it's not just about preschool.
- 48:50>> And you would agree. Oh,
- 48:52sorry.
- 48:52>> I was going to say every
- 48:54family's needs are really
- 48:55different. We have public
- 48:56school preschool in Kentucky
- 48:57that does an excellent job of
- 48:58serving children with
- 48:59disabilities, because they have
- 49:01supports from the federal
- 49:03government for special
- 49:05education. We have Head Start
- 49:06that offers wraparound services
- 49:07to low income families that
- 49:08make sure that those kiddos get
- 49:11to go to the doctor and get
- 49:12dental exams, and that their
- 49:14parents have the opportunity to
- 49:15get a GED. And then we have
- 49:17working families who, you know,
- 49:19as much as I admire my mom for
- 49:21being able to stay at home with
- 49:23me financially, I didn't have
- 49:24that opportunity as a parent
- 49:25and I needed full time
- 49:27childcare for my children. But
- 49:28I also needed it to be high
- 49:30quality enough that I didn't
- 49:31spend my entire day at work
- 49:32worrying while those kiddos
- 49:34were there and and thinking
- 49:36about, you know, year round
- 49:38care, thinking about holiday
- 49:39care. We have a lot of options
- 49:42that different families can
- 49:43choose from, but we have to
- 49:44make sure that the right
- 49:47families have access to the
- 49:48type of program that they need.
- 49:50>> And I mean, where where is
- 49:51the business community in all
- 49:53of this? Right.
- 49:54>> Let me first say, going back
- 49:55to the original question about
- 49:57those of us that spent time in
- 50:00preschool, I did not spend time
- 50:01in preschool. And the
- 50:02consequences of that is I had
- 50:04to spend ten years in college
- 50:05to get my PhD. So careful thing
- 50:07for us all to think about. You
- 50:09know, back in 2024 when we
- 50:11started the Kentucky
- 50:12Collaborative on Childcare,
- 50:13which included a lot of great
- 50:15folks like Doctor Vanover as an
- 50:17example, we brought together
- 50:18all these folks who had
- 50:19different opinions on this
- 50:20issue, and we asked them, where
- 50:21do you want to, where do you
- 50:23want to spend our time? What
- 50:24should be our focus as this
- 50:26conversation? And that group
- 50:28decided that we really wanted
- 50:29to focus on private, regulated
- 50:32childcare. As Doctor Vanover
- 50:33mentioned at the start of this,
- 50:34we have about 2000 of these
- 50:36small businesses, non-profits,
- 50:37faith based organizations that
- 50:39are serving north of 100,000
- 50:42children all across the state.
- 50:43And these are children of all
- 50:44ages, and they're helping
- 50:45families with all sorts of
- 50:47different needs from all sorts
- 50:48of different socioeconomic
- 50:50statuses. But we know that our
- 50:51current system is suboptimal.
- 50:53And so our thought was, let's
- 50:55focus in on that. How do we
- 50:56make that network of private
- 50:58childcare providers more
- 51:00functional so that we can help
- 51:01more of these working families?
- 51:02And so that's where we have
- 51:04focused in all of our energy.
- 51:06And that's where we think that
- 51:07the conversation is really,
- 51:09really important place to
- 51:10continue to focus on this
- 51:11conversation, I think is really
- 51:13highlighted the importance of
- 51:14that, not only for kids, but to
- 51:16our economy as a whole.
- 51:17>> Universal pre-K. You're
- 51:18still for it though,
- 51:19representative.
- 51:20>> I am, but I think we've seen
- 51:22multiple proposals for it. It's
- 51:23not there have been different
- 51:24things that have put out by the
- 51:26governor's office, but as well
- 51:27as some members of my own
- 51:29caucus, whether we're looking
- 51:30at expanding it gradually based
- 51:31on counties and where they are
- 51:33in certain metrics versus those
- 51:34who are on different income
- 51:35levels, there are ways to, I
- 51:37think, to do it gradually and
- 51:38intelligently. If we just try
- 51:39to say, every four year old in
- 51:41Kentucky gets preschool
- 51:42tomorrow, that's going to
- 51:43collapse in a heartbeat. It
- 51:44would that would fail. Child
- 51:45care around the state would
- 51:47fail. So there's a way to do a
- 51:49measured approach to it with a
- 51:50gradual rollout that's done
- 51:51intelligently. Rome was not
- 51:52built in a day. You know, the
- 51:54journey of a thousand miles
- 51:55begins with a single step. I
- 51:57think it's a great thing to
- 51:58aspire to that every child in
- 52:00Kentucky has the opportunity to
- 52:01go to preschool, but it takes
- 52:02people like us, people like the
- 52:04chairs here who are worked on
- 52:05these work, these working
- 52:06groups, these task forces to
- 52:08find these long term solutions
- 52:09that aren't just about let me
- 52:10pass something right now
- 52:11because I have a reelection
- 52:13coming up in a few months. What
- 52:14can we build? What seeds can we
- 52:16plant now that maybe after I'm
- 52:18already retired from the
- 52:19legislature, we'll be able to
- 52:20reap those and we'll be able to
- 52:22sit in the shade of that tree.
- 52:23>> So this question from his
- 52:25time is dwindling. Julie from
- 52:26Powell County, she says, quote,
- 52:27is there any consideration for
- 52:29policy or financial backing for
- 52:30summer programs through public
- 52:31schools to offer child care
- 52:33services when it's needed? For
- 52:34those underage kids of working
- 52:36parents?
- 52:38>> Well, a lot of that depends
- 52:39on whether or not the program
- 52:42is licensed or not. Public
- 52:44schools often have licensed
- 52:46after school programs, licensed
- 52:48summer programs, and if the
- 52:50program is regulated by the
- 52:52state, then they have the
- 52:53ability for those families to
- 52:55go and apply for the child care
- 52:56Assistance program, the subsidy
- 52:58program. And we're looking at
- 53:00families up to 85% of the state
- 53:03median income. As far as
- 53:05eligibility. They have the
- 53:07ability to qualify, and then
- 53:09the state says, where which
- 53:11center are you going to with
- 53:12this? So all of our programs
- 53:14are required to be in the all
- 53:17star program. And if you're in
- 53:19all stars, then you can accept
- 53:21that child care assistance
- 53:24after an annual training to
- 53:26remind you how to be good
- 53:28stewards of those funds.
- 53:30>> Yeah. So we've talked about
- 53:31House Bill six. We've talked
- 53:32about Senate Bill 191. And I
- 53:34think Senate Bill 160. What
- 53:35else are we missing? Is there
- 53:37another piece that's going to
- 53:38be a part of this maybe omnibus
- 53:40child care measure?
- 53:42>> You know, I think the one
- 53:43primary thing that we're
- 53:44missing in all this is the
- 53:46investment. And when we start
- 53:48looking at our kids as an
- 53:51investment and we do away with
- 53:53the conversation about
- 53:54subsidizing private businesses,
- 53:57and I agree, it's going to take
- 53:58every delivery model that we
- 54:01have to get us where we need to
- 54:03be. And it it's about our
- 54:05child's our children's
- 54:07development. It's about child
- 54:08care centers succeeding. It's
- 54:10about schools succeeding. It's
- 54:11about parents being able to
- 54:13work. It's about our economy.
- 54:15There are so many factors that
- 54:17go into this, but we're going
- 54:19to have to make a substantial
- 54:22investment to make sure that we
- 54:23get where we need to be. It
- 54:25needs to be a gradual growth.
- 54:27But that's what we're missing
- 54:28in this entire argument. And
- 54:30getting our legislature to look
- 54:32at it from that perspective. I
- 54:35think that's what where we're
- 54:37lacking and where we're going
- 54:38to need to be if we're going to
- 54:40be successful in the future. So
- 54:41many things hinge on it. We're
- 54:43going to have to invest in it
- 54:45and look at it as an investment.
- 54:46>> Well, House Bill 500, the
- 54:48state executive budget is in
- 54:49you all's court, right? Are you
- 54:51going to get your hands on a
- 54:52piece of that.
- 54:53>> And. You know and I hope.
- 54:55>> We do an investment. And,
- 54:57you know, one of the
- 54:58differences in the bill that
- 54:59I'm proposing with 191, that
- 55:00funding would go to every child
- 55:02care center, not just those
- 55:04that are two, three, four, and
- 55:06five stars. And so it would
- 55:08promote growth at every level,
- 55:09and there would be revenue that
- 55:10comes in that would allow some
- 55:12of those smaller centers to be
- 55:14able to reinvest in their
- 55:16facility and grow and improve
- 55:18quality and expand and bring
- 55:20new entrepreneurs in. So it's
- 55:22that type of on the private
- 55:24side of it, there has to be an
- 55:26ability to survive and, you
- 55:28know, and raise your family on
- 55:30the revenue that you create. If
- 55:31we can't get to that point, we
- 55:33can't succeed. And that's
- 55:35that's got to happen. And I
- 55:36hope that we start making some
- 55:38investments in the public and
- 55:39private sector as we move
- 55:41forward.
- 55:41>> Well, thank you all for the
- 55:43investment of your time. This
- 55:44has been a really good
- 55:45conversation. Most of you have
- 55:46been in this venue before, and
- 55:48you can tell that you are very
- 55:50interested stakeholders who
- 55:51work very collaboratively. So
- 55:53thank you so much for being
- 55:54here, and you can keep up with
- 55:56what's happening in Frankfort.
- 55:57We will be there all day
- 55:59tomorrow. You can watch that
- 56:00online and on our on air
- 56:03channel. And next Monday night
- 56:05we will not be here because we
- 56:06will have special programing,
- 56:08but you can keep in touch with
- 56:09everything that's happening in
- 56:11Frankfort. Weeknights at 630
- 56:12eastern, 530 Central on
- 56:14Kentucky edition. And of course,
- 56:15Bill Bryant and a panel of
- 56:17working journalists will be
- 56:18here on Friday night to go over
- 56:20the news of the week. And
- 56:21that's at eight eastern, seven
- 56:22central right here on KET.
- 56:24Thanks for watching. Have a
- 56:25great night and I'll see you
- 56:26tomorrow night.