Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Confirmation Bias & Folk Psychology: Why Common Sense Fails
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. What if
- 0:02I told you that punching a pillow when you're
- 0:04fuming mad is, well, actually the absolute worst
- 0:07thing you can do. Or that if you were just put
- 0:09in a small room for long enough, you could easily
- 0:11be convinced to confess to a horrific crime you
- 0:14didn't even commit. Right, because usually when
- 0:16people think about studying human behavior, there's
- 0:18this underlying assumption that we already, you
- 0:20know... kind of know how it all works. We live
- 0:22in human society. We talk to people every day.
- 0:24So we just think we have this innate, gut -level
- 0:28understanding of the world. It's an illusion
- 0:30of expertise, really. Just by being human, we
- 0:33assume we are experts on humanity. Oh, absolutely.
- 0:36I always thought of it like a moral compass.
- 0:38We assume we have this internal navigation system
- 0:41that just instinctively points to true north.
- 0:43Like, we think we know right from wrong or true
- 0:46from false just by feeling it in our gut. But
- 0:49as we are quickly learning this semester, that
- 0:52internal compass is actually incredibly glitchy.
- 0:56Glitchy might be a massive understatement, honestly.
- 0:59But I'm really glad we are sitting down to do
- 1:01this deep dive into the source material today.
- 1:04Same here, because that faulty internal compass
- 1:07is the core of what we need to study. And since
- 1:10we're both navigating our way through our psychology
- 1:12degree, we are inviting you to study along with
- 1:15us. Today we are pulling straight from chapter
- 1:17one of our Research Methods in Psychology textbook,
- 1:19the Canadian edition specifically. Which we love.
- 1:22We do. And the whole mission of this chapter
- 1:24is to explore why relying on everyday common
- 1:27sense to understand human behavior is just a
- 1:30massive trap. So we're going to unpack four critical
- 1:33terms. from the reading that explain why we are
- 1:36so easily fooled by our own brains, and more
- 1:40importantly, how the scientific method actually
- 1:42provides a fix. But I guess before we can look
- 1:44at how to fix the glitch, we really have to define
- 1:46the glitch itself. Right. The textbook calls
- 1:48this overarching problem folk psychology. Folk
- 1:51psychology. Yeah. Formally, it refers to our
- 1:54intuitive beliefs about people's behavior, their
- 1:57thoughts, and their feelings. It's that collective
- 2:00common sense. A culture just completely accepts
- 2:03this fact without demanding any actual proof.
- 2:06I actually came up with a way to remember this
- 2:08for the midterm. You just think of folk psychology
- 2:11as folklore. Oh, that's clever. Yeah, think of
- 2:14it like stories passed down around a metaphorical
- 2:17campfire. They sound deeply true. They have this
- 2:19nice narrative arc, but they usually lack any
- 2:22hard empirical evidence. Folklore is for campfires,
- 2:26not for science. That's a really good mental
- 2:29tag. Yeah. And the real danger of this folklore
- 2:31is just how convincing it is. I mean, the textbook
- 2:34highlights this with the catharsis myth. Oh,
- 2:37man, this one completely blew my mind because
- 2:39it goes against literally everything you see
- 2:41in movies or hear from, like pop psychology life
- 2:44coaches online. The whole idea of letting your
- 2:46anger out. Exactly. Folk psychology tells us
- 2:49that anger is like steam in a pressure cooker.
- 2:52If you don't release the valve. You know, by
- 2:54punching a pillow or screaming into the void
- 2:56or going to one of those smash rooms to break
- 2:58plates, you're just going to explode. It feels
- 3:01incredibly intuitive. The pressure cooker metaphor
- 3:03makes perfect physical sense to us. But the textbook
- 3:06cites a landmark study that completely dismantled
- 3:09this. Wait, really? Yeah. The researchers actually
- 3:12tested what happens when people vent. They deliberately
- 3:15made participants angry, basically by giving
- 3:18them terrible, insulting feedback on an essay
- 3:20they wrote. Wow. Right. And then they gave some
- 3:23of them a chance to hit a punching bag while
- 3:25thinking about the person who insulted them.
- 3:27So you would think that group would feel so much
- 3:29better, like they got it out of their system.
- 3:31But they didn't. When they were given a chance
- 3:33to retaliate later by blasting their opponent
- 3:35with loud noises, the people who hit the punching
- 3:37bag were actually way more aggressive than the
- 3:40people who just sat quietly and did nothing.
- 3:42Why, though? Mechanistically, what is actually
- 3:44happening in the brain? Well, when you punch
- 3:47a pillow, You aren't releasing anger, you are
- 3:50rehearsing it. Oh, wow. Rehearsing it. Exactly.
- 3:54The physical act of hitting something keeps your
- 3:56physiological arousal really high. Your heart
- 3:59rate stays up, your adrenaline is pumping. You
- 4:01are essentially training your brain's neural
- 4:03pathways to associate the feeling of frustration
- 4:06with the physical act of aggression. But folk
- 4:09psychology completely ignores that biological
- 4:12mechanism because the old venting steam story
- 4:14just feels so good to believe. Right, it feels
- 4:17right, but it's completely backward. That is
- 4:19so wild, and the second example from the text
- 4:21is even heavier, I think. False confessions.
- 4:24Yeah. That section was intense. Because my glitchy
- 4:27internal compass immediately says, well, I would
- 4:29never confess to a crime I didn't commit unless
- 4:31someone was literally physically torturing me.
- 4:35Therefore, if someone is on tape confessing,
- 4:37they have to be guilty. End of story. I think
- 4:40most people believe they would definitely hold
- 4:42out. But the research proved that false confessions
- 4:45are shockingly common, and they happen without
- 4:48any physical torture at all. I genuinely struggled
- 4:51with this part of the chapter. I just can't fathom
- 4:53signing my name to a murder I didn't commit.
- 4:56How does the textbook explain that actually happening
- 4:59in reality? It comes down to psychological pressure
- 5:01cookers that our common sense just can't comprehend
- 5:04until we're actually in them. Imagine you are
- 5:09incredibly sleep deprived. isolated in a tiny
- 5:12room for 16 hours. And authority figures are
- 5:16relentlessly lying to you. They're saying they
- 5:18have your DNA at the scene. That sounds terrifying.
- 5:22It is. Eventually, this profound cognitive exhaustion
- 5:25sets in. People reach a point where they believe
- 5:28that if they just confess right now to stop the
- 5:31interrogation, the actual evidence will clear
- 5:34them later. So they think... I'll say whatever
- 5:36they want so I can just go to sleep and tomorrow
- 5:38the DNA will prove I'm innocent. Exactly. Which
- 5:41is terrifying because the confession usually
- 5:43overrides whatever evidence comes later anyway.
- 5:46You know I was thinking about this last night
- 5:47and it's fascinating to connect this back to
- 5:50ancient moral or religious traditions. How so?
- 5:53Think about how many ancient texts explicitly
- 5:56teach patience. They emphasize turning the other
- 5:58cheek or sitting quietly with your wrath or valuing
- 6:01a quiet spirit over a loud one. Oh, that's true.
- 6:04A lot of ancient wisdom traditions basically
- 6:06mandate emotional regulation rather than explosive
- 6:09reactions. Right. And for a long time, modern
- 6:12society kind of mocked that. Our modern common
- 6:14sense was like, no, that's unhealthy repression.
- 6:16You need to vent your truth. But empirical science
- 6:19perfectly backs up that ancient moral teaching.
- 6:22Exactly. Venting is actually the destructive
- 6:25move. It just shows that sometimes carefully
- 6:29observed behavioral truths passed down over centuries
- 6:33actually align with scientific findings, while
- 6:36the snappy modern folk psychology we invent turns
- 6:39out to be totally toxic. It's a great observation.
- 6:42It brings up a huge problem, though. If folk
- 6:44psychology is so flawed, just how much of our
- 6:47everyday reality is built on this completely
- 6:50unverified folklore? Basically everything I mean
- 6:53the textbook references a book called 50 great
- 6:56myths is popular psychology These aren't obscure
- 6:58fringe theories, you know, no, these are things
- 7:00that literally everyone including us probably
- 7:03believed until this week Let's take the learning
- 7:05styles myth. This is a massive one for us as
- 7:07students Oh for sure the belief that students
- 7:10learn best when teaching styles are matched to
- 7:12their specific learning style Like visual versus
- 7:14auditory learners. I have had teachers in high
- 7:17school spend whole days testing us on our learning
- 7:20styles. They say, oh, you're a kinesthetic learner.
- 7:23You need to touch things. The problem is when
- 7:25researchers actually test this in controlled
- 7:27environments, adapting a lesson to a visual learner
- 7:30by giving them more diagrams doesn't actually
- 7:33improve their long -term retention or test scores
- 7:36compared to standard teaching methods. But wait,
- 7:38why do teachers believe it so strongly? I mean,
- 7:40I definitely prefer watching a video over reading
- 7:43a textbook. Preference is the key word there.
- 7:46People definitely have preferences for how they
- 7:48take in information. But preference does not
- 7:50equal cognitive encoding. So just because I like
- 7:53the video more doesn't mean my brain is forming
- 7:55stronger neural connections with the material.
- 7:58Exactly. But the myth persists because it feels
- 8:01good. It gives the student an excuse. Like, I
- 8:04didn't f— fail because I didn't study, I failed
- 8:06because the teacher didn't cater to my visual
- 8:09learning style. It lets everyone off the hook.
- 8:11Okay, what about the 10 % brain myth? Oh, the
- 8:14idea that human beings only use 10 % of their
- 8:16brain power. Every sci -fi movie uses that premise.
- 8:20Limitless, Lucy. But scientifically, we use all
- 8:23of our brain. Even when we're sleeping, almost
- 8:26the whole brain is active. So why do we cling
- 8:28to that one? Mostly because of the promise it
- 8:30holds. If we only use 10%, that means we have
- 8:3390 % untapped potential. It's an incredibly seductive
- 8:37piece of folklore. Totally. It tells us we could
- 8:40be geniuses if we just found the right trick
- 8:42to unlock the rest of our minds. Okay, I have
- 8:44to stop here because this is driving me crazy.
- 8:47If literally everyone believes these myths like
- 8:51our teachers, our parents, professionals, how
- 8:54are human beings wired so badly? What do you
- 8:56mean? How do we universally accept things as
- 8:59absolute facts when they are so easily disproven
- 9:01by a quick look at an MRI scan or a basic classroom
- 9:04study? Well, it's a fair question, but we aren't
- 9:06necessarily wired badly. We are just fundamentally
- 9:09limited by our biology. Forming truly accurate
- 9:12beliefs from scratch requires massive cognitive
- 9:15resources. You would need perfect. unbiased powers
- 9:19of observation, flawless memory of every event
- 9:22you've ever witnessed, and intense analytical
- 9:25calculation to weigh all the variables. Which
- 9:27obviously nobody has. I can barely remember what
- 9:29I have for breakfast. Same. Because we don't
- 9:32have the cognitive processing power to evaluate
- 9:34every single piece of data in our environment,
- 9:37our brains have to adapt. We rely on mental shortcuts.
- 9:41And in psychology, these shortcuts are called
- 9:43heuristics. Heuristics. I actually have a perfect
- 9:45analogy for heuristics. Think of them as your
- 9:48brain's autocorrect feature. Oh, I like that.
- 9:50When you are texting rapidly, autocorrect saves
- 9:53you a ton of time, right? It guesses what you
- 9:55mean so you don't have to perfectly type every
- 9:58single letter. Most of the time, it works and
- 10:00keeps you moving. but when it assumes the wrong
- 10:02word. Yes. When it changes definitely to defiantly,
- 10:06it fails spectacularly, and suddenly the message
- 10:09you send is completely wrong. That works perfectly.
- 10:12Heuristics are mental autocorrect. If a belief
- 10:15is widely shared, especially if it is endorsed
- 10:18by people we view as authority figures, our brain
- 10:20just autocorrects to, well, this must be true.
- 10:22It saves us the cognitive energy of having to
- 10:25independently verify the 10 % brain myth. Exactly.
- 10:29But once that autocorrect makes a decision, it
- 10:32seems like we refuse to change it, even when
- 10:34someone points out the typo. So what's that about?
- 10:37That's the second psychological mechanism locking
- 10:39the folklore into place. Confirmation bias. Right,
- 10:43confirmation bias. This is our tendency to focus
- 10:45intensely on cases that confirm our intuitive
- 10:47beliefs while completely dismissing or ignoring
- 10:51cases that disprove them. The textbook gives
- 10:53a really great everyday example of this. Let's
- 10:56say your folk psychology tells you that women
- 10:59are naturally more talkative than men. Okay.
- 11:01Once that heuristic is in place, your confirmation
- 11:04bias takes the wheel. Every time you are at a
- 11:07party and you see a woman talking animatedly,
- 11:09your brain goes, aha. Proof. See, women are so
- 11:13talkative. But consider what happens when you
- 11:15see a silent woman at that same party or a guy
- 11:17who will not stop talking. Your brain just deletes
- 11:19it. It doesn't even register as data. You only
- 11:22see the evidence that confirms the story you
- 11:24already told yourself. And this mechanism gets
- 11:26even stronger when emotions are involved. We
- 11:29often hold incorrect beliefs simply because it
- 11:31would be nice if they were true. It's called
- 11:34the wishful thinking heuristic. The textbook
- 11:36talks about weight loss with this, right? Yes.
- 11:39Millions of people deeply believe that simple
- 11:41calorie reducing diets are an effective long
- 11:44-term treatment for obesity. Eat less, lose weight,
- 11:47keep it off. It sounds incredibly logical. And
- 11:50it would be really nice and simple if it were
- 11:52true. Exactly. But a thorough review of the scientific
- 11:55evidence shows that long -term, these diets generally
- 11:58are not effective. Really? Yeah. People lose
- 12:01weight initially, but biological set points and
- 12:04metabolic adaptations almost always push the
- 12:06weight back on over a few years. The science
- 12:08shows obesity is a vastly complex systemic and
- 12:11biological issue. But the belief in simple diets
- 12:14persists wildly. Because the alternative that
- 12:17the problem is incredibly complex, genetically
- 12:19linked, and very difficult to solve. is really
- 12:22unpleasant. You want to believe we have total
- 12:24simple control over our bodies. Wow. You know,
- 12:27applying this confirmation bias to how we judge
- 12:29right and wrong is pretty chilling. How do you
- 12:31mean? Think about how this plays into moral judgments
- 12:35or prejudice against certain groups. If your
- 12:38cultural folklore tells you that a certain demographic
- 12:40of people is dangerous or immoral, your confirmation
- 12:44bias is going to hyper focus on every single
- 12:47bad thing one person in that group does. Oh for
- 12:50sure. You will point to the news and say see
- 12:52I was right. Well, your brain completely filters
- 12:55out the thousands of kind, law abiding, mundane
- 12:59things done by everyone else in that exact same
- 13:02group. It is an autopilot mechanism that leads
- 13:04directly to prejudice. Our brains autocorrect
- 13:06is literally generating bigotry because it is
- 13:09too lazy to look at the whole picture. If we
- 13:12just trust our glitchy internal compass, we're
- 13:15going to walk right off an ethical cliff. So
- 13:17knowing all of this, knowing about folk psychology,
- 13:19heuristics and confirmation bias, how do we fix
- 13:22the glitch? How do we supervise our brains autocorrect?
- 13:26The textbook says we have to deliberately cultivate
- 13:29the critical thinking attitudes used by scientific
- 13:31psychologists, and the first tool they give us
- 13:33is skepticism. Okay, skepticism. But I need to
- 13:36clarify something, because the word skeptic has
- 13:38a lot of baggage. When I hear it, I immediately
- 13:40picture a cynical internet troll who refuses
- 13:43to believe anything, who just argues in the comments
- 13:46for the sake of arguing. That is a very common
- 13:49misunderstanding. In science, Skepticism does
- 13:52not mean being a cynic or distrusting everything
- 13:55on principle. So what is it? Skepticism is simply
- 13:58an action. It means pausing. It is taking a breath
- 14:02to consider alternatives and actively searching
- 14:05for systematically collected empirical evidence
- 14:07before you accept a claim. It's literally just
- 14:09hitting the pause button before you hit send
- 14:11on that autocorrected text. That's a great way
- 14:13to put it. Let's walk through the textbook's
- 14:15example of how a scientist actually applies this.
- 14:18Imagine you are reading an article claiming that
- 14:20giving children a weekly allowance is a fantastic
- 14:23way to help them develop financial responsibility.
- 14:25Folks, psychology at its finest. Give them money,
- 14:28they learn to manage it. A non -skeptic accepts
- 14:31that and moves on. A scientific skeptic pauses.
- 14:36They generate an alternative hypothesis. They
- 14:39ask, is it possible that receiving an allowance
- 14:41actually teaches children how to spend money
- 14:45without earning it? Could it make them more materialistic?
- 14:48You force your brain to look for the counter
- 14:50narrative. Then you look for the mechanism. You
- 14:53ask, has anyone actually run a controlled study
- 14:55on this? Did they take two groups of identical
- 14:57kids, give one an allowance, deny the other,
- 15:00and track their financial habits into adulthood?
- 15:02And what's wild about this specific allowance
- 15:04example is that when you look for the evidence,
- 15:06there isn't any. Right. The textbook points out
- 15:09that there is currently no systematic scientific
- 15:11evidence proving allowances make kids responsible.
- 15:15but there is also no evidence proving it makes
- 15:17them materialistic. Exactly. The data just isn't
- 15:20there yet, which is incredibly frustrating. And
- 15:22that frustration leads us to the final and maybe
- 15:24the most difficult concept for today, tolerance
- 15:28for uncertainty. The acceptance of the unknown.
- 15:31Because there is often not enough systematically
- 15:33collected evidence to fully evaluate a claim,
- 15:37scientists have to cultivate the psychological
- 15:38strength to say, I do not know. Which is so hard
- 15:42to do. It is. They accept that the universe is
- 15:45full of mysteries they haven't solved yet, and
- 15:47they intentionally withhold judgment until the
- 15:49data arrives. Humans hate not knowing. We just
- 15:53crave closure. We want the world to be organized
- 15:56into neat little predictable boxes, which is
- 15:58exactly why we invent the folklore in the first
- 16:00place. We'd rather have a wrong answer than no
- 16:03answer at all. This actually ties perfectly into
- 16:05your earlier point about ancient traditions and
- 16:07morality. Think about the concept of faith. Like
- 16:11religious faith? Yes. In its deepest sense, true
- 16:14faith isn't about arrogantly claiming to know
- 16:16every single secret of the cosmos. Real faith
- 16:20requires the moral fortitude to accept that human
- 16:22beings are deeply limited. Oh, I see where you're
- 16:25going with this. It requires accepting that we
- 16:27cannot completely know the mind of the universe.
- 16:29and that we must tolerate the mystery of existence.
- 16:32That is a brilliant parallel. Just as religious
- 16:35faith requires the humility to sit with existential
- 16:38mystery, empirical science requires a tolerance
- 16:41for uncertainty. Absolutely. Both of them, at
- 16:44their absolute core, require massive humility.
- 16:47You have to be able to look at a complex world
- 16:49and admit, I don't have all the answers right
- 16:51now, and I have to be okay with that. They both
- 16:53demand that you stop pretending your glitchy
- 16:56internal compass is flawless. All right, as we
- 16:59wrap up our study session, let's look at the
- 17:01big picture of what we've covered from chapter
- 17:03one. We started with folk psychology, that campfire
- 17:06folklore we use to explain the world without
- 17:08any evidence, like thinking venting our anger
- 17:11is a good idea. Then we looked at how our limited
- 17:13processing power relies on heuristics, which
- 17:16inevitably leads to confirmation bias, those
- 17:19mental blinders that force us to only see what
- 17:22we already believe while ignoring everything
- 17:24that contradicts us. To fight back against that,
- 17:27we have to practice skepticism, not being a grumpy
- 17:30cynic, but just pausing, taking a breath to ask
- 17:32for the data before we accept a claim. And finally,
- 17:35we have to develop a tolerance for uncertainty,
- 17:38having the humility to withhold our judgment
- 17:40when the evidence simply isn't there yet. I feel
- 17:43significantly more prepared for this midterm,
- 17:45but maybe a little less confident in my own brain,
- 17:48which I guess is the point. Before we close the
- 17:50book, what is the final thought you want to leave
- 17:52us with today? I want to leave you with a direct
- 17:55challenge. Tomorrow morning, I want you to look
- 17:58at a deeply held moral or practical belief that
- 18:03you operate on every single day. Maybe it's how
- 18:06you judge a certain group of people, maybe it's
- 18:08how you handle conflict in your relationships,
- 18:10or even just how you approach your own study
- 18:12habits. Ask yourself, is this belief actually
- 18:15grounded in systematically collected evidence?
- 18:18Or is it just a comforting piece of folk psychology
- 18:21you've accepted because it makes you feel safe?
- 18:24What would happen if you applied a little scientific
- 18:26skepticism to your own absolute certainties?
- 18:29Would your compass point in a completely different
- 18:31direction? It's definitely something to think
- 18:32about. Thanks for doing this deep dive with us
- 18:35today on The Psychology Undergrad. Keep pausing,
- 18:38keep looking for the evidence, and we'll see
- 18:40you next time.