Latest / Thacher Report / The Democrats Are Irrelevant, Forever?
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, everyone. It's been a long time.
- 0:03I know you're not supposed to start a podcast by saying that,
- 0:05but it's been a little fitful for me.
- 0:08Big news. I had a son, a beautiful baby boy.
- 0:12Everyone is healthy and well. It's definitely taken all of my focus, and it's just been a joy.
- 0:19Okay, so a lot's been going on since my latest podcast episode.
- 0:26I continue to write more regularly, not as often as I'd like,
- 0:31on my sub stack. So that's Zachary Thatcher.
- 0:34If you know how to spell my name, Thatcher Report, you'll find it.
- 0:38If you don't know how to spell my name, it's T-H-A-C-H-E-R Report, no middle T.
- 0:44So something I've been thinking about, and I have a really lucky friendship
- 0:49with a senior journalist at a fancy big news organization who's a lifelong childhood friend,
- 0:56doesn't matter what he does for a living, he's a really smart guy in any context,
- 0:59but he's very plugged in.
- 1:01We come from almost the exact same milieu of this kind of Jewish, mixed Jewish, liberal.
- 1:10We were born in the early 70s. And so we have a lot in common.
- 1:15And he's a particularly articulate, educated, and passionate person and just
- 1:21an all-around mensch. So I always enjoy dialoguing with him about anything.
- 1:27And we often have some kind of disagreements because while we overlap so closely
- 1:33in our lives, we maybe, if we point a ship in one degree different direction,
- 1:38you know, 30 years later, or in this case, 50 years later, we're in slightly
- 1:43different places, but lots of overlap.
- 1:46So that's a big preamble of saying that,
- 1:49We all come from a blue Massachusetts Democrat, you know, through and through perspective.
- 1:55And I've been sort of surprising myself that I'm off the Democrats.
- 1:59I think they're a disaster, a total train wreck. I voted for Kamala Harris happily.
- 2:05I wanted her to win, obviously.
- 2:07But there are a lot of questions like, why did she lose?
- 2:11Why are the past elections been so close? I have some ideas about that,
- 2:17but it shouldn't have been close with Donald Trump in 2016. It shouldn't have been close in 2020.
- 2:24It shouldn't have been close in 2024.
- 2:27And so, is that about Trump or is that about the Democrats not having a political
- 2:33product that people want? I am not a Republican.
- 2:36I come from a very blue family. We'll hear about that in a minute.
- 2:42I focus my analysis and interests and insights onto the Democrats because,
- 2:48as I was sharing with my friend, if there's a fire, if there's an arsonist setting
- 2:54a fire, where the hell are the firefighters?
- 2:57I can't focus on the arsonist.
- 3:00I don't really understand Trump's motivations and certainly the entire Republican
- 3:06Party's capitulation to him.
- 3:07But I do think I understand the Democrats and where ostensibly they're coming
- 3:14from because that's where I've been coming from.
- 3:17So, I'm making a parallel in this pod to the Labour Party of Israel,
- 3:23not the United Kingdom, but of Israel, also called Avuda, which means work.
- 3:29And it's been a really interesting political history in Israel since the early
- 3:361990s with the signing of the Oslo Accords.
- 3:39Everything changed really dramatically, not in ways that are anticipated.
- 3:44So I'm going to read from my latest substack at the Thatcher Report and digress.
- 3:51So over 30 years ago, that was the 1993 Oslo Accords. Yours truly was in Jerusalem
- 3:55at the time as a college student.
- 3:57And I was studying with Michael Oren. So it was a super amazing position to
- 4:01be as a young man to see these giant changes.
- 4:04When the Oslo Accords were signed in 93, it ushered in a very,
- 4:09very new era for the Middle East.
- 4:11The Labour Party, which is the party that actually created the state of Israel
- 4:15and held power on and off, mostly on since 1948, took the bold initiative to
- 4:23make peace with Israel's nearest and most confounding enemy.
- 4:26Not only would diplomacy create safe borders for Israel and birth a new nation
- 4:31for stateless Palestinians, it would also, secondarily,
- 4:35catalyze a wider, bigger, more dramatic peace process, ultimately manifesting
- 4:40with Saudi Arabia, and therefore all of the Arab states, acknowledging Israel.
- 4:45Note that I say acknowledging Israel. God forbid the Arab states accept,
- 4:51love, and cherish other people who are not Arab Muslim states.
- 4:55No, that's asking too much in that region. Just to acknowledge that Israel has
- 5:00the right to exist is the issue that remains. In 2025, Israel was founded in 1948.
- 5:08So, you do the DEI math there. Why?
- 5:11Why can't? Why is it in Riyadh so hard? for them to accept Israeli sovereignty of 10 million people.
- 5:20The pathology of Arabism, racism against Jews and how it's mimicked in Columbia
- 5:27University is a subject for a different conversation.
- 5:30So at the time, in the 90s, with the signing of the Oslo Accords,
- 5:35the idea was that those massive landwards of 1967, 1973, those are all going
- 5:42to be in the rearview mirror.
- 5:43The future would have free trade, economic growth, and peaceful coexistence between,
- 5:48remember, a tiny Jewish state, about 10 million now, in a vast Arab region that
- 5:55stretches all the way from the Atlantic Ocean to the Arabian Sea,
- 5:59about half a billion people.
- 6:02And the center-left party at the time in Israel, they delivered the goods.
- 6:05And that would mean they would continue dominating Israeli politics for decades and decades to come.
- 6:11Prominent journalists in America, like Thomas Friedman, promised that this was
- 6:15the case. He had been saying it for so many years.
- 6:18Israel making peace with Palestinians would act as a linchpin for peace across the entire region.
- 6:23Later, that same journalist would tell us that the Israeli withdrawal from Gaza
- 6:27in 2005 could make it a new Singapore.
- 6:30And he also supported the Iraq War.
- 6:33But the same journalist and all of his other experts and colleagues at various
- 6:39news organizations in the State Department, they and universities,
- 6:43they warned that if peace didn't happen between Israelis and Palestinians,
- 6:47then nothing good would follow.
- 6:48This was the little thing of, OK, at the time, you know, under 10 million people,
- 6:53that was the whole make a deal with these two groups and then paradise will follow.
- 6:59So, at the time, the Labor Party that signed the Oslo Accords was helmed by
- 7:05these quasi-mythic founding fathers, Yitzhak Rabin, Shimon Peres.
- 7:10These are not, this is like saying George Washington.
- 7:12These are, not exactly, but these are Alexander Hamilton type of guys.
- 7:16And they told us that they had finally found a partner in peace,
- 7:20and however hard and reluctant and impossible it all seemed,
- 7:23that handshake on the White House lawn between Rabin and PLO founder Yasser
- 7:27Arafat meant that the Palestinian militias and revolutionary organizations would
- 7:32soon become a peaceful national government. A democracy, even.
- 7:36So you know the rest. I can get a little sarcastic about it.
- 7:39But in a sequence of monumental diplomatic events between Arafat and the Palestinians,
- 7:45and the very top tier of the most powerful person in the globe,
- 7:50the American president, Arafat denied the deals.
- 7:53And instead of coming up with a viable counteroffer, if he didn't like the president's
- 7:57offers, he launched a second intifada. A little bit more complicated.
- 8:02Hamas and others were going to maybe do it anyways. Arafat went along with it
- 8:05because otherwise he would lose power.
- 8:07And you know what happened. Thousands and thousands of people died.
- 8:10And diplomacy, this diplomatic effort that was going to change everything,
- 8:14just seemed like a cruel joke to the parents of children blown up in terror
- 8:18attacks and pizza parlors in Jerusalem and to the Palestinians killed by the Israeli military.
- 8:23The dreams were dashed. So now what's the historical perspective?
- 8:28Oslo Accords sounds antiquated. It sounds like ancient history.
- 8:33Those books are gathering dust.
- 8:35Wars are continuing, Gaza, Lebanon, Syria.
- 8:38But there's also been peace. All that linchpin talk about the Palestinians wasn't true.
- 8:44The Abraham Accords now has kind of quasi-peace status between several Arab
- 8:50nations and Israel. That was unthinkable before.
- 8:54And then what else happened? Well, there were elections. Palestinians elected
- 8:58Mahmoud Abbas as prime minister, and then they had legislative elections afterwards,
- 9:02and guess what? They voted for Hamas.
- 9:05President Jimmy Carter, formerly, who just passed away, verified the elections.
- 9:10These were fair elections. They were very, very well held.
- 9:12It's pretty impressive. Hamas won.
- 9:16And the Palestinian Authority, helmed by Abbas, learned its lesson,
- 9:20and that's why there's never been an election since the early 2000s,
- 9:23and the Palestinian Authority, or any Palestinians, don't get the vote,
- 9:26because they chose a terror organization.
- 9:29So that collapsed. And then what also collapsed is the Labor Party in Israel.
- 9:33It's like saying the Democratic Party in America, but even more.
- 9:37It's even more important.
- 9:39And labor, kind of like the Democrats, was out back in the 90s.
- 9:46And now the coups, kind of like the Republicans, are in.
- 9:49And they've been in for decades and decades.
- 9:52And maybe it's forever. Maybe it's a complete new realignment that doesn't seem
- 9:58like it's changing anytime soon. And people talk about Netanyahu.
- 10:01They don't talk about Likud going away.
- 10:04So, and even further proof to this is October 7th, 2023, when Hamas terrorists
- 10:09killed 1,200 Israelis and took so many hostages.
- 10:12That changed a lot in Israel. It changed their entire war strategies, security strategies.
- 10:19It's an ongoing change. It's not done yet. What didn't change?
- 10:22The relevance of the Labor Party.
- 10:24Out of 120 possible Knesset seats, they hold four.
- 10:30And they don't even hold all four of them. They share them with merits,
- 10:34which is an even more, which is sort of like saying this, the squad,
- 10:36a more progressive version of the left.
- 10:39And I believe they call themselves the Democrats. I don't know.
- 10:41It doesn't make any sense to me. They have four seats. They're completely irrelevant.
- 10:45I think you can see where I'm going with this argument. And Netanyahu has been
- 10:50the longest serving prime minister in Israeli history.
- 10:53And doesn't matter what you think about him, he has power.
- 10:56And the only person I think who could appreciate this is Thomas Friedman,
- 11:00who still also has a column published by the New York Times,
- 11:04despite being wrong most of the time.
- 11:06And we're being wrong enough at the time that nobody should ever read him ever again.
- 11:09But there you go. These two guys are sitting pretty, making their money.
- 11:15Leading people who follow them, and therefore the other people don't have any power.
- 11:22And I don't have a job at the New York Times, but Thomas Friedman does.
- 11:26So, Netanyahu is prime minister. Nobody else poses much of a threat to him right now.
- 11:31His health is not good, unfortunately, for him and his family.
- 11:35So, it's not going to be forever, but it's not a political threat.
- 11:40And my argument is that this, what happened in Israel over the past 30 years
- 11:45is happening right now in America.
- 11:47Now, it's really different. We're in a two-party system. But the Democratic
- 11:51Party is diminishing by the hour.
- 11:53The Klieg lights are growing dim.
- 11:57And can I prove it? Why were all the elections so close with Donald Trump,
- 12:01who seems completely insane to most people?
- 12:04Now, he might be right about a lot of things. That's a different conversation.
- 12:08He might be reading tea leaves in a way that nobody's ever read them before.
- 12:11But he's certainly an authoritarian.
- 12:14I don't think he's really going to make much of a difference for working or poor people.
- 12:20But he's popular, and therefore the Democrats are not popular.
- 12:24It's really, really, really simple marketing here.
- 12:28So what's going on with the Democrats? Now, I like you. You're listening to me.
- 12:32You read me. You probably know me. I'm thankful for your time.
- 12:35It would be a very, very long discussion about how ridiculous and irrelevant
- 12:40the upper Democrats have become.
- 12:42But let's just point to a couple of a couple of random things.
- 12:45One of them is Barack Obama left no party infrastructure at the federal or state
- 12:49level after he left office.
- 12:51There was like Obama for America or there was one of these kind of grassroots, you know, so exciting.
- 12:57Everything was about Obama and it was changing everything. Whatever happened to that?
- 13:02It's gone. So Obama left office, and he and his wife put their energy into insuring
- 13:09and building up their status as global celebrities, incredibly wealthy,
- 13:16creating documentaries, writing books, speaking tours.
- 13:20Doing all types of things, and that's it.
- 13:23That's their legacy. They became rich and famous.
- 13:27Sure, they're really nice people. I would be so amazed to meet them and to have
- 13:31dinner with them or something, but it's all about them and their family.
- 13:35At the DNC, Michelle Obama waxed poetic about her working class mom,
- 13:40but remind me the last time she fixed her toilet or Barack mowed the lawn.
- 13:44Remind me if their kids ever have to work, ever, to pay for anything.
- 13:50These are people who made their decision, they took the presidency,
- 13:54and they made it a profit center and a popularity center.
- 13:58Now, Trump, I think he's grossly incompetent as a manager. It's just kind of
- 14:03like a clown show and a train wreck coming together.
- 14:06I don't know how that works. Clown car, train wreck. It's just unbelievable.
- 14:10But when he was president, he passed legislation that was important to Republicans,
- 14:15the tax cuts, some criminal justice.
- 14:17He stacked the Supreme Court incredibly effectively.
- 14:20He survived two impeachments, no problem. And I think we have to be really honest here.
- 14:26If it wasn't for COVID, which was absolutely bonkers, he probably would have won in 2020.
- 14:32I mean, he came really close and he got more votes than he did in 2016.
- 14:35So I think he would have won.
- 14:37And none of Obama's massive popularity, none of it mattered the second Obama
- 14:44left office. There was no pushback. What happened?
- 14:48AOC posted on social media.
- 14:50Okay. Bernie Sanders got some attention.
- 14:53That doesn't seem very threatening to me. Okay, another big problem that the
- 14:58Democrats helped to kind of dig their own grave, not to use terrible and negative
- 15:02language like that, but what else did they do?
- 15:07Joe Biden appointed Merrick Garland as attorney general.
- 15:10Merrick Garland was going to become a Supreme Court justice,
- 15:13most likely, until Mitch McConnell blocked it.
- 15:16I would have much preferred him to be a Supreme Court justice than anybody that
- 15:19Trump appointed. He might have been good at it. We'll never know.
- 15:22But Merrick Garland was the chief law enforcement officer of this country.
- 15:26We had a former president who was clearly, I'm no judge, but he seemed guilty
- 15:32as hell of stealing documents, business fraud, election fraud,
- 15:38sedition, incitement to violence.
- 15:41We already had the civil penalties for his sexual attacks.
- 15:46He is a bad guy, and he's done some really terrible things in his life on television
- 15:51that we could just watch and see. What happened?
- 15:55Why didn't Merrick Garland go after this guy? Why did it take so long to appoint
- 15:59some kind of special counsel to give cover to Biden or whatever the logic of a special counsel is?
- 16:06It was for nothing. Merrick Garland completely screwed the pooch.
- 16:10He will go down in history as the worst attorney general in my lifetime.
- 16:14And I think he should be publicly humiliated and shamed wherever he goes in
- 16:18a respectful way, I guess, however you manage that, because it's just that was
- 16:23the opportunity and it did get done. That's Merrick Garland's fault.
- 16:28And that's Joe Biden's fault because he appointed him. And all the senators
- 16:31who supported it, they're part of it too.
- 16:33Now, the obvious last of the three points is that Joe Biden didn't step down by Christmas in 2023.
- 16:40And on top of that, the party lied about his ability to do the job.
- 16:44And this is the one I don't get. I understand why people who want power and
- 16:49they want to prop up Joe Biden because they're close to power.
- 16:52I've been in D.C. as a young guy. I was definitely not powerful.
- 16:55But the closer you get to power, the better it is for you.
- 16:58So you want to prop up your leader, right? That makes sense. That's logical.
- 17:01Why is it that every single American, sort of more liberal-leaning news organization
- 17:07with huge budgets, investigative journalists who do all types of amazing work,
- 17:11they're super prestigious, how come none of them could ferret out his true status?
- 17:17I'm not saying it's a conspiracy. I'm just saying it's a failure.
- 17:21And how do we know? We saw it on national television. I'm a complete political junkie, as you can tell.
- 17:27I don't care about the Super Bowl very much. No offense. But I love politics.
- 17:31And Biden was just an absolute disaster at that debate.
- 17:36And it was like, how come nobody wrote about that for months?
- 17:40I do not believe in conspiracy theories.
- 17:42I don't think it's some kind of massive cover-up. But it just shows you a failure.
- 17:45It's a failure of the Democrats and it's a failure of the left.
- 17:48And it's certainly a journalistic failure to go down the ages.
- 17:51There's lots of journalistic failures. They're constantly creating news.
- 17:55So there's going to be mistakes all the time.
- 17:57And there's lots of amazing wins and really important things about journalism.
- 18:01But, you know, tell me about Hillary Clinton's emails one more time,
- 18:04New York Times. I love those stories.
- 18:06And what the heck? Joe Biden, wonderful man, doesn't seem like he can do the
- 18:12job. Certainly not if the job requires running for office.
- 18:15Maybe he can maintain office, maybe, but running for office, no.
- 18:20Okay, and then a coda to Biden not stepping down is the selection of Harris.
- 18:26Why was she there in the first place, right? Kamala Harris. Biden needed South Carolina.
- 18:32James Clyburn was going to give him. The Democrat from South Carolina,
- 18:36a powerful black journalist, was going to essentially help out.
- 18:39And that's Clyburn's pound of flesh. It's got to get a black woman for Veep.
- 18:45And Kamala Harris had been running anyways and earlier. And then Biden picks her.
- 18:51And Harris was terrible running for the primaries. We're running in the primaries
- 18:56to get the nomination, but nevertheless, she's a black woman.
- 18:59She gets the job. She obviously is incredibly smart, professional.
- 19:02I think she would have been a great president in certain regards,
- 19:05other regards, probably a total disaster, but nothing to impugn her or her reputation,
- 19:10but it's a symbol, right? the Democrats believe very profoundly in the symbol of identity.
- 19:17How that's different from the KKK also believing in symbols of identity,
- 19:21I couldn't tell you. It all seems racist to me.
- 19:24But part of it was James Clyburn, and that's just political realities and exigencies.
- 19:31And so, you know, good for him for getting somebody that he wants.
- 19:34And he did deliver South Carolina to Biden.
- 19:38And that's fair. That's how politics works.
- 19:40But tell me, Clyburn, what is Harris doing for you now that she's licking her
- 19:46wounds in a mansion in Northern California?
- 19:49You know, this is just, it's really short-lived.
- 19:53Maybe on him, he gambled, whatever, he got something out of it.
- 19:56But it also points to the greater flaws of the identitarian politics of the
- 20:01left, where skin color, gender are more important than almost anything else.
- 20:07And obviously, Harris is an extremely brilliant person and totally qualified
- 20:11in other regards, but is she as qualified as other people?
- 20:15Objectively, no. She lost. So.
- 20:19Now we're telling, and I love reading these kind of news stories.
- 20:23Now there's a lot of news stories. Hair on fire.
- 20:25Trump has taken over the world. Trump's the worst thing in the universe.
- 20:29A lot of that's true. But we're also hearing that the Democratic Party is rudderless, right?
- 20:36Do you need to read that? Or can you just take a walk outside and see what's going on?
- 20:41So it is just so obvious to me that the very underpinnings of the Democratic
- 20:46Party, And by extension, the cultural and academic journalistic institutions
- 20:52that are all kind of part and parcel of the Democratic Party.
- 20:55It's not just a party. It's also a cultural movement.
- 20:58It's young people call it vibes. But it's it is it is they do.
- 21:03The Democrats don't exist purely as one little literal DNC organization.
- 21:08They have an ecosystem and they have support networks. And you don't need a
- 21:14PhD in political science, which I certainly don't have, to know that perhaps
- 21:18something is going wrong with these institutions and these groups.
- 21:23Maybe perseverating on gender and skin color, and by the way,
- 21:27accepting and perhaps endorsing mass anti-Semitism on college campuses and cultural institutions,
- 21:33maybe that's not the right focus for Americans who want to make America affordable
- 21:39again. I don't believe in MAGA.
- 21:42I can't believe I'm even talking like this. But make America affordable again
- 21:46seems like a good slogan to me that would be a lot more accurate than all the
- 21:51Trump kind of jingoistic stuff.
- 21:54And it just drives me nuts that none of these organizations seem to get it.
- 21:58And they just keep on talking about trans, BIPOC, half-poc, tri-poc. I don't know.
- 22:05They just come up with these terms, people of color. So that means that a Chinese-American
- 22:10woman had something to do with a black person, right?
- 22:14Politically or identity-wise, I don't see it.
- 22:18Maybe I have something more to do with a Black person because I live in a Black-majority
- 22:21neighborhood in Brooklyn, and a Chinese-American woman, who knows what her background is.
- 22:26If she's from Oklahoma, she has some other things going on in her life.
- 22:30I mean, it's just absurd that skin color is the hill that the left wing is going to die on.
- 22:36It's really ironic. I come from the 20th century liberals where they were fighting
- 22:40against that kind of thinking.
- 22:42But it's kind of gone full circle in a very, very, very perverse way.
- 22:46And guess what? People don't care. They don't want that.
- 22:49They want to make America affordable because it actually used to be affordable for the middle class.
- 22:56Yes, there's sexism and racism meant that it was not fairly portioned out,
- 23:02but there was a portion to give out.
- 23:05And there are seeds to that that we can take to go forward.
- 23:11So I don't, MAGA and all that stuff, a lot of that is demagoguery,
- 23:14but making America affordable, again, is not demagoguery because I have evidence that it was affordable.
- 23:22So my mom, I love her so much, I always mention her in a podcast.
- 23:27My mom is a daughter of immigrants who came here from Odessa.
- 23:31Now we would call them in the woke press or whatever you want to call it in
- 23:35the universities or just the evolution of language, we would call my grandparents
- 23:39refugees or asylum seekers.
- 23:41They didn't come here on vacation. They came here because they were going to
- 23:45get killed if they stayed in the Russian empire and the Ukrainian part of the
- 23:49Russian empire at the very beginning of the 20th century.
- 23:52So my mom grew up in the Bronx in a working class and then kind of middle,
- 23:58sort of, sort of kind of middle class-ish, but mostly working class area.
- 24:01She went to kindergarten, she went to an elite public high school she went to
- 24:06college for zero dollars.
- 24:09She lived at home to get through college with her sister sharing a room.
- 24:13So these were not people living high in the hog, but she was able to get totally
- 24:19educated for free. No debt.
- 24:22Now, that's my mom, and she turned that into a career and a mother and has done
- 24:28a lot with that education.
- 24:29And then my dad, he is a Vietnam War combat veteran, two tours.
- 24:34He was born into extreme rural poverty in northern New England and then later
- 24:41settled a little bit elsewhere in Massachusetts and lower New England.
- 24:46But he was poor. He was country poor.
- 24:49And he went to college thanks to the GI Bill after almost dying a million times in Vietnam.
- 24:56And so those are public subsidies. My mom enjoyed public subsidies in New York
- 24:59City. My dad enjoyed a federal public subsidy so he could go to college.
- 25:04Boston University is where he finally graduated from.
- 25:07And that basically enabled them to become middle class.
- 25:12They were not born middle class, but I was raised middle class because of things were affordable.
- 25:17Even their housing was much more affordable.
- 25:20And that was in the 1970s when I was born. And some of you know,
- 25:24it was crazy time of inflation, way more than we're having now.
- 25:27Mortgage rates were over 11%, but they still were able to do it even with those headwinds.
- 25:32Now, I myself went to public school. I was in a very nice neighborhood,
- 25:36but it was still public school. There was no debt incurred.
- 25:40And I went to a public university out of state in California.
- 25:44Costs about a quarter as what it does now.
- 25:46I was not born 500 years ago. I went to college 30 years ago.
- 25:50Why is it more than tripled to go to the same institution? I studied politics
- 25:55undergrad, the technology of teaching students politics, books, and a whiteboard.
- 26:01That's it. Some pens and paper, too. Has the cost of any of those items changed
- 26:05so dramatically in the past 30 years that it could justify cranking up tuition by 3x or 4x?
- 26:11That's just for UC school. It's even worse in private institutions.
- 26:16So what's going on here? Why did universities become such a grift?
- 26:22Why is there no oversight by any political party?
- 26:25Republicans might get political hay out of all the anti-Semitism that's part
- 26:29and parcel of the far left that sort of is incubated in American universities.
- 26:34But nobody's talking about affordability. And you know who else is not talking
- 26:38about affordability of colleges? Democrats.
- 26:41The working class party, but they don't talk about going to college.
- 26:46Bernie Sanders talked about it
- 26:47for community colleges and good for Bernie Sanders for focusing on that.
- 26:51But Bernie Sanders has zero political power. So it It doesn't really matter
- 26:55what a few outliers have to say.
- 26:57So why is it unaffordable? It's obviously a lot of this is due to Reaganomics,
- 27:03but Clinton and Obama were some of the greatest Reaganites of world history.
- 27:09These are neoliberals, got themselves rich, and impoverished huge tracts of
- 27:15America because they were essentially playing from the Republican playbook.
- 27:18Maybe they made some small changes on the margins, like Obamacare.
- 27:23Some small changes help some people. It's wonderful.
- 27:26Doesn't do squat for the middle class. So what's going to change?
- 27:31How are the Democrats going to get out of this hole?
- 27:34They are completely wed to a 20th century form of liberalism,
- 27:38which is completely irrelevant now.
- 27:39And they've doubled down on race and gender. And in my opinion,
- 27:44not popularly held by a lot of people on the left, I think it's sort of perverted
- 27:47the way that they even look at gender and some of these issues.
- 27:50It's sort of a perversion of what I think should be a more obvious and common
- 27:55sense way of thinking about things.
- 27:57But that's the Democrats. That's the lane. Some large news organizations,
- 28:04certainly most colleges, universities, cultural institutions,
- 28:07museums, the Academy of Motion Pictures, a lot of these groups,
- 28:11they're a part of this, right?
- 28:13It's about people of color. It's about transphobia.
- 28:17You have a phobia of transphobia. I'm not sure. I guess I'm phobic of transphobia.
- 28:23And we have all these sort of identitarian way of thinking about things,
- 28:28a privilege and ranking privilege.
- 28:30And supposedly somebody could tell you how to rank privilege.
- 28:33I'd be interested to see that chart. but it
- 28:36all kind of starts to sound like let them eat cake if you
- 28:40know what i mean this is just like a
- 28:43diversion or something it's just it's just
- 28:46crazy so and speaking of people of color and trans issues i suspect that most
- 28:55black people for bipoc native americans and the tiny tiny tiny tiny fraction
- 29:01of humans born with multiple genitals,
- 29:04what I think what they want to hear is, I can afford rent, or this is awesome.
- 29:10My health care, my health insurance costs just are going down,
- 29:13and I'm actually getting better care.
- 29:15My guess is that that's what they want to say, and maybe not be pandered to
- 29:18with 17 hours of NPR programming that doesn't help you eat dinner.
- 29:24So going back to Israel, I went out real deep criticizing the Democrats,
- 29:28But the point about what's happened in Israel is that I think it's happening here.
- 29:33The labor party in Israel is history.
- 29:36And you can follow Israeli politics as passionately as I do.
- 29:40I have a lot of friends who are way more informed than I am.
- 29:42Nobody's talking about labor coming back. That ain't happening. It's over.
- 29:46And why? In Israel, it's a very complicated situation, sure,
- 29:51but not really, maybe. It's really simple. It's really simple.
- 29:54Labor told Israelis that they could make peace with the people who won't make
- 29:59peace, which therefore means thousands and now tens of thousands of people will die.
- 30:06If that sounds kind of like a bad deal to you, that's why labor is out of power.
- 30:11Making peace with people who won't make peace with you, and therefore you're
- 30:15going to get war, is pretty stupid.
- 30:18So Democrats in America, which is a very different milieu, they're telling a
- 30:22similarly very stupid story.
- 30:25They're saying that niche identity ranking is more important than anything else.
- 30:30And I go off in my substack about what that means, but you get it.
- 30:36It's sort of like eyes are not on the prize. Is it about a black woman being
- 30:41on the Supreme Court or is it about justice?
- 30:44Doesn't mean I don't want a black woman on the Supreme Court.
- 30:46I think that's great, and we should have some type of representation in our
- 30:53political institutions that matches the people living in the country.
- 30:57I think that makes sense.
- 30:58It doesn't make sense for the NFL, but it does make sense for politics to a
- 31:02certain degree. But that can't be the most important thing, right?
- 31:06The most important thing is getting shit done, and it's not getting done.
- 31:11And so we get this kind of democratic focus on the wrong things.
- 31:17And then after they tell you about the wonders of their DEI program and how
- 31:23actually it's the right thing to do, despite the obvious harm to Jewish people,
- 31:27they'll also say, oh, by the way, that coffee is 12 bucks and you need to earn
- 31:31half a million dollars a year to buy a house.
- 31:34So, oh, and too bad you were just laid off. So if you as a politician can't
- 31:39devise policy that people need, like security in Israel or affordability in
- 31:45America, there's only one person to blame for your obsolescence.
- 31:49So let's cast a net a little bit more. What are we talking about when we're
- 31:53talking about the Democrats?
- 31:54Fetterman, Newsom, Whitmer, Walls, AOC, Sanders, Schumer. They're all twisting in the wind.
- 32:03Soon, like the names Biden and Harris, those names will drift away.
- 32:08So that's my big point. I think you get it. It's devastating. It's devastating.
- 32:13I don't think the Democrats are coming back from this. I think they need to
- 32:17be completely remade. I don't think Fetterman is the answer, even if I like him.
- 32:21I don't think Newsom is the answer, even if he has fabulous hair.
- 32:25I couldn't tell you if AOC and the squad and Sanders are going to take over
- 32:30the party and make it into a BIPOC workers' paradise in Palestine.
- 32:37I don't know where it's going to be, but it doesn't seem likely because people
- 32:42don't, they're losing primaries and people don't want it.
- 32:45So I really thank you for your time I'm experimenting with some new modes of
- 32:50communication I'm so excited to be a dad it's just been an epic and such a special
- 32:55part of my life happy to share it with all of you and look forward to talking to you soon.