Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Presuming Bias: How Implicit Bias Shapes the Burden of Proof in the Workplace
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Thank you for your patience
- 0:05this morning. Today's program is Presuming Bias,
- 0:09How Implicit Bias Shapes the Burden of Proof
- 0:11in the Workplace. I'm Ala Policastro, Director
- 0:14of Education and Professional Development at
- 0:17Beverly Hills Bar Association. And today I'm
- 0:19delighted to introduce our speaker, Dave Hall.
- 0:22Dave is a partner at Midtown Legal in Knoxville,
- 0:25Tennessee. Dave's practice focuses on family
- 0:27law, civil litigation, and civil rights matters.
- 0:30He's passionate about legal education, having
- 0:33previously served as an adjunct professor at
- 0:35the University of Tennessee, Winston College
- 0:37of Law. He also founded Velocity Test Prep, a
- 0:40virtual LSAT test preparation platform. We're
- 0:43so excited to hear about what he has to share
- 0:45with us today about his research. And so now
- 0:47I'm going to turn it over to him. Good morning.
- 0:51Thank you so much for that lovely introduction.
- 0:54So now is the key moment in the entire presentation
- 0:57where we see whether the screen sharing works.
- 1:07And it sort of worked. All right. So what we're
- 1:17doing is we're talking about A big swing that
- 1:22I propose at a big problem. I've written an article
- 1:29on this with my colleague Brad Earhart and we
- 1:32titled our article the bias presumption because
- 1:35that's our proposed solution to the entire question
- 1:39of dealing with the. the problems that we probably
- 1:43all know something about in burden of proof in
- 1:46essentially all Title VII litigation. Today,
- 1:53what I'd like to do is talk a little bit about
- 1:55what Title VII looks like right now. I want to
- 1:59talk a little bit about what bias looks like
- 2:01in the world and lived experience. I want to
- 2:05propose my statutory regime change, what I call
- 2:13bias presumption, and take a look at objections
- 2:17and responses and then think about how we might
- 2:20put some of this into practice. Spoiler alert,
- 2:24I don't think that my proposal will ever become
- 2:28law. I think it should. All right, the problem.
- 2:36Two cases are illustrative, I think. Thomas V.
- 2:40Ostal, an employee at this plant, comes into
- 2:45work and in his work locker is a noose with an
- 2:48effigy of him inside it. He's black. His fellow
- 2:53employees are white and the majority of them
- 2:56have Confederate flag stickers on their lockers.
- 2:59They wear Confederate flag clothes. They have
- 3:01Confederate bumper stickers on their trucks.
- 3:06There's graffiti around the workplace. It says
- 3:09things like, blacks should go back to Africa
- 3:13where they belong. Blacks are hired from the
- 3:17neck down, not to think. As you may imagine,
- 3:22the graffiti did not use the word blacks. However,
- 3:27when presented with this evidence, did I just
- 3:34lose the? When presented with this evidence,
- 3:51the court did not find that it was severe or
- 3:56pervasive enough to constitute workplace discrimination.
- 4:02not 1960. In Ash v. Tyson foods, the fact pattern
- 4:11was perhaps less shocking to the conscience.
- 4:17Some of the kinds of, some of the kinds of less
- 4:24overt, less articulated animus, and more of the
- 4:32Unfortunately, women may call the everyday, quotidian,
- 4:37run -of -the -mill different treatments. And
- 4:43two very qualified Black workers at Tyson Foods
- 4:48were passed over for promotion and in favor of
- 4:55two less qualified White workers. Some of the,
- 5:02you know, I say it's less overt because in contrast
- 5:04to the pretty shocking stuff we saw in Thomas
- 5:08V. Ostal, what we have happening in Ash is the
- 5:12manager, plant manager calling the black employees
- 5:15boys. And the jury sees it. However, defendant
- 5:23files a motion for judgment not withstanding
- 5:28the verdict. and the court grants it, and the
- 5:3211th Circuit affirms. So even in a case where
- 5:37a jury can see discrimination, the courts don't
- 5:41want to, or they can't. This strikes me as a
- 5:47real problem. And here's what I think is going
- 5:51on. I think that Title VII has just failed. There
- 5:55are two main problems with it. The first is the
- 5:58entire burden framework demands the kind of proof
- 6:01that plaintiffs can almost never provide this
- 6:07smoking gun idea. And even in the instances where
- 6:12they can, all too often there are structural,
- 6:17psychological, social factors that just prevent
- 6:21courts from being able to see or to recognize
- 6:25what they see. when we talk about bias. So the
- 6:30proposal is this, we amend Title VII. Instead
- 6:35of it demanding the burden of proof from the
- 6:38plaintiff, we want to switch that burden entirely.
- 6:43The simple showing of a prima facie case would
- 6:45trigger a rebuttable presumption of discrimination,
- 6:49the bias presumption. then the burden shifts
- 6:52to the employer to show that it had clean hands.
- 6:56In other words, instead of the plaintiff having
- 6:59to prove that the employer misbehaved, the employer
- 7:04has to prove that they didn't. As I was writing
- 7:10this article and as I was thinking about this,
- 7:12whole problem, it occurred to me that one way
- 7:17of looking at it is by thinking about like a
- 7:20woven tapestry on the wall. If you had a big
- 7:25enough tapestry and you were close enough to
- 7:29the tapestry, you wouldn't see the picture at
- 7:33all. You would just see the colors of thread
- 7:35right in front of you. And I think discrimination
- 7:39works in American society like that patterned
- 7:42tapestry. It is woven in. It is only visible
- 7:46from afar. And once you zoom in to try to find
- 7:50any individual instance of it, you fail to see
- 7:54the pattern altogether. You just can't. You're
- 7:56too close to it. And the current legal standard
- 8:02forces the courts to scrutinize these individual
- 8:05strands instead of looking at the patterns. And
- 8:09the evidence is in. There is no question we have
- 8:11implicit bias. We all share it. I have it. You
- 8:15have it. It doesn't mean we're bad people. We
- 8:18all share it. That just means we're people and
- 8:22all of us have our biases. They're baked in.
- 8:26They are expressed in the way that we congregate
- 8:29and expressed in the structures that we create.
- 8:33And the current system doesn't allow courts to
- 8:37recognize that, to take account of it, or to
- 8:40use that information in any useful or meaningful
- 8:44way. And I think that ought to change. The stakes
- 8:49are high. Roughly 90 ,000 EEOC charges were just
- 8:58resolved. Only 13 % got any relief at all. Most
- 9:04of that relief was settlement. Very few of these
- 9:07cases ever go to trial. The median settlement
- 9:10was very low, about $30 ,000. Summary judgment,
- 9:16employers always win. I mean, 80 % of the time.
- 9:22When it does go to trial, and again, that's very
- 9:26rare, when it does get to trial, only about 2
- 9:30% of plaintiffs win, and there are damage caps
- 9:34all over the place that, you know, those damage
- 9:39caps are informing, obviously, the amount of
- 9:42settlements, because employers' exposure is on
- 9:45the whole pretty low. Even when plaintiffs prevail,
- 9:51almost half of them are reversed on appeal. It's
- 9:56not a good picture for a plaintiff in an employment
- 9:59discrimination case. So, given all of that, the
- 10:06odds of an actually contested and upheld plaintiff
- 10:10verdict are about 1%. And the only people who
- 10:17have a worse track record of success than discrimination,
- 10:22employee discrimination, plaintiffs, prison or
- 10:24litigants. It's a mess and it's a problem. So
- 10:31what causes workplace bias? Four tent pole ways
- 10:40of thinking about bias. It can be animated by
- 10:44animus. This is that overt hostility. This is
- 10:47putting a noose in a co -worker's locker. This,
- 10:53as we see, is not always even sanctioned, but
- 10:57it is the one kind of bias that courts do tend
- 11:01to see. However, thankfully, it is also the rarest
- 11:08form in today's America. We might... consider
- 11:15whether it's becoming less rare and what we might
- 11:18do to try to counteract that. But it's not the
- 11:22primary driver of workplace bias. The primary
- 11:27drivers are implicit and structural. You've got
- 11:32apathy, which is, you know, the employer knows
- 11:35but doesn't really care. And A lot of that has
- 11:40less to do with any particular bias and more
- 11:44to do with the practical assessment that there
- 11:49is no real stick here. There's nothing keeping
- 11:53employers invested in creating and maintaining
- 11:57a safe, diverse, and fully functioning workplace.
- 12:02If their employees are creating some kind of
- 12:11animus driven bias, employers don't have a whole
- 12:15lot of incentive to stop it. And if it isn't
- 12:19heavily animus driven, employers have almost
- 12:22no incentive to stop it. So the apathy may be
- 12:27less true apathy and more a practical recognition
- 12:31that their obligations are very small. Implicit
- 12:37bias that unconscious, and this is important,
- 12:40it's unconscious. It is pervasive. We all share
- 12:46it. And it is invisible individually, almost,
- 12:52almost completely invisible in individuals. Implicit
- 12:57bias shows up in structures. It shows up in social
- 13:01networks, in the structures that we create and
- 13:05in the groups that we make. Structural bias is
- 13:10the built -in bias that comes from our implicit
- 13:15biases. It's the way we make our society that
- 13:20reflects the invisible, unconscious, but real
- 13:27biases that we all hold. There is evidence for
- 13:33this. Oh, I should say that I did not include
- 13:39all of my citations in this, but you do all have
- 13:45a copy of the article which is fully cited. So
- 13:50when I say, for example, that identical resumes
- 13:52yield significantly fewer callbacks for Black
- 13:54applicants, that's based on research. That research
- 13:58is cited in the article that you have. So if
- 14:00you're interested in chasing down some of my
- 14:03sources. I made those all available to you. But
- 14:06this is true. You get identical resumes and you're
- 14:08going to have, in the aggregate, fewer callbacks
- 14:12for black applicants. And we've been tracking
- 14:16it. And for the last two plus decades, we haven't
- 14:19seen any meaningful improvement in discrimination
- 14:23and hiring. We're doing the same things over
- 14:27and over. Something's got to change. But again,
- 14:34structural bias based on implicit, invisible
- 14:37bias, you can only be seen in the full tapestry.
- 14:41You zoom in and you lose it entirely. You can't
- 14:44see the picture. The doctrinal gap is just this.
- 14:53Title VII forces us to zoom in. It centers on
- 14:55individual, discrete, particular moments. and
- 14:59it always carries this presumption of non -discrimination,
- 15:05which wouldn't be a problem if there were no
- 15:09such thing as this real, existing, implicit structural
- 15:14bias. But there is, and it operates in the aggregate.
- 15:20So if you presume non -discrimination, you are
- 15:23almost deliberately turning a blind eye to the
- 15:25facts of the world, which is that there is an
- 15:29implicit bias. And as we said earlier, animus,
- 15:36the one strand that is most consistently recognized,
- 15:43thankfully, you know, is relatively rare. Unfortunately,
- 15:48it's not the only way to create harmful, disparate
- 15:54working conditions for our country's employees.
- 16:00All right, so we know that we have disparate
- 16:03treatment, and in the current legal regime, there
- 16:07are two ways of proving it. Direct evidence direct
- 16:14evidence. How could you? You know, disparate
- 16:18treatment coming from some kind of animating
- 16:23bias probably doesn't come along with a memo
- 16:27saying, I am not hiring you because you are black.
- 16:31Probably does not come along with an email saying,
- 16:36I'm passing you over promotion because this other
- 16:40guy is white and I like that better. Direct evidence
- 16:44just generally is not accessible to plaintiffs.
- 16:48And then you've got indirect evidence under the
- 16:50McDonnell Douglas standard, and we'll get back
- 16:53to that in a moment. It ends up sorting back
- 16:57to just another avenue for requiring plaintiffs
- 17:01to provide direct evidence. It isn't indirect
- 17:04evidence. Direct evidence rarely works because
- 17:09it requires the smoking gun. And, you know, we
- 17:14just talked about this. But also, there's, again,
- 17:19a structural impediment, and this is twigball,
- 17:23that heightened pleading standard can chop the
- 17:27legs out from underplanked this, and not just
- 17:29in discrimination cases and all sorts of cases,
- 17:32but... This is perhaps particularly problematic
- 17:36in discrimination cases before you ever get to
- 17:41discovery, which is the one place you really
- 17:43might be able to come up with some direct proof.
- 17:47But you don't get there because in order to get
- 17:50there, you have to have the proof, but you don't
- 17:52have the proof because you haven't gotten to
- 17:53discovery, but you can't get to discovery because
- 17:55you don't have the proof. You see the circular
- 17:57reason. I call it the McDonald Douglas seesaw
- 18:03because it works like this. Plaintiff brings
- 18:06a prima facie case, you know, that they remember
- 18:08a protected class, that they were qualified,
- 18:10that they were rejected, the position stayed
- 18:12open. So the plaintiff comes in with a case.
- 18:17The employer just produces a legitimate and non
- 18:20-discriminatory reason, which is always at hand.
- 18:23You can always find a reason for a bad employment
- 18:27outcome. So that's never really a bar to an employer's
- 18:34case. Is that legitimate non -discriminatory
- 18:38reason the actual reason? Well, now we put the
- 18:45burden back on the plaintiff and the plaintiff
- 18:47has to show that it's not. The plaintiff has
- 18:50to show that it's pretextual. So we went from
- 18:54this idea that the employer would have to show
- 19:00that there was a legitimate reason, and then
- 19:05just took all of the spine out of it by putting
- 19:09the burden on the plaintiff to show that the
- 19:11employer's reason is pretextual. And cases just
- 19:17collapse, and the plaintiffs are pushed right
- 19:19back into the direct evidence problem that they
- 19:21tried to avoid. because we presume that the employer's
- 19:28legitimate and non -discriminatory reason is
- 19:31non -discriminatory. Disprit impact. I think
- 19:41about disparate impact and criminal trials because,
- 19:47and we'll come back to this maybe in a minute,
- 19:50but I think there's a really maybe useful analog
- 19:54to criminal trials when we think about disparate
- 19:57impact. In a criminal trial, we cloak the criminal
- 20:03defendant in a presumption of innocence. But
- 20:09part of the reason for that is in the criminal
- 20:12trial, you have the individual defendant standing
- 20:16alone, but for their brave attorney. doing the
- 20:21Lord's work, against the entire apparatus of
- 20:26the state. The plaintiff, in its analogy, the
- 20:32prosecution, the state, holds all the levers
- 20:37of power. So the defendant needs the protection
- 20:41of that presumption of innocence. However, It
- 20:48seems that we've transferred some of that structure
- 20:51into workplace discrimination cases without thinking
- 20:54about how that structure doesn't really fit.
- 20:57Because in most workplace discrimination cases,
- 21:00it is the defendant, the employer, who wields
- 21:03the levers of power, and that plaintiff who does
- 21:07not. The employer does not need the protection
- 21:11of a presumption of non -discrimination. In fact,
- 21:16such a presumption just works to make sure that
- 21:22more plaintiffs have more trouble sustaining
- 21:25claims. The effective burden ends up being heaviest
- 21:30on the plaintiff. So why is this such a problem?
- 21:36Why don't courts see this? There are a few reasons.
- 21:43not necessarily presented here in any, in any
- 21:47particular order, but these are some of the reasons
- 21:50that courts have a hard time with it. One of
- 21:54them is that we, I say we, you know, systematically
- 21:59courts are expressions of us, right? And we do
- 22:04tend to have an overly narrow idea of what counts
- 22:10as discrimination. And that's a problem, right?
- 22:18If we're only gonna count that thin sliver of
- 22:20the actual lived experience of discrimination,
- 22:24then by definition, we're not capturing all of
- 22:27the discrimination. And because courts are us,
- 22:31we are courts, they are conduits of our implicit
- 22:35bias. So they are susceptible to the same invisible
- 22:42forces that we all are individually. I think
- 22:48it's fantastic that in general, our legal system
- 22:51is built on individual and not structural justice,
- 22:54right? I mean, that's a good idea. It should
- 22:57be about righting individual wrongs. But what
- 23:02happens when the individual wrong is caused by
- 23:07a structural not individual pressure, we have
- 23:14a legal system that's not well equipped to deal
- 23:16with that kind of problem. And, you know, I mean,
- 23:22the bench is made up of people that look like
- 23:25me, old white men. And, you know, hey, there
- 23:31are some pretty good ones. But the truth is,
- 23:37it is more difficult to get outside of yourself
- 23:42if you cannot recognize that you even need to
- 23:47do that. And because implicit bias is invisible,
- 23:52even to the actor, even to the one holding it,
- 23:58the less diverse the bench, the more likely it
- 24:04is to hold the biases of the people making it
- 24:09up. All right. So there have been a couple of
- 24:16attempted reforms in the past. I'm not the first
- 24:19person to be thinking about this. I looked at
- 24:26a couple of them and found them not particularly
- 24:30persuasive. There's Sparino's reform, which proposes
- 24:35to collapse disparate treatment and disparate
- 24:38impact into one quote, because of a protected
- 24:42trait test. And so the idea would be that you
- 24:46just show that the bad outcome was because of
- 24:50this protected trait. Now, what I like about
- 24:53it is that it does allow courts to recognize
- 24:57some of the bias factors that we've been discussing,
- 25:01but it doesn't require them to. And ultimately,
- 25:07it seems to me that the because of test just
- 25:11replays the motivating factor test, and we're
- 25:14back to essentially the same position we were
- 25:17when we started. So I think it's just too narrow
- 25:21to be meaningful. And Brodin proposes that we
- 25:30import inferred intent out of tort. Which, you
- 25:34know, as you may have seen already, I love me
- 25:37a good analogy. You know, that you show that
- 25:42the repeated use of devices or structures that
- 25:48are known to be discriminatory is itself a evidence
- 25:54of intent. I love this. I just think that it's
- 26:02too narrow because All it gets at is a slender
- 26:07class of known discriminatory selection devices.
- 26:11And those are not the only drivers of discriminatory
- 26:17practice in the workplace. So we need something
- 26:20that's broader. We need a presumption of bias.
- 26:28All right, so here's the core move. The plaintiff
- 26:32needs to make a prima facie case that they are
- 26:35part of a protected class and they experience
- 26:38an adverse outcome. That prima facie case triggers
- 26:43a rebuttable presumption, but a presumption of
- 26:48bias. And then the burden is on the employer
- 26:53to rebut that presumption by I suggest a standard
- 26:58of clear and convincing evidence that the action
- 27:01it took was not discriminatory. And this has
- 27:05the practical effect of just folding disparate
- 27:09impact into disparate treatment. And here's how
- 27:14I think it should look. We replace 42 USC section
- 27:182000 with this language. It's a violation if
- 27:24the complainant is a member of a protected class,
- 27:26the complainant experienced an adverse outcome,
- 27:29give some examples, and see the respondent cannot
- 27:33show by clear and convincing evidence that the
- 27:36outcome was solely job -related. Why shift the
- 27:45burden? For me, this goes back to, or I should
- 27:51say one clear way of explaining why I think we
- 27:55should shift the burden is to come back to that
- 27:58analogy to criminal law, you know, where we presume
- 28:02the criminal defendants are innocent because
- 28:05the state holds the power. But in employment
- 28:08cases that power imbalance is the other way around,
- 28:12so we should shift that burden the other way
- 28:15around accordingly. Who should bear the burden
- 28:17of proof? The one with the power, the entity
- 28:21that is strong enough to bear that burden successfully.
- 28:27And when the power imbalance is as extreme as
- 28:30it often is in these discrimination cases, it
- 28:36makes a certain amount of just plain intuitive
- 28:39sense that the employer should bear that burden.
- 28:43When we add to that intuitive sense, the fact
- 28:49that we know implicit bias is universal, it doesn't
- 28:56just make intuitive sense, it strikes me as a
- 29:00positive moral and legal demand. All right, so
- 29:06let's go back to Ash V Tyson. Ash V Tyson was
- 29:09the case we talked about where the manager referred
- 29:12to his black employees as boys, where he did
- 29:17not promote them because there were two white
- 29:25guys he could promote instead. In that case,
- 29:30under my proposed shift to a presumption of bias,
- 29:36uh, the, uh, employer loses. I mean, the jury
- 29:41saw it even under the current system, the jury
- 29:44saw it, uh, which means that, uh, even under
- 29:48the weak kind of, um, lack of burden, even with
- 29:54the presumption of non -discrimination, the employer
- 29:57and ash, uh, you know, Tyson foods wasn't able
- 30:02to, uh, to show that there was no bias. Well,
- 30:09now, if we require them to show that, the inability
- 30:16to demonstrate a lack of bias becomes even more
- 30:19striking. And we argue that both the district
- 30:26court and the appellate court are going to be
- 30:32compelled because of the presumption of bias,
- 30:36to uphold the jury's verdict rather than to discount
- 30:40it. OK, so I know I said at the beginning that
- 30:48I don't really expect any legislator, much less
- 30:54the US Congress, to take note of my big idea
- 30:59here. But it does make some sense to think through
- 31:03what this would look like if we did. What we
- 31:07might see is that a lot more plaintiffs survive
- 31:12summary judgment. Instead of 13%, maybe it becomes
- 31:21something more like 60%. I think one practical
- 31:26fact is that more employers would actually be
- 31:28held accountable. that it would change the way,
- 31:35you know, we talked about employer apathy as
- 31:38partly a practical, clear -eyed approach to the
- 31:43facts of the world. Well, what if those facts
- 31:46were you're going to have to behave or we're
- 31:49going to hold you accountable? That might change
- 31:52the way employers do behave. employers would
- 31:57have to think about structural bias. Right now,
- 32:02nothing's forcing them to even think about it.
- 32:06Which again, is a problem because it's existing,
- 32:09because it's here. We're all living with it.
- 32:11We're all seeing its effects. But we only see
- 32:15its effects. The bias itself is invisible. I
- 32:20think this might make courts become a little
- 32:22more socially attuned. You know, it might make
- 32:25courts look in the same sort of way that employers
- 32:29would have to look at the kinds of structural
- 32:33built in baked in ways of doing business that
- 32:39are present and sometimes harmful and yet almost
- 32:42never seen or accounted for. And listen, when
- 32:50employers account for that bias, take steps to
- 32:54counteract it, and clean their hands, all they
- 32:58have to do is show their work, show what they
- 33:00did. So it's not an insurmountable burden. It
- 33:05doesn't become an insurmountable burden. All
- 33:08it really is is asking for a recognition of the
- 33:11way that the world actually is. Okay, will people
- 33:18object? Yes, some of you may be objecting right
- 33:20now. That's okay. Reasonable minds can differ.
- 33:24Some of the predicted objections. Will this cause
- 33:28a flood at the courthouse? Maybe, but more litigation
- 33:35is actually part of the point. And even if we
- 33:42did see a significant uptick in plaintiff's actions,
- 33:46it wouldn't be enough to offset the twitfall
- 33:49decline. And it doesn't, to my mind, the twitball
- 33:58pleading standards were not a good thing on balance.
- 34:04So something that works a little bit to even
- 34:07the scales might be worth doing. And again, as
- 34:12I said, employers who do have clean hands, uh
- 34:16you know are going to be able to defeat weak
- 34:18claims there will be weak claims of course though
- 34:20though um but that doesn't you know i don't think
- 34:26anything about this proposal uh makes weak claims
- 34:31um successful you know if you know it's a weak
- 34:37claim because there was not real discrimination,
- 34:41and an employer who can show that they've accounted
- 34:44for their implicit and structural biases will
- 34:48be able to defeat those kinds of claims. Would
- 34:51it be the end of that will employment? Maybe.
- 34:57You know, I think this, yeah, maybe. But again,
- 35:02the point is to get us thinking about the way
- 35:08that we interact with one another, that employers
- 35:12need to be thinking about and accounting for
- 35:15the way that structural, otherwise invisible
- 35:19forces kind of induce a discrimination that doesn't
- 35:26have to be there, a discrimination that isn't
- 35:29even animated by any hatred and yet is enacted
- 35:34because we're not looking at it. We're not thinking
- 35:38about it. And if we can get us thinking about
- 35:43it beforehand, that, again, is a feature, not
- 35:49a part of it. A quota system? I mean, I just
- 35:53say no. Inclusive, documented, thoughtful anti
- 36:04-discriminatory hiring practices do not mean
- 36:10the same thing as a quota. It's a little bit
- 36:18like the slippery slope argument. Someone says,
- 36:21oh, you're starting down a slippery slope. And
- 36:24sometimes the best rebuttal to that is no, no,
- 36:28I'm not. And I think that that rebuttal holds
- 36:35true here. Calling for employers to take stock
- 36:40of their current practices and to account for
- 36:45the ways that they do business is not the same
- 36:47thing as calling for a system of quotas. They're
- 36:52two different animals and there's no real argument
- 36:56that they're not. All right, so what would all
- 37:01of this mean for us in practice? Or what can
- 37:06we take away from this? For employer side and
- 37:12in -house counsel, you start building the record
- 37:18right now. You go through. You are thoughtful.
- 37:26You do audits. You treat the current complaint
- 37:30and correction infrastructure. Use that as the
- 37:31model. The base point is, for employers, just
- 37:38think about what you're doing. That's it. It's
- 37:42not. Because, again, You know, my central thesis
- 37:47is not that there's this animus. My central thesis
- 37:50is because the bias is implicit and invisible
- 37:53that you just don't know you're doing it as an
- 37:56employer, in a lot of cases. So look at it. Think
- 38:01about it. And then build practices that will
- 38:06counteract that implicit, unconscious bias. Plan
- 38:13of sight. You know, it's got to be about forcing
- 38:18everyone to see the tapestry, not just the individual
- 38:22strand. You know, I'm in Tennessee in the Sixth
- 38:27Circuit, just rejects some of what I am calling
- 38:36for. But, you know, if you can target the places
- 38:43where the cases die, which is, you know, with
- 38:46the initial pleading and summary judgment and
- 38:49the pretext step, then show, you know, when we
- 38:53can show that this individual instance is part
- 38:58of a larger pattern, then we're beginning to
- 39:01do the work. Montana is, experimenting with cause
- 39:11protection. So that's interesting to look at.
- 39:15Tennessee just has codified McDonnell Douglas.
- 39:24So no matter who you are, being aware of how
- 39:32your jurisdiction operates within the existing
- 39:36framework is you know, is one way of beginning
- 39:41to see that tapestry. And, and of course, acknowledging
- 39:46that implicit and structural biases are exposures,
- 39:50independent of any individual bad actor. Okay,
- 39:56we are a little bit I anticipated leaving us
- 40:01with 10 minutes for questions. But I moved. fairly
- 40:08quickly through that. So I will open the floor
- 40:15to questions in as much as there are any. All
- 40:27righty. Let's see, it looks like earlier someone
- 40:31asks quite a 20 minutes ago or so. So trying
- 40:35to get the context, but they do not just get
- 40:39off because no discriminatory reason, but that
- 40:41the conduct has a discriminatory quote unquote
- 40:44effect. Yeah. Yeah. That's the idea. Then in
- 40:54order to counteract that, you know, because there's
- 40:58the, that's disparate impact is what it sounds
- 41:00like that question is describing, you know. All
- 41:08right, I'm going to just while we wait for other
- 41:10questions, I'm going to double check our help
- 41:12desk to see if someone has asked a question through
- 41:14email. Do you have any other closing remarks
- 41:16or comments in the meantime while we wait? I'm
- 41:24wondering if there's anything that I. You know.
- 41:42No, I wonder if there's anything that I missed,
- 41:46but I'm going back through it and I think I've
- 41:49said what I intended to say. So I don't know
- 41:54if I got the gist of that question there, but
- 42:00I do want to make sure that I'm addressing it.
- 42:02It sounded like someone was just saying, is this
- 42:04what disparate impact is? So it looks like we
- 42:10also have another question here. What do you
- 42:12do when a judge is acting discriminatory towards
- 42:14litigants and attorneys race disability? Yeah,
- 42:19I mean, so first of all, thankfully, you know,
- 42:23that kind of, you know, direct animus driven
- 42:29discrimination is rare. But in an individual
- 42:33instance, you know, the that's what the appeals
- 42:38process is for. Like there is, if the judge themselves,
- 42:43if this judge is behaving in discriminatory ways,
- 42:48the only way to hold their feet to the fire is,
- 42:51you know, with the possibility of reversal on
- 42:53appeal. So you build, you know, you have the
- 42:55record in the courtroom and you use that record
- 42:58on appeal because if the judge is operating under
- 43:05an animating animus, Nothing you say in a courtroom
- 43:11is likely to change that judge's mind or action,
- 43:17but what can change the way that judges behave
- 43:21is getting decisions overturned. All right. And
- 43:30it looks like we have another question. Are your
- 43:33arguments really equally applicable to all types
- 43:36of discrimination, including HOA and housing?
- 43:39Yeah, I think so. I think this is a framework
- 43:43that we could apply throughout American society
- 43:48in various ways. So in HOA or housing discrimination
- 43:54claims, the same kind of thing would apply in
- 43:57my estimation. whatever HOA or if it's realtors
- 44:07that aren't doing redlining, we hold their feet
- 44:14to the fire because we presume that they are
- 44:17acting under the same implicit bias that we know,
- 44:22in fact, that they are. So we know the bias exists.
- 44:27Let's stop pretending like it doesn't. And so,
- 44:31yeah, I see that as being a completely valid
- 44:37method of applying this train of thought. I'd
- 44:39love to see that. I think about it in criminal
- 44:44law, too. You know, prosecutors wield such broad
- 44:52discretion. You know, there's so much power,
- 44:56and it's an almost invisible power vested, I
- 44:58mean, unless you're in the system directly, so
- 45:02much power in the district attorney's office
- 45:06because they're deciding, they're deciding who
- 45:10they're going to hold accountable, right? And
- 45:13for the same crimes, some defendants get put
- 45:20on trial, other defendants do not. And they are
- 45:27covered currently under this presumption of non
- 45:32-discrimination. We're just going to presume
- 45:34that prosecutors are not being discriminatory
- 45:38in the way they select cases and in the penalties
- 45:46that they seek when they do prosecute cases.
- 45:51And that presumption that they are not discriminatory,
- 45:54that works directly against the evidence -based
- 46:01knowledge that we're all operating individually
- 46:06and collectively society with an implicit bias.
- 46:10So this bias presumption, we can apply it to
- 46:13prosecutors. We can apply it to HOAs. We can
- 46:15apply it to housing lenders. We can apply it
- 46:19to, of course, employers. I think because it's...
- 46:24Because the thing is, it's not really anything
- 46:28novel. All I'm really proposing is that we account
- 46:33for the fact of American existence, that there
- 46:38is an implicit and structural bias that we're
- 46:43all party to. All right, so it does look like
- 46:54we have other questions from our help desk as
- 46:57well. What state law analogs should practitioners
- 47:03be watching for? State law analogs should practitioners
- 47:09be watching for? Oh, oh, state law analogs to
- 47:17Title VII. Yeah. That, you know, I don't have
- 47:28my finger on state -by -state employment laws.
- 47:35The thrust of my research has shown that most
- 47:39states just let Title VII function as the governing
- 47:45standard within the state. But I think the way
- 47:53to do it would be to start with the state in
- 47:59question and start researching how that state
- 48:04handles employment claims. So sorry, I don't
- 48:07have a direct answer for that. All right. Let's
- 48:12see. So we have another one here. If Congress
- 48:19adopted the proposed language, which existing
- 48:21Supreme Court Title VII doctrines would become
- 48:24obsolete? Which do you think would remain intact?
- 48:30Well, it would completely replace the current
- 48:38regime of adjudicating these cases under Title
- 48:43VII. It could be adopted for use in every title
- 48:50that deals with any kind of discrimination claim
- 48:56in places other than employment law as well.
- 49:01You know, I tailored this language specifically
- 49:06for Title VII, but, you know, could we apply
- 49:13it in in education? Yes. Could we apply it in
- 49:19housing? Yes. I think it could be adapted with
- 49:24very little change to all sorts of federal law.
- 49:34And honestly, I think it should. If they would
- 49:39just give me the reins, I could fix it. I'm just
- 49:47going to presume that everybody's laughing at
- 49:49that joke. All right. Let's see. Let's see. I
- 49:56do have another question from an audience member,
- 49:58though I'm not too sure how to ask it. I could
- 50:01ask it if it maybe be reworded. Presumptive implicit
- 50:05bias in terms of who became appointed boards,
- 50:10a quote unquote. And the quote unquote entitlement
- 50:13mentality is so persuasive and assumptive that
- 50:15the system cannot see it. That was one comment.
- 50:20And then let's see. I have another question here.
- 50:26Who bears the burden of persuasion versus the
- 50:28burden of production? So in my proposal, all
- 50:37burdens live with the employer. All the plaintiff
- 50:42has to do is show that they're a member of a
- 50:45protected class and they experienced a bad outcome.
- 50:47And then we acknowledge, you know what? I mean,
- 50:52there is this social force at work that does...
- 50:59unfairly disadvantaged members of protected classes
- 51:02in American society. So I think this plaintiff
- 51:05has a point. What say you, employer? And now
- 51:09the employer has to produce the evidence and
- 51:15has to produce that evidence with a burden of
- 51:18clear and convincing proof. So the burdens lie
- 51:22with the employer. And I think they should. This
- 51:26is what I'm saying. All right, so it does look
- 51:33like we have two more questions here. Let's see.
- 51:38Would the proposal make pretext evidence less
- 51:40important or simply move the pretext inquiry
- 51:42to the employer's rebuttal burden? Well, I think
- 51:48it, you know, I submit that it's. does away with
- 51:55it altogether, that it's no longer a question
- 51:59of pretext because we're not pretending like
- 52:05the employer started with a non -discriminatory
- 52:09intent. We are acknowledging that without any
- 52:15animus, the employer did start. Did start. from
- 52:20a place of implicit bias. And then the question
- 52:22is, did the employer acknowledge that implicit
- 52:25bias and did the employer take steps to mitigate
- 52:29it? So, I think that's what's happening there.
- 52:34And then you had a second question. Yes. So,
- 52:38it looks like, how would the proposal interact
- 52:41with delegated decision -making, for example,
- 52:43when HR implements a manager's recommendation
- 52:45without independently investigating the underlying
- 52:48rationale? Yeah, that's a fantastic question.
- 52:55So if the basis for my entire argument is that
- 53:03bias is implicit and it is pervasive, then the
- 53:09way to counteract that and is pervasive and is
- 53:14systematic, then the way to counteract that is
- 53:17to build better systems. So would my proposal
- 53:23solve every problem in employment discrimination?
- 53:26No. But how do we attack those... lower level
- 53:38decisions that may be made without oversight,
- 53:41without proper oversight, we build systems that
- 53:44are strong enough to withstand them instead of
- 53:46the current systems that seem designed to allow
- 53:52them to go unchecked. We built different systems,
- 53:56thoughtful systems. Because and and again comes
- 54:00back to the root question We build these systems
- 54:03because we recognize that we are fighting something
- 54:07that is real and that is pervasive Okay, so it
- 54:14looks like we have just one more question left
- 54:16I know that we're getting close to time. So I
- 54:18just have one more question left It's a little
- 54:20bit more of a I guess a thinker implicit bias
- 54:23is invisible even to the person who has it How
- 54:26does a defendant ever rebut the presumption?
- 54:30Doesn't shifting the burden just make it unwinnable
- 54:32for employers? I don't think so. So one example
- 54:38would be that you acknowledge that as an employer
- 54:46that you are subject to this real measurable
- 54:51implicit bias and that because you know it exists,
- 54:59you are going to thoughtfully and purposefully
- 55:02take steps to counteract it. So, no, I mean,
- 55:08I don't think it's unwinnable at all. Because
- 55:11if an employer is doing that, is taking real
- 55:15steps to counteract the implicit bias, then...
- 55:19those steps will bear fruit in the form of outcomes.
- 55:23The employer will be able to say, look around,
- 55:26man. Not only do we have these practices that
- 55:29we're putting into place, that we hired a team,
- 55:32we hired an implicit bias team. Every employer
- 55:36ought to have, every large employer, I'm not
- 55:38saying mandated by law, I'm just saying they
- 55:39should have one, that looks at this stuff in
- 55:42the same way that we look at marketing. because
- 55:47it matters. And as the employer, we can say,
- 55:52look, here's our program, here's what we do to
- 55:54counteract it, and here are the results. So yes,
- 55:58this plaintiff did experience a bad outcome,
- 56:01but it's not because of our implicit bias, because
- 56:05we've looked at it, we've taken these steps to
- 56:07address it. And those steps have borne fruit
- 56:10over here with other employees who are not experiencing
- 56:15the kinds of discriminatory outcomes that they
- 56:19would have if we hadn't put this plan of ours
- 56:23into place. So I think it's still totally winnable
- 56:29for weak cases. All right. So that looks like
- 56:38that's it for questions. Thank you so much, Dave,
- 56:41for an excellent presentation today. And we'd
- 56:43also love to give a warm thanks to our audience
- 56:46for joining us. Have a great day, everybody.
- 56:49Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Bye -bye.