Latest / Migraine Relief Code with Dr. Amelia Scott Barrett, MD / "Pop a Pill and Power Through:" We're Ready to Move Past This Approach to Migraine
Transcript
- 0:00We are gonna have a conversation about an experience that I think is common for all of us
- 0:06with migraine.
- 0:07And it is related to, kind of, it's a reflection of the only tools we had available
- 0:17in medicine at the time when this way of handling migraine came about.
- 0:24Now, as time has gone on, we have of course gotten new tools.
- 0:30That's where these tools of precision medicine and functional genomics come from.
- 0:34They come from two decades of research about what's actually going on biologically for
- 0:42people with migraines.
- 0:44So we're going to have a little bit of a conversation since we're going to have to
- 0:51change our mindset around this way of doing things.
- 0:56Now, what I'm talking about is the idea that our job as people with migraine is to pop a
- 1:04pill and power through.
- 1:06Now, in the beginning, it was amazing that we even had pills that would help, right?
- 1:13You know, it's a massive step forward from the days of, you know, Willow Bark, which is what
- 1:18aspirin comes from.
- 1:20And so, you know, in the beginning, it was great just to have something that might make an
- 1:25impact on the migraines in the first place.
- 1:27And, you know, we are all grateful that they're there.
- 1:30Has anybody had an afternoon that just where the pills saved you?
- 1:33Yep, yep, lots of hands going up.
- 1:35Exactly.
- 1:36So they have their place for sure.
- 1:39But there comes a point where we have to realize that what's really happening when we
- 1:44get a migraine is that our brain is telling us that something isn't working right.
- 1:50Now, there could be many things going on under the surface that aren't working right.
- 1:55It could be something related to brain chemistry and so there might be an abnormality
- 2:00in one of those neurotransmitter systems in the brain.
- 2:04We know that the brain is over firing in migraine.
- 2:07That's part of the reason they call it a Ferrari brain.
- 2:10Like it's just going 90 miles an hour all the time.
- 2:13So we know that that is part of the picture for many people.
- 2:18The other thing that could be going on under the surface is inflammation.
- 2:22There's literally sort of a migraine thermometer in the brain.
- 2:26It's called the trigeminal nerve.
- 2:27And when that baby senses high levels of inflammation, it's gonna trigger a migraine for
- 2:32you.
- 2:33The other thing that might be going on, the brain cells might just be running out of
- 2:38energy.
- 2:39You know, an over firing brain that's constantly signaling these neurotransmitters,
- 2:44it's gonna run out of energy, right?
- 2:45And what organ takes up a fifth of all of our energy at any given time?
- 2:51This one.
- 2:52Right?
- 2:53So that can be part of it.
- 2:55Also low blood flow.
- 2:57Any of you ever had that feeling of getting dizzy when you stand up?
- 3:00We've had a heat wave here in Colorado.
- 3:02It's been like the whole last month for me.
- 3:04So many electrolytes, I'm telling you.
- 3:06So much water.
- 3:06Oh my goodness.
- 3:07But, yeah, that's decreased blood flow to the brain.
- 3:11Every time you feel that way, you bend over, you stand back up, you're dizzy.
- 3:15You don't have enough blood volume to get all of the critical nutrients delivered to your
- 3:20brain that it needs in order to function right.
- 3:23Understand that the pop up pill has its place, but we also understand that our brain is
- 3:30telling us that something's going on and we don't want that to be our only tool, right?
- 3:34But the other thing that happens, I think for us as women particularly, is that we are so
- 3:39programmed to power through.
- 3:42We take care of ourselves.
- 3:44We might take care of children or older parents.
- 3:48We might take care of a spouse.
- 3:49We take care of things at work.
- 3:52As women, we tend to be go givers, not so much go getters.
- 3:57And we respond to all of that by saying, no problem, I'm gonna pop a pill, I am still gonna
- 4:03get dinner on the table, I'm gonna help their kids with their homework and I can pick them up
- 4:08from soccer at 10:00 tonight, right?
- 4:10We power through.
- 4:12We are so programmed to power through.
- 4:16We think that's our whole job.
- 4:18I've got a migraine.
- 4:19I'm gonna take my pill.
- 4:20I'm gonna power through.
- 4:22And again, there comes a point when that doesn't work anymore.
- 4:28I'm a mom of three kids.
- 4:31They're all grown now.
- 4:32They're off doing their thing in the world, for a lot of years, that's a lot going on.
- 4:40I was also a doctor running a So is your day?
- 4:43Migraine is the number one reason women can't work under the age of 50.
- 4:48It's a little lower on the list once you get above age 50, but it's still on the list.
- 4:53And so it has an absolutely huge impact on women's lives.
- 4:57And I think that so often people don't understand that.
- 5:00They hear that statistic and they think I'm making it up or something.
- 5:03It isn't.
- 5:04It was published in the Global Burden of Disease report that came out for 2019,
- 5:09published a year later.
- 5:11And the reason is that migraine isn't just a headache, It's a brain disease.
- 5:17And part of the reason is that the impact on you isn't just the pain, it's the brain fog
- 5:23that y'all were talking about.
- 5:24It's all the other neurological symptoms that go along with it that make it have such an
- 5:31impact on people's lives.
- 5:33The difficulty thinking, the low energy, all of those things are part of the migraine and you
- 5:38can feel all those other things at times even when you don't have the pain.
- 5:43So you know there's a lot of reasons going on under the surface with all that.
- 5:48And, you know, I think the problem isn't so much just the taking the pill to try to get
- 5:54through.
- 5:55I think the problem is thinking that you're done.
- 5:58The problem is not recognizing that your brain is trying to communicate with you.
- 6:02So I'm going to share just a few slides with you guys here to really explain how it is that
- 6:08we figured out that this is not victory.
- 6:11Like how it is in mainstream medicine that we started saying, wait a second, just suppressing
- 6:16the pain is not actually fixing the brain.
- 6:22Right?
- 6:23That, you know, it was a step forward compared to the willow bark for sure, but there's more
- 6:28work to do on migraine and in subsequent episodes we'll get into exactly what those
- 6:34tools are.
- 6:34But let me show you just one thing here.
- 6:40All right.
- 6:44All right.
- 6:44So as we have said, you know, was kind of our first model of what to do with migraine.
- 6:52It's the pop up pill and power through.
- 6:54And we were all glad that existed.
- 6:58That was a step forward.
- 6:59However, where has this gotten us?
- 7:02It's gotten us to a place where migraine is now the number one cause of disability in women 50.
- 7:08Here's the exact study that was published for you.
- 7:11It's in a very prominent medical journal, the Journal of Headache and Pain.
- 7:14It was published in 2020, and these are findings from the Global Burden of Disease
- 7:20report 2019.
- 7:22So they look at a lot of different measures of how disease is impacting people's lives all
- 7:28over the world.
- 7:29So this is not just a problem in The U.
- 7:31S.
- 7:32It's not just a problem in developed nations where we're stressed out or whatever.
- 7:37This is a global problem that this disease is here and this brain disease impacts the lives
- 7:45of women disproportionately compared to men.
- 7:49Not that it doesn't impact men too, but we outnumber them three to one.
- 7:54So it has a much bigger impact on our lives.
- 7:58So why don't medications fix this problem?
- 8:02Well it's because your meds don't fix the root causes of migraine, right?
- 8:05They don't fix anything in your brain, right?
- 8:09So this is what we've been able to demonstrate with a certain type of MRI scan that shows how
- 8:16your brain is functioning.
- 8:18We call it a functional MRI because it's, you know, it's related to how it's functioning.
- 8:23So on this image, yellow means that the brain is firing like a lot, a lot.
- 8:30Red means it's firing like a little less of a lot.
- 8:34And what we're seeing on the right is that this brain is over firing.
- 8:38Now, this is not just during migraine.
- 8:42This person on the right, when this image was taken, they don't have pain at the moment.
- 8:46You're not seeing the effect of pain here.
- 8:49What you're seeing is this brain is not firing normally, even in between migraines.
- 8:55Why?
- 8:56That is the real problem, right?
- 9:00So medications are good at suppressing the pain, but it's a little bit like if you break
- 9:05your leg, you want to like go get an x-ray, maybe get a cast, maybe get surgery.
- 9:11You want to go do all that stuff first.
- 9:13You don't just want to jump straight to the Demerol, right?
- 9:17You got to fix it and then you work on pain control and then your body can heal.
- 9:22It's the same thing with migraine.
- 9:25We're just not used to thinking of it that way because it's been defined as a purely pain
- 9:31thing rather than a brain disease for so long that all of our attention was directed at,
- 9:36well, how do we just make the pain go away?
- 9:38When the real issue is, wait, wait, wait, wait.
- 9:40How do I make the brain actually go back to firing normally?
- 9:45Now, these images are almost ten years old at this point.
- 9:50So we've known for a long time that there's something going on in the brains of people with
- 9:55migraines, making the brain fire abnormally and resulting in this whole experience of migraine.
- 10:04We call this chronification.
- 10:06A couple of you have already used that word on the call.
- 10:08And I just want to make sure you know that chronification actually begins when you're only
- 10:13having two to three headache days a week, and they don't have to all be migraines.
- 10:18People would tell me this for years.
- 10:20They'd come in and say, Yeah, I'm having headaches, like, I don't know, almost every
- 10:25day, but they're not all migraines.
- 10:26You know, as if that makes it okay.
- 10:29It actually doesn't.
- 10:31I mean, I'm glad they're not that severe on those days.
- 10:34That's fantastic.
- 10:35But it's still contributing to abnormal firing in the brain.
- 10:41It's still a reflection of these underlying root causes that are causing migraine in the
- 10:47first place.
- 10:48So I did a TEDx talk about this in 2023 because I don't feel like most neurologists have much
- 10:55of a conversation around this.
- 10:58I feel like what happens for a lot of people is they don't know that this can be the result of
- 11:07that pop a pill and power through mentality.
- 11:10It just gets worse and worse.
- 11:11Your headache days get more and more frequent because you're not fixing the underlying
- 11:15problems that are making the brain fire abnormally in the first place.
- 11:18And then you get to a place where the medications stop working because it's about
- 11:22more than the pain.
- 11:25Then because of the brain's neuroplasticity, it just makes the brain continue to adapt to this
- 11:34new normal because the brain is always learning.
- 11:40A lot of people think the brain is in charge.
- 11:43The brain's actually not in charge.
- 11:44You're in charge.
- 11:45The brain tries to automate everything that it does.
- 11:51If you keep practicing the piano over and over again, you get better at playing the piano.
- 11:56That's neuroplasticity.
- 11:58That's all it is.
- 11:58It's learning.
- 11:59But your brain learns bad habits too, right?
- 12:03So if you're firing migraine all the time, your brain will also learn the bad habit of staying
- 12:10in that loop of firing the migraine circuits in the brain.
- 12:14We call that a maladaptive neuroplasticity.
- 12:17I just did a lecture about that for a bunch of doctors.
- 12:21And so what it means is that even this pop up pill and power through thing, it kind of ends
- 12:30up putting us at a place where we're teaching our brain to have more migraines inadvertently
- 12:36because we're focusing on the pain, we're not focusing on the underlying problems, and then
- 12:43we stopped doing anything about it.
- 12:45Now, the key game changer here, like we've known for ten years in neurology that this
- 12:51chronification thing happens.
- 12:54I think, like I said, I don't think we've done a great job of telling people that can happen.
- 12:58Like, really take your sleep seriously earlier before it gets that bad or whatever, whatever.
- 13:04Sometimes the reasons that migraine is happening are obvious, sometimes they're not.
- 13:08But I think that the game changer for all of this has been new kinds of testing that helps
- 13:15us figure out why the brain is firing abnormally in the first place.
- 13:21One set of testing comes from functional medicine and that does tell you some useful
- 13:28things about leaky gut, about how depleted your body is, about toxins that you might be
- 13:34accumulating.
- 13:35All of those are directly relevant to migraine biology.
- 13:39But I think the real game changer, the thing that's completely turning migraine upside down
- 13:46is functional genomics.
- 13:49And now a lot of people have questions about what's the difference between functional
- 13:53genomics and regular genetic testing.
- 13:56So let's spend a minute talking about that and then I'm going to turn it back over to you guys
- 14:00for questions.
- 14:02So regular genetic testing, which by the way, was not even possible when I started off as a
- 14:11neurologist, like it didn't exist.
- 14:13The human genome had not been sequenced.
- 14:15You couldn't do it.
- 14:17It happened while I was learning to be a doctor that the human genome got sequenced.
- 14:22So, and it took billions of dollars and lots of years, right?
- 14:25Now I know many of you on this call have had it done literally with a cheek swab.
- 14:29So dramatic advances in the research, but let's go over a little bit what the different kinds
- 14:35of genetic testing are.
- 14:37So in the beginning, we started looking at all this DNA information and saying, okay, let's
- 14:42look at one hundred people with migraine.
- 14:45Do they have any abnormalities of their DNA compared to other people?
- 14:50And we found a couple of things, but not very many.
- 14:55The main gene we found was for something called familial hemiplegic migraine.
- 14:59It literally makes you go paralyzed on one side of your body when you get a migraine.
- 15:03It's a very severe thing.
- 15:05You can imagine it as being like a really bad aura, except it's worse, it's genetically
- 15:09mediated, it's because of the way the nerve cells fire in the brain and they just shut
- 15:13down.
- 15:14And it's like having a stroke, except that it comes back, it's reversible.
- 15:19So we found very specific genes for that.
- 15:22And then we thought, we've figured out migraine, this is awesome.
- 15:27We didn't, because then they went on and looked at a lot of different people who just have
- 15:31regular migraine, who don't get paralyzed with their migraines.
- 15:35They don't have the same genetic variation.
- 15:37They don't have that gene for migraine.
- 15:41So, okay, we figured out only one percent of people with migraine.
- 15:46What about the other ninety nine percent?
- 15:48And that is literally what we've spent the last twenty years doing in genetics research.
- 15:53So it turns out that we have been able to do a very sophisticated type of testing called
- 16:01genome wide association studies and this is the coolest thing you guys, here's what they do.
- 16:05They do genetic testing on 100,000 people with migraine, looking at particular details of the
- 16:12genes.
- 16:13They compare that to about seven hundred and fifty thousand people who don't have migraine.
- 16:18And they said, okay, what's different?
- 16:20They're looking at billions of data points comparing these two things.
- 16:25So of course, we couldn't do this until we had good computers, right?
- 16:28They looked at billions of points and they said, okay, well, there's almost 200 different
- 16:34genes that are different about these people with migraine.
- 16:38What do those genes do?
- 16:39They regulate the things you're constantly hearing me talking about brain chemistry,
- 16:43inflammation, energy production, and blood flow.
- 16:47So there are a couple of outliers.
- 16:49What I'm telling you is like 85% of the genes.
- 16:53There's a couple other random ones.
- 16:56But those are the main biological systems in the body that are regulated by these genes.
- 17:04So functional genomics isn't so much about do you have the gene for migraine?
- 17:09That's kind of old school genetic testing.
- 17:11Do you have the gene for this kind of breast cancer, colon cancer?
- 17:16Do you have the MTHFR gene?
- 17:19Which everybody has it.
- 17:21Do you have an abnormality of it?
- 17:23Really the question.
- 17:25So that's kind of how we all kind of grew up thinking about genetic testing.
- 17:32What's fundamentally different is this idea of saying, all right, let's look at 15 different
- 17:38genes that are involved with how your body handles inflammation.
- 17:46How does that whole system work as a result of this gene going a little faster, this gene
- 17:52going a little slower?
- 17:54How does that make your whole body process inflammation?
- 18:00So that's really what functional genomics is about.
- 18:03It's how are these genes actually functioning to regulate the biology that is relevant for
- 18:10migraine?
- 18:11Because some parts of your biology don't matter so much for migraine.
- 18:14Some parts of it really, really do.
- 18:17They directly influence your migraine susceptibility.
- 18:20So that's kind of the difference between these two testing.
- 18:23Sometimes you'll see things about like whole genome sequencing and it can be super
- 18:28expensive.
- 18:30It's really hard to sort through all the different kinds of testing that are available.
- 18:34Is 23andMe okay?
- 18:37Does that tell you anything?
- 18:39What do you need?
- 18:41So that tool, functional genomics, is at a much more accessible price point and it is much more
- 18:51usable information because it's not just do I have that migraine gene?
- 18:57What does that really tell you?
- 18:58It just tells you how you're wired, honestly.
- 19:02It tells you what your diagnosis is likely to be, which is kind of obvious if you go
- 19:06paralyzed with your migraine.
- 19:08Like, that's what you have, you know?
- 19:10So what's so so much more useful about functional genomics is how is your body
- 19:15actually functioning?
- 19:18And that's the kind of thing that we can do with the cheek swabs that get get delivered to
- 19:23your home.
- 19:24So that is why this whole idea of pop a pill and power through is turning on its head and
- 19:30we're thinking, wait a minute, wait a minute, we don't want to just suppress the pain.
- 19:33We actually want to figure out why this is happening in the first place.
- 19:36Which biological systems are responsible for making this brain fire abnormally?
- 19:44Those are the new questions that we are trying to answer.