Latest / Situational Awareness Tactics / WE CHAT WITH FORMER ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE ON HAVANA SYNDROME, ESPIONAGE & MORE
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to Situational Awareness Tactics podcast. This podcast provides the crucial art of understanding
- 0:09current elements in an environment to increase your safety and survival. Here's your host,
- 0:15forensic psychologist and consultant, doctor Carlos Too. Welcome back everyone. Today
- 0:30we have a great guest, doctor Eric Hazeltine. You can find him on
- 0:34Eric doctor Eric Hazeltine dot com. Who is he, Well, he who
- 0:37had a great book to new His book actually is called a Spy in Moscow
- 0:41Station, a counter spy's hunt for a deadly Cold War threat. But today's
- 0:46conversation won't only be discussing this. We're gonna be discussing a whole lot of
- 0:50things, such as the Havana syndrome. You've heard our podcasts in the past.
- 0:54We're gonna talk about that a little bit. We're gonna talk about mind
- 0:57and body. Because doctor Haselton is also a neurosciencest let's read a little bit
- 1:02about his bio his background. He was a director of research at the NSA
- 1:04and the Associate Director of National Intelligence in charge of science and technology for the
- 1:10US intelligence community. So yes, we will be talking about intelligence as well.
- 1:14Before joining the NSA. He was executive vice president of Disney Imagineering.
- 1:18He's a PhD neuroscientist. He has given several popular TED talks on the future
- 1:22of science and as an inventor with over seventy patents and pending patents. He
- 1:26also was reading co authored books with his wife, doctor Chris Gilbert, and
- 1:32we're going to talk about some of their books as well. He's got a
- 1:34whole host of books that I really recommend. They're really fascinating. The newest
- 1:38ones called writing the Monster five ways to innovate inside buocracies. That's going to
- 1:42be a tough task. Another fascinating one is Brian's Brain Safari five minute experiments
- 1:48to explore the space between your ears. How about long FEUs Big Bang achieving
- 1:52long term success through daily victories. His wife and him co authored a great
- 1:56book called The Listening Cure Healing Secrets of an Unconventional Doctor. But today we're
- 2:00focused on the spy in Moscow Station, doctor Hazleteon's career, and a whole
- 2:06lot more. So let's get started. Before we do, though, make
- 2:07sure to share a subscribe hit that I like, but you know we like
- 2:09it. Let's not waste any more time over to the show, Doctor Hazleteon,
- 2:13Welcome sir, great to be here, Thank you, thank you very
- 2:15much for being here. And I guess my first question would be what did
- 2:21your career start in the Intel world, because you have a pretty diverse career,
- 2:25how did you get involved with the Intel service? Well, when I
- 2:29was at Disney, I ran their R and D group for the whole corporation,
- 2:32and I was heavily involved in both film and television production. And when
- 2:38after nine to eleven a videotape was found of Bin Laden talking to a Saudi
- 2:42cleric admitting nine to eleven, ABC News, who I'd been working closely with
- 2:46over the last several years, brought me on to give my opinion about whether
- 2:51that tape had been faked, and wow, my opinion was it hadn't been
- 2:54faked, and I explained why with photogrammetry and things like that. But the
- 3:00more interesting part is you know how they have a chiron underneath you that says
- 3:04who you are, and it said executive vice president Disney imagineering. Well,
- 3:10someone at NSA, I believe it may have been General Hayden himself saw the
- 3:15imagineering part and Congress had been on the intelligence communities rear end to get more
- 3:22of an imagination after nine to eleven. So one reason he hired me to
- 3:27run R and D at NSA is to help get them more of an imagination.
- 3:32Oh wow, I guess you could say it all started with a crawl
- 3:37across the bottom of my face on TV. Hey, whatever it takes,
- 3:43right, that's fascinating. So now the NSA, the CIA has their own
- 3:47R and D because I'm aware of so, I know we've had individuals that
- 3:51came from the CIA area. Did you follow their lead or did you create
- 3:54something completely different? Did you model more of the Disney's imagineering? Well whatever
- 4:01you can share, you know, honey. You say that because the competition
- 4:05between all the intelligence agencies, but particularly the Big four, which is NSA,
- 4:12CIA, the National Conaissance Office NNGA, FBI is in there too,
- 4:17but they're really domestic, although they do get involved in espionage because it's their
- 4:23job to track down and stop foreign spies on US soil. But we're very
- 4:30competitive with each other, so much so that when I first took the job,
- 4:33I went to my counterpart, who was a deputy director at CIA,
- 4:38and I said, don you know let's cooperate. You know, I'm from
- 4:41Disney. I don't have any act to grind. And he said, look,
- 4:43Eric, al Kaita is our target. You are our enemy. You
- 4:46don't get out of here, did we, you know, borrow from CIA?
- 4:54I mean. The other thing to understand is that the largest and by
- 4:58far most technologically sophisticated intel agency is NSA. It really everybody else. Yeah,
- 5:05and you think about why where is data today? It's in the electronic
- 5:10world, right, And so that's NSA's job is to acquire electronic secrets.
- 5:17Now, do you provide anything to the CIA in regards to gear and technology
- 5:21or do they even accept them. We actually did that. We especially in
- 5:29the so called Global War on Terror. We provided a lot of technology that
- 5:32they used, and the relationship at the working level wasn't all that bad.
- 5:38And when you get out into the field, like for example, I spent
- 5:41a lot of time in Islamabad and in Bagram Air Base and places like that
- 5:46involved in the hunt for al Qaeda seniors, and the cooperation increases is the
- 5:51square of the distance from Washington, DC. So in the field, the
- 5:57CIA chief of station is the boss over everybody, and you do what that
- 6:02person says, and people cooperate, and it's there are a lot of reasons
- 6:06for that. You know. One is, in some places you're literally looking
- 6:10out for each other's lives. You know, in a lot of those places,
- 6:15they're pretty nasty. And so if someone's going to get an early warning
- 6:18of an attack on the embassy or on some other station, they're going to
- 6:24pass that along because they know those people. And by the way, it
- 6:28may also be their own skin their saving. So uh, I think that,
- 6:33you know, my personal cooperation with the CIA was quite good in the
- 6:39field back in d C. Not so much now. You know, I
- 6:44teach psychologists. I usually give a little bit of a psychology bent to these
- 6:46shows. But one of the thoughts that popped in my head as you were
- 6:49talking was, wait a minute, doctor Haziartine Disney imagineering. Okay, I'm
- 6:56going to go to NSA lead their program, but now I'm in Bogram,
- 7:00I'm an Islamabad. That to me all of a sudden, says, did
- 7:03you think, well, what am I doing over here? I thought I
- 7:05was just going to be sitting off and have a lot of computers or did
- 7:08you want to do that? No, no, I'll tell you why.
- 7:11And it's because people very senior like I was, at the very top of
- 7:14NSA and very top of the intelligence world, you know, and you don't
- 7:18get the information on what's going on down on the ground. And I learned
- 7:23this when I first became a vice president of Disney. We went through this
- 7:26program where we went all around and one thing we did was we became walk
- 7:30around characters at the Disney parks. So I was rare bear and my job
- 7:34was to find daddies with little girls and grab them and dance with them without
- 7:39asking permission, and you know, watching little girls squeal with delight. I
- 7:45emerged from that experience realizing that I'd been in the entertainment business. I didn't
- 7:49understand it until I actually had to do it, until I find it put
- 7:55in emotion in some kid's heart myself, you know, not working budgets,
- 8:01not working in the laboratory, but right up there making a kid have a
- 8:05better day. And I really understood the business far better. And that experience
- 8:11when I got to NSA said we're fighting two wars, one in Imaq and
- 8:15one in Afghanistan, and other wars, you know, in various other places.
- 8:20And I you know, I'm a leader and I don't know really what's
- 8:24going on out there. So I spent a lot of time. I worked
- 8:26on the roadside bomb problem by driving up and down brewed Irish from the Bagdad
- 8:31Airport, and that gave me great insights. And in my book, the
- 8:37last book I'm writing, The Monster, I talk about how that experience of
- 8:43short circuiting ten layers of the chain of command gave me insights. It helped
- 8:48cut the casualties about and half over about a two month period. Oh wow,
- 8:52So you know, I learned that here's the problem. You know,
- 8:58in the NSA, it's a military organs and I was a senior civilian,
- 9:03but I had a military equivalent rank, which was nine are what they call
- 9:07three star general. And so when I went down and talked to sergeants,
- 9:11it really roughed a lot of feathers. Imagine. Yeah. I worked closely
- 9:16with men and Stan McCrystal, and I once went to the board that governs
- 9:22the Intel community something they call XCOM, and I said, look, you
- 9:24know Stan and Mike and I want you to give us one of your best
- 9:28scientists a year to send down range, meaning to the to the battlefield because
- 9:35that's where the action is. And you got to put the brains where the
- 9:37action is because something gets lost in the translation. And Uh, Admiral Callen,
- 9:43who was a deputy at CIA sitting in for the director, said we're
- 9:48not going to help you. We know who you are. You're you know,
- 9:50a three star general and you go down and talk to sergeants. You
- 9:52can't do that. And I didn't myself to him, and I said,
- 9:56Admiral, how did you ever get to be an admiral without realizing the chief
- 10:00petty officers run the navy? How did that go over? It didn't go
- 10:07I wouldn't imagine, so, but I have to commend you. I mean,
- 10:11that's that's the way to do it, really because it's it is the
- 10:13way to do it. And I'm most proud of in my career of the
- 10:16things that I did in Iraq because of it was there and I wasn't.
- 10:20The other thing is General Hayden used me, as a very senior person to
- 10:24go there on the spot and tell him what was really happening. And there
- 10:30are many times I'd come back from Iraq and I'd say, you know,
- 10:33you know, the love and sunshine you're getting from certain people. There is
- 10:37all bs, you know, really, so they hate us there and we
- 10:41got to do something better. So he immediately did things in response to the
- 10:46input I gave him, because I'd tell him the truth. My fondest hope
- 10:48was to get fired and go back to making serious money at Disney. You're
- 10:54trying to get out of there. It's interesting because I know when I talked
- 10:56to I do another podcast, Stories of Special Forces, and they talk a
- 11:01lot. We talk about that sometimes. It's how difficult it is for them
- 11:05when they have individuals making policy decisions that affect their tactics, their strategies.
- 11:09But the people who are making it never been there, never been on the
- 11:13ground, and I'm telling them, you just can't do that. Doesn't make
- 11:16any sense. How did you not do that, especially in a combat situation.
- 11:20Yeah, well, it's the military in particular, but all organizations have
- 11:24this flaw that information doesn't get up to the top from the bottom. You
- 11:28know, people do not speak truth to power. It's the bottom line because
- 11:33you get punished for it. And like I say, literally I took like
- 11:37a five x pay cut at least probably more than that, you know,
- 11:43And to go from Disney to NSA and I gee, you know, so
- 11:50what I'm gonna do is I'm just going to get more and more outrageous and
- 11:52tell the truth more and more. And the problem was General Hayden was the
- 11:56kind of guy that that he really appreciated that instead of losing influence, I
- 12:01gained influence and then I got promoted to run S and T for the whole
- 12:05intelligence community. It's amazing. You remember that show Undercover Boss. Yeah,
- 12:11I've heard about it. Yeah, that kind of gives me the kind of
- 12:15reminds me of that where the CEOs, I think, really get a lesson
- 12:18that they learned when they talk about their front line workers. Yeah, we
- 12:22know. John McCarey, the great fine novelist, said an office is a
- 12:26terrible place from which to see the world. That's a great quote, very
- 12:31fitting. So let's do this before we get to your book. Any intelligence
- 12:37stories or anything that you worked on, And you mentioned Rude Irish, which
- 12:41is actually pretty popular. We've talked a lot about that, were out several
- 12:45guys in Special Forces keeps popping up. But anything at all that pops up
- 12:48that you can share story, you know, the one that's in the book
- 12:52writing The Monster, I think it's the most interesting because what happened there is
- 12:56I'm writing day after day after day with this convoy from Michigan. It was
- 13:01an artillery unit that didn't have anybody to shoot at, and so they got
- 13:05convoy duty. And so I got to know this lieutenant and one day we're
- 13:09in a In those days, we're talking early two thousand and four, we
- 13:13didn't have all the right armory yet on Humvey. So we rode on sandbags.
- 13:18We took out the seats and we put in sandbags, and we sat
- 13:22on the sandbags. And of course, if a one five to five Mike
- 13:28was going to get you, a sandbag wasn't going to help you. But
- 13:31anyhow, I once, you know, I've been back in the States working
- 13:37with Pentagon on anti ied technology. So I said to the lieutenant, Hey,
- 13:43what if we could detect the presence of these things outside their blast radius
- 13:48and tell you roughly what quadrant they're in. And he goes, oh,
- 13:50my god, I would love that. And then the next to him,
- 13:54a twenty year older sergeant in theory inferior to him and rank, got real
- 14:01stiff and attitude, and you know, so lieutenant says, sergeant, what
- 14:05is it? He goes, you know, permission to speak freely? Sir,
- 14:09okay, yeah, go ahead. So he turns to me and he
- 14:11says, doctor, that's the dumbest effing idea I ever heard. I goes,
- 14:15whoa, we're spending billions of dollars on that. You know. Why
- 14:18is that dumb? He said, because think about it. If we detect
- 14:20it and the thing works with who says, it's really going to work because
- 14:24most of crap we get out here doesn't work, but anyhow supposed to works.
- 14:28We're going to stop three hundred meters back and the moves. That was
- 14:31their turn for the insurgents. They're smart because we killed all the ones that
- 14:35weren't and they're going to say, oh, we put the trigger here.
- 14:39They're going to stop here, so that's where we'll put the explosive. You're
- 14:43gonna get us all killed. Yes, we're gonna have to wait for bond
- 14:48disposal, you know. Yeah, no, no, I said, whoa.
- 14:52See that's again, the people spending all that money on counter IEDs hadn't
- 14:56been in a convoy on rude irish. They didn't know, and there's no
- 15:01way to know that unless you're there. That's right. So uh he said,
- 15:03I said, well, Sargeant, what should you do? And he
- 15:05told me and I did it, and two months later we had really cut
- 15:09the casualties significantly. We didn't stop them, but we did cut them.
- 15:15And uh so that's one story. The other story, and this is a
- 15:18brain thing that I have written about too. One day, you know,
- 15:22God knows why. I mean, common sense says you don't leave at the
- 15:26same time by the same route with the same car every day, right,
- 15:31that's right. We did, we did, you know. And the guys
- 15:35who were working in the commissary or the shop are the ones that are also
- 15:37killing, you know, and so uh, you know, you know when
- 15:43you're leaving, and so you know. But there was a good part of
- 15:46it, and that one day in the morning, we were driving to the
- 15:50green zone for a meeting and I told the driver to stop and turn around.
- 15:54And it was like I was watching myself say it. No thought came
- 15:58in to my head. I just said stop, turn around now. And
- 16:03I had learned to trust my intuition and in the battlefield people do, so
- 16:08he didn't question me. He just turned around. And then you know,
- 16:12in the rearview mirror a few maybe ten fifteen seconds later, we see this
- 16:18big bill of black smoke. We were about to hit an ied and the
- 16:23guys behind us did hit the ied. So you know, the guy driving
- 16:32said, how did you know? And I said, I don't know how
- 16:36I knew. Let me think about it. So I calmed down because it
- 16:38was really you know, it wasn't a thought that I felt. It was
- 16:45an overriding terror that I felt. And so I examined it and I went
- 16:49back at what I had seen, and what I realized was at that particular
- 16:56stretch of rude, Irish kids were always playing, you know, some kind
- 17:03of soccer game out in a dirt lot. That morning, they weren't.
- 17:08There's your anomaly. And that's because moms knew that something was happening and they
- 17:12didn't want their kids around. And some lizard part of my brain knew that.
- 17:18And that's fascinating. I mean, it was really fast. It was
- 17:19totally unconscious, and most people who've been in situations like that will tell you
- 17:25that they have that that experience. That's fascinating. I know good friends of
- 17:33mine. I don't know if you're familiar with Combat Hunter and Greg Williams,
- 17:37and that's One of the things they talk a lot about is that gut intuition
- 17:41and situational awareness aspect, which we've mentioned in our other podcast. Situational awareness.
- 17:45A lot of times you have to trust your gut instinct. And it's
- 17:48interesting if I can share a story really quickly with you. I know,
- 17:51there was a I think it was a Navy seal. He was working with
- 17:56LPD and something, and there was a woman who went to a apartment.
- 18:00The guy asked her, can I get in? I forgot my buddy doesn't
- 18:04answer the phone. I want to get into you my letting me in,
- 18:07And she said she she felt something weird intuitively, but she felt that she
- 18:11was going to be a jerk if she didn't, so she said, just
- 18:15come on in. And he's sexually assaulted her. But another woman, same
- 18:19guy, same tactic, Can I get you mind my buddy to answer the
- 18:23phone? She said, I felt the same thing, and I said no,
- 18:27So I shut the door on him, and he got really upset and
- 18:32starts, you know, shaking the door, yelling at her, cursing at
- 18:34her. Eventually arrested him get raped seven or eight women. But again the
- 18:38importance of that intuition is really amazing. I can see if we're hers too.
- 18:44I think it's implicit learning. You know, this is a phenomena in
- 18:48perception and learning and memory where we absorb and learn all kinds of things.
- 18:52So that realized and we're doing it. And the best example is, you
- 18:56know, please don't get grossed out by this, but you're sitting in your
- 19:00office or your studio right and there are objects all around you. So I
- 19:03want you to imagine that you're licking them, you know, like lick what's
- 19:08on your desk, or you know, put this or that in your mouth.
- 19:11Look at I'm not going to ask you to do it, and you
- 19:15imagine doing it and imagine what it would feel like on your tongue and in
- 19:18your mouth, and you have a pretty damn good idea of what every single
- 19:23thing would feel like, your taste like, or you know, and how
- 19:26is that because when you were a baby you put everything in your mouth.
- 19:33Your brain remember of implicit learning, and I think that that you know,
- 19:41like when you drive the same way every day, you see certain rhythms and
- 19:45patterns in your brain records it and registers it, but you're not really aware
- 19:49of doing that except when something's missing, So are you You've heard that concept
- 19:56where we are conscious miles of soaking three to forty bits of information. But
- 20:00then some argue that our unconscious mind can soak up and it goes anywhere from
- 20:04a million to three million pieces of information. So you kind of seem like
- 20:07you're supporting that idea. Oh you know, Actually, the thing I am
- 20:11most fascinated about in neuroscience and psychology is the unconscious because and this is the
- 20:18essence of my book with my wife, The Listening Cure. How really,
- 20:22when we get you to get in touch with your body, we're taking a
- 20:26deep dive into your unconscious where you where your different body parts live. I
- 20:32don't want to go more into it because you know, I want to bring
- 20:33my wife on because she invented all this. But that's the essence of it.
- 20:37And I believe that almost nothing of what drives our behavior and what goes
- 20:44on in our brain is conscious. It's it's it's like a tiny fraction of
- 20:49a percent of what's really going on. I agree with you there, And
- 20:52folks, the doctor Hazelton will be coming on with his wife in the future
- 20:56on another podcast. We're doing the Circle of Insights, So keep an eye
- 21:00open for that one. Maybe we'll share here this spotcast as a special one
- 21:03as well. Spycraft again, folks, is doctor Eric hazelteen Haselteine. I
- 21:08lived on a street called Hazelton uh E r I C. Hazel Hazeltine is
- 21:12h A s E l t I n E. The book is called a
- 21:15Spy in Moscow Station. We're going to head over to there now a counter
- 21:18spies hunt for a deadly Cold War threat. But the interesting thing, too,
- 21:23folks, is that he says there's some aspects of this book that kind
- 21:26of correlate with the Havana syndrome. So first, let's find out why he
- 21:30wrote this book. Why did you write this book? Well, I actually
- 21:33explained that in the opening chapter. When I first took over at NSA.
- 21:37You know, you said, wow, Disney NSA, and that doesn't compute.
- 21:41Now. There are a lot of people at NSA who thought that too,
- 21:45really, So they gave me as a gift, quote unquote an advisory
- 21:48board made up of great beards who were from the industry, meaning intelligence officers,
- 21:55retired intelligence officers and so forth. And they kind of looked over my
- 21:59shoulder and at the very first meeting in January of two thousand and three where
- 22:07I was presenting my plans for the research group there at NSA. You know,
- 22:14in the break, this gentleman comes up to me and it almost felt
- 22:18like the tale of the ancient Mariner, you know, with a long gray
- 22:23beard and glittering eye. Whie, father, those stop at me. So
- 22:27this guy, who was, you know, an elderly gentleman, came up
- 22:30to me and I recognized him vaguely because he had interviewed me for the job
- 22:37and he had actually voted against me because he thought I was a Mickey mouse
- 22:41candidate. He says, no, he has this. Unfortunately he died in
- 22:48May, but he is. I'm getting into this because he's the hero of
- 22:51the book. His name is Charles Gandy, and he's from rural Louisiana and
- 22:55he speaks in this very slow southern drawl, and he said, you know,
- 23:02doctor, we were very surprised by what you presented, and that you
- 23:07actually seem to not a little bit about what you're doing personally came as a
- 23:12great shock to me. But you're missing one thing and I wanted to tell
- 23:18you in private, so it's not to embarrass you. There's a huge blind
- 23:22spot here at NSA and in your group, and it has to do with
- 23:26certain kinds of trade craft that the Russians are way better at us then,
- 23:33and I need you to really put focus on that. And I said,
- 23:37well, you know, I want to be polite because this is the same
- 23:41board that recommending the firing of my predecessor, and he had been fired and
- 23:45that's why I was there, so I wanted to handle this carefully. So
- 23:52I said, well, I want to hear what you have to say,
- 23:56but please understand that the President has asked us to focus on finding al Qaeda
- 24:00seniors and in helping put an end to the insurgency in Iraq as our top
- 24:06priorities, and Russia isn't in there. And in fact, Russia, you
- 24:11know, is down on their luck and they're not doing well at all.
- 24:14So I'm not honestly convinced that we should spend much money focusing on them.
- 24:21And he says his eyes lit up, and he goes, don't ever underestimate
- 24:26the Russians. Let me tell you a story. And the story he told
- 24:32is the story of the book, and it begins in nineteen seventy eight,
- 24:37seventy seven in Moscow, where we have what we call assets in the intelligence
- 24:45world. These are people that we hire or persuade to steal secrets for US,
- 24:49and they're foreign nationals. So in Russia we had human assets that were
- 24:55getting arrested, tortured, and executed in shockingly high number, and so much
- 25:02so that the CIA director Stansfield Turner, shut down all human intelligence gathering in
- 25:07Moscow starting in nineteen seventy seven. Late nineteen seventy seven, So the head
- 25:14of station there is basically out of business, a guy named Gus Hathaway,
- 25:17who's an old Cold warrior, and he said, well, screw this,
- 25:22I got to find the leak so that I can get back in business.
- 25:26And so, in desperation, he remembered hearing a presentation from this guy,
- 25:34Charles Gandhi, who was going around trying to tell anyone who would listen that
- 25:38the Russians had really cool stuff that was far ahead of us. And so
- 25:44he calls him up and he says, look, I got a problem.
- 25:48Could you come over to Moscow and help me find a leak. So you
- 25:52have to understand the animosity between CIA and NSCA. You realized the enormity of
- 25:57this event. So anyhow, Gandhy goes over there in seventy eight April of
- 26:04seventy eight, and he does find some things. He is there when they
- 26:11break into a chimney and they find a really unusual antenna pointed at the ambassador's
- 26:17office. And he also had a crew of people there that was listening to
- 26:23what we call ex filtration signals, and he was hearing things that he knew
- 26:29were probably text but he didn't know what they were. Anyhow, at the
- 26:33end of three weeks, he goes to the chief of station, he presents
- 26:36his finding. He says, yeah, you got a leak. He played
- 26:38him certain clicks from it, and he said, here it is. And
- 26:41by the way, and this gets a little delicate. You know, the
- 26:48Russians, of course, were spying on everything that he was doing inside the
- 26:52embassy, but they were using equipment that he himself could turn around and spy
- 26:56on, so he knew what they were picking up from him, and he
- 27:00knew what they were saying about what he was doing. We call this robbing
- 27:07the highway robber, you know, And I mean he was good, but
- 27:11they didn't quite realize how good he was. And so he presented all that
- 27:18evidence translations of what the Russians were themselves saying about this operation, and it
- 27:22was a smoking gun. It's like here it is okay. So he goes
- 27:27back and he can't convince anybody. For some reason, nothing happened. Now
- 27:33this is where the parallels with the Havana syndrome come in. You know,
- 27:37you had experts at State Department, who's responsible for the embassy at CIA,
- 27:41who's responsible for classified systems there, and they're all saying, wow, this
- 27:45is really you know, Gandhi is saying this, but we don't really think
- 27:48it's true. So they basically denied it or said they didn't understand it,
- 27:52which was very similar to the microwave radiation that had been going on at the
- 27:56embassy for many years. That the Russians were beaming microwaves at the embassy of
- 28:02various frequencies and so forth for a long time from many different locations, and
- 28:07they didn't really know what they were and you know, they didn't think they
- 28:08were of much consequence. And later now that's going to turn out to be
- 28:14hugely significant for Havana syndrome, because I think it's incredibly likely that that's what's
- 28:18causing Havana syndrome that exact same kind of attack. And in fact, the
- 28:23National Academy of Sciences came out with a report within the last year that said
- 28:29that they said pulse microwave, but translation is that kind of irradiation that the
- 28:34Russians have been beaming at our diplomats and spies forever. So anyhow, there
- 28:44ensued a period of three to four years where nothing happened, and he kept
- 28:52trying to, you know, get people's attention, and in fact, it
- 28:56got so bad he was making such a nuisance of himself that no less than
- 29:00the Director of the CIA told his boss, the Director of NSA, which
- 29:06at the time reported to CIA, or rather the director of CIA, that
- 29:11job is now taken over by the DNI, the Director of National Intelligence where
- 29:15I work. But anyhow, he said, you are to stand down and
- 29:18cease and desist. This isn't your job. Knock it off. And George
- 29:25Schaltz, who we interviewed for the book, actually he was the Secretary of
- 29:27State, he said, look, show me a smoking gun or shut up.
- 29:33Okay. So years go by and it's now nineteen eighty four and the
- 29:42French, in a very unusual show of cooperation because the head of French counterintelligence
- 29:49had been a buddy of the head of NESSA when they worked at NATO as
- 29:53military officers together. He called him and he said, you know, we
- 29:56found this thing in our embassy. We think he is a very sophisticated bug.
- 30:00We can't really figure it out. So head of NSA had Gandhy send
- 30:06his best guy over there and analyze it. And they found out that it
- 30:10had an unbelievably sophisticated optical bug and an optical character reader. And I won't
- 30:15go into all the details of what it was, but it was really really
- 30:18clever. And so at that time, so Gandy compiled this report and he
- 30:25sent it out and the number three guy at NSA was a guy named Walter
- 30:27Deeley, and he was responsible for all defense of really the highest nuclear launch
- 30:34codes and presidential communication and spyglass and Air Force one, I mean, and
- 30:40then all the top military communications. He was in charge of protecting all of
- 30:44that. And he sees this report that the Russians have got something that we
- 30:48don't understand, or now we do understand it, but it's like way beyond
- 30:52what we could normally detect. And he comes in and he says again,
- 30:55and he throws it down on the guest desk and he goes, you know,
- 30:57damn, he said, this is sophisticated stuff they've thrown up against the
- 31:02French, who are, let's face it, at third rate power. What
- 31:06are they using against us if they're doing this against the French. So Gandy
- 31:11says, uh, yeah, that's a problem. I think they're using much
- 31:15more sophisticated stuff and I found evidence of it and here it is. Wow.
- 31:21So Dealey says, well, what the hell, let's work on this.
- 31:26He says, I can't to see how a director ordered us to stop
- 31:27investigating all of this kind of stuff. And I was putting my job on
- 31:32the line to send a guy over to France to investigate this sub So Dealey
- 31:37says, what would it take to get past this stupid roadblock? And Gandy
- 31:41jokes, he goes, well, I guess a letter from President Reagan would
- 31:45do it. He says, okay, got it. Three days later,
- 31:51Dealey comes back with the signed letter from President Rake and it says, essentially,
- 31:57Charlie, this is to certify that Charles Gandy, you know, his
- 32:00team has my full authority. He is to be given every assistance by whoever
- 32:05reads this. So Reagan said enough of this. BS. He wasn't a
- 32:12big fan of the Russians, as you know. And so anyhow, the
- 32:19game was back on after you know, six years of nothing happening, and
- 32:25this again, I want to pause a moment and say, when you look
- 32:30at the Havana syndrome, I'm not going to say nothing is happening, but
- 32:32when you look at the public pronouncements by State Department and others, you know,
- 32:37they're not sure what it is. They're not even sure that there's anything
- 32:40at all there maybe a psychosomatic illness or who knows, And that is exactly
- 32:46the line that State Department was using back in those days. And so anyhow,
- 32:55so well, Deeley, then with Charles Gandy, they start this project
- 33:00called Project Gunman, meaning you know, finding the smoking gun that George Schutz
- 33:06had asked for. Well, I won't go into it because I want people
- 33:08to buy the book and read it. But of course they eventually do find
- 33:13and prove the bug that Gandhi had known about since nineteen seventy eight, and
- 33:20now we're talking nineteen eighty four, and they what they did is one final
- 33:25little note is that they on the cover it said Project Gunman and it showed
- 33:31two forty five pistols crossed with smoke coming out of the barrels. It was
- 33:37that f you in your face to George Schaltz, is what it was?
- 33:40You want your smoking gun? Here's your smoking gun. And the guy who
- 33:45was present when that report was delivered to Schaltz said Schaltz looked at it and
- 33:51slammed it down because he knew it was an fu and he was furious with
- 33:54his own people who had assured him there was nothing to it. How could
- 34:00you allow this to happen? Well, and this again is the part that
- 34:05correlates with the Havana syndrome. You know, the National Academy of Science has
- 34:12you know who's you know, our top scientists in the nation has said this
- 34:15is what it is. And yet you know, it still goes on and
- 34:20is recently is the incident Hanois, recent incidents in Vienna and in Berlin and
- 34:25even near the White House. It still goes on. And by the way,
- 34:30the same thing happened forty years ago in my book that the State Department
- 34:36really didn't improve its security, and you know they they allowed leaks like this
- 34:44to continue and do to this day. And this is going to sound horrible,
- 34:50and I apologize to any listeners out there, but I actually said this.
- 34:53I give a lot of talks on cybersecurity, and someone asked me way
- 34:59back during the twenty sixteen elections, why really did Hillary Clinton have her own
- 35:04email server when they had top secret you know, at the State Department.
- 35:08And I said, without joking one scintilla, Oh, her private email system
- 35:15I'm sure was far more secure than the State Department's top secret network. Really,
- 35:21I'm meant it. Man. You know, we always said Department of
- 35:27State DOS doesn't offer security. Let me ask you this, you know,
- 35:35because we've had cybersecurity experts in the past, and I know somebody floated this
- 35:38idea back not too long ago, probably about six months ago, and every
- 35:44time I asked them. By the way, folks, we're talking to doctor
- 35:49Eric Hasseltein. The book is Spy The Spy in Moscow Station. Must read,
- 35:53folks. He just kind of gave us the tip of the iceberg.
- 35:57But you see a lot of twists and turns in this, a lot of
- 35:59Spida stuff. I highly recommend it. It's a great read. But doctor
- 36:04Hesseltine when I've asked them, have we lost it? Is? I guess
- 36:08my question to some of these cyber expert securities people, have we lost control
- 36:15of it? Because it seems like we see a lot of these hacks that
- 36:17are happening now and hacking into our own state department, as you mentioned,
- 36:23kind of some of the weaknesses there. Some of them are even suggesting that
- 36:28some of our more sensitive types of institutions should go offline and go back to
- 36:34the old school where they can't hack it, because we have lost the ability
- 36:37to protect them. What do you think about that? I agree with it.
- 36:44You know what's happened is if you look at any operating system on Apple
- 36:49or Microsoft, there's hundreds of millions of lines of code. Yeah, you
- 36:52can't know what all of those are doing. You can't. And if you
- 36:57go to any enterprise and ask I want you to now every note and edge
- 37:00in your network, they can't do it. You know. For one thing,
- 37:05nodes are coming on and dropping off all the time with wireless and so
- 37:07forth. So these systems are far too complex, and especially when something new
- 37:14is rolled out, the bad guy always has a lead on you, and
- 37:16that they watch for it coming, they find the holes in it before it
- 37:21comes out, and then boom you get a zero date. So I think
- 37:27it is a problem that's cannot be solved, and you cannot solve it by
- 37:35air gapping either. Just to make a couple observations, the centrifuges at atons
- 37:43in Iran, we're air gapped and they got taken down with Cyper. Okay,
- 37:49Now, when we get into what the Havana syndrome is all about,
- 37:54I believe, and I say this in my article that I published, that
- 37:59I believe it's what I call an air gap jumping technique, a technique of
- 38:02injecting malware into an information device remotely without having it beyond any network. Wow.
- 38:13So no, there is no such thing as air gap. And that's
- 38:20not really the answer I give. This is kind of what I'm an expert
- 38:22in and I do a lot of speaking and consulting on this issue, and
- 38:27I say, you have to take a completely different approach. You have to
- 38:30assume that you are penetrated twenty four to seven. Disassume it because it's not
- 38:37a bad assumption, and then you operate very differently. And my wife and
- 38:43I, again, who's a biomedical person. We give the speech called what
- 38:45the Octopus Can teach Us about cybersecurity, and we talk about the movie My
- 38:52Octopus Teacher, and in that you have this octopus and anyone who hasn't seen
- 38:58that movie you have to see it on Netflix. It's an incredible movie and
- 39:01you realize just how unbelievably smart octopuses are. I mean, you know,
- 39:07like up there with dolphins and monkeys, and I mean they're really smart.
- 39:10And you know, the way the octopus survives is, you know, it
- 39:15lives in the water next to sharks that eat it, so its neighbors want
- 39:21to kill it twenty four to seven and yet usually it survives. And what
- 39:27does it do. It has no perimeter defense. It has about eight or
- 39:31nine technolog you know, things that it has evolved over billions of years to
- 39:37counter the threat that's living right next to it. Literally, I mean,
- 39:43one thing it does is it gathers shells from the floor and gets up in
- 39:46a little ball and makes itself look like a bunch of seashells that are on
- 39:50the floor. And then if the shark doesn't get fooled, then comes after
- 39:53it. Because sharks have good sense of smell, and they also have electro
- 39:58reception, so they can tell when there's living tissue around because of their electric
- 40:02field perception. Then the ocopus shot jumps on the shark's back where the shark
- 40:09can't get it. I mean, there are all of these kinds of things,
- 40:13and each one of them has a homologue in cybersecurity. Fascinating, and
- 40:20so as a biologist, I think biology is wise and it has evolved solutions
- 40:27to these same kind of problems, you know, over and over and over
- 40:30again, and we should pay attention to that because you know, really the
- 40:37internet and networks are like a ocean. Everything's connected to everything, so all
- 40:43your baddest predators are right there next to you all the time. And so
- 40:49I think that that is when I advise people, I go down the road
- 40:54of you know, okay, you don't care so much if they steal your
- 41:00you just care that they act on it. So what if you just salt
- 41:02it with a bunch of misinformation or even stuff that they download, It is
- 41:07going to blow them up. You know, they're either not going to trust
- 41:10what they steal from you, or they're going to worry about what they steal
- 41:13from you. That's a very different approach to cybersecurity psyops now it is.
- 41:21It is because it's very much a mind game, and so that's really you
- 41:25know, when it comes to cyber I think most of the approaches that are
- 41:30taken at best or temporary band aids, there needs to be a complete rethink
- 41:37of the philosophy of how you approach these problems. It's a fascinating and fascinating
- 41:43It kind of reminds me a little bit too, how I always tell people
- 41:45that how important chess can become strategizing and thinking about consequences ahead. And it
- 41:52sounds like the same thing with you in the networking and the ability to be
- 41:54able to think ahead and to do these counter moves as you mentioned a minute
- 41:59ago, setting them up, well, I think, and the number one
- 42:01thing is to always assume you've been penetrated. You know, the chief security
- 42:08officer tells the CEO and the CFO, hey, we're protected. I've got
- 42:13the latest and greatest stuff. We do passes, we do this, we
- 42:15do that. It's all blowning. It's all complete blowning. They're not safe
- 42:22and they know it, and they're not because here's the thing. Okay,
- 42:28clearly someone in Iran put something in a computer that they shouldn't have put in
- 42:32there, even upon pain of death if discovered. Literally, but they did
- 42:39it. Okay, So okay, they say there's CIS admins pass their systems
- 42:45regularly and correctly. Well, no, they say they do, but do
- 42:52they really one hundred percent? There's human error, there's laziness, there's you
- 42:55know, most of these problems come down to human problems. You know,
- 43:00Rob Joyce, who's had a cybersecurity and say, gave a public speech in
- 43:04which he said, you know, people think we're super duper hackers and that
- 43:07we have this super duper technology. It's not true. We exploit human weakness.
- 43:13Excellent point. It's an excellent point. I think about a lot of
- 43:16those cases that we've heard last year alone, A lot of them people who
- 43:20had got tricked by emails or whatnot, and they give them wrong information or
- 43:23inserted software. The other thing too, you mentioned. I think one of
- 43:28the agencies that does cybersecurity forgot who it was. It was a really large
- 43:31agency, but better I don't say it. It's not a federal agency,
- 43:34but it was a private entity and they got hacked. These are the guys
- 43:38that are supposed to be protecting everybody else. That's where I started really realizing.
- 43:44I think we were starting to lose the whole of this thing. We
- 43:47never had a hold on it. Oh, we never had it. By
- 43:52the way, folks, doctor Hasselteine, it's doctor d R H A S
- 43:57E L T I n E dot com. Who want to find more in
- 43:59from We got a couple more questions before to wrap up, and doctor Chris
- 44:01Gilbert his wife, you want to learn more about her? Doctor is d
- 44:06R C H R I S Gilbert g I L B E r T dot
- 44:08com Doctor Haslton in the last few minutes together, you're a futurist. You're
- 44:14a lot of things. They're an author, a neuroscientists, intelligence office,
- 44:17but you're also a futurist. Anything you see on the horizon in regards to
- 44:22intelligence or technology that you think either concerns you or maybe gives you hope.
- 44:29I worry about the intersection of AI and cyber We're talked about that a little
- 44:35bit, and I have worked a lot with AI. I've been doing a
- 44:39number of projects in that area over the last several years, and I can
- 44:45see what it can do and what it can't do. But one of the
- 44:47things I worry about is an adversary that's AI, and it's a force multiplier.
- 44:54Like you know, you assume that nation states have a lot of human
- 44:58resources to throughout the and they do, and that creates problems for us.
- 45:02But you could have one individual with an AI do serious damage, I mean
- 45:08serious damage. And the thing that's nasty about that is a nation state that
- 45:15attacks you has their own country to protect, and so they got to be
- 45:21a little careful about really ticking you off, right if their thinger found on
- 45:25it. But an individual, especially one who could be like a suicide bomber
- 45:30type mentality, M not so much. And so I think that the leverage
- 45:37that AI would give someone who's a cyber terrorist for example, and the damage
- 45:45that can be done, I mean, you look at the colonial pipeline,
- 45:46you look at you know, various other hacks that have happened that are devastating.
- 45:53You know, one person could do that to a nation I don't believe,
- 46:00go ahead, Yeah, And so that's really when you ask about the
- 46:04intersection, I think you have to AI has to be a very big part.
- 46:10And you know, as a futurist, what I see is inflection points,
- 46:15what happened with AI about ten years ago was this thing called alex net
- 46:20where they used a convolutional h deep learning neural nets, you know, many
- 46:28layered deep and they were able to do image classification about as good as humans,
- 46:34you know, with very high training corpor That was a huge breakthrough.
- 46:38I mean, it's really kind of laid the foundation for a lot of the
- 46:42miracles that we take for granted. Today. We are waiting for that next
- 46:47breakthrough, and you know, I'm hoping to advance that, you know,
- 46:54applying neuroscience to AI in kind of new ways. But I think I think
- 47:00that the thing is we know that there are big inflection points out there where
- 47:04you say, there's before that and after that, and when I think about
- 47:07the future, that's what I think about. It's not just generically the future.
- 47:12We know Moore's law, which is what drives everything, is probably going
- 47:15to continue for another ten years, at least not in the way that Gordon
- 47:21Moore originally envisioned it with miniaturization, but in other ways. Three D being
- 47:25one quantum being another. I don't see really any end in sight to Moore's
- 47:32law, honestly, I mean, we're already well passed the point where it
- 47:37was supposed to be dead due to quantum tunneling limits and things like that.
- 47:40So that I think is the single most important thing that is going to drive
- 47:46the future is computers are going to continue to get either smaller and cheaper and
- 47:52cheaper and cheaper and cheaper and penetrate every single thing in your life. They
- 47:58already do. You know, there's a computer in your credit card that use
- 48:00as a chip, and you know everywhere there's a computer everywhere. So that's
- 48:07one trend is you know, writing the cost curve way down, you know,
- 48:13from a few things to a billions of things. And then the other
- 48:15is the very high performance computing with with AI and an intelligence. One of
- 48:22the things you have to worry about is crypt analysis. You know, high
- 48:29performance computers are It's well known they're used in crypt analysis for obvious reasons.
- 48:35I mean, in the simples case, if you wanted to just have a
- 48:37password guesser, having a computer that could you know, rapidly go through very
- 48:43fast every possible permutation and combination. You know, if you have enough speed
- 48:49and enough memory, you can do amazing things right, and you don't have
- 48:53to be that sophisticated and now someone can just order hunt and cold running super
- 48:59comput her from the cloud, and so you know, you compare that to
- 49:06AI and you do things like crypt analysis, and I think you can definitely,
- 49:12you know you can. You can definitely see that there could be big
- 49:19opportunities ahead, in big trouble ahead. It's so right. It made me
- 49:23think of so many people I've had on the show that I've had individuals who
- 49:28she's a cyber hacker and she was hired by the law enforcement to hack in
- 49:32the cars from a hotel window and she can disarm the car and get it
- 49:37to stop from a distance. And then I was thinking about the article I
- 49:40read about the computers inside the toilets so they can check to see your health.
- 49:45And it's just mind blowing how much they're they're creating these things, and
- 49:49how much access they have to each and every individual. That's really scary.
- 49:54That's right. Well, there's a good part of it too. One of
- 49:58the things my wife and I work on is predicting public health events from masses
- 50:05of data. You know, the fact that almost everybody's on the Internet and
- 50:07has a mobile device means that we've instrumented most of the population and we have
- 50:12data on them, and we're learning all kinds of things. One of the
- 50:15things we discovered is that there's a correlation between allergies and strokes. They tend
- 50:19to happen at about the same time of year. No one knew that before.
- 50:24Also, what month of the year you're born, to some degree,
- 50:30can predict what kind of illnesses you're going to suffer from throughout your lifetime and
- 50:32even maybe what you're going to die from. And why that is we don't
- 50:37know, but it's definitely a statistically significant finding. And we also are looking
- 50:45at, you know, a lot of mental illnesses it now appears are related
- 50:52to systemic inflammation, particularly mood disorders, and so we looked at seasonality of
- 50:59mood disorders using Google search and Wikipedia page use where we can track search interest
- 51:04over time, which peaks in the fall and winter and then early spring.
- 51:08And so do suicides. By the way, and if you look at searches
- 51:14on things like inflammation and you go in to look at CDC data on aggregated
- 51:19data on inflammatory proteins in the blood of patients from hospitals around the country,
- 51:24you see they're highly correlated. Now, does that mean there's a causal link.
- 51:30I don't know, but a lot of kind of leading edge neuroscientists looking
- 51:35at mood disorders now strongly suspect that systemic inflammation is a big factor. Wow.
- 51:43That's amazing because you made me think. One of the things I'm always
- 51:46doing a lot of research on is the neurobiology and neurodevelopment, especially in utero,
- 51:52and all the different things that can impact with babies neurodevelopment. And now
- 51:54you're mentioning different birthdays in the months and things of that nature. And I'm
- 51:58thinking holidays and thinking drinking, feel alcohol, exposure, all kinds of things.
- 52:04Yeah, fascinating. We could be here all day, friends, man,
- 52:09doctor Haselton, and everybody. Again. You can find more information at
- 52:13d r H A s l H s E L T I n E dot
- 52:16com. Definitely go catch the book, hey, and then you was called
- 52:20one. It's called Writing the Monster, which is a fascinating read. And
- 52:22of course this is a spy book called The Spy in Moscow Station, a
- 52:28counterspies hunt for a deadly Cold war threat. Doctor Haselton, thank you so
- 52:30much for being here. It was delightful. Thank you very much, Thank
- 52:35you. It was an awesome time. Thank you everyone for listening. Make
- 52:37sure to get the book, make sure to catch you and subscribe and hit
- 52:40that I Like button. Thanks for listening, everybody,