Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How To Ask For Your Job Back After You Quit
Transcript
- Lucas: So you quit your job, gave a two-week notice, maybe even had a goodbye lunch. And then — within a month — you realize you made a mistake. The new role isn't what was promised, the culture is toxic, the commute is brutal. And your old job? It's still sitting there, waiting to be filled. What do you do? Luna: You ask for it back. Which feels terrifying. Like admitting failure in front of everyone you just said goodbye to. Lucas: Exactly. And that fear is the biggest barrier. But the data says it's more common than you think. A 2024 survey from the workforce analytics firm iCIMS found that about 15 percent of employees who voluntarily left their jobs have later asked to return. And of those, roughly 40 percent were rehired. Luna: Forty percent — that's not a long shot. That's almost a coin flip. Lucas: Right. And a lot of companies actually have boomerang employee policies — they officially welcome back former staff within a certain timeframe. Netflix, for example, is known for rehiring people who left on good terms. So the door isn't as closed as your ego tells you it is. Luna: But the key phrase there is 'left on good terms.' If you stormed out or sent a nasty email, that's a different conversation. Lucas: Absolutely. Today's episode is about the scenario where you left well — professional resignation, no bridge-burning — and then regret sets in. We're going to walk through a real case. A marketing manager at a midsize tech company. Let's call her Sarah. Luna: Sarah had been at the company for about three years. She was good — led the product launch campaigns, had solid relationships with the sales team. But she got headhunted by a flashy Series A start-up offering 20 percent more and a 'director of marketing' title. Lucas: She accepted. Gave her notice. Her then-boss, a VP named Dan, was disappointed but handled it gracefully. He even said, 'If it doesn't work out, my door is open.' That exact line. Luna: Classic. And then three weeks into the start-up, Sarah realized the product roadmap was fiction, the CEO was a micromanager, and she was working 70-hour weeks. She missed her old team, her old work-life balance, and honestly, the work itself. Lucas: So she did the hard thing. She emailed Dan. Subject line: 'A tough conversation — would love 15 minutes.' No preamble. Dan agreed to a call. And on that call, she said: 'I made a mistake. The start-up isn't what I thought. I'm wondering if the marketing manager role is still open, or if there's something similar I could reapply for.' Luna: And Dan's answer was — it's still open. He hadn't even started interviewing because he was waiting for the perfect candidate. And he liked Sarah. He knew her work. So he said yes. Lucas: Now, that sounds like a happy ending. But a lot of things had to go right. First, the timing — she asked within three weeks. That's what we call the 'three-week rule.' If you wait longer than a month, the position may be filled, or the company may have moved on emotionally. Luna: Second, she didn't demand. She didn't say, 'You owe me.' She admitted fault and asked if there was an opportunity. That humility is huge. Lucas: Third, she had a relationship with Dan that was strong enough to withstand a resignation. That's not true for everyone. If you left because your boss was toxic, going back to that same boss is a bad idea — even if they say yes. Luna: So before you even make the ask, you need to assess: is the old environment actually better than the new one? Or are you just scared of the unknown? Lucas: Right. Let's talk about the actual script. Because how you ask matters as much as what you ask. You want to acknowledge the awkwardness head-on. Something like: 'I know this is an unusual request, and I'm a little embarrassed to be making it. But I've had time to reflect, and I realize I made a hasty decision. I valued my time here, and I'm hoping there might be a path back.' Luna: That's good. It's vulnerable without being pathetic. And it opens the door for the manager to say, 'Let me think about it,' without pressure. Lucas: Exactly. Now, what if the position is already filled? That's the worst-case scenario. But it doesn't have to be a dead end. You can ask: 'Is there another role on the team or elsewhere in the company where my skills might fit? I'm open to a different title or a pay adjustment.' Luna: And that shows flexibility. You're not just asking for your old job; you're offering to solve a problem. That's attractive to a manager. Lucas: Let's talk about the pay angle. If you left for a 20 percent raise, coming back might mean taking a pay cut. Sarah took a 15 percent cut to return — her old salary plus a small retention bump, but less than the start-up. She decided the stability was worth it. Luna: And that's a personal calculation. You have to be honest with yourself: is the lower pay worth the better environment? For Sarah, it was. But for someone with student loans or a mortgage, it might not be. Lucas: Another thing — if you go back, expect some ribbing. Coworkers might joke about your 'failed adventure.' You need to have a thick skin for a few weeks. But if you own it — 'Yeah, I gave it a shot, it wasn't for me' — people respect that. Luna: And if you're the manager receiving this request, what's your move? I think there's a temptation to say yes out of convenience, but you should also check if the employee left a void that's now filled. If you've already hired someone great, bringing back the old person could create tension. Lucas: That's wise. As a manager, you also want to ask: why did you leave in the first place? If it was just money, a counteroffer might have solved it. But if it was culture or growth, those problems will still be there when they return. You need a candid conversation about what changed — or what hasn't. Luna: One more thing: if you do get rehired, don't assume you'll pick up exactly where you left off. Your old projects have likely been redistributed. You may need to rebuild trust with your team. It's a reset. Lucas: And sometimes the answer is no. Maybe the company has a policy against rehiring, or the manager feels burned. If that happens, don't burn the bridge again. Thank them for considering, and move on. You can even ask for a referral elsewhere if the relationship is good. Luna: Yeah. Because even a 'no' can leave the door open for a future opportunity — maybe at a different company where that manager later works. Lucas: Exactly. Now, I want to tie this to something we talk about a lot on this show: the importance of maintaining relationships even when you leave. If you quit professionally, send a thank-you note, connect on LinkedIn, stay in touch. That's what made Sarah's ask possible. Luna: And if we've helped you think through a career move like this — or any tough workplace decision — you might want to support the show. We keep it ad-free, and listener support is what makes that possible. If you're inclined, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, it's a small way to keep this conversation going without any corporate interruption. And we appreciate every single person who chips in. Luna: Alright, back to the topic. So let's say you get the yes. What's the first week back look like? Any special etiquette? Lucas: First: don't complain about the start-up. Nobody wants to hear 'I told you so' or a litany of complaints. Keep it brief: 'It wasn't a good fit.' Second: reconnect with key stakeholders individually. A quick coffee with your old teammates to say, 'I'm glad to be back, I missed working with you.' Third: deliver early wins. Show that you're not just returning — you're bringing back new perspective. Luna: I like that. A friend of mine who did this — she came back to her old consulting firm after six months at a tech company. She used the tech tools she learned to streamline their reporting process. That was her early win. Lucas: Perfect. That's the playbook. Now, what if you're the person who's thinking about quitting and you're worried you might regret it? You can hedge your bets. Before you resign, have a candid conversation with your manager about what would make you stay. Sometimes a counteroffer comes from that. Luna: But if you do leave, leave a door. Don't say 'I'll never come back.' Say 'I'm open to staying in touch.' Because you never know. Lucas: Alright, let's do a quick recap. If you want to ask for your job back: one, do it within three weeks if possible. Two, lead with humility — admit the mistake. Three, be flexible on role and pay. Four, prepare for a 'no' gracefully. And five, if you get the yes, own the return with grace and early wins. Luna: And remember: a 'no' doesn't mean you're stuck. It might be the push you need to find a better fit elsewhere. Lucas: Exactly. Sarah got her yes, but the process taught her something about what she values in a workplace — stability, respect, and a manager who says 'my door is open.' That's worth holding onto.