Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Bankruptcies and Receiverships: Comparing Stakeholder Perspectives
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. My name is Chantal Malmed, and
- 0:06I'm going to be the moderator for this panel.
- 0:09This is the Beverly Hills Bar Association's bankruptcy
- 0:11section panel on bankruptcies and receiverships,
- 0:15comparing stakeholder perspectives. And I'm joined
- 0:18by our lovely panelists, the Honorable Judge
- 0:21Victoria Kaufman of the U .S. Bankruptcy Court,
- 0:25Central District of California, Byron Moldow,
- 0:27partner at Irvin Cohen and Jessup, and Kira Andrassi,
- 0:31a partner at Rains Feldman Littrell. And this
- 0:34panel is presented by Steven Mott, an associate
- 0:37at Rains Feldman Littrell, and myself. I'm an
- 0:40associate at Irvin Cohen and Jessup. And I think
- 0:45I'll go ahead and actually allow our panelists
- 0:47to give a little quick introduction of their
- 0:50practices and how they've touched on bankruptcies
- 0:53and receiverships throughout their practices,
- 0:55starting with Judge Kaufman. Okay. Hello, this
- 1:00is Jess Kaufman. I'm really excited to be here
- 1:02today and I hope to learn a little bit more about
- 1:04receiverships myself. I've been a bankruptcy
- 1:07judge for 20 years, point in 2006 and before
- 1:10that I was a bankruptcy lawyer for 16 years.
- 1:14And mostly in receiverships, I get involved when
- 1:19there's a receivership that's pending before
- 1:21the bankruptcy is filed. So I've had a little
- 1:23bit of that. I've had a lot of bankruptcy experience
- 1:26in all the different chapters within the and
- 1:29corporations. I'm in Woodland Hills now. I've
- 1:32been in downtown LA before. Thanks, Judge Kaufman.
- 1:38Now turning to Byron. Thanks, Chantal. I'm Byron
- 1:42Muldow. I'm a partner in the law firm of Irving
- 1:45Cone and Jessup in Beverly Hills. I'm the chairperson
- 1:48of the receivership bankruptcy and creditor rights
- 1:52practice group. I have practiced in the receivership
- 1:56area for my entire career serving both as a receiver
- 2:00and as counsel for receivers and I was a bankruptcy
- 2:03trustee for about 10 or 12 years and I also serve
- 2:07in various fiduciary capacities and various types
- 2:11of matters in state and federal court. I'm Kira
- 2:16Andrasi. I'm a partner in the Newport Beach office
- 2:19of Raines Feldman Littrell and I do chapter 11
- 2:22work. I also represent trustees in bankruptcy
- 2:25cases and I represent federal and state court
- 2:29receivers. I have a lot of experience with federal
- 2:32equity receiverships in the context of regulatory
- 2:35enforcement actions usually brought by the SEC.
- 2:38And I have a case right now with Byron as receiver
- 2:41that you're going to be hearing about later on.
- 2:45I'm so excited to hear all about it. And with
- 2:48that, let's jump into it. So I'm gonna be sharing
- 2:51my screen. Okay, perfect. So this panel is gonna
- 3:09be focused on five different discussion topics.
- 3:13First, we're gonna... go over both bankruptcies
- 3:15and receiverships generally and provide a brief
- 3:19overview of both of them. And then we're going
- 3:21to go into the similarities and differences between
- 3:23them and the trade -offs within them for lenders
- 3:28and borrowers as well as the mechanisms within
- 3:30them and the goals that are presented within
- 3:34both of them. Then we're going to go into a little
- 3:39bit about receiverships in California, and specifically
- 3:42the governing statutes that actually give the
- 3:45receiver his powers and allow him to do what
- 3:49he or she needs to do to marshal in property
- 3:54of the receivership estate. And then we're going
- 3:57to be going into the effect of filing a bankruptcy
- 4:00on a pending receivership action, specifically
- 4:04looking to bankruptcy code sections 541 and 362.
- 4:09And then we're going to go into the turnover
- 4:12duties under bankruptcy code 543 and how those
- 4:17play out under a state court receivership action
- 4:20with regard to a receivers obligations during
- 4:26a bankruptcy. Let's jump into it. So the different
- 4:31types of bankruptcies and receiverships and where
- 4:34each is filed. So first, there's many different
- 4:37types of bankruptcies. Each one is filed in a
- 4:40federal bankruptcy court where that is governed
- 4:43by one uniform bankruptcy code nationwide. There's
- 4:46a chapter seven bankruptcy that's a liquidation
- 4:48where a trustee sells non -exempt assets and
- 4:51distributes those proceeds and individual debtors
- 4:54typically get a discharge. There's a chapter
- 4:5711 bankruptcy that is a reorganization bankruptcy.
- 5:00where the debtor, often a debtor in possession,
- 5:03proposes a plan to restructure while continuing
- 5:05to operate. And that is subject to creditor voting
- 5:09and court confirmation. And the court may appoint
- 5:11a trustee over a chapter 11 bankruptcy. And then
- 5:15there's a chapter five. Chapter subchapter five,
- 5:18chapter 11 bankruptcy, which is typically called
- 5:20a small business reorganization bankruptcy, where
- 5:24there's a limit on the debtors secured and unsecured
- 5:27debt, but no U .S. trustee fees are required.
- 5:30A standing trustee is appointed to help facilitate
- 5:33the process, and only the debtor, not the creditors,
- 5:35can propose a plan, although that plan is subject
- 5:39to creditor voting and confirmation by the court.
- 5:43And then there's a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, which
- 5:45is a consumer bankruptcy available for individuals
- 5:48with regular income that typically have high
- 5:51consumer debt. Then we go to receiverships. They're
- 5:55split into two broad types. There's regulatory
- 5:59enforcement receiverships that typically involve
- 6:02the SEC, the FTC, or PONSI schemes. And then
- 6:05there's private litigation receiverships where
- 6:08A party, typically a lender, business partner,
- 6:12or shareholder moves to appoint a receiver in
- 6:14a state court action. There's no single receivership
- 6:17code. Actually, the receivers' powers come about,
- 6:21they're vested in... through the appointment
- 6:23order and any governing statute that we're going
- 6:27to go into in another couple of slides. Venue
- 6:31is a choice. Although a receiver's authority
- 6:34generally stops at the state's borders, if they
- 6:37would like to exercise their power possession
- 6:39over receivership assets in a different state,
- 6:41they will need to file an ancillary receivership
- 6:44in that state. and nationwide reach is not automatic
- 6:47under 28 USC 754. A receiver must file an appointment
- 6:53order in every federal district where assets
- 6:55sit within 10 days or lose jurisdiction there.
- 6:58So with that said, I'd like to ask, I'd like
- 7:02to ask Byron. Byron, you deal a lot with receiverships.
- 7:05What are the different types? I mean, can you
- 7:08go into a little bit about the different types
- 7:10of state court receiverships and what they look
- 7:14like and how they differ? Certainly. Actually,
- 7:18it can happen both in state and federal court,
- 7:22the different types of receiverships. They generally
- 7:25fall into two different categories. You might
- 7:28have one where a secured creditor Will file an
- 7:33action and seek the appointment of a receiver
- 7:35over a specific property that's generally referred
- 7:38to as a rents issues and profits receiver where
- 7:42the receivers appointed primarily to protect
- 7:44the secured creditors collateral oftentimes pending
- 7:48the completion of a non judicial foreclosure.
- 7:51The other type is what's referred to as an equity
- 7:54receivership and in an equity receivership a
- 7:58receiver is appointed over. An entire entity
- 8:01or more than one entity oftentimes there's an
- 8:06order appointing a receiver, which provides the
- 8:09receiver is appointed over a corporation, including
- 8:13their subsidiaries affiliates. And oftentimes,
- 8:18the receiver has to take possession and control
- 8:21of many, many entities. And there's very distinct
- 8:24differences between the two types of receiverships.
- 8:27The equity receivership is more akin to a Chapter
- 8:3011 trustee having been appointed over a particular
- 8:34entity. And it requires the receiver to do much
- 8:38more tax reporting. Rights to initiate avoidance
- 8:45actions. It's more similar to a chapter 11 trustee,
- 8:50whereas the rents issues and profits receivership
- 8:52is much more limited and the receivers role is
- 8:55to protect the property. That's the collateral
- 9:00for a lender. As I said, pending the completion
- 9:03of a non judicial foreclosure. Very interesting.
- 9:10And Judge Kaufman, can you actually, going back
- 9:13to bankruptcies, can you talk a little bit about
- 9:15the different types of bankruptcies there are
- 9:16and how they differ? Well, I guess in addition
- 9:21to what's on the slide, Chapter 7, there's a
- 9:26trustee that's there right from the very beginning.
- 9:28They can be filed by businesses or individuals.
- 9:32They can also be involuntary, theoretically.
- 9:36That's not necessarily the best way to go. It's
- 9:38very risky move, but for the creditor that's
- 9:41filing them, but they can. There's a trustee
- 9:44that's there to sell assets. Chapter 11 can be
- 9:49also individuals or businesses. There's no debt
- 9:52limits. A regular Chapter 11 case, it starts
- 9:55off with a debtor in control. But a trustee can
- 9:59be appointed or there are ways in which a court
- 10:02could authorize a receiver to keep operating
- 10:04if there was a receivership ahead of time. But
- 10:08they would need permission from the bankruptcy
- 10:09court to do that. Subchapter 5 has become a very
- 10:14popular subsection of chapter 11. It's subject
- 10:18to debt limits. Right now those debt limits are
- 10:21a little over 3 million dollars in non -contingent
- 10:25liquidated Secured and unsecured debt combined,
- 10:29that doesn't exclude affiliated debt. Debtors
- 10:33like them because only a debtor can file a plan.
- 10:37There's no U .S. trustee fees. There's different
- 10:40confirmation requirements for the plan. And there's
- 10:45no need for a disclosure statement as well as
- 10:47a plan unless the court requires a disclosure
- 10:49statement specifically. So they are meant to
- 10:51move fast and a debtor is supposed to file their
- 10:53plan within 60 days. Generally speaking, there
- 10:57is a sub chapter five trustee, but it has a very
- 10:59limited role, mostly to facilitate. It doesn't
- 11:03have the same powers as a chapter seven trustee
- 11:06or a regular chapter 11 trustee if one were to
- 11:09be appointed. And chapter 13 is for individuals
- 11:12also with debt limits. And there's a chapter
- 11:1613 trustee, but that person mostly is involved
- 11:19in monitoring confirmation of the plan and distributing
- 11:23funds that are paid through the plan. Nice. Great.
- 11:29Well, with that, let's move on to the second
- 11:32slide and go over the similarities and differences
- 11:36of receiverships and bankruptcies. So, similarities.
- 11:42There's a fiduciary in both of them. In a receivership,
- 11:44it's the receiver. In a bankruptcy, it's the
- 11:47bankruptcy trustee that acts for the benefit
- 11:50of the creditors. Both receivers and bankruptcy
- 11:53trustees can pause collection efforts against
- 11:56property in their custody. And both fiduciaries
- 11:59owed duties of care and impartial administration
- 12:02to the estate and the receivership as a whole.
- 12:05Although as the panelists know, and we've talked
- 12:08about, that doesn't always mean that fiduciary
- 12:11is always impartial. Now, the difference is there's
- 12:16many the initiation of a of a receivership usually
- 12:20entails a single secured lender that obtains
- 12:23a receiver by way of motion moving to a point
- 12:26of receiver unilaterally based on a loan default
- 12:30and whereby. where a lender would like to have
- 12:35an entity file for bankruptcy, three creditors,
- 12:39three petitioning creditors, filed that entity
- 12:41under involuntary bankruptcy. The costs are vastly
- 12:45different. The cost of a receivership is the
- 12:48receivership's principal recurring costs, which
- 12:50are the receiver's bond premium and compensation,
- 12:54with comparatively little court appearances,
- 12:58whereby a regular Chapter 11 bankruptcy touches
- 13:02on the U .S. trustee quarterly fees, professional
- 13:05fees, and in a reorganization, the fees associated
- 13:09with preparing and filing a disclosure statement
- 13:11and a Chapter 11 plan, which can be very hefty.
- 13:16Lenders remedies in a receivership versus a bankruptcy
- 13:18are also different. In a receivership, the lender
- 13:22can handpick a receiver by way of their motion,
- 13:26but in a bankruptcy, obviously, no one can handpick
- 13:30the The chapter 11 trustee, who usually does
- 13:34not really know any of the parties stepping into
- 13:37the case. And finally, the borrowers and debtors
- 13:41and that sort of entails different remedies and
- 13:44the panelists can kind of go into that. And so
- 13:48the borrowers and debtors remedies in a bankruptcy
- 13:51versus a receivership. kind of touching on credit
- 13:55bidding differ, whereby in a bankruptcy, a lien
- 13:58holder's right to credit bid at a 363 sale is
- 14:01statutorily guaranteed. But in a receivership,
- 14:05credit bidding depends entirely on the receivership
- 14:07order and state procedure. So credit bidding
- 14:12is not really guaranteed in a receivership. Now,
- 14:16stepping back a little and looking at all these
- 14:19factors, I was wondering, Kara, could you walk
- 14:23through all these factors with us, cost, speed,
- 14:27control, and availability of a discharge, and
- 14:30kind of walk us through what actually drives
- 14:33the choice between a party moving to a point
- 14:39or a receiver versus trying to put together an
- 14:42involuntary petition for an involuntary bankruptcy
- 14:45for an entity. Yeah. So a couple of things I
- 14:49want to start with. First, going back to the
- 14:51similarities. In a Chapter 11 case, you don't
- 14:55automatically get a trustee appointed. In fact,
- 14:58what you have is a debtor. And they're actually
- 15:00called a debtor in possession. And they're vested
- 15:03under the bankruptcy code with the authority
- 15:04of a trustee. And they are a fiduciary. You get
- 15:08trustees appointed in a Chapter 11 case for fraud
- 15:11or mismanagement. And then with respect to other
- 15:16similarities, like the pausing of collection
- 15:19efforts. It's actually a little bit broad. It's
- 15:21a lot broader in a bankruptcy case than it is
- 15:24in a receivership. So in a bankruptcy case, you
- 15:26get the automatic stay that applies to attempts
- 15:30to collect any pre -protection debt from the
- 15:32debtor. It also protects the property of the
- 15:35bankruptcy estate, and that's any interest that
- 15:37the debtor has in property under state law as
- 15:40of the date that it files. In receiverships,
- 15:43you don't have an automatic stay. You sometimes
- 15:46have injunction provisions in the order appointing
- 15:49the receiver. that limit parties' ability to
- 15:52exercise control over assets or to, say, sue
- 15:56the receiver. But it's not typically as broad
- 15:59as in a bankruptcy case. Now, an exception to
- 16:03that is federal equity receiverships because
- 16:05those are administered a lot like bankruptcy
- 16:07cases. I just wanted to add that for some color.
- 16:13In terms of how they differ and what people are
- 16:15evaluating, the obvious thing is that bankruptcies
- 16:18are typically voluntary. So if I'm a creditor
- 16:21trying to figure out how best to protect my asset
- 16:23or the business, and I think a receiver would
- 16:27be beneficial, I'm probably not thinking of a
- 16:31bankruptcy case. And the reason for that is,
- 16:33number one, to force the company into a bankruptcy
- 16:36case, you have to file an involuntary petition
- 16:39against it. And there are statutory requirements
- 16:42on the number of creditors you have to have and
- 16:45that their debts can't be contingent, unliquidated,
- 16:48or disputed. And you also have to prove that
- 16:52the debtor is insolvent either on a balance sheet
- 16:55basis or that they're generally not paying their
- 16:58debts as they come due. And if you lose on any
- 17:01one of those, the repercussions are pretty severe.
- 17:03You can have sanctions issued against you and
- 17:07also would probably be liable for the attorney's
- 17:10fees incurred by the alleged debtor in bending
- 17:13off the involuntary petition. So that's a huge
- 17:16disincentive, together with the fact that if
- 17:19you put it into a seven, you're going to have
- 17:21some trustee randomly appointed. You don't have
- 17:24any control over who that party is. Another thing
- 17:29is that all of the property that the debtor owns
- 17:32becomes of that bankruptcy estate, and it gets
- 17:35distributed in accordance with the priorities
- 17:38set forth in the bankruptcy code. If you're looking
- 17:41at a receivership, you have a lot more control
- 17:44over that process because you may just have the
- 17:46receiver appointed over a particular piece of
- 17:49property, say like in the rents and profits context
- 17:52or over a business to preserve it pending the
- 17:55outcome of some litigation between the parties.
- 17:58So it's a lot more discreet and you have control
- 18:00over the scope. You don't have that control in
- 18:03a bankruptcy case. And so those are factors I
- 18:06think that are certainly taken into consideration.
- 18:09You know, one other thing that can be powerful
- 18:11though in a bankruptcy, this is sometimes why
- 18:14receivers file bankruptcy cases, is if you see
- 18:17that there was a lot of money going out the door
- 18:19in the 90 days prior to the filing, because you
- 18:23might be able to get those back as preferential
- 18:25payments in a bankruptcy case. It goes back 90
- 18:29days for regular creditors and a year for insiders.
- 18:33You don't have that ability to, there's no preference
- 18:35equivalent in a receivership case. So that can
- 18:40be one instance where bankruptcy might actually
- 18:42be beneficial. And there's also a statute in
- 18:45California that said in the event of a bankruptcy
- 18:47filing, writ of attachment liens are void. They're
- 18:52obtained within 90 days of the bankruptcy filing.
- 18:54So that can be another reason why bankruptcy
- 18:56might be better, but generally when you're talking
- 18:59about it from a creditor perspective and creditor
- 19:02remedies, you're looking at a receivership because
- 19:05the risks of an involuntary are great. and there's
- 19:08a lot of drawbacks. No, that's really insightful.
- 19:13Yeah, very insightful. And the rate of attachment
- 19:16piece of the puzzle you were talking about is
- 19:20actually, I think, a really good reason to look
- 19:23at a bankruptcy in a more broad way than in a
- 19:31receivership, because I see that happening all
- 19:35the time. Very interesting. Okay, so next slide.
- 19:43We're going to go into the statutes that kind
- 19:46of govern state court receiverships in California.
- 19:49So there's a few the most important are. I think
- 19:54564, 567, 568, 568 .5. so. Just touching on those,
- 20:03Section 564 is the grounds for the receiver's
- 20:06appointment. Usually authorizes a receiver in
- 20:10actions involving fraudulent purchases, foreclosures,
- 20:13corporate dissolution, an unlawful detainer,
- 20:17whenever appointment is necessary to preserve
- 20:19the property or rights of any party. And that
- 20:24usually entails a lender or a party moving for
- 20:29appointment of that receiver. Section 567 deals
- 20:34with the oath and undertaking. So before a receiver,
- 20:37it can actually act as a receiver. They need
- 20:43to actually take an oath and an undertaking.
- 20:45They need to be sworn in and post an undertaking
- 20:47to faithfully discharge the duties of the office
- 20:50in a sum the court directs. Section 568, I think,
- 20:55is the most important statute that applies to
- 20:59receivership because it gives the receiver his
- 21:02or her powers. So under that statute, the receiver
- 21:06can sue or be sued in their own name, take possession
- 21:09of property, collect rents and debts, compromise
- 21:13claims, make transfers, and otherwise perform
- 21:16such acts respecting the property as the court
- 21:18may authorize. And that's generally the language
- 21:23that vest the receiver with the power they need
- 21:26to do things like file UD actions and potentially
- 21:32sue people that violate the appointment order.
- 21:37Section 568 .5 is also really, really valuable
- 21:41statute because it actually allows a receiver
- 21:44to sell real or personal property in the receivership
- 21:48estate, free and clear of all liens. obviously
- 21:53after a court confirmation and the horse pool
- 21:56case touches on that and is very important to
- 21:59look at. And sections 569 to 570 deal with receivership
- 22:04funds. So looking at all those statutes, I want
- 22:10to ask Byron. So Byron, in your practice, section
- 22:15568's grant of authority, it's really broad,
- 22:18but it still requires court authorization for
- 22:21anything beyond those enumerated powers. In practice,
- 22:26how specifically do you draft the appointment
- 22:28order to avoid a second trip back to court for
- 22:32further instructions? Well, it's very important
- 22:36for an attorney that is considering seeking the
- 22:41appointment of receiver to consult with the proposed
- 22:44receiver in advance. And to share a proposed
- 22:49or appointing receiver with the proposed receiver,
- 22:52because my recommendation is always to include
- 22:56as many powers as possible in the initial appointment
- 23:00order, because that's just going to be much more
- 23:02cost effective and will avoid the receiver having
- 23:05to go back to court to seek further instructions
- 23:09or to seek further authority. One of the unique.
- 23:13powers that a receiver has, unlike a bankruptcy
- 23:16trustee, is that the receiver can go to the court
- 23:18and say, here's the situation, here's the problem.
- 23:23I need to ask for instructions or I need to ask
- 23:26for specific authority. Since it's a court of
- 23:29equity, a receiver has that luxury of going to
- 23:32the court and essentially asking for what might
- 23:35be considered a comfort order in terms of protecting
- 23:39the receiver from attack further on. or later
- 23:43down when the case is further litigated. I'd
- 23:47also add that in addition to the statutes that
- 23:51you've shown on the screen, there are other statutes
- 23:54that provide for the appointment of a receiver.
- 23:56For instance, the family code provides for the
- 23:59appointment of receiver. There are corporations
- 24:02code statutes, there are government code statutes,
- 24:06and there are penal code statutes that. allow
- 24:09for the appointment of a receiver. We're only
- 24:11touching upon some of them right here. I mean,
- 24:15there are many, many statutes that provide for
- 24:18the appointment of a receiver. But again, going
- 24:20back to what I said before, it may be an appointment
- 24:23of a receiver over a specific property, or it
- 24:27could be the appointment of a receiver over a
- 24:30particular entity, which is considered an equity
- 24:33receivership. And do you think that Section 568
- 24:39.5, I mean, do you think that that's a pretty
- 24:42significant statute? Because I think maybe not
- 24:47a lot of people know that a receiver can sell
- 24:50free and clear, because that's a pretty, in my
- 24:55eyes, that's a pretty significant thing to be
- 24:58able to do, obviously, after court confirmation.
- 25:01Do you think that that sort of that sort of made
- 25:06change how lenders perhaps or other parties might
- 25:10see their remedies in our state court receivership
- 25:15versus a bankruptcy? I would say that prior to
- 25:20the city of Riverside versus Horspool case coming
- 25:25out that there was the belief that receivership
- 25:30courts didn't have the power to approve sales
- 25:33free and clear of liens. There was some authority
- 25:37going back to, I believe, the 1920s. There was
- 25:40a case called Spreckel's involving the old Spreckel
- 25:43Sugar Company. But that was not exactly the most
- 25:48clear authority. I used it a few times, but most
- 25:52judges, in my experience, didn't feel comfortable.
- 25:56issuing orders selling free and clear of liens.
- 25:59Since the horse bull case was decided in 2014,
- 26:03it now provides a definite authority for judges
- 26:07in state court and for that matter in federal
- 26:11court to approve the sales free and clear of
- 26:14liens prior to the horse bull case coming out.
- 26:18It certainly was the common belief that state
- 26:22courts didn't have the authority to approve sales
- 26:25free and clear of liens. And that's why if there
- 26:28was a possible sale being considered, that bankruptcy
- 26:32was probably considered the only option until
- 26:35the horse bull case did come out. I have a question
- 26:38just because I read the case. It seemed like
- 26:41such a compelling situation. Do you know what
- 26:44I mean? The lenders didn't oppose the sale free
- 26:47and clear. The property was like It was a mess.
- 26:51It was a hazard to the public. The owners kept
- 26:56litigating about, you know, they didn't have
- 26:58to fix it and the receiver didn't have it right.
- 27:01And I mean, it just seems, I just wonder how
- 27:04broadly is it applied outside of the context
- 27:07of a particular property that's dilapidated and
- 27:09a hazard and the county's moving to have it be
- 27:12like fixed and the owners are. doing everything
- 27:15they can to get in the way and have been labeled
- 27:17vexatious litigants. And the lenders know that
- 27:20it's not. I mean, they don't want to spend money
- 27:22fixing it and they don't want to foreclose on
- 27:24it either. Well, unlike the bankruptcy code where
- 27:29you've got specific a statute that allows you
- 27:32to sell free and clear and you need to make a
- 27:35certain showing. My experience has been that
- 27:37in state court, it generally is in the context
- 27:40of perhaps when you've got a property that has
- 27:44been tagged for health and safety code violations,
- 27:48there are issues, many times public policy reasons
- 27:53for that might form the basis for which allows
- 27:58the court to approve the sale free and clear
- 28:01of liens. That's my experience. So, I mean, it
- 28:04isn't like something like, if you were a junior
- 28:05lender, I don't think, right, and you thought
- 28:08that there was value to the property, it's not
- 28:11going to get sold free and clear of your lien,
- 28:13right? I mean, unless, right, if you're - That's
- 28:16correct. Yeah. Just because you're in his junior
- 28:19position, you're not going to get sold out. That's
- 28:21correct. Yes. But I mean, it's possible. I mean,
- 28:25it's now, it's an option. Yes. But it's not like
- 28:29it's a guarantee in every situation. It has to
- 28:31be equitable. Correct. But at least now there
- 28:35is authority for a state court judge to approve
- 28:39a sale free and clear of liens and transfer the
- 28:43liens to the proceeds. Yes. Right. And I think
- 28:47something I've learned Because I just started
- 28:50practicing and learning more about receivership
- 28:52to start practicing in receivership actions is
- 28:55that there's not a lot of case law that actually
- 28:58deals with state court receivership. This is
- 29:01very different than the bankruptcy world where
- 29:03there's so many different cases that that are
- 29:06always cited in various, you know, regular motions.
- 29:11There are not a lot of cases outside of maybe
- 29:13horse pulls and a few others. So. I think it's
- 29:17a completely different world. And the fact that
- 29:20there is this sort of case that specifically
- 29:22talks about the receiver's ability to self -fearing
- 29:26clear is very, very important. And it just helps
- 29:32make things, the receivership world and the language
- 29:36within it just a bit more clear. I'm sure you
- 29:39can attest to the fact that it's just very sometimes
- 29:43hard to persuade Byron, a judge one way or another
- 29:49based on state court law in a receivership versus
- 29:53a bankruptcy judge, right? Well, I think that's
- 29:57right. But again, in a receivership court, you
- 29:59are in a court of equity if you make out a good
- 30:03faith argument and support your motion seeking
- 30:08authority to sell free and clear. My experience
- 30:11has been that If you make a good faith argument
- 30:14and support it as to the value of the property
- 30:17being supported, that you've marketed the property
- 30:21adequately, you're probably going to get a court
- 30:25to agree with you. Right. Chantal, the one thing
- 30:29I would add to this is with respect to the federal
- 30:32laws governing receivers. So if you have an equity
- 30:35receivership in federal court, those will arise
- 30:38in the context of private disputes where there's
- 30:40allegations of fraud. Usually you see them in
- 30:43investment fraud, but I've had them in breach
- 30:45of contract type actions as well. There's a...
- 30:49complete lack of, there's like literally two
- 30:51statutes in the U .S. code on receivers. There's
- 30:54one governing how they sell property, and there's
- 30:57another, I got ancillary and kind of like what
- 31:01the general scope is, but the order is the Bible
- 31:04in federal equity receiverships, and it also
- 31:07is in state court. But there's like, you said
- 31:09there's not a lot of case law in California,
- 31:11and that's in the federal courts. You know, there's
- 31:14actually not a ton of published case law. There's,
- 31:17I mean, in federal court, I'm often citing to
- 31:19unpublish decisions because there's such a lack
- 31:21of case law in this area. But in the federal
- 31:24world, there is case law to support that you
- 31:27draw on the bankruptcy code when it's helpful.
- 31:30And it would achieve an equitable result. But
- 31:32otherwise, you're just relying on equitable principles.
- 31:36So it's really kind of the Wild West. And what
- 31:38you're trying to achieve is really just is always
- 31:41equity. And Kira, just to follow up on that,
- 31:45I One of the rules that applies is that if you're
- 31:49selling real estate, you're supposed to get 3
- 31:52appraisals of a piece of property unless the
- 31:56court excuses that requirement. I did have 1
- 32:01situation many years ago where a federal judge
- 32:05required us to get 3 appraisals. And it obviously
- 32:10took a lot of time and we came back. And the
- 32:13ultimate sale of the property or the purchase
- 32:16price was exactly what we had proposed after
- 32:18the property had been marketed for sale with
- 32:20a licensed real estate broker. In my opinion,
- 32:23all it did was cause delay and cause the receivership
- 32:27estate to incur a lot of expense to obtain three
- 32:30appraisals. Yeah. And I'll just note that I'm
- 32:32five for five on getting federal court judges
- 32:34to not require the three appraisals. So they
- 32:38don't want to impose unnecessary burdens on receivers.
- 32:41So if you can make a case for why you shouldn't
- 32:43have to do that, you're adequately marketing
- 32:45the property. Otherwise, you may be able to get
- 32:47that order. I would agree with you. This was
- 32:51a unique situation. I'll leave it at that. Well,
- 32:55it really does sound like the Wild Wild West
- 32:58compared to bankruptcies. Okay, so let's jump
- 33:01into the next slide. So the filing of a bankruptcy
- 33:07on a pending receivership, what freezes the moment
- 33:11a bankruptcy case lands on top of the receivership
- 33:15action? So looking at bankruptcy code sections
- 33:20541 and 362, 541 deals with what actually is
- 33:25pulled into this state at the moment of the bankruptcy
- 33:27filing. And it includes all legal and equitable
- 33:31interests of the debtor in property as of the
- 33:33petition date. And section 362 deals with the
- 33:37automatic stay and all legal proceedings or collection
- 33:41efforts being paused during the bankruptcy, once
- 33:46the bankruptcy is filed. And it doesn't reach
- 33:50a separate interest that that does not belong
- 33:52to a debtor and in the in resource in that bankruptcy
- 33:56case in the 1st district. we see the practical
- 34:00consequence of that. So a filing, a bankruptcy
- 34:02filing, freezes further action in a pending state
- 34:06court receivership as to a state property, effectively
- 34:10pausing the receivership for that property. And
- 34:13in that case, the court held that a state court's
- 34:16post -petition default and foreclosure orders
- 34:18violated the automatic stay. They were judicial.
- 34:24They weren't just ministerial acts or errors.
- 34:30that retroactively annulling the state to validate
- 34:32them required compelling facts that the creditor
- 34:36had not shown. And so this is pretty much like
- 34:41what happens when there's already a receivership
- 34:46in place and a bankruptcy is filed and the two
- 34:49sort of start to interact. It's really this interesting
- 34:52zone. It doesn't really happen. And so I kind
- 34:55of wanted to ask, so looking at sections 541
- 34:58and 362, I wanted to ask Judge Kaufman, if section
- 35:03541 really is the gatekeeper for the bankruptcy
- 35:06estate and the automatic stay, how much diligence
- 35:11does a receiver or should a receiver do on a
- 35:14debtor's property interest before assuming that
- 35:17the automatic stay automatically reaches that
- 35:20property interest? The 541 is very broad. It
- 35:27includes, like, I want to mention equitable interests,
- 35:28right? So that could be the debtor saying, well,
- 35:32I helped pay the mortgage or I contribute, you
- 35:34know, I mean, it could be very, you know, like,
- 35:36or I helped with other expenses. And so now I
- 35:38have an equitable interest. So it's kind of hard
- 35:40to necessarily know what that is. Also, it includes
- 35:44community property. So I wanted to mention that
- 35:48because it's not mentioned specifically on the
- 35:50slide. So community property also comes into
- 35:51the estate, even if the spouse doesn't file if
- 35:55it's an individual. So the thing about the automatic
- 35:59stay is it's automatic and anything you do that's
- 36:03contrary to it is void. Plus you can get into
- 36:06trouble for violating the stay. Um, so if you're
- 36:09not sure that, I mean, like one thing I would
- 36:12do definitely is wait for the debtor's schedules,
- 36:14look at the debtor's schedule, see if it's something
- 36:16that's scheduled because if it's scheduled, you
- 36:18definitely don't want to get in the way before
- 36:21asking the bankruptcy court for approval. And
- 36:24the best, the best situation honestly is either
- 36:27go get court approval based on relief from the
- 36:30RMX day or get excuse, get excused from, um,
- 36:35turnover, which is the obligation of a custodian
- 36:38to turn over property to a trustee or a debtor
- 36:41in possession in a bankruptcy case. So we're
- 36:44going to talk about that. But I would never,
- 36:47I think if you, if, if when in doubt, go for
- 36:50one of those two things, any doubt, go for one
- 36:53of those two things. Okay. And also like we mentioned,
- 36:57the interests are defined by state law. So you
- 37:00want to keep in mind that it's state law that
- 37:02defines a debtor's interest. Um, but it's the
- 37:05bankruptcy code that governs the protections
- 37:07for that interest. I see. So, and you mentioned,
- 37:12yeah, community property interest is included
- 37:15in the bankruptcy estate. Yes. Okay. Yeah. Also
- 37:19proceeds product, you know, things that, you
- 37:21know, result from, you know, things that are,
- 37:23um, anything that's an offshoot of the property
- 37:26and the estate is also included as property of
- 37:28the estate. Got it. Okay. When we're considering
- 37:35property of the estate, your honor, if a receiver
- 37:40has been appointed at the request of a secured
- 37:42creditor, and there's funds in a receiver's possession,
- 37:47those funds though, are the collateral for the
- 37:50secured creditor, correct? They can be, I mean,
- 37:55they can be collateral, but that doesn't mean
- 37:57they're not property of the estate. I agree.
- 38:00Yes. Yeah, I mean, when there's a bankruptcy,
- 38:05there could be a cutoff to a certain extent depending
- 38:07on what the security interest is. But yeah, nothing
- 38:15changes whether it's collateral, but unless it's
- 38:21become property of the lender in some way, it's
- 38:26still subject to the stay. So it can be if it's
- 38:31frozen in a bank account, or if it's been, you
- 38:35know, if it's the subject to a lien, it doesn't
- 38:38change the the fact that the debtor has an interest
- 38:40in it, which would be subject to the stay. And
- 38:46and state court and state state case law would
- 38:49govern. I mean, like you mentioned, obviously,
- 38:53it's state case law. Yeah, state case law does
- 38:57govern. in a sense, like what really is the definition
- 38:59of what the debtor's interest in the property
- 39:02is so so we mentioned this slide this brace brace
- 39:06and brace was about and it was um community property
- 39:10comes in and it was really about but it was held
- 39:14in joint it was um it was titled in both husband
- 39:18and wife's name as far so it was really about
- 39:21what governs the the form of title presumption
- 39:25under state law or the community property presumption.
- 39:29And the Ninth Circuit said, well, we have to
- 39:32look at state law as to what is going to govern.
- 39:34Does it only the husband's half interest come
- 39:37in, because it was only his case, or does the
- 39:41whole community property interest come in of
- 39:42the husband and the wife? And so they had to
- 39:45go to actually the California Supreme Court to
- 39:48decide which of the state law presumptions governed
- 39:50the interest of the estate in the property. Was
- 39:55it just the half or was it the entire community
- 39:59property interest? And so that's an example of
- 40:02where state law was used to determine what, you
- 40:05know, what was what was actually property of
- 40:08the estate, you know, based on those two competing
- 40:13concepts. That's helpful. I mean, it's it's it's
- 40:19I think it's helpful that there's a there's a
- 40:21different like Yeah, a different sort of authority
- 40:25that you can look at, because sometimes the bankruptcy
- 40:28code is not always like the definitions or the
- 40:31language within it is not always very clear.
- 40:34So I think it's helpful that sometimes we do
- 40:37look at state law. Yeah. Debtors' property interests
- 40:41are usually defined by state law, unless there's
- 40:43a conflicting bankruptcy code provision specifically,
- 40:47which then would govern. Okay. Okay, I think
- 40:53we should get to the next slide, which is actually
- 40:56the last slide. We saved the best for last. The
- 41:00best for last. Exactly. I was just going to say.
- 41:05So turnover duties. Turnover duties under bankruptcy
- 41:09code section 543. That section basically says
- 41:14that once a custodian, including a state court
- 41:16receiver, acquires knowledge of a bankruptcy
- 41:19filing, that section 543A through B requires
- 41:24that custodian to deliver a state property plus
- 41:27any proceeds, rents, profits to the receiver
- 41:31or the debtor in possession. file an accounting
- 41:34and stop making further disbursements except
- 41:40to preserve the property. And there's actually
- 41:43a case that deals with this, a Supreme Court
- 41:45case called United States versus Whiting Pools.
- 41:48And it shows just how broadly courts read that
- 41:52turnover concept under Section 543. The Supreme
- 41:57Court in that case held that it The turnover
- 42:04obligation reaches basically anyone that holds
- 42:07a state property, including a creditor that already
- 42:09seized it pre -petition in service of the codes,
- 42:12reorganization, and fresh start goals. You see
- 42:15that language all the time in bankruptcy case
- 42:18law. In the case, the court held that the IRS,
- 42:22even the IRS, was required to turn over a taxpayer's
- 42:25equipment. It had seized pre -petition to satisfy
- 42:27a tax lien because property of the state under
- 42:30sections 541, 542, reaches the debtor's possessory
- 42:35interest, even when a creditor already holds
- 42:38the property. And again, that's in furtherance
- 42:41of the Fresh Start Goals chapter 11 bankruptcies.
- 42:47And pursuant to section 11 USC 541 D1, actually,
- 42:54as Judge Kaufman was kind of touching on earlier
- 42:57after notice in a hearing, a bankruptcy court
- 43:01can actually excuse compliance with subsections
- 43:04A, B, or C if the interest of the creditors and
- 43:08if the debtor is not insolvent of equity security
- 43:13holders would be better served by permitting
- 43:16a custodian to continue in possession, custody,
- 43:20or control of such property. So it's kind of
- 43:23like, Basically what Judge Kaufman was talking
- 43:26about earlier was this excusing this turnover
- 43:29obligation. And so I kind of wanted to ask our
- 43:34panelists, given how broadly Whiting Pools reads
- 43:38the turnover concept and also looking at obviously
- 43:43541 D1, where should a receiver draw the line?
- 43:47between property, it has to immediately hand
- 43:50over and property can hold while the parties
- 43:53sort out an exemption. Let me first say it should
- 43:57be 543 D1. Yes, I noted that and I was trying
- 44:02to... That's right. The typical situation is
- 44:08a receiver is in possession of property and the
- 44:11bankruptcy is filed and the receiver will get
- 44:18a phone call from the debtor's council or the
- 44:22debtor demanding turnover. That's the typical
- 44:25situation. If it's a situation where a secured
- 44:30creditor has sought and obtained the appointment
- 44:32of a receiver and the property maybe had been
- 44:36mismanaged or had fallen into disrepair and maybe
- 44:40was cited for health or safety code violations,
- 44:44I would expect that the secured creditor would
- 44:48file a motion under 543D1 seeking to preserve
- 44:54the receiver in possession. In the meantime,
- 44:58while that motion is being prepared, the receiver
- 45:01would typically remain in possession of the property
- 45:04pending the court hearing the secured creditor's
- 45:07motion. That's generally the way it would work.
- 45:12Kira and I have a recent case right now where
- 45:17I was appointed receiver and it was the day of
- 45:23the scheduled foreclosure sale and the owner
- 45:27of the property filed bankruptcy to prevent the
- 45:30foreclosures being completed. I've remained in
- 45:37possession of the property. I never obtained
- 45:40a demand for turnover of possession. The property
- 45:44was riddled with problems. The secured creditor
- 45:49has continued to fund the shortfall during the
- 45:53receivership, and the bankruptcy court has been
- 45:56fine with allowing me to remain in possession.
- 46:01It's essentially being done by way of consent.
- 46:04I would say this is the atypical situation. In
- 46:09my experience, there usually is either a stipulation
- 46:12for the receiver to remain in possession or the
- 46:16secret creditor files a motion and the court
- 46:19issues an order excusing the turnover. This,
- 46:22in my experience, is the only one where it's
- 46:25literally been done by way of oral consent. Kara,
- 46:28any comments? Yeah, I mean, I definitely think
- 46:31it's the exception and should not be the rule.
- 46:35A couple of things. First of all, if any of you
- 46:40practice in state court and you've ever looked
- 46:42at the form receivership order that some judges
- 46:45require be used, it has a provision that's really
- 46:47not consistent with the bankruptcy code that
- 46:50provides that the receiver can hang on to stuff
- 46:53and see if the party that sought their appointment
- 46:56within 10 days is going to file a motion in the
- 46:59bankruptcy court to excuse turnover. I mean,
- 47:02really, typically when I represent a Chapter
- 47:0511 debtor where there's been a receiver appointed,
- 47:07I'm making demand immediately on the receiver.
- 47:12I'm on the phone with the council for the party
- 47:16who sought their appointment saying, are you
- 47:18going to be filing a motion and if so, when?
- 47:21The practical way you do it is generally the
- 47:25receiver remains in possession pending the outcome
- 47:27of that motion and can spend only that amount
- 47:31of money that's necessary to preserve the property.
- 47:34and then you've got a determination. So my case
- 47:36with Byron right now is unusual because we're
- 47:39doing it just basically, my client contact is...
- 47:45kind of a mess. And so we're happy to have the
- 47:49receiver in possession running the property dealing
- 47:51with the issues and the lender is funding the
- 47:55delta that my client can't afford to fund. And
- 47:58so it's sort of an unusual situation. In two
- 48:02other cases that are related to the one where
- 48:04Byron is, there's a different receiver who was
- 48:06appointed. And in those cases, the lender actually
- 48:10filed really quickly a motion to excuse the turnover
- 48:13requirements And what we've done is that allowed
- 48:17me some time to bring in new management for my
- 48:20company because it needed a fiduciary at the
- 48:23helm. And so we did that and we've done a stipulation
- 48:26transitioning the receiver out over a certain
- 48:28amount of time because everybody's satisfied
- 48:30that the new management I'm bringing in is basically
- 48:33akin to the receiver and we don't wanna pay for
- 48:35it. per both. So there's different ways you can
- 48:37do it. You know, I've had another situation where
- 48:40I represented the receiver and it was a hotel
- 48:43that suffered from like the management was at
- 48:46odds with each other is subject to a shareholder
- 48:48dispute and everybody was accusing everybody
- 48:51else of having stolen money. And so the parties
- 48:54are very early on stipulated with the secured
- 48:57creditor to keep my client in place pending a
- 49:00sale of the property. And then when that was
- 49:03done, we returned to state. and the receiver
- 49:06got discharged after the property was done. So
- 49:10I definitely would say that if you find yourself
- 49:13in this situation, you know, the party seeking
- 49:17the appointment, who sought the appointment of
- 49:18the receiver should be the one who files the
- 49:20motion, and they should do it pretty quickly.
- 49:22And if they don't, you know, 543A says as soon
- 49:25as the custodian knows about the case, they're
- 49:28supposed to start the process of turning over
- 49:30possession. There's not a 10 -day thing built
- 49:33into 543A. So there's, you know, a little bit
- 49:37of give and take, and there's some flexibility.
- 49:38I think in terms of timing and so forth, but
- 49:42really you need to be on the phone right away.
- 49:44And one more thing that I'll add is that it's
- 49:47usually not the receiver who files the motion
- 49:49to excuse turnover because the receiver is considered
- 49:52a neutral party, an agent of the state court.
- 49:56And so it does happen if this party who's seeking
- 49:59the appointment isn't doing it and the receiver's
- 50:02needing instructions. But I think usually it's
- 50:05the party who sought the receiver's appointment
- 50:07where the onus should fall to file the motion
- 50:10to excuse turnover. I would agree. Judge Kaufman,
- 50:14have you had instances where you've had a superseded
- 50:17receiver who then files an application for compensation
- 50:21before you? I think it's usually been where we
- 50:27look at whether the state court is the right
- 50:29court to be reviewing the fees of that receiver.
- 50:32So I haven't actually, that I can recall, dealt
- 50:36with the fees of a receiver and if the receiver
- 50:39was left in place. I just briefly want to mention
- 50:43there's another provision which is the abstention
- 50:47provision under Section 305, which sometimes
- 50:49comes into play, which is where you can ask the
- 50:52bankruptcy court to suspend the bankruptcy case
- 50:55or dismiss the bankruptcy case because basically
- 50:57it's being handled well somewhere else in the
- 51:01best interest of creditors and the debtor to
- 51:02let it stay where it is. So that's why a lot
- 51:05of debtors will try and beat the receiver. Because
- 51:08once a receiver's in, there's a greater chance
- 51:11that a bankruptcy court will excuse turnover
- 51:13or could even abstain under section 305 by putting
- 51:22everything in bankruptcy on hold or by dismissing
- 51:25the bankruptcy case because it's being handled
- 51:28appropriately in the state court with a receivership.
- 51:33So when you found abstention was appropriate,
- 51:37do you schedule periodic status conferences just
- 51:41to kind of check in and find out what's going
- 51:43on in the state court? I would if it wasn't dismissed.
- 51:46I would if it wasn't dismissed. Yeah. OK. OK.
- 51:51Yeah. And Byron, I have had that situation when
- 51:53the one the hotel example that I gave the bankruptcy
- 51:56judge. Because it's an open question. There really
- 51:59isn't a statute on it. The only thing you know
- 52:01is that the receiver's expenses are entitled
- 52:04to administrative priority. And that includes,
- 52:06by the way, the fees and costs of the receiver
- 52:09and the professionals hired by the receiver prior
- 52:11to the bankruptcy filing. If the receiver is
- 52:14forced or required to turn over the property,
- 52:18the receiver gets an administrative claim for
- 52:20the reasonable fees and costs of that receivership
- 52:22estate. So all is not lost if a receiver finds
- 52:25themselves in that position. But back to my hotel
- 52:28case, the judge in that situation really wanted
- 52:31to be able to, because it was ultimately gonna
- 52:32get paid from the proceeds of this hotel and
- 52:35the estate. And so she wanted to have control
- 52:37over the fees. And so during the case, we had
- 52:41to file. At the end, once the property was sold,
- 52:43we had to file a motion to allow the attorney's
- 52:46fees and costs. And she evaluated it under the
- 52:48standards that you would any other fee application
- 52:51in a bankruptcy case. And then we had to go back
- 52:53to state court after we got relief from state
- 52:56to do that in the bankruptcy case to file something
- 52:59with the state court saying, you know, bankruptcy
- 53:01judge bless the fees for this period. We're done.
- 53:03We sold the property. Can you please discharge
- 53:05us? Right. Because that's typically the way I've
- 53:09done it as well is that The receiver would need
- 53:12relief from stay from the bankruptcy court in
- 53:15order to go back to the state court to be discharged
- 53:18because it was the state court that appointed
- 53:21the receiver. It was the state court that required
- 53:24the receiver to post a bond. And it should be
- 53:27that court that discharges the receiver and exonerates
- 53:30the receivers bond. Yeah, agreed. I'm learning
- 53:37so much. This is really insightful. This is really
- 53:41interesting. And I just realized that I misspoke
- 53:45and Byron, we were premature in our error. So
- 53:54the 542, section 542 reference I made in paragraph
- 53:57two, that's actually correct. The court in that
- 54:00case was analogizing the custodian's turnover
- 54:04obligations under 543, analogizing that section
- 54:08to the expansive definition of turnover generally
- 54:10to section 542. So that's correct for all of
- 54:15our viewers. Right. The third bullet point should
- 54:18be 542. 543. Yes. 543. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. There's
- 54:26actually a question for Kira in the questions
- 54:30board. This is pertaining to the federal securities
- 54:35receiverships. And I think we have a little bit
- 54:40of time, so I think I can read it to Kira since
- 54:45we're done now. And actually we have, so we do
- 54:49have like four more, now three more minutes,
- 54:51four questions. So if there are questions, you
- 54:54know, you can. type of question, and we'll answer
- 54:56it. But I'll go to this question because this
- 54:59was sent a bit ago. So for Kira, would a violation
- 55:04of federal securities laws be sufficient grounds
- 55:07to appoint a receiver on application of an injured
- 55:10creditor as opposed to the SEC? Yeah, I mean,
- 55:14you do see that in private, you know, you'd probably
- 55:16presumably be suing the company for fraud and
- 55:21for some private right of action that you would
- 55:23have. And in those situations, I mean, yes, depending
- 55:27upon the level of it and the evidence that you
- 55:30have that fraud, generally, it's really just
- 55:33a fraud theory, you know, that fraud was committed.
- 55:36um, by the, uh, entity that's a defendant or
- 55:40the person who's a defendant, um, and that there's
- 55:42something to be done. I mean, it can't just be,
- 55:44you want a receiver appointed over an asset just
- 55:46because usually it would be, there's an operating
- 55:48business and there's got to be some evidence
- 55:51of dissipation of assets or that mismanagement
- 55:54in addition to just the fraud that he lied to
- 55:56me. So it's all kind of, it's a high level of,
- 55:59um, evidence because you're putting somebody
- 56:02in control of the business at that point and
- 56:05ousting management. So it's not necessarily easy.
- 56:08I think you have to be able to establish those
- 56:11things and meet your evidentiary burden. But
- 56:15the answer is yes. I mean, it actually it does
- 56:17happen. And I've been involved in cases like
- 56:20that. Well, and it might be a bigger fraud. There
- 56:25may be. a bunch of investors, for instance, who
- 56:29were defrauded and maybe it ends up being more
- 56:32than just one party that seeks the appointment
- 56:36of a receiver. There are statutes that provide
- 56:41for involuntary dissolution in certain situations.
- 56:44So it might be appropriate in state or federal
- 56:48court to seek the appointment of a receiver.
- 56:51Right. So similar to like a Ponzi scheme situation.
- 56:54Possible. Yes. But it is, you know, in those
- 57:00situations, I do just want to emphasize it's
- 57:02a pretty high bar that you have to show in order
- 57:05to get a receiver appointed because the ramifications
- 57:07in that context are pretty significant. So it
- 57:10can't just be an allegation of fraud. It's really
- 57:13got to be something a little, I think, a little
- 57:15bit more than that. Yeah, because all the cases
- 57:18which talk about the appointment of receiver
- 57:20refer to it as a drastic remedy. And oftentimes,
- 57:24the court will deny applications or motions seeking
- 57:27the appointment of receiver, and judges will
- 57:31suggest that there's a lesser onerous remedy
- 57:34that might be appropriate. Sometimes perhaps
- 57:37it's seeking a writ of attachment. Sometimes
- 57:39it's seeking a writ of possession. Judges, in
- 57:43my experience, will go out of their way trying
- 57:45to fashion some other remedy if, in fact, it
- 57:49could at least solve the problem temporarily.
- 57:56Well, we just reached our time. So I wanted to
- 58:00thank I want to thank all of our panelists for
- 58:03making this such a insightful discussion. I certainly
- 58:06learned a lot and we don't yeah, I think we oh
- 58:13You know what there there are a couple more questions
- 58:15If we have a couple minutes, do you do you guys
- 58:19would you guys be okay answering a few more questions?
- 58:22Sure, I'll take the Seth Freeman question, which
- 58:26says sometimes the receivership runs out of money
- 58:29to pay all the fees. Does the party that wanted
- 58:31the receivership have to pay the fees? The answer
- 58:36generally is yes, there there's case law to the
- 58:39effect that in the event that there are insufficient
- 58:41at the receivership estate to pay all the expenses
- 58:46of the receivership. Generally, the receiver
- 58:49will look to the party that sought to receive
- 58:51his appointment to pay the shortfall. Interesting
- 58:58and then there's 1 other question. I mean, anyone
- 59:03can answer this is a receivers question that
- 59:06applies. To bankruptcy is there strong language
- 59:10you suggest to include in a receivership appointment
- 59:12order to instruct the receiver or underlying
- 59:15parties to direct them to seek relief from the
- 59:19bankruptcy court. To abstain and find the receivers
- 59:23doing a good job. So basically, is there a language
- 59:26that you would suggest, including in the appointment
- 59:28order that. Basically, if a bankruptcy is filed
- 59:32that directs the parties to in the bankruptcy
- 59:36to abstain and the court in the bankruptcy to
- 59:38abstain and allow the receiver to continue performing
- 59:43their tasks in the receivership and get things
- 59:46moving along. Well, I think you have a federalism
- 59:49problem. So the bankruptcy code is going to trump
- 59:53anything that the state court says in its order.
- 59:55So it's going to be governed by 543 and by the
- 59:59case law and that standard, no matter what the
- 1:00:02state court judge tries to say. Well, I think
- 1:00:05what he's saying is should you put in the order
- 1:00:08of putting the receiver that if there's a bankruptcy,
- 1:00:10you need to move to, you know, somebody needs
- 1:00:12to move for abstention, right? That I think you
- 1:00:16could do. I think, or I guess any, I mean, authorizations
- 1:00:21to seek, I mean, I don't know if you need to
- 1:00:22have that in the appointing order, but authorizations
- 1:00:24to seek relief from, you know, the automatic
- 1:00:27stay from turnover. I think you should just consult
- 1:00:33with competent counsel who will advise you appropriately.
- 1:00:36Yes. Yeah, no, they I mean the order isn't gonna
- 1:00:41govern what the bankruptcy judge does I mean
- 1:00:44the sense of like it's not gonna You know, it's
- 1:00:45not gonna be like well we said in the order that
- 1:00:47the but I don't think that was the intent of
- 1:00:48the question Yeah, I don't reading it now again.
- 1:00:51I don't think so either I understand so Okay,
- 1:00:56yeah, I think and Well, just going back to that
- 1:01:00question, if the question was, you know, should
- 1:01:01you put language in an order, like directing
- 1:01:04the receiver or some party to file a motion if
- 1:01:06a bankruptcy court gets filed? I think the form
- 1:01:08order actually says something similar to that.
- 1:01:11But that's what I was referencing earlier where
- 1:01:13it says, you know, within 10 days of a bankruptcy
- 1:01:16filing, I think it says the party appointing
- 1:01:18the receiver should file a motion for turnover
- 1:01:20if they're going to do that. And it's a bit of
- 1:01:24a conflict with the code because the code says
- 1:01:25immediately the receiver needs to turn things
- 1:01:27over. So, but like, as I've indicated, I mean,
- 1:01:30parties work that out. But that is in the foreign
- 1:01:34receivership order. So I do think you can spell
- 1:01:37that out in advance. I just query the enforceability
- 1:01:41of that provision. Well, it's certainly not binding
- 1:01:44on the bankruptcy court. Yeah. I don't know if
- 1:01:52they would necessarily need to be authorized
- 1:01:54to seek relief. Do you know what I mean? If they're
- 1:01:57a party initiative. I don't think it's necessary
- 1:02:01either. I guess if you're worried that they won't,
- 1:02:08I don't know, maybe you're worried that they're
- 1:02:09going to just be like, you take it bankruptcy
- 1:02:12court. It's your problem now. Maybe you want
- 1:02:17to encourage them to be. And in my experience,
- 1:02:25there's always some time lag. Immediately, I
- 1:02:27think it's just a contrast between a custodian
- 1:02:29versus other parties that may be in possession
- 1:02:31of property. Do you mean where there's a sense
- 1:02:35that for other people that are in possession
- 1:02:36of property, there may need, you know, you're
- 1:02:38not sure, is there an adversaries or contested
- 1:02:40matter, but for custodians, it's meant to be
- 1:02:43like, you are now being replaced by someone else.
- 1:02:46You are now being replaced by a trustee or you're
- 1:02:47now being placed by possession. So you're not
- 1:02:49allowed to wait around. Like you have a more
- 1:02:51of an affirmative turnover obligation. And, but
- 1:02:54in my experience, there's usually, yeah, sometimes
- 1:02:57there's like, no judge has been like, well, you
- 1:02:59didn't do it, you know, like. five minutes after
- 1:03:03getting the bankruptcy petition information.
- 1:03:05I mean, there's an understanding that it's going
- 1:03:07to take a little bit of time. But as long as
- 1:03:09they're being, they're not just sitting on it,
- 1:03:11they're doing something to get either some kind
- 1:03:15of relief, like by filing relief from stay, filing
- 1:03:18an excuse from turnover, something that they're
- 1:03:21doing and not just holding on until the debtor
- 1:03:23or some other trustee takes action, right? Great.
- 1:03:32Okay, well, I think, I mean, we don't have any
- 1:03:36more questions and we are past time. Yeah, we
- 1:03:43don't have any more questions. Thank you, Chantal.
- 1:03:45Thank you guys so much. This has been really
- 1:03:48very insightful and I've learned a lot. Thank
- 1:03:51you guys so much for your time. and for taking
- 1:03:54all of your experiences and imparting them on
- 1:03:57us. I'm sure all of our viewers agree. Thank
- 1:04:02you so much, and thank you all for joining. Good
- 1:04:05night. Thank you. Thanks. See you later.