Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / When It Isn't Just Alzheimer's: Cognitive Decline, Undue Influence, and Elder Financial Abuse in California Trust and Civil Litigation
Transcript
- 0:03Good afternoon, and welcome to When It Isn't
- 0:06Just Alzheimer's, Cognitive Decline, Undue Influence,
- 0:11and Elder Financial Abuse in California Trust
- 0:14and Civil Litigation. I am Jennifer McNeil -Ozono,
- 0:18co -chair of the BHBA's Trust and Estates Law
- 0:20Section. Before we begin, I'd like to take a
- 0:23moment to thank our sponsors. The Trust and Estates
- 0:25Section is sponsored by Bond Services of California,
- 0:29Liberty Mutual Assurity, the California Title
- 0:32Company, Pickford Escrow Company, along with
- 0:37the Sanborn team. I am delighted to introduce
- 0:40our speakers today, Michael Hackard and Matthew
- 0:42Davis. Michael A. Hackard is a California trust
- 0:45and estate litigation attorney with 50 years
- 0:48of experience representing families and elder
- 0:50financial abuse and inheritance disputes. He
- 0:53is the author of six books on elder vulnerability
- 0:56and family protection. Most recently, stolen
- 1:00inheritance, how the vulnerable lose their estates,
- 1:03and what families can do. He has testified before
- 1:07the U .S. House of Representatives Committee
- 1:09on Ways and Means and is the recipient of a 2026
- 1:12Silver Telly Award for introducing the sage AV
- 1:16preeminent super lawyer. After thousands of cases,
- 1:21he sees the pattern others miss. Matthew D. Davis
- 1:25is a partner at Walk Up Melodia at Kelly and
- 1:28Schoenberger, one of California's leading plaintiff
- 1:30side trial firms. A 1989 graduate of UC Law,
- 1:35San Francisco and the school's 2024 Alumni of
- 1:38the Year, he has helped recover hundreds of millions
- 1:41of dollars in verdicts and settlements and catastrophic
- 1:43injury, wrongful death and premise liability
- 1:47cases tried in state and federal court. He has
- 1:50been named the Law Dragon 500 leading plaintiff
- 1:54consumer lawyers list every year since 2022.
- 1:57He brings the civil trial jury strategy and mediation
- 1:59perspective on elder financial abuse litigation.
- 2:03Thank you, gentlemen. Now let's get started.
- 2:07Thank you. Thank you very much. Well, I'll start
- 2:12here and then Matt will soon follow. Our intent
- 2:16today is to, we'll go to the next slide. So,
- 2:23Our intent today is to recognize recurring things
- 2:28that you'll see in your practice and see in your
- 2:30life. And that is, you know, having to do with
- 2:33cognitive decline of an elder and then what type
- 2:36of exploitation patterns there are. And this
- 2:39crosses Alzheimer's, vascular dementia, alcohol,
- 2:44post -surgical impairment, all kinds of things.
- 2:47What we're going to talk about too are parallel
- 2:49civil and probate architecture. including jury
- 2:52trial, which will be really interesting because
- 2:55I don't think many people have covered this,
- 2:58but we're going to cover it today, and Matt will
- 3:01cover it very well. And then how you cross -examine
- 3:06the drafting attorney, which again is interesting.
- 3:12We'll go next to four elements. And with that,
- 3:16because that's what you're going to be trying
- 3:18if you're in civil court, for the most part.
- 3:21Matt, go ahead. Yeah, thanks, Mike. You know,
- 3:26the first thing I'll say is I've been a lawyer
- 3:30for a while, but I'm fairly new to this area
- 3:32of the law. I ended up kind of at the last minute
- 3:35trying a financial elder abuse case a few years
- 3:38ago. And that's how I got interested. In full
- 3:42disclosure, probate law still remains somewhat
- 3:45arcane to me. There's lots of special rules and
- 3:48procedures, and for the most part, they're bench
- 3:52trials. What I'm interested in are the cases
- 3:57that head in the direction of a jury trial, primarily
- 4:00on an elder financial abuse claim. In one area,
- 4:05one reason I got interested in this area is because
- 4:08I sort of had a realization And it's kind of
- 4:14been borne out by a lot of stories I've seen
- 4:16in the newspapers recently. The Chronicle recently
- 4:19had a series of articles that were entitled The
- 4:22Great Wealth Transfer. And it basically speaks
- 4:25to the fact that a majority of the wealth in
- 4:29this country and in California is held by the
- 4:32baby boomer generation. And the people on the
- 4:35upper end of that generation are now I guess
- 4:38in their 80s who are approaching that. And there's
- 4:42some older people in that. And many of them have
- 4:45a lot of assets and they are becoming vulnerable
- 4:48to exploitation and abuse. And so I think there's
- 4:52just been an epidemic of exploitation happening
- 4:56in instances of undue influence. And there are
- 5:00a lot of sizable states that have been, if you
- 5:04will, raided by unscrupulous people. And so we
- 5:09can talk about who's vulnerable and things like
- 5:11that, but I think this is a growing practice
- 5:14area. Every time Mike and I have done this, more
- 5:17and more people are coming to us and saying,
- 5:19oh gosh, we have a case that's just like this.
- 5:23Thank you. Matt and I have an example with the
- 5:28next slide, and it's very similar case that we
- 5:34have. we're going to just talk about this briefly.
- 5:38But it is an example of how this kind of thing
- 5:41happens. So what's the underlying facts? An 81
- 5:46-year -old woman, she's dying in a hospital.
- 5:49Her daughter's been a caregiver for two years.
- 5:52She brings an attorney to the hospital room.
- 5:54All this, I know, sounds outrageous, except that
- 5:58it happens with frequency. And the restatement
- 6:01moves the residue from three children to one.
- 6:04to the one that's hired the attorney. So just
- 6:07a quick little timeline there. You know, power
- 6:10of attorney's signed. One week later, there's
- 6:13a new trust restatement signed. Another week,
- 6:17she dies. And we see these across, we see these
- 6:23with increasing frequency. So Matt, again, I'll,
- 6:29you know, you know, I've looked at this case
- 6:30and once you carry it here. Yeah, yeah. And so
- 6:36a couple things. We'll talk a little bit about
- 6:40starting something on a probate track, because
- 6:42there's typically a different probate department
- 6:45in our California court system. And then those
- 6:48are matters that are tried to the bench versus
- 6:53starting something in the civil department, typically
- 6:56an elder financial abuse case. But One thing
- 7:00I'm noticing as I get involved in these cases
- 7:03is sometimes the defense, the person who's defending
- 7:07the defendant who's accused of undue influence
- 7:11and the lawyer who's representing the party that's
- 7:15claiming undue influence are talking past each
- 7:17other. And really if you're on the plaintiff's
- 7:21side, it's good to recognize this and maybe I
- 7:25can even share my screen if that's okay. And
- 7:32one of my quick points is there's a difference
- 7:36between capacity and undue influence. And we
- 7:47can see that just because someone has capacity
- 7:52doesn't mean that they cannot be the victim of
- 7:55undue influence. And so you often hear the people
- 7:59who defend a claim of financial elder abuse to
- 8:02say, look, there's plenty of evidence that the
- 8:05person who made this donative transfer or change
- 8:08of state or their trust or made a big gift that
- 8:11they have legal capacity to do so. And they may
- 8:14be right, because the threshold is so low to
- 8:18have capacity to make that type of decision.
- 8:21And I hope you can see it on the screen. I sort
- 8:24of have on one side the basic statutes and laws
- 8:28that you look to. Capacity is presumed. If you're
- 8:33challenging, you've got the burden of proof.
- 8:36Just because somebody has a disorder or a mental
- 8:39condition doesn't mean they don't have capacity.
- 8:42It sort of goes on and on. And if you have a
- 8:45situation and we've all seen parties and clients
- 8:48like this where they're... fairly lucid and sane
- 8:51one day, and they may go off the rails the next
- 8:53day. You see that with people of bipolar condition
- 8:56or something like that. There's kind of a presumption
- 8:59that they were lucid on the day they executed
- 9:02the document. I know there's some exceptions
- 9:05to that that I can talk about in a second, but
- 9:08I don't think you need to necessarily get drawn
- 9:12into the fight. You can give up if you're representing
- 9:15the plaintiff that the the decedent or the elderly
- 9:19person may have had capacity. But the question
- 9:22is really whether there was undue influence.
- 9:25And that's really a different question. And that's
- 9:29undue influences. It's defined in the Welfare
- 9:31and Institutions Code. It's defined in the probate
- 9:34code. It's excessive persuasion that overcomes
- 9:38someone's free will. And you look at these four
- 9:41factors that are listed. This would be the victim's
- 9:44vulnerability. the influencer's authority, et
- 9:49cetera, et cetera. And just because you don't
- 9:56have to prove incapacity, I guess, is my point.
- 9:58If you prove it, that's great. But it's not a
- 10:02required element of proving undue influence.
- 10:05And then when you look at the probate code, there's
- 10:08this section that people cite all the time, 21380,
- 10:11that has a list of of certain relationships where
- 10:16undue influence is presumed with respect to when
- 10:21you have a donative transfer or a will or a trust
- 10:25change or something like that. And there's a
- 10:28long list or a fairly long list of situations
- 10:32where undue influence is presumed. And one of
- 10:36them that Mike and I see all the time is when
- 10:39you have the situation of a care custodian. of
- 10:42an adult. And it's very, very common in what
- 10:45we've seen in our practice that the typical fact
- 10:48pattern we see is a gentleman who's maybe in
- 10:52his 80s, he was maybe never married or he's widowed.
- 10:56Maybe there are kids or nephews or nieces out
- 10:58there that he's close to, but suddenly there's
- 11:00someone who's a caregiver. And before you know
- 11:03it, that caregiver has isolated him and he suddenly
- 11:07changed all of his... trust documents or his
- 11:10wills to make her the major beneficiary of his
- 11:13estate. And the thing that's interesting is under
- 11:16the elder and financial abuse statute, there
- 11:19is a presumption that that was the product of
- 11:23fraud or an undue influence. Now it can be rebutted,
- 11:26but the presumption is there. And if you establish
- 11:31that the person was a caregiver when the transfer
- 11:35was made or the document was signed, then that
- 11:39presumption can only be rebutted by clear and
- 11:42convincing evidence. And so my view is once you
- 11:46have the defendant in the category of something
- 11:50like a care custodian, they are really behind
- 11:54in terms of prevailing on the case, or I'd say
- 11:57that you're in good shape as a plaintiff on that
- 11:59one. Let me just mention also this issue. It's
- 12:08a strange creature that I've run into, the certificate
- 12:10of independent review. It's this creature of
- 12:14the probate code that almost, it almost treats
- 12:18a lawyer like that they're a neurologist who
- 12:21can make a determination that someone has competence
- 12:27to enter into an agreement and the person goes
- 12:30to a lawyer and they have some type of meeting
- 12:32and this lawyer can issue something called a
- 12:34certificate of independent review that that may
- 12:37create a safe harbor in terms of the claim of
- 12:41undue influence of the probate code. Let me just
- 12:43stop sharing for a moment on this one. And Mike,
- 12:47maybe you can speak to that for a moment. Yeah.
- 12:52Sometimes people think it's kind of like a get
- 12:55out of jail free card. In my view, it isn't.
- 13:00Some lawyers do. strong certificates of independent
- 13:05review, but the statute itself just recites what
- 13:07you have to say. My experience is at least to
- 13:12the major fraud cases or major elder financial
- 13:16abuse cases, that the whole CIR certificate of
- 13:21independent review can be part of the overall
- 13:24plan, taking plan. That doesn't mean the lawyers
- 13:29who does the CIRs a co -conspirator, but I will
- 13:34say I've seen so many situations where the CIR
- 13:41is just, you know, somebody advertises, a lawyer
- 13:43advertises, they do certificates of independent
- 13:46review of CIR for a thousand dollars. Well, that's
- 13:51really kind of ridiculous because, you know,
- 13:55chances are that It takes a little more time
- 13:58than that to really make an analysis whether
- 14:01this person not just has capacity, but whether
- 14:04the person is being unduly influenced. And Matt
- 14:09and I have cases where there are large, clear
- 14:14undue influence. But part of the whole pattern
- 14:18of undue influence was to include an entirely
- 14:21new attorney to the settler. uh, and to have
- 14:26that, uh, entirely new attorney change the documents,
- 14:30change all documents so that the caregiver got
- 14:32everything. And then that attorney had a buddy
- 14:36of some type who sends it out for the certificate
- 14:39of independent review. Uh, I can say to SS as
- 14:43the litigators. Some lawyers think of them as
- 14:47a real bar. They usually just don't bother me
- 14:50at all because I've seen so many crazy things
- 14:53that I saw an attorney doing where the person
- 14:56was blind, settler was blind and didn't read
- 15:00the document to the blind person. So that's pretty
- 15:03interesting. How do you certify that that person
- 15:06knew what they were doing? Another one where
- 15:10all documents were in English. and the attorney
- 15:13doing the CIR, couldn't speak the language of
- 15:19the settler, which was Spanish. There again,
- 15:22that was an interesting thing. How do you do
- 15:24that? And I just have a lot more examples. For
- 15:29the most part, I just don't view them as an impediment.
- 15:34And there are a few exceptions. I have seen some
- 15:36cases where a few certificates of independent
- 15:40review were done that were really legitimate.
- 15:43The attorneys were probably like many of the
- 15:46attorneys listening today. They were strong estate
- 15:50and trust planning attorneys. They knew better
- 15:55than they'd just do a drive -by CIR. So that's
- 16:00kind of our take. Yeah. I mean, I have limited
- 16:03experience. I guess I'd be concerned if there's
- 16:07CIR in the file. If I'm going to trial, I think
- 16:10I'm going to have to possibly deal with that
- 16:12one way or the other. And let me just say this.
- 16:16A couple that I've seen, I'm not saying that
- 16:19the attorney willfully did anything wrong. But
- 16:22I think some lawyers, this is a little sideline
- 16:25that they get into where they can make a couple
- 16:27thousand dollars quickly without putting in too
- 16:30much effort because the statute really gives
- 16:33you know almost anyone could do it if they check
- 16:36a few boxes and I know Mike and I have one instance
- 16:39where the caretaker literally shopped for lawyers
- 16:44and then she drove the the client who the decedent
- 16:49the eventual decedent to the lawyer's office
- 16:52sat in the waiting room while the CRI interview
- 16:56was done a total of about 30 minutes was spent
- 16:59talking to this woman. And it just like, really?
- 17:05And it was in a state that was worth $20 million
- 17:07too. And so the one thing that, and we have a
- 17:11good question. We have a few good questions already.
- 17:14There's one here that says, how would you value
- 17:17the significance of a non -statutory independent
- 17:19review? i .e. not specifically required by the
- 17:23statute conducted by an experienced trust and
- 17:25state litigator who after privately meeting with
- 17:28an elder trustor issued a certificate of independent
- 17:32review after a private meeting. I think that
- 17:35that would be a good thing for someone who is
- 17:38defending the transaction. It would be concerning
- 17:41to me if I got the file and I felt a need to
- 17:46challenge that or that was an issue in the case.
- 17:48The one thing I'm going to say is, if you get
- 17:51involved in doing that type of thing, and a lot
- 17:54of you probably already know this, beware. Because
- 17:59when that person dies, you may have to give up
- 18:02your files and have to answer questions about
- 18:05what happened. And if I can share my screen briefly.
- 18:19There are three provisions of the evidence code
- 18:23just to be aware of, sections 953 and 960 and
- 18:28961. And they basically say that when someone
- 18:32dies and there's an issue with respect to a transfer
- 18:36or will or something like that, then the attorney
- 18:39-client privilege may be gone. And so if you
- 18:44are involved in issuing a certificate of review
- 18:50or engaged in something like that, just be aware
- 18:54that you might have to answer questions sometime
- 18:57down the road. And some of the most uncomfortable
- 19:00times I've had as a lawyer is when I've had to
- 19:04give up a client's file to someone on the other
- 19:08side. I've yet to have to give a deposition about
- 19:11my conduct in a particular case. And that's not
- 19:13something that I would ever look forward to.
- 19:15And I actually hate suing and deposing lawyers,
- 19:19but that just could happen. So just be aware
- 19:23of that possibility. Yeah. And kind of a color
- 19:29behind that is who set up the call with the CIR
- 19:35lawyer, who drove the settler. Was it a private
- 19:40meeting? How much time was spent? What documents
- 19:43did the CIR lawyer look at? Just look at the
- 19:47new document. How many conversations were there
- 19:50between the referring lawyer and CIR lawyer?
- 19:54Does this occur with frequency? You in your own
- 19:56minds can go on and on and on, as we have, as
- 20:00we look at these cases. There's a question about
- 20:04capacity, and it says, you know, if a client
- 20:07is autistic but fully functional, is gainfully
- 20:10employed, knows property, et cetera, I think
- 20:12the question is whether that person is presumed
- 20:14to have capacity, and I think the answer is absolutely
- 20:17yes. You know, there's no question in my mind
- 20:21that just because someone has a condition like
- 20:24autism or even a serious mental illness, they
- 20:27may still have capacity. Does not mean they're
- 20:30not vulnerable, though. doesn't mean that they
- 20:32can't be a victim of some type of elder financial
- 20:38abuse or dependent adult financial abuse. There
- 20:42is a quote from a case from 1912 that I recently
- 20:46read that's a great quote. It says, soundness
- 20:48of mind and body does not imply immunity from
- 20:52undue influence. It may require greater ingenuity
- 20:56to unduly influence a person of sound mind and
- 20:58body and more evidence may be required to show
- 21:01that such a person was overcome than in the case
- 21:04of a weak mind and body. But history and experience
- 21:07teach that minds of strong men and women have
- 21:09often been over -born and they may have been
- 21:14a master mind persuaded to consent to what in
- 21:17their sober and normal moments are free from
- 21:19undue influence they would not have done. And
- 21:22so it's the idea that someone could both have
- 21:25capacity and be the victim of undue influence
- 21:28is nothing new. It's been in the law for over
- 21:31100 years. And it just brings to mind just over
- 21:37the years how I've attacked the state planning
- 21:41documents that were prepared for. I think one
- 21:44rocket scientist, probably a physician several
- 21:47times, attorney several times, financial people.
- 21:51So again, the fact that they have capacity and
- 21:54they're extremely bright or educated is, again,
- 21:58not a pass. We might look at, it's a few slides
- 22:06ahead, the case three, eight days, just as a
- 22:10quick look. Okay. Again, I think this is similar
- 22:20to what Matt and I have done. Eight days out,
- 22:24so this person leaves treatment against medical
- 22:27advice. Eight days later, there's an amendment
- 22:32signed. The attorney file has no capacity note
- 22:36whatsoever, no independent, no evidence of an
- 22:39independent meeting, no memorandum as to what
- 22:43went on. I do remember this one now, a 63 -year
- 22:48-old man. So you have a dependent adult issue
- 22:51on this one. But Korda Vodka, a day for years,
- 22:54state planning attorney of 35 years, walks him
- 22:57through an amendment. He's shaking in the conference
- 23:00room, texting his wife that he's seen goblets
- 23:03in the corner. And that's a real case. I had
- 23:06to change it a little bit to protect the innocent,
- 23:09so to speak, but a real case. Matt, as a litigator,
- 23:16how would you look at that one? Well, I guess
- 23:23the way I should start looking at these cases
- 23:27is, are we looking at a situation where it seems
- 23:30odd that the person who got the money got the
- 23:33money? Like, is this a sudden change in the decedent's
- 23:37plans? You know, have they for years been intending
- 23:42to give the money or their estate to somebody
- 23:45else. And was this a sudden and kind of odd change?
- 23:48And if it is, I think I began looking closer
- 23:52and closer about whether there was undue influence
- 23:55and whether we can meet that burden in a civil
- 24:00case, which is just proving by preponderance
- 24:02of the evidence. And again, it is our burden,
- 24:06but the fact that this person might have capacity
- 24:09is not necessarily defense. And again, we've
- 24:14seen so many times where a state planning lawyers
- 24:16who are not regularly involved in this litigation
- 24:19or particularly in the civil litigation, just
- 24:24kind of hang their hats on capacity. And in my
- 24:28experience, settlement conferences, unless you
- 24:31have a judge who's not familiar with the law
- 24:34or mediators, and for the most part, because
- 24:37we have a hand in who gets to mediate these things.
- 24:42long -term, excellent, well -experienced mediators
- 24:46are not going to fall into, oh, well, there's
- 24:48a question of capacity. For the most part, the
- 24:51way I've treated that through the years is when
- 24:53other counsel, oftentimes inexperienced counsel
- 24:56comes back and the mediator says, you know, they
- 24:59had capacity. And that's a bit like if you're
- 25:02doing tort law where, you know, you've looked
- 25:04at what's wrong in the tort law. And the other
- 25:07side comes back and says, well, the defendant
- 25:10says they didn't do anything wrong. It's kind
- 25:12of like, well, let's not waste any time on this
- 25:14one. Let's get to what this is really about,
- 25:16which is usually the undue influence. It usually
- 25:21is. There's maybe an exception. And obviously,
- 25:25we're seeing it more and more. There's old cases
- 25:28that stand for this proposition. If someone is
- 25:31diagnosed with progressive senile dementia, or
- 25:36Alzheimer's that's reached a particular point
- 25:38on let's say May 1. And on that date, they're
- 25:43so incapacitated that they don't have the ability
- 25:46to enter a trust or a will. There is a presumption
- 25:50that that's still gonna be true a month or two
- 25:53later. So in other words, with those diseases,
- 25:57which are more and more common that we're seeing
- 25:59as so many of these victims have been diagnosed
- 26:02with Alzheimer's or dementia. or progressive
- 26:07senile dementia, that the presumption is if they're
- 26:11at a point on a certain date where they can no
- 26:14longer have capacity or they're incapacitated,
- 26:18going forward they're presumed to be incapacitated.
- 26:22Yeah, good point. Let's, oh, go ahead, Matt.
- 26:26Go ahead. You know, and you asked, you know,
- 26:29since I've gotten involved with Mike and been
- 26:32working on these cases, He sort of asked, well,
- 26:35what do I look at? And the one thing I just try
- 26:39to do is apply tried and true practices that
- 26:43you do in a personal injury world to these cases
- 26:46that go to a jury, the elder abuse cases. In
- 26:50these cases, in any case, I handle what the practitioners
- 26:54tell you over and over again, if you want to
- 26:56reverse engineer your case. What they mean is
- 27:01you start with what's the verdict you want to
- 27:02get. To get that verdict, what is the verdict
- 27:05form and what do the instructions look like?
- 27:07And so if I'm doing the case the right way in
- 27:10the beginning of the case, I look at what is
- 27:13the jury instruction going to look like in this
- 27:16case? And so I have drafted a proposed jury instruction.
- 27:21It's really based, for the most part, on the
- 27:24Casey instructions. And I can show those. And
- 27:28while he's showing them, this is really valuable
- 27:33information. I've been doing these cases for
- 27:37quite a long time. And what Matt's put together
- 27:41here is something that explains the whole thing
- 27:45well. But also, as I said, he'll reverse engineer
- 27:49the case right from the beginning. Yeah. And
- 27:52so in this case, the plaintiff is the personal
- 27:55representative of the estate. I think there's
- 27:58sometimes a question, sometimes you have some
- 28:01flexibility as to who can be the plaintiff and
- 28:03that's something to consider and think about
- 28:06and maybe test with the focus group, whether
- 28:08you should have a personal representative of
- 28:10the estate or the beneficiaries of the estate
- 28:12or all of those parties involved to get a sense
- 28:17of how a jury might react to who's seeking the
- 28:20money. I think that the... The typical burden
- 28:24of proof instructions, you know, you don't think
- 28:27about them too much, but they actually matter
- 28:28here because as the person bringing the elder
- 28:33abuse claim, you have the burden of just preponderance
- 28:37of the evidence on your elements. But if you
- 28:40shift the presumption in this, for example, you
- 28:44establish that someone's a caregiver, then the
- 28:47burden shifts to them. to rebut that presumption
- 28:50by clearing convincing evidence, which is a pretty
- 28:52high standard to make. So it's worth keeping
- 28:55that in mind when you're putting the case together.
- 28:58And then KC 3100 actually has a pretty good instruction
- 29:04for financial elder abuse. And I think it's really
- 29:07great to look at that instruction before you
- 29:10really dig into the case and before you do your
- 29:14discovery and take your deposition, because you
- 29:16can look at What's the type of evidence or information
- 29:19or testimony I'm going to need to meet each one
- 29:23of my elements, you know, that this person took
- 29:27or obtained the decedent's property that's usually
- 29:29going to be easy to show? The age of the person
- 29:33at the time of the conduct? Well, it's usually
- 29:35no dispute about that. Number three is an important
- 29:41one. And the other one's all important. And then
- 29:45if you look at the rest of the instructions.
- 29:48Again, you'll have ideas about what type of documents
- 29:51to ask for, what type of questions to ask during
- 29:54your depositions. There's another great KC instruction
- 29:59that defines influence in elder abuse cases,
- 30:06KC 3117. I printed it out verbatim here. And
- 30:11again, this is, if you look at the factors that
- 30:14are to be considered, you can get a sense of
- 30:19the type of questions that you should be asking
- 30:21during depositions or who you should be talking
- 30:24to, what type of documents you should be getting,
- 30:26the client's medical or the decedent's medical
- 30:28records, things of that sort. I think if you
- 30:34bring one of these cases, I think there's a question
- 30:37as to whether the presumptions in the probate
- 30:39code would apply in a civil case brought under
- 30:45the federal, I mean, the financial elder abuse
- 30:48statute. I think they should apply. I would ask
- 30:51for a special instruction if you're gonna seek
- 30:54to prove that one of the presumptions apply.
- 30:56And I've got a draft of what I think that special
- 30:58instruction would look like here. And then, of
- 31:01course, you just have your verdict form that
- 31:03you, as a plaintiff, you want those to be as
- 31:06simple as possible and the fewest number of questions
- 31:09that you can get poured out as possible. And
- 31:12that's included as well. Yeah. That's fascinating.
- 31:22And let's move on on slides. go off to downstream
- 31:29a little as the diagnosis is not the threshold.
- 31:33We're not going to spend much time on this because
- 31:35we've just covered it quite a bit. But again,
- 31:38sometimes people will look at whether it's a
- 31:42plaintiff or a defendant. So a defendant may
- 31:45say there's no Alzheimer's disease or vascular
- 31:49dementia and feels like, you know, they're home
- 31:52free. Well, they're not home free. And the same
- 31:55because of all the undue influence issues and
- 31:59vulnerability under the code. In the same way,
- 32:03as a plaintiff, you're not exactly home free.
- 32:06if you've got diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease,
- 32:09vascular dementia, or there's alcoholism or substance
- 32:13abuse there. All of those things though, certainly
- 32:17show vulnerability. So we don't discard them.
- 32:21And I know one of the things that Matt does first
- 32:23is to gather the medical records. So in order
- 32:27to show some of these things, maybe address that,
- 32:29Matt. I think the medical records, you have to
- 32:40start there, just to see if there's something
- 32:43that is conclusive one way or the other. If there's
- 32:47a diagnosis of early onset dementia in 2015,
- 32:51and we're talking about conduct that happened
- 32:53in 2021, I'm thinking about a particular case
- 32:56that Mike and I have, that's really good evidence
- 32:59that by 2021, she didn't have capacity. If you
- 33:03look at the records, there's... note after note
- 33:06that her Alzheimer's is progressing, is getting
- 33:09to the point where she's getting more and more
- 33:10forgetful, so on and so forth. The other thing
- 33:14I'll say is one thing I've learned in handling
- 33:17these cases, and I think we just all have experience.
- 33:20If you reach a certain age, we all have either
- 33:23relatives or friends who have been unfortunate
- 33:29victims of this disease. I know my mother had
- 33:32Alzheimer's. And there's a period of time where
- 33:35they get really good at masking. It's called
- 33:38their disease, where they can kind of pretend
- 33:40that they're fine and that they know what they're
- 33:42talking about. But if you dig a little deeper,
- 33:45they actually are very confused about a lot of
- 33:47things. But they get really good at what the
- 33:49doctors call masking. But again, in terms of
- 33:54either establishing that they lacked capacity
- 33:57or that they were vulnerable, I think the medical
- 33:59records are critical. And then you just find
- 34:03pieces of information here or there. I mean,
- 34:05Mike and I are handling a case right now where
- 34:08the target is claiming that the decedent, when
- 34:15he was in his late 90s, he was fine and he was
- 34:18of sound mind and knew exactly what he was doing
- 34:21when he made these decisions to transfer quite
- 34:24a bit of money and property to a charitable foundation.
- 34:28It's a very questionable conduct in that case.
- 34:31And we have got a voicemail, a couple of voicemails
- 34:36that the decedent left several years before he
- 34:39made those transactions. And he sounds like a
- 34:44rambling, disoriented, confused, at times nice,
- 34:49at times angry, for no reason guy. And to me,
- 34:54that's just such powerful evidence. If we ever
- 34:56put this case in front of a jury, and every time
- 34:59the defense says, He knew what he was doing here.
- 35:02We have a memo to the file that says when we
- 35:05met with him, he was lucid. He was candid. He
- 35:08could do this. He could do that. And then you
- 35:11play that phone recording from two years earlier.
- 35:15And it's just such a disconnect between their
- 35:17theory and what that evidence shows. So that's
- 35:20the type of thing I'm looking for as a trial
- 35:22lawyer. Matt, talking about the things that you're
- 35:27looking for as a trial lawyer, you You've talked
- 35:30about this before, but the difference between
- 35:32how you used to approach it with focus groups
- 35:37and how you do it now, which is pretty high tech.
- 35:41Well, I think any case, this could be the subject
- 35:46of a whole different MCLE, I think any case of
- 35:50significant value, you have to do a focus group
- 35:53today. And I think you have to do a particular
- 35:57type of focus groups. They become much more sophisticated
- 36:01and scientific in recent years. And there are
- 36:06several organizations that have basically taken
- 36:10concepts that corporations use to test their
- 36:13products and test their sales pitches and apply
- 36:17them to a case. And you can present. a fair and
- 36:22balanced presentation of both sides case to hundreds
- 36:26of people through the internet. And there's lots
- 36:29of ways to make sure that the testing is valid.
- 36:31And you can find out a lot of information. You
- 36:36can actually get objective answers to questions
- 36:38like, who should be the plaintiff in the case?
- 36:41What is the reaction to this person's testimony?
- 36:44You might show a video of that particular person.
- 36:47And you can have some level of assurance that
- 36:50the focus group is valid because of the way it's
- 36:52conducted and some of the questions they have.
- 36:56I mean, one way they make sure that the focus
- 36:58group is valid is one of the questions they ask
- 37:00the participants is who do you think sponsored
- 37:03this focus group? And if too many people say
- 37:05the plaintiff side sponsored the focus group,
- 37:08then the whole thing isn't valid because there's
- 37:11a natural tendency of people to want to answer
- 37:13questions in a way that favor who they think
- 37:15is sponsoring. the focus group. And so that's
- 37:19kind of a long -winded way of me saying I would,
- 37:22if I had a case that's significant and I put
- 37:24that in the category of $5 million or more at
- 37:28issue, then I think you have to do some focus
- 37:31group testing. And for those, I have done focus
- 37:36groups in the past and I completely agree that
- 37:39there's some much better process that you're
- 37:41now describing. But for those maybe that haven't
- 37:45done focus groups that were Just describe how
- 37:48it used to be or still is. In some cases, you're
- 37:51picking your group on a Saturday or wherever
- 37:54it is, and the defense might be doing the same.
- 37:57And why that may not work so well. Yeah, there's
- 38:00just, you know, those can be really helpful.
- 38:03You get to practice your opening statement. You
- 38:06get to do things. You know, you try to set them
- 38:09up in a way where they don't know which side
- 38:11is putting them on. But there's usually the sample
- 38:14size is not big enough. There's usually too many
- 38:18clues as to who's putting it on. There's some
- 38:20bias in how it's presented. And I'm not saying
- 38:25it's not a good idea, but I've actually moved
- 38:27away from doing those. And I'm doing more of
- 38:32this very scientific online focus groups in part
- 38:36because I have learned the hard way that sometimes
- 38:38I have a gut feeling or instinct about a case.
- 38:43Like I know this. jury is going to feel this
- 38:45way about this particular piece of evidence,
- 38:48and I can be wrong. I might think that the jury
- 38:52is going to have a great reaction to a particular
- 38:54witness, and I'm sure of it in my bones, and
- 38:56someone says, I'm not so sure about that, and
- 38:59then we can test that. You can actually test
- 39:01that. You can show some of that witness's testimony
- 39:04to a focus group, a large panel of 300 or 400
- 39:08people that's done in this online format, and
- 39:12you don't even need to show much much testimony,
- 39:15but you can get a really solid reaction to how
- 39:21people are going to view that particular witness's
- 39:23testimony. And we know that this is valid because
- 39:26the organizations that do these focus groups,
- 39:29they actually follow the cases to verdict and
- 39:34they see how closely the verdicts align with
- 39:37what their studies revealed. So I'm a big believer
- 39:43in them. I am too. Let's move just a little bit
- 39:49further out to how none of this was created by
- 39:53anyone building a case. Okay, there we go. And
- 39:59this is up again, primarily for Matt, and he'll
- 40:03add things to it, I know, but those are the kind
- 40:06of makeup or the mosaic of what you do when you're
- 40:09building a case. Yeah, I again you should Ideally
- 40:17you get these materials from your client or prospective
- 40:22client before you file And you know, we all have
- 40:28experiences The case is never as good as the
- 40:31first day it walked into your office. You hear
- 40:33your clients side of the case And it sounds great,
- 40:38and you don't see any weaknesses. And then as
- 40:40you get into the case, you find out more information.
- 40:43And usually, it's not helpful information. But
- 40:47to the extent you can gather this type of information
- 40:51before you decide to take on the case or before
- 40:54you file, the better. And then certainly, as
- 40:58you are conducting your discovery and thinking
- 41:01about building your case and gathering all the
- 41:03evidence you need to support each of the elements
- 41:06that you have to prove in the case. This is the
- 41:11type of stuff that you're going to want to get,
- 41:14either by way of documents or by way of witness
- 41:18testimony. We're getting a lot of questions.
- 41:22Oh, let's go with that. We will share the handout.
- 41:26The statute of limitations for undue influence,
- 41:29great question. It's four years. And that actually
- 41:32brings up a big issue in these cases involving
- 41:37the 120 -day time period with respect to trust
- 41:41and then the four -year period for elder abuse
- 41:44claims. You want to talk about that, Mike? Sure.
- 41:48As to trust cases, challenges to trust, which
- 41:53are in the probate court, there's a probate code
- 41:5716061 .7 that essentially tells mandates that
- 42:02the trustee of that trust send out notice of
- 42:08the settler's death or permanent incapacity.
- 42:11But let's talk about death, supposed to be done
- 42:14within a fairly short amount of time after the
- 42:17person dies. And then the notice is sent out
- 42:22to all beneficiaries and heirs, essentially.
- 42:29they have 120 days from the time of the sending
- 42:34of the document to do a challenge. And you kind
- 42:39of get into this gray area, like sending of the
- 42:42document. What does that mean? And who knows
- 42:46exactly, because it seems far more rational from
- 42:49the time of the receipt of the document, but
- 42:51maybe that's always up in the air. So you run
- 42:54it off the time of the sending of the document.
- 42:59Trust don't, or the trust documents aren't accompanied
- 43:03by that or an election of the sender they could
- 43:06be. And the notice, you know, describes the ability
- 43:11that to ask for a copy of the trust document,
- 43:14which people should do. Sometimes these people
- 43:17just completely ignore these things. And so you
- 43:20have, you know, 120 days is run and you're out
- 43:24of luck as far as challenging the trust document.
- 43:27And Matt's got some insights in just terms of
- 43:31why it is that people sometimes simply ignore
- 43:33it. Well, this is something that is new to me.
- 43:39I'm used to dealing with statutes of limitations,
- 43:43the one that always makes a plaintiff's lawyer
- 43:46most nervous or when a public entity is involved,
- 43:49because usually you have six months from the
- 43:51date of the incident to file a tort claim. And
- 43:53if you blow that statute, you might lose your
- 43:57right forever to bring the case. And so, we're
- 43:59super mindful of that limitations period. Here,
- 44:04you have a much shorter deadline to challenge
- 44:07a trust. And the notice that the client gets
- 44:10of this 120 -day rule is often phrased in a very
- 44:16sort of gentle letter. It almost lulls the person
- 44:20into complacence here. It probably is intended
- 44:22to do that. It's sort of... often begins with
- 44:25my condolences about the death of your grandfather
- 44:28or whatever it is. I'm really sorry to bother
- 44:31you at this time, but you just need to know about
- 44:34this and that. And if you want copies of these
- 44:36documents, call me. And you have, by the way,
- 44:39you have 120 days to do something about this.
- 44:43But it's written in a way where it's probably
- 44:45pretty easy to ignore that letter, especially
- 44:48if you're grieving the person's loss. And so
- 44:51I think what Mike has seen in his practice is
- 44:53he gets a lot of calls from people on what day
- 44:5790, day 100, day 110. And tell us, Mike, how
- 45:06that makes you feel when you get a call. It's
- 45:09a really good case, but with only a few days
- 45:10left. It's it is a red flag because and particularly
- 45:17where there's just a few days left because you
- 45:19have a very short amount of time to do due diligence
- 45:22and probably not enough time to do the due diligence.
- 45:28So you have to analyze and say, am I willing
- 45:30to do this? And you're going to have to plead
- 45:33some of it probably on information and belief.
- 45:38It's very uncomfortable. And I've I've had people
- 45:41that this happened. probably 10 times. They have
- 45:45a day or two left. No, I'm not taking that case.
- 45:49A day or two left. And just to be clear, if you
- 45:52decide to challenge the change or the amendment,
- 45:55what do you have to do, Mike? What do you have
- 45:56to file? You've got to file probate code section
- 45:5917 -200 petition in the probate court to overturn
- 46:05the trust. the document, and based upon, generally
- 46:11you're going to base it upon, you're going to
- 46:15plead in capacity, but most of the time it's
- 46:18going to be overturned on the basis of undue
- 46:20influence. Every once in a while, forgery, fraud,
- 46:26but that's, forgery's a rabbit hole. Yeah. You've
- 46:33seen enough of that. And I think does the client
- 46:36have to verify the petition too? Yeah, they verify
- 46:39the petition. So it's quite a bit of work to
- 46:42do that on short notice. And again, we've seen
- 46:46this where the story comes in with the client.
- 46:50And what you don't know is the rest of the story,
- 46:52like that there was an earlier amendment 10 years
- 46:56earlier that had cut out that person from the
- 47:00estate of the decedent. Be mindful of that. But
- 47:08if the statute is gone, in other words, if someone
- 47:12approaches you and either there wasn't a 120
- 47:15-day letter because there was never a trust or
- 47:18the events happened a year or two earlier, there's
- 47:21a four -year limitations period for a claim of
- 47:24financial elder abuse. That's right. And that
- 47:29is something that we use. And the courts are
- 47:34general and because again, it's in civil court.
- 47:37Courts are more cognizant of that statute and
- 47:41the rights under it than they were, say, five
- 47:45or ten years ago when I started doing this. We'd
- 47:48have courts say, well, this should be in probate.
- 47:51You can't do this. You can't file in civil. Still,
- 47:54sometimes we see that. You can't file in civil
- 47:57and in probate based on the same facts. They're
- 48:01really not based on the same facts or all the
- 48:04same theories at all. So, yeah, you know, file
- 48:07a separate claim in civil, the civil department.
- 48:10And then I would also put on the face of the
- 48:13complaint jury trial demanded just to make that
- 48:17clear. And then once the cases, if two cases
- 48:21on file, what I'm seeing is they often get coordinated
- 48:25or consolidated or I don't know what the right
- 48:27term is, but. I think what you're going to want
- 48:30is for the civil case to be the lead case too.
- 48:34I agree. And that is something that we do try
- 48:37to do. And you may have some motion practice
- 48:40on all of that, notice of related case, et cetera.
- 48:44But this is why we look at a major hammer in
- 48:49these cases is elder financial abuse. It is just
- 48:53because of the statute. Uh, and Matt, you might
- 49:00talk a little more about why, because you're,
- 49:03you're so accustomed to doing tort and personal
- 49:05injury. Well, why is this statute such a hammer?
- 49:10Well, the, uh, a couple of things is, is, is,
- 49:16you know, you look at, at the burdens and they're
- 49:18not that onerous, um, in terms of what you need
- 49:22to show, you know, often I just see it more and
- 49:26more. We've all seen it happen to people we care
- 49:29about. Elderly people are getting victimized.
- 49:33From Mike and I's perspective, the cases that
- 49:36are viable to consider taking on, you want to
- 49:39make sure you still have assets that can be recovered.
- 49:42We get a lot of calls about cases where maybe
- 49:46a sizable amount of money was taken from a vulnerable
- 49:50elderly person, but the money is gone. It was
- 49:53transferred to a bank account or something like
- 49:57that offshore and it'll never be recovered. The
- 50:01cases that we wanna get involved in are cases
- 50:04where there are funds that could be locked down
- 50:08in a financial account, a Schwab account or something
- 50:11like that, or there's real estate property that
- 50:14we can file a list pendants on to keep it from
- 50:17being sold and that there's a fair amount of
- 50:21assets at stake. And then the other thing is
- 50:25the remedies are good. You get your damages,
- 50:29you can also get attorney's fees, you can get
- 50:31double damages, you can get punitive damages.
- 50:34Now, most of the cases we take on, it's not realistic
- 50:38that you're gonna get those types of damages,
- 50:40because the dependents typically are like a caregiver
- 50:43who most of their assets are the money that we
- 50:45say they wrongfully took from the elderly person.
- 50:49But nevertheless, it's a very powerful statute
- 50:52in the case law. There's not a lot of case law
- 50:55on it, but it says it should be broadly interpreted
- 50:57to achieve its purposes of protecting elderly
- 51:02people and undoing these injustices. And you
- 51:07use described how you use the same analysis say
- 51:10that you use in a personal injury case and that
- 51:14is the three -legged stool. So how do you look
- 51:17at that? So you know when you have a PI case
- 51:21We often talk about a three -legged stool. You
- 51:23want to have good liability. You want to have
- 51:26a big injury or a significant value to the case.
- 51:30And then the third leg is you want to have collectability.
- 51:33You want to have a good insurance policy or someone
- 51:36who's in the course and scope or a corporation
- 51:38or something like that. And those are the three
- 51:41legs of the stool. And we see a lot of two -legged
- 51:44stools. personal injury, wrongful death work.
- 51:48You see a lot of cases with really good liability
- 51:51and horrible injuries, but there's just no one
- 51:53that you can collect the money from. It's an
- 51:55under -insured driver who's undocumented and
- 51:58gone from the scene or something like that. And
- 52:02those are cases where you feel terrible for the
- 52:05family or the victim, but there's not too much
- 52:07you could do for them. Same thing here. You want
- 52:11to have good liability. You want to have good
- 52:14evidence of undue influence. You want to have
- 52:18a large amount of assets involved because the
- 52:21cases can be a lot of work and the game, you
- 52:25know, has to just, the candle has to justify
- 52:27the game or whatever that old expression is.
- 52:29You want to make sure that that makes sense.
- 52:32And then often most importantly is, are those
- 52:36assets still around? Can they be reached? You
- 52:39know, if they're gone, if they disappeared and
- 52:41they've been dissipated, then it may be a great
- 52:44case except All you're going to do is get a verdict.
- 52:48And that piece of paper is going to be worthless.
- 52:51And you're not doing anyone a favor by taking
- 52:53on that case. I'm sorry. We're getting a lot
- 52:58of questions. Because I didn't see. Go for it.
- 53:02No, no, no. These are quite questions I can't
- 53:05really answer. But there are a lot of questions
- 53:06about the certificate of independent review and
- 53:09what should I do. And I don't really know because
- 53:12I've never issued one of those. All I know is
- 53:15I'd be the jerk of the lawyer asking the person
- 53:19questions who issued the certificate of independent
- 53:22review. And so I don't know if you have any thoughts,
- 53:25Mike, as to what people can do to make that process
- 53:28somewhat bulletproof from attack. Yeah. Well,
- 53:34first, my own disclaimer. I was asked to do one.
- 53:37I've been asked to do them. I won't do them.
- 53:39I was asked to do one on about a I think $20
- 53:42million trust and wouldn't do it. It wouldn't
- 53:47do it in part because to really, for me to do
- 53:50it, knowing that I could be called as a witness
- 53:53and be knowing about this, it would take on an
- 53:56hourly time. It probably would have been 10 ,000,
- 53:5915 ,000 plus on a $20 million trust, because
- 54:04I'd want to know everything about it. I want
- 54:06to know everything about the person that's making
- 54:08changes of the trust. So, but the question is,
- 54:12so how would you really protect it? Well, first
- 54:15of all, I would say don't try to look for the
- 54:20bargain basement lawyer to do a CIR if you're
- 54:24really concerned about this thing. You find someone
- 54:28who's well known, I think, strong ethics, knows
- 54:33what the law is in estate planning and undue
- 54:37influence. and is able to speak with the maker,
- 54:44testator or settler, unfettered by anyone else,
- 54:51takes a very strong look at not just the current
- 54:53document, but at previous documents by know what
- 54:58the family relationships are, try to figure out
- 55:02what is the health of this person at that point.
- 55:08It's just a bit of using common sense. I'd also
- 55:11say do some research on it. I'd be just very
- 55:15uncomfortable doing one unless you really researched
- 55:20it and understood if you're doing it, again,
- 55:25it is not a get out of jail free card for lawyers
- 55:28that are accustomed to challenging them. There
- 55:31are lots of reasons that we can challenge. It
- 55:33doesn't mean that it's been wrongful conduct.
- 55:36It just may be that it's not just wasn't well
- 55:40done. Yeah, one of the people who made a comment
- 55:45said that they they interview family members
- 55:48sometimes as part of that process. That sounds
- 55:50like a good idea to me. It does. But I guess
- 55:55the more you can document your file and truly
- 55:58be objective, don't just say they have capacity
- 56:02because that's what they want to hear. I guess
- 56:05if you're going to take on that job, take it
- 56:08on. Yeah. Be serious about it because you may
- 56:12be called beyond the fact. Be serious about it
- 56:15because that's what your profession and our ethics
- 56:18require. But take very good notes, strong notes.
- 56:24Sometimes, you know, in the past I've said to
- 56:30clients, what we're doing here is we're writing
- 56:34for the court. We're writing for a judge. Just
- 56:37trying to get the point across that whatever
- 56:40documentation we have at some point may be reviewed
- 56:44judicially. So with that in mind, you just, you
- 56:49want to do the best job you can. Yeah, the only
- 56:53other thing I'd say, and this is just a good
- 56:55practice anyways, is document your file. Just
- 57:00put it in a memo to the file and keep that in
- 57:03the file because it may be years later that you're
- 57:06asked about this and we all forget things. So
- 57:09that's a good reason to document it. There is
- 57:14a question, as a respondent, how do you secure
- 57:17a jury trial? And I guess my response is to ask
- 57:20the other side to file an elder abuse claim against
- 57:24your client. I think if you're in probate court
- 57:27as a respondent, you don't get a jury trial.
- 57:31Is that right? That's right. You don't get a
- 57:34jury trial. You have a bench trial. Yeah. That's
- 57:37an interesting point. Like if you think a jury
- 57:41would really help, I'd have to think that one
- 57:45through. I'd try to see if there's some creative
- 57:48a cross complaint or some type of thing. I don't
- 57:51know. Just off the top of my head, I don't know.
- 57:54I mean, it's been a long time since I took remedies,
- 57:56but probate is generally an equitable remedy.
- 58:00And when you're in civil court, you're talking
- 58:01about civil remedies or legal remedies. And that's
- 58:05usually the dividing line. One is decided by
- 58:09the court. The other is decided by the trial
- 58:12effect, which is usually a jury. And here is
- 58:18the question, do you ever find a civil case is
- 58:20not available in a matter because the court denies
- 58:23that there's deems there's an adequate remedy
- 58:26in probate court? Where you see that is intentional
- 58:33interference with an expected inheritance. That's
- 58:36an adequate remedy. So probate court's an adequate
- 58:39remedy. So that that particular cause of actions.
- 58:43you know, will be set aside. And usually in a
- 58:47meet and confer, I mean, I've done it before
- 58:50where I've pled that even knowing what the rule
- 58:53was later and looked at and said, yeah, you're
- 58:57right on a meet and confer. That doesn't belong
- 58:59there. But the intentional or rather the financial
- 59:04elder abuse case, that one's going to live. That's
- 59:09going to get you to your civil jury trial. If
- 59:12you've got underlying facts that are going to
- 59:14support it, you're going to get a jury trial
- 59:16on it. Yeah, I would agree. So but there may
- 59:22be findings that the probate court proceeds first.
- 59:25You know, you might run into a res judicata,
- 59:27Clara Lestapel, if there are similar issues in
- 59:30the cases. But but I don't think you're precluded
- 59:33simply because there's a probate claim. So can
- 59:36you still file? Can you still claim? financial
- 59:40elder abuse in civil court if they did the 120
- 59:43-day letter. Answer? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
- 59:50You can. Again, you've got a four -year statute
- 59:54from wrongdoing, and oftentimes it's continuing
- 59:59wrongdoing, but you've got a four -year statute
- 1:00:02on that. And I think over the years a few times
- 1:00:05I've done those. I know I've done them even a
- 1:00:10few years after. Maybe a 120 days, 120 day notice,
- 1:00:18because again, we were going to be in civil court.
- 1:00:20We had reasons for being in civil court and we
- 1:00:24didn't feel precluded by the fact that people
- 1:00:27blew the 120 days. This is one right up your
- 1:00:32alley, Mike. Can you address the promise to inherit
- 1:00:34in the statute of limitations? Yeah, I wish I
- 1:00:38could remember all the particulars of that. I
- 1:00:40would say go look at the statute. I think it's
- 1:00:44a year. I do. I think it's a year. And it has
- 1:00:48a lot of peculiar aspects to it. It's plaid.
- 1:00:54As many cases as I've had, I think I've only
- 1:00:58done it a couple of times. And the conduct was
- 1:01:02so egregious. that it worked fine. But that is
- 1:01:07a creature of statute. Changing law on it over
- 1:01:10the last several years, you're just going to
- 1:01:12have to look at that closely. Yeah, I know we're
- 1:01:18probably out of time. There's one more question.
- 1:01:21It's sort of a proof question. Can you speak
- 1:01:23to the need to prove intent, knowledge, wrongfulness
- 1:01:26of the defendant, alleged abuser as to the capacity
- 1:01:30and vulnerability of an elder? in an elder abuse
- 1:01:33matter, you mentioned that the elder may be able
- 1:01:36to effectively mask their condition and may not
- 1:01:38actually have capacity. But if the elder is masking
- 1:01:42their condition, what challenges does a plaintiff
- 1:01:44have in showing that the elder lacked capacity?
- 1:01:46It's kind of a good question. It goes on from
- 1:01:48there. I think that's right. That's a challenge.
- 1:01:51I mean, Mike and I have a case where... There's
- 1:01:56a body cam footage of the decedent talking to
- 1:01:59a police officer, and she actually seems somewhat
- 1:02:01lucid in the superficial conversation. But we
- 1:02:07know that some of her answers were completely
- 1:02:09made up or false. And one of the things that
- 1:02:14we did in that case, at least we considered doing,
- 1:02:16was hired an expert on cognitive decline in Alzheimer's.
- 1:02:23It's more of me explaining why someone seems
- 1:02:26like they have capacity or they seem like they're
- 1:02:29not vulnerable when in fact we think that or
- 1:02:32we contend that they are. Yeah. Anything else
- 1:02:39to add, Mike? No, that one, it does bring to
- 1:02:43mind that was fascinating case. Because on its
- 1:02:46face, it looks like, yeah, she really knows what
- 1:02:48she's doing. You probe a little bit further as
- 1:02:51Matt says. She was making this up as she went
- 1:02:54along. Yeah. In that particular clip, she did
- 1:02:57a good job of keeping the officer from entering
- 1:03:00their house. And it's too bad he did not, because
- 1:03:03we know that the house. was in total disarray
- 1:03:07once she got inside. And this was an instance
- 1:03:10where we contended her caregiver was committing
- 1:03:14the elder abuse. And it's too bad the officer
- 1:03:18didn't walk in the door on that particular one.
- 1:03:21You said you would discuss how to depose a drafting
- 1:03:24attorney. And I guess we didn't really do it.
- 1:03:26We sort of touched on it. I guess I'll end with
- 1:03:29that. I think I gave you some sense. I'm going
- 1:03:33to get the drafting attorney's file. I'm going
- 1:03:36to ask a series of questions. And they may be
- 1:03:40able to defend or explain their conduct beautifully,
- 1:03:43or they may have some problems answering some
- 1:03:46of the questions or explaining some of the decisions
- 1:03:48they made. That's all I can sort of say to that
- 1:03:51point. What I what I've done before is to. In
- 1:03:58the beginning, sometimes for 40 minutes, is to
- 1:04:01have that drafting attorney reiterate, well,
- 1:04:05or simply agree that the ethical rules regarding
- 1:04:08this or this, and you support that, you support
- 1:04:12this and you don't see a drafting attorney saying,
- 1:04:16no, I don't support that ethical rule. No, the
- 1:04:19fact of it is. He does support, he or she does
- 1:04:22support it. And then you just, you're moving
- 1:04:24that thing along like a funnel to where ultimately
- 1:04:27if there were mistakes, as an example, failure
- 1:04:31to keep notes, you're going to have an agreement
- 1:04:35from that attorney earlier on that it's an important
- 1:04:39fact to have extensive notes and for all the
- 1:04:44various reasons. So again, these aren't, combative,
- 1:04:48they're not necessarily combative depositions.
- 1:04:55And what I've done, and Matt knows this so well,
- 1:04:58but when I've done some larger ones, I'll actually
- 1:05:02use some trial consultants. And I've done it
- 1:05:06where I've prepared six, seven hours for a two
- 1:05:09-hour deposition. Yeah, and some, I guess I'll
- 1:05:12finish. Some of the deposition theme might be,
- 1:05:16well, you didn't know about this. You didn't
- 1:05:17know about that. You weren't made aware of this.
- 1:05:20You weren't made aware of that. And so the attorney
- 1:05:23could sort of be a sounding board for getting
- 1:05:27into evidence all of the things that the alleged
- 1:05:30perpetrator hid in that process, especially if
- 1:05:36Mike and I have at least one of these cases where
- 1:05:38the the defendant was the one who drove, who
- 1:05:42selected the attorney and drove the client to
- 1:05:46the attorney's office to get the CIR. And that
- 1:05:49attorney didn't know a lot. And that was the
- 1:05:53basis of that examination. I think we're at the
- 1:05:58end, Mike. Yeah, we sure appreciate this opportunity
- 1:06:01to share all of this. And we hope that it's good
- 1:06:07and helpful. And this is a growing area of law
- 1:06:12and one that I think you can do a lot of good
- 1:06:14in. Yeah. And we'll share the materials. Thanks,
- 1:06:16everybody. Thank you.