Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline for Tuesday, February 20, 2024
Transcript
- 0:00H h. Good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio.
- 0:29You are agency get your radio turned off from the studio so w v
- 0:39RC Media and the Metro News Radio Network, the Voice of West Virginia comes
- 0:45the most powerful radio show in West Virginia. This this is Metro News Talk
- 0:50Live with Happy Kerchible Activated switch network. Can you from Charles stand by you,
- 0:58Hoppy? You're on Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kerchival is brought to
- 1:03you by in Covia Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care
- 1:07about most. Visit in covid dot com to learn more. Good morning,
- 1:12Welcome to talk Line on Metro News all across the great state of West Virginia.
- 1:15The phone numbers one eight hundred seven six five eight two five five one
- 1:21one hundred seven six' five t alk or text me three oh four talk
- 1:26three oh four, three oh four talk three oh four. I read all
- 1:29the texts, respond to most and read a few on the air. Coming
- 1:34up. First of all, this morning, I want to get you updated
- 1:38on a breaking story, and that is there's been a vehicle pedestrian accidents at
- 1:44Liberty High School in Harrison County. This happened about seven point thirty this morning
- 1:49as school was beginning. There was a pedestrian struck by a vehicle in the
- 1:55parking lot at Liberty High School and one person has been transferred to Ruby Memorial
- 2:01Hospital. And that's all that's been confirmed at the moment, so our crew
- 2:07is working on that. Will give you additional information as it becomes available.
- 2:13But the word is that the individual who is struck is an adult, not
- 2:17a student. An adult. That doesn't make it any less serious, but
- 2:21for those who have students there and may be concerned, that's what we have
- 2:25so far. So vehicle pedestrian accident in the parking lot at Liberty High School
- 2:30in Harrison County. An adult transferred to Ruby Hospital via Health Net. We
- 2:36are working on the story, giving updates throughout our show this morning on that.
- 2:40At the West Virginia Legislature today, when the House goes in session at
- 2:46eleven o'clock, expect a pretty intense debate over a bill that would allow school
- 2:53teachers to arm themselves. School teachers to arm themselves. This is a bill
- 2:59that's come up several times over the last couple of years. It is back
- 3:01again. It is on second reading, which is amendment stage, and that's
- 3:06when things get somewhat exciting. Brad mclinny would be following that. Today he
- 3:09joins us from our Charleston studios, is report brought to you by AARP,
- 3:15your ally for real possibilities in the Mountain State. Brad, good morning.
- 3:19What can we expect today? First of all, before what we can expect,
- 3:22explaining in what this bill would do, so you know, there's real
- 3:27alarm legitimately so about the number of school shootings that have taken place in America
- 3:31and what to do about them, and the answers are probably complex, like
- 3:35pardening up the entrances and exits and windows. In West Virginia, there has
- 3:39been an effort to provide resources for school protection officers, but West Virginia has
- 3:47so the school protection officers ideally would be former law enforcement or retired military people
- 3:53with training. However, West Virginia's counties are somewhat rural. Some counties have
- 4:00had trouble identifying and getting those people in place. In some cases, maybe
- 4:06there's one school protection officer for the entire county and the elementary school is ten
- 4:12miles away from the high school. So this is an effort to try to
- 4:16make available another kind of school protection officers, in this case educators. So
- 4:24the educators would volunteer, they would have their own concealed carry permits, and
- 4:30they would go through potentially twenty four hours of training that would include mitigation techniques,
- 4:35neutralization of potential threats and active shooters, de escalation techniques, crisis intervention,
- 4:43that kind of thing. They could be authorized to carry a concealed firearm
- 4:47or a taser. So the advocates of this bill say, look, our
- 4:53schools need to be protected. If it takes a few minutes for law enforcement
- 4:57to get there in an emergency, there's got to be somebody inside the school
- 5:00who can protect everybody else. The critics of this bill say, this is
- 5:05going to introduce more firearms into our schools. Accidents can happen. What if
- 5:11at the high school level, or even middle school, a teacher carrying a
- 5:15weapon is overpowered by a large student who is potentially emotional or suicidal and they
- 5:21get their weapon taken away. So a lot of risk assessment in this bill,
- 5:27as you said, today, is going to be amendments in the House
- 5:30of Delegates, potentially up for passage tomorrow. The amendments themselves are interesting the
- 5:36way I'm sorry, I'm sorry. In advanced listeners, you're going to have
- 5:41to listen to my language. Here, as it stands, this bill is
- 5:46permissive. It says that school districts may accept the volunteering of educators who want
- 5:55to get that concealed care permit, who want to go through the training,
- 5:58and who volunteer to be school protection officers, as opposed to may right,
- 6:02as opposed to shall right. It's an option for the schools. The way
- 6:05the bill is now. Yeah, this this amendment that is proposed by a
- 6:11few Republicans, including a Republican Jeff Foster of Putnam County, says that the
- 6:15school district shall accept the volunteering. Okay, so, I mean we can
- 6:20go into what the pluses and minuses of that might be. But the second,
- 6:26the second is proposed by Democrats, and they are suggesting that teachers ought
- 6:32to make more money if they volunteer to be the first line of defense in
- 6:36school, to go through this training and to carry their weapon on a daily
- 6:40basis. They're saying that any person who is designated as the school protection officer
- 6:46should receive a one time bonus of twenty five thousand dollars within thirty days of
- 6:50completing all the required training. This bill right now financially doesn't account for whatever
- 6:57that might cost. But they're suggesting if you're saying that you are taking on
- 7:01the responsibility, if you are going through the training, getting the concealed carry
- 7:05permit, bringing your own weapon and ammunition to the school, and you're going
- 7:11to be the person who is first in line to defend against an armed intruder,
- 7:15then you should make more money twenty five thousand dollars in terms of a
- 7:19bonus is and that's a democratic amendment Blue Hardy, Hornbuckle, Hamilton Garcia,
- 7:26Griffith, Hanson, Lewis Rowe and Young. So is that there to legitimately
- 7:31pay those teachers who would choose to arm themselves twenty five thousand dollars? Or
- 7:36is that meant as they don't have enough jewice to have a poison pill,
- 7:41but to just that, I mean to foul up the gears or maybe both.
- 7:49The legislature this year is really watching spending. It does every year,
- 7:54but right now there is a real attunement to the personal income tax that's gone
- 8:03cut, that's gone into effect this year so this may be something where the
- 8:09additional cost is not accounted for, and so that potentially could be something where,
- 8:13you know, people on the Finance Committee say, well, we can't
- 8:16afford fifty five counties every school twenty five thousand dollars per volunteer. But you
- 8:24know, I think that you could make a legitimate argument that if you are
- 8:28going through all these steps, you're paying for your own concealed carry permit,
- 8:33for the weapon, for the ammunition, and potentially you are going to have
- 8:39your life on the line as the one who's supposed to defend against an attack.
- 8:43Is that worth twenty five thousand dollars as a bonus? I think.
- 8:46I'm not saying that. I it's not up to me. I'm just saying
- 8:50I think there's an argument that could be made that that will be a justifiable
- 8:54bonus for an educator who volunteers. This is going to be a fascinating debate
- 9:00in the House of Delegates today. They go in session at eleven o'clock second
- 9:05reading. That's Amendment stage. Brad, you'll be covering that, so we
- 9:07look forward to your reporting on that. Thank you, sir, Thanks Hapy,
- 9:11all right, thank you. When we come back former Charleston mayor Danny
- 9:13Jones joins us in or Charleston's studios will be right back. It's good to
- 9:18have options when choosing health coverage for your family, your employees, and your
- 9:24company. You want to plan with people you know, like the Health Plan,
- 9:31known for exceptional local customer service and are headquartered right here in West Virginia.
- 9:37We are families, we are businesses, and we are all moving forward
- 9:43together. We are here for you the Health Plan. What if you played
- 9:48the West Virginia Lottery. Because you play, I have a place to exercise
- 9:54after my knee replacement. Because you play, I can enjoy nature's views at
- 9:58the state Park with my grandchildren. Because you play, new schools continue to
- 10:01be built across the state. Each time you play the West Virginia Lottery,
- 10:05A portion from every purchase goes back to seniors, tourism, and education,
- 10:11more than twelve point four billion dollars since nineteen eighty six. West Virginia Lottery.
- 10:16What if you played? Feeling the crunch of high electricity bills, urge
- 10:20your legislators to support community solar and net metering. Community solar, currently available
- 10:26in twenty two other states, gives access to solar energy without rooftop panels.
- 10:31Net metering is already lowering West Virginia energy bills, but its benefits could be
- 10:35stripped away. Join the seventy percent of West Virginians who support affordable electricity.
- 10:39Learn more at WVSUN dot org. That's WVSUN dot org, paid for by
- 10:46Solar United Neighbors Action. Business Leaders. Do you have a remote workforce?
- 10:50Are security concerns keeping you up at night? Fear not sitting at has your
- 10:54back with easy to use, in budget friendly security tools to keep your remote
- 10:58employees safe and out. Our state of the art solutions make security a breeze,
- 11:03ensuring your team stays protected without breaking the bank. Because it's citty net,
- 11:07we believe that cybersecurity should be seamless, not stressful. Elevate your remote
- 11:11work experience with sitting net where safety meets simplicity. Call us today at one
- 11:15eight four to four sitting Net, or visit us at citynet dot net.
- 11:18This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. West
- 11:24Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain state's only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the
- 11:30more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris
- 11:33Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years.
- 11:37No matter where we stalk the fish, they're ultimately going to look for
- 11:43the best suitable habitat. And as an angler, that's the secret of learning
- 11:46how to read the water and learning where the fish are most likely to be
- 11:50staged for feeding, whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about
- 11:54the enjoyment of the great outdoors. And then right after the colds vale the
- 12:00pattern and I came in and it was the first time out hunted him in
- 12:03the morning, about eight point thirty he strolled in and I finally connected.
- 12:07With two days left than the season. Really, West Virginia Outdoors covers it
- 12:11all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for your daily fix, Outdoors
- 12:16Today brings you two and a half minutes of news and notes from the woods
- 12:18and water every weekday morning on Metro News of Voice of West Virginia. Hey,
- 12:24everybody, it's Tony Courritty, I'm Greg Hunter, and I'm Brad Howe,
- 12:28and we invite you to join us Sunday through Fridays right here on the
- 12:31Metro News radio network. It's the city Nets statewide sports line. We talked
- 12:35West Virginia University, football, basketball, baseball, you name it. If
- 12:39it's got anything to do with the Golden Blue, We're on it. And
- 12:43don't forget the text line available every night. So we invite you to join
- 12:46us. The Senator Coach Hunter and me Tony Courritti. It's the city Net
- 12:50state wide sports line on Metro News. News in the Mountain State happens quick
- 12:56and for decades you have depended on Metro News for accurate news use delivered fast.
- 13:01Now here's your chance to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If
- 13:05you see news happening, become a Metro News hawk by texting News to three
- 13:09five sixty five to one. If you take a picture or video of what
- 13:13you see, submit that as well. Text the word news to three five
- 13:16sixty five one to submit your tip or story. Standard texting rates apply.
- 13:20Please don't text and drive. Metro News Talk Line with Hoppy Kerchible is brought
- 13:37to you by Encoda Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care
- 13:43about most. Visiting Coca dot com to learn more. Coming up in just
- 13:46a couple of minutes, we'll have an update on this accident that happened in
- 13:50the parking lot of Bridgeport High School. I'm sorry, not Bridgeport of Liberty
- 13:54Liberty High School this morning where an adult was struck by a vehicle and what
- 14:01is being termed as an accident, and this appears to be a very serious
- 14:05accident. One individual, an adult, the staff member the Liberty High has
- 14:09been transported to WU Hospital. We'll get a report from Mike Nolton here in
- 14:15just a couple of minutes, an update on that. Right now, let's
- 14:16go to former Charleston Mayor Danny Jones in our studios in Charleston. Good morning,
- 14:20Danny, how are you hey? What'd you make of Joe Manchin's decision?
- 14:24I wasn't surprised. I had lunch with him a couple of months ago
- 14:28and he was completely relaxed, and I just had a feeling then and he's
- 14:35thinking, he's just a feeling. He didn't say anything that would lead me
- 14:39anyway, but I just had a feeling he would be it'd be crunch time,
- 14:45you know, if he was going to do something. So I think
- 14:46he's I think he's gonna take his time, do what he wants, and
- 14:52I'd highly recommend it. He'll be in August, he'll be the youngest seventy
- 14:56seven year old man. I know, do you think that he Do you
- 15:05think that he just got done, got worn out with what politics are today?
- 15:11Or do you think it was a personal you know, at a certain
- 15:15age, even though it's a young seventy six, will be seventy seven August,
- 15:18his wife in a serious accident not long ago, wanting to spend more
- 15:20time with his family. I mean, what do you think were the factors?
- 15:24Factors having left the governor's office to go to the Senate. I think
- 15:30he felt that way the first year. I mean, he was very frustrated
- 15:33and it took some getting used to to be up there and be one of
- 15:37a hundred and be part of a party at which you don't really belong in.
- 15:43But Joe's always been like that hobby. I was in the legislature when
- 15:48he was a senator, and there was the Democrats and Republicans, and then
- 15:52Joe was off somewhere else. He was very unpredictable, and he had a
- 16:00conservative streak to him, so he could be counted on for a little mischief
- 16:07and he was the vice chairman of Finance back then. I think Arlray did
- 16:11that so he keep his eye on him. I mean, I really believe
- 16:18that. So. And when Oilray became president Senate, he kept Truman at
- 16:25majority leaders so he could keep it on him. And he had Joe where
- 16:27he keep his eye on him, and I think that's I think that was
- 16:33what he wanted to do. And he had an independence Streek as governor and
- 16:38he had an independent Streaks as Senator. And I talked to him the morning
- 16:45that President Trump got convicted or not convicted the first time. I was trying
- 16:52to talk him out of voting for it because I I don't think they had
- 16:56it. I'm not a Trump fan, but I don't think they had it
- 16:57on him. But he just wasn't He wouldn't hear of it. And that
- 17:00was at seven thirty that morning, and he just he does his own thing.
- 17:06And I kind of like it myself. There used to be a lot
- 17:08of senators like that. You know, you had Nixon had a conservative Democrat
- 17:14wing that supported him and then a liberal Republican. Now none of that is
- 17:21out up there anymore. Do you think former Charles May Danny Jones is with
- 17:23us. Do you think that the kind of person you're describing in Joe Manchin
- 17:29and the guy who always wanted to make a deal and bring everybody together around
- 17:32the table and try to find bipartisanship for the most part, I mean,
- 17:37as much as any politician can do that. Do you think that that time
- 17:41has passed in our governance? Yeah. I was reading an article in The
- 17:47New Yorker yesterday about Matt Getz, and I think we're into the era of
- 17:52Matt Getz. And there's a Republican wing up there, and a bunch of
- 17:56them voted against money for Israel and Ukraine, and that's the forgive that the
- 18:04putin wing of the party, and Joe wouldn't have anything to do with that.
- 18:08He voted for that bill. And I think that as more Senators and
- 18:14congressmen leave, they're going to be replaced with people like that, and there's
- 18:21going to be another words instead of let's put one together, let's tear one
- 18:25apart. That's what you're defined by what you're against and not what you're for.
- 18:30And I think to Danny that it's pretty obvious right now on the Republican
- 18:36side, especially with what's happened lately. But Democrats have theirs too. They
- 18:38have the squad, and it's that they're not there to get anything passed.
- 18:45They're not there to get anything done. They're not there to try to adopt
- 18:51the policy. They're there to get clicks and raise the rockets. Well,
- 18:55and you've got two Vermont senators like that, but not so much in the
- 18:59sense. But you've got these Republicans in the Senate and they're the anti Mitch
- 19:03McConnell wing of the party and led by Ted Cruz and the other senator from
- 19:10Kentucky. But they're not going to have the votes to take out McConnell or
- 19:14whoever from his leadership team will put themselves up for election beginning eleven months from
- 19:22now when the new Congress takes over. But it's going to happen sooner or
- 19:26later. I always, you know what, in my own mind, I
- 19:30point back to what happened in the Republican Party this year with them wanting to
- 19:33exclude the independence and that's so they can have a closer edge to nominate the
- 19:40craziest guy in the room. And that's in other words, to me,
- 19:45a political party has always been a loose confederation of folks that try to help
- 19:49each other getting elected, and sometimes they have differences of opinion. That's not
- 19:55the way it's coming down anymore. It's changing well, And you're talking about
- 19:59the decision by the Republican Party Executive Committee to limit the primary election voting to
- 20:07those who are registered as Republicans and not those who have no party affiliation.
- 20:11Was a big debate about that a couple of weeks ago. The initial proposal,
- 20:15which Attorney General Patrick Morrissey was very much in favor of, was for
- 20:19limiting the primary to Republicans only starting in this election. They eventually said no,
- 20:26we'll start in twenty twenty six But Danny, the argument was in doing
- 20:33that is that this is a function of the Republican Party to choose its nominees,
- 20:37and why should those who are not Republicans have a voice in choosing who
- 20:42the party's nominees are. That was the logic. Doesn't that make sense?
- 20:45Even though I left the Republican Party in twenty sixteen, I always leaned that
- 20:52way and always felt like I was still a Republican. Well not anymore,
- 20:56not after this vote and no more money. It's when you exclude people,
- 21:02they'll leave political it's hard to get elected sometimes, and these guys are not.
- 21:07I don't think they're looking to the future. Your picture should be to
- 21:12try to encompass, to try to gather, and that's not what this is.
- 21:17This is an effort exclude at exclusion. What do you think of the
- 21:22proposal that's moving to the legislature to phase out the income tax on Social Security
- 21:30benefits for middle and income West Virginians. It's already phased out for West Virginians
- 21:33who are lower in moderate income. This would phase it out over three years
- 21:38for middle and upper income folks in West Virginia. Hobby, I think it's
- 21:41great. I think all these tax cuts are great. I just hope we
- 21:45don't have to pay a price down the road. When I became a legislator
- 21:48in nineteen eighty nine, Governor Caperton called a special session before the regular session
- 21:56so he could pass four hundred million dollars worth of taxes in a weekend,
- 22:03which in fact we did. And this is the same Democrat legislature that wouldn't
- 22:07give archmore and nickel gasoline tax because the state was broke. They weren't paying
- 22:12their bills, and so we did that, and Vernon Chris was there.
- 22:18He was in the room. He's the only one left in that legislature that
- 22:22was there then, and he knows exactly what I'm talking about. And I
- 22:26just hope that we have shot forward and looked to see what the picture is
- 22:33so they never have to come back and raise taxes again like they did.
- 22:40I'm just hoping that they've got that picture. I hope that Vernon has factored
- 22:44all that into his thinking about this, being the chairman of Finance Committee.
- 22:48Yeah, Vernon Chris, a longtime Republican delegate from Wood County, chairman of
- 22:52the Finance Committee. And I think that you're right, Danny. I think
- 22:55that stayed with him because he doesn't want to go back to the bad old
- 23:00days, and that's why he was for phasing out that tax rather than doing
- 23:03all one at one time, which would be a thirty seven million dollar hit
- 23:07to the state. Danny Jones, former Charleston mayor, thank you, sir.
- 23:11Thank you good to speak with you. We'd take a break and come
- 23:12back on Metro News talk Line again. We'll get an update on this accident
- 23:17this morning that happened at Liberty High School in Harrison County. An adult struck
- 23:22by a vehicle and that adult is a staff member at Liberty High School and
- 23:30he was transported to WVU hospital. Was health was some helicopter to WVU Hospital
- 23:37in Morgantown. And will get an update on that story when we return.
- 23:41Also coming up, Deligan Mike Pushkin, a Democrat from Knall County, concerned
- 23:47about a proposed change in the Legislative Auditor, not the state auditor, the
- 23:52legislative auditor. This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West
- 23:55Virginia. It's ten thirty. Let's get a news update, checking with the
- 23:59Metro News Radio network. Final what's happening statewide this hour, all across the
- 24:03great state of West Virginia, West Virginia Metro News design Kerrie Zuda. Sec
- 24:10Members of the West Virginia Museum Association say they're keeping a close eye on what's
- 24:14called the Library Bill. The measure passed last Friday about the House of Delegates
- 24:18could result in criminal charges when it comes to materials that some consider obscene in
- 24:22libraries and museums that children see. Board member Alex Bennett says there needs to
- 24:26be an open dialogue over historic materials that may be considered obscene, so that
- 24:30can make somebody uncomfortable, and instead of having a conversation about this is why
- 24:34it's there and this is what it means, it could turn into I don't
- 24:37want to hear that. You know, I don't care about what it means.
- 24:41I'm offended that's obscene, and then not, you know, then we're
- 24:47in jail. The bill is now before the state Senate. US Senator Joe
- 24:49Manchin is shedding more light on his decision not to run for president. Mansion
- 24:53says he didn't want to be in a race where he had no chance to
- 24:56win but could have impacted the overall election negatively. I didn't want to be
- 25:00a spoiler. I'm not going to handicap it for one or the other or
- 25:03trying to get someone an advantage and would say, well, your vote took
- 25:06this away or that away. And there's no guarantee that I could get on
- 25:10fifty ballots right now, fifty state ballots, and that was the big decision
- 25:15I had to make. Mention was a guest on Monday's Metro News talk Line
- 25:18after announcing his twenty twenty four plans back on Friday, and state routen in
- 25:22Logan County has closed this morning for rock removal. Doh crews are removing overhanging
- 25:26rock from a massive rock slide that occurred on Saturday. Detours are in place.
- 25:30You're listening to Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. A West
- 25:36Virginia Scholar program changes the lives of families forever. High school juniors can now
- 25:41apply for full scholarship at West Virginia Wesleyan College, one of our state's finest
- 25:45institutions of higher learning. If your child is a high school junior, now
- 25:49is the time to go to WV metro News dot com, have them applied
- 25:53today and they could win a full scholarship to West Virginia Wesleyan that includes room
- 25:59boyd, to ish and these. To apply, simply log on to WV
- 26:03metro news dot com and click on the West Virginia scholarlink. You have until
- 26:07midnight April twenty eighth to apply. The twenty twenty four West Virginia Scholar Program
- 26:11is sponsored by Greer Industries, West Virginia Hospital Association, ZMIL Architects and Engineers,
- 26:18a West Virginia Farm Bureau, and Friends of Coal. If you're a
- 26:22high school junior, in West Virginia. Here's your chance to possibly change your
- 26:26life forever. Go to WV Metro News dot com, click on the West
- 26:30Virginia scholarlink and apply today. A WU fraternity remains under investigation for an alleged
- 26:37hazing incident. Phive Sigma Phi was suspended late last week. WVU Fraternal Values
- 26:41and Leadership Director doctor Matthew Richardson says they're taking this seriously. Any allegation we
- 26:47get of something where somebody's coming forward, whether that be a student or a
- 26:51family member, community member and saying I saw this and it was distressing.
- 26:56Those are the things that we're absolutely going to be taken action on. He
- 26:59says, there will be conspt once as if the fraternity is found responsible.
- 27:02From the Metro News anchor desk on, Kerrie Huda Suck talkline from me and
- 27:23COVID Insurance Studios, as we've been telling you a serious accident in the parking
- 27:29lot of Liberty High School in Harrison County this morning. Mike Nolton following the
- 27:33story and joining us in the newsroom. Mike, good morning. What do
- 27:34we have, Mike you there, what do we have? All right,
- 27:41don't have, Mike, but I can tell you what we do have,
- 27:44and that is, there was an accident this morning at about seven point thirty
- 27:47in the parking lot of Liberty High School in Harrison County, and adult who
- 27:52is a staff member at the school was struck by a vehicle. It appears
- 27:56to have been an accident, not intentional, and the individual was life flighted
- 28:02to WVU hospital and the individual is deceased. The individual has died. There
- 28:07is no name that has been released yet, except that there's an identification that
- 28:12the individual was a staff member at Liberty High School's a lot circulating on social
- 28:18media, but we don't have an official release from authorities. So authorities did
- 28:22stress that it was an accident, certainly a very tragic accident in the parking
- 28:29lot and Liberty High School in Harrison County this morning, a vehicle striking a
- 28:33staff member at the school, serious injury and the individual is deceased. No
- 28:40name has been released yet. Again, there's a name because it's a school,
- 28:42everybody knows everybody name circulating on social media, but authorities have not released
- 28:48that name. All right, So there's that. That story We be posted
- 28:52here momentarily at wv metronews dot com let's move on to another story from the
- 28:57West Virginia legislature. There's a proposal in this legislative session to alter how the
- 29:04Legislative auditor functions. Now that's not the state auditor, that's separate. This
- 29:11is the Legislative auditor. And this is an agency that audits primarily the executive
- 29:17branch and all agencies of government. And it's been very helpful over the years
- 29:21in turning out information, particularly financial information. It is uncovered a lot of
- 29:26waste, fraud and abuse that has occurred in state government. But legislative leaders
- 29:30are proposing to change how this operates. Now, those who support this,
- 29:34including how Speaker Roger Hanshall, say, look, this is this is really
- 29:38kind of clean up and to ensure the efficacy of its operation. But not
- 29:44everybody is seeing it that way, including can all Canadelicate Mike push Can,
- 29:47who joints us from our Charleston studios. Mike, good morning, thanks for
- 29:51joining us. What's your problem with this proposal to change up legislative aritor.
- 29:56Well, the Legislative Auditor's office has largely acted with the certain amount of independence
- 30:02in the past and what they do, it's not like you said before,
- 30:04it's separate from the West Virginia Auditor. This is a helps the assist with
- 30:11the legislative branch of government in their oversight of both the executive branch in the
- 30:18judicial branch. But with this bill, it's such a very dangerous precedent which
- 30:23removes any semblance of independence from that office and puts it completely under the purview
- 30:30of the Speaker of the House and the Senate President. Now, the Legislative
- 30:33Auditor's Office has been acting in this way for thirty years. I'm not sure
- 30:37what the problem is that we're trying to address. I'm concerned that it's not
- 30:41so much about investigations that aren't that we're not looking into, but it's about
- 30:48some of the ones that they have been looking into, And it would give
- 30:52the Senate President and the Speaker of the House the ability to curtail any investigation
- 30:56that they might not want the public to know the results of. Do you
- 31:00have then that's a fear or suspicion? Do you have any reason to believe
- 31:03that, for example, the current Speaker or the current Center President would not
- 31:08release legislative audits that have occurred because they didn't want information to get out.
- 31:14Well, I mean, there was an investigation into, well an audit of
- 31:18how much taxpayers were on the hook for this state of emergency in our prisons
- 31:23with the National Guard staffing our prisons. I know there was an investigation into
- 31:27that. I don't know the status of that investigation right now. I've heard
- 31:32that that investigation has been halted. That's concerning. I think taxpayers deserve to
- 31:37know how much this state of emergency caused by staffing issues because of the failure
- 31:41of the legislature to act and actually to make that an attractive enough job that
- 31:45we're able to attract and retain correctional officers, and then the governor calls for
- 31:51a state of emergency. We're staffing our prisons with National Guard. That's cost
- 31:55the taxpayers a lot of money. Taxpayers deserve to know how much. Also
- 32:00this past year, there because of a bill that passed back and up even
- 32:04in twenty one that that recalculated the way that the gas revenues for the counties
- 32:08was coming in. Several of our gas producing counties were about thirty million dollars
- 32:14short, more than thirty million dollars short. You know, that office was
- 32:19was that that's who uncovered that was an office under the Legislative Auditor's Office.
- 32:23So it's an investigation like that that gives me concern that maybe this is becoming
- 32:29political and the Speaker and the Senate President there's information that they don't want out
- 32:32there. You know, one of the requirements that's removed from the bill is
- 32:38the requirement that these that these investigations are made public, that they're reported on.
- 32:44That's way that's that's removed from the bill. That is that requirement in
- 32:50the House version of the bill, the version of the Speaker Hanshaw is the
- 32:53lead sponsor of it, removes the requirement for the public reporting really releasing of
- 32:59the public information. Now I believe it was restored in the Senate version.
- 33:04However, that you know the vote yesterday, this should tell you why people
- 33:08should be concerned about this. If you've been paying attention to the West Virginia
- 33:14State Senate this year, there's been very little debate on anything, and they
- 33:16have their marching orders in the Republican caucus and they come out and they don't
- 33:20debate anything and they just pass it. Well, eleven Republican senators voted against
- 33:24this bill. They spoke against it. Of course, the three Democrats voted
- 33:28against it as well. There were fourteen no votes on this bill. That's
- 33:30that's been unheard of this year in the Senate. You know, we've been
- 33:35passing most bills rubber stamping things with very little discussion. So yeah, so
- 33:40eleven Republicans has shared my concern. You know, Mike Pushing's with his Democratic
- 33:45delegates from Kanalla County on this bill. And this is kind of down in
- 33:47the weeds a little bit. It's not the sexiest thing. But I got
- 33:51to tell you, I am I am interested in this bill, and I
- 33:53know that the House Speaker and the Center President has been somewhat defensive about it,
- 33:57saying, look, we're just trying to clean this thing up and make
- 34:00it work better or whatever the reasons are. And I need to talk to
- 34:02Roger Hanstraw about that. But I have found over the years the Legislative Auditure
- 34:07under Aaron Alred, who since left the agency after like thirty years, to
- 34:10be very helpful in doing audits and releasing public information about the operation of state
- 34:16government and providing information that's been very valuable about the operation of agencies and turning
- 34:22up a lot of very relevant public information over the years Yeah, I'm not
- 34:27concerned that that's not going to be happening if this bill is to pass,
- 34:30if we're if we're removing it, removing the independence from this office and putting
- 34:35it completely under the Speaker of the House and the president of the Senate.
- 34:39I said, it's going to be more about the investigations that don't occur.
- 34:44It could very well be an office that is weaponized, either now or in
- 34:47the future. We don't know who the future Speaker of the House or a
- 34:52future Senate president could be, you know, a either party. This is
- 34:55about, you know, a power grab. It's too much power under the
- 35:00two leaders of the legislature. And if we want to make we want to
- 35:04make this nonpartisan, you will make it a political like it should be.
- 35:06They could at least add the minority leaders to the bill as well, and
- 35:08the decision making promises runs now is it is totally independent? Like did the
- 35:14state the legislative auditor aeron all read? Was he the one that just decided
- 35:17what God audited? But there was in statute, right, wasn't it a
- 35:20statute? Yeah? With the Joint Committee as well, there were more eyes
- 35:23on it, but there was at least there was enough independence where they could
- 35:28investigate what they felt needed to be investigated. But now it would be about
- 35:32the investigations that don't occur. If if the Senate President and the Speaker at
- 35:37the House want to curtail an investigation, if this law passes, they can
- 35:40do it. They can shut it down. And I have, Like I
- 35:43said, I just spoke about the investigator the audit of how much taxpayers were
- 35:47paying for the National Guard to staff the prisons. Uh, I'm really interested
- 35:52and learn about the status of that investigation. I've heard that it has been
- 35:54halted. Well, that's okay. We will watch that. These are bills
- 36:00being moving right now in West Virginia Legislature. Mike Pushkin, Democratic Delegate from
- 36:05Knell County Kanallack County. Mike, thanks, thanks for having me. Good
- 36:07to talk to you one. So I'll watch that again. I'm just starting
- 36:10to dive down into that and try to better understand the bill. I know
- 36:15that Mike and the House Speaker had a debate on public broadcasting last night.
- 36:19I watched that this morning. Try to better understand this. Meanwhile, again
- 36:22in updates, just a tragic accidents at Liberty High School in Harrison County,
- 36:30this morning was about seven thirty. School just starting and a staff member at
- 36:34the school who has not been identified publicly. Again, it's out of school.
- 36:39Everybody knows. There's a lot of social media traffic, but authorities have
- 36:43not released the name of the individual struck by a vehicle and has died as
- 36:49a result of those injuries. Authorities are saying this was an accident, a
- 36:52tragic accident. Talk line continues, will return into just a moment. Virgin
- 36:58Medical the West Virginia legist is considering a bill making it legal for people who
- 37:01are not medical doctors or trained surgeons to perform my surgery. Housepell for seven
- 37:07eighty three will permit autometrists who did not go to medical school and are not
- 37:10trained surgeons to operate with lasers on your eyes. To legislators that only medical
- 37:16doctors and trained surgeons should be performing surgery and ask them to vote no on
- 37:21Housepell for seven eight three, paid for by West Virginia Academy of i Physicians
- 37:25and Surgeons. A West Virginia scholar program changes the lives of families forever.
- 37:32High school juniors can now apply for full scholarship at West Virginia Wesleyan College one
- 37:37of our state's finest institutions of higher learning. If your child is a high
- 37:42school junior, now is the time to go to WV metronews dot com,
- 37:45have them apply today and they could win a full scholarship to West Virginia Wesleyan
- 37:51that includes room, board, tuition and fees. To apply, simply log
- 37:54on to WV metro neews dot com and click on the West Virginia Scholar link.
- 38:00You have until midnight April twenty eighth to apply. The twenty twenty four
- 38:04West Virginia Scholar Program is sponsored by Greer Industries, West Virginia Hospital Association,
- 38:09ZMILM Architects and Engineers, a West Virginia Farm Bureau, and Friends of Coal.
- 38:15If you're a high school junior in West Virginia, here's your chance to
- 38:17possibly change your life forever. Go to we metronews dot com, click on
- 38:22the West Virginia scholarlink and apply today. In os West Virginians, we are
- 38:29proud of the natural beauty of a mountain state and a ZLMILM Architects and Engineers.
- 38:34Our goal is to provide design solutions that give people the same pride in
- 38:37our built environment that commitment to quality can be seen in recreational facilities throughout the
- 38:44state, from the Charleston Coliseum and Convention Center to the Valley Park Community Center,
- 38:47the Shawnee Sport Complex, and through the recent improvements to the lodges at
- 38:52Pipestem Resort State Park. Zomilm architects and engineers. You see us in your
- 38:57community every day. You're listening to talk Line on Metro News, the voice
- 39:00of West Virginia. WV metronews dot com the only website you need to stay
- 39:08informed in the Mountain State. Get the latest news in sports, story information
- 39:14on the great outdoors, and never miss an episode of your favorite Metro News
- 39:17programs and podcast including Talkline, Hotline, sports Line, and Three Guys Before
- 39:22the Game. Make a bookmark now and visit WV metronews dot com first thing
- 39:28every morning to find out what's happening all across the state. WV metronews dot
- 39:32com. West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show
- 39:37dedicated to the more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award
- 39:43winning host Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than
- 39:46twenty five years. We used to always joke when we came up here,
- 39:50that's a smallmouth here born two pounds. It's it's rare. I mean it's
- 39:54it's more common to catch a four plus than it is one under twelve inches
- 40:00here. Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment
- 40:04of the great outdoors, it's got back up and must stay in. Around
- 40:07nine o'clock, he came cruising through kind of an open area that I could
- 40:10see on the stand as fortunate enough to bagging probably the biggest bred buck I've
- 40:15ever seen it the moon I normally West Virginia here don't get that wide.
- 40:17West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for
- 40:22your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of news
- 40:27and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News, the
- 40:30Voice of West Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation to wrap up your
- 40:36weekend. It's the City Net Sunday Night Sports Line. Hey, this is
- 40:38Travis Joes joined myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six oh six until
- 40:43eight o'clock. As we wrap up the sports weekend, we talked Mountaineers,
- 40:45High School, Mountain East Conference, and the latest in the national scene.
- 40:50The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive. You could call or text the show
- 40:53at three oh four Talk three oh four. It's a perfect weekend sports wrap
- 40:58up on your favorite metroo horor watch the show at wv Metronews dot com.
- 41:16Metronews talk Line with Hobby Kirchible is brought to you by Encoca Insurance, encircling
- 41:22you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting Covia dot com
- 41:25to learn more talk Line from the co Insurance studios. Vandalia Health has exciting
- 41:30career opportunities across all their hospitals and outpatient locations. You'll find conferdenceve benefits,
- 41:37as well as training and educational assistance programs. Learn more about Vandalia Health locations,
- 41:42services, and career opportunities at vandiliahealth dot org. One of the great
- 41:46sports stories in West Virginia has been the success of the WU rifle team nineteen
- 41:52national championships nineteen national championships. This year they're undefeated, headed for the NCAA
- 41:58Tournament again and the tournament's going to be in Morgantown, and one of the
- 42:02reasons is they've had a great coach over the years. John Hammond has I
- 42:07think he's got five. I think he has five national championships. Six,
- 42:10No, we met six national championships to his credit. He's going for his
- 42:15seventh. And he joins us on Metro News Talkland coach, good morning,
- 42:16how are you. I didn't put any pressure on you, did I no
- 42:19pressure, not at all. Not. It's all thanks for having me.
- 42:22Hey, So the tournament's coming to Morgantown. Tell us about that. That's
- 42:24going to be pretty exciting. Yeah. Absolutely. It's the second time that
- 42:30we're hosting. The last was twenty nineteen. I think the most exciting part
- 42:36is we're going to be competing in the coliseum, So just you know,
- 42:37seeing the coliseum turned into a rifle range sort of down on the court,
- 42:44a little bit different from what we're all used to seeing, and just you
- 42:49know, it's not often. Well, I think in twenty nineteen it was
- 42:52the first time that you know, a national championship would be decided, you
- 42:57know, in Morgantown, and this will be the second time. We were
- 43:00just a little bit short, came up a little bit short last time,
- 43:02but you know, hopefully, you know, we'll try and do our best
- 43:06this year. But I think just yeah, great a great sporting event to
- 43:08be able to see a national championship decide it, you know in Morgantown for
- 43:13for home Mountaineer fans, and obviously having a WVU team competing there as well.
- 43:16Does that give you coach home range advantage? No, not really,
- 43:23you know it's we we don't get to practice in there, so so really
- 43:28there's not really you know, there there's little parts. I mean, there's
- 43:31probably there's the small elements of home advantage that you know, we have the
- 43:37opportunity to sleep in our own bed, we maybe know where to go out
- 43:42and have dinners. There's a you know, we don't have to get on
- 43:44a bus or a flight or travel the day before. But besides that,
- 43:47you know, we're walking to the coliseum with no more advantage than than any
- 43:51other team. So you know, that's that, it is what it is,
- 43:55and we, you know, we'll just try and prepare the best we
- 43:59can for that. Coach John Hammond was from the w rifle team and they
- 44:02are headed to the National Championships will be which will be in Morgantown March eighth
- 44:07and ninth at the wu conlseeam. Do you also have responsibilities to to pull
- 44:13off this tournament or does the NC double a handle that you can just focus
- 44:15on your team. I think there's a little bit of both. I mean,
- 44:20it is an NC Double a championship that they come in and the NCAA
- 44:23committee kind of help, and our facility staff here do an excellent job.
- 44:29You know, our sport administrator is Zach Eker and obviously Zach overseas you know
- 44:32facilities and stuff too. But it's also you know, we're a unique sport.
- 44:37We're not used to hosting rifle matches you know, all the time,
- 44:42or it's certainly not big championships like that. So there's definitely an element that
- 44:45myself and my assistant coach, we're still I think fairly heavily involved. As
- 44:51we get closer and closer, we want to be able to focus on our
- 44:53team, but you know, we've been involved with you know a lot of
- 44:58the committee meetings and being part of hosting it and stuff too, So it'll
- 45:01be finding the right balance. Our staff, I think are doing a great
- 45:05job and it's probably just a little bit of element of us, you know,
- 45:08like you know, wanting to be in control, and you know,
- 45:10I want it to be the best championship it can be, so you know,
- 45:14I'll have to make sure that I kind of release things to Zach and
- 45:17trust that it'll be an amazing championship and so that, you know, the
- 45:21week leading up we are able to focus on our team. But so far
- 45:23we've had quite a bit of involvement and so it's just a bit of a
- 45:25balancing act there. Coach, you've established or continued a great tradition at WVU
- 45:34nineteen national championships. I believe you have six to your credit, but and
- 45:37I hate to say it this way, you haven't won in a couple of
- 45:39years. And your quote in a storial metrin you said, over the last
- 45:45several years, we simply haven't been the best team. So again, no
- 45:49pressure, but is this a better team? Is this a national championship caliber
- 45:52team in your opinion? I mean, we definitely have a great opportunity,
- 45:57for sure, probably a better opportun unity than we've had the past couple of
- 46:00years. But it's it's a it's a tough sport, you know. Our
- 46:05season you know, it comes down to one weekend and it's a very mental
- 46:08spot. It's very mentally challenging, and it'll be very much how we kind
- 46:15of handle just the conditions of being at home and possibly some more expectations and
- 46:19probably shooting in front of a bigger crowd than any of them have competed in
- 46:23front of before. So but yeah, I'm definitely pleased that we're we're in
- 46:29a much better position. I think we've we've probably been, you know,
- 46:32the best team throughout this season, and we just have to stay focused and
- 46:37hopefully have two more really good performances and see where it ends up. Here's
- 46:39an idiot question, but that's my specialty. You say there will be a
- 46:44crowd there, I mean people can come out obviously March eight to ninth for
- 46:45the Championships. Do people cheer, Can people get involved? Can they get
- 46:50a let's go mountain ears going? Does that just throw throw off the shooters?
- 46:53It's hard. I mean, we're we're preparing for it. There was
- 46:57definitely more noise I remember from the Championships and twenty nineteen, there was definitely
- 47:00more kind of noise than we're used to it at rifle competitions. Typically there's
- 47:07more noise in the in the individual finals. So the format both days,
- 47:10there'll be two relays, you know, half the team competing on the first
- 47:14relay, then the second half, and then at the end of the day,
- 47:15the top eight competitors from the forty eight competitors there will shoot the individual
- 47:21final. There's typically a lot more cheering and shouting and encouragement in the individual
- 47:25finals, just a kind of different atmosphere. But I think during our match
- 47:30as well, like we're we're kind of preparing that they'll be you know,
- 47:34cheering, and they'll be you know, rounds of applause sporadically for good scores
- 47:38and things like that, and so you know, we're not going to say,
- 47:42you know, we're going to prepare that hopefully it's not off putting,
- 47:45and our team members are prepared for any distractions. And ultimately that's you know,
- 47:49that's how you have to be. You don't know what's going to happen.
- 47:52There could be total silence, or there could be you know, crazy
- 47:54noise, or we just don't know. So but yeah, I mean,
- 47:59there's certainly no rule to what the you know, what the crowds can do.
- 48:01They'll there'll be music playing, so you know, you kind of like
- 48:05drowned out, you know, conversation. It's not a sort of you know,
- 48:07golf golf tournament, golf shot where there's silence expected and stuff like that.
- 48:13WV Rifle coach John Hammon, they've had a great season and they're headed
- 48:16into the nc DOUAA Championships that will be at the WU Colsey in March eight
- 48:21and nine, So folks welcome to attend that and certainly encourage you to in
- 48:24that. Coach, congratulations on a great season. We will watch with interest
- 48:29and enthusiasm as you enter the NC doublea's good luck to you. It's good
- 48:31to talk to you again. Thank you all right, Thank you very much,
- 48:34appreciate it as always, all right, talk soon. Need help with
- 48:37your prescriptions? Tired of long wait times? Did your current pharmacy close or
- 48:40is moving? Give Fruth Pharmacy a try. We make it easy to transfer
- 48:45your prescriptions and we always welcome new patients. Fruth makes it easy to transfer.
- 48:51Call a local Fruth Pharmacy and they will handle the transferring process for you.
- 48:54We offer prescription rewards too. Give Fruth Pharmacy a call today from details.
- 49:00Fruit makes it easy fruth your hometown family pharmacy. The Wound Institute the
- 49:07only wound center in the area with providers who are Board certified in wound and
- 49:12ostomycare. Doctor carry framan her dedicated team of skilled professionals are ready to provide
- 49:16you with the latest treatments and personalized care. Visit their new office location on
- 49:22Kenton Drive in Charleston for cutting edge woundcare. Find more information and start your
- 49:27recovery today at the Wound Institute dot org. The Wound Institute healing complex wounds
- 49:32using advanced treatments. At the WVU Hard and Vascular Institute, our board certified
- 49:37and Fellowship trained thoracic surgeons use the most advanced equipment and latest surgical techniques to
- 49:44achieve the best possible outcomes. With minimally invasive robotic surgery and video assisted surgery
- 49:50options, you can rest assured you'll receive the most comprehensive, innovative and supportive
- 49:55care in the region. Visit WVU Medicine dot org Thoracic or call eight five
- 50:01to five WVU Care. It's good to have options when choosing health coverage for
- 50:07your family, your employees, and your company you want to plan with.
- 50:14People you know like the Health Plan, known for exceptional local customer service and
- 50:22are headquartered right here in West Virginia. We are families, we are businesses,
- 50:30and we are all moving forward together. We are here for you.
- 50:34The Health Plan West Virginia is home. It's where we work, live and
- 50:39raise our families. At the heart of our communities are West Virginia Hospitals and
- 50:45they're compassionate caregivers, from life saving treatments and emergency care to wellness support and
- 50:51screening services. We are improving your quality of life through extraordinary achievements and amazing
- 50:57results. West Virginia Hospitals, Your health is the heartbeat of our communities.
- 51:02This is talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. Metro
- 51:08News this morning the biggest stories from around the state of West Virginia when you
- 51:13want them, brought to you by Burdett Camping Center, home of the RV
- 51:16warranty Forever Chris Lawrence at the anchor desk. We are ready to get to
- 51:20day who started in West Virginia With all of the information you nage. Harry
- 51:22Houda Sect brings you the day's headlines. Charleston attorney Jesse Forbes says he's representing
- 51:28two West Virginians who are filing a lawsuit against the Dunbar Police Department after public
- 51:31records relating to misdemeanor arrest were denied. The city says those cases are not
- 51:37part of any ongoing investigations. Forbes says they're hoping to schedule a court hearing
- 51:40soon. Kyle Wiggs at the sports Desk, we had a rare walk off
- 51:45win with Kansas City and San Francisco. The forty nine ers in overtime get
- 51:50the field goal, but Patrick Mahomes had the ball last. Kansas City wins
- 51:53Super Bowl fifty eight over San Francisco twenty five to twenty two. And Hoppy
- 51:58Kerchible's daily Come Montari. Metro News This morning brought to you by Burdett Camping
- 52:02Center. Listen where you get your favorite podcasts and online at wv Metronews dot
- 52:07com. Metro News is your source for high school sports coverage and the exclusive
- 52:13home of the high school Sports Line. Presented by Parmah, Kyle Wiggs and
- 52:17Joe Burcado bring you the latest scores and news, along with player and coach
- 52:22interviews and in depth stories. Get your high school sports fixed all winter long.
- 52:27The High School Sports Line, presented by Parmah Wednesday nights at seven oh
- 52:30six here on the Metro News Radio Network and online at wv metronews dot com.
- 52:37Hey there, Dave. Weekly here at your host from Metro News Hotline.
- 52:40Get ready for an epic journey. Every weekday from three to six pm,
- 52:44We've got all the excitement you need from sports to tech, music,
- 52:47pop culture, and everything in between. Join Coop and I as we bring
- 52:51you engaging discussions, captivating interviews, fun games, and the latest sports and
- 52:54entertainment headlines that will keep you a book. Petronews Hotline is your go to
- 52:58source for sports, news, entertainment, and most importantly fun. Tune in
- 53:02weekdays from three to six on Metro News and wb metronews dot com. Jackpots
- 53:19are in the millions here in West Virginia. Who doesn't want to be a
- 53:21millionaire? Get in the Powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays and the Mega
- 53:24Millions drawings on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next big Winter play
- 53:29Today? The Powerball jackpot is three hundred and forty eight million dollars the Mega
- 53:32miguse jackpot four hundred and ninety three million dollars. All Right, we're going
- 53:37to take a break and come back. When we come back, we'll hear
- 53:39a different perspective on this bill that would criminalize museum curators and librarians if they
- 53:45have material deemed to be obscene available to minors. That's in six minutes.
- 53:52This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. Alrighty,
- 54:28I back our number two talk line on the Metro News radio network once
- 54:31again. As you probably heard in the news at the top of the hour
- 54:35on many of these stations, a tragic accident at Liberty High School in Harrison
- 54:39County this morning at about seven thirty. School just starting a vehicle pedestrian accident.
- 54:45A vehicle struck a staff member, an adult, and that staff member
- 54:50struck and killed. They were life flighted to WU hospital, but they were
- 54:53pronounced dead. The name has not been released, however, again it's at
- 54:59the school. Word travels fast. We haven't released the name because authorities haven't
- 55:04released the name, but a lot of traffic on social media identifying the individual,
- 55:08but authorities just saying it's just a tragic accident and not intentional and really
- 55:15awful story story posted at wv metronews dot com. The West Virginia Association of
- 55:22Museums is among groups urging lawmakers to oppose a bill that would criminalize public libraries,
- 55:31school libraries, and museums for displaying material deemed as obscene to miners.
- 55:38This is the bill that came up early in the session. Then it was
- 55:42sideline, but it's back up again, and it started in the House and
- 55:46again. This is a legislation that says if that a librarian or a museum
- 55:52curator could be held criminally liable, criminally responsible if there is a material deemed
- 55:58obscene that is accessed by minors. Joining us from the West Virginia Association of
- 56:05Museums is Vice president Katie Thompson. Katie, thank you for joining us.
- 56:08Good morning, How are you hy? Good morning? Thank you? Do
- 56:12me a favorite, speak up a little bit if you can. Sounds like
- 56:14there we go, and what is your organization's objection to this bill? So
- 56:20our concern is that the language of the bill as it is currently written is
- 56:25very vague in terms of what is considered obscene matter, as well as who
- 56:30would be responsible for that, and that really opens the door for museums of
- 56:37all sizes to potentially face attacks or litigation for any exhibit or program that someone
- 56:45might deem offensive to their point of view or their opinions. Katie Thompson's with
- 56:51his vice president of the West Virginia Association of Museums, the do you have
- 56:55a procedure in place now as an association to deal with material that individuals who
- 57:01come to the museum might see as controversial or obscene or quote unquote dirty,
- 57:06anything like that. How do you handle things like that now? Because I
- 57:07guess you may get those complaints now. Fair yes, So one thing to
- 57:13be clear is that the Association Museums itself is a nonprofit, volunteer run organization,
- 57:20so we don't have a policy in place for the entire state. What
- 57:24we do follow best practices that are used in the museum field nationally, and
- 57:30that is what we kind of educate and recommend to the museums in West Virginia
- 57:36in terms of museums that you know, muse and professionals have been trained in
- 57:40both professional historical research methods as well as interpreting that history to a wide diverse
- 57:49audience. Exhibits are always a collaborative process, so text, images, anything
- 57:55that goes into an exhibit is often reviewed several several times, and you know,
- 58:01it depends on what you consider obscene, especially with the language under the
- 58:05bill. But oftentimes museums if there is something that is maybe more sexually graphic,
- 58:10or for example, I've seen this with you know, pictures or images
- 58:15of skeletons or dead bodies, oftentimes there might be a disclaimer or those images
- 58:21might be set aside in a separate area where you can choose to go in
- 58:23and view those, or you can choose to not view those. But for
- 58:28the most part, exhibits are made for anyone who walks in the door,
- 58:31so it has to be appropriate for any age a visitor that walks in the
- 58:37door, and so a lot of these are vetted by a collaborative process that
- 58:42will ensure that those are good. Katie Thompson's with his vice president of the
- 58:46West Virginia Association Museums on the bill that would open museum curators and librarians to
- 58:51criminal charges if they allow miners to access obscene material. Is this do you
- 58:57think this is a solution looking for a problem? Is this a problem now,
- 59:01not that I have seen. In practice. Most museums and librarians are
- 59:09not going to be just peddling, you know, pornographic materials to their audiences,
- 59:15and so I have not seen many complaints in my time in the field
- 59:22of anything that would be seemed offensive. What we do see often, though,
- 59:25is that history or content in museums might challenge somebody's point of view.
- 59:31You know, if someone holds a strong opinion about something and they don't agree
- 59:37with the interpretation in the museum. That's where we kind of are concerned about
- 59:42the very opay, you know, the vague language and the bill, because
- 59:45it opens the door for that kind of controversy if someone doesn't agree with the
- 59:51interpretation, that they might then try to, you know, legally challenge that.
- 59:55Yeah, and I'm thinking of I'm just thinking out loud here, but
- 1:00:00I'm thinking of an artist interpretation that might have historic significance, of a depiction
- 1:00:07of the Native American or Black West Virginians or something like that. Maybe is
- 1:00:13that kind of what we're talking about. Sure, there's many many topics in
- 1:00:17our history that can be considered difficult knowledge that people might have very strong feelings
- 1:00:23about one way or another. You know, if you think about our modern
- 1:00:30society how diverse it is, you're going to have a lot of diverse stories
- 1:00:34to tell. But you're also going to have a lot of diverse visitors coming
- 1:00:37in, and they're going to come in with their own background, knowledge,
- 1:00:42their own opinions, their own values, and so, you know, museums
- 1:00:45are places of learning, and learning is sometimes uncomfortable. That learning sometimes challenges
- 1:00:51or a viewpoint of the world, and that's a really important thing to happen
- 1:00:54in libraries and museums, and so we're really just concerned about some one coming
- 1:01:00in and having their viewpoint challenge and then using the language of this bill to
- 1:01:04then attack the museum or attack the staff of that museum. Katie Thompson's with
- 1:01:08his vice president of the West Virginia Association of Museums on the bill that would
- 1:01:13open museum curators and librarians to criminal charges if they allow miners to access obscene
- 1:01:19material on the I think, though I don't have the bill in front of
- 1:01:23me, but I think there's a reference to what is in code in West
- 1:01:27Virginia on the definition of obscene, So I think there is a specific definition
- 1:01:30beyond Potter Stewart, this Prime Court justice who said, I note when I
- 1:01:34see it, I think that there are definitions are it could be used.
- 1:01:38The first two definitions of obscene matter do relate specifically to maybe sexually graphic materials.
- 1:01:46It's the third definition that is on the code for obscene matter that we
- 1:01:51are the most concerned about. And I have that in front of them.
- 1:01:52Okay, good, what is it? That definition is quote A reasonable person
- 1:01:57would find taken as a whole lack thereous literary, artistic, political, or
- 1:02:01scientific value. That is very open ended, and with the very very diverse
- 1:02:07viewpoints and opinions that we have as society, even just on social media or
- 1:02:15in literature, there's constant debates about what is scientifically valuable or what is historically
- 1:02:22valuable. And so that very vague definition of what obscene matter is that's where
- 1:02:29we're concerned. It could then become a problem for our museum. That's it.
- 1:02:31I mean, you could have a book on well, not I'm thinking
- 1:02:37of Live right now, but you could have a display on evolution, or
- 1:02:39you could have a display depicting the great textbook controversy in Kanala County, right,
- 1:02:45you know, things like that look, I have trouble. I have
- 1:02:47trouble asking you tough questions because I think this is a terrible bill. I
- 1:02:52really do, because I think about museum curators and I think about librarians who
- 1:02:59are I'm going to give them the give you all the benefit of the doubt.
- 1:03:01You're trying to do your job to fulfill your mission, and you're thinking
- 1:03:07of a display that you think has value, and you're thinking, you know,
- 1:03:10but it's also edgy, and I could be I could be arrested,
- 1:03:16I could be subject to criminal penalty for putting this out there. I think
- 1:03:22that would have a chilling effect. I think that has a chilling effect.
- 1:03:23DoD really don't like that it does. And another thing to point out is
- 1:03:28that, you know, curators is one position in the museum world, but
- 1:03:31especially in West Virginia where you have a lot of small museums. These are
- 1:03:36volunteers, These are docent these are interns, AmeriCorps members. The bill labels
- 1:03:43any adult right. So if you're going to see a loss of volunteer staff,
- 1:03:46people are not going to want to engage in their museums and libraries because
- 1:03:51they might be afraid of this penalty. It is certainly going to discourage museums
- 1:03:57from doing good history and following best practice. This is, you know,
- 1:04:01engaging with those diverse and sometimes controversial stories that are in our human history.
- 1:04:08It's going to it's going to really like reduce the ability of museums to do
- 1:04:15their job. Katie Thompson, vice president of the West Virginia Association Museums,
- 1:04:18on the bill that would open museum curators, volunteers, others librarians to criminal
- 1:04:24charges that they allow minors to access material deemed obscene. Katie, thank you
- 1:04:29for watching this bill closely. I appreciate you coming on today. Thank you
- 1:04:31so much for having me all right, when we come back to here at
- 1:04:33halprin Fox News Radio, when talk line continues on Metro News, want to
- 1:04:39remind you that jackpot's in the millions here in West Virginia. Who doesn't want
- 1:04:43to be a millionaire? Getting the Powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays and
- 1:04:46the Megamigaan drawings on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next big winner?
- 1:04:49Play today? The Powerball jackpot is three hundred and forty eight million dollars.
- 1:04:54The Megami is jackpot four hundred ninety three million dollars. Feeling the crunch
- 1:04:57of high electricity bills, Urge your legislators to support community solar and net metering.
- 1:05:02Community solar, currently available in twenty two other states, gives access to
- 1:05:06solar energy without rooftop panels. Net metering is already lowering West Virginia energy bills,
- 1:05:12but its benefits could be stripped away. Join the seventy percent of West
- 1:05:15Virginians who support affordable electricity. Learn more at wvsun dot org. That's wvsun
- 1:05:23dot org, paid for by Solar United Neighbors Action. It's good to have
- 1:05:29options when choosing health coverage for your family, your employees, and your company.
- 1:05:35You want to plan with people you know, like the health Plan,
- 1:05:41known for exceptional local customer service and are headquartered right here in West Virginia.
- 1:05:47We are families, we are businesses, and we are all moving forward together.
- 1:05:55We are here for you. The health Plan. Mon Health Medical sen
- 1:06:00is accredited as a Center of Excellence for minimally invasive Gynecology by the Surgical Review
- 1:06:04Corporation, setting the gold standard for women's care. Through open communication and unwavering
- 1:06:09support, our goal is for patients to feel heard and empowered throughout their healing
- 1:06:13journey. With renowned gynecologic oncologist doctor William McBee and his expert team, you
- 1:06:17can experience personalized women's cancer care where compassion meets excellence. Learn more at modhealth
- 1:06:24dot com, slash cancer, Choose mod Health, feel the difference. As
- 1:06:28West Virginians, we are proud of the natural beauty of the mountain state,
- 1:06:31and at ZMM Architects and Engineers, our goal is to provide design solutions that
- 1:06:36give people the same pride in our built environments. That commitment to quality can
- 1:06:41be seen in recreational facilities throughout the state, from the Charleston Coliseum and Convention
- 1:06:45Center to the Valley Park Community Center, the Shawnee Sport Complex, and through
- 1:06:50the recent improvements to the lodges at Pipe Stem Resort State Park. ZMM Architects
- 1:06:56and Engineers, you see us in your community every day if you played the
- 1:07:00West Virginia Lottery. Because you play, I have a place to exercise after
- 1:07:04my knee replacement. Because you play, I can enjoy nature's views at the
- 1:07:09state Park with my grandchildren. Because you play, new schools continue to be
- 1:07:13built across the state each time you play the West Virginia Lottery. A portion
- 1:07:17from every purchase goes back to seniors, tourism, and education, more than
- 1:07:21twelve point four billion dollars since nineteen eighty six West Virginia Lottery. What if
- 1:07:27you played? You're listening to talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of
- 1:07:31West Virginia. This Saturday and every Saturday throughout the high school basketball season.
- 1:07:40Don't miss the High School Basketball Round Up, a weekly update of high school
- 1:07:44teams across the Mountain State, featuring scores, rankings, and in depth features.
- 1:07:48Join Kyle Wiggs, Joe Riccado, and your host Fred Persinger for the
- 1:07:54latest high school basketball news on the high School Basketball Round Up from the Voice
- 1:07:59of high school sports in West Virginia, the Metro News Radio Network. Hi,
- 1:08:04this is Hopy Kurchible inviting you to join me weekdays from ten o six
- 1:08:08till noon for Metro News talk Line. Each day, I trying to provide
- 1:08:11the very latest news and information about our state and our nation. I interview
- 1:08:15newsmakers and thought leaders who help us better understand these stories. Yes, I'm
- 1:08:18mixing my observations, but mostly I just want us to be better informed.
- 1:08:23So I'm inviting you to be my radio and streaming companion as we sort out
- 1:08:27and work through the news and information of each day. That's a talk line
- 1:08:30weekdays ten o six till noon on this Metro News radio station. Hey everybody,
- 1:08:34it's Tony Curridi and I'm Brad Howe. And that makes two of the
- 1:08:39three guys that bring you the podcast entitled creatively Enough, Three Guys Before the
- 1:08:43Game. It's our opportunity to really drill down on WVU football and basketball.
- 1:08:47We break down the opponent and then review every single game. We'll give you
- 1:08:51some numbers, we'll bicker back and forth, we'll take your calls, your
- 1:08:56text your tweets, and get into some of your questions. And we invite
- 1:08:59you to join us every episode at three Guys Before the Game from Metro News,
- 1:09:04the Metro News Capital Report bringing you the latest news from the West Virginia
- 1:09:09State Capitol Complex and the twenty twenty four legislative session. Hoppy Kerchival, Jeff
- 1:09:15Jenkins, Brad McElhinney and the rest of the Metro News staff bring you daily
- 1:09:18updates on what's happening inside the House of Delegates and State Senate, including committee
- 1:09:24meetings and introduction of bills. Each weekday morning and afternoon, get the Capitol
- 1:09:28Report on your favorite Metro news radio station. Metro News Talk Line with Hoppy
- 1:09:47kerchival is brought to you by Encoca Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect
- 1:09:53what you care about most. Visiting Coca dot com to learn more. Talk
- 1:09:57on from the Encod Insurance studios in the Miller Building. Please welcome Jared halprin
- 1:10:00Fox News Radio in Washington. As we used to say growing up in Eastern
- 1:10:03Penhandle, good morning, sir, Good morning to you. You headed to
- 1:10:06Columbia, South Carolina soon. I'm not I will not be in South Carolina.
- 1:10:13Too bad. I would have tried to set up shop in Myrtle Beach.
- 1:10:15Yeah really, if I can get in a couple of rounds of golf,
- 1:10:19I will be watching Nikki Haley speech to after your Yeah, what's that
- 1:10:23all about? Because that's been plugged. That's being plugged as something something right.
- 1:10:28Yeah, and it's not going to be her dropping out of the race.
- 1:10:30I think that's pretty clear. She has made clear that her path is
- 1:10:36extends beyond South Carolina, and from a money fund raking standpoint, that's absolutely
- 1:10:41the case. Now she is going to face. I think after Saturday an
- 1:10:44awful lot of pressure, more pressure than she's already facing, to end her
- 1:10:48her candidacy. But listen, I'm not sure what her motivation would be to
- 1:10:53do that. She's got the financial resources to at least hang in there through
- 1:10:56Super Tuesday. That needs to be her plan. Her campaign has already set
- 1:11:00up events in some of those super Tweesay states, Michigan and others. There
- 1:11:04are big delegate counts in California and Texas, So I think that's her plan,
- 1:11:11is to just kind of see if she can keep kind of plugging away,
- 1:11:15continue to maybe chip in a little bit of that lead that Trump has.
- 1:11:19But if it's a blowout on Saturday in South Carolina, in her home
- 1:11:24state, those calls for her to step aside, I can grow louder and
- 1:11:28louder. Is it going to be a blow out? Polling right now has
- 1:11:31Trump? I've seen some between sort of twenty and thirty points ahead right now.
- 1:11:39I guess a blowout in the eye of a holder. But that's well,
- 1:11:42it's her home state. Though it looks bad, that's a big yeah,
- 1:11:44it's home state that it's a state that Trump still remains really popular.
- 1:11:48In and that's going to bear out. But yeah, I think that twenty
- 1:11:54or thirty points if it is that now, maybe maybe she cuts the deficit
- 1:11:59a little bit, but thirty points is a lot. And again, I
- 1:12:02think it kind of speaks to people that are going to start asking what's the
- 1:12:06path here to get the nomination? I think said she is the only other
- 1:12:12candidate, sort of major candidate in this race that's providing any sort of alternative
- 1:12:15voice right to the former president in her concerns with him go beyond kind of
- 1:12:21the courtroom drama and the chaos that she says he brings. She is starting
- 1:12:27to really hammer him on some of these foreign policy remarks as well. Do
- 1:12:31not know if that's going to have a big impact in a state like South
- 1:12:34Carolina in a Republican primary, But again, I think it also speaks to
- 1:12:38what her motivation is, right that that she is kind of the last defender
- 1:12:43of that wing of the Republican Party that she has belonged to for an awfully
- 1:12:46long time. Yeah, and you could also just say in for a penny,
- 1:12:51in for a pound. I mean, if she's got the money,
- 1:12:55you could see an argument for maybe not a pathway forward to win, but
- 1:13:00to stay in through Super Tuesday because there's so much at stake, fifteen or
- 1:13:02sixteen stags and just see, I guess, yeah, I guess she's got
- 1:13:08the money to stay in. Like I said, I think that's probably gonna
- 1:13:11start a dry up if she doesn't start making some progress here sooner rather than
- 1:13:14later. But you know, I think a lot about like, what's the
- 1:13:17motivation for her to drop out? I don't think she is on the short
- 1:13:21list to be the vice president. I do not know if she would serve
- 1:13:27in another administration Trump administration if there were one, and even this idea of
- 1:13:34like, well, eventually she'd have to endorse them, right, People remember
- 1:13:38the twenty sixteen campaign, right, Ted Cruz spoke at the convention where they
- 1:13:44nominated Trump and he told people to vote their conscience. Ah, I forgot
- 1:13:47about that. Yeah, So so you don't even really have to like endorse,
- 1:13:54I guess if you don't want to. Now obviously that is the relationship
- 1:13:59between Ted Cruz and Donald Trump has improved quite a bit now. But but
- 1:14:04you know, but a little bit. At the same time, Jared,
- 1:14:05you've been around her, you know politics, I mean, on what one
- 1:14:09day you can say vote your conscience the next day. You can you can
- 1:14:11say I love Donald Trump. I mean, Tim Scott, I mean you
- 1:14:15can do that. Well, I mean I think you say yeah. I
- 1:14:16mean I look, and I think she probably if she drops out, and
- 1:14:19if he is the nominated, she probably makes the case support the nominator than
- 1:14:23Joe Biden, right right, But again, I just don't know in her
- 1:14:30as you kind of look at where things are right now, why she would
- 1:14:34necessarily be in a hurry to drop out. Well, you know what we're
- 1:14:38talking about her, and she's in the news cycle all the time. There
- 1:14:41you go, right, I mean you just said, you just said,
- 1:14:44hey, I got to see what major address. Yeah, it's going to
- 1:14:45get a lot of attention, and you know that's sometimes what you need in
- 1:14:50the home threats here if she tries to make this case and look if she
- 1:14:56and and she has ratcheted up her direct attacks and criticism of Donald Trump and
- 1:15:03everybody up to when there was a five or six people in and people kind
- 1:15:06of playing Patsy with that except for Chris Christie. So you know, maybe
- 1:15:11go all in and then see what happens. I mean I don't probably often
- 1:15:14not on the shortlist. Well, no, I think Tim Scott. I
- 1:15:18think Tim Scott has has has has hugged. It's like the hug campaign,
- 1:15:26you know, he just just not the first. Yeah, listen. I
- 1:15:28think Tim Scott is somebody that a lot of people close to Trump probably are
- 1:15:31looking at. He probably serves the role kind of like what Mike Pens did
- 1:15:38in twenty sixteen, right, some of the kind of you know, maybe
- 1:15:42softened a little bit, somebody who's got a lot of buy in with kind
- 1:15:47of traditional cultural conservatives. I also think that there has been a lot of
- 1:15:57speculation that Trump is looking it putting a woman on the ticket. He is
- 1:16:02vulnerable with women. If you look at the polling and how Republicans writ large,
- 1:16:06it's kind of performed over the last several years. There has been a
- 1:16:10big gender gap that had not existed, at least a wire gender gap that
- 1:16:15had existed. So maybe he's looking to maybe, you know, do that.
- 1:16:20I don't know. It certainly seems like there's a lot of people auditioning
- 1:16:23for the job right now. Indeed, inde Jared Holpin Fox, He's radio
- 1:16:27in Washington and be covering a Sucklina primary. Thank you, Jared, good
- 1:16:30to talk to you, buddy. Sure thing, thanks man, Tech topy
- 1:16:33museums. So is Michaelangelo's sculpture of David considered obscene to minors? See?
- 1:16:40That's what I think it. It opens the door to those kinds of questions.
- 1:16:48And again, I think the biggest thing is one is I I shouldn't
- 1:16:54say this because I don't know for certain, So that's when you get into
- 1:16:57trouble. But I just you know, we cover the news, and you
- 1:17:00don't hear much about obscene material that is legitimately obscene, that is accessed by
- 1:17:09miners and from libraries and museums. You just don't don't hear much about that.
- 1:17:15I would imagine there are instances and controversy, there are controversial books.
- 1:17:20I understand that, but this to me feels like feels like a sledgehammer hitting
- 1:17:28a gnat. And to put library volunteers and librarians and museum curators and volunteers
- 1:17:40under the threat of criminal penalty seems overly severe to me. This is talk
- 1:17:47Line on Metro News. Metro News is the voice of West Virginia. It's
- 1:17:51eleven thirty. Let's get a news update. Check in with the Metro News
- 1:17:54Radio Network Final What's happening statewide this hour, all across the Great State of
- 1:17:59West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News. I'm Chris Laurence. An accident this
- 1:18:05morning has claimed a life in the parking lot of a Harrison County High school.
- 1:18:09Sheriff Robert Matheny says the victim, a member of the school's staff,
- 1:18:13was hit by a car about seven point thirty this morning, a students and
- 1:18:15staff were arriving for the day at Liberty High School. Witnesses indicate the driver
- 1:18:20was a student and may have been blinded but the sun. The victim was
- 1:18:24flown to Morgantown's Ruby Memorial Hospital, where they were pronounced dead at their injuries.
- 1:18:27The sheriff said indications are at this point it was nothing more than a
- 1:18:30tragic accident. A special ed teacher in Canawa County says she's behind a bill
- 1:18:34that would increase the pay for more teachers and aides who are in self contained
- 1:18:39special ed classrooms. Rachel Brown is a special ed curriculum specialist in Canawac County
- 1:18:44and says keeping people employed in those difficult jobs is not easy, and improving
- 1:18:48the pay might help. It's hard when you're experiencing these extreme behaviors and the
- 1:18:55stress of not having enough staff in your classroom to really have an wall.
- 1:19:00She's backing of Senate Bill six' eighty what, which would increase pay by
- 1:19:03ten percent for aids and special ed teachers. Site prep continuing at the Tech
- 1:19:09Park in South Charleston for a new facility to house nearly all of the state's
- 1:19:12laboratory services. State Administration Secretary Mark Scott. We've got seven agencies plus West
- 1:19:18Virginia and Marshalls that are going to be a part of that, so we
- 1:19:21get nine total agencies. Design work for that new facility is underway. You're
- 1:19:26listening to Metronews the Voice of West Virginia. Hi, I'm Chris Lawrence,
- 1:19:30and the Great Outdoors is coming inside. Join me at the twenty second annual
- 1:19:34West Virginia Fishing Hunting an Outdoor Sports Show March second and third at Miland Park
- 1:19:39in Morgantown. More than one hundred thousand square feet of fishing gear and hunting
- 1:19:43supplies, outfitters and charter boats, ATVs, campers, tractors, guns,
- 1:19:46knives, and much more, all of it under one roof and Outdoorsman's Paradise.
- 1:19:50Don't miss the West Virginia Fishing Hunting an outdoor sports show March second and
- 1:19:55third in Morgantown, AU. WVRC Media Events. Episode of Live Healthy West
- 1:20:00Virginia is now posted on the podcast center of metronews dot com. We're talking
- 1:20:04about injectable weight loss drugs like wig V and zep bound. Are they good
- 1:20:09for your heart? The biggest thing that we know is weight loss, decreased
- 1:20:15heart attacks, and admissions to the hospital. I think those are the biggest
- 1:20:17things that we can feel good about. Listen to Live Healthy West Virginia for
- 1:20:20candid conversations with insights about improving your health and well being. Live Healthy West
- 1:20:26Virginia is presented by WVU Medicine DOU. WVU is issued a notice of investigation
- 1:20:30involving an alleged hazing incident at the Phive Sigma five fraternity. They are now
- 1:20:35suspended from all activities pending the outcome of that probe. Campus officials said the
- 1:20:39fraternity members are accused of violating in two sections of the WVU campus student Code
- 1:20:45of Conduct in the incident that occurred in recent days, and it made Arnoby
- 1:20:47and Logan County Route ten is closed temporarily to clear up overhanging rocks left from
- 1:20:54a weekend mudslide. From the Metro News anchored ESK. I'm Chris Lawrence,
- 1:21:25talk client on Metro News. I'm being COVID Insurance Studios. Michael Tamaski.
- 1:21:28He's a Morgantown, West Virginia native, a progressive commentator, columnist, and
- 1:21:32author editor of the New Republic. His most recent book is The Middle Out,
- 1:21:38The Rise of Progressive Economics and a Return to Shared Prosperity and other socialist
- 1:21:45ideas. I just threw that way. Yeah, that's not on the cover.
- 1:21:49It's nice to hear that song, though, you know, I still
- 1:21:51think of that as later Stones. It's forty five years old. That song
- 1:21:56that yeah, Waiting on a Friend by the Rolling Stones. I know that
- 1:21:59goes. I'm like that too. I hear a song go oh man,
- 1:22:00I like that. That's more recent stones now. It was forty years ago.
- 1:22:04And in fairness, I did throw in that last part. It's that's
- 1:22:09not actually the title. Tit title. So what did you make of the
- 1:22:14mansion stuff? I was, well as somebody who you know, wants to
- 1:22:18see Joe Biden. When this election, I was relieved because Mansion would steal
- 1:22:23more votes from Biden than from Trump. I believe would have stolen. As
- 1:22:28a as an observer of politics, just as neutral as I can be,
- 1:22:32I think it was the rational thing for Joe to do, because, as
- 1:22:36you and I have discussed before, just it's just not in the cards the
- 1:22:41way our party system is structured, the way our electoral college is structured for
- 1:22:45a third party Canada to win even a state. So you know, he'd
- 1:22:49walk away his ninety nine point five percent likely with zero electoral college votes and
- 1:22:56having really accomplished very little of what he wants to accomplish. Of his goal
- 1:23:01is to change the direction of the Democratic Party or to change the direction of
- 1:23:06American politics, that's just not very effectively done by running a quixotic presidential campaign.
- 1:23:16Could this year have been and we still have other people in your RFK
- 1:23:20and others RFK Junior. Could this year have been different though, because of
- 1:23:25the unpopularity of the two likely nominees that you could go to. When states
- 1:23:30say, look, you just need maybe thirty five forty percent and you could
- 1:23:32get electoral votes, I don't think so. I just I think, you
- 1:23:39know, well, the Democratic and Republican parties have been around for a long
- 1:23:43time, and most people by the by November fifth, which is I believe
- 1:23:48as election day this year, most Republicans aren't voting for Donald Trump and most
- 1:23:54Democrats aren't voting for Joe Biden. They're vering against the other guy to keep
- 1:23:59the other guy out. The political scientists to call this negative partisanship, excuse
- 1:24:03me, and it drives our elections. So I just think that you know,
- 1:24:10each side has the low forties absolutely locked in. Maybe not in every
- 1:24:15single state, but you know, so you get three electoral votes or six
- 1:24:19or something. I don't know anyway, Michael Tamaski's with this? It would
- 1:24:24you're an observer and chronicle or of democracy, would it be? Wouldn we
- 1:24:28be better if we didn't have this thing so locked down? I mean,
- 1:24:31the two parties, as you said, have it so locked down, and
- 1:24:33if you win a state, you get all electoral votes except in Maine and
- 1:24:36Nebraska. I mean, is there a would we be better with the legitimate
- 1:24:40third way? Well, we'd be better with a different system, okay,
- 1:24:45because a different system would open it up to more parties. And I'm all
- 1:24:48for it. I'm against the electoral College. A lot of people are h
- 1:24:54it's a vestige of a very different time, and it was. It was
- 1:24:59instituted to give slaveholding states a little bit of extra power in the early days.
- 1:25:03That's really what it was about, to give Virginia more power than Pennsylvania,
- 1:25:09say, and electing the president. And I think our first seven presidents
- 1:25:15were from slaveholding states, so it worked the way it was intended to work.
- 1:25:19But it's no good today. I think we should have a popular vote,
- 1:25:25and then in addition to that, putting aside how we elect president,
- 1:25:30I think we should the real reform hoppy as you read in my previous book,
- 1:25:35if we can keep it. Real reform is to change the way we
- 1:25:40elect Congress. And this is too complicated to explain in a few minute radio
- 1:25:44slot. People can go google about it if they want to. But we
- 1:25:47have winner take all, single member districts, and there's a and other countries
- 1:25:53do other things. They have proportional representation, mixed systems, other kinds of
- 1:26:00systems. Very few countries, in fact, have winner take all single member
- 1:26:04district systems. And if we changed that, we'd open up our system and
- 1:26:10it would be the end of the two party system, because if you look
- 1:26:13at say, you know, if the United States were a parliamentary system in
- 1:26:18the way Germany is, the Democratic Party would be about four parties and the
- 1:26:25Republican Party would be four or five parties, and then they'd have to make
- 1:26:30those coalitions and stuff the way they do in their other countries. A lot
- 1:26:33of people think that would be more democratic, smulty and representative, and I'm
- 1:26:41among them. You know, I was reading about what's happening in Germany and
- 1:26:45right now their chancellor's not very popular or no, and there's a problem with
- 1:26:49the ruling party not ruling, but you know, the majority party there.
- 1:26:53But as you said, it's a coalition and a parliamentary system, and I
- 1:26:58got sort of rose colored glasses about a parliamentary system where you say you have
- 1:27:01to build coalitions. I mean, nobody's going to get a majority, so
- 1:27:04you got to say, well, we got to get this group in you
- 1:27:06We've got to get this group in here. And there can be a downside,
- 1:27:09like you see in Israel when I get to the far far right,
- 1:27:13but still you have to build a coalition, and that's right now. You
- 1:27:15don't have to do that in America. You don't have to do that.
- 1:27:17You don't have to be right, No, no, you don't. And
- 1:27:24you know, the people from the smaller parties don't have the people who would
- 1:27:28prefer to be members of a smaller party dedicated, say to a single issue
- 1:27:32like the Greens, like the Greens, or say a gun owning party or
- 1:27:38an anti gun party. Yeah, we'd have both of those in the United
- 1:27:41States if we had that kind of system, people who prefer to be in
- 1:27:44that kind of party feel unrepresented. Now, it doesn't solve everything, as
- 1:27:48you just suggested, things are messed up in Germany too. You know Germany,
- 1:27:53Germany is governed by human beings, just like and human beings are going
- 1:27:57to make imperfect screwed up systems. But you know it's let me give you
- 1:28:04a specific example. We have a lot of states where congressional delegations are completely
- 1:28:12Republican or completely democratic. And it's not fair in either case because even in
- 1:28:17you know, well West Virginia, West, you know, thirty something percent
- 1:28:24of the people are Democratic or maybe forty and even in Massachusetts forty percent of
- 1:28:30the people are Republican. They have some representation in the House of Representatives.
- 1:28:34You know, it would be a lot better if West Virginia had you know,
- 1:28:40what do they have? Three now? Two oh two? Jeez boy,
- 1:28:45take another state. But like a state like Oklahoma, you know,
- 1:28:47should have you know, four Republicans and two Democrats. In a state like
- 1:28:53Massachusetts should have you know, seven Democrats and three Republicans or something like that
- 1:28:59to be fairer. And there is a way to try and do that,
- 1:29:01but we don't have that system. Yeah. I in West Virginia, we
- 1:29:05went to single member districts in the House, and frankly, I thought that
- 1:29:09was a good idea because when you had multi member districts, you were it
- 1:29:15was unclear like, okay, who exactly was your delegate, and frankly,
- 1:29:17some bad delegates could hide because they were just part of a group. And
- 1:29:21but and so I thought we need single member districts. I'm not sure now
- 1:29:26that was a good move because it we have the same issue that in West
- 1:29:30Virginia where there's just not going to be broad representation. So I don't know,
- 1:29:39I get I Look, you need to talk me down, because I
- 1:29:42really I just have a bad feeling right now, you know, I just
- 1:29:45don't like where we are as a republic in this country, and I don't
- 1:29:49like that. And this the failure of the border building. I know,
- 1:29:53I get a lot of feedback on this. I know the border bill was
- 1:29:55imperfect. I understand that, but I thought, I mean, James Langford,
- 1:30:00James Langford was the key negotiator and came to the table saying, you
- 1:30:03know, we got something here that we can that we can use. Is
- 1:30:06not perfect, but it's actually legislatively deals with some of the primary issues,
- 1:30:11particularly asylum, and this will help. And I mean it didn't even get
- 1:30:15off the launching pad. To me, that's very very discouraging. Just is
- 1:30:19that was that was discouraging. And you know, I'm not the guy to
- 1:30:24talk you down. My empire pretty much every day about this and and and
- 1:30:30here's the other thing I'll go, I'll make it bipartisan, is that I
- 1:30:33think what Joe Biden is doing and has been doing, I think and will
- 1:30:36do is incredibly selfish, incredibly incredibly selfish. I mean, he may not
- 1:30:44it's going to be very very hard for him to win this election, yet
- 1:30:45he's saying, you know, I'm the guy, I'm the guy that can
- 1:30:47beat Trump. You know you are, You're just barely hanging on here,
- 1:30:51okay politically and and it is very very selfish and self absorbed to do what
- 1:30:58he's doing. In my opinion, they're there, okay, So there's a
- 1:31:00by Parson attack on both sides. So yeah, no, that's fair enough.
- 1:31:03And I you know, and I take the point the difficulty the Democratic
- 1:31:09Party faces is well, it's several fold. But you know, if he
- 1:31:15were to stand down, there's no guarantee that anybody's any a better candidate he'd
- 1:31:20come on the Democratic Party. I don't know, there just isn't, you
- 1:31:26know, I mean, I don't know. You know, it's first of
- 1:31:30all, he probably endorsed Kamala Harris. She's not very popular. You know,
- 1:31:32what, can she beat Donald Trump or or Nikki Haley or whoever?
- 1:31:38I don't know. I mean, you know, she's she's doesn't have rave
- 1:31:42reviews her performance as vice president. And then you have you know, Gretchen
- 1:31:46Whitmer and and Pritzker and Gavin Newsom and all these people. They're impressive governors,
- 1:31:50they're they're good governors. But you know, Ron DeSantis was an impressive
- 1:31:56good governor. You know, everybody just doesn't translate to the national stage.
- 1:32:00Reasons that it's very difficult to identify, you know, so, and nobody
- 1:32:05among those governors. It's it's a it's a game of chicken, where nobody
- 1:32:11among those governors wants to jump and challenge is sitting president. And there's just
- 1:32:16and if you're thinking about your future and the party, there's just no advantage
- 1:32:21in doing that. So so it's a whole bunch of like, you know,
- 1:32:27the system motivates certain kinds of behavior, true, and right now,
- 1:32:30the system just doesn't motivate anybody challenging Biden. Michael Tamaski Morgantown, West Virginia
- 1:32:38native progressive commentator, columnist, and author, editor of The New Republic.
- 1:32:42His most recent book is The Middle Out, The Rise of Progressive Economics and
- 1:32:45a Return to Shared Prosperity and other socialist ideas. I just I'm just key.
- 1:32:50I'm just teasing about that. It's a good book, and we had
- 1:32:54you in Morgantown to talk about it. So I enjoyed. Didn't agree with
- 1:32:56everything, but I certainly enjoyed it was it was informative in education to read.
- 1:33:00It's good to talk to my friend. Fun night, always a pleasureable,
- 1:33:02Right, take care, We'll be right back stay with us. As
- 1:33:09Governor Justice always says, West Virginia is a diamond in the rough. That
- 1:33:13diamond just got a bit shinier with the state being named one of the top
- 1:33:17travel destinations in the world. Our scenic beauty, natural wonder and unique culture
- 1:33:23are unsurpassed, and it's no surprise people are catching on. And for those
- 1:33:27visiting, we hope you'll decide to stay in West Virginia. Job opportunities abound,
- 1:33:31especially in the coal industry. Coal mining is a high tech, high
- 1:33:35growth industry that exists side by side with exceptional hiking, biking, climbing,
- 1:33:41kayaking, hunting, fishing, and so much more. With state of the
- 1:33:45art mining operations, West Virginia's coal industry is recognized as the best in the
- 1:33:49world. We produce the coal that makes the steel that built this great country
- 1:33:54while continuing to power America. Today, join one of America's most honorable professions
- 1:34:00while living in one of the top travel destinations in the world. Join us
- 1:34:03in almost Heaven, West Virginia. A message from the friends of coal.
- 1:34:09Met coal makes steel. Did you know that metallurgical coal impacts our daily lives
- 1:34:14in many ways? It's the coal used in the steel making process. Driving
- 1:34:16over a bridge or loading your family into an automobile, you experienced the value
- 1:34:20of metallurgical coal. Most met coal produced in the United States is found right
- 1:34:25here in our Appalachian basins. Infrastructure, comfort, and convenience all made possible
- 1:34:30by metallurgical coal. Learn more about met coal and the impact of the Metallurgical
- 1:34:33Coal Producers Association at Metcoal Producers dot com, and remember, met coal make
- 1:34:39steel. It's good to have options when choosing health coverage for your family,
- 1:34:45your employees, and your company. You want to plan with people you know,
- 1:34:51like the Health Plan, known for exceptional local customer service, and are
- 1:34:58headquartered right here in West Virginia. We are families, we are businesses,
- 1:35:04and we are all moving forward together. We are here for you. The
- 1:35:10Health Plan West Virginia is home. It's where we work, live and raise
- 1:35:15our families. At the heart of our communities are West Virginia Hospitals, and
- 1:35:19they're compassionate caregivers. From life saving treatments and emergency care to wellness support and
- 1:35:26screening services. We are improving your quality of life through extraordinary achievements and amazing
- 1:35:32results. West Virginia Hospitals Your health is the heartbeat of our communities. This
- 1:35:39is talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. West Virginia
- 1:35:45Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more
- 1:35:49than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence
- 1:35:54has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years.
- 1:35:58No matter where we stalk the fish, they're ultimately going to look for the
- 1:36:02best suitable habitat. And as an angler, that's the secret, learning how
- 1:36:06to read the water and learning where the fish are most likely to be staged
- 1:36:11for feeding, whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the
- 1:36:15enjoyment of the great outdoors. And then right after the colds Vale, he
- 1:36:18started a pattern and I came in and it was the first time out hunted
- 1:36:24him in the morning, about eight point thirty he strolled in and I finally
- 1:36:27connected. With two days left in the season. Really, West Virginia Outdoors
- 1:36:30covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for your daily fix,
- 1:36:34Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of news and notes from
- 1:36:39the woods. And water every weekday morning on Metro News of Voice of West
- 1:36:43Virginia. Hey everybody, it's Tony Caridi. I'm Greg Hunter and I'm Brad
- 1:36:46Howse, and we invite you to join us Sunday through Fridays right here on
- 1:36:50the Metro News radio network. It's the city net statewide sports line. We
- 1:36:56talk West Virginia University, football, basketball, baseball, you name it.
- 1:37:00If it's got anything to do with the Golden Blue, we're on it.
- 1:37:02And don't forget the text line available every night. So we invite you to
- 1:37:05join us. The Senator coach Hunter and me Tony Courritti. It's the city
- 1:37:10net statewide sports line on Metro News. News in the Mountain State happens quick
- 1:37:15and for decades you have depended on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast.
- 1:37:20Now here's your chance to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If you
- 1:37:25see news happening, become a Metro News hawk by texting news to three five
- 1:37:29sixty five to one. If you take a picture or video of what you
- 1:37:32see, submit that as well. Text the word news to three five sixty
- 1:37:36five one to submit your tip or story. Standard texting rates apply, please
- 1:37:41don't text and drive. Metro News talk Line with Hoppy Kirchible is brought to
- 1:37:59you by Incovid Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about
- 1:38:03most. Visit in covid dot com to learn more. Talkline from me.
- 1:38:08COVID Church studios with seventeen hospitals and one hundred and ninety outpatient locations, more
- 1:38:13than thirteen thousand employees over two thousand providers. Vandelia Health provides expert, patient
- 1:38:19centered care close to home. Learn more about Vandelia Health locations and services at
- 1:38:25vandelah Health dot org, Vandaia Health dot org. Text Dear Hopy, Lock
- 1:38:30up those criminal librarians along with hardened criminals, build more prisons, get more
- 1:38:34National Guardsmen to work in the prisons. Obviously they're being sarcastic. These legislators
- 1:38:41are ridiculous and wasting our money. The I don't like to speak in terms
- 1:38:48of absolutes, because there's just a lot of gray that exists, and I
- 1:38:56don't know everything about everything, or even most things. But to my knowledge,
- 1:39:01librarians, library volunteers, museum curators, museum volunteers are not significant problems
- 1:39:11in our state. Right now, or the museums or the libraries. And
- 1:39:14by the way, the government if there are problems or issues at the library
- 1:39:19or at the museum, the government doesn't have to solve everything. We don't
- 1:39:24have to have a law for everything. And we're still a population that if
- 1:39:31you object to something, it's reasonable. It may not be successful, but
- 1:39:35it's reasonable to go and talk to a person, talk to the librarian or
- 1:39:40the museum curator, get a group of people together and rationally raise your objections
- 1:39:45and about certain material and then try that. I mean, rather than passing
- 1:39:54a law and criminalizing behavior like that, I just I don't. I mean,
- 1:40:00I understand in the bigger picture, I understand, and it is legitimate
- 1:40:05to be concerned about minors accessing obscene I mean really obscene material. Okay,
- 1:40:15as a parent, right even though we know the kids are going to do
- 1:40:18certain things, so that I understand that as a concern. But to me,
- 1:40:26that's like, okay, parents sort it out, deal with it.
- 1:40:29We all have to all, as all of us who have been parents,
- 1:40:30have to work through all that. And just I don't think we need a
- 1:40:34I don't think we need a law for that. And by the way,
- 1:40:36this is this is what happens too, is I got to text them somebody.
- 1:40:39They said, wow, what are you going to do about Ezekiel in
- 1:40:42the Bible? That's a that's a fair point too. I mean, if
- 1:40:45you want to start, because when you get something like this, you have
- 1:40:46to sort of carry it out to the extreme right. It's not just well,
- 1:40:50this is clearly obscene because it talks about this, this, this,
- 1:40:55and this, it's clearly obscene. So that would qualify. Okay, well
- 1:40:58what about this? What about this second in Ezekiel? Well that's the Bible,
- 1:41:00okay, but it is a little bit racy there, so you just
- 1:41:04you open this Pandora's box. It just don't. I don't see why you
- 1:41:08need to go there. I really don't. I really don't text three oh
- 1:41:13four talk three o four. Hopey. I agree with you on the library
- 1:41:17bill, but it seems to be the mindset of our legislators at the most
- 1:41:20pressing issues are moonshine, raw milk, driving in the left lane. No
- 1:41:26wonder we are ridiculed so much, says the texture will take a break of
- 1:41:29me back talk on continues, and I'm on a new episode of Live Healthy
- 1:41:31West Virginia is now posted on the podcast center of metronews dot com. We're
- 1:41:36talking about injectable weight loss drugs like WEGOVI and zep bound. Are they good
- 1:41:41for your heart? The biggest thing that we know is weight loss, decreased
- 1:41:45heart attacks, and admissions to the hospital. I think those are the biggest
- 1:41:48things that we can feel good about. Listen to Live Healthy West Virginia for
- 1:41:53candid conversations with insights about improving your health and well being. Live Healthy West
- 1:41:58Virginia is presented by w v you Medicine. West Virginia is home. It's
- 1:42:02where we work, live and raise our families. At the heart of our
- 1:42:08communities are West Virginia Hospitals and they're compassionate caregivers, from life saving treatments and
- 1:42:14emergency care to wellness support and screening services. We are improving your quality of
- 1:42:19life through extraordinary achievements and amazing results West Virginia Hospitals. Your health is the
- 1:42:27heartbeat of our communities. What if you played the West Virginia Lottery. Because
- 1:42:31you play, I have a place to exercise after my knee replacement. Because
- 1:42:35you play, I can enjoy nature's views at the state park with my grandchildren
- 1:42:41because you play, new schools continue to be built across the state. Each
- 1:42:45time you play the West Virginia Lottery, a portion from every purchase goes back
- 1:42:48to seniors, tourism, and education, more than twelve point four billion dollars
- 1:42:54since nineteen eighty six. West Virginia Lottery. What if you played the crunch
- 1:43:00of high electricity bills? Urge your legislators to support community solar and net metering.
- 1:43:04Community solar, currently available in twenty two other states, gives access to
- 1:43:09solar energy without rooftop panels. Net metering is already lowering West Virginia energy bills,
- 1:43:15but its benefits could be stripped away. Join the seventy percent of West
- 1:43:17Virginians who support affordable electricity. Learn more at wvsun dot org. That's wv
- 1:43:25sun dot org, paid for by Solar United Neighbors Action Urgent Medical Alert.
- 1:43:30The West Virginia Legislature is considering a bill making it legal for people who are
- 1:43:34not medical doctors or trained surgeons to perform my surgery. Housepill for seven eighty
- 1:43:40three will permit automotrists who did not go to medical school and are not trained
- 1:43:44surgeons to operate with lasers on your eyes. Tell legislators that only medical doctors
- 1:43:49and trained surgeons should be performing surgery. Ask them to vote no on Housepill
- 1:43:54for seven eight three paid for by West Virginia Academy of I Physicians and Surgeons.
- 1:43:59You're listening to Talkline on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia.
- 1:44:05Wvmetronews dot com the only website you need to stay informed in the Mountain state.
- 1:44:11Get the latest news in sports, story information on the great outdoors,
- 1:44:15and never miss an episode of your favorite Metro News programs and podcast including Talkline,
- 1:44:20Hotline, sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game. Make a
- 1:44:25bookmark now and visit wv metronews dot com first thing every morning to find out
- 1:44:30what's happening all across the state. Wv metronews dot com. West Virginia Outdoors
- 1:44:34is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than
- 1:44:40quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has
- 1:44:45been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. We
- 1:44:48used to always joke when we came up here, that's a small mouth here
- 1:44:50born two pounds. It's it's rare. I mean it's it's more common to
- 1:44:57catch a four plus than it is one under two Well benches here, whether
- 1:45:00it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great
- 1:45:04outdoors, You've got back up and must stay in. Around nine o'clock,
- 1:45:08he came cruising through kind of an open area that I could see on the
- 1:45:12stand as fortunate enough to bagging probably the biggest brett buck I've ever seen it
- 1:45:15the mon eyes normally West Virginia, dear, don't get that wide. West
- 1:45:18Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am and for your
- 1:45:24daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of news and
- 1:45:27notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News, the Voice
- 1:45:31of West Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation to wrap up your weekend.
- 1:45:36It's the City that Sunday Night Sports Line. Hey, this is Travis
- 1:45:40Joes joined myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six oh six until eight
- 1:45:44o'clock. As we wrap up the sports weekend, we talk mountaineers, high
- 1:45:46school, Mountain East Conference, and the latest in the national scene. The
- 1:45:50Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive. You could call or text the show at
- 1:45:55three oh four Talk three oh four. It's a perfect weekend sports wrap up
- 1:45:59on your face favorite Metro News affiliate, or watch the show at wb metro
- 1:46:01news dot com. Talk line on Metro News, Texter said, I failed
- 1:46:21to point out that this legislation was to deal with miners who would be exposed
- 1:46:27to pornography obscene material. Okay, fair point. If I skip past that,
- 1:46:30that is what it's intended to do. I was thinking more about who
- 1:46:33is gonna make the complaint. It's not gonna be the minor, It's gonna
- 1:46:36be the adults. I got a short time here, but let's go to
- 1:46:41Alan Dodgers County. What do you have on this subject? Uh? Seems
- 1:46:45to me that everybody's raised baby ghosts instead of children. Can he get that?
- 1:46:51Click? Uh? What a way to wrap up the show text topy
- 1:46:58concerning the obscenity, It's impossible to legislate morality. One test, though,
- 1:47:02is to have the material read or shown in public to see if it's embarrassing.
- 1:47:06Well, there are specific definitions. I know what Potter Stewart said about
- 1:47:12note when I see it, But there are specific definitions of what constitute obscenity.
- 1:47:15I don't have it in fun of me, but it's material that has
- 1:47:17no socially redeeming value, etc. Etc. But again, that kind of
- 1:47:21thing can still be open to interpretation. The biggest thing, The biggest problem
- 1:47:29to me is is that it criminalizes librarians and volunteers and people work in museums
- 1:47:36for doing your job, potentially doing your job. Talk Line on METRI new
- 1:47:40is the voice of West Virginia.