Latest / Film And Whiskey / Dune: Part Two / Bushmills 30-Year Single Malt Irish Whiskey ft. David Thomas Tao
Transcript
- 0:00In 2024, director Denny Villeneuve and star Timothy
- 0:04Chalamet gave the world a bombastic science fiction epic
- 0:08that challenged the rules of the game.
- 0:11In 2024 we visit the totally sandy dunes of Ireland to try a
- 0:1630 year whiskey. The film is Dune part.
- 0:20Two, the whiskey is Bushmill's 30 year single malt.
- 0:24And we'll review them both. This is the.
- 0:27Film and Whiskey podcast. Welcome to the Film in Whiskey
- 0:49podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:52glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:55I'm Brad G. And Brad, it is our last
- 0:59official episode of 2024. We are ending the year on a
- 1:04pretty damn high note here too 'cause we're actually talking
- 1:06about a movie from 2024. It's absolutely wild and I feel
- 1:13like it's a movie that has the most recognizable like since
- 1:18Inception's. I feel like the is like the most
- 1:27recognizable little sound piece from a movie in a decade.
- 1:31Yeah, it's it's amazing, though, how, you know, we've talked
- 1:34about this with any movie set in Iraq or Afghanistan.
- 1:37Like you get that like kind of questionable like Minaret call.
- 1:43And now here we are on a desert planet thousands of light years
- 1:48away, and we're still getting that exact same like whoever is
- 1:51paying that person to keep them employed with that little trill
- 1:54of a voice. They are making bank off of
- 1:57Sandy. Movies.
- 1:58Here's the thing though, man, it doesn't matter when you make it
- 2:01freaking awesome. And I would say Dune Part 2 is,
- 2:06in fact, freaking awesome. Brad, I literally just finished
- 2:10watching this movie about 20 minutes before we hopped on
- 2:12tonight. It's my third time having seen
- 2:14the film, and I realized that I don't think we've actually
- 2:18covered Dune Part 1 on this podcast before.
- 2:22So it's going to be a really interesting conversation.
- 2:24I'm sure we'll have to lay some groundwork for both the Dune
- 2:27books and the Dune movies. And in order to do that, we're
- 2:30going to need some help. So we've enlisted the help of a
- 2:33good friend of ours making, I believe, his third appearance
- 2:35already on the podcast. Second, we're well, we're gonna
- 2:40say third. It sounds better.
- 2:41He's he's he's making numbers at me.
- 2:44It's our friend David Thomas Tao.
- 2:45David, how are you today, man? I am.
- 2:48I'm excellent. And you know what the the fun
- 2:50fact, you watch Dune 2, Dune Part 2, right before this, right
- 2:54after this, I'm gonna watch the new episode of Dune Prophecy,
- 2:57which has become my Sunday night tradition.
- 2:59So the timing of this couldn't be better from a nerd.
- 3:03Perspective, it's amazing how quickly the, you know, the Star
- 3:09Wars Disney acquisition pipeline has gone for the Dune IP.
- 3:14Warner Brothers was like, you know what, we own this now we're
- 3:16going to pump out two movies and then immediately get ATV show
- 3:19going as well. I have not yet watched Dune
- 3:21Prophecy. I'm sure a lot of people are
- 3:23catching up on it here over the holidays.
- 3:25What's your opinion on the show so far 'cause you're you're the
- 3:27only authoritative voice here on it?
- 3:29I'm really enjoying it and I think I'm liking it more than
- 3:32others. And I think the criticism, the,
- 3:35my quick thing is, I think a lot of the criticism is that it
- 3:38feels different than Dune and that things don't feel as
- 3:41coalesced or as tight. The thing I'll say about Dune
- 3:44Prophecy, it's set 10,000 years before Dune, and it gives
- 3:49background on how a lot of the social structures and groups
- 3:52that are major players in the Dune movies and books actually
- 3:56came into being. So the criticism I'm hearing
- 3:59from a lot of folks is that it feels like Dune, but not as like
- 4:01tight, not as congealed. That's kind of the point, right?
- 4:06It's like, let's go 10,000 years in the past and see how all
- 4:08these social structures and norms and heuristics originated.
- 4:12And like, it shouldn't feel as tight, right?
- 4:14It should feel a little different, but directionally
- 4:17similar. And that's what it feels like.
- 4:20I'm really enjoying it actually. And I'm enjoying it, I think
- 4:22more than than most, because I enjoy the large timelines on
- 4:29which the Dune IP operate. Well, and that's the beauty of a
- 4:34television series, right, is that it doesn't have to be as
- 4:37tight. Like, like Denny talks about how
- 4:41for him, the editing room is where he becomes most brutal
- 4:44with a movie because he he like it's like he is like cutting
- 4:49down his children when he throws them on the floor.
- 4:52And ATV show you don't quite have to do that as much as like,
- 4:55yeah, we can leave it a little bit because we got two seasons,
- 4:57three seasons to work on this. Well, and Denis Villeneuve, you
- 5:00know, you know, famous for his brutality in the editing room.
- 5:03That's how you get down to a tight 2 hours and 47 minutes,
- 5:06you know, but. That said, we'll talk about this
- 5:10on the podcast. I'm sure one of my favorite
- 5:12actors currently working in Hollywood was entirely cut from
- 5:16the movie. Yes, because the director had to
- 5:20be brutal in the editing room. Because the story is so it's
- 5:24it's true, it's epic. It's epic in nature.
- 5:26It is the definition of an epic. You're talking, of course, about
- 5:30the extended cameo by Jerry Seinfeld, which I am talking
- 5:33about. Really controversial.
- 5:34What's the deal with the spice? Is it a is it a Prague?
- 5:41Is it a seasoning? I can't do a Jerry Seinfeld
- 5:43impression, clearly. That was, that was great.
- 5:44That was, you know. What's what's Yeah, what's
- 5:47what's the deal with Space Guild food anyway, that's a real.
- 5:51Brad, a couple weeks ago we did District 9 on the podcast and
- 5:55talked and lamented a bit at that time about how we don't
- 5:58really do a lot of hard sci-fi on this podcast and we we broke
- 6:02down soft sci-fi versus hard sci-fi.
- 6:06This is like, this is probably the most intricate sci-fi world
- 6:12building and lore we've ever had from a Yeah, it's the hardest of
- 6:16all hard sci Fi's, yes. Here's here's Hurgid sci-fi.
- 6:24It's I'm sorry as opposed agreeing to this, I'm so sorry
- 6:30this. Is only listen, this whole part
- 6:32is only Patreon because we need to get into the turgid versus
- 6:36flaccid sci-fi spectrum here. Go ahead, Brad.
- 6:41Here's the thing with Dune. I would say Part 1 and Part 2.
- 6:46I think that the reason it is so successful is because Denny
- 6:51wraps all of the hard sci-fi elements in this, in this
- 6:58mystical cinematography and sound design and it's just kind
- 7:03of flowing. And it almost feels like a
- 7:07slower version of a Terrence Malick film at times where it
- 7:12it's just this almost like a drug induced haze of a film that
- 7:18is masking like very, very deep sci-fi roots.
- 7:26All right. Well, I think maybe the best
- 7:27place to start is to get into our first segment of the day,
- 7:30which we call, Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 7:33movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock, so let's go
- 7:37ahead and do your take with this little segment that we call,
- 7:40Brad explains. Brad Explains is the part of the
- 7:43show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 7:46just seen often for the 1st time.
- 7:49Brad, this was not your first time seeing Dune 2.
- 7:52I did convince you to go to the movie theater and see this film.
- 7:56One of my proudest moments, if I'm being honest.
- 7:58After failing to get me to see Oppenheimer in theaters.
- 8:01Or Dune Part 1, which I was really striking out on on huge
- 8:06scale movies. It would have been funny if
- 8:08you'd been like, you know what, I think I'm going to go see
- 8:10Barbie in IMAX. I think that's the movie that's
- 8:13going to get me there. But no, you saw Dune Part 2, so
- 8:17it's not your first time. However, there is, I think
- 8:20there's a short way to explain this movie and there's a very
- 8:23detailed way to explain this movie.
- 8:25So I'm interested to see what you can cram into 60 seconds
- 8:28here. Folks, if you've not seen Dune
- 8:30Part 2, I'd encourage you to press pause, go watch this
- 8:33movie, and then come back and join us for the rest of the
- 8:35episode because Brad is going to spoil the hell out of it.
- 8:39So Brad the movie has not hit the Oscars yet.
- 8:42People are going to be catching up with this movie.
- 8:44Hopefully they'll return to this spoiler filled conversation
- 8:46afterwards. One minute on the clock and go.
- 8:50Dune Part 2 is a film that follows Paul Atreides and his
- 8:55mother as they are taken in by the Fremen after their entire
- 8:59house was slaughtered by the Harkins in the previous film.
- 9:04Paul learns how to be a Fremen warrior while the Fremen begin
- 9:09to slowly believe that he is the prophesied savior of their
- 9:15people that will bring prosperity back to the planet.
- 9:19He falls in love with a Fremen woman named Chandri.
- 9:23Is that it Chani? Yes, Chani.
- 9:27And eventually follows his mother to the Deep South where
- 9:31there are is a large portion of fanatical Fremen where he knows
- 9:37that he will be made a profit, which he doesn't want, but he
- 9:41goes anyways. Drinks worm piss and man.
- 9:45He has all the visions and he unites the frammen under 1
- 9:49banner, takes the Emperor of the Galaxy hostage, kills his
- 9:53champion and decides to wed his daughter so that he can rule a
- 9:59galactic empire. Boom Dune Part 2.
- 10:03Not bad. Not bad at all, Brad.
- 10:05Thanks man. I'm going to throw over to our
- 10:08friend David. He's been patiently waiting,
- 10:10chomping at the bit over here. We sent our list of movies out
- 10:13to you and said take your pick of the litter here.
- 10:16And you said let's do Dune Part 2.
- 10:19So I'll let you set the stage for our conversation because I
- 10:22want to know what was the immediate attraction to Dune
- 10:24Part 2? Why this movie as opposed to any
- 10:27other? I think the I think it's because
- 10:30Dune Part 2 exists at that the center of that rare Venn diagram
- 10:34or the rare the small center of the Venn diagram of based on
- 10:38existing IPI really truly love and also fantastic execution.
- 10:45Like I think that if you don't know, if you don't know anything
- 10:48about the Dune universe and you see Dune and then Dune Part 2,
- 10:50Dune Part 1 and Dune Part 2, I think you're getting a great
- 10:53two-part cinematic experience. And I think it's a fantastic
- 10:56introduction to a very complex world that Frank Herbert built
- 11:03and that really set the standard for sci-fi fantasy.
- 11:06I mean, you, you name it, it, it's it's, it's impossible to
- 11:09understate the cultural influence, the literary
- 11:12influence and the genre influence of the Dune universe.
- 11:15You combine that with the fact that this is just a really well
- 11:18done movie. It's hard to do.
- 11:22This isn't really a sequel. It's truly a Part 2, right?
- 11:25These are two movies. The the first book, the book
- 11:28Dune was split across 2 movies. But it's really hard to do a
- 11:31second movie well. It's hard to do any movie well.
- 11:34And Dune to I think nails it. It's a sort of movie where I go
- 11:38into the theater. I love the IP.
- 11:40I've read the book multiple times.
- 11:41I've read the sequels. I've immersed myself in this and
- 11:46I've been on fan forums and I sit down and I'm nervous.
- 11:49I'm nervous about the execution and I'm nervous about what is
- 11:53not going to make it into the film, what has to be cut.
- 11:58But I didn't think throughout the entirety of the film.
- 12:00It wasn't until well after the film when I was thinking about,
- 12:03wait a minute, I think this character might have been cut,
- 12:05which is not a problem. But like during the film, I was
- 12:07not distracted by what didn't make it in.
- 12:11It was immersed in the universe. And I think it's fantastic
- 12:14execution and I think it's rightly an Oscar contender,
- 12:18which is tough for sci-fi films. We don't see that happen.
- 12:23But this is a cinematic achievement and I am just so
- 12:29happy that this IP that I really grew up with and was, especially
- 12:32in high school, so obsessed with, is now in a mainstream
- 12:37form that does it justice, at least as as well as we can,
- 12:43right? I don't think anything
- 12:44replicates the universe and the world building you can do in
- 12:47your head when you're reading the book, right?
- 12:49But as far as a visual and audio representation on a big screen,
- 12:53I thought it was great. And you know, from casting all
- 12:57the way through execution to scoring, lovely.
- 13:00So that's why it was like a no brainer.
- 13:02I was like, this is this is the one, right?
- 13:04This is it. I.
- 13:05Was going to say I I believe a rival would have been the last
- 13:09like serious sci-fi contender and I I know it.
- 13:13It didn't have a huge shot at winning Best Picture, but it was
- 13:16nominated at the very least. Well, yeah, and Dune Part 1 was
- 13:19nominated as well. And I think kind of
- 13:21controversially, it got a lot of what is called below the line
- 13:24nomination. So all of your crafts, you know,
- 13:26cinematography, costume designs, that design.
- 13:29Denis Val Neuf not nominated for best director for Dune Part 1,
- 13:33which was a huge controversy. Because if all of these things
- 13:38that add up to a cohesive vision do not point to a really, really
- 13:44smart and astute director behind the camera, I don't know what
- 13:49does. And, and just when you're
- 13:51talking about scale and scope of a film, I don't really know that
- 13:56anyone is doing it the way that Villeneuve is doing it right
- 13:59now. Like the the only real
- 14:01comparison is Nolan, but a Nolan film feels very different to a
- 14:07Villeneuve movie. And Brad, especially having just
- 14:10done Oppenheimer a couple months ago, Oppenheimer's a movie and
- 14:14I, I really want to tread lightly because I gave it a 10
- 14:16out of 10. It's a great movie.
- 14:18It's a movie that's made so much in the edit.
- 14:21Like there's so much of that that is, you know, relying upon
- 14:25callbacks to different time periods and jumping across
- 14:28timelines and kind of creating this overwhelming experience
- 14:33through the edit. Whereas I think Villeneuve is
- 14:36really good at just building massive sets and putting like
- 14:39really good at geography, making you feel the scale of someone
- 14:42that's this big against a sandworm.
- 14:44That's enormous. And I don't know that anyone has
- 14:47that kind of old school understanding of scale the way
- 14:53that Villeneuve does right now. I, I just want to interject and
- 14:57I, I would, I this is a yes. This is a yes.
- 14:59And I don't think there since the original Star Wars series
- 15:08when we saw the death * and we had to get a sense of how big
- 15:13that was. Has anyone done physical scale
- 15:19this well in a major sci-fi film release?
- 15:22Right. Like, and there are multiple
- 15:25aspects of that could be the size of the sand worms.
- 15:27It could be the size of the Spacing Guild craft and you see
- 15:32how big these, you know, what's like 20 kilometer long
- 15:35spacecraft are relative to like the actual ships, the transport
- 15:40ships transporting people. Like the scale of everything is
- 15:43so to the Emperor's arrival ship, right, Which we see here.
- 15:50I think a a challenge here is this movie has to have sci-fi
- 15:53elements, but it's also imperial.
- 15:55It has to have pomp and circumstance, right?
- 15:58And so you look at this and you're like, oh, I'm seeing a
- 16:01lot that reminds me of Star Wars.
- 16:03But then you look at the original Star Wars series and
- 16:07I'm sure there have been books written about this Star War.
- 16:12It's, it's arguable like, could Star Wars exist if it weren't
- 16:15for the Dune books, right? The answer is maybe not.
- 16:19Right 'cause Dune was first. They were the first to do this
- 16:22operatic epic scale sci-fi world building.
- 16:26Yeah, and it's well documented that Lucas was a huge fan of the
- 16:29books. I think that another good
- 16:31comparison point and one that I'd really like to pick Brad's
- 16:34brain on a little bit is this both literarily and
- 16:39cinematically as a comparison point to The Lord of the Rings.
- 16:42I think this is probably the most intricate, like I've
- 16:46already said, the the phrase intricate world building, but
- 16:48especially from a sci-fi or fantasy film spread across
- 16:52multiple movies done on this scale.
- 16:54It's the first time this has really happened since Lord of
- 16:56the Rings. Like you could argue Harry
- 16:58Potter a little bit, but I just think that we're not talking
- 17:00about quite the global scale that, you know, Lord of the
- 17:05Rings or Dune is operating on. And I think that there's a lot
- 17:11to dive in on here. And I've got some great Nuggets
- 17:14from my research about like what Tolkien thought of the Dune
- 17:16books and everything else. But Brad, as a fan of Lord of
- 17:19the Rings, as a super fan of Lord Lord of the Rings, the Dune
- 17:26story, does it grip you in the same way as a Lord of the Rings
- 17:31does? I don't think it does.
- 17:36I oh man, that it's such a hard comparison, Bob.
- 17:41I Tolkien was way less interested in the internal lives
- 17:49of his characters. Like at the end of the day,
- 17:53Tolkien was way more fascinated by the external forces of the
- 17:58world around it of like what's going on in Middle Earth and
- 18:01these larger than life characters who are like
- 18:05utilizing their will to shape the world in a way that they see
- 18:09fit. And you see Sauron do that in
- 18:11negative ways and you see Gandalf and Aragorn do that in
- 18:15powerful ways for good. And you know, the, the movies, I
- 18:20will say, show way more of the struggle internally for Frodo
- 18:26and Sam and Aragorn and, and all, all of these characters
- 18:31Ferromir, right? Like one of the most famous
- 18:33differences from the books to the movies is that Ferromir
- 18:37doesn't even come close to being tempted by the ring in the
- 18:41books. And I actually think that that's
- 18:43a good a good comparison to bring up because talking
- 18:50believed in good people being good and that they're not
- 18:55necessarily tempted by the darkness.
- 18:58And like Frank Herbert essentially was like, no, that's
- 19:02not true. Everybody is tempted by the
- 19:04darkness. Everybody is tempted by power.
- 19:07What will we do to gain control of it?
- 19:09Now, I will say, David, you're more the expert on June here.
- 19:13I have not read those books, but from the comparisons I've seen
- 19:17of Lord of the Rings, the Dune, as you were alluding to Bob
- 19:22about your research, Tolkien hated.
- 19:25Dude not a fan of books he. Did not like those books.
- 19:29And I, I think it comes down to that.
- 19:32They just had a different underlying foundational view on
- 19:37humanity and the world and and all of those things.
- 19:40Yeah, I mean, they're written to two entirely different
- 19:42historical context too, even though they're only, you know,
- 19:4520 years apart at the most. But Tolkien is writing
- 19:49immediately post war when he and Lewis are trying to extrapolate
- 19:56their own beliefs and reframe this fight that they have seen
- 20:00on a continental and global scale of good versus evil, and
- 20:04to reaffirm what they believe to be the good and the good that is
- 20:07inside of everybody and which is worth fighting for.
- 20:10And it does not, obviously, it is not hindered at all by the
- 20:15fact that. Tolkien and Lewis are both
- 20:19avowed Christians, and so there are tons of Christian themes in
- 20:21the Lord of the Rings books. Herbert, on the other hand, is
- 20:24writing 1520 years later, and he's a little bit disillusioned
- 20:30with what America is doing at the dawn of the military
- 20:34industrial complex. He doesn't like what we're doing
- 20:36to kind of position ourselves to get oil.
- 20:39He looks at new drugs like LSD, and he's writing, I mean, he's
- 20:44kind of a contemporary of, of authors like Ken Kesey, who's
- 20:47writing One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest about LSD at this
- 20:50time as well. It's a much more cynical, not
- 20:56quite nihilistic, but just really emotionally cold tale.
- 21:01And you can see why Tolkien wouldn't like it.
- 21:04And I guess I'm wondering how that affects your enjoyment of
- 21:10this adaptation, Brad and David, because I think that it is, it
- 21:16perfectly captures the cold, calculating kind of castle
- 21:22intrigue politics that Herbert is getting at in a way that
- 21:26appeals to fans of shows like Game of Thrones.
- 21:28Like it it it's right in line with shows like that.
- 21:30I. Was just going to say this like
- 21:32this so clearly points towards a Game of Thrones like belief
- 21:37about the world than it does ACS Lewis Tolkienesque view of the
- 21:43world. And I, I, I think it's
- 21:46fascinating because I actually think that Dune Part 2 at the
- 21:51very least leans less into the cynicism and more into a belief
- 21:58mindset like a a token type mindset then maybe Herbert would
- 22:04have been intended it to. I mean, obviously the nerve is
- 22:07making it, but like for me that especially this time through, I
- 22:10was struck by the end of the film when Paul's mother
- 22:17essentially tells the former like head of her order, the been
- 22:20a Jesuit witches. I don't know, space witches,
- 22:23coven, Coven I mean. That's, that's what they're
- 22:26referred. That's like, how do you insult
- 22:28them? You call them like witches or
- 22:29something, like yeah, yeah. Sure.
- 22:32I I apologize, Ben. A Jesuit.
- 22:33I'm not trying to offend you. Don't make me do things.
- 22:38But like, at the end of it, she tells her, like, you chose the
- 22:41wrong side. And she goes, ah, there's never
- 22:44a side. There's only survival
- 22:46essentially. And like, that's the core
- 22:48tension for me of this film is that Paul continues to say, I
- 22:53don't believe in your BS missionary like propaganda
- 22:58proselytizing. I just want to fight and win
- 23:02this war on my father's behalf. But at the end of the film, and
- 23:06you know, I don't know where Part 3 or, or Messiah or
- 23:10whatever he's going to call it is going to be.
- 23:13But this film at the very least seems to say that believing in
- 23:18something is more powerful than being cynical.
- 23:21That it's it's when Paul finally believes in the prophecy, he
- 23:26goes and drinks the water of Life and his eyes are opened
- 23:30that that is the better way than the cynical, We're all just here
- 23:36fighting our own battles type of view.
- 23:38I'm going to say we have polar opposite readings of the end of
- 23:43this film, Brad, but that's that's good.
- 23:44It's going to be good for conversation.
- 23:47I might also be just be more because I I understand like
- 23:50where the arc of the the do novels goes from here, but I was
- 23:55going to kind of try to set the stage for the rest of the
- 23:59episode by saying the coldness and the sort of emotional arm's
- 24:04length Ness of this overall story, I think continues to be
- 24:09for me, the biggest fault in the in these stories.
- 24:13And it's purposeful and I think that Villeneuve captures it so
- 24:15well. But there is there is just
- 24:19something that I can't breakthrough with with the Dune
- 24:21films that I appreciate them and I thoroughly enjoy them.
- 24:26But like, I'm not going to come back to them to the extent that
- 24:30I do something that captures my emotions and my heart the way
- 24:34that like a Lord of the Rings does.
- 24:36And again, that's not the intention of these films.
- 24:38But I think especially when you start comparing them, there is
- 24:42something about the they couldn't have made these movies
- 24:46successfully back when David Lynch was trying to do them or
- 24:49in the 1990s. And I don't think it's a
- 24:51technological thing. I think it's because we were
- 24:53just a fundamentally different people then and in the wake of
- 24:579/11 and all of the wars that we've had since then, this is
- 25:00like, this is the sci-fi movie for our times.
- 25:05And I just constantly keep asking myself, what does it say
- 25:09about us that this is what we resonate with now?
- 25:12Do you know what I mean? Wow.
- 25:16Episode done. Wow, it's a good Bob.
- 25:19Bob nailed it, folks, like we did.
- 25:21We did No, but David, for real, you know, you're the dune expert
- 25:24here and I'm I don't want you to be the stand in for the American
- 25:28people. But oh, I'm happy to be the
- 25:30stand in for that. Let's do that.
- 25:31Let me speak for everyone now. OK, my here's my reaction.
- 25:37I think that I think actually, I actually don't think you all are
- 25:40necessarily coming from polar opposite perspectives here
- 25:43because I think that there is, I think Brad is speaking to a
- 25:49reaction from watching this film as someone who's not intimately
- 25:54familiar with the IP. And Bob, I think you are someone
- 25:56who who knows a bit more about the arc of where this goes,
- 25:59right? And that's one thing that makes
- 26:00the Dune series really great. And when I was reading these,
- 26:04when I was reading them, I really enjoy as a young person.
- 26:07I really enjoy that because I enjoy the arc.
- 26:08And for me it was telegraphed but somehow still not
- 26:12predictable, right? Like the entire setup is about a
- 26:15golden path for humanity and about having future sight,
- 26:20right? At this, at the same time, the
- 26:22book series actually has has is a progression of interesting
- 26:27reveals, even if the characters can literally see into the
- 26:31future, right? Which I think is no small feat
- 26:34literally. And I think that it's a
- 26:35testament to the fact that Frank Herbert was also quite a great
- 26:38writer and quite a great storyteller, as much as I think
- 26:40some of his contemporaries or the generation right before, for
- 26:44lack of a better term, kind of Pooh poohed him a little bit,
- 26:48right? I think that his reveals and the
- 26:51way he set up and the way he actually constructed narratives
- 26:53was really quite interesting. So you all are kind of saying
- 26:55different things. But I think again, that's that's
- 26:58that's the path of the reader. And that's the path of someone
- 27:01who has to go through this story and experience this story
- 27:04because so much of this is internal.
- 27:08So much of the writing of Dune, and it occurs in the later books
- 27:11as well, but it's especially pointing in the 1st 2:00.
- 27:15It is internal monologue. It is very different than
- 27:19Tolkien, right? Like it was brought up earlier.
- 27:22Tolkien didn't super care about the internal thoughts or depth
- 27:26of his characters necessarily. He was kind of writing for the
- 27:28plot more. I don't want to that might be an
- 27:30oversimplification, but Herbert Oh, so much is happening in the
- 27:34mind, right? So much is happening in Paul's
- 27:37mind, in Lady Jessica's mind, right in Paul's sister's mind,
- 27:42like in we see, we see this happen with his characters and
- 27:45later on his children and the successive progressions of these
- 27:48folks who have the power of future sight.
- 27:51So what I'll say is I don't think what you're saying are,
- 27:55are two things that are opposed. I think it's, it's an
- 27:57illustration of how good the progression of this narrative
- 28:00really can be. And the last thing I'll say is
- 28:03survival. I think we can all where where
- 28:04we can link these is that this is ultimately about pragmatism
- 28:07and survival in many ways. There are a lot of themes in
- 28:10Dune. I'm not trying to distill it
- 28:12down to just those two. But if you look at Dune and not
- 28:17as a singular book, but as a 5000 year arc over the course of
- 28:23Herbert and his son's writings, who kind of kind of finished the
- 28:25narrative in in controversial fashion, I will say it is about
- 28:30survival. How does humanity survive
- 28:33against weapons of its own creation and against its awful
- 28:37instincts? Because we are a
- 28:39self-destructive species, right? Is there a way for us to survive
- 28:44as our power grows and as the power of our creation grows?
- 28:47And for me, that's what I take away ultimately from doom.
- 28:50There are a lot of other themes. So if we can all agree that this
- 28:55is a story of survival and the question does humanity actually
- 29:00make it long term, I think there's a lot of common ground
- 29:04and different evolutions of that understanding.
- 29:08Yeah, and the way you're talking about it makes it sound like
- 29:10this might be the ultimate Cold War novel.
- 29:13Yeah. Or series I should say.
- 29:16I think it's especially poignant too, because right now we're so
- 29:20everything. You can't turn on the news or
- 29:23read anything without hearing about AI.
- 29:26Herbert's stroke, one of his strokes a genius was to say, OK,
- 29:30we're gonna set up a universe in which that's banned, right?
- 29:34We're gonna set up a universe. We don't have droids.
- 29:36We don't have thinking machines thinking.
- 29:39And in fact, it's the whole point of the plot.
- 29:41It's it's outlined in the Orange Bible, which is like the tome
- 29:45for the Dune universe, for the people in it.
- 29:47You know, thou shall not make a machine in the likeness of the
- 29:50human mind, right? And Herbert was literally
- 29:54generations ahead of so many authors and being like, well,
- 29:58that's a consideration in the earliest phases of the computer
- 30:01age. He was already thinking about
- 30:02the ramifications of that. Right?
- 30:04This is pre Matrix. Do you get the Matrix without
- 30:08Dune? No, you know, no, no hate to the
- 30:10Wachowskis. Dude the the scene when Paul is
- 30:14in the chamber with millions of Fremen, like all I could see was
- 30:19like oh this is a better version of is it Matrix 2 I think that
- 30:24has that. And similarly, what Doom
- 30:27Prophecy, which I'm watching right now, gives more of the
- 30:29back story Doom Prophecy set like 100 and some 120 years
- 30:33after the war with the Thinking machines.
- 30:36And by the way, I don't wanna give too many spoilers, but the
- 30:38relevance of the danger of thinking machines becomes a
- 30:44central plot point, a more central plot point in subsequent
- 30:48Dune novels. So the further you go into the
- 30:51sequels, the more you understand why Herbert kind of set that.
- 30:55Up I think I think that's one of the brilliances of this, at
- 31:00least the visual adaptations, you know, and and what Herbert
- 31:03did was by D technologizing some of it like he just made for a
- 31:10really cool universe where people stab each other with
- 31:13swords instead of just shoot each other with bullets.
- 31:16Like I somehow he's created this world where I readily believe
- 31:22that they can be shooting down helicopters with like RPGs and
- 31:27also need to fight in hand to hand combat.
- 31:31Like that's. So cool he he does kind of do
- 31:34this day. I think it's I, I, I should know
- 31:36this on the top of my head. I think it's called the Holtzman
- 31:38effect, which is where like, oh, that's the thing that explains
- 31:41we figured out levitation. We figured out like space-time
- 31:44folding and we figured out it figured out invisible Shields.
- 31:48And it's all due to this one thing that we haven't discovered
- 31:50yet, right? And like that explains all the
- 31:53technology that we can't comprehend right now.
- 31:56It's just like all of it is kind of just figured out by this
- 32:00thing that he never goes into detail on, which you kind of
- 32:02have to do, right? At a certain point you kind of
- 32:04have to be like, here's a plot device stunt.
- 32:07Guys, before we get to break, I want to pull us out of our super
- 32:11nerdy sci-fi conversation here and let's talk about the
- 32:14cinematic merits of the film. We've talked about Villeneuve a
- 32:17little bit. I think we should just kind of
- 32:19dive into the cast because where I really want to take the back
- 32:22half of the episode is exploring the moral and ethical quandaries
- 32:27that are presented, especially by Paul, that I think that's
- 32:30where Herbert's story is the most unique and significantly
- 32:34different from what you get with Tolkien.
- 32:36This idea that he may or may not actually be a Messiah, or he may
- 32:40be one that has wholly manufactured his own savior ship
- 32:44and how dangerous that might be. And I think that that is, it's
- 32:49been such a long time since we've had a protagonist who
- 32:53makes potentially very evil decisions at the end of his own
- 32:58hero's arc in this film. But in order to talk about that,
- 33:02we got to talk about the performances.
- 33:03And I say we start right at the top here with Timothy Chalamet.
- 33:07Now, I just went to a press screening of his new film that's
- 33:11just come out called A Complete Unknown, in which he plays Bob
- 33:14Dylan. It's a good film, and he does a
- 33:16good Dylan. And then I watched this movie
- 33:19again, and I am once again reminded that Oscar voters often
- 33:23go for the keys that are being jingled in front of them.
- 33:27This is a better performance than his Bob Dylan, and he is,
- 33:32I'm like legitimately spectacular.
- 33:35The last 40 minutes of the movie are what I'm going to rave about
- 33:38the entire time we're talking. But specifically with Chalamet's
- 33:41performance from the time he wakes up after drinking the
- 33:45water of life and he has the scene where he confronts all the
- 33:48Fremen in a theater on the round type environment.
- 33:52And like, everything after that is just, it might be the best 40
- 33:58minutes of acting I've ever seen from Chalamet.
- 34:00It's absolutely Oscar caliber acting, Brad.
- 34:04The final 40 minutes, yes. The rest of the film?
- 34:08Not even close. What?
- 34:11I I think Chalamet is so weak in so many parts of this movie.
- 34:16Oh. Brad.
- 34:18He and Zendaya don't have good chemistry.
- 34:25You see these things so dogmatically as if they are the
- 34:29predominant opinion on these things.
- 34:31They have like moments together, but there's so many places of
- 34:35awkward dialogue, which I think if there's one thing for me,
- 34:38some of the dialogue in this movie is just straight up bad.
- 34:42And I I don't think that Chalamet or Zendaya or anybody
- 34:49else can really redeem it. I think that the two weakest
- 34:51performances of this film are Chalamet and Zendaya.
- 34:57Everybody else in this movie is like top notch, incredible.
- 35:02I I just Brad, I I really like you so much.
- 35:08Do it. Finish him.
- 35:11I really The thing is, I really like like you're.
- 35:13So you're much better than Bob. No, I'm kidding.
- 35:15I love you both. Obviously.
- 35:17I'm joking. I'm joking.
- 35:19I've, I fundamental, I disagree with that.
- 35:21I'm sorry. I, I don't, I don't know if it's
- 35:22my turn to speak, but I, I disagree with that.
- 35:25I think Chalamet and Zendaya, I think Zendaya's performance is
- 35:27actually extraordinarily nuanced.
- 35:29And I think she has a real challenge of of like she has to,
- 35:36we have to show both of these are young people who are coming
- 35:39of age and falling in love for the first time with universe
- 35:43shattering or shaking consequences.
- 35:47And they have to balance this like youthful finding yourself
- 35:52post pubescent. Who am I self discovery with
- 35:55like an order of magnitude of importance more than we, we, you
- 36:00know, folks face. And and I think there's a lot of
- 36:02nuance to her performance. I think it's like there's a
- 36:05scene where she has to, and I think this is really brilliant
- 36:08of, of the creative team to include this where she like
- 36:12plays a little joke on him, right?
- 36:14And she's like kind of schoolgirl talking with her
- 36:16friends and making fun of him, right?
- 36:18Which is like a nice little moment of levity.
- 36:22It's a little Helga Pataki making fun of Arnold, you know
- 36:25what I mean? And then we find her fear of
- 36:27falling in love, but also we see her becoming disillusioned while
- 36:32everyone else is buying into the savior complex and the Messiah
- 36:35complex, right? And that's a lot of weight.
- 36:38And I just want to point out one thing.
- 36:40I love face acting. And it's something that like is,
- 36:44is or is not a real thing. But the scene, there is a scene
- 36:47toward the end of the movie where there's like a premonition
- 36:50of the future after the the holy war.
- 36:53And after Paul's forces win the holy war that kills trillions
- 36:57across the universe, there's a scene of him and Zendaya's
- 37:02character and some other characters standing on, like,
- 37:05this ship while they're overlooking this planet that has
- 37:08been conquered. And like, you wanna see good
- 37:11subtle face acting? Look at Zendaya in that scene,
- 37:14right? So I think that she, I think
- 37:17it's a role that's impossible to do perfectly because she has to
- 37:20convey such an arc, falling like maturing, falling in love,
- 37:26getting disillusioned, kind of falling out of love, but also
- 37:29wrestling with the fact that like, does she say is she more
- 37:33effective in curbing the negative effects of this by
- 37:35staying close to Paul? It's so much to balance.
- 37:38And I was really impressed by her performance.
- 37:42I'm not sure it's the best acting I've seen from Timothy,
- 37:45but I really enjoyed the performance.
- 37:47I thought it was really good. I think it is award nomination
- 37:50consideration worthy. I think for me, one of the
- 37:53struggles with Timothy is that in moments, like I said, when
- 37:58he's in the round doing his talk to everybody, he's incredible.
- 38:03But the rest of the film, and maybe this was intentional, but
- 38:06every single time he ever raises his voice and tries to be like a
- 38:11leader of some sort, I just found myself going like, dude,
- 38:16you can't pull that off. It's just not there.
- 38:19I, I, I don't know if that was just me, I really struggled with
- 38:25with him throughout. I do think that if Zendaya, I
- 38:31think that her and Timothy are fine together.
- 38:34I think when the cameras just shoved up into her face, her
- 38:37eyes are incredible. Like she has a real talent to
- 38:42move the viewer with her eyes. Yeah, I I agree with both of you
- 38:47about Zendaya, especially because she was in a movie at
- 38:50the beginning of the year called Challengers, a really great
- 38:53movie by Luca Guadagnino. And I to this day, I think it's
- 38:56the best lead female performance I've seen all year.
- 39:01I think she's getting completely left out of awards
- 39:03consideration, but in that was. That the tennis movie.
- 39:06Yes, fantastic movie. One of my good friends is a
- 39:10sucker for three things. Like in films, he loves tennis,
- 39:15he loves Zendaya and he loves love triangles.
- 39:19And when they came out, when they came out with that trailer,
- 39:23he texted me and he was like, they've made the perfect movie
- 39:26for me. I.
- 39:27Was going to say if if his fourth favorite thing was strong
- 39:30homoerotic themes then that movie is like absolutely up his
- 39:34alley. That he didn't mention those,
- 39:36but I who knows? Well, based on the director,
- 39:39like those are things that are besides tennis, those are all
- 39:43things that are kind of themes in that director.
- 39:44'S Cat exactly. So I, I think she's so good in
- 39:48that movie because she's she's almost playing older than she is
- 39:52in parts of it, but it's also like a 15 year spanning film.
- 39:55And so at the beginning of the film she's playing like a 17
- 39:58year old. And I think her ability to not
- 40:00tip into caricature when she's playing a disillusioned 30
- 40:05something or a really young ingenue type.
- 40:09Is really, really stellar and she does it here as well.
- 40:13To Brad's point, I think our supporting cast, which if you
- 40:16guys don't mind it, just indulge me for a second if I can just
- 40:19read this cast list. So Timothy Chalamet and Zendaya,
- 40:24followed by an order of credits. Rebecca Ferguson, Josh Brolin,
- 40:29Stellen Skarsgard, Dave Batista, Charlotte Rampling, Javier
- 40:33Bardem, Austin Butler, Florence Pugh, Christopher Walken, and
- 40:37Leia Seidu. Maybe the best cast assembled
- 40:41for anything that's not a Marvel IP in the 21st century.
- 40:46The I want to give a quick, just a quick pour one out.
- 40:49Actually, you know, I'm going to open my Bushmills.
- 40:51Will I do this and make it a literal pour one out, crack the
- 40:54seal on the sample bottle. Pour one out for Tim Blake
- 40:57Nelson, who was in the movie but whose scenes were cut.
- 41:04And I was personally, I'm not saying it wasn't correct, but I
- 41:10was personally excited when I saw the casting news.
- 41:13No, David, come out and say it. You know more than Denny about.
- 41:20Whiskey, maybe, you know, but even that's debatable.
- 41:24I don't know. I don't, I don't know the man,
- 41:27no. Tim Blake Nelson was originally
- 41:31in the movie. I believe the scenes were
- 41:32filmed. Those were cut along with a few
- 41:33other folks. He just happens to be an actor
- 41:35that I have a particular affinity for.
- 41:37Oh, brother, where art. That was my favorite film of all
- 41:39time. So that's that's just my that's
- 41:42just what I have to say about that.
- 41:44And the other thing this is a spoiler spoiler alert.
- 41:47Fast forward 30 seconds if you don't want a spoiler.
- 41:50Anya Taylor Joy in a brief cameo as as Paul's sister, which I got
- 41:56to be honest, I'm not. That wasn't my favorite part of
- 41:59the movie. If I have to point to 1 weakness
- 42:01in the movie, how? Cause like in the book, she's
- 42:05actually born and like is like 3 years old, three or four years
- 42:10old at the end of the book, but they've just decided to take her
- 42:13this very packed movie. And I think it was actually a
- 42:14good call. I think it was a good call to
- 42:16not have her as like a significant character in this
- 42:18book. And we're gonna see her maybe in
- 42:20future movies. But in the book, she's born and
- 42:22has an active role in the plot. In the movie, she does not.
- 42:27It's just kind of like like, you know, future sight scene and
- 42:32it's more of a cameo you. Said she's three.
- 42:35I just like I have a three that just turned 4 year old.
- 42:38I just like to see her like running around the desert
- 42:41telling grown adults what to do. Well, that's like if you guys, I
- 42:45don't think you guys have seen the David Lynch film.
- 42:48Yes. I have multiple times and they
- 42:51did that in the David Lynch film.
- 42:53She's like a three. She's a real creepy 3 year old
- 42:57and and you know, you know what? They accomplished making her
- 43:00real creepy. Yeah, yeah.
- 43:03Brad, what what I would like for you to do is follow your newly 4
- 43:07year old around with the microphone so that we can get
- 43:09little transitionary statements of her saying Dune things like
- 43:14just getting her. It's, it's the quiz at Tatarak.
- 43:19It's Muadeeb. We'll just throw those in in
- 43:22between each of our segments, you know?
- 43:23All right, I'm ready. And Brad, this is this is
- 43:26interesting like again, this is a spoil.
- 43:28This is a book spoiler book spoiler.
- 43:30In the book Paul Sister, 3 year old Paul Sister, she's the one
- 43:34who kills Baron Harkonnen. Let's freaky I would go read
- 43:39those books now. Like as a three-year old.
- 43:41Yeah, yeah. The thing that was keeping Brad
- 43:44was the assumed lack of child murders in this in the book
- 43:48series. But child murders in that it's
- 43:50the children doing the murdering, yes.
- 43:52The children getting important, important.
- 43:56All right, guys, I think this is a good place to press pause.
- 43:59Otherwise, we're about to go way off the rails.
- 44:00Child murders. Great place to push pause, Bob.
- 44:03We'll. Come back after break, we'll
- 44:04talk about the supporting cast. We'll get into all the ethical
- 44:07quandaries as well. But it's time for us to drink a
- 44:10very expensive whiskey. Brad, what do you say?
- 44:12No. Twist my arm, Bob.
- 44:22All right everybody, today we are drinking Bushmills 30.
- 44:28Now this, as one might guess, is a 30 year old Irish whiskey that
- 44:35Bushmills has recently released. I believe, Bob, we are getting
- 44:40into some rarefied air here. We certainly are.
- 44:44And just a peek behind the curtain, we told David what we
- 44:48had planned to drink for this episode.
- 44:49I don't think he had it on hand. And knowing that the guy has a
- 44:52lot of whiskey on hand, I just sent him a list of all the
- 44:54whiskeys we'd plan to drink in the next 8 weeks or so.
- 44:57And he said, oh, Bushmills 30 sounds good.
- 44:59Let me contact my Bushmilts guy. And I don't know what magic he
- 45:03worked, what been adjusterate schemes he's been up to in the
- 45:06background, but he was able to secure his own sample of
- 45:09Bushmills 30 single malt. Now there is also a Bushmills 29
- 45:14year that we'll be trying next week and that is called
- 45:16Bushmills 29 year Rare Cask. So there's a difference between
- 45:20just the rare cask and the single malt.
- 45:23We're drinking that 30 year old variety here today, Brad.
- 45:26This was aged in bourbon barrels and Sherry butts for 14 years,
- 45:30taken out of those barrels and then finished again in first
- 45:34fill PX Sherry casks for an additional 16 years.
- 45:38And I have to say that of all the Irish whiskeys we have ever
- 45:41tried on this podcast, this is by far the darkest in color.
- 45:44Brad, Oh. Far and away the darkest in
- 45:47color and Bob. I was actually thinking with
- 45:50with so many things like finished in PX casks, I want to
- 45:56like, I don't know how rare it is.
- 45:58I want to actually get my hands on some Pedro Jimenez Sherry
- 46:01sometime and and try it because I feel like with so many things
- 46:06finished in it I I need to know what is the the OG juice
- 46:10actually like? Well, I'm sure David's got APX
- 46:13guy that he can hook us up with. I was just saying we can make
- 46:18that happen. I'm not coughing because I'm not
- 46:21coughing because of this. I'm coughing because I have the
- 46:24where winter allergies. I do want to give a quick shout
- 46:26out. I, I reach out to, there's a,
- 46:29there's a group called Articulate, which is a lot of
- 46:33the PR for Bushmills in the US. And I reached out to my contact
- 46:37there knowing they were at Bushmills and they were super
- 46:41excited about this. And they were just like, how can
- 46:45we like, how can we help? And they just messengered this
- 46:48sample of Bushmills sturdy. The best thing was they asked
- 46:51like, wait, Bushmill's 30 like they they were like they wanted
- 46:54to get it right. They're like, do you want the,
- 46:56the, the quote UN quote regular single, single maul.
- 46:59Do you want the rare cast? Like they want to make sure we I
- 47:01got the exact right thing. So shout out to them because
- 47:05like, this is not a a whiskey that you just find every every
- 47:09day, you know, and also, I just want to point out I'm especially
- 47:13excited because I do review a good bit of Irish whiskey.
- 47:17I've I've been to I've been to an I've covered and as a member
- 47:21of the media, a number of distilleries in person in
- 47:24Ireland. Most of the Irish whiskey that I
- 47:27do quote UN quote work with like review, it's actually Irish
- 47:31single pot still, which is a different type of whiskey than a
- 47:34single malt, right. Bushmills.
- 47:38They they are, they make single they are, they only make single
- 47:41malt, right? And so I don't get to review
- 47:47their products as much as I maybe would like.
- 47:48I don't get to review Irish single malt as much as I like.
- 47:51It's one of the styles of Irish whiskey, of which there are
- 47:54several and you know, one that I don't get to cover as much.
- 47:58So super excited about it. Yeah, and let it be known as the
- 48:01purveyors of budget whiskeys that we are.
- 48:05We were not making you try the rare cast.
- 48:07We're just the, you know, the the bottom shelf. 30 year
- 48:11Bushmills here. I could have found rare cast.
- 48:14I just want to be clear here. I could have, OK, you know,
- 48:18unless you're if you're calling me out, that's.
- 48:20Funny, man. All right, guys, let's dive in.
- 48:22Brad, let's let's hear your nosing notes.
- 48:24I think you drank it right before we pressed record
- 48:26tonight. I'm trying it live on air
- 48:28alongside David. So I'm going to stick my nose in
- 48:30this class now. Yeah, this is a beautiful nose,
- 48:35Bob for me. There's a really nice bit of
- 48:39almond throughout. It's got dried cherry.
- 48:42It has that that the PX kind of a sweet grape kind of nose.
- 48:48There's a bit of melon here, and it all has a nice little
- 48:51foundation of barley throughout. I think this is an incredible
- 48:56nose. 9 out of 10. Yeah, I'm, I'm there with you,
- 49:00man. This has an really deep, rich
- 49:02decadence to it that we don't typically get on Irish whiskey.
- 49:06I mean, we've also done a lot of really young or blended Irish
- 49:10whiskeys as well. So this is obviously in a
- 49:12different category. But even among those, you don't
- 49:15usually get this much caramel this much.
- 49:19You know what it reminded me of Brad, honestly, was a couple
- 49:21years ago, we did the Amroot fusion, which had this note of
- 49:26like stewed plum on it, like really heavy, like date plum
- 49:32prune. It's syrupy sweet.
- 49:35It's got Maple on it. I, I mean, obviously I think
- 49:37it's coming from those, those bourbon ex bourbon cast that was
- 49:40sitting in, but there is just wave after wave of really dark,
- 49:45carmally syrupy notes going on here.
- 49:48I'm going to give it a 9.5 Brad. I, I, I think you all get great
- 49:51notes. You know, Brad, I get a, you say
- 49:54almond. I get kind of an almond extract
- 49:56note here, particularly Bob to your notes about, you know, it's
- 50:00like dates. We get black raisins.
- 50:03I get Luxardo cherry for me, the note that I often use for really
- 50:09good single malts with some good PX influence, like if they go a
- 50:13really good direction, I get a lot of figgy pudding, right?
- 50:16And figgy pudding is not something that like I have
- 50:18eaten. But I just want to be clear.
- 50:19I don't like make it every holiday, but it's it's it's just
- 50:22looks like Nexus of dark and fruity and decadent and rich,
- 50:25but also sweet and confectionery a little bit.
- 50:29And so I don't really have much to add.
- 50:30I'm just kind of yes, Anding really what you all are saying
- 50:33here. And for me that kind of
- 50:34coalesces is like, honestly, like flombed figgy pudding,
- 50:38right? With like you just lit it on
- 50:41fire and you get some of that like extra care, alcohol,
- 50:44caramelization, caramelization, loveliness.
- 50:46Yeah, I really, really enjoy this.
- 50:48And you know, Brad, to your, to your point, I do get the
- 50:51underlying molt that's not lost from the wood influence, which
- 50:55is really, really lovely. You know, for me nose wise, I'm,
- 51:01I'm, I'm gonna say it's like high eights for me, probably
- 51:06probably a nine. See, I'm used to doing stuff
- 51:08also on 100 point scale for like spirits competitions.
- 51:10The 10 point scale is very different, so I'm just gonna
- 51:13round up and say A9 on this. It's it's really lovely.
- 51:16I have been lucky to have some of the rare cast expressions
- 51:19from Bushmills and some of those I would rate the nose even even
- 51:22a little bit more, but you really can't ask for much more
- 51:26than this on the nose. This is like, really, really
- 51:28good stuff. Yeah, I and that's, that's for
- 51:31me. I, I think that David, your
- 51:34expansive whiskey is going to lead to a slightly lower score
- 51:39than us. And I, I think that's probably a
- 51:41good thing because I am quite effusive about this.
- 51:46I I texted Bob earlier and was like dude, I drank this
- 51:50Bushmills 30 and dear sweet Jesus.
- 51:54I I, I one thing I will want to say on the nose this listen, a
- 51:59lot of folks in Scots like the poo poo Irish single malt and
- 52:02they shouldn't be poo pooing Irish single malt because it's
- 52:05it can be really, really spectacular and it can punch
- 52:08right, right up there with the best.
- 52:10And I have no some cherry finished in like really good,
- 52:14like legendary single estate pork pipe scotches that are 40
- 52:21plus years old and have really lovely like PX influence.
- 52:26And this is right up there with them.
- 52:27This 30 year old Iris single mole is right up there with some
- 52:31of the really expensive, incredibly highly regarded,
- 52:34super rare charried 40 plus year old scotches I've I've reviewed
- 52:38or sampled in the past couple years.
- 52:40So like it's, it's good stuff. I'm.
- 52:43Going to go as fast as I can with my tasting notes here.
- 52:46Brad, this is only a 46% ABV whiskey, but it had, it's a
- 52:50flavor bomb and I will say incredible prickliness on the
- 52:55tongue here. I, I would you could have
- 52:56convinced me this was much higher proof than it is.
- 52:59What I'll say about it is all the notes that we identified on
- 53:03the nose are here on the palate. You do get a slight bitterness
- 53:06from the malt, but what I love about this is that it doesn't
- 53:09turn into a burnt or ashy flavor at the back.
- 53:12It's not overly oaked and the bitterness actually presented
- 53:15for me. I've been making these a lot
- 53:17lately. One of my favorite whiskey
- 53:19cocktails is called the Brown Derby, which is a bourbon and
- 53:23grapefruit juice cocktail. I get notes of grapefruit on the
- 53:27back of this. It's not overly bitter, it's not
- 53:29pithy, but it it brings a note of kind of slightly sour, bitter
- 53:34citrus to the party that covers up for what might have otherwise
- 53:38tasted a little bit too charred. I'll give it a nine on the on
- 53:42the taste bread. Yeah, I think that this palate
- 53:46is like near perfection for me. Like the raisins really come
- 53:51through. The melon is there.
- 53:52I I put grapefruit as like one of my key elements of this.
- 53:57And once again, the barley is there and it has like a, for me,
- 54:02the almond almost moved into like a hazelnut like like
- 54:06praline almost kind of vibe. I'm at a 10 out of 10 on this
- 54:10flavour, Bob. I think it is everything I want
- 54:14in a whiskey. I, I like the I prefer the
- 54:17palate to the nose. I love the nose.
- 54:19I want to be very clear here. I think the palate's even
- 54:23better. You know, Bob, I, I get that you
- 54:26kind of predisposed me. For me, it's grapefruit candy
- 54:30specifically, not great. Like there's these specific
- 54:33small grapefruit candies that I used to love as a kid that
- 54:35really reminds me of, I think the palate.
- 54:39I there's AI have a moment on the mid palate where I'm worried
- 54:43that this is going to go too dry and it's gonna be a little too
- 54:47maybe ashy get into too much like dry wine territory.
- 54:51But what it does instead, it blossoms with tropical fruit led
- 54:54by grapefruit, but with also some some papaya and guava.
- 54:57And you said prickly, but I also get prickly pear cactus fruit on
- 55:00this or prickly pear on this, which is actually is something
- 55:03that I do eat occasionally 'cause it's like a bodega near
- 55:06me has it weirdly cheap. So I'll just like buy a bunch of
- 55:09them. So this is I love when single
- 55:13malts, like when they they blossom into tropical fruit,
- 55:17like kind of after the mid palette and it really carries
- 55:19through for just this like bright, vibrant finish.
- 55:23And this really does. So you know, on the pallet on
- 55:26A10 point scale, I you know, I'm like a 9.4 maybe on this maybe
- 55:339.5. It's this whiskey like shows up
- 55:38and then holds its own through the entire through the entire
- 55:42phase of the sample. Absolutely, yeah.
- 55:44And continue to get through on to the finish.
- 55:46I think there's a creaminess that develops as well.
- 55:49Like the grapefruit is the predominant note that I'm left
- 55:51with. But again, it doesn't tip into
- 55:54like a really bitter grapefruit kind of pith flavor.
- 55:56And it's not overly sweet, but I think that's where the viscosity
- 56:01really like takes over is on the finish for me.
- 56:04It's a really long mouth watering finish.
- 56:07I get a little bit. Do you remember those candies
- 56:09we've referenced a couple times, Brad Cream Savers.
- 56:12They're like the Lifesavers with the little swirls in them.
- 56:15It's it's like that with a nice little hit of grapefruit juice
- 56:19on top of it. Once again, I'm going to be
- 56:20pretty high on this. I do think I'll come down just a
- 56:23hair to an 8 1/2 out of 10 here. I I think the finish reminds me
- 56:30of an Aldi's chocolate that my wife really likes.
- 56:33It's a dark chocolate with orange peel in it.
- 56:36Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.
- 56:37Like that. Like there that I was, I was
- 56:40sitting here after I drank it and I was just kind of enjoying
- 56:43the finish and I was like, oh, it's that dark chocolate with
- 56:47orange. It's so, so good.
- 56:50The there's still hazelnut in there for me.
- 56:54The grapefruit sticks around the the raisins stick around for me.
- 56:59It finally fell into that like plum category on the finish.
- 57:05I'm I'm still really high on this.
- 57:08I'm at a nine out of 10 on the finish.
- 57:10I'm. Coming down just a little for
- 57:11the finish, but I thought the finish was still very good.
- 57:14You also predisposed. I like going last because I can
- 57:16just RIP off of what you all say and it makes me sound like a
- 57:18better taster than I am. You know those chocolate
- 57:21oranges, the table you got around the holiday that you like
- 57:24hit on the table to open? Yes, okay, if you made one with
- 57:27grapefruit instead of orange. That's what this is like on the
- 57:30finish. Do you remember those Guinness
- 57:32commercials from back in the day with the cartoon characters that
- 57:35would just shout brilliant, Yeah.
- 57:37Like the two? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 57:39That we need to pitch that to the Terry's Corporation over in
- 57:42England and just they need to have a grapefruit one now that
- 57:45sounds fantastic. But it's just this is this.
- 57:48I do get a little grapefruit pith on this and I don't mind
- 57:51that, you know, I get a tiny, tiny bit of minty and menthol on
- 57:55this. It's due some action.
- 57:57There's some fun action on the upper palate, actually, which I
- 58:01get, which surprised me a little bit.
- 58:04You know, it's not the best finish I've had on an Irish
- 58:08single malt. I've had some Bushmills finishes
- 58:11that are actually a little more memorable for this.
- 58:13But again, when I'm coming down back down to like a nine, this
- 58:17is still a better finish than the vast majority of whiskeys
- 58:21I'll ever taste. You know what I mean?
- 58:23And weirdly, the finish has some things in common.
- 58:28I I tasted the Stranahan Snowflake release for this year.
- 58:32Recently I had a call with their blender, Justin.
- 58:34Great guy and I'm only mentioning that because it's
- 58:38another Proximo company and I'm going to stay in portfolio here.
- 58:42So everyone's going to be really happy with me on the brand side,
- 58:45right? I'm not going to mention
- 58:47anything out of portfolio, right Stranahan's Bushmills, both
- 58:50Proximo brands company, you know they're going to love Hopefully
- 58:53they'll like me for that. Justin is a great blender.
- 58:55I think some of the things I got on this year's snowflake as far
- 58:58as like the drier pithier fruit on the finish.
- 59:02I'm, I'm, there's like, I'm getting a little bit of that
- 59:05here, right? And so I've been drinking a lot
- 59:08of American single malt lately and it's really cool to see some
- 59:11notes that I'm getting in really phenomenal multi decade age
- 59:16single malts from abroad. And I'm able to tie those to
- 59:19notes in really high end super premium single malts from
- 59:22American single malt makers, right?
- 59:24For me, that's like, that's really cool.
- 59:25And something that five years ago would have been maybe next
- 59:29to impossible. Yeah.
- 59:32You know, when we get into the balance here, folks, if you, if
- 59:35you're new to listening to our podcast, by the way, the way we
- 59:37talk about balance, think of it as cohesiveness and especially
- 59:42in the first 3 categories. So from the nose to the taste to
- 59:44the finish, was any one of those kind of wildly out of whack with
- 59:48the other three? And I don't think they were.
- 59:50I think this is actually a spectacularly well balanced
- 59:53whiskey. I'm getting, I'm still getting
- 59:55notes that are coming up on the finish.
- 59:57You know, like when you go to like a hibachi restaurant and
- 1:00:00they give you the little slivers of ginger on the side of your
- 1:00:02meal. Like I'm getting ginger on this,
- 1:00:04which is something that I never get on Irish whiskey.
- 1:00:07I just. Got Cafe cream, like Cafe Creme
- 1:00:09or cafe cream, just a tiny bit of coffee, but with that
- 1:00:13milkiness that you were referencing.
- 1:00:14Bob, I also want to point like I, I have my notes, like my
- 1:00:18tasting notes, how I would rate a whiskey.
- 1:00:20There's also a crush ability factor, like do you just want to
- 1:00:24do you just want to drink the ever loving crap out of?
- 1:00:26This crushability factor here is very hot.
- 1:00:30Off the charts. Like I literally was sitting
- 1:00:33here when I finished. Just hold it.
- 1:00:35You know how like you hold a bottle to like get every last
- 1:00:38drop into your glass? I was holding the glass so that
- 1:00:42I could get every lost drop into my mouth.
- 1:00:45Absolutely, man. And I think that I was ready to
- 1:00:47kind of come into this part of the review and say it's not the
- 1:00:50most nuanced or the most complex whiskey we've ever had.
- 1:00:54But especially when you're thinking about the Irish
- 1:00:57whiskey's that we reviewed on this podcast, Brad, I think it's
- 1:01:00at the top or near the top for Irish whiskey.
- 1:01:02And I think that the more I talk about it, the more notes I keep
- 1:01:05finding in it. So it's almost like, you know,
- 1:01:08the little engine that could hear it.
- 1:01:09It's just funny because you would think that I wouldn't have
- 1:01:13to talk about it like it's punching above its weight.
- 1:01:15It's a 30 year old single malt. I think the balance here is
- 1:01:18really, really great. I'm going to give it a 9.5 out
- 1:01:21of 10. Brad, what are you at?
- 1:01:22I'm at a 9.5 as well. I I think that this is complex
- 1:01:26and rich and yet every single note that we get is a river that
- 1:01:32runs well together like that. There's no Rapids, there's
- 1:01:36nothing throwing you off course. It's all working together so so
- 1:01:41Oh well. How does this tasting experience
- 1:01:44approximate the sensation of riding a sandworm?
- 1:01:47That's really what we should be. That's the.
- 1:01:48Scale we should be. That is a great question.
- 1:01:51Bob, you, you. You picked a big one like in
- 1:01:55Dune 2 when he asked to ride the sandworm for the first time and
- 1:01:57he picks a big one. How would Shai Haloud think of
- 1:02:01this whiskey? That's what we really need to be
- 1:02:03asking. David, where are you at
- 1:02:04numerically on the balance here? I'm I'm just a little bit below
- 1:02:08you guys and it's not because this isn't a stellar, stellar
- 1:02:11whiskey. It's because like I feel like
- 1:02:14I've been lucky to kind of see the mountain top of what
- 1:02:17Bushmills can do. And I know they can.
- 1:02:20They can produce some things that as great as this is, stick
- 1:02:24with me with punch, but elegance, like even slightly
- 1:02:29more so for me, I'm probably a 9.4.
- 1:02:31I just want to point out though, the crushability factor here is
- 1:02:36rare. Like I reviewed some whiskeys
- 1:02:38that are off the charts good and I rate very highly and I just
- 1:02:42like sit with 1/2 ounce of them for like an hour.
- 1:02:45This is a whiskey where my glass is basically empty now and I'm
- 1:02:48like, when do I get to pour some more, right?
- 1:02:50This is just whiskey I want to drink.
- 1:02:53So there's like this X Factor there that my numerical rating
- 1:02:57is like underselling it a little bit, even though my numerical
- 1:03:00rating is extraordinarily high. This is a great whiskey, guys.
- 1:03:03This is a great whiskey, Yeah. And with, with our final
- 1:03:06category here, David, we normally do our value category
- 1:03:10and we give a price and we will give the price on this whiskey.
- 1:03:14But it is falling within our our luxury category, which
- 1:03:19essentially for us is like, but for a lot of people, once you
- 1:03:24hit three $400.00, the upwards range of the price might not
- 1:03:29start to matter as much As for somebody who's used to spending
- 1:03:3330 and looking at a 70 or $80.00 bottle, you know what I mean?
- 1:03:38Yeah, there's, there's really no cost is not an obstacle at this
- 1:03:42point if you're looking at buying this whiskey.
- 1:03:44And So what we've kind of done at this point when we're
- 1:03:46reviewing luxury whiskeys and Brad, I'm finding this around
- 1:03:49$2000 online just as a baseline, I'll say 2 grand.
- 1:03:53If you're, if you're already looking at spending two grand on
- 1:03:55a whiskey, we know that you can afford to spend 2 grand on a
- 1:03:58whiskey. And so we usually come in with a
- 1:04:01baseline of five out of 10 and can go up or down from there.
- 1:04:05I think I'm going to go up from 5 out of.
- 1:04:07Ten. You usually come out with a 5
- 1:04:10out of 10 baseline. Speaking for the both of us,
- 1:04:13we're, we're at a 5 out of 10, but I, I do think that among
- 1:04:17luxury categories here, we're not actually comparing this to
- 1:04:21like all the $2000 whiskey's we've had.
- 1:04:23Which one's the best? Is this a product that can
- 1:04:27justify costing this much? Absolutely.
- 1:04:30Based on the market, based on the actual amount of liquid left
- 1:04:34in the barrels after 30 years, yes.
- 1:04:37They I don't feel like they're price gouging.
- 1:04:38I don't feel like there's anything gimmicky happening
- 1:04:41here. I'm going to give this a 7 1/2
- 1:04:44out of 10, Brad, just because I don't know that I can go really
- 1:04:46higher than that. If you're already thinking about
- 1:04:49spending two grand on this whiskey, you don't need my
- 1:04:52endorsement for it. No, I, I, I will give my
- 1:04:55endorsement for it. I think this is a nine out of 10
- 1:04:57value, Bob. Wow.
- 1:04:58Like I know it's $2000.00 but if I were to ever spend $2000 on a
- 1:05:05whiskey I know what I would be spending it on.
- 1:05:08So like that. Like for me that just once again
- 1:05:13I have not drank nearly as many $2000 plus whiskeys nor has Bob
- 1:05:17as as have you David. So like I am a OK with knowing
- 1:05:21that my score is based on a smaller sample size, but for me
- 1:05:27I think this is a great value. What I will say is in the scheme
- 1:05:31of in the grand scheme of like 30 year old single malts, you'll
- 1:05:35see a lot that are more expensive than that.
- 1:05:39And I think this is frankly better than a lot of more
- 1:05:42expensive single malts. You know, I'm going to probably
- 1:05:44say value wise, value is something I actually rarely
- 1:05:47asked to put that in review. So I am actually, I feel much
- 1:05:49less qualified to talk about monetary value than you guys
- 1:05:53because I'm actually often asked to just ignore that.
- 1:05:55Even if I want to factor it in, I'll probably say 8 on this
- 1:06:01because I think this is a whiskey that you're not going to
- 1:06:04be. It's impossible to be
- 1:06:05disappointed with this whiskey, right?
- 1:06:07This is a truly, truly special whiskey.
- 1:06:10I think you can pay much more for whiskey that's not nearly as
- 1:06:13good. Frankly, it's great stuff. 1
- 1:06:18little plug I want to give, I'm not paid by Bushmills by the
- 1:06:21way, I want to point out like I did not accept money from
- 1:06:23Bushmills. They sent me this.
- 1:06:24I have AI have a contact at the PR, at their PR agency of
- 1:06:27record. They sent me this.
- 1:06:28I'm very thankful for that. But like I will you know, look
- 1:06:31at this like I do any other liquid.
- 1:06:33One thing I like I will say is you want, if you don't want to
- 1:06:36spend $2000.00, but you want a really good well aged Bushmills,
- 1:06:40you know, Irish single malt. If you are flying through
- 1:06:44different parts of Europe, go to Duty free because Bushmills has
- 1:06:47a number of duty free like special bottles.
- 1:06:50Many of them I think are like 21 years and they roll them out
- 1:06:53with some frequency and they have like different expressions.
- 1:06:56I have yet to have a Bushmills duty free exclusive that I
- 1:07:00didn't really like. Some I like more than others.
- 1:07:03And I'm not saying that they're like they're not like punching
- 1:07:06where this is, but they're really good and they're like
- 1:07:09USD. It's like 160 or 200 bucks,
- 1:07:13right? And there's some really, really
- 1:07:14fun ones. And I'm not saying they're all
- 1:07:16this good, but if you want to have a really great Irish single
- 1:07:19malt experience and you want to try some really fantastic
- 1:07:22Bushmills that you're, you know, that is is different than like
- 1:07:25the 10 year, you're going to be able to find it most like most
- 1:07:28liquor stores in the US. If you're flying through Europe
- 1:07:30or you're flying internationally, check out the
- 1:07:31duty free Bushmills 21 year duty free exclusives I find are often
- 1:07:36worth it. They're often the bottle that I,
- 1:07:39in coming back from Europe especially or Ireland
- 1:07:41especially, will often regret not getting more bottles of.
- 1:07:46What I hear you saying is Bushmills has an incredibly
- 1:07:49well-rounded portfolio. Yeah.
- 1:07:51Yeah, I mean, I would say, well, I wouldn't say well-rounded
- 1:07:53because they're they, they produce single malt, right.
- 1:07:55You have a lot of Irish distillers that produce a lot of
- 1:07:57different styles of whiskey. Some are producing single malt
- 1:08:00and Irish single pot still and single grain.
- 1:08:02Like they're doing a lot of different stuff.
- 1:08:04Bushmills is doing a lot with single malt, right?
- 1:08:08So take that as you will. But what they do, they do well.
- 1:08:12And it's, I want to point out too that like there are about,
- 1:08:15there are around 50 active distilleries in Ireland right
- 1:08:18now. At one point there were only two
- 1:08:21and it was within like our parents lifetimes and Bushmills
- 1:08:25was one of them, right. And for a long time, Bushmills,
- 1:08:28like a lot of the highly aged Irish single malt that you'll
- 1:08:32see these days released from other brands is actually sourced
- 1:08:35from Bushmills. Yep.
- 1:08:37And you see people putting their spin on their own spin on it.
- 1:08:39And some of this whiskey's very highly regarded and very well,
- 1:08:42well rewarded. And it starts with really great
- 1:08:44bass distillate and Bushmills. Their bass distillate's very
- 1:08:47good. They produce good single malt.
- 1:08:49They know what they're doing. You know 100.
- 1:08:51Percent, Brad. I'm coming out to a 44 out of 50
- 1:08:54on this one and it's because my my value score is a little bit
- 1:08:57lower. If I had given it the 10 out of
- 1:08:5910, I'd be at what, 46 1/2 out of 50 on this.
- 1:09:02Where are you sitting on this one, Brad?
- 1:09:04You called it man 46 1/2 out of 50.
- 1:09:07All right, David, I did not do the honors of tallying up your
- 1:09:11score. We're going to be on the lookout
- 1:09:14for your print review of this sometime soon with, you know, a
- 1:09:18proper attribution of film and whiskey, of course and the and
- 1:09:21and the check in the mail, obviously so.
- 1:09:22And then, well, that's the that's royalties.
- 1:09:25This is a film podcast. I was going to say.
- 1:09:27That it would be a check from us to him to be.
- 1:09:30Exactly. We're coming out to an average
- 1:09:32of a 45.25 out of 50 or a 90.5 out of 100.
- 1:09:38This has hit the 90 mark, Brad. That is a, that is rarefied air
- 1:09:42here on film and whiskey. You know, we've done it 500 plus
- 1:09:45reviews now and I think we've only had maybe 5 or 6 ever hit
- 1:09:49the 90 mark. Yeah, I I was about to say I'm
- 1:09:52pretty. I know for a fact it's less than
- 1:09:5410. Yeah.
- 1:09:56Yeah, the at the end of the day, like if you get the chance to
- 1:09:59try Bushmills 30 or Iris single malt, do it like I like.
- 1:10:06I don't. I can't imagine a seasoned
- 1:10:08whiskey drinker or even a novice whiskey drinker who's not, who's
- 1:10:12not going to be able to appreciate this W100.
- 1:10:14Percent, I think. I think that's what blew me away
- 1:10:17is that this is the most perfect combination of like complex and
- 1:10:23approachable. Approachable 100%.
- 1:10:25And I think the best way to describe it is crush ability.
- 1:10:29I like David. We might steal that word and.
- 1:10:32I stole it. I stole it from my friend Mark,
- 1:10:34right? Like, I have no original
- 1:10:35thoughts. I just RIP off you guys and my
- 1:10:37friends. But it's so crushable.
- 1:10:40It's so crushable. Not that we would ever endorse
- 1:10:43drinking to excess. No.
- 1:10:45Sure. But crushing?
- 1:10:47Yeah. You know, You know what else is
- 1:10:49crushable, Brad? What's that, Robert?
- 1:10:52All those guys that get crushed by a sandworm at the end of Dune
- 1:10:54Part 2 dude. What I let?
- 1:10:59Let's get into it. I've thought, all right.
- 1:11:01Man. All right everybody, that was
- 1:11:07Bushmill's 30 year single malt, one of the best whiskeys we have
- 1:11:12ever drank on this podcast, and it is easily paired with the
- 1:11:17greatest sandworms that we have ever seen in a film.
- 1:11:21Well, now I'm rethinking that transition.
- 1:11:24So Brad, let's get into our game for the day, which we call 2
- 1:11:29facts and a falsehood. Brad.
- 1:11:31Is going to try to stump your ball and what is wrong?
- 1:11:382 facts and a. Falsehood. 2 Facts and a
- 1:11:41Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me with
- 1:11:43three items as facts about the making of this movie, one of
- 1:11:47which is a complete lie. Brad, I'm doing pretty well on
- 1:11:50the season. Am I at?
- 1:11:52What am I at now? I think like 8:00 and 3:00.
- 1:11:55Yeah, sounds about right. Something around there.
- 1:11:57Now we do have a guest today and that what that means is that if
- 1:12:01I enlist David's help and we get the question right, I get one
- 1:12:07victory, but if we get it wrong, I get 2 losses.
- 1:12:10So we often end up at the end of the season with more than 32
- 1:12:13points for our 32 weeks. It gets very confusing, but it,
- 1:12:17you know, it's a system that is meant to penalize me.
- 1:12:20Yes. So David, I can tell you
- 1:12:21immediately I'm going to enlist your help because otherwise it
- 1:12:24makes for very bad audio by just ignore the guest for 5 minutes.
- 1:12:28You also know more about Dune than I do.
- 1:12:30So I feel like you are going to be a a fountain of knowledge
- 1:12:33here. Brad, why don't you hit me with
- 1:12:35your two facts and a falsehood? Fact number one.
- 1:12:37To capture the ferocity of Arakis sandstorms, the crew
- 1:12:42built a wind tunnel that could generate speeds over 150 mph and
- 1:12:47mixed in with it, real desert sand.
- 1:12:50Several cast members referred to these shoots as the most intense
- 1:12:54exfoliation of their lives. Fact #2 director Denis
- 1:12:59Villeneuve and cinematographer Greg Grieg, Greg Fraser
- 1:13:04carefully scouted desert locations and selected sites
- 1:13:07based on the precise curve of the sand or the ideal alignment
- 1:13:10of sunlight. Maintaining the untouched look
- 1:13:13at the landscapes required a military level of discipline
- 1:13:17from the crew members, who were instructed to move in tight
- 1:13:20single file corridors to avoid disrupting the sand.
- 1:13:25Fact #3 Director Denis Villeneuve envisioned Fayed
- 1:13:29Rotha Harkinen, played by Austin Butler, as a blend of
- 1:13:32psychopathic killer, Olympic level swordmaster Snake and Mick
- 1:13:36Jagger. Interestingly, Jagger himself
- 1:13:40was once slated to portray the character in Alejandro
- 1:13:44Jodorowski's ambitious but unrealized Dune adaptation of
- 1:13:47the 1970s. All right.
- 1:13:51Let me tell you what I'm immediately targeting here,
- 1:13:54David. So fact #3 what Brad will often
- 1:13:57do is he'll give 90% of a fact and then add like a little
- 1:14:02phrase at the end to throw me off.
- 1:14:04That is not true. Bob, I do not often do that.
- 1:14:07I rarely do that. And it pisses me off every time.
- 1:14:11And pisses. You off so much that you think I
- 1:14:13often do it? Sticks in my brain man, I know
- 1:14:16that. I think it's pronounced
- 1:14:18Yodorovsky's Dune was unrealized.
- 1:14:22I have no idea if Mick Jagger was ever considered for that
- 1:14:24project. There's a documentary about the
- 1:14:27making of that unmade movie, so I I have not seen it.
- 1:14:31I have no idea about the Mick Jagger of it all apart from that
- 1:14:36fact #1 sounds pretty made-up to me. 150 mile an hour winds that
- 1:14:40they were dumping sand into. Because, David, we've both
- 1:14:43worked. We, we've both worked one of us.
- 1:14:46You, what am I saying? You have worked with real
- 1:14:49actors. I have never worked with real
- 1:14:50actors. I have heard stories about
- 1:14:54people who work with actors. Did you almost claim that you
- 1:14:57worked with? Man, I was out on a limb there
- 1:14:59dude. You sure were I?
- 1:15:00Had to pull that one back quickly.
- 1:15:02I don't even know why I thought that that was what should come
- 1:15:05out of my mouth. I haven't been nowhere near
- 1:15:07actors in my life, Brad. All that to say, I can't imagine
- 1:15:14much of A world where agents and stars are getting themselves
- 1:15:19into a wind tunnel where they're having sand blown at their
- 1:15:22corneas and talking about the exfoliation fat.
- 1:15:25Like unless they had goggles on, which they do in some parts of
- 1:15:28the movie, but that just seems like something that probably
- 1:15:32didn't happen to me. It also doesn't mean that
- 1:15:35Zendaya was in the thing. Well yeah, that just means they
- 1:15:38dragged her double in there and forced that poor girl to endure
- 1:15:41life altering cornea damage. And we know that double s are
- 1:15:45treated so so well. Wait, just to Brad, just to
- 1:15:49clarify, the first act is 150 miles an hour.
- 1:15:53Yes. That's hurricane force, man.
- 1:15:57That's more than hurricane. That's like, I think hurricane
- 1:15:59force stops like that's more than that's.
- 1:16:04Are we? Are we?
- 1:16:05Do you think that's the falsehood?
- 1:16:08So the The thing is, the thing about #3 is I think #2 is almost
- 1:16:11certainly correct, right? Because I think it just needs
- 1:16:15like, I think that there had to be have been discipline
- 1:16:18regarding like not disturbing because like that makes sense,
- 1:16:21right? I think that, like, was how the
- 1:16:23film was filmed. Three.
- 1:16:28I kind of remember that. I think I might be conflating.
- 1:16:30It's a little confusing because in David Lynch's version, Vedra
- 1:16:33also is played by Sting, who, by the way, does a really good job.
- 1:16:36Like, I really like that performance.
- 1:16:38I thought it was really of all the weird stuff in that movie.
- 1:16:40I was like, oh, this actually was pretty well done, this.
- 1:16:42Kind of works, yeah. This kind of works.
- 1:16:44So I feel like I'd heard that about Mick Jagger, but like, I
- 1:16:48can't quite remember at the same time, the 150 mile an hour.
- 1:16:54Like I don't think humans survive 150 mile an hour winds,
- 1:17:00right? Like 8000 mile an hour winds are
- 1:17:03like you. You like dying though.
- 1:17:06Like you're just dead. You know what I mean?
- 1:17:07Like I think. I think #1 would have worked if
- 1:17:10it had been like. Like. 75 miles an hour.
- 1:17:14I would have been like, Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, 100. 150 does sound
- 1:17:19instantly fatal. I think that's just lethal like
- 1:17:24so, and I think we would have heard about that like entire
- 1:17:27cast of Dune killed cause of really bad decision.
- 1:17:32When they make a horror film based on that wind tunnel.
- 1:17:35We've essentially created a sand blaster at that point.
- 1:17:38More like I think sand blasters don't hit that volume.
- 1:17:42OK. Are are we in agreement that
- 1:17:44we're going to go with #1? Then I, OK, so I, I think #1
- 1:17:49here's the problem though. I, I get all of the UPS, I get
- 1:17:52to share in the upside of a win. But I, I, I have none of the
- 1:17:56repercussions of of getting it wrong.
- 1:17:59But I will say #1 is my is what I would suggest.
- 1:18:02I was leaning towards one anyway.
- 1:18:03So David, that no fault falls on you, I'm going to go with #1
- 1:18:08Brad. And I'm going to lock it in as
- 1:18:09my final answer here. I feel like I feel like you guys
- 1:18:12have beaten this one to death as 150 mile an hour wind tunnel
- 1:18:16would also do. That is correct.
- 1:18:18It is the falsehood. At any point in writing that
- 1:18:21falsehood, did you think to yourself 150 sounds like a bit
- 1:18:25much? Maybe I should.
- 1:18:26Maybe I should tone that down you.
- 1:18:27Know, I've never lived in Florida, I've never paid a ton
- 1:18:31of attention to hurricanes. So no, I I didn't really think
- 1:18:35about it. Yeah, I want you to next time,
- 1:18:39next time the weather report says in your area you have 30
- 1:18:43mile an hour gusts step outside just.
- 1:18:45Go outside, check it out. Step outside, face in like face
- 1:18:49the wind, and go and go. OK, five times this speed 100.
- 1:18:54And 50. Baby, would I have a face if
- 1:18:57this hit one face? Yeah.
- 1:18:58Like five times the speed and sand, you know what I mean?
- 1:19:01Like. It'd be like the end of Raiders
- 1:19:04of the Lost Ark. The face is just melting off.
- 1:19:09Oh my gosh. All right, guys, David did have
- 1:19:11to jump off of our call. So Brad and I are going to
- 1:19:13finish out most of the episode here.
- 1:19:15We'll bring David back in for final scores.
- 1:19:17Brad, I want to jump back in where we left off talking about
- 1:19:21this supporting cast. And it's such a big cast that I
- 1:19:24think maybe let's just pick one or two people that that blew our
- 1:19:28minds, starting with someone who is very quickly becoming our
- 1:19:32person on this podcast, Rebecca Ferguson.
- 1:19:35Dude. I may have she's.
- 1:19:36So good. I may have a crush on Rebecca
- 1:19:38Ferguson. In fact, I think I probably do
- 1:19:41like she's She's really, really beautiful and also an incredible
- 1:19:44actress. I absolutely have a crush on my
- 1:19:48wife and that is the only person I have a crush on.
- 1:19:52I mean it's. Not that you know that that kind
- 1:19:54of crush. It's just like.
- 1:19:56Rebecca Ferguson is incredible in this movie.
- 1:19:58She has this brooding intensity within her that just screams
- 1:20:05when it's on screen. I I mean.
- 1:20:08What an actress, What a performance.
- 1:20:11I think one of the overarching things that we've already talked
- 1:20:13about in this episode is like this second film in the
- 1:20:17franchise, to me is leaps and bounds better than the first
- 1:20:21movie and I. So much better.
- 1:20:22I liked the first movie quite a bit.
- 1:20:23That's like an 8 out of 10 for me.
- 1:20:25This. It does everything better,
- 1:20:27including being a little more Hollywood, right?
- 1:20:30Like, there's a lot more punch lines, there's actual jokes and
- 1:20:33laughs, and a lot of them come from Javier Bardem and some of
- 1:20:37them come from Josh Brolin. But even Rebecca Ferguson, for
- 1:20:40as eerie and creepy and dark and sometimes evil as she is, they
- 1:20:44play that for laughs a couple times.
- 1:20:46Like the way she cuts people off and uses the voice, or the way
- 1:20:49that she's just like walking around the halls talking to her
- 1:20:52unborn baby. It's kind of funny sometimes.
- 1:20:55And I think that Villeneuve recognizes that to his credit.
- 1:20:58Yeah, and he implements her for the absolute most impact that
- 1:21:05she could have had in this movie.
- 1:21:06A. 100% So we started talking about Javier Bardem.
- 1:21:10I I personally believe this man should be nominated for an
- 1:21:13Academy Award for this movie. It is exactly what a supporting
- 1:21:17performance is supposed to be. He's so funny, he's so over the
- 1:21:21top at parts, but he also has a believability and a real
- 1:21:26emotional depth. You know, there's a moment where
- 1:21:28he's been wounded in battle and he's talking to Paul about, hey,
- 1:21:31you should just kill me and then go talk at the council and he's
- 1:21:35because. Killing him would make him the
- 1:21:36leader, right? And he's like, man, you know, I
- 1:21:39don't believe in any of that prophecy stuff.
- 1:21:41And he's like, I don't care if you don't believe in it.
- 1:21:43I believe in it. And it's one of the like to see
- 1:21:47this character who's been portrayed at times as kind of
- 1:21:51like the fanatic who is also a buffoon, be able to impart on
- 1:21:57the audience I'm not a buffoon. I really believe this.
- 1:22:00And it's OK if you don't believe it because I have faith in you.
- 1:22:04It it's just a real, it's a more nuanced performance than I think
- 1:22:07it's gotten credit for. I think it's the best
- 1:22:09performance in the movie about like, I think he does such a
- 1:22:13stellar job of everything that you said.
- 1:22:17Like he plays things for laughs. He knows that he's a mentor
- 1:22:21figure in Paul's life and he takes that so seriously.
- 1:22:26And the belief with which he looks towards Paul, like it like
- 1:22:32once again, like I said earlier about Zendaya, like his eyes
- 1:22:35communicate so much about who this character is.
- 1:22:41I I was hoping we would get to him soon because I I do think he
- 1:22:45is my favorite performance of this movie.
- 1:22:48I feel like we're kind of getting short shrift to the rest
- 1:22:50of the cast, but they're all like uniformly very, very.
- 1:22:53Good. They're so good, dude.
- 1:22:55Austin Butler. Austin Butler.
- 1:22:57He has black. Teeth not doing the Elvis voice.
- 1:22:59Yeah, it's pretty great. OK, Brad, I do want to talk a
- 1:23:04little bit about the end of the film, which I do think we have
- 1:23:07different reads on. And in order to do that, I want
- 1:23:10to get to my let's make it a double.
- 1:23:12I won't do the little spiel here.
- 1:23:14We'll do that when it's time for years.
- 1:23:15But I'm going to pair this movie up with the Godfather Part 2.
- 1:23:19Now we have not done Godfather 2 on this podcast, so I'm I've
- 1:23:22kind of seen. It so don't spoil it, yeah.
- 1:23:23I'm well so the arc of the main character Michael Corleone
- 1:23:28across the 1st 2 Godfather movies.
- 1:23:31It's intended to be taken as one arc and you see from the the
- 1:23:37young upstart in the 1st movie who doesn't want anything to do
- 1:23:40with the family business to then becoming the godfather at the
- 1:23:42end of the first movie. You see the moral decay of
- 1:23:46Michael across the second film, and it's a much darker movie
- 1:23:51than the first one is. It's much more sad.
- 1:23:53It's it's really does play on the level of tragedy because
- 1:23:56it's intercut with the story of Marlon Brando's character when
- 1:23:59he was young and 1st coming to America.
- 1:24:02And so you watch the juxtaposition, Brad, of Michael
- 1:24:06alienating his family and kind of ruining the legacy of his own
- 1:24:09family, interspersed with Brando doing everything for his family
- 1:24:14and like, right, making them rise to power.
- 1:24:17And I think that this movie is really similar in how it does
- 1:24:21that arc with Paula Tradies because by the end of the film,
- 1:24:24what you've seen is a really complex portrayal where you can
- 1:24:29take multiple readings of it. Is he a conniver?
- 1:24:34Has he just done all of this to further advance himself and or
- 1:24:40ensure his survival, which has been what he's been saying the
- 1:24:42whole time? But then you also see moments
- 1:24:45throughout the film where he's legitimately concerned for the
- 1:24:49well-being of the Fremen in not going South because he knows
- 1:24:54it's going to cause death. And then it just kind of gets to
- 1:24:56a point where it seems like it's inevitable.
- 1:24:58It is his fate to go South, to become the Lisan Al Gaib and
- 1:25:03truly lean into what is his destiny and fate, knowing that
- 1:25:08it will kill millions or perhaps trillions of people.
- 1:25:11And I think that it's it's a portrayal of a heroic character
- 1:25:16that we haven't seen since movies in the 70s, like The
- 1:25:20Godfather, where your protagonist, you know, it's I
- 1:25:24don't want to compare it to like Breaking Bad because I don't
- 1:25:26think he becomes the actual villain of the story.
- 1:25:28But you could feel the energy in the theater of like, oh, God,
- 1:25:33like Paul is Paul is starting the jihad at the end of this
- 1:25:37movie. Like this is this is not where I
- 1:25:39thought this was going to go. He is declaring war on the
- 1:25:42entire Galaxy. What the Hell's going on here?
- 1:25:45Is this good? Is this bad?
- 1:25:47These people certainly seem to appreciate it.
- 1:25:49But we know that it's going to cause death and destruction.
- 1:25:53And so I'm I'm really interested to hear your read on the end of
- 1:25:56the film. Do you see it as uplifting from
- 1:25:59the point of view of the Fremen, or do you see it as a a big
- 1:26:02blinking red warning sign for the character of Paul?
- 1:26:06I think I saw it as like inevitable, like I, I don't
- 1:26:11think at any point in the film I ever doubted that he was going
- 1:26:15to go South and become the least on Al Gaid.
- 1:26:17But like that, that felt in, like I said, inevitable to me.
- 1:26:23I don't think I see it in terms of good and evil per SE.
- 1:26:30Like for me it it feels like Paul as a character isn't
- 1:26:36actually concerned about survival that that never seemed
- 1:26:39to be some his own survival that never seems to be his thing.
- 1:26:43Like, oh, I have to survive. Like his whole motivation for
- 1:26:47the first half of the film is revenge for his father.
- 1:26:52And as he learns the ways of the Fremen and falls in love with
- 1:26:55Chani and with the Fremen culture as a whole, like he then
- 1:27:02wants to become the savior of the Fremen.
- 1:27:04And so it feels like a trans, a transformation of his
- 1:27:09motivation. And the only way to truly free
- 1:27:13the Fremen is to take on the entire Galaxy because of the
- 1:27:18value that spice has that the only way to bring freedom to the
- 1:27:22to the planet is to control the entire Galaxy.
- 1:27:26And so I, I, I guess I just don't, I don't really see it in
- 1:27:29the same way that you do. Interesting.
- 1:27:32Yeah. I'm, I'm surprised that, well, I
- 1:27:35don't want to say that you're taking a surface level reading
- 1:27:36of it 'cause I don't mean it in a negative way.
- 1:27:39I'm surprised that you're reading it on its face so much
- 1:27:41though, because I, I think that the movie really is
- 1:27:43interrogating the questions of like, is this inevitable or was
- 1:27:47this manufactured? Did they pull so many strings to
- 1:27:50make him become the Lisan Algaeb, even if he does have
- 1:27:54these powers as a result of drinking worm piss, Like, is he
- 1:27:57really fulfilling a prophecy or is this sort of a, you know,
- 1:28:00Macbeth self fulfilling prophecy kind of thing?
- 1:28:03And I do think that there is a lot of kind of Shakespearean
- 1:28:06ambition and perhaps folly in the Paula Treaties character.
- 1:28:10And so you're right, I do think that it's inevitable.
- 1:28:12Like at no point do you think, oh, I wonder if he's actually
- 1:28:15going to go South. But it is inviting you as the
- 1:28:18viewer to question, like, even if this is his destiny, are we
- 1:28:23supposed to just, are we supposed to root for it?
- 1:28:25Or are we just kind of helpless bystanders watching the collapse
- 1:28:30of the universe here? Yeah, I mean, the the way the
- 1:28:33film portrays it, though, is that the Fremen have a better
- 1:28:38culture than the spacefaring races that have enslaved them.
- 1:28:43And for me, it seems like more of a battle of like Paul
- 1:28:48learning to understand and love that culture and then fighting
- 1:28:54on its behalf. Like I, I, I don't know if
- 1:28:56that's a surface level reading or not.
- 1:28:58Maybe it is. No.
- 1:28:59And I again, I'm not trying to insult like I'm not saying
- 1:29:01you're taking a. I'm just saying like, I just
- 1:29:03want you to know that I'm not I, I didn't mean it in a negative
- 1:29:06way. No, I know dude.
- 1:29:07I I think that I like the big stories like I, I don't.
- 1:29:15I like the grand operatic narrative of a hero rising to
- 1:29:22the occasion, rising from the ashes like a phoenix to save a
- 1:29:28people group to make the Galaxy a better place.
- 1:29:31Now once again, David probably knew the IPA million times
- 1:29:36better than us. And maybe the entire thing ends
- 1:29:39with the Galaxy falling into ashes and every single human is
- 1:29:43killed. I like who knows.
- 1:29:46I just think that if you take Dune 2 on its own merits, I
- 1:29:51think the story ends in a place where belief in the prophecy
- 1:29:56triumphs over cold, calculating, manipulative scientific, you
- 1:30:03know, just desperate bid for survival.
- 1:30:06Sure. So, So what I'm hearing from
- 1:30:08Brad is it's OK to colonize as long as you're really sure that
- 1:30:14your culture is the better culture, right?
- 1:30:16Yeah, yeah, 100% cool. All right, man, on that note,
- 1:30:20let's get into let's make it a double for Brad presented by
- 1:30:25Blackwood Distilling Company. We're.
- 1:30:27Near the end of the episodes of Things, listening to the film
- 1:30:30and Whiskey Show, let's have another film with this one, even
- 1:30:33if it's struggling, it's the final segment of the day.
- 1:30:35Now let's make it a double. Let's Make It a Double is the
- 1:30:38part of the show where we pick a movie to pair up with this one
- 1:30:41to make the perfect double feature.
- 1:30:43I've already picked Godfather Part 2.
- 1:30:46Brad, I'm really interested to hear what you'd like to pair
- 1:30:48this one up with. Man, I I feel like you could go
- 1:30:52a ton of different directions. I normally don't like to pair it
- 1:30:55with a movie we mentioned, but we we barely mentioned it.
- 1:31:00I'm going to pair this with the Matrix.
- 1:31:02I. Like I think that I I wanted to
- 1:31:05stay in the sci-fi vein for let's make it a double and I
- 1:31:10think that the matrix is a one of the greatest sci-fi movies
- 1:31:14ever made. And BI think that you have those
- 1:31:17similar ideas of struggles with being the one, right?
- 1:31:22Paul is the one of Dune, Neo is the one of Matrix, and you have
- 1:31:27really interesting lead characters who struggle to come
- 1:31:32to terms with their identities and their new powers and what
- 1:31:36that will mean for the world around them.
- 1:31:39And I, I, I think that though it would be a heck of a night.
- 1:31:42It'd be a very long night, but it would be a heck of a night to
- 1:31:45watch those two movies. All right, so I've paired it up
- 1:31:48with Godfather 2. Brad has paired it up with The
- 1:31:50Matrix. Whatever you choose to pair this
- 1:31:52movie up with, you can always make it a double with Blackwood
- 1:31:56Distilling Company. And if you go to
- 1:31:58bourbonoutfitter.com/filmwhiskey, once again, that's bourbon
- 1:32:02outfitter.com/film Whiskey and use our code film whiskey at
- 1:32:07checkout. You'll get 5% off your bottle of
- 1:32:10Blackwood as well. Brad, I think it is time for us
- 1:32:13to get into final scores on this movie.
- 1:32:15So let's bring back David for this.
- 1:32:17David, I'm going to throw to you first.
- 1:32:20Where are you landing on Dune Part 2?
- 1:32:21We're on a one to 10 scale. Half points are allowed.
- 1:32:24Yeah, thank you. 8.5 for me. Really, really enjoyed it.
- 1:32:30Not perfect, but I think it should certainly be in award
- 1:32:35contention and I hope that it can overcome the the handicap
- 1:32:40that I think a lot of hard sci-fi faces when it comes to
- 1:32:44being taken seriously during Movie Awards season.
- 1:32:48Yeah, 100%. And the question we've been
- 1:32:51asking all season would you consider this a modern classic?
- 1:32:55Yeah, I would. I, I would for this.
- 1:32:58I think it's AI think it's a classic for two reasons.
- 1:33:00One, I think it's a great achievement in film, or at least
- 1:33:04a very, very good achievement in film.
- 1:33:05And I think it is a really fantastic.
- 1:33:10It's the interpretation of storied, legendary IP that we've
- 1:33:15been waiting for. All right, Brad, what are you
- 1:33:16thinking about this one? Bob I think that the only way
- 1:33:21this would have been a perfect movie is if when Paul confronts
- 1:33:26the emperor near the end of the film, when they're like in his
- 1:33:31ship area before they take him prisoner, if he had said
- 1:33:34something about his father and how he killed his father.
- 1:33:37And then Christopher Walken pulls a watch out and goes.
- 1:33:42I wore this uncomfortable hunk of metal up my ass.
- 1:33:46Two years gave the speech. I think that would have made
- 1:33:51this a perfect movie really quickly.
- 1:33:55How did you feel about Christopher Walken being in this
- 1:33:57film? I.
- 1:33:58Thought he was great. It was a it was a way toned down
- 1:34:00Christopher Walken, but they they do a great job of capturing
- 1:34:03his weirdness as emperor. There's a couple of guys you
- 1:34:06could have done this with, like you could have gotten a Willem
- 1:34:08Dafoe if you wanted to. But I think, dude, I think
- 1:34:11Walken's a great choice and he he plays a guy with the burden
- 1:34:16of being emperor very well. I agree with that.
- 1:34:18Yeah, there's one specific line that he delivers right before
- 1:34:23the the fight between Paul and Vedratha that I was like, oh,
- 1:34:28that was a bad line delivery. Like like that was the one you
- 1:34:32chose, Denny. Other than that, I think he was
- 1:34:35spectacular. I'm actually in the same place
- 1:34:38as David on this. I'm at an 8.5.
- 1:34:42Like I think it is stunning and spectacular and I will watch
- 1:34:46this movie again. You know, we didn't really talk
- 1:34:50about it much. The the mixture of the
- 1:34:53cinematography and the sound design of this movie is a 10 out
- 1:34:59of 10. I mean, far and away one of the
- 1:35:04most beautiful and moving movies I have ever seen in my life.
- 1:35:09The the problems with the movie come with some of the dialogue
- 1:35:14and then at the end of the film, Bob, I'm not going to lie, I
- 1:35:18think that there was way too much stuff at the start.
- 1:35:22I really wish there was more battle.
- 1:35:25Like you see the sandworms come in, it's freaking awesome.
- 1:35:30And then you don't see anything, anything of the main battle.
- 1:35:35And that, like I'm here for the spectacle, I'm here for the
- 1:35:39Battle of Helms Deep. I was just going to say.
- 1:35:41You're expecting a Helms Deep like it's set up where you're,
- 1:35:45you understand where they have all these guys surrounded from.
- 1:35:48And when the sandworm comes in from that cloud of dust, it is
- 1:35:51the coolest shot in a movie I've seen this year.
- 1:35:54But you're right, they give you about 30 seconds of the fight
- 1:35:57and then they cut away. And then that way it's much more
- 1:36:00akin to Pelinor Fields than it is to Helms Deep because it just
- 1:36:04feels like the fights over immediately.
- 1:36:06Yeah, yeah, and you know, Palmer Fields great battle scene, but
- 1:36:10they had another battle, the black gate battle scene to get
- 1:36:13to and and a ton of other stuff in this movie.
- 1:36:16It's like this is what we've been building towards.
- 1:36:19And the exact same problem happens in the fight with him
- 1:36:22and Fayed Rotha. Like for for one of the best
- 1:36:26choreographed and sound designed fights I've seen in a long time.
- 1:36:33You can't have Paul kill Fayed Ratha off screen.
- 1:36:38I want to see him stab that blade.
- 1:36:40I don't understand how he executed that maneuver, and I
- 1:36:43don't understand how he got gutted like a fish and then was
- 1:36:46just like, all right. Totally fine, let's.
- 1:36:48Let's game plan some more here. And and then he guts Fayed Ratha
- 1:36:52in the exact same way that he just got stabbed, and yet Fayed
- 1:36:55Ratha dies. Immediately lethal, Yeah.
- 1:36:57And so it's like a few things like that, that I'm like, like
- 1:37:02this is an 8 1/2. That was like a few things away
- 1:37:05from being like a 10 out of 10. I think that this movie is
- 1:37:10almost hitting the ceiling. It can hit.
- 1:37:12And I'm also at an 8 1/2 Brad, which is, I don't think we've
- 1:37:15ever been in lockstep like this with our guests.
- 1:37:17But I remember sending you, like, screenshots of my ratings
- 1:37:20of this movie earlier in the year.
- 1:37:22And you kind of made fun of me after the second or third time I
- 1:37:24went to see this in the theater. And you're like, it seems pretty
- 1:37:28solidly like it's an 8.5 for you, dude.
- 1:37:31And I can't quite put my finger on it.
- 1:37:33I think it's that I'm, I'm more impressed by this movie than I
- 1:37:37am in love with this movie. Agreed.
- 1:37:39It's an incredibly impressive feat of movie making.
- 1:37:43I think part of the reason it hasn't gained the Oscars
- 1:37:45traction this year is that everyone is impressed by it on a
- 1:37:49craftsmanship level. But I don't know if it really
- 1:37:52has captured many people's hearts.
- 1:37:54And that's what's keeping this from being a Lord of the Rings
- 1:37:57for me. So I'm in an 8.5, you're in an
- 1:37:598.5. IMDb 8.5 out of 10 Brad.
- 1:38:03Oh my goodness. There you go.
- 1:38:04Yeah. I was going to say it like, it's
- 1:38:06hard for sci-fi to capture your heart because kind of the whole
- 1:38:10purpose of sci-fi is to stay away from the heart.
- 1:38:14And so it's like, yeah, like, this is the ceiling, I think,
- 1:38:18for a grand, operatic sci-fi movie.
- 1:38:23We do want to say thank you once again to our friend David Thomas
- 1:38:26Tao. We're sorry that he had to drop
- 1:38:27off before the end of the episode, but as you know, we be
- 1:38:30talking on this podcast. Right.
- 1:38:32Don't you know? I would say this is this is one
- 1:38:34of our longer episodes. Bob it.
- 1:38:36Sure. Well, we had like a 30 minute
- 1:38:37whiskey review too, because that whiskey, that's true.
- 1:38:39Really damn good. So folks.
- 1:38:41It was really it was really daggone good and like David is a
- 1:38:46premier whiskey taster and judge.
- 1:38:51Next week we will be back with Mad Max Fury Rd., a movie that
- 1:38:55Brad has not seen that exists on Earth but I think is a great
- 1:39:00follow up to Dune because it is kind of like soft sci-fi Brad.
- 1:39:03Yeah, yeah. I'm super excited for it.
- 1:39:05It's one of those films that like slipped out of my grasp
- 1:39:09like once it was out of theaters and I just never got around to
- 1:39:13it. And then we started the podcast
- 1:39:14and I was like, well, we'll, we'll watch it eventually.
- 1:39:16So here I am, a week away from reviewing Mad Max Fury Rd.
- 1:39:22We'll be back next week with that one, but until then, I'm
- 1:39:24Bob Book. I'm Brad G.
- 1:39:26And we'll see you next time.